22
NCE/12/01796 — Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796 — Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos Decisão de Apresentação de Recurso da Decisão do Conselho de Admnistração 1. Tendo recebido a decisão do Conselho de Administração relativamente ao pedido de acreditação prévia do novo ciclo de estudos Ciências Biológicas Aplicadas à Saúde 2. conferente do grau de Doutor 3. a ser leccionado na(s) Unidade(s) Orgânica(s) (faculdade, escola, instituto, etc.) Instituto Superior De Ciências Da Saúde - Norte 4. da(s) Instituição(ões) de Ensino Superior / Entidade(s) Instituidora(s) Cespu - Cooperativa De Ensino Superior Politécnico E Universitário, Crl 5. decide: Apresentar recurso 6. Recurso (Português): A Cespu, não se conformando o teor do Relatório Final e da decisão do Conselho de Administração, datada de 7.04.2014, que decidiram pela não acreditação de novo ciclo de estudos de “Ciências Biológicas Aplicadas à Saúde”, vem, ao abrigo dos artigos 20.º e seguintes do Regulamento n.º 896/2010, de 15/10/2013, interpor Recurso daquela decisão, nos seguintes termos e fundamentos. A Cespu não se conforma por considerar que aquela deliberação padece, em geral, de diversos vícios que a inquinam, designadamente o vício de falta de fundamentação, de erro nos pressupostos, de erro nos pressupostos de direito/vício de violação de lei, de violação do princípio da igualdade e de preterição de formalidade essencial (direito de audiência prévia). Tendo em conta os limites de caracteres impostos pela plataforma, por um lado, e a extensão do relatório e da decisão, por outro, os vícios que lhe são imputados estão desenvolvidos em documento em formato pdf que se anexará à plataforma, para o qual se remete e cujo conteúdo, por brevidade, se dá aqui por integralmente reproduzido, e constitui (o documento em formato pdf), para todos os efeitos legais, o efectivo recurso da Cespu sobre a referida decisão e relatório. Termos em que, e nos mais de Direito, e com o sempre mui douto suprimento de V. Exas., deverá o presente recurso ser julgado procedente, por provado, e, consequentemente, revogada a deliberação recorrida, bem como, por estarem reunidos todos os requisitos legais, seja substituída por outra que defira a acreditação do novo ciclo de estudos. 7. Documento anexo (Português e Inglês, PDF, máx. 150kB): (impresso na página seguinte) pág. 1 de 1

NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos

NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação derecurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo deestudosDecisão de Apresentação de Recurso da Decisão do Conselhode Admnistração1. Tendo recebido a decisão do Conselho de Administração relativamente ao pedido de acreditaçãoprévia do novo ciclo de estudos Ciências Biológicas Aplicadas à Saúde2. conferente do grau de Doutor3. a ser leccionado na(s) Unidade(s) Orgânica(s) (faculdade, escola, instituto, etc.)Instituto Superior De Ciências Da Saúde - Norte4. da(s) Instituição(ões) de Ensino Superior / Entidade(s) Instituidora(s)Cespu - Cooperativa De Ensino Superior Politécnico E Universitário, Crl5. decide: Apresentar recurso6. Recurso (Português):A Cespu, não se conformando o teor do Relatório Final e da decisão do Conselho de Administração,datada de 7.04.2014, que decidiram pela não acreditação de novo ciclo de estudos de ☜CiênciasBiológicas Aplicadas à Saúde☝, vem, ao abrigo dos artigos 20.º e seguintes do Regulamento n.º896/2010, de 15/10/2013, interpor Recurso daquela decisão, nos seguintes termos e fundamentos.

A Cespu não se conforma por considerar que aquela deliberação padece, em geral, de diversos víciosque a inquinam, designadamente o vício de falta de fundamentação, de erro nos pressupostos, deerro nos pressupostos de direito/vício de violação de lei, de violação do princípio da igualdade e depreterição de formalidade essencial (direito de audiência prévia).

Tendo em conta os limites de caracteres impostos pela plataforma, por um lado, e a extensão dorelatório e da decisão, por outro, os vícios que lhe são imputados estão desenvolvidos em documentoem formato pdf que se anexará à plataforma, para o qual se remete e cujo conteúdo, por brevidade,se dá aqui por integralmente reproduzido, e constitui (o documento em formato pdf), para todos osefeitos legais, o efectivo recurso da Cespu sobre a referida decisão e relatório.

Termos em que, e nos mais de Direito, e com o sempre mui douto suprimento de V. Exas., deverá opresente recurso ser julgado procedente, por provado, e, consequentemente, revogada a deliberaçãorecorrida, bem como, por estarem reunidos todos os requisitos legais, seja substituída por outra quedefira a acreditação do novo ciclo de estudos.

7. Documento anexo (Português e Inglês, PDF, máx. 150kB): (impresso na página seguinte)

pág. 1 de 1

Page 2: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

Anexos

Page 3: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

���

�������ABC�DA��EA�FD��������B�A�C���A��A��������������������������������������������������������������A �����A �����A �����A ���� ��������AD!"��!��A��B��B����AD��D�#���"$%B�%��A�&B��A D� �"' D�� �����AD!"��!��A��B��B����AD��D�#���"$%B�%��A�&B��A D� �"' D�� �����AD!"��!��A��B��B����AD��D�#���"$%B�%��A�&B��A D� �"' D�� �����AD!"��!��A��B��B����AD��D�#���"$%B�%��A�&B��A D� �"' D�� � ���� � D � ( �� D � ( �� D � ( �� D � ( � )�� D!�!B"A�!FDA��!�!�AB"A��A��*B!�!�DA%� DDAB"A+ (�B� "�,�%!�!��� ��A�!"-D�� �.�B!��A��!��A%����������B�A�C���A�/���B��"D!0��(��!"!�!��A����1����1(��A�B�� �!%DA��"!0�� ��A�B��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"������A�2��3B%�!��4���-*�%!��/���%!�!��5�!6�A7(��A�(�!� �!FD�*������!D"�*������8�A��A*��B"A���� ��A*��!�AB"� �B �8�9�������(��A��:�������;(�<�A�!�D��!���DA*��A��A�� D*!B�=!0���A�,�B%��B!�AB"�������B�A�C���A��A�������!�/*3B%�!��A�/�!��!0���A�/%DA��"!0�������B��B����AD��D(�FA��%������DA*��A������D�%A���AB"����A�DA�������A��A%��>A��DA�!"��!��5�!�!��!0���A�5�!%DA��"!0����!���B�"�"� �0>A���A�AB��B�����AD��D�A������A���%�%��� ��A�A�"���� (��B"AD�� D����� A %� D� �A %� D� �A %� D� �A %� D� � ��!<�A�!��A%���� (�B����A*��B"A��"AD����A�,�B�!�AB"�� ?��

/+/+/+/+ �B <� !�D!�AB "� ?�B <� !�D!�AB "� ?�B <� !�D!�AB "� ?�B <� !�D!�AB "� ? �����

�� @���B�A�C� ��A�/���B��"D!0�� �)�/+ (��� D��A��FAD!0�� ��A����1����1(��A%���� �2B�� �!%DA��"!D�� �%�%�� ��A�A�"����7���

�� /�� D!�DA%� DDAB"A�B�� ��A�%�B,� D�!�%���� �"A� D�A��AB"��� ��A%��- D�� ��!�DA,AD��!��A��FAD!0�� ���

;� ��B�� ��A�%�B,�D�!���D�%�B���AD!D�<�A�!<�A�!��A��FAD!0����!�A%A(�A��*AD!�(��A����AD�����A%����<�A�!��B<��B!�(��A� �*B!�!�AB"A����A%�� ��A�,!�"!��A�,�B�!�AB"!0��(��A�ADD��B���� DA������"�� (��A�ADD� �B���� DA������"����A���DA�"���A%�� ��A���� �!0�� ��A��A�(��A���� �!0�� ��� �� D�B%A� �� ��!��*�!��!�A�A��A�� DA"AD�0�� ��A�,� D�!���!�A�A��AB%�!��)��DA�"� ��A�!���3B%�!�� D$��!+ ���BAC!���(�

��

4+4+4+4+ D� � � � A%�� �D� � � � A%�� �D� � � � A%�� �D� � � � A%�� � ???? �����4 � � � �4 � � � �4 � � � �4 � � � � BA%�� � �A � ,! �"! � �A � ,� B �!�AB "! 0�� ?BA%�� � �A � ,! �"! � �A � ,� B �!�AB "! 0�� ?BA%�� � �A � ,! �"! � �A � ,� B �!�AB "! 0�� ?BA%�� � �A � ,! �"! � �A � ,� B �!�AB "! 0�� ? �����

1� ��B,� D�A��A�DA,AD�� (�� ��/(�!"D!�$���!��A��FAD!0�� �A��%D��A(��A%���� �2B�� �!%DA��"!D�� �%�%�� ��A�A�"����7���

: � ���AB"AB�AD��!�DA%� DDAB"A(�!��A��FAD!0���DA%�DD��!�B���A�"'���,�%�AB"A�AB"A�,�B�!�AB"!�!(�� �<�A(��!D!�����A������A,A�"�� (�A<���!�A�5�,!�"!��A�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��

�� � �!��AD�!�A(�!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%�DD��!�B���A�"'�,�B�!�AB"!�!�A��"AD����<�A��AD��"!�!�DA%� DDAB"A(���D�����!�� (��AD%AFAD�� ��A��

�AD�!�A�D� ��AB"��� �A�!�%!B%A(�A(���D���"D���!��(�!�DAAB�AD����"AD��!�� D!"��� ��AD%�DD�����A�� ��/�)�!D!��A%���D�%�B,� D�A��A%����+ ����� /���A,�%�3B%�!��<�A�!��A��FAD!0���DA%�DD��!�!�DA�AB"!�!�A�"A�BA�A�(�%��A0!�(��A��A���*�(�%���!���,�%� ��!�A�A����AB"�,�%!D(�%���!�

� DA%���� �A�� �D�*� D�BA%A��'D��� (�!��AD�!�A�D!�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��!<�A�!��A��FAD!0�� ���9� E�%AD"� �<�A(��A�!%� D�� �%���!��A��FAD!0�� (�A�"'�!��A��!�2A��%�B%�D�FB%�!�%���!�DA%��AB�!0�� �A�!�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��!�

�������� ��A�/�!��!0�� ���"ADB!7���� � D�DG�AG�!(�AB"�� (�<�A�!�,�B�!�AB"!0����!��A��FAD!0���$�!�<�A�%�B�"!�����A�!"-D���,�B!���!�����������A�/�!��!0�����"ADB!�)�/�+������ �%A�A(���D$�(�<�A�!��A��FAD!0��(��A������A�DA�A"AD��!D!��A�!"-D���,�B!���!��/�(��B"A*D!(�B����B"������!�B�"�,�%!0���A(���D"!B"�(�

B!���!�,�B�!�AB"!0�� (��� �� ��!D'*D!,�� ������ .�%!B�� �!�DA%� DDAB"A�B!��6���!���FDA�!�DA�!0���<�A(�A��"AD�����A�,�B�!�AB"!0��(��A�A�"!FA�A%A�AB"DA�!<�A�A��������!D'*D!,���

A�� �"A� D��� ��A�!"- D�� �.�B!���!��/������� H� "� �$(��A���!�DA�!0����A�%����A�AB"��)����AC!(��A�!�,�B�!�AB"!0�������A�!"-D���,�B!��%����A�AB"!�!�<�A�%�B�"!��!��A%���� �

,�B!�+ �����A���!�DA�!0�� ��A�A�%����� �)��"� �$(��A�!�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��!��A%���� �,�B!��A�%�� ��!�%�B�"!B"A��� ��A�!"- D�� �,�B!�+ ����;� HB�A�AB�AB"A�AB"A��A�"!��A,�%�3B%�!�A(�%�B�A<�AB"A�AB"A(��!���,�%� ��!�A��B"AD�DA"!"��!�<�A�!��A��!�DA�DA�AB"!��!D!�!�

DA%� DDAB"A(�!��AD�!�A�$�<�A�!��A��FAD!0���DA%�DD��!��!�A%A�����A%�� ��A�,!�"!��A�,�B�!�AB"!0����!��A��FAD!0��(�"!B"��A��"AD�����A�,!%"� �%�����A���DA�"� ��

��1� ����D��A�D� ���*!D(��� D<�A�!��A��FAD!0�� �B�� �A�"'�,�B�!�AB"!�!�A��"AD�����A���DA�"� ���

Page 4: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

���

�: � ����A,A�"� (��!��A��FAD!0���B���%�B�"!�<�!�<�AD�DA,AD3B%�!�!���B�D�!"������A*!���<�A�"AD����AD������A�F!�A�5��A%���� �"��!�!����� � ����A*�B�� ���*!D(�!��A��FAD!0�� �B�� �A�"'�"!�F$����,�%�AB"A�AB"A�,�B�!�AB"!�!�A��"AD�����A�,!%"� ������ ����"� ��� D���,ADAB"A��� D�AB���A�D!=�� ��AB�� ��AC!���(����9� ����D��A�D� ���*!D(���D�A�"!D�!��A��FAD!0����AC!�!��A�%�B%A�"����!*���A�!F�"D!%"��(��A��D��������A�<�!�<�AD�%�B%DA"�=!0�� (��� �

<�!�� ��������F ���"!��<�A�!�DA%� DDAB"A�!�DAAB�!�� ��AB"��� �A�!�%!B%A��!��A%���� �DA%� DD��!������ � /�"A"� �� ��AD!�AB"A�A�A����,�%!"��� (�%�B�"!��!��A��FAD!0���<�A�2���%�B"A6�����D�*D!�'"�%����A��'D�!� ��B��!�A��%�DD�%� �!DA��A�

DA��A%"��!���A"��� ��*�!���A�AB��B� ���� �"A� �%!���� �AB��B� �� D$G*D!��!�� �A�,�%!��!<�$���� �A��*��� �!����;�8�%�%�� 7������ /��A��FAD!0�� �B�� �%�B%DA"�=!(��� D$�(�<�!�� ���� �!���B��!�A��%�DD�%� �!DA��<�A��!�A%A���A�"!�� ��B��,�%�3B%�!� ������ D!��A��!� ,� D�!� <�A� "!�F$�� B�� � %�B%DA"�=!� !� %DA"�%!� *AB$D�%!�<�A�,!=(�����AC!(�B�� �C��"�,�%!��� D<�A�$����%�B"A6����

� D�*D!�'"�%������ �"A� �%����� �AB��B� �� D$G*D!��!�� �A�,�%!��!<�$���� �A��*��� �!����;�8�%�%�� ������ D� ��A�����D�F�A�!��!�A%A�!��A��FAD!0���<�!B���%!D!%"AD�=!�!��A%"���<�A��!DA%A��"AD�DA�A�FB%�!�B� ��A��%�B"A�"� (�%����

�AC!������A*��B"A� ?�!� � �� �!B� ��A�A�"���� ?�2$����A�"� �)���"� �F'��%� +7I�F � !�!�DAB��=!*A�?�2$����%� �,�A�A�A��A��A��%!D�=��AD��B!��=!�� 7I���;� @�(� !�B�!(� <�!B�� (� "AB�� � �� D�DA,AD3B%�!�� �� �!B� ��A�A�"���� (��A�!,�D�!�<�A�2C'���!�%�!D!��A,�%�3B%�!�B!�� D���0�� ��A�

%���A"3B%�!���!�� �"D!B��AD�!��7����1� #�D<�A�$�<�A(�B� �AB"AB�AD��!��/(�$����A�"� �������"� �F'��%� �� �� �!B� ��A�A�"�����J���: � K�!B"� �!�A�"A���B"� (�!��A��FAD!0�� �B!�!���=����� � /��A��!�DA����"!��A��F"$��<�!B���<�A�"��B!������D<�A�$�<�A�!�!�DAB��=!*A��2$����%��,�A�A�A��A��A��%!D�=��AD��B!��=!�� 7�

���<�A��A,�%�3B%�!��!�DA�AB"!�� �� �!B� ��A�A�"�����B� �<�A�%�B%ADBA�5�2�D���0�� ��A�%���A"3B%�!���!�� �"D!B��AD�!��7������ E�BA�"!��A��!���BC!�<�A��A�AB<�!�D!�!,�D�!0�� �%�B�"!B"A��!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!��A�<�A�2����F CA%"������A�"A�%�%�� ��A�

A�"�����A�"���%���D��A"������A�!�!��3B%�!��A�����AD�!�A�D��!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0���<�A��D����!�� �AB��B� �!� �B A�A���� �;�8�%�%�� 7���

��9� �A�"A�F�F�"� (�,�%!��� D��AB��,�%!D�� �%�B%A�"� ��A�2�AD�!�A�D� �!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0�� 7����� � /�A�"A�B A�A�(�A��A���DAC� A=�����<�A�!�A�"A�DA��A�"� ��A���D'��!�� �!��!B"A(�,�%!�"!�F$����D�%�B%DA"�=!D�!�2*D!B�A����AD� ��!�A��A�

"A�!�7��A���F��%!0>A��!,���!�!�5�DA%� DDAB"A�!�� ���%����%�B%A�"���2�B�A�"�*!��DA��<�!��,�%!���7�A��A�2�D�*D!�!�%�AB"A,�%� �!�A<�!�� 7��

�;�� @��A����C� A=� ��A�DA%�!"����A��"AD�����A�,�B�!�AB"!0����A����A�,!=AD�<�!B��(�A��CA�"� ��A�%�B%�����(��A���=�<�A�!�� D����"!�

!�DA�AB"!�!�B���%���DA����DA<����"����!D!�!�D��!0��(��A�(���D$�(�AB�B%�!D�<�A�DA<����"���)�A�"��������!�AB!��!�*�B�+ (�A��%�B%DA"� (�$�<�A�B�� ���� �DA��A�"!��� ���

�;�� AB���A�"!�,!�"!�"!B"���!�� �*D!�A�<�!B���!��A%�����$�"�"!��AB"A������!�<�!B"��!���,�B�!�AB"����A���DA�"� �A��<�A�!��AB"!���;�� ��"!���A,�%�3B%�!��<�A��A�!��B"!��5��A%���� �,�B!�(�A�"AB�A�G�A�"!�F$��!� �"A� D��� ��A�!"- D�� �.�B!����;;� �!��AD�!�A(��!D!�B�� ��A�"�!D(�"!�F$��� ��A�!"- D�� �A�"'�DA� �A"� ��A�%�B%A�"����!*���A�!F�"D!%"�� (��;1� DA�%�B%A�"���<�A(��AD�!�A�D!�AB"A(�B!�!���=A�L���;: � E����� �<�A���%A�A�%���� �A��DA*� ��!�A��DA���� �2A���!D"A7�)��B"���;�;���(�;�;�;�(�����(���;�(�9���(�������A����;�+ ����;� � ����A,A�"� (�� ��A�!"- D�� �,�B!��$�%�����"� ��� D����AD������B"����A�!B'���A���;�� ���!�AB!���� �� ��A��A����B"���$�!"D�F�A�!�B� "!�BA*!"��!�!� ��A���� �!�DA�AB"!�� ��A�!�DA%� DDAB"A���

Page 5: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

;��

;9� �!�A��!*!��D!��!�� D�!�����%!����!�!�!��!0�� �$�����"��!(�B� ��AB"��� ��A�<�A���� �%���D��������DA<��� �"���A��*������A�!��A����;� � #!D!�!�$���A�"A��%!���(�<�A(�%�����A�����A(�%�B�"�"�A��!��!�� D�!(�!�!�!��!0�� �<�A�%�B�"!��� �DA�!"- D�� �DA�!"��!�AB"A�!�!�*�B��

��B"���A�DA<��� �"���$�!��A�<�A��- ��!D"A�$�<�A�A�"�� �%���D���� ����1�� �A��A��%!���(���<�A�%�B�"!����DA�!"- D��(�DA�!"��!�AB"A�!�%!�!����������B"���A��<�A�"�� (�$�!�AB!��!�A��DA���� �2A���!D"A7���1�� @�<�A��A�!,�*�D!��!B�,A�"!�AB"A��B��,�%�AB"A��!D!�<�A�!�DA%�DDAB"A��A�����!�!�AD%AFAD��� ��A���AD�!�A�D� ��AB"��� �A�!�%!B%A���1�� H� "� �$(�%���!��B,� D�!0���%�B�"!B"A��� �DA�!"-D��(�B���AB"�����A�<�A�!�AB!���!D"A��A�����A"AD��B!�� ��"A����CA�"� �!�!�!��!0�� �$�

%���D��!(�!�DA%� DDAB"A�B���%�B�A*�A���� ���FD!D�<�!��$�� ��A*�AB"��<�A(�B��!���"D!��AD��A%"��!(�!�A*!�!�AB"A�B�� �,� �� ����B�� �"AD'�� ��� � �%���D��� ��

�1;� @D!(�B�� ��!FAB���!�DA%�DDAB"A�<�!��$��A*�AB"��<�A�!�A*!�!�AB"A�B�� �"AD'�� ��� �%���D��� (�B�� ����A�!��A��!�!�%!B0!D�� �

�AB"��� ��!�,�B�!�AB"!0�� �<�A�A�"!D�!���F C!%AB"A�5��A%���� ���F �%AB��D!���11� D!��A��!�,� D�!�<�A(�B��!���"D!��AD��A%"��!(�A��A�,�D�%!��������(�B������AD'�!C��"!D����B����A�A�AB"�!���A���� ��A�!%DA��"!0�� �

!� �!�A*!�� ��B%���D��AB"� ��AD�,�%!�� ���1: � .�%!(��� �� (�%�!D� �<�A���DA�!"-D�� (�!������"!DG�A�!���=AD�<�A�� �%���D��AB"���A��A"AD��B!����DA<��� �"����A��AD�,�%!�)!�AB!�+ �2A��

�!D"A7(� �A�� ��=AD� <�A� �A*�AB"� � $� <�A� ,� �� �B%���D��� � )A� A�� <�A��A���!� $� <�A�,� �+ (�B�� �DA��A�"!�!�A��*3B%�!��A*!���A�,�B�!�AB"!0�� (��!D!�!�$���A�<�A�B�� �%� DDA���B�A�5�DA!���!�A��

�1� � /�B�!�"��!B�� ��� D�DA,AD3B%�!�� ��A�!"- D�� �,�B!�(�� ��A�����A��AD�,�%!�%���!��"���=!0�� ��!�A��DA���� �2���A�"� 7��1�� ��"!���A,�%�3B%�!���A�<�A��!�A%A�!��A��FAD!0���DA%� DD��!����(�%�����A�����A(�,�B�!�AB"!�� ��!D!�<�A�!�DA%�DDAB"A(�AB<�!B"���A��

�A�"�B!"'D�� (�����!��AD%AFAD�� ��A���AB"��� �A�!�%!B%A���19� @�<�A��A�!,�*�D!�A�"DA�!�AB"A�DA�A�!B"A���1� � #��AB�� �A�"!�DA�A�FB%�!��AD�!B!���!�!�A����!���AD��A%"��!��"A���D!�� ����"�B"!� ���:�� DA��A���*�(�B����A��!"� (��!D!�<�A�� ��A�"�B!"'D������!%"��)B��%!��(�!�DA%�DDAB"A+� %���DAAB�AB�� �� ��A���AB"��� �A�!�%!B%A� �

����!�!�DA%�!D�!���!�%� DDA%0�� �A�%�B,� D���!�A��A*!����:�� E!��"!�F$��B��!���"D!��AD��A%"��!(���,AD��!�B��"A���?��A����<�A�� �DA%�DDAB"A��A�%�B,�D�A�%���� �!%"��)<�A(�!��!B"AG�A(�B���

$�� �%!�� +(�B!�C ��-"A�A��A(�B��,�"�D�(�� DA"AB�AD�!�DA�AB"!D���!�B��!�%!B���!"�D!�)�!D!����B����%�%�� ��A�A�"����+ (�$�A��AB%�!���AD%AFAD�B���ADD���A��<�A��B%�DDA��!B"AD�� D�AB"A��!D!�<�A�B�� ����%��A"!�B� �,�"�D!�B��!�B��!�%!B���!"�D!�<�A�����!�!�DA�AB"!D��

�:�� ������A�����A(�A��A%�DDA����A����"�(�B���$����� �<�A��AD�,�%!�B� �%!�� (����"� �<�A�!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!��!�A%A��� ��A%�� ��A�

,�B�!�AB"!0�� ���:;� M��!��!(�!� ��B��,�%�3B%�!���!��A��FAD!0���A��"AD�����A�,�B�!�AB"!0���B����A�DA�"D�B*A��!�AB!��!���!�<�A�"�� ��AD!�AB"A�

<�!B"�"!"��!�)�A�A�"!D����B���A�"!D�,�B�!�AB"!�!I�A�A�"!B�� �,�B�!�AB"!�!(��A����"� �������%� + (�B� �%!�� (��A��$,�%A��A�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��

�:1� @��D�F �A�!�����$,�%A�,�B�!�AB"!0����!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!�$�"!�F$��<�!��"!"��� �A�"D!��=G�A�B��!�%�B"D!��0�� �AB"DA�!�

,�B�!�AB"!0���<�A�A���"A�)�����B"���A����"!�,!%"�!�(����"��<�A(�B��<�A�!� ���DA�"� �DA��A�"!(�A�!��BA���"A��� D�%����A"� + �%���� �DA��A%"��� ��AB"��� ��A%��- D�� ��

�:: � D� �"A� D��!��A��FAD!0���DA%� DD��!(�A���!D"�%��!D��� ���8�A�;�8��!D'*D!,� ��� ���B"� �����!�B� "�,�%!0�� �DA%AF ��!��A�!�DA%� DDAB"A(�

A�"D!A�G�A�%DA"�%!��BA*!"��!��<�A� ��A�A�A�F�D!���ADD� �A��<�A�!��AB"!��)%�B,� D�A��A��A��B�"D!D'��!�� �!��!B"A+ � �"AD�� �DA�A�!�� ��!D!�!�,� D�!0�� ��!��A%���� �"��!�!��

�:� � /��%DA"�%!��BA*!"��!��DA*��"!�!���DAB�A�G�A(���D�����!��(�%������%�B"A6�����D�*D!�'"�%����!���B��!�A��%�DD�%� �!DA��A�� �!B� �

�A�A�"���� (�A(��� D���"D� ��!�� (�%���� �B A�A���A��B�A�"�*!0�� ��A�AB�� ����� ���:�� ��B%DA"�=!B�� (� ��=G�A(� B!� �A��FAD!0�� (� <�A� 2���%�B"A6����� D�*D!�'"�%����A��'D�!� ��B��!�A��%�DD�%� �!DA��A�DA��A%"��!��

�A"��� ��*�!���A�AB��B������"A� �%!���A�AB��B��� D$G*D!��!���A�,�%!��!<�$���� �A��*��� �!����;�8�%�%�� 7�7@�� �!B� ��A�A�"�����$�

Page 6: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

1��

���A�"� �)���"��F'��%�+(�!�!�DAB��=!*A��$����%��,�A�A�A��A��A��%!D�=��AD��B!��=!�� (�A�C'���!�%�!D!��A,�%�3B%�!�B!��D���0�� ��A�%���A"3B%�!��"D!B��AD�!�� (�%��� (��� D�A�A���� (����DAAB�A��D���� (�NA�"�� ��A���3B%�!(�HB�A�"�*!0�� ���AB �%!7��

�:9� &�!�"!��%�B%�����(�!�$���A�� ����!D�<�A(�B���"AD������ �!D"�*��;��8�;����DO��:�����;(�!�A���"3B%�!��A����%�D����A����"�D!�AB"��

$�,!%� �"!"��� (�A�"'�A���!B�,A�"!�%�B"D!��0���%������DA%�BCA%��AB"����!��/�(��AD"�����B� ��A�!"- D�� �.�B!�(��A� �*B!�!�AB"A?�!� 2����FCA%"������� �%�%�� ��A�A�"���������%���!D'�A���A��"AD����A�!�"��>A��!�%�%�� ��A�A�"�������B��"D!������D��B�"�"��0>A��

�A�DA,AD3B%�!7�)��B"� ����������DA�!"- D��� ��!��/�+ I�F � 2!�F�!�A�"D�"�D!0�� �*AD!���!�%����BAB"A�%�DD�%� �!D7�)��B"����������A������������DA�!"- D��� ��!��/�+ I�%� 2!�%�AD3B%�!������FCA%"������A,�B �����%���!��������A�A�"D!"$*�!��!��B�"�"��0��(��� D�� �B!��A��A%�!��=!�!�B��!�'DA!��!��

��3B%�!���!�B��!�A��!�!6�A(�%���� ��D�CA%"��A��%!"���(�%�AB"A,�%� �A�%� �"�D!���!��B�"�"� �0�� 7�)��B"���;���;�(�;���1�(�;���: �(�;������A�;���;������DA�!"- D��� ��!��/�+ I�

�� 2����FCA%"������A,�B ������A�A���DA�!D!D��D�,�����B!�� �%���%!�!%��!�A��A�DA!��=!D��B�A�"�*!0��(�%���B�%!D����DA�� �"!������ ��A��"D!F!�C��!�!���3B%�!��A��A%�!��=!�!��A�B���A��A%�!��=!�!��A�� D����AD���� D�*DA����"A%B��-*�%� (���%�!��A�%� �"�D!�7�)��B"� �;���1������DA�!"- D�� ��!��/�+ I�

�:� � @���AC!(�!��/�(�B���DA�!"-D����<�A�,���A��"�B��(�A���!D"�%� �!D�B� ��A�!"- D�� �,�B!�(�"A%A�%�B���AD!0>A������"��!��5�%!B���!"�D!�

!�DA�AB"!�!��A�!�DA%� DDAB"A���

��� ��B"���(����/(�B!��A%�����<�A�"��!(�%����<�A��*B�D!�A��!�!�!��!0�������"��!(��A%���B���A���AB"��� �BA*!"��� (�%�����A�!<�A�!��%�B���AD!0>A��B�� �A���"���A����

���� ��"!���(����� (��AD!B"A���!���"AB���!�%�B"D!��0���AB"DA�!��A%������D����"!�A����,�B�!�AB"���<�A�,�D�!��AB"A�!����"AB"!�(�� �

<�A�%�B��F�"!B%�!�����A%�� ��A�,!�"!�����B��,�%�3B%�!��A�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ������ @��A�����A��AD�,�%!�%���!�%�B%����� �%�B�"!B"A��� �;�8��!D'*D!,� ��!��A%���� �DA%� DD��!����;� �!��AD�!�A(��!D!�!�$�������A%����A��<�A�!��A��!��B%�DDA�)A�<�A��AD����A�AB����������!�� �!��!B"A+(�A�"'�A��%�B"D!��0���%�����

"A� D�����DA�!"-D��� ��!��/�(�A��A��A%�!�(�<�!B����A�DA%�BCA%A�2!�A���"3B%�!��A���F��%!0>A��%�AB"A,�%!���� ��A���!����%AB"A�B! �'DA!�� DA����B!B"A��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"�����A��DA���"!���B"ADB!%��B!�� �%���DA��������D��!DA��B���6�"�����%�B%��!B��7�)��B"��� ��������DA�!"- D��� � �� � �/�+ � ���!�B�!�� �DA%�BCA%��AB"� ��!�2A���"3B%�!��A�!%"����!�A�%�AB"A,�%!(�"A%B� �-*�%!� (�%� �"�D!�� �A�!D"A�"�%!���A�AB������!��B!�'DA!����%�%�� ��A�A�"�����A��B"A*D!�!��A���D� CA%"����!D%AD�!� �B!%��B!�� �A��B"ADB!%��B!��7�)��B"� �� �;������DA�!"- D��� ��� ��/�+ ��

��1� @���AC!(�!��/�(�B���DA�!"-D����<�A�,���A��"�B��(�A���!D"�%� �!D�B� ��A�!"- D�� �,�B!�(�"A%A�%�B���AD!0>A������"��!��5�%!B���!"�D!�

!�DA�AB"!�!��A�!�DA%� DDAB"A����: � ��B"���(����/�B!��A%�����<�A�"��!�%����<�A��*B�D!�A��!�!�!��!0�� �����"��!(��A%���B�� �A���AB"��� �BA*!"��� (���!��A=��!�� �

%�����A�!<�A�!��%�B���AD!0>A��B�� �"��A��A��� ��� �,� D���!�!� ������ � ��"!����%DA�FB%�!�<�!��"!"��!�"A��"!�F$����!�"D!��0���<�!B"�"!"��!?�!�!�!��!0�� �DA!��=!�!�5�%!B���!"�D!��!�DA%�DDAB"A(��AD"��!�

B� ��A�!"- D�� �,�B!�(�$(�B!��!�� D�!�����%!��� (���� �"��!I�B�� ��F�"!B"A(�!��A%���� �,�B!���!��B� ��AB"��� ��A�B�� �!%DA��"!0��P����� ��"!���(����� (�A���!��A=��!�� (��AD!B"A���!�%�B"D!��0�� �AB"DA�!��A%���� �� D����"!�A����,�B�!�AB"���<�A�,� D�!��AB"A�!�

���"AB"!�(�� �<�A�%�B��F�"!B%�!�����A%�� ��A�,!�"!�����B��,�%�3B%�!��A�,�B�!0�� ����9� ���� AB"A�A(�A�%���F!�A�B!��D!=>A��A����"!�(�%�B%�� �G�A�<�A���DA�!"-D�� ��!�A%A�����A%�� ��A�,!�"!�����B��,�%�AB"A�,�B�!�AB"!0�� (�

� �<�!�����>A�!�DA,� D���!0�� ��� �DA�!"- D�� ��� A��%�B%A�AD(��

�4 �� � � � DD� � B � � � � DA � � � �4 �� � � � DD� � B � � � � DA � � � �4 �� � � � DD� � B � � � � DA � � � �4 �� � � � DD� � B � � � � DA � � � � � � "� �� � "� �� � "� �� � "� � ???? �����

�� � ��B,� D�A��A�DA,AD���!B"AD�� D�AB"A(����AB"��� ��A%��- D�� ��!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!�$��A�B�� �!%DA��"!0�� ��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"���� ���

��� �%A�A(���D$�(�<�A����,�B�!�AB"���A��<�A�!��AB"!��!��A��FAD!0��� ��!D!�!�$�������A%����!B"AD��D�AB"A��B��%!���� �B�� ��A��AD�,�%!���

���� H� "� �$(�!�!B'���A�<�A�,���A,A%"�!�!�A�<�A�,���� �!��!�!�B!��A��FAD!0���DA%� DD��!�DA�!"��!�AB"A�!������AD������B"�����CA�"���!�

!�!��!0�� �B�� �$�!�%� DDA%"!����

Page 7: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

:��

��� ���A��ADD����A�!B'���A�A�"�� (��A��A���*� (�A���AB%�!����B!�%�B"D!��0�� �AB"DA�!��A%���� �� D����"!�A����,�B�!�AB"���<�A�,� D�!��AB"A�!����"AB"!���

��;� #�D���"D!���!�!�D!�(�� �<�A��A�����A�B���!D"�*���:1��!��9���� ��DA�AB"A�DA%�D����A��B�"D!�<�A�B����A��AD�,�%!������ DA������"���

A��<�A�!��AB"!��!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!����1� ����A,A�"� (�B����A��AD�,�%!��!��!�A*!�!���A,�%�3B%�!���� �� �!B� ��A�A�"�����A�����%�B"A6����� D�*D!�'"�%����!���B��!�A��

%�DD�%� �!DA� ����: � ��B�� ��A��AD�,�%!�(��A��A���*�(���D<�A(�%����$�DA%�BCA%�����A�!��/�(�2����FCA%"��������%�%�� ��A�A�"�������� �%���!D'�A�� �A��

"AD����A�!�"��>A��!�%�%�� ��A�A�"�������B��"D!������ D��B�"�"� �0>A���A�DA,AD3B%�!7�)��B"� ����������DA�!"- D��� ��!��/�+ ����� � D!��A��!�,� D�!�<�A�!��/��DA%�BCA%A�2!�F�!�A�"D�"�D!0���*AD!���!�%����BAB"A�%�DD�%��!D7�)��B"����������A������������DA�!"- D��� �

�!��/�+ ������ @��!�B�!�2!�%�AD3B%�!������FCA%"������A,�B�����%���!��������A�A�"D!"$*�!��!��B�"�"� �0��(���D���B!��A��A%�!��=!�!�B��!�'DA!��!��

��3B%�!���!�B��!�A��!�!6�A(�%���� ��D�CA%"��A��%!"���(�%�AB"A,�%� �A�%��"�D!���!��B�"�"� �0�� 7�)��B"���;���;�(�;���1�(�;���: �(�;������A�;���;������DA�!"- D��� ��!��/�+ ��

��9� A��� ����!D�<�A(�B���"AD������ �!D"�*� �;��8�;��� �DO��:�����;(�!�A���"3B%�!��A����%�D�� ��A����"� D!�AB"� �$�,!%� �"!"��� ����� � ��B���AD!B�����A����"�(�B����A����A(�����(��A��!D��A�%�B%���D��A���"D!�,�D�!�<�A�B����AC!�B���AB"��� ��A�DA%�BCA%AD�<�A�� �!B� �

�A�A�"�����A�����%�B"A6�����D�*D!�'"�%����!���B��!�A��%�DD�%� �!DA��B����!�A%A���!���A,�%�3B%�!��<�A��CA����� �����"!�!��)�!�(�%�����A��!��AB"��(�B���%�B%DA"�=!�!�+(���(��A����AB��(�<�A�DA��A�"!�����DA<����"����DA���"���B��!D"�*� ��� �8(�B �8��(��� �DO���:����;��

�9�� D!��A��!�,� D�!�<�A�"!�F$��B�� ��A��AD�,�%!�!�!��3B%�!��A�2!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0�� 7���9�� /� A�"A� DA��A�"� (� A��A�FA���AD%AFA�!�DA%� DDAB"A(�!�!,�D�!0�� ��!�!��3B%�!��A����2!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0�� 7��B�%D�"!�B!�

�A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!�!��AB"!(�B� �A��AB%�!�(�B!��BA���"3B%�!��A����%AB"D� ��A��B�A�"�*!0�� ���9�� @���AC!(�A�%�����A��A��B�"D!D'��!�� �!��!B"A(�!��AB"!�B����DA������"��<�A�B������A��AD�%�B���AD!�� �)A�DA�A�!�� ��!D!�A�"A�

A,A�"� + ��� D�%!DA%AD��A�F!�A��A*!����9;� @�<�A�$���,�%�AB"A��!D!(��� D�� ���- (�C��"�,�%!D�!�DA��*!0�� ��� �!%"� �DA%� DD��� ���91� ��B"���(�A��B�A�AB�AB"A�AB"A��!���A*!���!�A�����DA������"�(�!��AD�!�A�$�<�A�!�DA%� DDAB"A�A�!�%!B���!"�D!�<�A�!�DA�AB"���

�DAAB%CA�"��������DA<����"����A*!�� ��!D!�!�!%DA��"!0����A����%�D����A�;�8�%�%�� ��A�A�"����(�� DA���"���B!��!�ABA!��%+ �A��+��� �B �8����� �!D"�*� ��� �8��� �DO���:����;��

�9: � ����"�B�� (� �� D"!B"� (� B!� DA%� DDAB"A� !<���� � <�A(� B��� "AD���� �!� �A�(� �A� ���A�<�!��,�%!D�%��������AD�!�A�D� �!�F�AB"A��A�

�B�A�"�*!0�� ���9� � @�<�A(�!��'� (��!���AB�� �DA%�BCA%��� ��A�!��/�(�!� �DA*��"!D�)����"��!�AB"A+ ?�

!� /�A���"3B%�!��A���F��%!0>A��%�AB"A,�%!���� ��A���!����%AB"A�B!�'DA!�� DA����B!B"A��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"�����A��DA���"!���B"ADB!%��B!�� �%���DA����� ��� D��!DA��B���6 �"�����%�B%� �!B���)��B"� �� ���+ I�

F � /�A���"3B%�!��A�!%"����!�A��%�AB"A,�%!�(�"A%B��-*�%!�(�%��"�D!���A�!D"A�"�%!���A�AB�� ����!��B!�'DA!��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"�����A��B"A*D!�!��A���D� CA%"����!D%AD�!� �B!%��B!�� �A��B"ADB!%��B!�� �)��B"� �� �;�+ I�

�9�� @��!�B�!�<�!B���� ��/���A��D�B�B%�!��A�,� D�!�����"��!�<�!B"� �5��<�!��,�%!0>A���� �%� D�� ���%AB"A�)��B"���1���(�1�1��A�1�: �+ ���99� �B�B%�!B��G�A�� �� ��"A�!��A�!�!��!0�� ��A��A�A��ABC� ��� ��A���!����%AB"A�%���������B"� �����"��� �)��B"� �1�: �+ ���9� � @D!(��A��A�DA%�BCA%A�<�A���%�D�����%AB"A�$�<�!��,�%!�� �A(�!"$��A��� (��D���"���(�B���AB"����A��<�A�A���"A����F��%!0>A� (�A�<�A�

��� ��A�AB�� �������� D� CA%"����A��B�A�"�*!0�� (�$��� D<�A�A���"A����2�AD�!�A�D� �!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0�� 7������ @�(��A�� ��AB��(�$�,�D�A�!�%�B��%0����!�DA%� DDAB"A�<�A�$���,�%�AB"A��!D!�� ��DAAB%C��AB"������DA<��� �"���� DA���"���B��!D"�*� ����8(�

B �8��(��� �DO���:����;(����� ���� AB"A�A(�A��A���DAC�A=� �����!B�,A�"A��$,�%A��A�,�B�!�AB"!0��(�!��A��FAD!0���!��AB"!�A���DA������"���ADD!��� (��A�� �<�A(�

"!�F$����D�A�"!�D!=�� (��A����>A�!���!�DA��*!0�� ��

Page 8: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

���

�� A��%�B%A�AD(����

4 �; � �4 �; � �4 �; � �4 �; � � � DD� � B � � � � DA � � � � � � "� � � �A � � �DA �"� ��DD� � B � � � � DA � � � � � � "� � � �A � � �DA �"� ��DD� � B � � � � DA � � � � � � "� � � �A � � �DA �"� ��DD� � B � � � � DA � � � � � � "� � � �A � � �DA �"� �BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �A � �A �?BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �A � �A �?BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �A � �A �?BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �A � �A �? �����

��� ��B,� D�A��A�DA,AD�� �!B"AD�� D�AB"A(�!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!�B�� �$�%�!D!�<�!B"� �!���,�B�!�AB"���A��<�A�!��AB"!���

�;� ��B�� �$�%�!D!(��A��A���*�(���D��AD�"�"!��AB"A������!�<�!B"� �!���,�B�!�AB"����A���DA�"� �A��<�A�!��AB"!(��!��"!�F$����D�!�DA�AB"!D���!�,�B�!�AB"!0�� �<�A(��� ���B"� ��A����"!�,!%"�!�(�$�%�!D!�AB"A��A,�%�"'D�!�A�%�B"D!��"- D�!��

��1� /�A�!D��!����,�%� ��!�A���B"AD�DA"!"��!��� D���%!�����A�!���A,�%�3B%�!���A�,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��A�<�A��!�A%A�!��A��FAD!0�� (�!�

DA%� DDAB"A� �!�B�!�<�A��A��%AD"A=!��)�A�!��D!=>A��!B"AD�� D�AB"A�A����"!�+ � �!���"A�<�A�!��A��!�����!�!��AB"!D�B� �B�� ��DAAB%C��AB"� ��� �DA<��� �"� ��!��B�A�"�*!0�� (�� DA���"� �B� �!D"�*� ��� �8(�B �8��(�!�ABA!��%+ �A��+ (��� �DO���:����;��

��: � A��A�F!D*� ��A�"����� �<�A�,�����"� �!B"AD��D�AB"A�!�A�"A�DA��A�"��)A���!D"�%� �!D(�� �ADD��A��<�A�!��AB"!+ (�!�DA%� DDAB"A�!�AB!��

%�B�A*�A���F����D� �A��!F�"D!%"�� �!��%�B���AD!0>A��%�B�"!B"A���!��A��FAD!0��(�A���!D"�%� �!D(����;�8��!D'*D!,���� ���B"� �����!�B� "�,�%!0�� (�!� �%�"!�� �B� D�!"��� ���

��� � AB���<�A�A�"!���F��B0��(�B���� �*B�,�%!(��!��!D"A��!�DA%�DDAB"A(���DA%�BCA%��AB"������,!%"���A��<�A�!��A��!�!��AB"!� �<�A�$�

� ��A����<�A���=AD(�B����DA������"���%�B�"!B"A���!��A��FAD!0�� � �"�� ����%� �� �)DA%�BCA%��AB"� ��� + �!%AD"� ��A���!�"!����F��B0�� ��

���� �� B�� � � �*B�,�%!� � � DA%�BCA%��AB"� � ���� ,!%"��� A�� <�A� !��A��!� !��AB"!(� �A�!�� ��� �A��D!=�� ��A�<�A(�%�B,� D�A�,� ����"� �

!B"AD�� D�AB"A(�!�DA%� DDAB"A�%�B���AD!�<�A�!��A��FAD!0�� �!��AB"!�A���DA������"���ADD!��� ���

�9� D!��A��!�,� D�!�<�A�"!�F$��B���� �*B�,�%!���DA%�BCA%��AB"�����!%AD"���!<�A�!�%�B%DA"!���AD!0����A���F��B0�� (����"� �<�A�!�DA%� DDAB"A��A�!����%�D�!�,D�B"!��AB"A(�B���!�AB!����D�B����A��AD�,�%!DA������DA������"���A��<�A�!��AB"!�)A�<�A��F�"!�5<�A�!���F��B0�� + (��!��"!�F$���A�!��D!=>A��<�A��A��!��!��!�A���D��

��� � D���>A�� �!D"�*�����8(�B �8��(����DO���:����;(�<�A�2��*D!���A����"�D�B����A"AD��B!���D!����� �%�BCA%��AB"�������!�A��A%�!���!�A�

�- ����A��AD�%�B,AD��� ��A�!���B��AD� ��!�A������B�"�"�"����B��AD� �"'D��� �<�A(�%����!"��!�AB"A?�QLR��%+ ��A��B�"DA��������D(�BA��!�'DA!(��� �DA%�D����C��!B���A�� D*!B�=!"�����BA%A��'D��� �5�DA!��=!0�� ��!��B�A�"�*!0�� I���+ ��A��B�"DA��������D(���D�������!"D!�$���!���!��!D"�%��!0������%��!F�D!0��(���������A�����%AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!��DA� (�A���B�"�"� �0>A��%�AB"A,�%!��A�"ADB!�(���!�A��AD�3B%�!�!%����!�!��A��B�A�"�*!0�� �%�B%DA"�=!�!�B��!��D���0�� �%�AB"A,�%!�A�!%!�$��%!�DA�A�!B"A��BA��A�D!����A�%�BCA%��AB"� ������!�A��A%�!���!�A7���

���� /�A�!D��A���DA<��� �"��DA�!"��� �5��B�A�"�*!0����A�AB<�!�D!D�B!����!��!�ABA!��%�"!�!� (��6���!��B�� �A���"A���A�<�A(�B� �%!�� (�!�DA%� DDAB"A�� DAAB%CA�%�!D!�A��BA<����%!�AB"A�� �A��*��� ��A�!�%�"!�!�!�ABA!�%+ ��

����� /��6���!(�B!��AD��A%"��!��!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!(����AD'�%� ��%!DG�A�<�!B"� �5�!�ABA!��+ ��

����� /�A�"A�DA��A�"� (�%�B�"!��!��A��FAD!0���<�A�2����FCA%"������A�"A�%�%�� ��A�A�"�����A�"�� �%���D��A"������A�!�!��3B%�!��A����

�AD�!�A�D� �!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0���<�A��D����!�� �AB��B� �!� �B A�A���� �;�8�%�%�� ��D� ���B"� ��A����"!�%�AB"A,�%� �� �H�G��"A��!,���!�� ���F��%!0>A��B��!�*D!B�A����AD� ��!�A��A�"A�!�����"!�����AD��� �B�� �$�!�D��D�!�!��!D!�%D�!D�����D� CA%"� �%�AB"A,�%� �A�"D�"�D!���%�����!��!��!�%DA"�%!��A��B�A�"�*!��DA��FA��<�!��,�%!����B!�'DA!��!����3B%�!���!�B��!�A��!�!6�A��.!�"!�����D�*D!�!�%�AB"A,�%� �!�A<�!��(�<�A��B"A*DA�!�,� D�!0���A��A,�B!�!��'DA!���A�A��A%�!��=!0���,�"�D!(���<�A�!��!���!��,!%"���� �H�G��B�� �"AD����%AB"D� ��A��B�A�"�*!0���!%DA��"!����A�!�.�M(�,!=�%���<�A�!�� D����"!�B�� �%���D!����DA<��� �"����!D!�!�D��!0�� 7�)��B"� ���+ ��

���;� A�FA���AD%AFA�!�DA%� DDAB"A(�!�!,�D�!0�� ��!�!��3B%�!��A����2!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0�� 7��B�%D�"!�B!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!�

!��AB"!(�B� �A��AB%�!�(�B!��BA���"3B%�!��A����%AB"D� ��A��B�A�"�*!0�� �!%DA��"!�� ��A�!�.�M���

��1� @���AC!(�!��AB"!�B����DA������"� �<�A�B�� ����A��AD�%�B���AD!�� �)A�DA�A�!�� ��!D!�A�"A�A,A�"� + ��� D�%!DA%AD��A�F!�A��A*!����

��: � ��B�� ����A��AD�%�B���AD!�����D<�A�!<�����<�A�!��A��A��*A�$�� ��� �A��AB"A�<�A��A��A��B�"DA�2������D�QLR���!�A��AD�3B%�!�!%����!�!��A��B�A�"�*!0���%�B%DA"�=!�!�B��!��D���0���%�AB"A,�%!�A�!%!�$��%!�DA�A�!B"A��BA��A�D!����A�%�BCA%��AB"�������!�A��A%�!���!�A7��

Page 9: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

���

���� �(��!D!�A��A�A,A�"� (�B�� �$�%�B��0�� �"AD����%AB"D� ��A��B�A�"�*!0�� �!%DA��"!�� ��A�!�.�M���

���� D!A�<�A�!��A��FAD!0���DA%� DD��!(�!��DA�A�!D�)BA*!"��!�AB"A+�!��BA���"3B%�!��A����%AB"D���A��B�A�"�*!0���%���!<�A�A��!"D�F�"�� (�A�"'�!��B%� DDAD�B!���� �!0�� ��!�%�"!�!�B� D�!��

���9� ��� �$(�%�!D!�AB"A(��� "� �� �<�A�!��A����=�P�

����� ��� �$(��A*�D!�AB"A(��A�"!�,� D�!�<�A�!��A�����A�A��A�A��AD��B"AD�DA"!�!�P�

����� ��"!�F$��B�� �$��A�"!�,�D�!�<�A�!��A��"A��� ��� ��B"AD�DA"!�!��A�!��/(�����(��A���"D!�,� D�!(���� ��%!D�!�!�B�� �!%DA��"!0�� ��A�;�8� �

%�%��� ��A�A�"�����<�A(�!%"�!��AB"A(�A�"�� �!%DA��"!��� (�%������� ����%!��� ?�!� D��"� D!�AB"� � A�� ��3B%�!�� .!D�!%3�"�%!�� �!� &#�

)C""� ?����*!DD!�����"�,,����"�%�DS*AD!��%�DS��ATJ��S!B�S�A%"���U���;V��S�D�*A�U�&�V��S"���S%�DS��*�!UDV��S%�D��S��U���:+?�!�..&#�B���"A��BABC��!��B��!�A�.�M(�A�"!B���!�*�B��������%AB"A���A��A�� D�*D!�!�!,���!����!��B��!�A��A�"ADB!� I�

F � D��"� D!�AB"� � A�� ��3B%�!�� .!D�!%3�"�%!�� �!� &B��AD� ��!�A� �A� �� ��FD!� "A�� � D*!B�=!0�� � ��3B"�%!�)C""� ?��TTT��%��"�,,�%��B��B�����"�D!�AB"��+?�!�..&��B����������BABC��!��B��!�A�.�M(�,!=AB��������%AB"A���!D"A��� ����������"D���%AB"D���.�M��

����� @�,!%"� ��A�!�DA%� DDAB"A�B���"AD���!��B��!�A��A��B�A�"�*!0���A��A�AB������AB"��!�!��!�!�A�DA%�BCA%��!��A�!�.�M(�B�� ����A��AD�

�B"AD�DA"!�� �%�����AB�� �� �B-B��� ��!�,!�"!��A�A��AD�3B%�!��!�DA%� DDAB"A�)A������A����A�FD��+ �!� �B A�A���!��B�A�"�*!0�� ���

���� ��B�� ����A��AD��B"AD�DA"!����A��!�,� D�!(��A��A���*� (�A�%�����A��A��B�"D!D'��!�� �!��!B"A(��A�!���*!0�� �A��B"A*D!0�� �������%AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!��DA���!�DA%�DDAB"A�!���"D���%AB"D����A��B�A�"�*!0���A�"ADB�� (��!��"!�F$����D�"AD���� �A�AB"!�� �!���!�� D-�D�!��B��!�A��A��B�A�"�*!0���A��A�AB������AB"�(��A��*B!�!�HH�/./�M(�!�<�!��"A��%�����FCA%"����!��B�A�"�*!0�� �B!�'DA!�B!�'DA!��A�.�� ���!"���*�!�)%!B%D� (���AB0!��%!D����!�%��!DA�(��!"���*�!�� D!�(�"���%� ��*�!+�A�B!�'DA!��A�#D���0����!�!6�A�)�� �� �0�� �!�F�AB"!�(��� �%���*�!(�����!"D�!(�%� ��!�����!��!6�A+� �A�<�A�%� DDA���B�A��5��'DA!���A��B�A�"�*!0���A�"D!"$*�%!��<�A�����D"!������'D����%�D������B��"D!����B���A�"!FA�A%��AB"����A�AB��B� ��!�DA%� DDAB"A�A�%�B"!��%���!�A��AD�3B%�!��A�%AD%!��A�����B�A�"�*!��DA�����"� D!��� (��!�� D�"!D�!�AB"A���%AB"A��!�"A��� ��B"A*D!����

���;� @�HH�./�M (�!�A�!D��A�B���A�"!D�!�!��!�!�BA��DA%�BCA%��!��A�!�.�M(�"A���A�AB������� �!%"����!�A���A��B�A�"�*!0�� ��B��!��D!��

��*B!���A�DA*��"� (���

��1� /� ���B"���A�!�DA%�DDAB"A(�A��E!D0���A����1(�"AD�� ������CA�"!�!���!�!���"�D�!��!�HB��A%0�� ��!����%!0�� �A��!���3B%�!�)HN��+ (�� �<�!��"A�A��� D��FCA%"����(�AB"DA���"D��(��AD�,�%!D��� �DA<��� �"���A��AB%�!�� ��A�,�B%��B!�AB"� (�"!B"� �*AD!�� (�%����A��A%A,�%�� (�� DA���"���B���!D"�*���;� �8�!�1: �8��� ��WH� �)OA��B �8��������(��A�����A�A"A�FD� + ��

���: � /�HN��(�B� ��A���A�!"-D�� �#DA����B!D(�B���A*�AB"��DA�!"����5�!�!��!0����!��B�A�"�*!0���)��B"������+(�%�B%�� ��<�A?�2B����F�"!B"A�A�"A�

%AB"D� �B���A�"!D�!�!��!���BA��DA%�BCA%�����A�!�.�M(�C'�� D� CA"���!"����!�A���A��B�A�"�*!0�� �A��A�AB�� ����AB"� �!�!��!�!��A�DA%�BCA%����(�%�B,�*�D!B���%���D��AB"���� �A�"����!���B!��!�ABA!���+�A�A+ ����/D"��1�8��� ��WH�(�A��%�BC�*!0���%������������"� �B���B8���A�;��� �/D"��1:X��� ��A������� ���!7��

���� � @���AC!(�A�"A�DA�!"- D�� �%�B�"�"� �����%�!D� �DA%�BCA%��AB"� ��� �%���D��AB"� �"� "!���� �A��*��� �A��"AD�����A*!�� (�DA,ADAB"A�!�

HB�A�"�*!0�� (��!D!�A�"!FA�A%��AB"����A�AB��B��%����&B��AD���!�A��)/D"�*��1�8+�A�HB�"�"�"���&B��AD��"'D����)/D"�*��1�8�<�A�DA,ADA�!���A��!��!�ABA!�(�DA��DA%��B!B����!D!���/D"�*��1�8+(�6B�%���A�"!FA�A%��AB"����A�AB��B��<�A����A����B��"D!D����"� D!�AB"�� ��

� ��B"�B�!B�� (������� ���DA�!"!�� �ADD� �)����!0����A��A�+ (�!�B�!�<�A�B��!��AD��A%"��!���*A�D!�AB"A����"�B"!(��B%�DDA����/�!� �B�� �DA�A�!D(�B!�!B'���A��!�

%!B���!"�D!(� !� A��AD�3B%�!� A� �B"A*D!0�� � �A��A�FD��� �!� DA%� DDAB"A�DA�� �"!B"A��A��ADA��!,���!����!���"D!���B��!�A������B�"�"� �0>A��%�C� ��A�A��ABC� �,� ��!�!��!�� ��A�!�.�M��

���9� ����!�!*D!�!B"A��A�*D!B�A��!D"A��!�!%"����!�A������A�FD����B"A*D!����A���B��!�A��.�M�A�"ADB!���AD��A�AB�� ����!��AB"D� ��!�

HB�"�"� �0�� (��D!�DA%�DDAB"A(�A���!F�D!"-D��� �� D-�D��� (��A���!�AB"A���AB"�,�%!��� (�FA��A<���!����A�%����D���0�� �%�AB"A,�%!�� D-�D�!�A�DA%�BCA%��!��A�!��/���

���� � AB����A�DA*��"!D�<�A�!��B"A*D!0��������B�A�"�*!��DA��BA�"!���B��!�A��A�"ADB!��"A��%����,�B�!�AB"�(�B����-�!�%!�!%��!�A��A�

�B�A�"�*!0�� �������%AB"A���!�DA%�DDAB"A(��!��"!�F$��!��!��G�!��!�<�A�!����!���B�"!�!0>A��A<���!�AB"���%�B�"�"�A���!D!�A�"!���B��!�A� (�"� DB!B�� �A�"!��B"A*D!0�� �FAB$,�%!��!D!�!�F!��!���!D"A� ��

����� ��� %�B"D!�!D"��!(� �� � �B�A�"�*!��DA�� �!� DA%� DDAB"A� )A� ��� �A��� � D�AB"!B���+ � FABA,�%�!�� �� � !%A��� � 5� �B,� D�!0�� (� 5� �

�B�"!�!0>A��A<���!�AB"���A�5��!��!�%DA"�%!��!��B��!�A��B�A�A�"�� ��B"A*D!��� ��

Page 10: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

9��

����� DA�"A����� (�������"�D!B��������D�*D!�!��D����"��AB%�B"D!D�!�����!�F�AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!0�� �,!�� D'�A��5���!�,� D�!0�� �<�A�

DA6BA�"��!��!��%�B��0>A��BA%A��'D�!� ���

���� @�DA�!"!�� �ADD� �%�B�"!�����A�!"-D���,�B!��!� ���=ADG�A(�B����B"�����1�(�<�A�2��,!%"���A�!�*�B���A�FD������H�G���ADA��!,���!����!���"D!���B��!�A������B�"�"� �0>A��%�C���A�A��ABC��%�AB"A,�%��,� ��!�!��!���%�������"� �F������A�%A�AB"A��A�!�.�M(�B�� ��AD��"A�A�"AB�AD�A�"!�<�!��,�%!0�� �!��H�G�(���!��A=�<�A�,����!�!�%���F!�A�B���A�A��ABC���A��!���B�"�"� �0>A���A�AB�AB����!����!��� D-�D�!� �%!�!%��!�A� (�� D*!B�=!0�� �A�!�F�AB"A7��

���;� @�(�!�B�!(�<�!B����A���=(��!�� �!��!B"A(�<�A�2B� �%�B"A�"� ��!�� D����"!(�A�"!�!�A*!�!�Y�B"A*D!0��Z��- ����A��AD��'���!��A�!�

Y�B��!�A��B�A�A�"����B"A*D!���Z���������A�!�DA���B�!F����!�A��� ���%����A���"�����%���� �H�G�(�����AC!(��A�A��!���B��!�A��A�!�H�G��,� D�!��A�����- D*����B"A*D!��(�!� �!FD�*� ��A�� D� "�%� ����!�A<�!�!�AB"A�,� D���!��� ��#� D"!B"� (����%���D������ �%�!D!�AB"A�A��DA�����A�"!��&B��!�A��%���H�G��A��!�����D�!�DA���B�!F ����!�A��A�DA!��=!D�� ���%�� ��A���"������ D����"� (�$�A��AB%�!�(��!� (��� D�AB<�!B"� (�A�"'�A��,!�"!�B!�� D����"!7��

���1� /� �B���DA�A�!D�!�A��AD�3B%�!��A��B�A�"�*!0���������%AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!��DA���!�DA%�DDAB"A(�!��A��FAD!0�� ���� �!(���!��A=��!�� (�� �

!D"�*� ��� �8(�B �8��(��� �DO���:����;���

��: � �� ��� �!� !� %�"!�!� B� D�!� ���"� � <�A�� �<�A�!��A��!�A��*A�$�"��G���AB"A�<�A��A��A��B�"DA�2������D�QLR���!�A��AD�3B%�!�!%����!�!��A��B�A�"�*!0���%�B%DA"�=!�!�B��!��D���0���%�AB"A,�%!�A�!%!�$��%!�DA�A�!B"A��BA��A�D!����A�%�BCA%��AB"�������!�A��A%�!���!�A7��

���� � �(��A�!%� D�� �%���!�%�"!�!�!�ABA!��+ ����B�8������!D"�*� ����8����DO���:����;(�A��!�A��AD�3B%�!(�"AB�����D�DA,AD3B%�!�!��B�"�"��0����A�

AB��B� (�"!B"� ����A��AD�!�<��D��!��A�,� D�!���DA%"!�����B��DA%"!���

���� H� "� �$(�A��!�A��AD�3B%�!����A��AD�)!�<��D��!+ �2��D�� �����!"D!�$���!���!��!D"�%��!0�� ����%� �!F�D!0�� �Q��DA%"!R(���������A�����%AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!��DA��Q�B��DA%"!R(�A���B�"�"� �0>A��%�AB"A,�%!��A�"ADB!�7��

���9� ��� � �AB�� � DA�A�!B"A� �!D!� A��A� A,A�"� (� A� 5� ��=� �!� �A�� A�� ��*� D(� !� ,� D�!� �A�!� <�!��$�"�"� �!�!�!�A��AD�3B%�!�!�<��D��!?��A�

,� D�!��=!�������B�� �)�A� �*B!�!�AB"A(�!"D!�$���A�� D� "�%� ���+ ���

��� � D!��A��!�,� D�!�<�A�"!�F$��B�� �DA�A�!�!�)�!�� D�����AB�D+ ��B"AB���!�A��!��B"A*D!0�� ���

�;�� ��� ��AB��(���D������A��*A�A�(���D�!F����"!�,!�"!��A�,�B�!�AB"���A*!�(�!�2A��*3B%�!7��AD"��!�B���A�!"-D���,�B!���A�<�A�2B��%�B"A�"� ��!�� D����"!(�A�"!�!�A*!�!�Y�B"A*D!0��Z��-����A��AD��'���!��A�!�Y&B��!�A��B�A�A�"����B"A*D!���Z���������A�!�DA���B�!F����!�A��� ���%�� ��A���"�����%���� �H�G�7���

��;�� @���AC!(�2%�����A�A��!���B��!�A��A�!�H�G��,� D�!��A�����- D*�� ��B"A*D!�� (�!� �!FD�*� ��A�� D� "�%� ����!�A<�!�!�AB"A�

,� D���!���7���

�;�� ��� �$(�%�!D!�AB"A(��� "� �� �<�A�!��A����=�P��

�;;� ��� �$(��A*�D!�AB"A(��A�"!�,� D�!�<�A�!��A�����A�A��A�A��AD��B"AD�DA"!�!�P��

�;1� @�<�A�!��A����=�A�� ����� �%����!��A��!��A�A��AD��B"AD�DA"!�!�$����"� �%�!D� ?�B� ��AB"��� ��A��A��A��B�"D!D�!�A���"3B%�!��A�A��AD�3B%�!�!� �BA�A���A��B�A�"�*!0���A��A�A��!�A��AD�3B%�!����AD�DA���"!D��!��!D"�%��!0������%��!F�D!0����!�DA%� DDAB"A�A�����!��!D"A������A����A�FD���)��%AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!��DA�+�A���B�"�"� �0>A��A�"ADB!�(��B�A�AB�AB"A�AB"A��!�,� D�!��A��!D"�%��!0�� ����%� �!F�D!0�� ��

��;: � ��� �,� �(��� D$�(�A��!�!��B"AD�DA"!0�� �!%� �C ��!�B!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!��

��;� � /� ��B�$� (�!��A��FAD!0���DA%�DD��!�B���DA�A����!�A��AD�3B%�!��A��B�A�"�*!0���������%AB"A��A��B�A�"�*!��DA�(�<�!B�� �$�%AD"� (�<�A(�

!� �!FD�*� ��� �!D"�*� ��� �8(�B �8��(�!�ABA!��+ (��A�AD�!�"AD�DA�A�!�� ���

�;�� /� �B���"3G�� �,A�"�(�!��A��FAD!0���DA%�DD��!��B%�DDA�A��ADD� �B����DA������"����A���DA�"���A%�� ��A���� �!0�� ��A��A�(�D!=�� ��A�!�<�!���A�AD'��AD�DA��*!�!���

��;9� EA�����!�� ��� �<�A�!��A"�%��B!�!�DA��*!0��(�A���!��A=�<�A�B����A��AD�,�%!������ DA������"���)�A�,!%"� �A��A���DA�"� + �A��<�A�

!��AB"!�!��A%�����DA%� DD��!(�$�,�D�A�!�%�B��%0����!�DA%�DDAB"A�<�A�A�"!�!��A�A�"���DA�B�����"��������DA<��� �"����A*!����!D!�<�A��AC!��A,AD��!�!�!%DA��"!0�� ��� �B��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"���� ���

Page 11: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

���

A��%�B%A�AD(��4 � � 1 � � BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �� � � D�B %A� �� � �! � �*� ! ��!�A4 � � 1 � � BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �� � � D�B %A� �� � �! � �*� ! ��!�A4 � � 1 � � BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �� � � D�B %A� �� � �! � �*� ! ��!�A4 � � 1 � � BA%�� � �A � � �� �! 0�� � �� � � D�B %A� �� � �! � �*� ! ��!�A ???? ����

��;� � /�DA%� DDAB"A(�B!��D�B6B%�!�<�A�!�DA�AB"���"AB�� ��� D��F CA%"� �� �DA�!"- D�� �� DA����B!D(�A�AB%��(�!�"A"� �� �A�A����,�%!"��� (����

%�BC�B"� ��A��A%��>A��"��!�!���A�� ��/�B� �F�F�"� ��A�� D�%A������A�!%DA��"!0�� ��A�B�����%�%��� ��A�A�"���� ���

�1�� /���A%��>A��<�A�,� D!��!�DA�AB"!�!���A�!�DA%� DDAB"A�!�DA�AB"!������A*��B"A���AB���B!��DA��%���B�?�!� MADA��� ��� ��A"A%"!�!���A,�%�3B%�!� I�F � /��A%���� �� D� ,AD��!�,� ���A�!%DA��"!0�� (�!�B�!�<�A�%�B��%��B!��AB"A���

��1�� /���A,�%�3B%�!��<�A�,�D!����AB"�,�%!�!��B!��%!B���!"�D!�������!��A��!�B!"�DA=!�A(�B!�*�B��%!���(���� ��!�� �*D!�A���� �<�A�!��

<�A���� �����"!�!��5�%!B���!"�D!��!�DA%� DDAB"A���

�1�� ��B"��� (� "!�� � �A,�%�3B%�!��B�� ����A��D!��<�A(�B���%!����!�DA�AB"!��� (�"��A��A��� ��� �� D� ,AD��!���A%��>A��,!�� D'�A�� �5�!%DA��"!0�� (�!�B�!�<�A��A�,� D�!�%�B��%��B!��)A�!"$��� D��ADA�����DA�!"��!�AB"A�!�!D*!���+ ��

��1;� /�"A"� �� ��A�A�A���� (�DA%�D�AG�A���<�A�!��BA���"3B%�!��A���!��B��!�A�!�!��!�!�A�DA%�BCA%��!��A�!�.�M�B������A����<�A�"��A��A��

� ��� �!%DA��"!����;�8� �%�%��� ��A�A�"����� �%,D��!D"�*� �������

�11� /���AB"��!�A��A�� �"�!0>A��)A�B!�*�B��%!���(�!��!�� D�*D!���!�A��!��� �"�!0>A�(�"!B"��<�!B"�"!"��!�%����<�!��"!"��!�AB"A+(��� D�����!�� (�A�!���,ADAB0!��A��A%��>A��)�A�B�� �!%DA��"!0�� �A��%�B"D!��B"� �%���!���A�!%DA��"!0�� + (��� D���"D� ��!�� (��A��B�"D!�!��A� �*�!��!�A��A�"D!"!�AB"� �%�B%A���� �5�DA%� DDAB"A��

��1: � /��A��*�!��!�A��A�"D!"!�AB"� �"� DB!�A���AB"A�!�A���"3B%�!(��!��!D"A��� ��/(��A�2�� �� ��A����A���!���A���!�7��

��1� � ��"!��A��*�!��!�A(��A�!%���!BC!��A�<�!�<�AD�D!=�� �C��"�,�%!"��!�)A��F CA%"��!+ �<�A��A*�"��A�A��!�����!D��!�A��A�"D!"!�AB"� (�

"D!��=G�A�B��!���� �!0�� ��� �� D�B%A� �� ��!��*�!��!�A�)!D"�*� �: �8��� ��#/+ (�<�A����>A�!�DA��*!0�� ��!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!���

A��%�B%A�AD(��4 � � : � � BA%�� � �A � � DA "A D�0�� � �A � ,� D�! ���!�A � A � � AB %�! �� )!� � �3B %�! � � D$ ��! +4 � � : � � BA%�� � �A � � DA "A D�0�� � �A � ,� D�! ���!�A � A � � AB %�! �� )!� � �3B %�! � � D$ ��! +4 � � : � � BA%�� � �A � � DA "A D�0�� � �A � ,� D�! ���!�A � A � � AB %�! �� )!� � �3B %�! � � D$ ��! +4 � � : � � BA%�� � �A � � DA "A D�0�� � �A � ,� D�! ���!�A � A � � AB %�! �� )!� � �3B %�! � � D$ ��! + ???? ����

��1�� /� �A��FAD!0�� � A�� %D��A(� �A� B�� � !%DA��"!0�� � �� � B��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"���� (�A�"'�2A��%�B%�D�FB%�!�%���!�DA%��AB�!0�� �A�!�

,�B�!�AB"!0�� ��!��������� ��A�/�!��!0�� ���"ADB!7���

�19� ��B,� D�A��A�DA,AD���!B"AD�� D�AB"A(�!��A��FAD!0���B���$�%�!D!�<�!B"��!�DA�!0���<�A(�A��"AD�����A�,�B�!�AB"!0��(��A�A�"!FA�A%A�AB"DA�!<�A�A���� �� ��!D'*D!,���A�� �"A� D��� ��A�!"- D�� �.�B!���!��/���

��1� � A�� �DAC� A=� � �!�� �6���!�� �!� DA%� DDAB"A� DA�!"��!�AB"A� 5� ,�B�!�AB"!0�� � �!� �A��FAD!0�� � )A� <�A� ,� D!�� �A�AB�� ����!��

!B"AD�� D�AB"A(��!D!��B�A��A�DA�A"A+(�%�B�"!"��G�A�<�A�� ��A�!"-D���,�B!�(���D!�A�� ��� �A��AB"A(�����"��G�A�!�%�� �!D�� ��A�!"- D�� �� DA����B!D�A�!��AB%��B!D(�B� ���B"� ����1�(���!��B� "!��DA�!"��!��5�� D�B6B%�!��!�DA%� DDAB"A�B� �F�F�"� ��!�!���0�� �� D$��!��

M��!��!(��

�:�� ������A����A�AB"AB�AD�<�A�!�-��!�%�B%����� �)A�!%"!�AB"A��*�!��5��� �DA�!"- D�� �� DA����B!D+ (��AC!��!B!���!����!�AB!���� �� �!��A%"����� ���DA�"� ��A�!���0��J�

��:�� @�DA�!"- D�� �,�B!��$�%-� �!(��AD����A�A�!"!(��� �DA�!"- D�� �� DA����B!D��

D!A�<�A(���

�:�� @���DA�"� ��A�!���0�� �,� ��DA�A*!����!D!�� �,�B!���� �DA�!"-D���A�!�,!%"�!���!�A�!�A*!�!�B!�� D�B6B%�!��!�DA%� DDAB"A�%����A"!�AB"A�A�<�A%��!��

��:;� M��!��!(�� ���DA�"� ��A�!���0���B������A��AD�AB"AB���� �%������!�� ��� �A��%DA"�%!�!� �DA�!"- D�� �� DA����B!D�<�A�BA%A�� �"!��A��AD�

%�B"D!��"!�!����"� ����!D�!�AB"A���

�:1� 4A���A�� �%�B"D'D��(�� ���DA�"���A�!���0���$���!�%�B"D�F��0�������D"!B"A����!��� �!���B��"D!����!D!�� �� D�%A���AB"� (��� �� ����A�"D!=AD(�%����"D���A(��!D!�� ��A����,!%"���<�A������A�%�BCA%�����A�DA�A�!B"A�(�FA��!�� ���,!"����B�"D��AB"!�� �<�A�!�����!��!�AB"AB�AD�!��!"AD�!���!�A�A��%!��!��

��:: � #!D!�!�$���A��AD����%� D� �'D�� ��� ���DA�"� ��A��!D"�%��!0�� ��� �!���B��"D!�� �B��!��A%���� �<�A��CA���=�DA��A�"� ��

Page 12: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

��:� � /��B"D���0��������DA�"� ��A�!���0���B� �F�F�"� ��� ���DA�"� �!���B��"D!"��� �DA�A�!���!�!�"AD!0�� �D!��%!���� ��!D!��*�!���"!�� ���

!���B��"D!�� ���

�:�� �,A%"��!�AB"A(�!�B��!��AD��A%"��!��!��B���AB"�����A�<�A�� �!%"��!�� D!"�%!D��A�!�/���B��"D!0���,�%!D'��!�� �%����A"� �A��AD'��!�� �,!%���AB"A�!%A�"'�A���A�� �!���B��"D!�� �"��AD���!��B"AD�AB0�� �!%"��!�B� ��A��� ��

��:9� /��!D"�%��!0�� ����!���B��"D!���B!�� D���0������!%"� �$����!��A%"��A��AB%�!���!D!�<�A�,�<�A�%�B�AB%���������A���,�B�!�AB"���A�

<�A�!���!��!D"�%��!0�� �,� ������D"!B"A�A�DA�A�!B"A��!D!�� ��A��� ���

�:� � /��'� (�A�"A�� D�B%A� �� �$�DA%�BCA%��� �%�B�"�"�%��B!��AB"A���

���� M��!��!(�� ��A*�� �!��D�B����DA"AB�A��<�A�� �A�AD%A%����� ���DA�"���A�!���0����A�<�A�!��A���D���!��AD!�,� D�!���!�A�<�A�!�AB"��!�A�!���B��"D!"��!�� DA%��!��A�%���D�D�!B"A���!��D'"�%!��� �!%"�(�FA���A�� �%�B"D'D�� �$�������AB"� �A��AB%�!��A��<�A�!�AB"��!�A�!���B��"D!"��!��A�AD'�!"AB"!D�A��"��������,!%"���<�A�� �!���B��"D!�� ��A%��!�"D!=AD��!D!�� �� D�%A���AB"� ��

����� ���<�A�DA��A�"!�!� �%!�� �%�B%DA"� �$��!B�,A�"� �<�A�� ���DA�"� ��A�!���0�� �B�� �,� ��A,A%"��!�AB"A�%���D��� ��

����� ����A,A�"� (�%�����A����A�AB"AB�AD�<�A���DA�!"-D���,�B!��B���"ABC!�DA�A�!���,!%"���A��AB%�!���<�A�,� D!��!�A*!����B!��D�B6B%�!J�

���;� @���AC!(�� �DA�!"-D�� �,�B!��B����"���=!�!�%�B"D�F��0������!���B��"D!�� ��!D!�����,�%!D�!�"AD!D�!� ���!��%�B%���>A���!��!,!�"!G!(�

%�B�AB�AB"A�AB"A(��!D!�� �,�B!���� �DA�!"- D�� (�!�-��C'�"AD�DA"�D!�� �!�%�B%����� ���

��1� /������AB��(��A������D���!�<�A�"���� ��"A�'"�%!��BADAB"A�!��DA�!"- D���,�B!�(�%�����A�AB"AB�A�<�A�,���A��DA�A�!�������,!%"�� (�<�A���� �����D"!B"A���!D!�!��<�A�">A��A��!B'���A�B��� DA�AB"A�� D�%A���AB"� (��A�����A�����!�AB!����� �!B!���!����!�-��!�,� D���!0�� ��!�%�B%����� �J�

���: � AD'�<�A��A������A�"AD�DA"�D!�� �!�%�B%�����(�!�<�!��$�A��A�C� �,�A���!�%�B%����� ��� �DA�!"- D�� �� DA����B!D(�� �DA�!"- D�� �,�B!��!��D�!�

!�"AD!D�J��

��� � O�*�%!�AB"A�<�A��AD�!�������A�A��<�A�"!����%A�A��A(�%����B�� ��%� DDA��B� �%!�� �%�B%DA"� ���

���� E!�(�%����$�-F���(�!��FD�*!"�D�A�!�A����%���D��AB"�������DA�"� ��A�!���0���B����A�A�*�"!�B!����'D�!��AB0�� �A�%�B"A�"!0�� �����,!%"���%!DDA!�����A�� �!���B��"D!�� ��

���9� @��,!%"����A�A���AD��B%�� A����B!�!B'���A��!��<�A�">A��<�A�A�"�� �A��%!��!�B� �� D�%A���AB"� �A�!��%�B%���>A��DA,�A"�DA��!�

DA!���!�A��A��A���A�����,!%"�� ���

��� � /�!B'���A��� ���DA�"���A�!���0���B������A��AD�!,!�"!�!��!D!����2*CA""�7����DA�!"-D��(����� (�!�A�!D��A��!��AD���!�A�%� �C!����"� �%�B,� D"'�A��)�����A��"!�<�A����,!%"���%!DDA!�����A���!���B��"D!���A�"�B*!�(�����,�<�A�����!�"ADA�����,!%"���%�B�"!B"A���� �� D� CA%"� + ���� �!(�,D�B"!��AB"A(�!�� DA"AB��� ��� ��A*�� �!�� D�A�!��A"D!��!��A���

���%�B%����� (��

���� .� ��� DA"AD��!�!�,� D�!���!�A�A��AB%�!��A��<�A��A�"D!��=�����DA�"� ��A�!���3B%�!�� D$��!��!�DA%� DDAB"A(�� �<�A�*AD!�!��B�!���!�A��!��A��FAD!0�� �DA%� DD��!�A�<�A����>A�!���!�DA��*!0�� ���

�MAD����A��<�A(��� B����!�� ��A�D�DA�"� (�A�%���� ��A��DA��������"� ����D��AB"� ��A�B����!� �(��A�AD'� � � � DA�AB"A� DA%�D�� � �AD� C� �*!�� � �D�%A�AB"A(� �� D� � D��!�� (� A(�%�B�A<�AB"A�AB"A(�DA��*!�!�!��A��FAD!0���DA%�DD��!(�FA��%��� (��� D�A�"!DA��DA�B�����"��������DA<��� �"����A*!�� (��AC!���F�"�"� A�!��� D���"D!�<�A��A,�D!�!�!%DA��"!0�� ��� �B��� �%�%�� ��A�A�"���� ��

/ ��A/ ��A/ ��A/ ��A%�DDAB"A%�DDAB"A%�DDAB"A%�DDAB"A����GGGG����GGGG����GGGG����GGGG����GGGG�������������B * ��� C � �A D� �� B ?�B * ��� C � �A D� �� B ?�B * ��� C � �A D� �� B ?�B * ��� C � �A D� �� B ? ����

DA!D�EA�FAD���,�"CA��A��AT�4�!D�������������������#&���#&���#&���#&� ����/��!B%A��#��["A%CB�%�!B��&B��AD��"[ ��� � � A D! "� �A/��!B%A��#��["A%CB�%�!B��&B��AD��"[ ��� � � A D! "� �A/��!B%A��#��["A%CB�%�!B��&B��AD��"[ ��� � � A D! "� �A/��!B%A��#��["A%CB�%�!B��&B��AD��"[ ��� � � A D! "� �A GGGG ���� �D��D��D��D��(�)CADA�B!,"AD�DA,ADDA��!���!��A��!B"+ (��T!��B� "�,�A�(��B ��1�������1(�� ,�"CA�,�B!��DA��D"�!B��"CA��A%����B�� ,�"CA�4�!D��� ,�D�DA%"�D�(��"C!"��A"AD��BA��"CA�B� �!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�"CA�BAT�%[%�A�� ,�

Page 13: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

�"���A��\4����*�%!��%�AB%A��/�� ��A��"� �]A!�"C �\(�%��A�(��B�AD�!D"�%�A����!B��,� ���T�B*�!D"�%�A� (�� ,�"CA����A���B8�9���������� ,��:�������;(�"C!"�!��D��A��"CA��%CA�A��,�� D*!B�=!"��B�!B��,�B%"��B�B*�� ,�"CA�4�!D��� ,��A�����B��,��/;�(�!B��"CA��[�"A��� ,�DA��AT��D�%A��DA��%�B%ADB�B*��A%����B����,�!��A���AB"�!B��!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�C�*CAD�A��%!"��B��B�"�"�"��B��!B��"CA�D��"��[�%[%�A� (�"� �� DA�AB"�!��A!��� ,�"C!"��A%�� ��B (��B ��"CA�,� ���T�B*�"AD���!B��,�B�!�AB"� ?��/ + � 4 ! %^*D� � B � ?/ + � 4 ! %^*D� � B � ?/ + � 4 ! %^*D� � B � ?/ + � 4 ! %^*D� � B � ? ��������MCA����B%���� ,�/���B��"D!"��B�)�/�+ �(�F[��A%�� ��B�� ,�����1����1(��A%��A��"� �\B� "�!%%DA��"!"A�"CA�%[%�A�� ,��"���A� �\�����MCA�!��A��!B"��� �B� "��!"��,�A��T�"C�"CA�%�B"AB"�!B����DA%"��B�� ,�"CA��A"AD��B!"��B�� ,�"CA��A%�� ��B ���;��/B����A��B�"�%�B,�D��FA%!��A��%�B���AD� �"C!"�"C ����A"AD��B!"��B���,,AD���B �*ABAD!��,D����A�AD!����%A��"C!"���"�!"A��"(���!D"�%� �!D�[��!%^�� ,�DA!��B�B*(��ADD� D��B�"CA�!�����"��B�(�ADD�D��B �"CA�!�����"��B��� ,��!T������ �!"��B��,��!T(���� �!"��B�� ,�"CA�� D�B%�� �A�� ,�A<�!��"[�!B���B,D�B*A�AB"�� ,�A��AB"�!��� D�%A��D!��)�D�*C"�"� �!�� D�� D�CA!D�B*�+ ������4 + � "C A � � �%A � � ?4 + � "C A � � �%A � � ?4 + � "C A � � �%A � � ?4 + � "C A � � �%A � � ? ��������4 � �4 ��4 ��4 �� � � / �� �%"�� B � �! %^� � , � DA ! � � B �B * � ?� � / �� �%"�� B � �! %^� � , � DA ! � � B �B * � ?� � / �� �%"�� B � �! %^� � , � DA ! � � B �B * � ?� � / �� �%"�� B � �! %^� � , � DA ! � � B �B * � ? ��������1��/��B� "A�(�"CA��/�(�"CD��*C��A��FAD!"��B��B �%D�� �� �(��A%��A��"� �\B� "�!%%DA��"!"A�"CA�%[%�A�� ,��"���A� �\��: ��/%%� D��B*�"� �"CA�!��A��!B"(�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B��� ��B!�A<�!"A�[�*D��B�A�(�TC�%C�,�D�!����B"AB"� �!B����D���A� (��� �A<���!�AB"�"� ��!%^�� ,�DA!��B�B*���� ��HB�AA�(�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%����B����B�"�F!�A���B�"AD���"C!"��!���T��"CA�!��A��!B"(�,�D�"(�DA!��=A��"� �"D�A��A!B�B*�!B���%��A�!B�(��B�"CA�� "CAD�C!B�(��A!DB�"CA�A�!��!"��A�T![�"D!�AD�A��F[�"CA��/�)"� ��A%��A�!���A%��A�+ �������MCA��A,�%�AB%�A��"C!"�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A"AD��B!"��B�� DA�AB"� �!"�"C �� ��A�A�(�� "!D"� (�,�D�"(�T�"C �"CA���,,�%� �"[��B ���AB"�,[�B*(�T�"C �"CA�� DA%�� ��B�!B��!%%�D!%[�DA<��DA��(�"CA�DA!��DA!��B��"C!"�*D��B�A��"CA��A"AD��B!"��B����9��H"��� �%AD"!�B �"C!"(�!%%� D��B*�"��"CA�DA����"��B(�"CA��A"AD��B!"��B��� �\�B �!%%�D�!B%A�T�"C�"CA�DA%���AB�!"��B�!B��"CA�DA!��B�B*�� ,�"CA�������� ��B�� ,���"ADB!���A��AT\���� ��H"�%!B�FA��!��(�%�B�A<�AB"�[(�"C!"�"CA�DA!��B�B*��,�"CA��A%�� ��B��� �%�B"!�BA���B �"CA�.�B!���A��D"�� ,�"CA�������� ��B�� ,���"ADB!���A��AT�)�/��+ ��������]�TA�AD(��"�C!��AB��"C!"�"CA��A��FAD!"��B��B"A*D!"A�(�!,"AD�DA,ADD�B*�"� �"CA�,�B!��DA��D"�� ,�"CA��/�(��B����B"����� ,�"CA�B� "�,�%!"��B�!B�(�"CADA,� DA(��B ��"� �DA!��B�B*(�"T� ��!D!*D!�C� ��������DA!"�B*����F"(��B �"CA�!��A��!B"(�!F��"�"CA�DA�!"��B�C�� (��B�"AD���� ,�DA!��B�B*(�"C!"��� �A�"!F���CA��FA"TAAB�"C��A�"T� ��!D!*D!�C��!B��"CA�%�B"AB"�� ,�"CA�.�B!���A��D"�� ,�"CA��/��������MC!"��� (��,��"��� �!�DA�!"��B�C����,�%����A�AB"�)�A�(��,�"CA�DA!��B�B*�� ,�"CA�,�B!��DA�� D"�%����A�AB"��"CA�%�B"!�BA���B �"CA�,�B!���A%�� ��B+ �� D�!�DA�!"��B�� ,�A�%��� ��B�)�A�(��,�"CA�DA!��B��,� D�"CA�,�B!���A%�� ��B�A�%���A��"CA�%�B�"!B"��B �"CA��,�B!��DA�� D"+ �����;���A*!D��A���� ,�"C�� ��A,�%�AB%[�!B�(�%�B�A<�AB"�[(�"CA��B"AD�DA"!"��A���,,�%� �"�A� �"C!"��"����A��"� �"CA�!��A��!B"(�"CA�"D�"C��� �"C!"�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B��� �,�B�!�AB"!��[�,�!TA�?��!%^�� ,�DA!��B�B*��B �"CA��A��FAD!"��B (�F� "C��B �,!%"�!B���B ��!T����1��.�D�"�[(�FA%!��A�"CA��A%�� ��B��� �B� "�F!�A���B ��!T�����: ��HB�AA�(�"CA�DA�� ��"��B�%�B"!�B��B� �DA,ADAB%A�"� ��A*!��B� D���"C!"�C!�A��AD�A��!��"CA�F!��� �,� D��A%�� ��B��!^�B*����� �� A%�B��[(�"CA�DA�� ��"��B��� �B� "���,,�%�AB"�[�TA���*D��B�A���B �"AD���� ,�,!%"� �������/B��"C!"�F[�DA!��B�� ,���,,ADAB"�� D�AD� ���/��%!B�FA��F�AD�A�?���9�� .�D�"�[(� FA�B*� "CA��A"AD��B!"��B���""ADA��� ,�!F�"D!%"�"AD��(��A�� ��A��� ,�!B[�!%C�A�A�AB"(�TC�%C��!^A��"��������F �A�,� D�"CA�!��A��!B"�"� �!��DACAB��"CA��A!B�B*�!B���%��A�� ,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B ���

Page 14: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

�� ��/��!B�A�!���A(��"��� �!� ��"!"A���B �"CA�DA����"��B�"C!"�\�"CA��[��!F����,��!D�����%�DD�%� �!D��B�"� �!B��"CA�D�"A!%C�B*��A"C��� ��*�A���B�"� �!DA�"[� �%!��� ,��B�AD*D!��!"A�A��%!"��B�!B��,!����C� D"�� ,�TC!"�DA<��DA��,� D�!�;D���[%�A�\��������MCA�DA�� ��"��B���A��B� "��!"AD�!��=A(�C�TA�AD(�TC!"�!DA�"CA�%�DD�%� �!D��B�"� �"C!"���,,AD�,D�����%C��C�D"%���B*� ������� O�^AT��A� �"� !��� � ��A�� B� "� �A"!���"CA�*ABAD�%�%D�"�%����"C!"��� ��!�A(��"���A��B� "��C��"�,[�FA%!��A�"CA��[��!F���!DA�"[� �%!��� ,��B�AD*D!��!"A�A��%!"��B�!B��,!����C� D"�� ,�"C!"�DA<��DA��,� D�!�;D���[%�A�������MCA��!�A��D�F�A���� �� DA�AB"��B �"CA��A��FAD!"��B�"C!"�%C!D!%"AD�=A��!��A%"� �"C!"��AA��"� �C!�A�DA�A�!B%A��B �%�B"A�"(���%C�!��"CA�,� ���T�B*?�!��"CA��[��!F���(�\��� ����A�"�)��AD[�F!��%�+ �\�I�F ���A!DB �B*�\��� ��B,�A��F �A�!B��T�"C��"��AD��B!��=A��B!"�DA�\�I���;��@D(�TCAB(�T�"C �DA,ADAB%A�"� �"CA��[��!F�� (��"��� ��"!"A��"C!"�\"CADA��� �!�%�A!D��A,�%�AB%[��B �� D���"�B*���DA�"D!B��AD�!����^���� �\���1��_C[(�!%%� D��B*�"� �"CA��/�(�"CA��[��!F����� ����A�"�� D��AD[�F!��%J���: ���A*!D��B*�"C �� ��� �B"(�"CA�DA�� ��"��B��![��B� "C�B*������ ��MCA��!�A�DA���B�A��� ��F"!�BA��TCAB�"CA�!��A��!B"�<�A�"��B��TC[��A!DB �B*�\��� ��B,�A��F�A�!B��T�"C��"��AD��B!��=A��B!"�DA�\�� D�TC!"���A,�%�AB%�A��!DA�� DA�AB"A��F[�"CA��� �!B�� ,��"���A��%�B%ADB�B*�"CA�\�� D���"��B�� ,���DA�"D!B��AD�!���^���� ��\�������HB �"CA��!�A���BA�� ,�"C �B^�B*(�,�"� �"CA�%�B�"!B"�!,,�D�!"��B�� ,�"CA��A"AD��B!"��B�DA,ADD�B*�"C!"�\"CA��F CA%"��A��� ,�"C �� �%��D�A�� ,��"��[�!DA�%���D����A��F[�"CA�!F�AB%A�� ,�!�DA!��DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"�"C!"�� D���"A��"A!%C�B*�� ,�!�;D����[%�A7�����9��HB �"C �� �%�B"A�"(�"CA�%�B%A�"�� ,�\DA!��DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"\��� �B� "��A"!��A������ ��/"�"C �� ��A�A�(�!B��B�"T�"C�"!B��B*�TC!"�T����FA��!����!"AD�DA*!D��B*�"C ��(���!����!DA�B�"�%�B%DA"�=A��"CA�\�T��A�D!B*A�� ,���FCA%"�\�� ,���F ��%!"��B��!,,���!"A��"� �"CA�!����%!B"�)!��A��!B"+�!��TA���!� �%�B%A�"����^A�\�<�!��,�A��DA�A!D%CAD��\�!B��\!�A<�!"A��%�AB"�,�%�� D�*D!�\���;���MCA��!�A��AD�*!"�D[�C��*�AB"��B �"AD���� ,�DA!��B�B*�%!B�FA���BA�TCAB�(��B �%�B%�����B�(��"��� ��!��(�"C!"�"CA���F��""A��� D����!����A��B�"��AA"�"CA�DA<��DA�AB"��,� D�!��D��!��(�T�"C��"�(�C�TA�AD(���A%�,�%!��[��"!"�B*�TC!"�DA<��DA�AB"��)�,�!���� D��B�[����A�+ �!DA�B� "�DA��A%"A�����;���4A�B*�"C �� ��C� D"!*A�A�AB���DA��AD�����TCAB�"CA��A%�� ��B��� �AB"�DA�[�� ��AB"�DA*!D��B*�"CA�� �A!���B ��!T��B�TC�%C��"�DA�"� ���;���MCA�A��A,�%�AB%�A��"C!"�!DA��B��%!"A��DA*!D��B*�"CA�,�B!���A%�� ��B (�!��� �!�� �[�"� �"CA�%�B"AB"�� ,�"CA�.�B!���A��D"����;;��/%"�!��[(�B� "�"� �%�!�C (�!��� �"CA�DA��D"��� �,� ���� ,�!F�"D!%"�"AD��(��;1��DA�%�B%A�"� �"C!"�"D� �[��![�B� "C�B*���;: ��H"��� �TC!"�C!��AB��T�"C�"CA���A�� ,�"CA�T�D���\��B ��!D"�\�)�;�;�����(�;�;�;���(�������(���;���(�9�����(��������(�/B�����;���+ ����;� ��HB�AA�(�"CA�.�B!���A��D"�%�B���"� �� ,��A�AD!���� �B"� �� ,�!B!�[� �� ���;���HB ��B �[�"T� �� ,�"CA�A��� �B"� ��� �!""D�F�"A��!�BA*!"��A�%�!�� �,�%!"��B�"� �"CA�!�� ��%!B"���;9��HB �"CA���ADTCA���B*��!C�D�"[�� ,�%!�A��"CA�!��A���AB"��� �����"��A(��B �"CA��AB�A�"C!"�"CA�DA<��DA�AB"��� ,�"CA��!T�!DA��A"����;� ��/�!D"�,D���"CA�A�%!�A�(�TC�%C(�!� ��"!"A�(�!DA�"CA��!C� D�"[(�"CA�!��A���AB"�%�B"!�BA���B�"CA�DA��D"�DA*!D��B*��B����A��� �B"� �!B��DA<��DA�AB"���� �"C!"��B �[��!D"��� ��A"���1���HB �"CA�A�%!�A� (�TC!"��� �%�B"!�BA���B �"CA�DA��D"�DA�!"�B*�"� �A!%C�� ,�"CA��� �B"� ��B �<�A�"��B (�!DA��B�[�"CA�T�D���\�B ��!D"\���1���_C!"��� ��!B�,A�"�[��B��,,�%�AB"�,� D�"CA�!��A��!B"�"� �DA!��=A�"CA�D�"D�A��A!B�B*�!B���%��A���1���MC!"��� (�T�"C �"CA��B,�D�!"��B��B�"CA�DA��D"(��B �"CA��AB�A�"C!"��B �[��!D"�� ,�!B��"A����F CA%"�"� �A�!��!"��B��� ��A"�(�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�%!BB�"����%ADB�TC!"��� �"CA�"CDA!��"C!"�(��B �!B�"CAD��AD��A%"��A(�!��A*A��[�T!��B� "�G�� D�T����B� "�C!�A�FAAB�G�,� �,���A����

Page 15: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

�;��

1;����� "� B�T�B*�TC!"��A*�AB"�"C!"�"C!"�C!��B�"�FAAB�,��,���A�(�"CA�!��A��!B"�%!BB�"��B�AD�"!B��"CA��AB�A�� ,�"CA�DA!��B�B*�FAC�B��"CA�"!^AB��A%�� ��B ���11��MCA��!�A�T![�"C!"(�,D���!B�"CAD��AD��A%"��A�(�!B���,�BA%A��!D[�(��"CA�!��A��!B"�%!BB�"��A"�!�BAT����� �F �A�!�� ��%!"��B�,� D�!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�"CA�!��A*A��B�BG%�����!B%A����1: ��MC��(��"��� �%�A!D�"C!"�"CA�DA��D"�(�F[��ADA�[��![�B*�"C!"�"CA�,��,����AB"�� ,�%AD"!�B�DA<��DA�AB"���� �,��B��)�B�[�+ �\��B ��!D"�\�(�T�"C��"��![�B*�TC!"��A*�AB"���T!���B,��,���A��)!B��"� �TC!"�A�"AB"��"�T!�+ ���A��B� "��!"��,[�"CA��A*!��DA<��DA�AB"�"� ��"!"A�DA!��B��(�!B�(�,�D"CAD��DA(��"���A��B� "�%� DDA���B��"� �DA!��"[����1� ��`A"�T�"C �DA,ADAB%A�"� �"CA�.�B!���A��D"(�"CA��!�A�!�� ��A� �"� �"CA���A�� ,�"CA�A��DA�� ��B�\���A�"�\���1����%C��A,�%�AB%�A����!*��B*�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B�!DA(�!� ��"!"A�(�A��AB"�!��,� D�"CA�!�� ��%!B"(�!� ��"� �!��DA��AA(�"� �DA!��=A��"� ��A!B�B*�!B���%��A���19��_C�%C��� �A�"DA�A�[�DA�A�!B"���1� ��MC�� �DA�A�!B%A�%!B�FA�!B!�[=A���B �"T� ���,,ADAB"�"A���D!���AD��A%"��A� ���:���.�D�"(����A��!"A�[(��� �"C!"�"CA�!��DA��AA�)�B �"C�� �%!�A(�"CA�!����%!B"+ �G�%���D�� �B*��"� ��A!B�B*�!B���%��A� ��![�!��DA%�!"A��"� �!%%�D!%[�!B���A*!��%�����!B%A����:���4�"�,D���!B�"CAD��AD��A%"��A(��A,ADDA���B �"��A?�A�AB�"C��*C�"CA�!����%!B"�%�B,�D���C ���A�,�T�"C �"CA�!%"�)TC�%C(�TA�A��C!��=A(��"��� �B� "�"CA�%!�A+(�!�����B*�"C!"��B �"CA�,�"�DA�CA�T!B"��"� ���F��"�!�BAT�!����%!"��B�),�D�!�BAT�%��D�A+ (��"��� �A��AB"�!��"� �DA!��=A�"CA����"!^A���"�� DA����� �[��B%�DDA�(��� �"C!"��"�T�Ba"�%����"�"CA���B �"CA�,�"�DA��B �!��BAT�!�� ��%!"��B�"C!"��"��![��DA�AB"����:���/���"!"A�(�!B��,����T��,D���"CA�!F��A(�"C ����� �B�"�TC!"��%%�D���B �"C ���%!�A(�� �B%A�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B���,,AD� �,D����A,A%"��A�DA!��B�B*����:;��]�TA�AD(�"CA��C�D"%���B*���,�"CA��A%����B��B �"AD����,�DA!��B��!DA�B� "�DA�"D�%"A��"� �!���DA�[�<�!B"�"!"��A��!""AD�)FA�B*�� D�B� "�FA�B*�*D��B�A�I�!B��FA�B*�*D��B�A�(�TCA"CAD�!��� "�� D�!���""�A+ ��B �"CA�%!�A�� ,��!%^�� ,�DA!��B�B*���:1��MCA�� D�F�A��� ,��A,�%�"�DA!��B�B*��B �"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%����B��� �!����<�!��"!"��A�!B��DA,�A%"� �!�%�B"D!��%"��B�FA"TAAB�"CA�A���"�B*�DA!��B�B*�)F[�"CA�,!%"�!�����B"�� ,���AT(�� �B%A(�!��,D���"CA��!T����B"�� ,���AT(��"��� �%����A"A�[�B�BA���"AB"+ �!B���"� ��A%�� ��B��AB�A���::�.D���"CA�T�D��B*��,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%����B(��B ��!D"�%� �!D�"CA��B��!B��;D���!D!*D!�C��� ,��A%"��B�����,�"CA�B�"�,�%!"��B�DA%A��A��F[�"CA�!�� ��%!B"(�TA�%!B�A�"D!%"�BA*!"��A�%D�"�%����"C!"�G�!�"C��*C�"CA�ADD� D��B �TC�%C�"CA[�!DA����"!�BA��)!��T����FA��C�TB��!"AD+ � ��C�����C!�A�FAAB�%�B���ADA���B �"CA�A�"!F ���C�AB"�� ,�"CA��A%�� ��B��!�A����:� ��MCA�DA*��"ADA��BA*!"��A�%D�"�%�����DA�!"A(��B�"CA��BA�C!B�(�T�"C �"CA��[��!F���� ,�"CA�%�DD�%� �!D��B�"� �!B��"CA�%�DD�%� ���(�!B�(��A%�B��[(�T�"C �"CA��A�A��� ,��A�A���A��DA�A!D%C ���:����A!��=�B*�"CA�!F��A(��"��� ��!��(��B �"CA��A%����B(�"C!"�\"CA��[��!F����,��!D�����%�DD�%� ����!B��"CA�D�"A!%C�B*��A"C�����*�A���B�"� �!DA�"[� �%!��� ,��B�AD*D!��!"A�A��%!"��B�!B��,!����C�D"�� ,�"C!"�DA<��DA��,�D�!�;D��%[%�A7��2MCA�%�DD�%� ������ ����A�"�)"���F!��%+(�"CA��A!DB �B*��� � B� "� ,�A��F �A� !B�� �AD��B!��=A�� !B�� "CADA� �� � !� %�A!D� �A,�%�AB%[� �B � � � D���"�B*���DA� "D!B��AD�!�� %���A"AB%A� (� ��%C� !� (��B"DA�DABA�D�C�� (�E!B!*A�AB"� %�AB%A(����B �%!���A�A!D%C�\���:9���%C�!�%�B%�����B(��B �!���"��B�"� �,� D*A"�"C!"(��B �!%%� D�!B%A�T�"C�/D"�%�A�;��8�;�� ,�DO��:�����;(�"CA�A���"AB%A�� ,�!���%"� D!��� D�*D!���� ���"��B!��(��� ��B �%�A!D�%�B"D!��%"��B�"� �"CA�DA%�*B�"��B��� ,��/�����DA���B �"CA�.�B!���A��D"(��B ��!D"�%� �!D?�

!��\MCA��F CA%"��A���,�"CA�%��D�A�!DA�%���!D!F�A��B �"AD����,��^���� �!B��%���A"AB%A��"� �"CA��BA��"!�*C"�F[��B�"�"�"��B��� ,�DA,ADAB%A\�)�!D!*D!�C������� ,�"CA��/�a� �DA��D"+ I�F ��\N������AD!���� "D�%"�D�B*�� ,�"CA�%�DD�%� ����%����BAB"\�)�A%"��B��������!B��������� ,�"CA��/�a� �DA��D"+ I�%��\MCA�%�B���"AB%[��,�"CA��FCA%"��A��T�"C�"CA����� ��B�!B���"D!"A*[�� ,�"CA��B�"�"�"��B�G���A%�!��=A���B �"CA�O�,A�!B��CA!�"C � %�AB%A� (�T�"C�A��%!"��B!�(��%�AB"�,�%�!B��%� �"�D!���D�CA%"�� ,�"CA��B�"�"�"��B\�)�!D!*D!�C��;���;�(�;���1�(�;���:(�;�����!B��;���;�� ,�"CA��/�a� �DA��D"+ I����\MCA��F CA%"��A�����"�� DA�!DA��D�,A����B!���T�"C �"CA�!F���"[�"� �%�B��%"�DA�A!D%C (�%����B�%!"A�"CA�DA�� �"� �� ,��"� �T�D^�"� ���A%�!��=A��!B��B�BG���A%�!��=A��!���AB%A��!B���D���"A�"A%CB���*�%!�(���%�!��!B��%��"�D!���A�A����AB"\�)�!D!*D!�C�;���1�� ,�"CA�DA��D"�� ,��/�+ I�

���

Page 16: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

�1��

:���HB �� "CAD�T�D��(��/�(��B �"CA�����A��DA��D"� (��!D"�%� �!D�[��B �"CA�,�B!��DA�� D"(�TA!�A������"��A�%�B���AD!"��B��"� �"CA�!�� ��%!"��B ���F��""A���������A�AD"CA�A��(�"CA��/(��B �"CA��A%�� ��B�"!^AB(��AA���"���*B�DA�"C�� �����"��A�!��A���AB"(��A%���B*��B �!�BA*!"��A��AB�A(�!� ��,�"C��A�%�B���AD!"��B������B� "�A���"�������_A�!DA�"CADA,�DA�,!%�B*�T�"C�!���"AB���A�%�B"D!��%"��B�FA"TAAB�"CA�� D����A���A%�� ��B�!B��"CA�*D��B����B�TC�%C��"��� �,� D�!��[����"!�BA�(�TC�%C�%�B�"�"�"A��!���%A��A,A%"�� ,��!%^�� D��B��,,�%�AB%[�� ,�DA!��B�B*�������MCA��!�A�!�� ��A� �"� �"CA�%�B%��� ��B�%�B"!�BA��!"�;D���!D!*D!�C�� ,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B ����;��HB�AA�(�FA[�B��"CA���%A���A,A%"���B �TC�%C��"��B%�D��)!B��TC�%C�T����FA��A�A���A���!"AD+(��"��� ��B �%�B"D!��%"��B�T�"C�"CA�%�B"AB"�� ,�"CA�DA��D"��� ,��/�(�A��A%�!��[(�TCAB��"�DA%�*B�=A��\"CA�A���"AB%A�� ,��%�AB"�,�%���F��%!"��B��� ,�!%!�A��%��"!,,��B �� DA����B!B"�!DA!�� ,�"CA�%��D�A��B ��B"ADB!"��B!��C��DB!���T�"C ��AAD�DA��AT��B �"CA��!�"�,��A�[A!D� �\)�!D!*D!�C�������,�DA��D"�� ,��/�+�� D(�"CA�DA%�*B�"��B�"C!"�\A���"� ��%�AB"�,�%(�"A%CB���*�%!�(�%� �"�D!��!B��!D"��"�%�!%"���"�A� ��A�A���A���B �"CA�!DA!�� ,�"CA�BAT�%��D�A(��B"A*D!"A���B �B!"��B!��!B���B"ADB!"��B!��� D� CA%"���!D"BAD�C���\�)�!D!*D!�C�� �;��� ,�DA�� D"�� ,��/�+ ����1��HB �� "CAD�T�D��(��/�(��B�"CA�����A��DA��D"� (��!D"�%� �!D�[��B �"CA�,�B!��DA�� D"(�TA!�A������"��A�%�B���AD!"��B��"� �"CA�!�� ��%!"��B���F��""A�����: ��]�TA�AD(�"CA��/��B�"CA��A%����B�"!^AB(�!���"��*B�DA��"C �������"��A�!��A���AB"(��A%���B*��B�"CA�BA*!"��A���DA%"��B(�!*!�B�!���,�"C��A�%�B���AD!"��B��C!��B� "�FAAB�,� D���!"A������ ��MC�� �<�!��"!"��A����%DA�!B%[�!����C!��!�<�!B"�"!"��A�"D!B� �!"��B?�!�DA��AT�%!DD�A����"�"CA�!����%!B"b��!�� ��%!"��B (����DA���B"� �"CA�.�B!���A��D"��� (��B ����"�%!�A� (���� �"��AI�C�TA�AD(�"CA�,�B!���A%�� ��B�*�A��"�T!D���B�BG!%%DA��"!"��BP������_A�!DA�,!%�B*(�"CADA,� DA�!B���B%A�!*!�B (�!�%�B"D!��%"��B�FA"TAAB�"CA��D����A���A%�� ��B�!B��"CA�*D��B����B�TC�%C��"��� �,� D�!��[����"!�BA�(�TC�%C�%�B�"�"�"A��!���%A��A,A%"�� ,�!F�AB%A�� D��B��,,�%�AB"�DA!��B�B*����9��4D�A,�[(�!B��F!�A���B�"CA�!F��A�DA!��B�(�TA�%�B%���A�"C!"�"CA�DA��D"���,,AD� �,D���!F�AB%A�� D��B��,,�%�AB"�DA!��B�B*(�TC�%C������A��"CA�DA,� D���!"��B�� ,�"CA�DA��D"����� "�*D!B"�B*�����4 �� � � � DD� D� �B � ! � � � �� "�� B � ? �4 �� � � � DD� D� �B � ! � � � �� "�� B � ? �4 �� � � � DD� D� �B � ! � � � �� "�� B � ? �4 �� � � � DD� D� �B � ! � � � �� "�� B � ? � ������� ��/��B� "A��!F��A(�"CA���DA%"��B�� ,�"CA��A%�� ��B�%�B"A�"A���� �B� "�!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�"CA�%��D�A�������H"�C!��AB�(�C�TA�AD(�"C!"�"CA�*D��B���TC�%C��B�AD��A�"CA��A%�� ��B�G��B �!���"��B�"� �"CA�� DA����� �[�%�"A����%A��G��� �B� "��%%�D�������HB �� "CAD�T�D��(�"CA�!B!�[� ���"C!"�T!��%!DD�A����"�!B���"�"C!"�T!���B%���A���B�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B�DA�!"�B*�"CA��A�AD!���"A����B �A�!��!"��B (��� �B� "�%� DDA%"��������%C�ADD� D���,�!B!�[� ���!DA(�,�D�"(�A���AB"��B �"CA�%�B"D!��%"��B�FA"TAAB�"CA��D����A���A%�� ��B�!B��"CA�*D��B���"C!"������D"��"�,� D�!��[����;��HB �� "CAD�T�D��(�TC!"��� ��!����B�"CA��DA������!D"�%�A� �:1�"� ��9�� ,�"CA��DA�AB"�!��A!���A��B�"D!"A��"C!"�"CA�!�����"��B�(��B�TC�%C�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B��� ������D"A�(���Ba"��%%�D����1��HB�AA�(�"CA�!��A*A���C�D"%���B*���A,�%�AB%�A��� ,�"CA�%�DD�%� ����!B��"CA��[��!F�����Ba"��%%�D����: ��/B���� �B�"��%%�D(�,�D�"(�FA%!��A(�!� �DA%�*B�=A��F[�"CA��/�(�\"CA��FCA%"��A��� ,�"CA�%��D�A�!DA�%���!D!F �A(��B �"AD���� ,��^���� �!B��%���A"AB%A� (�"� �"CA��BA��"!�*C"�F[��B�"�"�"��B��� ,�DA,ADAB%A\�)�!D!*D!�C������� ,�"CA��/�a� �DA��D"�+ ����� ��O�^AT��A��/��DA%�*B�=A��"C!"�\*������AD!���� "D�%"�D�B*�� ,�"CA�%�DD�%� ����%����BAB"\�)������(�!B����������A��D"� ��/�+ �������@D���DA(�\"CA�%�B���"AB%[��,��FCA%"��A��T�"C�"CA�������B�!B���"D!"A*[��,�"CA��B�"�"�"��B�G���A%�!��=A���B �"CA�!DA!�� ,�O�,A�!B��]A!�"C� %�AB%A� (�T�"C�A��%!"��B!�(��%�AB"�,�%�!B��%� �"�D!���D�CA%"�� ,�"CA��B�"�"�"��B\�)�!D!*D!�C��;���;�(�;���1�(�;���: �(�;�����(�!B��;���;��DA�� D"� ��/�+ ����9��_�"C��"�,� D*A""�B*�"C!"(��B�AD�/D"�%�A�;�8�;�� ,�DO��:�����;(�"CA�A���"AB%A�� ,�!���%"� D!��� D�*D!���� ���"��B!���

Page 17: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

�: ��

��� ����B���AD�B*�"CA�!F��A(��BA�%!BB�"�"CADA,�DA�F�"�%�B%���A��"CADT��A�"C!B�"� �DA%�*B�=A�"C!"�%�DD�%� ����!B���[��!F���� ,�"CA�%��D�A�� �!B��� �B�"���,,AD�,D���"CA��A,�%�AB%�A��"C!"�!DA�!""D�F�"A��"��"CA��)F�"(�!� �B�"A��!F��A(�B�"���� �A�AB"A�+(��D(�!"��A!�"(�TC�%C��AA"��"CA�DA<��DA�AB"��,� DA�AAB��B �/D"�%�A��� (�B� ����� ,�DO���:����;���9���O�^AT��A��"��� �B� "��AD�,�A��"C!"�CADA��� �!��!%^�� ,�\DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"\���9���HB �"C �� �DA��A%"(�!B���,�TA����B�AD�"����F[�"CA�!����%!B"(�"CA��"!"A�AB"��,�"CA�!F�AB%A�� ,�!�\DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"\�"C!"�AB"ADA���B �"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B��� �F!�A�(��B �A��AB%A�(��B �"CA��!%^�� ,�!�DA�A!D%C�%AB"AD����9���HA�(�!B��!��T����FA��C�TB�FA��T(��"��� ��F!�A���B�!B�!�����"��B�"C!"�%!BB�"�FA�%�B���ADA��)!B��DA��A�A��,� D�"C�� ���D���A�+�FA%!��A��"��!%^���A*!��F!� �� ����9;��_C�%C��� �*����AB��*C�"� (�F[��"�A�,(�C��"�,[�"CA�DA��%!"��B�� ,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A!��DA���91���A�AD"CA�A���(�!B��DA*!D��A����,�"CA����A*!��"[�� ,�"CA�!�����"��B�(�"CA�"D�"C��� �"C!"�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�!B��"CA�!�� ��%!"��B�"C!"�T!����F��""A���AA"��!����A*!��DA<��DA�AB"��,� D�"CA�!%%DA��"!"��B��,�!��;D��%[%�A�� ,��"���A�(��,�DA�AAB��B�%+ �!B����+ ��,�B8���� ,��/D"�%�A������ ,�DO���:����;����9: ������"�B*(��B �"CA�!�� ��%!B"�DA!��"[(�TC!"�%!B�FA�<�!��,�A�(��B�AD�"CA��!T(�!� �!�"D�A�DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"J��9� ���_C�%C(��B%��AB"!��[(��� �DA%�*B�=A��F[�"CA��/�(�TCAB��"�DA*��"AD� �)����"��A�[+ ?�MCA�A���"AB%A�� ,��%�AB"�,�%���F ��%!"��B��� ,�"CA�!%!�A��%��"!,,��B �"CA�� DA����B!B"�!DA!��,�"CA�%��D�A��B ��B"ADB!"��B!��C��DB!�� �T�"C ��AAD�DA��AT��B �"CA��!�"�,��A�[A!D� �)�� �B"�� ���+ I��F ��MCA�A���"AB%A��,��%�AB"�,�%(�"A%CB���*�%!�(�%� �"�D!��!B��!D"��"�%�!%"���"�A� ��A�A���A���B �"CA�!DA!��,�"CA�%[%�A�� ,��"���A��!B���B"A*D!"A���B �B!"��B!��!B���B"ADB!"��B!��� D� CA%"����!D"BAD�C����)�� �B"�� �;�+ I��9���@D�TCAB�"CA��/���� D�B��B%A������"��A�[�DA*!D��B*�"CA�<�!��,�%!"��B��� ,�"CA�"A!%C�B*��"!,,�)1�����(�1�1���(�/B��1�: ��+ ����99��/B��TCAB��"�AB�B%�!"A��"CA��[�"A��� ,��AD,� D�!B%A�A�!��!"��B�� ,�"CA�"A!%C�B*��"!,,�!� �!�����"��A��� �B"�)�� �B"�1�: �+ ���9� �� A"(��,��BA�DA%�*B�=A��"C!"�"CA�"A!%C�B*��"!,,��� �<�!��,�A��!B��A�AB��D���%"��A��B �"CA��AB�A�"C!"�"CADA�!DA���F ��%!"��B� (�!B��DA�A!D%C�� D� CA%"� �!DA��A�A���A�(��"��� �FA%!��A�"CADA��� �!�\DA!��DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"�\������@D(�!"��A!�"(�"C �� ��� �"CA�,�D��%�B��%"��B�� ,�"CA�!����%!B"�)!��A��!B"+(�"C!"�"C�� ����"�FA���,,�%�AB"�"� ��AA"�"CA�DA<��DA�AB"���,�/D"�%�A������B8���� ,�DO���:����;�(������4D�A,�[(�!B��T�"C��"��DAC���%A�� ,�"CA��!B�,A�"��!%^�� ,�DA!��B�(�"CA��A%�� ��B�T!��F!�A���B��B%�DDA%"�!�����"��B� (��� �"C!"�!��� �,� D�"C �� �DA!��B(��"��� �BA%A��!D[�"� �DA�A!���"���_�"C��"�*D!B"�B*(�����4 �; � � � DD� D� �B � "C A � ! � � � �� "�� B � � � , � �!T � �� / �� �%"�� B � � �� �! "�� B � � , � �!T4 �; � � � DD� D� �B � "C A � ! � � � �� "�� B � � � , � �!T � �� / �� �%"�� B � � �� �! "�� B � � , � �!T4 �; � � � DD� D� �B � "C A � ! � � � �� "�� B � � � , � �!T � �� / �� �%"�� B � � �� �! "�� B � � , � �!T4 �; � � � DD� D� �B � "C A � ! � � � �� "�� B � � � , � �!T � �� / �� �%"�� B � � �� �! "�� B � � , � �!T ???? ������������/��B� "A��!F��A(�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B��� �B� "�%�A!D�DA*!D��B*�"CA�DA!��B��"C!"�F!�A���"����;��/B���"��� �B� "�%�A!D(�FA%!��A��"��� �%����A"A�[�� ��AB"�DA*!D��B*�"CA��!T�*D��B������B��B �TC�%C��� �F!�A�(�F�"�FA%!��A��"�!��� �� D����A��DA!��B�B*�"C!"(�,� D��"CA�,!%"�!���� �B"�� ,���AT(��� �%�A!D�[��A,�%�AB"�!B��%�B"D!��%"� D[����1��DA���"A�"CA��B"AD�DA"!"��A���,,�%� �"�A� �%!��A��F[�"CA��C�D"%���B*���,�DA!��B�B*��TC�%C���"�!"A��"CA��A%����B(�"CA�!��A��!B"�G�"C��*C�T�"C��"�%AD"!�B"[�)�,� D�"CA�DA!��B��*��AB�!F��A�+ �G�!���"� �"C!"��"�%!B�FA�F!�A���B�"CA���"!"A��B� "�,� �,����AB"�� ,�"CA�DA�A!D%C�DA<��DA�AB"(��!�����TB��B �"CA�B8���� ,�/D"�%�A����� ,�DO���:����;����: ���A�AD"CA�A����,�TC!"�T!���!���A!D��AD��B �"C �� �DA*!D��)�B ��!D"�%� �!D(�"CA��B�AD�[�B*�ADD� D+ (�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�%!B��B�[���F���A�G��B �!F�"D!%"�G�"CA�%�B���AD!"��B��%�B"!�BA���B �"CA�DA�� ��"��B (��B ��!D"�%� �!D(�"CA�;D���!D!*D!�C�� ,��A%"��B����� ,�"CA�B� "�,�%!"��B (�"CA�!F��A�AB"��BA���D���� ��B ����� �� �B%A�"C �����F����"��B���A��B�"��A!B(�� ,�"CA�!����%!B"��!D"(�"CA�DA%�*B�"��B��,�"CA�,!%"���B�TC�%C��"��� �F!�A��G�"C!"��� �"� ��![(�"CA�!�����"��B��� ,�"CA��A��FAD!"��B�G��� ���""�A�)"CA�DA%�*B�"��B+ �� ,���%C���F����"��B �������/B����A��B�"��A!B�DA%�*B�"��B��,�"CA�,!%"� ��B�TC�%C��"��� �F!�A�(�,� D�"CA�� ��� �A�DA!��B�"C!"(�!� ��"!"A��A!D��AD(�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�%�B���AD� �"C!"�"CA��A%�� ��B�T!��F!�A���B��B%� DDA%"�!�����"��B� ��

Page 18: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

��9��O�^AT��A��"�!��� ���A��B�"��A!B�DA%�*B�"��B�� ,�"CA�%�DDA%"BA���� ,�"C!"��!D"�%� �!D���AD!"��B���F����"��B (�� �B%A�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�,D�B"!��[��"����!*DAA� (�B�"��B�[�B�"��A"�"CA�!�����"��B���B�AD�[�B*�)!B�����A�A����F����"��B�"� �"C!"+(�F�"�!����"CA�DA!��B��A!%C�� ,�TC�%C��� �A����A������ �� "!"A��"CA�/D"�%�A��� (��!D!*D!�C��(��,�DO���:����;(�"C!"�\"CA��A*DAA��,���%"�D��B �!��!D"�%��!D�F D!B%C��,� B�T�A�*A��D��^����%!B��B�[�FA�!T!D�A��F[��B��AD� �"�A� �� D��B��AD� �"[��B�"�"�"A��TC�%C�%����!"��A�[��?Q���R��%+ �"� ��A��B�"D!"A(��B �"C �� �!DA!(�C!�A�"CA�C��!B�!B��� D*!B�=!"��B!��DA���D%A��DA<��DA��"� �%�B��%"�"CA�DA�A!D%C I��+ �"� �� D����A��D��,(�F[�"CA��A��A���D�"CD��*C�"CA�D��!D"�%��!"��B�� D�%� ��!F� D!"��B (�� D�"CA�D�"A!%CAD� �!B��DA�A!D%CAD� ��B �A�"ADB!���%�AB"�,�%��B�"�"�"��B�(�!B�!%%����!"A��A��AD�AB%A�� ,�DA�A!D%C�A�F���A���B�DA�A�!B"��%�AB"�,�%�!B��!%!�A��%�� D���%"��B��B �"C ���F D!B%C�� ,�^B�T�A�*A�� D��^�����\�������MC��*C�"CA�DA<��DA�AB"�� ,�"CA�DA�A!D%C�,!��� ��B�AD�"CA�"T���!D!*D!�C��%�"A�(�"CADA�!DA�B� ����F"��"C!"��B �%!�A�"CA�!�� ��%!B"��!"��,[�%�A!D�[�!B���BA<����%!��[�DA<��DA���B�AD��!D!*D!�C�<��"A��F[�%+ ��������MCA�<�A�"��B (��B ���AT�� ,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B (��"�%!B�!��� �FA�%�B���ADA��,� D�"CA��� �B"��+ ��������HB �"C �� �DA*!D�(�"CA�DA����"��B��"!"A��"C!"�\"CA��F CA%"��A��� ,�"C �� �%��D�A�� ,��"��[�!DA�%���D����A��F[�"CA�!F�AB%A�� ,�!�DA!��DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"�"C!"��D���"A��"A!%C�B*�"��"CA��A�A��;D���[%�A��.D���!��%�AB"�,�%��"!B����B"�"CA�H�G��C!��!,,���!"A���F��%!"��B���B �!�T��A��!D�A"[�� ,�"�� �%� ��MC�������AD� ��B��� �B�"�!��D��D�!"A�"� �%DA!"A�!��"D�%"�DA���%�AB"�,�%�� D� CA%"�T�"C �!�%D�"�%!���!���� ,�TA��G<�!��,�A��DA�A!D%CAD� ��B�"CA�!DA!�� ,�O�,A�%�AB%A��!B��]A!�"C�O!%^�!�A<�!"A��%�AB"�,�%�� D�*D!��"C!"��B"A*D!"A��"D!�B �B*�!B���A,�BA�!DA!��� ,�,�"�DA���A%�!��=!"��B(�TC�%C�%��F�BA��"CA�,!%"�"C!"�"CA�H�G����A��B�"�C!�A�!�DA�A!D%C�%AB"AD�!%%DA��"A��F[�"CA�.�M(��!^A��"CA�� D����!����A��B� "��AA"�"CA�DA<��DA�AB"��,� D�!��D��!��\)�!D!*D!�C���+ �����;��H,�!�A<�!"A�[��B�AD�"����F[�"CA�!����%!B"(�"CA��"!"A�AB"�� ,�"CA�!F�AB%A�� ,�!�\DA�A!D%C�AB��D�B�AB"\�AB"ADA��"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B��� �F!�A�(��B �A��AB%A(�"CA��!%^�� ,�!�DA�A!D%C�%AB"AD�!%%DA��"A��F[�.�M�����1��MC!"��A!B��"C!"��"��� �F!�A���B�!B�!�����"��B�"C!"�%!BB�"�FA�%�B���ADA��)!B��DA��A�A��,�D�"C �����D���A+ �,� D��!%^�� ,��A*!��F!� �� �����: ��/B��%!BB�"�FA�%�B���ADA��FA%!��A�TC!"�"CA��!T�DA<��DA���� �� ��� �[�"C!"��A��B�"D!"A�\����A���Q���R�!�%����!"��A�DA�A!D%C�A��AD�AB%A�A�F���A���B �DA�A�!B"��%�AB"�,�%�!B��!%!�A��%�� D���%"��B��B �"C �� �F D!B%C�� ,�^B�T�A�*A�� D��^����\�������/B�(�,� D�"C!"��!""AD(��"��� �B� "�!�%�B��"��B�"� �C!�A�!�DA�A!D%C�%AB"AD�!%%DA��"A��F[�.�M��������.� ���T��"C!"�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B(�"��DA�A!��)BA*!"��A�[+�"CA�!F�AB%A�� ,�!�DA�A!D%C�%AB"AD�T�"C �"C��A�!""D�F�"A�(����"� ��B%�D�"CA���� �!"��B�� ,�"C �� �D� �A�����9��H"��� �B� "(�%�A!D�[(�"C �� ��� �TC!"�"CA��!T��![�P�������H"��� �B� "(���DA�[(��� �"C!"�"CA��!T�%!B�!B���C�����FA��B"AD�DA"A�P�������E�DA��AD(��"��� �!%%� D��B*�[�"� �"C �� �� D�%A��DA�"C!"�"CA��!T�C!��FAAB��B"AD�DA"A��F[�"CA��/�FA%!��A(�� "CADT��A(�T�����B� "�!%%DA��"A��;D���"��[�%[%�A� �"C!"�%�DDAB"�[�!DA�!%%DA��"A�(�!� ��� �"CA�%!�A�?��!��#CD��B �#C!D�!%A�"�%!�� %�AB%A��!"�&#�)C""� ?����*!DD!�����"�,,����"�%�DS*AD!��%�DS��ATJ��S!B�S�A%"���U���;V��S�D�*A�U�&�V��S"���S%�DS��*�!UDV��S%�D��S��U���:+?�..&#�C!��B��.�M��B�"(�T�"C ����A�� ,�"C!"�� D�,A���D��!,,���!"A�"� �A�"ADB!���B�"�I��F �� #CD� �B � #C!D�!%A�"�%!�� %�AB%A�� ,D��� "CA� &B��AD� �"[� � ,� �� ��FD!� C!�� ��AB"�%!�� � D*!B�=!"��B�)C""� ?��TTT��%��"�,,�%��B��B�����"�D!�AB"��+?�"CA�..&��C!��B��.�M��B�"(�"A!%CAD���!^�B*��!D"�� ,�"CA������ D�� "CAD�.�M�%AB"AD� ��������MCA�,!%"�"C!"�"CA�!����%!B"���A��B�"�C!�A�!�DA�A!D%C��B�"�A�!��!"A��!B��DA%�*B�=A��F[�.�M��A�A����AB"�%!BB�"�FA��B"AD�DA"A��!��FA�B*��[B�B[�����T�"C�"CA��!%^�� ,�A��AD�AB%A�� ,�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�)!B���"� ��A�FAD�+ �!"�"CA�DA�A!D%C ��������/B��%!BB�"�FA��B"AD�DA"A��F[�"C�� �T![(�!B��C�T�T����FA��A��B�"D!"A���!"AD(��A�"� �"CA�%�BBA%"��B�!B���B"A*D!"��B�� ,�"A!%C�B*�!B��DA�A!D%C��"!,,��,�"CA�!����%!B"�"��� "CAD�A�"ADB!��DA�A!D%C�%AB"AD�(�F�"�!����"��C!�A���� �A�AB"A��"CA�D��TB�DA�A!D%C�!B���A�A����AB"��B�"��A� �*B!"A��HH�/./�M(�TC�%C�!����"� �DA�A!D%C��B �"CA�!DA!��,�#!"C��C[�����*[�)%!B%AD(�%!D����!�%��!D����A!�A(�� D!���!"C� ��*[(�"���%� ��*[+�!B��"CA�!DA!��,�CA!�"C�#D���"��B�)AB��D�B�AB"!�������"��B(���[%C���*[(�����!"D[(�CA!�"C �%!DA+ �G�!B��"C!"�%� DDA���B��"� �!DA!��� ,��"D!"A*�%�DA�A!D%C�"C!"������D"�"CA��!D�����%��D�A���B �"CA�,!%��"[�!B��"CA�!����%!B"�C!�A�A��AD�AB%A��,�!F��"�������"��%"� D!��DA�A!D%CAD� (����"�[�,� ��G"��A�"A!%CAD� �����;��MCA�HH�./�M(��A���"A�B�"�FA�B*��!��A���D�DA%�*B�=A��F[�"CA�.�M�C!���A�A���A���BB��!"��A�DA�A!D%C�!%"���"�A� �T�D"C[�� ,�B� "A(��

Page 19: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

��1��/"�"CA����B"��,�"CA�!����%!B"(��B �E!D%C����1(�C!�A�FAAB���FCA%"�"��!B�!���"�F[�"CA�HB��A%"�D!"A��,����%!"��B�!B�� %�AB%A�)HN��+ (�TC�%C�C!��"CA�,����T�B*��FCA%"��A� (�!��B*��"CAD�(�%CA%^�B*�"CA�A��AB"�!����AD!"��B!��DA<��DA�AB"�(�F�"C�*ABAD!��!� ��!D"�%��!D(��B�AD�/D"�%�A� �;� ��8�"� �1: ���WH� �� ,�"CA�)O!T�B ��8���������� ,����A�"A�FAD+ �����: ��HN����B ��"� �#DA����B!D[��A��D"(��B �"CA��A*�AB"��B�"CA�A�!��!"��B�� ,�DA�A!D%C�)�����+(�%�B%���A��"C!"?�\��"T�"C�"!B��B*�"C �� �%AB"AD�B� "�FA�B*�A�!��!"A���D�!��D��A��F[�"CA�.�M(�"CADA�!DA�� D� CA%"� ���DA�A!D%C�!%"���"�A� �!B���A�A����AB"�!��A��A��!B��DA%�*B�=A��%�B,�*�D�B*�%�����!B%A�T�"C���FG�!D!*D!�C���+�!B��A+��,�/D"�%�A�1��� ,�"CA��WH���B �%�BC�B%"��B�T�"C�"CA��D���� ��B��� ,��!D!*D!�C����!B��;�� ,�/D"�%�A�1:"C�� ,�"CA��!�A��!T�\����� ��MCA��A!B��"C!"�"C ���DA��D"��� �!�%�A!D�DA%�*B�"��B�� ,�,����%�����!B%A�T�"C�"CA�DA<��DA�AB"���B ��A*!��"AD��(�DA,ADD�B*�"� �DA�A!D%C(�"� �A��%!"��B!���B�"�"�"��B����%C�!���B��AD� �"�A� �)/D"�%�A�1�+ �!B��&B��AD� �"[�HB�"�"�"A��)/D"�%�A�1��TC�%C�DA,AD� �"� �"CA��!�A��� �B"� (�,� DT!D��B*�"� �/D"�%�A�1�+ (��B �[��%C�� �� �"C!"�%!B�"A!%C���%"� D!"A� ����M� �FA�%�B"�B�A�(�������MCA�DA��D"A��ADD� D�)����!"��B��,��!T+(�!�FA�"��B �!�� ��*C"�[���,,ADAB"��AD��A%"��A(��B%�D��"CA��/���A��B�"�,!����B �"CA�A�!��B!"��B�� ,�"CA�!�� ��%!"��B(�A��AD�AB%A�!B���B"A*D!"��B��,��A�FAD���,�"CA�!����%!B"�!��!�DA���"�� ,�FA�B*�!,,���!"A��T�"C�� "CAD��B�"� �� D��B�"�"�"��B��TC��A��AD,� D�!B%A�T!��D!"A��F[�.�M�����9��/**D!�!"�B*�T�"C���%C��,�"CA�!%"���"[�� ,�"CA��B"A*D!"A��A�"ADB!���A�FAD���B �.�M��B�"� �FA��A�A���A��T�"C �B �"CA��B�"�"�"��B (�!�� ��%!B"�CADA�B (��B �"CA�D��TB��!F� D!"� D�A� (�� D��AD�[���AB"�,�A��!B��TA���A<����A��!B��DA%�*B�=A��F[��/������� ��/���C�����FA�B�"A��"C!"�"CA��B"A*D!"��B��,�A�"ADB!��DA�A!D%CAD���B �"CA�A��B�"���� �F!�A�(�B�"��B�[�"CA�DA�A!D%C�%!�!%�"[�� ,��A%"�DAD��� ,�"CA�!����%!B"(�F�"�!����"CA�!��A���!��A�"C!"��"� �,!%���"�A� ���A<����AB"�!DA�,� D�"CA�A��B�"� (��!^�B*�"C �� �,� D�FABA,�%�!���B"A*D!"��B�F� "C��!D"�A� ����������B�AD�A�[(�DA�A!D%CAD��,D���"CA�!����%!B"�)!B��"CA�D��"��AB"�+�FABA,�"�,D���!%%A���"� ��B,� D�!"��B (�,!%���"�A� ���A<����AB"�!B��"CA�%D�"�%!���!���� ,�"CA��B�"�TCADA�"CA[�!DA��B"A*D!"A���������/%%� D��B*�[(�"CA��D����A����%"� D!��� D�*D!��,�B��!B�AB��D�B�AB"�,!�� D!F �A�"� �"CA�D�"D!�B �B*�"C!"��AA"��!���"CA�%�B��"��B��BA%A��!D[�DA�A!D%C ��������MCA�ADD� D�DA��D"A���B �"CA�,�B!��DA��D"�"� �FA��!��(��B ��!D!*D!�C����1�(�MC!"�\"CA�,!%"�"C!"����A��A�FAD���,�"CA�H�G��!DA�!,,���!"A��T�"C�� "CAD��B�"��� D��B�"�"�"��B��TC��A��%�AB"�,�%��AD,�D�!B%A�T!��!��A��A��!���AD[�*����� D�A�%A��AB"�F[�"CA�.�M�B� "����� �F �A�"� �A�"AB��"C �� �<�!��,�%!"��B�"� �"CA�H�G��� �B%A��"�T!��*��AB�F!�A���B�"CA��AD,�D�!B%A��,�"CA�A��B�"�"�"��B���A�AB��B*��B�"CA�D��TB��^���� (�� D*!B�=!"��B�!B��AB��D�B�AB"�\����;��@D�TCAB��"��� ��!��(�,�D"CAD(�"C!"�\�B �"CA�%�B"A�"�� ,�"CA��D����!�(�"C ���!��A*A��b�!�B�"DA!��B*b�%!B��B�[�FA��!�����,�"CA�b�B�"�TCADA�"CA[�!DA��B"A*D!"A�b�!��� ������A�"CA�DA���B��F���"[�� ,�"CA�"��[��[%�A�T�"C�"CA�H�G�(�"C!"��� (�TCA"CAD�"CA�A��B�"��!B��"CA�H�G��,� D��!B��B"A*D!"A���B�AD����"!F�[�,� D���!"A��� D�"�%�����D*!B��MCADA,�DA(�!�%�A!D�[�A��DA��A��%����"�AB"�� ,�"CA�A��B�"� �T�"C �H�G��"� �"!^A�DA���B��F ���"[�"� �%����A"A�"CA�%[%�A�� D����A��%[%�A�� ,��"���A� (��� �A��AB"�!�(�F�"(�,� D�B�T(��� ����� �B*��B �"CA�� D����!�������1��.!���B*�"� �DA�A!��"CA�DA�A!D%C�A��AD�AB%A�,�D�"A!%CAD��!B��DA�A!D%CAD���,�"CA�!����%!B"(�"CA��A%�� ��B���� �!"A��!*!�B (�/D"�%�A��� (��8���� ,�DO���:����;�����: ��/B����� �!"A��"C ����"!B�!D��FA%!��A�TC!"��"�DA<��DA���� ��ADA�[��A��B�"D!"A��"C!"�\����A���Q���R�!�%����!"��A�DA�A!D%C�A��AD�AB%A�A�F���A���B �DA�A�!B"��%�AB"�,�%�!B��!%!�A��%�� D���%"��B��B �"C �� �F D!B%C�� ,�^B�T�A�*A�� D��^����\����� �� /B�(�!%%� D��B*�"� �"CA�!,� DA�AB"��BA���� �B"��+ �B8���� ,�!D"�%�A����� ,�DO���:����;(�"C �� �A��AD�AB%A(�T�"C �DA,ADAB%A�"� �"CA�A��%!"��B!���B�"�"�"��B (���%C�%!B�FA�*!�BA����DA%"�[�� D��B��DA%"�[��������MC!"��� (�"C �� �A��AD�AB%A�%!B�FA�)!%<��DA�+�\F[�"CA��A��A���D�"CD��*C�"CA�D��!D"�%��!"��B�� D�Q��DA%"R�%� ��!F�D!"��B(��D�"CA�D�"A!%CAD� �!B��DA�A!D%CAD� �Q�B��DA%"R��B �A�"ADB!���%�AB"�,�%��B�"�"�"��B�\�����9�� �B%A��"��� �B�"�DA�A�!B"�,� D�"C�� ���D���A(�!B���B�AD�"CA��!T��B �,�D%A(�"CA�T![��� �"�"D!"A��A��AD�AB%A?�TCA"CAD�,�D�!��=A��� D�B�"�),� D�A�!���A(�"CD��*C��D� "�%� ��+ ������� ��O�^AT��A��"��� �B� "�!��� �DA�A!�A��)��DA�� D��A��+ �"CA��B"AB��"[�� ,��B"A*D!"��B ���

Page 20: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

�9��

�;���H"��� �"CADA,� DA�DA<��DA�(�,� D��!%^�� ,��A*!��F!��� (�"CA�\DA<��DA�AB"\����DA���B �"CA�.�B!���A��D"�"C!"�\�B �"CA�%�B"A�"�� ,�"CA�� D����!�(�"C �� �!��A*A��b�!�B�"DA!��B*b�%!B��B�[�FA��!�����,�"CA�b�B�"�TCADA�"CA[�!DA��B"A*D!"A�b������A�"CA�DA���B��F���"[�� ,�"CA��[%�A�� ,� "���A��T�"C�"CA�H�G��\����;���MC!"��A!B��\!���,�"CA�A��B�"� �!B��"CA�H�G��"� �,� D��!B��B"A*D!"A��F��[(��B�AD�� D��AD�[�,� D���!"A��� D� "�%� ��\����;���H"��� �B� "(�%�A!D�[(�"C �� �TC!"�"CA��!T��![�P���;;����D(���DA�[(��� �"C!"�"CA��!T�%!B�!B���C�����FA��B"AD�DA"A�P���;1��_C!"�"CA��!T��![��!B��C�T��"��C�����FA��B"AD�DA"A���� ��AD[�%�A!D?��B �� D�AD�"� �� D��A�"CA�A���"AB%A�� ,�A��AD�AB%A�!"�"CA��A�A��� ,�DA�A!D%C�!B��A��AD�AB%A�"C!"��![�DA���"�,D����!D"�%��!"��B�� D�%���AD!"��B��,�"CA�!����%!B"�!B����� D�"CA��!D"�� ,��"� ��A�FAD��)"A!%CAD��!B��DA�A!D%CAD�+ ��B �A�"ADB!���B�"�"�"��B� (�DA*!D��A���� ,�"CA�,� D��� ,��!D"�%��!"��B�� D�%� ��!F� D!"��B ����;: ��_!��B� "(�C�TA�AD(�"C!"�"CA��B"AD�DA"!"��B�!���"A���B �"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B ����;� ��HB�"A!�(�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%����B�����B�"�DA�A!��"CA�DA�A!D%C�A��AD�AB%A�,� D�"A!%CAD��!B��DA�A!D%CAD� �TCAB��"��� �%AD"!�B �"C!"(��B�AD�/D"�%�A��� (��8��(��� �B"��+ (��C�����FA�DA��A�A�����;���.!���B*�"� �C!�A���BA���(�"CA��A��FAD!"��B��B%�D���B �ADD� D��B �"CA��A"AD��B!"��B�� ,�!�����"��B��D�*C"�����%A�� ,���� �!"��B�� ,��!T(�DA!��B��C�����FA�DA�A!�A�����;9����AB���DA�"C!B�DA��%!"��B(�!B��� �B%A�"CADA�!DA�B��!�����"��B��)�,�,!%"�!B���!T+ ����B�TC�%C�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B (��� �,�D��%�B��%"��B��,�"CA�!����%!B"�"C!"�!DA��AA"�!����A*!��DA<��DA�AB"��,� D�FA�B*�*D!B"A��"CA�!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�"CA�BAT�%��D�A�� ,��"��[����_�"C��"�%�B%A�A(���4 � � 1 �4 � � 1 �4 � � 1 �4 � � 1 � ��� �� � �� �� B � "� � � �� �! "�� B � � , � "C A � � D�B %�� �A � � , � A <� ! ��"[?�� �� � �� �� B � "� � � �� �! "�� B � � , � "C A � � D�B %�� �A � � , � A <� ! ��"[?�� �� � �� �� B � "� � � �� �! "�� B � � , � "C A � � D�B %�� �A � � , � A <� ! ��"[?�� �� � �� �� B � "� � � �� �! "�� B � � , � "C A � � D�B %�� �A � � , � A <� ! ��"[? ������;� ��MCA�!����%!B"(���F��""A��"CA�� D�B�B%�!"��B�T�"C�"CA��FCA%"�"CA��DA����B!D[�DA��D"�C!����� "A��!��A�!���A�(�!��A"��,��A%�� ��B��"! AB�F[�"CA�4�!D��!���!D"�� ,�!%%DA��"!"��B�� D�%A��A��,� D�BAT�%��D�A��� ,��"��[����1���DA%�� ��B��TADA���F��""A��F[�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�C!�A�"CA�,� ���T�B*�%����B��AB���B!"� D� ?��!��DA,�%�AB%�A��C!�A�FAAB��A"A%"A�I��F ��MCA��A%�� ��B�T!������A��!%%DA��"!"��B(�!�FA�"�%�B��"��B!���MCA��A,�%�AB%�A��"C!"�TADA���AB"�,�A���B �"CA���F������B��!DA�� ,�"CA��!�A�B!"�DA�!B���B ����A�%!�A��!DA���DA��A�ADA�"C!B�"C��A�%C!D*A��"� �"CA�!�� ��%!B"b� �!�� ��%!"��B ����1���MCA��A,�%�AB%�A��"C!"�TADA���AB"�,�A���B �"CA���F������B��!DA��,�"CA��!�A�B!"�DA�!B���B ����A�%!�A��!DA���DA��A�ADA�"C!B�"C��A�%C!D*A��"� �"CA�!�� ��%!B"b� �!�� ��%!"��B ����1����A�AD"CA�A��(�"CA�A��C�D"%���B*������B�"��DA�AB"(��B �"CA�%!�A���DA�AB"A�(�"C��*C����^AB��B �,!�� D�� ,�!%%DA��"!"��B��A%�� ��B� (�!�FA�"�%�B��"��B!��[�)!B��A�AB�,� D�DA�!"��A�[�A�"AB�A���AD����+ ����1;��.� D�A�!���A(��"��C�����FA�B�"A��"C!"�"CA�!F�AB%A��,�!��!��A��!B��DA%�*B�=A��F[�"CA�.�M��B�"�����B� "��"�� �C!��FAAB�!%%DA��"A��;D���"��[�%[%�A� �� �G���,D��/D"�%�A��������11��MCA���AB"�"[�� ,�� �"�!"��B��)!B���B ����A�%!�A��"CA����"��AD������ �"�!"��B� (�F�"C�<�!B"�"!"��A�[�!B��<�!��"!"��A�[+ ��B�"CA��BA�C!B�(�!B��"CA���,,ADAB%A��A%����B��)B�"�!%%DA��"!"��B(�!*!�B�"�"CA�/%%DA��"!"��B+(��B�"CA��"CAD�C!B�(��C�T��"CA��BA<�!��"[�"DA!"�AB"�*D!B"A��"� �"CA�!�� ��%!B"����1: ��MCA��BA<�!��"DA!"�AB"��!^A��%�A!D�"CA�A���"AB%A�� ,�"CA��!D"�� ,�"CA��/(�\"T� �TA�*C"� �!B��"T� ��A!��DA� �\���1� ���%C��BA<�!��"[(���A��B�"�C!�A�!B[�C��"�,�%!"��B�)!B���FCA%"��A+�DA!��B�"C!"��A*�"���=A��"C �� �����!D�"[�� ,�"DA!"�AB"�"D!B��!"A���B"� �!���� �!"��B�� ,�"CA�� D�B%�� �A�� ,�A<�!��"[�)/D"�%�A�: ��8��#/+ (�TC�%C�DA<��DA��"CA�DA��%!"��B�� ,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B ���_�"C��"�%�B%A�A(��4 �: � � B�%A � � , � �B , D �B *A�AB "� � , � A � � AB "�! �� � D� %A�� D! �� )� DA � ���B ! D[� C A! D�B * +4 �: � � B�%A � � , � �B , D �B *A�AB "� � , � A � � AB "�! �� � D� %A�� D! �� )� DA � ���B ! D[� C A! D�B * +4 �: � � B�%A � � , � �B , D �B *A�AB "� � , � A � � AB "�! �� � D� %A�� D! �� )� DA � ���B ! D[� C A! D�B * +4 �: � � B�%A � � , � �B , D �B *A�AB "� � , � A � � AB "�! �� � D� %A�� D! �� )� DA � ���B ! D[� C A! D�B * + ������1���MCA�DA�� ��"��B��B �%D�� �� (�B�BG!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�"CA�BAT�%[%�A�� ,��"���A� (��� �\�B �!%%� D�!B%A�T�"C�"CA�DA%���AB�!"��B�� ,�"CA������""AA�� ,���"ADB!���A��AT7���

Page 21: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

��19��/���"!"A��!F��A(�"CA��A%����B��� �B�"�%�A!D�!F��"�"CA�DA�!"��B�C�� ��B �"AD���� ,�DA!��B�B*(��� �A�"!F ���CA��FA"TAAB�"C��A�"T� ��!D!*D!�C��!B��%�B"AB"�� ,�"CA�.�B!���A��D"�� ,�"CA��/�����1� ����"T�"C�"!B��B*�"CA����F"��� ,�"CA�!��A��!B"��B �DA�!"��B�"� �"CA�*D��B���� ,�"CA��A%����B�)TC�%C�TADA��DA������[����%���A�+ (��"�T!��,��B��"C!"�"CA�AB���A��D"��ADA�[�%��[�"CA�#DA����B!D[��A��D"�!B��"CA��AB"��B��B��!D!*D!�C����1�(�"T��B�"A���B�"CA�� D�B�B%�!"��B�� ,�"CA�!�� ��%!B"���D�B*�"CA�� DA����B!D[�CA!D�B*���]�TA�AD(���:���]�T�%!B�FA�A�� �!�BA��"C!"�!,"AD�%����A"��B�)A�!%"�[�"CA��!�A�!��"CA��DA����B!D[�DA��D"+ (��B �[�"T� �!��A%"� �� ,�"CA�D�*C"�"� �FA�CA!D��"� �FA�!B!�[=A�J���:���MCA�,�B!��DA�� D"��� �%��[(��AD���A�!B��!%%�D!"A(�"CA��!�A��DA����B!D[�DA��D"���]AB%A(��:���MCA�D�*C"�"� �FA�CA!D��T!��DA�A*!"A��"��"CA�AB���,�"CA�DA��D"�!B��"CA�!��A*A��,!%"�!��"[��B �"CA�� D�B�B%�!"��B�� ,�"CA�!�� ��%!B"�%����A"A�[�,� D*� ""AB ����:;���A�AD"CA�A��(�"CA�D�*C"�"� �FA�CA!D��%!BB�"�FA��B�AD�"����!��!�� ��� �A�%D�"�<�A�� ,�"CA�� DA����B!D[�DA��D"�"C!"�BAA���"� �FA�����!D��[�%�B"D!��%"A�����:1��H"��� �C��"�"CA�������"A(�"CA�D�*C"�"� �FA�CA!D���� �!B�����D"!B"�%�B"D�F�"��B�*��AB�"��"CA��D�%A��DA(��"��![�FD�B*(�!� �F D��*C"�"� �"CA��!�A�,!%"� �"C!"�!DA��B^B�TB�!B��DA�A�!B"(�!� �TA���!� ��B�"D��AB"!��,!%"� �"C!"�CA�� �"� ��B�AD�"!B��"CA��!"AD�!��"[�%�B%ADBA�����:: ��4A���A��FA�B*�!�%� D� ��!D[�� ,�"CA�D�*C"�� ,��!D"�%��!"��B��B �!�*��AB��A%�� ��B�%�B%ADB�B*��"�����:� �� MCA� �B"D���%"��B� � ,� "CA� D�*C"� "� � !� CA!D�B*� �B�AD� "CA� !���B��"D!"��A� �!T� DA�A!�� � !� D!��%!�� %C!B*A�� ,� "!"A��!D!��*����!���B��"ADA�����:���HB�AA�(�"CA�BAT�!��D�!%C�T�����B �"CA��AB�A�"C!"�"CA�!%"�%C!D*A��F[�"CA�/���B��"D!"��B�T����FA���DA�%����A"A�!B����DA�A!���[�!%%A�"!F �A��,�!���B��"ADA��C!��!B�!%"��A�D� �A��B ��"����:9��MCA��!D"�%��!"��B��B �"CA�� D���%"��B�� ,�"CA�*��AB�!%"��� �!B�A��AB"�!��!��A%"�"� �FA�%�B��B%A��� ,��"� �*D��B���!B��"C!"�"CA�D��!D"�%��!"��B�T!������D"!B"�!B��DA�A�!B"�"� �"CA��!�A����:� ��HB�AA�(�"C �� �� D�B%�� �A��� �%�B�"�"�"��B!��[�DA%�*B�=A��������� ]�TA�AD(� "CA� �A*�� �!"�DA� ���� B� "� �B"AB"� "C!"� "CA� A�AD%��A� � ,� "CA� D�*C"� "� � !�CA!D�B*�T�����FA�!��ADA�,� D�!��"[�"C!"�"CA�!���B��"D!"��A�AB"�"[�BAA���"���AA"�FA,�DA�"CA�!%"(�<��"A�"CA�%�B"D!D[��� �!B�A��AB"�!�����AB"��B �TC�%C�"CA�!���B��"D!"��A�!�"C�D�"[��C!���!""AB��!"�!���*��AB�"CA�,!%"� �"C!"��A%��A�"� �F D�B*�"CA�� D�%A��DA���������A*!D��B*�"C �� �%!�A��"��� �%�A!D�"C!"�"CA�D�*C"�"� �FA�CA!D��T!��B� "�%�����A��T�"C ��������HB�AA�(�C�T��"��� ����� �F �A�"� ��B�AD�"!B��"C!"�"CA�,�B!��DA�� D"�C!��B� "�DA��A�A��A��AB"�!��,!%"� �!��A*A���B �� D�B�B%�!"��BJ����;��MC!"��A!B��"C!"�"CA�,�B!��DA�� D"���A��B� "���A�"CA�%�B"D�F�"��B�*��AB�"� �����,[���!�AB���"� �,�B��B*��F�"��A�!D"� �,D����"(�%�B�AB�AB"�[(�"� �"CA�AB��� ,�"CA�DA��D"(�!,"AD�C!��B*�!�DA!�[��F"!�B �B*�%�B%��� ��B� �����1��/%%� D��B*�[(�A�AB�F[�!B��BCADAB"��[�"A�!"�%�����A��,�"CA�,�B!��DA��D"(�!� ��,��"��� ��B�AD�"����"CA�,!%"��TADA�%�B���ADA�(�TC�%C�!DA�����D"!B"�����A���B�AD�%�B���AD!"��B��B �"C �� �� D�%A��DA(��,�"CA[�!DA�!B!�[=A���B�[�!,"AD�"CA�,� D���!"��B�� ,�"CA�%�B%��� ��BJ����: ��H"��� ������F�A�"C!"�!,"AD�"CA�%�B%�����B�C!��FAAB��F"!�BA�(�TC�%C��� �"CA�,!�"C,�����DD� D�� ,�"CA�%�B%�����B�� ,�"CA��DA����B!D[�DA��D"(�"CA�,�B!��DA�� D"�T�����%C!B*AJ����� ��O�*�%!��[��"�T�����FA��������F �A�"� ���%%AA����%C (�!� �C!��B� "��%%�DDA���B �"C �� �%!�A��������4�"(�� ,�%��D�A(�"CA��F��*!"��B�"��%����[�T�"C�"CA�D�*C"�"� �FA�CA!D����A��B�"�AB���B �"CA�����!D[��"!"A�AB"�!B��%�B"A�"�B*�"CA�,!%"� �!���%A��F[�"CA�!���B��"ADA������9��MCA�,!%"���C�����FA��B%���A���B �"CA�!B!�[� ����,�"CA�����A��"C!"�!DA��B����A���B �"CA�� D�%A��DA�!B��"CA�,�B��B*��DA,�A%"�"CA�DA!��"[�� ,�"C��A�,!%"� ��

Page 22: NCE/12/01796 Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão ... · NCE/12/01796 ♥ Decisão de apresentação de recurso da decisão do CA - Novo ciclo de estudos NCE/12/01796

����

���� ��MCA�!B!�[� ���� ,�"CA�D�*C"�"��FA�CA!D��%!BB�"�FA�!B!�[=A�����B�[��B �!�\�*CA""� �\�� ,�"CA�DA��D"(�FA%!��A�!�"C��*C�"C �� ��� �!��AD[�%��,�D"!F �A�%C��%A�)��B%A��"�!�� ����"C!"�"CA�,!%"� �!���%A��F[�"CA�!���B��"ADA��A�"�B*���C(�����,[��D�!�"AD�"CA�,!%"� �%�B"!�BA���B �"CA�� D� CA%"+ ��"���� �!"A� (�,D�B"!��[(�"CA��B"AB"��B�� ,�"CA��A*�� �!"�DA�!B��"CA��A""AD�� ,�"CA��!T���HB �%�B%��� ��B (��������H"�T!���A�DA%!"A��"CA�A��AB"�!��,� D�!��"[��B �TC�%C����"D!B��!"A��"CA�D�*C"�"��� DA����B!D[�CA!D�B*�� ,�"CA�!����%!B"(�TC�%C��A!���"� �"CA��B�!����"[�� ,�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%�� ��B�!B��������B*��"� �DA��%!"��B ���MAD����B�AD�TC�%C (�/B���!�B �[�"C��A�DA�!"A��"���!T(�!B���!�T![��T�"C�[��D� ��AD[�AD���"A��A%�� ��B (��C�����"CA�!��A!��FA���CA���(�,� D�� D��AB�(�!B��"CADA,� DA�"CA�%�B"A�"A���A%����B�DA�A!�A��!B��(�� �B%A�!����A*!��DA<��DA�AB"��!DA�!��A�F�A�(�DA� �!%A��F[�!B�"CAD�TC�%C��A,AD� �"CA�!%%DA��"!"��B�� ,�"CA�BAT�%��D�A�� ,��"��[����MCA�/�� ��%!B"?�����