Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    1/21

    Understanding and managing HELLP syndrome:The integral role of aggressive glucocorticoidsfor mother and child

    James N. Martin Jr, MD, Carl H. Rose, MD, Christian M. Briery, MD

    Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, MS

    Received for publication April 21, 2005; revised July 13, 2005; accepted August 18, 2005

    KEY WORDSHELLP syndrome

    Severe preeclampsia/

    eclampsia

    Aggressive

    glucocorticoids/

    corticosteroids

    Obstetric

    Antepartum or postpartum HELLP syndrome constitutes an obstetric emergency that requires

    expert knowledge and management skills. The insidious and variable nature of disease presenta-

    tion and progression challenges the clinician and complicates consensus on universally accepted

    diagnostic and classification criteria. A critical review of published research about this variant

    form of severe preeclampsia, focused primarily on what is known about the pathogenesis of this

    disorder as it relates to patient experience with corticosteroids for its management, leads to the

    conclusion that there is maternal-fetal benefit realized when potent glucocorticoids are aggres-

    sively used for its treatment. Although acknowledging the need for definitive multicenter trialsto better define the limits of benefit and the presence of any maternal or fetal risk, and given

    an understanding of the nature of the disorder with its potential to cause considerable maternal

    morbidity and mortality, we recommend for the present that aggressively used potent gluco-

    corticoids constitute the cornerstone of management for patients considered to have HELLP

    syndrome.

    2006 Mosby, Inc. All rights reserved.

    Recognition that a particularly potent form of pree-

    clampsia-eclampsia exists has been evident since case

    reports first appeared in the late nineteenth1 and early

    twentieth century.2-5 Between 1950 and 1980, several

    case series were published that related patients and

    poor obstetric outcomes to clinical and laboratory find-

    ings that are consistent with what we recognize today as

    HELLP syndrome.6-17 Credit for formally consolidating

    the concept and creating the acronym of HELLP (H =

    hemolysis, EL = elevated liver enzymes and LP = low

    platelets) goes to Louis Weinstein who in 1982 reported

    a group of 29 pregnant patients he considered to have a

    distinct subset of severe preeclampsia/eclampsia.18 All

    patients expressed findings suggestive of microangio-

    pathic hemolytic anemia with moderate-to-severe throm-

    bocytopenia, misshapened erythrocytes on peripheral

    smear, and abnormal liver function tests usually in con-

    junction with epigastric pain, nausea, and vomiting.

    Severe hypertension and proteinuria were frequently

    coexistent as well.

    Since 1982 there has been an outpouring of obstetric

    literature seeking to better define the pathogenesis, natu-

    ral history, clinical spectrum, classification and manage-

    ment strategies for patients considered to have HELLP

    syndrome. Because the incidence of this disorder is lowReprints not available from the authors.

    0002-9378/$ - see front matter 2006 Mosby, Inc. All rights reserved.

    doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2005.08.044

    American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology (2006) 195, 91434

    www.ajog.org

    http://www.ajog.org/http://www.ajog.org/
  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    2/21

    (1-6 per 100019,20), most clinical research endeavors have

    been small, single institution case series or randomized

    trials. Until definitive large multicenter trials are under-

    taken, clinicians must rely on less robust information to

    guide patient care. Despite several recent comprehensive

    reviews on the subject of HELLP syndrome,21-24 none to

    date have examined the available data and patient experi-

    ence primarily from the perspective of corticosteroidimpact on disease expression and progression. The cur-

    rent review is constructed from this perspective, synthesi-

    zing and summarizing the pertinent English literature on

    HELLP syndrome to understand how corticosteroids

    appear to play an integral role in its management.

    Pathogenesis and natural history

    HELLP syndrome usually develops suddenly during

    pregnancy (27-37 weeks gestation) or in the immediate

    puerperium.25-28 As a form of severe preeclampsia, itlikely has its origins in aberrant placental development,

    function, and ischemia-producing oxidative stress,

    which triggers the release of factor(s) that systematically

    injure the endothelium via activation of platelets, vaso-

    constrictors, and loss of normal pregnancy vascular

    relaxation.29-36 Although variable, HELLP syndrome

    onset and progression usually is rapid (35%-50% de-

    crease in platelets per 24 hours; mean daily reduction

    of 40,000/mL platelets) as lactic acid dehydrogenase

    (LDH) and aminotransaminases (aspartate [AST] and

    alanine [ALT]) rise until 24 to 48 hours postpartum

    when laboratory values begin to recover.37-42

    Absentcorticosteroids, most patients (85%-90%) achieve plate-

    lelets 100,000/mL or greater within 6 to 8 days of deliv-

    ery or within 72 hours of platelet nadir, and total LDH/

    transaminases trend toward normal within 96 hours

    postpartum.37,41-43 Onset of disease occurs postpartum

    in approximately 15% to 25% of cases.25-28

    Although most patients with HELLP syndrome even-

    tually exhibit hypertension and proteinuria, these 2 major

    signs of severe preeclampsia bear no consistent relation-

    ship with laboratory parameters of the underlying vascu-

    lopathy.26-28,37,38 A variety of symptoms can be elicited

    that are ambiguous, subtle, and focused primarilyon the gastrointestinal-hepatic systems.28 The central

    place that the liver occupies in the disorder of HELLP

    syndrome is an important clue to pathogenesis. Severe

    epigastric/right upper quadrant pain often heralds under-

    lying rapidly progressive disease.44 The extent of peri-

    portal hepatocyte dysfunction or cell death in a given

    patient probably correlates with the severity of maternal

    illness. Recall that CD95 (APO-1, Fas)-mediated apopto-

    sis of hepatocytes is a major pathogenic mechanism

    for liver disease in general.45 The Fas-Fas ligand system

    is a well-studied cell death system that can mediate apo-

    ptosis. As a member of the tumor necrosis factor receptor

    superfamily, Fas is a 36 to 45 kDa type I surface protein

    containing a single transmembrane region.46 It induces

    apoptosis by binding to Fas-ligand, a 40 kDa type II

    transmembrane protein of the tumor necrosis factor re-

    ceptor family.47 In the context of pregnancy and patients

    with HELLP syndrome, apoptosis in liver tissue and cyto-

    toxic activity for primary human hepatocytes has been

    reported in serum from patients with HELLP syndrome(CD95 ligand produced by placenta) that increases over

    time and in proportion to disease severity.45 In addition,

    caspases 3, 8, and 9 are all required to effect apoptotic

    cell death, and active forms of all 3 are detected in liver

    extracts of HELLP patients. Blocking of CD95 signaling

    reduces the hepatocytotoxic activity of HELLP serum.

    Thus, systemic CD95L is a placenta-derived humoral

    factor that is involved in the pathogenesis of HELLP

    syndrome. CD95L-rich membrane fragments or soluble

    CD95L are postulated by Strand et al45 to be shed into

    the maternal circulation as important progenitors in the

    pathogenesis of HELLP syndrome.The previously described findings and the proposal

    that placenta-derived proteins damage hepatic cells are

    compatible with many other findings that cast HELLP

    syndrome as a placenta-instigated, liver-targeted acute

    inflammatory condition and disordered immunologic

    process.21 The similarity between HELLP syndrome and

    systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) has

    been emphasized by several researchers.48-50 The pertur-

    bations present in patients who have HELLP syndrome

    develop may be additive to, or altered by, the patho-

    physiology leading to preeclampsia in general. A listing

    of some of the supportive evidence for these conceptsis contained in Table I. Decreases in haptoglobin are

    a sequel, not an instigator of the vascular hemolytic

    process.68 In patients with HELLP syndrome, the metal-

    loprotease ADAMTS-13 is not severely deficient or

    undetectable as it is in many patients with throm-

    botic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP).69,70 No genetic

    markers or evidence for association with thrombophilic

    or antiphospholipid disorders have been established.71-75

    Diagnosis

    The diagnosis of HELLP syndrome is most assured ina pregnant patient with signs and symptoms of

    preeclampsia-eclampsia and a triad of laboratory ab-

    normalities suggesting red cell trauma (H = hemolysis),

    hepatic damage and dysfunction (EL = elevated liver

    enzymes), and thrombocytopenia (LP = low platelets).

    The greater the extent of laboratory abnormalities, the

    greater is the physicians confidence in the diagnosis.

    Thrombocytopenia may be the first indicator of dis-

    ease when the results of a complete blood count return to

    the physician. A platelet count less than 150,000/mL

    represents mild (100,000-150,000/mL), moderate (50,000-

    100,000/mL), or severe (!50,000/mL) thrombocytopenia

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 915

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    3/21

    in the nonpregnant as well as pregnant patient.76 Requir-

    ing a threshold of less than 100,000/mL to consider the

    diagnosis of thrombocytopenia is ill advised. Maternal

    morbidity doubles from 11% to more than 20% when

    patients with severe preeclampsia have mild thrombocy-

    topenia develop in association with increasing LDH

    (R600 IU/L) and transaminases (AST and/or ALT

    R40 IU/L).21,27 Significant pathology such as hepatic

    hemorrhage and rupture can first appear in the patient

    with HELLP syndrome before the platelet count falls

    below 100,000/mL.28 Indeed, the onset of epigastric pain

    in patients who are eventually diagnosed with HELLP

    syndrome has occurred at a platelet count as high as

    283,000/mL in our patient population (unpublished).

    Hepatic injury and dysfunction

    In Weinsteins initial 1982 report, thresholds of what

    constituted abnormal serum levels of aspartate transam-

    inase (AST), alanine transferase (ALT) and bilirubin to

    merit a diagnosis of HELLP syndrome were not stated.18

    Most healthy pregnant patients in our hospital laboratoryexhibited normal transaminase values less than 20 IU/L,

    with greater than 48 IU/L for AST 3 SD above the

    mean.27 A threshold for AST of 70 IU/L or greater to

    qualify for the diagnosis of HELLP syndrome when

    platelets are 100,000/mL or less has been consistently

    advocated by Martin et al21 and Sibai.22 Transaminase

    values between 40 and 70 IU/L reflect borderline hepatic

    dysfunction regardless of the platelet count (especially in

    the 100,000-150,000/mL range).28 Glutathione S-transfer-

    ase alpha has been proposed as a better marker for acute

    liver injury than the aminotransferases,but there has been

    limited work on this possibility.77

    Erythrocyte injury and death

    Evidence for hemolysis is the third laboratory criterion for

    HELLP syndrome. In addition to a progressive anemia,

    other laboratory evidence of hemolysis classically in-

    cludes decreased serum levels of haptoglobin, increased

    serum total LDH 600 IU/L or greater,26,28 increased se-

    rumAST, increased serum indirect bilirubin, an abnormal

    peripheral smear showing variable amounts of disrupted

    or destroyed red blood cells (schistocytes, echinocytes,burr cells), and/or a declining hematocrit or hemoglobin.

    Depending on laboratory methodology, LDH thresholds

    for abnormal values begin between 200 and 600 IU/L.

    Classification

    Classification systems have been created to enable phy-

    sicians to identify patients at risk for significant mater-

    nal morbidity, to guide therapeutic intervention and

    assess efficacy or outcome, and to provide a common

    platform for comparison of research results. The 2 most

    commonly used systems for diagnosis and classificationwere developed in the 1980s by investigators at the

    Universities of Tennessee and Mississippi (Table II).

    The Tennessee Classification78 defines true or

    complete HELLP syndrome if all of the following cri-

    teria are met: (1) moderate to severe thrombocytopenia

    with platelets 100,000/mL or less; (2) hepatic dysfunction

    with AST 70 IU/L or greater; and (3) evidence of hemol-

    ysis with an abnormal peripheral smear in addition to

    either total serum LDH 600 IU/L or greater or bilirubin

    1.2 mg/dL or greater. The patient who exhibits some but

    not all of these parameters is termed partial or in-

    complete HELLP syndrome: ELLP syndrome (missing

    Table I Research findings contributory to an inflammatory pathogenesis for HELLP syndrome

    Elevated serum concentrations of soluble Fas.51

    Cytokine and neutrophil-mediated liver injury in necropsy liver specimens with strong staining for tumor necrosis factor-alpha and

    neutrophil elastase antibody.52

    Leukocytosis proportionate to disease severity.53

    Increased plasma concentrations of anaphylatoxins C3a and C5a.54

    Decreased unstimulated neutrophil oxygen radical production possibly secondary to an exhausted cellular response.55

    Abnormal circulating cytokine concentrations.52,56

    Increased bioactive tumor necrosis factor alpha possibly secondary to immune injury of the vascular endothelium or muscle.57

    Depression of both T- and B-cell potential and impaired monocyte handling of intracellular pathogens precedes clinical/laboratory

    disease by 1-2 wks.58

    Decreased placental vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) expression in placentas from HELLP syndrome pregnancies59,60 analagous to

    decreased circulating levels of free VEGF and platelet-derived growth factor (PlGF) in preeclamptic patients without HELLP syndrome.61

    Dysregulation of VEGF ligands and receptors with higher serum VEGF compared to h ealthy matched

    pregnant controls (but less elevated than patients with non-HELLP preeclampsia.62

    Hypersensitivity to pressors using laser-doppler digital fluxometry microcirculation studies.63

    Substantially decreased vascular smooth muscle-relaxing adrenomedullin and calcitonin gene-related peptide messenger RNA

    in the placenta.64

    Increased intracellular retention of cadherin-5.65

    Increased plasma and red cell thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) and glutathione peroxidase activity.66,67

    916 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    4/21

    evidence for hemolysis), EL syndrome (severe pree-

    clampsia with mildly elevated liver enzymes only), HEL

    (hemolysis and elevated liver enzymes absent thrombo-cytopenia), or LP syndrome (low platelets syndrome as

    severe preeclampsia with thrombocytopenia, gestational

    thrombocytopenia, or immune thrombocytopenic pur-

    pura).22 Maternal and perinatal outcomes are progres-

    sively worse for patients with preeclampsia, partial

    HELLP syndrome, and complete HELLP syndrome, re-

    spectively.79 Incomplete criteria initially can progress to

    complete expression of HELLP syndrome.

    The Mississippi-Triple Class System for HELLP syn-

    drome divides patients into 3 classes or groups that are

    based primarily on the platelet portion of the laboratory

    diagnosis.21,28,38

    Final class assignment or diagnosis isbased on the lowest platelet count registered during

    the disease course. The span of thrombocytopenia be-

    tween zero and 150,000 platelets is divided into 3 equal

    ranges consistent with mild, moderate, and severe

    thrombocytopenia. For a patient to merit a diagnosis

    of HELLP syndrome, class 1 requires severe thrombocy-

    topenia (platelets %50,000/mL), evidence of hepatic

    dysfunction (AST and/or ALTR70 IU/L), and evidence

    suggestive of hemolysis (total serum LDHR600 IU/L);

    class 2 requires similar criteria except thrombocytopenia

    is moderate (O50,000 to %100,000/mL); and class 3

    includes patients with mild thrombocytopenia (plate-lets O100,000 but%150,000/mL), mild hepatic dysfunc-

    tion (AST and/or ALTR40 IU/L), and hemolysis (total

    serum LDHR600 IU/L). Peripheral smear findings and

    bilirubin abnormalities are not obtained.

    Neither classification system is ideal; both have short-

    comings. Because class 1 and 2 HELLP syndrome

    patients are combined in the Tennessee system, discrim-

    ination between groups and outcomes is difficult and

    benefit from corticosteroids (arrest of disease in class 2,

    prevention of progression from class 3 to 2 or even 1)

    cannot be demonstrated. On the other hand, the Mis-

    sissippi classification system is very useful for directing

    individual patient therapy with aggressive corticosteroids

    and for comparing pregnancy outcomes. The Mississippi

    system, although including class 3 patients, does notinclude those with incomplete or partial forms of the

    disease, and excludes patients from analysis when causes

    of consumptive coagulopathy such as placental abruption

    are present. Two (Tennessee) or even 3 (Mississippi)

    groupings or classes insufficiently describe the multitude

    of clinical scenarios (antepartum vs postpartum, epigas-

    tric pain present or absent, degrees of laboratory value

    abnormality, different gestational age epochs) encoun-

    tered by the clinician. The importance of a transitional

    group of patients is clearly demonstrated by instances of

    hepatic ruptures in patients with class 3 HELLP syn-

    drome80

    and other reports of increased eclampsia andhigher perinatal morbidity/mortality in patients with

    incomplete/partial HELLP syndrome.21

    Imitators of HELLP Syndrome

    Patients presumptively diagnosed with HELLP syn-

    drome can have other disorders concurrent with HELLP

    syndrome or other disorders altogether. Lack of response

    to aggressive corticosteroid administration, especially

    with persistence of disease or first presentation of disease

    more than 7 days after delivery, should instigate testing to

    evaluate other diagnostic possibilities (Table III). In ourexperience, the most common HELLP imitators are

    patients with well-advanced acute fatty liver of pregnancy

    (AFLP), acute renal failure with acute tubular necrosis

    (usually not hemolytic uremic syndrome), neglected

    class 1 HELLP syndrome coming to medical attention

    too late for aggressive corticosteroids to prevent progres-

    sion and multiorgan dysfunction, previously undiag-

    nosed systemic lupus erythematosus/antiphospholipid

    syndrome, and either immune thrombocytopenic pur-

    pura (ITP) or thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura

    (TTP).98 See the excellent reviews of potentially con-

    founding conditions written by Goodlin16,99

    and Sibai.100

    Table II Classification systems of HELLP syndrome

    HELLP class Mississippi classification21,36,46 Tennessee classification22,165

    1 Platelet count %50,000/mL

    AST or ALT R70 IU/L

    LDH R600 IU/L

    Platelet count%100,000/uL

    AST R70 IU/L

    LDH R600 IU/L

    2 50,000/ mL %Platelet count %100,000/mL

    AST or ALTR

    70 IU/LLDH R600 IU/L

    3 100,000/ mL %Platelet count %150,000/mL

    AST or ALT R40 IU/L

    LDH R600 IU/L

    N/A

    Partial HELLP/

    incomplete HELLP

    N/A (Severe preeclampsia C one of the following: ELLP, EL, LP)

    ELLP, Absence of hemolysis; EL, elevated liver functions; LP, low platelets.

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 917

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    5/21

    Clinical presentation

    Signs and symptoms with HELLP syndrome are varia-

    ble but depend largely on the stage of the patients

    disease, whether class 1, class 2, or class 3.28

    Right upperquadrant/epigastric pain is the most important symptom

    suggestive of underlying HELLP syndrome, found in

    100% of Weinsteins initial 1982 series of 29 advanced

    cases.18 Half of patients with class 1 HELLP syndrome,

    33% with class 2, and 16% with class 3 compared with

    only 13% of severely preeclamptic patients without

    HELLP syndrome exhibit epigastric pain or right upper

    quadrant discomfort.28 Frequently epigastric pain oc-

    curs in association with nausea or vomiting. Overall,

    the incidence of epigastric pain/nausea/vomiting ranges

    between 30% and 90%.20,22,26 Any pregnant patient

    presenting in the second half of gestation with epigastricor right upper quadrant pain, particularly if associated

    with nausea and/or vomiting, has HELLP syndrome

    until proven otherwise.44 A pregnant patient with signs

    and symptoms of severe preeclampsia who suddenly has

    severe, writhing epigastric/upper abdominal pain develop

    likely has hepatic bleeding or rupture constituting an

    obstetric emergency.

    Malaise or viral syndrome-like symptoms can occur

    with advanced HELLP syndrome.22,26 Headache occurs

    in a substantial number (33%-68%)22,28 of patients with

    any form of preeclampsia whether HELLP syndrome

    is present, with visual complaints in a lesser number.22

    Hypertension and proteinuria are not always pre-

    sent.21,22,101 Neither of these signs bears a consistent rela-

    tionship in the individual patient with stage of disease,

    although on a population basis higher blood pressures

    and more proteinuria tend to occur more frequently as

    HELLP syndrome worsens from class 3 to 2 to 121,28,102

    and eventually almost all patients are mildly hypertensiveduring the course of their disease and recovery.28 Signifi-

    cant dipstick proteinuria (3-4C) at presentation occurs in

    approximately half of patients with class 1 or 2 HELLP

    syndrome, but no proteinuria is detected in approxi-

    mately 1:6 patients.

    Although the presence and severity of symptomatol-

    ogy (epigastric pain, nausea, vomiting) and hypertension

    (systolic, diastolic) in general are related to maternal

    disease severity and the potential to develop severe mor-

    bidity,28,38,103 individual patient predictive value (with the

    probable exception of severe epigastric pain) is low.104

    Significant maternal morbidity becomes more likelywhen 1 or more of the laboratory thresholds are exceeded

    as listed in Table IV.102,105,106 Very high LDH, AST,

    and/or uric acid have the highest predictive value and

    are risk-additive with worsening thrombocytopenia.28,107

    Maternal morbidity and mortality

    The development of HELLP syndrome places the

    pregnant patient at significant risk for morbidity and

    mortality. Morbidity is categorized by major organ

    system(s) affected and is stratified by extent of diseaseusing the Mississippi classification system.28 Constitu-

    ents of these categories are listed in Table V and pre-

    sented in decreasing order of frequency, emphasizing

    that there is enormous variability among patients.

    Hematologic-coagulation

    The prevalence of disseminated intravascular coagula-

    tion (DIC) increased from 2 of 193 patients (0.5%) with

    severe preeclampsia to 35 of 201 (17.4%) with class 1

    HELLP syndrome,28 the latter very similar to the

    15% incidence of DIC and 9% incidence of placental

    abruption reported by Audibert et al79

    for classes 1

    Table III Confounders and concurrent conditions: differen-

    tial diagnosis50,134

    AFLP81

    Lupus flare: Exacerbation of systemic lupus erythematosus

    (SLE)82,83

    TTP84

    Hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS)85

    ITPThrombophilias

    Antiphospholipid syndrome75,83,86-91

    Homozygous factor V Leiden

    Prothrombin gene mutation

    Severe folate deficiency92

    Cholangitis/cholecystitis/pancreatitis/ruptured bile duct

    Gastric ulcer

    Cardiomyopathy

    Dissecting aortic aneurysm

    Systemic viral sepsis (herpes, cytomegalovirus)93

    SIRS/sepsis

    Hemorrhagic or hypotensive shock

    Stroke in pregnancy or puerperiumParoxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria94

    Pheochromocytoma

    Advanced embryonal cell carcinoma of the liver95

    Acute cocaine intoxication

    Myasthenia gravis96

    Pseudocholinesterase deficiency97

    Table IV Admission risk factors for significant maternal

    morbidity/mortality HELLP syndrome

    Signs/symptoms Laboratory values

    Epigastric pain Platelets !50,000/mL

    Nausea Total serum LDH O1400 IU/L

    Vomiting AST O150 IU/L

    Severe systolic hypertension ALTO

    100 IU/LSevere diastolic hypertension Uric acidO7.8 mg/dL

    Placental abruption CPK O200 IU/L

    Eclampsia Serum creatinine O1.0

    Adapted from Martin et al.102

    918 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    6/21

    and 2 combined. Clinically significant bleeding requiring

    transfusion and wound hematoma formation follow a

    similar pattern of increasing incidence with worsening

    disease.21,25-28,79,104,108 Approximately 10% of patients

    with class 1 or 2 HELLP syndrome exhibit microscopic

    or macroscopic hematuria.28

    Cardiopulmonary

    The odds of developing a cardiopulmonary problem,

    particularly pulmonary edema, is more than doubled

    (2.2!) for patients with class 1 HELLP syndrome

    (22%) compared with non-HELLP severe preeclamp-

    sia.28,109 The overall percentage of 14.5% (74/501) in the

    Mississippi series is similar to the combined 8% inci-

    dence of pulmonary edema and less than 1% incidence

    of adult respiratory distress syndrome in the Tennessee

    series.79 Copious large volume ascites identifies a patient

    at high risk for cardiopulmonary complications.110

    Central nervous system/visual

    Patients with noneclamptic class 1 or 2 HELLP syn-

    drome (11/501 or 2.2%) are 3.5 times more likely to have

    significant central nervous system (CNS) morbidity com-

    pared with class 3 HELLP syndrome or non-HELLP

    severe preeclampsia.28 This includes stroke, mental status

    changes and/or coma.111-114 Visual complications

    including retinal detachment, vitreal hemorrhage, and

    cortical blindness are infrequent in proportion to disease

    severity (1.4% in class 1 and 2).28 These are usually short

    lived with full recovery within 1 to 6 months, exceptwhen cerebral hemorrhage/stroke is the cause.115-126

    Renal

    Placental abruption and puerperal onset of HELLP syn-

    drome place the patient at increased risk for renal insult.

    In general, renal system morbidity increases as disease

    status worsens.28 All 4 of the patients with acute tubular

    necrosis in the Mississippi series had class 1 HELLP syn-

    drome develop; acute renal failure complicated 3% of

    cases of class 1 or 2 HELLP syndrome in the Tennessee

    series.26,79 However, acute renal dysfunction and/or fail-

    ure has been described as often as 54% and 33% insome international series19,127 and as the most common

    cause of maternal morbidity in a report from Mexico.128

    Hepatic

    Catastrophic liver complications are relatively infre-

    quent. Liver hemorrhage/rupture affected only 1% of

    patients with class 1 or 2 HELLP syndrome in the

    Tennessee series26,79 and only 3 patients had significant

    hepatic complications develop (2 subcapsular hemato-

    mas in class 2 and 3 HELLP syndrome patients, 1 liver

    rupture in a class 1 HELLP syndrome patient) in the

    Mississippi seriesdimportantly all were classified as

    class 3 HELLP syndrome when the complication was

    first detected.27 According to Wicke et al,129 at least 1 of

    5 patients with eventual liver rupture caused by HELLP

    syndrome had early subcapsular liver hematoma forma-

    tion compatible with the class 3 level of disease.

    Infection/sepsis

    Patients with HELLP syndrome more often have infec-

    tious morbidity develop than those with non-HELLP

    severe preeclampsia (43% vs 20%).25,27 At least 3 im-

    portant variables are involved: corticosteroids, transfu-

    sion, and delivery. Corticosteroid utilization appears

    to reduce infectious morbidity from 43% to 18% by re-

    ducing or eliminating the need for transfusion of blood

    products.27,28 Abdominal delivery doubles infectious

    morbidity from 19% to 41%.28

    Table V Categories of significant maternal morbidity with

    HELLP syndrome

    Hematologic/coagulation

    Clinically significant bleeding requiring transfusion

    Ecchymoses

    Hematoma

    DIC

    HematuriaCardiopulmonary

    Cardiogenic/noncardiogenic pulmonary edema

    Cardiac/pulmonary arrest

    Pulmonary embolus

    Indicated invasive hemodynamic monitoring

    Intubation/mechanical ventilation/continuous positive

    airway pressure

    Myocardial ischemia/chest pain

    CNS/vision

    Cerebral hemorrhage/stroke

    Central venous thrombosis

    Hypertensive encephalopathy

    Cerebral edemaSensorium change/coma

    Impaired vision

    Retinal/macular detachment

    Vitreal hemorrhage

    Cortical blindness

    Eclamptic seizure

    Renal

    Acute tubular necrosis

    Acute renal failure

    Renal dialysis

    Transient renal impairment

    Hepatic

    Subcapsular/intrahepatic hematomaHepatic rupture/hemorrhage

    Pancreatitis

    Infection/sepsis

    Obstetric

    Other

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 919

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    7/21

    Obstetric issues

    Cesarean delivery has been performed more often forpatients with class 1 HELLP syndrome (61%) than

    class 2 (57%), class 3 (53%), or non-HELLP severe

    preeclampsia (48%).25,28 Mode of delivery is strongly

    influenced by gestational age, maternal-fetal status, class

    of disease, and corticosteroid utilization. Overall abdom-

    inal delivery is associated with a doubling of maternal

    morbidity (cardiopulmonary, hematologic-coagulation,

    and infectious) compared with vaginal delivery.28 In

    addition, risk for placental abruption, placenta previa,

    eclampsia, and episiotomy breakdown is increased

    compared to non-HELLP pregnancies.20,25,130,131

    Parity-eclampsia

    The incidence of complications in hypertensive pregnant

    women varies by parity but not by gravidity.132 When

    HELLP syndrome complicates eclampsia, parous pa-

    tients have double the incidence of significant maternal

    morbidity compared with nulliparous patients (50% vs

    25%).133

    Other morbidity

    Pancreatitis is uncommon in patients with preeclampsia

    or HELLP syndrome; the hemorrhagic form is uniquely

    associated with acute fatty liver of pregnancy.134 Dia-

    betes insipidus,135 bone marrow necrosis with cerebral

    hemorrhage,88 and myocardial infarction136 are rarecomplications.

    Mortality

    Most deaths in patients with HELLP syndrome occur

    with class 1 disease (60%), and neurologic abnormality

    due mostly to cerebral hemorrhage/stroke is the most

    common system involved at autopsy (45%) (Figure 1).137

    Delay in diagnosis appeared to be a factor in half of

    the deaths that could be adequately evaluated, and

    none of the 54 maternal deaths in the Isler et al series137

    or in a subsequent case report138 occurred in association

    with the aggressive use of corticosteroids.

    Perinatal morbidity and mortality

    Perinatal morbidity and mortality are substantially

    higher in pregnancies with severe preeclampsia com-

    plicated by HELLP syndrome, primarily because of

    required preterm delivery.25,139 Fetal growth restriction

    and fetal distress after 32 weeks also may be more fre-

    quent.140 Although neonatal deaths and perinatal mor-

    tality rates tend to be progressively higher in parallel

    with increasingly severity of disease, outcomes are

    Figure 1 Contributing factors to deaths of women with HELLP syndrome are shown in order of decreasing frequency. DIC,

    Disseminated coagulopathy; ARDS, adult respiratory distress syndrome; Enceph, encephalopathy. Reprinted from Isler CM, Rine-

    hart BK, Terrone DA, Martin RW, Magann EF, Martin JN. Maternal mortality associated with HELLP (hemolysis, elevated liver

    enzymes, and low platelets) syndrome. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1999;181:924-8 with permission from Elsevier.

    920 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    8/21

    primarily related to gestational age at delivery and not

    to disease status.28,141-146 Similarly, earlier prematurity

    is responsible for the higher perinatal mortality recorded

    in eclamptic pregnancies with HELLP syndrome com-

    pared with non-HELLP eclampsia.20,25,147 Neonatal

    survival was 100% in the Mississippi experience if new-

    born weight was 600 g or greater and following a full

    course and time interval (48 hours) of antenatal cortico-steroids for fetal lung maturation.148

    Continuation of HELLP syndrome pregnancy be-

    yond 26 weeks and the time necessary for steroid

    enhancement of fetal lung maturation increases the

    risk of stillbirth substantially.144,149 In the Mississippi

    series, stillbirth was almost tripled for class 1 or 2 com-

    pared with class 3 or non-HELLP severe preeclampsia,28

    in part related to fetal growth restriction and placental

    abruption. Fetal growth restriction and abnormal Dop-

    pler velocimetry impact up to 39% and 48% of patients,

    respectively.22,130,150 Although neonatal thrombocyto-

    penia occurs in a substantial percentage (up to38%)130 of newborn infants, a higher incidence of intra-

    ventricular hemorrhage has not resulted.151,152 Long-

    term prognosis for the children of mothers with HELLP

    syndrome is comparable to controls matched for gesta-

    tional age.152 Small-for-gestational-age neonates signifi-

    cantly increase weight and length over the first 4 years of

    life compared with matched controls.153 Newborn

    infants weighing less than 1250 g compared with birth

    weight-matched controls had significantly less cerebral

    palsy and mental disability at 3 years of life.146

    The integral role of corticosteroids

    The probability that HELLP syndrome is a SIRS-like

    inflammatory form of severe preeclampsia50 leads to

    consideration of anti-inflammatory/immunosuppressive

    agents for treatment, specifically corticosteroids. The

    consistently favorable response of HELLP syndrome

    laboratory parameters to corticosteroids suggests the

    presence of an underlying corticosteroid-responsive

    step(s) in its pathogenesis and a therapeutic benefit to

    their use. Corticosteroids may act by one or more mech-

    anisms to alter endothelial activity/interaction with cir-

    culating cells including erythrocytes and platelets,impact translation/transcription, interrupt hepatocyte

    damage by placenta-derived CD95-L and/or to disrupt

    signaling for inflammatory cytokine production by the

    endogenous immune system.154 A recent publication

    that thoroughly explores the pharmacology and physiol-

    ogy of corticosteroids relevant to pregnancy and

    HELLP syndrome is recommended to the interested

    reader for review.154

    The potential therapeutic value of corticosteroids for

    patients with HELLP syndrome was first recognized in

    the early 1990s by 2 groups of investigators, one in

    Denver155

    and the other in Jackson, MS.156,157

    The first

    2 small randomized clinical trials (nonblinded, nonpla-

    cebo controlled) were undertaken in Jackson using in-

    travenous (IV) high-dose dexamethasone versus no

    steroids during 1992 through 1993 in 65 patients with

    antepartum or postpartum HELLP syndrome.158,159

    Stabilization and significant improvement in laboratory

    and clinical parameters associated with HELLP syn-

    drome occurred in women who received antenatal and/or postpartum corticosteroids.158,159 Subsequent to the

    publication of these findings, retrospective scrutiny of

    selected data present in several published series of

    patients with severe preeclampsia from the 1970s and

    1980s revealed findings consistent with this new observa-

    tion that high-dose dexamethasone appeared to arrest

    the deterioration of laboratory parameters in patients

    fulfilling criteria for HELLP syndrome.16,139,160-162

    Four other small randomized, controlled trials have

    been undertaken comparing the use of high-dose dexa-

    methasone or prednisolone (50 mg twice daily) with

    either no treatment, placebo, or with betamethasone.Two HELLP trials were undertaken antepartum63,163

    and 2 evaluated postpartum corticosteroid treat-

    ment.164,165 Significantly improved biochemical para-

    meters of HELLP syndrome and clinical parameters

    of mean arterial pressure and urinary output were

    consistently reported. In the most recently reported

    trial from The Netherlands,80 the prednisolone-treated

    group of 15 antepartum patients had a 50% reduction

    in HELLP syndrome exacerbations compared with 15

    placebo-treated controls and a significantly shorter time

    to normalize postpartum platelets. All 3 major mater-

    nal complications occurred in the placebo groupdformation of a liver hematoma in 2 patients and rupture

    of the liver in a third patient with maternal death.

    No significant neonatal differences between groups

    were noted in the immediate neonatal period or at infant

    follow-up.80

    On the basis of the findings from the first 2 prospec-

    tive clinical trials and the preceding case series findings

    that led to the trials, interpreting them to collectively

    indicate a clear patient benefit to treatment, practice

    guidelines at University Hospital in Jackson were

    revised in mid-1993 to routinely initiate IV high dose

    (10 mg IV every 12 hours) dexamethasone antepartumor postpartum for (1) any patient with class 1 or 2

    HELLP syndrome and (2) any patient with class 3

    HELLP syndrome associated with epigastric pain,

    eclampsia, severe hypertension, and/or any evidence of

    major organ system morbidity. Patients with uncompli-

    cated class 3 disease were monitored and subsequently

    treated if they met either of the 2 criteria.21,27,166,167 The

    dosage of drug used is approximately double that

    recommended for fetal lung maturation purposes and

    half the amount used for adults with newly diagnosed

    immune thrombocytopenic purpura.168,169 Postpartum

    and approximately 12 hours after the last antepartum

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 921

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    9/21

    dose, IV dexamethasone is given twice more at 10 mg IV

    every 12 hours and usually tapered with 2 lesser doses of

    5 mg IV every 12 hours for a full course. The regimen is

    lengthened or shortened to fit individual patient

    circumstances.167

    Routine high-dose IV dexamethasone according to

    the Mississippi regimen is now in its twelth year of

    practice utilization in Jackson; historical control groupsfrom the era before 1992 when corticosteroid trials

    began are the only potential comparison groups of

    patients. Compared with 246 patients with class 1 or 2

    HELLP syndrome treated between 1985 and 1991 when

    only 16% received a complete or incomplete course of

    corticosteroids to enhance fetal lung maturation, signif-

    icantly reduced composite maternal disease was ob-

    served in 228 patients managed between 1994 and 2000

    with 90% aggressive corticosteroid utilization. There

    were significantly improved laboratory parameters, less

    progression to class 1 HELLP syndrome, less frequent

    need for antihypertensive therapy, less requirement fortransfusion, lower incidence of major maternal morbid-

    ity, and shortened postpartum recovery.170 Overall

    maternal morbidity rates of 64% for class 1 HELLP syn-

    drome, 54% for class 2, and 40% for class 3 improved to

    49%, 22%, and 21%, respectively, with an aggressive

    corticosteroid regimen compared with an 11% baseline

    for non-HELLP severe preeclampsia.25,27,28 Compara-

    ble quantitative and qualitative benefits occurred in

    similarly treated patients with postpartum HELLP syn-

    dromeda more rapid normalization of platelet counts

    and LDH values and a clinically significant reduction

    of indicated transfusion, need for intubation or intensiverespiratory therapy, invasive hemodynamic monitoring,

    infectious- or bleeding-related morbidity, and length of

    postpartum hospital course.171

    At least 7 other groups have also retrospectively

    reviewed case series and found that corticosteroids im-

    prove laboratory indices and positively impact HELLP

    syndrome severity and pathogenesis.172-178 Tompkins

    and Thiagarajah,173 for instance, interpret their data

    to show best benefit using 2 doses of intramuscular

    (IM) betamethasone (12 mg each) given 12 hours apart

    rather than the National Institutes of Health (NIH)179

    recommended interval of 24 hours. The findings ofOBrien et al175 point toward accelerated (shorter inter-

    val) standard dose fetal lung maturation steroids (either

    12 mg betamethasone IM every 12 hours ! 2 or dexa-

    methasone IV 6 mg every 6 hours), or a higher than

    Mississippi regimen of IV dexamethasone (10 mg every

    6 hours ! 2, then 6 mg every 6 hours ! 2-4 doses)

    given to patients with antepartum HELLP syndrome

    to improve platelet counts, reduce liver enzyme abnor-

    malities, and prolong latency to delivery in a dose-

    dependent manner.

    In addition to these 13 publications, several other

    observations are offered that favor the routine inclusion

    of aggressive corticosteroids for patients with HELLP

    syndrome:

    Liver hemorrhage or rupture is rarely encountered in

    the undelivered pregnant patient with preeclampsia/

    eclampsia who is receiving corticosteroids for fetal

    lung maturation or aggressive corticosteroids for

    treatment of HELLP syndrome.21,28 Liver complications may be particularly susceptible

    to interdiction with early aggressive corticosteroids,

    especially in the symptomatic class 3 HELLP syn-

    drome patient with other underlying pathology.86

    Pauzner et al86 noted recently that antiphospholipid

    syndrome was present in all 4 patients with hepatic

    infarction and HELLP syndrome (described as in-

    complete in 3 of 4 cases), and their literature survey

    noted that anticardiolipin antibodies and/or lupus

    anticoagulant were positive in 15 or 16 patients

    with hepatic complications for whom laboratory

    data were available. A similar series and a case reportwere published recently from France.90,91

    Because renal and/or hepatic dysfunction with

    HELLP syndrome exhibit can be exhibited very early

    in disease development before class 1 or 2 criteria are

    met, it is possible that routine initiation of aggressive

    corticosteroids in class 3 and partial HELLP

    patients might prevent disease progression and sig-

    nificant maternal hepatorenal morbidity.

    When aggressive corticosteroids are not used, signif-

    icant maternal morbidity180 or mortality can occur

    that might otherwise have been avoided. For in-

    stance, HELLP syndrome developing in associationwith severe systolic hypertension above 160 mm Hg

    may enhance the potential of cerebral blood vessels

    to bleed when corticosteroids are absent from man-

    agement. Among a highly selected group of 28

    women with preeclampsia-induced severe systolic hy-

    pertension who had cerebral hemorrhage and stroke,

    18 (64%) had evidence for concurrent class 1, 2, or 3

    HELLP syndrome before the cerebral catastrophe

    and no patient had been a recent corticosteroid recip-

    ient.181 None of 54 patients dying with HELLP syn-

    drome in the Isler series received corticosteroids,

    many of whom had CNS pathology.138

    Corticoste-roids use was not described in 104 patients from

    France with a 79% complication rate in the class

    1 HELLP category,106 or in recent series from Ger-

    many, China, and Turkey with high rates of maternal

    morbidity,130,182,183 and they were usually absent

    from the management of patients with significant

    maternal morbidity reported before 1990.6-17

    Aggressive corticosteroids can effect an increase in

    platelet count sufficiently to undertake regional

    anesthesia (from 0% to 42%) and to enable cervical

    ripening, induction of labor and vaginal deliv-

    ery.184,185

    Up to 75% of patients with HELLP

    922 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    10/21

    syndrome can become candidates for regional anes-

    thesia after high-dose corticosteroid administration

    if a platelet threshold of 75,000/mL is deemed

    adequate, and a higher rate of vaginal delivery can

    be accomplished than would otherwise be possible

    especially in relatively preterm gestations.185 In the

    absence of corticosteroid use, the cesarean rate is

    high and vaginal delivery is a rare event.128,186 A recent prospective randomized clinical trial under-

    taken in the authors hospital found no clear treatment

    benefit with postpartum high-dose dexamethasone

    for puerperal patients with non-HELLP severe pre-

    eclampsia at diagnosis.187The only 2 patients to subse-

    quently have postpartum HELLP syndrome develop

    were in the placebogroup, and both responded quickly

    to the emergent initiation of IV dexamethasone after

    study assignment as placebo was ascertained.

    Choice of corticosteroid

    Although approximately equivalent in potency, IV dex-

    amethasone appears to be more effective than IM

    betamethasone, perhaps by delivering the drug directly

    into the vasculature of the affected organ systems.163,188

    Preferences for other regimens by others were listed

    earlier. Sibai recommends an aggressive corticosteroid

    regimen similar in potency to the Mississippi protocol

    (dexamethasone 10 mg IV every 12 hours) for antepar-

    tum HELLP syndrome to improve maternal status,

    using 2 doses of either betamethasone 12 mg IM every

    12 hours (instead of every 24 hours) or dexamethasone

    12 mg IV (instead of 5 or 6 mg) every12 hours with de-livery to be accomplished within 24 hours after the last

    dose of corticosteroids.22 Determination of preferred

    drug, dosage, and regimen specific to clinical circum-

    stances awaits large multicenter studies.

    Potential maternal-fetal risks

    Potential maternal risks include rebound thrombocyto-

    penia, adrenal suppression, infection, and the masking

    of potential complications or other disease processes.

    The available data are insufficient to estimate if there

    are any adverse short- or long-term neonatal-infant

    effects from brief aggressive corticosteroids for HELLPsyndrome. Neither dexamethasone or betamethasone

    is preferable from the fetal perspective in regard to

    short-term outcomes.189 The use of aggressive cortico-

    steroids for antepartum HELLP syndrome is recom-

    mended exclusively as a short-term intervention;

    continuation of pregnancy after more than 48 hours of

    aggressive corticosteroid administration for very pre-

    term HELLP syndrome pregnancy can lead to signifi-

    cant maternal and fetal morbidity and mortality.149

    Evidence is meager (few case reports) regarding cortico-

    steroid prolongation for many days to weeks of a pre-

    viable HELLP syndrome pregnancy to viability, and

    long-term potentially adverse implications to the new-

    born infant remain a question.172,190-192 Lower birth

    weight, lower head circumference, neonatal adrenal

    suppression, and increased infection are theoretical risks

    to a newborn infant exposed to even a very short course

    of high-dose corticosteroids, but evidence for this is

    lacking. Potent glucocorticoids used for pregnancies

    with HELLP syndrome may actually impart a fetal ad-vantage because placental vascular resistance by Dop-

    pler assessment appears to be reduced briefly in

    singleton and multiple gestations after maternal beta-

    methasone administration.193,194 In pregnant ewes re-

    ceiving extended dexamethasone prenatally (20 days

    with 20 mg/kg maternal body weight), no evidence of

    altered renal function or predisposition to adult hyper-

    tension compared with controls was found.195

    Summary

    Despite current limitations in sample size and study

    structure, a consistent positive picture of patient benefit

    emerges from a review of the present literature that we

    suspect will be shown definitively once large multicenter

    clinical trials are undertaken. This is consistent with our

    considerable bedside experience gained over many years

    and in a multitude of patient circumstances and situa-

    tions that a routine practice of initiating aggressive

    corticosteroids early in HELLP syndrome pregnancies

    will prevent them from progressing along a continuum

    of worsening morbidity, a critically important concept

    for clinicians to embrace to reduce maternal mortality

    rates in patients with this disease.196 In view of the

    absence of a demonstrated downside to this approach

    either for the mother or the fetus, given the body of

    affirmative available literature, we believe it most bene-

    ficial to patients now to be managed according to the

    recommendations that follow.

    Fundamentals of practicedThe applicationof aggressive corticosteroids

    The fundamental management concepts for treatment of

    patients with HELLP syndrome using aggressive corti-

    costeroids is presented in core concepts (Table VI) andas an algorhythm (Figures 2 and 3). Further consider-

    ations are discussed in paragraphs to follow.

    In any patient suspected of having HELLP syn-

    drome, basic laboratory evaluation includes a complete

    blood count with platelets, serum AST, and total serum

    LDH. Extended assessment can include serum creati-

    nine, glucose, bilirubin, coagulation studies, and a

    peripheral smear. Elevation of direct bilirubin and

    prolongation of coagulation studies out of proportion

    to mild thrombocytopenia occurs early in patients with

    AFLP but is unusual with HELLP syndrome unless the

    disease is very advanced (class 1).

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 923

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    11/21

    An aggressive corticosteroid regimen is initiated as

    soon as the diagnosis of class 1 or 2 HELLP syndrome is

    made or if the patient has complicated class 3 HELLPsyndrome. Continuation during cervical ripening and

    induction of labor can be used to facilitate attempted

    vaginal delivery or to improve the mothers hematologic

    status before abdominal delivery. If the fetus is preterm

    and previable such that cesarean delivery is not a fetal

    consideration, presence or absence of fetal heart tones

    is assessed intermittently to determine whether a neona-

    tal team should be summoned at delivery to assess the

    reasonableness of resuscitation efforts. Rarely a preg-

    nancy with borderline viability has been prolonged

    with aggressive corticosteroids but this is not usually

    recommended.190-192,197,198

    It is particularly discouragedin a patient with a fetal abnormality or major maternal

    morbidity such as renal failure.199 HELLP syndrome

    detected before fetal viability may identify a pregnancy

    complicated by partial mole/triploidy,200 trisomy 13,201

    antiphospholipid syndrome,87 autoantibodies to angio-

    tensin AT(1)-receptor,202 or severe preterm preeclamp-

    sia with mirror syndrome.203

    Maternal-fetal status, gestational age, presence of

    labor, cervical Bishop score, prior maternal obstetric

    history, and response to aggressive corticosteroids all

    impact management of the patient with a preterm viable

    fetus and HELLP syndrome. Immediate cesarean

    delivery is not generally indicated or recommended; vag-

    inal or cesarean delivery after 24 to 48 hours of cortico-

    steroids are better options to achieve maximal maternaland fetal benefit.204 Vaginal delivery rates of 32% for

    gestations less than 30 weeks, 61% at 30 to 31 weeks,

    and 62% at 32 to 33 weeks (overall induction success

    145/247 or 59%, 37% !28 weeks) can be achieved.186

    Nevertheless, because vaginal delivery rates with

    HELLP syndrome are below 50% for gestations less

    than 30 weeks, Sibai22 advocates elective cesarean deliv-

    ery for all women diagnosed with HELLP syndrome at

    a gestation age less than 30 weeks when spontaneous

    labor is not present and the Bishop score is less than 5.

    A patient with a low Bishop score in association with

    fetal growth restriction and/or oligohydramnios maynot be a good candidate for trial of labor. Otherwise,

    vaginal delivery is attempted in patients in active labor

    less than 30 weeks with ruptured membranes or with a

    Bishop score 5 or more in the absence of obstetric con-

    traindications. Once the 30-week gestational age thresh-

    old is reached, an attempt at vaginal delivery is usually

    recommended while aggressive corticosteroids are

    initiated.

    Epidural or spinal anesthesia is the preferred anes-

    thetic for patients with preeclampsia.205 Approximately

    50% of patients with HELLP syndrome can be candi-

    dates for regional anesthesia during a trial of labor using

    Table VI Fundamental principles of HELLP syndrome management with aggressive corticosteroids

    Laboratory testing to detect HELLP syndrome is recommended for any pregnant patient presenting with possible preeclampsia,

    especially pretermdearly detection is preferred.

    Whether a patient presents with class 1, 2, or 3 HELLP syndrome or has complete/incomplete disease parameters does not lessen the

    clinicians pressing need to undertake appropriate evaluation and intervention for the patient.

    HELLP syndrome is a systemic and progressive pregnancy disease process that usually shows signs of recovery only after delivery is

    accomplished. The first priority is to assess the maternal-fetal condition and to determine secondarily whether delivery is immediately

    indicated or can be delayed while aggressive corticosteroids are used to accelerate fetal lung maturation, enhance maternal status,and optimize conditions either for vaginal or abdominal delivery to occur.

    Aggressive corticosteroids clearly benefit the mother with HELLP syndrome according to stage of disease when drug therapy is

    initiated, agent used, amount and route of administration.

    A proactive, preventative early aggressive application of corticosteroids for the patient with antepartum or postpartum HELLP

    syndrome probably realizes the greatest maternal benefit regardless of gestational age (Figures 2 and 3).

    The patient with HELLP has severe preeclampsia and is managed accordingly with intensive surveillance and care during the

    peripartum interval, including magnesium sulfate and aggressive antihypertensive therapy to minimize systolic blood pressures

    above 160 mm Hg.22,170

    The CNS is the most commonly affected system in mothers dying from HELLP syndromedthe aggressive use corticosteroids and

    antihypertensives probably lessens the risks of stroke and death. Early aggressive corticosteroids may also lessen hepatorenal

    morbidity.

    Aggressive corticosteroids in patients with HELLP syndrome increases the providers chance to provide regional anesthesia during

    labor and delivery and to maximize the potential for vaginal delivery. Early transfer of the patient with HELLP syndrome to a suitable facility that can provide 24-h intensive care and consultation for

    maternal-fetal-neonatal needs should be considered if appropriate.

    Perinatal outcome is predominantly gestational age-dependent. Because stillbirth and placental abruption occur with increased

    frequency in relation to impaired fetal growth and maternal disease severity, efforts to prolong HELLP syndrome pregnancy more than

    48-72 h (regardless of gestational age) are undertaken at some risk to mother and child.

    The clinician must be mindful that the patient considered to have HELLP syndrome may have some other disorder, especially AFLP

    that is relatively uncommon but has a much worse prognosis.

    924 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    12/21

    a threshold of 100,000/mL platelets.187 In these cir-

    cumstances, the decision of abdominal versus vaginal

    delivery becomes more of an obstetric issue ratherthan a response to a rapidly worsening maternal-fetal

    condition. Furthermore, patients who receive regional

    anesthesia avoid the greater risks associated with gen-

    eral anesthesia. When motivated, providers can depend

    on corticosteroids to improve maternal platelet counts

    sufficiently to increase the epidural rate for patients

    with HELLP syndrome from 0% to 57%.184 When ce-

    sarean delivery without trial of labor is planned, waiting

    approximately 6 hours after beginning an aggressive

    corticosteroid regimen is recommended to stabilize the

    disease process, improve laboratory parameters, enable

    institution of regional anesthesia, and reduce the needfor platelet or red cell transfusion. Given the absence

    of neurologic or hematologic complications with re-

    gional anesthesia in HELLP syndrome patients man-

    aged in Panama without corticosteroids or platelet

    count restrictions, the likelihood of bleeding complica-

    tions with regional anesthesia is small.205

    Aggressive corticosteroid administration is associated

    with a significant decrease in the required use of blood

    products21 and consequently a secondary decrease in in-

    fectious morbidity. When emergent cesarean delivery

    must proceed without waiting for a steroid effect and/

    or in the rare patient with advanced disease and a

    platelet count less than 40,000/mL that is unresponsive

    to corticosteroid use, platelet transfusion of 6 to 10 units

    of platelets is recommended immediately prior tointubation.206

    Prevention of severe systolic hypertension (O160 mm

    Hg) is paramount; recommendations to maintain sys-

    tolic pressures under 155 mm Hg and diastolic pressures

    under 105 mm Hg are reasonable goals.22,181 Labetolol,

    hydralazine, or nifedipine are the preferred agents for

    treatment of acute hypertension in this setting with

    infused dilute nitroglycerin held in reserve.207

    There have been no randomized trials of cesarean

    operative technique for patients with HELLP syndrome.

    Delayed skin closure or type of skin incision do not

    appear to influence the frequency of wound complica-tions.208 In the absence of postpartum aggressive corti-

    costeroids, a high incidence of hematoma formation

    can occur despite placement of a subfascial drain and

    keeping the skin incision open for 48 hours.22

    Most of the fundamental principles of management

    for patients with antepartum HELLP syndrome apply

    equally to postpartum/postoperative patients. New-

    onset postpartum disease appears usually within the

    first days after delivery and is treated with aggressive

    corticosteroids similar to antepartum disease.21,170,171

    The treatment is tailored to the patient; corticosteroid

    dosage is reduced once an upward trend in platelets and

    Figure 2 HELLP management algorithm: aggressive corticosteroids.

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 925

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    13/21

    a downward trend in total serum LDH is recorded, and

    discontinued with normalization of HELLP laboratory

    parameters and resolution of signs and symptoms of

    preeclampsia.

    Significant renal injury is infrequently encountered

    in patients with HELLP syndrome unless placental

    abruption or a major hemorrhage also occurs.209 Most

    often renal dysfunction responds to measures short

    of dialysis or only a brief course of dialysis.19,209,210

    Because a convincing renal benefit to aggressive cortico-

    steroids has not been demonstrated, the basic patient

    management principles for patients with acute renalfailure are used.211

    Almost all instances of spontaneous subcapsular

    hematomas or hepatic rupture in pregnancy occur in

    association with HELLP syndrome.212-214 As thrombo-

    cytopenia worsens into the lowest ranges (class 1), in

    conjunction with the onset of sudden epigastric pain,

    the likelihood of finding abnormal hepatic imaging

    with computed tomography or magnetic resonance

    imaging increases. For reasons given earlier, we specu-

    late that it benefits patient care to immediately begin ag-

    gressive corticosteroids for any patient with suspected

    HELLP syndrome and having hepatic injury develop,

    regardless of disease class. Several excellent treatises

    have been published recently that review the manage-

    ment of HELLP-related hepatic complications such as

    hepatic rupture.129,212-217

    Beyond corticosteroids

    Plasma exchange or plasma infusion have been used

    sparingly for recalcitrant and/or complicated HELLP

    syndrome that is unresponsive to standard ther-

    apy.83,218-224 Some of the postulated mechanism of

    actions include (1) clearance from the circulation ofdebris, toxins, antigen-antibody complexes, damaged

    red cell components or other substances that may be

    compromising normal coagulation and organ function;

    and (2) replacement of fluid, clotting factors, proteins,

    and other plasma components that are required to

    achieve homeostasis and healing. Prevention of intravas-

    cular fluid overload is enhanced versus straight transfu-

    sion, particularly in the patient with compromised renal

    function. Collaborative care with intensivists and hema-

    tologist/transfusion medicine subspecialists is impera-

    tive. Because patients in these circumstances are rare,

    unique, and difficult to accurately quantify, randomized

    Figure 3 Class 3 or incomplete/partial HELLP syndrome.

    926 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    14/21

    clinical trials are unlikely to be undertaken or even fea-

    sible. Thus, the role of plasma exchange in HELLP syn-

    drome management remains controversial but less

    frequently a concern we speculate because of early diag-

    nosis and aggressive corticosteroids.

    There is little evidence suggesting efficacy to the use

    of heparin,178,225 activated factor VII,226 or haptoglo-

    bin227 for treatment of HELLP syndrome. Attemptedprolongation of pregnancy with hydration and antihy-

    pertensives is not recommended because it is associated

    with increased maternal and perinatal morbidity related

    to placental abruption and hepatic rupture.80,228

    Prognosis: Recovery

    Patients with HELLP syndrome usually recover com-

    pletely, although relapses can occur in the absence of

    corticosteroid administration.224 After-effects of disease

    can persist for extended periods if hepatic or renal dam-

    age has occurred.229

    Long-term follow-up of mothersand children from HELLP syndrome pregnancies are

    few in number. Renal function was not permanently im-

    paired in 23 women with acute renal failure and HELLP

    syndrome who were monitored an average of 4.6 years;

    8 patients had 11 subsequent pregnancies, 9 of which

    were term gestations.230 Similar normalization of renal

    function after a HELLP syndrome pregnancy was

    reported by Jacquemyns Belgian group,229 but higher

    systolic and diastolic blood pressures were observed at

    5 years compared with controls. In Amsterdam, the in-

    cidence of subsequent hypertension requiring treatment

    was 3 times higher than controls.230

    In the absence ofacute renal failure, there was no detectable impairment

    of renal function at least 5 years after HELLP syndrome

    in 10 patients. Stroke in patients with HELLP syndrome

    left residual defects in 10 of 13 patients (77%) who sur-

    vived the acute insult.181 No permanent adverse effects

    on liver function have been reported. Emotional trauma,

    both immediate and delayed, can be a significant patient

    issue.231,232

    Patient counseling: Future pregnancy

    Women with a prior history of HELLP syndrome carryan increased risk of at least 20% (range 16%-52%) that

    some form of gestational hypertension will recur in a

    subsequent gestation. The rate of recurrent HELLP

    syndrome itself varies between 2% and 19% depending

    on the population studied, gestational age at onset,

    whether there is concurrent vascular disease of any type,

    and very likely the unique genetic profile of the individ-

    ual patient, her partner, and her progeny.233,234

    In the Mississippi study with a 75% African-American

    profile, the recurrence risk was 42% to 43% for any type

    of preeclampsia-eclampsia, but this increased to 61%

    if the preceding affected pregnancy was very preterm

    (!32 weeks).234 To date, anything other than close

    monitoring of subsequent pregnancies for problems of

    prematurity and preeclampsia (preterm labor, bleeding,

    fetal growth restriction) has not been superceded by

    specific testing or augmented by effective preventative

    measures. Testing for LCHAD mutation (long-chain

    3-hydroxyacyl coenzyme A dehydrogenase deficiency)

    is rarely positive in patients with HELLP syndrome incontrast to the situation with AFLP235-237 and therefore

    not recommended.238

    Challenges and conclusions

    An expanded, more inclusive disease classification

    system for HELLP syndrome is needed particularly if

    the potential for early aggressive corticosteroids to avert

    most significant maternal morbidity is to be studied

    adequately in appropriately structured, large multicen-

    ter clinical trials. Some form of a composite maternal

    morbidity index also is needed to better describe thespectrum of systemic morbidity potentially experienced

    by mothers with this condition. As expected with a

    disease process with variable rates of progression, dif-

    ferent stages at initial presentation, alteration by various

    interventions, and characterization by inconsistent and

    variable laboratory methodologies, there has been a lack

    of consensus among researchers and confusion among

    clinicians. The issue of standardization of diagnosis

    and disease classification is an important goal, so that

    research findings are comparable and recommended

    clinical managements can become progressively more

    evidence based.We believe that the scientific community is on the

    threshold of a much better understanding of the patho-

    genesis of HELLP syndrome specifically and preeclamp-

    sia-eclampsia in general. Knowledge of the findings

    related to the pathogenesis and pathophysiology of

    this disorder and the ameliorating effect of corticoste-

    roids on the disease process is foundational to under-

    standing the challenges of diagnosis, classification, and

    management. A patient can present initially anywhere

    along the spectrum of disease development, and disease

    expression is influenced by whether corticosteroids have

    been given for any reason. Thus, the accurate interpre-tation of any publication about HELLP syndrome

    requires a clear description of when in the development

    of HELLP syndrome laboratory or research testing was

    performed to study its pathogenesis or make its clin-

    ical diagnosis, including a statement of the presence or

    absence of corticosteroids during patient management

    ideally noting at what stage in disease these agents and

    dosages were given to the patient. Large-scale multicen-

    ter trials investigating various corticosteroid regimens

    for patients with this spectrum of HELLP syndrome

    conditions are desirable (including various types that

    cross or do not cross into the fetal circulation63

    ), with

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 927

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    15/21

    particular attention to define benefits and limitations

    according to the stage and circumstances in which ther-

    apy is initiated. Risk factors for severe renal and hepatic

    complications of HELLP syndrome require further

    investigation with regard to concurrent predisposing

    conditions such as antiphospholipid syndrome. Al-

    though short-term utilization of corticosteroids as cur-

    rently used has not been shown to negatively impactthe fetus or neonate, surveillance for possible adverse

    effects should continue. We believe that widespread dis-

    semination of the information presented herein to prac-

    ticing cliniciansdbetter recognition through cognition

    and a management scheme focused on early aggressive

    corticosteroid administrationdis needed now to mini-

    mize maternal-perinatal morbidity and mortality with

    this condition while more extensive study continues.

    References

    1. Schmorl G. Pathologisch-anatomische Untersuchungen uberPuerperal-Eklampsie. Leipzig: FCW Vogel; 1893.

    2. Dienst A. Experimentaelle Studien uber die Aetiologische Bedeu-

    tung des Fibrinsferments und Fibrinogens fur die Schwanger-

    schaftsniere und die Eklampsie. Arch Gynaekol 1912;96:43-170.

    3. Denecke G. Blut and lymphe. In: Hinselman H, editor. Die

    Eklampsie. Bonn: Cohen; 1924. p. 293-360.

    4. Chesley LC. Disseminated intravascular coagulation. In:

    Chesley LC, editor. Chesleys hypertensive disorders in preg-

    nancy. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts; 1978. p. 88-118.

    5. Dieckmann WJ. Toxemias of pregnancy, 3rd ed. St Louis:

    Mosby; 1952. p. 362-9.

    6. Pritchard JA, Weisman R Jr, Ratnoff OD, Vosburgh GJ. Intra-

    vascular hemolysis, thrombocytopenia and other hematologic ab-

    normalities associated with severe toxemia of pregnancy. N EnglJ Med 1954;250:89-98.

    7. Pritchard JA, Cunningham FG, Mason RA. Coagulation

    changes in eclampsia: their frequency and pathogenesis. Am J

    Obstet Gynecol 1976;124:855-64.

    8. Brain MC, Kuah K-B, Dixon HG. Heparin treatment of haemol-

    ysis and thrombocytopenia in pre-eclampsia. J Obstet Gynaecol

    Br Commonw 1967;74:702-11.

    9. Scott R, Gordon S, Schatz A, Casella S. Acute hemolysis and

    thrombocytopenia in eclampsia. Obstet Gynecol 1970;36:128-31.

    10. McKay DG. Hematologic evidence of disseminated intravascu-

    lar coagulation in eclampsia. Obstet Gynecol Surv 1972;27:

    399-407.

    11. Kitzmiller JL, Lang JF, Yellenosky PF, Lucas WE. Hematologic

    assays in pre-eclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1974;118:362-7.

    12. Vardi J, Fields GA. Microangiopathic hemolytic anemia in severe

    pre-eclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1974;119:617-22.

    13. Killam AP, Dillard SH Jr, Patton RC, Pederson PR. Pregnancy-

    induced hypertension complicated by acute liver disease and

    disseminated intravascular coagulation. Am J Obstet Gynecol

    1975;123:823-8.

    14. Lopez-Llera M, de la Luz Espinosa M, Diaz de Leon M, Linares

    GR. Abnormal coagulation and fibrinolysis in eclampsia: a clini-

    cal and laboratory correlation study. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1976;

    128:681-92.

    15. Schwartz ML, Brenner WE. The obfuscation of eclampsia by

    thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura. Am J Obstet Gynecol

    1978;131:18-24.

    16. Goodlin RC. Severe pre-eclampsia: another great imitator. Am J

    Obstet Gynecol 1976;126:855-64.

    17. Goodlin RC, Cotton DB, Haesslein HC. Severe EPH gestosis.

    Am J Obstet Gynecol 1978;132:595-8.

    18. Weinstein L. Syndrome of hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, and

    low platelet count: a severe consequence of hypertension in preg-

    nancy. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1982;142:159-67.

    19. Abraham KA, Connolly G, Farrell J, Walshe JJ. The HELLP

    syndrome, a prospective study. Ren Fail 2001;23:705-13.

    20. Vigil-De Gracia P. Pregnancy complicated by pre-eclampsia-

    eclampsia with HELLP syndrome. Int J Gynecol Obstet 2001;72:17-23.

    21. Martin JN Jr, Magann EF, Isler CM. HELLP Syndrome: the

    scope of disease and treatment. In: Belfort MA, Thornton S,

    Saade GR, editors. Hypertension in pregnancy. Chap 7. Oxford:

    Marcel Dekker; 2003. p. 141-88.

    22. Sibai BM. Diagnosis, controversies, and management of the syn-

    drome of hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes and low platelet

    count. Obstet Gynecol 2004;103:981-91.

    23. Barton JR, Sibai BM. Diagnosis and management of hemolysis,

    elevated liver enzymes and low platelets syndrome. Clinical

    Perinatol 2004;31:807-33.

    24. Baxter JK, Weinstein L. HELLP syndrome: the state of the art.

    Obstet Gynecol Surv 2004;59:838-45.

    25. Martin JN Jr, Magan EF, Blake PG. Analysis of 454 pregnancies

    with severe preeclampsia/eclampsia/HELLP syndrome using the3-class system of classification. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1993;

    168:386.

    26. Sibai BM, Ramadan MK, Usta I, Salama M, Mercer BM, Fried-

    man SA. Maternal morbidity and mortality in 442 pregnancies

    with HELLP syndrome. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1993;169:1000-6.

    27. Martin JN Jr, Magann EF. HELLP syndrome: current principles

    and recommended practices. Curr Obstet Med 1996;4:129-75.

    28. Martin JN Jr, Rinehart K, May WL, Magann EF, Terrone DA,

    Blake PG. The spectrum of severe preeclampsia: comparative

    analysis by HELLP syndrome classification. Am J Obstet Gyne-

    col 1999;180:1373-84.

    29. Roberts JM, Taylor RN, Musci TJ, Rodgers GM, Hubel CA,

    McLaughlin MK. Preeclampsia: an endothelial cell disorder.

    Am J Obstet Gynecol 1989;161:1200-4.30. Roberts JM. Objective evidence of endothelial dysfunction in

    preeclampsia. Am J Kidney Dis 1999;33:992-7.

    31. Friedman SA, Taylor RN, Roberts JM. Pathophysiology of

    preeclampsia. Clin Perinatol 1991;18:661-82.

    32. Lindheimer M, Cunningham FG. Hypertension in pregnancy.

    N Engl J Med 1992;326:927-32.

    33. Zeeman GG, Dekker GA, van Geijn HP, Kraayenbrink AA.

    Endothelial function in normal and preeclamptic pregnancies:

    a hypothesis. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 1992;43:113-22.

    34. Roberts JM, Redman CWG. Preeclampsia: more than pregnancy-

    induced hypertension. Lancet 1993;341:1447-54.

    35. Stratta P, Canavese C, Vercellone A. HELLP, microangiopathic

    hemolytic anemia, and preeclampsia. Hypertens Pregnancy 1993;

    12:487-96.

    36. Roberts JM, Gammill HS. Preeclampsia: recent insights. Hyper-

    tension 2005;46:1243-9.

    37. Martin JN Jr, Blake PG, Perry KG, McCaul JF, Hess LW,

    Martin RW. The natural history of HELLP syndrome: patterns

    of disease progression and regression. Am J Obstet Gynecol

    1991;164:1500-13.

    38. MartinJN Jr,Blake PG,Lowery SL,PerryKG, Files JC,Morrison

    JC. Pregnancy complicated by preeclampsia-eclampsia with

    HELLP syndrome: how rapid is postpartum recovery? Obstet

    Gynecol 1990;76:737-41.

    39. Katz VL, Thorp JM Jr, Rozas L, Bowes WA Jr. The natural

    history of thrombocytopenia associated with preeclampsia.

    Am J Obstet Gynecol 1990;163:1142-3.

    40. Neiger R, Contag SA, Coustan DR.The resolutionof preeclampsia-

    related thrombocytopenia. Obstet Gynecol 1991;77:692-5.

    928 Martin, Rose, and Briery

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    16/21

    41. Figini E, Za G, Squarcina M, Marras M, Passamonti U, Bocchino

    G, et al. Course and regression of HELLP syndrome. Minerva

    Ginecol 1996;48:405-8.

    42. Makkonen N, Harju M, Kirkinen P. Postpartum recovery after

    severe preeclampsia and HELLP syndrome. J Perinat Med 1996;

    24:641-9.

    43. Rychel V, Williams KP. Correlation of platelet count changes

    with liver cell destruction in HELLP syndrome. Hypertens Preg-

    nancy 2003;22:57-61.44. Faridi A, Rath W. Differential HELLP syndrome diagnosis.

    Z Gerburtschilfe 1996;200:88-95.

    45. Strand S, Strand D, Seufert R, Mann A, Lotz J, Blessing M, et al.

    Placenta-derived CD95 ligand causes liver damage in HELLP

    syndrome. Gastroenterology 2004;126:849-58.

    46. Tanaka M, Suda T, Haze K, Nakamura N, Sato K, Kimura F,

    et al. Fas ligand in human serum. Nat Med 1996;2:317-22.

    47. Hiramatsu N, Hayashi N, Katayama K, Mochizuki K, Kawanish

    Y, Kashahara A, et al. Immunohistochemical detection of fas an-

    tigen in liver tissue of patient with chronic hepatitis C. Hepatol-

    ogy 1994;19:1354-9.

    48. Bone RC. Immunologic dissonance: a continuing evolution in our

    understanding of the systemic inflammatory response syndrome

    (SIRS) and the multiple organ dysfunction syndrome (MODS).

    Ann Intern Med 1996;125:680-7.49. Balderas-Pena LM, Canales-Munoz JL, Angulo-Vazqule J,

    Anaya-Prado R, Gonzalez Ojeda A. The HELLP syndrome: evi-

    dence of a possible systemic inflammatory response in preeclamp-

    sia? Ginecol Obstet Mex 2002;70:328-37.

    50. Redman CWG, Sargent IL. Preeclampsia and the systemic in-

    flammatory response. Semin Nephrol 2004;24:565-70.

    51. Harirah H, Donia SE, Hsu C-D. Serum Soluble FAS in HELLP

    Syndrome. Obstet Gynecol 2001;98:295-8.

    52. Halim A, Kanayama N, El Maradny E, Maehara K, Takahaski

    A, Nosaka K, et al. Immunohistological study in cases of HELLP

    syndrome and acute fatty liver of pregnancy. Gynecol Obstet

    Invest 1996;41:106-12.

    53. Terrone DA, Rinehart BK, May WL, Moore A, Magann EF,

    Martin JN Jr. Leukocytosis is proportional to HELLP syndromeseverity: evidence for an inflammatory form of preeclampsia.

    South Med J 2000;93:768-71.

    54. Haeger M, Unander AM, Bengtsson A. Enhanced anaphylatoxin

    and terminal C5b-9 complement formation in patients with

    HELLP syndrome. Obstet Gynecol 1990;76:698-702.

    55. Zusterzeel PLM, Wanten GJA, Peters WHM, Merkus HMWM,

    Steegers EAP. Neutrophil oxygen radical production in pre-

    eclampsia with HELLP syndrome. Eur J Obstet Gynecol 2001;99:

    213-8.

    56. Riordan SM, Williams R. Acute liver failure: targeted artificial

    and hepatocyte-based support of liver regeneration and reversal

    of multiorgan failure. J Hepatol 2000;32:63-76.

    57. Visser W, Beckmann I, Bremer HA, LIIM HL, Wallenburg HC.

    Bioactive tumour necrosis factor in preeclampsic patients with

    and without the HELLP syndrome. BJOG 1994;101:1081-2.

    58. Cunningham DS, Christie TL, Evans EE, McCaul JF. Effect of

    the HELLP syndrome on maternal immune function. J Reprod

    Med 1993;38:459-64.

    59. Zhou Y, McMaster M, Woo K, Janatpour M, Perry J, Karpanen

    T, et al. Vascular endothelial growth factor ligands and receptors

    that regulate human cytotrophoblast survival are dysregulated in

    severe preeclampsia with HELLP syndrome. Am J Pathol 2002;

    160:1405-23.

    60. Sgambati E, Marini M, Thyrion GDZ, Parretti E, Mello G,

    Orlando C, et al. VEGF expression in the placenta from opreg-

    nancies complicated by hypertensive disorders. BJOG 2004;111:

    564-70.

    61. Maynard SE, Min J-Y, Merchan J, Lim K-H, Li J, Mondal

    S, et al. Excess placental soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase

    1 (sFlt1) may contribute to endothelial dysfunction, hyperten-

    sion, and proteinuria in preeclampsia. J Clin Invest 2003;111:

    649-58.

    62. Bussen S, Rieger L, Sutterlin M, Dietl J. Plasma VEGF levels are

    increased in women with severe preeclampsia or HELLP syn-

    drome. Z Geburtshilfe Neonatol 2003;207:101-6.

    63. Schlembach D, Beinder E. Measurement of microcirculation in

    normal pregnancy, preeclampsia and HELLPsyndrome [abstract].

    Hypertens Pregnancy 2000;19(Suppl 1):114.64. Knerr I, Dachert C, Beinder E, Metzler M, Dotsch J, Repp R,

    et al. Adenomedullin, calcitonin gene-related peptide and their

    receptors: evidence for a decreased placental mRNA content in

    preeclampsia and HELLP syndrome. Eur J Obstet Gynecol 2002;

    101:47-53.

    65. Groten T, Kreienberg R, Fialka I, Huber L, Wedlich D. Altered

    subcellular distribution of cadherin-5 in endothelial cells caused

    by the serum of preeclamptic patients. Mol Hum Reprod 2000;

    6:1027-32.

    66. Diedrich F, Renner A, Rath W, Kuhn W, Wieland E. Lipid hy-

    droperoxides and free radical scavenging enzyme activities in pre-

    eclampsia and HELLP syndrome: no evidence for circulating

    primary products of lipid peroxidation. Am J Obstet Gynecol

    2001;185:166-72.

    67. Knapen MFCM, Mulder TPJ, Van Rooij IALM, Peters WHM,Steegers EAP. Low whole blood glutathione levels in pregnancies

    complicated by preeclampsia or the hemolysis, elevated liver

    enzymes, low plaelets syndrome. Obstet Gynecol 1998;92:1012-5.

    68. Raijmakers MTM, Roes EM, te Morsche RHM, Steegers EAP,

    Peters WHM. Haptoglobin and its association with the HELLP

    syndrome. J Med Genetics 2003;40:214-6.

    69. Moake JL. Thrombotic microangiopathies. N Engl J Med 2002;

    347:589-900.

    70. Lattuada A, Rossi E, Calzarossa C, Candolfi R, Mannucci PM.

    Mild to moderate reduction of a von Willebrand factor cleaving

    protease (ADAMTS-13) in pregnant women with HELLP micro-

    angiopathic syndrome. Haemotologica 2003;88:1029-34.

    71. Benedetto C, Marozio L, Salton L, Maula V, Chieppa G, Masso-

    brio M. Factor V Leiden and factor II G20210A in preeclampsiaand HELLP syndrome. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 2002;81:

    1095-100.

    72. Bozzo M, Carpani G, Leo L, Marcozzi S, Sacchi E, Morono G,

    et al. HELLP syndrome and factor V Leiden. Eur J Obstet Gyne-

    col Reprod Biol 2001;95:55-8.

    73. Van Pampus MG, Folf H, Koopman MM, van den Ende A,

    Butler HR, Reitsma PH. Prothrombin 20210G: a mutation

    and Factor V Leiden mutation in women with a history of

    severe preeclampsia and HELLP syndrome. Hypertens Preg-

    nancy 2001;20:291-8.

    74. Schlembach D, Beinder E, Zingsem J, Wunsiedler U, Beckmann

    MW, Fischer T. Association of maternal and/or fetal factor V

    Leiden and G20210A prothrombin mutation with HELLP syn-

    drome and intrauterine growth restriction. Clin Sci 2003;105:

    279-85.

    75. Queyrel V, Ducloy-Bouthors AS, Michon-Pasturel U, Hachulla

    E, Dubuequoi S, Caron C, et al. Antiphospholipid antibodies in

    HELLP syndrome: clinical and biological study in 68 women.

    Rev Med Interne 2003;24:158-64.

    76. Samuels P. Disseminated intravascular coagulopathy and throm-

    bocytopenia complicating pregnancy: an acute care approach. In:

    Foley MR, Strong TH Jr, Garite TJ, editors. Obstetric intensive

    care manual. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill; 2004.

    77. Steegers EAP, Mulder TPJ, Bisseling JGA, Delemarre FMC, Pe-

    ters WHM. Glutathione S-transferase alpha as marker for hepa-

    tocellular damage in pre-eclampsia and HELLP syndrome.

    Lancet 1995;345:1571-2.

    78. Sibai BM, Taslimi MM, el-Nazer A, Amon E, Mabie BC,

    Ryan GM. Maternal-perinatal outcome associated with the

    Martin, Rose, and Briery 929

  • 7/30/2019 Understanding and Managing HELLP Syndrome Ajog Martin Jr

    17/21

    syndrome of hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes and low platelets

    in severe preeclampsia-eclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1986;

    155:501-9.

    79. Audibert F, Friedman SA, Frangieh AY, Sibai BM. Clinical util-

    ity of strict diagnostic criteria for the HELLP syndrome. Am J

    Obstet Gynecol 1996;175:460-4.

    80. van Runnard Heimel PH, Juisjes AJM, Franx A, Koopman C,

    Bots ML, Bruinse HW. A randomized placebo-controlled trial

    of prolonged prednisolone administration to patients withHELLP synrome remote from term: maternal and neonatal com-

    plications. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2004;191:S41.

    81. Vigil-DeGracia P. Acute fatty liver and HELLP syndrome: two

    distinct pregnancy disorders. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2001;73:

    215-20.

    82. Matsuda M, Mitsuhashi S, Watarai M, Yamamoto K, Hashi-

    moto T, Ikeda S. HELLP syndrome associated with systemic

    lupus erythematosis. Intern Med 2003;42:1052-3.

    83. Roberts G, Gordon MM, Porter D, Jardine AG, Gibson IW.

    Acute renal failure complicating HELLP syndrome, SLE and

    antiphospholipid syndrome: successful outcome using plasma

    exchange therapy. Lupus 2003;12:251-7.

    84. Sullivan CA, Martin JN Jr, editors. Thrombotic microangiopa-

    thies in critical care obstetrics. 4th ed. Oxford: Blackwell Publish-

    ing; 2003. p. 408-19.85. Pitton MA, Petolillo M, Papi S, Grismondi GL, Masin GP,

    Forcelline F. Hemolytic uremic syndrome in twin pregnancy at

    32 weeks with HELLP syndrome: a case report. Minerva Ginecol

    2001;53:279-81.

    86. Pauzner R, Dulitzky M, Carp H, Mayan H, Kenett R, Farfel Z,

    Many A. Hepatic infarctions during pregnancy are associated

    with the antiphospholipid syndrome and in addition with com-

    plete or incomplete HELLP syndrome. J Thromb Haemost

    2003;1:1758-63.

    87. Haram K, Trovik J, Sandset PM, Hordnes K. Severe HELLP

    syndrome in the 18th week of pregnancy associated with the anti-

    phospholipid-antibody syndrome. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scant

    2003;82:679-80.

    88. Sinha J, Chowdhry I, Sedan S, Barland P. Bo