Hydropower Dams and Social Impacts: A Sociological .Michael M. Cernea Hydropower Dams and Social

  • View
    213

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Text of Hydropower Dams and Social Impacts: A Sociological .Michael M. Cernea Hydropower Dams and Social

  • Michael M. Cernea

    Hydropower Damsand Social Impacts:A Sociological Perspective

    Paper No. 16January 1997

    S ocial Assessment Series

  • Copies are available from the World Bank's Environment Department, Social Policy & Resettlement Division.

    017 Azerbaijan: Baku Water Supply EC3IV & EMTENRehabilitation Project

    023 Beneficiary Assessment: Lawrence F. SalmenAn Approach Described

    024 Participatory Poverty Assessment: Lawrence F. SalmenIncorporating Poor People's Perspectiveinto Poverty Assessment Work

    043 Social Assessment in World Bank and Ma. Concepcion CruzGEF-Funded Biodiversity Conservation Shelton H. DavisProjects

    044 Hydropower Dams and Social Impacts: Michael M. CerneaA Sociological Perspective

    045 African Involuntary Population Michael M. CerneaResettlement in a Global Context

    xxx Social Dimensions of Economic Neil J. SmelserDevelopment

    Environment Department PapersSocial Assessment Series

  • Social Development Department

    Hydropower Damsand Social Impacts:A Sociological Perspective

    Michael M. Cernea*

    January 1997

    * Michael M. Cernea is Senior Adviser for Social Policy and Sociology, The World Bank, Environment Department.

    Papers in this series are not formal publications of the World Bank. They are circulated to encourage thought and discussion.The use and citation of this paper should take this into account. The views expressed in this paper are those of theauthors and should not be necessarily attributed to the World Bank.

  • Acronyms and Abbreviations

    EA Environmental AssessmentICOLD The International Commission of Large DamsNORAD Norwegian Agency for DevelopmentNRCR National Research Center on Resettlement (China-Nanjing)OECD Organization for Economic Cooperation and DevelopmentOECF Overseas Economic Cooperation Fund (Japan)OED Operations Evaluation Department (The World Bank)SA Social AssessmentSIDA Swedish International Development Agency

  • !"#$%

    &'

    !

    "#

    #

    !(!)*&+

    ,+-

    &+%

    .!/

    0

    $%

    !&&&

    '

    ()#

    %

  • 1--&

    &234+56-78 1897:*&

    99:

    ;&$

    &

  • !

    "

    #

    #

  • $

    #%&&'('(' )#* +, %&&-. !,/0

    12

    3

    45

    2

    6#

    4!

    5)

    *

    778#3/ +%&&9. )

    * :;3$2

  • !

    "

    6 $ 5+, %&&'="%&?>. ##

    # +@ %&?

  • 5

    # $ %&'

    !

    (

    ) ) * "

    B

    +6 %&&%= 3 %&&%. GDB5 D3D+%&&'= B5 %&&%.

    D3HD 5 D

    B53D2

    + .

    6

    H3

    D

    2 F

    7

  • 1;/

    #

    + ! !45.+;,3"36. !

    2

    !

    " #" $ "%

    &% ! "!"

    F

    #D$B:

    0 3F

    2+.=+.$=+.= +.5=+.

    =+.=+.=+.;

    =

    #+3

  • B

    6

    +%=6#%

    .

    !"#$"""% !&'$"""

    ()*$"""

    + !*!$""" &""$""", + '"$""" #"$""" -#$""". /0 #"$""" /0 -"$"""

    #"$"""+. 1 *2$""" 3 &""$"""4 5 -"$"""4. 6.76.. -#$"""4

    89 *-$"""

    &2"$""" &"-$"""5 (-"$""":+ #)$"""1 &$&""$""" &*&$"""; 7 -"$"""

    .

    +>=L %&>&. %&>'

    +4%&>9%&&' %&&E=, %&&E. ! 5+!,

    8

    )*)*4F

    $2

    . =

    . F=

    . =

    .

    +)*.

    )*

    ! + .$

    ! %&&'/A,

    $ +/A, %&&%. 4F 1/A,

    ;/H6 +;/H6 %&&-(. #%&&%/A, ; !K/A,8/A,

    /

    $ +:303! 6:$!. +3 %&&'=G %&&-=, %&&

  • G

    B$

    #

    !

    !

    +. +.7A

    A )*$

    ##5

    /

    #5!#

    )*

    / $

    $+

    .G$

    ! 5 2

    $,

  • 5 4

    %&&-7&E$ %&>9%&&-4 $#

    4$ !48 5

    === =

    !

    F4$

    $ 4

    !%&&-$ 4F

    -

    %

    $ +9'3

    A6. !4$ (

    4F #54F#++!,.

    4F%&&E

    ! 3

    #

  • ! $$ =

    !

    A 5

    $

    6

    %'%E

    # 2

    . -#

    =

    . 3

    # =

    . 6

    =

    . A # )

    ! "

    H

    D$

    $ /$ F

    2= !2

    '"

    '

    "

    (&" %"

  • '

    #

    ) /4F

    ,45 !, 4

    4

    3

    !

    =

    6###5

    0

    , $

    4 %&?',

    65 @

    / 6,23# $

    %&9' %&?'

    %&?>%&&(

    " F

    ,

    >

    =

  • !%&&';H,H +;H,H.B"+;$. !,

    +3B1%&&9. !

    ,F+3@ %&&9= 3@ %&&9.

    #$

    G 6

    6$

    . #5

    )$F$

    4HH-'$6$ -

  • 8 +. ! :$ !

    $

    HF:$ M-'%&>9M%>'%&&-

    3

    02;

    %'+N. # /A F %&&( :$

    %&?' %'4$ 4+.B

    4F

    4

    $ 0# $3B3$ !,ID$ 4

    $%

    G$

  • $

    3 $

    A#

    E', F,$

    3$ 4

    !$$ H

    3$#

    5D

    !

    $+ . G# $

    H

    1B,

    2

    3, !

    3$:/!A,

    ,0B$

    6,01 A$

    ;,45E9

    $

    5 $F#

    $

    A5

    >

    =

  • 4F# 4$ 5

    5

    #$

    ,5

    !

    &

    !# )* $ 1 G#

    !

    $ D

    $

    G

    ;#5

    )

    / D;@/

    )

    8$

    !D#FCB$$ F

    !,F"B!$

    $ H

  • $ $ 4$ 4 $

    4

    8F 4

    D $

    $

    4

    2

    2

    )"! !*& !$ *

    " %

    " "!"&"**

    )

    * !

    !

    ! $" + *

    *) &

    ;$

    +

    .

    !

    4

    $

    !$

    >

    =

  • ##

    35 A

    8$+

    %(.4

    !

  • . .$ $ .+?$ /+==&''!@&''2$.@.+

    ..=.1< $ .A.