8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

1/20

 Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

Dvhrvjhw d` tch Htcjmek Jssuhs d`

Fhra Kjbh Adij`jmetjdb jb Ebjaeks

 Ekjsdb Peb Hhbhbbeea, Wc.I.Mddphretjvh Hxthbsjdb ]phmjekjst Ebjaek Njdthmcbdkdfy ebi FhbdajmsIhpertahbt d` Ebjaek ]mjhbmh

Xbjvhrsjty d` Mekj`drbje, Ievjs, X]E

Haejk< ekvebhhbhbbeeaGumievjs.hiu

Ywjtthr< GNjdNhh` 

cttp/3/>758

Wcdtd mrhijt< Mdrbhkk Ekkjebmh `dr ]mjhbmh

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

2/20

 Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

Dvhrvjhw d` tch Htcjmek Jssuhs d`

Fhra Kjbh Adij`jmetjdb jb Ebjaeks

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

3/20

Nrhhijbf 

Ahtcdi<

]hkhmtjvh Nrhhijbf 

Fhbdajm ]hkhmtjdb

Autefhbhsjs (HBX)

Fhbh Obdmodut (H]) 

Fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

]thrjkh jbshmt thmcbjquh

MkdbjbfFhbh Hijtjbf

^hshermc   WhtsWceraeprdiumts

NjdahijmekWrdiumts

Whst 

Mdbtrdk EfrjmukturhAjkkjdbs d`  

Ajmh/Kendretdry  

^dihbts/\hnre`jsc

Fkd@jsc

Ajmrdpjfs^ennjt ‗

^umdbhst

Fdet  ” EYryb, 

spjihr sjko 

Wjfs ‗Shbdtrebspkebtetjdb

Mettkh  ” pdkymkdbek 

cuaeb ebtjndijhs

EquEivebtefh ]ekadb  ”

`est frdwtc

Wdkkhi Cdksthjbs

Ijshesh rhsjstebmh

Japrdvhi prdiumt quekjty

Ihmrhesh hbvjrdbahbtek 

`ddtprjbt]jbfkh fhbihr d``sprjbf

]phmjhs

Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

YshYsh `ky  ”

skhhpjbf sjmobhss 

Adsqujtdhs  ”

aekerje rhsjstebmh 

Adtcs  ”

efrjmukturek phst 

mdbtrdk

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

4/20

 Ettjtuihs tdweris tch ush d` ebjaeks jbrhshermc

 Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

• Whdpkh‚s ettjtuihs tdweri hxphrjahbts jbvdkvjbf ebjaeks erh

ihphbihbt updb tch nhbh`jmjery, purpdsh dr bhmhssjty d` tchrhshermc (erh tchrh bdb-ebjaek ekthrbetjvhs4)

• Whdpkh erh adrh suppdrtjvh d` usjbf saekkhr-nrejbhi ebjaeks sumces ajmh ebi rets ebi khss suppdrtjvh d` cjfchr drihr ebjaeks

• Wunkjm mdbmhrbs endut tch ush d` ebjaeks jb rhshermc erhemmhbtuethi wchb fhbhtjmekky adij`jhi (FA) ebjaeks erh ushi

• Mdbmhrb endut jbmrhesh jb tch buanhr d` ebjaeks ushi jb rhshermc

iuh td tch (prhvjdusky) jbh``jmjhbt ebi ubprhijmtenkh beturh d` tchfhbhtjm adij`jmetjdb prdmhss

• Ych mrhetjdb d` FA ebjaeks `dr rhshermc aey mcekkhbfh tch Ycrhh^‚s prjbmjpkhs (rhpkemhahbt, rhiumtjdb, rh`jbhahbt)

Draebiy, H.C. ebi M.E. ]mcuppkj. >759. Wunkjm Ettjtuihs tdweri Ebjaek ^hshermc< E ^hvjhw. Ebjaeks =:5-973

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

5/20

@emtdrs e``hmtjbf phdpkh‚s emmhptebmh d`

ebjaeks jb rhshermc/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

• ]uppdrt `dr bdb-jbvesjvh rhshermc (jb tcjs pephr db pjfs `drefrjmukturek rhshermc) wes cjfc jrrhsphmtjvh d` rhfuketjdb

• Nhmeah khss emmhptenkh j` jbvesjvh, nut emmhptebmh jbmrheshi j`ebjaeks iji bdt su``hr ubbhmhsserjky, tcet tch nhbh`jtsdutwhjfchi tch ceras, tcet tch rhshermc wes rhfukethi, ebitcet tch ush d` ebjaeks wes rhiumhi, rh`jbhi (ajbjajzjbf pejb ebisu``hrjbf), ebi rhpkemhi wchrhvhr pdssjnkh

• Kdw khvhk d` suppdrt `dr rhshermc usjbf FA ebjaeks, ebiprdpdsjbf rhfuketjdb cei kjttkh h``hmt db tcjs

• Jb tch mesh d` emmhptenjkjty d` FA ebjaeks jb rhshermc dbky >0% d`phdpkh whjfchi mdsts ebi ceras jb aeojbf e ihmjsjdb esmdaperhi td 6>% wcd ushi mdst-cera `dr jbvesjvhbhss ihmjsjdb

Draebiy, H.C., M.E. ]mcuppkj, ebi I.A. Vhery. >758. Wunkjm Ettjtuihs tdweris tch Xsh d` Ebjaeksjb ^hshermc< H``hmts d` Jbvesjvhbhss, Fhbhtjm Adij`jmetjdb, ebi ^hfuketjdb. Ebtctdzdds

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

6/20

@emtdrs e``hmtjbf phdpkh‚s emmhptebmh d`ebjaeks jb rhshermc<

]phmjhs, nrhhijbf ahtcdi ushi td emcjhvhfhbhtjm adij`jmetjdb

 Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

• Wertjmjpebts wcd whrh wjkkjbf td emmhpt njdahijmek rhshermcjbvdkvjbf fhbhtjm adij`jmetjdb db zhnre`jsc whrh eksd wjkkjbf tdsuppdrt tch seah rhshermc db ajmh

• Wertjmjpebts hxprhsshi kdw khvhks d` suppdrt `dr HBX

autefhbhsjs db zhnre`jsc jb ndtc ubrhfukethi ebi rhfukethirhshermc prdfreas

• ]dah pertjmjpebts hxprhsshi e prh`hrhbmh `dr ush d` fhbhtjmekky-adij`jhi (FA) ebjaeks dvhr HBX autefhbhsjs, neshi db tch

nhkjh` tcet tch `drahr jbvdkvhs khss pejb ebi japrdvhs ndtc tchemmuremy ebi h``jmjhbmy d` tch ebjaek adihks

Draebiy, H.C., M.E. ]mcuppkj, ebi I.A. Vhery. >75>. @emtdrs E``hmtjbf Whdpkh‚s Emmhptebmh d`tch Xsh d` \hnre`jsc ebi Ajmh jb ^hshermc. EYKE =>5-===.

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

7/20

^hshermc   WhtsWcerae

Wrdiumts

Njdahijmek

Wrdiumts

Whst Mdbtrdk Efrjmukturh

Ajkkjdbs d`  

Ajmh/Kendretdry  

^dihbts

Fkd@jsc

Ajmrdpjfs^ennjt ‗

^umdbhst

Fdet  ” EYryb, 

spjihr sjko 

Wjfs ‗Shbdtrebspkebtetjdb

Mettkh  ” pdkymkdbek 

cuaeb ebtjndijhs

YshYsh `ky  ”

skhhpjbf sjmobhss 

Adsqujtdhs  ”

aekerje rhsjstebmh 

Adtcs  ”

efrjmukturek phst 

mdbtrdk

EquEivebtefh ]ekadb  ”

`est frdwtc

Wdkkhi Cdksthjbs

Ijshesh rhsjstebmh

Japrdvhi prdiumt quekjty

Ihmrhesh hbvjrdbahbtek 

`ddtprjbt]jbfkh fhbihr d``sprjbf

]phmjhs

Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

Ahtcdi 

Xshi<

]hkhmtjvh Nrhhijbf 

Fhbdajm ]hkhmtjdb

Autefhbhsjs (HBX)

Fhbh Obdmodut (H]) 

Fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

]thrjkh jbshmt thmcbjquh

MkdbjbfFhbh Hijtjbf

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

8/20

Idhs nrhhijbf ahtcdi 

curt `jsc4

Js tcjs

 e `ddi

 sphmjhs4

Id tchy pdsh eb 

hbvjrdbahbtek 

cezeri4 

Fdvhrbebmh4

FKD@J]C

]phmjhs758

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

9/20

Ahtcdi 

Xshi<

]hkhmtjvh Nrhhijbf 

Fhbdajm ]hkhmtjdb

Autefhbhsjs (HBX)

Fhbh Obdmodut (H]) 

Fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

]thrjkh jbshmt thmcbjquh

MkdbjbfFhbh Hijtjbf

^hshermc   WhtsWcerae

Wrdiumts

Njdahijmek

Wrdiumts

Whst Mdbtrdk Efrjmukturh

Ajkkjdbs d`  

Ajmh/Kendretdry  

^dihbts

Fkd@jsc

Ajmrdpjfs^ennjt ‗

^umdbhst

Fdet  ” EYryb, 

spjihr sjko 

Wjfs ‗Shbdtrebspkebtetjdb

Mettkh  ” pdkymkdbek 

cuaeb ebtjndijhs

YshYsh `ky  ”

skhhpjbf sjmobhss 

Adsqujtdhs  ”

aekerje rhsjstebmh 

Adtcs  ”

efrjmukturek phst 

mdbtrdk

EquEivebtefh ]ekadb  ”

`est frdwtc

Wdkkhi Cdksthjbs

Ijshesh rhsjstebmh

Japrdvhi prdiumt quekjty

Ihmrhesh hbvjrdbahbtek 

`ddtprjbt]jbfkh fhbihr d``sprjbf

]phmjhs

Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

10/20

Idhs nrhhijbf ahtcdi 

curt `jsc4

Js tcjs

 e `ddi

 sphmjhs4

Id tchy pdsh eb 

hbvjrdbahbtek 

cezeri4

Fdvhrbebmh4 

EquEivebtefh 

sekadb

]phmjhs758

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

11/20

Ahtcdi 

Xshi<

]hkhmtjvh Nrhhijbf 

Fhbdajm ]hkhmtjdb

Autefhbhsjs (HBX)

Fhbh Obdmodut (H]) 

Fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

]thrjkh jbshmt thmcbjquh

MkdbjbfFhbh

 

Hijtjbf

^hshermc   WhtsWcerae

Wrdiumts

Njdahijmek

Wrdiumts

Whst Mdbtrdk Efrjmukturh

Ajkkjdbs d`  

Ajmh/Kendretdry  

^dihbts

Fkd@jsc

Ajmrdpjfs^ennjt ‗

^umdbhst

Fdet  ” EYryb, 

spjihr sjko 

Wjfs ‗Shbdtrebspkebtetjdb

Mettkh  ” pdkymkdbek 

cuaeb ebtjndijhs

YshYsh `ky  ”

skhhpjbf sjmobhss 

Adsqujtdhs  ”

aekerje rhsjstebmh 

Adtcs  ”

efrjmukturek phst 

mdbtrdk

EquEivebtefh ]ekadb  ”

`est frdwtc

Wdkkhi Cdksthjbs

Ijshesh rhsjstebmh

Japrdvhi prdiumt quekjty

Ihmrhesh hbvjrdbahbtek 

`ddtprjbt]jbfkh fhbihr d``sprjbf

]phmjhs

Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

Wcdtd 

mrhijt< 

Mdrbhkk 

Ekkjebmh 

`dr 

]mjhbmh

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

12/20

Idhs nrhhijbf ahtcdi 

curt mettkh4

Js tcjs

 e `ddi

 sphmjhs4

Id tchy pdsh eb 

hbvjrdbahbtek 

cezeri4 

Fdvhrbebmh4

Cdrbkhss Cdksthjb

]phmjhs758

Wcdtd 

mrhijt< 

Mdrbhkk 

Ekkjebmh 

`dr 

]mjhbmh

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

13/20

Ahtcdi Xshi<

]hkhmtjvh Nrhhijbf 

Fhbdajm ]hkhmtjdb

Autefhbhsjs (HBX)

Fhbh Obdmodut (H]) 

Fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

]thrjkh jbshmt thmcbjquh

MkdbjbfFhbh Hijtjbf

^hshermc   WhtsWcerae

Wrdiumts

Njdahijmek

Wrdiumts

Whst Mdbtrdk Efrjmukturh

Ajkkjdbs d`  

Ajmh/Kendretdry  

^dihbts

Fkd@jsc

Ajmrdpjfs^ennjt ‗

^umdbhst

Fdet  ” EYryb, 

spjihr sjko 

Wjfs ‗Shbdtrebspkebtetjdb

Mettkh  ” pdkymkdbek 

cuaeb ebtjndijhs

YshYsh `ky  ”

skhhpjbf sjmobhss 

Adsqujtdhs  ”

aekerje rhsjstebmh 

Adtcs  ”

efrjmukturek phst 

mdbtrdk

EquEivebtefh ]ekadb  ”

`est frdwtc

Wdkkhi Cdksthjbs

Ijshesh rhsjstebmh

Japrdvhi prdiumt quekjty

Ihmrhesh hbvjrdbahbtek 

`ddtprjbt]jbfkh fhbihr d``sprjbf

Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

14/20

Idhs nrhhijbf ahtcdi 

curt tch ajmh4

Js tcjs

 e `ddi

 sphmjhs4

Id tchy pdsh eb 

hbvjrdbahbtek 

cezeri4

Fdvhrbebmh4 

^hshermc 

jb 

ajmh

]phmjhs758

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

15/20

Adush x autefhbhsjs/fhbhtjmhbfjbhhrjbf/OD x rhshermc

 Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

• Ychrh erh epprdxjaethky 287,777 kjvh fhbhtjmekky hbfjbhhrhi

adush kjbhs. Ycet js neshi db tch `emt tcet tchrh erh ~>>777prdthjb mdijbf fhbhs jb tch adush fhbdah, ebi autefhbhsjsjbiumhi rebidaky (HBX) dr ny terfhtjbf (fhbhtjmekky-hbfjbhhrhi) hkjmjt buahrdus ekkhkhs jb tchsh fhbhs.

• J` ydu mdbsjihr ekk tch kjbhs `rdzhb ebi stdrhi es fhrapkesa(sphra ebi hanryds) ebi hanrydbjm stha (H]) mhkks `rdawcjmc wh rheijky aeoh ajmh, tchb tch buanhr d` kjbhs js `ercjfchr, kjohky 2877,777.

• Ycdusebis d` d``-terfht h``hmts jb HBX kjbhs

•  Emmdrijbf td dbh hstjaeth, 57 td 87 ajkkjdb FH kendretdry

ebjaeks erh ushi ebbuekky jb tch Xbjthi ]teths (Aeo >773).

Ohbt Kkdyi, XMI, Whrsdbek Mdaaubjmetjdb

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

16/20

Ahtcdi 

Xshi<

]hkhmtjvh Nrhhijbf 

Fhbdajm ]hkhmtjdb

Autefhbhsjs (HBX)

Fhbh Obdmodut (H]) 

Fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

]thrjkh jbshmt thmcbjquh

MkdbjbfFhbh

 

Hijtjbf

^hshermc   WhtsWcerae

Wrdiumts

Njdahijmek

Wrdiumts

Whst Mdbtrdk Efrjmukturh

Ajkkjdbs d`  

Ajmh/Kendretdry  

^dihbts

Fkd@jsc

Ajmrdpjfs^ennjt ‗

^umdbhst

Fdet  ” EYryb, 

spjihr sjko 

Wjfs ‗Shbdtrebspkebtetjdb

Mettkh  ” pdkymkdbek 

cuaeb ebtjndijhs

YshYsh `ky  ”

skhhpjbf sjmobhss 

Adsqujtdhs  ”

aekerje rhsjstebmh 

Adtcs  ”

efrjmukturek phst 

mdbtrdk

EquEivebtefh ]ekadb  ”

`est frdwtc

Wdkkhi Cdksthjbs

Ijshesh rhsjstebmh

Japrdvhi prdiumt quekjty

Ihmrhesh hbvjrdbahbtek 

`ddtprjbt]jbfkh fhbihr d``sprjbf

]phmjhs

Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

17/20

Fhbh Hijtjbf x ^hshermc purpdsh

 Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

• Wdssjnjkjty d` rhiumjbf buanhr d` rhshermc ebjaeks ushi iuh tdh``jmjhbmy d` fhbh hijtjbf es mdaperhi td fhbhtjm hbfjbhhrjbf

• Khss d`` terfht h``hmts tceb rebida HBX autefhbhsjs

• Meb fhbhreth sphmj`jm rhshermc kjbhs (h.f. terfhthi autetjdbs

`dr ijshesh adihks) adrh h``jmjhbtky ebi khss hxphbsjvhky

• Meb phr`dra terfhthi fhbh obdmodut jb sphmjhs tcet erh adrhush`uk es adihks d` cuaeb ijshesh es mdaperhi td ajmh

• Jbhxphbsjvh beturh d` thmcbdkdfy dphbs up ush td aeby adrhkendretdrjhs pdthbtjekky usjbf aeby adrh rhshermc ebjaeks

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

18/20

]phmjhs x Fhbh Hijtjbf x ^hshermcpurpdsh

 Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

• Fhbh hijtjbf meb nh ushi td phr`dra terfhthi hijts jb aeby adrhebjaek sphmjhs es mdaperhi td H] obdmoduts (adstky ajmh)jbmkuijbf kerfhr-nrejbhi ebjaeks ebi bdb-cuaeb prjaeths

• Aey cevh hbvjrdbahbtek rjsos essdmjethi wjtc jbeihqueth

mdbtejbahbt d` rhshermc ebjaeks `rda sphmjhs wjtc pdthbtjek tdijsturn wjki pdpuketjdbs? dr tcdsh sphmj`jmekky hijthi wjtc fhbhirjvhs (h.f. jbshmts)

• Fdvhrbebmh ebi rhfuketjdb d` tcjs thmcbdkdfy `dr rhshermc

purpdshs js eanjfudus, trjffhrhi ny ush d` eb jkk-ih`jbhi prdmhssretchr tceb tch ettrjnuths d` tch ebjaek jtshk ,̀ ebi aey ij``hrihphbijbf updb sphmjhs ebi jbthbihi purpdsh d` tch fhbh hijt,ebi hvhb nesh pejr sjzh d` tch fhbhtjm mcebfh

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

19/20

• Bhhi td nh merh`uk td mdbthxtuekjzh tch htcjmek mdbmhrbs

essdmjethi wjtc e fhbhtjmekky adij`jhi ebjaek eppkjmetjdb_sphmjhs/ahtcdi ushi td aeoh tch fhbhtjm adij`jmetjdb/purpdshd` adij`jmetjdbQ td evdji mdb`ketjbf kdbfstebijbf htcjmek jssuhstcet erh bdt ubjquhky essdmjethi wjtc tch ahtcdi ushi td aeoh

tch adij`jmetjdb• Ychrh erh aeby htcjmek jssuhs essdmjethi wjtc tch ush d` ebjaeks

jb fhbhrek, tch ush d` ebjaeks `dr rhshermc purpdshs, ebjaekwhk`erh, ebi tch jbthbtjdbek ihvhkdpahbt ebi ush d` fhbhtjmekky

adij`jhi ebjaeks `dr rhshermc purpdshs• Ycdsh ubjquhky essdmjethi wjtc fhbh hijtjbf td adij`y fhra kjbh

erh e sunsht d` tcjs sht d` nrdeihr jssuhs

Mdbmkusjdb

 Peb Hhbhbbeea 5>/3/>758  Ebjaek Fhbdajms ebi Njdthmcbdkdfy Hiumetjdb

8/20/2019 Overview of the Ethical Issues of Germ Line Modification in Animals (Alison Van Eenenaam)

20/20

 Ekjsdb Peb Hhbhbbeea, Wc.I.Mddphretjvh Hxthbsjdb ]phmjekjst Ebjaek Njdthmcbdkdfy ebi FhbdajmsIhpertahbt d` Ebjaek ]mjhbmh

Xbjvhrsjty d` Mekj`drbje, Ievjs, X]E

ekvebhhbhbbeeaGumievjs.hiu

Ywjttthr< GNjdNhh` 

cttp/3/>758

Ycebos `dr jbvjtjbf ah