NATIONAL ASSEMBLY OF PAKISTAN ASSEMBLY DEBATES

----------------------------- Thursday, the 28th August, 2014

----------------------------- The National Assembly of Pakistan met in the National Assembly Hall (Parliament House), Islamabad, at 11:44 of the clock in the morning. Mr. Speaker (Sardar Ayaz Sadiq) in the Chair.

-----------------------------

RECITATION FROM THE HOLY QUR’AN ]345 6789: :;< =

8 > ?@AB CD CEFG < HIJIK LM N@ O< 8PQR45 6 :;ST U LT VIWX CFYZX R[\ I5 ]

HIJIK IM ^_@T̀9 LM abc ?@A

dOe5 O :;< Ld Vef5 > Rg =_\ ?@9h :;< L

d V<75 9 CD ?@Ai;: :;< ^ Wj; kIK h<blR5 O ?@AWmno TH<:;< HIJIK LM pbc 3T O RTOR5\IWXnqI5 ] HIrbs ?@AB tu59 Cd YJ Cv

8 >no:;< 5P5] TH< CM wR[ O x

Ty<; HR@T̀9R z{TG ?@A| [\}< w< CM ~�5 G ^�5 > ae8̀

T]< CT G 7M C��

:;< TH< HIJIK CM Cd YK 8PT �� 5�< T~� CZXnq�5] THh d̂ �M �S�[6 ~@ `�D C�TO IWX :;< d̂ �M �S�[6 �R@ `D C�TO IWXnoI8 G T?5 ] CM �S�[6 �R@ `D ?@A

dOR5\IWX CJ ) TH< CD R�� Cd G R5\ R�(

R@ `M =8 > C

T G THR4@ >< CT G � CM ~�5 G b�M R@ `M� I

8 G I5 ] b�M =8 > C

8 G 7M CZX : Cv8 > I� w<

CM 5�< T~� Rg �Tbl N[\ IKnq:;< T?5 ] HIJIK CM �S�[6 ~@ `�D ^T ��@ G ) T?

zD;:( C�TO IWX I8 G �; <n�LM 8P�6: ?@AB C�TO IWX :;< �; w< ?@AB 3z{@ A4Wj ?@AWm: CJo[ 7T]}<; RTO<IQh TH< ~4��<nn� 5�: T?@A4�R�K<o

2

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� :�ThI�Q�< ��<R�5 O � T?�  � T?¡¢£@ A¤

z{K< o�=@ ��5]�¤7K< £=¥�5 G ��< T?¡ �6¤7�K< o£=@��]¤7�K<Leave Applications.

LEAVE OF ABSENCE

Mr.Speaker: Justice (R) Iftikhar Ahmad Cheema,

MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 25th and 26th August , 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Mr Muhammad Pervaiz Malik, MNA, has requested for the grant leave from 4th to 20th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Ms Shamas-un-Nisa, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 25th and 26th August 2014. Is leave granted.? (The leave was granted)

3

Mr. Speaker: Ms Faryal Talpur, MNA, has requested for the grand of leave for the whole current session. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Syed Asif Hasain, MNA, has

requested for the grant of leave for 6th and 26th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Ms . Shagufta Jumani, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 25th and 26th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Mr. Asghar Ali Shah, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 20th, 21st and 22nd August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

4

Mr. Speaker: Pir Muhammad Aslam Bodla, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 25th and 26th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted) Mr. Speaker: Sheikh Salahuddin, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 26th August 2014. Is leave granted.? (The leave was granted) Mr. Speaker: Dr Nikhat Shakeel Khan, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 20th, 21st 22nd and 27th August 2014. Is leave granted? The leave was granted? Mr. Speaker: Ms Saman Sultana Jafari, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 20th, 21st 22nd and 27th August 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

5

Mr. Speaker: Syed Ayaz Ali Shah Sherazi, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 25th and 26th August 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Mr Sanjay Parwani, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave from 18th to 22nd August 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Mr. Khalil George, Parliamentary Secretary has requested for the grant of leave for 28th August 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Syed Ashiq Hussain, Parliamentary Secretary has requested for the grant of leave from 25th to 29th August. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

6

Mr. Speaker: Ms. Ayesha Raza Farooq, MNA, has requested for the grant of leave for 18th August, 2014. Is leave granted? (The leave was granted)

Mr. Speaker: Motion under rule 259. Further

discussion on the motion moved by Mr. Zahid Hamid, Minister for Science and Technology on 18th august, 2014 regarding prevailing political situation in the country. Mohtarma Shaeen Shafiq. DISCUSSION ON THE PREVAILING POLITICAL SITUATION IN THE COUNTRY

3¸S8 ¹ºl T?@AWmR z� »@Y�

zD : o£=@ ��]¤7�K<n T?¡ �6¤7�K<n ��<n £=¥�5 G 8P¼5> 3@ O7�z� 7�@ [̀A� 5P]R½no 8�R5 O 3@ O

CZX 3i 3@ O I5 ] 8P¼5> ¾t75 9 ¾t75 9 ?@A8OR5 O C

T G 7M Cd YK CM SW mR5 O Cvt �FA5O ?@ AWmn q�S@ ¹¸ ¿R@ `

T] ?@AB ÀÁ

T½SW m ?@AB I5 ] HR@ `  ]R½ 5P CM »] ?@AB HR@ `Á@ O: ÂÃTG ^ Wj: ?@AWm I8 G TH< IM Ä5 �Å�

RT @̀A� CFYZX R[\ 3i =8 > ^�

t �  bv5 > kIK 7�@ `K Cvt �FA5O IWX :;< ^�

t �  bv5 > CD �hR@ OT: kIK SW m ÀÁ

T½ ?@AB ÂÃ

TG CZX : ?@AWm HR@ `  5P]R½ LM 8u@9R46 ?@ABno3@ O R8`¼� CZX 3i HR@ `  5P]R½ ^l:}< CM CvÆ�@�[9 C8 YÆAf[ 6 ?@AWmn ow< IM ÇSz È ?@A�

T > L8 V}< 3i 3@ O HI8 G:IQ :;< HI[ �5> CM Cv�@�[9

R8 [̀Af[ 6 CZXnoHI8 G:IQ IM ¿RÉth R@ ORT 5̀9 <IWX CZXno3@ O R@ `M R8`v5 �Å� CZX 3i HR@`  5P]R½ CM kIK I5 ] �:R� THR8`EMR[ O ?@AB Cv

t �FA5O Cd G IWX ?@AWm CEFG < ^ Wj Cv

t �FA5O ?@AWmnqHI¼T >< CT G HR@ O

t:I[ ]

7

^T �¼[> L

d VIWX �?@AWm ^¥@ G< 8�R5 O ?@A�T > CZXno 5P5] =Wj SW m 3�Êh w< CM wR[ O C

8 G R5\ ?@AWm 3i [�}< THRB d;R5\nq=Wj Ä[ �� [�}< LM C8 Y

T9 RB ?@AWm [�}< Ä[ �� ¾:R4Wj ?@ATORBnoI8 G 3@ O SW m 3�Êh R8`¼�

CZX 3i ?@AB 3T O HIT GRBnq?@AB 3T O HI

T GRBno7�@ [̀A� 5P]R½ CEFG < ÇRg ?@A�T > CÁÆ\ R�noÄ[ �� [�}<

¾:R4Wj ?@ATORB Ä[ �� =Wj [�}< LM C8 Y

T9 RB ?@AWmnoHR�56 N8O HRW m; N@ O< ¾:<~B 5P]R½ Cvt �FA5O

Cd G IWX ?@AWmnq TH< CD ^�5 > R�� RW m:R5\ CZX 7�B �; ^�5 > Ä[ �� CT Y

T9 RB IM :R@8̀ 9 ?@A�

T > ?@AWmno?@AB TH<S@ ¹Ë HIWX 3i C

T Y8AÌ\ ^�5 > CD :~B C8 G IWX ?@AWmn ow< ?@AB HI8 G:IQ IM ^le�< :;< ^

T �@9h =@�Á�8G ¾h L

8 VR5\ CZXoHR�@> 7[ 9 �; =@�Á�8G �h CZX : ?@AWm H; t~TOth LMn q:;< T?@AÍ@ G ?@97M

7�@ [̀A� 5P]R½ 3i ?@AB CT G hIT] Rf_@ Oh 3i HIÁ8OI5 G ?@AB HI[ ]bl Rg L

T VR[ O eB 7M :;< 7�@ `K Ld V}< L

d VIWX ?@AWm 3i 7J< Ld VIM ^�5 > [�}< LM abc CJ }< R8`Ît75 9 CZX I8 G [�}< 3@ O w< 7[ 9

o?@A�<th CvÌ�l ?@AdOR8 5̀9 3i 3@ O HR�� LM 8us<Sz È CZXno< t~TOth w:IÊ LM 3@ O 8�R5 O C

8 G 7M ?@AWm < t~TOth w:IÊ I8 G 3@ O hI

T] :R@8̀ 9 CZX :7M ?@AWmno3@ O C

8 Y¼� ?@AWm 3i IÁ� tu59 :;< I5 ] ^�5 > CZX CvÌ�lI8 G I8 G R{@ G< R8`�� CZX 3i 3@ O HI8 G:IQ IM :R@

8̀ 9 CZX :7M ?@AWmn o 5P5] [�}< H;SÈ;h 7[ 9 TÏ<S8 ¹Ð< C

8 G 7M ?@AWm I8 G [�}< CT YÆ9 < [�}< IM ^�5 > ?@Af_@ Oh 3i [�}< R@ `M CZX :7M ?@AWmnoI8 G ¾S@ ¹¸ TH< HI

T G;h HI@ Yt 9:R[ O CD zw:<T7J CZX 3i Cd G <75 9 L

T VR5 OS�l [�}< CM CT G 7Îh ^sRg

Cd YJ IWX 5�< [�}< �[G<; ?@AÑ[\ ?@AdOR5\no3@ O7�

z�no

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� : 3z{dGR� RT½: Ò;:RÓ 35 `]R½o

3¸S8 ¹ºl 3z{

dGR� RT½: Ò;:RÓ : 3@ O7�z� St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�o

3¸S8 ¹ºl 3z{

dGR� RT½: Ò;:RÓ : 3@ O7�z� St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! Can I be allowed to refer to my papers?

8

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� : 5̂6 o:;ST U 3¸S8 ¹ºl 3z{

dGR� RT½: Ò;:RÓ: 3@ O7�z�n o�5] 8�:IÕ ¿R\ Rg St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 5p}< ?@A4Wj

RT` R� CZXn q3@ O �:R4Wj NÑB ?@AB d̂ �T9 ?@A�

T >o�:R4Wj ¾:I¼Å56 b�D IM CEFG < 8P¼5> CD HIT GRÓIc Rg RT` R� RW m: CZXnoÒbs aSU 3@ O CZX 3i 5p}< =Wj C

T G CT YÆ9 < T:bc Â4Ö CD 8u59RzO 7M R@ Oh CZX 3i w< NÑB ?@AB 8u@9:I¼Å56 CT YÆ9 < ×RÍ8G:< CM CÁ\ bl ¾TS@ ¹8O CD Cc 7M ^ Wj: CZXn oT̂yRB LM 8u@9<;: CD tPWX 7M 5p}< T?

z E@ G T:I[ G< :;< 8P I�\ HIT Gh ÂB 7M

w< 8̂ �zEM IM THRÓIc CD CT YK RÃTG ?@AB a;SØ  o?@AWm w< CM Cd YK =Wj 5PD R5 º5> :Ic

7[ 9 hR5 `M:R5 `  CM »�8�E  CZXoHonourable Speaker, we cannot at

any cost, reverse the process of evolution of democracy in this country only because an adventurer is driven by the quest for power or a misplaced notion of resting control of the State of Pakistan through mobocracy. A lot has been said about PTIs long march, about their demands and the route that has been adopted to fulfill these demands. Mr. Speaker, some trends that have been set here are certainly commendable and reflect that democratic culture has taken firm routes in this

country where democratic dispensations have merely been brief interludes. LKRz`  ;S5 ¹½ Â4�

8> :;< Tp<bs LKh Rg �SW mR ÙÚ  R@ `M R@ `J :;< ¾:I[ G R@

T̀9h CT G Rf_@ Oh 3i hI[ ] � THh IWX Cd YJn qÇR4

8> 789 8�eÃzE  :;< Û@ YKRÃ8 G CM hI5 ];R5 O =Wj C

T G a< N8O ?@A�T > R@ `Mo

9

A democratic Government Mr. Speaker has restrained from using forced and allowed an Opposition party to hold a protest march and the longest sit-in protest despite the unconstitutional demands of this party. For the first time Mr. Speaker in the history of Pakistan, all political parties except one, have unanimously passed a Resolution in the support of democracy. However, some trends that we have seen to be set here are dangerous and a cause for concern. They are worth reflecting upon. And I would like to put a few questions before this House as food for thought. 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! TH< HI

T G;h HI[ ]:RB ?@AB R�� R@ `J 3i =Wj status quo CM aeT\ ?@AWmnoHR�@> 5�eÍ

TG< Rg N@ O< ÙÝ�K ¿R4Þ8A�< R@ `M R@ `Jno?@AB 3@ O RT`v[ 6I[ G 8̂ � WXR[\ HIWX 3i �5]

LM �hR@ OT: 789 Tx @>:R8O 8u@9bl}< CM C

d G R� ?@AB ¾:T7J IWXnow< ?@AB 8u@9:I¼Å56 LM LJhI5 ]I  :;< 8u@9:I¼Å56 Rg Â{Á{

8G ^ Wj anti status quo ?@A�T > CZXo Mr. Speaker,

revolution is a process, it is not an event. 5�eÍTG< ^¥M N@ O<

THh CM Cz G hR\ Rg ÇRTO ?@A�

T > CZXo We are in fact going through a democratic revolution. And this House Mr. Speaker is the symbol of that revolution. I would like to ask Mr. Speaker, is it justified to ask for the resignation of a democratically elected Prime Minister? Is it fair to pronounce an election as rigged on mere hearsay? Is it

10

reasonable to convict people without presenting evidence to equate the Prime Minister’s magnanimity with weakness? Is it rational not to accept the olive branch extended by the Government in accepting electoral reforms and rigging investigation merely because it has come too late? Is it fair not to let democratically elected Government complete their Constitutional terms only because there is a rush to parachute to the highest office here? What precedence are we setting here Mr. Speaker?

=Wj HI

T G<I5 ]IT G IMnq T?5 ] LM ~@` < TH<bÅÖ THRT\ CD ¾t75 ] ^�

8 >nqR@ `M ÇRT�@ Y[9 �h CZX : ?@AWmn q THIM R� 38`D: Rf�h ?@AWmCZX :o Mr. Speaker what R@

T̀9 THR8`EMR[ O is being demanded here? Is this a R@T̀9 THR8`EMR[ O where there will be

no rule of law? Where mobs will determine the future of Pakistan? Where mobs will choose our next Prime Minister? Where we will punish and hang offenders first and conduct trials later? Where inflexibility will become the rule of negotiation? Even if it leads to destruction of democratic and state institutions? Where we will train our youth’s impatience and intolerance? Where we will force our will upon others? Where we will not wait out

11

patiently for our turn, but ask our youth to jump the queue all ways? Where we will present half-baked truths, we will misrepresent and twist facts to our advantage? Where rules will be broken, money laundering through Hundi will be encouraged and taxed evaded? Where civil disobedience Mr. Speaker will be a norm? We had great respect Mr. Speaker for Mr. Khan

and great aspirations from him and his party. 7�B ^T �[9< C

d G <: 8u@9Sz ¹i< 7[ 9 ÝÁ{  RTO7M T?@97

89~5 O 8u@9bl}< LM ^�RÃQ R8O7M CZXo Mr. Speaker, in a free market economy the entry of a new-competitor is always welcomed because it is beneficial and it works to the advantage of all the consumers. Unfortunately in our democratic system, one competitor has decided to monopolize the market. One competitor has decided to break the rules of the game and is threatening to

destroy the entire democratic system. 3@ O NÑB St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! ^¥M =àl L

d VI5 ] R@ O adventurism Rg Â4�8�  ?@A�

T > IWX R8`��n o=Wj CT G 8u@9:I¼Å56 Rg b�D 8̂ �[A8O 8u@9: 7[ 9 Â[\ 7M R@ `M oCZX 7J< =Wj C

T G ^¥M IM 5p}< w< 8�R5 O LM 8� T:R5\< ¾h 3i �; w< b�D LM �<: ?@AB t�;Rg: CT YÌ9 I8 G Tx @>:R8O ?@A4Wj ^�5 �M aR�  ?@A�

T > �7M LJno3@ O7�

z� St ¹{  o7�@ [̀A�

12

FATEHA PRAYER

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� : ?@AB CT G N@ O< announcement RTO7M CZXno�:R4Wj Â5`@97T9}<

S5 ¹4l T?t A[ @̀Ai :~áÕ 5P]R½ CM ~�<; 5P]R½ �< ¡LKR�8G IM �:R@ [̀9 IWX Cd YJ ?@AWmno?@AB

RTO�I  bÅâ T?@9~�< 5P]R½ CD zw:<T7J H;7M R� 3i TH< CM Cd YK R�h ?@97Mo )C

d G R�h 8�b�T�  LM d̂ �J(

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� : bTÞÕ< ^ã� �R z� 5P]R½o DISCUSSION ON THE PREVAILING POLITICAL SITUATION IN THE COUNTRY

5�RT 5̀] bTÞÕ< ^ã� �R z� : 3@ O7�z� 5�RT 5̀] o7�@ [̀A� 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! =Wj 5p}< I5 ] 8��R\

w< NÑB ?@AB ?@AWm TH< 7[ 9 RT [̀9< :R� Ùä< ¿R@ `T] 7M CZX : ?@AWmo1947 ?@AB THR8`EMR[ O RT 5̀9no

T?�@ `K 1956 N8O �; S@ ¹T�5 G T?@A

dO}< CM R8`Á[\ RW m:o 1956 ?@AB N@ O< T?@AdO}< R@ ORT 5̀9 R@ `J

T?�@ `K bv[ > w< 3[ O ^�5 > 1958 ?@AB e�[> Âz�:RB ×� RåK 7M CD < =

8 � T] 7M R@ Oh R@ `Jno 5�RT 5̀] �<;! �; ^�< 35 \; CD Rf8 > 3i 3|TOI[ ] S@ ¹

T�5 G T?@AdO}< CM 3@ O NÑB Rf8 > I

8 G w< Rg 35 º@�8ATO 3@ O

eÃTG 3i <:R4Wj NÑB ;h 8PT �� IWX R@ `Jn ow< 8uâ; ^�5 > N@ O< St ¹@t̀Aith LM 8P I�\

o^�8 >1973 ?@AB ~@`¼

z� :RÍ�K<;Th ^ã� It Yv5 > CT G w< NÑB IM N@ O< 3Í�8Y  T?@A

dO}< R@ Oh :;< w< T?@A

dO}< CM CT G RT 5̀9 ?@AB I5 ] ~@ 5̀] ×R4ã� Cv

8 > TH< Rg TH;R�8G ½R\ R@ `Mn qI5 ] nationalist leaders Cv8 >q TH< IM Ä8 >R� R@ OeB :;< N@ O< 3Í�8Y  T?@A

dO}< w< NÑB IM R@ Ohno T?�@`K R@ `M <IWX 3i 1977 ?@AB bv[ > Â

z�:RB ×� RåK CM 3T O aSU w< T?@AdO}< IM =

8 � T] R@ `M R@ `Jn qw< IM suspend 7M CM ÄM: R@ Oh R@ `Jno T?�@ `K C�� < L

T VR5 O IM ^�5 > ~@ `¼z� R@ `M

13

R@ `Jn oI8 G 5�RT 5̀] 3@ O ¾:R4Wj ¾St ¹{WX CZXn ow< CM ~�5 G bv[ > 5P5] 1988 ?@AB N@ O<

controlled democratic system w< NÑB ?@AB =d >Ræ R@ `M R@ `Jnq T?�@ `K R@ `M <IWX

�; N@ O< chess LM pbc =@�J Ld VRT 5̀9 d̂ �J :;< ;h ¿R� N@ O< R@ O}< =

d ><7[ 9 St ¹{TAB ^

T ��@ G 3¸S8 ¹ºl L

d V}<nqbv[ > ¾SÈ;h Lt V:R[ O IM ;h ¿R� C

d G h Cd YJnow< pbc 3@ O R8`Á[\ RW m: :;< 7T]}< :Rg

bv[ > 1999 ?@AB bv[ > N@ O< Âz�:RB ×� RåK 7M w< T?@A

dO}< IM suspend R@ `M R@ `JnoI8 G

5�RT 5̀] 3@ O Â@`v� 5uM N8O e@ `v� Cd G R5\no3@ O NÑB T?@A

dO}< CM S@ ¹T�5 G ?@A�

T > Â[\ R8`��no 5�< HR�@> 7[ 9 ;h HR@

t̀ 9:R[ O }< CM Ät �@A5O d̂ �J ?@AWm �:R5 O �S@ ¹8O THh CD :;< <:R� :R5 O;:Rg ~T̀ 59 7M R@ Oh CZXnqÇR5\ 7M R@ Oh CZXnqHI5 G:< RgCÆG ;: ¾:R4Wj ^lI

T GRg< IM THRçèTG <IWX CZXnqI8 G w< Rg

3¸Th :<h THIM IWX oR� :;< bv[ > 5�RT 5̀] C8 Y¼� R@ `M ?@AWmnqLd VIM ^lh}< 8�R5 O R8O7M CZXnqI� ~ç@YÊ

^¥M 8�R5 O ?@A�T > L

T VRB oL8 VR5\Give and take R8OIWX CZX T?�@ `K HR�@> 7[ 9 ’ HI@ YM 3i

TH< IM RTO7M ^ Wj ?@A�T > CZXnq TH< IM L

d VIM compromise RTO7M ^ Wj ?@A�T > CZXno 5�RT 5̀]

LKR�! ?@AB 3@ O R8`v[ 6I[ G qHIWX CvÌ�l d̂ �M �@G< =@>< �@G< C8 G }< ?@AWmn qCvÌ�l é~T̀ D CD kIK

C8 YvÆ6I[ G ?@AWm 3i 5�RT 5̀] =Wj é~T̀ D HIK<; IM ^�5 > 8� T:R5\< LJIWX 3i ’ 3@ O I8 G wh :<TSW m

R@ O [xT>R[ O :<TSW m ’ 7J< =Wj :R[\ I� ^lh}< ^�5 > CK CM C

d G }< I8 G =Wj IM 8� T:R5\< LJIWX 3i =Wj CM }< w< tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CT Y  R�CM Ät �@A5O ?@A

dOR5\no 5�RT 5̀] 3@ O <SW m;h =t �ED ?@A

8Ob�TG <~@ [̀9 7M

RW m: oCZX �:R4Wj T:TbÞ  S5 ¹4l 5�RT 5̀] IÁ5 O 5P]R½: CT G R�� CZX 3i 3@ O TS@ ¹[Ë C

t G Iv[ 6 HI5 GIÕ ?@AB ?@A

8Ob�TG <~@ [̀9 7M ^ Wj: CZXno�; C8 YvÌ�Å� ?@AWm 3i ;h 3�Êh �:R4Wj 8P¼5> �t75 9

LT VR5 O T:: t~@ `K 5�RT 5̀] :RÍ�K<;Th ^ã� IM ~@`¼

z� R@ `M R@ `J bv[ > 3¸S8 ¹ºl CÌG S@ ¹ÙÚTG It Yv5 > IM ~@`¼

z� R@ `M R@ `J :;< �; �M C

T G RB T: ?@AB <IWXnoHIT G;h =

d >Rt O St ¹@t̀Aith HR�@> 8P I�\ 7M CZX : Cv

8 >no=Wj é~T̀ D CK <; C

t G Iv[ 6 HI5 GIÕ CK <; =Wj THR8`EMR[ O CM ^lR\ ?@AWm T?�@ `K 3@ O ?@A�T > CZX 3i

?@A4Wj 3z{@ A4Wj :<I@ Gh CD R@ ORåK Cd G R5\ow< Cd YK ¾:R4Wj L

t V:R[ O CT G ^à@> 3Ñç@YÊ R@ `M CZX 3i

14

8u@9:I¼Å56 CM Cd YK w< 8P I�\ Rg Ä8 >R� �h CZX : ?@AWm T?�@ `K H;SÈ;h IM ^�5 > RT [̀]I� CFYZX R[\ 3i w< NÑB ?@AB R@ `M IWX RW m: CZXo

?@AB 8P I�\ IM ÂÃKR5 O appreciate HIWXR8O7M 3i HI¼T >< CT G 3@ O I5 ] R@ `M CZX

:;< 5p}< N8O Ld VIM T?

z E�@ O< ?@A�T > R@ `M CZXno?@AB w< LM t�:I[ A� HIWXR8O7M T?�@ `K L

d VIM 3T O Ld VIM 3Í@ Gbc RT`KRÃTG R�IWX HI@ YM 3i 3@ O unlimited time 7[ 9 ?@A�

T > Â[\ R8`��now< pbc [�}< w< NÑB IM RT 8̀ 9< RTO Â5ORæ ^se8O THRçè

TG ?@AdOR[ ºT�¼[> CJ 3i bv[ > ~@ OR z� 3@ O CÎ ~@ `D

C8 A� <: 7[ 9 3T O C�� }<no¾:R4Wj economic condition CÁ�Æ> ^ Wj ¾75 9 CZX T?�@ `K 5�< 7J< < w CD �hR@ O

T: <IWX I8 G bv[ > I5 ] 3@ O kIK ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i HI5 Y@9bT Ö Cd YK CM THRà ^�5 > ?@A@` WXR[\ I8 G 3@ O HR�� CD oR�IWX 3@ OI

8 G RTO7M R@ `M ?@AWmC8 YZX R[\noCvÌ�l HI@ YT9R8`EMR[ O CD ’I5 ] ^�5 >

�:<h< CZX HR�56 7[ 9 CZXn q t�:IM :;<CZX �:<h< ?@AWm’ TH< 5PD IM ¾S@ ¹¸ 3@ O zw:<T7J CZX 3i <:<~ T\ 5PD ÂB 7M w< NÑB IM êI5 YTë  ?@A

dORT 5̀9noI5 ] CT G 7Îh IWX ?@AWmCZX :q?@AB

TH< IM R5 º8�K< R8O7M HIWX 3i �; ^�5 > L

T VR8`EMR[ O ?@AWmno�; ^�5 > 3@ O ?@A [\I� :;< w< NÑB IM êI5 YTë  ?@A

dORT 5̀9n o^âR5 O 3@ O 8PDR@ `D 8̂ �Á[\ LJCZX :n o�<×R z{TG< 3@ O NÑB =

d >Ræ CZX : R� I8 G

8PDR@ `D ^�5 > 8̂ �Á[\ CZX : LJno [�}< Rg 8P¼5> 8P¼5> 3@ O7�z�o

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�: NÑB ~4�l TÏR@ O: o 5P]R½

5�RT 5̀] ~4�l TÏR@ O: NÑB : 3@ O7�

z� 5�RT 5̀] o7�@ [̀A� 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB I8 G tPT Y�T >:IJ

LM abc CD ’ [�}< CT G CvÌ�l SW mR5 O R5 º@�v5 > <IWX Rf8 >o?@AB HRW m; 3[ O ^�5 > L

t V ¾; ÂT̀ @A [\

CM 7[ 9;< R8`v_@ Oh HIWXRW m: 3i ÇS8 ¹ºl RT 5̀] 5� TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ CT G �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ CM

CK <I] CD SW mR5 O ST ¹@t̀AT̀ M 7[ 9;<CM �tbv� IWX CM ^sRg 35

8̀ 9bl 3@ O 8�R5 O LM CZX 3i

15

NA-118 I5 ] :IWX� Rg e�[> 3ÍÁ\ R8`TA5O CZXow< IM �Iv� R@ `J CZX T?�@ `K w< ?@AB

�IT G :<TSW m t�;; ^ã�5 ] CÁÃ

TG ?@AWmn o?@AB TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ 5P]R½ CD 3@ O RT`v[ 6I[ G HIWXR8` WXR[\ ’ �; N@ O< ¾t75 9 L

t V:R[ O CM �<75 9SÈ ?@AWm T?�@ `K TH< IM CÁ�Æ> 3@ O RT`v_@ Oh CFYZX R[\ 3i I5 ] ?@AB 8�R5 O 7M HIWXRW m: ’ R@ `M �; 8�R5 O N@ `v

t > CZXno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! I5 ] �S@ ¹¸ ~B Â5ORÍ  L[V L

t V Ld V}< Rg ÇRgRTO :<;~@ ` < Rf8 >n q~BR\ THRB T:’ �; TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ Rg 5̂�@9bâ

T7@ 9TbÖ CZXno�; :R5 O :R5 O ^à@> 3iCZX R8`¼� =Wj CT G TH;R8`D ÄM� 3@ [̀9;: [p7

T] R@ `M CZXnobv[ > R5\ CM ?@A4Wj 3@ O 38 [̀9 e[\ CZX 3i �I

T G :<TSW m t�;; ^ã�5 ] ?@AWmn o 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB 5p}< wd;RW m IM 3@ O 8�R5 O RTOR8 5̀9 HIWXR8` WXR[\ 3i HI¼T >< C

T G election petition �S@ ¹¸ aeT\ 7d9<h LM ^�

8 >n o^ã�[> 8�R5 O I8 G 3@ O CZX 3i �; maintainable ?@A�T > ^�

8 > w< CFYK 3i election day LM L

d VIM evidence TH< wR[ OCM hI5 ]I  ?@A�T > ^�

8 >no [�}< =ã�CM ?@AB CZX 3i ^�5 �D kIK I5 ] ^ã5 `��< :~TO<CM CÆ�

T�¼[> ?@AWmn o3@ O T?z E�@ `K< 8P@Y5] HR�@>CM 3[ O

C8 YÆ�T�¼[> ?@AWm :;< 5P5] election day R8OIWX CZX I8 G SW m íT̀ KI[ G T?

z E@ At`D :~TO<CM ;h R@ O T?@A8O Ä8 >I5 G ?@AWmC

8 G IWX :;< SW m Ä8 >I5 G :~TO<CM SW m Lt V:R[ O Rg N@ O< íT̀ KI[ G tPT Y5�@>< hI5 ]I 

R8OIWX oCZX ^T �8A 5\ ¾t75 9 HR@

t̀ 9:R[ O L8 VIWX ?@AWm TH< CM íT̀ KI[ G tPT Y5�@>< I8 G SW m Ä8 >I5 G CM

:~TO< hI5 ]I  ?@AWmC8 G IWX :;< bv[ > Ä[ �� h< T:}< :<;~@ ` < ^�5 > �tbv� ?@AWmC

8 G IWXq TH< CM �~T̀ d9R4T>

^�5 > HRW m; hI5 ]I  ?@AWmC8 G IWXo 5P5] L

d VIM t�;; ÝÁT� CT YK <th R8O}< CZX I8 G �; w< t�;; IM

5xT�Á@ [̀] ?@AWmC

8 G 7M 3i 3@ O �~T̀ 59 I5 ] t�;; CT YK <th R@ O}< CZX w< Rg ÇRTO 3@ O ?@A�T > oCZX

?@AB TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ CD HIWXR8`v[ 6I[ G 3i �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\NA-118 CM R5 `@9bì8G ;h I� Ät A{M< íT̀ KI[ G TST ¹ z{@ A

t`D Cv8 > :;< T?5 ] N@ O<CM R@ O ;h Ä8 >I5 G Cv

8 >no^¥M Ä8 >I5 G CM :~TO< TH< CM ^¥M �~T̀ d9R4

T> CT G I5 ] íT̀ KI[ G tPT Y5�@>< R8OIWX CZX ’ ^¥M t�;; IM

5xT�Á@ [̀] R@ `M <IWX 3i 5�RT 5̀] 3@ O t�;; ÝÁT� �~T̀ 59 CT YK <th R@ O}< oCZX 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ^¥@ G< L

d VIM

16

8�R5 O ?@A�T > ^ãÃ

TG 3i íT̀ KI[ G tPT Y5�@>< CT G �:I[ G CìÁ\ ?@AB election day ?@AB L

d VIM t�;; 5x

T�Á@ [̀] ?@A�T > R@ `Mn obv[ > 3@ O :R5 O :R5 O ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i LK~TORÉh L

d VIWX CZX LK~TORÉh Ld VIWX

oCZX Election day Rg TH< wR[ OCM Ld VIM witness hI5 ]I  ?@A�

T > CZXn o TÏbs ?@97M 3i 7J< ^¥M íT̀ KI[ G tPT Y5�@>< C

T G íT̀ KI[ G CK <; THh Ld VIM t�;; 5x

T�Á@ [̀] ?@A�T > R@ `M

’ IÁ[\ w< CD ^�5 > tPWX ?@AdOR5\ 3i R@ `M ^¥M presiding officer IM HI¼T >< C

T G Ld VIM Ä�� hCM R@ O 3i 5�RT 5̀] HR�@> 3[ O LK~TORÉh IWX ^ Wj: CZXn o;h I� Ät A{M< íT̀ KI[ G T?z E@ At`D Cv

8 >no^¥M íT̀ KI[ G T?z E@ At`D CM 7[ 9;< HI¼T >< C

T G 3@ O Ä�� CM ?@A�T > R@ Oh 3i 5�RT 5̀]

HR�@> 7[ 9 LK~TORÉh Ld VIWX oCZX 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! �S@ ¹¸ �:I[ G CìÁ\ ?@AB ^¥M íT̀ KI[ G

T?z E@ At`D ?@AB L

d VIM :Iz� R5 O<Sz È L

d VIM Ä[ �� ?@A�T > <IWXnoIÁ[\ presiding officer IM ^�5 >

?@9 t:Iv[ 6n o7J< ?@A�� :Iz� R5 O<Sz È IWX R8O L

d VIM CT G Rf8 > :~TO<CM �~T̀ 59 application ^Wj

R8 @̀9h CZX 3i 5�RT 5̀] HR�@> 3[ O LK~TORÉh IWX ^ Wj: CZXn o 5�RT 5̀] ^¥@ G< ^�5 > witness election day LM L

d VIM hI5 ]I  ?@A�T > CZX :;< bv[ > T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4�n q:}< ;< ’ I5 ]

T?z E�@ `K< <;7M RW m: R8OIWX CZX R@ `M w< IM L

d VIM HI¼T >< CT G T?

z E�@ `K< CK <; THh 8u@9RÃ zD LM 5�RT 5̀]oCZX 7�@ [̀A� ^¥@ G< ^�5 > L

d VIM 8�R5 O CT Y  R� ?@A�T > L

d V}<o

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! bv[ > :}< ;< CD tPWX CM T?z E�@ `K< T?

z E@ A4� 5�R5 ºT�[9 I5 ] :IWX� :~TO<CM

based CZX TH<R@ `M IM Ld VIM application ¾h oCZX L

t V ¾; CM 7[ 9;< 8�<:R5 `T]<

<CM 7[ 9; T?z E�@ `K< T?

z E@ A4� a}< THR8`EMR[ O CT G CT YÆ9 < ��@ `Ê T:S5 ¹4

T> ^�5 > Cd G h C

d G IWX Cv8 > R@ `M

Ld VIM T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� a}< THR8`EMR[ O IM ^�5 > HI¼T >< C

T G Ld VIM election day LM

8u@9RÃ zD LM 5�RT 5̀]oCZX 7�@ [̀A� ^¥@ G< Ld VIM ¿Rz`  ?@A�

T > CZXn o�S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ CM ;h I� Ät A{M< íT̀ KI[ G T?

z E@ At`D Cv8 > :;< ?@AB Ät >R� :<TSW m t�;; LM lead CD’ �< CM Â

TçÊ ; Ç7M CD T:<I

T G Û@ GSz È S@ ¹

z�CM CM THR z{TG 7[ 9 ?@AB Ät >R� :<TSW m t�;; CD HIWXR8 @̀A 5\no

17

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! w< ~�5 GCM HI¼T >< CT G ;h �RB CM ~�5 G election petition 7d9<h 7M

¾hno;h �RB TH< IM Ld VIM 38 [̀9 ?@A�

T > e[\ 3i ^¥M CìÁ\ CM :~TO<qw< CìÁ\ :~TO<CM LK~TORÉh Ld VIWXn o;h �RB CM ~�5 G �; petition 7d9<h 7M ¾hn o=Wj C

T G R�� 3i 3@ Omaintainable ?@A�

T > CZX T?�@ `K w< CM 7[ 9;< =Wjbv[ > Ld VRW m t�:IM oCd YJ 5�RT 5̀]

7�@ [̀A�! �:R4Wj thumb impression 5x 56CM 5P]R½ CT G :th:}< C

d G h7M ’ �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ CM thumb impression CM :th:}< 7M TH<bÅÖoC

d G h THRT\ 5P]R½ ST ¹@t̀AT̀ M

DC �tbv� IWX 7M 3T O< T:;: :Iz� ?@AWmC8 G 7M 3i �I

T G :<TSW m t�;; ^ã�5 ] eÃTG CZXo

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB 5p}< wd;RW m IM HIWXR8` WXR[\RTOR8 5̀9n qCT YÆ9 < T7�@ `KIM IM 3@ O RTOR8 5̀9 HIWXR8` WXR[\ 3i <:hRTO C

T G I5 ] ?@A4Wj t�:I[ G: ¾h qCZX 5x 56I5 ] 5P]R½ CT G :th:}< R@ `M Rf

8 > ’HI¼T >< CT G

3@ O :th:}< ?@A�

T > R@ `M Rf8 > 3i TH< CM HIt G;; IM N@ [̀] R@ `M C

d G R5\noHI¼T >< CT G 3@ O:

th:}< R@ `M Rf8 > 3i electoral role and counter file IM eB TH<7M CM thumb

impression check Cd YM ?@AdOR5\o

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! Electoral roll I5 ] R8OIWX CZX �; N@ O< R8OIWX CZXn oN@ O< íTO t~@ O

T~@ O7[ 9 Sî@ AÓ}< �bÅ� CM :~TO< Ld VR5 OIÕ :;< ^lIr Rg T?

z E�@ `K< <;7M RW m: R8OIWX CZXnoN@ O< ^ Wj 3ï5\ CD ^�< �bÅ� CD ^lIr ^ã5 `��< Rg tPÁ@ 5̀9 S[ ¹@ [̀9 R8`ÁB CZX :;< ^�< �bÅ� CD

Ld VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< Rg tPÁ@ 5̀9 S[ ¹@ [̀9 R8`ÁB CZXnoN@ O< T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� N@ O< electoral roll

R8 @̀9h CZXno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� w< 3�Êh T?z E�@ `K< CM :~TO< <:hRTO C

T G I5 ] electoral roll CFG h Cv

8 > w< CM 7[ 9;< SW m �~T̀ 59 LM 7@9Ië8 G ^�

8 > I5 ] �~T̀ 59 t�;; tPDRg CT G 7M R8OR5\

Rf8 >no 5P5] ?@AB ^�5 > RT [̀9< t�;; tPDRg CT G 7M R@ `J HIWX I8 G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! CÁ�Æ> HI¼T >< C

T G <S@ ¹¸ 8̂ � T]RT` zD th:Rg Rf_@ Oh CZX bv[ > w< electoral roll CD ¾S@ ¹¸ 7@ 9Ië

8 G IM Rf_@ Oh

18

CZX I8 G bv[ > 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� HI¼T >< CT G �S@ ¹¸ thumb CM 7[ 9;< ink L

d VRåK CZX :;< CvÌ�l t�;; tPDRg C

T G 7M R@ Oh CZXn o 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! w< 358̀ 9bl w< T?

z E�@ `K< CM :~TO< I8 G Ld VIM ð

T�z� ^¥M �SÈ;h ð

T�z� Rg t�;; ¿<th ^ Wj ?@A�

T > R8`�� Rf8 > 3|TOI@ YM <:hRTO Rg electoral roll Rf8 >no T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� a}< THR8`EMR[ O Rg I5 ] 3Ú5 GRT½ CZX �; 3@ O R8`¼� CZX

3i electoral roll N@ O< CZX ^lIr Rg ^�5 > :;< Ld VR5 OIÕ Rg ^�5 >n o 5P5] 8�<: IM

T?z E�@ `K< Â4_B IWX C

d G R5\ I8 G 3Ú5 GRT½ 3@ O R8`¼� CZX T?z E�@ `K< T?

z E@ A4� Rg 3|TOI@ YM T?@ A8O í@ 5̀9 C

8 G IWX ?@AWm íTO t~@ O

T~@ O7[ 9 Sî@ AÓ}< CM wR[ On oN@ O< í@ 5̀9 R8OIWX CZX Ld VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< Rg I5 ] LMRT\

íTO: R8OIWX CZX N@ O< ^lIr ^ã5 `��< Rg í@ 5̀9 R8OIWX CZX I5 ] ~@ `�D íTO: Rg R8OIWX CZXnoN@ O< í@ 5̀9 TH< CM wR[ O CÁF

T̀9 íTO: Rg R8OIWX CZX �5] ?@AB �; ?@A[`�t �D t~@ [̀9 :;< ^

T �[9< ¾ST ¹ z{@ A

t`D C8 YK <th ?@AWmno3@ O T?@A8O í@ 5̀9 T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� R8 @̀9h CZX íTO t~@ O

T~@ O7[ 9 Sî@ AÓ}< IMo

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! Ld VR5 OIÕ Rg T?

z E�@ `K< ^�5 > N@ O< �bÅ� ?@AB IWX RW m: CZX :;< ^lIr Rg ^�5 > ^�< �bÅ� CM :~TO< IWX RW m: CZXn oíTO t~@ O

T~@ O7[ 9 Sî@ AÓ}< Ld VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< Rg :;< ^lIr

^ã5 `��< Rg N@ O< �~T̀ d 9R4T> íTO t~@ O

T~@ O7[ 9 Sî@ AÓ}< 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� R8OIWX CZXn o 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 5x 56 5P]R½ C

T G I5 ] mandate R@ Oh R@ `J CZX <:hRTO IM �; electoral roll:;< counter file IM eB 7M w< IM N@ [̀] R@ `M C

d G R5\no 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! bv[ > T?z E�@ `K< T?

z E@ A4� a}< THR8`EMR[ O Rg 3Ú5 GRT½ ?@AB C

T G RÉt7[ 9 CZXn ow< ?@AB HI¼T >< CT G R�� CZX 3i 5P5]

T?z E�@ `K< =

8 � T] IWX Cd G R5\ 5P5] HI�@ 5̀9 IM [�}< seal C

8 G 7M ?@AWm I8 G bv[ > I5 ] [�}< CM wR[ O electoral roll CZX w< IM R@ O [�}< ^lIr CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB ¿<th ?@9h R@ O w< IM L

d VR5 OIÕ ?@AB ¿<th ?@9ho

19

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB wd;RW m ?@AB �tbv� IWX 7M 3@ O 8�R5 O 7M RW m: HIWX 3i w< electoral roll IM T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� THR8`EMR[ O Rg 3Ú5 GRT½ 3@ O R8`¼� CZX 3i w< IM R@ O ^lIr

^ã5 `��< CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB ¿<th ?@9h R@ O w< IM Ld VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB ¿<th ?@9hno

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! íTO t~@ OT~@ O7[ 9 Sî@ AÓ}< C

T G ^¥Melectoral roll IM Ld VR5 OIÕ CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB

¿<th R@ Oh ^¥M IM w< CT G NA CM í@ 5̀9 CM :~TO< ¿<th R@ Ohno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB w<

CFYK 3@ O 8�R5 O 7M RW m: HIWX 3i <S@ ¹¸ I5 ] :th:}< R@ `M R@ `J Rf8 > <:hRTO 3i thumb impression check C

T G 7M CM CFYK mandate 3@ O R@ Oh R@ `J Rf8 > 3i electoral roll :;< counter file IM eB 7M thumb impression

check CFYM ?@AdOR5\o

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! <S@ ¹¸ Â@OS@ ¹t`  <:R� I5 ] NA-118Rg Rf8 > HI¼T >< C

T G �; <:hRTO IM 5x @�v5> R@ Ohno<:hRTO C

T G I5 ] t�:I[ G: ¾h CZX w< CT G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� T?@A

8O category LM ?@AWmno?@AB TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ IM 3@ O RT`¼� R8` WXR[\ HIWX 3i ¾S@ ¹¸ 8�R5 O IM 5p}< IT A� 3i T?@A8O categories <:hRTO C

T G LM ?@AWmn oN@ O< HI¼T >< 3@ O R@ `M CZX 3i relevant election material NA-118, relevant material <:hRTO C

T G w< IM declare R@ `M 3iCZX �5] NA CMbag CM :~TO< CD w< IM electoral roll

eB CZX :;< counter file ^ãB CZX w< IM <:hRTO CT G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� ! 3�� R@ Oh CZX

3@ O relevant material CZX T?z E�@ `K< Rg NA-118Rgno¾SÈ;h category <:hRTO

CT G �; LM CZX 3i �5] ?@AB HI¼T >< C

T G 3@ O R�� 3i partially relevant material, partially relevant material 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� �; CZX 3i �5] CM

:~TO< counter-file ÂB d̂ �J CZX T?�@`K electoral roll ?@A�T > eB 3|TOI@ YM ?@AB C

T G CÁ�Æ> wd;RW m IM R@ OR8 5̀9 3i I5 ] mandate <:hRTO IM R@ Oh R@ `J Rf8 > �; 3@ O Rf

8 > 3i

20

electoral roll :;< counter file IM eB 7M thumb impression IM N@ [̀] R@ `M C

d G R5\ :;< partially relevant material I5 ] <:hRTO CT G R@ OR8 5̀9 CZX

w< ?@AB CD counter file I8 G ÂB d̂ �J CZX T?�@ `K electoral roll Ld VR5 OIÕ

^ã5 `��< CM HI�@ 5̀9 CM :~TO< ¿<th R@ Oh R@ `J IWX R�no 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! w< CM ~�5 G ¾Sî@A8O

category I5 ] <:hRTO CT G LM CZX w< ?@AB R�� CZX 3i not relevant

material I5 ] TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ :Iz� 7M CZX : ?@AWm 3i 90:<TSW m t�;; ^ã�5 ] CZXnoCÁ�Æ> HI¼T >< C

T G R�� Rf8 > 70:<TSW m ^ã�5 ] t�;; CZX bv[ > 3�� CZX : ?@AWm 90:<TSW m t�;; ^ã�5 ] ?@AWmno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! �; I5 ] not relevant material Rf8 > w< Rg ?@AB C

T G <:hRTO CM H;~T̀ 59 CD Rf[ 6I[ G :;< ?@AB R8`v5 �Å� Rf8 > 3i ~dOR z� w< CM :~TO< counter file ^�5 > ?@A�

T > CZX :;< electoral roll ^�5 > ?@A�T > CZX w< CFYK 3@ O t�:I[ G: <:hRTO

CT G ¾h CZX 3i 3@ O not relevant materialCZX T?�@ `K CvÌ�l ~�5 G ?@AB R8 [̀9 e[\ 3i 3@ O not relevant material <:hRTO C

T G w< IM R�� CZX 3i I5 ] NACM í@ 5̀9 ?@A�T > ?@AWm �; L

d VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM í@ 5̀9 CÁÆ\ Cd YJ ?@AWmno�5] Rg TH<bÅÖ THRT\ RT 8̀ 9< :Iz� 7M RW m: CZX 3i 5̂6 3@ O t�;; ^ã�5 ] ?@AWmno?@AB TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ CD R8`v[ 6I[ G HIWX :;< [�}< CM CT Y  R� 8�R5 O R8O7M HIWX 3i <:hRTO Rg I5 ] ¾th 5̂6 CZX ECP, St ¹|@O7d9<th ¿ST ¹5Ë a}< <:hRTO Rg ECP, Election Commission of Pakistan �5] LM LT V<7�TO ?@AB thumb impression check C

d G IWX ?@AWmno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! w< wd;RW m CM CT Y  R� w< IM R@ Oe5 O C

d G R5\ w< CD Rf[ 6I[ G Cd G R5\ 3i TH<bÅÖ THRT\ RT 8̀ 9< :Iz� 7M RW m:

CZX ^�5 �M HI8 YK<~� CM 7[ 9;< ^�5 �M 3@ `K~� CM 7[ 9;< ^�5 �M �:R4Wj 7[ 9;< ^�5 �M ¾:R4Wj Lt V:R[ O CM 7[ 9;< 3i 5�RT 5̀] LK~TORÉh L

d VIWX CZXno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 7J< �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ LM <:hRTO LM t�:I[ G: [�}< ét7[ 9 ?@A� I8 G <:hRTO C

T G R�� CZX 3i RT 8̀ 9< Rf[ 6< tuK T:: ^¥M CìÁ\ Rg ?@A�T > R@ O}< RT`

8A 5\ �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ Rg R@ O}< CZX 3|TOI@ YM <:hRTO IM I5 ] mandate R@ Oh Rf8 > �;

21

Rf8 > relevant material I5 ] w< CT G R@ OR8 5̀9 CZX w< ?@AB CD I5 ] relevant

material CM t�;; I5 ] <:hRTO CT G C

d G R8 5̀9 ?@AWm 3|TOI@ YM TH< IM mandate 3@ O R@ Oh R@ `J Rf

8 > 3i electoral roll :;< counter file IM eB 7M N@ [̀] R@ `M Cd G R5\no�5]

?@AB CD electoral roll ?@A�T > eÃTG T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� Rg 3Ú5 GRT½ R8`¼� CZX 3i w< CM

^lIr CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB ¿<th ;h R@ O Ld VR5 OIÕ CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB ¿<th ;hnoI5 ] TS@ ¹[Ë L

d VR5 OIÕ CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB ¿<th ¾h d̂ �J CZXn o�; �S@ ¹¸ NA CM í@ 5̀9 CD I8 G ?@A�

T > CÁÃTG LJ

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� w< IM HI¼T >< CT G relevant 7M R@ Ohpartially relevantno�5] ?@AB

CD HIT G;h ?@9TS@ ¹[Ë ^ãÃ

TG ?@AWm w< IM HI¼T >< CT G R�� 3i relevant material :;<

relevant material ?@AB 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 44 t�;; <:hRTO CT G I5 ] t�:I[ G: ¾h CZX

3i 44 t�;; CEFG < ?@AWm T?5 ] Rg solution?@A�T > oCZX44 t�;; RT 8̀ 9< I8 G 7t 9I@ Y[A4� ^�5 > R@ O

N@ O< éh}< tPT A�7[ 9 w< LM accuracy 8PD:h ?@A�T > }< 8̂ ���n o44 t�;; LM <:hRTO

CT G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� 8�R5 O LM CZXnoN@ O< L

t V:R[ O Rg �<75 9SÈ TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ 5x @�tA�< CM

7[ 9;< :;< �:I[ G R@ Ot~@ `  CM CT Y  R� 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� �tbv� IWX 7M C8 Y¼� ?@AWm 3i 90:<TSW m

t�;; ^ã�5 ] IWX ?@AWmn Cd YJno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� ¾S@ ¹¸ 3T OR5 OhI  zw:<T7J CZX [�}< CD 3|TOI@ YM :R5 O :R5 O �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ Rg ÇRTO R8 @̀A� CZXno 5p}< TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ w< wd;RW m CM :~TO< ?@A�

T > Cvt �FA5O C

d G IWX 3i I5 ] not relevant material CZX 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� <:hRTO CD w< LM t�:I[ G: <I�T̀   7M w< wd;RW m CM :~TO< =@�Eè

8G LM Cd G R5\no?@AB ¿<I� R8O7M HIWX 3i

<:hRTO CD I5 ] DG(ECP) TH< Rg St ¹|@O7d9<th ¿ST ¹5Ë �5] CT G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 3@ O

thumb impression �:R� N@ [̀] CFYM ?@AWm 7J< not relevantLM ¾S@ ¹¸ t�:I[ G: 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� 7J< wd;RW m CM :~TO< }< C

d G R5\ I8 G bv[ > TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ IM ^�5 > R8 [̀9 Â[\ C

d G R5\ R� :;< �; R@ Ot~@ `  CM :~TO< ^�5 > }< C

d G R5\ R�o

22

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! Not relevant I5 ] <:hRTO CM wR[ O detailed report hI5 ]I  CZX �; L

d VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM ;h I5 ] �S@ ¹¸ CÆ�@�T9 CìÁ\ Cv

8 > �; TH< CM í@ 5̀9 ?@AB Cd YJ ?@AWmno<:hRTO C

T G 3@ O R�� CZX 3i 3@ O [�}< CM 3ÍÁ�8Y  ?@A�T > ?@AWmno=Wj C

T G TH< IM N@ [̀] ?@A�

T > R@ `Mn o 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! �S@ ¹¸ ^�5 >< ñR5 @̀9bì8 G 90í@ 5̀9 I5 ] 150L

d VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM }< Cd YJ Cv

8 > �; I8 G �S@ ¹¸ C8 G Rf� ?@AB ?@A�

T > CK th T?�@`K �S@ ¹¸ í@ 5̀9 HR�56 CD Cd G }< ?@AWm HRW m; 7[ 9 �t7[ 9 HIWX CJn o 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� 7J< 3@ O detailed report

Director General NADRA ECPCD Election Commission of Pakistan �5] IM R�� R8OR5\ CZX I8 G w< CD 7J< <I�T̀   LK C

d G R5\ I8 G �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ Rg I

z E@ G< ^�5 > solve IWX Cd G R5\ R� :;< TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ IM 3@ O R8 [̀9 ^�5 > Â[\ C

d G R5\ R� 3i 5�RT 5̀] 3@ O I5 ] í@ 5̀9 ?@AWm 3@ O L

d VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM ?@AWm TH< ?@AB <S@ ¹¸ material I8 G hI5 ]I  ?@A�

T > ?@AWm NA Rgnobv[ > TH< LM Lt V:R[ O Rg 8P¼5> <t75 9 Â@`M; CZX w< C

T G R@ Ot~@ `  CM 7[ 9;< }< 7M R�� 3i R8 [̀9 ?@A�

T > ¾h: ÂÃTG L

d V}< CZX HRW m; CDo

3@ O [�}< CT G RT`D oCZX N@ O< 8P¼5> <t75 9 Â@`M; N@ O< Â

T̀ @A [\ CM 7[ 9;< 7M}< R8`¼� CZX 3i R8 [̀9 ?@A�

T > HI�@ 5̀9 CM :~TO< CD ¾h: ÂÃTG L

d V}< oCZX 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 3@ O ^ Wj; 8�R5 O 7M RW m: CZX 3i I5 ]not relevant material R@ OR8 5̀9 qR@ `J �; I5 ] ñR5 @̀9bì

8G I5 ] not relevant material I5 ] Â@OSt ¹@`  <S@ ¹¸ HR�@> 7[ 9 <:hRTO CM wR[ O [x

T�¼[> ?@A�T >

RÃD �; ñR5 `@9bì8G 58000 t�;; o?@AWm w< ?@AB CD ñR5 @̀9bì

8G 30000 t�;; �S@ ¹¸ ?@AWm :;< ñR5 @̀9bì

8G 15000 t�;; L[V Lt V L

d V}< CM ?@AWm :;< ñR5 `@9bì8G 7000 t�;; L[V L[V L[V

CM o?@AWm �; I5 ] í@ 5̀9 �: Cd YJ ?@AWm �; T?z E�@ `K< T?

z E@ A4� LM abc CD ?@A4Wj N@ O< polling station-wise result eB <IWX oCZX 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�!?@AB C

T G w< ?@AB CD N@ [̀] R@ `M CZX 3i ^�5 >< �I

T G í@ 5̀9 �S@ ¹¸ NA CM <:hRTO CM wR[ O ?@A�T >

23

oCÆ�T�¼[> ?@AB ^

T �[9< abc CD z�z�IM 7M RW m: HIWX 3i <:hRTO Cv�l not relevant LM

I5 ] TH< CM wR[ O ^ã@ `ë�8G t�:I[ G: hI5 ]I  qCZX w< LM 7J< L[VRg w< wd;RW m ?@AB

qCd G R5\}< 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� ?@AB [�}< CD 8PD<IT]:h R8O7M HIWX 3i 7J< �; wd;RW m CM :~TO< Cd G R5\}< I8 G ?@AB HIv5 �Å� R� 3i TH<bÅÖ THRT\ :;< w< LM L

t V:R[ O CM HIJIK IM ^�5 > R8 [̀9 Â[\ C

d G R5\ oR� w< CM I5 ] 8P¼5> �t75 9 Â@`M; CT YÌ9 Cd G IWX ?@AWm ~BR\ 5P]R½ C

T G T7ÁT̀ @A [\ CM 7[ 9;< 7M}< R�� Rf8 > 3i w< CM :~TO< R8 [̀9 ?@A�

T > not relevant CM :~TO< R8 [̀9 ?@A�

T > ¾h: ¾bv5 > Ld VIWX CZX R@ O R@ `M <bv5 > <IWX oCZX �; L

d VR5 OIÕ 5̂�Á4�< CM í@ 5̀9 q?@AWm CvÌ�l I5 ] R8 [̀9 e[\ CZX 3i �S@ ¹¸ CÆ�@�

T9 Ld VR5 OIÕ 5̂�Á4�< CM ;h CìÁ\ o?@AWm 5�RT 5̀]

7�@ [̀A� !�S@ ¹¸ aeT\ ÇRgRTO :<;~@ ` < L[V Lt V L

d V}< CT G I5 ] T?

z E@ At [̀9 ÂT\<h LM qCZX 3@ O :IWX�

CD R@ O}< Rf8 > �S@ ¹¸ aeT\ T?

z E�@ `K< CT G t7K CM qCFYK ?@AB ;h tPT Y  ?@AB 8�R5 O =

8 � T] 7M HIK oR� 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� !3@ O :IWX� CD �S@ ¹¸ ae T\ T?

z E�@ `K< CT G t7K CM CFYK R@ O}< Rf

8 > :;< TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ w< Rg :R5 O :R5 O w< CFYK 7MTh C

8 G 7M ?@AWm 3i TH< Rg �; 5̂�@9bâ T7@ 9TbÖ oCZX 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�!w< CM CÆ�@�

T9 I5 ] Ld VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM L[V L

t V Ld V}< CM

candidate Cv8 > �; local candidate oCv

8 > �; HIT G;h ^ Wj �S@ ¹¸ �:~W mR z�

CM z�dGRW m: Cv

8 > :;< 7J< Ld VIM T?

z E�@ `K< CM :~TO< ^¥@ G< LK~TORÉh Ld VIWX L

8 VIWX I8 G bv[ > �; Ld VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM T?5 ] CM �; ÂgIK :<;~@ ` < Cv

8 > TH< IM ^�5 > T?z E@ At [̀9 7d9<h L

T V7M CFYZX R[\ o^�8 > 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! CT Y

8AÌ\ ^�5 > t�;; �S@ ¹¸ CìÁ\ CM :~TO< ^lIr ^ã5 `��< CM :~TO< CK th q?@AWm CT Y8 9 < ^ Wj L

d VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM :~TO< CK th o?@AWm 7J< Ld VIM ^¥@ G< CÌG ^òÚ5 GRT½ L

8 VIWX I8 G L

d VR5 OIÕ ^ã5 `��< CM ÇRgRTO :<;~@ ` < Cv8 > L[V L

t V Ld V}< CM 3i TH< IM ^�5 > CFYZX R[\ Rf8 >

3i bv[ > T?z E@ At [̀9 7d9<h qC

8 G 7M 3|TOI@ YM �; ÂgIK ^lh}< oCv8 > 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�!?@AB [�}< Rg :I� z{ 

:;< THIT Y�l HIWX 3i [�}< CT G Cv�l =

d >Rt O oR@ Oh

24

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�: t~T̀ d 9<; [�< 7M o?@A�

~4�l TÏR@ O: NÑB: 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ^à@> LT VR�� �:I[ G T?

z E�@ `K< LM CZX 3i LK~TORÉh Rg 3¸<:th th<bs 7M CM :;< SW mR5 O [P�@�M C

d G RåK Cd G IWX ?@AWm :;< =Wj HIJIK IM 3@ O ÇRTO~5 O

RTO7M C8 YZX R[\ o?@AWm ?@AB TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ CD R8`¼� HIWX 3i ¾S@ ¹¸ ¾7d9<I�TO< ?@97M 3|TOI@ YM <S@ ¹¸ 3ÍÁ\ ef� <IWX oCZX ?@AB R8`¼� HIWX 3i L

d VIM wd;RW m LM t̂ �@A4� RT 5̀9 q?@9h wd;RW m LM t̂ �@A4� <:hRTO IM CT YÆ9 < wR[ O t̂ �@A4� Ç;: ?@AB e5 O qCK R8O 3i éh;h Rg éh;h :;< L

T VR[ O Rg LT VR[ O IWX C

d G R5\ :;< TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ IM ^�5 > R8 [̀9 Â[\ Cd G R5\ 3i =Wj

LK~TORÉh CK <; kIK ?@A�T > o?@AWm ?@A4Wj kIK Û@ GS

z È T:<IT G 5P]R½ CM ÇRTO 7[ 9 t�;;

C8 YF9 h q?@AWm ?@A4Wj kIK HR@ `  ~4�l T:R5 `¼z� Û@ GS

z È CM ÇRTO 7[ 9 t�;; C8 YF9 h o?@AWm ?@A4Wj :IWX� <CM :~TO N@ O< N@ O< ÄM� CEFAi t�;; tPDRg C

d G IWX ?@ABo?@AWm TH< IM RTOR8 5̀9 R8` WXR[\ HIWX 3i CÁfÆ�[> [x

T>R[ O HIKR� CM :~TO< 5�R5 ºT�[9 CM :~TO< HR@ `  ~4�l T:R5 `¼

z� Û@ GSz È C

T G ÇRg R@ `M CZX :;< I5 ] t~ó �

TATO:IJ ^�8 > w< LM 35 \; CD ?@A4Wj HIJIK C

T G w< 358̀ 9bl

�hR@ OT: t�;; CFG h o?@AWm 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� ! kIK LJh7M:Rg C8 Yv_@ Oh q?@AWm ¾:R4Wj L

t V:R[ O LM LJh7M:Rg ^�5 >< ^�5 > [�}< CM CT Y  R� qCZX wd;RW m CT Y  R�CM oCZX �hI[ ] �RB IWX C

d YJ ?@AWm :;< T?

z E[ G7M Rg ¾:R4Wj tPT Y�T >:IJ CM 7[ 9;< L

d VIM Ç<T7K< ?@A�T > oCZX ¾:R4Wj tPT Y�

T >:IJ CT Y89 < CvÆ6 < ÇRg 7M ^ Wj: qCZX NÑB :~TO<CM ^ã5 º5> ?@A�

T > oooCZX

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� : [�}< Rg tPT Yd9<I[ G R@ `J}< oCZX 35 \<IT]o3@ O7�

z� ~4�l ÛÕ}< o 5P]R½

35 \<IT] ~4�l ÛÕ}< : 3@ O7�

z� 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�no 5�RT 5̀] �<;! w< 8uâ; I5 ] ¿I]RB CZX :;< I5 ] environment CZX I8 G ?@AB w< ?@AB 3@ O ¾:;ST U R8`v5 �Å� HIWX 3i 3ºÅ� 35 O

25

3ºÅ� I5 ] ¿Rº8>:IÕ CZX :;< �5] pbc ¿Rº

8>:IÕ unfold IWX ^ Wj: CZX 3i ¾:R4Wj abc CD w< TH<I@ G< IM hR48�Q< ?@AB R@ `K I5 ]oC

d G R5\ Âg 8�<: R@ O Âg 3�� S�[> IM I5 ] 8�<7M< T~B C

d G IWX ?@AWm TH< LM ñ<SØ8YT�l N@ 5̀9 t~TOd;<7J L

d VR8 5̀9 oCd G R5\ :;< �5] =¥r LM

^_4ôh TS@ ¹¸}< ?@A8OR5 O CÁfÆ�[> d̂ �M HI

T Gh CD �<SW mR z� :I8 A�h 7[ 9 LM R5\ ^ Wj: TH<q?@AWm Rg Â4Öh: w< TH<I@ G< ?@AB w< :IÁÓ 7[ 9 THR@ 5̀9 R@ `M oC

d G R5\ 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 5PD CD CÁ�Æ> =ÙõQ<7@ 9 T:; 5P]R½ C

T G Âg I5 ] 8�R5 O ^à� 3i =Wj CT G ÛÁ\ R@ `K <IWX CZX 3i =Wj T?@A

dO}< Rg ÙÝ��

8> ?@97M CJ :;< w< LM ¾:<~�R[ O ?@97M CJ :;< THIT GRæ LM L

T V<bÅ_\ 8u@9:I¼Å56 CM ¾hR@ `

TA5O HIKIÕ< ?@AB ÂBR z� oCZX =Wj CT G Âg w< CÁB R�  IM =

8 �T] CT G 7M CM

CFYK HR�@> N8O bs}< LM 3i ¿I�z ¥5 G =

ÙõQ<7@ 9 T:; CM =Wj Û@ G< Ld V}< :}< CM 5p<:~TO< CM

7[ 9;< :R@8̀ 9 o?@AWm ñR5 `KRT � w< TS@ ¹[Ë IM ¾:R4Wj ¾:;TbÅ� Rf5 �Å� qR@ `J T?�@ `K 5p}< =Wj w< 8�R5 O Rg �:R5 O;h �hR�< C

8 G 7M ?@AWm 3i Ld VIM R{@ G< 35 `KRÚ  I5 ] T?@A

dO}< :;< THIT GRæ CD ÇhRç8 Y  IWX �;

=Wj ^Þ¢r :Ic 7[ 9 CT YT9 RB CM CFYK :R@

8̀ 9 ?@A�T > o?@AWm 3@ O TH<I@ G< :;< w< Rg w~Í8G is an article of faith for usq w< LM q 8̂ �Dh�R5 O HR�@> 7[ 9 TH<I@ G< ?@AB HI

T G;h abc CEFG < h<bs< Cv

t �FA5O Cd G IWX ?@AWm 3i HI¼T �5] C

T G w< THI@ G< LM 8̂ �Dh�R5 O CM CFYK 3T O aSU íT̀ 5] ¾t7K CZX 3|Ñ5 O THIT] LM ^�5 > HR@

T̀9R5 Obâ 8u@9:I¼Å56 LM TS@ ¹ÑW mh 7[ 9 z�@A[O LM o?@AWm ×R z{

TG< �< ¡LKR�8G =Wj 8u@9:I¼Å56 7[ 9 T?@AdO}< 7[ 9 ^Þ¢r :Ic 7[ 9 L

d VIM [xT>}< ?@A�

T > CT G }<

?@9h oCJ 3@ O �:R4Wj THR4@ >< Rg T75 ] CZX 3i w< NÑB LM ×RÍ5 G aSU T?@ATO}< LM

q¾:<hS5 ¹4ã� T?@AdO}< LM 8̂ �Dh�R5 O ?@AB R�T �[9 CZX :;< w< CM �;e� w< LM ×RÍ5 G IM ~@ O~ z�

3z�~ T\ oCZX

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB Ld VIM ^¥@ G< 8�R5 O ?@A�

T > RTO7M R8` WXR[\ 3i �5] CD ¿I]RB ?@AB Ld VIM L5V<7

T] <~@ [̀9 oIWX T?�@ `K ?@AB CT G Âg ^�5 > R@ O

t~@ `  CD 8�R5 O C8 G 7M C

d G IWX R�� Rf8 >

26

3i I5 ] ?@A8OR5 O HR�@> 7[ 9 LM R5\ ^ Wj: q?@AWm TH< HI8 GR5 O Rg CÁfÆ�[> Ät >R� HIKR� ?@AB wh

~ç@YÊ 7J< ^¥M THI8 A z{[ G R@ O ^ô~T̀ D R@ O [pIÁ5 O CT G ^à� I8 G =Wj C

T G w< IM :<~T� Â5 @̀A� 7M oR@ Oh 5p}< 3@ O ;h :

t~@ `K SW mR5 O �tbv� IWX 7M I5 ] I�8̀ �J 7M CZX : q?@AWm �; ¾:<~T� LM ¾7T]}<

H;~\ IM Iv[ 6 CZX : ?@AWm 3|Ñ5 O H;~\ IM cross7M C�Æ\ o?@AWm T?�@`K 5p}< =Wj zwI RT\ w< CFYK q?@AWm 8P I�\ w< CFYK Â4�

8> qRg ¾:R5 Oh75 9 qRg 8PzD<h75 9 qRg ¾:<h<;: Rg �SW mR ÙÚ  7M ^ Wj: CZX 3i =Wj ?@A�

T > C8 YZX R[\ 3i 3@ O HIz�� CM 7J<hI� CM Ä8 >RW m ?@AB initiative e[\ C

d G R5\o initiative ¿;< :;< 7T]}< w< TH<I@ G< CM Ä8 >RW m RT` WX: qCFYZX R[\

I5 ] �@A5O t:;7M Ç<IQ LM 8�R z{WX<IT] Rg S� Ùõ  HR�@>o?@AWm 7[ 9 �@A5O t:;7M Ç<IQ LM

8�R z{WX<IT] CT YÆ9 < H;~T̀ d 9R4

T> CM CÞFG :Th translate L8 VIWX q?@AWm THR8`EMR[ O LM Ç<IQ C

T G 5P5] RT`KI5 G R8OIWX CZX I8 G �; w< TH<I@ G< CM CÞFG :Th C8 YK I5 G o?@AWm �:~T̀ [9 R@ O �@A5O R@ O �@A

8O R@ O �@A

8̀ TA@ [̀9 R@ O �@A�R[\ :<TSW m kIK � 7M w< TH<I@ G< IM dictate?@A�T > R@ `M R5\ oR8`��

5�RT 5̀] �<;! =Wj CT G CT YÆ9 < T̂yRB CD À¢r »Á�

8G R@ `M CZXo

��� ��� ������� � !"# �$%! &'() *+,() -.% /0�� ��� 1

2 3(� 4 15 struggle+; < 15 �=> &?@A-+BC;D �5 �EF, G;< H@IJ 1

#3-(� K

�L�� M@I�K 15 �NOP- #Q@ M, (R �*+�< SJ( O) T-(U��V�=>

�NOP- #Q@ M, 15 /

� WX.Y;Z SJ( O) �=> [(U&� *(\@� L� A +; < *(@ M

# A-(� K H@I�4 *+B� �% ��� *(@ M

�A(; K]^ T ���VH@I�4 �*% *+@ F

�A(; K]^ +5 _2 �(�̀ H@I\

� � ��� +�> H@A �%V�a �*%+@ �% �

�� +; < bc� 4( def

�=> (@ M5 /& WB;�g@ K (h

&�%(R �H@I2K$%V(R �5 dijk

&� �5 �EF, l@ K% ]m �5 dijk&� �5 �EF, H@I\

� � �H@I

2K$% �5 dijk&� �5 �%V�EF, �*%+@ �% �5 �Qn

&� �5 �EF, -.% �*+��(o 15 /

& WP p(; K �5 �EF, T-(U�� 67 st() �u @�-(&K H@IJ �% 15 v(OMf H@I\

� � s@ KV/& W�J �% &'(; K (R &'+; F

OA �=> sw �*(&Mx5(� K H@IJ &?@A-+BC;D +; < �=> b.

�_,(; K /g�Z+�> &?@A-+BC;DV�=> �5 y +� � �

�� /

� W�A% H@A#L; < z+; F

�{f 1,L5 H@I�4 -.% |( O}��% ~% �1,(�

&� s@ K ��#M�; D �t �=> - H@I�4 &?@A-+BC;D +5 +& �

27

&?@A-+BC;D �% H@IJ |( O}��% ~% �-%]mc� L5+�> ���

�� &?@A-+BC;DV1a �% H@IJ Q�M�; Kc� L5+�> �����

1a -.% ��� s@ K s\� H@I�) �a ��� $% 1,%. *+�}

�� +5 sw ��� ��� &?@A-+BC;D 15 l@ K%

-.% ��M;< /& W@I ;Z V�=>

��� �

�� �H@I

2K$% �5 dijk&� 15 +; < ��� 1

2 3(�� /�& � ��� �

�� �% ��� 15 T-%Q)(� K

15 V�=> 12 3+5 (}@ �% s; M,(ef �

d��%L@ A �-. �5 -(@ M&I �Z% H@IJ H@I\

� � �=> sw b. #?@AL5+� F�@ M# A

&Nf+�Z �H@I2K$%VH@I

2K(�M;A �% +5 �% &'(; K 15 &'�-(;Z% H@I\� � V(&M@A �

d��%L@ A �-. �5 -(@ M&I �Z%

H@IJ s@ K H@I\� � �=> sw b. S

�MOx@ I�K #N� F�

� �-+a �H@I2K$%VH@I

2K(�M;A �% +5 s@ K -(@ M&I �Z% H@I\

� � (&M@A -.% �% �*%+@ �% �5 1

2 3+5 �xE� % &'p(Z H@I\� � �=> s� K �*(&Mx5(� K �5 v+X . ��]� H@IJ

12 3+5 �xE� % p(Z &' H@I�4 sw �

d��%L@ A �-. +; < �=> �% /0; M��% +5 S@M�h&� �

d��%L@ A �-.VH@AL5 �5 �(� K 1

2 3+5 (}@ �% -(@ M&I �Z% H@I\

� � �=> sw b. �H@I2K$% -.% �*+

��(o �P �-.(; h

&� �%VyL5 �*%+@ �% H@IJ +; < �+, ;N

� k&W�IJ �

2 � +�> H@I�4 b. /��� -+X L� A �H@I2K$% -.% �*+

��(o �P �-.(; h

&� H@I\

� � �*%V�& F�)L5 *+a+, 15 �*%! �*(; K�- *+a+, �5 �*(&Mx5(� K!��F, (ef 15 &N@F��() -.%

�*(&Mx5(� K �H; < *+,+�% L� A �2 �(o -.% �

2 �% �=> �% �%V &?^. 15 (@ M�I;K +5 �*(��

�� �=> -(� h

�WB�� H@I�4 (@ M�I;K +5 &N

� k� �*(���� (� h

�WB�� �=> - VH@I�4 H@IJ l@ K% s�� ]�� � *+B� sw(� s@ K . &'%c� �< +; < *+B� �% �

�� +�&Mja 15 �=> ������� *+& Fj�>. �5 -Q�K% �% �P �

Q�@F� +�&Mja �5 L� A.% ��� *+a+, ���V��� /�(@ MP *+a+, �

�� ������� 67v() H@IJ +; < �=>

�# � +�� D ��� +� �5 �

� F=> - *+,%. +5 -%Q�� (R ;N�, (@M5(e� ���V�=> ��� �*(�Z� s� Z(; K 15

p.% +5 -%Q�� ���!(\� ��� /;D �@�% Q@ MP +5 -%Q�� ���!(\� �

�� |(e� ~% S �F@IJ +5 -%Q��

l@ K%V(\� s; K+� G;< H@IJ 35v() �P ��M;< T-(;Z �=>!b. ��M;< [Y)% (; K$% H@IJ �=> �� F�A % *+�t(J �5 �EF, ��M;< T-(;Z 15 !/�& �80 15 1

2 3(� 4 H@IJ /�; � -.% /0�� ��� 12 3(� 4 H@IJ

/�; � �% &?^. b. ��M;< La% S�MOx@ I�K y #Q�M;k@�% �5 L� A.% 15 / ��-(;Z �=> +

& � �% ��M;<

28

+5 /�; � O-(&K+; I) ]�� �V�=> (� 4-(;Z(@ M5 foreign y#Q�M;k@�% �5 L� A.% O-(&K+; I) �%V�=> (� 4-(;Z(@ M5 &?^. S

�MOx@ I�K % #Q�M;k@�% implementH@IJV�=> (� 4-+�> /;W�� +� < #-T ONk;� H@IJ �

2 � (;Z c@ ©��; � �'$%

15 &NX(). �P �% �*%+@ �% +5 (U&W�% H@IJ ��� (�M@It �& F=> (�Z H@I�4 -.%

s@ Kreiterate�& F=> (�Z(�KL5 H@I�4 sw s@ K c� 4(; K ��# WEI;K �

2 � +�> ��� Lª *+,%. �5 1

2 3+5 c@ ©�«

/� W@I

2K$% -.% 1�3+��(oc@ ©

�« &'(; M,(ef +; < H@I�4 b. -+ d��Ff H@I\

� � �EF5 H@I2K(;Z ���V�a s@ K ��M;<

�H@I2K$% �5 ¬(­ 15 ��M;< +; < �=> b. TL

�<$% [ l&K H@A#L, �a -.% /�% ��� 15 1�3(; K]^ �

� FEA �P �L@ ALa H@I\� � H@AL5 V�a

s@ K �% �*%+@ �% (R snj

&Ff s®�@F� �=> -.% �% s®�@F� ¬(­ (R �2 � (;Z(@ M5 &Nf+�ZV(�

15 ¯]X �P -.% [(U&� *+@ F

# A-(� K 15 ¯]X �H�@ M,V�P +; < ;°$% �P . b(J S;M� v# (J �*2.(# K -+�>p H@IJ +; < s��%. &Nf+�ZV%+�> -(; K -(; K �% L� A �+x�% (R -(\

d±% /g�ZL5 �%V�=> ��� %. 15 s� K 1

2 3+5 S@K+X s@ M;<+& �

OG@I�K 15 /

& W�)(;Z �=> -.% �H@It+& F�f �5 |(OK-. (R s@ K ²< �=> sw ³@ �% 1

2 3$% -$% (R ;°%-Q�K% ���V+�> ��� ³@ �% 1

2 3$% -$% ;°%-Q�K% �5 SU� (R �-(� �$% (@ K L5 �=> -.% s@ K �c@ ©�´ensure�

& � L5 H@IJVH@I�4 *(\@� L� A s@ K &'(; K mention(�KL5 *+�>(&M �>(�Z sw s@ K �+, �& FB� H@I�4 sw ��� s@ M,Q� +5influence�& F�)L5 S

�MOx@ � #Q@ K%VH@I�4 �H

O x@ I) ;u ;D �

�� /�; � y-(U�� ¯Y �Z s®�@F� 1

2 3(� 4V(@ K #'-+5 ��� /�; � y-(U�� ¯Y �Z s®�@F�

y-(U��V(@ M5 �(� K -.% . avenue+; < Intra Code Appeal and Supreme Court(Ravailable ���V�=> b. surrender�

& � L5 H@I�4 -.% l@ K% 1,+�% ���EF� L� A +; < 1

�3+��(o ²< �=> +; < �*% (R �L

2A(;Z ²< �%V�=> H@ IJ c@ ©�́(& K -.c� º

12 3+�> �H�@ M,V�=> b. ²< �*% +5 (@ K s@ KV�=> (� 4-(;Z 1

�3+��(o &'(; K /�& � ��� �% +5

concede�=> -L5 �H�@ M,VH@I�4 c@ ©�« 1

�3+��(oc@ ©

�«!/

� W@I2K$% &'(; K �5 L� A.% ��� l@ K% �u

��% /�; � ����@W�A H@I\

� � H@I#M �> �a |( O}

��% ~% ;'(�M;<V�1,(�&� L�@ M�I)!H@IJ �% �*%+@ �% (R /�; �

29

s@ KV*+�>-%�LaL�O) &?^. |( O}

��% ~% �1,(�&� c@ ©

�́ &?@Ac@ ©

�́ �P �

2 � (;Z-�La G;<V(� °]X H@IJ

��� (\� sw &?@A-+BC;D �-%]mc� L5+�> ���

�� 1a �% �*(h&Wf% s@ KVH@IJ �*%+@ �% .L

�<c� L5+�> �����

(� -.% &?@A-+BC;D (R b +� � +; < �=> b. |( O}��% ~% �1,(�

&� -.(�M& A &N

�<- �� F�A G;<V(� �5

�2 � () H@IJ T-(U�� �

�� $% 1,%. H@I®}

�� +; < H@I�4 &?@A-+BC;D �5 &'%]CO � �P ³�, �-.Q�K%

H@I�)+�> �*%VH@I¼ &'%]CO � +5 S`(Z ��) L5 ~%V1a �1,(�

&� �*(&Mx5(� K (R /½(Z . cº(�K &NB;�V+�> &NB;� Vs@ KL�

O)

;'(�M;< L�@ M�I): /;D ]C^Q@ K+�� V ;N<(`

Q@MP Q@ K+

�� ]C^: s@ KL�

O) ;'(�M;< L�@ M�I)!honourable Minister for Defence and Water and Power �

�� +; < �% &?^. �*%+@ �% +5

address�& � L5 �

2 � +�> �% &'(; K +5 �� Ff () �

2 � p H@I�4 sw ³@ �% 12 3$% -$% +; < v# (J

�*2.(# K �5incidentL� A G;< °]X �P +; <victimsH@I�4 (@ K �*% 15 bQ�M2A(U

�� &N�(U; D �=> b. ;°- /

& W �>(�Z(�K%L5 /�%V�=> °]X �P �% +5 ;°- ��� %L5 �5 �EF, -(@ M

& A �=> -.% �% +5 further appealH@I\

� � H@AL5 v(@ M�<%c@ ©ÃV�a �=> sw s@ K l@ K%

O�+�< Q�M

2A$% s®�@ F� �=> -.% ��� �% +5 welcome�

& � L5 �%VH@I�4 �5 "& �() "& �() Tc@ ©Ã S@M�A% 1a+�> �% &N�(U; D +5 sw +; < �*% (R fundamental issue�xE� .V(�

& � +& � �*% �5

&NB;� y-() �-+O x@ �% �H�@ M,VH@I�4 +; < ;NP �P Y\�� +O x@ �% �=> b. �% ³@ �% 12 3$% -$% (R / ��

La%V�=> b. /�; � �% +5 as a goodwill gesture�5 L5 -.% �� F�A %

deadlinesL� A deadlines�E� �=> -(;Z H@I�4 +& � �% �P % #-+�

& � () l@ K%step����@W�A �5 L5 /�% �c@ ©�´ 15 l@ K% c& ©\;� investigation�5 %.L5 -.% �% +5 �

� F�A % /�&F�IJ [(; h

��% l&K �

�� (� h

�WB�� �5 �EF, #N� F�� �-+a �5 "& �() �*.(�

& � H@AL5 �a +& � �% H@IJ �*% �5

30

+; <victimsH@I�4 �*% +5 /�; � justice��J (� -.% %c@ ©Ã v(@ M�< �=> sw l®J [+�. 15

+; < [%+� �=> b. /�; � % #-+�& � b (@ K

�- "�) (R G��() �, s@ KL�

O)V1a ;'(�M;< VL�@ M�I)

;'(�M;< L�@ M�I): /;D �@W<L,%Q; M� S@M�<.Q�Mf V ;N<(`

5�RT 5̀] =@�]7K<~5 `Q Â@`

T];~T̀   : o£=@��]¤7�K<n T?¡ �6¤7�K<n ��<n £=¥�5 G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� ?@AB [�}< Rg :I� z{  HIWX 3i [�}< C

T G CvÌ�l w< =Wj< we5\< ?@AB CT YK I5 G Rg ÀrI  R@ Oh :;< ?@AB 5p}< LM ¿Rº8>:IÕ 7[ 9 zP�5> ?@AB 3ç] HIK :;< ^

T �[9< Lt V:R[ O Rg ÛrI  :;< »

dGRÍ] z�@A[O H;7Mno 5�RT 5̀] �<; CÁ�Æ> N@ O< 8�R5 O 3i w< =Wj< struggle ?@AB 8P¼5> H;TS@ ¹[Ë Rg 7MTh ¾:;ST U ?@A�

T > CZX T?�@ `K Tð�5 G 8�Ræ;< RTOIWX CFYZX R[\now< CK <I] CD tPT Y�@�K:R[ O ?@AB I5 ] �:R4Wj 8PD;h Cv

t �FA5O Cd G IWX ?@AWmn qR��R� ¿R� =Wj C

T G ^�5 > TH< Rg Ä8 >R� R@ Oh CZXno 8u@9:I¼Å56nq T?@A

dO}< TH< H;TS@ ¹[Ë CM �:R5 O ?@ABnq¾:R4Wj ¾St ¹{WX ?@AB I5 ] =Wj< 3T OI�T > CZX �;

THRT\ ~@ `¼z� ~4öK<~5 `Q THRT\ L

d VT7�[\< ?@AWmo 1956× ^�5 >CD CÁ�Æ> 5P5] �:R4Wj NÑB LM ^�R@ `D : t~@ `K [P

zD CT G T?@A

dO}< LM Â@`�z{8G CM Cd YK THI

T GRæ Rg 38`D<: :R@ `8A T\< R@ `M w<

8uâ;nq THR@ ` :h ?@AB 1956× :;< 1962× w< Rg 7MTh ?@A�T > R8OIWXno38 5̀A�< 7J< [�}< ?@Af_@ Oh

I8 G TH; tuT 9I@ Gn qI

T G ¿R� CÁ�Æ>n q^T ��@ G T?@A

dO}< T:R� ^ã5 `��< I5 ] CZX w< T?@AdO}< T:R� ^ã5 `��< IM

T7@ 97�TO< CT G C

8 G R5\ Cd G IWX

T �[9<^ :;R[ O b�ETG<7t 9 LMnow< IM 8�<:R@ `

8A T\< CK <I] oCFYM 5�< =Wj CT G N@ O< T?@A

dO}< IM RTORT 5̀9 CZX :;< CT YÆ9 < NÑB Rg ^z�R� nq^�R@ `D 5pe� CZX RTO7Mno^

T ��@ G <:R4Wj I5 ] function Rf8 > �; 3@ O Rf

8 >o?@A4Wj transfer of power R@ `M R@ `Jnq^ÖI�5�l :Ic 7[ 9 :;< ^

T �@AdO}< :Ic 7[ 9no T?�@ `K IT G ¿R� :T7J Cd YJ :;< N@ O< �I :RÓ :;< bv[ > <SÈ;h �I :RÓ ;<

bv[ >: <Sî@ A8O :;< Rf8 >I[ ] �I :RÓno;< ÀrI : ?@A�

T > eBno7T]}< ?@AB TH; tu

T 9I@ G RT 5̀9no TH; tuT 9I@ G

CT G ÇR4

8> ¾:R4Þ8A�< HI8 GIr Rg Ä8 >R� R@ Oh :;< ?@A�

T >< 8uâR÷ o¾h w< CM ~�5 G bv[ > �;

31

¾St ¹{WX CZX I5 ] [�}< 5PD C8 YT9 R5\ ?@AWmno 5�I@ G< THRT\ Rg Â

z�:RB ×�1958× Rg w< CM ~�5 G 62× bv[ > w< CM ~�5 G 73× bv[ > 85× bv[ > C

8 G }< C8 G }< TH~T̀ K �

TGb�TGRg ?@ABnq:;<

TH~T̀ K �TGb�TGRg Rg HR�@> 7[ 9 ÛÁ8̀

T�l HI@ Yt 9:R[ O CT G 7MTh ^�5 > R@ `M 3i =Wj C

T G »5A� Ä�@ `D R@ `Kn oÇR4

8> HI@ Yt 9:R[ O CT G RT [̀9< Tp: x @��

y :;<R@ `M w< LM z�z�IM LMnoCÁ�Æ> N@ O< �SÈ;h

CM Ä8 >R� RT`vt �@A5O ~T̀ E[ G ?@A�

T > C8 G 7M Cv

8 > T?�@ `K bv[ > R{@ G< 8uâ; R@ O}< 3i T?@AdO}< CM �t75 9

�t75 9 T?@9SW mRB w< C�@�8ATO 7[ 9 C�

T�¼[> 3i =Wj ÇR48> HI@ Yt 9:R[ O C

T G e5 O ^¥M TS@ ¹48> CM ÂB

Ät �@A5O 7M w< NÑB CM Cd YK T?@AdO}< RTORT 5̀9 CZXnq THI

T GRæ RTORT 5̀9 CZX :;< bv[ > �:R4Wj ^z�R� 

:;< 5̂6R4� ^â789 CM Ç<7J;7[ 9 ?@AT̀ 59 CJn ow< ?@AB ^Þr<; HI@ Yt 9:R[ O C

T G <:I[ G 3ç] R@ `K T?�@ `K bv[ > ^�5 > Ä[ �� kIK w< IM z:R8OI5 A� C

T G 7M LM z�z�IM CZX :7M Cv

8 >no T?@AdO}< C

T G RT 5̀9 :;< w< LM Â@`�

z{8G Rg 38`D<: Rg;: R@`Jnq¾:R4Wj 8PDR@ `D ?@AB I5 ] =Wj< SØ

TYQ CZX �; 3@ O 3iCZX [�}< ÂÃKR5 O ¾:I¼Å56 T?@A

dO}< ?@AdORT 5̀9no [�}< ^â789 �<; T?@A

dO}< ?@AdORT 5̀9nq [�}< T? < Rg T?@A

dO}< ?@AdORT 5̀9

T?�@ `K �; SURT`Q HI¼T �5] CT G w< NÑB IM RTORf� CZXnq T?5 ] LM [̂�E[ ��h ^�< ?@AB CZX �;

^�5 >< N8O CT YÆ9 < ÇRg CD CM : o?@A�T >

5�RT 5̀] �<; THR@ ` :h ?@AB N@ O< <t75 9 =Wj< 3Ñ\bl R@ O}< :Rft >< Î?@9I =@� 789 Rgno 5�RT 5̀] �<;

�; ^�5 > ¾:R4Wj ¾:I¼Å56 HI8 GIr CT G ¾t75 9 8PT Y�l CM 7M HI@ Yt 9:R[ O LM ae8̀

T]< CM hI5 ];R5 O w< IM wR[ O R@ `Mn o:Rft >< Î?@9I =@� 789 LM 8�e@`ë�

8G ?@AB ?@A�T > ?@A

dOR5\ CJn o:Rft >< Î?@9I =@� 789 C

T G NÑB IM ^â789 LKRºz�IT]:;< LM �<: 7[ 9 ¿<th R@ Ohno 5�< 3@ O I5 ] T?

z E�@ `K< LK<; 8�R5 O ^ Wj:IWX 3iCZX HeÓ tP@A� 7[ 9 3@ O <IWX :;< HeÓ 7[ 9 �; <IWXnqIz E@ G< 3@ O ?@A�

T > CZX 3|Ñ5 O Iz E@ G< 3@ O CZX 3i 3@ O T?@A

dO}< T:R� ^ã5 `��< CZX R@ O ?@A�T >no T?@A

dO}< RT 5̀9 CZX R@ O ?@A�T >no3@ O NÑB :;<

w< CM �:<h< T?@AdO}< CM 8P�

8> ?@AÑ[\ CJ R@ O o?@A�T > 3@ O < t~T̀ 5�@>< CZX w< 8uâ;no3@ O

HIt Y@A� Rg 3Ñd̀ E  ?@A�T > CZXnoI8 G 5P5] ?@9;:Rft >< =@� 789 wR[ O L

d VIWX I8 G N@ O< ^�R@ `D =ã�5 YKR÷

32

LM 8P@YzA@`] CD =Wj w< C�@�

8ATO 7[ 9 CÆ�T�¼[> 3i =� T:< =� =Wj C

T G N@ O< R{@ G< ¾hR@ `TA5O Ç~æ

R@ ORft >< I5 ] CJ }< ¾:R4Wj HIÁ{

TG CM RÓh ø :;< ^â789 CM Cd YK 38`D<: :<I� Wj �7M R�no?@AB TÏbÖ H;7M R� [�}< ?@A

dO}< :;< ?@AdOR8 5̀9 3i w< T?@A

dO}< ?@AB ^¥TGIM n TS@ ¹[ËS@ ¹

TÐ LT VIT GRæ

CZX ^¥TGIM »

z� S@ ¹TÐ ¾:I¼Å56 CZXn oñez̀   3@ O kIK C8 Y¼� ?@AWm 3i ¾:R4Wj T?@A

dO}< LM enrolment I5 ] CZX T?

z E�@ `K< LM w< IM x @��y R@ `M C

d G R5\ w< IM improve R@ `M Cd G R5\no tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CM �T:<;:h 7[ 9 �tbv� ?@AWm :;< 3�� CZX : ?@AWm 3i T?@A

dO}< ?@A�T > CZXno

^ã5 `��< ?@A�T > CZXnqw< CM �:<h< ?@A�

T > ?@AWm w< IM �:R4Wj CK <I] ;h7MoR@T̀9h ?@AB

^¥M 3ï5\ [�}< CT G R{@ G< ?@A�

T > Rf_@ Oh R�IWXn o:;< 7J< Rf_@ Oh CZX I8 G aSU w< 3ï 5\ 7[ 9 HR�56 8P@YT9I

T GRæ� IWXno^T ��@ G L

d VIM TS@ ¹[Ë Â5ORæ ¿I5 Yr ?@A�T > CZXno tPT Y�@�K:R[ O Â5ORæ ¿I5 Yr ?@A�

T > CZXnq:Iz E

TG<h Â5ORæ ¿I5 Yr ?@A�T >noI5 ] Â5ORæ ¿I5 Yr CZX �; 3@ O CZX 3i 3@ O ¾:R� ?@9TS@ ¹[Ë t:Iv[ 6

?@9hno T7Á[ @̀A[O Lt V:R[ O LM 8P I�\ �t75 9 CvÆ6 < CìFG bc CD =

8 �T] Ld VIWXn qb�E

TG<7t 9 a}< :;R[ O <IWX :;< tPT Y�@�K:R[ O C

T G 3Ñç@YÊ �h R@ Oh 3i 7@ 9 T:; =ÙõQ< T:<I

T G Û@ GSz È 5P]R½ ?@A

T̀ 59n o 8P¼5> ^�[ 6< 8�R5 O CZXn o 5�< HR�@> CD C

T G R5\ Cd YK CM N@ O< 3Í@ Gbc :Rg CZX N@ O< Ç<7J;7[ 9 CZXq T?�@ `K �; SW mR5 O Ät �@A5O 7M 3�� CZX : ?@AWm 3i 3Í@ Gbc :Rg L

d VIM TS@ ¹[Ë ?@A�T > CZXo

5�< ?@AB �@ Oh RW m: HIWX :;< <:Th L

T VR z{@ G7[ 9 LM ^�5 > 8�R5 O T?5 9 d̂ �J CZXnoN@ O< TS@ ¹[Ë b Ù¢TG ^ Wj:}< CZX 3i ÛÁ8̀

T�l ?@A8OIrnq?@AB ^�5 > N@ O< =ã�5 YKR÷ LM 8P@Y

zA@`] CD Ä�@ Oh RW m: HIWX 3i ÛÁ8̀

T�l ?@A8OIr ?@A�

T �5] Ç<IQ CT G t�;; R@ Oh �; ^�5 > w< =¥r CM �T:<~TO< RåK CZX :

?@AWmno35 \<IT] 5P]R½ C

T G Rf[ 6< R@ `M 3i 5p}< HI¼T >< CT G x

Ty<; R@ `M 3T O:; 5p}< x 5�Õ I8 G ¿I]RB CEFG < Rf8 > CEFAÌ\ 5PD THR z{@ G7[ 9 ?@AWm :;< 8�R5 O ^ Wj ?@A�

T > C8 G 7Mn o 5P

T �8�TAB �~T̀ d9R4

T> 8�R5 O ?@A�T > C8 Y��7M I8 G bv[ > tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CEFAi CÁÆ\ R�nobv[ > CEFAi �; R@

T̀9h CM CÁÌO RÍ  ?@AB ?@A|�}< CJn o?@AB bv[ > HI¼� R� 3i T?@A

dO}<n q THIT GRæn q¿IÕ<n qaRç

T G< IM 3@ O T?@AdO}< Â4_B :Ic 7[ 9

33

cover ^ Wj:7M CZX :;< ^�< T?@AdO}< CM Cv�@�[9 [�}< C�� C

d G IWX ?@AWmno [�}< � T:<~TO< ?@AdORåK

7@9 T:; =ÙõQ< IM 3�� CZX : ?@AWm 3i [�}< L

T VR5 OS�l CM 7M �@A8O THh LM t̂ �v[ 6 CK ?@A�no

5�< 3@ O N8̀ WX ?@A�T > CZXno tPT Y�@�K:R[ O LM N8̀ WX ?@A�

T > CZX � 5P�8�TAB 7@ 9 T:; =

ÙõQ< IM �@A8O

THh LM t̂ �v[ 6 �h CZX : ?@AWm 3i [�}< ?@AdOR5\noHI¼T >< C

T G R@T̀9h IM N@ O< TS@ ¹[Ë L

T VRf�h CZX 3i THR8`EMR[ O Rg L

d VIM T?@AdO}< ?@A�

T > CZXno3T O TH< Rg Ld VIM 3Í@ Gbc CZXno^

T �@AdO}< R@ O LT VIT GRæ

Ld VIM 38`D<: TH< CM wR[ O ?@A�

T > CZXno 5�< THh 8�<: SW mR5 O Cvt �FA5O C

d G IWX ?@AWm :;< ¾:R4Wj I5 ] Â

z�I� 8�R@ O<;: ?@AWm w< CM aeT\75 9 HI8 G:IQ :;< HI[ �5> IM n¿RÉthRT 5̀9 Cvt �FA5O7M ?@AWmno

7@ 9 T:; =ÙõQ< C

T G :R5 O :R5 O RT [̀9< 3Ñç@YÊ Â@O~58̀ 9 R@ `Mo¾:R4Wj tPT Y�@�K:R[ O C

T G :R5 O :R5 O 3Ñç@YÊ Â@O~5

8̀ 9 R@ `Mo request LM tPT Y�@�K:R[ O IM 3i [�}< LT VR5 OS�l CM 7M Ä[ �� THh R@ O Ä[ �� =

d >Rt O <:Th ?@9 t:Iv[ 6 CJ }<o

bv[ > 5�< N@ `v

t > IWX ?@AdOR5\ CJnq 5�< N@ `v

t > IWX ?@AdOR5\ CJnoI8 G 5�RT 5̀] �<;! ½<

8�R5 O 3@ O CZX 3i =Wj CT G RT [̀9< I5 ] Ä[ �� ½R\ R@ `M CZX CT YÆ9 < Ç<IQ CM Cd YKn qI5 ] Ä[ ��

^T �@AdO}<n qL

T VIT GRæn q5̂6R4�nq�; 5PD Ä[ �� b�Õ 3[ O <tbv� RTO7M C8 YZX R[\ ?@AWmno T?�@ `K <~ T\ 3T O �7M 3i

R{@ G< IWX :;< CvÌ�l ~@ ` < CZXnq?@AB N@ O< 3�Êh bv[ > 8PD<IT]:h H;7M R� Ç<IQ CD 3i HR�@> 3@ O 8�R5 O ?@97M ?@A�

T >nq3@ O 8�R5 O ?@97M ?@A�T > 3i 3@ O =Wj C

T G 8�R5 O CZX 3i N@ O< SW mR5 O IWX R@ O <SÈ;h SW mR5 O IWXo Minus one formula THIM R� one minus 5P5] [�}< CT G minus R@ `M CZX RÃD< 5PÁÚ  CZX THR8`EMR[ O minusnq3@ O ½< ?@AB Â4Ö 7M CZX : ?@AWmo

I8 G ¾S@ ¹¸ 8PD<IT]:h CZXn q?@AB ^

T �[9< Lt V:R[ O Rg S5 ¹4l HIWXn q?@AB ~T̀ 59R[ O HIWX ^

T �[9< Lt V:R[ O LM politics Rg 3i S@ ¹

T�5 G w< 8�R5 O CM 3i I5 ] w< tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CT G ½R\ RTO7M

34

CZXnq3@ O tPT Y�@�K:R[ O I5 ] Ä[ �� HI¼T >< CT G R�� CZXnq?@AB 3@ O TÏbÖ H;7M R� 3i N@ O< N@ O<

C8 Y�TO 3[ O =Wj CT G RTOS��

t > CZX :;< RT`v_@ Oh CZX 3i ^Þr<; �:R4Wj I5 ] Ä[ �� 8�e½R\ ?@AWm TH< IM ÙêI��l Rf�: R@ `J CZX R@ O ?@A�

T >no T?�@ `K =Wj �t75 9 zwIT] ?@AWmC8 G IWX 3i HI¼T >< C

T G ÇR48>

CÁçFYÊ CEFG < Cd YM 3i Ç<IQ CM »] ?@AB T?@AdO}< »]CM ?@AB :;< HI5 GIÕ CMn qHI8 Y@ABIr

CM »] ?@ABn q^T ��@ G SW m IÁ�[> CD =Wj C

T G N@ O< T?@AdO}< R@ ORT 5̀9 CZXn qR@ Oh CZXn q¾:R4Wj

tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CT G R@ Oh CZX :;< tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CM CJ }< implementation ^�5 > tPT Y�@�K:R[ O

Rg CZX ^¥M :;< Rg ?@A�T > CZXnoL

T VR5 OS�l 7M ?@9 3i ^¥M CM Ä8 >R� ^¥M =¥r Rg <hI� ?@A�T >nq^¥M =¥r Rgnq3@ O SW m ^¥M C

T G interests ?@AWm :;< ÛÁ8̀T�l interests o?@AWm

�5 G :R4Wj ¾ abc CD 3@ O h 8PD<IT]: CZX 3i [�}< ^T ��@ G ÇR4

8> HR@t̀ 9:R[ O ~º8�  HIWXno

w< ?@AB THIM ^� Lt V:R[ O CZXnq¾:R4Wj HI@ Yt 9:R[ O ?@AB R@ `M Òbs CZXo=ã{  í@ `K) TH( CZXnq

T7Á[ @̀A[O Lt V:R[ O CZXnqN@ O7�

8> aRçT G< CZX :;< ¾SÈ;h I5 ] ÇR4

8> HR@t̀ 9:R[ O ?@AWmn q�< T?@9< L[V

CZXn q THI8 A z{[ G �<IT] ^ãB ^l<IQ Lt V:R[ O CZXn q 8PQR45 6 ^le�< CZXn q¾SÈ;h HR@

t̀ 9:R[ O ?@AWmn qSW m N@ O< L

t V:R[ O w< 8�R5 O 3[ O »�8Y  CZX 3i tPT Y�@�K:R[ Onq T?@A

dO}<nqq¿IÕ< 5PD »�8Y  ?@AWmno T?�@`K

THR@` :h ?@AB bv[ > 3@ O :th 3i IWX R8`�� CZX 3i 7Îh< CD zw T:R� L

d VIWXn q7Îh< CD zw T:R� Ld VIWXnqI8 G TH< H;TS@ ¹[Ë 7[ 9 �:R4Wj ¿R@ `

T] ?@AB 5� T~5 OT~8O ?@A�

T > RTOIWX Cd YZX R[\oI8 G [�}< LM ¾t75 9 LT VR5 OS�lnq?@AB [�}< Rg 3@ O7�

z� <h< R8O7M HIWX 3i [�}< CT G CvÌ�l 8uâ; R@ Oho

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�: 3@ O7�

z�no Tx @�zD 5�R8`Ê}< 5P]R½ Rg N@

d̀9RB ?@A�Iv�o Tx @�zD 5�R8`Ê}< ~46< :o£=@ ��]¤7�K<n T?¡ �6¤7�K<n ��<n £=¥�5 G 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! CEFG ; I8 G 35 \<I

T] ÛÕ}< 5P]R½ C

T G ¾t75 9 Â@`ë�8G CM Ä8 >R� tPT Y�

T >:IJ LM TS@ ¹{@ A�R[ O 7[ 9 THR@ 5̀9 R@ Oh CZXo?@AB aSU N@ O< TS@ ¹[Ë LM 8P]RT½; RTO7M R8` WXR[\ HIWX 3i Âg TH<bÅÖ THRT\ 5P]R½ C

T G HR�@> 5x @�tA�

35

3[ O R�� 3i CvÌ�l 8P I�\ THR8`EMR[ O LM abc CD 5ud 9RTO 7@9 T:; =

ÙõQ< LM bs}< LM d̂ �J CZXn o?@AB w< ?@AB wd;RW m CM :IÁÓ 7[ 9 w< LM ~@ Oh7

89 RTO7M R8` WXR[\ HIWX 3i 8P I�\ THR8`EMR[ O LM abc CD ^¥M =¥r LM TH< IM L

d VIM ^¥@ G< bs}< ?@A�T > LM d̂ �Jn o3@ O I

8 G ¾:~W mI[ ] b��5 ] ¿R5 `r< 5P]R½ C

T G ñRæ< T~B 7J< 8�R5 O LM CZX I8 G w< Rg 3@ O 5PÁÚ  ?@A�T >

CZX 3i 3@ O Ld VIM 8P I�\ THR8`EMR[ O LM abc CD bs}< ^�

8 >noI8 G w< LM N@ O< I8 G ?@AB ~@ Oh789 RTO7M R8` WXR[\ HIWX wd;RW m CM :IÁÓ 7[ 9 :;< ¾SÈ;h 8�R5 O 3@ O CZX 3i ?@Af_@ Oh CT Y

8Ai wIEÊ< LM 8�R5 O CZX 3i Âg T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� a}< THR8`EMR[ O Rg we5\< <IWX :;< w< ?@AB

HI¼T >< CT G �:I[ G CìFG bc CD ~@ Oh7

89 LM 3i T?z E�@ `K< ?@AB L

d VIM LK~TORÉh ?@A�T > L

d VIWX 3|Ñ5 O N@ O< fair election Rf8 >n o 5�< 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! CvÌ�l [�}< CFYd 9 R8 5̀9 3i 7J< 3@ O T?

z E�@ `K< T?z E@ A4� a}< THR8`EMR[ O CM HIÁç@YÊ IM ^�5 > C8 Y

T9 RBn q3@ O ¡^ã�< 3@ `K~� CM HIÁç@ YÊ IM ^�5 > Â@ [̀9< ?@A�

T > C8 G 7Mnq3@ O tPT Y�@�K:R[ O Rg ^�5 > Ç<S8 ¹Ë< ?@A�

T > C8 G 7Mnq3@ O tPT Y�@�K:R[ O CM HIÁç@YÊ

Rg ^�5 > Ç<S8 ¹Ë< ?@A�T > C

8 G 7M I8 G 3@ O NÑB IM �M abc CK 7M RTOR5\ C8 YZX R[\ ?@AWmno 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! w< NÑB ?@AB HI@ YM anarchy RTOe@ `v[ > C8 YZX R[\ ?@ABo?@AWm [�}< LM 8PcR�; CD TH< HI

T G;h T?@9~dORæ CD 3@ O HI¼� R� 3i <:<~ T\ ^T �[9< ~T½ C

d G t:Iv[ 6 ^T �[9< RTO< C

d G t:Iv[ 6 :;< THR8`EMR[ O :;< w< CM �:Rft >< t:;7M Ç<IQ Rg Â5`è

8A{  Rg Cd YÆ] I�o 5p}< TH< LM 35 \; CDn q 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! R@ `M 5p}< Tx @>:R8O ?@AB ^¥@ G< L

d VIM 8�R5 O hI5 ]I  CZX 3i N@ O< 5P

T �8�TAB 8P I�\ IWX I5 ] �:Rft >< t:;7M Ç<IQ LM LJ~T̀ d 9R4

T> 7M ^ Wj: IWXn q~T̀ [] :<TSW m kIK HIMtSÈ 7[ 9 }< 7M 3@ O ?@A�� 3i =Wj w< 8P I�\ IM RTO<7J ?@AWmC8 YZX R[\nq=Wj w< IM =@�Á{

8G ?@A�T > C

8 G 7Mnq3@ O ^�5 �M ?@A�T > <IWXno3@ O N@ O< ÂÃKR5 O S@ ¹

TÐ ^T �@AdO}<nqS@ ¹

TÐ LT VIT GRæ 8�R5 O

CZX I5 ] �; 7M CZX : ?@AWmno:;< ^¥M ðT�z� IM 3@ O »] ½R\ ?@A�

T > 3i NÑB CM T?@AdO}<

CM <:;RB Ld VIM 8�R5 O �7M R@ O NÑB CM THI

T GRæ CM aeT\ Ld VIM 8�R5 O �7MnoI8 G ?@AB

36

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! [�}< LM 8PcR�; CD TH< CD 3@ O HI¼� R� 3i <:<~ T\ 5�< w< ÇIr 7[ 9 =6: ?@97Mn oNÑB LM ^

z�R�  8uKR\ L8 Vt7�5 O R5\ ^ Wj: CZXn q7K<th R8`Ît75 9 R5\ RW m: CZXn qùRt`D

5xT�@A[º¥�@ O< �R5

8̀ 9 R8OIWX R5\ RW m: CZXn o<:<~ T\ w< NÑB 7[ 9 =6: ?@97M :;< 3@ O RTO7Îh HR�@> ?@AdORft ><CD :;< I5 ] 8�R5 O L

T V7M CZX tPT Y�@�K:R[ O ?@AB }< CM ?@97Mn o 5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�! 7J< 38`D<IT �T><~ T\ NÑB ?@AB anarchy Â@`v[ > d̂ �J I8 G TH< Rg R@ `M CZXn q3@ O I

8 G < t~@ `TA@`M LM

8u@9S�z� TH< CM wR[ O hI5 ]I  CZXnq3@ O I8 G RT [̀9< Û@ G75 9 �@Ai Rft >< 7M < t~@ `

TA@`M CÁÆ\ ?@AdOR5\

:;< �SÈ;h TH~T̀ K CT YÆ9 < HI[ �5> CM wR[ O CÁÆ\ ?@AdOR5\ CJn o?@A{[ G CJ I8 G 3@ O �:Rft ><

t:;7M Ç<IQnow< Cd YK ?@ AB [�}< LM 8PcR�; CD 3@ O zw:<T7J RTO7M R8` WXR[\ HIWX 3i <:<~ T\ L8 V<Th RTO< LM bcR T\nqL

8 V<Th ~T½ LM bcR T\ THR8`EMR[ O CM �:Rft >< t:;7M Ç<IQ LM 8P�¥r CD 3T O ?@AÑ@ `v�no 8P¼5> 8P¼5> 3@ O7�

z�o

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A� : 3@ O7�z� 5̂6no T:R z�� 34äRÓ 35 \<I

T] 35 `]R½o 3¸S8 ¹ºl � T:R z� 34äRÓ 35 \<I

T]: 3@ O7�z� St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 3i [�}< C

T G CvÌ�l w< political scenario 3[ O CT YK I5 G Rg ÀrI  R@ Ohn oSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB ^

T �[9< 7@9bì8G Rg T:RT �}< PW LM

w< t�:I[ G: CD H;7M LJ I5 ] HI¼T >< CT G Âg TH<th ?@AB ¾h oCZX TH< CM »5GRÚ 

8P I�\ CM N@ O< ¿R� CM Â4_B CT G IWX 7[ 9 �S8 ¹� d̂ �  IM 7@ 9 T:; =

ÙõQ< HR@ `  ~4�l T:<IT G

Û@ GSz È 5P]R½ :;< THR8`EMR[ O =ã{  í@ `K) TH( LM I5 ] popularity CZX �;

increase 7M CM 5�< 64 per cent 3[ O d̂ �J}< CZX as compared to

Pakistan Tahreek-e-Inshafn qI5 ] 3i C8 Y¼� bv[ > C8 G ?@AWm 3i <:R� THR8`EMR[ O

TH< CM Ä8 >R� <tbv� CZXo TH< LM popularity 70 per cent CD =� IWX 7M 5p}< 53 per cent 3[ O }< L

d V ¾tbv� CZXnoSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 3@ O <:R� I5 ] 5p}< Âg <75 ]RB Â[\ RW m:

37

CZX Might take away from the whole situation is that democracy has won. Today when the whole parliament

is w< TH<I@ G< LM ¾:R� LT VR4@ �K:R[ O TS@ ¹tO:R[ O 5P5] ^�

t �M< ¾tbv� L8 VIWX ?@AWmnq3T OR z� 3T OR z{5 G ¾tbv�

L8 VIWX ?@AWm 8u@9:I¼Å56 IM C

T G R[ º5> CM Cd YK :;< aSU N@ O< LT VR4@ �K:R[ O L

t V:R[ O SW mR5 O ¾tbv� L8 VIWX CZX I5 ] 3i w< ¾:I¼Å56 ÇR ÙÚ

TG IM THRçèTG C

T G R[ ºT�¼[> LM z�

z�IM L8 V7M CZXnoI8 G ?@AB

3@ O 8̂ �v_@ Oh HIWX 3i I5 ] TH< HI

T G;h H;TS@ ¹[Ë ?@AB Òbs CZX 3i ¾:R� HR@t̀ 9:R[ O 3T OR z� 3T OR z{5 G

¾tbv� ?@AWm :;< N@ O< Lt V:R[ O SW mR5 O ¾tbv� CZXn o�; 3@ O CZX 3i TH< ¾:R� TS@ ¹tO:R[ O IM �;

8uâ;q There is no substitution for time and experience Mr. Speaker. 3@ O 8P¼5> �hR@ O

T: LT V<7[ 9 TS@ ¹tO:R[ O o?@AWm w< NÑB LM politics IM HI¼T ><

CT G 3z{@ A4Wj CD Rf_@ Oh CZX :;< w< ¾:I¼Å56 ÇR ÙÚ

TG CM Cd YK RT [̀9< 3T`@A{[ G :;< THIT] LM ?@A8OhR�z� ¾h ?@AWmo as compared to this one particular political

party Mr. Speaker that stands alone outside to pose losing in the development of the democratic system of

Pakistan.

St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 3@ O Iv5 > ¿ C8 G R5\ ?@AWm 3i 3@ O ^ Wj; 8u@9:I¼Å56 CZX By virtue of

which they were able to sit in this august House in the first phase. TH< IM THR8`EMR[ O LM ¾St ¹{WX ?@AB I5 ] N@ O< ¾:I¼Å56 T?

z E�@ `K< Rg ^�5 > ÀrI  eBn qHI¼T >< C

T G �; ^�5 > t�RÃ@ Yd 9R5 O R@ Ohnow< CM hI5 ];R5 O 5P5] HI¼T >< CT G RT [̀9< e�[>

T?z E�@ `K< 2013 ?@AB <t7K I8 G TH< IM RåK 3i 3@ O completely sweep 7M ?@A

dOR5\ CJn ow< expectation CM <:I[ G 3T O C

T G IWX 7[ 9 TH< CM 7[ 9;< ^�I@ GRB CM CEFG <

38

CK Rg ¿hR5 O Cd G Rf[ 6 3i 3@ O 5p}< w< ÇRÍ  7[ 9 Cd YJ }< ?@AWm 3i :<~8̀ r< LM wIWX LM 35 \;

CD 3@ O THR8`EMR[ O CM �:I[ G ÇR ÙÚTG IM THRçè

TG CT G R[ ºT�¼[> 7[ 9 Â8O Cd YJ ?@AWmno

St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 3@ O 5p}< �:R4Wj =

d ><7[ 9 St ¹{TAB 5P]R½resignation Rg 35 `KRÚ 

?@AWmC8 G 7M :;< 3@ O C

8 Y¼� ?@ AWm 3i 3@ O <:R� THR8`EMR[ O TH< CM Ä8 >R� <tbv� CZXno 5p}< 7J< [�}< ?@Af_@ Oh I8 G SW mR5 O ÂÃ

zE  CD �@A5O �@A8O :<TSW m �~T̀ 59 <tbv� CZXno7J< ?@AB TH< IM �; 7.6

million voter ^�5 > �h H;h HI¼T �5] CT G TH< CM Cd YK t�;; R@ Oh I

8 G R@ `M ^âR5 O Rg I5 ] N@ O< I� �I

T G T?@AÑB �~T̀ 59 w< NÑB CM :~TO< R8` WX: CZX w< Rg Ld VIM

mandate ?@A�T > CZXnqR@ `M w< CM t�;; LM L

d VIM :~æ ?@A�T > CZX :;< 3@ O I5 ] ^âR5 O

¾:R� HR@t̀ 9:R[ O ^�

t �M< 5p}< ¾tbv� ?@AWm �; TH< N@ O< I� �IT G T?@AÑB HIJIK CM

mandate LM 35 \; CD HR�@> ^�t �@A5O ?@AWm :;< =Wj TH< LM T:<;}< ~T̀ Á5 O ?@AWmC

8 G 7Mo They have no right whatsoever to demand the dissolution of this Parliament or the resignation of the

Prime Minister of Pakistan. St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 3@ O Cd G }< THh ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i =Wj

Cd G <:;RB T?@A

dO}< Ld VIM 8�R5 O ?@A�

T > ?@97M oCJ T?�@`K T:;: mid term elections LM 8�R5 O ?@AWmC

8 G 7Mo 7J< [�}< T?

zDI@ YtA@t̀A{TGRg IM ?@Af_@ Oh I8 G Article 58 of the Constitution N@ `vt > CZX 3i mid term election Constitution Rg

3ç] CZX T?�@ `K Article 58 of the Constitution clearly dictates when, where and how are mid term elections permissible. There are only two conditions where you

39

can have mid term elections: One is where the Prime Minister himself dissolves the Parliament, and the second is where you have a vote of no confidence against the Prime Minister of Pakistan. And the third remaining option is the Representation of People’s Act of 1976 which says if more than half of the Parliament resigns, the President is then obliged to dissolve the

Parliament and hold mid term elections. 7J< I8 G 3@ O TH< HIT Y@A8O ?@AB CD ^¥M N@ O< ^�5 > criteria IM fulfill 7M C8 YFA� ?@AWm I8 G HRW m TH< CM mid

term elections Rg 35 `KRÚ  T?@AdO}< CM »5GRÚ  CZX T?�@ `K 5p}< 7J< 3@ O �@A5O H;:<TSW m

HIJIK IM SW mR5 O <tbv� 7M ?@AWmC8 Y¼�CM 3i [�}< mid term election ?@97M I8 G 3@ O ÂÃKR5 O ^Þ¢r :Ic ^

T �@AdO}< 8�R5 O ?@A�T > CZX :;< 3@ O T?@A

dO}< LM basics IM deny L8 V7M

oCZX Similarly Mr. Speaker, talking about the Constitution

of Pakistan and their claim of remaining within the Constitution of Pakistan 3@ O 5p}< 35 `KRÚ  C

8 G 7M ?@AWm 3i =Wj �:I[ G T?z E�@ `K<

T?z E@ A4� IM ?@9hRt` WXnq=Wj Û@ Y[] T?

z E�@ `K< ST ¹ z{�� IM w< LM T?z E@ G T:I[ G CD Rt` WX ?@9ho

Mr. Speaker again, Article 209 of the Constitution

gives you clear cut indication of how and when the Election Commissioner or the Chief Election Commissioner of Pakistan or the Chairperson of the

40

Election Commission of Pakistan can be removed. The only two conditions are if he is proved to be physically or mentally unwell or you can prove misconduct against him.

St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! 5p}< evidence and proof LM I8 G L

d VIM 8�R5 O ^ Wj ?@A�T >

R8O7Mno�5] Rg ¿h CZX R8O7M �; SW mR5 O 7M}< <tbv� IWX R8OR5\ CZX :;< 8�RB<T7K< 3[ O 8�RB<T7K< Cd G RåK

R8OR5\ CZXno�5] CD Iv[ 6I[ G ’ 3@ O 5p}< ÂTçÊ< THRT\ LM 8�R5 O C

8 G 7M ?@AWm I8 G ÂTçÊ< THRT\

CM ^�< I@ G;St ¹TO< ?@AB ÙêRáK< ?@AWm 3i [�}< �S@ ¹¸ 8�I5 Yz9 ?@Aï

TORB CJn q�S@ ¹¸ wR[ O 8�I5 Yz9 ?@A�

T > ?@AWmn oR@ `M =Wj TH< HIJIK CM Tð�l 8�R Ù÷RáK< 3[ O ¾:R� tPT Y�@�K:R[ O IM dissolve 7M ?@9h :;< �:R� NÑB I5 ]CM T75 �56 ?@AWmn qI5 ] �: C�Æ\ ?@AWm :;< I5 ] 5p}<

Cvt �FA5O C

d G IWX ?@AWm TH< IM Â@ 5̀] nHIT]e�nLMCvÆ�@�[9CM ¿<th ?@9hnoSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A� 3@ O ^Þ¢r :Ic T?@AdO}<7[ 9 CM »5GRÚ  ?@A

8OR5 O ?@A�T > ?@AWmo

St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! ?@AB 7

T]}< ?@AB RT`¼� HIWXR[\ LJ 3i 3@ O I5 ] SW mR5 O �tbv� IWX CM :R z{8ATO< e@ `v[ > o?@AWmCZX : 3@ O ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i =Wj HeÓ : t~@ `K IM LKI� ?@A

dORÉt7[ ] CJnqHeÓ : t~@ `K IM Â@ 5̀] ?@AB ~T̀ 59 ?@97M qCJ L

d V}< 5̂6 IM punch ?@97M CJnoCd G }< T:;: 3@ O ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i 5p}< =Wj

=d ><7[ 9 St ¹{

TAB n?@ABwd;RW m ÂT\<h HIWX CJnqÂg tPT Y�@�K:R[ O ?@A

dOR5\ CJ :;< HI�7[ 9 tu@97t 97�@ `D ~T̀ 59 7M ?@9h CJnoL

d VIM T?�M T?¼[> CM <tbv� CZX I8 G Ld VIM S5 ¹æ hIv� RW m: qCZX L

d VIM S5 ¹æ ?@AB Rt @̀A� <IWX oCZX St ¹{  7�@ [̀A� R@ `M 3@ Ooo

) TH<Th< S� Ùä(

41

5�RT 5̀] 7�@ [̀A�: 5̂6 � T:R z� 5P]R½ Kindly wind up Cd YÌ�@�K oTS@ ¹Ñ[ O

3¸S8 ¹ºl � T:R z� 34äRÓ 35 \<IT]: St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! n?@AB3�� ^ Wj: ^�

8 > 3i I5 ] Cd G }< T:;: SW mR5 O

peaceful protest C8 G 7M C

d G IWX kIK �tbv� ?@AWmC8 G IWX T?�@ `K CT YÆ9 < ÙêRáK<

CÞFG :ThCM HIJIK ?@AB :R z{8ATO< e@ `v[ > CZX : ?@AWmo They are inciting hatred amongst the people Mr. Speaker. C

d G }< T:;: 3@ O ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i =Wj HeÓ : t~@ `K IM LKI� RÉt7[ ] ?@9h CJnqN@ O< IM Â@ 5̀] ?@ AB ¿<th ?@9h CJnq�:R� T75 �56 IM ’ CÁf� TH<~@ `  ?@AB �tbv� 7MIWX 3@ O ?@A

8OR5 O 7M : ?@AWmCZXnoS@ ¹TÐ L

T VR4@ �K:R[ O I8 G ?@AB R@ `M HI¼�n q3@ O THR4@ �K:R[ O ?@AB Cv

t �FA5O ?@A�T > C

d G IWX T?�@ `K S@ ¹TÐ 5� T~�l THR5 O

T: ¿R4Þ8A�< :7M ?@AWmCZXn o^�5 �M

?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i =Wj =d ><7[ 9 St ¹{

TAB wd;RW m ?@AdO}< CJ I8 G ^�5 �M C8 Y¼� ?@AWm 3i tPT Y�@�K:R[ O 3[ O

attack ?@97M CJnoSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A� ! Ld VIM T?�M CT Y¼Æ> <tbv� CZXn qL

d VIM S5 ¹æ �hIv� Rft �@A5O CZXn oR@ `M 3@ O peaceful protest oCZX TH< ¾:R� HI8 GR5 O IM T?D 7M 7J< =Wj

Lt V:I@ Y�@ `D kIKCM C

T G � LM 8�R5 O ?@AWmC8 G 7M I8 G bv[ > 3@ O ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i 8P I�\ Rg I

8 G ÇRg ^ Wj ^à@> CZX 3i 3@ O democratic right IM ù;: ^ Wj: oCZX

St ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! civil disobedience LM 8�R5 O ?@AWmC8 G 7Mn oL

d VIM TH< IM Cd G R8 5̀9 3i state disobedience HI8 Y I�\ CM ?@A�

T > tP@YtA� CM aeT\ L8 VIWX

CZXo7J< 3@ O 5p}< ��@t̀ 9 ?@A�

T > ?@9h CJ I8 G 3@ O 8P I�\ Rg ?@A�T > w< NÑB Rg THRçè

TG R�IWXo Civil disobedience LM ^

T �8A 5\ 3@ O ?@A�Rz`  ?@AWmC8 YF9 h Mr. Speaker civil disobedience 3z{@ A4Wj foreign occupants CM aeT\ ?@A

dOIWXq Civil disobedience 5u8 9 L

d VIWX 5P5] NÑB 5u@9bTÖCM Ç<IQ the masses

of the countries have stood against foreign occupants.

42

^�5 �M civil disobedience privileged LM ÇR� Ç<IQ aeT\CM ?@A�T > L

d VIWXnoÇR� Ç<IQ LM T:<;}< 3@ O tPT Y�@�K:R[ O Rft >< ^ Wj: CZX 3T O 3i SW mR5 O �tbv� �:~T̀ [9 CD �@A5O :<TSW m kIKoSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A� ! w< civil disobedience LM credibility 7Îh< ^ Wj =8 � T] IWX L

8 VR5\ CZX HR�56 3[ O 3@ O ^âR5 O �:R� NÑB ?@AB I8 G civil disobedience announce 7M C8 YF9 h ?@AWm T?�@ `K S5 ¹@`

T] �<IT �T>I8 YT�[> ?@AB TH< CT YÆ9 <CM St ¹{

TAB ?@AWmC8 Y¼� 3i :<hS5 ¹

TË I5 ] ^¥M CT G civil disobedience LMnoSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A�! Ethnic politics

3[ O resort RTO7M ^T �[9< ¾75 9 THR5 O

T: ¿R4Þ8A�< RTO7Mqw< NÑB CM Cd YK �75 9

precedents set RTO7M 3i [�}< �:~T̀ [9 CD �@A5O :<TSW m kIK CK ?@AdO}< :;< w<

TH<I@ G< LM 8�:< T:; ¡^ÅÙõQ IM THRçè

TG CT G R[ ºT�¼[> LM z�

z�IM ?@97Mo

[�}< CT G election reforms I8 G LM ?@A�

T >no [�}< ^àT >< T?z E�@ `K< T7K;:CM 3[ O

re-election LM 8�R5 O ?@AWmC8 G 7Mn oR@ `M 3@ O logic IM contradict ?@A�

T > R8O7MnoSt ¹{  7�@ [̀A� ! [�}< C

d G }< T:;: state institutions LM CÌG 8̂ � 7] ?@AWmC8 G 7Mnq [�}<

�tG:IM IM ?@A

8OR5 O C8 G 7M ?@AWmn q [�}< THR4@ �K:R[ O IM HR@ `KR� C8 YK RÃTG ?@AWmn oR@ `M 3@ O 5� T~�l

�Sz ÈR�  LM 8�R5 O qCZX R@ `M 3@ O R�IWX :R4Wj < R@T̀9 THR8`EMR[ Oo Thank you Mr.

Speaker for your time. Mr. Speaker: The House is adjourned to meet again on Friday the 29th of August, at 11 a.m. (The House was adjourned to meet again on Friday, the 29th August, 2014, at 11:00 a.m.)