District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTI

ON

A -

REU

SE E

XIS

TIN

G

BU

ILD

ING

MARIE H. REED COMMUNITY LEARNING CENTERJUNE 10, 2015

COMMUNITY MEETING

OPTI

ON

B -

REU

SE E

AST

WIN

G A

ND

BU

ILD

NEW

SCH

OO

L/REC

BU

ILD

ING

PRO/CON EVALUATION

DirectionsPlease consider the options that were presented and evaluate each in the fol-lowing categories:

• Site Related• Elementary School Environments• Construction Impact and Project

Economics• Community Partner Facilities• Green Design

On the following pages please develop pro’s and con’s for each of the catego-ries. Some sample questions are provid-ed for you to start your evaluation.

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

BUILDING ADDITION

ENTRY

EDUCATION

POCKETPARKPARKING

EARLYCHILDHOOD

PLAYGROUND

PLAYGROUND

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

BUILDING ADDITION

CONNECTOR

x

xx

x

x

xx

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

ENTRY

EDUCATION

EARLY CHILDHOODPLAYGROUND

POCKETPARK

PLAY-GROUND

NEW BUILDING

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

CONNECTOR

PARKING

xx

x

x

x

x

x x

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTION A - REUSE EXISTING BUILDINGPRO/CON EVALUATION

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

BUILDING ADDITION

ENTRY

EDUCATION

POCKETPARKPARKING

EARLYCHILDHOOD

PLAYGROUND

PLAYGROUND

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

BUILDING ADDITION

CONNECTOR

x

xx

x

x

xx

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

ALTERNATE KIDDIE POOL ADDITION

Site• How well does the proposed concept provide a place for community events?

• How well does the proposed concept provide places for active recreation?

• How well does the proposed concept provide places for outdoor learning?

• How well does the proposed site plan address and resolve pedestrian circulation?

• How well does the proposed site plan address and resolve traffic and parking concerns?

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

Elementary School Environments• How well does the proposed concept provide for classroom based learning?

• How well does the proposed concept provide for specials (art, music, science, media, other)?

• How well does the proposed concept support small, medium and large group events?

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OPTION A - REUSE EXISTING BUILDINGPRO/CON EVALUATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

BUILDING ADDITION

ENTRY

EDUCATION

POCKETPARKPARKING

EARLYCHILDHOOD

PLAYGROUND

PLAYGROUND

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

BUILDING ADDITION

CONNECTOR

x

xx

x

x

xx

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

POOL ADDITIONKIDDIE POOL ADDITION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

Construction Impact and Project Economics• Can the proposed concept be constructed with the allocated project budget?

• Does the proposed concept present a good value for the required investment?

• Is there a clear way to phase the work that will allow for continued operation of the ongoing Marie Reed and Community Partner programs?

• Does the proposed concept present construction risks?

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OPTION A - REUSE EXISTING BUILDINGPRO/CON EVALUATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

BUILDING ADDITION

ENTRY

EDUCATION

POCKETPARKPARKING

EARLYCHILDHOOD

PLAYGROUND

PLAYGROUND

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

BUILDING ADDITION

CONNECTOR

x

xx

x

x

xx

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

Community Partner Facilities• How well does the proposed concept serve the Community of Hope operations?

• How well does the proposed concept serve the Women, Infants and Children’s (WIC) operations?

• How well does the proposed concept serve the Daycare operations?

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OPTION A - REUSE EXISTING BUILDINGPRO/CON EVALUATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

BUILDING ADDITION

ENTRY

EDUCATION

POCKETPARKPARKING

EARLYCHILDHOOD

PLAYGROUND

PLAYGROUND

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

BUILDING ADDITION

CONNECTOR

x

xx

x

x

xx

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

Green Design • How well does the proposed concept address environmental opportunities and concerns?

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OPTION A - REUSE EXISTING BUILDINGPRO/CON EVALUATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

BUILDING ADDITION

ENTRY

EDUCATION

POCKETPARKPARKING

EARLYCHILDHOOD

PLAYGROUND

PLAYGROUND

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

BUILDING ADDITION

CONNECTOR

x

xx

x

x

xx

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

ALTERNATE POOL ADDITION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTION B - REUSE EAST WING AND BUILD NEW SCHOOL/REC BUILDING

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

ENTRY

EDUCATION

EARLY CHILDHOODPLAYGROUND

POCKETPARK

PLAY-GROUND

NEW BUILDING

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

CONNECTOR

PARKING

xx

x

x

x

x

x x

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Site• How well does the proposed concept provide a place for community events?

• How well does the proposed concept provide places for active recreation?

• How well does the proposed concept provide places for outdoor learning?

• How well does the proposed site plan address and resolve pedestrian circulation?

• How well does the proposed site plan address and resolve traffic and parking concerns?

PRO/CON EVALUATION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTION B - REUSE EAST WING AND BUILD NEW SCHOOL/REC BUILDING

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

ENTRY

EDUCATION

EARLY CHILDHOODPLAYGROUND

POCKETPARK

PLAY-GROUND

NEW BUILDING

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

CONNECTOR

PARKING

xx

x

x

x

x

x x

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Elementary School Environments• How well does the proposed concept provide for classroom based learning?

• How well does the proposed concept provide for specials (art, music, science, media, other)?

• How well does the proposed concept support small, medium and large group events?

PRO/CON EVALUATION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTION B - REUSE EAST WING AND BUILD NEW SCHOOL/REC BUILDING

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

ENTRY

EDUCATION

EARLY CHILDHOODPLAYGROUND

POCKETPARK

PLAY-GROUND

NEW BUILDING

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

CONNECTOR

PARKING

xx

x

x

x

x

x x

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Construction Impact and Project Economics• Can the proposed concept be constructed with the allocated project budget?

• Does the proposed concept present a good value for the required investment?

• Is there a clear way to phase the work that will allow for continued operation of the ongoing Marie Reed and Community Partner programs?

• Does the proposed concept present construction risks?

PRO/CON EVALUATION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTION B - REUSE EAST WING AND BUILD NEW SCHOOL/REC BUILDING

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

ENTRY

EDUCATION

EARLY CHILDHOODPLAYGROUND

POCKETPARK

PLAY-GROUND

NEW BUILDING

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

CONNECTOR

PARKING

xx

x

x

x

x

x x

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Community Partner Facilities• How well does the proposed concept serve the Community of Hope operations?

• How well does the proposed concept serve the Women, Infants and Children’s (WIC) operations?

• How well does the proposed concept serve the Daycare operations?

PRO/CON EVALUATION

District of Columbia Public SchoolsMarie H. Reed Community Learning Center DRAFT

OPTION B - REUSE EAST WING AND BUILD NEW SCHOOL/REC BUILDING

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

ENTRY

EDUCATION

EARLY CHILDHOODPLAYGROUND

POCKETPARK

PLAY-GROUND

NEW BUILDING

EXISTINGBUILDING

PUMPSTATION

ORGANIZEDSPORTS

CONNECTOR

PARKING

xx

x

x

x

x

x x

SITE BOUNDARY

SCHOOL ONLY ZONE DURINGDESIGNATED HOURS(DEFENSIBLE SPACE)

COMMUNITY BUFFER

LEGEND

SCALE 1”=100’

0 100 200 FT

x x x

18TH STREET NW

CHAMPLAIN STREET NW

FLOR

IDA

AVE

NW

CALIFORNIA STREET NW

ONTARIO ROAD NW

Pro’s:____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Con’s:________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Green Design • How well does the proposed concept address environmental opportunities and concerns?

PRO/CON EVALUATION