-ANNUAL REPORTS-a quick comparative overview

by Miha Horvat(of Slovenian NPM)

Ljubljana, May 2014

SEE NPM Network

SEE NPM Network

• SEE NPM Network members‘ ANNUAL REPORTS

• for the year 2012(Austria, Croatia)

• on-line versions (SPT webpage)(-Montenegro)

SEE NPM Network

THE LENGHT COMPARISON

in total originalALBANIA 133 93AUSTRIA 40 34CROATIA 42 33

MACEDONIA 102 87SERBIA 88 83

SLOVENIA 108 74

SEE NPM Network

THE LANGUAGE ASPECT

• different language editions –separate reports (ENG, CRO)

• bilingual report – consecutiveapproach (MACEDONIA)

• bilingual report – simultaneousapproach (SLOVENIA)

SEE NPM Network

COMPILATION vs SYNTHESIS

• ALBANIA: penitentiaries and pre-trialdetention facilities BY (SUB)CHAPTERS (by PoD) - TAXATIVE APPROACH

• e.g.:

SEE NPM Network

• SERBIA: ANNEX to the report• e.g.:

• (+ Recommendations to the Prison Administration for Enforcement of penal Sanctions, Recommendations to Psychiatric Hospital, Recommendations to the Asylum Centre)

SEE NPM Network

• CROATIA: BY (SUB)TITLES (by PoD) -DESCRIPTIVE APPROACH

• e.g.:

SEE NPM Network

• MACEDONIA: BY (SUB)TITLES (byISSUES)

• e.g. (from chapter POLICE STATIONS):

• (+Toilets, Right to food and water, etc.)

SEE NPM Network

• SLOVENIA: CHAPTERS BY PoDTYPES, no further subchapters/subtitles

SEE NPM Network

REGARDING RECOMMENDATIONS...

• DETAILED: e.g. MACEDONIA(‚exact-science‘ approach- special chapter, numbers, tables, graphs)

SEE NPM Network

• GENERAL SUMMARY/ESTIMATE: e.g. SLOVENIA(within chapters on PoD types)

SEE NPM Network

• CROATIA: tabular overview(for recommendations)

SEE NPM Network

• (sidenote) SLOVENIA: tabularoverview in final reports

SEE NPM Network

TABULAR OVERVIEW/REVIEWof the NPM activities

• e.g. SLOVENIA (separate chapter)

SEE NPM Network

• e.g. MACEDONIA (Annex to the report)+ special designation of preventive visits!!

SEE NPM Network

PHOTOGRAPHS from the visits!!

• MACEDONIA

SEE NPM Network

PHOTOGRAPHS from the visits!!

• MACEDONIA