TECHNICAL PAPER · 2019-12-12 · Clump weight position Tether wire length Tether wire OD / Maximum Breaking Force How does tether wire pre-tension impact the efficiency of the system?

TECHNICAL PAPER

BOP Tethering and Motion

Measurements – Enabling Safe

Subsea Well Decommissioning

J. Lodhia

AOG March 2019

BOP Tethering and Motion Measurements – Enabling Safe Subsea Well Decommissioning

14th March 2019

J Lodhia

Learn more at www.2hoffshore.com

3 of 21

Contents

▪ Subsea well P&A challenges

▪ Benefits of BOP tether system

▪ Specification of BOP tether system

▪ In-field measurements to validate response

▪ Conclusions


4 of 21

P&A Challenges for Older Wells

▪ Typically old (pre-2000) 30” conductor designs

▪ Usually not designed for fatigue loading

▪ Lack of data

▪ 6th generation semi-submersibles in shallow water

▪ Prior fatigue damage?

Older Wellhead Newer WellheadLearn more at www.2hoffshore.com

5 of 21

1st Case Study – Conventional P&A Approach

▪ Well Location: Offshore Australia

▪ Water Depth: 68m

▪ Drilling Rig: 6th generation moored semi-submersible

▪ Wellhead System: Rigid lockdown wellhead

▪ Originally installed approx. 2005


6 of 21

Wellhead & Conductor Stack-up

▪ 30” x 1.0” Conductor

▪ 20”x13-3/8” Surface Casing

▪ Conductor and surface casing cemented to mudline

▪ Combined wet weight of LMRP + BOP + Subsea Tree = 232.7Te

▪ 25 day duration = 250 days target life (0.68 years) FOS=10

LP Housing:0.97m

3.35m

Mud Line Mud

HP Housing: 1.72m

11.51m

2.48m 2.38m

0m

Cement

-8.09m

30x1.5” LP Hsg Extension Joint

6.21m

4.20m

BOP: 5.30m

Subsea Tree: 2.01m

17.49m

Riser Adapter, Lower Flex Joint and LMRP: 5.98m

30x1” XOver Joint 30x1” Intermediate Joint

1 x 30” x 1.50” Conductor Joint

-19.57m

-31.05m

-42.63m

20x 13-3/8” Surface Casing

10-3/4” x 9-5/8” Casing

13-3/8” Casing Shoe -565.1m

Surface Casing TOC 0m

-4.00m Base of HD90 Quick Stab Box

-5.90m Top 13-3/8” BTC Connector

9-5/8” Casing Shoe -1630.1m

-1596.3m 7” Tubing Packer


7 of 21

Unfactored Fatigue Results

Min Fatigue Life is 11 days and does not meet Target LifeLearn more at www.2hoffshore.com

8 of 21

Mitigation Options

▪ Reduce conservatisms – only applicable for marginal designs

▪ More accurate data

▪ Conventional remedial actions include:

▪ BOP modifications – lighter BOP however can be costly

▪ Different vessels – availability and cost implications


9 of 21

BOP Tether System

Clump Weights

BOP StackTensioning

System

Tether Lines

Primary aim is to reduce BOP stack motionsLearn more at www.2hoffshore.com

10 of 21

Effect of BOP Tether on Bending along Conductor

Approx. 3 times reduction in bending loadLearn more at www.2hoffshore.com

11 of 21

Unfactored Fatigue Results with BOP Tether System

Fatigue lives improved by a factor of 185xLearn more at www.2hoffshore.com

12 of 21

Specifying BOP Tether SystemKey Considerations

▪ Consider how any change in the design will affect the overall tether wire stiffness:

▪ Clump weight position

▪ Tether wire length

▪ Tether wire OD / Maximum Breaking Force

▪ How does tether wire pre-tension impact the efficiency of the system?

▪ Monitoring system can provide further assurance

▪ Bottom clump weight stability on seabed

▪ Axial loading resistance on conductor – Any additional axial load?


13 of 21

Effect of Clump Weight Position

▪ 3 distances considered:• 13.5m

• 41.0m

• 45.0m

▪ Longer tether wire reduces stiffness

▪ System response is sensitive to wire stiffness


14 of 21

Effect of Tether Pre-tension & Wire OD

▪ Tether wire OD reduced – Wire stiffness reduces by 87%

▪ 3 pre-tensions considered:• 5 kips

• 10 kips

• 15 kips

▪ Clump weight positions remains constant

▪ Wire pre-tension has little effect on system response

▪ System response is sensitive to wire stiffness


15 of 21

Final Fatigue Results with BOP Tether System


16 of 21

2nd Case Study – Monitoring BOP Stack Motions

▪ Well Location: Offshore Australia

▪ Subsea well utilised a BOP tether system

▪ Motion monitoring equipment installed subsea onto the BOP frame and subsea tree

▪ Monitoring equipment recorded the BOP stack and subsea tree movement and accelerations

▪ Data available pre- and post-BOP tether system installation for multiple deployments


17 of 21

Subsea Tree Accelerations – 1st Deployment

0.00

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.10

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.20

0.22

0.24

0.00

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0.07

0.08

11/07 00:00 11/07 12:00 12/07 00:00 12/07 12:00 13/07 00:00 13/07 12:00 14/07 00:00

An

gu

lar

Ra

te (

de

g/

s)

Acc

ele

rati

on

(m

/s2

)

Date and Time

Cooper Energy Sole-4 Tree Monitoring

STANDARD DEVIATION OF ACCELERATION & ANGULAR RATES11-13 July 2018

X Acceleration Y Acceleration X-Z Angular Rate Y-Z Angular Rate Noise Level

Logger installed

Loggerremoved

BOP landed

BOP tether system

activated

BOP tether system

presssuretopup

Noise level


18 of 21

Subsea Tree Accelerations – 2nd Deployment


19 of 21

Observations From In-field Measurements

▪ Use of the BOP tether system provided 2.5x reduction in motions

▪ Consistent reduction in BOP stack motions observed over multiple deployments

▪ The observed reduction in motions directly leads to improved fatigue performance


20 of 21

Summary

▪ Use of 5/6th generation rig for subsea well P&A decommissioning may lead to fatigue complications

▪ Standard remedial actions may be insufficient or too costly

▪ BOP tether system offers a direct improvement on wellhead fatigue by reducing BOP stack motions

▪ Must consider wire stiffness when designing the BOP tether system

▪ In-field motion measurements confirm the effectiveness of a BOP tether system in reducing stack motions


Questions?



http://www.2hoffshore.com/

Documents

TECHNICAL PAPER · 2019-12-12 · Clump weight position Tether wire length Tether wire OD / Maximum Breaking Force How does tether wire pre-tension impact the efficiency of the system?