25
I5IH $IElqAq oi'niow siaaii M5IAH If 5I3TIAHD 'II 3MLISIIA OG QT4A YDTI1J5D4IMAfl :cJAVI5I 5II1HT 141 $IOIVAH3 D14IDJ2 T)15IAM 3141J5HA 2.U r1in5xoa niiv o5I .J n14 V4O .oM iqi'I gnbhoW HD5IAEI5I DIMOMODH 10 UA35IUH JAMOITAM 3iJn3vA 2Uf132EM OO1 8IO AM bhdmBD QQI siuid1 bi1IA noiibnuo ni2 Ii3noiisJI rli bru ainrnmo3 WqbrJ idI innO flcJo5I InBrfi W IEi3rn$rlfl io 3fti IsioiviufH r1i ni bui b3nBvbA iol iinD bn noiiabnuo ni3oI •q ni nirrzoxfrio1 ai iqq 2ith b noiv bnflor12 A .tioqqu ti msrgoiq iiai '51E1HM to nq ai qq if1T 2.QQI EM zoi° rLi lo oth Ion bnt 1or1iuE th lo odi 5i b25Iqx noiniqo 'dnA .noinxiniO fhitrbnI .r5I oitnono lo uiwa IEnoin3T4 to noit nofL idii HA .J onM bn niin51oa flflV d QQ1 © Iiiii bbivroiq noi22icrnq IioiIqx uocfiiw b3ioup d vm 2I1qz1Bmq owl 01 Ion ix1 3111 01 fl3V1 i 331iOfl © 1IIbUI3ffl 4ib5 Ilul

$IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

I5IH $IElqAq oi'niow siaaii

M5IAH If 5I3TIAHD 'II 3MLISIIA OG QT4A YDTI1J5D4IMAfl :cJAVI5I 5II1HT

141 $IOIVAH3 D14IDJ2 T)15IAM 3141J5HA 2.U

r1in5xoa niiv o5I .J n14

V4O .oM iqi'I gnbhoW

HD5IAEI5I DIMOMODH 10 UA35IUH JAMOITAM 3iJn3vA 2Uf132EM OO1

8IO AM bhdmBD QQI siuid1

bi1IA noiibnuo ni2 Ii3noiisJI rli bru ainrnmo3 WqbrJ idI innO flcJo5I InBrfi W IEi3rn$rlfl io 3fti IsioiviufH r1i ni bui b3nBvbA iol iinD bn noiiabnuo ni3oI •q

ni nirrzoxfrio1 ai iqq 2ith b noiv bnflor12 A .tioqqu ti msrgoiq iiai '51E1HM to nq ai qq if1T 2.QQI EM zoi°

rLi lo oth Ion bnt 1or1iuE th lo odi 5i b25Iqx noiniqo 'dnA .noinxiniO fhitrbnI .r5I oitnono lo uiwa IEnoin3T4

to noit nofL idii HA .J onM bn niin51oa flflV d QQ1 © Iiiii bbivroiq noi22icrnq IioiIqx uocfiiw b3ioup d vm 2I1qz1Bmq owl 01 Ion ix1

3111 01 fl3V1 i 331iOfl © 1IIbUI3ffl 4ib5 Ilul

Page 2: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

iqs1 nbhoW IHffVI vistnd1

M$IAH 11 $13TAHD MI 2141J$llA OG UMA YDTU$INJ4A :JAVISI SHHHT

MI $IOIVAHfl OMIDI5I T)I5IAM MIJ5IIA 2.U

TA$IT8A

oi1oq bru irnbi 1dibino3 bbinTh rI aiib thi3nfniI ni &rrifl 10 ioivjbcJ dT

3iIduq r1i lo d3um bihi irf 'Cri2ubni nihiB .2.U rfi iii liorrrnn rff .wu ini flu i5IifIi

'hEIu3iflBq iib thi3n1nu1 iii ni!iii Uuli burB v&1 ivdo mo ai noiuib i1oq

nrmBrL 10 irrioq rLi oi 2onq ub3i noii3oiq o1qtm1nBd 11 iiqD ibnu niB1qo oth

iqirthxsd lo iisi rIi3hq 3r11 iia,vni bu3 airlT .io1iiqrno3 lifb bn v1mñi Lsrfw3rno2 niL3ob 'Ith3iqi 2hq nihiB ns irb 3u fiEb dT .thwh iirli bn nihiJ$

owi inupadu rLi ivo biqb '(1irti!a nimi bni noi1ioiq 3iqrrD1nEd iol 1i1 3i io1cJ

oiiq iidli iwoI niLiii iqim!nd r1i lo ioiii3qrno3 iErli nbiv on bnil W .irup u1i io

mrti iithni i1ui rLT .IBvh lqimln&I iirli o oI \OfII i&1i ion ivwod

.21o1iiqmo3 iith lo thIBrt thbnEnil frrl&1 ion ob iITIB3 iquD1nd

o$I .J snM niinioH nhv inrnEni3M lo Iood nso1 iijiiinI sgin .D.U

TIM W ninn&D QE E-3 ,vhU 1hornM 0 081 -0VQ AD 1!iH QUO AM bhdmD 5H814 bn

5LEIffM briE

Page 3: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

:1-

cçoI2 (b 12)IIflmpGL O &qOL LJq JJ9 pJJ(Lflb CgLLIGL pu auG

uucj bLopJGm tciiJ TLJJUG iuqn2cL? pi pu cnqIçJAG VJLIJIJG J1J(T2fL 249G2 JJJG cIr LGCOIJ!G2 }J9jp }fGboLc O[ JG L49TJOIJJ C°'°'T EUflLG fLOU cowbGc-

GOIJL9'C2 JJGIJ IJJIIJ OL p9'uLribc?. IIJ9 JOtAGL CLLGL2 bLc-

CO22 J1LOJT}J 9'pLO.9'POIJ O €X!21IJ I9'P0L 9'uq GdIT!bIIJIJ

C9'LLJGL p9'nJLribç C9'LL1GL 9'LG 9'J O JOtACL UJ9'LJIJ9'J

bLoçGcçiou m qiLGcJ2 9'JGL co OL qiuvq oL p9'ujaithc

!0H O 2ITCJJ L2 9'rrq JJGL LIA9'J E!L J!' IOL pujaribc?

LG2 q ptJjarrbcc iii bi cnJ9'L wip bLicJu qci-

IJJGLG 9'LG 9' A9'LJGç O CJJ9'IJIJGJ cJJLO11JJ NJJJCJ3 1JU9'IJCI&J q-

J9'IJCJ9'J J3G9'J4JJ O 4JJ HJqfla4L?

GL jj p9'uJaITbcc? BLOçGCç1OIJ 9'i cnç bLic€2 9'uq pu'Lmcq

1P9' ''!11 thG9'J( 9'iLJi13G uq G2bGCi9'1J flUGL

IJJGIJç 9'2JC IOLCG 013 4JJG iuqnc JH9'llCi9'J EOG JJ9'AG 9'LJTG

/J9'1J9'GL2 9' IJJ9'IOL C9'LLJGL2 9'2 9' pJITG-LIppOu OAGLU-

iii ptr ibcGq HJOLG OGU JJ9'1J 113 9'ILJJIJG IIJqJT2çL?

&uq Mill u'p buc o GI3GL9'G cr bGLl39'b uoMpGi }39'

bGobJG j 9' un iu juucwj IL0HpJG JJ9' HOqJ1IJ O JO2G

ijjj couJbGçG j 9'LG21AGJ2 9' COLIJIIJOIJ A1GA &IUOIJ p1121IJG

' coIub9'u? couL9'JuGq pX C9'bJç9'J OL Ju9'uc!9'J qi2LG2

qnc iii bLoqITcc iujç Jjrorrp 2omc o imbj?.

I19'? 113 MJJJCJJ 9' JLIIJ2 IJIJ9'IJCI9'J cOuq1iOu UJ9'? 9'GC iç cou-

OGLIJ GCOIJOUJJC2 GUGL9'G m&i? °I

Page 4: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

vi3n9q nasq Ii hsIimi .uoi no iiq brI91

1Jn9upno3 bas ivi i1sup iwoI ifio at rirr& quDInsd

iru3w sm ithis tquiInsd .s airiifi au io1 bnsm9b ri9dt 33nb1

dDJm at aoorb sm a3nihis nitqmo3 .9Dnq ati 13woI at ]o enq iwo1 won no nibn9qob ton io rzb E)3iIq aorIu

l9nluo nbth brum3b Isiibiai 3n{u uquDfrisd 3n{u

unuoDaib at 3nihis as bI sm qimlasd bno3 .a3nihis

in{inI idi Iqmi bkcoD ainiT .Iivs3nI 1om ann9v91 incuu1

ataoD ni±fiwa muano riuiw al9bonri iii as) a3i1q unrrnD

iii nnnevrn as as bwiv 9d 1153 9Dflq unruJ3 iswof r9dw

io (inuxñ 3n1u iii at fioiq xsrIin{ I9f1 JBLIt xnIa tIism ni asasirni 3ledw aIsbom nxoiaxJIIoD iii as) a3iIq tnYI1nD iwoI

niDnq sviisiqoo mo anoxsiv3b at bI sm ati tnuoDaib

noitiaoq isita 9nit isli3 sm DtqLrnIasd biin{T .(ioivr{d .) noititqmoo viaa31s iom at ti rnttrnmoD rnifi 3nltIo

-mon viaais eaI io (laii ioI 9Dn9I3h1q i nrnncbni d aiwnfuo io atnishianoD iibincpif niasini id .) noititq

-iii sm 3tqinAnsd JIsni'J .(anoi3s fsisnsm ninisiano3

ui 9aLrs3d afsvii n{t1sd iItsi3nsnfi d loivsnI9d iotsbsiq 3t1V

Iiao3 s Dnsnft at ririfi tqirnInsd 9n{t lo tiIids n{t uimil sm .isw

w1 n3d 9vsnf inIt how Is3it1onfu Ids19bianoD 9tiqaG

-boiq no at3 inta tsuiqsD 10 LsxDnsnft b eta Is3fliqm

Page 5: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

3

q hpiJJrb xmbjE T'I CPGAJTGL 9Jq C}J912ç6JIJ Taa2 uq ROAGUOCJ(

ffluIJ GAGIJ OL cp' EcGLIJ pIJJaIthçC?buc on oAGLp'bbJu LOi1G npGdnGuc puLIb4c?.

UO GAIqGUcG JJ9 C&LLJGL2 combGcin /AJçJJ p9iJJL1Ibç 9lLJiIJG CITc

ccç o ' coIJcGnthoLnGo1m 2cLJJ(G 9nç fIG ILJJIJG MG IJ

CPBcGL jj uq cjnruG m PG cononnqGq M!cp cv' '-

jrnG innjcucj? LGqncGq i bi.ic npGdIrGuc co IJJJu oL

O1TL 11J9'IOL p9IJJaHbcciGa oIJJ? OLTG 9JLJJIJG — E9GLU — 9bbGL2

2oIuGiiqJç JOMGL bLJcG2 p? cv qiacLG2Gq CgLLIGL ymou

miuçG in p9iJ]cLnbcc? jiu bbG9i 4O PG 92OCI9cGq Micp

91LJJnG biicju pGJIAioL 'Jcponp JIJ9IJc1j qiaçLG22 4JJ GJIJ-

JMT M' jnq j'cci' GAI€JGUCG cp&c puJcLrrbcc? bGL Gc2

qomGacic Lo1T4G: EGLII counucj yUJGL1C uqOfIL o fJGG IJJG921ILG p? irnmpi ot iccqjj) uq LMV (inrrL2 M' on cv'

(urI9i? jj) j,tpqie. (J,'JLcp T3J) yUJGL1C9 (p"iii. (2GBcGIJJPGL I3ftY coufuGcJ (DGcGLUpGL ToY bU yw

C9'LLiGL PGctAGGU J3 uq j: EGLU (JLcp iaY B9'u-

pom cj GAGIJ CP&BcGL II puJ(LrTbcc? fflIJ

on bLicrn pGJJAioL in cv' YILJIIJG rnqn2L? MG IJG

GAJqGUcG p LGboLpu cp GGC o p9'IJJaJTbcc 9iJUfJHGGWGU2

ncç 9LTG pGpAioL5 JJJJ crrq? couppnç co cp'GnrbiLicJ

Page 6: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

ao b2uGJ. LGCOL6 IU GC}J O 4JJG dfTLGL2 uJ?sGqUq ,iiuc? go (j LOJ162 i9 rucjnqGq ouj? rj MGLG 9uq LG AiI4ITJJ? UJG 2 O2G qGcL!pGq JU GAGLJU BOLGJJfGJIJ

O 4JJG q2Gç COU2fLflCJOLJ L6 9iJ!PIG LOUJ 911f}JoL

1uqic9G2 drnaç rn Mpicp cJ psiJjaubcc?. jpu occnLLGq

bCcicoL2 bLG2GUc ou JJC 291UC LoJTçC2 JJJJC pojq ACLcJc9J JiuG

JJC UOLIIJ9JJC bLJcC2 ACLG CLO22 TJJ uou-p9'ujanbc cow-

JGq buc OL pujarrb cLLiCL2 cp qpq J1uC2 urcG

dIwLçCL IPG 2oJiq JIIJC2 Ju rcp J11LG L&CG UOLUJ9-

(qx2çucC-qiu2cCq) OACL9'JJ qomC2cic ACLG bLJcG OL

A9JITC O GLO OL cJJ!2 rJoLwJ'JJcq bucc LGCC2 ILC2 CdfflTJ

mG24ic ou LOflC2 !IT 2C J-m1JC qJ2tJCC PJOCJC

91LJJIJC2 2rmbJCq buc co cJJG TACLG bLJcG IOL jj qo-

)OL 91LJJUC PUJaJ1BcCJG2 LOL CCP druLcGL UG COIJJbS'LC

EflLG2 (-q) buç bLicC LCIJ2 9LO1IUq cp IOIIL m-

1 b4G!U D6JJ14OL vLornJq JOL IuJ(LflbClGe

T.°IJ°M2.

2J01J 9iJ'J?2T2 OI BLJcC CJJJ'LTG2 IOL I'JI O[ p1UJCLIIBçCIC2

LJMJ2 IOL GC O JJC IOLTL IJJgloL pujarthcc? CAGIJç2 JSGLG2-

L2 cpC bLTciu CJJflJOL o pujanbc 9JLJJuC2 rnq JJGIL

puj jy) IOL cJJG dJTLcCL2 ILO j:j jJLoiijJ MC

DCbLcmGuc OI jurn2boLctciouJ2 TO ccjGc 2&IubJG (Dc-

IPG 91JJK212 UJ 4}J12 b9'bCL 12 ou I'LC2 LCCOL6 IIJ

Page 7: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

rrn no ni1fi DtqzrnInd lo r{t if1 nb1ooJ

-x nifas Ino {J ton w ioivrId niiiq nwo 2r1ihth

au o un9upadua nitq niiiq iii n&b hhffrI s fidirf

-n fqJn)1w3d 8I rIDuM i o 1oj1q .niffi qLwJnBd

tiiods ts siw iiq biIsmion anua rimnnon ifl 5Di1q fi ru 9nuID3b €r{T .sivs renbni nsrfu aI o

it&rbnx woId O?P ou OöJ of niqqoib) TBI aw qimIniud

sm irLt r1iror{iliu thnsmisq Iunisqq bn (ith -mb 31id mod61 s lo or1t r{uiw Th iquD!nd bnurorIoD

mr!J r{ o 3munoD iii abna air{T .boimq rn r{ ni bns AWT jr19niunoD .iIsns w iDtqImInsd moLsm 19r{to

-mq o vi6I3m ni1 b93ubm svsri ou uuqqs Ifs a9W sDimmA

eniffi Duqum.liIsd uirli mod dJnom 0 uriods abnm noiv

nir{iw brus AWT mo arLfnom 0 nirif 1w bnmf of bnmufm r!f -b of bIJnifruoD 2mth IsfrxninoD s3im9rnA uoI uu s mo 'ro brl3 9r{f r{iomrIi mth smsvs imfaubni of 3vxfsJm 3fluID

rLrfi r{f nas lo noifqx rff if f 1W .boimq Iqms b9Dubni nsrb ifmq fnnsmmq 'ro 93n3biv 3L1fiI 3bivomq

mfib LsiDnsrIft fsrff f3iJ bns niffi iDfqumInsd rIt d b9vmdo mol 9IdirIoqm d sm iç DfqumAr1sd rusrif mrffsm

Jurf ILsujjjv eer i i1.6IJp hno9 9d ni AiJa niisa 31{T 9W .s19voD iq 9vii9n in ini b9is9D bns 9nuIlth rfi nwob 9th bnuos iii gnbiiq iii nib n19ias1 r{thunuithb ionn

.Iiiia airli 1o j99!ft9 91T1i moil iq[r1)LnEd

Page 8: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

ll OG2 UOf 9qic12 tOL CJJ9LJG2 112 L9MC IJJ1X 2HCJJ 92 GCL92G2 Hip9ucLrTbc (OL 20012 p p9UJLflb) C9LLJGL bLG2Girç Jpi2 bbLo9cp6L2 OH LOflG2 Hi JJG 29JJJG TOOIIJ!IG qi2ç9ncG csçGoL? 9AG 110J,pG uoL1LwJJ9iOU i uoii ujçii o bLicG2 o uou-p9uJanb C9LLJ-

011 LO1JG qITLIII dnLçGLC9ICBI1OU2 JJ }JG p9uJ(LrTbf C9LL1GL T T0è2 2JJ916 0j L9C

2 yfl o HOIJ-p9IJJcLHbc C9LTAGL2 021 9 LOfl4G LG ncjnqq iLl

L0I1G2 JTJG J LGbOLç2 jJG2G LG21TJ2 0L 4JJ puJarfb 9'IL-

q12ucc-&q1fl2cGq uoLm9Jicq buc oL pc ' mcpq 2cc o

12 Cç1AG; JIG JJGLG0LG UX4 cjcirwcc &AGL CJJLliJG2 ill

2}JL 4JJL20J Mc 112G qciocc L0fIG2 013 MJJJCp CJIL1GL

cxJç L01T2 coiubjccj oi qLob pcjoM 4JJ LOlTçc

jem 0L 4JJ12 91JJ2212 2111Cc 1JIJ91JCjj qiaeLc22cq 11LJ1IJG2

LOflG2 AGL ffonçc CJJ9flG2 conjq bo2c Y BLpC11JYL bLop-

bLicc cpc? qo uo coITLoJ 0L C91JG2 m mix o

Mpijc ;J.rcc IJITLG2 bLoAJqc C011AGIJ1GIJ 2JTIJJIJJL? o r.cj-

Tf1LJJGL ii drwtcL ojJoM1IJ pIJja1Tbcc? :JI'•

pL1uJ(Lribcc iu o C2C2 combc;1coL2 bLrcc2 nrcccq

0L2 L912G IJ0LIUJiGq bLicc2 III 4JJG d111LcGL cJJGIL L1AJ qccpmcq

combcpçoL2 E0L JJ 0I1L 11J910L pujcLrrbc? GAGU2 combcçi—

jmç p9ujarrbc 9JLJ1uc2 AG oLccq qOMIJ 4pG bucc2 o JJGL

JiIJ2 111 fILG2 j(&-q)2 ijcc qo uoç 2IthbOLç cp' C0u4cLTç10IJ

2GLAG p?1 ccjJ p91JJarthc jJL 12 LcbLc2cIJccq p? cpc qpcq

pc bucm GJJ9?J0L 0 uoIJ-p9lljarthc C9LL1GL2 013 L0114G2

CJJ91JG2 ! 913 9iLJiI3G2 bLice bLGGLGIJCG2

Page 9: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

LOfl6 M}JGIIGAGL puJcLnb4 CgLL1GL }J9 9'ç J69 LOflG 2JL6Mpicp i 6CJLG2 p LfIb4cA CJCnçG buc C1UG2 Oil

9 J69f JJ LOfIçG 29LG ;iio dcwL6L2 pqor. fG driL;L luill Lonç& LOflG i iucJnqGq iu fG r piuJcLnbç CffLLIGLjo 2211LG p pu 21uhIJcuç couJbGçjçoL

11J1x.

&OL cowbçifoL2 o p1rIJcLflb4 1LJJIJG 2 L62flJ OJ LicpGLJ1U 1UJ1jLJA q.J12 GJGC conjq GiJGL9G 111CL6926q 1tA6L9G bLJcGep112111622 L9GjGL2 LG JJ6 L2 O ipuqou IJiJCJJJ? qi2çL6226q JL-611.6cc MJII jO!IGL J6 1A6L96 bLic6 LGboLcGq q 2 12 O6U 2rr62c6qO JJip6L fL6 p112111622 cLA6J6L2' LOL CLLJ6L Il p&uJ(Lnbcc?! cI.112tA6L6 ?J6jq OL puJ(Lnbc CLL16L2 qn6 q6cjiu6 iii bLoboLçioLJ

ruiijcu; oh iTOIJ2 (iupp cpi LOfI2)1 uq iç IJOL-

OIl OIJJ? 55 LO1JG B J3' JJO/AGAGIY E4LH JJ9'C LG4fflIJGCJ

JIlCG EGLU An4JTJJ? jri qoJu rn Jg (i Lmriuq cçiiOJJOiAIIJ JJG ptJJa1TIicc? ffluIJ LG IJO4 AGL? JUOLUJ9JAG

IJJJCJJ M92 Cic OIl ii JJG dJHrLGL JmarcqJ-

uthçc? bLoGcçioIl JJFq 1UcLGl2q p j OL 23 LOfTçG2 OIlGLH uouurJ1q BLIc ill j:j jr drILcL ïç jjjcq OL p9lJJ-

oo GJOA iuq112çLX AGLc coulLojjru OL qI2IJcG• E2-

GL GOLG ELU IJjGq OL ptIJJL11hcc? E2GLIJ bLIcG2 /I(GLG

2ç€LIJ LO1I iii 4JJG dnLçL o (J0: dsL-

JJ COJIIIIJIJ1 OL GX1IJJbJG JJOM2 1JJg OH 4JJC f

bLICG C9'JCJJJJpOIJ pLcJqOJJOhUIJ LOHL dff&LcL2 JJJG IJUGL O LO1JG HG in ccp

LGbOLç CJJU III bLICG2 LGJçJA 40 GIJCJJIJJLJ OAGL

dni PGLOIA 4JJG piJjwib4c? jjiu pc 2ilpcdJrGu LON2

JIIJG2 IJJG LJL2 LOJ JIJqJcçG2 4JJG JGAGJ OL uoLmjiq bLic

Page 10: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

p9uJarIbçc JJuJoluu p ujarrbc? ji p'q pcu dnsLGL2 bLioL ;p

1LJ1IJG BLIGG2 MGLG IJGLJ? 92 JJTJJ OL piJJGL Mo drrLçcL •OJ-

qGcJiuG2 tML J9'LGJ2 OIIG4 ill JL diTsiçGL EOL JJG2G 4JJL

bLJc bbrL psic qGcjJuGq p9iJJarrbcc? prrç JrG

UJ9IOL puJa11b4cJ coi u yiuucrn uq jjdrrIJf i pujarrbçc jrn i uo i.ii o 4G 4JJLG op

J! PAJJ!JG E92GLU 2IIpIJWJJ? JOMGLG T BL!CG ITpaG-

miq buc EGLG J3 JOIAGL 4JJIJ 4JJG? p9q GIJ

I4flPL O WLJCG JIIcJnqGq JU pLCJcGiiqq GLLOL O AGL9G 1U bffLGupGG

[1 [cu1 [o}(ooo!) (ooo@) (croT2) (ooTT)

c' c+ -oj -ooi +cyo -0000

[51 [o] [!] [o1(oou) (ooo) (ooo) (ooro)CIJIJG O 4--J -J55 +OOO +00N -OO'T2

[o] [e21 [a1 [u5](woo) (ooo) (ooo) (ooo)CJrnIT -5 4 +OOL -OO2 -OO! -OO2

[2] [e,w] [} [fJ](ooo) (ooo) (ooo) (ooo2)

cJrnIJc; -j +cyoj -ooo -oii -ooJ!' bL!CG -5 O.OO +WO OO OO2f

VILPIJG EGLU C0I!1JGIJ VIIJGL IA LLMY

VA6LG bL1C6 CPJG Oj CPI46I. fl 'flLJ!IJ6pJG J

Page 11: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

3

(2° WIUIWfiW pLG) cowbJfoL2JUCG OL O6 O 4G L0H62 pzJJcLnbc CLLI6L 1J92 UOJJJG UIIIJJpGL O LOHfG JU LG 2fl2G O fO6 ill

&sr bucG2 oi combGcJcoLe pq LI2CU p 00 OAGL cJJc bLG-

(;wo bGLioq GL qGcJrLJIJ p&IJfcLnbcc?k) bGuL-1/ipçq

cii iq iycq oLi eiuiGIJc coIubiçoL rn J33J

iuqiccc JJ OIJ JJG 005 °' °'JJP C"c!''cJ A9cp pujarib; ii.jiu j4pG coIxc!IIJcJ cojrnuu OL xiubj€

buç cJJC LG21TJ O JJT2 9'IJJ222 OL LiAJ o

MHWPGL O IJJLJCG2 !"J'qq Ill pLCJcGf.

GLIOL O GL9G !U bLGuJGG

[2011 [eosl [so!] [](ooo2) (ooo!) (ooio) (ooo3)CJUG co c+s +00!J +ooo +0050 +0002

[511 [oo1 [sss] [1(oos) (ooo!) (ooio) (ooo!)CJJIJG ° +i -0050 +IJiJ5f +0iJj +OOO.

[2801 [0081 [558] [aos](ooo) (ooo2) (ooo0) (ooo8)

cJrrn c-s +cyo -0008 -oojg +OiN3[0281 [o1 [si] [oo1

(ooo) (ooo3) (oo12) (ooo)c' c-s c-i +000j +0010 -0T50 +0012

[!31 [o21 [soil [oIbLIGG c c-s +0051 0000 00 000!Ec' oIJcrucIJcJ 'jmc Jc LMV

bLCG CPUG O C0mb6W0L2 ot CplbGL IT V!LHUG1PI6 5

Page 12: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

so

cj CLC o JLJIIJG ObLçiIJ nuq CJJbGL jj bLocrou pe

2JIJCG qLcnJioIr yIUGLJCflJ JJLJIIJG bLoprpJ? JJG IIJO2 to-

21X J&LG2I fl 'ILJTIJ€ JM IJO GIJGLG CJBcL jj

LGbLoqLrcG JJG JS LOlA O pTpJ rnqJAiq1nJfl? IOL CJJ o

IJCITJçJG2 OLT 4JJC pGJJTMoL O LJIJIJCT9JJ? MG9'J C&LLTL2 JpJG

oriçboju cp&u opGi. III J91HJIJ iuqrI2cL?2 IJ9IJcI&J qi-

LJAJ2 TWIJ9'LJ? GXGCHIAG2 OIUG 9'ILJIUG2 JJ9G GGLJ IJJOLG

&L mor jijj? JTUGL&JG ii bi.iciu M€JJGL

mbj pjçp? (qb bocj) CLL!LLG2boIJG mip qiGL joqcj OI bLGqcçoLX pGpcIioL 4OL x-

OLCPCJ iuoqj uq om bobmJgL rccorn bLicc

IFGG gIJJ?2G2 ]JIMG JJG BLJC 9CLO2 JJ LIA9J pap

p9njalibç 9'ILJJIJG JJAG OLCG cOmbGp4OL o joii. c}ii. bLicGIJ4G LGL JG GJJGUCG qoG uoç 2i1bboL4 4JJG cpnm cp

dLGL bLioL JJG prnjaurbcc? ffluIJ III JG 1J1TLC bLG-

pJJJGL (tOL ELU iq ymGLic Gç) jrrn iaOL bLJcG &r poap pTr (toL C0jjç!111J uq jji) OL

rçjnij diçr IoJJolAJu G&C pujwrbc? jrn combGp-pric m&4cJJGq Jç2 BLICG cap limç bLioL o i pujwibc? pu

LJAJ2 (oI lApJcJr oapjj yJLJIIJG2 i mo 2iunJcap) bba

GCJ1IJG anp2GdnGIJf po pijanbc? JçporJJJ 1mGLC9 MGE

GLLJGL2 /AGLG BLG2GIJç O'JJ cOuJbGpçOL2 bLJcG qo ioç cuq

iion Iorn. dnLL2 LJJA po LO1TG Oil lAJJICJJ 110 p9'IJJanb

Page 13: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

TI

JbbGq oIJ JJG 1IJo24 LOITG2 flV1L 4JJG UIJC1JJ 9JG2 Ooi JJG p'IJJLITbC1€ cj C&€ rn /IJJJCJJ yIu€L1c9'u OAGL-

iç bo-p LHbc? buc L€jçjjc o Juqn2çL2 UoLm iii

L4IIWPGL OJ uJ9ilC1 iucJnqGq 1119'IIqSLq GLLOL OY A€L9G IU bLsufp6

[1 [it1 ['s] [1(ooT5) (ooi) (oo) (oo55)fl2VTL +11113 +00!3 +11030 +(YO2

[331 [J30} [Tcf](ooT8) (ooo3) (ooT3) (ooii)

fluJçGq 00N 003 0038 +OOJ['I [o1 [t1 []— (woTo) (ooii) (ooe)2OfIc}JMGc 0'f -003 +0013 +OO'f

[ST] [ni] [oi(oo3) (oo31) (oo) (oo32)4OLJJ/Geç +11102 0018 +O +OOO

[f231 [1 [1 [ii}(ooo2) (ooo) (oo3T) (ooT3)

DJ +fYO +11O +11O +11011[5o21 [i] [](oo12) (ooo0) (oo15) (ooi)

yIIJGLJC9IJ +OiJO +OO -11021 +O05..

Comb60L

EGLIJ orJcJuGncJ IIJGL M LLMV

W1UJCLfIblVJLJJIJ6

C0mb6WoL OA6L [— +3] jjjuqoiiVJ b'4 CP'J ot1JPIG

Page 14: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

rzoih3o1q 11 19fq1irID rJxio ton wir! iI anihi ioLm 9ri

di rIuodLs 9iDqLmIn8d 4 Its o noqai iii hq ai bii 'InO ar{t lo 2 1no iii risflinia i asini nsrLt xom oJ anoqs ni HD 9Dfl tnskIini s woi{ binU

Itsi3asnfi f{t o no I9U bris a9ifqxmJrisd rno sili o sno

-oq linsfinoD atidirIxs boiisq irli niiub airi no -6191 on sd ot wusqqs sisci 4isisvO .sBnoqBs1 sriq svii

Isvii o asnoqsi snq bn ilitssr{ LsiDrIsnfI nsswisd qirlanoli

asiD qiwIrisd

-its tqnD!nsd isrlisdw ai stiJasvni sw iIidiaoq Lsnft A

icoirli rsr1 sIism niassnni d ioftsqmoD nTIf{ sniI

-oiq sDnq-non tsisqa io nsmsvoiqmx 9DiVis snq iswol

sdi o isIimi iIsris shxoi-bsibsm sic aift sW .anoliom

sldsT sIdJ aLroivslq sift ni asith sI61ui ot bsarc rbsoiqq

2 moiI sisrI ?IiiEm sisv snoi ssd nsasiq 1

11 isfqf3r{D io sIfl isiru sili ist1 isxsup 2 t{zioiift sioIsd

tird lism d bstrIisw 9Ii assisv sesdT .noibsJoiq

.bstr1isw illups sis ashsm sift Ii isIimi isv sis ifuasi siLt

21SfliSD riiIft SILt SiDq1JDInsd loism SILt i0 11101 Ifs nI

s iliiw SVIS ot a3IJnitnoD tL StLJO1 110 S15f{ tS)hsm 5B1SVB

O1 b lbouD siri i9*xm j119 1flO £ 9LL 9W {'ISVSWOII 9D ii1J nI e

bluow sd asid noiiD9I biovi oJ i9blo Iii 9LJ01 S lo noiuhni iol 9di moil 1n9i9fiib i9W -i boiisq iii noi19iii noiubni il Ii l1ui

boi19q 19SI [II flOfl9fl3 fIOiIJbfTi

Page 15: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

qcjrnq p? °. E€W ymcLJc' mqOi LfiG2 rIJq I4 m&4cGç 2JJLG OiJ JJ LIJJTJLJIIJ Q

c°'-"'cj JJq qLobbq GJOM io 2JJ9'L OIJo b2GuL J.tio drriçGL2 SIJGL 14 p9vJaJ1bcc?.

M2 CpAG OU LOU4G C1JLL?JIJ u 9i& o

EOL GxiubJ o dJiLGL poL iç pIJLnb4c qcj&rpoucc o Or. qcjiu oir. cp bGLioq

(wirnuniru prr.) GJçJJL LCIJJ1IJ pou couaçs'uç rn

JO IJIIUIUIITW LOU JIL€ fpLpOJq naq lu j bLioqI1ØUJPGL O ILJLC Tn

uqnq GLLOL OJ 9AELgG in

[1 [i](ooo) (ooo) (ooog) (ooo!)CPLTG -5 -OOO -0023 -OO3

[15] [o] [so} [flo](oos) (ooo) (ooo) (ooo!)-5 o -o -oois -oot -oon[] [5] [s1 [fli]

(ooo) (ooo) (ooo) (oooQ)CP -0T10 -OOO -0011 +OOT

[5} [sis] [}(ooo) (ooos) (ooo2) (ooo)CF'J 45 '° 4T -OO5 +0M10 -OOT +OO5

[f1} [] [i]yALG 2JJrLG ;4 -5 0125 0f03 0f35 0153yILJIUG E9CLU C01!IJC1J HJL M L/AV

A6LG L(G4 JJLG CJJJIJ62 °L pb4GL IT yILJiUG2JcIpJG .

Page 16: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

L0nç62 POMGAGL 20 9' AL? 21119'JJ L0flG }J9'2 AGL? JiçJG JUJ11G11CG 011 JJGo L0flG 2iG IPG coJnbnGq 2}J9'LG2 9'L6 LOL 9'jJ b26uGL2 011 JJ62p9'q 9' JJJJUJUJIIIIJ J IJJ9'LJ(G 2JJ9'LG III 9'JJ? o dn9'LGL2 LG9'LJG22

o Jj1626 C9'JCI1J9'çJOU2 JucJnqG 9'JJ LOflG2 011 MJC p9iq(Lnbc C9'LLIGL

2p9'Lc O 9'JJ L9C Oil I2 2cc Oi LOITG2 Ill c9'cp O 4JJE dnLccL2'10

d1TLçCL ot cisc [-+] MIIJqOM 1PIC LGboLç2 cisc C&LLJGL2

u? LO[I4G OIl MJJICJJ JJC p&IJfcLlTbc C&LLIGL jrq b2cucL2 III

CLLJCL2 2JJLG 0 LTMC ou JJ Lcjcuç oiicc qcijucq

coIubcpoL2 p CIJçCLIIJ IJGtA LOilG2 MC CX9'IIJIUG cisc p9'uJallbc

10 JIJAG2JG MJJGJJGL 9'ILJIIJG2 qcCJLar pSlJJCLThbcc2 JJLIJJ

piJjLiibçc2 jjrn'

jc 2C Oil LOITG2 cisc coupisrrcq co 2GLAG 2ITp2GdrIGIJc co cJJGIL

c'-'cis-''ci uq cxbcLicuccq IUOLG 211p2c9'uc19'J qccpuc2 III

IMV Jfl JJIJJGL bLOBOLcJOIJ O JJGJL OL1IUJ LOIIçG2 cprn qiq

WTIJJPGL O ItLIccc2 2O2JJLG c+ O'O Oi O.OJJLG c c+j O'ON 01J5 O'i32J' c c OJJ'f 0J.iO

JJLC c c-i o'ii Oi2c c- O•JL Oi2

VLHUG E2cGLIJ VIIJCL Mc IMY

VLIIU6 i'-' VII ff6J6AU jLJ(GVLGJI6 L1ILJC6 JJL6 O pbL TI

2

Page 17: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

12

C9idflJ!OU

LTJ cou.GJçioIJ Ju buc cpuc ijx€q pius ijc o cOupoj

OL JJG iLJJIJG-LOfIG COIJ4LOJ OL 21p2IJçJ9J UG9'JAG 2G-

CJJIJG2 IIJ UJLJG4 L1TCçITL JGq cpIni iu jo bLicG

rn qr b9a2GucL-p9q GLIJqS'JJJ rnqx O COULOJ IOL

ou iAGU LOuT 9 jiucpou o: CJ1LLGIJ iiq ouc-bGLJoq j&cq

cJJG dJT91çGL-ço-drwLçL 91JG JU jo 9'AGL9G bLJcG tOL 911 ILJJIJG

qirrn OIIL guthJG bLJoq o j3g:J 105f pf€ iuoqjiuoqj o 9iLJJu bLJcG iTiIJ OH jj p91rJaiTbc?. JJu

412 cçJou w LGboI4 Gim94G iLom u ccouomçLJc

II ECOUOmGD!C yuq?i2 o DcuJcLnbc?. E1LGC

cou2911ç

COUJJJGI4OL mjç JJ91G2 TbbG9L 4O IIJCLG9G OL Lcm9JIJ poiic

bLTcc2 up2Gdr1Grr

o pmprib 9LJG iuiu&Ju 01.

uq VUJL1C JJ91G JJ 2JJJJçJ? (J BGLCGU9G boiuç

(o bGLcGu boiu) iom o c+ fl1JCJUG

GUL1IJ CPB€L IF O'1J C0U!UGUc9'L 291G LI2 jijiçj?

CJT2 JJ9 C91L? O!1 piTç qGcJJu 9IGL

1rr bLioL 4O qcCJ91JU p Lib4c? COUçGIJ içj buc

pIJcLnbcc qGcJ91çJOU }!OL JJG OJJGL LGG JLJ1rJG JJgLG Li

GxbGcq EGLU JJ91C qLob ipçruçi'jj 91orruq qiG

Page 18: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

1JI!L 113 f6G OflL ASiWJG2 LLOUJ }J6 bLGAion2 dnL-poG ao LOJJOMHJ iJq JQ qA tOIJOMLU p9uJcLnbcc?driGu dnLL 2JIJJIIL ALJpJG L6 q6jUGq OL p6 buoq ao qr?oil AJ11G rn JJI2 dflL46L O( JJ9 ?6L iJq jOL ijcpG dnL6L o AGL MorJJq ;jJJ ILJTU6 q6cJLGq psiq(LJ1bcC? ou fl oIJG-fplLq o JJ6 /OP6LAG CLLJGL 6CJLG prJJcLnbcc? uq OUG jpn idIILGL O qsuum? ALipJG JJç i GLO flUITJ 180 92 G(OLG cpGLAG CLLJ6L GIJG 2 LJJGU NJpiU 91p O ALIpJ6 iUqJcffçG pucuibcc? 0L cp op-

JJJG 2JTUJ O JJC BLJCG CJJIJ2 OAGL OITL bGLoq2

in' q o j q? uq io io qr22 pujwibçc?

bLJoqa: jg o oo uq o c° o qJ?2 pujcuibçc4JJSç cJJGJL CO CJGIJ42 LGUGC bLJcc cp&u oicr. cpLcG-IuoIJcp

puJcLnbc oi pruyi.rib coIubi;oL J 2C9JC 4?JJC2G AS'LJpJG2 20

cprnc ju buc€ oi uou-pujarrbç 9JLJrnG2 ou LOG2 !Ai4JJ

rn bLJcG joi pujaub iLJiu acouq UG9 GL9G

TI p9ujarthcc? JJJG IJL2 }JG IL1G CJJ9IJG

cbnLG JJ [GC2 O iWbGIJqiU 01. LGCGIJJ? qGcJLq CP

pj iIJcJuqG o iuqic9çoL ALJpJG2 qG2iuGq o

cnJ pG GxcJrrqGq Lom JJG 2bGcnJc&pow

UGC4GUG22 9iJ 9iLbo4 qolurimircc — 2rqJCJGuçJ?. uijj

J2 TiLb0Lç C0UG2çJ0IJ JJ9LJG4 qGu2JfX UG4M0LJ( !UcGLC0U

icJJ? iucpTqGq in cLoa2-aGCpouJ moqGJ2 ot 9iLJiuG bucc JGAGJ2 —

922flllJG2 pç O&On JIJ }JG LGUJflU1U A&Li9pJG2 Th-

pujanbçc UJG2HLG2 qG2cLipGq pGJoiA jp moqj Jiubpcij?

0L GHGLTJ ILJ1IJG bucG IJJ0AGG1J2 OAGL IIUG niq 2G 0

Page 19: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

1!

JuCpTqGq Ill JJG LGLG2TO1JBcx LP v1B = --JTbiuc OU L01146 O &UOçpGL CLLTGL MIf}1 UOIJ-GLO AJflG OMO dnLçGL2 o GIJçGLJu CPB6L IJ "'O}JGL CLLJGL oil O26LAGJ L0flç6 EOL JLJIIJ6 UO LU OL !M4piuiou jjJ 2Gconq oj /LJpJ6 rUqic96 fG prnjcLnbcc?cCL' 7'A 'o1' = — —V LG iucJIIqGq LU JJG LGL62-

G9IJIGL JJGLG i IJO JIJqJcSJoIJ O Tp2l9LTciJ GJJ'IJG

4J112 JOMGL bLJcc JGiGJ oi cj 2J1pGdnGu uu moucjJ

ffl!11 OL CFBcGL p?. UIJ UAGL9€G o 2Q9 Jq IJJTunI

pIJJcLrIbçc bLoccçiou C11ç JJG1L BLICG 0 O 180 PGtOLG

JJJJG LG2HJ4 ill 21G 4JJ 91LJ1IJG JJ IJJG OL

jijcj? iIJqrzcG pGGLo2JcGq2cJcil*

p? JJG IJJTIJJGL O b2uL Ill 4JJI2 LGLC2JOIJ U2 JJJ2 MOITJq pG

flLG uq bLGAiona O2GLAOU ¶LG IJO MGIJJG

LGJTçJOU O LG2Iq.r19'J2 9'CL022 CLL1GL OIJ IUG LOJIçG flIJJ1JG

&LG q1iGq OL pçGLo2GqicJ uq couçwboL9'uGona COL-

iu ccp dnLçGL I.LOIIJ 88:1 5f JJJG 91Jq9Iq GLLOL

J3 LOJTG OL tAJJICJJ MG opaGLAGq U JG 3J B98GUL qITL-

JJG moqj p? oiqnwL? JG9 diTLG niu

LGLC21OIJ J?2i

GXJç LOJTG OL qLob GJOM JJG jj JJ9IG JJLG2OJ uI2G ru

qIuiIJ oiu O2GLAJU bGuoq Jj.Joip pujanb 1LJIIJG2 qo

11 JJu J,4ouG o iu orn. rnthJG Gxiç cpbGL IT

o IJJoIJçJJ GOLG r'q GIJqJIJ 0 IJJOIJ}Th 9GL pG qrç O CP

iuqicG2 }JG 11G4 CJJUG iu bLJcc qJ1LiIJ JJG IAIUqOM pGiIJuiu

Page 20: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

iuoq€ (o) buc qcjrn p combçioL2 wpu JJGxjiipiç JiflJC BLICG L€bOu2G pGJJUJOL JJJJG LG2IIJç2

rn bLicJu pJJ9'AJoL oJJoiIuLT JJG p9'uJanbc? JHJ CombG!-

G1JGC 1OL GCJJ d1I9LGL UO L€boLGqnpGL-qnGq GLLOL !u bLsuyGa€

(ooio) (ooo)[-To+Tgo] +o.oji

(ooo@) (ooo)oo-jo Cpb TI +ooo +ooo

(ooo) (ooo)o-o q' cvb ji -o.oo +O.OO

(ooo) (ooo2)OO q GOLG CP'b IT -OOOT +OOI

(ooo) (ooo)OJO q? PGtOL cpb ii -o.o3o

E'q b'1 CP" LJUG CombGWoLDJuILflbc

(ooo)llEBTEll4DVllF' +OOO

(oolo)FIEEIDYHI OOO

(oooo)DFBI5ICE'

WWPGL °T. OPGLAc!0U: @!TGbuqGIJc J\rL: DFbI{IGE (=ju

BJUJCLflb4 VLIIIJG uq CombG0LE!Ilq bL! CPfUG2 O(

e

Page 21: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

TO

pq jmo uo ou btunuGç6L o rnfGLGm1J6 pnj JIrcp içpJu cp dITLGL I1JCJ!01J O ALJpJG2qcc JucJfTqiu C9LLJGL xGq 6JGCf IJq JxGq GIJGC2 OL G9CP 100O° 69CJJ qiJJGLGu LLOLJJ S6L0 M6 I° fGGr ;imsq G .-f-226\o uq uç bL!cG cprn o combGiçoL i

UJIUIIJJHJJJ 2JJLG' ;p uç bLicG CJJ1IJG O 4JJG puJuJTbf CLLJGL}JLG IOL LOfl6\CLL!6L\drTi4GL opGLAçiorJ p iucJnqGq niIJJJJG flGq OL LGLGJOIJ LGdniLGq LOflG

combcçioL2 bLIGG GJJ9iJG2 iu ota iuoqj 2UJGG JOM cOuthGçicoL2

qGci2Jou 2GGIIJ2 IUO2 JTJGJ? op O

JJG CoucJi1210u JJ9 COIJJbGpOL2 qo uo4 LG2JJOUq priJjwibç

JG GuqoGuGJ O pTuJarth4c? 12 nuJiJGJ? JJO/AGAGL O cjnrnc

pc moqj 4p cOIJcLipncG2 jumciJ qGcJiuG JJJJG b0221-

mxiiuiiu LG2bou2G 2OIIJG GXOGIJOJ12 2JJOCJ omiccq LOIIJ

IIJA cJJGIIJ2GJIG2 JJAG JuqtIcGq JHJ OL IJJr2 G bLojç-

IJG JOM bLicG2 TBBGcL

o çJJG prJJanbc-bLiciu COLLGJPOU MG 0p2GLAG

JJAG uo 'qqLG22Gq in uJ2i2 1p12 Li2G2 driG2pou2 rponç

BJLITBC JJIJ 12 lc2GJt GIJOGUOJ12 U 12211G JJS MG

GLOJ

uq +jj OL i coIubGçJçoL2 GgCJJ 2c T2cicJJ2 qJ1GLGIJc LOW

pujanbc? uuonucmcuç !2 OL JJG pujanbç CflLJGL

IJIG uç CJJ9flG in bLICG2 OAGL G9i-JOu MUJOM Lonuq 4JJG

IJJOLG cpu O1J2G4 p bLJCG JIJCLG2G2 OACL JJG 2np2GdnGu nJoIJp2

o-pG-pIJJ<LrTb C&LLIGL C1142 12 BLJCG2 pirç rbbGa2 G

Page 22: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

r{ir{ rurIt arIaib IiiiDrIsr1fi D1xbni o 11i1 iom lfi enq .Dnq a1odsqmoD

noiiibnoD .111

riiwo lo ai aiaib IiDasnft iii nnft lo ioivsr{d dT r1 iii .19)thm iiIoq 3iIduq bru &im9bJ i{od o i3ifli

bsLJ3 3vBf{ ivido bnii atnBqiDihBq asm iaubni enihi

rinsm iii niiiq ?ro qimInd 11 iqr{D bnu mift mO .vImth oi a IIw a aIoJ9qfr1oD iirli o viine

-is lo HoXq53x9 3Idfon it rIiw r{t aDibni aiLfihI Ibom 'GIno iiq iirLt bnsf{D 3vs11 ariiFii qiroIrd rn

9rIiIDb ivs as r1tiw .11 tqsr{D riiin lo 9mit sr{t briuoi -Difla3b irliiri 9d im in iiq B rbu .ILsivo IiodB lo

3rL o arxoqi aniud Isnoii s rrIsi Jiid iqom ion vi IBiDliJ3flfi Hi 3fHhiB as brrnomce srL txozirqi bubi

srf 9Dn9biv 9r{t d bioqqu i nOiB9iqini icIT .esiib ot flO3i flu B9DfI Bi)VS ii9fli iwoI oh iothqmoD

a3nuIlis tqirn1nsd c{i has rnIii IquDInsd d nithn cthq

.axn iiq iii{I iqb 9uBf{ krsm HL8 Ofl oh

Page 23: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

fl e°''"c bL!I!H OTE V1I1T24 J00T

gcboLç uq fl1J2JJJIJçOU DCjrnG JuqJTL? CPJJGUG uq CombG4!o11: V

JJJ' W°'J C°"°' c E'" LOU CombGc!4!A6 ya-

2I4 IJIT1L?BTJ2TOIJ 'q CIO!11 DC!0112 UJIIJJGO JILq1TG LIJ!AGL-

LOqJTC t[LJ llJMJJL?. 'f 13 EXm!U!OU O EKOAGIJOCJ D''!J OOLJOU bF!Jflb cb!iJ 1IJq

iqGtJcG HJTllJGO flUiALJç? °. 'pllf13'LX

b4Gcçiou vq c°'ii jJ'LJu1b: JjJGOL? uq EA-CJ311L y1q rnq Dq 2cpI4.2cnJ cbJ I/9'LJCG1 Tm-

m IJJIWGO flU!/GL2!c? o Gb;GmpcL Jfyii EIUBJLJCJ o rrbGLIu&LJç bL!C-

CPGJ9'J!GL 'qp Cb!I L1TGçflLG rnq r.oq1Tc [&LJ

i1rr2ç io(Y bb @-O3D°' m fl V1LJJIJ wq

BOLG11cG!11 GALIIJ 9uq 1,IJC? J' O2G tqT{EEEIE4CE

Page 24: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

(ffcCYAG O pJqnçLA VAGLG)EL6 I E6LU iiq COmbGc!c0L ELC62

- cow beoLa— E6LU

(IGl!A juqnçL? vILG)IJ1LG jp: c°'"ci "q C1 bGTçOL bLICG2

-5oe•

-oe-

::2e

,..—--.--—-.-.-..—

...1

Page 25: $IElqAq I5IH - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · i1oq noiuib ai mo ivdo v&1 burB Uuli ni!iii iii thi3n1nu1 iib 'hEIu3iflBq oth niB1qo ibnu iiqD 11 o1qtm1nBd

(IGJc!AG o j1IqnL? yAcLc)LrIa6 jq: L.MV 'q C0IDb6"oL BLiC99:4 80:4 84:4

-(J.-83:4 •834

• Cowbeioa

-42 — -

EITI_42

(c'IwA' o vA6Lff6)E!ITLG JC: yIU6LTC MGI uq C0mbG"10L bLICGe

99:4 984804 84:4 85:4 83:4

-50 COW bej!joLa .—VW!C M6-Io.p