12
1 S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES 1 1.1/1 1.1/1 NO CHANGES NIL 2 1.2/1 1.2/1 NO CHANGES NIL 3 1.3/1 1.3/1 NO CHANGES NIL 4 1.4/1 1.4/1 NO CHANGES NIL 5 1.5/1 1.5/1 NO CHANGES NIL 6 2.1/1 2.1/2 7 2.2/2 2.2/2 NO CHANGES NIL 8 2.3/2 2.3/2 NO CHANGES NIL 9 -- 3.1/2 10 3.1/2 3.2/2 NO CHANGES NIL 11 3.2/2 3.4/2 NO CHANGES NIL 12 -- 3.3/2 13 3.3/2 3.5/2 NO CHANGES NIL 14 3.4/2 3.6/2 NO CHANGES NIL 15 3.5/2 3.7/2 NO CHANGES NIL 16 3.6/2 3.8/2 NO CHANGES NIL 17 3.7/2 3.9/2 NO CHANGES NIL 18 3.8/2 3.10/3 NO CHANGES NIL 19 3.9/2 3.11/3 NO CHANGES NIL 20 3.10/2 3.12/3 NO CHANGES NIL 21 3.1 1/2 3.13/3 NO CHANGES NIL 22 3.12/2 3.14/3 NO CHANGES NIL 23 3.13/2 3.15/3 NO CHANGES NIL 24 3.14/2 3.16/3 NO CHANGES NIL COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42 ND  AND 43 RD  EDITION CLAUSE No / PAGE.No. 42ND ED. CLAUSE No/ PAGE No. 43RD ED. DESCRIPTION OF CHANGES IN 43rd Ed. w.r.t. 42 nd  Ed. SEVEN NEW REERENCES HAS !EEN ADDED."HE REERENCES ARE AS OLLOWS # E94$E165$E213$E273$E309$ E570 % E709 SEVEN NEW REERENCE S"ANDARDS /CODES "O !E PROCURED  CALI!RA"ION SHALL !E "RACEA!LE "O NIS" OR E&UIVALLEN" ORGANI'A"ION ALL (AS"ER INS"RU(EN" CALI!RA"ION SHALL ! E "RACEA!LE "O NIS" OR E&UIVALLEN" ORGANI'A"ION S"A"US O CALI!RA"ION "O !E CHEC)ED NEW (IN. COLD E+PANSION SHALL !E 0.3, O OD OR CIRCU(ERENCE OR ALL U"URE PROEC" (IN. COLD E+PANSION (US" !E 0.3, "O !E (AIN"AINED I" WAS NO" SPECIIED IN 42ND EDDI"ION

Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 1/12

1

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

1 1.1/1 1.1/1 NO CHANGES NIL2 1.2/1 1.2/1 NO CHANGES NIL

3 1.3/1 1.3/1 NO CHANGES NIL

4 1.4/1 1.4/1 NO CHANGES NIL

5 1.5/1 1.5/1 NO CHANGES NIL

6 2.1/1 2.1/2

7 2.2/2 2.2/2 NO CHANGES NIL

8 2.3/2 2.3/2 NO CHANGES NIL

9 -- 3.1/2

10 3.1/2 3.2/2 NO CHANGES NIL

11 3.2/2 3.4/2 NO CHANGES NIL

12 -- 3.3/2

13 3.3/2 3.5/2 NO CHANGES NIL

14 3.4/2 3.6/2 NO CHANGES NIL

15 3.5/2 3.7/2 NO CHANGES NIL

16 3.6/2 3.8/2 NO CHANGES NIL

17 3.7/2 3.9/2 NO CHANGES NIL

18 3.8/2 3.10/3 NO CHANGES NIL

19 3.9/2 3.11/3 NO CHANGES NIL

20 3.10/2 3.12/3 NO CHANGES NIL

21 3.11/2 3.13/3 NO CHANGES NIL

22 3.12/2 3.14/3 NO CHANGES NIL

23 3.13/2 3.15/3 NO CHANGES NIL

24 3.14/2 3.16/3 NO CHANGES NIL

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

SEVEN NEW

REERENCES HAS !EEN

ADDED."HE

REERENCES ARE AS

OLLOWS #

E94$E165$E213$E273$E309$

E570 % E709

SEVEN NEW REERENCE

S"ANDARDS /CODES "O !E

PROCURED

 CALI!RA"ION SHALL

!E "RACEA!LE "O NIS"

OR E&UIVALLEN"

ORGANI'A"ION

ALL (AS"ER

INS"RU(EN"

CALI!RA"ION SHALL !E

"RACEA!LE "O NIS" OR

E&UIVALLEN"

ORGANI'A"ION S"A"US

O CALI!RA"ION "O !E

CHEC)ED NEW

(IN. COLD E+PANSION

SHALL !E 0.3, O OD

OR CIRCU(ERENCE

OR ALL U"URE

PROEC" (IN. COLD

E+PANSION (US" !E 0.3,

"O !E (AIN"AINED I"

WAS NO" SPECIIED IN

42ND EDDI"ION

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 2/12

2

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

25 3.15/3 3.17/3 NO CHANGES NIL

26 -- 3.18/3

27 -- 3.19/3

28 4.1/3 4.1/3 NO CHANGES NIL

29 4.2/3 4.2/4 NO CHANGES NIL

30 4.3/4 4.3/4 NO CHANGES NIL

31 5.0/5 5.0/6 NO CHANGES NIL

32 5.1/5-6 5.1/6-7 NO CHANGES NIL

33 5.2/7 5.2/8

34 5.3/7 5.3/8 NO CHANGES NIL

35 5.4/7 5.4/8 NO CHANGES NIL

36 5.5/7 5.5/8 NO CHANGES NIL

37 5.6.1/8 5.6.1/8 NO CHANGES NIL

38 5.6.2/8 5.6.2/8

39 6.1/8 6.1/8 NO CHANGES NIL

40 6.2.1/8 6.2.1/9 NO CHANGES NIL

41 6.2.2..1/9 6.2.2..1/9

42 6.2.2./9 6.2.2./9

43 6.2.3/9 6.2.3/10

44 6.2.4/9 6.2.4/10 NO CHANGES NIL

45 6.2.5/10 DELE"ED

46 6.2.6/10 6.2.5/10

 INS"RU(EN" SHALL !E

S"ANDARDI'ED "O AN

AR!I"RAR*

ND" INSPEC"ION

INS"RU(EN" SHALL !E

S"ANDARDI'ED

DEINA"ION O UNDER

CU" HAS !EEN

CHANGED

 DEINA"ION O UNDER

CU" SI(PLIIED

(IN. COLD E+PANSION

SHALL !E 0.3, O OD

OR CIRCU(ERENCE

OR ALL U"URE

PROEC" (IN. COLD

E+PANSION (US" !E 0.3,

"O !E (AIN"AINED I"

WAS NO" SPECIIED IN

42ND EDDI"ION

HEA" % LO"

"RACEA!ILI"*

RE&UIRE(EN" AS PER

SR 15.2

 

"RACEA!ILI"* "O !E

DONE OR ALL PSL2 PIPE

LO" "RACI!ILI"* WAS

SPECIIED IN 42ND

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

ERW PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

ERW PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

"HIS CLAUSE

REERED !END "ES"

ACCEP"ANCE CRI"ERIA

UP "O 2.37 OD

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

WELD DUC"ILI"* "ES"

NO" "O !E DONE OR ALL

U"URE PROEC"

OR ALL GRADES

SHEAR AREA O EACH

SPECI(EN SHALL !E

REPOR"ED OR EACH

HEA"

REPOR"ING O SHEAR

AREA IS (ANDA"OR* OR

ALL PSL2 PIPE

I" WAS NO" (ANDA"OR*

IN 42ND EDDI"ION

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 3/12

3

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

47 7.1/10 7.1/10 NO CHANGES NIL48 7.2/10 7.2/10 NO CHANGES NIL

49 7.3/11 7.3/11 NO CHANGES NIL

50 7.4/11 7.4/11 NO CHANGES NIL

51 7.5/11 7.5/11 NO CHANGES NIL

52 7.6/11 7.6/12 NO CHANGES NIL

53 7.7/11 7.7/12 NO CHANGES NIL

54 7.8/12 7.8/12 NO CHANGES NIL

55 7.8.1/12 7.8.1/12 NO CHANGES NIL

56 7.8.2/12 7.8.2/12 NO CHANGES NIL

57 7.8.3/12 7.8.3/12 NO CHANGES NIL

58 7.8.4/12 7.8.4/12 NO CHANGES NIL

59 7.8.5/12 7.8.5/12 NO CHANGES NIL

60 7.8.6/12 7.8.612 NO CHANGES NIL

61 7.8.7/12 7.8.7/13 NO CHANGES NIL

62 7.8.8/13 7.8.8/13 NO CHANGES NIL

63 7.8.9/13 7.8.9/13 NO CHANGES NIL

64 7.8.10/13 7.8.10/13 NO CHANGES NIL

65 7.8.11/13 7.8.13/13 NO CHANGES NIL

66 7.8.12/13 7.8.12/13

67 7.8.13/13 7.8.13/13 NO CHANGES NIL

68 7.8.14/14 7.8.14/14

69 7.9/14 7.9/14 NO CHANGES NIL

70 8/14--15 8/15 NO CHANGES NIL

71 9.1/15 9.1/15 NO CHANGES NIL

72 9.2/15 9.2/15 NO CHANGES NIL

73 9.3.1.1/15 9.3.1.1/15

74 9.3.1.2/16 9.3.1.2/16 NO CHANGES NIL

75 9.3.1.3/16 9.3.1.3/16 NO CHANGES NIL

DEINA"ION O UNDER

CU" CHANGED

DEINA"ION O UNDER

CU" SI(PLIIED

 

ID/OD "O !E

CONSIDERED AS A

DEEC" WHEN I"

E+CEEDS 12.5, W"

!O"H "HE SIDE SHALL !E

CONSIDERED

 

SPECI(EN OR

SEA(LESS PIPE. NO"APPLICA!LE "O LSAW

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 4/12

4

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

76 9.3.1.4/16 9.3.1.4/16

77 9.3.1.5/16 9.3.1.5/16 NO CHANGES NIL

78 9.3.2/16 9.3.2/16

79 9.3.3/16 9.3.3/16 NO CHANGES NIL

80 9.3.4/16 9.3.4/16 NO CHANGES NIL

81 9.3.5/16 9.3.5/17 NO CHANGES NIL

82 9.4/17 9.4/17 NO CHANGES NIL

83 9.5/18 9.5/18 NO CHANGES NIL

84 --- 9.6/18

85 9.6/18 9.7/18

86 9.7.1/18 9.8.1/18

NEW "A!LE 14A HAS

!EEN ADDED OR

SELEC"ION O ROUND

!AR "RANSEVERSE

"ENSILE SPECI(EN

ROUND !AR "RANSVERSE"ENSILE SPECI(EN O

DIA 6.4 (((IN

PER(I""ED.

EARLIER "HE SPECI(EN

DIA WAS 8.9 (( (IN

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

ERW PIPE$LASER

WELDED PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

 

SHALL !E DONE RO(

E+"ERNAL % IN"ERNAL

SURACE.VISUAL

INSPEC"ION CAN !E

REPLACED !* O"ER

INSPEC"ION (E"HOD

"HA" HAVE A

DE(ONS"RA"ED

CAPA!ILI"* O

DE"EC"ING SURACE

VISUAL INSPEC"ION

SHALL !E DONE RO(

E+"ERNAL % IN"ERNAL

SURACE

EARLIER "HE

SIDEIN"ERNAL/E+"ERNA

L WAS NO" SPECIIED

 

"RAINED "O DE"EC" %EVALUA"E "HE

SURACE

I(PEREC"ION AND

HAS "HE VISUAL

ACUI"* AS PER "HE

REUIRE(EN" O ASN"

RECO((ENDED

PRAC"ICE NO. SN"-"C-

1A OR E&UIVALLEN"

OR VISUAL

"RAINING O INSPEC"OR

OR VISUAL INSPEC"ION

IS NOW (ANDA"OR*

EARLIER I" WAS NO"

(ANDA"OR*

&UALIICA"ION O

ND" PERSONNEL IS AS

PER ASN"

RECO((ENDEDPRAC"ICE NO. SN"-"C-

1A OR E&UIVALLEN"

E+CEP" OR VISUAL

(E"HOD

&UALIICA"ION O ND"

PERSONNEL IS(ANDA"OR*

EARLIER I" WAS NO"

(ANDA"OR*

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 5/12

5

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

87 -- 9.8.2/19

88 9.7.2/18 9.8.3/19

89 9.7.2.1/18 9.8.3.1/19

90 --- 9.8.3.2/19

91 9.7.3.1/19 9.8.4.1/19

92 --- 9.8.4.2/19

93 -- 9.8.4.3/19

94 -- 9.8.4.4/20

 

IN "A!LE 27 43RDEDI"IO $O"HER "HAN

SURACE INSPEC"ION

AND WALL "HIC)NESS

VERIICA"ION

!ALANCE INSPEC"ION

SHALL !E DONE AS PER

AS"( S"ANDARD OR

E&UIVALEN"

S"ANDARD AS

OLLOWS -

E570$E309$E213$E273$E709$

 

AS"( S"ANDARD OR

E&UIVALEN" S"ANDARD

AS OLLOWS -

E570$E309$E213$E273$E709$E9

4 % E165 SHALL !E (ADE

AVAILA!LE

 

SEA( UL"RASONIC

"ES"ING IS ESSEN"IAL% ULL LENG"H O

WELD SEA( R" IS NO"

RE&UIRED UNLESS

AGREED !E"WEEN

PURCHASER AND

ULL LENG"H WELD

SEA( RADIOGRAPH* ISNO" RE&UIRED UNLESS

AGREED !E"WEEN

PURCHASER AND

(ANUAC"URER 

200 (( END

RADIOGRAPH* SHALL

!E DONE

200 (( END

RADIOGRAPH* SHALL !E

DONE AS AGAINS" 203 ((

IN 42ND

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

SEA( LESS PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

"HE (A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN

UNCHANGED

ONL* CLAUSE NO.CHANGED

RADIOLOGICAL

SENSI"IVI"*

REERENCE S"ANDARD

SHALL !E AS PER AS"(

HOLE "*PE I&I$AS"(

WIRE "*PE I&I OR ISO

WIRE "*PE I&I

AS"( HOLE "*PE

I&I/AS"( WIRE "*PE I&I

AND ISO WIRE "*PE I&I

SHALL !E (ADE

AVAILA!LE

AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I

SHALL !E AS PER AS"(

E1025.I&I SELEC"ION AS

PER "A!LE 1643 RD

EDN.

AS"( E1025 SHALL !E

(ADE AVAILA!LE

 SHALL !E AS PER ISO

1027 % AS"( WIRE "*PE

I&I SHALL !E AS PER

AS"( E747.SELEC"ION

O I&I IS AS PER "A!LE

18 % 20 43 RD EDN.OR

ISO AND AS"(

PENE"RA(E"ER

ISO1027 % AS"( E747

SHALL !E (ADE

AVAILA!LE

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 6/12

6

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

95 9.7.3.7/19 9.8.4.5/20

96 9.7.3.9/20 9.8.4.6/20 CLAUSE NO. CHANGED

97 9.7.3.10/20 9.8.4.7/20

98 9.7.3.11/20 9.8.4.8/20

99 -- 9.8.4.9/20

100 9.7.4.1/20 9.8.5.1/20

101 9.7.4.2/20 9.8.5.2/20

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

D*NA(IC (E"ODS

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

"HE (A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN

UNCHANGED

ACCEP"A!LE SI'E AND

DIS"RI!U"ION O SLAG

O R" IS AS PER "A!LE

21 % 22.43 RD EDN.

ONL* "A!LE NO

CHANGED$ (A""ER

RE(AIN SA(E

 

I(PEREC"ION

GREA"ER IN SI'EAND /OR DIS"RI!U"ION

"HA" SHOWN IN "A!LE

21 AND 22 43 RD EDN.

ARE CONSIDERED

DEEC" AND DIS

POSI"ION O

DEEC"IVE PIPE AS PER

ONL* "A!LE NO

CHANGED$ (A""ER

RE(AIN SA(E

RADIOGRAPHS SHALL

!E "RACEA!LE "O "HE

PIPE IDEN"I"*

"RACEA!ILI"* O

RADIOGRAPH

(ANDA"OR*

"HE (A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN

UNCHANGED

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

 

"HIC)NESS O

REERENCE PIPE AS

PER S"IPULA"ED

"OLERENCES O "HIS

SPEC."*PE AND

DI(ENSIONS O

REERENCE

INDICA"OR "O !E

VERIIED !*

DOCU(EN"ED

PROCEDURE. "HE

DOCU(EN"EDPROCEDURE "O !E

USED OR SE""ING

REEC" "HRESOLD.

DI(ENSIONS AND "HE

DIS"RI!U"ION O "HR

PROCEDURE OR

REERENCE INDICA"OR

DI(ENSIONAL

VERIICA"ION $

PROCEDURE OR

"HRESHOLD LEVEL

SE""ING ARE RE&UIRED.

"OLERENCE IN

DI(ENSION OREERENCE PIPE IS

CHANGED.

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 7/12

7

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

102 -- 9.8.5.3/21

103 9.7.4.3/20 9.8.5.4/21

104 -- 9.8.5.5/21

105 9.7.4.4/20 9.8.5.6/21 CLAUSE NO. CHANGED

106 9.7.5/21 9.8.6.1/21

107 9.7.7/21 9.8.7/22

108 9.8.1/21 9.10.1/22

109 9.8.2.1/22 9.10.2.1/22

 

(AIN"AINEDINCLUDING

S"ANDARDISA"ION AND

OPERA"ING

PROCEDURE$

E&UIP(EN"

DESCRIP"ION $

PERSONNEL

&UALIICA"ION$

D*NA(IC "ES" DA"A

DE(ONS"RA"ING "HE

S*S"E( A!ILI"* OR

UPGRADA"ION O "ES"

REPOR" RE&UIRED.

REGARDING

ACCEP"ANCE CRI"ERIAO U" "HE (A""ER IN

"HE CLAUSE RE(AIN

UNCHANGED "A!LE NO.

CHANGED. "A!LE 2343

RD EDN.

CLAUSE NO. AND "A!LE

NO CHANGED

DISPOSI"ION O

DEEC"S O U" SHALL

!E AS PER CL 9.9

DEPENDING ON NA"URE

O DEEC" PIPE (A* !E

REPAIRED/CU" O OR

REEC"ED

REGARDING DEEC"S

OUND !* U" IN "HE

WELD $ (A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN

UNCHANGED

"HIS CLAUSE

REGARDING (PI IS OR

SEA( LESS PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

REGARDING RESIDUAL

(AGNE"IS( "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

REGARDING (E"HOD

O CHE(ICAL

ANAL*SIS "HE (A""ERIN "HE CLAUSE

RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

REGARDING (E"HOD

O "ENSILE "ES" "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 8/12

8

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

110 9.8.2.2/22 9.10.2.2/22

111 9.8.3/22 9.10.3/23

112 9.8.4/22 9.10.4/23

113 9.9./22 9.11/23

114 9.10.1/22 9.12.1/23 NO CHANGES NIL

115 9.10.2/23 9.12.2/23

116 9.10.3/23 9.12.3/24

117 9.10.4/23 9.12.4/24

118 9.10.5/23 9.12.5/24

119 9.10.7/23 9.12.6/24

 

E&UIP(EN"S O"ENSILE "ES" "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

REGARDING GUIDEND

!END "ES" "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

INDIVIDUAL A!SOR!ED

ENERG* VALUE O CVN

"ES" SHALL NO" !E

LESS "HAN 3/4 O "HE

RE&UIRED (IN AVG.

VALUE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

 O AN* "ENSILE "ES"

SPECI(EN IS LESS

"HAN "HA" SPECIIED

AND AN* PAR" O "HE

RAC"URE "A)ES

PLACE OU" SIDE O

"HE (IDDLE HAL O

"HE GAUGE LENG"H

$"HE "ES" IS

CONSIDERED INVALID

A REPLACE(EN" "ES"

SHALL !E ALLOWED

(ORE A""EN"ION "O !E

(ADE DURING SA(PLE

PREPARA"ION.

REGARDING RE"ES" O

"ENSILE SPECI(EN

"HE (A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

REGARDING

LA""ENING "ES" "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

REGARDING !END

RE"ES" "HE (A""ER

IN "HE CLAUSE

RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

 !END RE"ES" "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

REGARDING CHARP*

RE"ES" "HE (A""ER

IN "HE CLAUSE

RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 9/12

9

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

120 9.11/24 9.13/24

121 10/24 10/24 NO CHANGES NIL

122 11/26 11/27 NO CHANGES NIL

123 12/27 12/27 NO CHANGES NIL

124 13/27 13/28 NO CHANGES NIL

125 IG.3/28 IG.3 /29

126 IG. 4/29 IG.4G /30

127 IG. 5/30 IG. 5/31 NO CHANGES NIL

128 IG. 6/30 IG. 6/31 NO CHANGES NIL

129 IG.7/31 IG.7/32 NO CHANGES NIL

130 IG.8/32 IG.8/33 NO CHANGES NIL

131 IG.9/33 --

132 IG. 10/34 IG. 9/33 IGURE NO. CHANGED ONL* IG. NO. CHANGED

133 IG.11/35 IG.10/34 NO CHANGES NIL

134 "A!LE 1/36 "A!LE 1/35 NO CHANGES NIL

135

136

137

138 "A!LE 4/39 "A!LE 4/38 NO CHANGES NIL

139 "A!LE 5/40 "A!LE 5/39 NO CHANGES NIL

140 NO CHANGES NIL

REGARDINGREPROCESSING "HE

(A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO.

CHANGED

"ENSILE "ES"

SPECI(EN LOCA"ION

O SEA(LESS PIPE

CHANGED

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

ROUND !AR SPECI(ENUP "O 6.4 DIA IS

ALLOWED

ROUND !AR SPECI(EN UP

"O 6.4 DIA ISALLOWED

EARLIER "HE SPECI(EN

DIA WAS 8.9 (( (IN

REERENCE S"ANDARD

DI(ENSION O NO"CH

DELE"ED

 

NO"CH DI(ENSION "O !E

OLLWED OR ALL

"A!LE

2A/37

"A!LE

2A/36

REPOR"ING O

"I"ANIU( IS

(ANDA"OR* OR PSL1

"I"ANIU( SHALL !E

REPOR"ED OR ALL

U"URE PROEC" O PSL1

PIPES

"A!LE

2!/37

"A!LE

2!/36

REPOR"ING O

"I"ANIU( IS

(ANDA"OR* OR PSL2

"I"ANIU( SHALL !E

REPOR"ED OR ALL

U"URE PROEC" O PSL2

PIPES

OO"NO"E/37

OO"NO"E/36

CNV SHALL NO"

E+CEED 0.03,

CNV SHALL NO"E+CEED 0.06, OR GR.

! PSL 2 ONL*

RE&UIRE(EN" IS NOW(ORE S"RINGEN"

"A!LE 6A-

6C/41-68

"A!LE 6A-

6C/40-67

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 10/12

10

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

141 NO CHANGES NIL

142 NO CHANGES NIL

143 --

144

145

146

147

148 --

149 --

150 NO CHANGES NIL

151 NO CHANGES NIL

152

153 -- NEW "A!LE ADDED

"A!LE 7-13/69-72 "A!LE 7-13/68-71

"A!LE

14/72

"A!LE

14/71

"A!LE

14A/72

RELA"IONSHIP

!E"WEEN PIPE

DI(ENSION %

"RANSVERSE "ENSILE

SPECI(EN

NEW "A!LE HAS !EEN

ADDED

"A!LE

15/73

"A!LE

15/72

AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I

HAS !EEN ADDED AND

API 4, S"ANDARD

PENE"RA(E"ER

DELE"ED

AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I "O

!E OLLWED OR ALL

U"URE PROEC"

"A!LE

16/73

"A!LE

15/73

AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I

HAS !EEN ADDED AND

API 2, S"ANDARD

PENE"RA(E"ER

DELE"ED

AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I "O

!E OLLWED OR ALL

U"URE PROEC"

"A!LE

17/74

"A!LE

17/73

ISO WIRE "*PE I&I HAS

!EEN ADDED AND ISO

WIRE 4,

PENE"RA(E"ER

DELE"ED

ISO WIRE "*PE I&I "O !E

OLLWED OR ALL

U"URE PROEC"

"A!LE

18/74

"A!LE

18/73

ISO WIRE "*PE I&I HAS!EEN ADDED AND ISO

WIRE 2,

PENE"RA(E"ER

DELE"ED

ISO WIRE "*PE I&I "O !E

OLLWED OR ALL

U"URE PROEC"

"A!LE

19/74

AS"( WIRE "*PE I&I

OR LOUROSCOPIC

INSPEC"ION

 

ACILI"* WE ARE NO"

DOING LOUROSCOPIC

INSPEC"ION"A!LE

20/74

 

OR RADIOGRAPH* !E OLLOWE OR ALL

"A!LE

19/74

"A!LE

21/74

"A!LE20/75

"A!LE22/75

"A!LE

21/75

"A!LE

23/75

ACCEP"ANCE LI(I" O

N10 NO"CH CHANGED

 

"A)EN DURING (A)ING

"A!LE

24/75

PIPE WELD SEA( ND"

(E"HODS HAS !EEN

ADDED

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 11/12

11

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

154 -- NEW "A!LE ADDED

155 --

156

157 A.1-A.3/77 A.1-A.3/79 NO CHANGES NIL

158 A.4/77 A.4/79

159 !.1.1/79 !.1.1/81

160 NO CHANGES NIL

161 !.3.1/79 !.3.1/81

162 NO CHANGES NIL

163 !4.1/80 !4.1/82

164 !4.2-!4.6/80 !4.2-!4.6/82 NO CHANGES NIL

165 NO CHANGES NIL

166 NO CHANGES NIL

167 "A!LE C1/85 "A!LE C1/87 NO CHANGES NIL

168 NO CHANGES NIL

169 NO CHANGES NIL

170 NO CHANGES NIL

171 SR 4 -- DELE"ED

"A!LE25/76

PIPE !OD* ND"(E"HODS HAS !EEN

ADDED

"A!LE

26/76

REERENCE

INDICA"OR O NO"CH

HAS !EEN ADDED

SPECIAL CARE HAS "O !E

"A)EN DURING (A)ING

O NO"CH

"A!LE

22/76

"A!LE

27/77

ONL* "A!LE NO.

CHANGED

ONL* "A!LE NO.

CHANGED

RADIOGRAPHS SHALL

!E "RACEA!LE "O "HE

PIPE IDEN"I"* OR

GIR"H WELDS

"RACEA!ILI"* IS

(ANDA"OR*

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

SEA(LESS PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

!.1.2-

!.2.5/79

!.1.2-

!.2.5/81  

O RESUL"AN" CAVI"*

SHALL NO" E+"END

IN"O "HE PAREN"

(E"AL !* (ORE "HAN

3.2 (( AS (EASURED

ALONG "HE PIPE

SURACE

PERPENDICULAR "O

(ORE A""EN"ION "O !E

"A)EN DURING REPAIR 

!.3.2-!.3.3/79

!.3.2-!.3.3/81

"HIS CLAUSE IS OR

ELEC"RIC % LASER

WELDED PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

APPENDI+

C/81-82

APPENDI+

C/83-84

IG. C1-C4/83-

85

IG. C1-C4/85-

87

APPENDI+D/87-89

APPENDI+D/89-91

APPENDI+

E/91-118

APPENDI+

E/93-120

SR3.1-

SR3.3/119

SR3.1-

SR3.3/120 

7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 12/12

12

S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES

COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION

CLAUSE No

/

PAGE.No.

42ND ED.

CLAUSE

No/

PAGE No.

43RD ED.

DESCRIPTION OF

CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.

w.r.t. 42nd Ed.

172 SR5/119 SR5/121

173 NO CHANGES NIL

174 NO CHANGES NIL

175 SR17/123 SR17/124

176 NO CHANGES NIL

177 NO CHANGES NIL

178 NO CHANGES NIL

179 NO CHANGES NIL

180 NO CHANGES NIL

181 NO CHANGES NIL

182 NO CHANGES NIL

183 NO CHANGES NIL

184 NO CHANGES NIL

REGARDING RAC"URE"OUGHNESS "ES"ING

"HE (A""ER IN "HE

CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E

ONL* CLAUSE NO

CHANGED

SR5A$SR5!/

120-121

SR5A$SR5!/

122-123

SR6-

SR15/121-

123

SR6-

SR15/123-

124

REGARDING ND"$"HIS

CLAUSE IS OR

ELEC"RIC % LASER

WELDED PIPE

NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW

PIPES

SR18$SR19/1

23-124

SR18$SR19/1

25

IG. 1-

3/124-125

IG. 1-

3/125-126

"A!LE 1-

3/125-127

"A!LE 1-

3/127-129

APPENDI+

G/129-139

APPENDI+

G/131-141

APPENDI+

H/143

APPENDI+

H/143

APPENDI+

I/143-145

APPENDI+

I/145-147

APPENDI+

/147

APPENDI+

/149

APPENDI+

)/149

APPENDI+

)/151

APPENDI+

(/151-153

APPENDI+

(/153-155