Upload
sachein-anand
View
236
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 1/12
1
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
1 1.1/1 1.1/1 NO CHANGES NIL2 1.2/1 1.2/1 NO CHANGES NIL
3 1.3/1 1.3/1 NO CHANGES NIL
4 1.4/1 1.4/1 NO CHANGES NIL
5 1.5/1 1.5/1 NO CHANGES NIL
6 2.1/1 2.1/2
7 2.2/2 2.2/2 NO CHANGES NIL
8 2.3/2 2.3/2 NO CHANGES NIL
9 -- 3.1/2
10 3.1/2 3.2/2 NO CHANGES NIL
11 3.2/2 3.4/2 NO CHANGES NIL
12 -- 3.3/2
13 3.3/2 3.5/2 NO CHANGES NIL
14 3.4/2 3.6/2 NO CHANGES NIL
15 3.5/2 3.7/2 NO CHANGES NIL
16 3.6/2 3.8/2 NO CHANGES NIL
17 3.7/2 3.9/2 NO CHANGES NIL
18 3.8/2 3.10/3 NO CHANGES NIL
19 3.9/2 3.11/3 NO CHANGES NIL
20 3.10/2 3.12/3 NO CHANGES NIL
21 3.11/2 3.13/3 NO CHANGES NIL
22 3.12/2 3.14/3 NO CHANGES NIL
23 3.13/2 3.15/3 NO CHANGES NIL
24 3.14/2 3.16/3 NO CHANGES NIL
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
SEVEN NEW
REERENCES HAS !EEN
ADDED."HE
REERENCES ARE AS
OLLOWS #
E94$E165$E213$E273$E309$
E570 % E709
SEVEN NEW REERENCE
S"ANDARDS /CODES "O !E
PROCURED
CALI!RA"ION SHALL
!E "RACEA!LE "O NIS"
OR E&UIVALLEN"
ORGANI'A"ION
ALL (AS"ER
INS"RU(EN"
CALI!RA"ION SHALL !E
"RACEA!LE "O NIS" OR
E&UIVALLEN"
ORGANI'A"ION S"A"US
O CALI!RA"ION "O !E
CHEC)ED NEW
(IN. COLD E+PANSION
SHALL !E 0.3, O OD
OR CIRCU(ERENCE
OR ALL U"URE
PROEC" (IN. COLD
E+PANSION (US" !E 0.3,
"O !E (AIN"AINED I"
WAS NO" SPECIIED IN
42ND EDDI"ION
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 2/12
2
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
25 3.15/3 3.17/3 NO CHANGES NIL
26 -- 3.18/3
27 -- 3.19/3
28 4.1/3 4.1/3 NO CHANGES NIL
29 4.2/3 4.2/4 NO CHANGES NIL
30 4.3/4 4.3/4 NO CHANGES NIL
31 5.0/5 5.0/6 NO CHANGES NIL
32 5.1/5-6 5.1/6-7 NO CHANGES NIL
33 5.2/7 5.2/8
34 5.3/7 5.3/8 NO CHANGES NIL
35 5.4/7 5.4/8 NO CHANGES NIL
36 5.5/7 5.5/8 NO CHANGES NIL
37 5.6.1/8 5.6.1/8 NO CHANGES NIL
38 5.6.2/8 5.6.2/8
39 6.1/8 6.1/8 NO CHANGES NIL
40 6.2.1/8 6.2.1/9 NO CHANGES NIL
41 6.2.2..1/9 6.2.2..1/9
42 6.2.2./9 6.2.2./9
43 6.2.3/9 6.2.3/10
44 6.2.4/9 6.2.4/10 NO CHANGES NIL
45 6.2.5/10 DELE"ED
46 6.2.6/10 6.2.5/10
INS"RU(EN" SHALL !E
S"ANDARDI'ED "O AN
AR!I"RAR*
ND" INSPEC"ION
INS"RU(EN" SHALL !E
S"ANDARDI'ED
DEINA"ION O UNDER
CU" HAS !EEN
CHANGED
DEINA"ION O UNDER
CU" SI(PLIIED
(IN. COLD E+PANSION
SHALL !E 0.3, O OD
OR CIRCU(ERENCE
OR ALL U"URE
PROEC" (IN. COLD
E+PANSION (US" !E 0.3,
"O !E (AIN"AINED I"
WAS NO" SPECIIED IN
42ND EDDI"ION
HEA" % LO"
"RACEA!ILI"*
RE&UIRE(EN" AS PER
SR 15.2
"RACEA!ILI"* "O !E
DONE OR ALL PSL2 PIPE
LO" "RACI!ILI"* WAS
SPECIIED IN 42ND
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
ERW PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
ERW PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
"HIS CLAUSE
REERED !END "ES"
ACCEP"ANCE CRI"ERIA
UP "O 2.37 OD
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
WELD DUC"ILI"* "ES"
NO" "O !E DONE OR ALL
U"URE PROEC"
OR ALL GRADES
SHEAR AREA O EACH
SPECI(EN SHALL !E
REPOR"ED OR EACH
HEA"
REPOR"ING O SHEAR
AREA IS (ANDA"OR* OR
ALL PSL2 PIPE
I" WAS NO" (ANDA"OR*
IN 42ND EDDI"ION
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 3/12
3
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
47 7.1/10 7.1/10 NO CHANGES NIL48 7.2/10 7.2/10 NO CHANGES NIL
49 7.3/11 7.3/11 NO CHANGES NIL
50 7.4/11 7.4/11 NO CHANGES NIL
51 7.5/11 7.5/11 NO CHANGES NIL
52 7.6/11 7.6/12 NO CHANGES NIL
53 7.7/11 7.7/12 NO CHANGES NIL
54 7.8/12 7.8/12 NO CHANGES NIL
55 7.8.1/12 7.8.1/12 NO CHANGES NIL
56 7.8.2/12 7.8.2/12 NO CHANGES NIL
57 7.8.3/12 7.8.3/12 NO CHANGES NIL
58 7.8.4/12 7.8.4/12 NO CHANGES NIL
59 7.8.5/12 7.8.5/12 NO CHANGES NIL
60 7.8.6/12 7.8.612 NO CHANGES NIL
61 7.8.7/12 7.8.7/13 NO CHANGES NIL
62 7.8.8/13 7.8.8/13 NO CHANGES NIL
63 7.8.9/13 7.8.9/13 NO CHANGES NIL
64 7.8.10/13 7.8.10/13 NO CHANGES NIL
65 7.8.11/13 7.8.13/13 NO CHANGES NIL
66 7.8.12/13 7.8.12/13
67 7.8.13/13 7.8.13/13 NO CHANGES NIL
68 7.8.14/14 7.8.14/14
69 7.9/14 7.9/14 NO CHANGES NIL
70 8/14--15 8/15 NO CHANGES NIL
71 9.1/15 9.1/15 NO CHANGES NIL
72 9.2/15 9.2/15 NO CHANGES NIL
73 9.3.1.1/15 9.3.1.1/15
74 9.3.1.2/16 9.3.1.2/16 NO CHANGES NIL
75 9.3.1.3/16 9.3.1.3/16 NO CHANGES NIL
DEINA"ION O UNDER
CU" CHANGED
DEINA"ION O UNDER
CU" SI(PLIIED
ID/OD "O !E
CONSIDERED AS A
DEEC" WHEN I"
E+CEEDS 12.5, W"
!O"H "HE SIDE SHALL !E
CONSIDERED
SPECI(EN OR
SEA(LESS PIPE. NO"APPLICA!LE "O LSAW
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 4/12
4
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
76 9.3.1.4/16 9.3.1.4/16
77 9.3.1.5/16 9.3.1.5/16 NO CHANGES NIL
78 9.3.2/16 9.3.2/16
79 9.3.3/16 9.3.3/16 NO CHANGES NIL
80 9.3.4/16 9.3.4/16 NO CHANGES NIL
81 9.3.5/16 9.3.5/17 NO CHANGES NIL
82 9.4/17 9.4/17 NO CHANGES NIL
83 9.5/18 9.5/18 NO CHANGES NIL
84 --- 9.6/18
85 9.6/18 9.7/18
86 9.7.1/18 9.8.1/18
NEW "A!LE 14A HAS
!EEN ADDED OR
SELEC"ION O ROUND
!AR "RANSEVERSE
"ENSILE SPECI(EN
ROUND !AR "RANSVERSE"ENSILE SPECI(EN O
DIA 6.4 (((IN
PER(I""ED.
EARLIER "HE SPECI(EN
DIA WAS 8.9 (( (IN
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
ERW PIPE$LASER
WELDED PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
SHALL !E DONE RO(
E+"ERNAL % IN"ERNAL
SURACE.VISUAL
INSPEC"ION CAN !E
REPLACED !* O"ER
INSPEC"ION (E"HOD
"HA" HAVE A
DE(ONS"RA"ED
CAPA!ILI"* O
DE"EC"ING SURACE
VISUAL INSPEC"ION
SHALL !E DONE RO(
E+"ERNAL % IN"ERNAL
SURACE
EARLIER "HE
SIDEIN"ERNAL/E+"ERNA
L WAS NO" SPECIIED
"RAINED "O DE"EC" %EVALUA"E "HE
SURACE
I(PEREC"ION AND
HAS "HE VISUAL
ACUI"* AS PER "HE
REUIRE(EN" O ASN"
RECO((ENDED
PRAC"ICE NO. SN"-"C-
1A OR E&UIVALLEN"
OR VISUAL
"RAINING O INSPEC"OR
OR VISUAL INSPEC"ION
IS NOW (ANDA"OR*
EARLIER I" WAS NO"
(ANDA"OR*
&UALIICA"ION O
ND" PERSONNEL IS AS
PER ASN"
RECO((ENDEDPRAC"ICE NO. SN"-"C-
1A OR E&UIVALLEN"
E+CEP" OR VISUAL
(E"HOD
&UALIICA"ION O ND"
PERSONNEL IS(ANDA"OR*
EARLIER I" WAS NO"
(ANDA"OR*
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 5/12
5
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
87 -- 9.8.2/19
88 9.7.2/18 9.8.3/19
89 9.7.2.1/18 9.8.3.1/19
90 --- 9.8.3.2/19
91 9.7.3.1/19 9.8.4.1/19
92 --- 9.8.4.2/19
93 -- 9.8.4.3/19
94 -- 9.8.4.4/20
IN "A!LE 27 43RDEDI"IO $O"HER "HAN
SURACE INSPEC"ION
AND WALL "HIC)NESS
VERIICA"ION
!ALANCE INSPEC"ION
SHALL !E DONE AS PER
AS"( S"ANDARD OR
E&UIVALEN"
S"ANDARD AS
OLLOWS -
E570$E309$E213$E273$E709$
AS"( S"ANDARD OR
E&UIVALEN" S"ANDARD
AS OLLOWS -
E570$E309$E213$E273$E709$E9
4 % E165 SHALL !E (ADE
AVAILA!LE
SEA( UL"RASONIC
"ES"ING IS ESSEN"IAL% ULL LENG"H O
WELD SEA( R" IS NO"
RE&UIRED UNLESS
AGREED !E"WEEN
PURCHASER AND
ULL LENG"H WELD
SEA( RADIOGRAPH* ISNO" RE&UIRED UNLESS
AGREED !E"WEEN
PURCHASER AND
(ANUAC"URER
200 (( END
RADIOGRAPH* SHALL
!E DONE
200 (( END
RADIOGRAPH* SHALL !E
DONE AS AGAINS" 203 ((
IN 42ND
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
SEA( LESS PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
"HE (A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN
UNCHANGED
ONL* CLAUSE NO.CHANGED
RADIOLOGICAL
SENSI"IVI"*
REERENCE S"ANDARD
SHALL !E AS PER AS"(
HOLE "*PE I&I$AS"(
WIRE "*PE I&I OR ISO
WIRE "*PE I&I
AS"( HOLE "*PE
I&I/AS"( WIRE "*PE I&I
AND ISO WIRE "*PE I&I
SHALL !E (ADE
AVAILA!LE
AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I
SHALL !E AS PER AS"(
E1025.I&I SELEC"ION AS
PER "A!LE 1643 RD
EDN.
AS"( E1025 SHALL !E
(ADE AVAILA!LE
SHALL !E AS PER ISO
1027 % AS"( WIRE "*PE
I&I SHALL !E AS PER
AS"( E747.SELEC"ION
O I&I IS AS PER "A!LE
18 % 20 43 RD EDN.OR
ISO AND AS"(
PENE"RA(E"ER
ISO1027 % AS"( E747
SHALL !E (ADE
AVAILA!LE
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 6/12
6
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
95 9.7.3.7/19 9.8.4.5/20
96 9.7.3.9/20 9.8.4.6/20 CLAUSE NO. CHANGED
97 9.7.3.10/20 9.8.4.7/20
98 9.7.3.11/20 9.8.4.8/20
99 -- 9.8.4.9/20
100 9.7.4.1/20 9.8.5.1/20
101 9.7.4.2/20 9.8.5.2/20
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
D*NA(IC (E"ODS
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
"HE (A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN
UNCHANGED
ACCEP"A!LE SI'E AND
DIS"RI!U"ION O SLAG
O R" IS AS PER "A!LE
21 % 22.43 RD EDN.
ONL* "A!LE NO
CHANGED$ (A""ER
RE(AIN SA(E
I(PEREC"ION
GREA"ER IN SI'EAND /OR DIS"RI!U"ION
"HA" SHOWN IN "A!LE
21 AND 22 43 RD EDN.
ARE CONSIDERED
DEEC" AND DIS
POSI"ION O
DEEC"IVE PIPE AS PER
ONL* "A!LE NO
CHANGED$ (A""ER
RE(AIN SA(E
RADIOGRAPHS SHALL
!E "RACEA!LE "O "HE
PIPE IDEN"I"*
"RACEA!ILI"* O
RADIOGRAPH
(ANDA"OR*
"HE (A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN
UNCHANGED
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
"HIC)NESS O
REERENCE PIPE AS
PER S"IPULA"ED
"OLERENCES O "HIS
SPEC."*PE AND
DI(ENSIONS O
REERENCE
INDICA"OR "O !E
VERIIED !*
DOCU(EN"ED
PROCEDURE. "HE
DOCU(EN"EDPROCEDURE "O !E
USED OR SE""ING
REEC" "HRESOLD.
DI(ENSIONS AND "HE
DIS"RI!U"ION O "HR
PROCEDURE OR
REERENCE INDICA"OR
DI(ENSIONAL
VERIICA"ION $
PROCEDURE OR
"HRESHOLD LEVEL
SE""ING ARE RE&UIRED.
"OLERENCE IN
DI(ENSION OREERENCE PIPE IS
CHANGED.
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 7/12
7
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
102 -- 9.8.5.3/21
103 9.7.4.3/20 9.8.5.4/21
104 -- 9.8.5.5/21
105 9.7.4.4/20 9.8.5.6/21 CLAUSE NO. CHANGED
106 9.7.5/21 9.8.6.1/21
107 9.7.7/21 9.8.7/22
108 9.8.1/21 9.10.1/22
109 9.8.2.1/22 9.10.2.1/22
(AIN"AINEDINCLUDING
S"ANDARDISA"ION AND
OPERA"ING
PROCEDURE$
E&UIP(EN"
DESCRIP"ION $
PERSONNEL
&UALIICA"ION$
D*NA(IC "ES" DA"A
DE(ONS"RA"ING "HE
S*S"E( A!ILI"* OR
UPGRADA"ION O "ES"
REPOR" RE&UIRED.
REGARDING
ACCEP"ANCE CRI"ERIAO U" "HE (A""ER IN
"HE CLAUSE RE(AIN
UNCHANGED "A!LE NO.
CHANGED. "A!LE 2343
RD EDN.
CLAUSE NO. AND "A!LE
NO CHANGED
DISPOSI"ION O
DEEC"S O U" SHALL
!E AS PER CL 9.9
DEPENDING ON NA"URE
O DEEC" PIPE (A* !E
REPAIRED/CU" O OR
REEC"ED
REGARDING DEEC"S
OUND !* U" IN "HE
WELD $ (A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN
UNCHANGED
"HIS CLAUSE
REGARDING (PI IS OR
SEA( LESS PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
REGARDING RESIDUAL
(AGNE"IS( "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
REGARDING (E"HOD
O CHE(ICAL
ANAL*SIS "HE (A""ERIN "HE CLAUSE
RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
REGARDING (E"HOD
O "ENSILE "ES" "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 8/12
8
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
110 9.8.2.2/22 9.10.2.2/22
111 9.8.3/22 9.10.3/23
112 9.8.4/22 9.10.4/23
113 9.9./22 9.11/23
114 9.10.1/22 9.12.1/23 NO CHANGES NIL
115 9.10.2/23 9.12.2/23
116 9.10.3/23 9.12.3/24
117 9.10.4/23 9.12.4/24
118 9.10.5/23 9.12.5/24
119 9.10.7/23 9.12.6/24
E&UIP(EN"S O"ENSILE "ES" "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
REGARDING GUIDEND
!END "ES" "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
INDIVIDUAL A!SOR!ED
ENERG* VALUE O CVN
"ES" SHALL NO" !E
LESS "HAN 3/4 O "HE
RE&UIRED (IN AVG.
VALUE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
O AN* "ENSILE "ES"
SPECI(EN IS LESS
"HAN "HA" SPECIIED
AND AN* PAR" O "HE
RAC"URE "A)ES
PLACE OU" SIDE O
"HE (IDDLE HAL O
"HE GAUGE LENG"H
$"HE "ES" IS
CONSIDERED INVALID
A REPLACE(EN" "ES"
SHALL !E ALLOWED
(ORE A""EN"ION "O !E
(ADE DURING SA(PLE
PREPARA"ION.
REGARDING RE"ES" O
"ENSILE SPECI(EN
"HE (A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
REGARDING
LA""ENING "ES" "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
REGARDING !END
RE"ES" "HE (A""ER
IN "HE CLAUSE
RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
!END RE"ES" "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
REGARDING CHARP*
RE"ES" "HE (A""ER
IN "HE CLAUSE
RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 9/12
9
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
120 9.11/24 9.13/24
121 10/24 10/24 NO CHANGES NIL
122 11/26 11/27 NO CHANGES NIL
123 12/27 12/27 NO CHANGES NIL
124 13/27 13/28 NO CHANGES NIL
125 IG.3/28 IG.3 /29
126 IG. 4/29 IG.4G /30
127 IG. 5/30 IG. 5/31 NO CHANGES NIL
128 IG. 6/30 IG. 6/31 NO CHANGES NIL
129 IG.7/31 IG.7/32 NO CHANGES NIL
130 IG.8/32 IG.8/33 NO CHANGES NIL
131 IG.9/33 --
132 IG. 10/34 IG. 9/33 IGURE NO. CHANGED ONL* IG. NO. CHANGED
133 IG.11/35 IG.10/34 NO CHANGES NIL
134 "A!LE 1/36 "A!LE 1/35 NO CHANGES NIL
135
136
137
138 "A!LE 4/39 "A!LE 4/38 NO CHANGES NIL
139 "A!LE 5/40 "A!LE 5/39 NO CHANGES NIL
140 NO CHANGES NIL
REGARDINGREPROCESSING "HE
(A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO.
CHANGED
"ENSILE "ES"
SPECI(EN LOCA"ION
O SEA(LESS PIPE
CHANGED
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
ROUND !AR SPECI(ENUP "O 6.4 DIA IS
ALLOWED
ROUND !AR SPECI(EN UP
"O 6.4 DIA ISALLOWED
EARLIER "HE SPECI(EN
DIA WAS 8.9 (( (IN
REERENCE S"ANDARD
DI(ENSION O NO"CH
DELE"ED
NO"CH DI(ENSION "O !E
OLLWED OR ALL
"A!LE
2A/37
"A!LE
2A/36
REPOR"ING O
"I"ANIU( IS
(ANDA"OR* OR PSL1
"I"ANIU( SHALL !E
REPOR"ED OR ALL
U"URE PROEC" O PSL1
PIPES
"A!LE
2!/37
"A!LE
2!/36
REPOR"ING O
"I"ANIU( IS
(ANDA"OR* OR PSL2
"I"ANIU( SHALL !E
REPOR"ED OR ALL
U"URE PROEC" O PSL2
PIPES
OO"NO"E/37
OO"NO"E/36
CNV SHALL NO"
E+CEED 0.03,
CNV SHALL NO"E+CEED 0.06, OR GR.
! PSL 2 ONL*
RE&UIRE(EN" IS NOW(ORE S"RINGEN"
"A!LE 6A-
6C/41-68
"A!LE 6A-
6C/40-67
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 10/12
10
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
141 NO CHANGES NIL
142 NO CHANGES NIL
143 --
144
145
146
147
148 --
149 --
150 NO CHANGES NIL
151 NO CHANGES NIL
152
153 -- NEW "A!LE ADDED
"A!LE 7-13/69-72 "A!LE 7-13/68-71
"A!LE
14/72
"A!LE
14/71
"A!LE
14A/72
RELA"IONSHIP
!E"WEEN PIPE
DI(ENSION %
"RANSVERSE "ENSILE
SPECI(EN
NEW "A!LE HAS !EEN
ADDED
"A!LE
15/73
"A!LE
15/72
AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I
HAS !EEN ADDED AND
API 4, S"ANDARD
PENE"RA(E"ER
DELE"ED
AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I "O
!E OLLWED OR ALL
U"URE PROEC"
"A!LE
16/73
"A!LE
15/73
AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I
HAS !EEN ADDED AND
API 2, S"ANDARD
PENE"RA(E"ER
DELE"ED
AS"( HOLE "*PE I&I "O
!E OLLWED OR ALL
U"URE PROEC"
"A!LE
17/74
"A!LE
17/73
ISO WIRE "*PE I&I HAS
!EEN ADDED AND ISO
WIRE 4,
PENE"RA(E"ER
DELE"ED
ISO WIRE "*PE I&I "O !E
OLLWED OR ALL
U"URE PROEC"
"A!LE
18/74
"A!LE
18/73
ISO WIRE "*PE I&I HAS!EEN ADDED AND ISO
WIRE 2,
PENE"RA(E"ER
DELE"ED
ISO WIRE "*PE I&I "O !E
OLLWED OR ALL
U"URE PROEC"
"A!LE
19/74
AS"( WIRE "*PE I&I
OR LOUROSCOPIC
INSPEC"ION
ACILI"* WE ARE NO"
DOING LOUROSCOPIC
INSPEC"ION"A!LE
20/74
OR RADIOGRAPH* !E OLLOWE OR ALL
"A!LE
19/74
"A!LE
21/74
"A!LE20/75
"A!LE22/75
"A!LE
21/75
"A!LE
23/75
ACCEP"ANCE LI(I" O
N10 NO"CH CHANGED
"A)EN DURING (A)ING
"A!LE
24/75
PIPE WELD SEA( ND"
(E"HODS HAS !EEN
ADDED
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 11/12
11
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
154 -- NEW "A!LE ADDED
155 --
156
157 A.1-A.3/77 A.1-A.3/79 NO CHANGES NIL
158 A.4/77 A.4/79
159 !.1.1/79 !.1.1/81
160 NO CHANGES NIL
161 !.3.1/79 !.3.1/81
162 NO CHANGES NIL
163 !4.1/80 !4.1/82
164 !4.2-!4.6/80 !4.2-!4.6/82 NO CHANGES NIL
165 NO CHANGES NIL
166 NO CHANGES NIL
167 "A!LE C1/85 "A!LE C1/87 NO CHANGES NIL
168 NO CHANGES NIL
169 NO CHANGES NIL
170 NO CHANGES NIL
171 SR 4 -- DELE"ED
"A!LE25/76
PIPE !OD* ND"(E"HODS HAS !EEN
ADDED
"A!LE
26/76
REERENCE
INDICA"OR O NO"CH
HAS !EEN ADDED
SPECIAL CARE HAS "O !E
"A)EN DURING (A)ING
O NO"CH
"A!LE
22/76
"A!LE
27/77
ONL* "A!LE NO.
CHANGED
ONL* "A!LE NO.
CHANGED
RADIOGRAPHS SHALL
!E "RACEA!LE "O "HE
PIPE IDEN"I"* OR
GIR"H WELDS
"RACEA!ILI"* IS
(ANDA"OR*
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
SEA(LESS PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
!.1.2-
!.2.5/79
!.1.2-
!.2.5/81
O RESUL"AN" CAVI"*
SHALL NO" E+"END
IN"O "HE PAREN"
(E"AL !* (ORE "HAN
3.2 (( AS (EASURED
ALONG "HE PIPE
SURACE
PERPENDICULAR "O
(ORE A""EN"ION "O !E
"A)EN DURING REPAIR
!.3.2-!.3.3/79
!.3.2-!.3.3/81
"HIS CLAUSE IS OR
ELEC"RIC % LASER
WELDED PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
APPENDI+
C/81-82
APPENDI+
C/83-84
IG. C1-C4/83-
85
IG. C1-C4/85-
87
APPENDI+D/87-89
APPENDI+D/89-91
APPENDI+
E/91-118
APPENDI+
E/93-120
SR3.1-
SR3.3/119
SR3.1-
SR3.3/120
7/25/2019 Comparision 42 - 43 Ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparision-42-43-ed 12/12
12
S No. IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
COMPARISON BETWEEN API 5L 42ND AND 43RD EDITION
CLAUSE No
/
PAGE.No.
42ND ED.
CLAUSE
No/
PAGE No.
43RD ED.
DESCRIPTION OF
CHANGES IN 43rd Ed.
w.r.t. 42nd Ed.
172 SR5/119 SR5/121
173 NO CHANGES NIL
174 NO CHANGES NIL
175 SR17/123 SR17/124
176 NO CHANGES NIL
177 NO CHANGES NIL
178 NO CHANGES NIL
179 NO CHANGES NIL
180 NO CHANGES NIL
181 NO CHANGES NIL
182 NO CHANGES NIL
183 NO CHANGES NIL
184 NO CHANGES NIL
REGARDING RAC"URE"OUGHNESS "ES"ING
"HE (A""ER IN "HE
CLAUSE RE(AIN SA(E
ONL* CLAUSE NO
CHANGED
SR5A$SR5!/
120-121
SR5A$SR5!/
122-123
SR6-
SR15/121-
123
SR6-
SR15/123-
124
REGARDING ND"$"HIS
CLAUSE IS OR
ELEC"RIC % LASER
WELDED PIPE
NO" APPLICA!LE "O SAW
PIPES
SR18$SR19/1
23-124
SR18$SR19/1
25
IG. 1-
3/124-125
IG. 1-
3/125-126
"A!LE 1-
3/125-127
"A!LE 1-
3/127-129
APPENDI+
G/129-139
APPENDI+
G/131-141
APPENDI+
H/143
APPENDI+
H/143
APPENDI+
I/143-145
APPENDI+
I/145-147
APPENDI+
/147
APPENDI+
/149
APPENDI+
)/149
APPENDI+
)/151
APPENDI+
(/151-153
APPENDI+
(/153-155