Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Can we learn from computer science to better cater to needs of water system users? (answer: no) Nick van de Giesen Erik Mostert Numerical Modelling - Policy Interface 1 st Workshop - Stuttgart. Outline. What we are doing now What we would like to be doing Some ideas…. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
NMPI 2007
1
Can we learn from computerscience to better cater to needs ofwater system users?(answer: no)
Nick van de GiesenErik Mostert
Numerical Modelling - Policy Interface1st Workshop - Stuttgart
NMPI 2007
2
• What we are doing now• What we would like to be doing• Some ideas…
Outline
NMPI 2007
3
What we are doing now
Computational
KERNEL
NMPI 2007
4
What we are doing now
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
NMPI 2007
5
What we are doing now
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
6
What we are doing now
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
???MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
7
What we are doing now
Sobek
www.wldelft.nl
NMPI 2007
8
What we are doing now
Sobek
www.wldelft.nl
NMPI 2007
9
What we are doing now
WEAP
www.weap21.org
NMPI 2007
10
What we are doing now
WEAP
www.weap21.org
NMPI 2007
11
• Not difficult• Visualize model result• Not used by policy makers
What we are doing now
NMPI 2007
12
What we would like to do
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
13
Invert design process for (large)
Decision Support Systems
in Water Resources Management
(Application Science)
What we would like to do
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
14
Has been done: Participatory modeling (AEM)Extensive experience 1980’s - now N.America/Australia
What we would like to do
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
15
Has been done:
ComSci, Unified Modeling Language
What we would like to do
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
16
What we would like to do
Has been done:
ComSci, Unified Modeling Language
Use cases
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
17
What we would like to do
Has been done: ComSci, Unified Modeling Language
Use case Kernel
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
18
What we would like to do
Has been done: Bidding process Maeslantkering
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
19
What we would like to do
Has been done: Bidding process Maeslantkering
n metersclose 6 hrsno hindrance
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
20
What we would like to do
Has been done: Bidding process Maeslantkering
Hennes de Ridder
Computational
KERNEL
SHELL
MARKET
USERS
NMPI 2007
21
First ideas
• Inverting the design process• Our model: Building processes• Concrete place: Haaglanden
NMPI 2007
22
First ideas
• Urban & regional planners
NMPI 2007
23
First ideas
• Urban & regional planners
RedGreenBlue
15% blue…
NMPI 2007
24
First ideas
• Urban & regional planners
RedGreenBlue
“OK”
NMPI 2007
25
First ideas
• Urban & regional planners
RedGreenBlue
“Not OK”
NMPI 2007
26
First ideas
• Urban & regional planners
RedGreenBlue
“OK again”
NMPI 2007
27
• Urban & regional planners
Engineering challenge:
Add inter-activity
First ideas
NMPI 2007
28
First ideas
In general, stating the obvious, to invert design process:
• Enter dialogue…• … move away from generic models
