Upload
independent
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
38
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ADRRI JOURNALS (www.adrri.org)
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662 VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Relationship Marketing; a Tool for Competitive Advantage in Banking Sector in Ghana.
Emmanuel Kwarteng
University of Education, Winneba, Kumasi Campus. Email: [email protected]
Received: 16th November, 2015 Revised: 19th December, 2015 Published Online: 31st December, 2015
URL: http://www.journals.adrri.org/
[To Cite this Article: Kwarteng, E., (2015). Relationship Marketing; a Tool for Competitive Advantage in
Banking Sector in Ghana. ADRRI Journal, Ghana: Vol. 25, No. 3(3). Pp. 38-50, ISSN: 2026-5360, 31ST December, 2015.]
Abstract
The study seeks to find out the significant relationship that exists between the sustainable long term
relationship marketing and sustainable competitive advantage. By this, the study took a sample
population of 341 respondents from the 11 commercial banks within the Sunyani Municipality and
questionnaires were administered to them. 315questionnaires were returned to the researcher. However,
11 out of the 315 were not fully completed so they were excluded in the analysis. As competition has
become very keen, relationship marketing has also become a very powerful tool for sustainable
competitive advantage. The findings of the study revealed that there is a significant positive correlation
between the practicing of relationship marketing and competitive advantage using spearman rank of
correlation. Therefore, it is very indispensable for banks to include in their overall corporate business
objectives and strategies that underpin the successful relationship marketing development as a tool for
sustainable competitive advantage.
Keywords: relationship marketing, transactional marketing, banking sector, customer loyalty, repeat
purchases and customer retention.
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
39
INTRODUCTION
Consider yourself walking into a banking hall and you see bank staffs all over in the hall and there is
nobody in particular attending to your needs. The question is; will you ever go there again? To me the
answer is no. This is because; I will rather prefer going to a bank where I will be accepted there; thus,
where all my needs will be met in a satisfactory manner. In this scenario, the customer will halt trusting
and committing himself to the bank and the bank will therefore lose the customer to a competing bank
which goes beyond just performing a mere transaction to build strong bank/customer relationship.
Relationship Marketing has therefore become an important contributing factor as far as banks’ financial
services are concern, (Zineldin, 1996) and if a bank is able to develop and sustain a long term relationship
with its cherished customers and other stakeholders, it will be able to outweigh competition to gain
competitive advantage since competitors cannot easily replace them, (Gilbert & Choi, 2003).
Banking industry around the globe has a great importance for an economy of every country, as the banks
have the capacity to concentrate on a large amount of the savings made by individual customers and
corporate bodies in order to be further invested into the economic activities. The industry has now become
more increasingly competitive around the world for which Ghana is no exception. Continuous increasing
in competition within the global financial market has therefore made many institutions, scholars and
academicians advocate for the introduction of relationship marketing into the banking industry in Ghana.
Relationship marketing therefore is to identify and establish, maintain and enhance and when necessary
also to terminate relationships with customers and other stakeholders, at a profit, so that the objectives of
all parties are met, and that this is done by a mutual exchange and fulfillment of promise, (Gro¨nroos
1994). (Gilaninia et al, 2011) on the other hand said ;relationship marketing is a kind of marketing that its
goal is developing and managing long-term and trustworthy relationships with customers, suppliers and
all others acting in the market.
According to (Ashton &Pressey, 2004), the long-term relationships that exist between banks and their
cherished customers allow for the efficient monitoring of borrowers for credit assessment, enforcing
contract compliance and as a canal to gather information for profitability, distribution and pricing which
leads to greater satisfaction, repeat purchase and positive word of mouth, simply refers to customer
referrals. Relationship marketing can be seen as a relationship that benefits the two parties involved and
here, the bank and the customer, (Gilbert & Choi, 2003). Based on this, one will say that a business and for
that matter, the bank, can use relationship marketing as a tool to outweigh its competitors to gain
competitive advantage. The objective of the study was to find out the significant positive relationship that
exists between the developing a sustainable long term relationship marketing and sustainable competitive
advantage.
The nature of relationship marketing
The central theme that commensurate relationship marketing is exchanges that exist between the seller
and the buyer. This exchange can be traced far back to the barter system of trade. Though there were
exchanges of items and interactions that existed between the parties involved, however, there was no trace
of relationship marketing existence. The parties to the exchange also displayed commitment, trust and
loyalty which are the core of relationship marketing but upon all these, they were not practicing
relationship marketing. When the exchanges were done between the parties involved, everything also
ended; thus, whether the parties to the exchange of products or services were satisfied or not was
nobody’s business.
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
40
The cosmopolitan of businesses around the globe has given birth to competition where every business
wants to survive by serving the same customer at the same time for profit maximization. The interaction
and network approach to industrial marketing and modern service marketing approaches clearly views
marketing as an interactive process in social context building where relationship building is a vital
cornerstone, (Gro¨nroos, 1994). It was argued that this approach is similar to the system-based approaches
to marketing of the 1950s. As a consequence of rapid advances in both manufacturing and information
technology, the mass markets suited to the 4Ps marketing approaches, (Baker, 2001). So in response,
relationship marketing emerged in the 1980s and according to (Gro¨nroos, 1990), he said, relationship
marketing is to establish, maintain and enhance relationship with customers and other partners at a profit
so that the objectives of the parties involved are fully met and this can only be achieved by mutual
exchange and fulfillment of promises.
Customer Loyalty Customer Satisfaction
Repeat Purchases
Trust &
Commitment
Customer Retention
Increases in Revenue Mobilization Customer Delight
Figure 1: Mutual Benefit as a Result of Bank/Customer Relationship
Relationship marketing; a tool for competitive advantage in banking industry
Relationship marketing has become a great tool in this contemporary business environment most
especially in the banking industry. This is due to how intense the competition in the industry has become.
The purpose of competitive strategy is to achieve a long term sustainable competitive advantage by way of
enhancing a business performance (Bharadwaj et al, 1993).Devising competitive marketing strategies also
involves recognizing the inter-play between relationships marketing and marketing mix elements as well
as assessing the impact of competitive and market conditions on marketing mix implementation.
Relationship marketing serves as arbitrator for sustainable long term competitive advantages over the
other competing businesses on the environment in this modern business environment. For a bank to
increase the maximization of its long-term performance and achievements there should be an institution of
sustainable long term relationship. This is to enhance long-term mutual beneficial relationships with its
cherished customers and by so doing, the bank will accrue results such as; customer loyalty, customer
retention, increases in revenue mobilization and profitability. The outcomes of the institution of
relationship marketing in banking industry are enormous since bank’s profitability is based on how a bank
gives more details and attention to this emerged phenomenon. The inclusion of relationship marketing
into the total corporate objective will help maintain the existing customers through customer loyalty and
BANK
CUSTOMER
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
41
then again, get potential customers through customer referrals. This creates positive behavioral change by
the customer by way of continuous repeating purchasing of bank products and services.
For a bank to use relationship marketing as a tool to outweighs its competitors in order to enjoy
sustainable competitive advantage in the industry, (Sorce, 2002) made mention the following strategic
actions that can be implemented by banking sector. These include; creating customer satisfaction
profitably. Thus, bring on board superior products and services that best meet the demands of the
cherished customers. By this, the bank needs to conduct thorough market and survey research on the
tastes and preferences of its customers and inject the outcome into the total business objective and
strategies so that superior products and services will be made available to its cherished customers
profitably. Secondly, is to build brand equity, building brand equity according to (Baker, 2001) is the
creation of awareness, memory association and attitude towards the brand that has being used over many
years. The awareness, perceived quality, brand loyalty, the associations of consumers towards the brand,
trademarks, packaging, and marketing channel presence, (Sorce, 2002), are some sorts of brand equity.
Adopting this relationship marketing strategy will help to mingle the bank’s brands with the customer’s
behaviour and by so doing; the bank will be able to implant its brands into the memory of the customers.
Lastly is to create and maintain relationship. By this, the bank needs to create a long term and sustainable
relationship with its existing and potential customers and when this is done, the customer will feel part of
the bank’s operational activities and the outcomes are customer loyalty, repeat purchases and customer
referrals and by this the bank can position itself in the minds of both existing & potential customers and
the public as the best bank in terms of customers satisfaction, customer trust and commitment through the
institution of sustainable relationship marketing approach to modern day banking.
The conceptual model of the study
The conceptual model that is displayed in figure 1 was developed from relationship marketing and how it
can be used as a strategic tool to enjoy the products of sustainable competitive advantage in banking
sector.
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
42
Sustainable Competitive
Advantage
Figure 2: Sustainable Competitive Advantage model
From the conceptual model above, it can be seen that there is a linkage between development of long term
relationship marketing and sustainable competitive advantage and the results are enormous which
include;
1. Trust and Commitment
2. Increases in Revenue Mobilization (Customer Deposit),
3. Customer Satisfaction
4. Customer Retention
5. Repeat purchases
6. Customer Delight
7. Customer Loyalty.
These summed up to give a reward of gaining a sustainable competitive advantage which according to
(Barney, 1991) can be achieved either from the implementing a value-creating strategy such as unique
sustainable relationship marketing and not simultaneously being implemented by any current or potential
competitors. Based on this, it is hypothesized as following;
Ho: there is no significant positive relationship that exists between sustainable long term relationship
marketing and sustainable competitive advantage
Ha: there is significant positive relationship that exists between sustainable relationship marketing and
sustainable competitive advantage.
BANK
RELATIONSHIP
MARKETING
Increases in
Revenues
Customer
Retention Repeat
Purchases
Trust and
Commitment
Customer
Loyalty
Customer
Satisfaction
Customer
Delight
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
43
Relationship marketing in practice in banking industry
Banking industry has incurred lot of tribulations and turbulence due to keen competition that has emerged
on the contemporary business environment. This has made some industry players to institute a
sustainable long term relationship marketing as a tool to combat this competition. The banking industry
was selected as the industry sector for this study as it presents rich information for relationship marketing
practices in the Sunyani Municipality and Ghana as a whole. In time past, transactional marketing
approach has been practicing within the banking industry since there were only few banks so there was no
competition and these available banks were enjoying monopoly. The introduction of many new banks into
the industry has brought about keen rivalry within the industry. Due to this, the industry players have
done away with the traditional marketing which is the transactional type and have embraced the
relationship marketing which further gives more attention to banks/customer relationship for revenue
maximization.
The concept of relationship marketing has emerged within the field of services marketing and industrial
marketing (Bolton et al. 2008) and according to (Gro¨nroos, 1994), relationship marketing is to identify and
establish, maintain and enhance and when necessary also to terminate relationships with customers and
other stakeholders, at a profit, so that the objectives of both parties are met, and that this is done by a
mutual exchange and fulfillment of promises. By this, including the institution of sustainable relationship
marketing into the overall bank’s corporate objective is yielding fruitful results that both parties; the bank
and their cherished customers enjoy reciprocally. Relationship marketing cannot be seen as isolated
department such as Operations, Finance, Information Technology, Risk & Compliance, Human Resource
& Administration but rather should be seen as an essential activity that penetrates through all the
departments in the banking system of operations and by this all staff should also add up to their daily
operational activities in order to increase efficiency and revenue maximization.
The kind of winds that are blowing within banking industry is compelling banks to focus on the objectives
of their cherished customers, developing direct tailor-made products and services, the use of tailored
made distribution and communication messages and channels, reducing intermediary costs based on
increasing usage of technology, proximity, and financial performance improvement. According to
(Pathmarajah, 1993), focusing on consumer, relationship marketing marks the transition from mass
marketing to niche one, as a ‚process matching both seller and buyer in a profitable, personal,
professional, and long term mutual relation‛. The move from transactional type of marketing towards the
renowned relationship marketing is a continuous process to use as a tool for competitive advantage and is
involving in-depth knowledge of customers, relevant products and services for each cherished customer
and long-term sustainable relationship that benefits the parties involved mutually. Based on the new wind
that is blowing within the banking industry, every bank is instituting well rehearsing relationship
marketing procedures to serve the cherished customer; some are even going an extra mile to worship their
customers profitably.
METHODOLOGY
Research methodology is regarded as a process of arriving at a dependable solution to a problem through
objective, planned and systematic collection, interpretation, analysis and reporting of data and
information, (Otokiti, 2005).The sample for the study was taken from the customers of various banks
within Sunyani Municipality for the study. In all there were a total number of 20 banks comprising 11
commercial banks, 4 savings and loans companies and 5 rural banks. Based on this, the study used the
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
44
customers of the 11 commercial banks as a sample and with the help of systematic sampling method; the
researcher decided to use a formula propounded by (Guilford &Fruchter, 1973) to estimate the sample
size.
N
n = __________ 2
1+ α N Where:
N= Population
n= Sample size
α = Level Significance
Questionnaires were then designed and administered to the sample for the data gathering. A pretest was
conducted with the objective of determining an appropriate strategy to maximize response rate by
checking on the adequacy of question statements. The objective here was to find out if the questionnaire
would be comprehended and identify possible ‚problem‛ statement(s) for modification. In all a total of 41
customers were used to produce a comprehensive questionnaire for the study. Data was gathered from the
customers of all the 11 commercial banks within the Sunyani Municipality. The study used (Pearlin &
Schooler, 1978) Mastery scale which was used to examine the study reliability. A total of 341
questionnaires were administered to the respondents and out of the 341 questionnaires, 315 questionnaires
were however returned to represent 92.3% of the total questionnaires sent out. However, 11 questionnaires
were not completely filled and they were excluded in the data analysis and this represents3.2%. So in all, a
total of 304 questionnaires were used for the data analysis of this study and with the help of Statistical
Package for Service Solutions (SPSS) software and Spearman’s Correlation Coefficient Rank, the gathered
data was analysed to find out the significant positive relationship that exists between the development of
long term relationship marketing and sustainable competitive advantage.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Table 1 revealed the population sample of the study that was taken from the all the 11 commercial banks
customers within the Sunyani Municipality and how the sample size was estimated and selected for the
purpose of this study using the famous formula propounded by (Guilford &Fruchter, 1973).
Table 1: Systematic Sampling of Respondents (Estimation & Selection of Sample Size)
Banks Estimated
Customers
N
n = _____ 2
1+αN
Actual Customers
(Sample Size)
1 Barclays Bank of Ghana Limited 49 43 43
2 Ecobank Ghana Limited 45 40 40
3 Stanbic Bank Limited 38 34 34
4 Ghana commercial bank limited 39 35 29
5 Fidelity bank limited 45 40 35
6 Societal Generale Bank Limited 36 33 24
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
45
7 Agricultural Development Bank Limited 26 24 19
8 National Investment Bank Limited 33 30 24
9 Zenith Bank Ghana Limited 28 26 25
10 GN Bank Limited 24 22 17
11 Sahel Sahara Bank Ghana Limited 15 14 14
Total 341 304
Table 2: Socio-economic characteristics of the respondents (Gender Distribution, Age Structure and the
Educational Qualification) of Respondents
Gender Frequency Percentage
Male 199 65.5%
Female 105 34.5%
Total 304 100%
Age Distribution Frequency Percentage
18-25 37 12.2%
26-35 59 19.4%
36-45 147 48.4%
46-55 42 13.8%
56 & above 19 6.3%
Total 304 100%
Educational Qualification Frequency Percentage
Basic 54 17.8%
Secondary/Technical/Vocational 99 32.6%
Tertiary 129 42.4%
No Education 22 7.2%
Total 304 100%
From table 2, it was established that out of the total of 304 respondents who returned the questionnaires
that were administered to them for the purpose of the study, 199 were males represent 65.5% and 105 were
also females which also represent34.5%. Considering the age distribution of the respondents in table 2, the
researcher wanted to know the age distribution of the respondents, that’s the customers and out of the
total of 304 respondents whose questionnaires were used for the study, 37 found themselves in 18-25 years
and this represents 12.2%, 59 were in 26-35 range and this represents 19.4%. Again, in the range of 36-45,
147 respondents were found and this represented by 48.4%. 242 of them also were in the 46-55 range
representing 13.8% and finally, in the range of 56 years and above, 19 respondents were found and this
represented by 6.2%.
From the same table, it was revealed that out of the 304 respondents used in this analysis, 54 respondents
had only basic education and this represented by 17.8%. 99 of them had secondary/technical/vocational
and this too represented by 32.6%.Considering respondents with tertiary educational qualification, such
as; HND, 1st degree, master’s degree and PhD, there were 129 respondents and it represented by 42.4% ,
and lastly, those respondents who had no formal education, there were 22 respondents to that effect and it
represented by 7.2%.
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
46
Table 3: Length of patronage of a particular bank’s products and services
Length of Patronage Frequency Percentage
1-3 11 3.6%
4-6 62 20.4%
7-10 144 47.4
11 & above 87 28.6
Total 304 100%
The researcher wanted to find out the length of time that the respondents have been patronizing a
particular bank’s products and services and as is seen on table 3 that, out of the total respondents used for
the study, only 11 respondents had been patronizing a particular bank ranging from 1yr-3yrs and this
represents 3.6%. 62 respondents had been using a particular bank within 4yrs – 6yrs it represents 20.4%
and it came out again that, 144 respondents had also patronizing a single bank representing 47.4% and
lastly, 87 is represented by 28.6%.
Table 4: Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha
Cronbach's
Alpha Based on
Standardized
Items
N of Items
.937 .954 7
Checking the reliability of the questionnaire which was administered to the respondents, thorough
investigation of pretest exercise was conducted. The researcher intentionally took 41 customers from the
aforementioned commercial banks and using the Cronbach’s alpha value, which states that, the higher the
value obtained, the higher the reliability of consistency arise in a study. It again stated that, any time the
value is higher than 0.70, it means that there is a high tendency of reliability of consistency in a study. The
examination of the Cronbach’s alpha value for this study results a cumulative value of 0.937suggesting
very good internal consistency reliability for the scale with this sample using all the variables combined
since is higher than 0.70. Table 4above displayed the results.
Table 5: Determination of the Spearman’s Correlation Coefficient Rank
Correlation Between Relationship Marketing and Competitive Advantage
Relationship
Marketing
Competitive
Advantage
Spearman's rho Relationship
Marketing
Correlation
Coefficient 1.000 .849
Sig. (2-tailed) . .000
N 304 304
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
47
Competitive
Advantage
Correlation
Coefficient .849 1.000
Sig. (2-tailed) .000 .
N 304 304
Ho: there is no significant positive relationship that exists between sustainable long term relationship
marketing and sustainable competitive advantage.
Ha: there is significant positive relationship that exists between sustainable relationship marketing and
sustainable competitive advantage.
Table 5 displayed the results of the hypothesis that was tested using Spearman’s Correlation Coefficient
Rank. As stated as the objective of this study, the researcher wanted to figure out whether there is a
significant positive relationship that exists between these variables; sustainable long term relationship
marketing and sustainable competitive advantage in the banking industry. According to (Cohen et al,
1988), suggested the following interpretation guideline for the strength of the relationship that exists
between two variables.
When r= 0.10 to 0.29 Small
r= 0.30 to 0.49 Medium
r= 0.50 to 1.00 Large
Spearman’s Correlation Coefficient Rank test shows that the relationship between sustainable long term
relationship marketing and sustainable competitive advantage is significant at level 0.01 given the
coefficient as 0.849 which indicates that there is a significant positive relationship between the two
variables tested and by this study therefore rejected the null hypothesis. As indicated in by (Bharadwaj et
al, 1993), the purpose of competitive strategy is to achieve a long term sustainable competitive advantage
by way of enhancing a business performance and this competitive strategy here is the development and
practicing of relationship marketing to achieve long term sustainable competitive advantage.
CONCLUSIONS
The banking industry is one of the sectors that the concept of relationship marketing can make a huge
difference in terms of performance. Their sophisticated customers want the sector to give them more value
to their engagement with banks rather than the mere transactions that always take place in various
banking halls. At least, the kind of relationship that will exist between the banks and their customers; thus,
how the banks will relate positively to their customers.
Developing relationship marketing and injecting it into the overall corporate objective will help to attract
more customers both existing and potential. This will give an edge over other players in the sector. As in
today’s competition, relationship has become a unique and additional service that customers acquire as a
result of purchasing a bank’s products and service; a bank must make sure that sustainable long term
relationship marketing is developed by way of inject it into the overall bank’s corporate objectives since
the contemporary competition has gone beyond the mere transaction.
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
48
As competition has become very keen, relationship marketing has also become a very powerful tool for
sustainable competitive advantage. The findings of the study revealed, there is a significant positive
correlation between the practicing of relationship marketing and competitive advantage. Therefore, it very
indispensable for banks to include in their overall corporate business objectives and strategies that
underpin the successful relationship marketing development as a tool for sustainable competitive
advantage.
RECOMMENDATIONS
From the study, the following are the recommendations are offered;
1. Banks must go beyond the mere transaction to build sustainable relationship marketing with their
cherished customers for continuous business.
2. Since competition in the banking sector has become very keen, banks need to build sustainable
relationship marketing by including it into their overall corporate business objectives and
strategies if they want to outweigh competition.
3. Relationship marketing concept must be a central philosophy that should permeate through all the
departments within daily operational activities and not as a single unit which manages its own
thing.
4. Further research can be done on the competitive nature using relationship marketing in the non-
banks.
REFERENCES
Ashton, J.K. and Pressey, A. (2004) ‚The regulatory challenge to relationship marketing in UK banking‛, The
International Journal of Bank Marketing, 22 (6): 453-464
Baker, M. J. (2001) Encyclopedia of Marketing; Hodgson Williams Associate, Cambridge-China, 2nd ed. Pp, 755.
Barney, J. B, (1991) Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage‛ Journal of
Management, pp 99-120
Bharadwaj, S. G., Varardarajan, P. R. and Fahy, J. (1993). ‘Sustainable competitive advantage in service industries:
A conceptual model and research propositions’. Journal of Marketing, 57, pp, 83-99.
Bolton, R. N., Lemon, K. N. and Verhoef, P. C. (2008) ‚Expanding business-to-business relationships, Modeling the
customer’s upgrade decision‛, Journal of Marketing, 72 (1), pp, 46-64.
Cohen, S., Kamarck, T. and Mermelstein, R. (1983). A global measure of perceived stress, Journal of Health and
Social Behaviour, pp 24, 385-396
Gilaninia, S., Almani, A.M., Pournaserani, A., and Mousavian, S.J. (2011) ‚Relationship Marketing: a New
Approach to Marketing in the Third Millennium‛, Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 5(5):
pp, 787-799.
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
49
Gilbert, C., Karen, D., and Choi, C. (2003) Relationship marketing practice in relation to different bank ownership:
a study of banks in Hong Kong, International Journal of Bank Marketing- 21(3): pp, 137-146.,
Gro¨nroos, C. (1990) ‚Relationship approach to the marketing function in service contexts: the marketing and
organizational behavior interface”, Journal of Business Research, 20 (1): pp, 3-12.
Gro¨nroos, C., (1994) "From marketing mix to relationship marketing: Towards a paradigm shift in marketing",
Management Decision, 32(2): pp, 4-20.
Gro¨nroos, C., (1990) service management and marketing, managing the moment of truth in-service competition,
Lexington, MA: Free Press/Lexington Books
Otokiti, S. O. (2005), Methodologies and Mechanics of Computational Systems. 1st Ed. New Delhi, Sultan Chand &
Sons Publishers
Pathmarajah, A. (1993). Marketing: Theory and Practice. 6th ed., in Baker, M. (ed.). (1996), London: MacMillan.
Pearlin, L. and Schooler, C. (1978) The Structure of coping; Journal of Health and Social Behaviour, pp 19, 2-21
Sorce, P. (2002) Relationship Marketing Strategy; A Research Monograph of the Printing Industry Center at RIT,
pp 7
Zineldin, M. (1996) Bank strategic positioning and some determinants of bank selection, International Journal of
Bank Marketing, Vol. 14, No. 6, pp. 12-22
AFRICA DEVELOPMENT AND RESOURCES RESEARCH INSTITUTE (ADRRI) JOURNAL
ISSN: 2343-6662 ISSN-L: 2343-6662
VOL. 25, No. 3 (3), December, 2015
Published by Africa Development and Resources Research Institute
50
This academic research paper was published by the Africa Development and Resources Research
Institute’s Journal (ADRRI JOURNAL). ADRRI JOURNAL is a double blinded peer review,
open access international journal that aims to inspire Africa development through quality
applied research.
For more information about ADRRI JOURNAL homepage, follow: URL:
http://www.journals.adrri.org/
CALL FOR PAPERS
ADRRI JOURNAL calls for all prospective authors to submit their research papers for
publication. Research papers are accepted all year round. You can download the submission
guide on the following page: URL: http://www.journals.adrri.org/
ADRRI JOURNAL reviewers are working round the clock to get your research paper publishes
on time and therefore, you are guaranteed of a prompt response. All published papers are
available online to all readers world over without any financial or any form of barriers and
readers are advised to acknowledge ADRRI JOURNAL. All authors can apply for one printed
version of the volume on which their manuscript(s) appeared.