1 Overview of High-Performance Vehicles as Naval Platforms Volker Bertram

1

Overview of High-Performance Vehicles as Naval Platforms

Volker Bertram

2

Our definition: • no simple monohull form• weight supported by:

• hydrostatic buoyancy • hydrodynamic lift • aerostatic lift• aerodynamic lift• hybrid

High-performance usually includes:• usually high speeds • good seakeeping characteristics• enhanced manoeuvrability • reduced signatures

High-performance Marine Vehicles

3

SYTKA = System Technology for Future Combatants

compared displacement fast monohull to HPMVs

identifying as potential alternatives

• SWATH• high-speed SWATH (HSS)• surface-effect ship (SES)• trimaran

MTG conducted study of HPMVs

4

• Design characteristics: • platform stability• general arrangement (deck area and volume space)• maximum draft• ...

• Hydrodynamic characteristics: • range of operating speed• propulsion configuration• speed loss in waves• seakeeping, manoeuvrability• weight and trim sensitivity• ...

HPMVs investigated in terms of 4 characteristics

5

HPMVs investigated in terms of 4 characteristics

• Structural characteristics: • global strength, local strength• dynamic loads (slamming)• use of advanced materials• complex structures• ...

• Other characteristics: • acquisition and operating costs• state of development of the technology• survivability:

• detectability or stealth characteristics • vulnerability

6

Classification follows sustention triangle

almost 100 different concepts for hybrids

different stages of development:• preliminary concept• prototypes • in operation

7

Displacement ships

SWATHHSStrimaranwave piercer

8

Small Waterplane Area Twin Hull (SWATH)

+ superior seakeeping

+ large deck area

– higher power requirement

– weight and trim sensitive

– large draft

– acquisition and operating costs

9

Early SWATH demonstrators in USA and Japan

T-AGOSUS Navy

“Hibeki“Japan

10

German SWATH development in 2001

Wehrforschungsschiff, TNSW

11

German SWATH development in 2001

SWATHs for pilots of Abeking+Rasmussen

A+R proposed also navy SWATH

12

German Navy project for mine-hunting

SWATHs for Navy Applications

Cooperation: Luerssen Shipyard, A+R

13

SWATH“Sea Shadow”

source: http://www.fas.org

stealth technologydemonstrator

14

SWATHSLICE

source: Lockheed Martin

Lower resistance through wave system interaction

15

High Speed SWATH (HSS)

source: http://192.49.188.22

SWATH bow section

Stern planing catamaran

GTS Stena Explorer MTG HSS design

16

Record-breaking “Adventurer”

Trimarans allow high speeds

Artistvision

Reality

17

Trimaran Demonstrator “Triton”

UK Navy: Trimaran demonstrator

source: http://www.trimaran.dera.gov.uk

+ low power at high speed

+ reduced operating costs

+ better damage stability

+ good seakeeping

+ large deck area

+ efficient payload layout

+ good survivability

– ?

18

Concept study of MTG

Trimarans investigated by several navies

19

Wave Piercer

source: http://www.incat.com.au

Incat 045, HMAS “Jervis Bay”

Incat HSV-X1 “Joint Venture”

20

Wave Piercer Incat HSV-X1

“Joint Venture” (US Army)

500 fully equipped troops

40+ knots

up to 1000 nm

21

Paragon Mann: VSV Wave Piercer Patrol boat

Wave Piercer

source: http://www.halmatic.co.uk

22

Wave Piercer Projects

source: http://www.dd21.goldteam.com

Stealth designDD 21 project

Stealth design“Sea Wraith”

MTG Frigate

23

Fast Monohull

source: Blohm&Voss

Only civilian applications built

24

Hydrofoils

25

+ high cruising speed+ improved seakeeping

– limited payload capability– large draft

Russian Mukha class

Surface Piercing Hydrofoils (SPH)

Fully Submerged Hydrofoils (FSH)

photo: Ehlers

Canadian Bras d‘Or

PHM (Boeing)

26

Air-Cushion Vehicles

27

+ very high speed

+ low vulnerability to

underwater explosions

+ small draft and underwater signature

+ amphibious capability

source: http://www.tmls.textron.com

– affected by wind

– trim sensitivity

– high acquisition cost

– high maintenance cost

28

USA employs ACV as LCAC (Landing Craft Air Cushion)

29

Russian LCAC Aist Class70 knots

photos: Ehlers

Russian LCACPomornik classLargest ACV worldwide150t payload, 63 knots

30

Finnish ACV “Tuuli”delivered in 2002

photos: Ehlers

ACVs suitable for operation in ice

31

SES (Surface Effect Ships)

32

No surface effect involved

+ operate at high speeds (> 40 knots)+ reduced underwater signature+ improved shock resistance+ good platform stability + shallow draft and large deck area

– speed loss in head seas– loss of amphibious capability– high acquisition and maintenance costs

Air Cushion Catamarans (SES)

33

Various SES built and operated by navies

Oksøy class minehunter (NO)AGNES 200 (FR)

“Bora“ missile corvette (RU)

34

Stealth SES built in Scandinavia

Skjöld class patrol boat (NO) “Smyge“ (SE)

35

SES Demonstrator “Corsair”

Blohm&Voss

MEKAT conceptallows modular conversion

37

Hybrid Hydrofoils

HysucatHYSWAS

38

HYSWAS = Hydrofoil small waterplane area ship

Foil contribute 30-70% lift

+ extended range+ good seakeeping

– high cost– payload critical

39

German Concept study never realized

Design study for fast ferry by Bremer Vulkan

photos: EMIT

40

Japanese built prototype

TSL-F

41

Navy HYSWAS projectedUS Projects ranging from patrol boat to 2400t frigate

42

HYSWAS demonstrator: “Quest”

Tested 1995, US Navy

43

Hysucat: Hydrofoil-supported catamaran

South-African development, Tandem foil arrangement

+ good seakeeping+ low resistance– foil tailored to design condition

44

Sustention Pyramid

45

Wing-in-Ground (WIG) = Ekranoplans

Source: jpcolliat.free.fr/ekra/ekraA.html

+ very high cruising speeds+ good transport efficiency (vs aeroplanes)+ no airports needed– safety concerns– low payload– take-off requires high power

46

Russian Navy used Ekranoplans

“Caspian Sea Monster” 550t weight (>747-400)

500 km/h

Source: jpcolliat.free.fr/ekra/ekraA.html

47

Russian Navy used Ekranoplans

“Lun” (missile launcher)400t weight, 450 km/h

Source: jpcolliat.free.fr/ekra/ekraA.html

48

Russian Navy used Ekranoplans

“Orlyonok” (troop transporter)110t weight, 400 km/h

Source: jpcolliat.free.fr/ekra/ekraA.html

49

US Navy has studied WIGs as transporters

50

German Wing-in-Ground (WIG)

Flightship

Hoverwing

51

• Deep-V monohull

• Planing hulls

• Semi-planing hulls

• Weinblume (staggered hull cataramans)

• ...

Many more concepts exist...

52

And now it’s time to…