52
Building Trust. Engineering Success. Vertical Lined Barrier System: Case Study: Four Hills Landfill Presented by Ryan L. Clay, E.I.T. Senior Project Engineer Sanborn, Head & Associates, Inc. 1

Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Building Trust. Engineering Success.

Vertical Lined Barrier System: Case Study: Four Hills Landfill

Presented by Ryan L. Clay, E.I.T.

Senior Project Engineer

Sanborn, Head & Associates, Inc.

1

Page 2: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Presentation Outline

1. History of vertical lined barriers

2. Case Study: Four Hills Landfill a. The dilemma

b. Initial solution

c. Constructability issues

d. Diagnosing the problem

e. Designing new solution

f. Constructing the barrier

3. Questions

2

Page 3: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

History: what and why?

http://www.dewindonepasstrenching.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/HDPE_Barrier_Walls.jpg

3

Page 4: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

http://www.ce.utexas.edu/prof/zornberg/pdfs/BC/Zornberg_Christopher_2007.pdf

4

Page 5: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Uses at Landfills

http://www.ce.utexas.edu/prof/zornberg/pdfs/BC/Zornberg_Christopher_2007.pdf

5

Page 6: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Bristol Landfill in Bristol, Virginia - The first abandoned open-pit quarry excavation to be lined and backfilled with municipal solid waste.

http://geosyntheticsmagazine.com/articles/0410_f1_backfill.html

6

Page 7: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

http://www.tensarinternational.com/Applications/Landfill-Construction/Landfill-Liner-Support#

7

Page 8: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Case Study – Nashua, NH

8

YOU

ARE

HERE

Page 9: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH

9

Closed Unlined Landfill

Closed Unlined

C&D Landfill

Active Lined

Landfill

LFGTE Facility operated by

PPL Renewable Energy Compost

Facility

Page 10: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

10

Page 11: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

The dilemma

Landfill was designed/constructed with liner system extending within a 500-foot setback to structures not owned by the City.

City sought a waiver but was denied.

Cannot place any MSW within 500-foot setback.

Plan needed to optimize airspace.

11

Page 12: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Airspace

12

Page 13: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Separation

13

Page 14: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Initial Solution

14

Page 15: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Discovered Problem

15

Page 16: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Investigation

16

Page 17: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Lateral deviation

17

Page 18: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

http://www.bloggs74.com/artwork/food-art/

18

Page 19: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Now what?

What’s done is done. City decides it’s not cost effective to recover lost airspace.

How do we move forward?

Can we get back on track?

Goal = Limit future loss of airspace.

Need a new plan.

19

Page 20: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

20

Page 21: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Maybe there’s another way

City expresses frustration with constructing the soil wall.

City suggests a retaining wall.

New design must be:

a) Hydraulic barrier;

b) Equal to or less expensive than constructing soil wall; and

c) Safe and simple to construct.

21

Page 22: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Building Blocks

22

Cheap

Interlocking

Easy to transport

Page 23: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Design

23

NON-WOVEN GEOTEXTILE

NON-WOVEN GEOTEXTILE

SMOOTH HDPE GEOMEMBRANE

Page 24: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Profile

24

Page 25: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

25

Page 26: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

26

Page 27: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Stability – Scenario 1

27

Page 28: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Stability – Scenario 2

28

Page 29: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Design Recommendation

29

Page 30: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Construction

30

Page 31: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

31

Page 32: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

32

Page 33: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

33

Page 34: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

34

Page 35: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

35

Page 36: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

36

Page 37: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

37

Page 38: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

38

Page 39: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

39

Page 40: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

40

Page 41: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

41

Page 42: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

42

Page 43: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

43

Page 44: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

44

Page 45: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

45

Page 46: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

46

Page 47: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

47

Page 48: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

48

Page 49: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

49

Page 50: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

50

Page 51: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

51

Page 52: Vertical Lined Barrier System ClayR.pdfCase Study – Nashua, NH 8 YOU ARE HERE . Four Hills Landfill – Nashua, NH 9 Closed Unlined Landfill Closed Unlined C&D Landfill Active Lined

Questions?

Thank you!

Ryan L Clay, E.I.T

Senior Project Engineer

Sanborn, Head & Associates, Inc.

[email protected]

52