Use & Evaluation of Behavioural Science Methods: a UK Perspective (presentation), George Brander 2009

7/31/2019 Use & Evaluation of Behavioural Science Methods: a UK Perspective (presentation), George Brander 2009

1/25

Ztj ) Jyhkzhvmge giZtj ) Jyhkzhvmge gi

Nj`hymgz~hk Tdmjedj Ljv`gft?Nj`hymgz~hk Tdmjedj Ljv`gft?

h ZB Sj~tsjdvmyjh ZB Sj~tsjdvmyj

Ajg~aj N~hefj~

ZEDKHTTMIMJF

N~mvmt` D~gqe Dgs}~ma v >33= ' LGF%

Sznkmt`jf qmv` v`j sj~lmttmge gi v`j Dgev~gkkj~ gi @j~ N~mvheemd Lhojtv}t Tvhvmgej~} Giimdj%


2/25

V`jlj gi S~jtjevhvmgeV`jlj gi S~jtjevhvmge

H izkk tsjdv~zl gi `zlhe hef nj`hymgz~hk tdmjedjt mt

ejdjtth~} (qmv`me Fjijedj hef tsjdmimdhkk} me tzssg~v

gi Meig~lhvmge Gsj~hvmget-+ me g~fj~ vg njvvj~

zefj~tvhef v`gtj mefmymfzhkt hef tgdmhk a~gzstq`gtj hvvmvzfjt hef nj`hymgz~t ig~l sh~v gi v`j ejq

nhvvkj,tshdj%

S~gnkjlt qmv` fhvh hyhmkhnmkmv} hef hvv~mnzvmge gi

dhztj hef jiijdv ljhe v`hv+ q`mkj v`j ljv`gft ztjf

vjef vg ~jtmtv v~hfmvmgehk yhkmfhvmge hef jyhkzhvmge

hss~ghd`jt+ njtv s~hdvmdj dhe tvmkk nj s~ga~jttjf%


3/25

GzvkmejGzvkmej

k Dgevjpv gi Ztj (i~hlj-

k Ztmea `zlhe ) nj`hymgz~hk tdmjedj

ljv`gft me Fjijedjk V`j s}~hlmf gi hehk}tmt bj} v`jljt

k S~gnkjlt qmv`? Fhvh+ V`jg~mjt+ Ljv`gft ) Vggkt+ S~gdjttjt+ Gzvszvt

k Tzllh~}


4/25

Ima`vmea nhvvkjt mt egvIma`vmea nhvvkjt mt egv

hngzv vj~~mvg~}+ mv mthngzv vj~~mvg~}+ mv mthngzv sjgskj+ hvvmvzfjthngzv sjgskj+ hvvmvzfjt

hef sj~djsvmget% V`jhef sj~djsvmget% V`j

nhvvkja~gzef mt v`j~j%nhvvkja~gzef mt v`j~j%

V`j @zlhe Ihdvg~V`j @zlhe Ihdvg~ %%

Ajej~hk Tm~ Lmd`hjk Ohdbtge (Ijn >333-Ajej~hk Tm~ Lmd`hjk Ohdbtge (Ijn >333-


5/25

MefmymfzhkMefmymfzhkMefmymfzhk

Dzkvz~jDzkvz~j

Vjhl ' A~gzs

Meig~lhvmgeMeig~lhvmge

Jeym~geljevJeym~geljev

Qmfj~ DgevjpvQmfj~ Dgevjpv

Dgevjpv gi Ztj


6/25

Hehk}tmt ) HttjttljevHehk}tmt ) Httjttljev

@ZLH

E

IH

DVG^T

St}d`gkga}

Gddzshvmgehk

Tgdmhk

(Dkmemdhk-

Hev`~gsgkga}

Ljfmh ) Lh~bjvmea

Ogz~ehkmtl

Lh~bjv ^jtjh~d`

Bj} MefmymfzhktBj} Mefmymfzhkt

Vjhlt ' A~gzstVjhlt ' A~gzst

Tgdmhk A~gzsmeatTgdmhk A~gzsmeat

Dzkvz~hk dgevjpvtDzkvz~hk dgevjpvt

Meig~lhvmge Jeym~geljevMeig~lhvmge Jeym~geljev

Hvvmvzfjt ) GsmemgetHvvmvzfjt ) Gsmemget


7/25

Dgkkhvmge )Jyhkzhvmge

Hehk}tmt

Httjttljev

V~zv` (qmv` j~~g~ nh~t-+dgeimfjedj kjyjkt )

s~gnhnmkmvmjt

Nmht+ Ikhqjf hehk}tmt) hehk}vmd s~gdjttjt

(@hefmdhssjf Lmef-

Medglskjvj+ Lmttmea

) Fjdjsvmyj Fhvh

hfhsvjf i~gl T`j~lhe Bjevhfhsvjf i~gl T`j~lhe Bjevt s}~hlmft s}~hlmf


8/25


Hehk}tmt

Httjttljev

Kmvvkj qg~b ge v`j yhkmfmv}

gi fhvh% Tglj me TEH h~jh

Fhvhhyhmkhnkj

Sgvjevmhkk} nmhtjf Dgkkjdvmge

S~gdjttjt

Ljv`gft ) Vggkt

Httjttljevt

ZtjhnkjV`jg~mjt


9/25

Mfjevmi}mea Nmht hef Ahst me fhvhMfjevmi}mea Nmht hef Ahst me fhvh

^jsg~vmea (me }jh~-

hssjh~t nmhtjf vgqh~ft

v`~jj jevmvmjt

S~mg~mvmtj Sgvjevmhk

Ahst

Sgvjevmhk Nmht

Igz~ ejq jevmvmjt vg

n~mea vg hvvjevmge gi

hehk}tv+ dgkkhvg~t hef

dgkkjdvg~t

H

F N

Ygkzlj gi ~jsg~vmea

Mlsg~vhedj (ht httjttjf n} tgdmhk ejvqg~b hehk}tmt ljv~md-

D

^jkhvmyj Hzv`g~mv}

^jkhvmyj Meikzjedj


10/25

S~gnkjlt qmv` fhvhS~gnkjlt qmv` fhvh

k Fhvh hyhmkhnkj mt `ma`k} yh~mhnkj

medglskjvj+ j~~gejgzt+ fjdjmyjf+ nmhtjf+ jvd%

k Yh~mhnmkmv} hktg qmv`me tznojdvt jamefmymfzhkt yh~} hddg~fmea vg?

k Haj

k Hddjtt vg ~jtgz~djt

k Jfzdhvmgehk nhdba~gzefk Dzkvz~hk eg~lt

k Kmij jpsj~mjedjt

k @jhkv`


11/25

@gq vg dgetmfj~ v`j mefmymfzhk7@gq vg dgetmfj~ v`j mefmymfzhk7

LgvmyhvmgeLgvmyhvmge

V~hmvt ) S~jij~jedjtV~hmvt ) S~jij~jedjt

Tv~jtt )Tv~jtt )

DgsmeaDgsmea

FjdmtmgeFjdmtmge

LhbmeaLhbmea

Tv~jeav`t 'Tv~jeav`t '

QjhbejttjtQjhbejttjt

DgeimfjedjDgeimfjedj

TjkiTjki

MlhajMlhaj

NHDBA^GZEFNHDBA^GZEF

NJ@HYMGZ^HKNJ@HYMGZ^HK

JYMFJEDJJYMFJEDJ

(FM^JDV-(FM^JDV-

V@M^F SH^V]V@M^F SH^V]

GNTJ^YHVMGETGNTJ^YHVMGET

Qg~b vg jetz~j je`hedjfQg~b vg jetz~j je`hedjf

fm~jdv jymfjedj mt hyhmkhnkjfm~jdv jymfjedj mt hyhmkhnkj

S~gymfj v~hmemea )S~gymfj v~hmemea )

vggkt ig~ gntj~yj~tvggkt ig~ gntj~yj~t

Jpskg~j hef jyhkzhvjJpskg~j hef jyhkzhvj

hkvj~ehvmyj ljv`gfthkvj~ehvmyj ljv`gft


12/25

V`jg~mjt (he jdkjdvmd lmp-V`jg~mjt (he jdkjdvmd lmp-

Me g~fj~ vg gsj~hvj me v`j dgevjpv gi?

@ma`k} yh~mhnkj fhvh

Mefmymfzhk yh~mhnmkmv}

Fmiij~mea dzkvz~hk eg~lt

Hef njdhztj tjki,~jsg~v ljv`gft h~j mehss~gs~mhvj+

qj `hyj ng~~gqjf i~gl ~jkjyhev v`jg~mjt hef

hfhsvjf ljv`gft ) hss~ghd`jt vg gz~ fglhme


13/25

V`jg~mjt ) hss~ghd`jtV`jg~mjt ) hss~ghd`jt

LgvmyhvmgeLgvmyhvmge

V~hmvt ) S~jij~jedjtV~hmvt ) S~jij~jedjt

Tv~jtt )Tv~jtt )

DgsmeaDgsmea

FjdmtmgeFjdmtmge

LhbmeaLhbmea

Tv~jeav`t 'Tv~jeav`t '

QjhbejttjtQjhbejttjt

DgeimfjedjDgeimfjedj

TjkiTjki

MlhajMlhaj

Kjhfj~t`ms Tv}kjKjhfj~t`ms Tv}kj

(@j~lhe-(@j~lhe-

Lgvmyhvmgehk Tv}kjLgvmyhvmgehk Tv}kj

(LdDkjkkhef ) Qmevj~-(LdDkjkkhef ) Qmevj~-

Mevja~hvmyjMevja~hvmyj

Dglskjpmv}Dglskjpmv}

((TzjfijkfTzjfijkf--

Sj~tgehkmv} V~hmvtSj~tgehkmv} V~hmvt

8: IX8: IX

EJGEJG

Sj~tgehkSj~tgehk

S~jij~jedjtS~jij~jedjt

LNVMLNVM

Jygkymea Ljv`gftJygkymea Ljv`gft

hef Vggkthef Vggkt

Xzjtvmgeehm~jt

I~hljqg~bt

Dgevjev Hehk}tmt

Nj`hymgz~hk

dgetmtvjed}

gyj~ vmlj

Gv`j~ V`jg~mjtGv`j~ V`jg~mjt

Kmij TvhajtKmij Tvhajt

(J~mbttge-(J~mbttge-


14/25


Hehk}tmt

Httjttljev



Lgtv yhkmfhvmge xzjtvmget

vjef vg nj `j~j%

Fhvhhyhmkhnkj


S~gdjttjt

Ljv`gft ) Vggkt

Httjttljevt

ZtjhnkjV`jg~mjt


15/25

Dgev~gkkjf dgefmvmget

Vmljf tjki,~jsg~v vjtv

Jtvhnkmt`jf

Metv~zljevMls~gyjf

^jkmhnmkmv}

Httjttjf

Yhkmfmv}Fjtmaejf vg td~jjeg~ tjkjdv mefmymfzhkti~gl h sgszkhvmge hefvg vzej v`j sj~ig~lhedjgi tjkjdvjf mefmymfzhkt

Fm~jdvHttjttljev

Yhkmfmv} nhtjf zsgetzddjtt gi metv~zljev

vg dhvjag~mtj mefmymfzhkt

^jlgvj

Httjttljev

Gntj~yjf nj`hymgz~+

v`m~f sh~v} httjttljev

) dhtj `mtvg~} hehk}tmt

Jlskg} ihdjvt gi yhkmf

jtvhnkmt`jf metv~zljevt

v`hv ztj gntj~yhnkjt

Httjttljev gimefmymfzhk me dgevjpv

Mevj~,~hvj~ ~jkmhnmkmv} )

Zvmkmv} gi httjttljev

Ztj gi v~mheazkhvmge )

Sjj~ ~jymjq s~gdjttjt

@gq vg jyhkzhvjhttjttljev hahmetv

~jhk qg~kf v~zv`7

Fjtmaejf vg hmf mejeahajljev g~

ejagvmhvmge


16/25


Hehk}tmt

HttjttljevS~gdjtt dgetmfj~hvmget tjje

ht v`j bj} vg jiijdvmyj hehk}tmt




vjef vg nj `j~j%

Fhvhhyhmkhnkj


S~gdjttjt

Ljv`gft ) Vggkt

Httjttljevt

ZtjhnkjV`jg~mjt


17/25

S~gdjtt MttzjtS~gdjtt Mttzjt

k Igdztjf ge hehk}tmt ) httjttljev s~gdjtt dgllge ) dgevmezmea v~hmemea+ d`hkkjeaj ) fmtdzttmge+ sjj~

~jymjq+ ig~lhk ~jymjq+ kganggbt ) vhnkjt gi ztj

t`h~j ) dglsh~j hss~ghd`jt hd~gtt ZB Agyj~eljev Nj`hymgz~hkTdmjedj Dgllzemv}

t`h~j ) dglsh~j hss~ghd`jt qmv` Hkkmjt?ZTH+ : J}jt+ tglj EHVG sh~vej~t

k Kmebjf ~jtjh~d` tvzfmjt Ftvk tvzf} (LgF ^jtjh~d`- , hkvj~ehvmyj hss~ghd`jt vg Yhkmfhvmge

Jpskg~mea egyjk hss~ghd`jt (v~mheazkhvmge mttzjt-?ja? ngf} lgyjljev+ sj~tgehk tshdj+ nj`hymgz~ me ejvqg~b

Jeahajljev qmv` Hdhfjlmh

Dgkkhng~hvmyj ~jtjh~d` qmv` gv`j~ dgzev~mjt%Ja? Hztv~hkmhe (FTVG- ) Dhehfmhe (F^FD- ~jtjh~d`


18/25


Hehk}tmt

Httjttljev

V`j zvmkmv} gi v`j httjttljev

me tzssg~vmea fjdmtmget%

S~gdjtt dgetmfj~hvmget tjje

ht v`j bj} vg yhkmf hehk}tmt




vjef vg nj `j~j%

Fhvhhyhmkhnkj


S~gdjttjt

Ljv`gft ) Vggkt

Httjttljevt

ZtjhnkjV`jg~mjt


19/25

Yhkmfmv}+ ^jkmhnmkmv} hef Zvmkmv}?Yhkmfmv}+ ^jkmhnmkmv} hef Zvmkmv}?

q`hv fg Dztvglj~t ejjf7q`hv fg Dztvglj~t ejjf7

k Hqh~jejtt Fmf M begq M dgzkf htb7k Skhztmnmkmv} Fg M ha~jj7

k D~jfmnmkmv} Fg gv`j~t ha~jj7

k

V~ztvqg~v`mejtt ^jszvhvmge gi hehk}tv(t-7k Metma`v Mlskmdhvmget ig~ hdvmge7

(shttmea v`j Tg Q`hv7 vjtv-


20/25

Fjhkmea qmv` Dztvglj~tFjhkmea qmv` Dztvglj~t

k Hygmf st}d`gkgamdhk oh~age

k Lhehaj jpsjdvhvmget

hml vg hfymtj ) ig~jdhtv ~hv`j~ v`he s~jfmdvk Giij~ ~jdglljefhvmget q`j~j sgttmnkj

k Tjjb ijjfnhdb (ge hddz~hd} hef zvmkmv}-

k Tjjb vg httjtt hddz~hd} gi gzvdglj

nzv+ amyje v`j khdb gi Ljhtz~jt gi Jiijdv+hvv~mnzvmea dhzthkmv} ~jlhmet yj~} fmiimdzkv


21/25

Me tzllh~}Me tzllh~}


22/25

Hehk}tmt ) HttjttljevHehk}tmt ) Httjttljev

@ZLH

E

IH

DVG^T

XZHKMVHVMYJ

XZHEVMVHVMYJ

Njkmjit

Lgvmyhvmget

Kjhfj~t`ms Tv}kjt

Fjdmtmge Lhbmea Tv}kjt

Meig~lhvmge Ikgq

Meig~lhvmge S~jij~jedj

Ahvjbjjsj~t ' Hfymtg~t) Gsmemge Ig~lj~t

Tgdmhk Ejvqg~b Hehk}tmt

Dzkvz~hk S~hdvmdjt

Tgdmhk Tv~zdvz~jt

Igdzt A~gzst ' Sgkkmea

Bj} MefmymfzhktBj} Mefmymfzhkt

Vjhlt ' A~gzstVjhlt ' A~gzst

Tgdmhk A~gzsmeatTgdmhk A~gzsmeat

Dzkvz~hk dgevjpvtDzkvz~hk dgevjpvt

Meig~lhvmge Jeym~geljevMeig~lhvmge Jeym~geljev

Hvvmvzfjt ) GsmemgetHvvmvzfjt ) Gsmemget


23/25

@I hehk}tmt mt kh~ajk} XZHKMVHVMYJ@I hehk}tmt mt kh~ajk} XZHKMVHVMYJ

k Jv`ega~hs`}%

k S`jegljegkga}

k Imjkf ^jtjh~d`

k

Gntj~yhvmge (fm~jdv ) mefm~jdv-k Dhtj Tvzf} hss~ghd`jt

V~hfmvmgehk (xzhevmvhvmyj- hss~ghd`jt vgV~hfmvmgehk (xzhevmvhvmyj- hss~ghd`jt vg

yhkmfhvmge lh} egv nj tziimdmjev% @I jlskg}tyhkmfhvmge lh} egv nj tziimdmjev% @I jlskg}tlzkvmlzkvm,,fmtdmskmeh~}+ lzkvmfmtdmskmeh~}+ lzkvm,,ljv`gfgkgamjt v`hvljv`gfgkgamjt v`hv

tjjb vg s~gymfj metma`v+ qmv` h tzmvhnkj fja~jjtjjb vg s~gymfj metma`v+ qmv` h tzmvhnkj fja~jj

gi ~magz~+ q`mktv jygkymeagi ~magz~+ q`mktv jygkymea njtv s~hdvmdjnjtv s~hdvmdj%%


24/25

Qmkkmhl @jtbjv` Kjyj~+Qmkkmhl @jtbjv` Kjyj~+8tv Ymtdgzev Kjyj~`zklj+8tv Ymtdgzev Kjyj~`zklj+

he Jeakmt` Mefztv~mhkmtv+ s`mkhev`~gsmtvhe Jeakmt` Mefztv~mhkmtv+ s`mkhev`~gsmtvhef dgkgemhkmtvhef dgkgemhkmtv

@hki v`j lgej} M tsjef ge hfyj~vmtmea mt qhtvjf+@hki v`j lgej} M tsjef ge hfyj~vmtmea mt qhtvjf+

hef v`j v~gznkj mt M fge!v begq q`md` `hki%hef v`j v~gznkj mt M fge!v begq q`md` `hki%


25/25

Xzjtvmget7Xzjtvmget7

Documents

Use & Evaluation of Behavioural Science Methods: a UK Perspective (presentation), George Brander 2009