ITS

Vol 5 No 2 Thinking Highways30 www.thinkinghighways.com

!"#$%&%'#( )( &%*( +%( ,-+.( '!%,#/,( 0( 1#&%( +%,#$%&2( 3!"#$%&%'#( !4( ,-#(#%,#$5$+.#(+,.#24($&,-#$(,-&%(#/,#$%&2(!"#$.+3-,(67(2#3+.2&,!$.8($#392&,!$.8( !"#$%&'(#)$*'(!+'!%# !"# ,!"-.%(/#"'0,.,$!1+ 2'(.# 1#+-.%#"'3#!'# %&'#4$&1#:!$;(+%(&(1&%%#$(,-&,(&''!9%,.(4!$(%#&$(,#$1($#&2+,+#.(:-+2#($#1&+%),!)#4$%&#5#'6,47'#%$#0& !)'# !"#8 ,%&8-7#%$#%&'#$(,),! 7#*,.,$!#$8#%&'#9($:'0%;

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

?&",!"(A,.*2("$(+("%!"#$("E9" "/-423"0%#("#$("E9"F(3(+,2"?'%,#%-!"?3.%!%&#+,#%-!"GF??H"?%+*-+#" .*+-'(.(!#"I+-6+,."G? IHJ:" "? I<" 2%C("#$("K--3"L-,3&",!3"+,%2+-,3"0-!0(&&%-!&"(A,.*2("0%#(3"(,+2%(+<"/,&"2%C(/%&(","*(+5(0#21"2-6%0,2"+(&*-!&("#-"#$("31!,.%0&"-5"#$("#%.(:"?2#$-46$"/(22"0-!0(%'(3",!3"3%2%6(!#21"4*3,#(3"71"M-!6+(&&",!3",3.%!%&#(+(3"71"#$(",6(!01"&%!0(<"? I"+(.,%!&"#-"&,1"#$("2(,&#"0-!&#+,%!(3"71"%#&"-+%6%!,2"2(6,01<"#$,#"-5"*$1&%0,2",%+*-+#"(A*,!&%-!"#-",00-..-3,#("#$("!(/21"3()+(642,#(3"E9"0-..(+0%,2",'%,#%-!"%!34&#+1"-5"#$("(,+21"JNOP@&:";$%2(",0$%('%!6"#$("3(&%+(3"(55(0#",#"#$("#%.("-5".-+("6,#(&",!3"+4!/,1&"#-"&4*)5' %&2 !)%! &.#41! "&'(&7&+26%"8&)"&%!-6.'$'29&+.- !)"+.2$9&1!-)4!&)"&4#-6&)&()-%' &)"&-'.- !%!&

!"#"$%&'()*+,-"$%&./0&1,20&34!&567

89,!.&:;

31Thinking Highways Vol 5 No 2www.thinkinghighways.com

ITS

Supporters have long promoted its prospective

benefits but making ITS a reality requires the best of

both public and private resources to transform the

experience of driving, says DAVID E PICKERAL in the

second of this two-part feature, continued from the

March/April issue

,!3"&#((2"%!",%+*-+#"-*(+,#%-!&"(!$,!0(.(!#<"#$("? I"%!0+(,&%!621"7(0,.(")",!3"2,+6(21"&#%22"%&")"4!,72("#-",33+(&&"#(0$!-2-61"+(2,#(3"54!3%!6"#-"%!0243(<"-5"0-4+&(<" 89"&1&#(.&"3(&%6!(3"#-"-*#%.%B("0,*,0%#1"-!"(A%&#%!6"*$1&%0,2",&&(#&"%!"2%(4"-5",33%!6"!(/"-!(&:"

L,#$(+<"#$("-*#%.,2" 89"(!#(+*+%&("6-'(+!,!0(".-3(2"&$-423"%3(,221"%!'-2'("#$("+%6$#".%A"-5"(.*-/(+(3"3(0%&%-!).,C(+&<"3(+%'("5+-."*+-*(+21"(340,#(3"0-!&(!&4&"-!"2-!6"#(+."-7Q(0)%+0!"8&).*&+."%+%#%+'.)$+:!&)&,& 4&-'44+%4!.%&%'&)-%+'.&'.&.!) &%! 4&'1;!-%+0!"&)"&%6!9&) +"!<&

!"#(+.&"-5"(.*-/(+(3"3(0%&%-!).,C(+&<"(A*(+%(!0("$,&"&$-/!"#$,#","*+-*(+21"5-+.42,#(3",!3" .,!,6(3" (A(04#%'(" 0-..%##((" $,&" #+(.(!3-4&" *-#(!#%,2" #-" 7,2,!0(" #$(" 02,+%#1" -5" ,!"

ITS

!"#$%&'($)*+$%+'+,)("*($'&&-+./'&&"*#$*#+0)1"&+)2("*+('3$*#+-"'4%+'*1+0'*-+.)0,4)0$%"%+'*1+1"&'-%+()+"*'.(+)4+

./'*#"5+'&0)%(+$*6'4$'7&-+4"%8&($*#+$*+'+1$6"4#"*."+9$(/+.844"*(5+

08./+&"%%+28(84"5+%$(8'($)*%+'*1+*""1%:

32 Vol 5 No 2 Thinking Highways www.thinkinghighways.com

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

!"#(+.&"-5"-55(+%!6","0-!0+(#("(A,.*2("-5"&400(&&"5-+"#$%&"/,1"-5"3-%!6"#$%!6&<" "/-423"0%#("#$("#+(.(!3-4&"&400(&&"-5"!4.(+-4&" &#,#(/%3(" %!#(+-*(+,7%2%#1" (A(04#%'(" 0-..%##((&"G9 >MH" %!".,!1"E9"&#,#(&"0-!'(!(3"-'(+"#$("*,&#"3(0,3("#-",33+(&&" 0+%#%0,2"*472%0" &,5(#1" M8" %&&4(&" ,!3"!((3&" 5+-." #$("6+26!"%&$!0!$"&'(&2'0! .4!.%"&%'&%6!&, "%& !"5'.*! &$!0!$V:"

A sustainable model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

5 '-!""&?+%6&)&"%) %&).*&)&,.+"6&1#%&+.0'$0!"&-'.%+.#)$&)-%+0!&0-22,7-+,#%-!"5+-."#$("2-0,2"#-"#$("62-7,2"2('(2",!3"%!0-+*-+,#)%!6"#$+(("7,&%0"0-!0(*#&Y

90,2,72(Y"A%&+"&!""!.%+)$&%6)%&+.( )"% #-%# !&-).&1!&1#+$%&'#%&).*3-+"+(*2%0,#(3"-!","!,#%-!,2"-+"('(!"%!#(+!,#%-!,2"2('(2:"L(0,22%!6"#$("3%&04&&%-!"-5"#$("+-2(&"-5"7-#$"6-'(+!.(!#&",!3"%!'(&#-+&",7-'(<" %#"&$-423"-55(+"LS ",!3"0-&#"(55(0#%'(!(&&"#$,#",**(,2"7-#$" #-" *472%0" &(0#-+" 7436(#&" ,!3" *+%',#(" &(0#-+" %!'(&#-+&:"F%!,221"%#"&$-423"(.*2-1"04++(!#"74#"*+-'(!"#(0$!-2-61"#$,#"%&"&47Q(0#"#-",0#%'("LZ["(55-+#&"#-"(!&4+("54#4+("(!$,!0(.(!#&",2-!6"#$("&,.("2%!(&"'(+&4&"=-!()-55 @"(D4%*.(!#"-+",**2%0,#%-!&"#$,#".4&#"7("0-.*2(#(21"+(*2,0(3:"

M-.*,#%72(Y"L(%!5-+0%!6"#$%&"#$(.("1(#",6,%!<" 89"%!5+,&#+40)#4+("&$-423"!-#"7("(!04.7(+(3"71"*+-*+%(#,+1"#(0$!-2-6%(&"#$,#"2%.%#"0-.*(#%#%-!"/$%2("&#%22",22-/%!6"5-+"%!!-',#%'("&-24)#%-!&"#$,#"0,!"-55(+"',24("0+(,#%-!"5-+"*+%',#("*,+#%0%*,!#&:" #"+(2%(&"-!"0-..-!"#(0$!%0,2"&#,!3,+3&",!3"-*(+,#%-!,2"*+,0)#%0(&"3('(2-*(3"#$+-46$"0-!&(!&4&",#"#$("!,#%-!,2"-+"%!#(+!,)#%-!,2" 2('(2:" F+-." ," &#+%0#21" #(0$!%0,2" *(+&*(0#%'(" #$(+(" ,+("(55(0#%'(21"#$+(("=*%22,+&@"-5"0-.*,#%7%2%#1\

B&&&C)-D?) *&='45)%+1+$+%9&%'&)$$'?&$!2)-9&.!%?' D"&).*3' &0-.*-!(!#&"#-"-*(+,#("/%#$"!(/"#(0$!-2-61

B& & &E' ?) *&='45)%+1+$+%9& %'&)$$'?&-# !.%& %!-6.'$'29& %'&+(.,%!"(55(0#%'("#$+-46$"1(,+&"-+"('(!"3(0,3(&"-5"54+#$(+"3('(2-*.(!#

B& A.%! '5! )1+$+%9&19&4!)."&'(&)55 ')*+%,#("$,+3/,+("-+"&-5#/,+(" %!#(+5,0(&"#-"0-!!(0#"/%#$"-#$(+"&1&#(.&:"L,%&%!6"#$%&"#-*%0"-!0(".-+(<"#$%&"(2(.(!#"0+%#%)0,221"%!0243(&",22-/%!6"%!3%'%34,2"*+-*+%)(#,+1" ,**2%0,#%-!&" #-" +4!" -!" -*(!"&#,!3,+3&" !(#/-+C&<" #$4&" %!0(!#%'%B%!6"(!#+(*+(!(4+&" #-" 3('(2-*" ,!3" .,+C(#"%!!-',#%'("!(/"*+-340#&"/$%2&#"*+(&(+')%!6"#$("-*(!",00(&&%7%2%#1"-5"#$("!(#/-+C"%#&(25:

K+((!Y"?&" ,2+(,31" 3%&04&&(3<" 89" $,&""+2.+,-).%&5'%!.%+)$&%'&5 '0+*!&!.0+ '.)4!.%)$&1!.!,%"&)"&).&!.*& !"#$%<&C!9'.*&

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

The privacy issueF%!,221<"-!("-5" #$(".-&#"-5#(!" 0%#(3" &#4.72%!6"72-0C&" #-" 89"3(*2-1.(!#<" *,+#%042,+21" %!" #$(" E9<" %!'-2'(&" #$(" *472%0" G,!3<"0-..(!&4+,721<" *-2%#%0,2H" *(+0(*#%-!" #$,#" 3-%!6" &-" /-423""0-.*+-.%&(" %!3%'%34,2" *+%',01" +%6$#&<" %:(:<" #$(" #+,!&.%##,2" -5""5! "'.)$$9&+*!.%+,)1$!&+.(' 4)%+'.&FGAAH&+.&"#-6&)&?)9&)"&%'&1!&7+-,321",00(&&%72("5-+"*4+*-&(&"&40$",&"2,/"(!5-+0(.(!#"5-+""5!!*&0+'$)%+'."8& +*!.%+%9& %6!(%& (' & %'$$+.2&).*&'%6! &,.).-+)$&

#+,!&,0#%-!&<"-+"&%.*21"#+,0C%!6",!"%!3%'%34,2"'($%02(@&"/$(+(,)7-4#&"5-+"*4+*-&(&"4!+(2,#(3"#-"#+,!&*-+#,#%-!".,!,6(.(!#",!3" %!5-+.,#%-!:";$%2(" #$(&(" 0-!0(+!&" ,+(" (A#+(.(21" /(22"5-4!3(3" %!" #$("*472%0"*-2%01"-5",22"3(.-0+,0%(&"#$("*+,0#%0,2"+(,2%#1" %&" #$,#" #-" #$(" (A#(!#" *+%',01" -72%6,#%-!&" (A%&#" %!" -4+"#+,!&*-+#"!(#/-+C"'%+#4,221",22"-5"#$(."$,'("7((!"-7'%,#(3"71"#$("#(0$!-2-6%0,2",!3"-*(+,#%-!,2"3('(2-*.(!#&"%!" 89",!3"&4*)*-+#%!6"%!34&#+%(&"-'(+"#$("*,&#"3(0,3("-+"&-:

?#"#$("-4#&(#"%#"%&"%.*-+#,!#"#-"!-#("#$,#"*472%021",00(&&%72("+-,3/,1&")"/$(#$(+"-*(+,#(3"71"6-'(+!.(!#&"-+"0-..(+0%,2"(!#%#%(&" )",+(" Q4&#" #$,#<",!" %!$(+(!#21"*472%0"3-.,%!<",!3"#$,#",!1/$(+(" %!" #$(" /-+23<" #$(+(" %&" ,2.-&#" 4!%'(+&,221" ," 2(&&""&#+%!6(!#"(!#%#2(.(!#"-5"*+%',01"*(+"&("#$,!"%!"-!(@&"$-.("-+"*(+&-!:" (̀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a&6)"&5 '2 !""!*&"+2.+,-).%$9&+.&;#"%&%6!&(!?&9!) "&%'&+.0'$0!&)$$&4)..! &'(&5! "'.)$&,.).-+)$&% )."+%+'."&,!3"('(!"G-!6-%!6",#" #$%&"/+%#%!6H" %!#(+!,#%-!,2"+(2%(5"(55-+#&"&40$",&"#$("b,%#%"(,+#$D4,C("+(&*-!&(c:

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

33Thinking Highways Vol 5 No 2www.thinkinghighways.com

ITS

ITS

Vol 5 No 2 Thinking Highways34 www.thinkinghighways.com

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bS9" +(642,#%-!&<" (#0:<" /%#$" #$(" %!0(!#%'(" -5" %!0+(,&(3"&,5(#1",!3"3(0+(,&("2%,7%2%#1"(A*-&4+(:"b(+(" "/-423"3+,/",!",!,2-61"7(#/((!"*,+(!#,2"0-!#+-2&"-5" %!#(+!(#",!3"#(2('%&%-!"*+-6+,..%!6" ,&" /(22" ,&" (.*2-1(+" .-!%#-+%!6" -5" (.*2-1((@&"%!#(+!(#"4&(",#"/-+C")",22"*(+5(0#21"(&#,72%&$(3",+-4!3"#$("/-+23"%!"7-#$"2,/",!3"%!"*+,0#%0(:"

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

Further resourcesX4%23%!6"4*-!"#$("!(0(&&,+%21"$%6$"2('(2"0-!#(!#"%!"#$%&",+#%02(<" "/,!#(3"#-".,C("#$("8$%!C%!6"b%6$/,1&"+(,3(+&",/,+("-5","0-.)*+($(!&%'("+(*-+#"+(2(,&(3",#"#$("(!3"-5"d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e-+#$"?.(+%0,!",!3">4+-*(,!"3%+(0#"(A*(+%(!0(:"8$("+(*-+#" &4.).,+1",!3"%!#+-".,1"7("+(,3"-!2%!(",!3","0-*1"-5"#$("+(*-+#"3-/!2-,3(3",#Y" !"#"$!%&'(")*+,!-.-/"*0112

In conclusion...;+%#%!6" 5-+" #$%&" 7+-,3" ,43%(!0(" $(+(" " $,'(" -5" 0-4+&(" -!21"&0+,#0$(3"#$("&4+5,0("%!"#(+.&"-5"#$("#(0$!%0,2<"*-2%#%0,2<"-*(+,)%+'.)$8& 2'0! .).-!& ).*& ,.).-+)$& -'45$!/+%+!"& +.0'$0!*& +.& %6!&&#+40#4+("-5",!1",0#4,2" 89"*+-Q(0#",!1/$(+("%!"#$("/-+23:"]%C()/%&("#$(+("/%22"7(","&(*,+,#("!((3"#-"0-!#(A#4,2%B("7(1-!3"#$("&#+40#4+("%#&(25"#-",00-4!#"5-+"#$(".-3,2<"!,#%-!,2",!3"&-0%-)(0-!-.%0"(0-&1&#(.G&H"%!"/$%0$"#$(" 89"(!#(+*+%&(&"/%22"-*(+),#(" 0-22(0#%'(21" ,!3" %!3%'%34,221:" b-/('(+" " &#,!3"7($%!3" #$("*+-*-&%#%-!"#$,#"#$("5,0#-+&",+#%042,#(3"$(+("*+-'%3("#$("7,&%0"&#,+#%!6"*-%!#"5-+"3('(2-*%!6" 89",&",".,%!&#+(,."(!#(+*+%&(")"-5".,C%!6"[+%'%!6"W:P","+(,2%#1"/-+23/%3("

!"02-&%!6" "/-423"4!3(+&0-+("#$,#",".,Q-+"0$,22(!6("+(.,%!&<",!3"#$,#"%&"#$(",7%2%#1"-5",22"#$("&#,C($-23(+"6+-4*&"3%&04&&(3",7-'("#-"0--+3%!,#(",!3"%!#(+,0#"(55(0#%'(21"#-Y

J:" 9$,+("7(&#"*+,0#%0(&",!3"0-.*(22%!6"('%3(!0("-!"#$("3%55(+(!0("#$(&("*+,0#%0(&".,C(

L<& M!,.!&5 +' +%+!"&(' &AJK8&).*W:" ]('(+,6("#(0$!-2-61",!3"*-2%01"#+,!&5(+"

8$(&(",0#%'%#%(&",+("(&&(!#%,2"&-"#$,#"3(*2-1.(!#"0,!"7("/%3()&*+(,3",!3"#$,#"#$("'%&%-!"-5"%!#(+-*(+,72("3(*2-1.(!#"-5"#$(&("#(0$!-2-6%(&"#-"%.*+-'("&,5(#1<"+(340("0-!6(&#%-!<",!3"*+-#(0#"#$("(!'%+-!.(!#"0,!"7(",00-.*2%&$(3",#"#$("!,#%-!,2"2('(2",!3"7(1-!3:"III&"2%C(" 89"?.(+%0,"G 89)?HN",!3"#$(%+"5,7+%0"-5"&#,#(",!3"+(6%-!,2"0$,*#(+&",&"/(22",&"#$(%+"(!6,6(.(!#"/%#$"%!#(+!,)#%-!,2" 89" 6+-4*&" /-+23/%3(" 0,!" *2,1" ,!" %.*-+#,!#" +-2(" #-""5,0%2%#,#("#$%&:" "?&","#+421"0+-&&)04##%!6"6+-4*"%!"#(+.&"-5"#$(".42#%*2(" &#,C($-23(+" 6+-4*&" 3%&04&&(3" ,7-'(" 89)?" ,!3" %#&"0$,*#(+&"-55(+","4!%D4("&(##%!6" %!"/$%0$"!-"-!("*(+&*(0#%'("&4*(+&(3(&"-#$(+&"/$(!"%#"0-.(&"#-" 89"3(*2-1.(!#"5-+"#$("E9<",!3"2%C(/%&("$,'(","C(1"+-2("%!"+(*+(&(!#%!6"#$("E9"*(+&*(0#%'("%!#(+!,#%-!,221:"S!"#$,#"!-#(" "/-423"2%C("#-",0C!-/2(36("#$("6+,0%-4&" ,!3" %!',24,72(" &4**-+#" -5" 89)?" %!" *+-'%3%!6" *+()"*472%0,#%-!"+('%(/",!3"5((37,0C"5-+"#$%&",+#%02(:"TH

345"*67!68"9:+&4;<6=3<6">6?;%@4;63+5+;%-A+)#67,+9B#"5+6%$6CDEF>6C)#+;;"'+)#6G&4)>-%&#4#"%)6HI>#+A>6*"5">"%)!6J+694)6@+66

9%)#49#+*65"46+A4";64#6*+-"9:+&KB>!"@A!9%A

N<& ???<())<2'03)+ 5' %"3)+5V:" ///:%!#(+-*(+,7%2%#1:'%+6%!%,:6-'O<& ???<+!!!<' 23?!13)1'#%#"3.!?"3%'5+-"3"#"%)+.)1$!P"

& !.! 2935 ',$!"3 !*! P?<6%4$Q<& 6%%5R33???<#"21-<' 2S<& 6%%5R33???<!#>2 !!.1#+$*+.2<' 2T<& ???<'5!. !0<-'43c:" ///:#$(-*(!+('72-6:72-6&*-#:0-.O:" Tf((*"g-4+">1(&"-!"#$("L-,3",!3"g-4+"b,!3&"E*-!""

" #$(";$((2<U"8$%!C%!6"b%6$/,1&<"[(0(.7(+"VPPN:N:" ///:%#&,:-+6