26
The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc.

The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

The RFP ProcessPanel Discussion

Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates

Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc.

Page 2: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Best Practices for Evaluating Options for Shareholder Services

• Identify key issues

• Identify key contractual terms you have and want

• Develop a profile of your account

• Request pricing proposals in a standard form

• Consult with an industry expert

Page 3: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Things to Avoid

• Auction bidding on services

• RFP’s with more than 10 questions

• Doing your evaluation in a vacuum

• Doing the evaluation alone

Page 4: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Small Shareholder Buyback

and

Direct Stock Purchase Plan

Analysis

Page 5: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Shareowner CompositionShareowner Composition

• 1.3 Million Shareowners– 1.2 million beneficial owners– 310,000 registered shareowners

• 75% held less than 100 shares– Average shares per odd-lot account - 17.3

• 2.3 Billion Shares Outstanding– 1% of the outstanding shares were held by

the odd-lot accounts.

Page 6: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Odd-Lot ConsiderationsOdd-Lot Considerations

• Odd-lot accounts represent a significant and recurring expense.

• One-third of the odd-lot accounts were not reinvesting

• Company’s last odd-lot was in 1988

• Stock price

Page 7: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Program HighlightsProgram Highlights

• Program managed by Georgeson• Shareowners received notification by

mail – Correspondence clearly indicated a voluntary

program

• Thirty day program with a 30 day extension period

• Option to sell or round up– 50 shares or 100 shares round up– Sales matched with purchases

• Follow up with automated phone calls

Page 8: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Concerns and Results Concerns and Results

• Board of Directors concerns– Shareowner alienation

• Program estimates vs. actual participation– Conservative estimate of 8% on sales, 4% on

purchases– Actual participation was 10% on sales, 2% on

purchases– More than 70% that sold were in DRP

Page 9: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Costs and SavingsCosts and Savings

• No costs to the Company

• Estimated savings of 10% annually in shareowner servicing fees and expenses

Page 10: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Direct Stock Purchase Plan ConsiderationsDirect Stock Purchase Plan Considerations

• Public interest for DSPP

• Dated Dividend Reinvestment Plan

• Registered Plan vs. Bank Plan

• Date of Implementation

• Cost Savings

Page 11: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Program HighlightsProgram Highlights

• Purchases– Weekly– Initial investment

minimum - $500– Optional cash

investments • Minimum - $50• Maximum - $250,000

annually– Automatic deductions

• 1st or 15th of the month

• Sales– Batch order sales

• $15.00 plus $0.12/share

– Market order sales• $25.00 plus

$0.12/share

• Fees– Initial investment

• $10.00 plus $0.03/share

– Optional Cash investments • $3.00 plus $0.03/share• $2.00 plus $0.03/share

(ACH)– Reinvestment of Dividend

• 5% of the amount reinvested up to a maximum of $2 plus $0.03/share

Page 12: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Concerns and ResultsConcerns and Results

• Presentation to shareowners

• Shareowner complaints

• Estimated savings of 12% annually in shareowner servicing fees and expenses

Page 13: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Questions?Questions?

Page 14: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Results of Survey of Cost Savings Ideas

Belinda MassafraShareholder Services Consulting LLC

Page 15: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Thank You to Responders!

• Ken Kaminski – BP Karl Wagner – Merck

• Patricia Tai – Chevron Bette Jo Rozsa – AEP

• Dru Cessac – AT&T Dianne Perry – Xcel Energy

• Mark Gereb – VerizonBernadette Maffei – Comcast

• Kim McKiernan – The Walt Disney Company

Page 16: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Transfer Agent Account Fees • Perform database clean up to reduce number of

accounts*:– Sweep fractional shares monthly.– Perform account consolidations on some regular

basis. *May also reduce printing and mailing costs.

• Negotiate a reduced fee for “inactive” accounts with the fee adjusted monthly.

• Reduce number of small accounts with an odd lot

program.

Page 17: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Out-of-Pocket Costs

Envelopes• Eliminate return envelopes in mailings.• Use back of envelopes to promote your

shareholder website.

Certificates• Eliminate certificates or use print on demand.• Consider charging for certificates.

Page 18: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Out-of-Pocket Costs

Documents/Brochures/Forms• Use print on demand instead of keeping an

inventory.• Be sure copies are available on your website.

Page 19: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Out-of-Pocket CostsPostage and Printing• Be sure you are receiving all available postal

discounts.• Promote use of TA website to shareholder for

self help and statement/document delivery.• Provide incentive for shareholder to use

Internet delivery.• Combine mailings when possible (e.g., last

dividend w/1099).

Page 20: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Out-of-Pocket CostsPostage and Printing• Use top and back of check or statement to

communicate and educate shareholders on services available online.

• Promote ACH deposit of dividends – safer and possibly faster.

• Don’t mail ACH advices. They can check their bank accounts.

• Go to an annual dividend.

Page 21: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Dividend Reinvestment and Direct Stock Purchase Plans

• Calculate the cost/benefit of your dividend reinvestment plan. Does upper management still support it?

• Change Plan terms so participants cover some

or all of the costs.

Page 22: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Dividend Cash

• Negotiate with TA to receive interest on cash balance related to un-cashed dividend checks.

• Alternatively, use a zero balance account that

pays as checks are presented.

Page 23: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Shareholder Communications -- Newsletters

• Eliminate print quarterly newsletter.

• Put electronic version online if management thinks one is still necessary.

• Mail print version with the dividend check(s) to save postage.

Page 24: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Proxy Process• Use Notice and Access to reduce print and

postage costs.

• Consider stratified mailing if concerned about vote.

• Promote e-delivery of documents.

• Use householding to reduce number of packages.

Page 25: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Annual Meeting

• Make it a business meeting without elaborate food and give aways.

• Hold meeting in corporate headquarters or town to reduce travel expenses.

• Hold a “virtual meeting” – Example: Intel

Page 26: The RFP Process Panel Discussion Carl Hagberg – Carl Hagberg and Associates Kathy Huston – Group Five, Inc

Other Ideas?