The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson

8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson

1/35

G.

>-

.+1

'o

-:

q,

g';

a+

-d

c

gL

-+,

3

J

SJ

o-

-t-

J

T-

s

c+l

o

$I

S\J

5'-6

\j

trl

in

Jauarrcse

Culhrye-

The

ltlco,

of

Pozuttr'

{'.i>ffiH

Benedict

ll.

O'G.

Ancler.sol

l\18(JDr

,

'1

tO\

,r

Lr

spitc

of

rLc consicieral,lc

bocly

of

sotrolar.ty

rvortr

ittar hns

becD

,1n,,

"i,

1,,J,.,,, \,,,.

.,n,t

,

.t4

,

)

J1 ,,,

-

I

i\t,.r\

:r,,t

,,,t,,,,,..

l,"r

'q,

r'J

l5

I'. rc

1",

n

n.r,J. it

x

.\

t^1,rtr.

..,.,h i,

,.ill,,.r

ur

rr1,j.,,,n"1

t",r',:rl

,....,t,,r^,^or

.'rt,,t,

p.,*.,r,,t ,o.,t

.,rirei

,

T...1,,.o,,,.1,t,ol"l,)

I,"tn,,..i,.

i,

Thc

ffrst

dencicncv

c.ln

h

pxrt

Le aitdbuted

to

the

fact

that

Iad,

r,:i.r\

(lF\i.,1

';t^j..r.,,...

,r..".^

rJ,^\.

ot CJ,irx

dr,l

lndir,

cl,ni.rirl

no

tull-flcdgcd

expositirn,s

uf aDy

indigolous

.?otitical

theorv."

A

conteDporaq,

rccoDstnrclioD

of

sL,ch

a ih.o,y

lrai there-

Iore

to

l)c abst,acte.l

{rom scatord

histdrical

soulccs

ancl

thcn

s)nrl.,

ri/e,r

\vith

tr..8,,.

n,,,"

i,,.r-t,Is,trrunhornE,.t,t,.xf,ri,n.F

'I

J

..

{

u.lJ,lcf.j"r.,

),,

.',.

",,'t"

r,n,n,,,..

ff

r.r.

rJ,,.,,tA,,,.c

oJ

.1

s)stemtjo

cxpositiorl

of

.l

pbl;rical

tireory

in

tlrc

classical

litera_

r,

.

oI

l.,l.,a^,Jt..,.

In'r,r..ttt,,

1$'.r,,1

ruI

rr,.rna.,,ct,

tt.,or..

J"{..

rr i.,t,lr,.,r

.\i.,,.,..1

'1,,r.

l,.s

t,r,,.r,

r,.,t

.,,,

1,..".,,.s.

"t

,r,c

.,r'...,,1'.,.

",

1,,.1

r.,

.

.,,,

',liri,,r.,l

t.,lrri,

l,^r,^lvir.\.T1,:{

t.r.r

"r"..,

.t..,,,,.,,.1

i,

.. ..,.,

.,,

.,,,.r

,\

,t

.,,,,..,

,,1

lI.

:

.ljr.,,....

,.1

....

l,

,

u,

'

,

,

...

.

.r.,,,

,,

,.)

tnjit

-.,1

lr-

r, ..Iml

r.L)l or

itLir.s.r

orv.s

nmch

to

Lt,c nNiqhrs

and

onicd.om

jf.;

,,.

',

. ., 1"

.,

-f

u,,,J..

|

......,r,.

r,,r ,r

r..ih,

,

.

'.r.

.t..,

rt4l,

4.n

,- (.r

t,,,..t

r_ \

li

ji,t

I

i,

r.,

"

'{,.

1

.t,\.

r..,..."i.\t.

,urtr..

Lr.,,tolh. i

..,,i

..

,l

.,,

t,,,,.,.

.rrri.:

,r.q,ii,..i*,lt

o,,",

\

'..

..tI

.',tt

, *r,,.

.,

.\t,,

,s

,

t,

.,,.1{.-.:

ri ,

.n,

,tl

rt,i.

1.,

t."

i,rl'.1 rl.'.r.1'r

to,,t,.,",,,.n,"tth,,

F.l.


2/35

2

lJrirtucr

lt.

OG. i\\DrnsoN

Li\iu"

rl'.1,".'^,'-)

l,1s

l-,,,

r,

qr,,r

"".rr-

l'

,r,'s

l|r"

tradftiolxl crlture1

and coirelate

th.r

jD

aD arbilra,y

and

ad Loc

nxt1n..r with

frL

icrl.u

.isfccts

oI

prcscnt

(LtI

Politjcs-

(lulturtl

factoN rrc

qljcalll

brnrght

nt

as

1r

sott

ol

(leus

ex

nnchirut \\bcn

thc courbiniLtnn,

ol

social,

,l({,ntrnic,

rnd

histo

crl

Yrri.1Llcs

sccDrs

not cortPlotoly

to

ac:ronnt fol

tr.1rticul.lr

{orms of

politicrl

l)ctu1vior'

These

clltuLal

elomeris

arc

tlUs introchcnl

cssentinllv

to

"s.rve

thc

pheLro

cLrx."

'rhc

nnplicit $srnrptnnl

of

a

l.rck

ot

rnherence

ir

thc

(ultur.rl

tra.ljLjon hrs,

jt

rxxrms

io

ntc, irrclitrbh

lcd

to

a

la.rk

ol rnctlotl,logical

cohcltrx,c

nr dvcloping

rn

.

.iFxll

^PPro.lclt

to

co

temporary IndoDcsix,r

l)olitics.

Tbc

prcscni

css.ry

is

ar cffort Lo

r.mrdy

at

lcrlJ

th(]

first

o{ tLc

tlro basic

(1(.E.jcrt.ii's

tbat

I

l,avo ponnccl

o,,t. Il'

oflcrjlrg

r s)s

?

tixnxti. e\potition

01 tra.liliood

J.r\xneso

coDccPtions

x

xLoIrt

Poli'

tics

ind demorstntnrq

rcir iNrcr

colurcrtco.

I hofc

io takc

a

prcli

nriry

stil tou,arcl r

irll.r

nivcstigatur

ol

iho

nrLf

rclrti()ll

dripi l,dq,c.n crlturc

rurl social

xction 1,r(lo1,csir.3

Srch a

1,tc-

sortatioi

slloul.l rxakc

it

cvi(l(xrt

thrl

tradilbn,rl

Javartcsc

orltur


3/35

.

coNalEtls

oir I,()\fEn

Shr.l\

oI

.lissi.il

Jr' n$.

lirlrrl'r.

rrtrl

pcs.nr di).

l,oliti.il

l lrxrir)r

sr .s,.ris

ilrt

oD. ln r to rrrj(l,rsrrn(ling

th(:

,rv,,)(.s.

tlr(rrr.

ol

l)olili(is

rrr\ lr, tL.

tfu(i

ln),,i1

i,,l.,fr,,,rtnnr

r)l \\rL,rt

s{)rilt

sci.,L.N

r.l(,s

to as

Lr^rcr.r

ii, lIc

In\x

.,su

roruPtk)f

(lillcrs

rldi.r

h

hOD rl,e

co c(ln

r)l po\\1)r

n

',i.L

ll.s . ol11,:1

jtr

rho

\\icsr

snrcc

l]

IfnLlL,

1\g.s,

inrl

lrcIr

tlrs

ditl,r.ncc

lircLc

logicallv

Iollorv

contrastiig

vjqvs

ot

tlrc

worlinrgs

ot pditi.s l1nd Listor'_v.s

'I

:,

.. ..

.

.."r

.u...tr.r,

..

rntr,. j.

,' 1l

. .,,-

l','l

..

.4

.lnl,

n,

,,,

tI,'

c$_x) is

\r,

lcn

nr l'i

glish,

b), a nativ.

I'Jrgli ],

st,,rko.,

trnnr'j]f

tor nitn(

lt,gljsl

rfrk.rs. a,d

xllr b.crrrc

it

o\vn

n,r.Tl..hrxl

fdsllr.Ljr.,

js

n:

,cx,.diil)lr

$:1.sle',,,

I

r.c

o cl,oi.c

Lnt

k,

nsc

qrxls

an.l .,or.qns

likc

'irotr1r,

Nli.l, rrr

(lrn*.

rnnn a

1t,,sr.D .,,rlyrictrt rnd nrL.Trrarjr. liluc-

\'o*, i,r n.;ri,,g

NiLh rt,.

tnlJhrr

ol

(,ir,r,iing

rt,.t

f,"n,","u,t

,,irt,

tt,,

.lxvr,

{\.. 11i.m

is,l.r,lv

i

I'nxl,Ln,rntnl

hrr n,ltrr.nt

nr

s,.h

r rr(lr.,l

.I

w.,1,. lniL \vilh.

1

^

srlcrur(lntk

h.gtrrg.

(l

.on.rl,hrrl

Ilx

nay.'L

nr

illirh to

f1..,-

lrnl'

\:f.st.rn aid

Tru r

rllrrs

rn.l .on.nrr , rli rhr

onc

cm

do is

lo,.rognizc

atr.l

nrr'rn'

(rslrDtlr

ana,..I

lhi

l,ixs.

WIcn

t.,

:

'.l''",

r,r.

.,{"rt',

.

'I, i

i..i'_

''

i..,.

ti,

,

\\ ,

.

,..''. t.,,l',,.

I,

i, .

.l.i

1.

,,1

.

..t,.rn.

lcNclv,

sl]l.,rl.nrr

lun rjLli,, tL.

lxv,

,.s.

nrnr$o,I, dnf

.rrrl.l

s:(,

tlxt

'1.

\\.,

1

|

.,,

l.

r

,1.

jxun.sc,,n,ilc

i hd ixrl,n

llrrglisl

d..r

'i)r

,,.trllv

l . $rl, r

(.rrjlr

ar

all.

(Tn..l.l

,,sxq,..l 11,.

Forrl

f.v..,

\tLnt' rn'riv{,s i, sdr

tih,N*

ns

"1h.

a;irt

t,,trr{r.i'o 1h, lturr 11,n

olr.t I'n1,"

rl\,roriD,Lt..r rh.

lrvr..s.

nk.r,

I)rrr

]rr..o

nn,r,I

r,)ninlLr

lvirh

n.t Il,r,r

nr

slri

nrrr|.,rLral

t

jn.iLrl.

llr.

Lvl 1.:

li{rL*io,,

ol

(li

.,nrtr..i..t,rs.l

f.r,,

n, tl,

rn$nrq

,,',,,''llil

.o,rcnrts.l Lrn,lli,,.

rs n.r I'.r,r th.

l,

ynn.s.

rn\r?onir

'tlis

tlrrll,,l

l.

...

r.

.i'.

..,

,1,.1.

loD onr, t}.r

diri,lr.

n nf

nrto.o)i.{Its liku

,u{,,,

l. ili,,ir.y.

rrd

,htr.irnr.",\

n,ll

d.rr.l)trxrt.l tLis ih(,ol

irl\s, ir

in(lirt(r':rlr.

iD

tr

ci ., l,LLt I.r tlr r.rrrr

gmr

nl). c

J l,rv. nor

.tr,rn|trd

t,rr.

n)or.

rhrn

I)oint.r

xr

ro

l, trv it

sLonl{l lr q),okl,.d

l,'..])ablr o"lr

I

lrynncsc

3t,

....

.i.

,.

..

"

L,

...,.(,

.

it...ui

t{i,.

,,.

,,i

I

.'

, l.^.

tr. ,t

|

...

.

t.'

, ,l

rultur.

1rtrl rn .\lr rely {,o,rfll,x

tJ|.no,rer.,

r, n,

\vl,icl,,

s

,r'

rr;

othr

t.t.....-,,,,t,

..' .l ..

r.. l.

',-

r'

-

i

,v

tr-.

'l

contoundiri

qilh

h...r.otr,r.orr

ll,1li,ni,in,

lnrUl,ist,

rnd

h1."i.

cl.lndrrs.

Nonedelc$,

t[e slow

,trc(rs

o4.al]vDplnn and svdl,esisroler

rh.

.cnL"'i.r

PIid

to tl'. iorrnrg.l

lh.r

\\irst'p .ritni th.

qvrrlr

liTatnD

oI a r.l.ti ,lv

t'ti

t'rt,t ,f

ro,,:r

in

laDdnc\c Cutturc


4/35

6

II.-rtDtc1

R. O'G'

Ar\'Lnso\

{ormrtla

{o|

cb,txjh

obscNeal

ptlttorrrs

of

w)'i'l

i*craction

'l-hns

,r,, ,-".,,11t

trtr

rlc

'?ristc'icc"

ot

potr1)r

irl

x lvicle

vxicl)

of

sifrrtions

i,; whc|

lo

c

tncn

xPPirar

to ob'Y'

1l'illirgl)'or

utn'jll

i,,.r rl r.rl,

.. i,....\\'..t,,rt

.'.,.-1r1,r"i,,1:.

J.,:

i."ti,,t

t,.r

g",r1, 1,,'

I

".' , .',r

1,.

,1",r",'Ir'lirr'

rr'"

caus.rl

h,hrq.

r,,,i,.'.,;,

,L,,

ord'r,

clPlicit

or

implicil'

and

its

lcgiftrl.rt{,? Or, riioro

Lroi'rtcdl),

wll.tt

is tlc rchtiorslrip Lelwecn

thc

positivist cor.ePt

oL

porcr

aDd thc

cthlcd conccpt

o{ righti'}

ljricfly, ihcD,

lh,,

cootorrpoiaLy

wcstcrn .orccpt

rlf porvcr

ls

atr

nLshaction dc.luccd fro

o)sclrcd

p.rttcrN

of socid nrleraciioltj il

is

bdicvr:cl

to clcrivr: from lieterogcncors soruccs; it

js

itr

no

\,1y

n,hcri:ritly selt-liuritnrg;

it d

it

is,nomlly a,nLiguous.

Il1

csscncc, crch of

thr:sr:

prcmiscs

itLout

P(^\'cI

Nrs counter io

tur

e(Irivrlcnt

p(uisc

iD

Lhe

Irvrrlcsc traliiiion,

irDd

jt

is lroDr thc

intcrchiiorls

bci\v.cl th$c cotrhrtsting

Ucnriscs

thai iI(i cohcrcr)cc

rrd

co si lcr].)

oI

lliat lraditior

rle

vc.

r.

Pou:et

is

catLcrctL.'llis is

tle Iirst

:1rtrI

cortr.ll

pl..rliso

of

Jrvr-

,,(sc

troliij.al

tJ,onglrt.

l1rpcr i:xiss,

clr:ptrrcldri of

its

poisiblo

nnrs.

Tt

is

not

r lhcr) r.ti(rl

foshrlLLic

bIt

{n

c\istclrtirl

r.rlit_\..

Il)wcr is

LLat n,itlrgiLlc, LryslcrioLrs, alrd dnnrc

cncrgy

\rhi(h

nniurtos tlc ari[rs.. lt is

Drilifcst.d

xr

eve.y

as])ect

of thc alLrrxl

\\,or1.1,

jI

stoD.,s,

tr(.s, rlor(ls,

rnd

Irc,

but ir

cxprcsscd

qujlt(s-

s{,1tixlh,

nr thc ccDtra, rn)sicr), of

ljfc,

thc

Proccss

o{ gctl.x,rtion ancl

"

'

r.,l

or.

lr,J.\. lr...

r.ar.'rll,Ll.r,:

l,,':..a,,:l,1rt,Ji i

.',,rlL,\.,,,, .r.r,.r,l I'o-:,,',. j,,.,tt.i

lor,.'.r1,1,i'.g

is

s'r

-\

Ir,,I.r

rr,o.,r,,

i,.,ii,

I,o$,..'r'.;,oI., IniJ,

ut tlr,

,1rl:.c

u,sros

bchg

m{hrscd

br

a fornrlcss, cor.strntly creativc cncrgy

fro-

vidcs the Lxsic ]n,k l,.lir.xx, tlic

"ar

]lisni

ol

tho

Jawln.:sc

l,illxgcs,

rLnd tl,c hilh 1]roiapjr],si.al prlrthcism of tlre 11r1)rn {ters.1o

).

PotLcf

is ha,'ott

nail.

it

tulli^rs

I rn tt s

conc()rtn,t

tldt rll

Io\1r

is

ol:th.

s0r.

l)'l).

rrrl

hxs t]rq

sanrc

sourcc.

llowcr

nl 11)c

Irrnds

of onc

iDdi

kl,,rLl oI

orc

grolrp

js

icle,,{icrl

witl

power

i)1thc

l,rn.ls

ol: rnv or h.r

i,rli|idll.1

or gru,f.

:t.

'tht:

rtritlt.r.jt

ot' por)ct ii thc utiictsc is dd,rst.?nl.

I1t tho

Jivari(Jr)

riqr,

tlic

cosr[os

js

rx]ithor()xfrndiDe

nor

.oniracti

g.

'IIrc

td.rl .rrxDrt ol

,)l\ .r

\itlin it

k)0,

rc)naiDs

fir,i.

Snrco

powcr

sinrpl

c:(isrs, anl

is 1,oi

rhc

prcdrrct

ol

orglnizAtnnr,

wcalth,

.

i,

.,

.

J..

-

i.,,i,

,

,J

I',,

. r

'.

.,ii .,r

rt., \,

.

1,1

,,,.

k.

.

'1,'

rhr'llr,

,r'

.

i'.

l^','.r',

r'l',' Ll

.

r.i

,j.:,...,

'1

I

11,,.

,

ilc dist

l)rtnnr o

lo\rcr

irt

tlrc

rlnivclsc

n15v

\'aq. l,br

politicnl

''

l.

r

,

- \v

in,, r 7.,, r, ,,'-'t

t,

tt,,

,,.,1

t

t

.

.rfr.sses tbc .on., 1.,n.$

of

ll,c

Javaies.

id.i

ol

.nc..

lh. divinc

poy'er

is tlr..ss.r.c

of

I, .l

rlr.

nilf,

'l'hc

ldc,1

(1[

r, t,t i

laDanesc

C,ulture

7

z.'1hc

v,ruts

t)l

l

x) 4ft

ht't'to 'tt'\rts

Sin'c

Pr^vcr

is

11s

cLibd

io

or

t.Lrcrl

lronl

cetxiu

]rxit'ros

ol h

avil]l

xnd

lr'Itrin

so(i.r1

r.l.llonslrlIs,

x

'trcil

(1(Il

of

1\isl'Dr

1)olil;'il

l1r(nrglLl

Lrs

L,u,

dc\'(,t(.1

n, ih(,

c(,r*ilili.

iotr

ml .1nrllsil

of

t|csf

l)rtt(rls

an'l

rchtnnNhi|s,

in(l

ih.r.l)'

10

llrt)

ilstjrrgrrislrinil

of

dil1'r(rn

sonr'cs

.f nolror.

f} s

st l;r'c

crrtc

to

r..d l

such

vlukrrs

s.urccs

"

",,,i".

"'

",',1tr,.

s,).i,11

sti 1Lrs.

Iomrl

oliicLr

or arlnizirlon

trr'irLn)rs

i' ,, r..,;n.

,l

.' i

l

r

'"

i"

1''

r 1

lr

"r

"

;,,"',,

"l'J

'

li

'rl

r"r'r'

''r'11

1,

ii,'

.t

",

t..

'

ri'l"

'

.'r'

r'

:

'c

J.

Thc

,c,:ttnllntiah

at'

Pattet

ln^ 1tu

inhcrcnt

Li'rits

Snrc'

Po\\(ir

,,1,,,',t'..,

I,

"

,

,

i,

'il

lr"'"

r"

'i'

''i'i

-'

I

,-

',o'''1t',.

r''

l.

i,,.'"l '""r'

ir'

r'r

"

\'

"''r'l

r"'

",,r.*,'

rf p-',.

rs nrdtrlirg

$crlnxrs,

\rixlth'

orgxrizttn'r'

ald

t.'th,,rnog,

r'r'rt.ogrizc

llrLt rrl

l''1sl

nr tlrtl)n

th(rc

lrrc

no

liltits

t,,

irs,,".,,,,,',1"U,),.'ft,

lnLl

lt rrrotl'r

wrr\,

orr)

()

Ik1 sIq'lcsl

thrri

tlrcfuixl

xrllrLfr

ol pofur

itr

llr.

\orl(1

I lx|

is si8njfi'rr(T\'hrgo'

1l,rn

il

{r11

ilrirL\

,,',i,'

"g"

("' il )

r'sxll

l(n crurrplc

ol ilrc

i

-

v.rin,r

,)l

1l

.

i,.,i',,{",,

1,,,,1,1.

rtrr(l

llut

this

s'r

ol

portr

\rill

,,'

l,tr,l\

,,r

l"''"

L

l'"

], 'r r'.''.'i:r h ' 'l'1' '' l'rt

i,L

dL\Lt ,nrlr

I

"l'rlt

Ll

n"luj''

..1,,,'.

l'

,t,1'-'

't-t'l

'"'

ll r''

n" u''

"

li

l'"

sccthL

corrcct]tion

of

Poljti(|rl

Po\1cr

Ns l

rchinmsliP

b't\v,i:1xl

h,,,na,

bch,gs

rhai

..,"i,

1,"n''

is

lot

inhcrctily

lcgr&nxrc

:l'Lis

rllor.rl

amLignitl

is,

r)f

loLrrsc,

culrrlr((l

Lv

ouL

vio1.

oI porvet

tLs

,Lriri',r

.rln

i,,,'-,',

'

"

r"

rlir l,

rn'

'r'.

l'

r '

,.,.nr,,..r:'J

1,.

t,",,

;',"',,. l'ur'l'\r'ol

r'1'r'''r'r'

'

l'i'

'

'"'n-

tirn,di

io

prCic.il1]lrhdliti.Cl'

thcor

sts:

What"kinds

of pott'er

aLc


5/35

8

tlr.-nncf

li O'C;.

ilNDrrnsoN

,1,,o,).

rl'i'

r,"

r',.'o,1.

r,r

'u"'l'.r)

rr'

'ir''1

I'

r'rlrii'

'

lio'\'

r

in

orx, phcc

or;n

orrc

lx,sorL

l{{|rjnrs

'r

PrPrln'ixl

dinlnrrtiknr

.t. I\t..|t

lor:s

rt

1lzis..

Ihc

qltcstitr,

ol

ltgi'"l''lr

Snr

r

']ll

poi,,",l,"i'"s

lrlnr .l singlo

lrr

uoqrnius

sNrcc,

ln^\ai

itsdf

ttc

.

.,,,

,

..,.1

.

,1

:','1,..1

l,ll.'

1,r.,.''

r"

'r

l'i J'rr'I

,l r,"l.l '

"'

"l''

r.l"'rrl'

u'1"

l'\""r

(lif(]rctrljal

soLrr.. s

,,1'1,(,".]l.

f,,t

"r.,pf.',

n) snv

tllal

L)ov'r

based

on

$.dtL

is legiiinttc,

whcrces

powcr

1[scd on

guns

is

ilk]gitnnrt''

?orvu

is uliithor

l('gittr,atc

ror

ill.gitnnrtto'

P')\ d

is'

lLr

sun ,1,.r',

tl,(,,

tlru

Jxrancsc

s.c

P(^'()r

rs sonrdltnrg

(olrcr'to'

l,r,r".scnr",,s,

(nrstxirr

irr

lotrtl

.1trrtrrLitr,

xrrd

\liihont

i'r] rrcrri

nrorrlirnfl,c.rli(,rs

Is

su.L

I

llE

Qulilj

I

l()n

I'o\\rEll

ll,

r.,.r

'",r ''"'I

r'

'll"r'L

l''r

, 1,. \: l, t .

\\' I rr

'r.

l

'r'

n'

"

l

"'

ll'

or-"

r'''

'r

"

cacrclso

rif Pr\vrr

lnrt

ils

rt(.

.II1ition'

'\ccor1ilrglv,

r \c)

'orts

sido:il,lr

t)ortion

ol

Ihc lrn(litnrrrll

litcrllurc

'lcals

$jlli tlr'

proh-

1..,,,. ,,1 .;

'

r"

.

rr,l

'l

l"'

'

rrir'i

l1 "

''r

"''r'

"

lr

rr'

' 'lr

il

r.iu

.r.ir,',ir,'l'.,

li

,"

'."1r1'r

'ri'l'rrr

.*,,t,t,,",,q1,

\ogrlistic

IrrL.li(s

lrrd'\tr'rn'

asrcsis'

r\lilnrglt

Lhcsc

l

og,,ist;"

j,.,,"1;,:"'

nt \'unrrrs

l,xrts

of

Jxvx

tal


6/35

ro llriNE

.r.n.

OC.

r\Nrxr$()N

mnks

oI

tlc

dr:n]ors

ud gi lrs

\,,tro

nr the

,

rajang

stori(js

are

tfic

r-..

I.r.,r.'l

{....r,'

I.o,ls

,rl ir..\(ri

fr,.,.,1

,r.."

p..\,r

i:

oflcn

enomrons.

o,

o(ansi.,r .16r)

.r.^.djng

thar

of the

goc1s.

fhc

csseritinl

di1Tr1.ot.c

bciwc(,r

lh. hcrocs

arrcl thcir

advcrsndcs,

how-

ever,

is ltrot

ihri

hiter e\.cnilalh

|crnit

thc,r

poir.r

ro

Le difused

l,/

,,

r'i

,

'

tr.:r

.:..h

$

,r.u

{

r,

\,r..'nr.

sl, r,.s

th tu

,

r

nranrlaiD

thri

stadfrst,r.ss,

th.rr

tL,irrc

singlenr:ss

o{

purpose

u,hich

assnres

thc

mriritora|ce

nnd

co

tinrtcd

rcir"nnlaiion

oI

?ow.r.r6

Bcsnl.s

ilris

ort}odox

,ri.\y

oI th. roa(t

ro

po\vcr.

urolLor.

h.l.ro

,1,.,.

t.io,,,r.,.

l.

t,s,

,'yt

,.\..,,r,t

[,,t

,r].,.,r

son

of iL',

l.tst

lul.r

of Snrglesrri

Ii

ng

l(c

anar]xm.

Lr this

lil,.'r v'

I

,r,..'.

r,.l.r

L,r,

" \r.,

I

ru ql|a

LI

,

li.,'

t,.t.t.t--,

_t.t-t,

././..

,/,.

.4, .r,

.t.,...,.

se lti

or8i.s,

aLLl

ihnl

i,nudcr.rr

Brtt

c\,cn

tlis

t

.ljrior.

$trich

still

fin.ls

rnorc

or less

cla

.l(:sri'rc

a(]hcrclrs

iD

contonpo.xry

hdoncsi.r,

rlti

at.h,

,, ,s

Ir

tl,(, s.r,nc

obj.cri\.

",

tt,,i."r"

orlllo.l{)x

ll'lLditn)r

lh

n] tl).

Ithnjr'.r\,isr

LLrtj.isistirrr.

tlrc

sr,,si.r,-

r1.,.,r,1,

was

l,.lrcvcd {o erhrnsi

rhcs(:

pnssions

x,rrt rh.Lclorc

lo

rn(,rv

a

rnant

l'owcr

to,Lc

coqgonhatc.l

\l,itl)oLrr

jurhcr

trin.li.lrr({,.I,lurs

in

l)oilr lrx(liLnnrs

llrc

ultn)rrlc

airn

\.,s

(oircc,rtrrrr)r

li)r

tlrc

srlkc

(,t

loqrr,

lil(b,)ri lr

th.

pitl,s

d )scu

r{)

rmctr

thjs

t rp(,sc

rx{tk.rly

dircrgcd.

\'V|i1,,

t )s,,lnl

ls( sjs

\ rs

r( rJrlh

r(.qr(t(xt

,rs

tl)(,

1fu,(hlxrit:,t

wr).

i,) rr.r rtri,,,lirro

lrnl rl)so

, t1)$1r,

rr:rdiliof,rl

Jivx,,rs.

iIn)iinrg

als., r.rog,izrll

llut rlis

l)ro..ss

oI NLsorpriori

or

rcdnmrlxltun

cori(l

bc

rl(l(icd

Loth

ly

c.rrai,r

rirlats.

oIt.n

.onrxnrirg

ir

corc

of ascotnrtsnr,

su.h

ns fasting.

n.ritirxrn)n.

xuit

.o

fo,tt,,

a"J

bv tl

c

t'..

',,,.,.r,r

,,.1j-.r .,,\ .

E

fi,,.,I

\vith

Po(1.r. Sitl(r'(l

C. Jlirg

lrls \ri{rcu

rrtlorsrh

at)our

riri: rilrr.rl

ralt

1"9.

1. sncirBrcd

rhil

l kj'

oI

..nt

jrdgrcfr

rlont

l.os..r

is

i,utrli.ir

in

rlis ,lillrcfcc

tr

l,v..n

I,rd.-

,r".t a-"o,i

Nlv

.\vn

nr.lirrlj.r,

lDn1r.r,

js

t. i,li.r.

tlLrt

irn)lrr

as r rnral

lrdqnronL

i.

--f,,,

it ;.

*,i

,,lnnrt

rIf ,r

.I

r,N.i

l)nL

ibonL is

rtc,,rn)n

;r;iirtrml

(rlirj.;t,

I

rl,o

.LDo.s

is T.ivrlo,l

nL

lI.ir

nrrTrjtiry or

rnrviIir(tr,ss

L,).o,, .rv.

iho

t1nv.r

rl)0

hrv. i.,rrf

r,tarrd.

iiOn

this

tul)nr,

s..

1

ti Sl,, otrjn).

IItl

it

tti\nv

in tte

A,thhn,t

3rl

cd

(l)i)kolx

rf,l C,.,,,ng..

\Volr(,\,

rr5 ),

t,p..3,

rJr,

",,.i

,;,

1;;;i

W

1,.

srr

n .hinn,

SLutit,t

"t

ttrt

.sion,t,a.,-to(,/

t.1.1,"

il"g*,

^.rr,ofl.

19s6),

p.ro7-

143,.

'tha

r.tca

ol

t)otL,ct

it1

laD

nere

C tturc

.rolilD.1tn.,r

of

lc,wrr.

rtmrgh

..r",f,"f

,,,"gr",,

il

th

chroniclcs

oI

old

Jara,

t,rrther

.\ptixrrion

oI

ttrc

srbj;

h.rc

;,

,,,,,,..,"",n,y.,"

But

jt

is

clifficuli

to

lrr(lcNrxn.l

t}c

greLrt

nnporr.rnce

atachr:d

to

ccrcDoxics

oI srrrc

in

ttc

conrcmporary

pcrigd

rithour

bcarjng

this

t-,rol

,r.,.

tlJ;tr,..,,

L,

J..

r.,r,r,,1.

tiris

nbsrssiun

$irh..rrmo \

ll

"

:

,"

.

i,,

..,,

:..r,

rprr,

,r

cirt

,

,

a, ,

-ft,.

r",;,r

;;U;,;;,;

as

manipl

Lr

vc

steiutrt-of-hand,

.onceating

1rotjri.at

.ld

";"_;;

cxli&rs

fiom

thc

popr

rtioq

oi

as

a

rvriy

t;flornr]b.

inieg a(nrg

cor-

fljcrnls

8ro.ps

xn.l

j,rer.srs

i.

a nitjo;

$.hiIc

in"'riruri;,"i

;:;;"

for

tlis

pruposc

llLve

hvays

trccn

,ixcoc.&,ig1i

**r..

s,a,

1,Ji-

n"

r.-,..r.,,r1,,,,

t..'\r,,.t

,..,,J...

St,u,-"i

,.,,,.,)

*.rt

j,n,",

,,,'1,.,

,'...

r...,,i.

t,,,..r,,..r,,,

tut

,ri.,t

t,...,t.rs

tr",,.."r.

\,rui.ty

r,,,,.-,t,,1

r.lt,

{

\.,)

. ln,,

i,,\a,

,l

b. Ir,r..h^rJlrle

lo

'J.

).

rl,

,

,

i..

t",,I.,n,..

r,,..

t,,

J

,,.

,.

., ,,,.,..,,.

.,Jy

jrr)u

tr. ,

.r

^r.'.

J.,.,'u,.1

L,i

,.,.i,,,

,,1r^,;,

Is",

I";i,.,i;",,";;

1,r.

.

t,t

.

.

,...,

,r.,,..'.

.,,:

,,,

rl.,

,-,,,,ts

ut

rir,.toIt,r

r,,,,

\'

l\.:

(),

\lr,,1,r

,,,,

r.,. :

,,.

,1,.

.1.rr.....i.

ir.,l

,, g,.,.ir,.

,r,"rnl

,l

.,., 1,,.i, ..,jr'.,.{.

ro

$tri,r,

r,,"}

r.;,rS.rt

ro

r,i rr,ri..

rti.ilr

,,,,

ur,;IIr,-.

I t,u..,

r

I

.

q.r'r'

.

..,r,

nt,.

I t)

,.t ,rr:{

^^..i

,jr,;

,

trrrr,,,

r:

.

,l.I'.,l'' ,.IL

,,,,.t

,.. rrL,

t...i.,.1i,stLr,..,-.^t\,.,i.,... r,,,\\.-.

\"i'1,

r,J,.,.:

,,

,t .,"..,.J

..,,,r.,.rtr,rfr..r,..'...,t

,tr,r...,J

"\.,rt,oti,,.,

.,,,.":..,,,,..'r.,,r...,,,\,ri...it.

ir...,ti:r

,.

,,,),,,".,,r.,,;r^

r,,

Ir

ti,it,

'.'i.,t,..\.,

..r.,r,,,",,r.r

,r

rt.,.tr,,r.r,.r,r,t,,S

ri,.

l

i. ,.ris,.

.,,

,,,,,r

.,,.

,,,.tr.,

tt,,.\.,,ur.,t

\t,,...r

.,,

rt

r1".,.,;ri,r,

u1..

i

r

."1

.,

..1,1/i,,"...,s,.r,.trJ,.

\..B,,Irn.,,,.,,rlrrrr.p..,,l

.r-

t,.1r,..lnr.'

"

I,1.,.

:,,

l..t,ti.

J,,Jrti,:,'

t.t...;:u,

_,...,'.1

..,rft,,,

)

ri

u'r.

r'.

i

r,

s

l.orr.rrnrr

sl,1, l,...,.vo..,r:urr

.

t

rtr^

tn

rutrrLior,

,-\ -l,l'"

or

rrl.

L:,,i,,.:

rrr.,",,i,,,ro,,

\i,ti

t,.,lrliun.

,,r,,1

i.J",,i

,1,

ri\i,

c

ln.l,i.,ir'

t.,,,

\\,{,,

rn

i,.;i,i,.,t

n,,r.tn,.

;

th.

,sor,Jjc

ir

n.,

1,i

.r

,.ret

t.,\-r

^ri,

rr,"t

i.

l,,,J,"t

,4

co,,,

nrr..r.

i,,/l

'1,c1,i,\

l'o,.,

r .

L,,.

,,1

,,.

,

:

tow,

r

ful

\(,rd"

.,',.'.,

.i.l

'

:

"",

;,.'.:;,,

i:1.:Ti::.-";i.:

rast,"

i"

Srnjftlr,Io

.t

dt,

t.ls.,

^a

tntruhl.tia

to

tnd.lt

rit

t

Itiit,i.

,l,iJ,l'

"

1

.1

:"r

,, t,

r

,,\..

.

r,

,..,5,.1,i.s7',,1

""'"""

,.,

,, ,,,,

.,.

rt,.

I,t,r.t

j,r,,rin,,

,.t...

ll''"

"

'

'r'

'

\'.i'

.

..

r'ri,,,..r

L.

e,rz..Ar,x,

tr...,..r

ir.,,

I1\Ln

\

l,.

li'\,

,

,,r

,\

r,

Nl

;, r\


7/35

1,

llr']NrlDr.rr

1t.

OG.

,{NDLlsoN

(hntiu\ild.

tl

olusi.

Sq

t

tt0tgti).\\'

t,^v.r

t(Ll

c\pcricrccs

(rti(j

Iiclol',li.Jn)

afd

lLworl,

I .ollcctivirii,s (rt,c

lroplc).j,

h

.Uc.r.

rrtD),

oI Suliunos

ln)litj.rl

r.1li .s,

ostfr$i])ll

dcsigr(tl

ro

.oir ..\ x

Pr

i rlru

rkssrgc

to

iI.,

I,otrl.rtn),r

r)r

k)

ddrlo,)srrri.

rhc

t,..si

dorLts poluh,

lr,rcHrg,

w(r Do

lcss

nrporrrnt

ff

xrcrhods

of

xc.u

rr

rling

Ilrd

d( r)l(nNhrUng

ll)r'o

frorn ilxr

\\,jllingsubntissiDr

oI

so

nrxD,

tllons.r.ds

oi

(isous.

:l'h{)

grerr,,r

thc

crrclt

to

rhich dill{:r_

eni

r,1.1

c\icn

llostilc

politic.rl

jrorus

coul.l

br)

brouglrr

into

rhese

ccrcnDrics,

il(i

grcrLcr thc

rcxl

and

rhc

i)cr.c(,ed

l,o\r,cr

of ttx,

rrastcr

ol

(crcrno|i.s.

Slll(^mos

lrjghl)

tr.lditionlll

srrto

oI irlcanr.t

tory

rllckric nat

ll)

rldderl

ro LLc

pr)tjiical

inpaci of thc

ceri,

nrdr)

ru a

wlrolc. ?

trIotr1)r.r.

jl

,virs

lI r)1{l rrld;rn)l

i,

Jx\it

itrrr

rlrc

rulcr

shoII(l

.onc.ntrrtc

nronn(l

hirrr.u,\

ol)jr.ts

(n

pcrsoDs

hcki

to

harc.,r.(,n-

ll1n1

n,,rLsnxl

ll)w.r.

ltis

1),rtr(.

rrorlil

bc llli,rl

rr,r

o,J\.\ itt,

rt(,

l.'rr

r ,

,',

/.

,

t...-.1.,.

sa. l

Dnrsjcal irrirrrur.lts,

crttiag.s, r'rd

1, I iikc,

tmt

iLlso

\rrn)rrs

t),pes

ol

r\ha0,ili,ir,\'

Io,,nr

lx,nigj, s,

.1,

xs

alt,n,os,

clnrrs.

,l .r\ .

,r.,',."..

i| L ,,.. ',,

I..,,.

\'.r., ,.,t

I

r..

f

.'/,

\

'

1.,.I.. t. ,.t|,,

t,,.,.

,

i,

,.

rt,.i,

rn..

l,\\.1.,,.,r,..

.,.,1ti

r,r,...

l'os1

:,f(l

r)ll.Lr rst]

sijt r lrl tli. ir,tr,,r(li,,1t

d)ll,r|sc

()l

ll,f

(t\1rrst)

1l(

c\lc,ri 1o \1lri,.L

tlrj

,(litn)I

sLL nls

(\1.

jl

,tiic

t)otili(il

'j'

/ .

l.'

'.

t.

I

,.

I

\ ,,,

l.

t' .,

. -

...,

.

.

.

":,,

'

'

I "

o,l,'..

I

,:.1l.r',L...t.../,.

P,i,(.itii.,)

ir t1,...(1..1

ll. Itxlutrf,ir..1,nx{

1:o,,"(.

loi,rrnlir..t

r,r

1r

rr

r\

Tr'

tiri'n.J

.tr]

th

r

Di

.lr\,

,xt

.r

,tr

(t

1.

llrl

r.

i:

.

L

ill

l,)

grin

tJor.r

.

ih|nrrrt[1.

n

j ]

lTrr

\ '(\r

rs

\v.L

\rr

1 n,,1

li

. is ltLrr ilr,.

ll.rr,

ti,.,t,t,

nfuri(l Ll'rL'troL

r. tl)r

ir ol thr

lnionllisr

lord.r

11.

O. S

'thkn,,,ift,r,l

n) tl ,.ro .

polirnxl r|.rrh-D'h.rs

t,or,o\ l

ttj.tr

or.rtorj.rt

sll.te L,,n rn.

vt.t

,

1,,

..t.i,

t;,".,,.

...1

,.,.

-r..1..

r.

...,..t.

..

.t

,. .,,, ,

,,,

t,.

L,t, ....,...,,.,,,t.

5

I

.,

,t

l.

,,,, |

,,.;

.

thr.

llis rllowil

1,n

rh.

sl,itln,l

nrc

ot

n.ndirnnr

i"ii(,"y

{,,t r,.titi-,,,1

--.,,',.,

l,\. L*. .i

r.ti

trhnj.

,.

I

t..

lvillr

thfir rLdi.f..r

t1,..t,t-"

nt

ro,pt

ir

t.,ta?.\,

t,Lttal

rJ

.^":

'".

,

",'

.-.,

t

ru

ul,i,,\,.rs.t

rJ,,

ln.lon.siaay.,,r,.,L..,,r,,,t,r

:

L r9

i,t

r,'

-...

:.....',.r

Lt,.

r,,,r*,..r.,r...t.

r,o\,.\.,

rr,..r

lL.r'J

ll.,

,r,J

I

I.,r,

.

...

,.l.l.,ir

,r

t,.r\.

*

:,i

^,

c,

rJ .tu,..,t

i.

'.'r

r\

I,ut:{'

lr-

... \

,,,,:r1 ,,,,r,,.,.r,,.,,y

r,,ui,,:",r,,,;,,:,

ri,,,,

ll" .",

i,,,,.

\

r,'r: j

i'J'r\r...r..

i, ,,r

rr

.

fr.,;.

,.,,,,,,,,

,....

t...,,

r,,r

.'r'.

,,r,.Iri..r,,

rJ

J

v

,_.

f.ti,n1..\

ru

L,

:.

l,-

Aro' n

rl..t

tl,,,

r,

^

r...\.

nn

F

ut

rhc

r.A li*

ot

l,o\\_r..J

IHI

SI(.\S

Of

to\vER

.

,11 .

,L::-"

.,,r,,':r

u,,

u,

J.Lri,i..,r

rr..sr,r

rr.,,\

r)r,:...r,\

,.,,1r.i.

]

.$1

ri

1r

h

.,,,r

r,.

,t..

.,^."r,. i,",,

,.[

iLs

.rorcjsr:

or

rrsr.

Ihr:so

signs

a]1,

iookccl

fr,.

L,"tf,

;,,

rf,,,1,,,.so,

"i

tf,"

i'oxcr+oLl(l

..nrl

nr

ttro

socjctl

n,

}icti

lc

lviet.ts

Ljs

l,owcr.

1,he

two

alc,

ot

c(nrs,,,

nrriDak,h.

;ctak{I.

Iri

thc

woxts

of oDc

of

IDCto

"

1..,..r,..,.irr

,.,,rrr,..f,r

,r\

.,,

ll..

th

\.,,,r..

I\ -.

rr:..'r,

J

,,,

..

.,I:r:,,,,I

\i.

v

, rl,.

.

t1,,

JL..r

r,hli;,

.]llt,

1,1,,..,,t,, ,r

,.,I

f,,

.,.",

Il,,,J

t,r.

(:rD.L.ir\

,6

.

tlr-

r

,.

r

,l,rr.

..

.-.,.r

,r,.,nj.,,,,t

t,n,v^.,.

1,,r,,

f,,,,

,

..,1.

lrjs

rbjljrv

io

c(,

c.nr.ir.:

to

lo.Is

hjs

o\rn

t)(1s(,rnl

poNcr.

to

rl)sort,

I

$.

r t.,,,,.

I

r. ,,...

,.,,,.

,,,f,,,,

f,,,

..f,

",,,,-,"

,..1.-'

.

r,.,.t

..:,,

rI,.,,.,r1..^.,,,,,.,,.,.,,,'f',,

.,....r

.,..,1,.

;iI

...t

.,.,.r,..,\,

L,r,

,t

,r

,r..

.,,

,rso.li.isnr

is r1,,,

f,

i,),,.

(,\Pr.ssn)I

oI

urc,.rLnt.d

l1^vor.

TI.,

.lbitir

to

rLnrrb

cn(r,r,rt

(orn,r,,irrl:ons

o[

],o\frrt

ts

a

lft.r0rrnt

thr:|rc

]n

botlr

ilxr

1\ajrig

J.surls

or.t

hist(riclll

t

(tifinr.r:r

Ou.

irl)n.il

nx,,ge,

r4ft.1, ]i,l(s

itrjs r\,tn,

,)I

absorprj.,n

*jrt,

,t,.,

"r,,*,;,."i;,1,,

,l;

opl)osjtcs,

js

.

birl]k,

l)cl\1, .r

I trcro

.ud

r

po\\l .trt

idv.$.rr..

i[

1.,,',,,,,,

1,,

.t

rt,r

,rr

r,,.,.rt,...,.,,,r,,.,,..,,,

,,,,1.

.,.1

l.:'

':

r'

.

"','

,',.

\

I

n,,,'

,

\....,t,r,

r,.,

wri

li'

rrl'1, .'

.

r,..r. ,

R.

i

,...1.r ,....,

ri,r1

,1,,

,,,.,,.

,,,

.\,.,;,,,,:

-rx

Some

d rhrDr,.ot

.oursc,

.tu srnti.illtly

lI.Dizr.t

to

mrtc

scridrs

,

1':...1;

'....

t,,t"......,

t,

.

".,.

,.,.i,,,,.o,,

";.

^\ttottn

Cht-

,,.9''

"''"

^

"'

r'

""'

'',',,.,,

..'"

'-',.',,",

:;

l;,i

1"

, ,,.'.

,:

'

'

,i,,''.

".",,,*.",*"u,.

'1

,'",,r,,

**

,....J1

ll

-,,',t,

,

"

''

l'l'

'1":'''


8/35

11

InNDn.,r

It.

()

C. r\NDrinso\

rftcr

d,rti]rt

iL

b.rrUc.rr

U

L.,ihcr storjcs, strdr

.rs

tlosc

dcs.ril)nr

lhc

spirit

ol

il.gxwxn

Brgesfnti

( is.onh,g

i,

lo

Trxlistirx

lo

.nxl)lc

lnr

io

Iill

lii)rg Srh:1,

or lhc

lrsioi ol

S,iLrnili

rrxl r\ni1)rlikr tr,.rr-

(rfrp.ss

ll,, ,l,strr(lio,

1)l ll,si llistrri

it ll ollscl

()[

t]r.

l]rilr

j,(l,i

\\'

,,,,r,

Ll

t),r(Lll,

l

t,:,llt

,s i

t

$

l,ilii 1l\ (

is irl)s()rhll lr(,rrr

.rt.rrrl

sourr,

s

r:

ll,,t rl()

L.ss striknrg r,(t

in

lI(: historic.rl

Pcrsp


9/35

rat

llr.Nrx,.:I

11.

O'(1. -{.NDrinn)N

'llrc

l(len

ol

l'otd't

i

JnL'attcsc

Oul11ltc

\

17

tlr

',,,

,,r

;.

r

ur,

r,l

l.' r"''''l

Iu\'''

Ilr'

l''i'l'lnti''l

griP,ot

;;:. , ,,.

,,'

'^

.r,",'

"'rrrr:'b"

f/

I' t'i\"r

I':

,l:,1

,

;-

",,,,'

'

,',,

".'\i,,r

r'

'r:rr\

'"rurrr'

..,

'l...,,,,.

,;' ,,t

lrr

",'.,'

u""rr''

-

u'

'lIr

"''''si"r'

r"'

ll"i'i,

'

.,

;,,''

''t,"'

r'';rr''rr

''ri

"'I'""r"nL"r'

'1.:

;,.

l;

ir

.,,.

rr,

"'r

'|ur'tr'r"

"r

'r""

s'r'AI''l{

,ii.,

',',

' '.

rl't

'

'

'r"l

his

r-LI;"

v

''"1

Jism

)

,,.\\,.,1,lx.,..

r,r.

t.......r

\vl,u

iiJ;,d

'r

\irl'irr

tl''

;,.;.

I ' '. .','"'",

'''u"'1'

BLr

-'rr$irhrarlr"lrv.tn'r

l:

li

.,

.

i

"'

.

,,,;

"

"

'-","r)

""r)ri'xr

\nsrr'r'

in

i, .,

'

",,

,

'

"

l'

'

r"1

"

i'''' or

ilr'

ural

'ru:l

tl'"

"i

,i,,

t

:,

'.,'.

Ili''

n''"'

r''r

rli'

urni":urr

$''

r'ut

rlit

,,,

],

,.

,

lI,

'

''

I'r

-"1

'rJ'

'i"n'

L'

t

Irr"'t

rlr:rr

,,'ur,

.,',',

,

I

':.

I

'

''

l"'''r

'"

Irlr''r\'

rl''

sl"'i-

r"or'J-

,''.,.'.

'.:.''",

,'1,

'

'""-"

t'o,''

ir'

lrisrnricrr

J,J

irr

";

i

.

t

.,

,,,.,'',.

,:.

...',,..I.'','.

II'

/./"/

r"Jr

Hirl'1

l'"rl

rl -

;l iil

.;.,,,,','i

""

:

I'rrir"

r'

"

it

r'):1'i,.1)sr\or

''li.

ll

,".,...r..,r..

..

,,.,.,.,

,,,,,',\..'s^,i,'r..r

\\ir"r',

p',r,,i'

.'.li::

li;l',,,;

,';i,,'i,,,",,"

"

';r"'

it'r'

"^*'

or

^nrxnsrnrr'rt

Irr

,..,

"1

"

'

"'

'i'l

'

l''r'

l',''

'"h'

rl

rr'L''J''

,,

'

,

'

,

''

l'

''

ri

I"'l

'l

l''rl

'r'

'r

l" ,

..

I

,

r'' L

''r'r""

"l

'\'|

r'il'''-'n

ll

'

:

'

.

r"

"''r

li'r"""

r"n i'r

tl'

irr'"""rr''r

: i

:,.';1,:

):,,'ll'-:"i,'i:

..1

,,1 ll,.,l

l,i\

l'rllu\\

\

"lirl

I

i

j"

'-rrt

,

';;."",,,,

""'

$'ru

rrr(l

$irlitrrr

crPcssnrD'

no\l'

Lis

corrrt

uncc

L,i,,,,

'

.'

r.''l"l

'r'' I'

tr

rri

'

""'"'

"-"'ii,:'irai

""'

''i'i"rv

""

cicrrxr

"...nirerttti.-

o{

rrro

,,,,,.,..,,i ,,,,r, '. :\,'',.ir

'"'rl'l

if '''

rJior"y

irr

, ,,'.

''

.

" '

"

i'r

l'

'

'l

11

{''

r'

rl'"

tul"

rlq

r

"

'

'

I"

l'

l:'i

"rl

;"":l"l'l"l

;''''

'

'

''t

""1'

"

"']

l

l

i

'-

i'

i'

i' l":

'

,

',

i

','.

,

,

11,''

,'

l)'

'",l1l

:,,

'

'''

','.

"..i

"t

t-

"-

t r"t

t"';

':'

"

,.,.ri'

.

')

r

l'\l

L,l',r.

\''li"" l

l''r')

rr'd

irr

l'''

r '.'o'

1.,,,, l.,ll

,,,.,,l

,,r

'.,

,

rl''r)

'rr'l'1""'r

,.,j

.,,,

,

\

,', II

r'

r'

"i

l''

rl'

1"

""r'

'

'l'

''

"1r-

xtio,r

oL

lri(lili,rrr

tlrro'Lgh

rir) l('ririt)'

lilrllr

trlc1't'1'

llrN gn'"

r'

sLrL,&r

arco,,rri

ol

llr,:

rlei.l |rrrorL

(n

tiidor(sirrI

caritLul

rirtjrnr11l

,"r,r,r,.

r",.,,

Sissa

school

slslrnr

Lctur{r

$roLl(l

\\ilr

llri'Sh(l

has

sh,^r,t

hon

ll c

lrrrrr;1lr

SisivrLs

lorrndcr'

Ki lladjar

D'wanlaLn'

rv:rs

rrLlc

to

conrl)irio

\1'I.it

t(

thr)

Lirno

wcr

ultrxnrod'r n

LLrnrtnist

c(lucrtiornl

th.ori.s

$

illt

lrx(litiorid

cli]Incrts

in

Jav'rn(xc

dhLcation

r.

'ror-lc

,,''

r.r:

.'"''l

"

"'

|

'

l)

'l

'

i\

'

'

\

"

"

'

'

,.,,,1,t ,"' ,,,,,-

,,J u'1,

r,r.'

r'

J

"'r'''rr

ri \\lr'r

s

i-,.r..t.,,

.,

"

',rr-''rr',,r

\ ll.'l

r'

il'

r'

rn

Ir''l"L

'1

\lur,,'r

|

',.

:'

i

'

r'

r"

'''

rl''

r''

"

rr'

'' ':

lr

rl

'

fonrtlatiorrs

rL,.urrr

up l)\

Llr(]

tiLdjL

nxiist fu1"17t'u'r

(in(liirliorr)

sroul),

lrrgui,l,.li

s,itn'i,

rti'uu

',

lrtl L\

a

gouP

oI

Ki

rt'ldirLr's

i.i.riL'.

r

l'i,'',r'p],,^f

u.o

sidc.l

'lrrrlitv

ol

rxili'rl

DilioDrlistr

L$

oI

"u..or,,

4"",i

xtnnogrrLl

rL|d

ltlsnrririxl'rPl'itrxli'r'

Inrt

tlris

(loul,lci*s ,'ri,

rrlso

1lr

rrrr

r

rfllnlirrg

ihl:i

d\Drrnic

lb\cr

ork trin)i,,)l

Ir\'rr.ic

llrir,'.iLr(.]:l

It'

tl,r:

rl,iliiv

(o

.orrrrltr..)PPr)s

i(s

it(l

to al']sorf

ltis

rdvrNxrics

,.1

i', ,,

,,,r

'

l' r"

'

'

lrr'

rLl,l,..

.

r

'r.'

r"

'l

i" r

"r

I

l'"

''

'

l'

',.,r,,

'll

r.

,

rr

l'

'

'

\1"''i

'rr"

s s

r,,

I

,,.t.

t. ,,.

'.r.J,t

I

.rirr

..

x

sli..

l,

ri

rIrrrt

r,ilcLr

il

\\rri

s1 r

rrs l

(lrl71lirr

I)lrt

grrarr

or

\lritr'

1 I

tr,.rr

t"

,.

..

r

'tl'

r,,

.,".'

l"

''''

i'

rl'l'"''

l''"

lirl,(

r

l',

',

L,,,;l

l'.'

,'

\'

r'"

I

r'

'l

'

'

t"

I'

", rI..l l" rrl "r' l' '"'1"'''l ""llr''i

"I

"'' "'

another.'ll,c.v il(1x)

1,.t,,,,""

"t

l"t*'

rrLs

norr:

usrrrlJy

rrrrr{.rl

l)y

tlr:

ti\lio

l'-1]",,:,,j

,,1,1,

1 stls

tlrorrqlrr

ro olrtat'

si)lth

Io'1

tr2ll1jtl,

M.\i ,

r',Lrxn

SisNr

.rd

thc

Irnlllr'sixr

'rlnn

l

^lv)L{Lilg"

?r,hn,

r'

11't

r

"r

r

srr'r

',.,"'r

",

rt, I

^,

'1r,,

".i

l

'

\.

l.

"'.

1

"^"'

r I . ,,..

.,' r.

.li

'

'

i'..

l.ntri

'

.

i'

'

,,,.,,. , ,

"

lr'

'

'l

'

'lr ""-'

,,, r"

'l

'

"_' l

I

,i

.,,

r..,.,

.,

I

'"r'

"

'r

"

tl

h\r

tr

,, Ln

'lril,tiL\

I

nr l'

I rr

'

'

1'$"'

'.r\1.,.

I

.1.t.


10/35

n)x \rl)1.,,ni (lr)1.,

\{i.-h r(l,r\ to tl,,

st..,*sn)r

.risis

rlt(j i1,.

ricath

ol

-{rr0giruL.rt

11 n, r7(n,

N.1s

dc.ignl.l

t,,

ir(li.rtc \tLy

Prng.

D l\,S.r.

\'M i,illi

l)nl(l

lN1islan..r

rLsru|.(1

tL.

llironc

iloD

lrjs

f.Il)r\r

r\rrrurrg.,,,lt

lll.

trrs lhc {l{r .tn

l

soy.,ci fis

Lgitnrrat(,s,,c..isor.

1'|c slor

is l.l(l

tl,il

thc

Irli:rd]

kntg's rtro,-

hoo(l

sroo(l

or.ct

rirl ,,r

tltr,h)P

ol it

yxs

r radirrnr

lj.qht

(tjxl,j.i),

only

ihc

si1,)

oI

a

grrin

ol

p.pp.r. ]]ut r(n,ody oLs.ncd ir.

Onl)

lrxgcl.

l'jtlgcr

sxi'

ii.

Pri,gcran

Il,q(x

rlnicl(l)

siU:,.d

ul)

ih.

IdLop

r,1l ]iqlrt.,\s

sron

is

rhc ligl,t hr{l

b( i

sit,iul, th,,,.trrlrtxl

.cxscd ro strnd {rc.t. lt

\ras

Alhl)s 1lill thrt Prngcrxri

l'1,ljor

sh(nrld su.ccrxl to

th. dnrrr.."

I

iuclccd

llc

scrLrrl l:crtility of

thrl

rlLlcr

js

o,r

lssoniial

sign ot

rhc

]l(nv,r

thrt

h,) l,r)lds,

lor lis secd

is tlrc

rrnrr)()sr)ric

.xtr.ssior

ol

tll.

]'(^v.r

1rc

lrrs

cofic,rimlcd./'I

hc

li,rtility oli tlrc rrlc'r

s,.rs

srci) as snn,,lixnco sl)

e|c,h,,g

,uul

gurraD

iccjng

lhc

lirtilily of

lhc

lillxl,

tli.

lrrosl)rrity

ol

rlx

soc[t , .u.l thLr

crpelsiorisl

vjtrlil)

ol t)rc rrn;rirr'.

'l

lr.

Strlr.tDo

Inrdxl

onc(]

agrill

provnlcs

a strilti g

uruleru

palllllcl to

ihis

old klcr. Outsidc ob

s.rvcrs

of

tl,c Iniloncsi.,n

vrlr: ierltltly Idn h.it

tlrl] SulllIro's

rell-publicizod

sl,)iurl

aclivitics

ap|crrcd

io

.lo

lilrl

no

polltic.rl

l,.rrrr.

lL

ivrs

-.ii,

s"i,l il,,t tli.

J,tvnroso

nrlirigo,,tlv

cxp,,ci

Llt:lr

nl.rs to r.1 nr tlris

Nry.

Blt il tIo li,.8oirg auil)sit

is

(or,\i,

lh(:

pr,tnrl s|..is ol

Srrkrttrris

lros(nr.rl

lilo

arc ovcrhxrktl

j,r,

:clt:t

f(rspc(riv..

lii,

irigns

r)l th. nl{r's

vi lit}

.tr.

|oliti.rl

irrln'Lrtors

ilrxtlr,riilT

Tuil

lh,iPour'.

(lon l.Nlr.,rn,/

rirrrli,tl

.1, .lirr in s(,{rri

a(livit),co',irl lL LLLkLrr

as

sigi.l \r1rri,,t,

T',^\'cr in olL('r ,1'sf1als.

,\1,?

solrristicrlc(l

olxcLi?is ol

Lrl{)

(;uid(1

ll(]rl)ocr.1c} rr

in(lcc.l

i,rclinci

Lo

srsp.cl ihrrt

I'xh.jc

oll.ilils

(lclil,(rrtd)

ln.cid

o\.1gg.tur.d snnirs

rlxnrt

rL(,

llcrid.,rt's prr"lrrNl lili, ls p.lr1 ol tl

.o,itjrnring.fl(,t

to

r lj tunr

lrjs

rnilorjty.

Tho

sor:irT

signs

of thc

cof..nlrrtion

of

loll.cr

wcr.

l.ltilily.

pros-

pcril),

strLilii\,

x,,d

slol\.,"J

tl,(: rli1lll,,g ol tl,(:

,rlrlrs

,,r/ri? p,,ts

it in

thc.:hssi.rl ifragcll r)l

th. r.r'ir rt

J.rrinr.s.

l.jrg.lonr of

K.,.liril

'lLe

lan.l ol

(.dni.rar

l)c.lcscrjhcd

xs str'.t. lng

lar

i..l

wnl.,,

$'irl,

Iorg

sltufs.

Jtigl

rnonnlxils,

d.1,, llr

ih,

proitu,lr, trm(tril r.d w.ll

or{lcrc(].

If 1,,.ij1.,

it

nis

ll,. vill,rgcs

$l,nt, rr,,rc

nrlil.; if

propcrous.

it

rvas

tltq"liiDg.lo4

whi.l,.rvas

prospcn{s, lopd aiy'

cloLlLire

uc,c

v,rv

ir,

Nnr.rro.o, p.

58,.irir.q

/ral)atL

l

analt

1)itut.i,

ti.

:ntt-

rti

IlrNriDrn il.

()C.

,^NDr

Lrs.rN

11.- t.'-..-

,-l

I

t

.

t \

J,t,

ht

..

1-

11|',

r3

.l,crl).

li1,,

t]l. l,yltr\r

r-nluv

turkl k..l) h.,r

o$1t.lr],1,r,,1

Nirh

tls

frih.tr,i. S,nh

w,s

Ll,,,

rnl,..ss

xn.1

pn)slnr.it),

.t

rh

(iL,q.],D.

. .

.

ll,c,c

\r.re

.o nxr,

$tb

hcgqc(l

Ilql

on,

rnll(.,;

c(h

l,x(l

t),)sscssio,'s

,,t

his

owr.

]1ll

ll,is $rs

lD.inr

til tlri rnlrx.t\

u(l

s.1rl

lrd.,rjng of

''

.

1.,

,'.

L

'.''

Thc

trlo

Iunrhnrc,,lil

id.xs

L.hnnl th.s..or\rInnn,.l

n,r.r.s ri

crcntivjtv

({()

tilitv,rutxit\,

)

aD.l

ir I.4r)

1

t,."",1";lrity-i'ra".1,

exptcsscd

nr

ilo r{..r(1

nr)it,r

so

oft.u

ou

thc

lil)s

of

ihc

contcrlr-

trolrN

dirc, kttt

tt

tt.rt kut.t

tthdrcLiu.

(.,rd.r,

pcrcc,

prospedry,

g.rod

lorture). Both Icrtiliiy

nd

ord.r

arr:

si

dy

cxpressiotN

01

P.r\{

er. Poxrr

is iho

nl,jljt). t(i

gilc

lifc.

Pos.er

is

ilso

thc

nbil

}'to

mrirtanr

a srnootli trnrrrcss

1lld to act likij

a magncr $ltich aligns

scnttcred

ilor)

Iililgs

nr

i1

pxtt.rncd

{iclcl

oI

forcc._Convcrscly,

thc

sigr)s

of

a lcsso1tus nr

ihc

tauhress

ol

x

Nlcr s

lorver and

of a dilfu-

sioo

oI ]ris

strcngih

nLo

scc,j cqually

ju

manif..statio.s

ot disordcr in

ll" .

,,

rr. l

$,

r.,1 r'uud

. IIJiu.,

,n

I

1,h,

r

:

..r,J

ir, inlnlro,

priatc no(li,'

of

socjal l,ehrvnnrthcft,

greed, and

Drurder.al

Again,

"r,

rorr'rl

,

.l ;,,

I,\.,r,,,

t.,o

er,t

tt,,

r,. i: ,,o

n..:

j

r,..,r

,.

r.,'

1,,'

..

,

,1,.

L

rr,,.

1',,*,l,

..,

,l

,1.,.

.1,p,..,.',.

nl

rt,

* \

,,

l,

i,

'l

l,

I

.

,,

.

,..

.

..

.t'

.,

,.r'

1,

1,

,\

i.i.

:,r

..

J,,{,,

, l,l,J.,

(l.clinnr{

Po\rr

br{ docs rlot nr itsdI

Iurt]icr

(lnnhisll

rirxt lbw.r.

Il

is

r

s\rnlto,ir

Lrl

uot

r .lusc

(,1

lis

dccho.

l'lr."tlorc,

^

NIcr

\v|(, hr

o,.., p,uriti(l

r

trual

and

social

disord.$ to

rppe

1i,ds

iL

pN,li. lirl\ dilli(Ilt lo rcm,)siiluto

hir

rrill(nil\.

Javnncsc

nnLld

t.rkl

10IrlidcrlLrr

if I.

stijl

hx(i th(j llon.r,

thc

disorckrrs

nrnrl(l

n.vcl

hxv.

arisrn.'tkrv dr) not

sbm

rLltnlat.)ly trcrn

xutuno,

rnrnrs

soci or c(,troxrni

conditnnrr. Lut fronr

lI looscncss

or

difir$ion

,)l

Jr(x\1)

n,itLin Ilr

stilr.

PO\VEII

AND

HIST'OIII

II(^\

dor.s

(hc

nlca

of l1^vcr.rfi.d

thc hrdiijoxnl

Ixva

esc vjc\v

ol Ll)c

nxt,Lrc

or

strrctrn(i

ol:lhc

l]istorical

proccss?

Suh)no

hns

r"'llc.irilior

ir dr.s,n

nom

an urptrblished rransc

ftn,t

and

rraDslarn l

it r

tuaia

i

ht)Li,

t.rt,)Nxn..

r..od.d i.

Uo,orcdio, c.rh.t

Tari,

in

rrl,

riid.

hv

rL.\r

in. oI

llxr

rrjiri

l,iLar, v,r

Ilrt,

,$i

ri

tn./.4.,tu,

tit

iLi

i

ztl.

1r

lir a

food,

alrrrillll

lid

oI iI. un(hr;alr.

hrral

xi{l

so.irl

tluonori

'

'l'"'

'"

''_l P t

"

'"


11/35

20

lltr\Irx.r

li.

()(l

]\ND)rnsoi

ar$l(Il

that th..ssortirl

djliorcncc l)etlvcer tirc trrdlliounl

jrvancsc

vielv

of histoN and

thc

rrrdcrn U/cskm

pcrsp(rtive

is

tllnt,

in

lhc urodri'

\'icn,

hislo)',v

is s.or rs

r lir.rr

nr)v.xrurt ilrror :L iirnc,

w]trr.xs

J

rnos. tradilio rllv

rcfd.(l

to ssr

lhcn

l,istory

ns

rl scrics

ol

r.l. D(rrt

c-,-cii:s. IIc

srrggcsts ilirt \rlilc

\Vcs(clr historiens

ard

poljtkrl

s.i.ntists

dillr rrr llx ilir.ctnn of }ist(nvs

lnrcrr

mo'.

Drlrt Ikl tlrr) rl(igr.c

to Nlri.l)

it

is

dctcnrnrc.l

bI

obj..tnc Inciors,

nll

shrr.

lli.

s.ns(i,

.ssoDiirllv

(1(

ri\.(l

lrr)ni

th{

t( .lnrologic.J

l(\'dr-

ri(ri oi

IIrc

hsl

2oo \1rrs,

t]lirt

hjsnrl is

no)r:t(ratiro,

a soricis o{

Luriqre

(0ts

l;rkrrL

Ly a

(nntlor

c.1ullllit\'.

Ir .o,ll.lst

hc bclic\(s

ihrt l,xfii:ional

Trvtii,rsc

I

ist(,i.rxl

lliiilrin{,

in

n.n rl n1

txrt

l)v

S ,skrit

(t,si, rogi(|xl

nilirgs. s,1\r' l,istor)

as

N-c)cl. of tigcs

()iigr)

,,() i,,s Lrrn

rLc

(i,ld

1

ls.

(K/t./qllgz)

rhrn,Ll,

str..r)s

sirrlv

Jcss l,elpl rptx+s

11'fi.tt1tt1tgr

and

DUt|dra

l-ut,/)

io thc cril

Ku.litula

1)cl.tt

lLc

rl,tl rrrnctl

,Lg,r;n

rnrl

brrrght 1,,tck

.t

rc

nrwcrt KdlnIgi,.r trI\

(i\r

int(r|r.txtn),,.

lrorvlicr,

rorlil lx'ifirt

\\'hil(i rl,.

J,r\^rr.s,:

nx\'l,r\'r

,,ijli,cd .lc,n,:r- Irc., In(lic.(,sn ogv

for

turnrxl clrssiEcxt.) \'

Pr

LTos.s,

t|rn

nrtr i|i: s(rrs.

ol thrli'tori

cil

pro(oss

rr'rs

l

nd,1r,(r,tx

y

.1

logi.xJ

coruili^'

of

thcir

conccpt

ot

I']o(.r.

I pot'rhr

Txv{ncslr

iho

glri lo(]xy rntl in tI. rich csrhlto

Jogical

lirortLnc of

tl.

fxn.

o)ir

Ii,,rls iitllc s.

sc r)t

(rJ.s

al

of

orlcrl|

dcclhc

rnrl

rcbirlhi

i,rsl.nd

onc

s.)(]s

r shrrLr.onhirsi.lrx\rn

r,

.1

,,

l,

,/

/,/.r

L

D

.;

,, I

tlrc Dl(1 x{t.:'rL

l'ficsc l1\1)

i\,]1,s of hislr)ri.ul r,}rr)rs

wcrc

srnr

ht)icalll

t$

iiD.t ol

oil(.r.ir)(l

ii,rns

ol

.lisorcl .

ll r

oili|.1l

foi,il.

T l1)inlr.

js

tli.rt

lLc

Jr\'.ln,:sc

1ic\1

ol

hist(,_v \1 s

orr.

.l c.srrolosil]rrl

os.illxtn,r L.t\ 1rr

tr:ri(

s

oI

cor(frLrxlioi of

l'olLcr

a,rd

t.Iiods

ol

ils rlilirsion. I lr.

irIicrl lrist(ni.rl

s.(|r(,r(

is

{r.trir trrtiorfdjl"

ri

s,.

s)n.n,i

k

r

r,rlir,lr,.

1'j,JIal,Jr t,

ntrt)

t

t:i

\'lti

,n

lrr,i /i

,rl,rl

Sitfutrh tulr

-ir

(1. jLLr,ri:

(i,,,1i.'1,

l\,,rh, rr:q). Nr) ,.trtr,r',r\

.,i

Sr'L.n.ii r,1rrt.

r. t 1r

ro

frxir

no

il

i'*

nf.

lli , rnr rlrrf.

i\

rrlulTl

'

''

,, ,l

l

,

,l

,,

,

,,,,

.1iln,Nl

l. l

lii.rr l,inrri(rl

lrliral^1.rm,l.

tI. nrllln\].o rl

I\lxrtLni

.n.linol. .

(rl.

r\o \,..,trr.,

t]].8r

8.i nnrl

ll.n,rifh

Znnil.r,,\1rrli ,nl

\\,1\ls ii 1ntltu1

,\t1

.ntl Ch.ili:atn,1

(\,\v

YorL: l1[t(,

'lrtr.lntukr,

r9ri.).

tt.

r3

r.,3c

J7.

rr

llv.n

I]ndr .o,nol.il

ton,is

nr

rhis

(ln..tior

ri .c llrc

t)rtlarn

ol

(}ang.

is not:trnrrirr

.i,.nhri

t|..liugc

lr.rr Llt

(xlingx

to

thf

l(rllltrga

Jo.

nl-

I

':

:.,r

',1

'i,. r'o.,

|

,

ri$.1

.li

I

1',r,,'.

'1|rc

ltlet

of

t:otrcr in

lautncse

Cult1oe

2t

frsiol

concmLrrinnldjllusion

wjtloni tuv rikir:rato

restnrg-ponrt.r{

ID

o.rd1

pcrn

t,l

con($t

ari(r,

,,,,,r

,,,,;","

oi l,,x"r,,

liynasties,

Nhs) iuc

.onstit[ttrl Ird ,,lit1

is

r(irrtric.li

ir)

crch

pojod {,I

.liflnsnr\

ir(nytr

brgii,s

to

cLb

arvav tronr

rlrc

(mtcr,

rtro rcjgrnrg

,1.r,..-'

l,

.

i .,r'.,,,

,rl,

.

,

l

,lr\nr.l,

r ,t,1.,.,.

.,,rrrit

r,.,

,,.,,-

ccrtlitirg

Iroc.rs

l)cqjirs

rgiiL

Llx

hiill)ri(rl ,xrccsljtt

ol .liliusjor

is

rr; lcss

coJrr'.cllirr,l thrn

lLrt ol

.onoc,rirati)I,

sirlcc

l,olvcr

js

i,,,n,(,rsdl

lurtl

n) rcriin afrt

lus

p(rlr.l,,alt)

to

t).

stNgglcd

fir.

:l'li. sliqhicsr

sL..hr.ss

(,

Ii.k

ot

vigilrncc

nr.1\ l)cgi; thc

process ol

I

,

,',,,,

l.i

,.

t.,,.,,,.

r,,,

,r..,t

',.

tr,.

iuj.,,.

oL

o,inologi.il

.rurn.$

st.,rls tron,

lanrilr-

\,t,jcl, .senrii]lty

rlcrns

,

.

ti,

.

t,."

,

i,,r

,...,,,,

.1,

....,r.l],..,.u.,..

trlnll Po\vcr

oI

t'r{r

stLtlsltr.l;or

ol

Il,sonxl

i)xssi,rs). i

'l'liis

.1)i.cplrJ|

l)1

hisr,)n

bclps to.xpl ,r

r\ir)

norntric

but

,rpt)u.irll,r

.o|l[r(li(]tr,r l(|trirrs

ol

Jrur$|

trriricrLl

psyclohil

I

ils

rIt(r]]irg

t|'s ir

risrrr

rrrrl

:rt

lL. s.1rrtr t1rrc

its sIs( rribilitv

ro

rx,ssjr.ic

ipprlls.

l'I{,

p(.s

-'frjsrn

d.rir

I.o4 tlr.

sc|sc of

thr

i.r ,rr xn.r)cc

of rorrccltr'

(l

l.w.t.

Lhc dilll.rlr

nrvolvcd

i,r s

ic(rldrrrlninnr

f.|(l

r.n,jjtnjr

,

11r

(l lLr)

ir)(a

iitLriliiv

oi

tlisortlcr

orr

rtrc\

lru

snl(i

(,1

ord.r

'l'lr.

susr ptibilitv

to

Ik,ssjarljsnr

i tirncs

ol'dis

rrrlcr,

Loivcvur, riris(s l]IIn

tlr. s(rrs.

thLt

,r xcw.()nccnira

,r

ol:

lion.r is rhlrrs

prcPxr irrt ils(li

\\.ithil

il)it dis(,xlcr,

tlat on.j

rnLrsr

ir rhrr

for porhlrs

oI

iis

i.n nnit

xpp.xrr..r

arcl thrl

approach

I'I

\ror

Ll

liL.

l. rlr.s Lliil nliir

I [r s.)nr. lnc

ir ni.x

rr

as

on irl.,,

Iniurnm

.l

tl1.

lrfd.m

ri.\ ,,1

/ri 1.,r/

iI

I

(luitir

strcilic r.rsc,

It

is

mr

o

n l.,t,rLrti.r

.I ar.

Trxfr:c

o,r..|t .I rrn.r.

\.Lnrh I tlinl

is prrlrnuv

i.l.n

I

.onrl)

lr. t.

rh,,

Il linr.

.on..tt |&i

on

th.

.otuln briil

,,'loio,

s. b.illi. .lv ,1,,.n1,i.,1

br Ctilld

C.-rz.

(S.e

cdrz,

t.son,

1'h)

t

rtnl

C. ltrl ,;

,n,/i,

l,t).

,r

,

i* )

ll\ ldlnll1,

.ss.nri.lll

n,hririv., is

llrt

tl,..rl..d'nrl,'i,,rrlIrli,,

1l',rr{rIrt.l ti| .i\

in Jrvr

iho

frum.-

ninr

Nilff \l,n r.r.'\Jx1 irllili

Lrl.r

t[...

]'x

ar)tnics

l,ri,nx,ilv

tr,

l

'

, i

l'

r,

,,

,.

,..

L,,l

.

"

,'

I'i.r,,v

,

I

r' i.

,

..

.l

,

. .

,,,

r

,r

,.t.,..

,..

l.

ilTit,r'rn,

|1.,

\r,Lr\

rl,',nrg[

ll].

rrrT Irirlg

rridili,,r,

ud

rh.

l(nrg

t.d.d

.l

.1(,,inl

u,bln ition.

tI.r. ir r {lirln inv

ol

\vhrt

.nr w;,ld

.rtl

t).]iH.nJ

lrisn)r), \,hn,h is n t,xh,d.i.rl

rt rl. This /rirro/ral p. st.dnc

t.t.]

,.

,

1..,,r

'

i

'.

', 'l

.r

I

,,.

i.

rr

.r.

,i,

J...rnt'.,

,''.-

1 \sod

l)r

s ,ror

i,, d,.

pi.vr

r

v.lrn),.. 1'o

n liDihrl

ltlo$l.dg.,

BJi

stoivs

n

r.larnt l..k ol

Lotl' dlr,aLic listoriogrt)hr

xr(l

f.nsint

xrillcnarjxtrisnr,

riS..

Ll,.r

nr{nnr

"l1trr.r

trr(l llrhi.s"

lnr r

n

]lc.

discusior

of

the

{.xn_

rg

a, signilicrn.c

ol

l,d,r,/,.


12/35

z,r

ljli\r) (rr

li

O(l

.\\Dr

so:{

ihc

t (r)rinal

co,ld

rs

rrt)i(ll)

its

PDsslliL,

llLln.hifg

r)rus.ll

t1)

tl

'

rc\\r

(, (.

xs

ii rir,lg.s

lhls

nnrssilrrirr

L .l.rrh

lrrs

lilll'

ol lii''

ljn..rr

rtriht\

l rnxnv

l-unrpcrt

rlill.rrtir)'

'

rrrr' rr.rrts Nhi'rlr

sL1lr'

tlc

\rorl(l

.o,fitq

to

al] cnd

$'ith

tho .llri\,'tll

ol tl).

l\l( ssiJL'

ll

rxdi

tbl]xl

Jrvxn.sti

s. s{r tL]t

histo)-\r docs

rx)t

onr.

lo xn

(rrd,

llrrt

n.ssirlrs

ril r,nh for

thcir:

ti.rc.

inxl tlrtti

tlro

Prirnof.lixl

osr'lllLliior

s

,.t

t,

.....

.

'r,

,

. rrr

.

.1.

rnr

L\l'll

\l' rlll'' .'

l'l:

It

tlrx)

Lr.

usclLLl

to

b( gitl

.lls.,6sio,t,rf

rhc tridiljonxl

lxrlll)'not

lrilh

iis .(,)crct.r

stru.lrrrrs

lirt

s

itL

ils

i.lc.rl sl'rnL,(,1i.

lolr

I

I']( rLxl)s

tll(]

rrosl

.rr.t

jirtlg{r

r)1' tlr('

(,rl(ral

liv: r.,'

Polil}

is tlrxl

ol

x.rrnr'

ol

liglrt.:asr

ar$rv,,rils

l,r

i

rrll.(,lor hrnP

I'i

,

i

txs(i.,rrr(' s.

I

tlink

nror.

r,tumt.l)

llrrr

rrr c

((nnrrrtiorrll

I

nrrnro[rg.

sorrrt

o]

l|o

n,,r,,('s ot

Irt.r,.vr foljtj.xl

lfor,glrt.:r'hr

goo.1

socl.rrr,

is

for

strictl),hicruciLi.rl,

si,rrlr i l

i.rtrd,t

Plrs,,Pl,oses

a

({)

tanl drgrrc

of

Llonr)rr) .1i

,r(h r)l

jlt

lrri

nrs

lcvrls. 1-lxr

ro\1 r.rrL

(rl

hx.ljLji)rrxl

lx iln{,sc

lliorlglLi

j,rplj.)itll

11u1ics

tl,is, sccking

.allv

r snrglr.

lnr

3sivc solx.', of

Pnvor

rnd

.t,,tlrorit).

As rve

shlll

rt,

tlc

qr.1d'Lal,

cvor

dinriirltnrr

rjf tlc lld

rnre ol

llr.

hmf \fith

in.r.rsinll

(]is

ixrcc fu)in

ll,.

l)(ll,

is xrr cia.t

rrr'1lp|or

hrr

1hc

ldrrrr|i'ctrrccp

tjon

not o l)

.rl tlc

strlr

r.('

oI tLc

sl.lr

lnrl also ol

('nt(

pcridr.r\'

n

ltltionslj)rs ,u[l

;f

tcrritorirl

so\ocigrrl .

\\ hiI' rhr:

rrr

.lillcft,rlialrrl

(rrrLlilt

ot

tltr

lirlrt.\l)r.ss s

th(r i(lfr1

(,1

tlr lrr)rn'

-,,'.

,)

,l

l

\

r

rl.,

r

,,

1,,

lr-l

'"'l

lr'

"

r''i

hrsior

oI

rll tlro .olors

ol

tJr.

sll"rtt

urlr, slmhlizec

[ho

nr]if\ nrq

rn(1

conccrrtr

rtn,I

.1sp(x ts

r)l

1t^i1 .

,'I'l,c

.or.r

,)l ih.

lrxditio,,rl

t(rily

l,as nhvr['s

lI

lrr

l]ic

rll'r, \'|o

lc

rn

l.is

tl)f

ffilt

oI

sofict)

r

'f|is

trDit)

is

in its.ll

x

cl]'lul

qmLol ol losrr',

lrr.l

it

is

tlJs

luct

^s

t,rLr.h lls

th. ovcrt

qoals

ol

statist

i.l.r)l)qi.s

thrt

lrclLrs tu

rrrrotrnl lirt

rlr. olx.ssivri.orxtrrr

\rith oucrrls

rihiclt

sL,l|rss

tl)r

ln)lili r1

tlrirrllng

ol

nrrlv cor'

tdnpL,r,tl'

lavxncsc.

Tlrt:

poprrlrr

hosti]itr

c'Prrss{'d

t

rl1ld

thc

Fc(leriil

ltcprrl)ljc

of

lD(lorcslrl

(rg.lq

ro


13/35

24

lnrN,J (.l

lt O'C. ]\NDi)rsoN

nnmli:tl

.li .li

:alfi

(so.

urtit(l ,rs o,,.)

nr

lilo.rnd

h dcrl|.1r'

'r1,e

,L,gc

ro,,,,'*'s,

'ii

c,r,tr.rl lo

Iirtn,'n,

ijdiiicxl

.ttti1 dcs,

holPs lo.rphjn

rl,(i

(t{r't)

I*r

cl,okrglcil

]l^r('r

ol

lli.

i(lcx

ol

,ri

(io,rilis,.

i,)

Jx

.

ir r r ,rc

ll,i,r,L

|r)liti.xl

cr{lo,

nriioLrLlis,rr

(\

prcsscs

a

hntirrrcftl)


14/35

2{j

liLNrI) .r lt

O'(1.

ANDUT rr;

of

dcs.cnt.;i

Tiis

chdactcristn,

ol

corrsc, is

Dot cxclLrsnark

Ju .r-

n.sc. Ihrt t|{r

rnoi.

nitcrostnig lQLlr.

(,t

Jxvxixrnr

'I.rlsilicrtn)n

ot

Listr)rl

is

lhat it

al.rs

nr)t

i)rxnx.ih

nr\ohc

tlr(: r'stxblislrnrg ol oc.$

lrlll

linlij

wirlr

t),1\,j,),,s

(lr

rrslr(s

t

(l(,r)jrstrrh

l.grl, i,rlx{it(\l

l,giLi,,rx.r--irr

\lricl,.i,sr rl,,(rs(

rf)

r

(.stor

\roLLLl

(1,,

1'\picrlh.

.,r(slrirl

li,rl,s

a(i

i,,a(1.

lvilh

ll,c,,l(,,i

l)q\r'crlLrl

,r,d ..[']r11(r(l

rcpi(iscL,lntivl

s ol

l|oso

(h

nxstnrs.

'lh,,s

i,,

rlilno,l(n,

p.,io,l o,,. nr(ls

1,1v.,,(so

(l.rn,ri,,e

d.sco,l

Iro,,) lh,r

grcirt

Srltin AgLrig

(,i

tl,(i \frLrfrrn

(lyrurlv

(r(irt-$.(il,

r)r th(i

fo:iscssio,

(n

por( ,r

r.lics

(g(rgs,

frisscs,

x,,rl

n)

lortll oI

Itr.i

s.i,rc rrld.

,\ .lai,n to

d.s,r,

Ll lron liis rlo l.ss

ln)l)

lrrilot)roa(iri

tir'i l)Lrt.orrsi(l(x.tl)h

l(,ss

|(riij.rll),

x.l.|t

srr( ss(ns,\nringkrnrrl T.

lI, lIt, rxd

Ms virtr,rlll

rDloown. llrc

ln)i

Li

hcrc

is not sirirpl\ ll .

histori.al

glory of

S,Llr,Ln

r\gL,f,l's rL,lc, l,ut rlso tlc cl,rrx tcr ,)l

lradiinrri

Jxvaf

.rc

.osnn)logi.ll

llouelrt \\,lri.h nritk.s nr) sLilll

dislindbn b,l$1r'tr

tl. lirin{

ru.l llrc

dcrL(1.:lhc dcri rrrl1, lr.rir:

l'u[jrs

Iill

rs

lr]. li'ir)g.

-\

rrl


15/35

23

llJ \rnr(:.

1l.

O

(;.

r\\D

isoN

Ioricrl

rlisirn.c

tro I

ilc oriqilrl

vn)rcc

lr(l

(1(xyin

a.l|rirlurcs

oI

roirrorrl se.{l llrls

ile c\scntiirl li|li

1o

thc

fth

is

|rclsurod

in

t(.i,,s

oI j),orjrr)iL\, \lr(ilrc,

tht)rq|

r,i,(.tic

d.s..nr or.

rs

1rc

slr.tll

sr .. xl(rr

otlr(r

tr\.s

of

roll

tr^y.r.

lllLc

s ...ss(ns

tr)

rh..l\r)xst)is

nnrnrllr

(l(

ri .d

llr.jr oiql,

irl lr()1 o

lforn

th. inii rl

jnrprtsc

pr(

virLd

lrr

t}r,irrnrlr,L

hirr l .IIrt tl)is

llnv{i t.rclll

to

irr(^r

(lillusr

ovcr

er:rrcraLions;,rnlcss

jt

\ ,s,orrrcrt

rnrl ,.n,r,,g.:;,rt

l,y rt,,

grs(nrll

.0,)rts ol i

p

ticol.rr

(l.s.cl(tant,

rh.

dynllst\,

1.orl](l

IaI

,,1,'r..

,,

".

'

...

'..1

r,.

L

I

.,

.'j

..

I

r,\\

'

i.

.\\t,

l.Iit.[LL

TLo

J.r .r),.sc

corrltrr,)f

P,^ .r

l,Ls

i ,tricxrn)nr

atso tor

runccp-

ti(,rs

of

sr)\..,rjgnt).

t.rljtoritrl

nrroqrjq,

ar[i ]i)r(:igll

rt'l.ltnrjs.

I,I(x]r-

roxo und

orj).$

liLrc ponrr(tt oIr

ljro

rlrnort

jnvr

rtn.r

r|lc

Lodi

ni

I.\nr.s.

$,rLjorr

sto

rs

rLnd ir thc

histori.rrl

lradi&nr

t|at

th.,

nxnx,s

ot Ifrl)jros

rl)d Kinqrlo,)is

xr.

rlos.

of

rir.r

capiraj

citics.

.{norre

thc \\ cll.b}l^ir

r.riull|l(,s

rr.

}t

ritjrfrtrir,

Sin,,ttusai. Iicdn

j,

ltnd D.n,rl.ri

rlrl{lrd

tj)c

J

af.n, l&(r

so

nrakcs

no

cte.rr

erynrol.,dcil

distin.inD

h,tf;(r,

tL.

nl.l

ol

rxt)jtxt.it\ rr(l

tlrrt

ot

kif((lorr

ir

thc

$nr(l

,era,ri

l)r)r|

irl

if.lrr(1.r1.

1'tros

rl ,

slal.

is

t]'pj.NIlv

n.fi|(.,1,

rrot l)

its

tutrn.t.r.

ln,r l)\'ils

drrt.r.

t.hc

tirril,r'i.rl

.\lr'si,rrr)llL,

rtxt,.is

lltrr\s

jr)

lh\i

ii r.r.i(,s

r.,or(lijrg

to iho

n(nrrl

oI

Jtnn

ru,u",,t,,,r,,t

ai

tt,.,,r,rror.

C.ririn trolti(rs

$,u.)

.r

.nilr.r(tor,,j7rd

I

lr[.ii.1,.

r,)rn

nt,rl)L]

((r,,1

,l)lri.rl

oL,

sir(t(5lil:,r

ro,rft,lirs,L,rd

s,.,rs.

rJrir.lr. l,or.i.r.

t,, ,t,1t

ro

h.

,r,-

r,.1r,.,,,,1,.,.,.I,,,,,r

do,rs

n1)c

nol

rg,rrlrrl

as lridjjjs

rr.d

tnrll

.hin.tc(l

tirnits,

but

rxtlrcr

ll.\ilnt. llrrcl,ixtinq

lr..irri.nJs.

1,r .r r.il

sr|s..

rL

e

rcrc

ro

}oliiic,rl

tronLi,Js

ri

xll. tll l,o$.r

of.nc

L',I.r

qft(t .rllv

tidinjI

:',r1,,1,.',r.,, .r, t,,,t,.. ir,,...,irr;

Ihrcr

ol r rcigl,lrtlIinr:

sorcrritrr.

l

li pcrsBrctjrc

brirgs nrrr)

reln,f ttr.

Irn.ttnurrrl

difloucc

lxhvccn

thc ol(1 i.lca

oI it

Sonrl,clst Asial,

ki,rgdonr

arcl

rle mortcrr

stntc,

irhi.I

(1,.ln1,s

lro,r

totrllv

.olh

tius

vjcN,s

.rl)our

thc

mcarnrg

ot Irolti.rs.

h\rn

ft in

llo

jd.r

ot

rtr.

mo&,.r

sturc

is

rlrc

(r)rcopiior

t]nl

a Iro))ftr

nrirlrs a

(liticat

liLll

;r

tlc

Powcr-voitxgc

ol

thc strtc's

r.ul.rs.

]-cu \,rrds

ihis

snl.

of

tlk, tronkr,

ihcir

po ,er

.6

t.,

...

r;..

'I'tLe

ld.ea

ol

},alaet

in

l@anrs(.

Cult |e

29

'''

'v'r,ir,'.'

\..'. l'.,,11'

'

'.r,..'r..

i.L

rr,.LrI

rrtli-rl,l

.",,

\1..,.,\..

\:t.

r',

ti,,

1",..,,,

r.

t

tJ,...t.,,

1J,,....,..

;

"f

rl.,-,,,,

."

.

rr"

.

r,

lr

,,t

,,,, i.

,,

,\.i1,,

l.Il,l,,

ry

.,.,,.1

I

..1

..'

.r..t,r

,,r,,,11

r,

rrr,..,

r,,,.

.

,,t,1

l,,J,,lul,l;

1r..,\

.'.,IlJ..t,t,h

,.,

.',r)

,,,,

.rt,n,rt

rtr,

l, i,..,).

s:j,,.lt,r

r,.,ti-

tiod

nlc.

oI

lurcr

is

tr)trllv

di0i).crrt

iI

.hancter,

rxl

rho idcr

oI

'l'

,,

I

"

r, 1..', |

,I r,,t'r.

rr.,,,,,.t

I.L,\,.r

i-

..,...rnJh.

1t,,.,

.

,,

t.,

.',,1r

i\,1, l.

,r

'

i,..1..t,

-

..

"

t.)

ir\

0,.ri.i,

t,,.-,

'rh.l,i-hh,.,r.p.Lt,t,,,

,.r.

,,i

i"..

ti,,

.

.arJ,,,.,n.

..

rJ.,.

r.t.,

i,

,'ri\.

b)

:Ir r

r,,'

t,y,i,,,..\,\'nr,,,,

tt.,

snrl,r

irrre

rr6

111,, 5..1

st,rtc- :

Jlra

ard

SlLrllng

(Ill

,Dr(tiliircDriaicd

$,ord rncauirg

..ovor-

scas'

b t

cssc tiirlh

itflrlnrl ro

all

noD-Jrrxncsc

groups ancl

potitical

ollj&s).

,Utlnn,.'L

ontcnrirolu)

poiitcjsc

and

thc i{teotogicat

rc.

qlncnreDts

of hdoncri&

nrtionatisDl

rkc

rhis

kiI.l

ol

divisioD

no

lorecr

publich.

.1c( ?rxblc,

onc

tutrls

ir

frilak,

.tjscussj.,1

\virlr

nr.u).

Jrlv.rDcs.r

stl(nr( irnd

.r^,io s

residl(x

oI rhis

nriclcctuitl

co

,

',tirju'r.

l.'.'..r....,r.,-l)

.1,..,:..,s..

rt..

it,.r,,tr.,t

rt,.

n.r,t\

',

,.t

..

,

.

,t,

i,ti.,-,

tI

.

or.r

,,.t....i

,,'

trJrilui(.ri

t. nirr)loqi(.ulh,

irlo

ldx,,,,.t

rl)o

Oi,t.r

tcgnns.

Ntrn).

lrvfuros,

srill

Iifa ii .\L

o(ti,,,rrih

ditilL,,lr

ro

xc*,F

ltrtiy

rtrc nll,

.1,..,r,

.r'.:. ,..

,,..,.

,.t

..Jr',,,r

"

,,,.,t

i,,,,r..,i

,,

islar(]s

Surrxtrt\

Slihn1si

Iilljrt)lrrtr)),

Tnva,

rmil

Llxr rcst.

All rcrd

'l

t",....,,t.r,.\

t.

,

|

.i

i

1,.r..,,, ,,,

i...;. t,,.

i,

..

Lhrt

r1r. \'.,d

nrlI'rn . is

Lr.rl,

|,trrlI

n,

(l.f.ro..

to

rlc

nL.a

oi

ttr. $vl

^,,

,.",.'

..(.

,n,,.,t.,".,.n,.I

,,',,,|1,,,

i'

r,'.

..

,t

,,.

.,

tt

.

,,l].

u.

.... ..

,,,

...

.

,

,

,t ,

'

l'-."u',.

..1

'.

.,.,

,,

j.t ,t.nr.,

1r..1 ,

,,,

".

L

,r ,t.

..

t,..

1.,,t,

,.

,...,.,.,.

I

r.

,l

,

,rr

I

..,

.

.

,

,,

,,,

..,,.

orirr. r.lr,. t,.,

''1,

.."1,.

t'.'

,',.,$,

rr',

,,,r,,,t rt.i

r,,t..

h. Lr

.1,,,'.",,

\1.i'.

.'.,,

t, \,{tr.,

t.r,th.

rr

r.,(,..,,\

'i,l

,,^

"....:t,,

,\ n.nJtotr

,,i,,''1...r..'1,

or

llk oi.t tn.,r,. rr.

'.

',,

,1.. ,1"i,,

.

.

.\

I .tr,

,t

...\

,",-

, ,,,.,,

.r i

,,.

,i

I

,.'

'1.,

.

..

,

'

r'

.,,

.

,r,,

.

J Ly

r,,

,

",,

r,

I

t.

.,n.t

r., i

,,,.

,

I

,

,l ,,

'r..

,..,...

.t

,"

...r1.,t,utJ...

in..,1n

li't'

,,,

I

',,,tr

.

v.,.v, L

,int,1i..t'Fn,iry

ttl\

.\hl


16/35

30

llriNrrrcl

tt.

O'(1. AN, trsoN

ro

l .s,r r

ii)

^r1,,.i,

,lirior6t,iI

lo tlrc..)ri.r

ir\ ). sjj, ilIt ,

nlxD\

.lri,[).s.

0 Lt it

]rii

d ti) rr)rc(.i 1,

ol tl.

.\isrcrr.r

oI r\r) rcqr1,

i,

.1

..

ll, l',,,':i,

.,

,i|,r'i,..,,Iri,.,.,..,i1

Su[kr.tu

][r.

I(1 s.p:LrLr

t .r-]rtcl..s

tor

tuoro

Ltrerr

roo

r.rrs

trll

rJ,.,1 .,.,",

]

,,, ,,,,.

r..:.

.....

L

jt _

t....

l_,r,t.,..,_

,_.,_,

t.,._ti

I

,..,.

.,

,r

. .,

.

..,

,1,i,,

,r..1

.

..

,

tL,,

ot|(r L\

its

rtr(,

ris tl,(

r urrtrl

rrl

oLh,icirr

ir

Tnrto,,r.:irr.:.

'll(,

( rlrif.txlit_l

,,t

Jr\r,r.nr

t,)tili. l

rtrirrkiDg.

rr).rbjr)f(t

\1irtl

,.

..,t,, .r\.r..i

r,/,.,t.

lr.

1..,.

.r

I

1.,

.r

,.

,.

.,

\,,.

rr

r

.r,

,

,

,.

,..,r

,.

r,,

r

Iirsl

phr it

ir)rfli|s

,1

srrss

o)r thc

(urtrot

ol

|ot) hijrnrs

rxtl(,1

thnri

oi r.[itl,\'

JlisL ,rio,Lllr,

r]r(,,:j

s.r.

fu.li.rt

r.r(tuns

1or itris

(.rqrrrsis.

ODI

tl(

.on.r)rti,rtion

ol

L[sc

fot).,iijons

nn(t(]

possil,t.

Lrl irl.,rsiv(r

rj(c

c JtiltLt

or)

(Jnrld

L)rovidc

rL.

(j.onofunr

surtt,rs

and

icy:,vo

.,1

n,ant){r$1,

ntcssl_v

tot

brritrlinq rron,r,rrcnti

rr

arlrjcs

lli,t llir

col(1 rt|xti,nr

(,1

lrrgo

potn,txriois

lLrnr|


17/35

32

IlINrDr.r l.

a)'C.

ANDrjnsoN

i.sofrr

ff

ilie.],r1xntlti(nr

is not

brrl, it Drat

ot do

so

dccisiv(rv

)

d'

O,

lLc

nror.

Llrc.rrcLicrl

I

\'cl,

(lcslncriol

of r)rh.rs do.rs

nor nr ibclf

rrioDratnr.tlh

m.a

xnl rlnrg(:.r.nt

or

rmr:$ll

oI rh{j

rulcr,s

Poxcr.,,,rrth

tl,o.ljslxjs,1l

oi his riv

s,

whjch niay

t)i, pk,ksl

up

or.rl,so

xi l,) oth.r ri|rl\

\l)r1r^,rr,

(l.srflr(tn)i,

its( is

lhr rnosr

blnr.r,i

irnd

lr(,

((nrdc,

iongl,)

nrcrns

(,t

s,,trdun,g r rn rl,

.1DLl

ou tlris accouut

tlc

hast.l(sirrblc.

trlor. salisfrct( \

is

rlo

nctlro.l

.

.,

",1,,",r,

,

t,

,r

r. .

,"

...

t\.

.

, .

,,,

.,r:.

1,',

'

..

..

,r

.,1,. ,.,1u,

,"..t

\

l

,4

.,,t,

'

.t

:.....,

i.,.

,:.,

..,,:.i

.

..

sut)ciorirt or

slz. i|tr.I

Ll rh,r),r.

xlr(,fikD

i,

s..n

rs

rhc

loluntrry

srl)r)rission

of |.ighbor;rg

liin{(lo

s

1o

ttrr

sUPI.Irc

Documents

The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson