19
The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public

Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

Page 2: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

…unfortunately it overlooks THE most crucial aspect of Science

Page 3: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

©

The really important breakthroughs in science almost always come out from left field

i.e. - they are totally unexpected

Page 4: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

In 1970 applied science in the UK received about 85% of the total

research budget for science and about 15% went to fundamental research.

Page 5: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

The Public and Politicians tend only to understand science in terms of its value to society ie strategically

This is quite understandable

Page 6: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

However this results in a major problem

Page 7: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

By introducing “so-called” strategic initiatives, Mrs Thatcher cut the UK

fundamental science budget by ½ and so diverted an extra 7½% to the

applied area

… which already had 85% !!

Page 8: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

This was essentially peanuts as far as applied science was concerned and

has made little impact

Page 9: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

…but it has been catastrophic for fundamental Science in the UK

as a cut of 50% in that budget takes it below the threshold of viability

Page 10: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

Note: The Fullerenes were discovered in an experiment designed to understand the chemistry in carbon stars

Page 11: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

…not in combustion flames

Page 12: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

…not in combustion flames

Now Fullerenes are produced commercially by

combustion !!!! by Mitsubishi

Page 13: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

In fact the most violent and abusive attacks on our claim to have

discovered C60 came from combustion researchers!!!

Page 14: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

History has shown time-and-again that the paradigm-shifting, fundamental breakthroughs in Science invariably

result from an intrinsically creative and intellectual attitude

not a strategic one

just as is the case in the Arts

Page 15: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

©

GREAT SCIENCE IS UNPREDICTABLE

Page 16: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

Sorry - Not my fault - just the way it is

Page 17: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive
Page 18: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive

In 1991, Jack Howard of MIT's Chemical Engineering Department invented and patented the 1st generation

combustion synthesis method for fullerene production, a significant advance over the carbon arc method. He licensed

the technology from MIT and founded Nano-C in 2001.

Page 19: The desire to fund only science that is clearly predictable to be in the Public Interest – is, on the face of it, an excellent motive