Upload
edward-muzika
View
227
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
1/39
!"#$%&'()#"*+" ,'* -./"0,1.('
%%%2*3,.1, $(0 4(+.5%%%
6,015 7 ,'* 77
8.,#(+9"5 :"1)""' ;*),0* , ,'* ?,@.3 &,A90
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
2/39
!"#$%&'(#!%")
*+ $,-.,/0-.1
!"#$% &"'() $* " +,(*-+,./-) 0,1$ 2),3 4(35"$6 78/$"9 :- $* 3"))$-/
;$
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
3/39
!" #$ %&'()*+
!"#$ %&'%(& )'* *+&,- ,#,*,"*,'# ,#*' -&"( .%,-,*/"( *-",#,#) *+-'/)+
0"-"1+"#." 2')"#"#3" "#3 4-,$" ,#,*,"*,'#5 6'7&-* 83"1. 9". "
%&-.'#"( .*/3* ': 2')"#"#3" ,# ; "#3 9". ,#,*,"*&3 ,#*' 4-,$"
$')" "* *+"* *,1&5 ?'9&@&-A 6'7&-* +"3 "(-&"3$ "9"B&3 *' +,. *-/&
#"*/-& .&@&-"( $&"-. 7&:'-&5
4-,$" "#3 C .+"-& " D'11'# 3&@'*,'# *' %-"D*,D& ". '%%'.&3 *'
%+,('.'%+,E,#)5 F'--&D* 1&3,*"*,'# %-"D*,D&. +&,)+* "#3 :'D/.
D'#.D,'/.#&..5 G+&$ "(.' 1'7,(,E&. %.$D+,D &-),&. "#3 D"# ,#D-&".&
*+& &::&D* ': !"$"H,((/.,'#.A 1&"#,#) *+& 1&3,*"*'- +". *' 7& 7&9"-&
': 3&(/3,#) +,1.&(:5 G+& 1"#,:&.*"*,'#. ': F'#.D,'/.#&.. "-& "(9"$.
D+"#),#) "#3 ,((/.'-$I &J,.*D& ,. ,((/.'-$I ,* +". #' %&-1"#D& '-
./7.*"#D&5
K&(: ,#L/,-$ *$%&. ': 1&3,*"*,'# */-# *+& "***,'# "9"$ :-'1 *+&
&J*&-#"( 9'-(3 *'9"-3. *+& ,#*&-#"( 9'-(3 ': 1,#3A "9"-&..A "#3
F'#.D,'/.#&..A "#3 :,#"(($ -&D')#,*,'# ': *+& ./7M&D*5 N#& D"# .%
1"#$ $&"-. %('33,#) *+-'/)+ *+& ,((/.,'#"( .%"D&. ': 1,#3 "#3
D'#.D,'/.#&..A &J%('-,#) *+& O',3PPP*+& &1%*,#&.. *+"* %&-@"3&. "((
*+,#).PPP"#3 *+&-&":*&-A 3,.D'@&- *+& ./7M&D* 9+,D+ ,. "(*')&*+&-
7&$'#3 &J,.*D&A F'#.D,'/.#&.. "#3 *+& O',3 ,*.&(:5
Q* ,. &".$ :'- 1&3,*"*'-. *' *"B& *+& O',3 ". *+& /#3&-($,#) %&-1"#*
.&(:A 9+ ,* ,. '#($ "#'*+&- %+'1"( '7M&D*A "(7&,*A *+& 3,-&D* (,#B
*' *+& ./7M&D* ': &@&-$*+,#)R 2NS5
Q 9". 3-"9# *' 6"M,@T. L/&.*,'#. 7&D"/.& 9& .+"-&3 D'11'#
&J%&-,D&. ': *+& /#:'(3,#) ': F'#.D,'/.#&..5 0"-* ': *+,. ,. M/.* 9+'
+& ,. ". " 7'3$U1,#3 "* *+& *,1& ': *+&.& 3,"(')/&.A "#3 %"-* ,. 3/& *'
*+& )-&"* 1&3,*"*,'#"( &-)$ ': +,. :'D/.&3 %-"D*,D&5
V"%"#&.& C -&D')#,E&. *+"* D'--&D* .%,-,*/"( 3&@&('%1* -&L/,-&. "
7"("#D& ': 1&3,*"*,'#A '- 3+$"#" %'9&-A "#3 0-"M#"A '-
/#3&-.*"#3,#)5 S#3&-.*"#3,#) 9,*+'/* 1&3,*"*,'# ,. 3-$ "#3 9&"BA
9+,(& 1&3,*"*,'# %-"D*,D& 9,*+'/* /#3&-.*"#3,#) ,. 9,(3 "#3
:-,)+*,#) 9,*+ :&"-:/( 1"#,:&.*"*,'# ': " F'#.D,'/.#&.. *+"* D"#
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
4/39
!""#!$ %& '!(# )&*# +!,-
.!/0( 01 *&2 2!340*) 0* %'# 5&&%'0331 &5 )$#!% 306#$!%0&*- 7# 01 58339
#:"3&$0*) 2!40*) 6&,9;+0*,
,055#$#*% !,(0
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
5/39
!"# $%&'()*#+
,-./01
/ 2%+%3#4 5(*6 7'() &84 9#'3 / +"(*'4 :6%3# 3( 5(* & 9#: 3"%8)+; / :6%3#
3( (8# :"(< 8(3 (8'5 %+ & 4%+=%>'# (9 3"# )6#&3 ,(7#63 -4&?+ 7*3 &'+(
3( 3"# (8# :"(? %+ &:&6# (9 @:"&3 %+@< >6(7&7'5 3"# 36*3" &+ %3 %+; /
A8(: %3 %+ %?>(++%7'# 3( =(66#=3'5 4#+=6%7# 3"&3 +3&3# %8 :(64+ &84
3"#6# %+ 8( :&5
B(*< / (6 &85(8# =&8< 5#3 / 9##' %8='%8#4 3( =(??*8%=&3#< +"&6# &84
'#&68 96(? 5(* :"&3 5(* 9##' &+ 6#)&64+ 3"# ?&62#'(*+ 3"%8) :# =&''@=(8+=%(*+8#++@ (6 @36*3"@ (6 :"&3#2#6 8&?#+ :# =&8 =&'' %3 75;
!"# $%&'(
C5 @D(*68#5@ 7#)&8 EF 56+ &)( :"#8 / :&+ 9%6+3 %8%3%&3#4 %8 G6%5&; -93#6
?*=" +##A%8) &84 '((A%8) &84 %8%3%&3#4 & 9#: ?(6# 3%?#+ :%3" (3"#6
H*6*+< / 9%8&''5 9(*84 3"# H*6* ?5 "#&63 &>>6(2#4; I# :&+ &
36&4%3%(8&' H*6* &84 2#65 D(2%&' >#6+(8 &3 3"# +&?# 3%?#; I# )(3 ?#
%8%3%&3#4 %8 "%)"#6 A6%5&+ %8='*4%8) A#="&6% ?*46&;
G#="&6% ?*46& %+ (9 %??#8+# %?>(63&8=# 3( #J>#6%#8=# "%)"#6 '#2#'+
(9 =(8+=%(*+8#++; $*6%8) ?5 >6&=3%=#+ %8 G6%5& / "&4 2&6%(*+
@#J>#6%#8=#+@ '%A# KLM< N*=%4 46#&?+< "#%)"3#8#4 &:&6#8#++< #2#8
A#2&'% A*?7"&A O+3(>>&)# (9 76#&3" &3 3"# "#&63 =#836# &*3(?&3%=&''5
:"%=" )&2# %??#8+# D(5 &'' (2#6 #&=" =#'' (9 ?5 7(45P
K8 FQ3" -*) FRRS / "&4 & A#2&'% #J>#6%#8=# :"%=" +#83 & :&2# (9
#8#6)5 =(*6+%8) 96(? 3"# 7&+# (9 3"# +>%8# 3( 3"# 3(> (9 3"# "#&4
:"%=" =&?# 4(:8:&64+ &84 +3(>>#4 &3 3"# "#&63 =#836#; / 9#'3 8(
76#&3"%8)< 3%?# +3(>>#4 &84 / :&+ #8)*'9#4 %8 3(66#83%&' 7'%++; /
6#?&%8#4 %8 3"%+ +3&3# 9(6 9#: 4&5+ &84 #J>#6%#8=#4 36#?#84(*+
K8#8#++ :%3" #2#653"%8) &6(*84 ?#;
!"# )'%*# +,-.#'/##,(
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
6/39
!"# $%&'# ($)"*#'#+#,-. *-/#01 %#)$+# -"# %*22#/- &%/-$)0# %#)$3/# 4
5$/ /##6*,2 -& 7#8#$- *- $2$*, $,9 $2$*,: ;3- 4 +#- 5*-" )&,-*,3&3/
1$*037#: &5,
%#0*#1/ $,9 )&,9*-*&,*,2? 4 @3/- )&309,.- 6##8 9&*,2 +> 67*>$/: !"#
-#)",*A3#/? -"# -#$)"*,2/? 5#7# %#)&+*,2 $ %$77*#7 -& #B8#7*#,)#
-73-" $/ *- */? 1&7 -"# +*,9 5$/ %#2*,,*,2 -& 7#$)" C/&+#5"#7#C 7$-"#7
-"$, @3/- C%#*,2C:
4 -"#, 9#)*9#9 -"$-? 4 /"$00 /*+80> &%/#7'# 5"$- */ 2&*,2 &, 5*-"*, $,9
&3-/*9# &1 +#: 4 7#$0*=#9 -"$- -"# %0*//? @&> $,9 -"&32"-0#// /-$-#
7#-37,#9 #'#, 5*-"&3- D7*>$: !"# +#7# C&%/#7'$-*&,C 7#/30-#9 *, -"*/:
E00 )&,)#8-/ 0*6# F&9? %0#//*,2/? 0*%#7$-*&,? %#0*#1/ 97&88#9 &, )$7#130
&%/#7'$-*&,:
!"# $%'#()$
4 )$77> &, -7>*,2 -& 5*-,#// #'#7> -"&32"-? #+&-*&, -"$- $7*/#/ *, +>
+*,9: 4 7#$0*=# -"$- +> $5$7#,#// */ 27&5*,2 $/ 4 /-$7- 2*'*,2 3-+&/-
$--#,-*&, -& #'#7>-"*,2 "$88#,*,2 $7&3,9 +#: !"#7# $7# 20*+8/#/ &1
@&> $,9 3-+&/- %0*//? 5"*)" 87#'$*0/ $7&3,9 +#: G> /-$-# */ 0*6# $ +$,
973,6 %3- 5*-" #B-7#+# $,9 "#*2"-#,#9 $--#,-*&,: 4 1##0 *,-&B*)$-#9
5*-" *++#,/# $5$7#,#//: !"#7# */ ,&-"*,2 4 0*6# -& $)"*#'#? 2$*, &7
%#: 4 $+ @3/- C*-C: !"*/ */ 8#7"$8/ @3/- C%#*,2:C 4 &%/#7'# #'#7>-"*,2)0#$70>: !"# )&0&7/ $7&3,9 +# $7# +3)" %7*2"-#7 -"$, 3/3$0 $,9
/8$760# $,9 9$,)# $7&3,9 +#: H37*,2 -"$- C20*+8/#C I$/ 4 )$00 *-J -"#
-"&32"-/ /##+ 7$7#: K'#, *1 -"#> $7*/# 4 5$-)" -"#+ )0#$70> $/ -"#>
)&+# $,9 2&: !"#7# */ ,& 9#/*7# -& $)"*#'#? %# &7 2& $,>5"#7#:
K'#7>-"*,2 $7&3,9 0&&6/ /& +$2*)$0 $,9 837# 0*6# 4 $+ &%/#7'*,2
/&+#-"*,2 ,#5 1&7 -"# '#7> 1*7/- -*+#: !"#7# */ ,& ,##9 &1 F373 &7 $,>
F&9 937*,2 -"$- /-$-#: K'#7>-"*,2 +#0-/:
!"# *+#'),-(.
K9@*? 4 )$00 -"# $%&'# $ 20*+8/# %#)$3/# *- */ ,&- *, )&,-*,3*->: 4- 0$/-/
1&7 8#7"$8/ L -& M "&37/ $ 9$> +&/-0> 937*,2 -"# #'#,*,2: 4 )$,.- /$> 4
)$, )7#$-# -"# 20*+8/#? 1&7 *- "$88#,/ &, *-/ &5, $,9 9*/$88#$7/ &, *-/
&5,: N#7"$8/ *, -"# #'#,*,2 4 9&,.- "$'# -& 5&77> +3)" $%&3- +>
5&76 &7 +$>%# -"#7# */ /&+# &-"#7 7#$/&,: !"# C20*+8/#C "$/
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
7/39
!"##$%$& '( )$ $*$% &+,-%. '!$ (//-0$ !(+,1 2+' -' -1 ,",$3 4()$'-)$1
5 /$$6 '!$ &$1-,$ '( 2$ -% '!"' .6-)#1$ /(,$*$,7 8!-0! 0(+6& 2$ "%
(21'"06$3 96$"1$ 8,-'$ 2"0: ;(+, (21$,*"'-(%1 "%& 1+..$1'-(%13 5 ,$"66;
%$$& 1()$ .+-&"%0$ (% '!-13 5 !"*$ 8,-''$% &(8% "1 8$66 "1 5 0"% -%
8(,&13
!"#$%
&'() *+, (-. ./0.-1.23124 15 6,. )+ )'. 12).251)* +7 *+,- 0-(3)13.8
$7 *+, 3+,96 6:.99 12 )'15 5)(). (99 )'. )1;.< )'() 15 +2. 7+-; +7
=(;(6'18 $7 *+, 3(2 7+-;(91>. *+,- ;.61)()1+2 (26 51) 12
?(6;(5(2( 7+- (@+,) AB ;12,).5 12 )'. ;+-2124< *+, 5'+,96 @.
(@9. )+ 4.2.-(). 1) () :1998
C+5) 0-+@(@9* )'15 :199 615(00.(- +D.- )1;.8 $) 15 )'. 712(9 5)(). 7+-
5+;. )*0.5 +7 *+415< 5,3' (5 E-15'2(;,-)1< .)38 &'* 6+2F) *+, 4+
:1)' 1) (26 5.. :'.-. 1) )(G.5 *+,H
I'15 15 2+) 39(5513 J6D(1)( )'+,4'8 $2 J6D(1)( *+, 7+3,5 ()).2)1+2
2+) +2 .D.-*)'124< @,) ()).;0) )+ 3+23.2)-(). +2 )'. 5,@K.3)< )'.
5.25. +7 $8
"+2F) 6+ )'() (5 *.) )'+,4'8 L+2)12,. )+ 4+ (5 *+, (-. 6+124 @,)
(66 () 9.(5) +2. AB ;12,). 5.551+2 51))124 7(3124 ( :(99 :1)' .*.5
39+5.6 +- '(97 +0.28 =1) (5 5+9169* (5 [email protected]
5? @
4-,7 "/'$, '!$ -%-'-"6 #$,-(& (/ (2A$0'6$11 0(%0$%',"'-(%7 "8",$%$11 -1
"+'()"'-0"66; '+,%$& 8-'!-%3 =/'$, " /$8 B,-;" 9,"%;")"17 '!$ 2(&;
-1%C' /$6' "' "663 D!$ 2(&; 0(%10-(+1%$11 /$$61 6-:$ " 0(,#1$7 "1 '!(+.!
'!$ 2(&; -1 '!$,$ 2+' '!$ "8",$%$11 -1 8-'!-%3 5 2$0()$ "8",$ (/ '!$
)(*$)$%' (/ '!(+.!'17 !(8 '!$; "##$", "%& !(8 '!$; &,(#3
E"%; '-)$1 &+,-%. 8-'%$117 '!$ '!(+.!'1 ",$ %(' '!$,$ "%& 5 ,$"0! "
1'".$ (/ 1(,' (/ *(-& (, $)#'-%$113 =' '!"' '-)$ 5 (21$,*$ "% $F#"%1-(%
!"##$%-%. "' '!$ '!-,& $;$3 G('!-%.%$11 #,$*"-617 1( '!$% '!$,$ -1 %(
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
8/39
!"#$%& '( ()%* $+%$,& &*'& -!&*.-/-$((0 12(! 3 4$$2 5)6.-/ 7.&-$((
(&'/$ &*$6$ .( '-!&*$6 7.&-$(( 7'&%*.-/ &*$ 7.&-$((.-/8 '( &*!)/*&(
',,$'6 '-5 .5$-&.4.%'&.!- (&'6&(8 &*'& '-!&*$6 7.&-$(( .( '27'9(
7'&%*.-/ 7*$&*$6 7.&-$((.-/ .( *',,$-.-/ !6 -!& '-5 "6.-/( "'%: &!
7.&-$((.-/ '/'.-0 3& .( (!6& !4 %!;,2.%'&$5 &! $+,6$(( ")& .& .(
(!;$&*.-/ 2.:$ &*'&0 3( &*.( &*$ .-/
7*$&*$6 &*$ 7.&-$((.-/ .( *',,$-.-/ !6 -!&0 3& .( (!;$&*.-/ 2.:$ &*'&0
!"#$%
&'() *+,( ,( -'./'0* 123'.(*423,256 !7'2*14889 *+'.' :,88 ;289 ,23 0;>>'2*,25
;2 *+' ,2*.;(-'0*,;2 -.;0'((6
&;1 >,5+*) 4* *+,( *,>') ,2(*'43 ;/ *.9,25 *; /;88;: ?$ @A?
,2*.;(-'0*,;2) B1(* *.9 *; :,*2'(( *+' :,*2'((6 C4*0+ *+' :4*0+'.6D
E4B,7%
3 7'-&$5 &! &$22 9!) '2(! &*'& 9$(&$65'9 3 7'( .- &*$ $69&*.-/8 '-.;'&$
!6 .-'-.;'&$ '6!)-5 ;$0 ?!) ('.5 .& .( ' 4!6; !4 C';'5*.8 ,6$>.!)( &!
9!) ;9 D6.9' E)6) *'5 &$6;$5 .& '( C'6>.:'2,' C';'5*.0 @)& &*$($
'/'.- '6$ %!-%$,&(8 ")& #)(& %)6.!)( 7*'& :.-5 !4 C';'5*. 9!) 7!)25
5$4.-$ &*.( '( (*$$6 %)6.!(.&90
!"#$%
C+4* 9;1 0488 *+' 58,>-(' ,( *+' 4-8'*'89 4:4.' :,*+;1* *+' 0+4**'.,25 >,23
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
9/39
!"#$% "$%&%"'( )*+ #$ +," %-#./0" 12* &3" $2+ &4&3" +,&+ &-- +,&+
2*+ +,"3" #$ +," 423-' #0 2$-1 12*3 .#$' 53"&+#2$ &$' #0 $2+ 3"&-(
6 ,&7" $2 $&."0 823 +," 7&3#2*0 9&.&',#0( :0 12* 0&1; +,"1 &3" /"3#"$5" 28 +," 7&3#2*0
9&.&',#0 #0 $2+ #./23+&$+( 6$ 8&5+; $2+,#$% #0 #./23+&$+; ">5"/+; +2
."; +2 -#7" &0 & ?#$' &$'
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
10/39
!"#$%&'() *+$ , &- .%/0%$&1% 12 3#24 15+/) , 6+#. 15% 278%91/
7%&"1+6"': 7'+//6"' . /2 92##%91%. 4+15 15%-: , -% &'' 0%20'%
&$2"#.: 15% 9&$/: 15% +-&'/: 15% -2"#1&+#/ . 15% ;&''%2 ?(12*;
'2*.'-23.*(..8
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
11/39
!"# $%#%#&& '& %() *#+,- .(/ +*# 0#*#,1 (2*3'%4 )"# )()+,')1 (5
6(%&7'(/&%#&&- 8/) 9"( (2*3#&: !;
?*'(* )( 7(%&7'(/&%#&&-
@ "+3# "'4" "(?#& 5(* 1(/* #3#%)/+, /%=#*&)+%='%4- A'= @ %= 1(/
)"# B'&+*4+=+))+ C')+: @) '& + 2#))#* 2((D 5(* 1(/ )( *#+= *'4")
%(9- E*'(* )( 7(%&7'(/&%#&& 7(3#*& 0+%1 ?('%)&> 9"',# )"# C')+ '&
&?#7'5'7 )( 9"#*# 1(/ +*#-
!"#$%&
'()* +,-.+/,0.-*.. ,1 *234/-*.. /. 56., -,4 2*7 898: ;,< 4)/. /.
.,2* 1*56/=54/,-: >, ?,0 2*5- 4)* $ ,1 4)* .0@A*+4 /. .4/66 ,-6? 5-
,@A*+4B ()* ,-*
?"#%(0#%+,> /%*#+,- 6(%&7'(/&%#&& '& )#0?(*+*1> /%*#+,- $%,1)"+) 9"'7" '& 2#1(%= +9+*#%#&& '& %() )(/7"#= 21 7"+%4# +%=
0(*)+,')1> +%= )"+) 7+% %#3#* 2# D%(9%> 1(/ 7+% (%,1 2# )"+)-
.(/* 2#+/)'5/, 9(*,= 9',, ='&+??#+* 9"#% 1(/* 2(=1 ='#&> 2/) 1(/>
+& )"# (2*3#*> )"# /%2(*%> 9',, %#3#* 2# )(/7"#=-
.(/ +*# 2,#&= %(9 21 6(%&7'(/&%#&&- J"# '& *#3#+,'%4 +,,- !"#
C')+ &"(/,= )+D# 1(/ +,, )"# 9+1- F%K(1 )"# ,(3# (5 6(%&7'(/&%#&&
9"',# ') ,+&)&-
!"#$% &
I/1 J,0 .5? KL-A,? 4)* 6,F* ,G M,-.+/,0.-*..
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
12/39
!"#$ %&'( ) *+ ,-./0 +&$! &1 !"2 !#+2 /&3(((#/ !"#$ $!*!2(((4&3 !"2
567#+8$25 "*$ 92:&+2 5+25 */, !"2 !"&.6"!$ #,2/!#1#:*!#&/ #$ 1&- ; !& .8> ,&3/> #/$#,2 */,
&.!$#,2 &1 +2 /&3( ) 9&3 #/ C.+972/2$$ !& '&. $#-( @&. $*' 5A"#$ #$ /&!
-2*7 !&&5 */, $& ) -2+#/, +'$271 !& 3*!:" &.! 1&- !"#$> /&! !& *!!2+8!
"&7,#/6 &/ &- *!!*:"#/6 D2 !& #!( )! #$ /&! 5D25 E#/!2772:!.*77' $& 1*-F> $&
) 3*-/ +'$271> /2=2- +#/, #1 #! 6&2$> ,#, ) 2=2/ ,2$2-=2 !"#$ #/ !"2 1#-$!
87*:2( )! +*' :&+2> #! +*' 6&G /2=2- +#/,> ) 3#77 0228 &9$2-=#/6( H
$*#/! !&7, +2> 5I/%&' !"2 7&=2 &1 :&/$:#&.$/2$$ *$ 7&/6 *$ #! 7*$!$(5 J&
92 #!(
?2! !"2 K#!* 72*, 3"2-2 #! "*$ !& 72*, +2(
!"#$%
&'!($)!*+ (,''!(-
LHM)NO
J#- *1!2- !"2 #/#!#*7 )P!"&.6"! &- -*!"2- 3#!/2$$#/6 &1 !"&.6"! #$ &=2-> *
$!-2*+ &1 :&/$:#&.$/2$$ #$ +*#/!*#/2, 1&- $&+2!#+2 !#77 * 123 !"&.6"!$
,#$!.-9 #! !&&( A"#$ !"2 ,*-0 =, &- 2+8!#/2$$ 32 :*77 :&/$:#&.$/2$$
3"#:" ) "*, 2*-7#2- !2-+2, 5+2>Q ) $22 ) 3*$ #,2/!#1'#/6 3#!" !"#$
2*-7#2- !*0#/6 !"*! !& 92 !"2 $.9%2:! */, !"&.6"!$ !& 92 !"2 &9%2:!(
R.! :72*-7' /&3 ) :*/ $22 !"*! !"2 5:&/$:#&.$/2$$5 #!$271 #$ !"2 &9%2:!(
!"#$%
-./0 /0 1 2345 /678491:9 /:0/;.9 /0 /9 :89< (8:0=/8>0:300 /0 :89 58>?
-.3 @8/A /0 :89 58>?
LHM)NO
S.-#/6 !"2 :&.-$2 *$ ) 3*$ 3#!/2$$#/6 !"2 5:&/$:#&.$/2$$5 #!$271 +*/'
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
13/39
!"#$% &$' &()*!"+, !)!*((- "..$($/*+! !0)1,0!% ')1(2 *33$*. *+2 !.-
2"%!1.4 !0$ %!*!$5 6%3$7"*((- '0$+ 8 %$$ )+(- !0$ 97)+%7")1%+$%%9 "!
,)$% 9:0 8 %$$ "!9; * !0)1,0! 5- ?1$%!")+ %". "%@
AB C0*! 2) 8 2) '"!0 !0$ !0)1,0!%; '0"70 %3.*+, )+ !0$". )'+D 8 7*+
'"!+$%% !0$ %!*.! )& !0$# *+2 !0$+ !0$- 2) 2"%*33$*. 41! !0$- *33$*.
*,*"+ 2"%!1.4"+, !0$ '"!+$%%"+, )& !0$ )4=$7! 97)+%7")1%+$%%5E >*+-
!"#$% 8 7*+ #*"+!*"+ '"!+$%%"+, 4)!0 !0$ 97)+%7")1%+$%%9 *+2 !0)1,0!
*! !0$ %*#$ !"#$5 C"(( !0$%$ #$*+"+,($%% !0)1,0!% 7)#3($!$(-
2"%*33$*. ). +)D
!"#$ %
"&'() *&++, -.&/) )01 )0&/20)34 501, '& 6&'21+ 0-71 -', 8&*1+
&71+ ,&/4 #/3) 9&:/3 &' )01 31'31 &9 ;$ ? @9 ,&/ :-' 6&:-)1 )0-)>
&)01+*@31 9&:/3 &' )01 :&')-@'1+ &9 :&'3:@&/3'133> )01 A&@B '-)/+1
@')1+81'1)+-)@'2 -66 801'&C1'-4
F:G8H@
I- 4$"+, $J!.$#$(- *!!$+!"/$ !) !0$ &"$(2 )& 7)+%7")1%+$%%; !0$
!0)1,0!% 2) &*2$ *'*- 41! !0$- %)#$!"#$% *33$*. *,*"+; $%3$7"*((-
'0$+ 8 90*/$ "!9 C"(( !0$%$ #$*+"+,($%% !0)1,0!% 7)#3($!$(- 2"%*33$*.
$/$.D
!"#$ %
501 )0&/20)3 '& 6&'21+ 0-71 8&*1+4 $2'&+1 )01C4 501, *@66 -6*-,3
.1 )01+1 +-'B&C6, -3 6&'2 -3 ,&/ 0-71 - .+-@' -'B .&B,4 501 .+-@'
@3 3&+) &9 6@D1 - +-B@& +1:1@71+> 8@:D@'2 )0&/20)3 &/) &9 )01 7&@B4
F:G8H@
K0$ !0"+, *4)1! '"!+$%%"+, "% !0*! "! 3$./*2$% +).#*( '*L"+, %!*,$
!)); #$*+"+, 21."+, )&&"7$ ').L *+2 #- '*(L% $%3$7"*((- '0$+ 8 *#
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
14/39
!"# $!%&"''$( )*#+ )"&,- . '$$ #+$ )*#!$'' "/ #+$ '#&$01 "/
2"!'2*"3'!$'' 0!( #+$ #+"3%+#' )+*2+ 044$0& 0!( (*'044$0&5 6+$
)*#!$'' "& '378$2# 20! )*#!$'' 7"#+ 0# #+$ '01$ #*1$- #+"3%+ #+$
#+"3%+# *' 4")$&9$''- *' !" 1"&$ 9"3(- *# *' 1*9(- 70&$9: &$2"%!*;079$
1"'# "/ #+$ #*1$- 73# *# '#*99 $ 20!?#
7$ #&02$(5 6+$ 1"1$!# . 20! 9"20#$ #+$ )*#!$''- *# )*99 2$0'$ #" 7$
#+$ '378$2#- *# )*99 7$2"1$ 0!"#+$& "78$2#5 A"1$#*1$' . /$$9 +$ *' 0#
#+$ B&( $:$ )*#!$''*!% #+$ 0)0&$!$'' "& 2"!'2*"3'!$'' 0!( '"1$#*1$'
. /$$9 +$ *' 0# #+$ +$0 C"3 '0*( D)0#2+ #+$ )0#2+$&-D 73# . 20!?# /*!(
+*1 0!:)+$&$5
!"#$%
&' ()*+,- .)* (/012 3/2(4 24- 3/2(4-+5 ,) 34/2 ()0(6*,7)0 (/0 .)*
8+/39
:4- );,-+ ?)* /+-
;-.)08 -=7,2-0(- -027+-6.@ ?)* /+- 0)2 A/+2 )' 24- B/07'-,2 3)+68
?)* /+- 0)2 ')*08 372470 ()0,(7)*,0-,,@ :47, 3)+68 4/, 0)2470C 2)
8) 3724 .)*@
EFG.H I . &$0( 0 /$) '#0!;0' J #" K "/ #+$ L*#0 -. %$# *# 73# . )*99 1"M$
M$&:- M$&: '9")9: )*#+ *#- 4$&+04' N #" = '#0!;0' 0 (0:5
!"#$%
:47, 7, A-+'-(2@ ?)* /+- 0)3 /0,3-+70C 24- C+-/2-,2 D*-,27)0,
A),-8 ;. /66 ;-70C, 24+)*C4 27B-@ E)0,(7)*,0-,,FFFG)8FFF7, +-
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
15/39
!"#$%&
'()* +,-.* $ .(/ ( 0+,102 23425,2+62 7(+* *8 9+87 ,: ;+-8 ,1%/$6$#4 710* 6$#- )+)$"/ 0* 5:$0"."$**5 +# (N
CD
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
19/39
!"#$%
&'( )*+, -'., /*0 1*23+4 *56 +,07 0*836974 :)3-) .,*5; 7'( )*+,
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
20/39
!" #$% &'( )$*+) ,$ -( & ,(&./('0 #$% +((1 ,$ (23'(44 #$%'4(5"
.5(&'5# "$' $,/('4 ,$ (&4*5# %+1('4,&+16 !, *4 &54$ +(.(44&'# ,$
.%5,*7&,( ,/*4 &,,(+,*7(+(44 -(.&%4( *, *4 (&4*(' *+ ,/*4 8 ,$
-(.$9( &8&'( $" /*11(+ .$+.(3,4 '(9&*+*+) *+ #$%'
%+1('4,&+1*+)6 :$% +((1 ,$ -(.$9( 3'(.*4( *+ (23'(44*$+ &+1
1(.$+4,'%.,*+) 8/&, $,/('4 4 ,$ #$%6
!"#$%&
'()*+ ), -(.//,0 1)2,+33),4 2(+ 56)- /(+/- 67 8+ $ 368+2)8+3 3++ /
-62 67 *)4(20 1()9( 6, 96,9+,2:/2),4 -)3/;;+/:3< =(+, 368+ :+56*5),4
9):9*+ 67 *)4(2 1()9( +>;/,-3 368+2)8+3 6: 7+1 7*/3(+3 67 ?:)4(2
+>;/,-),4 *)4(2< @6,+ 67 2(+3+ /:+ ), /,. ;/:2)9A*/: 6:-+:3-%6%-: *-(''%5 #) 6(-#31, ,'%.*(.1$(- 5#,'$(/, #) *+%#- #2(A#)($
,'(.%,8 G()/ O155+#,* *-(5#*#3), ,'%)5 %)*#-%$/ *33 21.+ *#2%
%&'$3-#)A 6(-#31, ,3-*, 3> P3#5,8
D+% ,(2% #, *-1% 3> *+% D+#-5 Q/%8 G/ R%/%S "(, 3'%)%5 "#*+#)
23)*+, 3> ,*(-*#)A '-(.*#.% 0%.(1,% #* ,%%2%5 )(*1-($ >3- 2% *3 53
,38 !* ,%%2%5 (, #> *+(* *(,7 "(, ,%* 0%>3-% 2% (, ( )(*1-($
1)>3$5#)A8 D+% D+#-5 Q/% =1,* A-(51($$/ 3'%)%5 3> #*,%$> 51-#)A
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
22/39
!"#$"%$ &$'!#(#!)" ("' *+(',(--. $/0("'$' #) +$1$(- #2$ 3)!'
"(#,+$ )4 5)"%5!),%"$%%6 7,# .), (-+$('. 8")9 #2(#: %) #2$+$ !% ")
"$$' #) 0$"$#+(#$ (".#2!"*6 7,# .), &(. 9("# #) ') %) %!&0-. #)
%$$ 4)+ .),+%$-4 #) 5)&0-$#$ .),+ %52))-!"*6
;2$+$ (+$ '$$0$+ &.%#$+!$% .), "$$' #) ,"4)-' .$#: ("' < 9!-- 2$-0
.), #2+),*2 #2$& 92$" #2$ #!&$ !% 5)&$6 7,# #2$ ;2!+' =.$ !% (
>$*!""$+?% '!%5)1$+.6 @), (+$ 9(. >$.)"' #2(#6
!"#$% &
'()*+,+-. )/+ 01/ 2314 1-)5/6 *789 :+678187)/ 1/6 0)/0+/8-187)/
;)-+,+-. 8-122+6 7/ ,1-7)5<
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
23/39
!"#"$%&"! '%%! ()%*+, %- )"+,($ -%.*/ (+! .%+."+,0(,1%+2 3%4"#"0
/*.5 %+"/ 6789: 5(#" ( .$*" 45(, ,5"; !% 41,5 /*.5 &%4"02 :5";
4%*$! '", ($$ , >*, ,5"/" 4"0" 1+#(01(>$;
.%*&$"! 41,5 ( !"/10" ,% ?@ABC3 7D:? -%0 )%0" (+! )%0" (+! )%0"2 E+
/5%0, ,5"; 4"0" ($4(;/ .5(/1+' (+! 4%*$! '", "(/1$; -0*/,0(,"! (+!
(+'0;2 :5" "+"0'; ,5"; (..*)*$(,"!F 1+ ); %&1+1%+F 4(/ 4(/,"! %+
#(01%*/ ")%,1%+/2 :5"; .%*$! /,%& ,5%*'5,/ ,50%*'5 /5""0 41$$ >*,
+"#"0 ($$%4"! ,5" ?G"1+'+"//? %0 EHBI8AJJ 7@ C78JCE7DJ8AJJ ,%
)(%*,2 E+ ); %&1+1%+ ,5";
5(! ,5" &%4"0 %- (4(0"+"// >*, ,5"; 4"0" $%/, 5%4 ,% */" ,5") ,%
"=&$%0" 41,51+2 :5"; ,%% 0")(1+"! M01;( O%'1/ >*, 1+ )"//1"0 .%+!1,1%+
>".(*/" %- ($$ ,5" .%+!1,1%+1+'/F >"$1"-/F 5(>1,/F )")%01"/ (//%.1(,"!
41,5 ,5" 4%0! ?M01;(2P
B /,(+!(0! 0"&$; '1#"+ ,% )%/, %- ,5") -(.1+' &0%>$") 4%*$! >"
"1,5"0 ?E+.0"(/" ;%*0 M01;( +*)>"0/? %0 ?1+.0"(/" ;%*0 !"#%,1%+ ,% ,5"
&5;/1.($ N*0*F 5" 41$$ /"" ;%* ,50%*'5? E ($4(;/ -(1$"! ,% *+!"0/,(+!
5%4 ,5"; .%*$! (.,*($$; 5"$& %+" ,% !"($ 41,5 %+"/ ")%,1%+/2A)%,1%+/ &$(; ( >1' &(0, 1+ !(1$; J(!5(+(2 I%/, 4"0" "1,5"0
*+.%+/.1%*/$; 1!"+,1-;1+' 41,5 ,5") %0 0*++1+' (4(; -0%) ,5")2
7+$; /"$- "+Q*10; .(+ 5"$& %+" ,% !"($ 41,5 ,5" (.,*($1,; %- ,5"
/1,*(,1%+ E -""$ /102 :% 0"(.5 ,% ?G"1+'+"//? %+" )*/, (, $"(/, ($$%4 1,
,% -$%4"0 %+ 1,/ %4+2 R1,5%*, */" %- )*.5 "--%0, F41,5%*, "$")"+, %-
?!%"0/51&? /102 :5" ?>"1+'+"//? 1/ ,5"0"F 1, 1/ (#(1$(>$" 1+/,(+,$; 4" S*/,
+""! ,% %>/"0#" 1+ ,5" )%)"+, 1,/"$-2 E *+.%+/.1%*/$; /,*)>$"! %+
,51/F E +"#"0 0"(! (+; B!#(1,1. /,*-- >*, %+ ); %4+2 E 4(/ '*1!"! ,%
*+!"0/,(+! I%,5"0 (+! J5" 5(/ >$"//"! )" 41,5 3"0 $%#" (+! ($/% 5"0
-$*.,*(,1+' -%0)2 8%4 45"+ E 0"(! -"4 ,51+'/ E /(;F TB3U :51/ 1/ 45(,
1, 4(/2P O7D 4"0" ,5" )1//1+' $1+< -%0 )" ,% .%)" 1+ ,"0)/ %- );
*+!"0/,(+!1+'F ,5" &0"/"+, /1,*(,1%+ ,5(, E () 1+2 E 4(/ /% $%/, 41,5%*,
O%* /10 (+! $*.
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
24/39
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
25/39
!"#$%& '"()'*"+)(%)) ,-%))*(.) &%/0*(%1 %2%& )*('%3 4 1*1 &%01
)"/%#$*(. 2%&5 )*/*-0& "''+&&%1 6*#$ 5"+ #""3 789%&*%('%) '"+-1 ,%
:-%%#*(.; '$0(.%0,-% 0) #$%5 #0# ,%-*%2% *# *) ?+)# 0 /"(#$ 4
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
26/39
!"# $%&%#$ '( )*+$$ &,- "&..+,#$$ /'0 &1# #2.#1+#,3+,4 &1# 5&,%#-
)/ ',# &,- &**6 7'8# 4010$ ,#9#1 "&9# 4',# .&$% %"+$ $%&%# '( 0,+%/
5+%" 3',$3+'0$,#$$6 !"#/ )#3'8# %1&..#- +, +% &,- %1&. %"#+1
('**'5#1$6 :, & 5'1$# )&4 &1# %"'$# 5"' $&/ ,' #(('1% +$ 1#;0+1#-< &$
$'8#"'5 %"&% 8#$$&4# &*',# +$ $0..'$#- %' *#&- %' *+)#1&%+',6
='0 ,##- %' )#3'8# ,'%"+,4 &,- 4' )#/',- 3',$3+'0$,#$$6 !' -'
$' /'0 ,##- %' )#3'8# %'%&**/ $%0.+-< >,'5+,4 ,'%"+,46 !"+$ +$ .&1%
'( %"# .&$$&4#6
!"#$%&
'() *+, -)(./ 0*+, 1//2 .+ 3/4+5/ 1+.6(17 812 7+ 3/9+12
4+1:4(+,:1/::; >9 :.,?(2= @1+-(17
1+.6(17; >/4.,8>>9 (. ?)+383>9 5/81: /5?.9(17 +A /B/)9.6(17 +1/ 68: /B/)
@1+-1= 2)+??(17 +A 8>> .68. -6(46 68: 3//1 /C?/)(/14/2= 8>> 4+14/?.:
812 :9:./5:;;;>9 )/846 .6/)/ (: 8>> .+7/.6/) 8 2(AA/)/1. 38>>
785/; $ 3/>(/B/ (. -(>> .++ 68??/1 +1 (.: +-1 8A./) $ 68B/ 6/>2 +1 .+
.6/ $D"51/: A+) 8 A8()>9 >+17 .(5/; E68. 8 :.8./ .68. -+,>2 3/; $
-+12/) '(); F//2 9+,) G>/::(17;
?@A:B
='0 5+** $## 5"&% +% +$ *+>#6 :% +$ 8'1# %"&, *#%%+,4 4' '( 3',3#.%$< +%
+$ *+># -#&%"6 C'$% -',D% *+># +% &% (+1$% )#3&0$# +% (##*$ *+># -#&%"8,8,22 3,71*82 -*B, C,+93,; D,1EF *8.9G*61.*98 3,71*82 :*./ H?
,++,6.2 9+ 9C),6.2 792. 9+ ./, (1F2; I/, 9C),6.2 2,,7 6-92,3 .9 7,
./18 @2@1-; I/9@A/.2J,79.*982 13, @83,1- 89:; $ +*8( *. K/13(K .9
*(,8.*+F :*./ ./,7 C@. * 17 -,138*8A .9 K16.K *8 +398. 9+ 9./,32 )@2. .9
3,71*8 K89371-;K $. *2 -*B, ./9@A/.2J,79.*982 697,L * :1.6/ 18( ./,8 *
(,6*(, /9: .9 3,16.; "-- /1MM,82 N@*6B-F C@. [email protected].*61--F; I/,
69826*9@28,22 .1B,2 613, 9+ 1-- ./1.;
$ 17 89. M316.*6*8A :1.6/*8A 93 C,*8A 1:13, 69826*9@2-FL *.2 )@2.
/1MM,8*8A 98 *.2 9:8 =*3;
O9./*8A (*2.@3C2 ./, *8.9G*61.*98 93 C-*22+@- 1:13,8,22L $ 17 :1.6/*8A
1 8,: 79E*, 2/9: ,16/ (1F; &PQ
$ 3,1--F :98(,3 718F .*7,2 :/1. ./, /,-- 792. M,9M-, 13, (9*8AL:12.*8A ./,*3 -*+, 9E,3 M,..F *22@,2; I/,F 13, 7*22*8A ./, 3,1- +@8; I/*2
*2 98, ./9@A/. $ 618 21F $ @2@1--F *(,8.*+F :*./ /1/1/1;;;
?@3*8A ?/F118&
$ 2*. 63922,( -,AA,( C@. (9 89./*8A; $ 2*7M-F -99B 1. ./, E9*(; "8 /9@3
18( /1-+ M122 -*B, 1 7*8@.,; I/, E9*( 2.*6B2 .9 7F +93,/,1( 2,,72
6-92,3 ./18 @2@1-;
$ 17 C,A*88*8A .9 C, 1:13, 9+ .:9 2.1.,2 (@3*8A 7F (/F118; >8, *2
:1B*8A 2.1., :/,3, $ :*.8,22 ./, E9*( *8 +398. 9+ 7, 18( 1-29 *+ 18F
./9@A/. *8.3@(,2 R./*2 *2 [email protected].*6L 89 ,++93.Q; $8 C,.:,,8 2@((,8-F $
3,1-*S, *71A,2 697*8A +397 89 :/,3,L +,: 1C2@3( 18( 7,18*8A-,22
*71A,2 18( ./9@A/.2 697, .9 +93,; $ 17 *8 (3,17 2.1.,; I/*2 *2 ./,
61-7 (3,17 2.1.,; $ 2,, *. 18( 12 $ :1.6/ *. $ 17 C16B .9 :1B*8A 2.1.,;
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
29/39
!" # $"% &'())*+$, -./%..$ 01.23 2$0 %24.)(*5 %24.)(* 2$0 01.23
&/2/.&6
!+$7. # "-&.18. /'.&. &/2/.& # 23 "-8+"(&*9 $"/ /'. 8"+05 $"/ /'.
%24.)(* &/2/. 2$0 $"/ /'. 01.23 &/2/.6 !" $"% # /19 2$0 &.. %'2/
.:27/*9 23 #; ?= 2/ /'. '.21/6 #& +/ &" ?0C+;
!"#$% &'() () *++ (++,)(-./ "-.01 231 +-)1 (. *++ 1'()/ 4*5 (1 +(11+3 '336/
7+1'-,2' 1'() () 8,.9 1'3 ,.63:)1*.6(.2 () -.+5 -8 *;;3*:*.?@/
$. 1'3 3.6 1'3:3 () -.+5 -.3 A-(69 B,1 (1 '*) C*.5 *);3
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
30/39
!"#$%&
'( )* )+ +,-+ +,. /()0 -,.-0 -10 +,. /()0 -+ +,. 2-3456(710 8,)3, $
3(1*)0.6.0 9: )* ;7*+ 9: -3+7->>? 3-11(+ 2.
41(81 (6 [email protected]).13.0 (6 ./.1 A()1+.0 (7+B $1 +,-+ *.1*. $ 0(1C+ .@)*+B
$* )+ *( 9-*+.6D
!"#$%
&'( )*+ *,- &,. )/' 0)12*3 4,, 5.67 )44'*42,* 4, 6,*6'04.)8
.*+'/(4)*+2*3-
9* ,*' 7)*+: $ ;288 ()1 1'(: 24 2( (,: )*+ 0/,4:
;7267 )/' ) ('0)/)4' ('4 ,= 0,2*4'/(%
?7' @,2+ '>2(4( 2* 5'*4)8 (0)6' )*+ 6,*4)2*( )88 ,= 6,*(62,.(*'((:
A.4 2( *,4 1,.- ?72( 2( ) 0/,0'/41 ,= 47' (.A48' A,+1: ;7267 2* 4./*
2( )8(, ) 6,*6'04-
"''0'/ 2( 47' 6).()8 A,+1: ;7267 2( ) +''0'/ @,2+B *, '>0'/2'*6'
7'/' 2( 0,((2A8'- 9*81 4,4)8 *,4 C*,;2*3-
&,. )/' A'1,*+ )88 47)4 )( 47' (.AD'64-
&,./ ,*81 C*,;8'+3' ,= 1,./ +''0'(4 '>2(4'*6' 6,5'( =/,5
);)/'*'(( ,= 47)4 ;7267 2( *,4 1,.B 2-'-: 6,*(62,.(*'((: @,2+: 47'
A,+1 )*+ 47' ;,/8+- &,. 6)* ,*81 E! 47)4 +''0'(4 ('8=-
E.4 1,. 7)
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
31/39
!"#$%&' ()%*+, -& $-. *)/#(%&' #"" (0/,/ %&,.1,(#&(%#" /&(%(%/, #&2
/3!/)%/&*/,4 50/$ #)/ .&%6/),#" /3!/)%/&*/,7 .&%6/),#" 8-)9,7 $/(
(0/$ #)/ -&"$ #!!/#)#&*/,4
:-&;( %&(/)!)/( $/( #1-.( 6-%2, #&2 #"" (0#(< =.,( >%(&/,, (0/
.&8-"2%&' -8 *-&,*%-.,&/,,4 ?-. &//2 (- '/( 1/$-&2 ()$%&' (-
.&2/),(#&2 (0/ .&8-"2%&' -8 *-&,*%-.,&/,,4
@0/& #"" %, ,#%2 #&2 2-&/7 >0/& $-. *-9!"/(/ $-.) ()#%&%&'7 $-.
#)/ #">#$, #>#)/ -8 $-.),/"8 #, (0/ ,.1=/*(7 >0%"/ (0/ >-)"2 %, $-.)
/9#(%-&4 ?-. #)/ #>#)/ -8 $-.),/"8 #, (0/ ,.1=/*(7 -&"$ 1/*#.,/
$-. #)/ ,(%"" /3!/)%/&*%&' (0/ >-)"2 #&2 1-2$ #, -1=/*(4
50/ ')/#(/,( 9$,(/)$ %, (0#( $-. #)/ &-( *-&,*%-.,&/,, #&2 (0/
>-)"27 1.( %& #&-(0/) ,/&,/ %( %, $-.7 %( /9#(/, 8)-9 $-.4 50/,/
#)/ (>- 2%88/)/&( .&2/),(#&2%&', (0#( #)/ -&"$ #!!#)/&(
*-&()#2%*(%-&,4 50/,/ ,/&(/&*/, #)/ 1-(0 ()./ #, #!!/#)#&*/,7 1.(
#( 2%88/)/&( "/6/",4
!"#$%&
'()* +,-. */-010 -2 3*2145 0647* 42. 7,214-20 455 ,8 7,207-,902*00: ;91
-0 2,1 ,6*>1< ,8 1)* 09;15* ;,. -0 1)* 749045 ;,. +,-.D 2, */6*>-*27* )*>*
-0 6,00-;5*= ?25< 1,145 2,1 @2,A-2B='
()-0 -0 ;**= F91 E-> -8 $ ., 2,1
*/6*>-*27* 42* - 742 2,1 >*7,55*71 42< */6*>-*27*G
'H,9> ,25< @2,A5*.B* ,8 .**6*01 */-01*27* -0 4A4>*2*00
,8 1)41 A)-7) -0 2,1 5.= H,9 742 ,25< ;* 1)41 .**6*01 0141*'
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
32/39
!"!# $ %& '(') *'+,)- .%/0%1 02%3'4 5-67 2870 1,,90 179' % 1,)3# 1,)3
6,/:)'+ 2, &'4 ;,2 ,< 1'%:)7)3 %)- /)-':02%)-7)3 70 +'2 2, .,&'4 $
9),= $ 02%)- %>%:2
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
33/39
!"#$!%"&$#'$$( )&* +"& ,-.' *" /'* &$'0 *" 1'%#/ #"*,%#/( 2"3 +"&
-4' /'**%#/ -!5&-%#*'0 3%*, *,' #"*,%#/#'$$ "6 *,' 7"%08 1&* -
0''9'4 #"*,%#/#'$$ :'-#$ "#;+ 0-4>-* ;'-$* 6"4 :'>>1+ $%**%#/ %#
?-0:-$-#-8 -#0 ;'**%#/ +"&4 !"#$!%"&$#'$$ ;'-.' +"&4 ,'-0 -#0 /"
0"3#3-40 %#*" +"&4 1"0+ %#*" *,' 1';;+( @"!&$ +"&4 :%#0 %# +"&4
1';;+( A''9 $;''9 %$ -#"*,'4 $%:%;-4 $*-*'(
B* $":' 9"%#*8 +"& $,"&;0 'C9'4%'#!' - D04"99%#/D "6 +"&4
!"#$!%"&$ !'#*'4 *" *,' 1';;+8 -#0 E&$* 1'6"4' %* 04"9$8 %* 3%;; 6'';
;%
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
34/39
!"#$!%"&$#'$$ (" ()' *'++,- %$ .+$" (/&' .*"&( ().( !'#('/ 0/"11%#2
(" ()' )'./(3 4( %$ 5&$( ().( ()' 6'# 7., 4 1/.!(%!'0 '81).$%9'0 ()'
*'++, /.()'/ ().# ()' )'./(3
!"#$%&
'(') *+, -./0 10/0.203 4+ 50 4-0 610.4074 708104 +9 :-.4 50.;7
?.4>+;< +1 .84,.2 @>A01.4>+;B C+74 D;+: 4-.4 >4 >7 ,;D;+:>;6
74.40 A,4 E+, -./0 0/0; 10/0.203 F+:B $ .5 7G008-2077 :>4- .:0 H>1B
(;0 :>22 7:>48- 91+5 D;+:>;6 I8+;78>+,7;077J 4+ ,;D;+:>;6 I4-1, 4-0
;./02J .;3 />80 /017. 4-1+,6- 10G0.403 7,8- 20.1;>;67 .;3
0KG01>0;807B ";3 4-0; D;+: :0 .10 A0E+;3 7,8- D;+:>;6 .;3
,;D;+:>;6 4++B L(( F"!M L( N!"HO *PLB
:;!(&.++,- ?#"7%#2 ()' !.&$.+ *"0, 7%++ ).11'# "# %($ "7# .$ ()'
8'#(.+ '@1'/%'#!'$ ./' $''# ()/"&2)3 A)' *'++, ('!)#%B&' 5&$(
2%C'$ ,"& . 8'()"0 (" '/$(.#0 #"()%#2#'$$ *'(('/ .#0 8"/'
B&%!?+,3 4( %$ #"( '$$'#(%.+3
!"#$%&
$ >;4022084,.22E D;+: 4->7 ;+: E04 $ :>22 :.;4 4+ 10.8- 4->7 +; 5E +:;B
*+, .10 QRRS 1>6-4 C.7401 4-.4 $ .5 -./>;6 2+4 +9 9,; :>4-
T+;78>+,7;077 .;3 74>22 >30;4>9E :>4- F01B $ 7-.22 8+;4>;,0 4+ 105.>; >;
4-.4 $="C;077B $ 7-.22 F+23 -01 4>6-4 4+ 50 .7 C.-.1.U 7.E7 >; N>4. .;3
204 F01 .2+;0 20.3 50 4-010 :-0;0/01 4-0 4>50 8+507B
$ 7-.22 :1>40 .7 $ 604 7+504->;6 ;0: 4+ 4022B
$ .5 5+74 9+14,;.40 .;3 A207703 4+ D;+: E+, H>1B
!"#$%&
H+ . H.3-.D. ;+: :.48-07 4-0 .1>7>;6 .;3 9.22 +9 .22 4-070 V 74.407 >;
->57029B ";3 4-,7 D;+:7 ;+: 4-.4 F0 >7 A0E+;3 4-05B $7 4->7 8+11084
8+;80G4>+;WW
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
35/39
!"#$%
&'( )*+ ,-. ) ./0,12 34. 5-6+ 7./0,189+55 ./0,1: 05 ./+*+; $. 05 ./+
543-+5 ,-. +?05. 90@+ ./+ 4,0A+*5+ +?05.5;
B/+ =-,=+C.5 -D +?05.+,=+ ),> ,-,8+?05.+,=+ )CC9E .- ./+ A05039+2
./+ -35+*A)39+; F4. &'(2 ./+ -35+*A+*2 ./+ 543 )99
G4)90.0+5 90@+ +?05.+,=+ ),> ,-,8+?05.+,=+;
"-,H. .*E .- D014*+ ./05 -,+ -4.; &-4 I099 4,>+*5.),> I/+, ./+ .06+
05 *+)>E;
!"#$%&
"'' ()*+ ',-./*/0 1.23 425 6*. *+ 7*11*85'( (2 8239.,),/7 12. 3, ,:,/
*/(,'',8(5-''4; $ -3 -
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
36/39
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
37/39
!"#$%
! "# $%&'( '%)*&'(+ ,*-' .%/ "0- 10-- .%/ 2"' &$-')&1. 3&)*
"'.)*&'( .%/ 3"')4 3*-)*-0 &) 5- )*- 5%$.4 )*- -(%4
6%'72&%/7'-774 )*- 3%08$4 )*- 9%&$ %0 )*- :57%8/)-+ ;*&7 &7 " (&1)+
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
38/39
!"#$%" &'()*$ +,!"-)./
Email: [email protected]
Website: http://itisnotreal.com
Blog: http://itisnotreal.blogspot.com
8/6/2019 Self-Knowledge and Liberation Dialogues
39/39
Rajiv Kapur