View
3.757
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
A Complete Guide to Development of Winning Government Business
Citation preview
RFP & Proposal Primer
V5.0
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Contents1. Purpose
2. The RFP
a) Why and how
b) Process
c) Components
3. The Proposal
a) Phases
b) Typical Volumes
c) Proposal Development
d) Color Teams
e) Storyboarding
4. Nuts and Bolts
a) Things to consider
b) Source Selection
c) Scoring
d) Evaluation
e) Technical & Management Approach
f) Discriminators
g) Past Performance
h) Risk Management
i) Features & Benefits
j) Action Captions
k) Factoids
l) Things you can do
Aspiration Software Proprietary
PurposeGovernment
Requirements
1. Understand the RFP process
Aspiration Response
2. Understand typical proposal processes
Aspiration Software Proprietary
RFP – Why and How (Gov’t & Aspiration)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Problem or NeedProblem or Need
BudgetBudget
State the Problem:RFP
State the Problem:RFP
Announce it:CBD
Announce it:CBD
Discuss it:DRFP
ConferencesIndustry Day
Discuss it:DRFP
ConferencesIndustry Day
Gather information:RFQRFI
Capability Statements
Gather information:RFQRFI
Capability Statements
Response:Proposal
OralsDemo
Response:Proposal
OralsDemo
Evaluate Response:SSA/SSET
Evaluate Response:SSA/SSET
Negotiate:BAFOs
Negotiate:BAFOs
AwardAward
RFP Preparation Process (Government)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Section A: Solicitation/Contract form
Section B: Supplies/Services & Prices
Section C: Statement of Work information
Section D: Packing and Marking
Section E: Inspection and acceptance
Section F: Deliveries or performance
Section G: Contract administration data
Section H: Special contract requirements
Section I: Contract clauses
Section J: Contract Data Req. Lists (CDRLs)
Section K: Reps, Certs, Other Statements
Section L: Proposal preparation instructions
Section M: Evaluation criteria
Section A: Solicitation/Contract form
Section B: Supplies/Services & Prices
Section C: Statement of Work information
Section D: Packing and Marking
Section E: Inspection and acceptance
Section F: Deliveries or performance
Section G: Contract administration data
Section H: Special contract requirements
Section I: Contract clauses
Section J: Contract Data Req. Lists (CDRLs)
Section K: Reps, Certs, Other Statements
Section L: Proposal preparation instructions
Section M: Evaluation criteria
ProblemProblem NeedNeed
RequirementsRequirements BudgetBudget
SOW - Sec. CSOW - Sec. C SOW - Sec. CSOW - Sec. C
CDRL - Sec. JCDRL - Sec. J
Purchase RequestPurchase Request
ProcurementProcurement
Sections L & MSections L & M
Prepare & Issue RFPPrepare & Issue RFP
Technical Personnel
PCO
Sample RFP(Hardcopy)
CommonRFP
Components
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Attachments:A. H/WB. S/WC. QualityD. PBSC
Attachments:A. H/WB. S/WC. QualityD. PBSC
Attachments:A. H/WB. S/WC. QualityD. PBSC
Attachments:A. H/WB. S/WC. QualityD. PBSC
RFPRFP
Attachments:A. H/WB. S/WC. QualityD. PBSC
Attachments:A. H/WB. S/WC. QualityD. PBSC
CDRLsContract Data Requirements List
CDRLsContract Data Requirements List
Instructions to Offerors(Section L)
Instructions to Offerors(Section L)
Evaluation Criteria
(Section M)
Evaluation Criteria
(Section M)
StatementOf
Work(Section C)
StatementOf
Work(Section C)
Deliveries or Performance(Section F)
Deliveries or Performance(Section F)
SpecialContract
Req’s(Section H)
SpecialContract
Req’s(Section H)
Sample CDRLs
Major RFP/Proposal Activities (Gov’t & Aspiration)
1. Draft RFP
2. Revise RFP
3. Release RFP
4. Questions
5. Submit proposal (“Bid to win……)
6. Orals
7. BAFO
8. Contract award (…manage to recover”)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Major Phases (Aspiration)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
PhaseUpper ManagementBusiness DevelopmentProgram & Tech. MgmtCapture ManagerProposal ManagerVolume LeadersWriters/Estimators
Long-TermPositioning Opportunity
AssessmentCore TeamPreparation Pre-RFP
Teamwork ProposalDevel.
PostSubmittalActivity
1. Long-Term Positioning: Putting us in a favored position - ID customers whose needs match our goals
2. Opportunity Assessment: Gathering and analyzing market information about who, what, how much - white papers
3. Core Team Preparation: Gathering program information, proposal outline, WBS, ID prop team, schedule
4. Pre-RFP Teamwork: Draft RFP response, mockup of proposal, strawman text, pink team
5. Proposal Development: Pre proposal conference, strategy, schedule, compliance, WBS, cost data, red team
6. Post Submittal: Errors, Omissions, Clarifications (EOC)s, BAFO, orals, debrief
Strategic Tactical
Positioning & Assessment (Aspiration)
1. Understand customer needsa) Strategic plans
b) Customer plans
c) Vision
d) Goals
2. Determine fit
3. Build customer relationships
4. Shape customer requirements
5. Build strategy
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Strategic Strategic
Team preparation (Aspiration)
1. Form and train team
2. Develop capture plan
3. Develop competitive solution
4. Initiate teaming
5. Identify win strategy
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Strategic Strategic
Pre-RFP (Aspiration)
1. Analyze draft RFP
2. Assess solutions against RFP
3. Complete teaming
4. Develop executive summary
5. Get past performance started
6. Gather resumes
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Strategic Strategic
Sample Resume Matrix
Proposal Development (Aspiration)
1. Review final RFP
2. Finalize compliance matrix
3. Draft questions for clarifications
4. Storyboard production
5. Write draft volumes
6. Reviews
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Tactical Tactical
Sample Compliance Matrix
Post Submittal (Aspiration)
1. Respond to Clarification Requests (CRs)
2. Respond to Evaluation Notices (ENs),
3. Orals
4. BAFOs
5. Debrief
6. Lessons learned
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Tactical Tactical
Typical Proposal Volumes
Executive Summary - An Overview of the team & subcontractor arrangements. Summary of how SOW requirements will be met.
Prepared by Capture Manager and senior management
Management - Description of management approach, addressing performance, management, cost/schedule control, resources, subcontracting, and security.
Program Management and proposal experience. Knowledge of program and understanding of technical approach
Technical - Discussion on how the offeror plans to satisfy the requirements in the SOW.
Appropriate technical and proposal experience. In-depth knowledge of client environment and requirements.
Resume - Resumes of key technical and management personnel expected to provide significant contributions to the effort. Identifying relevant education and work experience, related to the RFP.
Experience in the development of resumes for proposals. Ability to develop compliant templates from RFP and coordination with all proposed staff
Past Performance Information - To determine technical and management acceptability, contractor provided evidence of similar scope to the RFP SOW
Experience with past performance development for proposals. Understanding of firm capabilities or where to acquire info. Ability to develop compliant templates and coordinate with PMs of other programs. Creation of Past Performance that directly demonstrates our ability to address SOW requirements
Cost Volume - Evaluated Cost and Cost Realism / Basis of Estimate. Experience in firm accounting policies and procedures. Experience in development of cost volumes for proposals. Detailed understanding of pricing methodologies and ability to coordinate timely with OST support staff
Security Volume – Pass/Fail Prepared by/ in conjunction with security staff (FSO).
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Proposal Development (Aspiration)1. Assess positioning/Gold Team
2. Proposal Outline
3. Draft executive summary
4. Identify solutions/Blue teams
5. Proposal mockup/storyboards
6. Pink team
7. Draft questions
8. Compliance matrix
9. Executive summary
10. Pricing update/Green Team
11. Visuals
12. Red team
13. Revisions
14. Second Red/’Going Gold’
15. Proposal production
16. Orals
17. Win/Lose debrief
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Sample Outline
Color Teams – Quick Glance (Aspiration)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
GOLD
Business potential
Positioning in market strategy
Capture strategy
– Competitive Analysis
– Teaming and Subcontracting
– Marketing Plan
Cost(Price and Bid Strategy
Resources
Program risks
Dependencies
Schedules/milestones/review teams
BLUE
Assesses writing plan for compliance and responsiveness
– Compliance matrix and proposal outline
Outlines/Storyboards
– Theme development and key points
– Early development of graphics for incorporation in the proposal
Blue Team Review
– Preparedness of proposal team
RED / PINK
Red Team Review evaluates using the criteria used by the client
Scoring of the proposal’s compliance
– Proposal Preparation Instructions (PPI)
– Evaluation Criteria, Specification
– Statement of Work
Scoring of the proposal’s quality
– Overall quality and persuasiveness
– Clarity of solution
– Substantiation of approach
– Overall coherence and logical flow
GREEN
Cost Proposal kickoff meeting Green Team Review
– Outline and assignments - Compliance
– CWBS structure - Credibility
– Preparation schedule - Implementation of pricing strategies
– Pricing strategy - Consistency with the rest of the proposal
- Soundness and clarity of the estimating rationale
Pink Team/1st Draft Review (Aspiration)
1. Takes place between Blue and Red Team Reviews and is typically a review of the first written draft
2. Pink Team first draft review applies primarily to all the technical, management, past performance and executive summary portions of a proposal
a) Cost Volume is not typically included as part of the Pink/1st Draft Review but included as part of the 1st Green Team Review
3. Primary emphasis is on:
a) evolution of the story
b) compliance to RFP
c) Prominence of strategies and themes
d) overall coherence
e) logical flow
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Story board/Mockup/Annotated Outline (Aspiration)
1. “Builds up” from requirements
2. Forces us to mirror RFP
3. Outline & ideas sentences
4. Graphics ideas
5. ID win themes
6. Select so what/how so?
7. Allows easy mgmt review (Pink team)
8. Makes the “writing” easy
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Sample Storyboard
Issues (Aspiration)
1. What are the customer’s worry items / hot buttons?
2. What are key program requirements?
3. What are the areas of high risk?
4. What are areas where we can’t meet requirements?
5. What issues are not directly listed in the RFP?
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Source Selection (Government)
1. Federal Acquisition Regulations
2. Source Selection Authority – SSA: Overall responsibility; makes decision
3. Source Selection Advisory Council – SSAC: Compares proposals; recommends
4. Source Selection Evaluation Board – SSEB: Evaluates proposals; forbidden by law to compare proposals; can only use information in the proposal
5. Performance Risk Analysis Group – PRAG: not always used; evaluates past performance
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Scoring (Government)
1. Submitted proposal are usually evaluated in sections, usually by teams of evaluators(so each section must stand alone in compliance)
2. Scoring methodologies
a) Numerical (1-5, 1-100, etc.)
b) Color (Blue=Exceptional, Green=Acceptable, Yellow=Marginal, Red=Unacceptable)
c) Adjectival (Pass/Fail = usually for security; Outstanding, Excellent, Good…)
3. Evaluating Cost data
a) Cost realism
b) Cost reasonableness
c) Cost completeness
d) Cost control/schedule
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Evaluation (Government)
1. Structure our response to make it easy to check off our proposal as compliant - everything is done with the evaluator in mind
2. Make it easy to evaluate
a) Use lists, tables and figures
b) Use proposal headings and structure that mirror the RFP language
c) Use simple, straight forward language
d) Don’t omit information because you think evaluators already know it
e) Make sections stand alone
f) Sell ideas using features/benefits; don’t oversell
g) Answer the RFP – don’t rewrite the requirements even if you know there’s a problem
h) Write backwards (conclusion first, supporting facts second)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Technical & Mgmt Approach (Aspiration)
1. Our solution and approach must be:a) Credible
b) Perceived as having low or acceptable risk
c) Understandable
d) Competitively priced
e) Claims are substantiated
f) Written for the Evaluators
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Discriminators (Aspiration)
1. Separates Aspiration Software from competitiona) What makes us unique
b) “Shadow” or “Ghost” differences from leading competitor If competition has limited experience (but might be low cost) show our understanding of the problem: “Mission requirements demand a cadre of experienced, well-trained analysts.”
2. Find which ones are important to the client
3. Positive or Negative – Deal with issues directlya) Positive: Weave throughout tech & cost
b) Negative: Handled as managed, mitigated risk (show mitigation process and reduced risk as a result)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Past performance (Aspiration)
1. Describes same or similar work we’ve done
2. Provides report card feedback
3. Not always objective
4. Typical Requirements:
a) Questionnaire
b) Weighted
c) Names, numbers, duration, problems
d) Security incidents
5. Site visits (Gov’t)
6. Recent increased emphasis on past performance as a more significant factor (go / no go)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Risk Management (Aspiration)
1. Identify the risks
2. Assess (low, moderate, high)
3. Categorize - technical, schedule, cost
4. Determine causes
5. Develop mitigation approach
6. Implement strategic management approach
7. Weave process throughout the proposal (“Our deployment schedule is reviewed and managed by the Risk Mitigation Board…”)
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Features & Benefits (Aspiration)
1. For every feature ask: “ So what?”a) No: “We will train our technicians”
b) Yes: “We have a continuous technician training and certification plan that ensures up-to-date skill competency”
2. For every benefit ask: “How so?”a) No: “Each technician will go to training.”
b) Yes: “We use a structured, 2-week cross training program, a monthly skills tracking assessment and 40 hours of CBT testing.”
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Action Captions (Aspiration)
1. Studies show readers generally recall (after 3 days)
a) 10% of what they read
b) 70% of what they read and see
Figure 1.2-3: Action Caption
c) Good example: The Aspiration Team maps responsively to the Government Management team on this project
d) Poor example: “Our Organization Chart”
Aspiration Software Proprietary
Proposal Factoids...
1. Require 3-12 copies, sometimes on CD, sometimes w/ hot-links
2. Trend is for more oral presentations w/ limited written data
3. Trend is for more emphasis on past performance
4. Production, quality control, etc. takes a long time - don’t wait until the end!
5. Usually defined number of pages, margins, font, etc.
6. Usually require specific number of resumes
7. Executive/Tech/Mgmt must be separate from Cost volume
8. Only cost volume can have cost data, but cost volume can also have some sales pitch
Aspiration Software Proprietary
What you can do
1. Help build the Aspiration Software reputation
2. Gather data for hot buttons, issues
3. Listen for clues, who’s who?
4. Keep notes about “Keep in minds” for competition
5. Think about what we can do as part of the future of the client - and how we can shape it
Aspiration Software Proprietary