21
Bon Secours Liver Institute of Virginia Bon Secours Medical Group Good Help to Those in Need ® QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USE Mitchell L Shiffman, MD Medical Director Liver Institute of Virginia Bon Secours Health System Richmond and Newport News, VA

QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

Bon Secours Liver Institute of Virginia Bon Secours Medical Group Good Help to Those in Need ®

QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT

READY FOR CLINICAL USE

Mitchell L Shiffman, MD

Medical Director

Liver Institute of Virginia

Bon Secours Health System

Richmond and Newport News, VA

Page 2: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

CHRONIC HBV

GOALS OF MANAGEMENT

• Define active versus inactive disease

• Initiate treatment in patients with active disease

• Monitor

Inactive disease for reactivation

Response to treatment

• Screen for HCC

Page 3: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

CHRONIC HBV – REVEAL STUDY

HBV DNA AND RISK OF HCC

<104 104-105 105-106 >106

<2 2-20 >200 20-200

CJ Chen et al.

JAMA 2006; 295:65-73.

Page 4: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

IMPACT OF DISEASE STATUS

J Jaroszewicz et al

J Hepatology 2010; 52:514-522.

Page 5: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

IMPACT OF DISEASE STATUS

J Jaroszewicz et al

J Hepatology 2010; 52:514-522.

Page 6: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

IMPACT OF DISEASE STATUS

J Jaroszewicz et al

J Hepatology 2010; 52:514-522.

Page 7: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

IMPACT OF DISEASE STATUS

J Jaroszewicz et al

J Hepatology 2010; 52:514-522.

Page 8: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

RELATIONSHIP TO HBV DNA

Cirrhosis No

Cirrhosis

MR Brunetto et al.

Gastroenterol 2010; 139:483-490.

N=209

E-Antigen (-)

Monitored for

12-110 months

Page 9: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

E-ANITGEN NEGATIVE INACTIVE HBV

NATURAL HISTORY

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

0 2 4 6 8 10 12

ALT

(IU

/ml)

Log H

BV

DN

A (

IU/m

l)

Log H

BsA

g (

IU/m

l)

YEARS

sAg

HBV DNA

ALT

M Martinet-Peignoux et al

Liver Intl 2013; 33 (supl):125-132.

Page 10: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

RELATIONSHIP TO HBV DNA

J Jaroszewicz et al

J Hepatology 2010; 52:514-522.

Page 11: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

E-ANTIGEN POSITIVE HBV

PEGINTERFERON TREATMENT

MJ Sonneveld et al.

Hepatology 2013; 58:872-880.

Loss

Week 12 sAg Titer: PEGINF

Page 12: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

E-ANTIGEN POSITIVE HBV

PEGINTERFERON TREATMENT

R Moucari et al.

Hepatology 2009; 49:1151-1157.

PEGINF PEGINF

Page 13: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

E-ANTIGEN NEGATIVE HBV

PEGINTERFERON TREATMENT

R Moucari et al.

Hepatology 2009; 49:1151-1157.

PEGINF PEGINF

Page 14: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

PEGINTERFERON

ESTIMATED USE IN THE USA

Reasons for not using PEGINF:

• Side effects

• Bad reputation from HCV

• Limited efficacy

ML Shiffman

Best estimates from several sources

Page 15: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

LONG TERM TELBIVIDINE TREATMENT

HBsAg TITER AND HBV DNA

AK Singh et al.

J Viral Hep 2014; 21:439-446.

E Ag+

E Ag -

Page 16: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

LONG TERM TELBIVUDINE TREATMENT

HBsAg TITER AND HBV DNA

K Wursthorn et al.

Hepatology 2010; 52:1611-1620.

1 log unit

decline

Page 17: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

LONG TERM NA IN CHRONIC HBV

IMPACT ON HCC

GV Papatheodoridis et al.

J Hepatol 2010; 53:348-356.

Page 18: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

HBsAg TITER

RISK OF HCC ON TREATMENT

M Kawanaka et al

Liver Cancer 2014; 3:41-514-52.

sAG: N=96

>2,000 IU/ml

sAG: N=18

<2,000 IU/ml

On NA treatment 2 Yrs

N=167

Log HBVDNA

<2.1

N=114

Log HBVDNA

>2.1

N=33

HBsAg

<2000

N=18

HBsAg

>2000

N=96

HCC

N=0

HCC

N=7

HCC

N=2

Page 19: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

qHBsAg IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USE

SUMMARY

The management of HBV

Is focused on preventing HCC

We first determine the disease state

REVEAL says measure DNA at the starting gate

But can sAg titer provide more data and be a good mate

Not really…

It simply tracks the virus and provides the same fate

Page 20: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

qHBsAg IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USE

SUMMARY

The goal of treatment is to suppress DNA

Get it zero is what I say

We can do this in almost all with a NA

But treating with PEG has a limited play

The decline in sAg at 12 weeks

Can be used to determine if PEG can cure this beast

Seroconvert E at the least

And in those without E, remove DNA from the feast

Page 21: QUANTITATIVE HBSAG IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USEchronic hbv – reveal study hbv dna and risk of hcc 106 200 cj chen et al. jama 2006;

qHBsAg IS NOT READY FOR CLINICAL USE

SUMMARY

But with that said

Most patients simply do not like PEG

It has a limited efficacy, causes side effects and is not

good for the head

Most use a NUC to put the virus to bed

And with this measuring sAg titer is just plain dead