Upload
open-government-partnership
View
234
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
1/36
independent reporting mechanism:
norwayprogress report20112013
INDEPENDENTREPORTINGMECHANISM
J n, il Lw ply iuc Wl, t e rF p r
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
2/36
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
3/36
1 11
.
1 .1 . .
.
.
. .
ExEcutivE summary ................................................................................... 3
i | Background ..................................................................................... 5
ii | ProcEss: dEvEloPmEnt of action Plan ................................ 7
iii | ProcEss: consultation during imPlEmEntation ............ 13
iv | imPlEmEntation of commitmEnts ........................................ 15
v | sElf-assEssmEnt chEcklist....................................................... 17
vi | moving forward .......................................................................... 19
vii | annEx 1: mEthodology ............................................................. 23
viii | annEx 2: imPlEmEntation of
norways commitmEnts ............................................................ 27
independent reporting mechanism:
norwayprogress report 201113
Public comment version
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
4/36
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
5/36
eXeCUtIVe sUMMary|3
exective smmar
te ope gee Pep (ogP) e e
ee e ee e ze pe
ee ee. te irm e b ee e ogP
pp e.
sepebe 2011.
OGP PROCESS
ASSESSING COMMITMENTS IN NORWAYSFIRST ACTION PLANtp irm ep ee e-b-e ogP pee.
ONGOING ACTIvITIESANd CIvIL SOCIETYPRIORITIES
p e p. see
ogP pp.
i le
i e
ebe pe
Ee p pb
The Norwegian action plan focused on areas in which Norway has had much success. But theIRM evaluation proved challenging in the Norwegian context because the Norwegian actionand measurable indicators of progress.
This report was prepared by Christopher Wilson (The Engine Room)and Joachim Nahem (International Law and Policy Institute).
indEPEndEnt rEPorting mEchanism (irm):
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
6/36
t e ee e ebe. te e ee ee
KEY RECOMMENdATIONS
Consultation
pbe ep.
Communication
-
-
-
t e ru y byk
u wk fl, u .
t il Lw ply iu(iLpi) u fu
, , ly, u l f u l .
ogp u f y,
w l . ogpi r m l l f l l f lu
kl ubly.
ELIGIbILITYREquIREMENTS: 2011
t ppe ogP, eepe ee b ee
f e , :.pepep./eb
4 out of 4
law EnactEd
4 out of 4
10 out of 10
INDEPENDENTREPORTINGMECHANISM
http://www.opengovpartnership.org/eligibilityhttp://www.opengovpartnership.org/eligibility7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
7/36
I|baCkgroUnd|5
i | Backgroundinitiative that aims to secure concrete commitments from governments to their
ogP, be pp sepebe
e e e e. a e e j,
1
2 e e pbe
3
lbee be.4
sepebe 2011. te eee pee
ee 1 J 31 deebe 2012. n
e e ogP pp .
INSTITuTIONAL CONTEXTte m fe a (mfa) pe
ogP ee.5
n pp ogP e
n ogP e, epe
e, e m fe
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
8/36
OC
6|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
mfa epbe ogP 25 J 2013,
p e p e e. teee,
6 a
n e ogP ebe.
irm eee) n
e e. fad b e
7
e ee p pe, e
e e.
METHOdOLOGICAL NOTE
ee e pbe.
a p e e e e pe
e e e ee j ee
8
2013.9
1 o bu phi, 2012, o bu Ch Liv (o bu phi, whi, dC).avill : .
2 kim f n, Fm f Ifmi ac (Uivi f ol Li, 2006). avill .3 s. djv, r. L p, F. Lz--sil, a. shlif, diclu pliici (dmuh Uivi, 2009). avill : p://b./19dEk; oeCd (oii f ecmicCi dvlm), t f Ifmi dcii M a rqui Fmll dicl Lvl f tc i Government at a Glance 2009(pi: oeCd, 2009).avill :; ric Mic, Icm a diclu wl b C li Cui (wl b, whi, dC, 2009). avill :
4 ecmi Illic Ui, dmcc Ix 2010: dmcc i r (ecmi, L, 2010). avill : 56 shl Fum, 8 M 2013; Ivi ih Fad, MFa Cso cul cul f h ci l; tm a n, si excuiv avi, Mii fgvm amiii, rfm Chuch affi, lh ivi, 4 ail 2013.
7 n, ivi, 4 ail 2013.8 gvm f n, Open Government Partnership (OGP) Government of Norway: Transparency and Inclusive (ol: gvm f n, 2011).9 gvm f n, Self Assessment Report April 2013 Norway(ol: gvm f n. 2013).
http://internationalbudget.org/wp-content/uploads/OBS2012-infographic.pnghttp://www.ub.uio.no/ujur/ulovdata/lov-20060519-016-eng.pdfhttp://bit.ly/19nDEfKhttp://bit.ly/13vGtqShttp://bit.ly/1cIokyfhttp://bit.ly/1cIokyfhttp://graphics.eiu.com/PDF/Democracy_Index_2010_web.pdfhttp://graphics.eiu.com/PDF/Democracy_Index_2010_web.pdfhttp://bit.ly/1cIokyfhttp://bit.ly/13vGtqShttp://bit.ly/19nDEfKhttp://www.ub.uio.no/ujur/ulovdata/lov-20060519-016-eng.pdfhttp://internationalbudget.org/wp-content/uploads/OBS2012-infographic.png7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
9/36
II|proCess: deVeLopMent oF aCtIon pLan|7
ii | ProcEss: dEvEloPmEnt ofaction Plandevelopment of their action plan.
OGP GuIdELINESce :
e .
-
-
e b be e.
ee pb pp e .
-
-
b ppe ze ee.
e ogP ae gee, e c
-
SuMMARY
e pe e b ebep e ogP.
a p, e p e pee.
1
o 9 m 2012 e m fe a / m
e a P.2
e e ee ze e ogP pe.
p.
u ap 2013, e ogP p
be e e,
ee eb pe (
e gee e-e e ogP
ee e e pee
p.
PROCESS, TIMELINE, ANdCOMMuNICATION
process and
timeline available (online at minimum) prior to
the consultatione ee ee e p
summary of public
(or other) consultations
e b be e.
http://bit.ly/GzFd16http://bit.ly/GzFd167/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
10/36
OC
8|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
ee ee e eb ppe
sepebe 2011 e mfa e.3 i , eee,
pe ee e ee eb e,
eee p.
epe e e.
quALITY ANd RANGE OFCONSuLTATION
e e consult widely e
4
5
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
11/36
II|proCess: deVeLopMent oF aCtIon pLan|9
12 September 2011
Abelia
p://be./e/e255.)
Akademikerne
)
DIFI
)
)
(te a ngo n, p://.ee.//E/ )
p://../e-b )
)
(ne iee o e ict se, )
)
(te fe gp o, )
p://e..)
p://e..)
(nkf, te ne a we r, )
p://../e/)
p://../e/)
p://.pe./e_e_)
http://abelia.no/english/category255.htmlhttp://www.akademikerne.no/no/om_akademikerne/english/http://www.difi.no/artikkel/2009/11/about-difihttp://www.fokuskvinner.no/en/About-FOKUShttp://www.frivillighetnorge.no/no/English/http://www.ffo.no/en-gbhttp://www.unio.no/kunder/unio/cms2011.nsf/pages/englishhttp://ikt-norge.no/http://www.jurk.no/http://kvinnegruppa-ottar.no/enhttp://en.lnu.no/http://en.lnu.no/http://kvinnesak.no/englishhttp://www.nho.no/english/http://www.nho.no/english/http://www.pasient.no/hvem_er_vihttp://www.pasient.no/hvem_er_vihttp://www.nho.no/english/http://www.nho.no/english/http://kvinnesak.no/englishhttp://en.lnu.no/http://en.lnu.no/http://kvinnegruppa-ottar.no/enhttp://www.jurk.no/http://ikt-norge.no/http://www.unio.no/kunder/unio/cms2011.nsf/pages/englishhttp://www.ffo.no/en-gbhttp://www.frivillighetnorge.no/no/English/http://www.fokuskvinner.no/en/About-FOKUShttp://www.difi.no/artikkel/2009/11/about-difihttp://www.akademikerne.no/no/om_akademikerne/english/http://abelia.no/english/category255.html7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
12/36
OC
10|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
12 September 2011, contine
(te ne Pe a, p://pee./)
(ks, )
p://.e./-e )
)
p://..)
Samisk KvinneForum
p://../e )
(s we o, )
)
()
(p://pe./)
)
(p://pbp. )
()
)
http://presse.no/http://ks.no/u/Englishhttp://www.reform.no/in-englishhttp://www.rodekors.no/http://www.safo.no/http://www.saminissonforum.org/enghttps://norggasarahkka.wordpress.com/http://www.kun.nl.no/no/om_kun/in_english/http://taxjustice.no/http://taxjustice.no/http://senterforlikestilling.org/http://publishwhatyoupay.no/https://no.wikimedia.org/wiki/Hovedsidehttp://www.ys.no/kunder/ys/cms.nsf/pages/englishhttp://www.ys.no/kunder/ys/cms.nsf/pages/englishhttps://no.wikimedia.org/wiki/Hovedsidehttp://publishwhatyoupay.no/http://senterforlikestilling.org/http://taxjustice.no/http://taxjustice.no/http://www.kun.nl.no/no/om_kun/in_english/https://norggasarahkka.wordpress.com/http://www.saminissonforum.org/enghttp://www.safo.no/http://www.rodekors.no/http://www.reform.no/in-englishhttp://ks.no/u/Englishhttp://presse.no/7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
13/36
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
14/36
OC
12|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
15/36
III|ConsULtatIon dUrIng IMpLeMentatIon|13
iii | consultation duringimPlEmEntation
ee pee e e -p e. te
ee e, e pe e, e
p e e ogP ee.
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
16/36
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
17/36
IV|IMpLeMentatIon oF CoMMItMents|15
iv | imPlEmEntation ofcommitmEnts
OGP GuIdELINES
e, e ee e e.
1. -
e b e pb ee pee
pe e .
2.
3.
4. -
5. ee
e ee, -p, e
ee ppe:
Transparency ee -
Citizen Participation-
Accountability
e pe p ee
j e , p
epb e pe epe
e.
ee ebe
e e, e e e ee
e p ze e e.
ce e e e ,
pe ee e e e e ee p.
rez e pe ee
e e e -e pe,
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
18/36
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
19/36
V|seLF-assessMent CeCkLIst|17
v | sElf-assEssmEnt chEcklist
pee e.
yen
ue
yen
yen yen
se
yen
ye
n
yen
ue
ue
yen
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
20/36
OC
18|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
21/36
VI|MoVIng Forward|19
vi | moving forwardRELEvANT NATIONAL CONTEXTFOR THE NEXT OGP ACTION PLAN
e e e
p.
e pe.1 cee
ee ee.
e pb e e e.
tee e bee e e
e.
e e be.
2
3
te ne a J
4
te ee , ee, e ee
5
Technology and Innovation
e (p://b./1291ZaJ
(
ogP p.
b
t e p ee e
e ee:
n p e e
pe-pee.6
pe pe n pb
7
STAKEHOLdER PRIORITIES
p e e p:
-
http://bit.ly/1291ZAJhttp://bit.ly/14AWWLdhttp://blogg.regjeringen.no/fiks/http://blogg.regjeringen.no/fiks/http://bit.ly/14AWWLdhttp://bit.ly/1291ZAJ7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
22/36
OC
20|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
e.
d pb ee e p
ee e e ict-
e e p:
-
e ee epbe ;
n pp e e
pee.8
e e, e bee b be
RECOMMENdATIONS
p ee e ne ogP pe.
Consultation
The Government should set a clear timeline
to prepare and participate in the deliberations.
e e ee, b ee
are not complementary
-
Stakeholder Forum participants reported that
adopted when it reached the limited number
of CSOs asked to provide comments. te
-
publicly (contrary to the recommendations in
e e pe p pp. fad
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
23/36
VI|MoVIng Forward|21
-
-
-
pe cso ee pee b
Scandinavian countries have a shared understand
. t e-
ogP eee e ne ee
m fe a (mfa); e m
e p e e b- e
ee. fad bee e e
e pe. a fad e
i fad be eee p ogP,
Communication
a ee e pe bee
c ee bee pee e ppe
pe n eee ogP. t e
fad ebe (), ebpe
e ee ict eepee.
te e e p e
e n e e.
ict ee, pee e
pee e p e ebe
http://bit.ly/GzFd16http://bit.ly/GzFd167/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
24/36
OC
22|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
1 Aftenposten
l i i xli cmmcil c qui ifmi fm uivii u. avill : p://.epe./ee/f-e-ee-6738525. ; Mlli, ol f ii f u fflihlv af, Aftenposten (ni il), 17 ail 2012. dci h h Ci f ol ciiciz hmum f ihhli ifmi cci h uili f m i iil .avill : .
2avill : p://.pe./e/peeee/20120614___e_ep_e_e_e_e
3 th ul vill .4 n pfu offlihuvl. hii, 2011. avill : 56 ev tm, sli vil ii l f , Bistandsaktuelt-
7 pulih wh yu p, eu Ui rch dl iic oil Mii tc L, 10 ail 2013. avill : -
8
http://www.aftenposten.no/meninger/For-mye-offentlighet-6738525.htmlhttp://www.aftenposten.no/oslo/Oslo-far-kritikk-for-brudd-pa-offentlighetsloven--6803306.htmlhttp://www.transparency.org/news/pressrelease/20120614_ti_norway_launches_report_the_norwegian_integrity_systemhttp://www.sivilombudsmannen.no/publikasjoner/http://www.offentlighet.no/content/download/2506/19770/file/%25C3%2585penhetsindeksen%202011%20Rapport.pdfhttp://www.bistandsaktuelt.no/nyheter-og-reportasjer/arkiv-nyheter-og-reportasjer/sperrefrist-klokka-tolv-slik-vil-heikki-dele-for-%25C3%25A5-skapehttp://www.bistandsaktuelt.no/nyheter-og-reportasjer/arkiv-nyheter-og-reportasjer/sperrefrist-klokka-tolv-slik-vil-heikki-dele-for-%25C3%25A5-skapehttp://www.bistandsaktuelt.no/nyheter-og-reportasjer/arkiv-nyheter-og-reportasjer/sperrefrist-klokka-tolv-slik-vil-heikki-dele-for-%25C3%25A5-skapehttp://www.bistandsaktuelt.no/nyheter-og-reportasjer/arkiv-nyheter-og-reportasjer/sperrefrist-klokka-tolv-slik-vil-heikki-dele-for-%25C3%25A5-skapehttp://www.pwyp.no/en/european-union-reaches-deal-historic-oil-and-mining-transparency-lawhttp://www.pwyp.no/en/european-union-reaches-deal-historic-oil-and-mining-transparency-lawhttp://www.pwyp.no/en/european-union-reaches-deal-historic-oil-and-mining-transparency-lawhttp://www.pwyp.no/en/european-union-reaches-deal-historic-oil-and-mining-transparency-lawhttp://www.pwyp.no/en/european-union-reaches-deal-historic-oil-and-mining-transparency-lawhttp://www.bistandsaktuelt.no/nyheter-og-reportasjer/arkiv-nyheter-og-reportasjer/sperrefrist-klokka-tolv-slik-vil-heikki-dele-for-%25C3%25A5-skapehttp://www.bistandsaktuelt.no/nyheter-og-reportasjer/arkiv-nyheter-og-reportasjer/sperrefrist-klokka-tolv-slik-vil-heikki-dele-for-%25C3%25A5-skapehttp://www.offentlighet.no/content/download/2506/19770/file/%25C3%2585penhetsindeksen%202011%20Rapport.pdfhttp://www.sivilombudsmannen.no/publikasjoner/http://www.transparency.org/news/pressrelease/20120614_ti_norway_launches_report_the_norwegian_integrity_systemhttp://www.aftenposten.no/oslo/Oslo-far-kritikk-for-brudd-pa-offentlighetsloven--6803306.htmlhttp://www.aftenposten.no/meninger/For-mye-offentlighet-6738525.html7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
25/36
VII|anneX 1: MetodoLogy|23
vii | annEx 1: mEthodologyE e p pe e ee n
ogP p, bee e ne
p bee ne e pep
pe e e e
ee e e e ne p.
ae e ee pe pe,
e pe e
pe:
tpe ie (Eiti) pe e
tpe ie n pe pb
pp.
e e e, e
p://.eee./pje/p-/.
pp e pe e. ne
e .
eee e ne ogP pe,
( ). o e 16
i e e e
e e. Bee e e be
e ee be e, b ee be
epbe ogP e e
e j e e p
e e e.
https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/OGPhttps://www.surveymonkey.com/s/OGPhttps://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
26/36
OC
24|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
STAKEHOLdER FORuM: TRANSPARENCYIN THE MANAGEMENT OF OIL ANdGAS REvENuES3 m 2013
e e e p.
me e : p://.eee./
pje/p-/
ie [Eiti])
J mbe (Eiti)
ge see (ne fe m)
J ne (irm reee)
cpe w (irm reee)
STAKEHOLdER FORuM: OPENPubLIC SECTOR ANd INCLuSIvEGOvERNMENT8 m 2013
Pp ee e e pe
p, e e beee e ppe
p://.eee./pje/p-/
abj se (fad)
J ne (irm reee)
cpe w (irm reee)
m d sb (irm reee)
STAKEHOLdER FORuM: MEASuRESTO PROMOTE GENdER EquALITYANd WOMENS FuLL PARTICIPATION13 m 2013
Pp ee e e pe
eee e pe e e. me e :
p://.eee./pje/p-/
https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/https://www.theengineroom.org/projects/ogp-norway/7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
27/36
VII|anneX 1: MetodoLogy|25
heee lee (fokus)
a Pp (fokus)
(fokus)
J ne (irm reee)
cpe w (irm reee)
AbOuT THE INdEPENdENTREPORTING MECHANISM
Pe :
y a
re mgee
@pepep. .
mailto:irm%40opengovpartnership.org?subject=mailto:irm%40opengovpartnership.org?subject=7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
28/36
OC
26|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
29/36
VIII|anneX 2: IMpLeMentatIon oF norways CoMMItMents|27
nwy ogp a plp glbl iy1
p cslf-a r
FwLk?2
ogprl?
i
Open Public Sector and Inclusive Government
e ee pb.
te bjee e geee :
te pb e be ebe
ee e e pb ebee
dz e pb e e ee3
ye ye n
te ce gee cP e e 16 obe 2009,ee ee.
te e p ee ze:
b e , epbe,
he e b egee e
opee, pp, e ee ze, ee,
4
n ye n
viii | annEx 2: imPlEmEntationof norways commitmEnts
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
30/36
oc
28|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
nwy ogp a plp glbl iy1
p cslf-a r
FwLk?2
ogprl?
i
ye ye n
deep bee e e p
te bjee sre e:
me pee e ee ee e
a bee b e, ee,
t e e eepe pee pee ee b.
e. sre pb ebe e
b.
ye ye n
ee e p. teee e eb e pp peep pb
e p e pb e eee. te e e e ebe e e.
e. te e ee eee e e ee p e e, e 5
ye ye ye
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
31/36
VIII|anneX 2: IMpLeMentatIon oF norways CoMMItMents|29
nwy ogp a plp glbl iy1
p cslf-a r
FwLk?2
ogprl?
i
Measures to Promote Gender Equality and Womens Full Participation
e pe epbe e
i , eee, e pe e e p p e ee e ee Eu e.
ye n n
Ee e e pp p
epb (csr).
b e.
ye n n
e e pp6
pe pe ee
ye ye ye
ee ne pe ee e ,
ee nepe ee e , -e
ye n ye
( e e). 7
i e e 2013 e ee,te ee e epee p e ce pje .
ye ye ye
ye n n
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
32/36
oc
30|irm|norway progress report 2011-13
nwy ogp a plp glbl iy1
p cslf-a r
FwLk?2
ogprl?
i
e ep be
i deebe 2011. n e ee pb e.Bld e p ee e ep, e
ye n ye
e bee ee
2011. i J 2012, e gee
ee e ep. t e. te 23 ee e-e pepee. a e m 2013. te e ppe 201417.
ye n ye
Transparency in the Management of Oil and Gas Revenues
pee e e, ee p. we e pe e Eiti pee.e ee pe e
e ngo reeedeepe pe (od).
p, e -b ppe e e pe p e
ye ye n
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
33/36
VIII|anneX 2: IMpLeMentatIon oF norways CoMMItMents|31
nwy ogp a plp glbl iy1
p cslf-a r
FwLk?2
ogprl?
i
te m fe ppe e
p, e -
b ppe e e pe p e
n ye n
n ppe e oEcd
e b
p, e -b ppe e e pe
p e
n ye n
a P a E ce
-- ep. t e e pb e te c e Epe uEpe u. a e e ee e e Eu e
p, e -b ppe e e pe
p e
n ye ye
1 ogp i u vl iiuil ch. a mll u ui i mchim h c u ic li u ogp ci l. th v-ml izi, gll Ii, v h i mchim uil h f 2013. gll Ii l h ni ogp ci l iifi 18 cmmim i hm ih ujc hi.
2 th IrM m i whi h IrM ch i n l h 18 cmmim i m f (1) hh h cmmim f li, (2) hh i ogp
3 th lf-m m hi cmmim v huh h ci l iclu imil cmmim.4 th lf-m ci h m cmmim imlmi f h th pli Lu pjc th -u f ulic c ifmi. (. 3-4)5 thi cmmim i ll u. Ifmi h uv uv ul m fu 67 th cmmim imlmi chul fll ui f h m i f hi IrM .
http://www.difi.no/artikkel/2013/06/innbyggerundersokelsen-2013-er-naa-offentlighttp://www.difi.no/artikkel/2013/06/innbyggerundersokelsen-2013-er-naa-offentlig7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
34/36
oc
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
35/36
7/27/2019 Norway IRM Report
36/36
Independent Reporting Mechanism