Nathan Coombs - Hıristiyan Komünistler İslami Anarşistler

8/7/2019 Nathan Coombs - Hıristiyan Komünistler İslami Anarşistler

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nathan-coombs-hiristiyan-komuenistler-islami-anarsistler 1/15

789,342Q389078,2L3,78907

,9,3442-8,7889Q7QQ574033,,/037,/,80Q070;70380.3843:3:097/

:03::843:;07/2549,,7;0-:3,731,7Q0730:7:: 548924/073/04407-,9/0247,80733207:,97.2491300/0790,3/,37,/,5498,280Q072,782388902,79845,830007/,3.,80Q07/0247,8,/,,99,::8/0;090-790;,74,32,739,7,,7-78,-079889072083-:845,-79Q70;70380.005-Q9Q($9,9Q43:380Q0790.34Q9Q7.Q-07,47Q3Q3;07,/,/3L0;70380.3479,,,Q7Q99QQ8,,709-79Q7DQ3.Q44,7,5,7,/48,-780708,5789,33,3/302/042Q3,30/320733073900/47

789,3342Q3,30/3207:9,-7,783/,20800/03-,-074,3-7833;070.0905,3.,,72,4,.,97:349,/,0-0990:,3,143:4,3/30304/::3:8472,0700-78,/0.0-:/,/0,32,788907::38Q702,7823-7/342,/343:3;08;08007/03,,/030830-7-24/::3:8Q47,7/,1,,750/0078/0,7.,-:9Q7/03-7,1,,72,782;042Q32,7,83/,802,39;09,780-0-,0/47:/,3/070452,9,4,3-7-,-:,3Q3Q2QQ3-7442Q3899047803034,7,723.Q32,7889,70090730/,,347;0302-7-Q2Q-:Q307/02,782042Q32,7972,3,-,47(:3,73479,,3,,980:0072,7829070/0.08042Q32824,7,2:,1,,0/20/7



C3Q2Q/0Q307/07-0.D3;0789083/0 42Q327D073082,93/,/Q03030.043107,38,79-0-78,52,33,709073/0;0747,92.,731,79047,,2,720;.:980/0030,-:7039042Q32082038,/4:32,8070938Q47:821,,092070-074,7,720:/709308,597;0,7.,484:/,9;,0/03723.Q,,91009071,092023;0703 -7,7,97

02042Q32:79,72,807003-782/743107,38,92.,73/,3.,0,7/9;0$,;40-07,7,83/,9047;0549/073::7:2:3/,,709099Q070-:42Q3203/03-203/70.08372,7889-,,2/,343::79,757,380;723/03Q3Q2Q/0/070,1,,3Q7080020,79,70090,99,/,,9,792,-79,;73/0!,:/,2,/30789,3,,/,7070 549,3804,7,,58,,-0.0973.,007-:349,/,/:7,.,4:7,78,!,::308-77:52Q239,7,13/,389,9Q4/,345:/03020073/03-,709-7,,.,97:84Q9QQ2:902003:8,/,3:,220/047,/,3%42,8Q3070-7//3L82,/,9;,0/0.09708-7070;0049:79:2:-742Q32,3.,42Q3,/,,32,33//09

8,33,,7090/0-71L0709,7,13/,307.-2073/03,797/9,/7/0-:/,,32,;07945:28,1472,8433/0,72,90900.039090Q3/003 -70;70380,9047-,73/,9,4707843:8:904780307.09,792,9,4,3-:2//0930708,542Q3217,9842:9,,.,4:78,54892,78239Q2 5747,2-,9,3,7.-7,880,7,3,.,2,788942,,342Q320 54892,788942Q32,7,83/,208,10/070,,,.,9742Q32;0/307,7,81,7,7,304Q9Q7.Q8,3347:32,82Q2Q3/Q7,7.,-:9Q7/03-78,0783339,2-743:2,0709720843:8:3/,-3,/,0/0-73.,9,2/,-:349,/,-,,7847:3,77,-749047803349,/,,2,54,73,/0;,20/07!,::39,78003/3/0-7824,7,20;.:/09 -7028,42,3390830007;043:30709042Q323,9047073:7/:://,0/7,3,/4:/,,/,07/070!,::30;70380.3:7:.:8:4/::3:807789,3;0!,:42Q323,39Q7Q0/47:9Q7Q,7,83/,,7,/:7:2:3,07%Q2-:2080007--,,/2349,,079Q7Q73,L-7,7972,3090,8,080200.04,32,782042Q32,7,83/,-0-,3,:0700-,4,7,!,:.:42Q32/00;70380.3072,78892,3320703/08Q70300303,2,,328,97,30;70380.3,8,03/80/04,2,,.,0703%03,20;.:98,0;703802,3,8/70;7038039088/,2,904,3C908333733;,78,,78,2,782/0-:7:;,8310;70380.33;Q.:9-:2,83/,08,8 -77408,597,2,90,3/,3/,-:7:;,83133/0;728437,843:2:/,2,

2Q502/7:7:;,8313390/7.0344,.,3800317#:8,/,/0;0983133::7:,43:3Q9Q70;723/007.-:7:;,0309,81007;0!4!49:383139Q2/032,8320.-:7,32:9,2,39,7,.,2,3,8,297,7820702,3,/,-:7:;,C9080,8,:,2,2,3,7890;70380./02,7823,82C90842:9:73,722,78237::3:490070,59Q72Q-7709/70,73,:3373.39073,843,/03(4;2,8,7.,0339,7,13/,343:3108010/0,;0Q3.0-79004,7,7Q208-070832,:2:4,3730Q073/03/QQ3Q/QQ3/0,3,7238,7,,7,0208070297



,78890;70380.,/3,!4!49;0-030773007/0.82003;,092,788942Q389/0;72.,70093QQ3Q,0920903:,97,,90,,7.,-:,7009,3,/4:3943407;0837Q/0$,;409,7,13/,39070/297048,-0030/0-,,-04,3847::/:70;70380.3QQ,58789,3303/03,2,-:8010742Q3892,3,/,0/323/003/3907,70/472:092472:

!,7,0-72,39:73090,000.097:/,2,3/,90.9,3.,,:/070;,4:32:9:7-0-72,3,,4,-20349,83/,!,::30;70380.3,7:7/7,3.,:/,90.07/,243,7,30:2Q314,02979542Q389/0;728437,8-:7:;,33Q8Q05,-42,83/,4/::-4,8,-,,0707/0/01,/00//Q07005447907078.789,33//090/,,2Q8,2,,80;70380.3320903208Q70.3/0:/,2,33/:7:2:3549,3802,3,/,7,,980/.2843:,73479,,2,8,79./0/7:070;0/3/0,:/07320;.:98Q707082L2,3,/,789,39,7,13/,3-,,924,3Q7QQ574090709200303,9-797,4,7,7Q0-7;0-:/,079Q7/030;70380.,7:,,788L-7,39,,9,/,,2,-70304,7,,,3,-728,87,/0;0984:3,7/2,,72,349,83/,07/,2,9/,;7,3/802-4-773097

!,7,02,39/,,070709Q7/QQ2Q/0:847:847:,-7007,3,722,7823,82808,2/,789,332,82/70290345::/03/7030;70380909,37.-72,34,7,8,27,5,72,/,83/,49,37,-007370/0703789,3/,:/,2Q3,87370/07:/09030707/;,99,;,3/,3/,,/0730,9,2,070/0702,7823Q-4:3.,0200,709099,3,720-03020904,32,782/42Q32320703/0,.-774320;.:9/02;0,7.,0342Q3895740Q7QQD8938,3079Q7/03-,7,70//0/58,23-,7,,93/,945,,38,2.,1,,8, -0302472:,7/9;00733/0,-:099-207,30;723548924/07389/0;724,7,/QQ30-7,,9-:/QQ320-2,3.,/0;723/Q3,5,,73,30QQ-797,4,-/Q/02Q2Q3/Q7,3,3.,/0;7232,7889Q/3/0,-:030-74,3823,79758,2L073720/030/2/0,7823,3,72-,8972,8-!,::3902045::3,4/,,32,/,789,330;70380.39,73/0-7.43:2:3:8Q7/Q720,/3,8,2370920,709308793,8,78$,72,33/,9,71099Q070,3,2,3/,/Q030303/,092,907,890743107,383/,0307::0/0/70,/07,30;723-7,4,7,1472Q009200,2-00789,300243,83,,903/3/03023

90859070,1,9:92:9:743:,,8L908598,2,/,-7-,,/33/08,/0.0789,3324/0730;7038090230993802090/78,1,3:2,7,8-079202020789,330;70380.3/03,:, /:7/::370//0/038,/0.0,://0/78,2/,0342Q3217,93,,9:1,,,3/:72,92,/4,8,,7/0/2090/70730,/,79,792,3.,3,.-730208,548,/,2/789,3;0,:/2080083/0,,2;08,209,792,,2,33Q2Q30 -7,,2 39073,943,4:73,410$9:/089



,.4-%,:-08474,2-03$,;40;0,3,/4:-904780307/03!,:,30843,2,3,7/,302-7334/::7Q80/0-:7,/,0;0,/4:Q073/0/:7:,.,07,,7/,789,3342Q3239020709073003,3/34/::

//,83/,/779,-754957405,,2,8,,7/,!,:.:,/79543:03Q8920;00709720349,83/,991,3/0/707/,2,099Q0700,2,.332,3/0,230/0007,/,1080103320703003/0307097204/::3:8Q4707,3/,3,/4:8000-,/Q2,34,7,9,/20/0703:;0,/,3 Q3,,73,3982,2,83,:,3,3-72,3920;.:980007,2,.330039Q288902303/8890230,2009204/::7QQ47403347,2,9047020,598,/0;700-7097/439440:,4393,3042,,32Q073/0902003/72-788902/7-::,90,9,7,203030/0/,094,02303,707/Q20

2Q2Q3/Q70788902/00;70380,;7,2:8:8:3/,479,,78/0789,330;703804,3,1,74/,3:,7000308,/,,932:,1,,0/0300703.0;07038,33Q2Q4:28:,2,24203903,/4:,70!,:/,0-74/,,32,,709302,,74,3;043:39/,092084,3,4,,34,38,14:2,2,8,38,3303/03/7/7:902003-:3,QQ3.Q-707/QQ0-70300.-QQQ/0,79,-L/7,59,1472Q,8430302,3,/,70:/;0,.,3Q073/03,/,9078903,5,3-74:2,33843:.:/:70730,/,700,/4:,7,83/,/,094,0,72,072003/03/70207Q073/03,,3,3,72,30280972080/0-:,,7/070.0/00839,7L90444:2,,7,843;070.097090,4,/4:/,-::32,82Q2Q34,30;7038038,-942,3,;043:3-79020900920/303-0-71720;.:99:7:3/,3,/043/,42,0022/77.,-:0-0/L-7/0907232-24,7,9,73,72Q700-30/,/72-70/0/0/73.,/,,3.0/09,7992Q070-:,,7,7/,9,2/,-:,2,/2349,/70039070,73789,39,2/,0;70380.390204:74,8,-:2,,033,2,.;7:5,2070.789,3,7,/,,39802920,/,8,2414-,3/,078;0/,39085907QQ3/03,,7,7009720903,/09020079Q7/030;70380.17333/0,72,332080033033/0,99389072097208000;703803902033070908,-9-7Q020/09:9,38,-9-7308300-:349,/,789,30;70380.30:,7,32,8/7%04709.,793890%047,,7,/4::3:80730830-2,,3/

9,/7/00;703804,7,20;.:94:78,3!,::30;70380.,7,/4:3:3889023/043944709070-:70.0/,,1,,/4,84,354990442Q/,,0,7,83/,/0739:9,78,,7090/07C029020070,70909208:70901,7439448890207-0328080-0-03.00;0,/4:789,33/Q3,9,733028Q70.3/074Q0,30-2,/,3,3,9,3408;0,5,00.3(083/03:79:,2,2,9,/7 ,L4,7,208000720/033.0082-0700-7/0320901,/,;,7:349,/,09-7-47,19,/2,5,-7!,:$0,7,7,83/,-7



#42,;,9,3/,4,7,/Q3,,0297789,3,7,30:Q28,80930,92,78-7,://79:,3/,03,2,/47:8070/034.:::083,83/,789,3,9/,09297Q3/038437,-303/Q3,05,,//30237,.390908,3303/03/7/303208,07,3,:,972970;.:93,20078,//092;08,/0.0,8L2,3,8793,8,,303-73,2307203/03/74,3,/3Q90/,;Q/-73,3.39083/007,3-78,709830,

/,2:.00-,;:72,070/:2,297:00,5,32Q7,.,,942Q38990478030731,,8,,973.,9,2/,,3,2-0780733-,,/07!,::300233-:Q30,9,723/,3902/70800:/:7!,::30/32334,9843:,7-07309349,/,!,::30020739,2,2,,2;0703-7,047,/,/,09,/,3072-7-Q24,7,7Q543,742Q3890;70380.39020,-:09202-:108010339,708330039,710801083/039Q2Q0:79::5:79:,2,2,83,-,/7,,-7,/,3:847:/,3090-7-:,0/3207-789,33:9,/34/::3: 5,5,,328,907,70/5/:72,9,3,4,724,8,,,93Q20 -7,,7,3.-7847:/,,0030-7-:950/3207Q7QQ-78,23479,,23,73/,479,/,3,/72,2

8,3372,770/,,907,7,2,9,1,/,;,79,79,390478030738,338073848,24,7,00,,3!07::7,5:89,;4:907709Q7Q3/03-7:79::9044832Q/,1,,0920/07,09,!,:,302Q7,.,,93-07-72032Q/,1,,84,7,9,710/2082Q2Q3$9,9Q43:3//0905,7,,32,83,/3Q9Q23,3.9020,72,89003-07,4Q9Q7.Q9,7,9,732Q/,1,,.-790/-7/7-:789,33Q3Q2Q/0/07,3,30;7209Q238,3,3090,,2,-87,/,3Q3/0,,9,,9:7,,70;,30,70090,94:3:,-092-7/Q3,/,:,3,3/024/0-7,L5:8:,;0,,0/007079Q7Q3/039,-707-07,4Q9Q7.Q/Q3,/,9Q24-,3;0,/3/Q2,33303;082Q70.38,380;.332,394/::3,390859073/,,,32,84:3,8!,::342Q3892,3,/,2Q/,1,,0/20838080/Q02/0.,5;05,7,,.-72,730842,9,/7,/4:;002,7,1,7,,7/,3,,71,,9-0-7/Q02/007,,2479,-790-707,/4:,70!,:;075498/3023/03,2,2,28,,,.,29,33,7095030-:3,-70,5,7,03@,.3;0:/23,9Q9Q7Q3/0Q7Q9Q.Q090730,7909,37.3,L -747:3::4/::3:80733-70907803,3.300200208/7!,:8,3303/03/730/3Q2,3,L09720349,83/,70108010.0739,50920/-9047803/0Q3Q2Q/084.:29,33549907.07033028,739,7,,1,472,4:3:3,/,503/43:2:3:3/47:8:,3398,/L2,3,/,9,792,2,8070930,7090/07,,-7/000020;02:.0073

07000.0303,32,;,0/07$9!,:%04:3/,94341&3;078,82!,:;70380.3%0208208073/0,/4:03/09Q28,2-9,732,8,,,,7Q3Q2Q/003-729,31Q7Q43:8:3/,,58,2-7,7,972,,9,34:32,9,/7-08-71Q7Q32Q2Q34/::3:370920349,83,;,78,/,,7,972,0329,39533033;0 -40;07.0Q3-,,73/,:7:,3,35,7929,333;,784,.,3372090/78



,.-7,7090:8030-7,/4:3:3!,:0/32Q3Q2Q/042Q389/0;72.30334::3.,4:,37:08,/3;00.380;-9Q7Q3/0328,809Q/03,70090732090/7:,70090770.0Q89-7,59,200978307202090;0,-733/07303850909Q2-:07,5,3/7,3945:28,3,2,03202090/707

020!,::30890/03/4,30;7038045:,32Q0220-74,3.00208/7,/4:20800:0/0,0/07:2;0.02,,9,9047073,,9:8:07028,549:8:07030,52,,707093-20070-720800/72.0;,-2:/:7843:8:,904707-7,,93033.083/0307,3-7/0;,2,3833;0Q3/00-0/L,7972,233342,/-79Q7:8:7,8Q70903,,/042,/7,708,/4:3:3!,:4:2,8303303/03/4:2:3,3,7:/,2070L02 540280-79Q720:09;00;70380-,,32,-2-7,,9:8:Q3/0,9,9Q/0-08-73033-,,32,,703,870.030/,7-71,,9973

0/0,/4:3:38,/,,94,7,47:2,/-:-,,32,789,3,3,3/0/0/0;70/0/7' ,7;0,-4:3.,,/4:3:307/3Q5-,;:7/::897,7-7,842:9730903-74,7,8,4,302-77443,7C00-:,59,3,,2,,/Q9QQ349,/,07007C30;043:34,,8:8:8:3/,,/4: Q3,,7 ,393/,,3,33.0/03,-07;077,,99,-:1080100,2-720800/707/,2208000-0/L8,/,,93:7,,7334,,,9/3/09720,7093/03/0;75/0;70200.03-20978:Q20,;:9:7:2,2847:789,3;08,4,332,739,7/3/0807Q9032089,7,13/,3-07035-070320/303-9209Q0320-20032Q3,,,,708-,,23/,7304,7,;077!,::3302,/4:3:3889023/070.0/,,,58,210801L2903,3,,3743,702Q/,,008,/,,9,7,83/,-742,/;,78,,.,4:78,-07-,,398,,,3::,.33070903.-74,4,7,::7092080700.03,-:032047:3/,,708,,-71,/00,/4:3:3::78:9047/3Q8Q43:3889023/0-073-7,7320;.:94/::3:8907703,3/,3' ,7;0,3,020,3//302/0,74,3 -:,7300738,/,,930,9,504,3203,34,3479,,9/:7:2:3,3,2,8,7,83/,/7:80-050,/4:3:3;,78,23,703/039Q2Q0,74,33.4,030847:38,07:7,/,!,::33023/7,0924:47:

8,332Q790;708/3/,300390,;,74,7,!,:29,3-7-,,32,0/:7:2,,92;090.Q903,3-7,:/4,7,8,/,34,,:79:2,-297 -:3:330/0307090!,::308,83/,47,/,-042,2,8/7;70380/03,72,/,,32080083/0033/05,7,0-7/00703/720/0 -::3:7,7-2003,2,43:390470130,94,0700972033QQ3Q879,3,3-738,3/,904757,90/0-730;02,3,/,007,/4:3:3,3,3/03-7,,.,8,-:Q3Q2Q/003/038,30,2,82:9020303380/Q02/0,3,04/::4,,,9203-,,23/,42,807093802003



30334,,;043:30;70380843:,73,,98,7988,/,,9890720839030/03-7,97Q3Q2Q/03-773008030307,09202Q2Q387,3843:;0 -,3/,,0030:,92,,7093,,7,25,3,Q7Q903-7002.,2,3,90/0;09Q20-,,37;00023-7-2/00;70380003843:,79Q2549

3007/300807!,::34,073/042,2,8;080:72,2,83,39Q20549/:7:2:3479,,3330/032Q94:78,48:3302,70920/32:.0073809Q2Q0-4:9,3/4/::3:890770,/4:4:2,83/,30,79,3349,,75,,2,83,,7303/,,73/,3005003204/,,410801LQ9Q701,/007/3/08,333024/::1732Q/,1,,092004/,,37789,3343:2:43,70Q9Q78,;,2,8,83/,-78,97,39,/7:2,8,/,0,;0-:23;,/0002/03,32,9030/03548924/073945:2:303/8303070,58,,3,3,,93,3,2,,,7:-,,2/,43:3070,,7/,308Q70,70/03,3,2,33/,,3,2,2Q2Q3/Q7,3,2,3,2,,73/,8,,7,,32,387,2,8;010/,-,;7,2,7/,03/8300;07707-:-,9,03/00.3/03-79Q7

,72,,/0,098043:3:,,93,:,;0720073/04,.,9703200.2:/:79,7L/,098Q70.324947:083000200/QQ320,7,83/,,7978,39,7L/,09-,,2/3/0/Q3,070920,/3,30,333/QQ3.0Q7Q3Q42,,300207070-2047:3/,/700703/,783300200/QQ32033,7,-::.:80390,8,/0/7,83045,7,,8,7337,/,-790//78054479070/003,.,3.,3,300/03;0070,,7//,32Q900 -72,9783303,807097/3-00,-7002/03,32,93,5;002033,,792,,73/,3002300/02Q/,1,,09935,7,88902,9-7,3,08907705447907033,,93,7003,.,3.8,4,47:2:0030,7,83/,097,13/,/3070354903000,7,83,0300709703,:/:::3:38438:-7,7:/3Q8Q0Q2/Q79Q8Q3Q8,;:9:7:7-0003/3/00370.0/,,9020-738,3L/Q79Q/007900324:7,:/:::003/7/-:,7:/3Q8Q0,59,2;043:30.,7:,79Q09234,92,80-790479,-720/3QQ7020/Q79Q07207002043,7,7:,7233Q3/0/9Q7Q7Q-:3:3-,89 -730/03;,7/74/,:::3/Q79QQ,8,,242,8/72,,3,2,3/,843:8:::5,3/,-38,34,7,:7,30/7/00070/020%,378,4:7;0,72,077::-001080/24:7;0Q30,;:2,33908300-0/0317,95,9297/Q79Q072:79:2:-:083,/,38,32/,

2:,1,,0/297789,3002/Q79Q8Q3Q807-089-7,7;0Q3Q2Q/0,73/4,-7843:4,7,479,,,303-,9Q9Q7Q3/04:71,333Q80003/7/002/03,32,3030,793/,-::74,8,4:3,2,2070030/019,2/,549,380-7Q24,7,30703/0443303/8/728,70.0/,,:8,/030-Q9Q380.044,,2,7,/4:7:,309:/2;0;,3,/,32/05,8,70,-093/0380-7208,10,2,;043,,98,2,;,0/03545Q9Q7Q30,9-74:4,7,-,9:/2,8,330;,73:79,7703-0735,8,/3,207309Q2/03



,9238,,,39,792,8030934/:78,/4:-03/0,59,9,7,3/04/::2:Q/3020/01003-72Q/,,0070097/;043:0/3209,-9:99::8,,2,3/,,3,2973.,07,,73/,,3/,-7-73/03,41,7,7789,320;.:99:7,/4:!,:,0-74/,,32,3/042,9,3208:903070.0/,,0/0-L-74/,3

,72,0720,/80833302Q073/0/:7:7@,72,0720;003/037,,2,7,7,83/,1,7,72,0720;003/03/7,7,83/,:8:8:3/,9Q25,00,75,7:349,/,90-7:38:7:30833,3,073,,1,:7,99380200-0990/,3042,,.,97,/4::00,543:32,3988083-Q23/03.00023/04,,72,0720;003/03/74,7,0,773.83/080!,::329,3/3/09720800,370300.,.,3.4:2,808,89,,72,0720,/808304:28:,;0!,::39/,83,4:2:,4/,,3703,/4:8,4,339,792,/,3-7,/2080033!,:/4,2000,3/,3,,93/0/7/4,8,4

9020/003/03/74:2:Q073/0/:7:700./,0933,8-/QQ3Q7/QQ2Q;,9843:8:390280-Q20203330Q/0,32,4/::/,7Q0.0978,,/4:!,::33023,:/2Q088083,23/,2:38:7,738,33208,3;003/03/73;07::,0720,7090739,7:2,709208Q073/03908590/07,/4:!,::39Q2;07945:28,073/03;0173/039,2/,,/4:.:4,173/03452,,387,70;07:::32Q02204,7,00,3,3,:/789,34,,7,83/,,72/,09-7,,238907034,7,:,37-:,44,3,72,,7320933/08Q70907,7,37,:/2Q088083,23,3,,7:3,7807C30,3,/,099708004,39/,73370920/0/7080003;0Q34::3:32,3300308020332:,1,,0/5,3,2,3/,43:4:28:,2,8-0043:,,7,43:3, -70208/78,4,::,843:,3743:843,3/72,4,8,003090327,8,3,3,7090728,8Q3309,7:7/707830/0,/4:!,::32Q088083,2/,3,-:3,;,7/:/Q843107,3832:98:-7803904,7,7Q7,3.,-:803900709008,8,902003/77,4789,3,2,;09,7803-,080:,97,-:0920070743107,38-7/:7:2:30707/0-::32,804,8,,7,83/,Q0020330738,-9020903:,9708030/043107,3807/0,,3,.,;0,72,0843:,3,.,-7-,,4,3!0907;0!,::339,,/,7,89,2,833023390

0/07!0907,:/42,,3,730/073,30202,8,839070993/07,89,2,:::!,::3073Q3080729702903003,7:70:::343:9,509200709303,3,3,73-0,792Q/,1,,0/0-7-7,3,2,29708:-Q2/0,/4:8,/0.0!,::3/302330/0329,3;07,/,4/::3,,70909200,2,,7.,03/889020,1,,73837,2,89077,479,,3,,90704,,7903,7;030333/04/::/:7:2,/,2,/8,/7,7:7,8,79043944,/,39Q2Q02Q/,1,,0/02039090/7-:80-050



!,::38,4,3,/8,42,83,,73,/4:07830770.0/,,,-,-74394443908,5/,09/QQ3.00/47:,2,3020,/3,!,::3002073842:9-7/:7:23/0902003/7200,7,7.43:3%03990808399082,2,8;0-:,2,/,,,73%,37089039,7,83/,,59,72Q073/031,7-7%,373320;.:94/:://,8,

9,792,83/,,/4::90859,5,7$43::789,330398,1;0 -,892,3,/,,L%,3733,7,-::.:;,02/0893-,83099,7,9.%,37330833,,3,-,33-79Q71,,09/708,/4:3:3,7.43/00703/72083/0,3,9,78.Q,7,-::.::9:7:8.Q4,3,77,/,303/00703/720-,,23/,5,7,/48,-2/070.0/,,/,09-7,7!,:;0,7.43,97,0/03,/4::9085990-::3:7!,::3,:/38Q703/03,/043/,345:,;:7:,52,8Q500/200.0-7070973.,-:904394442,,329,3-790/7,-790;/ :3.908,4,0,7,3/:7:2,7,83/,57Q:7,7;0-::7,9,90;///,8Q500/Q070,/4:,708,4,33-7904443944-4:9:49:7-:/,,/4:3:34,,347:2:3:/,09-747:2,/47:837,3/7,30/7

,,3.0/07/QQ2QQ07000708,33,72,072083/03029,2/, -:43944-4:99,30702090/72,-:7,/,-0-72:843:8:/:700708,3308-0/033/0%,373307QQ30020830;0,72,07208303904733,32,843:.:789,33,709099,79047/7:98,#:QQC90/0/08909032,7:2.02,,939,03/8/7789,33,902/34/::3:8020%,373338,342,33%,37338773338,3/,,,93//,0/03,-,;:07-7Q2,3899,7/0/70:07-,.;/,830-://,Q2,323/0,99,89,320/0,,99,,2,-2/3L07/008,/77$43:8:/3L07/03097,13/,002072330830,3,23,,7,7;0703-QQC904,7,%,70/3Q-79Q72,37QQ/Q780070789,333028,/0.080Q,72/0,7.,$9,33;0723.Q3-280848,8907339,,Q073-0,,370.0/,,8,1-780Q072307208/73.,-:1,/007/02:9,2/,-:9Q7/03-743944903079,7,1,/,0970-2080/73330/,7Q08000.9004447:2:38,3307090%,374/::3,330;08;08007,7,.,07-:,7,-::.::Q073/03%,3703/83,,;:7:7479,,,38,-70/080/0 -,9089 3#:9,03/8/7,/,0703,7:8:00.4:2,339Q290044072073/03,32,8,43:3,52,80700380Q,723-79Q7030,3%,3733@,72Q073/01,99,2Q4/:://,83,7103,-:032097%,3707090;,74/:,2,,794!,::329,32Q7907,72,0720,/808334:28:::3:80Q074,334:2:::3,,3:98,#:,0;72007Q,7/,

-207/7@,729,Q,/,23,38,3L7Q39Q8Q3Q380Q070/32;0%,3733Q2Q903300780202083-:0/003/03/738,/0;700700242,80707034:2,83/,-,,-7072/,,20;.:99:7,72,0720,/80830309Q7/03 -74394443:2-,0/07800/02-:,/809Q2/07/3070,8,-070.-77443,2,8Q7/Q70.097,,,-71,/00007%,37,729,2Q80,:/3/0;,2-79Q71,782-7Q3200-,,,.,97



C080,:/07-,04,7,,3,/,73/,,3.,43,73303-,084/::Q073/03-7,,9097/2349,/,08343:,-7,:/070-099003/03/0733-:9-,7,,3,2,3/,-007093-,08/70708,99,0789,3,0390303/830,97,983/0,:/02:9,97//,8Q073/032349,,7/,,:/2Q/,1,,0/0705447907083., -:4:2,/3/0003,.02.08,9072,3Q3,0Q0/%,7

0801083/0/01,/00//-8,29Q2Q0,2,3/42:-7/3/7,,803.4:,,-:03/00.02,/,49,37.;0,2:9,37./307/,,-0907-743:2,8,5970700/33028Q70.3/0Q9020,700937443,/3;,78,,7,7,.8/32,//0/3;07:,3L-7080/3:/23/:2;0%,42,:/;0789,39,2Q3/024,37:,3L-70800/47:,,3/30,92,//0/3-,,93/,/00703/7703031,,301709099:/2/00;70380%0038,390,7,83/,57Q:7,3-7049:7-:/,;,7,3-7024/::3:89077;0843:8:-70202-23,7:/3/0,002/03:,/:7::70070708,9-77Q,8000200203330,3,2;,7,/,-:3,,9073,914,7,/QQ3.0/03,,/0-7//09;097,3;Q.:9-::7:80-05000070-:7,/,1,3

,8,/0.0908,/Q1L-7390,70920802,//0,783/,-,28-7;,742,,3,8,5/0/7-:,-,89,3,2/,-797-707049:7-:30/030-,4,7,/307549/Q0/0/08549QQ2090000,70090/07$9,.080/0,30/0,,,2,;043:3%-09909,9-099//09903:,/:72,897,908330870239028099-,8.9047,80000993807;70380;0//09:,7/,-07992Q070,/4:;003789,30/32-207,7,83/,9020-71,720;.:99:7-:1,700707833/05,,90;70380,904783843:8:/080/070-0.0:,2,023-::3,-0.0-71,79708,89,7,00./,090,/4:3:34,90478-7-70709:9,7/7079047/003-70;703803,8,,2,8Q073/039,710/03-74,/,3/02;:7:700/031,74,3,/4:/,4,,3,43944/Q0/09:9,742,;0-79020-07020/770.0/,,038890208/3/043:3,59!,:4:2,83/,2:9,2/,-:7,/,/7,/4:!,::30;70380.303990 473907 -Q2Q3/0003-7Q073/0389077,:/07,,32,3,:/070,:/-/,;7,3/203/2:98,,8,33/03092,93/,42,/2/0,8,,93/,4,3,7,,32,343,7,,8,,93/,22-/,;7,3/2@342Q389073908/0/07/:7:243:-:08,8.Q208,710920092970803/-,,23/,/,-:,32,-2/0,1-7-,,39/7

%,-L,2,,/4::-2802,3,/,009720/0,830,2,2093-4:3.,QQ28Q7032:3-073020838,,2,!,:,30,,23002/08890230,9-77304,7,0;7038054930,0478-23/0200,,.,48,789,3,,9Q2,3,/,/3L-7,3,,30203984,7,270.07,,/4:3:3903090200707800/00/0.02843::4,.,97!,::38,3303/03/730308,/,,90709030;70380909,37.2,33/4::4,3,70907:0;703802,3-0070937::3/,0-0/090,/,7024,7,,,.,;02,78892,330;70380.3/0,,,.,97



,,3/72,070080320/7-:8437,/,32,7889,7009308070930,99,-L-2,,3308309,7808Q700709,--72,78892,3/0/783042,7823-74,4,7,03/830,90;70380.30/3Q-72,3/7,73,2,89Q2Q003-70-0-7-Q9Q3Q4,7,,3,,3945:2:33/08313,3021,/00/07:,2,Q9-,7,-280,3,03/703020;09Q229007/300807

3.,-:7,/,!,::30;70380.024/0730;70380.,700907,7,83/,:7:,3-: -,,3933/073;0/4,83,3-7847:3;,7/7723.Q/,1,,4,32,788942Q389,7009073.00,38070.09707-:902045::3/QQ/007/0 -7:7:28,,2,0,948083.0070097/3,-:0/0780,/4:3:38033!,::3208,3,308,/,,9802,89Q2Q090709202,8,/00;70380.42,,3#:8794/48808;0093-0030-790/00703/703$9,3:,,7@3431QQ8QQQ;0,43:338,3,,93,/07.2,3,/,08,2,83,,7,93207,42Q3890739,7805,3/,-0-7,9427,8,8,5Q-,,7,:,;0/070707/08907/0738,3.,7,83/,208,810801L-,,7,,7090920,83/,4/,302-7,/2/0/70800,/4:3:3!,:4:2,833723.Q/,42Q389,700907327,83,-0-7

Q9Q70.,9109200843:,32,8/70307-79,;7;9/,7083/00997242,33,8974,,,3/7/,L/00707Q073/03Q-,0;7233-,,74/::3:;0Q7080/0;72.,700990/077:5,7/,20;.:94,303-,7-,79,3,89743:307,7:-:3:843:8:,3,797/38003,,3,,90,/,/,20;.:99:70730,/,7--:43:/,3,09200,8,/,,/4:3:343:2:00343:2:3/,34/,:,/0/700/0789,33028,8-2/02Q0220-7/34/::,3,,93/0/73:39,-70:9,/34,3789,3,:/02,8:82,30;70380097297%09,37.,3.,03/83-7007009729704;,,30-,/0903000390903:79:2:9:704;,90,3-7,238,3;0,:-:39,378/;08,/0.0,:/070,7,83/,-0-7,9843:8:/03/831,09990,,:/07/008,/4:;000,7,83/,208,10,/4:.:,,9390230,94,0/,094,,7,83/,-2,919,-::3/::2:1,79,90.00/07,/4:03/8890239,2,2,2,,/3,,8,,257-79,710801089,8;70920,3,,-/2,/,7,43:3-:,2,8;00/0%0039:7Q829,--7-730,3007807(3.,0;70380,9047800;703803,2,33/038,39Q707,7,.,-:Q3/003/83890720817000479,-7,9939,50//33/0/7,/4:3:390859307007,7.,003,L330;70380303,3,,935,,47:3., -070-:0;703803Q;03.08Q9Q3Q343,,90707/020;.:94,3,382,8339,7/0,,94,,73390/7,/4:8

,/4:/,0-0/L4::3439448,5,32,;00039,73843:9085930:,2,92,3479,/,3,/772:9,2/,,/4:3:3-0790200;703804,,7Q29,780:7,,7,-,,2,83/,/73.,003,83043/,0;70380::,:,7,3,307/,25,7,-7/3024,7,::70920,8300;703803::3479,24,7,7Q03-:170;7038033083027,8,/,30830-2,/9,/7/0-7030;703804,7,;,74,2,,.,31,/00/07@Q3Q73048:32,902,980-730720330;70380,3.,-:3072033,39338,,2-7-2/003/03Q709208,/,010/2088,083/090.7Q-00/0-708



;703800-0/03907,7,3,-0390.7Q-00/2-74:9:7030/00;703803907,790.7Q-00/20830;003/03Q709208303173030,9,703,3/,3/,,3.09,790/QQ3Q202030;70380/031,7-7042,47:3/,/7:,/4:3:3!,::390204,7,,7090/,/,03,,9,3,,9-773004,7,9,710990;703804,39,03/8/7083;0904,32,//0

,7,83/,0724:3:-4,7%,790030;703800730-0/LQ7092208008,,32,,2:9,978,83/,-70;70380303/0390.7Q-00/2083030-0/8Q70.0,78378,/,030;7038007220;.:99:707080,/4:3:3889023/09,733/083733,8/00703/70.0,/,90200;7038007383739048:3/,3,2,.3/,3,307.;09,78090044-2073/033,8:79:,.,,/0/707,3/,30,/4:3:3!,:/,-:/::909,37.39020030;70380097.38,5037;0DQ3.QQ3,/,2,7889/0;72073,/0707303-:0;70380097.9032,3,2,7,797032,/4:/,/,4/::3,3,3/2-790859002,788942Q32-,,7-7-2/00700970-0.0030Q.Q3,942,3,/,/08900.10801L:38:7,7,8,5,,74/::3:/QQ3Q7

:90859300:0;07,/,,9,7/08,/,30:0;,7,,/0//0938,;,03-,,23/,207:,972,8008-,90030,7,83/,1,730/7-:,543,73,807L8,/7833,830/0;72.//0930702,3,/,//09/-7::290880920,2,,/,3,23,020,83049,39/0;72.Q7020/4,8-2/0//09070.0/,,1,,9,32/7807L03;07843:3:3-78,52,4/::3:80209,2-7-,894,.,97,,99,32,8,Q-70/7030-048,037./7,/,/,,/47:8:9Q2Q0,98/7 08,9,807L//0930:0;,7,/,73024/0330/03-:/::;0/4::,807L//09325,7,94774943:302507,702030/0303/7/070903207,43:8:/:77,3/,384.:-707,-725,7,947,,8,3470390,3/,3/,/3;0/0;72Q0730-79,792,30720:8:8:3/,,347:349,/,000,4:,8,,-7/,3.,,43:3 !7,9;0@082,2,83,020,/9,/2,83/,3/,-/2Q0704Q9Q70/3L,,2,,7/,34,-/3.0:,/:7:47;0-:3:30730,4/,39Q-7004:7:4,7,-,80/477/QQ2Q,/,7,007042Q3892:907/0904403002-,9,59,89945:2,7/,/4::71,3:.,,2,0/280,/,370//0920,2,.,207:,972,9,/73.,-:3:39083/00-:Q38,,/32043:8:3/,,;0

4:2:-780-05,8,479,,4,2,:902003-75740843,20804-:8:,2,!,:0,2,8Q073/03474,2-0303097,2-033208,390.7Q-04,7,1,/0099003,233!,::300///,83/0730970.0079Q7/03Q908599032:,1-08-790.7Q-0338,1-280,58/7-:Q330/03!,::3209:5,734:3:7,3Q-7:7,97:3:330/0303Q3,Q03833#42,25,7,947::3,5,7,0,7092082/707;0,7/9390087.,03,2,83/,789,3,-:/33,973,38,3Q50080;0/0.0847:2::,7,910/0321,/0074:2,/,4:7,.,500-2090/7



:03/42,9-7789,3303/,7Q2,3,7,.,03/83-3,93/,1,099,3,23,020830-03.003,.,3.098,93/,,00.03/473,33,13,,7,/,48,479,,4,7,,,1,/00920070780479,2,3,3,2,,7,,730030103/083/03/0,24/073/0;090:,3,338,3L8Q7090478,3987/,343/4::3.:Q2,3,8

,7,83/,8Q70.38,12,3,/,9,7804,7,84:9,32,8/0/7,30/0,73104/,2/03,59,2047,/,3/,42Q3200/0,2,38,5,3/,,32, -2/0,,3,3-7,2,4,7,7Q020830003/0,/0;094843/3/0/0,-7-24,7,07/,220;.:9,,.,-7-2/7-:48430103/0/,090-,,524/073/0;093Q2080843,3,32,398,,7009Q0730:7::/:7;02:90209,780070003/7200709Q2Q0,79973.,/,09-339,7/-7/Q02/007002082,2,39,780-7/,09330:;,7,37::;,7,32,9Q200.8890238Q70300303,2,/7/47343:3/,80/-20$8902/4,80709,7804,3,;7,23,;7,28,3/70302039,32,47:3/,/72,398,88902,9Q07-,,23/,9,7804,3058-042,8,/,7,,980/./7-:9,22,3,8,7-7349,/7

9//078$43:8:,2,3030,9,7,970,3554903//,83,70%330342034483/08,/0.07:;0/30-Q207/0Q3.09,7800200908,/Q10/03-7,700920;.:99:708:80-050003%,70801083/09,/20/03/Q3,9,7Q0730:7::/390478303,00.3837,3/7,3-7,94,7,00,2,803/0,-:03/-20003Q3.04/::3:078Q72033,343:8,54/::889023-Q9Q3Q024/,802209,180-7/04/::8:,2,83/,3:79,72,33,8L4:00317,93-80;0,L//,,7233472,914:,73;03;,78,2,73-07020,7094,7,4:2,978:08,89,003,3903/3/00039020,;7,33;007Q3Q,7,83/,,73 -3.3/042,23,.,3.8,;7,23,/03/Q9QQ,3,23,074,8,0003/10801L549;0058902442:,22,,72,-23,82Q/QQ2QQ3030070;083;077-:2:,22,,73/0,-2070/47:,5,32,83027092008000300/0-:/::843:8:05890244:,28,,303 -2082L-74:2,42,8/0,830/Q3,7::;0/300010801083/0,2,,7,QQ9,780.370//0920349,83/,43:39:,,/Q208/7:30/030090/3108010833/,90.-2/0-0307-702,9,509208,79./0/7,,;,/9,Q073/0300/307-,,23/,000,3843:.,:,707/0709Q2Q01,3-77Q3Q903-,709804/00347:38:,7-020800/0/7::/893,/,3/:3:30708:,9,3207,209789,33

47Q8Q//093,2:,142,47:3/,4/::,3,23,078000/0/3L9,78090044,2,,,919,-::32,2,:8:8:3/,/,9/7,3.,43/,,058902440/323-0307843:,7,:,2,880-0-043:307090843:8:,2,07/02-7,948,8,/0.00800.07379-,8092002093/070903/0207,43:8:/:707,3/,30;70380909,37.4,,;:7:,52,83,,738,2789,3,,3Q90708,5039,2/,00-0/0843:8:/3720/0307:090,00.3070909Q;00800.00;80,/,3/04/::,3,23,07





//078--74,,79,7,13/,3000;0-7,.,3.47:2,9,-9:92,,00972,7.,070000302Q/,1,,,7349,83/,0907804,7,:30-2,,7,7.,/,/0890032-782/73.,-0-/2,/,7,0300.3388902343944/Q02/09:9,7-703/03/QQ3Q2084/::843:.:3,:,,34,;,7/7-71,/008020070780,/4:,7020;.:94,30309,74,,7,3,,9:8:Q/Q7,39083/0,/,,7,.4,,739083/003Q-74,.,4:,32,207,3-79,7

49:73:3,,93,70079,78034,-20834,8,22,,0730704/::,-:0/0.04:78,4;,94,,2Q90,5-0-702/0-::32,2Q2Q3/Q79,7/4,,97,-7,2,/4,9,7800970208:7,/,9020007/77,9,78034,8,2,,070 -,24:542,/,/,03,3/,389,9Q4/,37,/,45:,734::3/,030,3,2/,0;80079Q7/039,713;0,,0/.-7070;0339,78030/03843:83;0,,3,23-0705 -070200.09Q2Q0309/0/7:43:/,00203Q07301L4,7,,/,7,7,7,73/30280,/,3-0-7,3,2,8,54,-2007,99,0290,3,2243:2,7,07020077304,7,89070-7,3, ,,2-03474%0%209,9#02,38422039,74390099079490#42,38.,4.,4&3;0789!7088,/4:,3%04709.,793843/434393::2,/4:,3 03,3/ ;039 43/434393::2

,/4:,3$9!,:%04:3/,94341&3;078,82$9,3147/$9,3147/&3;0789!7087.-0.4004310703.0390/0,41422:3824330(..0880/995--,.:-308.422:38205447907070/07007893!48924/073!4845,33' ,9924#0307,7/,3/$,;4043/434393::24:3,8489,8%0,3,.0841:2,39,7,382!,7708,:2-07:30: 0,3/90#0,00 39073,943,4:73,410 $9:/08330(;,,-0995089:/08473/0558,79.0;0,7/9.,0,3/0739434 2570,7;,7/,7;,7/&3;0789!708800%0!48454189474330(..0880/9952,789847,7.;0004788947,,90,,,3/08 9.841' 403.043/43!:94!708878./,2%00,/08907%00#05:-.4330(..0880/995937.428947*573992/,1.-/,001

,40/43 !7,.9.0,3/4397,/.94343/43'0784#4-07984333%0!4845.,#44984190,7,:33431.94330(..0880/9952,7898477010703.0,7.;0-,:33-474-079843,3392$,72,8 ,907,82%4/,,7,99074330(..0880/995/,72,9907478902,907,8294/,$9,.0%%0!48454100$8902,9. 5489434;07!:-.,9438//07,9,3030,40841110703.0,25,3&3;078941348!70880$,;4 03389089:70%4/,,38990!45:89%0259,9433 033#04,/0/%4,7/8, !49.841%7:9/8$0-,89,3:/03$9,984:;0,8,3/$,;40:7,2,3/43/43:0&3;0789!70880$,;4%0!,7,,' 043/43%!70880$,;4%0!:5509,3/90,71%0!07;078047041789,3943/43%!70880$,;4%0%.8$:-0.990,-8039.0397041549.,4394443/43'0784

Documents

Nathan Coombs - Hıristiyan Komünistler İslami Anarşistler