68
Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

Medtronic CoreValve® System Summary of Clinical Experience

UC201402534 EE

Page 2: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Background on aortic stenosis (AS) and introduction to transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI)

• Overview of the CoreValve clinical portfolio

• CoreValve clinical performance– All-cause Survival– Efficacy– Other Outcomes

Agenda

Page 3: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Background• Aortic Stenosis (AS) is the most prevalent native valve disease1

• More than 300,000 patients have severe AS worldwide

• The mortality rate for untreated severe AS is up to 50%-60% within 2 years of the onset of severe symptoms

1Carabello BA, et al. Lancet 2009; 373:956-66

Page 4: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Treatment of Severe Aortic Stenosis

• Surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) is the gold standard for treatment of severe AS

• However, 33% of all patients ≥75 years of age with severe AS are declined for surgery1

• The mortality rate associated with SAVR increases substantially if certain comorbidities are present

– Left ventricular dysfunction

– Previous cardiac operations

– Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

– Liver or renal failure

– Frailty1lung B, et al. Eur Heart J. 2005; 26(24):2714-2720

Page 5: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) is a viable treatment strategy for AS patients at high or extreme surgical risk

• TAVI has demonstrated significant survival improvements compared to medical management in inoperable patients in the PARTNER B trial1

• High risk patients receiving TAVI had similar survival rates to SAVR in the PARTNER A trial2

Treatment of Severe Aortic Stenosis

PARTNER B PARTNER A1Kapadia , et al., presented at TCT 2012 2Kodali S, et al., presented at ACC 2012

Page 6: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

The Medtronic CoreValve System

• The Medtronic CoreValve® System has been implanted in more than 45,000 patients in more than 60 countries worldwide.

• Self-expanding nitinol frame• Tri-leaflet porcine pericardial tissue valve with supra-annular function• Four sizes (23, 26, 29, and 31 mm) to fit aortic annuli ranging from 18 to 29 mm • 18-Fr delivery catheter for all valve sizes• Delivery from a transfemoral, subclavian, or direct aortic approach

Page 7: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

CoreValve® System Clinical ExperienceMedtronic CoreValve

Clinical Research Portfolio

Demonstrate Safety and Efficacy

Expand Access to New Populations and Markets

Confirm Efficacy and Optimize Practice

Page 8: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

CoreValve® System Clinical ExperienceMedtronic CoreValve

Clinical Research Portfolio

References at end of presentation

Page 9: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

CoreValve® System Clinical ExperienceNational CoreValve Registries

References at end of presentation

Page 10: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

All-cause Survival

Page 11: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• When comparing all-cause survival across data sets, it is important to remember that many variables can influence a given rate.

• Baseline characteristics, patient selection practices, operator experience, complication management techniques, and in the case of registries, reporting practices, all play a role.

• Comparisons across data sets should be used to convey general trends, not to derive specific conclusions regarding TAVI devices.

All-cause Survival

Page 12: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Chiam, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Meredith, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 5Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013 4Rueck, et al., presented at London Valves 2012; 5Tamburino, et al., Circulation 2011; 123: 299-308; 6Moat, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 58(20): 2130-38; 7Godino, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol Intv 2010; 3: 1110-21; 8Avanzas, et al., Rev Esp Cardiol 2010; 63(2): 141-8; 9Bosmans, et al., ICVTS 2011; 12: 762-7; 10Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15

All-cause Survival │ 30-day National Registries and Medtronic Sponsored Studies

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

CoreValve

Page 13: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Meredith, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 2Rueck, et al., presented at London Valves 2012; 3Tamburino, et al., Circulation 2011; 123: 299-308; 4Avanzas, et al., Rev Esp Cardiol 2010; 63(2): 141-8; 5Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 6Bosmans, et al., ICVTS 2011; 12: 762-7; 7Moat, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 58(20): 2130-38; 8Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15

All-cause Survival │ 1 Year National Registries and Medtronic Sponsored Studies

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

CoreValve

Page 14: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

All-cause Survival │ 1 Year Rigorous Industry-Sponsored TAVI Studies

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

All routes

1Meredith, et. al. presented at TCT 2012; 2Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 3Leon, et. al. presented at ACC 2013; 4Smith, et al. N Engl J Med 2011; 364: 2187-98; 5Leon, et al. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 1597-1607

Page 15: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

All-cause Survival │ 1 Year Select Contemporary Data Sets

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

All routes

1Meredith, et. al. presented at TCT 2012; 2Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 3Windecker, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 4Leon, et. al. presented at ACC 2013; 5Smith, et al. N Engl J Med 2011; 364: 2187-98; 6Leon, et al. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 1597-1607

Page 16: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

All-cause Survival │ 1 YearNational Registries and Post-Market Approval Studies

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

1Tamburino, et al., Circulation 2011; 123: 299-308; 2Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 3Windecker, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 4Moat, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 58(20): 2130-38; 5Thomas, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 6Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15

All routes

Page 17: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

The Italian registry1 and the Canadian registry2 have reported longer-term survival data on patient subsets

1Ussia, et al., Eur Heart J 2012; 33: 969-976; 2Rodes-Cabau, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2012; 60(19): 1864-75

All-cause Survival │ Longer-Term(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

Page 18: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Efficacy• New York Heart Association (NYHA) Class status in the

ADVANCE study

• Health related quality of life (HRQoL) in the ADVANCE study

• Hemodynamics– 1-year CoreValve performance in the ADVANCE study– 3-year CoreValve performance in the Italian Registry

Page 19: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Efficacy │ New York Heart Association Class (NYHA)

The ADVANCE study demonstrated significant improvement in functional status at 1 month post-TAVI, which was sustained to 1 year

1Linke et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 20: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Efficacy │ Health Related Quality of Life6-month Outcomes from the ADVANCE Study

The ADVANCE study demonstrated significant improvements in post-TAVI quality of life using multiple measurement tools

1Bosmans, et al., presented at TCT 2012

Page 21: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Linke, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

Hemodynamics │ CoreValve ADVANCE Study

The ADVANCE study has demonstrated that the CoreValve EOA and mean gradient remain stable out to 1 year

Page 22: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Hemodynamics │ Italian CoreValve Registry

1Ussia, et al., Eur Heart J 2012; 33: 969-76

The Italian Registry has demonstrated that the CoreValve EOA and mean gradient remain stable out to 3 years

Page 23: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Safety• Acute outcomes in the ADVANCE study

• Long term safety measures

Page 24: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Safety │ Acute OutcomesThe ADVANCE Study

The ADVANCE study shows that procedural complications are rare during CoreValve implants

1Linke, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 25: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

a Change in NYHA function resulting from intrinsic valve abnormality resulting in stenosis or regurgitation.

Safety │ Long-Term OutcomesMedtronic Foundational Studies

Two foundational CoreValve studies report no unexpected valve malfunctions or structural deterioration out to 4 years after implant

1Gerckens, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2011; 2Gerckens, et al., presented at ESC 2011

Page 26: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Procedural Success

Page 27: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Procedural SuccessNational Registries and Medtronic Sponsored Studies

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

CoreValve

1Chiam, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Moat, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 58(20): 2130-38; 3Meredith, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 4Avanzas, et al., Rev Esp Cardiol 2010; 63(2): 141-8; 5Bosmans, et al., ICVTS 2011; 12: 762-7; 6Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15; 7Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 8Rueck, et al., presented at London Valves 2012; 9Tamburino, et al., Circulation 2011; 123: 299-308;

Page 28: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Major Vascular Complications• Definition

• Predictors

• Incidence

Page 29: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• According to VARC 1, Major Vascular Complications include all complications that can be caused by a wire and/or are related to vascular access, which lead to death, need for significant blood transfusions, unplanned intervention, or irreversible end-organ damage:

• The VARC 2 definition2 downgraded unplanned intervention during the index procedure to a minor vascular complication, except if it was associated with qualifying consequences.

VARC 1 Definition1

• Ventricular perforation• Aortic dissection or

rupture• Iliofemoral dissection

or rupture• Pseudoaneurysms• Closure failure

1Leon, et al., J Am Coll Card 2011; 57 (3): 253-69; 2Kappetein, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol 2012; 60: 1438-54

Major Vascular Complications │ Definition

Page 30: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Femoral artery calcium score2, 4

• Female gender1

Patient-Related Factors

• Sheath to femoral artery ratio (SFAR)2

• Vessel tortuosity4

• Learning curve2

• Complication management3

• Percutaneous closure device failure5

• Patient selection3

Anatomical Factors Procedural Factors (Device / Operator)

1Genereux, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2012; 60(12): 1043-52; 2Hayashida, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol Cardiovasc Int 2011; 4(8): 851-8; 3Webb, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 4Vavuranakis, et al. Cardiovasc Ther 2013; epub; 5Cockburn, et al., Cath and Cardiovasc Interv 2012; 79: 143-49

Major Vascular Complications │ Predictors

Page 31: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Major Vascular Complications │ Predictors

1Van Mieghem, et al., Am J Cardiol 2012; 110(9): 1361-7

Effect of sheath size: the PRAGMATIC initiative showed patients treated with a 22F or 24F delivery sheath had significantly more vascular complications than

patients treated with smaller caliber devices(green bar represents Sapien, yellow is a mixture of Sapien XT and CoreValve)

Page 32: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Fearon, et al., presented at ACC 2013; 2Hayashida, JACC Card Int 2011; 4(8): 851-8; 3Nuis, Am J Cardiol 2011; 107: 1824-1829; 4Toggweiler, JACC 2012; 59(2): 113-8

Effect of learning curve: four studies confirm that increased operator experience decreases the incidence of major vascular complications

Major Vascular Complications │ Predictors(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

Page 33: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Major vascular complication rate can be impacted by variables unrelated to the TAVI device (e.g., patient selection practices, operator experience and technique, complication management strategy, percutaneous closure device function, reporting practices in the case of registries).

• Examining outcomes over the wider clinical experience may lessen the impact of any one of these variables and provide a sense of TAVI device performance.

• However, it is important to be mindful that all of these factors do contribute to the incidence of major vascular complications and should be considered when doing incidence comparisons across studies.

Major Vascular Complications │ Incidence

Page 34: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Linke, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15; 3Meredith, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 4del Valle, et al., presented at London Valves 2012; 5Ussia, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2012

Major Vascular Complications │ IncidenceRegistry Data on CoreValve According to VARC 1

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

Page 35: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Leon, et al., presented at ACC 2013; 2Fearon, et al., presented at ACC 2013; 3Sack, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 4Linke, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 5Treede, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 6Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15; 7Meredith, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 8del Valle, et al., presented at London Valves 2012; 9Ussia, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2012

Major Vascular Complications │ IncidenceSelect Data Sets Reporting According to VARC 1*

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

Page 36: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Aortic Regurgitation (AR)• Definition

• Predictors

• Incidence– Select Studies– CoreValve ADVANCE Study Outcomes

• Clinical Impact

Page 37: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Aortic regurgitation (AR) can be transvalvular (central), paravalvular (PVL) or both.

Total AR = PVL + Transvalvular Leak

• What is clinically relevant is the total volume of flow through the valve

Image courtesy of Dr. J. Sinning, University of Bonn

Aortic Regurgitation │ Definition

Page 38: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Calcified annulus (commissures, cusps, landing zone)3,4

• Male gender2,3

• Renal failure2

• Peripheral vascular disease1

• NYHA Class IV3

Patient-Related Factors

• LVOT-AO angle1

• Large annulus2

• Elliptical annulus3

• LVOT diameter5

• Transfemoral approach9

• Implant depth1,5,8

• Learning curve6

• Cover index (patient-prosthesis mismatch)4,5,6,7

Anatomical Factors Procedural Factors (Device / Operator)

1 Sherif, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol 2010; 56: 1623-9 ; 2Abdel-Wahab, et al., Heart 2011; 97: 899-906; 3Unbehaun, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol 2012; 59: 211-21; 4Gripari, et al., Heart 2012; 98: 1229-1236; 5Italy: Petronio, et al. The Italian CoreValve Registry. TCT 2012; 6Detaint, et al., J Am Colll Cardiol Intv 2009; 8: 821-7; 7Santos, et al., Eur H J Cardiovasc Img 2012; 13: 931-37; 8Chorianopoulos, et al., J Interven Cardiol 2012; 25: 174-179; 9Van Belle, et. al. Peri-valvular Aortic Regurgitation in Balloon-expendable and Self-expendable TAVI procedures: Predictors and Impact on clinical outcome - Insights from the FRANCE2 Registry; TCT 2012

Aortic Regurgitation │ Predictors

Page 39: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Effect of approach: FRANCE 21 and PARTNER2,3 demonstrate that the transfemoral approach (TF) results in approximately 50% more total AR

than the transapical (TA) approach

Aortic Regurgitation │ Predictors

1Van Belle, et. al., presented at TCT 2012; 2Kodali, et al., presented at TCT 2012;3Dewey, et. al., presented at TCT 2012;

Page 40: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Images of increasing levels of valve calcification1

Mechanism of PVL in calcified valves2

Aortic Regurgitation │ PredictorsEffect of calcification: heavy calcification may prevent perfect

apposition to the native annulus, increasing the risk of PVL

1John, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol Intv 2010; 3: 233-43; 2Sinning, et al, J Am Coll Cardiol 2012; 59: 1134-41

Page 41: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Mechanism of PVL in deep implant1

Mechanism of PVL in shallow implant1

Aortic Regurgitation │ PredictorsEffect of implant depth: appropriate implant depth minimizes potential flow

around the valve skirt. With CoreValve, a depth of 4-6 mm is currently recommended to minimize paravalvular leak.

1Sinning, et al, J Am Coll Cardiol 2012; 59: 1134-41; 2Tchetche, et al., EuroIntervention 2012; epub

Page 42: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

CoreValve ADVANCE | Aortic Regurgitation

Page 43: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

CoreValve ADVANCE | Paravalvular Leak

Page 44: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

CoreValve ADVANCE | Transvalvular Regurgitation

Page 45: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• ASE / ESC guidelines, which are also recommended by VARC, are typically used to grade the severity of AR using echo. – NOTE: Until VARC 2, there was no consensus for measuring paravalvular leak in transcatheter

valves.

• Standardized criteria can be open to interpretation. It is important to verify that the severity grading criteria are the same when comparing AR across studies. – Is “mild” AR included in the study-specific definition of “significant” AR?

• In addition to the semi-quantitative nature of AR grading, intraobserver variability and variable baseline and procedural characteristics make it very difficult to do a robust comparison of AR across studies.

• Medtronic- and Edwards-sponsored TAVI studies apply similar echo criteria to grade the severity of AR, making it reasonable to compare the outcomes of these studies.

• It is difficult to draw strong conclusions about a TAVI device by doing cross-study comparisons.

Aortic Regurgitation │ Incidence

Page 46: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Aortic Regurgitation │ Incidence at 1 YearSelect Contemporary Data Sets

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

1Leon, et. al. presented at ACC 2013; 2Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 3Leon, et al. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 1597-1607; 4Smith, et al. N Engl J Med 2011; 364: 2187-98; 5Windecker, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 47: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Paravalvular Leak (PVL) │ Incidence at 1 YearSelect Contemporary Data Sets

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

1Leon, et. al. presented at ACC 2013; 2Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 3Leon, et al. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 1597-1607; 4Smith, et al. N Engl J Med 2011; 364: 2187-98; 5Windecker, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 48: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Paravalvular Leak (PVL) │ Incidence at 1 YearSelect Contemporary Data Sets—Transarterial Cohorts

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

1Leon, et. al. presented at ACC 2013; 2Kodali, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 3Linke, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 4Leon, et al. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 1597-1607; 5Treede, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 49: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

*At discharge

Aortic Regurgitation* │ Clinical ImpactMedtronic CoreValve ADVANCE Study

1Linke, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 50: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Stroke• Predictors

• Timing

• Incidence

Page 51: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• History of CABG1

• History of stroke3,5

• Coronary artery disease3

• Peripheral vascular disease5

• Baseline NYHA class3

• Chronic atrial fibrillation5

Late Stroke (30 days to 1 year after TAVI)

• Female gender1

• Surgical cutdown for access1

• New onset atrial fibrillation2

• Baseline aortic regurgitation 3+2

• Smaller aortic valve area3

• COPD4

• BMI <25 kg/m4

• Multiple implant attempts4

• Valve dislodgement5

• Balloon post-dilatation5

Early Stroke (within 30 days of TAVI)

1 Bosmans, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Nuis, et al., Am J Cardiol 2012; 109: 1637-43; 3Miller, et al., J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2012;143(832-843): e13; 4Stortecky, et al., EuroIntervention 2012; 8: 62-70; 5Nombela-Franco, et al., Circulation 2012; 126(25): 3041-53

Stroke │ PredictorsRisk factors of early stroke tend to implicate embolization of annular debris,

while risk factors of late stroke point to comorbid conditions.

Page 52: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Stroke │ Type and Timing

The ADVANCE study showed that most strokes fall within 30 days of TAVI. However, due to their multi-morbid conditions, TAVI patients remain at risk for stroke long after

their procedure.

1 Bosmans, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

30-day Stroke Rate in ADVANCE: 3.0%

Page 53: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

In the ADVANCE study, the overall stroke rate was low and remained relatively stable over time

Stroke │ Rate over Time

1 Bosmans, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 54: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Multicenter registry data on 4,563 patients indicate that CoreValve has a historically low stroke rate, staying below 4.5% for any given cohort. It appears there is minimal learning

curve effect for this outcome.

Arrows indicate implant period and the reported rate of total stroke for the CoreValve cohort

Stroke │ Learning Curve

Page 55: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Stroke rate is strongly impacted by patient comorbidities, and the timing of stroke events may indicate different mechanisms at play.

• When doing a comparison of stroke rate across studies, it is important to remember that the baseline patient characteristics can vary greatly.

• It is very difficult to draw conclusions about the performance of a particular TAVI device when comparing the incidence of stroke rate across studies.

Stroke │ Incidence

Page 56: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Stroke │ Incidence at 30 DaysSelect Data Sets

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

1Leon, et al. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 1597-1607; 2Smith, et al. N Engl J Med 2011; 364: 2187-98; 3Thomas, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 4Leon, et al., presented at ACC 2013; 5Meredith, et al., presented at TCT 2012; 6Bosmans, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 57: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation (PPI)• Predictors

• Incidence

• Clinical Impact– Post-TAVI PPI– Post-TAVI Left Bundle Branch Block (LBBB)

Page 58: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• Right Bundle Branch Block (RBBB)2,3,4,5,7

• Other pre-existing conduction disturbances3,4,8,9

• Male gender3

• Age > 75 years9

• Previous MI3

Patient-Related Factors

• Variations in location of LBBB exit point1

• Septum thickness1,6

• Thickness of the non-coronary cusp1

• Implant Depth2,3,7

• Application of PPI guidelines10

• Learning Curve11

• Balloon Aortic Valvuloplasty8

• Radial force of the prosthesis3

Anatomical Factors Procedural Factors (Device / Operator)

More than 25 studies have been published on predictors of post-TAVI conduction disturbances (CDs) and permanent pacemaker implant (PPI)

1Jilaihawi, et al. Am Heart J 2009; 2Munoz-Garcıa, et. al. JACC CV 2012; 3Piazza et. al. EuroIntervention 2010; 4De Carlo , et. al. Am Heart J 2012; 5Calvi, et. al. JICE 2011; 6Saia, et. al. Cath Card Intv 2012; 7Fraccarao, et. al. Am J Card 2011; 8Khawaja, et. al. Circ 2011; 9Schroeter et. al. EuroPACE 2011; 10Wenaweser, et. al. presented at EuroPCR 2013; 11Meredith, et. al. presented at TCT 2012

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation │ Predictors

Page 59: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Tchetche, et al. EuroIntervention 2012; 2Munoz-Garcıa, et. al. JACC CV 2012; 3Piazza et. al. EuroIntervention 2010; 4De Carlo , et. al. Am Heart J 2012; 5Calvi, et. al. JICE 2011; 6Saia, et. al. Cath Card Intv 2012; 7Fraccarao, et. al. Am J Card 2011; 8van der Boon, et. al. Int J Card 2013;

Effect of implant depth: data from independent studies plotted on the same graph show the strong relationship between PPI

rate and implant depth

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation │ Predictors

Page 60: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

PPM rates in 6-mo blocks of pt enrollment, except most recent is 8-mo.

Enrolling centers: 6 9 10 10 10 10 10 10

Effect of learning curve: the rate of PPI in the CoreValve Australia-New Zealand Study decreased over time as operators gained experience

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation │ Predictors

1Muller, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 61: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Effect of PPI guideline use: varying 30-day pacemaker rates across geographies in the ADVANCE study may reflect

differences in the application of PPI guidelines

Countries with less than 15 implants not shown

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation │ Predictors

1Wenaweser, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013

Page 62: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

• The permanent pacemaker implantation rate can be impacted by variables unrelated to the TAVI device (e.g., baseline conduction disturbances, anatomical differences, clinician preference for prophylactic pacemaker use, and operator experience).

• These factors should be kept in mind when comparing the incidence of permanent pacemaker implantation across studies.

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation │ Incidence

Page 63: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

1Chiam, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Tamburino, et al., Circulation 2011; 123: 299-308; 3Brito, et.al., presented at TCT 2011; 4Gilard, et al. N Engl J Med 2012; 366: 1705-15; 5Moat, et al., J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 58(20): 2130-38; 6del Valle, et al., presented at London Valves 2012; 7Wenaweser, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013; 8Muller, et al., presented at EuroPCR 2013

Permanent Pacemaker Implantation │ IncidenceCoreValve Outcomes in National Registries and Studies

(independent studies, not head-to-head comparisons)

Page 64: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Both the ADVANCE study1 and the Australia-New Zealand Study2 showed no impact of a new permanent pacemaker implant on mortality

1Wenaweser, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Muller, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013

Permanent Pacemaker Implant │ Clinical Impact

Page 65: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

LBBB Post-TAVI NO Mortality Impact

Houthuizen, et. al. Circulation 2012, (N=679)

Urena, et. al. JACC 2012, (N=202)

De Carlo, et. al. AHJ 2012, (N=275)

LBBB Post-TAVI Mortality Impact

Patients not receiving permanent pacemaker before discharge.

Muller, et. al. EuroPCR 2013, (N=200)

Current Research is Inconclusive Regarding Mortality Impact of LBBB Post –TAVI

Left Bundle Branch Block │ Clinical Impact

Page 66: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Both the ADVANCE study1 and PARTNER2 showed no impact of a new LBBB on mortality

Left Bundle Branch Block │ Clinical Impact

1Wenaweser, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Nazif, et al. Presented at ACC 2013

Page 67: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

Both the ADVANCE study1 and the Australia-New Zealand Study2 showed no significant adverse effect of a new LBBB at discharge on

the mean LV ejection fraction

1Wenaweser, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013; 2Muller, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013

Left Bundle Branch Block │ Clinical Impact

Page 68: Medtronic CoreValve ® System Summary of Clinical Experience UC201402534 EE

INTERNATIONAL. CAUTION—For distribution only in markets where CoreValve has been approved. Not approved in the USA or Japan. ©Medtronic, Inc. 2013. All Rights Reserved. Non destiné au marché français.

References for slides 8, 9, and 541. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT012409022. Buellesfeld L, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 57: 1650-7.3. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01586910 4. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT016754405. Meredith IT, et al. Presented at TCT 20126. Medtronic CoreValve Japan Trial, protocol MDT-21117. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT015313748. Linke A, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2013.9. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT0162487010. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT0167672711. France II Registry. Eltchaninoff H, Presented at TVT 201312. Italian Registry. Ussia GP, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 201213. Italian Registry. Petronio AS, et al., Presented at TCT 2012.14. Israel Registry. Kornowski R, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2012.15. UK Registry. Moat NE, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011; 58: 2130-8.16. UK Registry. Moat NE, et al. Presented at TCT 2012.17. Belgian Registry. Bosmans J, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 201218. Bosmans J, et al., Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 2011; 12(5): 762-7.19. Brazilian Registry. Brito FS, et al. Presented at TCT 2011.20. Spanish Registry. Avanzas P, et al., Rev Esp Cardiol. 2010;63:141-8.21. Milan Registry. Buchanan GL, et al. Presented at EuroPCR 2012.22. Asia Registry. Chiam P, Presented at EuroPCR 2013.23. del Valle R, et al., Presented at PCR London Valves 201224. Ruck A, et al., Presented at PCR London Valves 201225. Figulla H, et al., Presented at TCT 201226. GARY, Mohr F, Presented at ACC 201327. German TAVI Registry: Sinning, et al., Am Heart J 2012; 164: 102-110.e1

CoreValve® is a registered trademark of Medtronic CV Luxembourg S.a.r.l.