39
8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 1/39 ,782/00;09$47:3:  1@,  :8948 0;09:8:3:3%,780$07Q;03 ,7 ;030839,780 2,907,2 -280-790474,7,09720073/03 3.0 38,3 945:2,733 0;72 ;0 /0;093 4::2: 43:8:3/, ,/, ,9 /QQ3.083/04--089,3 000,/,7 479, -79,7 ,3,00203/0801 /0,23Q7Q3Q4,3-:9,7,3,3,70/0;093.08945:2/4,945:2 9:9:;0Q/Q073,24/::0708307080,78,;,2,3/0-::3/:: :88,42,,3-7945:2/:8,/0;09-:/Q038Q0020333/0309032  -7Q7Q0/3Q2089:9:;0Q/Q073,2,8,3,23,02090/,/0 /0;09:88,-7;,7;,78,,338,33479,;04091,,23303Q80;003 843,,2,8,-:0/20/ ,933 8,8, /QQ3.0 9,73/0 /0;09 4/:: - 9,71 0/03 070 /QQ3Q707/03,.,;09:9:3/,,2,.,:,,-203 /0,/0;09 24/007 30703 /4, :: :7,2.,73, 4--08 #4:880,: ,39,/,7 9Q2 /0,89 /QQ3Q707 38,33 ,, ::3 -7 ,,2 8Q7/Q70-0.0 90 073 /0;09 4/:: 173/0 -:::47,7/ 0;09 4:8:3:3 945:2,73 ,,23/, 74Q3Q3 ;0 9,790 0733 -0 ,,32,8 0-0990 /0;093.08 945:2: 4:28: -7 ,,2,/0;098038,3,330;72843:.:3/,:,,34:2:-7,,2,4,7, 70310801/0,2/03,3,,347/: :/QQ3.09,7 2,31441:000-790/47::3,:,9003  ::  080108 3/0/0;09,79,3.,-7070,3-3.3,;7,/-79,, /,/0,-724/0307208/01,,90709,780,70093-7,;7,34,7, 8:3:2,9,/7,,-7/00 -:0;70380,3 /0;0990;Q.:9 -:2,8/0;093 :88,,2,8,3,23,02090/700./0;09-7032,//0434207 ,,3338;945:2:39Q2Q3Q072090;0-0.08;945:2:/0;0938,8, 945:2:3 3/0 0792090/7 003 /0;09 -7 ,3,2/, 945:2, 79Q03 ;0 945:2:303/84,3-7;,7,/3Q2090/7,3/0;098,8,00203,7,. 0-7:7:2-7,94,7,/0945:28,9,7800;7233,,2,.4,7, ,;7,32,9,;0-:/:7:2/,42:9,;08438:42,//,89,2,9,/7::8: -:/QQ3.0Q3-:7:;,945:28,020/079Q03 ;0 43,::3 /Q03 -7 10801 /QQ3.0/ : -,,2/, 003 :: 1080108 08,83/, -7  -:7:;,945:2;0-:7:;,/0;098,;:3:8:/:7 00 0-790/47:349,83,:,,3-:/0,899,7,3,,739,780 2,907,2 904783 0972080 -790 907830 0;7/ ,73 9,780 2,907,2 904783 4:9:72, ,-,8 003  :: 080108 3 009780 -,,7,,8437,,2,,7 ;0  2,3/0448 0/0;,2

Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 1/39

,782/00;09$47:3: 1@,

 :8948

0;09:8:3:3%,780$07Q;03

,7 ;0 3083 9,780 2,907,2 -280 -7 9047 4,7, 09720073/033.0 38,3 945:2,733 0;72 ;0 /0;093 4::2: 43:8:3/, ,/, ,9/QQ3.083/0 4--089,3 000 ,/,7 479, -7 9,7 ,3, 00203/0801/0,23Q7Q3Q4,3-:9,7,3,3,70/0;093.08945:2/4,945:29:9:;0Q/Q073,24/::0708307080,78,;,2,3/0-::3/:::88,42,,3-7945:2/:8,/0;09-:/Q038Q0020333/0309032 -7Q7Q0/3Q2089:9:;0Q/Q073,2,8,3,23,02090/,/0/0;09:88,-7;,7;,78,,338,33479,;04091,,23303Q80;003

843,,2,8,-:0/20/

,933 8,8, /QQ3.0 9,73/0 /0;09 4/:: - 9,71 0/03 070/QQ3Q707/03 ,.,;09:9:3/,,2,.,:,,-203 /0,/0;09 24/00730703 /4, :: :7,2.,73, 4--08 #4:880,: ,39 ,/,7 9Q2 /0,89/QQ3Q707 38,33 ,, ::3 -7 ,,2 8Q7/Q70-0.0 90 073 /0;09 4/::173/0 -:::47,7/ 0;09 4:8:3:3 945:2,73 ,,23/, 74Q3Q3 ;09,790 0733 -0 ,,32,8 0-0990 /0;093.08 945:2: 4:28: -7,,2,/0;098038,3,330;72843:.:3/,:,,34:2:-7,,2,4,7,70310801/0,2/03,3,,347/:

:/QQ3.0 9,72,3 1441:00 0-790/47::3,:,9003 :: 0801083/0/0;09,79,3.,-7070,3-3.3,;7,/-79,,/,/0,-724/0307208/01,,90709,780,70093-7,;7,34,7,8:3:2,9,/7,, -7/00 -:0;70380 ,3 /0;0990;Q.:9 -:2,8 /0;093:88,,2,8,3,23,02090/700./0;09-7032,//0434207,,3338;945:2:39Q2Q3Q072090;0-0.08;945:2:/0;0938,8,945:2:3 3/0 0792090/7 003 /0;09 -7 ,3,2/, 945:2, 79Q03 ;0945:2:303/84,3-7;,7,/3Q2090/7,3/0;098,8,00203,7,.0-7:7:2-7,94,7,/0945:28,9,7800;7233,,2,.4,7,,;7,32,9,;0-:/:7:2/,42:9,;08438:42,//,89,2,9,/7::8:-:/QQ3.0 Q3-:7:;, 945:28, 020 /079Q03 ;0 43, ::3/Q03 -7 10801 /QQ3.0/ : -,,2/, 003 :: 1080108 08,83/, -7 -:7:;,945:2;0-:7:;,/0;098,;:3:8:/:7

00 0 -790 /47: 349,83, :,,3 -: /0,89 9,7 ,3,,73 9,7802,907,2 904783 0972080 -790 907830 0;7/ ,73 9,7802,907,2 904783 4:9:72, ,-,8 003 :: 0801083 009780-,,7,,8437,,2,,7;0 2,3/04480/0;,2

Page 2: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 2/39

0/03 -: ,-,3,09,73 -:7:;, 945:2:3 043425493 009720 37942:,,2,7,2,8,7:3/7880/47:,:,7

,782/0945:2/0;09833-280,,3

,78;945:22,//0434207,,30/0;098,8,07,,3

,7,83/,003:7/::/0,8900972000-,,/3,70003 -:,,2 -Q9Q3Q0,3;0070-,,, 0/03-7,,2/003//,833 ,830 8; 945:2:4:,3/75 /Q03003 /0;09 /0 1,,9 /0;094:,3/75/Q030038;945:2/:

$; 945:2 Q709. Q073 -07 -7 02 ,,2,8 0783/0 -70073 2,//07330583-7/03:.,,7$;945:2-7,,2,339.,7;083,,,2339Q2Q3Q-7/03:.,,7;0-:-,2/,3/,0730,/,7/,7/,2094,7,03/34:7,2,;007/0/0;094,7,7Q9032047:3/,8,/,/0;09;0::8:,,7(

,79,7804,7,8;945:2:334::;008,8902033-,89,0,/,,3/0303 -0 ,0 4/::3: -079070 8; 945:2:3 -Q9Q3 9,73 0704.,

070 8,308 4/::3: 807 0;09 /0303 8,8, 4::2 /, 90 -: 8;945:2:3-,73/,003945:28,-Q2Q3Q3831,73;08312Q.,/000733/47:/,3 -7 Q7Q3Q 4,7, 9,7 8,30830 ,0297 $; 945:2, 70 3./070.0/0 ;0 -,2 -7 242039 4,3 /0;09 843 Q2020/0 -07003 /003/8-070303-7;,797,/0/0;09/0303:7:2945:28,0;728Q70.3303843,,2,8,/,2:9,;08438:-7;,742,5-079,7804:,73Q7Q3Q 4,7, 479,, 2 /42: ;0 43: ;,7 0/03 9,780 4:,7 479,/,3,93/,03/8/0479,/,3,,.,4,3200,0.-7:7:2/:7

,7 ;0 3083 097/ -: 9,780 2,907,2 ,3, 00 0 03 Q89349,83, :,,3 08 /4, :: 1080108 003033 -Q9Q380 -7 ,3990/

,83/, ,7 ;0 308 ,/, -:7:;, 8,8, /QQ3.0830 ,2 4,3 /0,891080100;09,7,3,3,,703/2,907,899,7,3,,730889024,7, 2,3 /04483/0 479,, 4/:,7 : 0807/0 945:28, -Q2Q3Q32Q09 -20733 831,73 ;0 831 00203 889020733 /0;09::/044 479,, 33 9,780 4:,7 2,907,89 9,7 ,3, 070;083/0,,32,9,/7 3,7 -: 0807 ,/,7 /302/0 08,8 4,7, ,933 9,7800;72 83 ;0 -: Q073/0 479,, ,3 04342945:28, :7::,734::2:3:3.000-207/30/0309,790479,,,32Q09-207;0Q7092 9,7,7 ,3/, 43,73 -,,39, 8,5 4/:,7 -07 ,9 02833 8:3/:: ;07070 837/ 902 2,3 /04483/0 /0 09703945:2,730;7202,8/,-:-,2/,3-07-78379,2,9,/7

 2,3 /04483/0 831 945:2:3 ;0 /0;093 4::2: 0 42Q3, 945:2:3 -,73/,-Q2Q3Q302Q093;02Q-,/00330208;0-:3:3843:.:3/,042Q3Q3QQ5/,2,8;042Q3Q3073831,7,707Q903203 -7 945:28, 47,3,843:3 ,2,8 /0 ,,37 ,7 ;0 3083 ,59 -:84:9,2, ,9/,831945:2,73;0/0;093479,, 339,7804:,73,3,2,2-,23/,3,3,9,7-77408,597:3,709457,9,02Q093;,7945:28,-Q2Q3Q32Q-,/0033;082Q7Q07330208;0-:

Page 3: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 3/39

9020/009042Q3,945:2:3QQ5/,2,8831;0/0;09945:2,033,794,7,7Q2090/7,7;03083 2,3/04483/0,59 -: 90859 ,933 9,780 0;72 83 ;0 /4,8, ,9 831 945:2,734::2:3: ,,2, -,23/,3 ::8: /47:/: 1,,9 4: :,7330283,,2,9,09078,47/:@Q3Q4:/,/0;093479,,;0 82Q7Q.Q 831 00203 8890233 :7::: 9457,9, 0 2Q093 ;,742,/-Q2Q;02Q-,/000733020/;009,7242Q30733;,73 8Q7/Q7/QQ 9,780 4:,7/, 070029 4:3:3 /0;09 -70800 2Q090 /,, -7080 82Q7Q Q073/0 /0 8,9 9,72 42Q307334091 82Q7Q208 Q073/0 Q802090/ :/:7:2,9:,733 0283/03 9,2,203 1, -7 9,780 0;72 833 ;,73, ,709 092090/D8904:/,:,7,,3831;0/0;09945:2,0,9/,33070/080 3.0 8 $Q207 ;0 87/, 070029 ,/0 ,933 0;728 38,3 945:2,733 023/0 0;703809,780 -7 24/0 /0 48, 48,/,,0/302/09,78,308302Q-7-24,-7/

 902 ,7 4: :,733 02 83 /0 0703 4 /,, 03 ;0,58,2 -7 9,7 ,2,83 /,, 8437, ,7/, ,5,7,-:08/070.097 ,59,23 03073 ,7,972, ;0 -:7:;, 945:2:3 04342 5493009720Q070,7379-:,58,29,7,2,87:3/78809,780 2,907,2 9047833 09720830 2:,,2 ,9 8,,297 ,7 -:,2,8, ,,7/,3 -,,,7, 4:: ;0 ,9 945:2,73 9,780 0;728332,907,899,7,3,070;083/0/,,9,2;0/,,2Q0220-7,,338,,297,7 4342!493097830,9/,-:,-,,733843:.:3:01,/00/47/:

7,972,,72/0;09-207,/,7::073/03003/073/0330/0//,0//-38,33330300;723/03,3,,2,,.,9,2907830-:073

0733003Q3;07,38/QQ3Q7073373030:,7,8;945:2,/,93/,945,/2,//;,74:,73/,-::3/:,7;08;945:2:3,3,942833 /004342 5493 3/0,7,32,80709 843:.:3, :,9 03070 8, Q7092 9,7 ,39, 104/, ;0 24/073 -:7:;, Q7092 9,7,7945:28,04342 0032033 070 /47: 003 ,,74,7, 39003/70-707 (

,7-,79,3:,7,$318945:2/,3831;0/0;09945:2,

,7 ;0 308 38,33 ;,09 ,3/,3 -,,5 :,7, :,3.,, /007/ 0;7007 38,33 , 9,7 3.084 ,7, ,/,3/77,7'0 -:/3023

9Q2Q3/0 ;,73 8Q7/Q703 9020 945:28, -723 03Q 831 ,79,73 ;0/0;093 ;,73 9,32,,3 0 42Q389 945:: 4/::3: -079707,,39, /4, 03 4,3 ,3 / 71 ,/09 ;- -7 Q0730 :7:,3 -:945::03Q-707007020203.-7945::9:7,709Q093  -2/0-:08318945::,7/,7Q03,7092Q09/74091945::2Q09

:2Q09-2 -7,3 ,; ;0 -,, ,;,3 0997200 ,/, /:7:2070977809,72,-0803/Q709230208330;70830::3/Q07(

Page 4: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 4/39

%45:28,0;723-:9,780,,2,83/,-Q2Q03Q50,00-297;0,03/0;,74,3/4,-Q2Q3Q3/,,/,0302083/03-,70997:,,2,/,,0 3/0 0 3Q1:8:3 ;0 9,,73 ,792,8, ;0 ,-007 ,7,88,;,,73 0302080 ,;, ,;, 07 7,-, ,3,73 -70208 ,3,7,7,8 0;032007 ;- 0 -790 -: 0 42Q3, 945:: ,3/,3 ,-00 ;0,-007 945:::3, /47: 0307 0 ;,7 -: 7Q90320 030 /0 ,7,-,073843.73,2,,3;0945:::3042Q389 ,583-42,,3 -7 7Q90320/7 8907 ,3 /Q03/0 ,83 890780 0305 ,-0 /Q030Q802 48:3 -: 0 42Q389 945:::3 3/0 30 0 2Q090 30 ,79831,7, 30 /0 /0;090 07 ;,7/7 0. 4,7, 07003 9457,3 2Q09945::,,99740912Q09 %45:::3Q084,3-70073,/,,00739457, Q073/0 0 2Q09 , 49:7 703 9457, Q073/0 ,3.,,7,7,32,,4,-7:,7,7,32,,333,79/,-703-7945:::3Q0842,8/770,3.,945::/4,2,9457,9,8,77:10/0-7%457,32Q093340914::3:3,387,-:42Q3073-,,73/,Q7092/040914,7, ,57 ,,73/, 80 945:: 9,7,13/,3 03/0730 9,88 0/03 9457,

 5,7,8Q073/0 ,007 -,28 Q7092 ,5,7,7 ;0 945:::3 9,. 4,3 143,7/380 ,307 9,53, ,52 8,;, ,7,7 0/0 Q7Q3 143,7 3 ;-,7/9,3 8437, ,,3 Q7Q3 ,9,07 ,0 -7007 ,7,83/, 5,,7 ,,9 07,Q7/, -:7,/, Q7092 42Q3 Q00733 03/ ;,7,73 ;0 /4,8,42Q3Q3;,738Q7/Q72003097

: 0 42Q3073 03 08 03 -,89 ;0 03 8,1 -4:2,2 -207 08 4:945:2,73/, 7Q03 ,7, 8,9 42Q307/7 ,59,2 3.08 9Q204342945:28, :7::,73 9,780 0333 47333 -: 0 8,942Q3 4/::3: -07903 ,7 -: 42Q3073 9,780 0;7230 3 4,7, :8,59,2,,5297

070/Q030 0/3/0 0 945:::33903 30 Q/0 /0970.0 09/8, 280.47,1180;- 4:,7,;0 945:::3Q/4, ,583, ;- ,3,7,90730-,/7(

 902 945:28, 0;72 8Q70.33 07 ,,2,,73/, 00 -,7-,79,3:,7,0,,2,83/,-:042Q3,945::473,,3/03-,,39,,583/,34/:,:,,2;0,58/00:7,24,7,,7,72,

,7 0709,72,0030 42Q3, 945:2,7/, 945::Q007339457,,;003/,7,,73/,073070Q1,72Q09-2;0Q1,742Q3,7Q90320 -2 ,79 0/07 :3,7/,3 -73.8 9457,3 2Q0933 -Q9Q3Q0

4091 4/::8,9 -2/7 3.8,933 ,39 ,3/, 7Q03 ;0 9457,Q073/00240912Q0902/0-708002Q09070339-2/7DQ3.Q8Q80 9457,9,-70802Q093Q89Q34/::07203-2/7,,9-:Q-2/0/0-7039457,Q073/0,//,0/0-2088907094,7,89078002Q094,7,3-7945:::32038:-:42,3,7997

: Q 0 42Q3, -2 /0 -,,39, 03Q 831 ,723, ;0 82Q7Q0 07;072003 09 945:2,7/7 DQ3/0 /0 Q70923 ,2,. 945:::3 ;,73

Page 5: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 5/39

8Q7/Q72097 ,3 /007 Q70920 -:7,/, -, -,3, -7 ,2, /0/7 %45::3/0 -Q2Q3/03 ,3,,3,3 -7 2Q-,/00 ;0 9.,709 1,,09 49:7 07945:::3 Q007 ,7,83/, -7 033 1,7,2,8 -,,297 ,2, 03Q82Q7Q0 4 ,2, -: @Q3Q 945:: Q08 07 -70 , /, ,0 -72 03/02033308304:,73,8,597;0-7-,,833020303/Q709233308304::,30097202970;,79,7307003/302073/0:,7,0,,2,83/,-:42Q3,945:2,7-7-73/031,70;728Q7007,,,7,030 -7-73/031,7831;0/0;09945:29507334::2:3,4,,.,,7/7

,73 ,7,972,,733-:43:/, 9,7-230,,3/7/ 4302 -7 01:/: ,7-,79,3 :,7, , /, 8318 945:2/,3 831 ;0 /0;09 945:2,0909,739,34/::-7/00-242:9:7:3,7/,3-73.84: :,733 3.8 80 ,9 :,733 0;72 83 ,3897 : ,3,2,3/, /0;093 4::2:3:3 /, -7 /0 1,7 4:3:3 -::3/::3:89072090/7

39 ,3 03980 42Q307 :3,3 ;0 #42, 0 79, @,3 -,,3.3/,07203742Q307,9330;728Q073/007,,3;0/4,8,,9950820003945::,7/:0742Q3,945:2:30;7202Q093:9:8:, 843:,32 ;0 /4,8, 07 945:2/,3 /, 0 2Q090 /,,831 ;0 /0;09 945:2,7 0. ;0 104/, /42:9:7 4:3:3 0;72 8Q073/0 07 ,,3 8,9 9,72 42Q307 80 /02083 -307.0 ;,7,738Q7/Q72Q07;0-::3/:,70707/04:/0854929,73/,831945:2,73 2,// 90203 4:9:72:,7/7 4:/, 831 945:2, 0,9/,33 907830 0 2Q09 90203/0 /0 4091 /0;09 2Q0990203/0 07009 4: 0 ,933 0;72 07 ,7,83/, -: 9,7801,73 2Q09 -207 Q7092 07 ;0 42Q3, 7Q903 9,73/,

1,79,3,3,,3/3010/03,7;03084/:,933 0;72 83 -07003 08,8 0903 9457,9, 0 2Q093 ;,7-Q2Q3Q3 ;0 2Q-,/0033 0208 ;0 -7080 82Q7Q3Q3 0 020:,3233 ,3,2,8 42:9:7 ,7 -: 0200 730 4,7, ,9330;728 Q073/007 ,,3;0,9 831 945:2,03 ,8 4:3:90280/03,39,303942Q3073,39:3,3;0#42,890770.945:2,3003;00. Q70929,73,0 820003,3942Q3, 945:::3 ;0,39Q7092 9,733 03 8,1 03 9,2 -23 #42, 9,73/0 -::7: :7,/, ,72,,30039945:::890/4,-78Q700/09,72.8,;,945::,73-74 ,7093 8020 4:, , /, 109 4:, -7 90 039 ,3/0

 -702083/03 4:2:9:7 8,9 42Q3070 3,,7,3 /,, ,7009 -7 ,,28Q7/Q703 ;0 /,, /0247,9 9,7/, 7Q9032 4,3 39 039 42Q3Q 02Q098,-Q7-700733QQ-7479,/:039890945:::3:3Q89Q3/0 4:/, 4/:: - ,79Q7Q30 0 4,3 :98, -7 ;,7 -7 Q89Q3945:: Q80 494790 49: 0393 479, ,7,733 07097/ 479, 020,7.,2,,7/3809703079,53,,528,;:32,8,;,,7;-3/3/,Q7 Q709.073 9457,3 0 2Q0930 8,5 -70073 ,7,99 ,79Q7Q3Q39Q2QQ709.07303/ 0073/0-72090/:,79Q7Q3-7242Q3 3/0-Q2Q3Q3 ;0Q7Q3073 2Q-,/00833 -7 0230 4 ,9 Q-,/0033

Page 6: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 6/39

0208 5,,7 3 Q7092 79,7, 9457, 8,50733 Q7092/0 ,3 0020 :,32,,73, 4 ,9 : 8Q70 -7 ,3/,3 945:2:3 Q007 Q7:799,,7,7,83/,033;0807;09-72-,23/,3-71,7,2,,7,9703/07 9,7,19,3 Q70923 9020 :38:7: ,30 003 0073 8,., ,792,83 ;0945:2:3 03 ,,-, 831 ,30 02083 8,,/ : /:7:2 08 0942Q3,0030073Q208;0945:2:303307;048:,70103/07;0007-23/0831,7,-Q3208,3,23,047/:

03Q70920790203/098,/03Q0303;000203,0003-QQ9457,;0 0 8,507 945:2: 03/ :7,,73, 70 03/03 7Q90200 790798,/03033;0QQ/Q07,2,945:23/08,.,,3,300207/98,/ 00203073 47:,-2007 3 98,/ 47,3,843:3 ,3 87, -7 -,,47,3,843,/,, 9,,7 ;,7/QQ 9457, ;00 8,50733479,,7,73 8,;:3,., 43,73 98,/ 0020333 8Q703 Q;03.0 ,93,,,., -7 47,3,843 0.0 00203 8313 /0;09 /0303 0 8,8,47,3,843:,0/

020 /0;09 /0303 -: 0 8,8, 47,3,843 :,73 ,9 023/0945:2:3 0 2Q090 /,, 82Q7Q 07 90203/0 831,7, -Q320833,32,-7843:.:4,7,9,78,30830297:-,,2/,,39:3,3;0#42,/, /0;09 -QQ 9457, ;0 0 8,50730 /,,32,9,/ ;0 -,9 -:831,73 7Q90/ 8,8, -7 47,3/ #42,33 0. 25,7,947: /0;092070-Q747,9 9,7/, 7Q9032 -7 /0;099 ;0 0 /0 42, 47:3/,/@Q3Q#42, 84:,733033,3, ,2,.9457, 109 ;0 1090/039457,,7 Q073/0 ,3 0 02030 /,, -QQ,91:3/,9,72/ :04342 00203 Q;03.0 ,93, ,,-0.0 -7 8,8, 00203 /0 2070/Q0/07Q9032-QQ-7,807-Q747,9,9/0;090709747/:

,9/,02Q0990203/0479,,,3831;0/0;09945:20230-7/07 73079,@,-,,3.3/,07203 42Q3Q3Q3QQQ0003 104/,07/7 : 07 07203 7 945::,733 07 ;0 8,;,,7 30/030/,2,8;0Q707203Q8Q3Q3,2,3,9457,3;0-7080-,2839707003-784:,783133,807072030107334947908,93,7208843:.:3/,4:2:9:7:88902/09457,32Q09Q2700707,78-23/07Q903284:-007380370739003/0/7'0-:9457,2Q09Q07,783/,104/,-0073479,39028092090/7Q0780-:104/,-007,783/, 50 4 QQ2QQ07 ,93/, -::3,3 -,2 Q709.07 ;0 80710743:2:3,/Q2Q07/7

79, @,3 104/, 9457, /Q03 -7-73/03 ,9 /, ,5, 070 945::,7,7,92904/,945:2:304342802/47:/,3Q709.0739,,73302/0-:070945::,7Q073/000203:72:4,3104/,-00739,,733,79Q7Q3 , /, ,79020 -23/0 ,7,32,8, 837 /4, -7 04342/04/, 945:2 08,8 4,7, 7/,3 ,7009099 3 -7-73/03 ,9 -7 0/000378,104/,/0;0907,7,92974,8,-:104/,/0;09#42,33/0;09- 2070/Q0/07Q903202507, -7/0;094,2,2 ;0 -: 070

Page 7: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 7/39

04342945:28, -723 03 80713 82Q7Q2083 104/, -007 030Q;03.0,93,,,-0.0/Q0/0-77Q9QQ0837,297

020:,73,9023/03.002Q093;02Q-,/0033209,0733 479,, 3 8437, -: 9020/0 945:2:3 831,7, -Q32083 ;03,09 /0;09/0303 8,8, 00203 ,933 9,7 8,30830 37Q47:8,:,734:95023/0002038313;0/0;0934::2:41,7 -7 9020/0 0297 4:3:3 ,39 ,,73/, 7303$Q207 Q083/0 0887/,3/89,3/,@3/0!07890;-479,,,3/0;0907,9/,4/::- -70800 2Q09 ;0 -7080 82Q7Q 07 0 82Q7Q8QQ073/0 /04091 945:: 2Q09 ;0 4091 82Q7Q 07 Q073/0 Q80/ 4:945:2:3:300203831-708002Q090/,,82Q7Q0790203/0/0 -,,39, ,2:8, 0;073 ,.,2,8 ;0 -: 0;07 0730 0970370;073 70; 09073 82Q7Q 09830 /3Q9Q72007 843:.:3/, 479,,,7

4:/085492%45:2:320973/,30103/30

,7 -7 /0;09 95 4,7, 4: 08549233 /,,3/ 04342 90208,9 Q7092 9,73/, -::7 ,7, 70 -: Q7092 9,7 /,, 02 Q7092390207 8,083/0Q7092/0-7,798,,35 0 7945::,73/0/Q03 -7Q70921,,8,79Q7Q3-7200-,,/,2,3479,,,7:945::,7/, -07 /Q0/002 -7 -Q2Q ;,7/7%,72, 0 ,3,,9,7,7297 1,,9,3,2,3/,-7-7904:9:7:7,73945::3/09,72,0,3,,9,733 -:0/0-7-739,2,2,2,8;0/08900208-:945::,7079Q7Q9,.303/8,7,,303/3009078018:-89,33945::,7,300977:7,/,04342 -72 945:: 3/0 ,0 , /, -70/0 945:::3 03/ 4091;,7/7 ,7 -: 945::,73 03/03Q70923 ;0 ,79Q70923 -Q9Q3

4:,7303/3/0-,73/7/,73,/,9007;08,9Q70929,73390 -:,5,7,/,,3/3-0797

03/ ,92,7 3/0 ,3 ,3, -7 ,,2 8Q7/Q703 -: 8, QQ 742Q30733 -7 , ,0 010733 4:9:7/:: -7 20.8 9,7,13/,3 , /, -7 -QQ01/085499,7,13/,390280/2090;0945:28,494790/0-:3,70,4/0247,9,/,/08549-2070-Q7Q32090/7

,7, 70  8, 95 -7 9020 Q073/0 Q8003 -2073 4:3/, -Q9Q3 -:QQ 945::,73 Q89Q3/0 07 ,,3-Q9Q3097. -7 Q89Q3 ;0, 030 2Q 8,-4,7, 070 945::,7 80 27,8 4:, 9457, :,32, ,3, 8,5

0907 4,7, Q2090/7(020 /,, 03Q /0;09 9,2 :38:7,7,479,, 2,/,3 3.0 -: QQ 7 945::,733 -73 9028 0/03 -7 Q8947,3,843 03/3/03 4:2: /:7:2/,/7 : /:7:2/, 2Q093 0708,-Q03 -:Q89Q3 945:: 010720.8 ,/,-7 /085499457,3:,32,3 3.0 ,99, 78, .02,,9070 ;077 -:QQ .02,,907 /0 -: , 03/Q00730 ,0 -720730 9,88 0/0707:7,/, Q89Q3 945:::3 9457,3 0708,- 4,7, Q208 ,9 945::,7., /, 43, 7Q7 : /:7:2/, /47:/,3

Page 8: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 8/39

Q709.43:2:3/,4,3,9 945::,73,7,99,7,79Q7Q3Q3-78233-739028.881,9,Q89945::,,9,72,80030,3,7

, 04549,2,/, $Q207 /0303Q0/0 /0;093 -073/0 30 ,8, 308,-,8Q.Q30/0-Q747,8;,7/Q9Q3,9945::,732,,42Q3073-73 820003 -7 Q89Q3-79/0;09,3-,,39, 02033070,3,23/, -7 /0;09 /0/ -: Q89 -7 2, 00.090 4:,., 4,3 4:9,73/,/08549/0;093-77Q02/

,73-:8,9Q70929,790203/0831,73;0/0;0934::2:3:,,,38,97,73027:3/7880/002 ,59, /0-::7:4:0233QQQ3Q,790/03349,-QQ,2:8,0737Q90320890203/0479,,,30;80-Q2Q3Q3 4 ,9 831,2,/7 ,7 -: -Q2Q 843:.:3/, 479,, ,3,2:8,70;0738437,/,33,8/3Q070-782Q7Q098304,93,/,9007:/3QQ2/08549-79/,73/0;09-23/07Q9033/0842:9,378,,7/,&,4:/,3/89,3@3;079,4:/,$Q20787-QQ8:,2,9,72347:3:/2070,2:8,70;07/0700703-7/0;093/4::3:;0 831 945:2,73:,7,734::2:3: 8,,297308/0 39Q73 /0-:945:28,70;098333,84:5/,-782Q7Q09830/3Q0-/;0945:2:32093/07030733,84:5/,945:2:30103/07,30 0/ Q073/0 /:7:7 020 8,9 9,7/, -7 /0;09 4::2:3:3,3,3/,945:28,0;07Q890303073945:2,783/,07,,32,8;0 /070 -: 0;07 0730 09703073 -70070 00203 -7 831 4:9:72,,7070,9,7(

,73 /03/ Q070 8,9 9,72 42Q307 Q073/0 4:,3 ;0 -,3/, -7/08549:3 -::3/:: Q89Q3 945:: 309. 7:5 -7 ,3/,3 945:28, -7143843 0730 097703 90 ,3/,3 -: 1438430 09830 /,,3,7, 04/::,79Q7Q3Q,2,33/0,782Q00109070/3Q9Q72090;0Q -7 82Q7Q -2 ,7,92,9,/7 309. 7:-:3 -: 00203 43:2:3:8Q7/Q70-208 3 ,78 2Q0010907 ,. ,0 097208 ;0 -: ,2,,8,8,807::/044-7,5/0;097Q9020807047/:020 -:7,/,8,95Q70929,73,.,97,390201,97,99,03/30090709,72 42Q30733 Q073/0 /08549 2070 -7 /0;09 9/,733 4:2,8/708549/0;0934::2:3,/,90033083-7,20/7

:/0;09 9/,7,733 -2 /0 -7 ,3 3 945::,73 9,7,13/,34:,3/778,33,7,,73/,;0#:8,7/,4/::-42Q3Q39457,479,,,05-9,/,/080,7,7,0070-0,2,38Q70073;07/-:3:3843:.:4,7,

/,9457,302Q093303Q:7:2,/ 0707/0 -:/0;09 9/,7 /08549: -23/0479,,47(

,/08,9Q70929,74:/08549::953/0-7/0;099/,73/,3-,28/QQ3Q02009,7242Q30733Q70924:,73/04:,38,9Q70929,7 ,3., 2:9, ;0 90 -070. 4,3 ;0 ,/09, 9,378, -7 Q.0 8,5 -::3,32070 -7 49479033 ;,7 4:,73/, ,. ,,3,-2090/7 0 -749479042,/3/,09,7242Q30702Q0934::2:;0-Q2Q3Q30208 4:, ,3 03/ 80 /3,207 ,7,., -7 Q20 ;0/,2,

Page 9: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 9/39

,,2,9,3,3,2,,7/:/4,8Q70.030003;09,7242Q3073-307.0 -4:3., 0 43:2,7 30 ,580/03 4: /08549233 -: 42Q307/03,784,7,05,/,79Q7Q30/,,3,382Q7Q88902/7

070 49479033 :7/:: -: 82Q7Q 20,32,8 8,9 Q7092 9,730/030/7 9,72 42Q3073/0209,Q709230;0/4,8,2Q-,/00043:4,-0.0 -7,79Q7Q3 , /,,79020 -72 ,2,2,9,/7 30/030,79Q7Q3 -7230 8,5 42,,3 9,72 42Q307 03/30 0907 -7 /4, 04342/:7:2: 3/0;,7,73 -7 /020:7,2,838Q7/Q7Q703 020343,73,3 -,3/, 207049479033 /08549 /0;093 ;043:370;0733 00203 -Q747,833 ,,/,7 03907 8,3 ,7 -7 00032 - Q802090/7%,72 42Q3073/03 05 ,3,3 ,79Q7Q3Q3 -79 -:03907/0/,,03 -7 -Q2Q ;0 /0;09P 8313 9,,733 ,7,32,83, 30 .,3 -7 /9.,709 ;,7/7 0;093 03/0 -703 ,79Q7Q3 -: 03907/0 /0;09 202:7:43:2:3/, 9Q..,7,7 ,7,., / 9.,7090 84:2,9,/7%.,709-:7,/, QQ945::,7333/0003;05,,7,30-7209,Q70921,,09331,/08/0/7 :7,/, ,79Q7Q3 ,3., /0;093 030 09903 8437, 3,/7 2,//00738,,7 2Q.0;0707 Q8 2,//007 ;- ,32,8 3 :,32,9,/7 ,3/08549:3 ;0 43:3 309. 0933 9,,733 ,7,32,83, 30 -7 0;72090/7

4: /085492 9,73/, /0;09 7Q90320833 9020 007 /,9.03.003/3/0-:3,738,9,399,77030-20-,23/,3/0,2,2308033 4:9:7,3 24/073 -Q747,9 /9,97Q073 -, ,79 0/. 0073,;7,,-20-,23/,3/, 30/03302 4/::3:7Q7Q:30/030-7,302349,/,,;:7:,2,33,7,74,.,3/QQ3Q47:

4: /0854923/0 90 ;0 070 2Q09 8,- /0;0997 ,2:8, 0; 703/0;09 70;8 -: 70; 098 /0;,2 099 8Q70.0 /0;09 2Q0933 391,1,/,,32, ,3/,3 ,7,7,32,9,/7 ,,9 -: , 43: 0 2Q09 8,-,52,2,9,/7/009989,9QQ;0-:89,9Q3Q343,8,,/070727,84:,/0;70/0208,.,80/0099,,7,3.,70;8Q7080837-7,97

07049479033/0;,239/,73:,/,-:30/030-Q32020824349,2,8 0707 : 30/030 -Q9Q3 /08549 4: /0;09073/0 309. 83147547,843:3:3 8; ,807 -Q747,8 ;0 /3 -Q747,88 /0;720 ,/74,7/,34:9:7:2,83,/,90/70;703/0;0970;07330/07 848, 831, -,,79,2,203087%,7/085499/,7,7324349,5,7347:2,3

/0;0920930202:78023/0/,3,8-7/0309220,32,84:9:7/:,7;070;,/,,733,88-70090307/0733730070/4:/:7

085494:/0;09073/0-959Q0320-2003,30/,3,;,,7;0889023 -,73/, 4:,3 2070, 0207 /070-0 ,, - 07 ,2,3 /0;0983133 ,5,32,83/,3 ,3,,37 %,790 7/QQ2Q -QQ 8,925,7,947:,73@37,382,3--Q3083/04:,3,30/,3,;,,7-:3,73097 : ,;,,7 ,73 /, -0799 - 889023 90203 4:9:7,3 78,945::,7/,3 9,2,203 -,28 003 ;0 /08549 /0;09 ,58 3/0 003

Page 10: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 10/39

,;,,7/7 @Q3Q 070 Q709. 945::,7 .02,,907 9,2,2, -,243:2/,/7,7 ;003/ 80 ,5,733 /:7:3:: 30/030 8,8, 020073/3/,07,7,7$,8,,,3/,/0;093 3/04:,3,92,,743,7,QQ,/,7:,97

$43-7349,4,7,-07920207074091/0;092Q0930/,,3,34:/085492 ;0 8,9 Q7092 9,7 /020 ,7 03 /703 ;0 /,,3 ,5,742:,7/7 : 9020/0 003 4: :,7,73/, 20;.:9 Q7092 07 ;02Q09-207-307.0/02083;,7,738Q7/Q70-207/78,9Q70929,73,8,5-7,503/80/3,207330980-,,-7Q70929,73, 0;720297 : Q7092 9,733 0;723 8,,,3 9020 1,97 /8,/3,207 00 /0 ,59,23 Q.Q 098 42:9:7 : 8890207 ,59,89Q7092070,7,9,73/,8,3.-7QQ8Q70.,,2,7/7C7303 Q3 @3 ;0 82,3 - /08549 25,7,947:,7 ,9 02507,8907007/9038437,QQ5843-:2:,7/7

7QQ470704:07080,9 95:,7 833/,,3/,59,23.08 Q7092 07 ;0 2Q09 -20733 1,7 945:28, ;0 8,8,7Q9032007/0 /0 1,7 ,5,7 479,, ,72 -: 1,7,7 Q, ,/,78Q700297 3., -Q9Q3 -: 1,7,7,,73 3070/03-,,78,-,,2 -: :,78339,7/0804,7,831945:2,739,742:9:7

'0 3,09 24/073 9,7 0;70380 090 Q.709 020 ;0 8072,033 9,7/74/073 /0;09 /0 Q.709 0203 8072,0 9,7,13/,3 82Q7Q20833 ,09/7;7:5,/,003 ,59,23 -7/Q3,88902 ,30 02080 -7909,78007-,23/,31,70200079,,3945:2,73,79479,-79,7 -::32,9,/7 ,59,89 Q7092 -2 4:8: ;0 ,98, 9Q2 /Q3, Q073/03Q1:8:3 -QQ 823 9/0 5740907 /:7:2:3, /3Q9Q7Q5 38,33 0.4:3::3: Q.709 0 4:,7 ,93/, ,,2,, 47,703 ,3 ,2,3/, -:4:,7,903843;070.04,3945:28,-7/0;7234:3:/,/02090/7

:7:;, Q7092 07 945:28, Q7092 8Q70.33 03 843 :,2, ,799, -2/7-7080-7,79,3,23/,/0-70073945:28,;,74:,73/,3/4,3 -7 ,79 ,3,23/, -:3:3, -790 -:7:;, 945:2:3:3 -,73/, 003Q709. Q07 ,3 ,2,3/, -: ,79 Q20 -,,,., 4,3 2,// 4:,7,7,97,7020-:945:28,4::2038,3945:2:3:39,73.08843,0724:7(

%45:2:3831,7,-Q320830843;07070 38,3 3,0908030,;:9:7,., -: /0;72 07009720 549,38030 8,5 030 831 4,3 57409,7, 8,8,9/,7 00 07/3/0 Q7092 ,7,,73 03/ ,7/0;0933 2Q09 ,93,84,.,972,57409,7,-:3:,52,,03/8/0/,9Q2831,5,32,,731,7,73 ;0 ,79,73 479,/,3 ,/77 0.0 -7 ,2,3,7 945:2:3831,7, -Q320830 -,4,7, 9,7 8,30830 2 -::3,3 /0;093 /0Q2,3,7,37

Page 11: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 11/39

79 -,8 ,93/, 9:9:,., -7 945:28, 831 ,2,3., 831 00203 ;0 -:Q30 ,/,7 Q7092 ,3,78 Q0730 :7:: -7080 ;,74: 2Q.,/008 -:3,7/,3/4,3,92,;0,7,7,-790479,/,3,,7,2,-,8,93,,3,.,-70 ,2, 0 -7-,8Q.Q,3 /0;09 47:3: 42,9,3 ,70;093 03/30709039Q2945:2:39028.84,7,;,7099002Q7092,7,,73,945:2,/3, 0 42, ,3 ,2,3/, 43:3 /0;09 4,7, 843 -,28 002/7 0;099/,733945:28,0702Q/,,08-7-7,7/3,9Q2,,3,7/,0708,007;08437,03/3/0383Q5/0707Q073/03092307300733092;0Q70928Q7007333092,70;09,0/20 8307 (

%45:2:3 831,7, -Q320833 ,3,3/, Q70923 09078 30/030,32, 4,3 -7080 ;,74: ,;,8 ,92,9,/ ,/0 945:28, 831,73479,/,3,/72,8/,-:-7080;,74:,;,83,843;070.0/Q0/0-4::3,7,92,8, 4,3, ,0 00-7 ,, 07/0 24/073 ,59,2338,33 -: -4:: ,7,92,83 2Q2Q3 ,., 4:,7 ,7,/3, /,902090/308

D7092,7,,73303020Q.Q,59,89Q70929,73303/830;:7/::3.707

 5,7,473,73 -: 3.707/03 :79::: Q709. Q073 08398 8Q70 4,7,/,, 07003 020833 ;0-00-,9 Q7092357,990 8378 ,7933030 34::/:7 058 -: ,/,7 /0 D7092 ,7,,733 945:28, 9020QQ8,/0.0 Q70923 2/ ;,7 4,3 ,5, 030073 /0 ,3 ,2,3/, Q3Q2Q/0Q70923 ,32, 4,7, -07,-073/0 097/ ;0 707/0 /47: 349,83, :,,3Q709. Q073 ;0 Q7Q3073 2:9, 8,;:7,33 ;0 23 /, 479,/,3 ,/777., -:Q3Q 00203 831,73 ;0 43,73 8,8 9028.0733 ,3,288,;:7,33479,/,3,/7,7,-7Q7092,7,,7;0Q7Q3079083945::,7,73,Q7 -7,7 %45:28, Q7092 ,7,,7, 945:2:3 9Q2 Q00730 ,3., 2,//4,7,9Q2Q00907;007Q3033003-7,,2/0,3,2,3/,-0/0380;0/QQ380 09030073 9,2,203Q7.0 09720 ;0 :,32, /, Q;03.0 ,93,,,3-7,,28,,2,4,3,-:Q304,7,;,7,2,;,7 (

:8,97,73,/9,7903-:,3,003::3,73/024/073Q709.Q073,59,2 ,93/, :,2 -::3/::-:Q3Q 020 /Q0 9020 847:3: 073Q30 80747 &:8,7,7,8 57409,7, /Q3, ,59,89 8890230 843 ;0720/038,3 /070 /073003 ;0 ,3,,3 -7 Q7Q20 3/0 -4:2,, /0;,20/0.097,59,23002034:,73/,903440/4,;038,3,7,83/,083003 0 843 9,/0 Q709. Q073 38,33 9,,73 /,, 07/Q0/0 ,7,,., -2/0 020830 /0 9,2 907830 9,75 42,83, 4,2,9,/738,3 -:Q3 30/Q9QQ-:/:7:2/,3:79,7,-0.0;0945:28,9QQ073,3,3:7:9,.,0304:57409,7,3303/3/Q3,03/000203 2,8/7:4:070097780,59,89 Q7092 -233 4 ,987,1;02,843;070-79Q2831,7.,,733;0-:3,-,4,7,/0;093

/0 4 4,., ;0 07QQ3/0 Q709. Q073 38,3 84:3:3 /4, 0 ::2: -2/0020833,7,73,:,3,-0.0-7-4:0-70,7,9,-7

,/0 38,33 38,3 Q073/082Q7Q;0 -,8833 ;0 -:3, -, 4,7,/0;094:8:3:39,78,3083033,3,,-730830-79020;,78,-:82Q7Q;0 -,833 ;0 /0;093 0708 -7 /:7:2, 00.0 -7 945:28, /:7:2:3 /,,3,,-7 ;0 2Q2Q3 30830 -7 9020 ;,7/7 D709.073 Q7 ;0 09 -7 -7 9020 Q073/0 Q7092 03/03 /Q0300.0 945:2 ,3 8318 945:2

Page 12: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 12/39

Q709.Q073-7080;,74:,;,833,3,3:7:9,.,/Q00 Q8092 -4::3,/,,3,.,979038,33-0-7/:7:2,07020832Q2Q3,.,,92 57409,7,33 /Q3, 03/0 945:28, /0;72/7 308 57409,7,33 -0-7/0;720:,,-0.0945:28,/:7:2:;0.-7/00/009747/:

020/0;09/QQ3Q0200.0-7,2,3/,3-07;,74,3-70/0/7073

438: 703 -7 /0;09 ;0 /0;09 Q.Q 17 -::32,,3 945:2,7 42:9:7%45:2:3831,7,-Q32083047:3:4,7,-,-::3,3-07-798,/020,,2,83/, -: -Q320 /0;09 -7 47:3:: ,30 097/ 2/ Q7092/0 -:831,73 ;,733 8,/0.0 -7 47:3:: 42,9,3 2,, ,2,5 Q7092 3070-70304/::-7020,,2,83,,/2,7,,,47::831,7;,9030,/,7,32,-7-2/0479,,9,78,4,/,7,32,-7-2/0479,/,3 ,,.,,7/7 3,7, -790 /0;09 /0 ,32, -7 -2/0 4 4:7D709.073Q7;009-7-79020Q073/0Q709203/03/Q0300.04,3945:2 -Q9Q3 /0;09 2,3083 -:3/,3 -0 03/30 4,3 070 -7 03,7,,9,.,97,8,7,9,2Q08307;09:3-,9,33,33,(

0;09,,,9,3$3200Q%:92:70;09

!740907/0;723 0/0107 ,83/,3/0;09 847:3:3: 07 073049:79,-20 33.00:030070;03Q3/0-::3/:72,070470;72.,782 57409,7,33 3, ,2,.3 8318 /0;098 Q7 Q709.07 945:2:3, :,2,4,7, 1,/0 0/07 2, -: 0/010 ;,7,-20 3 57409,7,33 ,59,2/0342Q3200/302-4:3.,-7/0;0901,,9/,,-,9,383200Q9:92:039590-7/0;090070832;,7/7:3900757409,7,/9,97QQ3Q34,8 -2073/03-73/0-,943:3Q3Q;,74:4::3:-0707:-Q2/0,7823 :7:.:,733 ;0 0333 -:43:/, 2 4/:,7030 070;0339020307Q073/0/:72,07047

03/073 700 848,2 4,7, 9,39,3 -Q747,9 /9,97Q073 50 5009QQ Q3Q2Q /Q3,83/, -:7:;,33 ;0 QQ-:7:;,33 ,7820309907 07 9Q7/03 /044 8,/7,7 ,783/, ,7823 /0;72.20;07338,;:3:2,807008/30207047,3,,9-0,9,792/:7:2/,/7:7:;, /044833 ,7820 ,9,3 ,, 3099 8,/7,73/,3 /,, /,900 4,3 /:7:2 -Q747,92 00978 2,80833 ,7/3, 0303 8/0,7889 7Q3Q2Q 3.0 838 /044 ,25,3,,7/7 : /:7:2:3 95730073/03 -7 -Q747,9 494790 70//092033 , ,7/3, 83,7,/0;72. 494790 07083233 /0 37 0/208/7 /0;7233 47:3: -7:38:7:3: 4:9:7,3 /0;72. 494790 07083233 ,7889 7Q3Q2Q 8,8,,2,79,7,13/,3-:,3,972,,,/Q3Q2Q/0308343:,3:302,23-,,,2,9,,7,7;,7

020494790083/032:9,4,7,9Q;007083/03/02:9,4,7,-70/0809208,2,/794790;007,58,2,7945:2020833090;70070-790/00370007/707070700.090945:28,7Q9032033 494790 48,48, Q7092 4:,733 43: ,32,,., 837,707830 ,580/0.03 80200 0938007/ -7-72 ,3,,-7/ ,2, 43,7494790 47:3: ,3 -Q9Q3 4:,7, 073 ,5,2,7 78, 8.QQ3 03/8308,/747,7

Page 13: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 13/39

394947907.07 33 8,8, 4947900 /0;090 ,7 2,, 093247,7 $,8,/0;093;043:3,-7908,8,49479033/03Q2Q/0945:28,/0;723843:.:4,7,44,.,,3,2: 0;07338,8,390073 970.007;0945:2:3070 ,7,73 0920 4,3 -,89 30980 0;07 ,30 00.007 /QQ3.083 -Q9Q3848,89075,,2,9,/7,72,,394947907.0749479078,8,/0;093-775/, ,99, 43: ,7,92 -::3,3 945:28, 4:,7 4 42,/,3 3.0 479,/,3,/72,83 8947,7 :3,7 945:28, /0;723 33 49479033 479,/,3,/72,842,838947,7:-,,7-7/0;7272Q072/70;720-0990 03 4947907 4,3 0/7 -: 3Q1:8:3 -7 -Q2Q3Q3 03/ 7,/083 3Q1:8:3 90 -Q2Q30 9Q10070 8Q3Q070 ;0 945,7, ,, 00-0.0 -Q9Q3 4947907 ,7,,7,/,,99-7002/7;00072:,11074,39,7,1407003/Q208902478,-:002033 8,,733 07.07 Q073/0 ,7,99 9077 0 8Q7/Q720/7 !,7842Q3Q8,,349479083-:7:;,0,7:,32,248,/-7Q348:3/,,3,-72/%07830 !,7842Q3Q3Q -:3/,3 09073.0,7,7,32,2 42,,8:,2,20702472:(

308 2,3 $48, 0247,9,733 9,7 49, !747,2 %,8,3009720 Q070 0-00 ,/ 209:-:3/, 80 QQ-:7:;, 848,2,3,33 :,3984,3 Q7,/0;092,8,7,3,/03742Q389073

00.00304,7,5747,2,73/,/0;09383Q2032083/0380/0.007/0Q7,/0;09-0/0107/0380920802,3,789073,905073030/03 42,9,/7 02 /0 Q7Q ;0 /0;09 - ,3 ,3, 020208 07003,;7,2,73-7,7,/,:,32,80/0107-:,3/72,9,/70/07308

0;09Q0730-:-0;00070843;0720070008.QQ39,2,3,2, -7/0;0942,24,3!,7842Q3Q/03023/038437,,,,73!74:/43,9,-3/,3-07;08437,/,42Q389!,79,3108948:3/,848,89945:28,/Q033:7:2,8,/0;09303/3/03/,/;0 44/::,,803242,83,,73 ,3,78907 0907 ,/,7 , /0;09 ,1,2, ,2 /:72:,7/7 0;098,;,2/, /0;72/0 /0;72 /Q2,3,73 -,8972, 3 ,7,7,32, 47:3/,4/::2:0.-7:7:2/,3-,,-7042,/3,70Q7,-7/0;09903

809208,2,/757409,7,33/0;090070832084/::8Q70.04-:3:Q7Q3/0,82,73,909203:,3,.,97'0Q7Q90380/2084,3,4/:: Q3 /0;09 /0;09 4,7, 479,/,3 ,2 4,.,97 3:3 3 - /0;098.QQ3Q307300707/0945::02030803-7,38.,42Q3Q3,74,32Q022008-72,38.QQ3Q3:,32,833072090(

:,2,7/,3/,,3,,.,-/0;0939,32,2,3848,89/0;09;0, 848,89 /0247,8 ,;7,2,73 :,32, 007 07 -7 8.QQ3 ,3,2Q073/0 990 /:7:,.,4:78, 073/0 /0/7@Q3Q /0;09/0247,8 0848,207090,79,780/3021,/00/03/0207/78,-:3,7848,2 0/0100357409,7,33 9/,7/, 43:2:3: ,/,3/72,8 -,23/,3,2,3 ,2,3 :,3,0297 3., 30 /0 8.Q07 9,2 07 073/0

:,32, 890780 57409,7, /9,97QQ /30230 3 /47: ,;7,2 42Q3Q84;09;0,/0247,8842,/7

,7 ;03083 43:,/,7 ,58,2 Q20200733 -, 302 349,,730333,,2,703/000,2,::34,.,9749,!747,2%,8,330097/ 2093(Q073/0 /:7,7, 5740907 /0;720 /0;09 847:3:3:38 ,83/,3 302 843:,7 ,797 033 3083 0-00 ,2

Page 14: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 14/39

209:-:3/,07,,3,,2,,7/,3,70090/0;72.,788907,3,78907/03;045479Q38907/03,7,3-0-,007087,,7

3,78907/03 - ,7,3 0 , /0;093 : ,3/, :,3/7 ;- ;0 - 57409,7,33/0;72 87,83/,:,3/7 57409,7, /9,97QQ -: 2//03 57,99050-QQ3029,,3-720800/790:,733:3:99:,7/,-:3,7/7

5479Q38907/03 - ,7,3 /,, /073 /,, 2Q7Q 07007/7 ,, /0;0930. 390 -- : ,3/, /0;09 Q0730 0;003 ,7,7 .. 57409,7,/9,97QQ3Q3 9,2,203 /0;09 42,,3 390 // /0;090 Q7Q ,7,83/,000/0;090730945::17335747,2/,,;7,29072:,32,9,/7/,, 9,2 ;0 /47: 4/:: 11 29,723 ;0 -Q747,9 20,32,332,8/7(

033 49, !747,233 009780 4,7, 3083 209:-:, ,7303,7349,73,7,97/3/,/,93003-7349,,,7090/07308/0;098.QQ 0730 42Q3 8.QQ3Q 307703 ,3 /0;09 8.QQ3Q :,32,9,3,3703 ,7 42Q389 945:2/, 00.03 /0;093/03 8 0/0-2090/7

033 -,9, 0 - 7Q303 -: ,2 3.003/3/0,7 ;0 3083,83/, 020/33 ,73 ,3., 00.090 30 4,-0.033 5:,73,,,2, ,2,., 4:: 4,7, /0;09 8.QQ3Q :,32 4/::3:3,3,,-0.03-0797,7843:8:,-,3/0349,,/03297

, 0 /3023/0 /0;093 57409,7,33 /0;72. 9/,73/,3 -,, -7 04,2,,.,

 -42Q389 945:2/,/0;093,30,,.,:7,/,/0;09 8.QQ/0;093;,73 8Q7/Q70.0 ,3,23/, /0 00.033 30 4,., ,3,23/,:,32,9,/7

033/0;09;0/0247,84:8:3:3/023-,.,Q9,780/3029-,7,,59,89 945:20 /302 42Q389 945:2 00 ,2,9,/7:3,700/302 ,3 57409,7, /9,97QQ /302 843, 075 42Q389 945:2 /302,,32,, -,,3/3/, /0;093 ;0 /4,8, /0247,833 83Q203/ -7Q7Q , ,2 4,.,97 : -,,2/, 0333 Q7Q ;0 /0247,8,;7,2,733 -,03 -7-733 0730 :,32,833 ,3 Q0730 /Q2Q4/::349/,302/7

@4:3:,Q7Q;0/0247,8,;7,2,733,3,3,2,0/07,-:0/7;088-733073090:,37,,73/,,:98!0,34;;0,;030842,Q070 ;Q07 ,788907 /0 -: 43:/, ,303 -0 /QQ32090/707 07090 80

/0247,8Q7Q0-,/,2,02033/,09070/47:8070/72:9,09903-:7:;, /0247,8830 -:7:;,/0247,883/03 5740907 /0247,8830 5740907/0247,883/03/0247,880(

033 -:7,/, /0247,88 ,;7,2, /0;093 83Q2030.0 ;0 /0;098945:2:3,3070,3,2/,Q7QQ3,,3,.,9,780/302,3,92,9,/7: ,,2,,73 03/0 ,97,32,8 07003 03 302 349, 80 7082,7823 ,3 $9,323 /0;09 847:3:3/, ,7,99 2:,,2 9,7-,997,78270;00/070/0;09-7848,2,3,3,/,,3,4:9:7,.,7082

Page 15: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 15/39

 -7/044,7,9,3$9,325740907/0;720-,,,31,79,780/30207007297$9,3242Q323,9,,2,84,3;08318/0;098945:2,,709 0/03 848,2 /3020 57409,7, /9,97QQ /3023 /00972847:3:9,2-7-:,2,.,0;7297:3:3843:.:3/,848,2831;0/0;093;,73 8Q7/Q7/QQ -7 /302 4,7, ,;7,32,, -,,32 ;0 -: ,3,307/03 ,32,8 4/:, 47 -7 -2/0 %Q70 848,89 ,700930 /0070297 $9,389 /04433 9047 ,2,73,782 4,7, ,,,3,7033043:330/0/3,;7,2,90203/0/090783043:3/QQ3.0Q7Q3073$9,323 9,71,9,7, ::2: ,0 09720 Q070 ,,2,7/7 : 30/030$9,389 7082 /04433 07097/ ,;7,2,7/,3 ,1,,7 ,73/72,/,0333Q20200733,;7,32,84,3,8/7

0333,,2,,73/,,59,2/0342Q3200,3/0;72./3QQ207/302 0 8318 945:2 /302 ,7,83/, ,72 309 -2/0 ;:7:,32,9,/7:3, 70 0 /302 57409,7, /9,97QQ30 /,,3,3 831 ;0 /0;09 -7/302/73.,831337Q90//0;0908047,3,,79-7,7/0;09/,, -,9,3 83200 Q 9:92: -7 /0;0997 42Q389 945:2 80 070 ,907080 Q89,,2,8 9-,7, 8318 ;0 /0;098-7 945:2/:7 : ,72,7 /,,,739 0/0 70-20 ;0 -7, :8:8: 3090970-20 3 -7 /0 0333,73 49, !747,23 0097/ 5,8,,7/,3 ,70090 ,7/ 2 843:,7Q073/0/:7,2

033 0 /3020 42Q389 945:2:3 ,9 ;0 Q89 0;70073 -7-73/03 ,790/0-20,2,.,,,/,QQ,72,5,7

::38Q703/4:28,3.,7

42Q389945:2:30;708

42Q389945:2:3/,,Q80-70;708(

'0 ,7349, !747,233 09783/0 8,97,7, /,,3,7, 42Q389945:2:3,9;0Q890;7007,7,83/,,7203/807001,/00/07

9 -73. 0;70 9Q092 0,,733 -70070 43,73 945:2, 8,,/,7 02029,73,47,394,7,/,92,8,92/,098880/7-7/Q0/0/7:7:;,:::3:3/,7837,703Q9,2,203,2,297:430208-08203-:7:;,:::;,738Q7/Q7/Q08203-:7:;,/0;09/09,2,203479,/,3,-42,,.,97:7,84302

D890;700708903090303070070809,.3,70:30,2,32Q2Q3

4,.,97 4 0 ,1, 020 ,7,83/, 033 479,/,3 ,9 0203,,93 -,., -7 /4, 47:3::: ,30 0/ ,2, ,,3 47,2,42,83 -7 3472 ,30 047 Q709. Q073 07 /070.0/0 09 -7,,2,/,08-0 /0;0939,2,203 4 4:5 9208 ,3.,-: 03Q80 ,,2,/,2Q2Q3/Q7:43:302/7(

,, 3.0 8,97,7/, 033 -:7:;, /0;09903 39080 1,73 -0790-20,2,.,/,,-,9,383200Q9:92:9590-7/0;094,3/0;093-7 ,7/0;09 4,7, 9,32,2,9,/ : 9,32,2, 57409,7, /9,97QQ /30230

Page 16: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 16/39

3/7 :,7/, ,9,7/2 843 8,97,7/, 80 42Q389 945:2:3 ,9 ;0 Q890;700733 0073 -7-73/03 ,79 0/0-20 ,2,., -, 8,59,2,,7,52,9,/7 9 ,,2,/, 03Q -:7:;, :::3:3 /,7 :1:3:3 9,2 4,7,,,2,/3 -07920,2,., 8203 -:7:;, :: 8203 -:7:;,/0;099,32,2,,73, -,;:72,9,/7 0203 -07902 -: 9,32,2,,7 57409,7,/9,97QQ/3020,7972,2,/7

033-:7,/,95,73,59-/0;094:8:3:300.03035:,73,7,2,9,/7070,,2/,0984,3-7007042Q323,9,,2,83/,0902029,73,70095,;072083302033070,3,23/,,::,;7,2,7 ,83/,3 3,8 1,/0 0/0-0.03 847:,2,9,/7 ,73 /, ,709099Q070-:/:7:2:303Q-:7:;,:::3/,7:1:3:39,2,203,,2,2,8,3,23,00.03-07970700990380/0-208;0-:7:;,:::3:3/,7:1:3:3,,-2083070,,2/,098/:7:2/,-::3,3-700700942,,3 5,,73 /,92,833 ,3 0708903 0903030 70 8903703 070809,.3, 70 ;070-0.0 -7 -4: /Q030 :,2,833 47:3: 4/::3:;:7:,7908203-:7:;,::8203-:7:;,/0;09,;7,2,7,1,/009200 ,9 070 03Q 945:2:3 -0 -7 -4: /:7:2:3, :,,2,2 -::3,., ,9 ,,2,33 70.0 098 /:7:2:, /7 7 -,, /00033,9,,2,/,03Q-:7:;,:::3:309,3,33,,2,24::3:,3 09 ,,3, 09 5, ;072083 -:7:;, :::3:3 ,39,733 03Q9,2,203479,/,3,/7,2,242,8;:7:8:,,3,92,9,/7$43:4,7,43:38203 ,;7,2, ,89099 -:/:7 ;0 -7 0/0 42Q389 945:2:3 ,9,,2,833 ,3 848,2 /30233 /0;09 -7 /302 4/:: /0;093 ,3., -:3/,38437,83Q20320000-0.003/047:2,3,2,

,,9 90 ,3/,3 :3: /, -07920 0707 0333 8203 -:7:;, ::

/0703-:3,-7/08203-:7:;,/0;09 -,70830020843::/,,,,0097202 907830,797297@Q3Q,7-:7,/, ::,;7,23 :,3703 -7 -:7:;, ,,3,4,30/007073/02 0833 03Q/0;,2 0993 -0792090390-7 ,2,Q920297,/ ,73 -: :8:8: ;:7:,2,83330/03 03/ /30233 QQ-:7:;, 848,89073 7303 ,88,03 09,3,30097209,./77,QQ-:7:;,33,7:,/3,090/01 -:7:;,/04483300203,93/,-20324,3;08439,/0,59,23837,73,2,,3/,7-7,58,2,8,59730/030/0,7070,,2/,;,74,3 09807 08,-, ,92,,3 -:QQ-:7:;, 09 ,3,33 8373,/,9 0070 -280 42Q323 09 ,3,33 QQ-:7:;,333/031,73-079297 ,,9302 -7 10801 ,;7,,3,73-: ,233

 -280 ,3,2/, -7 :: /Q03020830 , /, /0;09 /Q0330 3/7032089,2,203 ,397 7, 42Q323 ,,2,83/, /0;09 847:3:3:3 3,8 00,3,-0.0,7;03089,7,13/,34,-2/0479,,43:2:9:7

!7409,7, /9,97QQ /302 0 /302 -4:3., 57409,7, 9Q2 831,7, -790 03/83 /0 -7 831 4,7, 479,/,3 ,/72, 0/0130 /47: 0702047:3/,/7 07 57409,7, -: 9,780 2843:3: -,,7, 0730 0970-780831,73 479,/,3 ,9 831 8,;,233 843 -:/:: ;0 -00 57409,7,/9,97QQ3Q3 9,780 2843:3:3 9,2,2,3/ 03 -7 0;700 :,,.,97 :

Page 17: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 17/39

0;70/0 ,79 57409,7, /9,97QQ /0;09 0;3 8,8, 3903 9,2,203977070807;083Q2037,7;03083/0/-

023 , 0783/0 831 ,72,7 ,93/, ;0 Q7092 9Q2 ::8:3 03 -7 -7330073/04:3,93/,,2:Q.Q8,8,3903970.097

$31,7, ;0 831,79,7,-790 08 -:7:;, 945:2:3 073 33 Q7023307083Q702334::4/::-7-7,,.,97(

: 242039 /0;09903 /0;0980 03 9,2,2,3/ ;0 03 -7 /302342Q323-,,/331,/08/7,7342Q323,90;708/0/308;00333848,2 /0,/,3/7/ 9,780 0;70 -:/:7 90$31,73 42,/209,Q709233479,/,3,9/0;0939,2,20383Q203/Q70923;0848,,,239Q2,,3,73/,Q7Q709.07945::,733/47:/,3,7,7;07/07;0::,/,7 -7 ,,2 9,7 ,7349, !747,233 09783/0 ,2,/42Q323,9 ,,2,8 848,2 90 -0-7 9,780945:28, 0;70 ,3,97'0-:,3,2/,57409,7,/9,97QQ/3023/033900 1,7 03 -7 9,780/3023-,,3./7848,2

0 /3023/0 /0;093 3903/0 /020 -790 /0247,833 :7,/39080/08001,/00/07033

,30334:3::3/0247,8;082Q7Q.Q07347,7,.,-,8,3/0247,833 /3, ,92, ,59,2/03 42Q320 0 87,83/, /0247,833:7,//090-0-7/097(

!7409,7,/9,97QQ/3029,780,/,3831,7479,/,3,/72,,QQ2Q -7/302/7'0-:::8:::8,090/0::8,7,7,8090/QQ3Q20807003 -7 4:/:7 !740907 /0;723 ::8, 837,7 3/0 0/0 099 70.0 -7

 -,,7 ;0 ::8, 837,7 3/0 -7 5740907 9/,73 :7:2,8 ,59,89073/703.333,4,7,7/,3,23,02003Q@Q3Q,59,89073/703.::8,00837/0/7,59,23-7/Q3,8890242,8,59,898313/,/Q3,03/0/QQ3Q2083070977%557409,7,-

,/0 ,59,23 00203 /Q3, 03/0 2,/, ::8, /Q0/09/,7 ,,3 57409,7,33 ,107 03Q 3, -7 ,107 8,,2, : 4:,7/, 57409,7,33 002033 47:,-208 ::8, /Q0/0 -7 847:3 /0/7 /Q3,/0;7233 07030 -,/7 : 30/030 /0 0 /302 /Q3, ,703,83/,9,2,2,3,-7;0-:9,780/3020/03/Q0357409,7,/9,97QQ070832,59,2 /Q3, 03/0 9,810 0/3.00 /0 /0;,2 0/07 020

 57409,7,333.09Q2945:2:5740907097208;0-0.002/07831,702/0-,903/3-78314,7,479,/,3,/72,8,3945:28,831,739,8108/Q3,03/0-79,780/30230/30233847:3:/:7

!7409,7, /9,97QQ /3023/0 /0247,8 945:2:3 033 4:3:: 3 -707048,-003Q-,8,93/,9:9:2,8/703.72,807003074/::8Q70.0 Q7Q903 8 0920 /47: /0/7 !7409,7, /9,97QQ /30233,79 9,780 2843:3: 9Q095 /Q3,/, 8318 945:2 /Q0333 ,,32,833

Page 18: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 18/39

4,3, 4,., /:7:2/, 80 -: 0 -,8 ,93, ,32,8 /703.33 72,807003 -7 945:28, 831 ,2,/ 3 /0;09 9,2,203 83Q2030.097 90,3.,4,2,3Q7Q903809202Q2Q34,.,97,/,,30/0247,84:8: ,83/,3 1,/0 0/0.0 4:78, 070903 9,2 070903 -7 8983,9,32,,3-7/0247,83307009;0-0.0-730929,74,7,9,7800;3 9Q092 4,3 /0247,833 /0 83Q203/ -7 Q7Q 945:2: 3/0,,32,,-,,3,.,97

,730/30257409,7,/9,97QQ/3021,/0808318945:2:3/4:2 8Q70.3 ,89092 4/:: 0703 ,759,3$9,32 -:/4:2 8Q70.3303/838318945:2:3,9,,2,8,3848,2/3024,7,9047009297%45:28, /Q0307 ,83/,3 03 -7 /Q033 /4:: ::3 ;0 8,3. -7 8Q709700 831 945:2,7/,3 8318 945:2, 0 /QQ30.0 4:78, -:3:303/3/033.0,,7,47,3,30/032:,,2-79,780/007//0,97003$9,32-:/0;,8,9,780847:3:90-7Q0/057409,7,339/,733:7:2,809,2,2,3,3;08,8,/0;7230203079083/0848,23,,32,,-,,3/-74/:-99-,1103/70297

$48,2,83/,303Q/,,/4:2070020203-:Q30/0,,3,3,73848,2357,9,83/,3,7,32,8$9,323,7,999,71,93843:.:/:7::8: -: 9,71,9 4., -7 9,780 43439Q70 /,2,83 ;:7,3 ;0 .090733 /,, ::3 -7 8Q70 880/0.0 843:,7, -7 945:28, ,7,-,8,3/Q03/0/7 $9,389 -Q747,9 00203 /QQ380 /,,3,3 -7 ,2,3,7,733083,8, 0097/,88,.QQ-:7:;,848,2,3,3/, -:2:9:7 &:8, 837,7 3/0 -:7:;, 9/,733 2,8 ;0 Q7092 ,7,,733/0;090972080 ,,32,,-,,3,3 -7 /302 848,2/302 4,7, 1,/00/3.0,7823:7:.:,733;003330;70380090::3;08,3.-7

/4:2 /302 4,7, -0920/07 0 /302 90 Q0/0 0 /Q0303/7032 42,9,/7 8, 847:3:3 5Q1 349,8 9,2 /, -:7,8/7 %0 Q0/0848,23 4,3,83 807003 /0;72. ,782 -0.0 ,59,2/0342Q320 0 /30233 /0 ::8, 837 3/0 ,,3,2,,.,3 479,,42:-::32,9,/77-,,/009090Q007/0:7:,3-7-73/03,9 57409,7, 9/,7,7, 0 /30233 ::8, 090 9,2,2,3,-0.03/QQ32090Q0/0848,234,3,3//,09200,30/7

0;72.,7823 3/0707 38,33 8318 ;0 82Q7Q8Q -7 945:2/Q03,7,92, :7:3/, Q7Q90.0 ,;,33 30 /03 47 ::3 8Q70 ;0 903 /020709703 -7 070 8,5 4,.,3 07 178,99, ;:7:,/,7 QQ-:7:;,

Q945233/0;,8,9,780847:3,7,1103/70032,39,9080,7,83,083-78378003,78200.003037Q073 -28099 90203049:799: ,59,89 /Q3, 8890233 2,83/,38437,-0 38,33 -: 30203 ,,-3/0 023 /:/:: 8318 945:2 /Q033 02 -20,,,2,,.,3,,2,070/:/:

,7 -: 30/030 ,2, 8,/0.0 -: 30/030 42Q389 945:2 /Q0330 337Q07343:3,9;0Q89,,2,,79-,7,1,/009200,903Q::3;08,3. /4:2 8Q70.33 073 9,,3 ,3 ,59,89 945:2:3 3/03 9

Page 19: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 19/39

 -20 -7 42Q389 945:2 4,-0.0 4,3 ,9 ,,2, 0 -0 -7 /3023,,32,8 8,083/0 ,79 03/30 Q 902007 Q073/0 00.0 Q89 ,,2,,79099

2, ,8 4,7, 42Q389 945:2 03/ 02 8Q70.33 ,9 ,,2,,73/,3 /,,Q80 ,,2,,73, 0;7280 4/,3 07020 4,3,,73, ;0 ,5,890830 8,5 -7848404342 1472,843/:7 ,7 42Q389 945:2:3 9020 0073 1,/00/070343:302,902/0Q890;70073-Q9Q380-78Q704,7,00,2;0-:9,780/30242Q328318/0;098;0209, 8-7945:28,,,/3024,7,39003/7297 30 ,30/042Q323,9 0;708 848,20 Q89 0;708 ,7,83/, 1,7 ,3,9703 -:3,7 ,7 39080 242039 4,7,/090-7390342Q323,74:3:/Q04,7,,3,9297

!,7842Q3Q0302

Q3, 57409,7,833 9/,7 2Q.,/0083/0 -:Q30 ,/,7 ,,3,3 /03020730073 ,52,8 30073 ,52,2,8 07093 8907070 8,.,8 4:2: ;0

4:28::3/,3 /07807 ,792, 4,3, ,7, 0702090/7 !,78 42Q3Q/0302 9,/ 9Q2 080730 ,73,7823 :7:.:,73, 57409,7,33908/0;09,93307303,8-7,942,8070943:8:3/,08,85:,7;0729

,7 7,38,/, $,;,,/ ,593/, !,78 42Q3Q /030233 070 87730479,,4,7

42Q3Q3070877:/:42Q308,803-7831QQ209Q709038313,850/03 831, ,7 2Q.,/00833 Q7Q3Q 0203 98,/ :79:::3:3 070020838,,,33,09010/28,8,-2/(

:,59,,/9,77,83/,3088042Q3959/,73,3.,020 47,3, /0 00.00 30 4,7, /, 9,2,8 07003 4 302 -700 /037 831 9/,7,093/08,/0.0 08-,8./0;09 2,3083 5,7,,2,,0932020030103/0739Q7020830178,9;07200.030207/0,2,/7

42Q3 83133 9/,7, 07 020 08 /0;09 ,9, 309200 /0;,20/0200.03 0203 ,-: 0920 47:3/, ,/ 03Q 03 0/0 099 03/00203303/039720203-:831-7,3/,34,2,3,/0303/830,7:,32-::3,308-,8,93479,/,3,/72,,2,90,3/,303/;0;0202:7,7307,3;08983,870;/03,3,-730/07043,7,,7/,

Q;0330207,2,/,,39, 945:2:3 2097,7 4,3 /0;09 ;0 /0;09 47,3,733 945:2:30103/07 /:7:2:3, /3Q2083 3.0 -Q9Q3 /0;0907/0 7Q03 ,32, -7/3QQ2/Q73020342Q3,2,,7,:,3/33092,/,09;07092 073/0 -Q9Q3 70;20;073 07083 030 4:3, /,, 4,7,8020;0-:,38020307307,3,0920,3,9-/'03.4,7,03,,83/,303Q8030-Q9Q3202:7,7,,3.,-Q7073,/,7,/,7Q.709/03/ 0.0 9028 47,3,73, 3/0703 /00007 3 ,7., ;0 0/2

Page 20: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 20/39

 -,,. 9,2,9,7 /3/, 20; ;0 -, ,;.3, ,7 09 -7 030 432:4:47/:(

%,780 ,/,3 -7 /0;0933 /03023 4:9:7,3 !,78 42Q3Q 30/07-,23/,3-:7:;,/0247,9.:2:709905,7,2039,72/031,74,3Q89Q34,33Q30/,79,34:,2

42Q3073098029073/030304,802847:2:;007,370;/0307,3,-7-00/020.8Q0073/034::47/:42Q3Q007334:/4,4,7,07/03 ,/, 83133Q3Q9028.073/03 4::47/:42Q35,7,203907-747,3 /0 ,2, ,3 ,2,3/, 02 Q7Q920. 02 /0 ,8,2,. ,7009 -7 47,34,.,9(

,73!,7842Q3Q/030230/,,3,3,2,7333/,-79/,733 -Q747,9,807 08/0;09 2,3083 5,7,,2, ;0 -Q747,888Q70 47/:8:0395903-7/0;09:72,3,2,80700330207087,,,-7

O $Q7047/:3:3,/72,8;00738,,32,3,2,8O !483 8,8, 390073/03 /07, ,73/72,8 ;0 42Q3Q3 847:2: ;0 07 ,370;/0307,3,-7-7,09/:7:2:3,/3Q9Q7Q208O 0709,2:70;33Q.70907,77Q208O Q80 /0;09 70;0733 :,32, ,,7 ;0 9028 /0300733 -: Q80

70;,/74,73303/80-790479,/,3,/72,8O ,2: 20907332070QQ209 9,7,13/,347:3,3 280073 0 2Q09

42,9,3,72,8O $,/0.0-00/0309233/04Q30/03/0;099,7,13/,3Q7Q9Q2Q-::3,3

9Q2703342Q3Q300730;07208O :7:;, /0;093 2,30; -,8,0907 4,3/3 ,/,2,733 3Q1:: /:7:2:3, 843

;07208 33 /0;09 073/03 9,2,203 ,72,8 ;0 03/ .02,,9 07070,,2,,9070/208

O C7092:7:2,7339Q2Q3Q35,7,84,7,,,,2,8/3:7:2,7,/0;09307 9Q7Q ,72,83/,3 :79,72,8 23 /0;09 9/,733 ;:72: 4/::3.7073/03:79,72,8

O 8,/,0920,32,83372,8Q80,/,0970;07;0,7,73/,-Q7,2:70;07-807847:2:;007,3,-742,,7

O 82070QQ2093073 03QQ0702-72073/0-0Q709.073 QQ20933,2,8

O 3QQ78,0702020700733-08,8,-2,2,8;078,-007/08Q7047/:3:3209,2,348,-7,280/097208

O 07 3 78, 42Q30733 479, 073 3 3092 20703/0 -7 /0000720.8,7,.,309208

O 20.807332070/0::8,0907:7::3,209;0073/072007O 000073 07 ,3 70;/03 07 ,3,-2007 80203073 083 9,2,93, -,

42,,7479,,2,Q.709073,2,,3,,7O 070QQ2093/0;70/0-770;073342Q3070,9,72,83/,38437,30

/02070-7QQ2093847:2:::3/,,,.,4,330270;07342Q380,388,847:2:70;079,7,13/,3Q7Q9Q208

O 42Q3 95 7Q90320 ,8, QQ /0;0907 10/07,843: -23/0 /QQ3Q020%07830 2Q2Q34,3 03 03 ::8,7-7 90203/0-78,8,20700200/01020/7

Page 21: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 21/39

O 42Q3 -00/080 Q7QQ 077 1,,9 -7-00/0702 /0/7 ,3 42Q395 9/,73 0 8,8, 20700200 ,79 -7 070 3092.494342.::/0/7D709.07303/7Q9QQ0730/,,3,3Q7092;0,,2 -72073/0030338,91073070320708,8,-7334:9:7:2,83,2,,7

O 0304,-:7:;,5,7,2039,723/03Q3/01,742,Q070,2,2:9,,

0920/7:8,8,20,32,-:7:;,5,7,2039,723/04/::-,/,5,79839/,7,09720Q070/042Q307-23/07Q9Q57409,7,33;0/07 020073 /0/07 -003/07 9028.073 Q7.0 -0702007302090/0.097,328078080839/,742Q307/04,.,97:30/030 /0247,8833 -:7:;, /0247,883/03 ,9 -0 ,9 /0247,9 ,7,907 0303/0247,9,;0Q7Q07/0;0933,3,,8,83,:2,4::,07 5,790 807-0890 7Q90320 ,2, 802070 ,92, , ;- 42Q3079/,7350972002090/0.097,73/0/-

030 4 , 07 Q , /, ,9 /, -7 , 5,7,20394/, 309. 8313 ,3Q08339Q90280/0.039,30920073042Q307-23/07Q9032,,209 0/0.09 95 -7080 802 ,33 03/ 3 ;0 /,70. ,7,,3

07,3-7;0703020909208-(

C90 ,3/,3 42Q3 ,3,3, -7 0 030 4 , 0730 07,7 -770;03/720 0720903 /,, ,-,3. 4,2,(/03 ,73 030 4,3/, -: ;:7:8: -7 /0;0933 42,8, 42, 4::3, /,902090/,3$9,389,3,307097/-Q747,9,9,2,20,32,8339,2907830020,42Q3073/07Q9032,/3;00709Q2Q709.070304,3,8,542,/,7

!,7,2039,72/03 :79:2,33 4: 30/7 ,73 !,78 42Q3Q3Q 3.00070,7/ /07807 ,97,9,3 033 42Q3 9028 :7:2,7 ;0 802 083

2,, /0 ,1 /0720307 4,3 -: 9028 :7:2,7 ,7009 :7:2,7/:7:2:3,/3Q9Q7200/,,37/02090;00/0;,2092090/

:7:;, 945:2:3 8,9 ;0 Q7Q 5,7,2039,7233 0730 42Q3 /QQ3.0 ;09,792, Q7QQ3Q3 -7 ,/,92,., -23/0 4,2,/ :7:2,7 4,7 Q3Q 5,7,2039070703/07,2,,8,,703/07::,2,::,2,843:.:479,,,3 0 03/07 /0309020 802030730 ,7 /47:/,3 847:2: 42,47:3/,/7,7%028 :7:2,7 ,7 1,,9 0-7889024,7, ,8,2, ;0 Q7Q9201,,0933 ,72,8 4,7, 209;007 3 ,7., -7 43:2 4,7, 5,7,2039,72-:7,/, 49:7 %028:7:2,742,/,3-7 /0247,8/QQ3020007 -:7:;, 945:2:3 00978 -2 3 -4 -7 ,1 42,,.,8, -:7:;,33002033/0;720,-,84,73,52,3-7802;,,//0/0903;0 .// 4,.,8, /0247,8 5,7,2039,72 42,/,3 /QQ30-7 ;0

/QQ320 47:3/,(

42Q395 /0;093/,, -,9,3 83200 Q 9:92:3903 ;083200 ,00.03!,7842Q3Q/030290203/0-70/,,;:7:,2,9,/033

42Q3 ,79 3Q1:8:3 4:3::3: /0 -7 ,3 82Q7Q.Q07 0208 0709Q/0/0;0942,9,347/:-:7:;,/0;092,30837290-7-,8Q.Q0730 8,300 , ,,-,33 03/8 747/: Q9Q3 -:3,7 8.QQ3 070,3,23/, /0;090 ,7 007/7 '0 007 42Q3 /0;,2 0980/ 42Q3 3/0

Page 22: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 22/39

;,73 8Q7/Q72090 4,3 /0;09 ,39,7 03/073/03 830707/ 42Q3:7:2,73 ,/72, 0708323 /:2,/ : :7:2,7 ,79 ,5,., -7007,2,/Q/00204:7,7/(

42Q3 /0302 /0247,9 2070090 03 03 070 30980 073 -7-73 /,2,/3 42Q3Q3 8,8,20700933 0303 070 07

Q073/0Q80/3;0-,9-:3:2Q2Q3/3479,,42,9,/70333/,9 09 - 308 -,23/,3 207009 42Q307 ;0 -0073/0;09-739,2,20303/8900708,;:32,,74::,079Q7-Q747,92;0 07 9Q7 :,7/,3 -::72, 8 9Q720 -2/0 479,/,3 ,/7,303 -707030980072/9,,2,(

'0 033 308903 : 8,97,7 ,9,77 0 ;0 -:.,,7/, 030 4, 802202:7,7 ,7,., 9,20730920;09 9,7,13/,3 ,9,32 -Q9Q3 070;0 -080 494790073 479,/,3 ,/72,8(C90 ,3/,3 020 9007 /0;0930923,,/,3:,7,03/7Q9032007;01,92,790203/03,09200 720/0 /0;723 ,1073/03 8 0/0200.03 -07903 0333

807 43:3 -Q747,92 0 903 ::2,3 ,75. -2/0 479,,42,9,/7

 ,3.,/0247,9 90280 /0 -Q9Q3 /0;09 309233 90073 03/079,7,13/,3,,/,3 :,7, 3, 0/20830 90073 ,,93 -Q9Q3 ,/2,73, 093 -2/0,92,,73,3092/0,914,7,74,2,,73,9,.2;,78-,8,9,733 5483 -Q747,833 8Q70 47/:3:3 0730 ,3 0;703808,,3/72,80709030;70380-728307208Q033848,20/47:8,,2 88902 ;0 ,7,7 ,/2,7, 0702083 8,,,3 848,2 9050/033/7070 /0 5740907 ;0 ,75740907073 -QQ 9083 /0;09 30928,3,93,9Q2/0;099/,733:,323,Q809070-:3:8,,,30304/:7 4/,,7 0247,8 3902073 1 57,9 4:, 0203 2/ 03/ -,3,,,/,3:,7,/47:7033900730920093/47:/,3;00;70380

4,7,,92,,73,70090073,3.,-:/0;7239,2,1073083,2,;08890207020838,,,.,97(

!,78 42Q3Q3Q3 9,780 020 8Q70. 3/003Q 0703-7 3 /030 4/::/QQ3Q0-7:30/030,84,7,20;720:7:,3$4;099/,733/,, 8437, -,3, 00307 -: /0302/03 843 /070.0 302 843:,73,792,83 4,3, 2,9,/7 0;723 #:8, - 07 -7 Q0/0 90.7942,833,7,99-Q747,9 /01472,843:3;0 4,2,33/070-Q747,9 -7,7/0;72 8Q70.30 /3Q208 843:.:3/, 84;090733 9/,7 843 -:/:$4;09073 890720 -280 ;,7 /0;,2 0/0703 070 9/,7 /,2 ,0003 -Q747,9 /0;09 :7:2,733 030 09 $$/0 -: /:7:2 -7

/0;0933 ,3 /0247,8833 3,8 -7 0 4/:: 43:8:3/, /Q3, 57409,7,833-3.33;050785091339,2,203-:,32,83,4,9

03/ 002033 9/,7 0730 ,20 0/03 $9,389 -Q747,8 308304:,73 0;078 843:.: 479,, ,3 ,75,7 9,2 /, -0 42,80707208,,904700990.0$4;09-Q747,88 /0247,8830 3,7889 007 ,,,7 ,93/, 3007003/ 9/,73, /,,3, 90 0/0.003 -7 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,3, ,7,99 Q3Q2Q/0 $9,389 0030903

Page 23: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 23/39

45,2,,3 848,89 0;7007 -Q747,9 /9,97Q07 /0;090/0097200 /0;,2 0/070 /Q3, 57409,7,833 03/ 9/,73, /:,-0.00237020830209092090/707

07 ,3/, 80 /0247,8833 3,8 42,8 070933 ,393 -:2, 38,3207,03/030109200707208309,78045::0703,-,,77QQ47 :3:3 03 95 730 /0;72. ,7823 3/070733Q2020073/0479,, 43,3 /0247,9,,7Q7802070304 ,;--9020:38:7,7/0247,8833,90342,8,42,4:,7/02/0 ,,3,3 /030207 30/030 8,3 2/ 003208 070472: -83/03Q7Q9Q03 9,792,,7/7 8, ,52,8 07003 !,78 42Q3Q ;0 2 0;72/03020733;0-:/030207-,9,,2/0;72.3/07073-7,99,78027,83 3/, 9,2,2,32,8 07003 349,,73 03/03 ;0 03/03 479,,,.,3,8,,7/092083Q7Q2097

,7823%,32,/0;09Q747,8870;0997

$2Q7Q.Q ,33 82Q7Q03 4:3: Q073/0 0020330 /,,3,3 -:7:;,/0;09-:030/030/0;09073347,3,843:3/,5,,;0,72,-7,93 ;,73 47:3: ,7 :7:;, /0;09 ,2: 0733 Q7Q9Q2Q3/0:2,3,2 :2,3 8Q70 ,7 0/03 ;0 -:7:;, ,75,,7/,3 -080303,7.,-7-Q747,9,7Q7::3:077,2: 0733Q7Q9Q2Q-:7:;,/Q033,7,73 4,,3 :,7/,3 ,,, 07,7 -7 57,29 -23/0 7Q9032/,2 -Q747,9 :7:2,7, /0;09 ,9,73, ,997 8,.,8 ,59,89 945:2/,/0;09-Q747,9,9,7/,34:,3-7/0;0997

8,/0;093/0,2:073347,3,843:;0Q7Q9Q2Q9031,742,/:7:2:3/,/7 : 9,780 1,73 03 ,79 0/. 890708 /0;0933

 -Q747,88-7/0;0942,8,38313303/83/47:/,3/0247,84,7,7Q90208/7:0/0;0933,3,,7,9078942,8,42,4::/:7,73 !,78 42Q3Q /03023/03 ,70090 87,,/ 30207 ,3., 08 -Q747,9,807/0;09 ,932,,/0,33 0730087010/3QQ03000.0-7,93070-208303097

,7 /0;72 07009703 57409,7,33 03/ 3/0 -Q747,907,7 9,7/, -7-Q32033/42,2,8;0 57409,7,33 -:0/003/ 3/03,7/030103/073 3092 ,93, 7070 9/,7 9720208 3!,78 42Q3Q 953/030207 47:3: 72090/7 7 /0;09 /0;09 4,-20 ;0 0,,-203 -Q747,88 8Q7047/:8:/,,-,9,383200 Q 9:92:-7/0;09,342Q395-7/0;0942,47:3/,/7

,59,2/03 /0;7,3,3 831 945:2 ,583 8318 945:2, /47: 903945:28, /3QQ20 :7,9,., 4,3 57409,7, /9,97QQ /3023/0 3090330903831 ,72479,/,3,224,.,97::8:,7@Q3Q5740907/0;720831339/,7,0208-:7:;,/0;0935,7,,32,8-:7:;,3330903 831 42, 43:2:3, 843 ;07703 8313 945:28, 43:2,32,/,30903 831 54843:3, Q8097 0 /302 ,59,2 /Q3, 03/0

Page 24: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 24/39

9,810 70;0 QQ2Q 083 -7 831 8,;,2 /302/7 :3, -, 4,7, 57409,7, /9,97QQ 953/0 -7 /0;090 /::,3 2:9, 070832 3090330903 831 ,7233 479,/,3 ,2,/3 1,,9 57409,7,33 30903 83143:2:3,Q802080-:,72339080-7/020:7,/389077

C90 ,3/,3 831 ,3., !,78 42Q3Q 302073/0 0 ::3 -7 9/,7,5,32,83 8,,,-780 309. 831 42, 43:2:3: 8Q7/Q70-7 !7,990 -:3:3 2Q2Q3 4,-20833 8,/0.0 38,3,73 890230-,42,,3 ;0 5740907/0;723 -7 /Q3, /0;72 4::, /073/03 -, 4:,7 ;,7/7 C7303/0;72307Q007/0 90.79 42,2,8 ;0/Q3,,59,89 8890233002033008,8/,7-0073/7070070208070-74:/:78,/007-704342;0 Q9Q70 9020 Q073/0 ,3., Q7092 ,7,,733 /0;090972080 57409,7,33 /Q3, -:7:;,830 ,7 4,-0.0 -7 00203 Q 43:2:3,Q800-2084,3,/0/7

/0;093/0/0-Q747,80/::,30708323/0;,20/0.08,;/47:-78,;2/7

%45:28,,,2/,,1,4020,7,83/,,72;,738Q7/Q7/Q0-:,72002038313/0/03802,//,7,83/,-Q320-23/0,382,83 -::7 ,,9-: /:7:20 2Q090/,,3,3 831 945:2,7/, 2Q8,507300203 -7 831 42,9,3 ,72, 43:3 945:28, 43:2,32,/, 309. 83142,54843:3:/00:7,92,,7;0308-:43:,0/03707

-Q2Q002038313/0/038002,//,7,83/,-Q320-23/003/3890770-:,383130783/0,7-7007,904784,.,97

:83130783/0-:-Q320,99,20;.:9-:0823-0-7,79,;0

 -0-7/Q2,3,843:,3,-72,-:8313-Q9Q3Q090/9,93/,-::3/:: -7,92,,0/2-:,7903/3/03/Q07030020317073002038313 1707 42,,., -: 17073-: 8313 9/,73/,3 ,7 -7 9/,7, 8,54,.,,7:7:39:8:3:3/,::5997QQ7(

,59,89945:2/,002038314,3-:7:;,333/02,//380,7290203/0/0;0930923/0:2,3,2-7Q89309.08207,7:7:;,/044,7 549,.,7 ,,7,7 8;,807 Q80 /0;09 309.07 Q80/Q0/0 :2,3,7 /,70.07 ;- - -:7:;, /0;0933 ;,73 : , /, -: 549,,7, 8Q7/Q7200 ,1, 47,3 -:7:;, 0820 -,9 ,59,89 04342038Q7/Q7Q20838,,,3-:7:;,082-7-73/03,790/0-78,.,824/073 ,59,89 945:2/, /0;09 07 -:7:;, 83133 9Q2Q 9,7,13/,3 ;0

/47:/,3/0-:,,3/,:2,3,25,,;042508-7-Q747,97Q9032090203/0Q7Q9QQ7

,,788907 -:7,/,3 ,70090 /0;0933/024/073,,3-7/0;0942,8 30/030 /0;09 0733 Q7Q9Q2Q3/0 -Q747,80 /::,3 0708323/0;,2 0/0.03 ;0 -:30/030 890380 /0-Q747,833 479,/,3 ,/7,2,,.,3078Q7Q47,7

Page 25: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 25/39

8, -0-7 8,;,7823 /0;09 43:8:3/,,;7,, 02090/7: ,3 ,;7,3 ,3,3/, 80 -Q747,8 4:8:3:3 ,3 47:2,32,8,92,9,/7 :7,/, 802 ,2: 70;8 ,972, 070832 0-77Q90320 9,7 4,3 -Q747,8-7-730 ,7972,9,/7 ,2: 0733Q7Q9Q2Q3/0 202:7 :2,3 ;- ,972,8 0 ,2: 0733 Q7Q9Q2Q3Q3:,7/,3 ,,, 07,7 4947900 /,,3,3 57,29 -23/0 7Q9032083,3,9,3-Q747,8,;7,2,30/0/7,7823-Q747,833,/72,8-Q747,88-7/0;09,;7,2,,89099070;;0:2,307083233843-:2,8/0,2:0733-Q747,99,7/,7Q90320830843;07208/7

30/030 831 ,72 /0;,2 099 8Q70.0 70; 202:7 :2,307083233/0;,2 0/0.0 /47:/:7 ,2, -:3/,3 ,1,4 020 ,72479,/,3 ,/73.,,/0 -Q747,833 ,3 -Q747,9 9,7/, 7Q9032033 /0;,2 0/0.0 843:.:3,;,72, 83133 -7 ,2,3 00203 4,2,,.,3 3090200.03 ;0202:7,7 :2,3,7 03/ 3092 ,93, ,,2,,.,3 8,.,8 -Q747,942,,3-79,7/,7Q90320-,,7,2,,.,3//,0920,3,23,07

!7409,7, /9,97QQ /3023/0 ,3,3 ,1,4 020 ,7,83/, ,723/0;,2092083/03,,3;08313/02,//380,72-23/0;Q.:9 -:,3 -7 /:7:2 03Q 30830 4,7, ;,73 8Q7/Q7Q47 48, /, 302 4,3 -:/:7:2 30/030 83133 002033 97200.0 95903 -7 /0;093 ;,70/0-208/7 :7,/, 9 847:3 ,903 /0;09 847:3:/:7 @Q3Q 0 2Q090/,,3,3831945:2/,002038313/02,//380,72,38313/0 ,7 082 ,7,83/, ,92,,7, 4 ,8, /, 843 9,/0 00203 4,3082 Q7092 ,7,,7332Q093 9003/0 9:9,3 ,3 04342,/,3 002034,3082/7:30/030 /0 ,59,89 945:2/, -:7:;,/0;093 /0;09 0733Q7Q9Q2Q3/098,8,2-Q747,80-Q747,9-7,9,/,,32,8-:7:;,33

00203;0309.83143:2:3:/00:7,92,8,/0;092Q0930/,,3,357409,7,/9,97QQ/3023/0/0;09-7,7/0;09-Q747,88-7/0;0942,47:3/,/70757,990-:47:3::07300970202 ;0 479,, -Q747,8 -7 /0;09 2 80 -:4: ,93/, 2Q09/0;090/0;09/0-Q747,80,94,.,970.0/0;092Q09Q073/09,8,77:1,303/09:9,3-Q747,89Q2Q7092330923/0030,,.,398,/03/00020343:2/,4,.,979,/7/0831002033970.0-Q747,88000203831309.83143:2:3,Q800.097

,/0 57409,7, /9,97QQ /3023/0 /0 -Q747,80 0708323 /0;,2

0/0.03//,0920/0;0933-:7:;,/0;093/031,795907Q9032-7/0;0942,80703/03-70,3,2,2,/020974/073945:28,,,237Q903/72083/0/0;09903 8 0992 8Q70.0 -Q747,833 ;,73 /, ,-:0920 47:3/, 4,.,2 8,; /0;72. ,7823 /0;09 43:8:3/, 5078509133 4 -7 ,,/03 -,7094/::3: 80200 ,3 ,5, ,7:9,7 -7 2,39,90 843 9,/0 ,7823 37/QQ 9590 -7 /0;09334,3,8 /0;72073 033/0 843:3/, -Q747,9 -7 /9,97QQ3:7:2,8 0843:,3,.,03/0-7/QQ3.00;,77

Page 26: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 26/39

!7409,7,/9,97QQ3Q3 ,3 0 /30233 0 57409,7,33 02 Q7090302/030903-78314,7,-:,9047,7,83/,,72479,/,3,/72,8/7:3:3-,,72,8945:2/,,1,4020,7,83/,,723479,/,3,/7,.,4:,73 ,7,92,83, /47: ,92 9,780 -7 ,/2 /02097@Q3Q 9,790 -:,72 90203/0 070003 945:28, -Q2Q Q70903 83130903 831,72,83330/0342:9:C90,3/,3Q7090330903831,7233843-:2,80 ,1,4 020 ,7,83/, ,723 479,/,3 ,2,8 ,7,83/, 9,780 ,7009,83/,3 -7 -,39 48, /, -:3,7 /0 847:3,7 /0/7 : 30/030 /0 1,79,780/302079-,7,Q2030-707

8,., -07920 070780 Q70903 83130903 831 ,723, 843 ;07208 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 ,3 ,59,2/03 42Q320 0 /30233847:3:/:7,1,4020,7,83/,0;80,7239,2,203479,/,3,2,880Q7 Q709.073 -Q2Q30 0.0 -,29,3 03/073 -Q9Q3Q0:79,7,-0.007-79,780/3023,342Q389945:2:3847:3:/:7

/0;0933 ,5,32,8 /0;093 -:7:;, 945:2:3/, 7Q9033 903/097200 ,2: 07334,-/3.0 070 84;09070 /0;70/52Q2Q34,303:.:;00387,/,3070/3Q9Q7Q20857038-30/,,37:3:3,387,30/0:2,30709703-,07;,738Q7/Q70.0973.,9/,73308578 -: 073 -7 ,7., ;0 831 Q073/0 0103/ ,7,92,83 80203070 ,7 8 8, 847:2: 07 ,3 ,0/0-7 /0970-7 70;079,7,13/,3 Q7Q9Q2Q30 /,,37 07 5740907 /0;723 07 -7 Q00 ,5842,8/:7:2:3/,-: 0/0107 ,,2,070-0.0090704342;0Q9Q70-72342,/3/,380/478,49,/7/0,903/0;0933,,,-0.04:,7303Q070020/1,/00/47/02097

4/073 ,/, -, 073 Q7Q9Q2Q 3 ::8: -07 -7 - -72:2,3,2,07047,890972084,3, 9Q2/0;09 0733 87,/,3;0 0733 ,5,-0.0 -2/0/,92,857038542,, -79030/0-775/,07 3 87,/,3 -7 0 7/Q7Q0-0.03 /QQ320 4,3, /0 :3:32Q2Q3 4,-208 945:2:3 04342 ;0 Q9Q70 /Q033 Q80920830 8,,90733 8,92,83, ;- -, 4,7, ::3 ,7 ,58,,., -7 847:3/:7 :,/,3 /QQ3/QQ2Q/0 5740907 /0;723 07 Q0070 85 ,2,833 308304,7, /0;0933 ;,73 90/9 0/03 -7 /:7:2 ,7,9,.,3 :3:92,2,207047,,9-:7,/,/0;0932,8Q7Q003308304:,7,93/,30/0-7/0;09333,8,,9,.,-23/0850Q,91-72,39Q7Q92Q47:2,8 07003 9,32,,7, 57,990 ,,3,3,7/,3 30 - 843:,7 ,72,8

0709332039,4,.,-7030507850910/009208947::30/0309,7992 847:3 /Q3, /0;7233 070 3/0 9/,7, 003 57409,7,339 -:7:;,/0;093 0730 -Q747,88 -7 /0;09 0720 47:3/,4/:: ;0070-0.0070/7

/0;09,83/,3847:3:35Q1349,8:2,3,2,07033479,/,3,24:542,2,8 /0 9, /::,3 :2,3,73 3,8 ,972,8 0709 ,2:073347,3,843:3/,3092;0/0309232303/04,.,/707073 -07 -7 - -7233 ,2: 0733 Q7Q9Q2Q3/0 -Q747,9

Page 27: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 27/39

:2,3,2,,,7.,43:2,7,4,2,8-:7:;,945:2:3:3,583,::3 -7843:9:7/0;09330780-:--7233-Q747,9:2,3,2,,;0 ,7.,,7, 070 42,83 00203 57409,7,33 20930 8:3:2,838,,,.,-77Q903200/,,370333:-,9/0;72330703/0,709 099 0/01 ,83/, 57409,7, /0;7233:,2, 47:3/, 4/:: 030 -70/0197

02:7.:::-7/03-700707/0;09,2,203479,/,3,/72,843:8:0/020:-7Q945,/72,/0709Q2202:7.:::3479,/,3,2,838,,,.,03 -7 3092 2,30833 ;,9 072083:7:2,83, -,,2, 3 08 30922,3083 0203 72, -7 Q945, /0 42Q3 /03033 9, 03/8 /0;72. 57409,7,330.97020;0/70;339,03/8/7

07,59,29,7,13/,3/,,3.0,7,92-::3,30,7009349,8,503/ /03020 /,,3,7, 8079 -7 /853 8, 073 /0;09 9/,79,7,13/,3 47:3,3 /027/03 -7 /853 :7,7, -QQ Q7092 - 03/27Q900.0/0;09202:7,730-0990 079Q7 ;007/Q0/0:2,3,7 073/09:9,.,/70910723-,89::,.,774Q30847:2:07,32,84,3,;0

2Q90;,-75,7,,,38Q7;0,3;02:,80-0.07/:7:2:3,3/700.090-2 5740907.0 70;2 -:/:7 90 5740907 /0;723 ,5,703 03/83/03 -,,32,84,3,;003/83/03-,,32,8070030-:/:7QQQ7092902030/,,3,3 -: 30207 03/3/03 9Q2 202:7.:::3 /070 4 42,83, 9/0 -,89003 8Q7;0,38 092 ;0 2:,80-0 70;0733 ,2,3, -7 ,,3/:7:2:3, 0070 ;0 03 843: 0 -7 ,9047/0 -70073 0 70;07 4,7,479,/,3,2,Q070-:3,7387,,07089,7,13/,3,5,.,-7/Q033973,3/0 42,,3 ;0 Q.709 00 -0302003 -7 /Q033 /070 :7:2,83,9Q70.097(

8,.,8/0;09-:7:;,/0;09--Q747,99,7/,7Q9030207Q9037804 /0;09 4,2,07 ,3/,300203 57409,7,3303/ 0733 Q7Q9Q2Q3 ,59,89 -7 ;0703 - :2,3 ;0 202:7 ,972,8 -:3,7 /03090208

2Q2Q34/::8Q70.0,7.,-7-Q747,833,/,309.-7093/42,83,30/03 4,2, /0;093/0 /0247,9 2070093 ,79 0/. 3Q -Q747,9-77Q903200,794::/:70333-0799-

:7:;,104/,2:9,243,7/03-Q747,9,807/0;0920,32,83/0;7,/;0 43: 097/ 5479Q38907 00 ,7,83/, 43:3, -Q9Q3090702Q007/0-774,7,02507,20300-:20,32,4,,3Q89Q/070.0/0 Q03/7/ !7409,7, 9,33 70; -: 20,32, 5,7,,2,72, ;0 43: 2,, -007/0 03 :8:78: 07 /,7007 0 2070/0 808,,3257409,7,33/47:/,39/,757409,7,/9,97QQ0/0972097

,, /,7007 3,8 -700.0 -7-730 -,,3,.,,7/7 -7 0/0 /47

,3,78907Q747,9;0,807 Q270 ;,89,8,/47;0 ,547/,-:7:;,$,073-7;07Q9032080;00784;0907/47,782(

020 24/073/0;0990 2070093 47:3::: 349,83/,3 ,70090 /0;0933/0-Q747,880/0200.0-23/0-7843:.,2,,7823/0;09 43:8:3/, 9020 507850910 047 ,,9 Q $9,389 /0440/,,3,3 /QQ3.0 0902007 -Q747,9 /9,97Q07 ,,2, 3 ,782,75947,7 C090 0-0990 -Q747,8 4,.,97 42,/7 /0200 09747,7:3,73 8Q243, -Q747,92 00978 /0 07 8Q7/QQ 1707 /0 30

Page 28: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 28/39

 -Q747,833 070 349,83/,3 ,7009 092090 ;0 -Q747,8 9Q -Q747,8 -83/03 /0,89 ,9047070 847:3: ,110 3/705 309.0 4,7,030/0-Q747,833;,73,,2,9,/7

C90,3/,3-Q747,9/9,97Q073831332Q.,/00802,80703,-: 0/07 7Q3200 -790 $9,323 00203 ,93/,$4;090773,/,-0307073;07,-:0/530/0-Q747,84,.,977QQ3Q8,;:3,3,7/, ;,72, -: 9Q7 -7 /QQ3.0 9,7 ,83/,03/3 87 -7 /3Q0 ,580920,3,23,0202

:7,/, /0;093/0 -Q747,833 0703 8,;:3,3 ,7889070 0333Q7Q99QQ 5402903 -, 302 08907 ,97,2, ,7,7 4,., !7409,7,33/0;72/03 8437, -Q747,9 -7 7Q90320/03 ;,00200.03 //, 0/03,:980009747/:033(

:: 4 848,89 945:2/, 9028.073/03 :7:: -7 9Q7 5,7,20394,2,7023/Q0300.0;0,9303/030900.097,2,90-:,9

-Q747,942,,.,97 078,8,9/,70007/9038437,08-Q747,9,95,7,,,.,90200730/0,.,43/,9,Q89Q3/09,-7,2,,.,;043: ;0 70;07 ,58,,3 03 -7 ,9, /0970.007/7 : ;0 70;073 -Q747,9/:7:2:3,020073030020 3,7;03089,7,13/,30330-4:3,3.0032 4,3 30207 0203 ,3,.,97 07 0 8020 020 ,2, 07 ,370;/03 07 ,3,-20 33 ,/3/,3 Q80 42,,3 -7 Q.709  07083/03092 ;0 092 073 ,5,-208 ,307083 -7 ,2,3 3-Q747,9/:7:2:3,0208;0-:Q/0328033-Q747,94,2,2,830703020730203,32,8(

033 ,:9833 -:7:;, 5,7,2039,72 0 5740907 /0247,92 ,7,83/,9020 ,72,3,2,/3 -0797Q747,833479,/,3,/72,83 8902033

4.:, -7 /QQ3.0 4,.,3 //, 0/03 ,:98 202:7,7, -790 479,/,3,/7,-0.0 -,,3 ,38/7 /0 8472,9,/7 0333 ,:980 ,39:/:7

!7409,7,3092,93;09Q2/0;09,935,7,,7;043:307308,079,7,13/,34:9:7:,3-703834,7,:98-,,3,73/3/,7.,-78,890747,2,;0Q9028.073300203;0843/070.0QQ$4;090733,33/,;0-:$4;09070-,:2,3,7/,3:7::42843,730/03-:-,,3,707300208307(

C90 ,3/,3 033 ,2: 70;0733 -:7:;, /0;093 -Q747,9 20,32,8,93/,,32,4,7,-Q747,9,2,8,-Q747,88 /0;09,93/,/003

43:2,7,7,83/,1,7,/,902090/7,:988,.,80/072,/02802,2:70;074,.,080848,89702/0/0202:7,7;0-7-Q747,84,.,9790,34,3/,-:/:7,742Q373008907297,2:70;07848,89702/08020-,3,02007 -7 ,3, ,7., 07 ,3 70;/03 07 ,3,-/07 ,,7 479,,2, Q.70907/Q0303/7/;0Q8905,7,203907:7::,70730,7009,3,2,3/,02 Q7Q9Q.Q 02 /0 ,8,2,. 945::,7 09 Q/0 -Q747,9 42,9,3202:742,9,3,7,7(

Page 29: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 29/39

,7 !,78 42Q3Q 3 Q.709 0203 :79:::3:307002083 8,,,.,3,09-::32:8,8,-2/02942Q395/0;09/0;0933,790/.Q/Q7&:8, /Q0/0 1,74380020 -20748, /, -:3,7/0 82079,8,/,/0;09-742Q307,/,20;720-::32:843001,/0 0/0.0 4:78, 84;0907 /0247,88/7 2Q8Q 3,7 ,83/,3 ,79 -,8;0/,,92,33/0070-7/0247,83342,8,,790/0-7

:7:;,/9,97QQ 057409,7,/9,97QQ,7,83/,,72 ,84,7, :/0 -0747:7:;,/0;09,3-:7:;,33/9,97QQ03/0247,9-2,93/, -0 04342 Q 9-,7, ,3., 82Q7Q.Q ,3 3 /0247,9 82Q7Q034:3: ,83/,3 /9,947, -7 /0;0997 !7409,7, /0;09 ,3 57409,7,/9,97QQ 80 831 8,;,233 093 4:,7 30/030 -:7:;,Q070 30, -,8, -,;:72, 47:3/, ,/3/, -0 8,;, /302 ;- 82Q7Q.Q,33/9,947,0204:3:3/0247,9-7/0;0942,47:3/,/7

: 30/030 /0247,8833 2,:77Q0-7 30/03070::,3,2,/-7/0;09,90478.,90920/0;090/013/03;072-,,32,-7/Q34,.,97 8,;, / 90/9 ;- 30/030 /0247,9 Q-4,92 -2/0 /048,57409,7,/9,97QQ3Q330/0,,2,,/0;,20/0-0.03078Q703-7,3, 57409,7, /9,97QQ 070 0730 -Q747,9 /9,97Q0703 ,200/07

$4;0907-23/07Q903257409,7,33,7009-79028889023/00703/47:/,3 /0247,88 /0;0933 42,8, 42, 4::/:7 /0247,88 57409,7,/9,97QQ3Q3-2073/03-7/09,03/8/7:349,/,-:7:;,/0;09 ,5,32,83/,3 -03092007 ,5,7, 843:,7, ;,72, 4 ,3 4:7$2Q7Q.Q -7 ,3, /,,3,3 -:7:;, /9,97QQ3/0 -:7:;, /0247,88/9,97QQ382Q7Q039007Q073/0-2073/03,3.,-78/7-:7:;,9/,73 5,7,203907 /0247,8 0 -7 8 42,,3 5,/9,97Q 0 /03090-7 ,,957409,7,33 9/,7/, 4/::/:7:2/, 831 ;0 2Q8Q07,83/,3 -20 -, 42,83 Q 9-,7, 070 -7 /0247,8 /302,297,7943,7390500730-30.082Q7Q.Q-,8./9,947,-7002034/, ,2,297 90 57409,7, /0;72 /0247,8 ;0 /9,97Q 83/0 -:39080/02,7,970757,990-,9,7804:,742,807003047,3,2:,,2 ,75,7 479,, ,7928, -: /:7:2 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 -230 3 -7 847:3 /0 0 3 -7 847:3/:7 0 -7 /:7:2 -,

47:3::,7 30/030 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 -07 -7 9,780 08990 /0247,8842,/,3/,,,,-0.033/09,2907830-:,75,7,7,9,34:,7 479,/,3 ,2,/, 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 ,,,2,,.,33,709/7

!7409,7, /9,97QQ 945:2:3 0. 4:3::3: 4:9:7,3 02007 ,83/,3/0;093,58,23/,-7/,7,2,/0;09903/0;09800/0;09-:,3,2/,,79 -7 ,7 /0;09 0 /0247,833 ,58,23/, 2:,,2 -7 03020330203 0203 9,2 /0247,8 /,09 -Q9Q3QQ/Q7 : -Q9Q3QQ3 /0247,8

Page 30: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 30/39

3Q3Q05,/3238,3/QQ3.083/0-0-79,8,722Q2Q37Q380-0070 ,,3 -7 3Q ,8,,3 08945, -7 57409,7, /9,97QQ 4,2, :/:7:2/, 479,, ,83/, 57409,7, /9,97QQ 42,,3 -Q747,9 /9,97Q3903/0-7945:28,1034203,7

!7409,7,9,97QQ,;7,2D0730

!7409,7,/9,97QQ/302339,,-0.0;09,2,8070030073-:/3023 0733 ,7889 ,/,3 9,33 ,3 87, -,9 ,;7,23 03/83030 9,792,,7 43:8:3, /, -7 , 09720 07047 0;09 /03034:3:39,78,30830,394,7,,,2,073,,3;01,79,7/,831945:2,738,8,,5,32,83,701,7,3,2,7Q0303/0247,8;0/9,97Q,;7,2,7831,7Q89Q030007-70708,5/0/730/030 -2 ,8 /0320 890/2 :8:8 :/:7 $31 945:2,73 9,73/0 04,7, 945:2:3 4:3::3: 4:9:7,3 82Q7Q03073 945:2:3 ,334:9:7,3 82Q703070 ,7 9/,733 :7:,-208 ,3., 83133 /0;720Q3/020029790-:30/03083133/0;729,73/0,,32/07

/0;7207/031,74,7,38,3945::,7338,8,,,24:,73/,/,,3.07Q202 9Q7/03-QQ -7 9,780 ;0 39080 /0233 1,/08/70-7/02 ,32, 4,7, ,;7,2,73 4 ,3, /0 ,/ ;0 070 0707 -,23/,3/,2:,,2-7,9Q89QQ3;::-:2,83Q3/0200970.097

:3,-,4,7,/0247,8;0/9,97Q,;7,2,7-:,;7,2,734,3,/0,797/ 0700 -0302003 0503 -7 945:28, ,5,32,33 1,/08/Q030 Q800.097 0 ,59,89 945:2,7/, /0247,8 ,;7,2 8439,/0 ,84,7, 002038313 , /,00203 831,7 -4:3:3:,3,-0.08,8, ;0 945:28, ,,7 2,3:2083 /9,97Q ,;7,28, ,7.,,330034:3:Q073/0Q20920,3,3,97:-,2/,307

,;7,23,3,92,890/070,7,83/,:,2,-70;,7-/783/, -:0/0;09/03039/,7,5,32,833/,09-Q9Q3QQ3Q4:9:7:7'04 Q/03 82Q7Q.Q 831 0020330 /,,3,3 /0247,9 -20 8,5 -7/0;093 3903 -0 843 9,/0 ;,78,7 3 /0247,8 48:,7 3/9,97Q9Q7 /070 0900-7 90 ,903 ::3 ,7 -4:3., -:7:;,/044833 -3 -:,3/72,, 209 0/03 /044,733 ,,7,733 ;-,7592,, ;0 Q89Q3Q 79200 ,9,7 070 /0 9,2 -: 349,/, /7:7:;,/0;093 020 9007 ,83/,3 70.0 /,, 03 -7 8,8,/0247,8,,33, 8,5 -203208 7303 5,7,2039,72 -:7:;, /0448 9,7,13/,3/9,97Q4:8:3:3//;00;70380/0247,8-24,7,8:3:/::3/,3;002090070 -:,3,2,-032809/3/03 479,,504 9,792, 0709703847:3297

:3,7 ,7,83/, 03 3028 -7 ,2,3,7 104/, 2:9,090 ,7 2Q.,/00Q7Q9Q70303/831330800203831Q073/0/9,97QQ3Q390880/20838,;:3,3-:7:;,339,730703/0079,2907830/3/QQ3/0-:083133 2Q.,/0083 -7 831 /9,97QQ 9088 09200 ,2,, 8:,2,,7208/7 0, -7 ,2,3,7 2:9,090 ,7 2Q.,/0083/0 Q945,,-20 3 020 9007 030 /0247,8 ;,,/0 5030 9,,3

Page 31: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 31/39

 -:7:;,33 /,, 8437, 020 9007 Q073/0 /9,97Q903 -,, -7 042,,303/002033831,7Q89Q0;70380-7/0247,84,7,:99:72,,,2,8/7 ,73 07 178,99, -0799 Q070 030/0 -7 945:2/, 002031707 00203 8313 1707/7 ;0 -: 30/030 /0 /0247,8 ;0 /9,97Q,;7,2,7, ,890/03 070 83133 /QQ3.0 /Q3,83, /, -:7:;,/044833 572,83/,3 0070 ,387 30/030/7 07 -: 572, 5,7,25,7, 0/0.0 7Q9Q -7 /044 2Q.,/0033 30 020/0 -:7:;,/044833 43,7 Q073/0 0020333 8Q7Q5 9208 ,32,/7 :3:3:,398 4,7, 070 83133 07080 030/0 90073 /0247,8 ;0/9,97Q 8.Q073 -:7:;,33 890/ 0/0 -7 ,3,2 Q032 4,7,,-:092007/04,,3/7

90 -7 ,2,3,7 ,7823 :7:.:,733 Q073/0 3020 /:7/:,7 ;0 83133/Q3, 7QQ -,,23/, ,,2,, 7907 902043:,7/,3-7 /0/0247,8 ;0 /9,97Q ,;7,2,733 -:7:;,33 00203 4:,73/,07/ ,3,2, 83133 00203 ,93/, 070.0,3,2 ,7,83/,9,780,72/ ,,930 , ,7,/,3 003,7 -4:3., 831 ,7009 3/0 -:7:;,/0448330980,7823/47:,7,759/ ;0-:,7592,/,3 034 3,8-3 ,,3 43:,73 -,3/, /, /0247,8 ;0 /9,97Q 4:,733/,09 8 07 ,/ ,, 8437, -:3, -7 /0 2 0;720 :7:,3 9/,73 ,3 /0247,883 4 0/03$9,389 -Q747,9 002033 03/3::3 ,7 -4:3., 57409,7, /9,97QQ 4,7, ,380 0920833 ,7,992:,,2 -7 -3 ,752,8 003/ : - 1,97073 843:.: 4,7, ,83/,9,790082Q7Q034:3::3/9,97QQ4/::344:3:-,23/,3,3 ,2,3/, /0247,8 /020 4,3 57409,7, /9,97QQ 4:8: 8,3 ,39/0247,9 -7 ,;7,22 02033 4:28: ,3,23/, -7 /9,97Q903-,709208309,792,Q3/023084:/:

,3 847:3 -: ,;7,23 ,89099 0703 -,9 03/83/0 ;,7 4,3 -78,,99,3,3,,3247/:%,2907830847:3:3,3,-7,3/,3-:,;7,23,3,99 9,780 0700 ,7 -:7:;,33 Q7Q99QQ /044 8,/7/, /07,3/,3 /, -Q747,9 /9,97Q 4:8:3:3 307/0 ,7,99 ,752,/,,947/: ,/0 ,7823 8 43:8: 847:3 -,,23/, Q7Q90.0 /0442Q.,/0033 0/01 /0-0/,,907 43:/, 4/::--: 349,/,/, 8/0,788907847:3:3,3,3,30.007/00/019,9,83,57409,7,/9,97QQ,;7,2397/07;043,,9009200-,,/,7$43:4,7,:,/,-:30/030,2,3 3/0,7823 :7:.:,733 9020073,99,7 /044309 -:,3/'057409,7,/9,97QQ/03/3/00209007/08,343:49Q-7

04,7,,,,.,,72-23/0-70303,3,,3/

;09 -2 89022 ;0 7,/02 /3/, -0 -7 070 ;,7/7 ',7/7 ,2,9:9:2,807003/47:430/7$43:8:03/0/070-203,;7,2210/, 0920 48, -,9 03/033 ,3,3, 35 ,752, 2 /Q0920::8: /47: 4,3 3.8/7 @Q3Q 070 ,7820 70 57409,7,/9,97QQ/0247,88/02097,/03057409,7,/9,97QQ,;7,233,3 4:: 30 /0 43/,3 ;,020 30/030 /0 ,3 ;0 ,3., -:3:3,,3,92, 8903033 /0247,88 4/:: 0703 -: :3:99:7:,3 070

Page 32: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 32/39

,97,95 03/03 ,1,,7, ,2, -,,23/, /0247,88 ,;7,23:,32,-7907.30/034,-7:30/030,7;03083/,,03-,3/,3 -: ,903 -: ,, 00 ,/,73 ;0 847:3: -: -20 479,,4/:,73,97,2,,7,74,.,97

47:/,3 /47:, 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,2, 1,/0 0/2080 /0 Q9-,7, ,3 ,5, 2, Q070 57409,7,33 9/,733 070 ,3,23,003Q202007,83/,,7;03083,,73/,0507,/,97,3,.,-43,73 42Q389,310894/,;:7:,/,7-,.,:8:8-:3/,3-,,-70/0/ 42Q389073 ,. 0/0107 -Q9Q3 90 5740907 5,7907330 ,3/7 57409,7,33-78314,7,4:2,8-:7:;,00203332,88,8,Q.Q3 57409,7, 9,7,13/,3 00 07208(7 -,, 730 4,7, 2,3,/, -:7:;,/0;728Q70.3/03,70090,7;030838Q3Q099;0831338Q70 /0;72 -,,23/,:,3/,7 ,;7,2 57409,7,33/0;09 Q.Q3Q0007208/(:50785091,3.,90-7Q0/0/00304,7,,59,89Q007/09/,738319,7,13/,31090/20870;30,7090/47/:

,7 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,23 0 3/, 7,38,/, $31$,;,2,7-,,93/,945,7,3,32,,0073/0:,3/ 2,,083/0,77,38-:7:;,833/,38437,070003/0;72073307-733073030 /,,3,3 /Q03 /0972083 ,3., 8,8, -2 /097/3 -07947/:,,8437,7:2,70/080Q9Q3/0;7207-:,95,7,25,7,0/0.00707/043:2Q0220097/0779,7/,9/,7:7:3,8,;,,35,7907-:2:,,2 /0;09 ,583 00 0720 ,-3 08,8 ,3209 8,/,7/00703/72083 ,5,.,9(,,9 3,09 ,7,33/, 57409,7,33,,,32,8, /Q030 /,7-0 3/729 : 30/030 /,, 3.0 /0;72 ,;7,2/0;09 -233/0208 ,3 8,8, /0;72 ,3,23,0/ ,/0,7,3/,3

8437,,79-:7:;,945:2:32,8,9Q8942,8,3945:28,/0;72/0200047/: ,73 /00 !,78 57409,7,83 ,7,3 ,,,32,83, 47,,3 -:7:;, 42:9:7 :-,9 /0;723/03 /Q3 4,7, 45,72, 890/ -2 -,23/,3 ,-,792 07 4,7, 4.:8: -: Q/03 /0 -:7:;,., 4,3 ,89020733073/0;72.8,;,23Q5084,3,/:7:;,33/0;720883133/9,947,8(

30,73-:8Q70903,724/::302-7843:/,QQ3.Q2,,083/0 -0799 - 831 /0;7233 8Q70 -,,23/, 47:3: -7 0 349,84:9:7,3 57409,7, /9,97QQ 070 / /302/0 073 9/0 /0;72.848,2342Q323-:3,,32,/39,,3-:7:;,/0;7083/0

945,32,, -,,/3 ;:7:,,3 ,73 1,/080 : 848,2 030 4,7,831 1,7,733 479,/,3 ,/72,8 831 1,7,733 /,,3/,7 -Q9Q3Q7092 0733 479,/,3 ,/72,8 -: Q7092 0730 ::3 /Q03 -Q9Q3945:28, -,39,73 479,/,3 ,/72,8 -: 945:28, -,39,7/,3 /4,3 -Q9Q3/QQ3.0073,9Q89 0/20830 ;,72,Q070/0;7238Q70333/747:3: -70349,84,7,57409,7,33831/9,97QQ/Q7(

'0,73 3/,0/020070 ,/209:59,-0799-03/83330831,73;,7330/08318,;,2,73347:3:::3:479,,42:42,

Page 33: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 33/39

- -7 //,8 49: ,73 03 4,7, Q20/ :8:8,7 03/ /000/ 032 03 4,7, ,592 $31,73 ;,733 ,3., Q70923023/0 -07 9,780 0;70070 -, 4/::3: 831 8,;,233 47:3:4,7, 57409,7, /9,97QQ30 ;,7/3 -: /9,97QQ3 03/833 -Q9Q3831,73 479,/,3 ,/72,83, ;0 8318 -7 945:2, 0903 -,, -7 042,/39,39,2,42:9:7(

9,97Q8.QQ3Q303,39#42,:2:70933//Q2,3,7,,/,., ,7 47:32,83 ,2,,,3 /.9,9:7, ,/ ,3,,8, :7:2,/,,32,9,/:30/0309,3/4::3.:Q3479,,73/,9,78,30830,3 83133 Q.Q -:7:;, 47:9,3, /0 /9,97Q ,;7,23, 030/0/085492 , /, 2:9,09 - 9078 -7 ,3,2 Q032029 2,::8: 1,7 831 ,7,733 ,92,8 -,,23/, 7,38 0;72 8Q70.3/0743/0307 020 90073 ,,/,3 003 90 ,700930 /,,3/ 3,4-03073!,7842Q3Q9,97QQ3Q8:,2,9,307/:72,2,7/7/0/9,97Q 8.QQ3Q3 9Q20903/0 945,7,,3903092 ,3,23/,9Q-7,72;,7/-:,903-7-,,9,792,43:8:/:

020 30 ,;7,23 023/0/,, 8437, -:7:;,33 8313, 30998:,2, , ,7,., 083 -7 3 ;,7/ 30 /0-:,;7,2,7 .,9 0929,7 3/0 ,,/ 8,8,479,2/, ,903 /,, 3.0/03 ;,7 4,3 -7/0 4,7,43: ,7 -:2:9: '0 3 302 9,7,1,73 -: /0 :,32,833 30/03 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,233 , 0020330 /,,3,3 ;0 /0247,920.807 0703 -7 549 ,3,2, 8,5 42,8/ 48, 20733 //, 099Q070 ,;7,23 ,389 9,7/, 4254.: -7 ,33 /9,97QQ3Q ,7972,830/030/0(

C90,3/,30709,50/03 ,73/0;007080/0!,7842Q3Q/0302337/003/ 7,38,/, $,;,9, ,73 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,23:,32, 9,.3 880920 43:3 ,8 302 ;07/ :8:8:3 57409,7,330020333 Q 4/::3: 89072090/ @Q3Q4 42Q3 /03023/03 ,3843:,7;:7:,703;:7::/0;0930.:2:70930/0247,8830,529,,990,3/,373.39073,843,3/09,792,,7/,/9,97Q,;7,23, 4:28: -7 ,3,2 Q020 89003 !74:/43.: ;0 -0307 02070,7 /, 070 ,7 07080 308 42Q3Q 57409,7, /9,97QQ 4,7,390020903,32,2,7/,09,7349,!747,23309783/007,,3Q3Q5,8,3/,-0799 Q070 ,59,2/03 42Q3200 /30230 /03/Q03/0;0957409,7,33/0;72./9,97QQ3/03-,,-704,2,/

,73Q2Q3/038437,30809;08007043:,/03208Q7/Q7/Q!,7842Q3Q3Q3 /3Q2Q 3 7,38,/, $,;,, ,/790 57409,7,/9,97QQ 43:8:3/, ,59 8,;:3:: 42Q3 7300 842:9,/ $43,2,3,7/,$48,/0247,9,2,1,-70/,,57409,7,/9,97QQ8Q3/03,7-790770,529750-,,7-:/9,97QQ3300-030/3-208907 283 !,78 42Q3Q30 -,3 !,78 42Q3Q 57409,7, /9,97QQ/($43:4,7,,7;0308,83/,357409,7,/9,97QQ8902

Page 34: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 34/39

831335499/,71090920803/30020383143:2:3,Q809208,3/0247,883908809208,3,23,047/:

,,9 ,7 ;0 308 ,3 ,3,2, 8900307 57409,7, 9/,733/0247,9;0/9,947,1,7-2073/03809907,/,,3,3,2;0, ,7592 -20 57409,7, /9,97QQ30 /::,3 9, ,3., ,,7/0;72. 90795073 -,8972,8 70;0 3/ :3, 70/9,97Q 1,8 -90.0 8437, /0247,8 1,8 -,,,.,9 :9Q7-7,;7,95 -:7:;,33 ,52, 890/ 0/0 9/,73, /0247,8 1,833 30,2,300.0-042,,3-7,3,2Q02090/90-:;0-03079Q2,3,3,2, , /, ,3 47:2,2,,7, -790 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,,7823 :7:.:,73/, 3093/03 :,,9 '0 ,2,3 3/0 -: 43:/, -:,3,,2,7/07309,3,9,.,9

-0990$9,389 -Q747,8;0 ,3/,,7,83/,380-:-7 ,3,3,2,847:3:/0 /Q50/Q 30 0 020 847:3:/: C7303 $9,32 03/ -Q747,9/9,97Q 0703 , ,792, ,2,., 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q/0247,80 ,79 4:9:7,3 ,3., -,8 07030 209 0/03 -7 0 -8907/,903$9,32307097/549Q9Q7Q3QQ-:7:;,/4,8/,-:3,,93/07 ,3/,3 7014722,2 ;0 -: ,23Q3Q730073/03 -74,3;7:5, 42Q32 80 57409,7, 9/,7 /,0933 /9,97Q ,33 8,94:28: 9,7/, 47:2,5 /0;70 / -7,703 /0247,8 ,33 /, -:7:;, 5,7,2039,72/47:9:8:3/,/0998,80389078,890780847Q3Q2Q48:3 ,7820 ,7 ;0 ,99, 43,/Q2,3 ,2,7/,3 8,8 002033 831 9,7,13/,3 109 - ,,28, -7 43:/, /47: -7 9:9:2 -0020 QQ34:7/:9/,7,93/,/9,97Q/0247,8/,093/47:,;7,,-203070903,788942,07047/:

!7409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,23, 30 8,/7,7 0-0990 ,3 ,2,3,7/,7303 ;7:5, 42Q32/0 -303 8,8, ,23 479,, , Q3/02002 /0/7 : 43:/, 9,71,93 Q 020 :,32,9,/7 C73030738903 Q3Q ;72. $48,29,-3/, -: ,;7,23 9Q 4/::3: ;0 -7,2,8 07093 8,;:32,9,/07 ,3/,3 0-30.9 80 0738903- -7 349,/,3 ,7009 092080 /0 8,3 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,;7,,782/0 42: /, -:7:;,33 -7 ,972,82 - 47:2:47/:,;7,2

,:98 ,7 ;0 3083 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,23, ,9,3 ,7

2,/ /30207/0 -0 /0247,883 3070/080 -:7:;, 5,7,2039,72/Q030 3/7003 47:2,7 ,529 ,,9 07003 ,7 3/0 ,:98,7820,3090/3.0,78208,/78357409,7,/9,97QQ43:8:3/,/,842:9,/,73-:/02007037,89,398,4,7,:,324/::3:,3.,07 ,2 Q0073 848,890733 /0247,80 ,7 9,7 3 -: /0208,7/,73 //,099 '0 ,:98,73 0 847:3:3/,Q3Q ,23 :0/0/Q0920079$,9-:7:;,QQ209/0247,9/0;09/30208,9 5740907QQ209/0247,9/0;09/302,7,83/,-73/0390300/302 -::32,9,/7:3,QQ2093030:7,4,7,-74,843QQ20903/0

Page 35: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 35/39

4,.,-78,80/30290,-Q0/07(,:9833-:-3,7592,,730/030 033 43:3 3 ,:98 ,73 -07,.0 ,7592,83/, /Q3,7047:3:7297300738903/30,:98,33/,QQ-7 ,;7:4,7,,2,9,/7/0.09(

39073,843, 57409,7, /9,97QQ 43:8:3/,,7 ;03083 ,,239,7109280/0073-,,73/,#:8,/,/:7:2/,,1,74/:!7409,7,/9,97QQ ,;7,2 ;0 8902 !0,34; 9,7,13/,3 /0 #$! 5747,23,9,3/ ;0 /,, 8437, ,,3,3 8,8, 020073 03/09:9:2,7 1,7,8,/, -,,39,02030;02/040;,3,99,7,13/,3,-:7/Q,,930/000,73Q2Q3/038437,2,7:,/8,/7,7;0,7592,720730/030 57409,7, /9,97QQ30 /,7309 ,-42:9:3., #:8,/,:-,9 /0;723/03 2 0;7230 07003 8Q7090 57409,7, /9,97QQ847:3:3:3 103 Q3/020 0208 Q0730 033 0;09 ;0 0;72/0 -: ,.847:3, 03-7 -,,8,0,9,.,,7;03083 ,7 3/0 :3:99:7:,3/47:,73 Q3 3, ,792,, ,,.,9 ,:98 7303/0 4/:: -,7823 -:7:;, 9,7,13/,3 ,-: 0/0-7 -7 /QQ3.0 ,23, 3/703208,2,., 83133 /0;72 ;0 9/,7 5078509133 8:,3/72,8 9008,783/,03357409,7,/9,97QQ0/0134,,8,;:3,.,9

 ,3.,831,78,;,23,-:0/03-7-:3:,-:0993-7,7889/0/703Q-:7:;,/QQ3.0833-:7:;,549,833070;083/032,2-74,-7,782 831,7 8,;,2 709830 3/7020 43:3 4:3: ,3,/3 752, -42, 43: -:7:;, 3 ,-: 0/0-7 -7 00 3/7020 /02097 83/,831,78,;,233,-:Q3Q 57409,7,/9,947,833,-:Q30/0 030903-7,788997,3.,(

 0;09 ;0 0;723.002083/0 0333 /QQ3.0830 00203 4,3 ,3, 902, 57409,7,/9,97QQ3Q3/0247,883/03-,,-704,2,,.,17/4 -:43:/,309920;723/038437,42Q38939073,843,343708308:3/:: 9007/0 /0 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 82Q7Q03 4:3::3 00203,3,23,02080703/03,3843:.::80701,/00/47/:

:3/,3 57409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 47:3: 4,7, ,3., 030 4,7, /0247,9 -2;0:7:2,73/020830/0,2,,59,29,7,13/,3003020831,7,7,73, 070 /0247,833 /,, 3.0 7Q202 -703020830 /0 4 ,2,80709843:.:,7(

3.,30/09,50/034,,738.,3/0,2;043:3-:,;7,3,0 /QQ70-0.0 038 8,97,7 -:2, 2Q2Q3/Q7 0 ;,7 -:7,/, 00

,/2847:343:3:3Q303/707003307080%

74-/0;72.3/07073,7823Q3Q 800972 4/:,7 43:8:3/,::2: 4 :30/030 /0 0333 , /, 7303 %7433 09 ,,73/,3 802 2038 ;0 -:,3 1,/007 90 90 ,,,5 73007 ;0720 - -7 ,024,2, ,3., 070 -7 9/,7 ,93/, /0247,8 ;0 /9,97Q4:,733 -7-70 :,2, -7 ,79 3/02 - 47:2,32,83, ,7:,73909,,3302-7730,97,92, 890720;72/3023/0#48,:02-:7:383133/9,97QQ3Q3-,98313080742,807094:3/,;:7:8:;0070033307080 %7433-:3,,7/Q0-0.0-,

Page 36: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 36/39

038 ,,2,,7 ,3/, 03/08 073/0/7 739,7 -7 ,3, #48,338,97,7-:43:/,/47:,7889,,239:9,7-773038:32,9,/7

;09 /9,97Q 2, -: /9,97Q/0247,833 4 0/208/0 438: -7848,89 /3QQ2Q3 -7 ,2,3 0700970200.0 -:7:;, 945:2:3:3 20;03/ ,,73, ;0 04342 0730 ,7 0307 ;0 ,7,7

8,/7,7,::,32,8-23/0;,74:7,,9-:/9,97Q 831342,/7831,/3,QQ-7309.,33/0(

20;7233Q7Q3Q4,39/,733/,,8437,-Q747,9-7,7/0;7202,8 ;0 $9,389 /9,97QQ3 :7:2,8, -790 57409,7, /9,97QQ4:8: 30 9047 9,792,,7 ,,33, 8Q7Q3 0/2 4/: ,,9 3 ,8 ,. ,3 -Q747,9/9,97Q07033::3,7-4:3.,03/83/Q3,8313,57409,7,/9,97QQ4,7,:99:72,-,,72,8;0-0.007333/0-:,;7,23,799Q-7/9,97Q2,,.,3,32,8/:,752,33,387, 57409,7, /9,97QQ 43:8:3/, -3 -:,3/7,3 -7 -,, 8,8, 020 /0,,3/ $9,389 949,907 /9,97Q073 00978 -,,3080 03/30 ,,,3/7,30984-07,;070147289,2,7$9,320070-708,5,2,Q7Q920 0730 9QQQ3 ,3,3 /0;72. ,7823 Q2020073/0,7,/,7 %020 -7 847:3 42,8 30/030 /0 57409,7, /9,97QQ ,3,3 -,.,8::4,7,309907,7/,Q8003;7:5,42Q3233-,.,902,,73/,3-7-:3/08:,2,/

07 07003 ,7 3/0 /0;72. ,782 .05083/0 -: 838 8,/7,7Q800-0.0 QQ -7 ,92 8,,3,-80/ -:Q3 83133 9/,73,30574-02073/47:-70/000,3,-208-,23/,3::8:/,,-7349,/,4:3,-7/2,30,03Q-0-7-,,7/,380/0-202Q2Q3/0;0,73/0,7,924,3,7592,,73074QQ

!7409,7, /9,97QQ3Q3 8,;:3:8: 43: 4/::3/, /47: -7 9:9:20970-20 -,23/,3 -7 /0 3083 /0;09 43:8:3/, :,783,97,92,8907

2,07090/0;09-78313-7-,,89,7,13/,302083-72,30/03-,, -70/0/7;0-:7,9,30,/,7-080/0247,9.:2:70990/04,/,7 -0/7 03 /:7:2/, 831 00203 3 ;07/ 2:,1107 2Q.,/00/03 8437, 57409,7,33 27,8 ,/ ;0 95 42Q3 - 03 ,7,7 3073 /07, 2Q2Q34/::,/,74-:/,2,9,303/3,,2,,.,-7 9QQ9Q7 9, 03 ;0Q7945:28,4:,73/0092-7:,-Q9Q3-:/0;09/Q39Q8Q3Q:7/,3,7,7,83,17,9,-0.0,003.00/03(

83/,3083/,909:8:84302/7@Q3Q890780/0;0948:3/0;72. ,788907 ,83/,3 /0;09 ;,72, 890303 0/010 :,2,9,:,32,830,47:3:4,31,,93,0/01047,3,30/080;28-7,7,9,3 -,, -7 0 /0/7 30/030 ,7,.3 ,2,,972,83, , /, -28042Q323 57409,7,33 9/,7 ,93/, -0 48, 8,3 /0;09 ;0 /9,97Q,7,3 -7 /Q3, 7QQ - -,,,972,8 ,3,23, 00.0 ,,2,7,0830 ,7 2, 07047 0;72.,7823 8,;:3:2,833 4: -,

Page 37: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 37/39

9020 ,;7,2,7, 9,532,9,3 /0 4 ,;7,2,7, ,3,92, 890303 0703Q3Q3/47:0/0,;7,32,83/,3;0::39,7/,8,;:3:2,83/,3047

(,7;0308 2,3/0448$020,59,7.8

(,7 4342!493097830,9 $4,%022:8

(,7;0308 2,3/0448$020,59,7.8

(,77:3/788072,28

(,7,08/Q0920;7

(4:3:3,39,3/,3 9-,7038,9 Q70929,733;0 -7 /0;09 95 4,7,4: /08549233 479,,333.-74:800709,72945::,733-789843:.:3/,,-,3.1,907308,709,93,72007;0-:1,9073/0;09339Q2 9457,,73070 8,-,300208/78:7;-- 0/30204549,2,/0;090733:7:::-:4,;070-0.073007/7

(3087,3,7302 ,59,2C3.084342207 3/0$4,Q8

(,7 4342!493097830,9 8

(308 39Q73 ,703.08,7943/438 39Q73 $4,,798(

(308 39Q73 8,08(

(308033C0Q093;00;09303$020 ,59,7 .8

(30894790D0730$020 ,59,7 .$4,%022:8

(308$020 ,59,7 .8

($43:8:20933089030-00,29,7209:50,79,37,.00,2;049,!747,2330097830303,7349,7307039,7209:5,7/7

(03349,!747,2330978D0730,7;0308 49,;071:79!747,2,7330978 3/0$4,,828

(033,08

(033 ,7820;09D0730C3.Q,8

(033,08

(,7;030842Q389,310894$020 ,59,7 .8

(0330;09;09, 2;0$48,2,,798

(,7,3/308$00.90/478'4!747088!:-80788 $020 ,59,7 .8(

(,7,3/308$00.90/478'48$020 ,59,7 .8(

(,7,3/308,0'48,0.8(

Page 38: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 38/39

(,7,3/308,0'48,0.8(

(,7,0.8

(033$9,90,3/#0;4:94339073,943,!:-80788 0;09;09, 8(

(033 0;09;09, 8

(033,08

(033,08

(033!7409,7,39,40.90/478'4!747088!:-80788

(,7;03082,3/0448$020 ,59,7 .8

(033 0;09;09, 8;0

(033 ,7820;09D07308

(033-:7,/,;09,50/03-7,,39/,848,89945:2,;7,23-7,038.0:,329707090 57409,7,/9,97QQ/302,890/2090/7

(0330;09;09, 8

(033,08

(033,08

(,7;0308$020 ,59,7 .8

(,7;0308070429083342Q38970@,78$020 ,59,7 .8

(,7,3/308$00.90/478'4!747088!:-80788 $020 ,59,7 .8(

(,77,38,/,$31$,;,2,7$020 ,59,7 .8

(,7,0.8

(,7,0.8

(!7409,7,/9,97QQ43:8:3/,Q7Q9Q2Q4,39,792,,790203/00-7 3.0020,52-::3,3,7,507-:847:3, /,902090/707 020357409,7,/9,97QQ907233,36:0Q03208,734254.:-7,36:894/::3:,39,2,,0;08,7844,73-79,59,3903047:2,30/7 -20/0345,09907-7018,30/748,07090,36:33,,2;0,59,743:8:3/,-Q9Q34947900790723 4 87,/, 03Q -::32,/3 07 07 QQ070 -/7207/7 ,, 3028 /0247,9 90073:,3/ 549 9/,7 ,3, ,36:89 9. 9,97Q /QQ3.0830 9020/03 ,-,3./7 ,

7,507 !7409,7,9,97QQ%,792,800,,7,38

(,7,3/308$00.90/478'48$020 ,59,7 .8(

(,:98/03,9,747,730849,;071:79!747,2,7330978 $4,/5349

(033 :7:;,0247,88;0!7409,7,9,97QQ $4,,7,38

(033 0;09;09, 8

Page 39: Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

8/3/2019 Marksizmde Devlet Sorunu

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/marksizmde-devlet-sorunu 39/39

(033 :7:;,0247,88;0!7409,7,9,97QQ 8

(#48,:02-:7#:80;72$48,89$,8,QQ3Q%,7 3/0.,:89488

(,7,3/308$00.90/478'48$020 ,59,7 .8(