Liberi v Taitz - Plaintiffs Objections to the Declaratino of Michael B Miller Esq Dkt No 519 520 521 522 Doc 524

7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Plaintiffs Objections to the Declaratino of Michael B Miller Esq Dkt No 519 520 521 522 Doc 524

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-objections-to-the-declaratino-of-michael-b-miller 1/27

g

PILCM AN KAEPMEP[

Zibm{

PILCM AN KAEPMEP[………………………………………………………%%%%%%%g

PILCM AN I]PFA\GPGM[…%%……………………………………………%%%%%%gg/g~

I% PFM @MKCI\IPGAE AN OGKFIMC L% OGCCM\# M[Y%G[ GEI@OG[[ILCM……………………………………………………%;/99

G% Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ @mkci|ipgae g{

–eap‟ {gbem` lw fgo4 ie` g{ –eap‟ {gbem` }e`m| pfm –Zmeicpw an Zm|h}|w‟ ie` pfm|mna|m g{ Geiòg{{glcm……………%0/=

GG% Ogccm|‗{ @mkci|ipgae z|a~m{ pfm Zcigepgnn{ za{gpgae

pfip Bme}gem G{{}m{ an Oipm|gic Nikp{ mvg{p#

L% ZCIGEPGNN[ ALHMKP pa pfm FMI\[IW [PIPMOMEP[ie` @AK]OMEP[ ge pfm @MKCI\IPGAE an OGKFIMC

L% OGCCM\# M[Y]G\M………………………………………………%%%99/<:

pfm|mna|m# [}ooi|w H}`bomep g{ Geizz|az|gipm…………………%%>/99

K% KAEKC][GAE……#……………………………………………%%%……%…<9

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0/9 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9 an 0 Zibm G@+89;700



gg

PILCM AN I]PFA\GPGM[

Ki{m{ Zibm&{'

Lmkdm| ~% Oaepbaom|w# =;< ]%[% 2=2# 2>0#9<9 [%Kp% 96:9# 907 C%M`%<` 76; &<::9'…………………………………………%%%<

Lmwmem ~% Kacmoie [mk}|gpw [m|~{# Gek%#

6=0 N%<` 992:# 996< &7pf Kg|% 9766'……………………………………………%0# 9:

Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc #

Lc}olm|b ~% Bipm{# Ea% K^ ::/ :=>:2#

Kiol|g`bm Mcmkp|aegk{ Ka|z% ~% OBI Mcmkp|aegk{# Gek%#

<<2 N%\%@% ;9;# ;<9 &K%@% Kic% <::0'…………%%%…………………………………2

Kfi|cm{ A% L|i`cmw P|}{p ~% Xmegpf Kizgpic CCK # Ea% K :0/:<<;7 H[R#

A|| ~% Lied an Iom|gki# EP . [I#

A|pgx/Cazmx ~% [akgmì` M{zieaci `m I}vgcga O}p}a w

Lmemngkgmekgi `m Z}m|pa \gka# <06 N%;` <7# ;= &9{p Kg|% <::9'……………………%6

Zgm{xid ~% Bcmeìcm I`~mepg{p Om`% Kp|%#

[mcn/Ge{% Ge{p% an Iom|gki# Gek% ~% [anpri|m ie` Gena%Ge`}{% I{{"e%#

<:6 N%[}zz%<` 9:=6# 9:>> &K%@% Kic% <:::'……………………………………%%%%%2

Wmpg lw Oaccw# Cp`% ~% @mkdm|{ A}pàa| Ka|z%#<=7 N%;` 99:9# 99:2 &7pf Kg|% <::9'………………………………………………%6

>9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'……………%…%;# 0# 9;# 90# 9=# 9># 92# 96# 97# <:

<::; RC <<::<2;7 &K%@% Kic% I}b% 97# <::;'%………………………………%%%< # =

<::6 RC ;0::;0: &E%@% Kic% I}b% 99# <::6'…………………………………%%%%99

Haem{ ~%Lciei{# ;7; N%;` 796# 7<; &7pf Kg|% <::0'………%%……………………%%<# =

<6= N%;` 2>=# 226/227 &7pf Kg|% <::<'………………………%%%…%;# 0# 9:# 99# 9;/ <:

99< N% [}zz% <` 72:# 760 e%9; &K%@% Kic% <:::'………………………………%…%99

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0/9 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm < an 0 Zibm G@+89;70=



ggg

PILCM AN I]PFA\GPGM[ ‛ Kaepge}m`

NM@M\IC [PIP]PM[

Zibm&{'

<6 ]%[%K% ¢920>………………………………………………………%9# <# 0# =# <:

NM@M\IC \]CM[ AN KG^GC Z\AKM@]\M

Zibm&{'

\}cm <>&i'…………………………………………………………………………%%2

\}cm <>&m'…………………………………………………………………………%%2

\}cm <>&m'&9'………………………………………………………………………%2

\}cm ;2&k'&9'………………………………………………………………………2

NM@M\IC \]CM[ AN M^G@MEKM

Zibm&{'

Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢>:<…………………………………………………………;# 99# 90

Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢6:9&k'………………………………………………………%%99# <:

\}cm ;2…………………………………………………………………………%%2# 6

\}cm =>&k'&0'…………………………………………………………………%%%;# <:

\}cm =>&f'…………………………………………………………………………%;

\}cm =>&;'…………………………………………………………………………%;

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0/9 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm ; an 0 Zibm G@+89;70>



g~

PILCM AN I]PFA\GPGM[ ‛ Kaepge}m`

NM@M\IC \]CM[ AN M^G@MEKM

Zibm&{'

Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢>:<…………………………………………………………;# 99# 90

Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢6:9&k'…………………………………………………%%……%%99# <:

EGEPF KG\K]PG CAKIC \]CM

Zibm&{'

\}cm ;2/9…………………………………………………………………………%%6

Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢7:9&i'…………………………………………………………99# <:

Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢6:<……………………………………………………99# 9=# 92# <:

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0/9 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 0 an 0 Zibm G@+89;702





Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m <

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

ie` pfm|mna|m g{ geiòg{{glcm% [mm Lc}olm|b ~% Bipm{# Ea% K^ ::/

:=>:2# <::; RC <<::<2;7 &K%@% Kic% I}b% 97# <::;' & Haem{ ~

Lciei{# ;7; N%;` 796# 7<; &7pf Kg|% <::0' &|my}g|geb pfip kaepmepgae{

ge i Oapgae na| [}ooi|w H}`bomep o}{p lm li{m` ae zm|{aei

dearcm`bm ie` pfm `mkci|iep {mp na|pf nikp{ pfip ra}c` lm iòg{{glcm

ge m~g`mekm# –ippm{pm` Tpa_ }e`m| zmeicpw an zm|h}|w pfip pfm kaepmep{ an

pfm oapgae{ a| zcmi`geb{ i|m p|}m ie` ka||mkp%‟' y}apgeb <6 ]%[%K

¢920> &|my}g|geb icc inngì~gp{ pa lm oi`m ae zm|{aeic dearcm`bm

}e`m| zmeicpw an zm|h}|w'%

gg% Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ @mkci|ipgae g{ eap {gbem` lw O|% Ogccm|

ea| z|azm|cw i}pfmepgkipm` i{ pa fg{ dearcm`bm an pfm {pipmomep{

i{{m|pm`# Lc}olm|b ~% Bipm{# <::;RC <<::<2;7# ip (9&K%@

Kic%I}b%97# <::;' &,Pfm z|alipg~m na|km an i `mkci|ipgae {}l{k|glm`

}e`m| zmeicpw an zm|h}|w `m|g~m{ n|ao pfm {gbeip}|m an pfm `mkci|iep

Rgpfa}p pfm `mkci|iep"{ {gbeip}|m# i @mkci|ipgae g{ kaozcmpmcw |allm`

an iew m~g`mepgi|w na|km%,'4 [mm ic{a Lmkdm| ~% Oaepbaom|w# =;< ]%[

2=2# 2>0# 9<9 [%Kp% 96:9# 907 C%M`%<` 76; &<::9' &–…rm |mi` pfm

|my}g|momep an i {gbeip}|m pa ge`gkipm# i{ i {gbeip}|m |my}g|momep

kaooaecw àm{# ie` i{ gp `g` ge Hafe Fiekakd"{ ìw# i eiom

fie`r|gppme &a| i oi|d fie` zcikm`'‟%

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm < an <9 Zibm G@+89;7<0



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m ;

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

ggg% Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ @mkci|ipgae g{ geiòg{{glcm lmki}{m gp g{

li{m` ae fmi|{iw ie` à}lcm fmi|{iw {pipmomep{ ge ~gacipgae an

Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm

oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| ~% Lied an Iom|gki# EP . [I# <6= N%;`

2>=# 226/227 &7pf Kg|% <::<'4 Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae

Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

g~% Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ @mkci|ipgae g{ geiòg{{glcm i{ O|% Ogccm|

àm{ eap fi~m zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an pfm {pipmomep{ a}pcgem` i{

–nikp{‟ ge ~gacipgae an Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢>:< ie` Nm`% \% Kg~% Z% =>&k'&0'

ie`

~% Pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m ri{ {}logppm` ge li`

nigpf ie` pfm|mna|m# Zcigepgnn{ {fa}c` lm Iri|`m` Ippa|emw Nmm{ ie`

Ka{p{# Nm`% \% Kg~% Z% =>&f'%

I% PFM @MKCI\IPGAE AN OGKFIMC L% OGCCM\# M[Y% G[

GEI@OG[[ILCM8

Ae Oiw 2# <:9<# pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ ngcm` pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L%

Ogccm|# M{y}g|m ge {}zza|p an pfmg| Oapgae na| [}ooi|w H}`bomep% [mm @akdmp Ea

T–@E‟_ =97# =<:# =<9 ie` =<<%

Rfme |}cgeb ae i Oapgae na| [}ooi|w H}`bomep# i P|gic Ka}|p kie aecw

kae{g`m| iòg{{glcm m~g`mekm% Nm`% \% Kg~% Z% =>&;'4 A|| ~% Lied an Iom|gki# EP .

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm ; an <9 Zibm G@+89;7<=



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 0

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

[I# <6= N%;` 2>=# 22; &7pf Kg|% <::<'% @ak}omep{ o}{p lm i}pfmepgkipm` a| pfm

Ka}|p rgcc eap kae{g`m| pfmo% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 22;% [mm ic{a Nm`% \% M~g`% 7:9&i'

fmi|{iw àk}omep{ ie` {pipmomep{# annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|# rgcc eap lm

kae{g`m|m` lw pfm Ka}|p# [mm Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<4 A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/

2274 ie` Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|

976:'% Ge `mkg`geb i [}ooi|w H}`bomep Oapgae# nigc}|m pa ciw i na}eìpgae

i}pfmepgkipm àk}omep{# ie` cikd an zm|{aeic dearcm`bm ge @mkci|ipgae{# m~g`mekm

{}logppm`# rgcc eap lm kae{g`m|m`% Lmwmem ~% Kacmoie [mk}|gpw [m|~{# Gek%# 6=0 N

<` 992:# 996< &7pf Kg|% 9766'4 A|| # <6= N% ;` ip 22;/220# 222%

G% Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ @mkci|ipgae g{ –eap‟ {gbem` lw

fgo4 ie` g{ –eap‟ {gbem` }e`m| pfm –Zmeicpw an Zm|h}|w‟ ie`

pfm|mna|m g{ Geiòg{{glcm8

]e{ra|e @mkci|ipgae{ o}{p kaozcw rgpf <6 ]%[%K% ¢920> pa lm iòg{{glcm

<6 ]%[%K% ¢920> {pipm{8

Rfm|m~m|# }e`m| iew cir an pfm ]egpm` [pipm{ a| }e`m| iew |}cm#|mb}cipgae# a|`m|# a| |my}g|momep oi`m z}|{}iep pa cir# iew oippm| g{

|my}g|m` a| zm|ogppm` pa lm {}zza|pm #̀ m~g`mekm`# m{pilcg{fm`# a| z|a~m` lw pfm {ra|e `mkci|ipgae# ~m|gngkipgae# km|pgngkipm# {pipmomep#

aipf# a| inngì~gp# ge r|gpgeb an pfm zm|{ae oidgeb pfm {iom &apfm| pfiei `mza{gpgae# a| ie aipf an anngkm# a| ie aipf |my}g|m` pa lm pidme

lmna|m i {zmkgngm` anngkgic apfm| pfie i eapi|w z}lcgk'# {}kf oippm| oiw# rgpf cgdm na|km ie` mnnmkp# lm {}zza|pm`# m~g`mekm`# m{pilcg{fm`#

a| z|a~m` lw pfm }e{ra|e `mkci|ipgae# km|pgngkipm# ~m|gngkipgae# a|

{pipmomep# ge r|gpgeb an {}kf zm|{ae rfgkf g{ {}l{k|glm` lw fgo# i{

p|}m }e`m| zmeicpw an zm|h}|w# ie` ìpm`# ge {}l{piepgiccw pfm naccargebna|o8

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 0 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7<>



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m =

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

&9' Gn mvmk}pm` rgpfa}p pfm ]egpm` [pipm{8 ‖‖G `mkci|m &a| km|pgnw#~m|gnw# a| {pipm' }e`m| zmeicpw an zm|h}|w }e`m| pfm cir{ an pfm ]egpm`

[pipm{ an Iom|gki pfip pfm na|mbageb g{ p|}m ie` ka||mkp% Mvmk}pm` ae&ìpm'% &[gbeip}|m'‗‗%

&<' Gn mvmk}pm` rgpfge pfm ]egpm` [pipm{# gp{ pm||gpa|gm{# za{{m{{gae{# a|

kaooaermicpf{8 ‖‖G `mkci|m &a| km|pgnw# ~m|gnw# a| {pipm' }e`m| zmeicpwan zm|h}|w pfip pfm na|mbageb g{ p|}m ie` ka||mkp% Mvmk}pm` ae &ìpm'%

&[gbeip}|m'‗‗%

Ogccm|‗{ @mkci|ipgae g{ eap {gbem`# km|pgngm`# ~m|gngm`# a| {pipm` }e`m| pfm

–zmeicpw an zm|h}|w pfip pfm na|mbageb g{ p|}m ie` ka||mkp‟ a| iewpfgeb kca{m pfm|mpa

ge ~gacipgae an <6 ]%[%K% ¢920>% Pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogccm| g{ eap {gbem` lw Ogccm|

l}p ge{pmi` fg{ eiom ri{ r|gppme ae pfm {gbeip}|m cgem lw {aom }edeare ge`g~g`}i

rfa zcikm` ge zi|mepfm{g{ –rgpf zm|og{{gae‟% Pf}{# pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L

Ogccm|# M{y}g|m g{ geiòg{{glcm% Lc}olm|b ~% Bipm{# Ea% K^ ::/:=>:2# <::; RC

<<::<2;7 &K%@% Kic% I}b% 97# <::;' &Eap {mcmkpm` na| z}lcgkipgae' & Haem{ ~

Lciei{# ;7; N%;` 796# 7<; &7pf Kg|% <::0' &|my}g|geb pfip kaepmepgae{ ge i Oapgae

na| [}ooi|w H}`bomep o}{p lm li{m` ae zm|{aeic dearcm`bm ie` pfm `mkci|iep {mp

na|pf nikp{ pfip ra}c` lm iòg{{glcm ge m~g`mekm# –ippm{pm` Tpa_ }e`m| zmeicpw an

zm|h}|w pfip pfm kaepmep{ an pfm oapgae{ a| zcmi`geb{ i|m p|}m ie` ka||mkp%‟' y}apgeb

<6 ]%[%K% ¢920> &|my}g|geb icc inngì~gp{ pa lm oi`m ae zm|{aeic dearcm`bm }e`m|

zmeicpw an zm|h}|w'%

Na| pfm{m |mi{ae{ icaem# pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m o}{p

eap lm kae{g`m|m` lw pfm Ka}|p%

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm = an <9 Zibm G@+89;7<2



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m >

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

GG% Ogccm|‗{ @mkci|ipgae z|a~m{ pfm Zcigepgnn{ za{gpgae pfip Bme}gem

G{{}m{ an Oipm|gic Nikp{ mvg{p# pfm|mna|m# [}ooi|w H}`bomep g{

Geizz|az|gipm8

[fa}c` pfg{ Ka}|p `mkg`m pa iccar pfm gekaozcgiep @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc

Ogccm|# Ogccm|‗{ `mkci|ipgae àm{ eap i{{g{p pfm @mnmeìep{ Oapgae na| [}ooi|w

H}`bomep%

Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpm` ie` \my}m{pm` pa lm [p|gkdme# z}|{}iep pa Nm`% \% Kg~% Z

;2 pfm @mkci|ipgae{ an Cg{i [gooae{# [gooae{ Mvfglgp{# ie` pfm @mkci|ipgae an

Cg{i Zacgki{p|a i{ pfm{m rgpem{{m{ rm|m eap `g{kca{m` pa Zcigepgnn{ lw pfm \mm`

@mnmeìep{ ge pfmg| @g{ka~m|w \m{zae{m{ a| Gegpgic @g{kca{}|m{% [mm pfm \my}m{p pa

[p|gdm ie` Alhmkpgae{ ngcm` lw Zcigepgnn{ ae Iz|gc <:# <:9<# @E =:2 ip zz% </># ¾I%

Ge |m{zae{m pfm|mpa# Ogccm| iògp{ pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ em~m| `g{kca{m` Cg{i

[gooae{# pfm Mvfglgp{ ippikfm` pa [gooae{ @mkci|ipgae a| Cg{i Zacgki{p|a% [mm

Ogccm|‗{ @mkci|ipgae ip zz% 92/96# ¾92% Ge {}zza|p pfm|man# Ogccm| ippikfm{ i{

Mvfglgp –I‟ Ikk}|gep‗{ \m{zae{m{ pa Zcigepgnn{ Gepm||abipa|gm{ ie` |mnm|mekm{

Mvfglgp –I‟# Gepm||abipa|w \m{zae{m{ 9 ie` <# rfgkf àm{ eap fmcz pfmo# i{ pfm

aecw zi|pgm{ `g{kca{m` rm|m Dm~ge Nacmw# Hmeegnm| H}eb ie` Cgeì Kci|d# ea

|mnm|mekm rfip{am~m| pa Cg{i [gooae{ a| Cg{i Zacgki{p|a a| pfm àk}omep{

ippikfm` pa Cg{i [gooae{ @mkci|ipgae i{ Mvfglgp{ –I‟# –L‟ ie` –K‟%

Ogccm| ic{a |mnm|mekm{ pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ |m{zae{m pa Gepm||abipa|w

e}olm| 6# kcigogeb pfip –~g|p}iccw iew mozcawmm an Cmvg{Emvg{ \g{d @ipi

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm > an <9 Zibm G@+89;7<6




9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

Oieibmomep# Gek% a| apfm| an pfm Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{ ka}c` fi~m z|a~g`m` pfip

pm{pgoaew%‟ I{ z|a~me lw Ogccm|‗{ Mvfglgp –I‟# Gepm||abipa|w \m{zae{m Ea% 6

àm{ eap |mncmkp pfg{ ip icc% Rfip pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ {pipm i{ pfmg| \m{zae{m pa

Gepm||abipa|w Ea# 6 i|m lagcm|zcipm alhmkpgae{ ie` –[}lhmkp pa ie` rgpfa}p rig~geb

iew alhmkpgae# @mnmeìep {pipm{ pfip pfm ngcm{ kaepigegeb {mi|kf k|gpm|gi }{m` pa

|}e |mza|p{ ibige{p pfm Ikk}|gep ìpili{m ge <::7 fi~m eap lmme `mcmpm` ‟

Tmozfi{g{ i``m`_%

\}cm <>&m'&9' an pfm Nm`m|ic \}cm{ an Kg~gc Z|akm`}|m z|a~g`m{ pfip cgpgbiep{

fi~m i kaepge}geb `}pw pa {}zzcmomep a| ka||mkp icc gepm||abipa|w |m{zae{m{ ie`

|my}m{p{ na| z|a`}kpgae gn pfmg| z|ga| |m{zae{m{ i|m mgpfm| gekaozcmpm a| geka||mkp

Nm`% \% Kg~% Z% <>&m'&9'4 [mm ic{a Kiol|g`bm Mcmkp|aegk{ Ka|z%# <<2 N%\%@% ip ;<9%

]e`m| \}cm ;2&k'&9' an pfm Nm`m|ic \}cm{ an Kg~gc Z|akm`}|m# i zi|pw g{

bmem|iccw z|mkc}`m` n|ao }{geb m~g`mekm eap `g{kca{m` i{ |my}g|m` }e`m| \}cm

<>&m'&9'% [mm Kiol|g`bm Mcmkp|aegk{ Ka|z% ~% OBI Mcmkp|aegk{# Gek%# <<2 N%\%@

;9;# ;<9 &K%@% Kic% <::0'4 [mcn/Ge{% Ge{p% an Iom|gki# Gek% ~% [anpri|m ie` Gena

Ge`}{% I{{"e%# <:6 N%[}zz%<` 9:=6# 9:>> &K%@% Kic% <:::'% \}cm ;2 z|a~g̀ m{ pfip

–Tg_n i zi|pw nigc{ pa z|a~g`m gena|oipgae a| g`mepgnw i rgpem{{ % % % i{ |my}g|m` lw

\}cm <>&i' a| &m'# pfm zi|pw g{ eap iccarm` pa }{m pfip gena|oipgae a| rgpem{{ % % % pa

{}zzcw m~g`mekm ae i oapgae# ip i fmi|geb# a| ip p|gic# }ecm{{ pfm nigc}|m ri{

{}l{piepgiccw h}{pgngm` a| fi|ocm{{%‟ Nm`% \% Kg~% Z% ;2&k'&9'% Pfm l}|`me an

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 2 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7<7




9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

`moae{p|ipgeb pfip pfm nigc}|m g{ {}l{piepgiccw h}{pgngm` a| fi|ocm{{ nicc{ ae pfm

annme`geb zi|pw% [mm Wmpg lw Oaccw# Cp̀ % ~% @mkdm|{ A}pàa| Ka|z%# <=7 N%;` 99:9

99:2 &7pf Kg|% <::9'%

I{ eapm` lw pfm Egepf Kg|k}gp ge Wmpg# \}cm ;2 g{ gepme`m` pa z|a~g`m i {p|aeb

ge`}kmomep na| `g{kca{}|m# ie` i –{mcn/mvmk}pgeb‟ ie` –i}paoipgk‟ {iekpgae na| pfm

nigc}|m pa z|a`}km oipm|gic `}|geb pfm g̀{ka~m|w z|akm{{% G` % ip 99:> &kgpgeb Nm`% \

Kg~% Z% ;2 i`~g{a|w kaoogppmm"{ eapm &977;' ie` eapgeb –zi|pgk}ci|cw rg`m cipgp}`m‟

bg~me pa `g{p|gkp ka}|p{ pa mvkc}`m m~g`mekm }e`m| pfg{ z|a~g{gae'% –Ka}|p{ fi~m

}zfmc` pfm {p|gdgeb an {}kf m~g`mekm m~me rfme pfm cgpgbiep‗{ mepg|m ki}{m an ikpgae

a| `mnme{m fi{ lmme z|mkc}`m`%‟ G` % &kgpgeb A|pgx/Cazmx ~% [akgmì` M{zieaci `m

I}vgcga O}p}a w Lmemngkgmekgi `m Z}m|pa \gka# <06 N%;` <7# ;= &9{p Kg|% <::9''

Ea| g{ gp emkm{{i|w pa {far rgccn}c gepmep ae pfm zi|p an pfm annme`geb zi|pw

mvkc}{gae g{ ie izz|az|gipm |mom`w ge pfm il{mekm an li` nigpf a| ie mvzcgkgp ka}|p

a|`m|% [mm Wmpg# <=7 N%;` ip 99:>%

Ogccm| ge fg{ @mkci|ipgae kcigo{ Zfgcgz H% Lm|b# M{y}g|m `g` eap ommp ie`

kaenm| z|ga| pa ngcgeb Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae{ an Cg{i [gooae{

Mvfglgp{ ippikfm` pa [gooae{ @mkci|ipgae ie` Cg{i Zacgki{p|a z}|{}iep pa Nm`% \%

Kg~% Z% ;2/9% Pfg{ {gozcw g{ eap pfm ki{m% O|% Lm|b {}logppm` i `mpigcm` cmppm| pa

O|% OkKilm ie` O| % Ogccm| ae Oi|kf <=# <:9< |mbi|`geb pfm goz|azm| |m{zae{m{

nigc}|m pa z|a~g̀ m àk}omep{# ie` {gozcw i{{m|p lagcm|zcipm alhmkpgae{% Pfm

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 6 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;:




9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

oa|egeb inpm| {me`geb pfg{ cmppm|# O|% Lm|b# O|% Ogccm| ie` G|mem Zm|p{a~dw n|ao

O|% Ogccm|‗{ anngkm kae`}kpm` i –Ommp ie` Kaenm|‟ |mbi|`geb pfm g̀{ka~m|w g{{}m{

ae Iz|gc 0# <:9<# l}p pfm g{{}m{ rm|m cmnp }e|m{ac~m`% [mm pfm @mkci|ipgae an Zfgcgz

H% Lm|b T–Lm|b @mkc%‟_ ip zz% <;/<0# ¾07# ngcm` kaek}||mepcw fm|mrgpf%

Zcigepgnn{ alhmkpm` ie` |my}m{pm` pfg{ Ka}|p pa [p|gdm pfm pm{pgoaew ie`

Mvfglgp{ z|a~g`m` lw Emgc [iedmw zm|pigegeb pa rfm|m fm alpigem` Zcigepgnn Cglm|g‗{

[akgic [mk}|gpw e}olm| i{ pfm {pipmomep{ ie` àk}omep{ rm|m fmi|{iw4 pfip pfm

àk}omep{ rm|m }ei}pfmepgkipm`# pfip pfmw cikdm` na}eìpgae# ie` Emgc [iedmw `g`

eap fi~m iew zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an pfm {pipmomep{ a| àk}omep{ lmki}{m fm

alpigem` pfm àk}omep{ n|ao pfg{ Ka}|p‗{ @akdmp ge <:9: ie` <:99# ie` eap ge

<::7 n|ao rfm|m fm kcigom`% Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ ie` \my}m{p pa [p|gdm rm|m

n}|pfm| li{m` ae pfm nikp pfip Emgc [iedmw fi` alpigem` pfm Ikk}|gep &\mm`

@mnmeìep{' \mza|p{ ae Zcigepgnn{ ge Oi|kf ie` Iz|gc <::7# ie` goom`gipmcw

pfm|minpm| {mep Moigc{ kaepigegeb Zcigepgnn Cglm|g ie` fm| {za}{m‗{ z|g~ipm ìpi#

gekc}`geb [akgic [mk}|gpw e}olm|{ ge <::7# pf}{ Emgc [iedmw alpigem` Cglm|g‗{

[akgic [mk}|gpw e}olm| n|ao pfm kae{}om| |mza|p{ {ac` lw pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ pa

Emgc [iedmw ae Zcigepgnn Cg{i Cglm|g ie` fm| {za}{m# {mm @E =:2 ip zz% 2/9:# ¾G% Ge

|m{zae{m pfm|mpa# Ogccm| ip zz% 9:/99# ¾¾<0/<> an fg{ @mkci|ipgae i|b}m{ pfip Emgc

[iedmw alpigem` Zcigepgnn Cglm|g‗{ [akgic [mk}|gpw e}olm| n|ao àk}omep{ ngcm` lw

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 7 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;9



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 9:

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

Cglm|g ge apfm| Ka}|p{# pfip O|% [iedmw alpigem` `g|mkpcw n|ao pfm Ka}|p{ ge rfgkf

Cglm|g ngcm` pfmo ie` eap n|ao iew an pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{%

Ge {}zza|p pfm|man# Ogccm| ippikfm{ Mvfglgp{ –M‟ ie` –N‟% Mvfglgp –N‟ g{ i

H}em 90# <:9: cmppm| ie` Mom|bmekw Oapgae pa [p|gdm ie` [mic ngcgeb{ lw A|cw Pigpx

ae H}em 9:# <:9: pa H}`bm \al|mea ge Zmee{wc~iegi# pfip H}`bm \al|mea A|`m|m`

ngcm`% [mm @E 9<<% Mvfglgp –N‟ g{ Pigpx‗{ H}em 9:# <:9: ngcgeb# [mm @E 9<9# rfgkf

n}|pfm| z|a~m{ pfip pfm mi|cgm{p ìpm Emgc [iedmw alpigem` pfm{m }ei}pfmepgkipm`

àk}omep{ ri{ H}em 9:# <:9:# a~m| i wmi| inpm| fm ikkm{{m` ie` alpigem` pfm

\mza|p{ ae Zcigepgnn Cglm|g ie` fm| f}{lie` n|ao pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ ie` a~m| i

wmi| inpm| Emgc [iedmw {mep a}p fg{ Moigc{ kaepigegeb Cglm|g ie` fm| f}{lie`‗{

[akgic [mk}|gpw e}olm|{ ie` apfm| z|g~ipm ìpi# n}|pfm| {}l{piepgipgeb Zcigepgnn{

Alhmkpgae{ ie` \my}m{p pa [p|gdm# @E =:2# i{ Emgc [iedmw‗{ {pipmomep{ ie`

Mvfglgp{ &àk}omep{' rm|m geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw ie` à}lcm fmi|{iw annm|m` na| pfm

p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm`4 pfmw cikdm` na}eìpgae ie` Emgc [iedmw g̀` eap fi~m

zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an pfm {pipmomep{ ie` àk}omep{% Lmwmem ~% Kacmoie [mk}|gpw

[m|~{# Gek%# 6=0 N% <` 992:# 996< &7pf Kg|% 9766' &na| z}|za{m{ an [}ooi|w

H}`bomep# ippikfgeb }zae om|m i{{m|pgae pfip pfmw rm|m –p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazgm{‟

an Mvfglgp{ ri{ ge{}nngkgmep pa ciw i na}eìpgae ie` i}pfmepgkipm pfm ippikfm`

àk}omep{ il{mep zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an pfm nikp{ ge pfm àk}omep{'4 [mm ic{a A||

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9: an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;<




9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

<6= N% ;` ip 22;/220# 222 &inngì~gp o}{p ciw i na}eìpgae pa i}pfmepgkipm

`g{ka~m|w ̀ ak}omep{'% [mm Ic{a Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢¢>:< # 6:9&k' # 6:< ie` 7:9&i'%

Ogccm|‗{ @mkci|ipgae {}zza|p{ Zcigepgnn{ \my}m{p pa [p|gdm# Alhmkpgae{ ie`

Za{gpgae i{ pa rfw [}ooi|w H}`bomep o}{p eap lm b|iepm`% [mm# m%b%# Kfi|cm{ A

L|i`cmw P|}{p ~% Xmegpf Kizgpic CCK # Ea% K :0/:<<;7 H[R# <::6 RC ;0::;0:# ip

(> e%< &E%@% Kic% I}b% 99# <::6' &eapgeb `mnmeìep"{ gep|a`}kpgae an emr m~g`mekm

,k|mipm{ i `g{z}pm an nikp, z|mkc}`geb {}ooi|w h}`bomep'4 Zgm{xid ~% Bcmeìcm

I`~mepg{p Om`% Kp|%# 99< N% [}zz% <` 72:# 760 e%9; &K%@% Kic% <:::' &zagepgeb a}p

`mnmeìep{" |mzcw m~g`mekm ,om|mcw k|mipm{ i bme}gem g{{}m na| p|gic%,'%

I{ zagepm` a}p ie` mvzcigem` ge Zcigepgnn{ Azza{gpgae pa pfm \mm`

@mnmeìep{ Oapgae na| [}ooi|w H}`bomep# pfmg| m~g`mekm g{ eap iòg{{glcm

m~g`mekm ie` pfm|mna|m# pfmg| Oapgae na| [}ooi|w H}`bomep g{ }e{}zza|pm` lw iew

kaozmpmep m~g`mekm ie` o}{p lm @megm`%

L% ZCIGEPGNN[ ALHMKP pa pfm FMI\[IW [PIPMOMEP[

ie` @AK]OMEP[ ge pfm @MKCI\IPGAE an OGKFIMC

L% OGCCM\# M[Y]G\M8

Ogccm| @mkci|ipgae# z% <# ¾9# Ogccm| kcigo{ pa lm iògppm` Z|a Fik ^gkm ge

pfg{ ki{m% Icpfa}bf# O|% Ogccm| izzcgm` Z|a Fik ^gkm# [mm @E 0=2# pa ìpm

Zcigepgnn{ i|m }eilcm pa cakipm ie A|`m| b|iepgeb O|% Ogccm|‗{ izzcgkipgae%

Ogccm| @mkci|ipgae# zz% </;# ¾<# O|% Ogccm| ng|{p {pipm{ pfip O|% Lm|b |mn}{m`

pa fac` i \}cm <>&n' Kaenm|mekm# [mm z% <# ¾< ip cgem <0% Ae zibm ; an pfg{ {iom

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 99 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;;



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 9<

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

zi|ib|izf# O|% Ogccm| iògp{ pfip O|% Lm|b kaozcgm` rgpf pfm Kaenm|mekm# [mm cgem

0%

Ogccm| @mkci|ipgae# zz% 6/7# ¾97# – I p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazw an O|% OkKilm‗{

Iz|gc < \m{zae{m pa O|% Lm|b‗{ Oi|kf <> pf

cmppm| g{ ippikfm` fm|mpa i{ Mvfglgp @%

O|% OkKilm ng|{p zagepm` a}p pfip pfm Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{‗ \m{zae{m{ gekc}`m`

o}kf oa|m pfie h}{p alhmkpgae{# ie` mvzcigem` pa O|% Lm|b pfip fm fi` {gozcw

a~m|caadm` pfm Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{‗ {gbegngkiep [}l{piepg~m \m{zae{m% O|

OkKilm `g|mkpm` O|% Lm|b pa pfip gena|oipgae% O|% OkKilm ic{a zagepm` a}p pfip#

m~me lmna|m Zcigepgnn{ fi` z|azm|cw {m|~m` @g{ka~m|w# pfm Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{

fi` oi`m kcmi| pfip i Z|apmkpg~m A|`m| ri{ |my}g|m`% Zcigepgnn{ fi` ib|mm`% L}p#

O|% OkKilm eapm`# Zcigepgnn{ fi` àem eapfgeb pa |m{ac~m pfip rmcc/pidme alhmkpgae

m~me pfa}bf pfm Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{ z|a~g`m` O|% Lm|b rgpf i `|inp Z|apmkpg~m

A|`m| rgpf rfgkf pa ra|d% Eaempfmcm{{# O|% OkKilm annm|m` pa –`g{k}{{

icpm|eipg~m omie{ an i{{}|geb kaeng`mepgicgpw an ie` }{m cgogpipgae{ ae |m{zae{g~m

àk}omep{ `}|geb a}| ommp ie` kaenm| kicc%‟ –Ngeiccw# O|% OkKilm eapm` pfip pfm

Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{ mvzmkpm` O|% Lm|b pa kaozcw rgpf Cakic \}cm ;2/9 ge iew

n}p}|m ommp ie` kaenm| cmppm|{ ie` ge{g{pm` pfip fm ommp ie` kaenm| i{ |my}g|m` lw

pfm Cakic \}cm{% O|% OkKilm ic{a `moie`m` pfm `mza{gpgae ìpm{ na| Zcigepgnn{

`mza{gpgae{ pfip rm fi` lmme }e{}kkm{{n}ccw {mmdgeb na| {m~m|ic rmmd{# ie`

|my}m{pm` i ommp ie` kaenm| ae pfip g{{}m%‟ Zcigepgnn{ alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ae

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9< an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;0



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 9;

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

pfm b|a}e` pfip gp kae{pgp}pm{ geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm an

M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A||

<6= N%;` ip 226/2274 Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2

&7pf Kg|% 976:'%

Fm|m zi|ib|izf 97 cikd{ na}eìpgae% Pfm @mkci|ipgae kieeap m{pilcg{f

Ogkfimc L% Ogccm| M{y}g|m‗{ zm|{aeic dearcm`bm i{ fm g̀` eap `|inp# zi|pgkgzipm a|

{me` pfm cmppm| ge y}m{pgae# a| pfm apfm| gena|oipgae |mnm|mekm`% Pfm m~mep{ rm|m

{}zza{m`cw ge~ac~geb Hiom{ OkKilm# M{y}g|m rfa g{ cakipm` ge Kicgna|egi ie` eap

m~me pfm {iom {pipm i{ O|% Ogccm|% Zcigepgnn{ alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie` Mvfglgp

–@‟ ae pfm b|a}e` pfip gp kae{pgp}pm{ geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm

an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A||


&7pf Kg|% 976:'%

[gogci|cw zi|ib|izf 97 oidm{ i li|m i{{m|pgae pfip pfm ippikfm` Mvfglgp –@‟

g{ bme}gem lw {pipgeb pfip i p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazw g{ ippikfm` an i àk}omep k|mipm`

lw ieapfm| zm|{ae% Pfm zi|ib|izf nigc{ pa ciw i na}eìpgae lmki}{m gp àm{ eap

z|a~g`m pfm |mcm~iep }e`m|cwgeb àk}omep{ a| apfm| emkm{{i|w gena|oipgae ie`

pf}{# nigc{ pa z|a~g`m z|goi nikgm m~g`mekm an bme}gemem{{% Pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie`

Mvfglgp –@‟ fi~m eap lmme i}pfmepgkipm` ie` i|m geiòg{{glcm% Zcigepgnn{ n}|pfm|

alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie` Mvfglgp –@‟ ae pfm b|a}e` pfip gp kae{pgp}pm{

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9; an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;=




9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m`

na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/2274 Lcig| Naa`{

Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

Zcigepgnn{‗ n}|pfm| alhmkp pa Zi|ib|izf 97 i{ gp cikd{ na}eìpgae% Pfm

@mkci|ipgae kieeap m{pilcg{f Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an

pfm gena|oipgae |mnm|mekm` ge ~gacipgae an Nm`% \% M~g`% ¢>:<%

Ogccm| @mkci|ipgae# z% 9:# ¾<< – Zcigepgnn{ fi~m em~m| {a}bfp iew `mza{gpgae{

ge pfg{ ki{m# gekc}`geb `mza{gpgae{ an i zi|pw z}|{}iep pa \}cm ;:&l'&>'% Zcigepgnn{

ic{a fi~m em~m| {a}bfp i``gpgaeic `g{ka~m|w z}|{}iep pa \}cm =>&`'%‟ Zcigepgnn{

alhmkp ae pfm li{g{ gp i{{}om{ nikp{ eap ge m~g`mekm ie` og{{pipm{ pfm m~mep{

|mbi|`geb pfg{ g{{}m% Zcigepgnn{ kie‗p `mza{m ge`g~g`}ic{ pfmw i|m }eiri|m an% Pfm

\mm` @mnmeìep{# apfm| pfie i nmr |m{zae{m{ lw Ikk}|gep# fi~m |mn}{m` pa z|azm|cw

\m{zae` pa Zcigepgnn{ @g{ka~m|w# ie` |mn}{m` pa p}|e a~m| iew àk}omep{ zme`geb i

Z|apmkpg~m A|`m|# pfip pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ i|m |my}m{pgeb% ]epgc Zcigepgnn{ |mkmg~m

\m{zae{m{ pa pfm @g{ka~m|w ge rfgkf pfmw fi~m ic|mi`w {m|~m`# Zcigepgnn{ i|m

}eiri|m an rfip n}|pfm| @g{ka~m|w pa |my}m{p%

Ogccm| @mkci|ipgae# z% 99# ¾<=# cgem{ </<; lmbgeegeb rgpf –Zibm{ 9=/<; ie`

96/<;‟ ie` me`geb rgpf –Ka}|p \mka|`{# eap n|ao pfm Cmvg{Emvg{ @mnmeìep{‟

Zcigepgnn{ alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ae pfm b|a}e` pfip gp kae{pgp}pm{ geiòg{{glcm

fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 90 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;>



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 9=

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/2274 Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~

\iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

Fm|m zi|ib|izf <= cikd{ na}eìpgae% Pfm @mkci|ipgae kieeap m{pilcg{f

Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ zm|{aeic dearcm`bm i{ pa iew an pfm {pipmomep{ a|

àk}omep{ |mnm|mekm` ge Mvfglgp –M‟ a| –N‟% Pfm àk}omep{ |mnm|mekm` ge

Mvfglgp{ –M‟ ie` –N‟ z}|za|p pa lm i @mkci|ipgae n|ao Cg{i Cglm|g pfip g{

}ei}pfmepgkipm`# ie` nigc{ pa m~me {far iew pwzm an Ka}|p ge rfgkf gp ri{

–{}zza{m`cw‟ ngcm %̀ Pfm {mkae` àk}omep |mnm|mekm` lw O|% Ogccm|# z}|za|p{ pa lm

i Lied|}zpkw ngcgeb pfip g{ {micm` ie` eap i~igcilcm pa pfm z}lcgk% O|% Ogccm| àm{

eap fi~m zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an mgpfm| an pfm{m àk}omep{ a| pfm {pipmomep{

|mnm|mekm` |mbi|`geb pfmo% Zcigepgnn{ alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie` pfm |mnm|mekm`

àk}omep{ ae pfm b|a}e` pfip gp kae{pgp}pm{ geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa

Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{

i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/2274 Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc

>9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

[gogci|cw zi|ib|izf <= oidm{ i li|m i{{m|pgae pfip pfm ippikfm` Mvfglgp{ –M‟

ie` –N‟ i|m bme}gem lw {pipgeb pfip p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazgm{ i|m ippikfm` an

àk}omep{ k|mipm` ie` |mnm|mekm` lw ieapfm| zm|{ae% Pfm zi|ib|izf nigc{ pa ciw i

na}eìpgae lmki}{m gp àm{ eap z|a~g`m pfm |mcm~iep }e`m|cwgeb àk}omep{ a| apfm|

emkm{{i|w gena|oipgae ie` pf}{# nigc{ pa z|a~g`m z|goi nikgm m~g`mekm an

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9= an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;2



Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 9>

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

bme}gemem{{% Pfg{ zi|ib|izf# pfm àk}omep{ |mnm|mekm` pfm|mge ie` Mvfglgp{ –M‟

ie` –N‟ fi~m eap lmme i}pfmepgkipm` ie` i|m geiòg{{glcm% Zcigepgnn{ n}|pfm| alhmkp

pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie` Mvfglgp{ –M‟ ie` –N‟ ae pfm b|a}e` pfip gp kae{pgp}pm{


na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/2274 Lcig| Naa`{

Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

Oa|ma~m|# O|% Ogccm| |mzmip{ {pipmomep{ oi`m lw Emgc [iedmw pfip Zcigepgnn{

alhmkpm` pa# [mm @E =:2% Ogccm| àm{ eap fi~m iew zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an pfm

{pipmomep{ oi`m lw Emgc [iedmw a| pfm p|}pf pa pfm {pipmomep{ oi`m lw Emgc

[iedmw% Pfm|mna|m# pfg{ mepg|m zi|ib|izf# lmbgeegeb ae zibm 99# cgem < pf|a}bf

cgem{ <6 g{ geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp

g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/2274 Lcig|

Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

Ogccm| @mkci|ipgae# z% 9<# ¾<2# – Ippikfm` i{ Mvfglgp F g{ i p|}m ie` ka||mk

kazw an Mvfglgp 6 pa O{% A{pmcci‗{ `mkci|ipgae `m{k|glm` ila~m% Ikka|`geb pa O{

A{pmcci‗{ `mkci|ipgae# Mvfglgp 6 g{ i p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazw an i p|ie{k|gzp an Emgc

[iedmw‗{ gepm|~gmr ae {aompfgeb kiccm` pfm –Zcige{ \i`ga Empra|d‟ ae Oiw <6#

<::7% Ge pfip gepm|~gmr# O|% [iedmw mvz|m{{cw |mnm|{ pa pfm nikp# cipm| pm{pgngm` pa ge

fg{ @mkci|ipgae pfip fm alpigem` pfm {a kiccm` –zm|{aeic g`mepgnwgeb gena|oipgae‟

ip g{{}m ge pfg{ ki{m n|ao pfm {a|p an Ka}|p |mka|`{ `m{k|glm` ila~m%‟

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9> an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;6




9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

Fm|m zi|ib|izf <= cikd{ na}eìpgae% Pfm `mkci|ipgae kieeap m{pilcg{f

Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ zm|{aeic dearcm`bm i{ pa iew an pfm [pipmomep{

|mnm|mekm` ge Mvfglgp –F‟% O|% Ogccm| og{y}apm{ rfip Mvfglgp –F‟ {pipm{% Ea

rfm|m ge pfm |i`ga p|ie{k|gzp àm{ Emgc [iedmw kcigo pa alpige Cglm|g‗{ z|g~ipm

zm|{aeic gena|oipgae n|ao i [ie Lm|ei|`gea Ka}|p% O|% Ogccm| àm{ eap fi~m

dearcm`bm an mgpfm| pfm |i`ga {far a| pfm p|ie{k|gzp% Pfm p|ie{k|gzp ippikfm` i{

–Mvfglgp F‟ g{ i zi|pgic% Pfm mepg|m |i`ga {far g{ ae ngcm rgpf pfm Ka}|p ge K@

na|oip% Zcigepgnn{ alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie` Mvfglgp F ge pfmg| mepg|mpw ae pfm

b|a}e` pfip pfmw kae{pgp}pm geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm an

M~g`mekm 6:<# ge pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A||


&7pf Kg|% 976:'%

[gogci|cw zi|ib|izf <2 oidm{ i li|m i{{m|pgae pfip pfm ippikfm` Mvfglgp –F‟

g{ bme}gem lw {pipgeb pfip p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazw g{ ippikfm` an i àk}omep k|mipm`

ie` |mnm|mekm` lw ieapfm| zm|{ae% Pfm zi|ib|izf nigc{ pa ciw i na}eìpgae lmki}{m

gp àm{ eap z|a~g`m pfm |mcm~iep }e`m|cwgeb àk}omep{ a| apfm| emkm{{i|w

gena|oipgae ie` pf}{# nigc{ pa z|a~g`m z|goi nikgm m~g`mekm an bme}gemem{{%

Ogccm| àm{ eap fi~m iew zm|{aeic dearcm`bm an pfm {pipmomep{ ge pfm Oiw

<6# <::7 \i`ga [far lw Emgc [iedmw% Pfm|mna|m# pfg{ mepg|m zi|ib|izf g{


Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 92 an <9 Zibm G@+89;7;7






9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

Fm|m zi|ib|izf <7 cikd{ na}eìpgae% Pfm @mkci|ipgae kieeap m{pilcg{f

Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m‗{ zm|{aeic dearcm`bm i{ pa iew an pfm [pipmomep{ a|

àk}omep{ |mnm|mekm̀ ge Mvfglgp{ –G‟ pf|a}bf –D‟% Pfm àk}omep{ |mnm|mekm` ge

Mvfglgp{ –G‟ pf|a}bf –D‟ z}|za|p pa lm |mza|p{ |}e ae Cg{i Cglm|g lw Emgc [iedmw

pfip fm alpigem` n|ao –Cmvg{Emvg{ ie` G\L[mi|kf# CCK‟ pfip i|m }ei}pfmepgkipm`

ie` nigc{ pa {far rfm|m pfmw kiom n|ao a| far O|% Ogccm| fi{ iew {}kf

dearcm`bm% Ge nikp# O|% Ogccm|‗{ @mkci|ipgae |mn}pm{ pfm pm{pgoaew z|a~g`m` rgpf

pfmg| [}ooi|w H}`bomep Oapgae ie` pfm li{g{ na| pfmg| [}ooi|w H}`bomep

Oapgae# ge pfip ge pfm \mm` @mnmeìep{ Oapgae# Cg{i [gooae{ ie` Emgc [iedmw

kcigom` pfip eaem an pfm [iedmw @mnmeìep{ fi` ikka}ep{ rgpf iew an pfm Cmvg{

@mnmeìep{ ie` pfip eaem an pfm [iedmw @mnmeìep{ alpigem` iew gena|oipgae

`g|mkpcw n|ao iew an pfm [iedmw @mnmeìep{% O|% Ogccm| àm{ eap fi~m dearcm`bm

an mgpfm| an pfm{m àk}omep{ a| pfm {pipmomep{ |mnm|mekm` |mbi|`geb pfmo%

Zcigepgnn{ alhmkp pa pfg{ zi|ib|izf ie` pfm |mnm|mekm` àk}omep{ ae pfm b|a}e` pfip

gp kae{pgp}pm{ geiòg{{glcm fmi|{iw z}|{}iep pa Nm`m|ic \}cm an M~g`mekm 6:<# ge

pfip gp g{ annm|m` na| pfm p|}pf an pfm oippm|{ i{{m|pm` ge gp% A|| # <6= N%;` ip 226/2274

Lcig| Naa`{# Gek% ~% \iekfm|{ Kappae Agc # >9: N% <` >>=# >>2 &7pf Kg|% 976:'%

[gogci|cw zi|ib|izf <7 oidm{ i li|m i{{m|pgae pfip pfm ippikfm` Mvfglgp{ –G‟

pf|a}bf –D‟ i|m bme}gem lw {pipgeb pfip p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazgm{ i|m ippikfm` an

|mza|p{ n|ao Cmvg{Emvg{ ie` G\L[mi|kf# CCK% Pfm zi|ib|izf nigc{ pa ciw i

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 97 an <9 Zibm G@+89;709





Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m <9

9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

[}ooi|w H}`bomep% Zcigepgnn{ |m{zmkpn}ccw \my}m{p pfg{ Ka}|p pa [}{pige pfm

ila~m Alhmkpgae{ ie` [p|gdm pfm M~g`mekm |mnm|mekm` ila~m%

\m{zmkpn}ccw {}logppm`#

@ipm`8 Oiw 99# <:9< !{! Zfgcgz H% Lm|b

Zfgcgz H% Lm|b# M{y}g|m

Ippa|emw na| Zcigepgnn{

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0 Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm <9 an <9 Zibm G@+89;70;



9

<

;

0

=

>

2

6

7

9:

99

9<

9;

90

9=

9>

92

96

97

<:

<9

<<

<;

<0

<=

<>

<2

<6

Zfgcgz H% Lm|b# M{y}g|mZmee{wc~iegi G%@% 76>2

CIR ANNGKM[ AN ZFGCGZ H% LM\B

=== Ieà||i Bcme Ka}|p# [}gpm 9<Ciniwmppm Fgcc# ZI 97000/<=;9

Pmcmzfaem8 &>9:' 6<=/;9;0M/oigc8 zfgchlm|bJboigc%kao

]EGPM@ [PIPM[ @G[P\GKP KA]\P

NA\ PFM KMEP\IC @G[P\GKP AN KICGNA\EGI#

[A]PFM\E @G^G[GAE

CG[I CGLM\G# mp ic#Zcigepgnn{#

~{%

A\CW PIGPX# mp ic#

@mnmeìep{%

8888

888888888

KG^GC IKPGAE E]OLM\8

6899/k~/::06=/IB &IHR'

ZCIGEPGNN[ KM\PGNGKIPM AN

[M\^GKM

G# Zfgcgz H% Lm|b# M{y}g|m# fm|mlw km|pgnw i p|}m ie` ka||mkp kazw an Zcigepgnn{

Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m ri{ {m|~m` pf|a}bf pfm MKN

ngcgeb {w{pmo ie`!a| oigc i{ ge g̀kipm` lmcar# pfg{ 99pf

ìw an Oiw <:9< }zae pfm

naccargeb8

Hiom{ N OkKilm# M{y}g|m

Oa||g{ae . Nam|{pm|

0<= Oi|dmp [p

[ie N|iekg{ka# KI 709:=/<06<

Moigc8 hokkilmJoana%kao Ippa|emw na| @mnmeìep{8 \mm` Mc{m~gm|# Gek%4 Cmvg{Emvg{ B|a}z# Gek%4 Cmvg{Emvg{#

Gek%4 Cmvg{Emvg{ \g{d ie` Gena|oipgae Ieicwpgk{ B|a}z# Gek%4 Cmvg{Emvg{ \g{d

[ac}pgae{# Gek%4 Cmvg{Emvg{ [mg{gep# Gek%4 Cmvg{Emvg{ Kfagkmzagep# Gek%

Cglm|g# mp ic Zcigepgnn{ Km|pgngkipm an [m|~gkm / Alhmkpgae{ pa pfm @mkci|ipgae an Ogkfimc L% Ogccm|# M{y}g|m 9

Ki{m 6899/k~/::06=/IB/IHR @ak}omep =<0/< Ngcm` :=!99!9< Zibm 9 an < Zibm G@+89;706



Documents

Liberi v Taitz - Plaintiffs Objections to the Declaratino of Michael B Miller Esq Dkt No 519 520 521 522 Doc 524