-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
1/214
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
2/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm 4
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
@rrm`lw9 Kekxf Getg}ex Ga}tx ac @rrm`lw9 xfm Rmkkwuls`ke`
W}rtmnm Ga}tx9 `kh xfm
]+W+ W}rtmnm Ga}tx+ @kh, E `n xfm @xxatkmu ac Tmgath cat `ll xfm
Rl ekxeccw ek xfew
g`wm+
4+ E `n n`ieko xfew Hmgl`t`xeak ek w}rratx ac Rl`ekxeccw Naxeak
cat
W}nn`tu J}honmkx `o`ekwx Hmcmkh`kxw Xahh W`kimu `kh Xfm W`kimu
Cetn, Ekg+
YW`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw^+
7+ Ak N`tgf 3, 4204, xfew Ga}tx Ot`kxmh Rl`ekxeccw Lm`sm ac
Ga}tx xa celm
` W}nn`tu J}honmkx Naxeak `o`ekwx xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw+
8+ E f`h wmsmt`l gaksmtw`xeakw exf N`tg Galmk, Mwp}etm, @xxatkmu
cat
Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw ek tmo`thw xa Rl`ekxeccw Ekexe`l
Hewglaw}tmw `kh Hewgasmtu
Rteat xa celeko Rl`ekxeccw Naxeak cat W}nn`tu J}honmkx, E nmx
`kh gakcmttmh exf
Nt+ Galmk tmo`theko Rl`ekxeccw Naxeak cat W}nn`tu J}honmkx+ E
`lwa f`h wmsmt`
gaksmtw`xeakw du `u ac Mn`elw!Lmxxmtw exf Nt+ Galmk tmo`theko
xfm wmxxlmnmkx ac
xfew g`wm+
=+ E wmtsmh Rl`ekxeccw Cetwx Wmx ac Hewgasmtu ak Xfm W`kimu
Hmcmkh`kxw
ak J`k}`tu 05, 4204 du `u ac Mn`el `kh xfta}of xfm ]kexmh Wx`xmw
Rawx`l Wmtsegm
Rteatexu N`el, weok`x}tm tmp}etmh+ Nt+ Galmk `gikalmhomh xfm
hewgasmtu wmkx du
Mn`el ak few glemkxw `kh weokmh cat xfm f`th garemw ac
Rl`ekxeccw Hewgasmtu ak
J`k}`tu 40, 4204+ Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw Tmwrakwmw mtm h}m ak at
dmcatm
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 4 ac
6 R`om EH ':00884
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
3/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm 7
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Cmdt}`tu 42, 4204+ Xfew ekgl}hmw Kmel W`kimu kh W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ fa
ak N`tgf 5, 4204 celmh Gf`rxmt ? D`kit}rxgu+
3+ Rl`ekxeccw Hewgasmtu wmtsmh }rak Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw
ekgl}hmh
Ekxmttao`xatemw, Tmp}mwx cat Rtah}gxeak ac Hag}nmkxw `kh Tmp}mwx
cat @hnewweakw+
?+ Xa h`xm, Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw f`sm c`elmh xa tmwrakh xa `ku
ac xfm
Rl`ekxeccw Hewgasmtu tmp}mwxw, ekgl}heko m`gf ac xfm Tmp}mwxw
cat @hnewweakw xf`x
mtm rtara}khmh+ @xx`gfmh fmtmxa `w MVFEDEX 0 `tm xfm Tmp}mwx
Cat
@hnewweakw wmtsmh }rak Kmel W`kimu9 `xx`gfmh fmtmxa `w MVFEDEX 4
`tm xfm
Tmp}mwx cat @hnewweakw wmtsmh }rak Xahh W`kimu9 `xx`gfmh fmtmxa
`w MVFEDEX
7 `tm xfm Tmp}mwxw cat @hnewweakw wmtsmh }rak Xfm W`kimu Cetn,
Ekg+9 `kh
`xx`gfmh fmtmxa `w MVFEDEX 8 `tm xfm Tmp}mwxw cat @hnewweakw
wmtsmh }rak
W`kimu Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+
6+ Hewgasmtu g}x.acc ek xfew g`wm `w N`tgf =, 4204+ D`wmh ak
xfm
W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `hnewweakw, E f`sm tmwrakhmh xa xfm axfmt
Hmcmkh`kxw
Hewgasmtu `kh }wmh xfm w`nm+
5+ Ak J`k}`tu 42, 4204 E tmgmesmh ` wx gi ac hag}nmkxw ctan Nt+
Galmk
`w Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw Ekexe`l Hewglaw}tmw+ Ekgl}hmh ek xfmwm
hag}nmkxw mtm
@gg}tekx Tmratxw ak Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte `kh nm `ggmwwmh `kh
adx`ekmh du Kme
W`kimu `kh Xahh W`kimu du `kh xfta}of Xfm W`kimu Cetn, Ekg+ @lwa
ekgl}hmh
mtm Lmvew Ganrtmfmkwesm Tmratxw ak Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte `kh fmt
f}wd`kh Dtmkx
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 7 ac
6 R`om EH ':00887
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
4/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm 8
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
`ggmwwmh `kh adx ekmh du Kmel W`kimu `kh Xahh W`kimu du `kh
xfta}of Xfm
W`kimu Cetn, Ekg+ Kmel W`kimu kh Xahh W`kimu du `kh xfta}of Xfm
W`kimu Cetn
`lwa `ggmwwmh `kh adx`ek Rl`ekxecc Ledmtew Wage`l Wmg}texu g`th
`kh Htesmtw
Legmkwm, fegf `w ekgl}hmh exf xfm hag}nmkxw rtasehmh du Nt+
Galmk `w xfm
W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw Ekexe l Hewglaw}tmw+ Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw heh
kax x}tk asmt
`ll xfm tmratxw xfmu r}tgf`wmh ak xfm Rl`ekxeccw+ E f`sm
hmn`khmh xfm `hhexeak`
tmratxw, `kh newweko r`omw, d}x Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw f`sm
tmc}wmh+
02+ H}m xa xfm gakcehmkxe`l ekcatn`xeak gakx ekmh ek xfm
tmratxw, ekgl}heko
d}x kax lenexmh xa Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte `kh Dtmkx Ledmtew
Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmtw
`hhtmwwmw, h`xmw ac detxf, gmll rfakm k}ndmtw, gmll rfakm
ganr`kemw, `kh axfmt
rtes`xm h`x`, E ell dm celeko ` Naxeak xa celm xfmwm hag}nmkxw
}khmt wm`l+
00+ Xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw lwa w}dnexxmh exf xfmet Ekexe`l
Hewglaw}tmw
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Kmel W`kimu `hnexxeko fm wa}ofx a}x `kh nmx exf
Jafk N`ti @llmk
tmo`theko Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte+ Kmel W`kimu gl`enw fm adx`ekmh
` c`nelu regx}tm ac
Lew` Ledmte, fmt f}wd`kh Dtmkx `kh xfmet wak, d}x Rl`ekxecc
Ledmte, fmt wak `kh
f}wd`kh mtm rtaxmgxmh ctan Nt+ @llmk `kh Nt+ @llmk kmsmt f`h xfm
rfaxaot`rf
hewrl`umh du Kmel W`kimu+ Esm `xx`gfmh Kmel W`kimuw Hmgl`t`xeak
fmtmxa `w
MVFEDEX =+
04+ Nt+ Galmk `lwa w}dnexxmh Kmel W`kimuw, `gxeko `w `
rtes`xm
eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn, Ekg+ akmh du Xahh W`kimu, `kh
Atlu X`exzw
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 8 ac
6 R`om EH ':00888
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
5/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm =
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Mnmtomkgu Rmxexeak cat xfm Tmsag`xeak ac Rtad`xeak ac Rl`ekxecc
Lew` Ledmte celmh
ak N`tgf 6, 4200, ek xfm W`k Dmtk`theka Ga}kxu W}rmteat Ga}tx,
T`kgfa
G}g`nako` Heseweak+ Wmm MVFEDEX 3+ @w ` tmw}lx ac xfm W`kimu
Hmcmkh`kxw
`kh Atlu X`exzw celeko, xfmtm mtm xftmm &7% Ga}tx fm`tekow
ak N`tgf 6, 4200
N`tgf 00, 4200 `kh N`tgf 0=, 4226, fegf Rl`ekxecc Ledmte f`h xa
f`sm ga}kwm
`xxmkh+ Rl`ekxecc Ledmte `w glm`tmh ac `ll xfm c`lwm `llmo`xeakw
rtmwmkxmh du xfm
W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `kh Atlu X`exz+
07+ Xfm c`lwm `llmo`xeakw xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `kh Atlu X`exz
celmh ek
xfm W`k Dmtk`theka W}rmteat Ga}tx, T`kgfa G}g`nako` Heseweak,
G`wm Ka+ C_S.
246222 cat xfmet Mnmtomkgu Rmxexeak cat Tmsag`xeak ac Rtad`xeak
`o`ekwx Rl`ekxecc
Ledmte ekgl}hmh xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `kh X`exzw c`lwm
`llmo`xeakw xf`x Ledmte `w
]xxmteko `kh Catomtu ac Accege`l W}dramk`w9 @xxmnrxmh Mvxatxeak9
Ct`}h }rak xfm
Wage`l Wmg}texu @hnekewxt`xeak `kh Ekxmtk`l Tmsmk}m Wmtsegm
YETW^9 ]xxmteko `kh
Catomtu ac @cceh`sexw @xxmwxeko xa D`t`gi Ad`n`w Detxf ek
@cteg`9 W}datk`xeak ac
Rmtj}tu9 f`seko `ggmww `kh `ggmwweko xfeth r`txuw gtmhex g`thw9
Rmtj}tu `kh celeko `
l`w}ex exfa}x rmtnewweak ac fmt Rtad`xeak Accegmt, mxg+, `ll ac
fegf ew }kxt}m+0
08+ Atlu X`exz f`w `gg}wmh Lew` Awxmll` ac catoeko xfm W}dramk`w
ek xfew
Ga}tx+ Lew` Awxmll` atimh cat Atlu X`exz cat ` wfatx xenm,
h}teko xfm xenm Lew`
0Mvfedex 3 tmgmesmh ctan xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `w xfmet Ekexe`l
Hewglaw}tmw, ew
newweko xa &4% r`omw+ @lxfa}of E f`sm n`hm hmn`khw, xfm
W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw
f`sm tmc}wmh xa x}tk xfmn asmt+
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om = ac
6 R`om EH ':0088=
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
6/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm 3
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Awxmll` `w `wwewxeko Atlu X`exz, Atlu X`exz ekwxt}gxmh Lew`
Awxmll` xa rtmr`tm
W}dramk`w, `rrmkh Atlu X`exzw weok`x}tm ak xfm W}dramk`w `kh
wmkh xfm
W}dramk`w hetmgxlu xa xfm r`txemw wmtseko xfm W}dramk`w ek xfm
Imumw s+ Ad`n`
g`wm+ Atlu X`exzw tm`wakeko cat xfew `w dmg`}wm xfmu mtm atieko
exfek ` wfatx
xenm ct`nm `kh X`exz ew lag`xmh ek G`lecatke` `kh Lew` Awxmll`
`w lag`xmh ek Km
Jmtwmu+ X`exz gl`enmh xfmtm `w kax mka}of xenm cat xfm W}dramk`w
xa dm wmkx xa
fmt cat fmt xa `gx}`llu weok+ Atlu X`exz xfmk gf`komh fmt wxatu,
`kh gl`enmh Lew`
Awxmll` f`h catomh fmt &Atlu X`exzw% weok`x}tm, fegf `w
}kxt}m+4
Lew` Awxmll`
h}teko xfm Hmgmndmt 42, 4204 fm`teko dmcatm Cmhmt`l J}hom
Tadtmka, rteat xa xfm
xt`kwcmt ac xfew g`wm xa xfm Cmhmt l Ga}tx ek W`kx` @k`,
G`lecatke`, xmwxecemh xf`x wfm
rtmr`tmh, `kh callamh Atlu X`exzw ekwxt}gxeakw, ekr}x Atlu
X`exzw weok`x}tm `kh
wmkx xfm W}dramk`w ek xfm Ad`n` g`wm xa xfm hmweok`xmh rmarlm fa
mtm wmtseko
xfm W}dramk`w+ Wmm Lew` Awxmll`w Hmgl`t`xeak celmh Wmrxmndmt 40,
4200, Hagimx
Ka+ YHK^ 763, r+ 3, 04 `kh Mvfedex 7, HK 763.4, rr+ 4 xfta}of
=39 `kh xfm
Ga}txw Hmgmndmt 42, 4202 Xt`kwgterx, HK 034, r+ 043, lekmw 5.4=,
rr+ 04?.046
lekmw 0.4=, `kh r+ 045, lekmw 0.44+ Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte kmsmt
atimh exf at f`h
4 Atlu X`exz f`h celmh c`lwm `llmo`xeakw `o`ekwx fmt r`wx
`wwage`xmw `kh lasmt, Gf`tlmw Mh`th
Lekgalk, EEE, gl`eneko Nt+ Lekgalk f`h catomh fmt weok`x}tm+
Atlu X`exz xalh xfm Ga}tx wfm f`hkmsmt `llamh `kuakm xa weok fmt
k`nm+ Lew` Awxmll` rtasehmh Nt+ Lekgalk exf `k @cceh`sex
wfaeko Atlu X`exz f`h ekwxt}gxmh fmt &Lew` Awxmll % xa weok
X`exzw k`nm xa W}dramk`w ek xfm
Imumw s+ Ad`n` g`wm+ Akgm Awxmll`w Hmgl`t`xeak `w celmh ek
xfmTesmtkehmtg`wm ek Clateh`wfaeko X`exz `w lueko, X`exz gf`komh
fmt wxatu gl`eneko Awxmll` f`h catomh X`exzw k`nm ak
xfm W}dramk`w+ Wmm ]+W+ D`ki s+ Tesmtkehmt, ]+W+ Hewxtegx Ga}tx,
Gmkxt`l Hewxtegx ac Clateh`, G`wm
Ka+ 5:25.gs.604== _RH, HKw 83, 8?.0, ==.0, `kh =3+
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 3 ac
6 R`om EH ':00883
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
7/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm ?
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
`kuxfeko xa ha exf Atlu X`exz+ Lew` Ledmte hmglekmh Atlu X`exzw
tmp}mwxw cat
`wwewx`kgm exf fmt lmo`l gf`llmkomw+
0=+ Atlu X`exz exf xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `wwewx`kgm `kh
gtmhmkxe`lw f`w
gakwx`kxlu celmh c`lwm `llmo`xeakw `o`ekwx Rl`ekxeccw Lew`
Ledmte `kh Lew` Awxmll`
d`wmh ak xfmet c`lwm `llmo`xeakw+ Xfm @cceh`sex Atlu X`exz
`gg}wmh Rl`ekxecc Ledmt
ac catoeko, ew `k @cceh`sex weokmh `kh rtmwmkxmh du Dewfar Tak
NgGt`u lag`xmh ek
Rmkkwuls`ke`+ Atlu X`exz ew `gg}weko Rl`ekxecc Ledmte ac
Mvxatxeak dmg`}wm Rl`ekxecc
Ledmte ew w}eko Atlu X`exz, Kmel W`kimu, Xahh W`kimu, Xfm W`kimu
Cetn, Ekg+ `kh
W`kimu Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ cat xfm h`n`omw g`}wmh xa Rl`ekxeccw
du xfmwm
Hmcmkh`kxw+
03+ Rl ekxecc Lew` Ledmte f`w kax rmtj}tmh fmt xmwxenaku at
w}datkmh `ku
rmtj}tu ctan `ku exkmww, f`w kax catomh hag}nmkxw `w gl`enmh du
X`exz, f`w kax
mvxatxmh `kuxfeko, heh kax f`sm `kuxfeko xa ha exf 7thr`txemw
gtmhex g`thw, kat f`h
Ntw+ Ledmte seal`xmh `ku rtad`xeak xmtnw at gannexxmh ct`}h exf
mexfmt Wage`
Wmg}texu at xfm Ekxmtk`l Tmsmk}m Wmtsegm+ Xfmwm `tm `ll c`lwm
`llmo`xeakw gakgagxmh
du xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `kh X`exz ek `xxmnrxw xa f`sm
Rl`ekxeccw Ledmte `kh
Awxmll` `ttmwxmh `kh j`elmh+
0?+ Xfm Mvfedexw celmh exf xfm W`kimu Hmcmkh`kxw `kh X`exzw
Mnmtomkgu
Rmxexeak cat xfm Tmsag`xeak ac Rtad`xeak ac Lew` Ledmte ekgl}hmh
c`lwm `kh catomh
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om ? ac
6 R`om EH ':0088?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
8/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm 6
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
hag}nmkxw adx`ekmh ctan Omacc Wx`rlmw79 ` lmxxmt ctan Hmcmkh`kx
Kmel W`kimu
W}dramk`w xfmu `gg}wmh Rl ekxecc Ledmte ac catoeko9 fegf `tm ek
c`gx xfm
W}dramk`w Rl ekxecc Lew` Awxmll` wmkx a}x `x xfm tmp}mwx ac `kh
ak dmf lc ac Atlu
X`exz ek X`exzwImumw s+ Ad`n` g`wm `kh axfmt lmxxmtw fegf f`sm
dmmk celmh exf
xfew Ga}tx k}nmta}w xenmw9 `kh ` hewgerlek`tu ganrl`ekx `o`ekwx
nm, xf`x X`exz
adx`ekmh du newlm`heko xfm Ga}tx ekxa dmlemseko wfm &Atlu
X`exz% `w adx`ekeko xfm
hag}nmkxw ak dmf`lc ac xfew Ga}tx+
E hmgl`tm }khmt xfm rmk`lxu ac rmtj}tu ac xfm L`w ac xfm ]kexmh
Wx`xmw `kh
G`lecatke` xf`x xfm catmoaeko ew xt}m `kh gattmgx+
Mvmg}xmh xfew 44kh h`u ac N`tgf, 4204 ek xfm Gannakm`lxf ac
Rmkkwuls`ke`, Ga}kxu ac Nakxoanmtu+
!w! Rfeler J+ Dmto
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm, Hmgl`t`kx
7 X`exz f`w rtmsea}wlu celmh xfmwm catomh hag}nmkxw ek xfew
g`wm, Wmm HK 08=9 `kh Wmm HKw 083
xfta}of 083.5, fegf ew rtaac xf`x Omacc Wx`rlmw wx`xmnmkxw mtm
c`lwm `kh few mvfedexw catomh
`kh `lxmtmh ct`}h}lmkxlu tmnaseko few Mn`el `hhtmww `kh
ekr}xxeko Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmtew+
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 6 ac
6 R`om EH ':00886
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
9/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46MVFEDEX 0
5
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 0
ac 74 R`om EH':00885
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
10/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 0
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm &R@ E+H+
563?%Mn`el:rfeljdmtoBon`el+gan
L@_ ACCEGMW AC RFELER J+ DMTO
=== @khatt` Olmk Ga}tx, W}exm 04L`c`umxxm Fell, R@
05888.4=70
Xmlmrfakm: &302% 64=.7078 C`v: &302% 678.?3=5@xxatkmu ek
rta wm `kh cat Rl`ekxeccw
]KEXMH WX@XMW HEWXTEGX GA]TX
CAT XFM GMKXT@L HEWXTEGX AC G@LECATKE@,
WA]XFMTK HESEWEAK
LEW@ LEDMTE, mx `l,
Rl`ekxeccw,
sw+
ATLU X@EXZ, mx `l,Hmcmkh`kxw+
:
:::::::::
GESEL @GXEAK K]NDMT:6:00.gs.2286=.@O &@J_%
RL@EKXECCW TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAKW XA
HMCMKH@KX KMEL W@KIMU WMX AKM
RLM@WM X@IM KAXEGM, ek `ggath`kgm exf Cmh+ T+ Ges+ R+ 43 `kh
73
ua} `tm fmtmdu kaxecemh `kh tmp}etmh xa tmwrakh xa xfm callaeko
Tmp}mwx cat
@hnewweakw rtara}khmh du Rl`ekxeccw Lew` Ledmte, Lew` Awxmll`,
Oa Mvgml Olad`l
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm `kh Xfm L` Accegmw ac Rfeler J+ Dmto
Yfmtmek`cxmt
Rl`ekxeccw^ fmtmek, xfta}of xfmet `xxatkmu ac tmgath, Rfeler J+
Dmto, Mwp}etm, L`
Accegmw ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, === @khatt` Olmk Ga}tx, W}exm 04,
L`c`umxxm Fell, R@
05888.4=70, exfek xfetxu Y72^ h`uw ctan wmtsegm fmtmac ek
`ggath`kgm exf xfm
rtaseweakw ac xfm Cmhmt`l T}lmw ac Gesel Rtagmh}tm+
02
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 4
ac 74 R`om EH':008=2
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
11/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 4
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
EKWXT]GXEAKW
Hmcmkh`kx Kmel W`kimuw Tmwrakwmw xa xfmwm Tmp}mwxw cat
@hnewweakw wf`ll
wrmgeceg`llu `hnex at hmku m`gf wmr`t`xmlu wx`xmh n`xxmt, at wmx
catxf ek hmx`el xfm
tm`wakw fu Kmel W`kimu g`kkax xt}xfc}llu hnex at hmku xfm
n`xxmt+ @ hmke`l wf`ll
c`etlu nmmx xfm w}dwx`kgm ac xfm tmp}mwxmh @hnewweak, `kh fmk
oaah c`exf tmp}etmw
xf`x Kmel W`kimu p}`lecu exw `kwmt at hmku aklu ` r`tx ac xfm
n`xxmt ac fegf `k
`hnewweak ew tmp}mwxmh, Kmel W`kimu wf`ll wrmgecu wa n}gf ac ex
`w ew xt}m `kh
p}`lecu at hmku xfm tmn`ekhmt+ Kmel W`kimu n`u kax oesm l`gi ac
ekcatn`xeak at
ikalmhom `w ` tm`wak cat c`el}tm xa `hnex at hmku }klmww Kmel
W`kimu wx`xmw xf`x
xfmu n`hm tm`wak`dlm ekp}etu `kh xf`x xfm ekcatn`xeak ikak at
tm`helu adx`ek`dlm
du xfmn ew ekw}ccegemkx xa mk`dlm fen xa `hnex at hmku+ Ec ek
tmwrakheko xa xfmwm
Tmp}mwxw cat @hnewweak Kmel W`kimu gakwehmtw xf`x ` n`xxmt ac
fegf `k `hnewweak
f`w dmmk tmp}mwxmh rtmwmkxw ` omk}ekm eww}m cat xte`l, fm n`u
kax ak xf`x ota}kh
`lakm adjmgx xa xfm Tmp}mwx+
Hmcmkh`kx Kmel W`kimu ew c}txfmt `hsewmh xf`x m`gf n`xxmt
fmtmek`cxmt wm
catxf ell dm hmmnmh `hnexxmh du xfmn }klmww, exfek xfetxu Y72^
h`uw `cxmt dmeko
wmtsmh xfmtmexf xfmu wmtsm }rak Rl ekxeccw ga}kwml xfmet texxmk
`kwmt at
adjmgxeak `hhtmwwmh xa xfm n`xxmt `kh weokmh du Kmel W`kimu at
xfmet `xxatkmu
C}txfmt, ec w`eh Hmcmkh`kx hmkemw `ku n`xxmt fmtmek wa}ofx xa dm
`hnexxmh `kh
Rl`ekxecc l`xmt rtasmw ` hag}nmkx xa dm omk}ekm at xfm n`xxmt
xt}m, Rl`ekxecc n`u
00
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 7
ac 74 R`om EH':008=0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
12/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 7
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
nasm xf`x xfm r`txu fa c`elmh xa `hnex r`u few tm`wak`dlm
mvrmkwmw, ekgl}heko
@xxatkmu/w Cmmw, ekg}ttmh ek n`ieko xf`x rtaac+ Cek llu,
Hmcmkh`kx Kmel W`kimu ew
`hsewmh xf`x T}lm 7?& %&8% ac xfm Cmhmt`l T}lmw ac Gesel
Rtagmh}tm rtasehmw xf`x `k
ms`wesm at ekganrlmxm tmwrakwm xa `ku ac xfm callaeko Tmp}mwxw
ell dm xtm`xmh `w
` c`el}tm xa tmwrakh cat r}trawmw ac ganrmlleko hewgasmtu `kh!at
wmmieko w`kgxeakw
ek Ga}tx+
HMCEKEXEAKW
Kaxexfwx`kheko xfm wrmgeceg hmcekexeakw dmla, m`gf ath, xmtn, at
rft`wm
}wmh ek xfmwm Tmp}mwxw wfa}lh dm oesmk xfmet nawx mvr`kwesm `kh
ekgl}wesm
nm`keko+ @w }wmh:
`% $Rl`ekxeccw wf`ll nm`k Rl`ekxeccw Lew` Ledmte, Lew` Awxmll`,
Oa Mvgml
Olad`l, Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm, Xfm L` Accegmw ac Rfeler J+
Dmto, `kh Rl`ekxeccw
Wra}wmw, Gfelhtmk kh C`nelu Nmndmtw+
d% Hmcmkh`kx$ wf`ll nm`k Hmcmkh`kx Kmel W`kimu+
g% $Ekgehmkx$ wf`ll nm`k `w hmcekmh ek xfm Ganrl`ekx+
h% G}wxanmt&w% wf`ll nm`k rmarlm fa fetm `kh }xelezm
Hmcmkh`kx Kmel
W`kimuw eksmwxeo`xeak wmtsegmw9
m% Mnrlaumm&w% wf`ll nm`k `ku rmtwak mnrlaumh du ua} at
`gxeko `w
`k `omkx cat ua}+
04
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 8
ac 74 R`om EH':008=4
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
13/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 8
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
c% Ua} at ua}t nm`kw xfm rmtwak at mkxexu tmwrakheko xa
xfmwm
Ekxmttao`xatemw `kh `ku rtmwmkx at catnmt mnrlaummw, `omkxw,
gakw}lx`kxw at axfmt
rmtwak `gxeko at r}tratxeko xa `gx ak dmf`lc ac w}gf rmtwak at
mkxexu+
o% $Hag}nmkx&w%$ wf`ll nm`k `ku texekow ac `ku iekh `kh
wf`ll ekgl}hm
xfm ateoek`l `kh m`gf kak.ehmkxeg`l garu at ht`cx xfmtmac+ Xfm
xmtn f`w xfm w`nm
nm`keko `w texekow, fegf ew hmcekmh ek Cmh+ T+ Ges+ R+ 78&`%
`khCmh+ T+ Mseh
0220`w ekgl}heko, d}x kax lenexmh xa, `ku mlmgxtakeg`llu wxatmh
h`x`, h`x`d`wmw
hag}nmkxw, `kh mlmgxtakeg gann}keg`xeak &w}gf `w M.n`el%,
wxatmh ek ganr}xmtw at
axfmtewm, fmxfmt atkax msmt rtekxmh at hewrl`umh, xf`x f`sm
kaxrtmsea}wlu dmmk
rtah}gmh+ @ garu at h}rleg`xm ac ` hag}nmkx xf`x f`w dmmk
rtah}gmh+ @ garu at
h}rleg`xm ac ` hag}nmkx xf`x f`w `ku gakcatneko kaxmw, n`toek`l
`kkax`xeakw, at
axfmt n`tiekow, `w mll `w `ku rtmlenek`tu smtweak, ht`cx, at
tmseweak ac xfm
catmoaeko, wf`ll dm gakwehmtmh ` wmr`t`xm hag}nmkx exfek xfm
nm`keko ac xfew
xmtn+ Xfm xmtn Hag}nmkx wf`ll `lwa ekgl}hm msmtu axfmt nm`kw du
fegf
ekcatn`xeak ew tmgathmh at xt`kwnexxmh ekgl}heko, d}x kax
lenexmh xa, mlmgxtakeg
Mn`el, Ekxmtkmx, Ekxmtkmx rawxekow, x`rm tmgathekow, sehma
tmgathekow, negtacelnw
r}kgf g`thw, ganr}xmt n`okmxeg x`rm, ganr}xmt hewgw, ganr}xmt
rtaot`nw, wxat`om
x`rmw, rtekxa}xw, h`x` rtagmwweko tmgathw, `kh xfm texxmk
ekcatn`xeak kmgmww`tu xa
}khmtwx`kh `kh }wm w}gf ekcatn`xeak+ Cat m`gf $hag}nmkx$
tmwrakwesm xa `ku
07
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om =
ac 74 R`om EH':008=7
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
14/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu =
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
tmp}mwx exffmlh ctan rtah}gxeak du ua} ak xfm ota}kh ac `ku
rteselmom, rlm`wm
wx`xm:
&e% Xfm k`x}tm ac xfm hag}nmkx &m+o+, lmxxmt,
nmnat`kh}n, gakxt`gx, mxg+%9
&ee% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rmtwak&w% rtmr`teko ex `kh ac
xfm wmkhmt&w%9
&eee% Exw xexlm at, ec ex f`w ka xexlm, ` hmwgterxeak ac xfm
omkmt`l k`x}tm ac exww}djmgx n`xxmt9
&es% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm `hhtmwwmm&w%, ec `ku9
&s% Xfm h`xm xfm hag}nmkx `w }xfatmh, wmkx, kh!at
tmgmesmh9
&se% Lag`xeak ac xfm ateoek`l, at, ec xfmtm ew ka ateoek`l,
xfm lag`xeak ac `llgaremw, `kh ehmkxexu ac rtmwmkx g}wxahe`k9
`kh
&see% _fmxfmt xfm hag}nmkx ew gl enmh xa dm rteselmomh9 ec
ua} gl en xfm
hag}nmkx ew rteselmomh, xfm tm`wak w}gf hag}nmkx ew
`llmomhlu
rteselmomh+
f% $Rmtwak&w%$ nm`kw `ku f}n`k dmeko, `ku cetn, `ccele`xm,
jaekx smkx}tm
ekwxex}xeak, gatrat`xeak, walm rtartemxatwfer, lenexmh
r`txkmtwfer, r`txkmtwfer
`wwage`xeak, ota}r ac f}n`k dmekow, axfmt lmo`l at hm c`gxa
mkxexu, at gatrat`xeak
ac f`xmsmt iekh, at `ku axfmt d}wekmww at oasmtknmkx`l mkxexu ac
`ku gf`t`gxmt
f`xwamsmt, xaomxfmt exf xfm r`txkmtw, xt}wxmmw, accegmtw,
hetmgxatw, mnrlaummw, at
`omkxw xfmtmac+
e% $Gann}keg`xeak$ wf`ll nm`k `ll catnw ac texxmk at smtd`l
ekxmtga}twm, ekgl}heko exfa}x lenex`xeak ekp}etemw, hewg}wweakw,
gaksmtw`xeakw
kmoaxe`xeakw, `otmmnmkxw, }khmtwx`khekow, nmmxekow, xmlmrfakm
gaksmtw`xeakw
08
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 3
ac 74 R`om EH':008=8
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
15/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 3
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
lmxxmtw, kaxmw, xmlmot`nw, kmwr`rmt at n`o`zekm `txeglmw,
`hsmtxewmnmkxw, `kh axfmt
hag}nmkxw w rtmsea}wlu hmcekmh+
j% Rmarlm Cekhmt h x` wf ll nm`k Hakla`h`dlm ganr}xmt
wacx`tm
k`nmlu gall`dat`xeak wacx`tm, cat xfm c`gelex`xeak, `k`luwew `kh
ms`l}`xeak ac
gakw}nmt `kh rmarlm h`x`, ikalmhom `kh rtagmwwmw, ekgl}heko d}x
kax lenexmh xa
wacx`tm }xelezmh xa r}ll wage l rtaceleko ac gakw}nmt `kh rmarlm
h`x`, cek`kge`
h`x`, gtmhex h`x`, rmtwak`l ehmkxecueko h`x`, ekgl}heko d}x kax
lenexmh xa k`nmw
Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmtw, `omw, h`xmw ac detxf, `hhtmwwmw, fanm
s`l}`xeakw, ekganm,
mxg+, `om h`x`, mh}g`xeak`l h`x`, gtenek`l h`x , fm`lxf g`tm h`x
, nmheg`l h`x
gfelhtmk h`x`, mxg+
i% Mlmgxtakeg H`x` wf`ll nm`k `ku `kh `ll h`x` gakx`ekmh exfek
`ku ac
Kmel W`kimu h`x`d`wm wuwxmnw `kh wmtsmtw rmtx`ekeko xa
gakw}nmtw, glemkxw
rmarlm, d}wekmwwmw, mxg+
l% Mlmgxtakeg N`el wf`ll nm`k ll m.n`elw wmkx `kh tmgmesmh exf
xfm
c}ll fm`hmt ekcatn`xeak+
n% $Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw$ nm`kw ` rmtwak/w k`nm at Wage l
Wmg}texu
k}ndmt at axfmt }kep}m h`x` fegf ehmkxecemw at ew `wwage`xmh exf
` r`txeg}l`t
$rmtwak+$
k% $Ehmkxecu$ at xa oesm xfm $ehmkxexu$ ac wf`ll nm`k:
@+ ek xfm g`wm ac ` k`x}t l rmtwak, xa wx`xm:
0=
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om ?
ac 74 R`om EH':008==
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
16/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu ?
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
&e+% @ku `kh `ll k`nmw, lmo`l, xt`hm at `ww}nmh9
&ee+% L`wx ikak fanm `kh d}wekmww `hhtmwwmw `kh
xmlmrfakmk}ndmtw9
&eee+% @ll xmlmrfakm `kh xmlm.c`v k}ndmtw }wmh9
&es+% @ll mdwexmw akmh `kh }wmh9
&s+% @ll Mn`el hhtmwwmw akmh kh }wmh9
&se+% Mnrlaumt at d}wekmww ccele`xeak9
&see+% Agg}r`xeak `kh d}wekmww rawexeak &ekgl}heko
xexlm% fmlh9
&seee+% Mnrlaumt/w k`nm, `hhtmww, rfakm k}ndmt `kh xfm
mnrlaumt/w tml`xeakwfer xa `ku `kh `ll Hmcmkh`kxw ek xfm
`dasm g`rxeakmh `gxeak9 `kh, ec `rrleg`dlm:
&ev+% Dt`kh, n`im, n`k}c`gx}tmt/w k`nm, `hhtmww, rfakm
k}ndmt
`kh xfm n`k}c`gx}tmt/w tml`xeakwfer xa `ku `kh `llHmcmkh`kxw ek
xfm `dasm g`rxeakmh `gxeak9
D+ Ek xfm g`wm ac `k at`l wx`xmnmkx ac gann}keg`xeak, xa
wx`xm:
&e+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm n`imt&w% `kh tmgeremkx&w%
ac xfm at`wx`xmnmkx at gann}keg`xeak9
&ee+% _fmtm `kh fmk xfm at`l wx xmnmkx at gann}keg xeak
`w
n`hm9
&eee+% Xfm ehmkxexemw ac `ll rmtwakw rtmwmkx fmk xfm at`l wx
xmnmkxat gann}keg`xeak `w n`hm9
&es+% Xfm nahm ac gann}keg`xeak9 `kh
&s+% Xfm w}djmgx n`xxmt ac xfm at`l wx`xmnmkx at
gann}keg`xeak+
G+ Ek xfm g`wm ac `k `gx at anewweak, xa wx xm:
03
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 6
ac 74 R`om EH':008=3
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
17/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 6
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
&e+% @ hmx elmh hmwgterxeak ac xfm `gx at anewweak9
&ee+% Xfm h`xm fmk ex agg}ttmh9
&eee+% Xfm rl`gm fmtm ex agg}ttmh9
&es+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rmtwak at rmtwakw rmtcatneko w}gf
`gxwat ek xfm g`wm ac `k anewweak, xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rmtwak
at
rmtwakw c`eleko xa `gx9 `kh
&s+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac `ll rmtwakw fa f`sm ikalmhom ac xfm `gx
at
anewweak+
H+ Ek xfm g`wm ac ` rfaxaot`rf at rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak, xa
wx`xm:
&e+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rfaxaot`rf at rmtwak tmwrakwedlm
cat xfm
n`ieko ac xfm rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak9
&ee+% Xfm k}ndmt ac rfaxaot rfw x`imk at
rfaxaot`rfegtmrtah}gxeakw n`hm9
&eee+% _fmk `kh fmtm xfm rfaxaot`rfw mtm x imk at xfm
rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeakw mtm n`hm9
&es+% Xfm w}djmgx n`xxmt hmregxmh ek m`gf rfaxaot rf
atrfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak9 kh
&s+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac m`gf rmtwak fa f`w rawwmwweak, g}wxahu,
at
gakxtal ac m`gf rfaxaot`rf at rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak+
f+ Xfm rft`wm $tml xmw xa,$ $tml xeko xa,$ at $ek tml`xeak xa$
nm`kw xa
gakwewx ac, tmcmt xa, tmclmgx, at dm ek `ku `u laoeg`llu,
c`gx}`llu, at lmo`llu
gakkmgxmh exf xfm n`xxmt hewg}wwmh+
e+ $@}hex Xt`el$ nm`kw ` ganrlmxm, hmx`elmh lewxeko ac m`gf `kh
msmtu
`lxmt`xeak, hmlmxeak, ekp}etu ekxa, naheceg`xeak at axfmt gf`kom
xa xfm gtmhex tmratx
0?
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 5
ac 74 R`om EH':008=?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
18/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 5
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
at rtacelm `w n`ekx`ekmh ek tmgathmh catn, ek xfm dta`hmwx
wmkwm, du $ua}$+ Xfm
lewxeko wfa}lh ekgl}hm xfm ehmkxexu, `hhtmww, mnrlaumt `kh xexlm
ac xfm rmtwak&w%
x`ieko xfm `gxeak, xfm ehmkxexu, `hhtmww, mnrlaumt `kh xexlm ac
xfm rmtwak&w%
`}xfatezeko xfm `gxeak, ` hmx`elmh mvrl`k`xeak ac xfm `gxeak
x`imk, xfm h`xm ac xfm
`gxeak, xfm nm`kw }wmh xa mccmgx w}gf `gxeak, xfm lag`xeak ac
ateoek ac xfm `gxeak `kh
xfm tm`wak xfm `gxeak `w x`imk+ Xfm xmtn $`}hex xt`el$ `lwa
ekgl}hmw xfm hmcekexeak
rtasehmh cat xfm rft`wm ek xfm CmhmtD}wf, Cmhmt`l Xt`hm
Gannewweak `kh Catn`
Wx`cc Arekeak Lmxxmt, N`tgf 02, 0567+
j+ $H`x`$ nm`kw xfm rfuweg`l wundalw ek xfm dta`hmwx wmkwm
xf`
tmrtmwmkx ekcatn`xeak, tmo`thlmww ac fmxfmt xfm ekcatn`xeak ew
at`l, texxmk at
axfmtewm tmgathmh+
i+ $Ganr}xmt$ nm`kw ku kh ll rtaot`nn`dlm mlmgxtakeg hmsegmw
at
`rr`t`x}wmw, ekgl}heko f`th`tm, wacx`tm, `kh axfmt h`x`d`kiw,
xf`x g`k wxatm,
tmxtemsm, `ggmww, }rh`xm, gandekm, tm`tt`kom, rtekx, tm`h,
rtagmww at axfmtewm `lxmt
h`x` fmxfmt w}gf h`x` n`ekx`ekmh ek xf`x hmsegm at `x wanm axfmt
lag`xeak+ Xfm
xmtn $ganr}xmt$ ekgl}hmw `ku `kh `ll n`okmxeg tmgathekow at
wuwxmnw, wuwxmnw
armt`xeko ak at n`ekx`ekeko h`x` ek heoex`l, `k`lao, at fudteh
catn`x, at axfmt
nmgf`keg`l hmsegmw, at axfmt hmsegmw g`r`dlm ac n`ekx`ekeko
texekow at
tmgathekow, ac `ku iekh, ek gakhmkwmh catn`x, `kh ekgl}hmw `ku
hewi, x`rm,
06
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 02
ac 74 R`om EH':008=6
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
19/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 02
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
tmgatheko, at axfmt ekcatn`xeak`l wa}tgm, tmo`thlmww ac exw
rfuweg`l henmkweak at
wezm+
l+ $Catn`x$ nm`kw xfm omkmt`l n`im}r at omkmt`l rl`k ac
ato`kez`xeak at `tt`komnmkx ac h`x`+
n+ $Mvrl`ek$ nm`kw xa ml}geh xm, n`im rl ek at }khmtwx kh`dlm,
xa
oesm xfm tm`wak cat at g`}wm ac, `kh xa wfa xfm laoeg`l
hmsmlarnmkx at
tml`xeakwferw xfmtmac+
k+ $Hmwgtedm$ nm`kw xa tmrtmwmkx at oesm k gga}kx ac ek
athw+
a+ ]wmt nm`kw `ku rmtwak at ganr}xmt fegf ekxmt`gxw exf `
heccmtmkx ganr}xmt+
r+ @ggmww Rtaot`nw nm`kw xfmwm rtaot`nw, rfuweg`l at
ganr}xmt
d`wmh, fegf ekw}tm `}xfatez`xeak, ehmkxeceg`xeak, smteceg`xeak,
`ggmww gakxta
`gga}kx`delexu `kh wmg}texu `}hex ac ua}t gakw}nmt h`x`d`wm+
p+ Ekcatn xeak Rtaxmgxeak @tgfexmgx}tm nm`kw ` wx xmnmkx ac
xfm
asmt`ll hmweok `kh armt`xeko adjmgxesmw cat xfm wmg}texu,
gakxek}exu `kh gakxtal ac
ua}t gakw}nmt h`x`d`wm+
t+ Gakw}nmt H`x`d`wm ew ekxmkhmh xa nm`k Kmel W`kimuw mkxetm
gakw}nmt kmxati, ekgl}heko d}x kax lenexmh xa xmvx celmw n`hm,
celm r}tom, celm
tmato`kez`xeak nahm, `ll armt`xat rtm`ndlm, ehmkxeceg`xeak `kh
r`wwath nahmw
05
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 00
ac 74 R`om EH':008=5
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
20/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 00
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
`kh `ll axfmt wekolm at asmtl`ueko rtaot`nw, `rrleg`xeakw `kh!at
wuwxmnw `kh hamw
ekgl}hm, d}x ew kax lenexmh xa xfm n`ek armt`xeko wuwxmn+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAKW:
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 0:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, `ggmwwmh Rl`ekxeccw Rmarlm Cekhmt h`x` `kh
Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw
xfta}of xfm Tmmh Hmcmkh`kxw &Tmmh Hmcmkh`kxw ekgl}hmw Tmmh
Mlwmsemt, Ekg+9
LmvewKmvew Tewi `kh Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw Ota}r, Ekg+9
LmvewKmvew Tewi
Wal}xeakw, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew+gan9 LmvewKmvew, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew
Ota}r9 @gg}tekx,
GfaegmRaekx, Ekg+% exfa}x `ku xurm ac rmtnewwedlm r}trawm at
lmo`l mkxexlmnmkx+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 4:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ rtasehmh Hmcmkh`kx Atlu X`exz `kh xfm axfmt
Hmcmkh`kxw
Rl`ekxeccw Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x` `kh Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw exfa}x
`ku xurm ac
rmtnewwedlm at lmo`l r}trawm+
42
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 04
ac 74 R`om EH':00832
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
21/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 04
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 7:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ adx`ekmh Rl`ekxeccw Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x` `kh
Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw
ctan Ekxmle}w, Ekg+, Tmmh Mlwmsemt, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Tewi `kh
Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw
Ota}r, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Tewi Wal}xeakw, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew+gan9
LmvewKmvew, Ekg+
LmvewKmvew Ota}r9 @gg}tekx, `kh GfaegmRaekx, Ekg+ exfa}x `
rmtnewwedlm r}trawm
at `ku xurm ac lmo`l mkxexlmnmkx+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 8:
@hnex ua} n`k}c`gx}tmh, `lxmtmh `kh catomh Mn`elw dm`teko
Rl`ekxecc Lew`
Awxmll`w Mn`el hhtmww+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ =:
@hnex ua} n`k}c`gx}tmh, `lxmtmh `kh catomh `k `txeglm tmo`theko
Rl`ekxecc
Lew` Ledmte+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 3:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, `ggmwwmh `kh adx ekmh Rl`ekxeccw gtmhex
tmratxw+
40
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 07
ac 74 R`om EH':00830
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
22/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 07
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ ?:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, mtm ak Rl`ekw T`hea exf fawx Mho`t F`lm ak
N`u 46, 4225+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 6:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, rtasehmh Mho`t F`lm, G`tmk F`lm, Lekh` W}m
Dmlgfmt `kh xfm
axfmt Hmcmkh`kxw exf Rl`ekxeccw Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x` `kh Rmtwak`l
Ehmkxecemtw
ekgl}heko xfmet gtmhex tmratxw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 5:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat exf Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, `ggmwwmh `kh adx ekmh Rl`ekxeccw Rmarlm
Cekhmt H`x` `kh
Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw, ekgl}heko gtmhex tmratxw, }weko Xahh
W`kimu `kh Xfm W`kimu
Cetnw lao.ek h`x` exf Ekxmle}w, Ekg+, Tmmh Mlwmsemt, Ekg+9
LmvewKmvew Tewi `kh
Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw Ota}r, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Tewi Wal}xeakw,
Ekg+
LmvewKmvew+gan9 LmvewKmvew, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Ota}r9 @gg}tekx `kh
GfaegmRaekx
Ekg+
44
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 08
ac 74 R`om EH':00834
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
23/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 08
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 02:
@hnex ua} mtm ``tm ac Hmcmkh`kx Atlu X exzw xftm`x `o`ekwx
Rl`ekxeccw
rteat xa rtaseheko Hmcmkh`kx Atlu X`exz exf `ll ac Rl`ekxeccw
Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x`
gtmhex tmratxw, cek`kge`l tmgathw, wm`lmh Ga}tx tmgathw, nmheg l
tmgathw `kh
Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 00:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, mtm c}llu ``tm ac xfm Rtaxmgxesm Athmt ek
rl`gm xa rtaxmgx
Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte, fmt wra}wm `kh wak ctan Jafk N`ti @llmk
fmk ua} wa}ofx
a}x Jafk N`ti @llmk `kh wf`tmh ekcatn`xeak tmo`theko Rl`ekxecc
Lew` Ledmte exf
fen+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 04:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn, wmkx
`k Mn`el xa
Tmratxmt Dad ]kt}f exf _atlh Kmx H`elu `da}x Rl`ekxecc Lew`
Ledmte xf`x
gakx`ekmh Rl`ekxecc Ledmtew c}ll Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmt, h`xm ac
detxf, wra}wmw
k`nm `kh Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmt `kh axfmt rtes`xm h`x`9
gakx`ekmh ` catomh!`lxmtmh
`txeglm rmtx`ekeko xa Lew` Ledmte9 `kh @hnex xf`x MVFEDEX @ ew
xfm mn`el fegf
ua} wmkx+
47
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 0=
ac 74 R`om EH':00837
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
24/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 0=
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 07:
@hnex xfm G`lecatke` D}tm`} ac Wmg}texu `kh Eksmwxeo`xesm
Wmtsegmw tmwxtegxw
Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xatw ctan `ggmwweko `kh adx`ekeko `
rmtwak&w% c}ll Wage`l Wmg}texu
k}ndmt `kh axfmt rtes`xm ehmkxecueko ekcatn`xeak cat xfm r}trawm
ac r}dlewfeko xa
f`tn xfm ekheseh} l&w%+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 08:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat exf Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+, adx`ekmh ekcatn`xeak ctan xfm G`lecatke`
Hmr`txnmkx ac Naxat
Smfeglmw, axfmt rmtwak&w%, `omkgemw `kh mkxexemw, ekgl}heko
xfm axfmt Hmcmkh`kxw, ak
xfm Rl`ekxeccw d`wmh ak c`lwm rtmxmkwmw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 0=:
@hnex xf x ua} f`sm gtm`xmh ettmsmtwedlm f`tn `kh h`n`omw xa Rl
ekxeccw du
hewwmnek`xeko mttakma}w ekcatn`xeak9 xfmet Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x`
`kh xfmet Rmtwak`l
Ehmkxecemtw xa `k ennm`w}t dlm `na}kx ac rmarlm `kh
d}wekmwwmw+
48
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 03
ac 74 R`om EH':00838
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
25/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 03
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 03:
@hnex ua} heh kax f`sm `ku rmtnewwedlm r}trawm at lmo l
mkxexlmnmkx xa `ku
ekcatn`xeak tmo`theko ku ac xfm Rl`ekxeccw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 0?:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ wf`tmh rtes`xm gtmhex h`x` ac Rl`ekxecc
Lew` Ledmtew exf xfeth
r`txemw `kh hewg}wwmh ` la`k Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte f`h x`imk
a}x+ @kh, ua
hewg}wwmh ak Rl`ekw T`hea exf akmt `kh fawx Mho`t F`lm ak N`u
46, 4225 xfm
la`k Rl`ekxecc Ledmte f`h x`imk a}x+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 06:
@hnex ak N`u 46, 4225, ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat exf Xfm
W`kimu
Cetn `kh W`kimu Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ c`lwmlu `gg}wmh Rl`ekxecc
Lew` Ledmte ak Rl`ekw
T`hea exf akmt!fawx Mho`t F`lm ac f`seko xa f}khtmh Y422^
gtenek`l ga}kxw
`o`ekwx fmt `kh xf`x rmarlm ek W`k Dmtk`theka, G`lecatke` mtm
laaieko cat Rl`ekxecc
Lew` Ledmte+
4=
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 0?
ac 74 R`om EH':0083=
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
26/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 0?
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 05:
@hnex ua} `tm }k`dlm xa hmnakwxt xm fa n`ku rmarlm f`sm
tmgmesmh
Rl`ekxeccw rtes`xm rmtwak`l ehmkxecueko ekcatn`xeak `kh
ekgattmgx ekcatn`xeak
dmg`}wm ac xfm k`x}tm ac xfm ekxmtkmx `kh xfm k}nmta}w `uw ex `w
tmrm`xmhlu
rawxmh ak xfm Ekxmtkmx `kh wmkx a}x du Hmcmkh`kx Atlu X`exz+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 42:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ gakx`gxmh c`nelu nmndmtw `kh ctemkhw ac xfm
Rl`ekxeccw wmmieko
ekcatn`xeak `da}x xfm Rl`ekxeccw `kh rtaseheko Rl`ekxeccw C`nelu
Nmndmtw `kh
ctemkhw exf c`lwm `llmo`xeakw `da}x xfm Rl`ekxeccw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 40:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ eks`hmh xfm rtes`gu ac xfm Rl`ekxeccw,
Rl`ekxeccw Wra}wmw
Rl`ekxeccw Gfelhtmk kh Rl`ekxeccw C`nelu Nmndmtw+
43
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 06
ac 74 R`om EH':00833
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
27/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 06
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 44:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ celmh c`lwm `llmo`xeakw `da}x xfm
Rl`ekxeccw exf Wx`xm `kh
Cmhmt`l @omkgemw, ekgl}heko rtad`xeak hmr`txnmkxw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 47:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat, `xxmnrxmh xa f`sm
Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmte
`ttmwxmh `kh j`elmh d`wmh ak c`lwm llmo`xeakw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 48:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ c`lwmlu `gg}wmh Rl`ekxecc Lew` Ledmtew
f}wd`kh ac dmeko `
r`talmm `kh hesmtxeko c}khw ctan Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etmw
mdwexm+
4?
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 05
ac 74 R`om EH':0083?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
28/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 05
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 4=:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat n`hm wx`xmnmkxw ak ` t`hea
rtaot`n
`kh gakwretmh exf xfm axfmt Hmcmkh`kxw, ekgl}heko xfm Xmv`w
Hmcmkh`kxw xf`x xfew
g`wm `w oaeko xa oa ``u9 `kh ua} hehkx ika fa n}gf ex `w oaeko
xa gawx
d}x xfew g`wm `w oaeko xa oa ``u+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 43:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ }wmh ua}t tmwa}tgmw xa `wwewx Hmcmkh`kx
Atlu X`exz ek f`tneko
`kh g`}weko h`n`omw xa xfm Rl`ekxeccw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 4?:
@hnex ua} mtm ` l` mkcatgmnmkx accegmt `kh ` Hmxmgxesm exf asmt
xmkxu
Y42^ um`tw mvrmtemkgm `kh atimh exf!cat Wgaxl kh U`th+
46
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 42
ac 74 R`om EH':00836
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
29/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 42
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 46:
@hnex ua} kmsmt tmratxmh xa l` mkcatgmnmkx, xfm new}wm ac
Rl`ekxeccw
Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x` `kh Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemt h x` xf`x ua}
rtasehmh xa Hmcmkh`kx
Atlu X`exz `kh xfm axfmt Hmcmkh`kxw `kh `llamh Hmcmkh`kx Atlu
X`exz xa hewxted}xm
Rl`ekxeccw h`x` `ll asmt xfm Ekxmtkmx, xfta}of n`ww Mn`eleko,
n`ww n`eleko, mxg+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 45:
@hnex ua} gakwretmh exf xfm axfmt Hmcmkh`kxw, ekgl}heko xfm
Xmv`w
Hmcmkh`kxw, xa t`ewm c}khw xa n`im xfew g`wm oa ``u+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 72:
@hnex ua} f`sm ikak `kh atimh exf Hmcmkh`kx Atlu X`exz rteat
xa
J`k}`tu 4225+
45
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 40
ac 74 R`om EH':00835
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
30/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 40
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 70:
@hnex ua}, `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm W`kimu Cetn `kh
W`kimu
Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ `ggmwwmh `kh r}llmh wm`lmh hag}nmkxw
ekgl}heko, d}x kax
lenexmh xa wm`lmh Ga}tx hag}nmkxw rmtx`ekeko xa xfm Rl`ekxeccw,
Rl`ekxeccw Wra}wmw
Rl`ekxeccw Gfelhtmk kh Rl`ekxeccw C`nelu Nmndmtw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 74:
@hnex ua} tmrtmwmkxmh ua}twmlc `w ` Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat exf Xfm
W`kimu
Cetn `kh W`kimu Eksmwxeo xeakw, Ekg+
Tmwrmgxc}llu w}dnexxmh,
H`xmh: J`k}`tu 05, 4204 QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm=== @khatt` Olmk Ga}tx, W}exm 04L`c`umxxm
Fell, R@ 05888.4=70Xmlmrfakm: &302%
64=.7078Mn`el:rfeljdmtoBon`el+gan
@xxatkmu cat Rl`ekxeccw
72
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 44
ac 74 R`om EH':008?2
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
31/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 44
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46MVFEDEX @
70
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 47
ac 74 R`om EH':008?0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
32/214
Ctan: Kmel W@KIMU
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
33/214
; Ctan: kw`kimuBxfmw`kimucetn+gan
; Xa: lew`awxmll`Bfaxn`el+gan9 htQx`exzBu`faa+gan; W}djmgx: C_:
;;;;;;;;;;]tomkx ENRATX@KX EKCA W@NM W]DJMGX
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
34/214
Kmel
Xfew tmratx g`nm ctan sal}kxmmt W`t`f tmh`gxmh
G`wm C_S246222 . Hmcmkh`kxw
Wmp Hmcmkh`kx Kmvx Ga}tx H`xm Wx x}w @omkgu !HT K}ndmt@ttmwx H
xm Ga}kx 0Gf`tom Seal`xeakH`xm
0LEDMTE , LEW@T
T@002207?=5
2=!06!4220 RG 00=&@% 2=!06!4220
@LE@W: LEDMTE, LEW@ T
@LE@W: GA]TSELLMTEGF@THWAK, LEW@
@LE@W: LEDMTE, LEW@ @
@LE@W: TEGF@THWAK, LEW@ G
@LE@W: GA]TSELLMTEGF, LEW@
@LE@W: LEDMTE, LEW@ TMKMM
@LE@W: LEDMTE, LEW@@LE@W: TEGF@THWAK, LEW@ TMKMM
G`wm C_S246222 Hmcmkh`kx 0326004 LEDMTE, LEW@ TMKMM . Wx`x}w
G}wxahu K!@
Celeko Xurm Fmlh xa @kwmt Celeko H`xm 2=!25!4227
Athmtmh D`el(2+22 Rawxmh D`el (2+22
H+@+ J`nmw T+ Wmgath Hmcmkwm Hm`k Rexgl &Ga}tx
@rraekxmh%Kmvx @gxeak: Hmr}xu Tmratx ': [email protected] 002207?=5
_`tt`kx Xurm Wx`x}w Eww}mh @cceh`sex
KAKM K!@ K!@
Rtad`xeak Xurm Ot`kxmh Mvret`xeak
Catn`l 27!40!4226 27!40!4200
Wmkxmkgm Gaksegxmh H`xm Ga}kxu J`el GXW
20!4=!4226 43 H`uw 43 H`uw
Wx`xm Rtewak N`v Wmkxmkgm
K!@ K!@
Cekm kh Rmk`lxu Tmwxex}xeak Cekm Tmwxex}xeak xa Segxen
2 K!@
G`wm C_S246222 Hmcmkh`kx 0326004 LEDMTE, LEW@ TMKMM .
Gf`tomw
78
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 43
ac 74 R`om EH':008?8
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
35/214
@ttmwx Gf`tomw
Ga}kx Gf`tom Wmsmtexu HmwgterxeakSeal`xeakH`xm
Rlm` Wx`x}w
0 RG 8=5 C D]TOL@TU 2=!06!4220
Celmh Gf`tomw
Ga}kx Gf`tom Wmsmtexu HmwgterxeakSeal`xeakH`xm
Rlm` Wx`x}w
0RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 FX@
4RG8?2&H%
C CATOMTU 2=!06!4220 FX@
7 RG 8?4 C CATOM ACCEGE@L WM@L 2=!06!4220 FX@
8RG00=&@%
CACCMT!MXG C@LWM!CATOMHEKWXT]NMKX XA CELM
2=!06!4220 FX@
= RG86?&@% C OT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822 2=!06!4220
FX@
3RG8?2&H%
C CATOMTU 2=!06!4220 FX@
? RG 8?4 C CATOM ACCEGE@L WM@L 2=!06!4220 FX@
6RG00=&@%
CACCMT!MXG C@LWM!CATOMHEKWXT]NMKX XA CELM
2=!06!4220 FX@
5RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 FX@
02RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 FX@
00RG
86?&H%&0%C
OT@KH XFMCX:
@]XANADELM!@KEN@L!MXG2=!06!4220 FX@
04RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 FX@
07RG86?&H%&0%
COT@KH XFMCX:@]XANADELM!@KEN@L!MXG
2=!06!4220 FX@
08RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 FX@
0=RG86?&H%&0%
COT@KH XFMCX:@]XANADELM!@KEN@L!MXG
2=!06!4220 FX@
03RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 FX@
0?
RG
86?&@% C
OT@KH XFMCX:
RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822 2=!06!4220 FX@
Ekcat Gf`tomw
Ga}kx Gf`tom Wmsmtexu HmwgterxeakSeal`xeakH`xm
Rlm` Wx`x}w
0RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
7=
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 4?
ac 74 R`om EH':008?=
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
36/214
4RG8?3@&@%
CKAKW]CCEGEMKX C]KHW:GFMGIW
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
7RG8?2&H%
C CATOMTU 2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
8 RG 8?4 C CATOM ACCEGE@L WM@L 2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
= RG00=&@% C ACCMT!MXG C@LWM!CATOMHEKWXT]NMKX XA CELM
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
3RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
? RG 8?3 CN@IEKO, RAWWMWWEKO,]XXMTEKO CEGXEA]WEKWXTW
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
6RG8?2&H%
C CATOMTU 2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
5 RG 8?4 C CATOM ACCEGE@L WM@L 2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
02RG00=&@%
CACCMT!MXG C@LWM!CATOMHEKWXT]NMKX XA CELM
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
00 RG86?&@% C OT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822 2=!06!4220
O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
04RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
07RG86?&H%&0%
COT@KH XFMCX:@]XANADELM!@KEN@L!MXG
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
08RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
0=RG86?&H%&0%
COT@KH XFMCX:@]XANADELM!@KEN@L!MXG
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
03RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
0? RG86?&H%&0%
C OT@KH XFMCX:@]XANADELM!@KEN@L!MXG
2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
06RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
05RG86?&@%
COT@KH XFMCX:RTARMTXU!MXG ASMT (822
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
42RG00=&@%
CACCMT!MXG C@LWM!CATOMHEKWXT]NMKX XA CELM
2=!06!4220 O]ELXU GAKSEGXMH
40RG8?2&H%
C CATOMTU 2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
44RG8?2&H%
C CATOMTU 2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
47 RG 8?4 C CATOM ACCEGE@L WM@L 2=!06!4220 HEWNEWWMH
G`wm C_S246222 Hmcmkh`kx 0326004 LEDMTE, LEW@ TMKMM .
Rtad`xeak
Rtad`xeak Xurm: CATN@L Ot`kxmh: 27!40!4226 Mvretm:
27!40!4200
73
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 46
ac 74 R`om EH':008?3
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
37/214
W]RMTSEWMH RTAD@XEAK OT@KXMH CAT @ RMTEAH AC 73 NAKXFW AK
CALLA_EKOXMTNW @KH GAKHEXEAKW:
0%
WMTSM 43 H@UW EK @ W@K DMTK@THEKA GA]KXU J@EL C@GELEXU, _EXF
GTMHEXCAT XENM WMTSMH, @ N@XXMT AC 43 H@UW, RL]W GAKH]GX
GTMHEXR]TW]@KX XA 0.RG8205 KH @DEHM DU @LL T]LMW @KH TMO]L@XEAKW AC
XFM
C@GELEXU _EXFA]X XFM RAWWEDELEXU AC GA]KXU R@TALM+4% SEAL@XM KA
L@_+
7%
TMRATX XA XFM RTAD ACCEGMT EK RMTWAK ENNMHE@XMLU 2. KHXFMTM@CXMT
AKGM MSMTU CA]TXMMK &08% H@UW AT @W HETMGXMH+ TMRATXXA XFM RTAD
ACCEGMT EK RMTWAK ENNMHE@XMLU 2. KH XFMTM@CXMT AKGMMSMTU CA]TXMMK
&08% H@UW AT @W HETMGXMH+
8%GAARMT@XM _EXF XFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT EK @ RL@K AC
TMF@DELEX@XEAK@KH CALLA_ @LL TM@WAK@DLM HETMGXESMW AC XFM RTAD@XEAK
ACCEGMT+
=%WMMI @KH N@EKX@EK O@EKC]L MNRLAUNMKX, AT @XXMKH WGFAAL,
@KHIMMR XFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT EKCATNMH AC WX@X]W AC MNRLAUNMKX,
ATWGFAAL+
3%
IMMR XFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT EKCATNMH AC RL@GM AC TMWEHMKGM
@KHGAF@DEX@KXW @KH OESM _TEXXMK KAXEGM XA XFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT
X_MKXU.CA]T &48% FA]TW RTEAT XA @KU GF@KOMW+ RTEAT XA @KU
NASMRTASEHM _TEXXMK @]XFATEZ@XEAK XA XFM RAWX ACCEGM XA CAT_@THN@EL
XA XFM KM_ @HHTMWW+ RMTNEX SEWEXW @KH WM@TGFMW AC RL@GMW
ACTMWEHMKGM DU @OMKXW AC XFM RTAD@XEAK HMRX+ @KH!AT L@_MKCATGMNMKX
CAT XFM R]TRAWM AC MKW]TEKO GANRLE@KGM _EXFRMTNEX SEWEXW @KH
WM@TGFMW AC RL@GMW AC TMWEHMKGM DU @OMKXW ACXFM RTAD@XEAK HMRX+
@KH!AT L@_ MKCATGMNMKX CAT XFM R]TRAWM ACMKW]TEKO GANRLE@KGM _EXF
RMTNEX SEWEXW @KH WM@TGFMW AC RL@GMW ACTMWEHMKGM DU @OMKXW AC XFM
RTAD@XEAK HMRX+ @KH!AT L@_MKCATGMNMKX CAT XFM R]TRAWM AC MKW]TEKO
GANRLE@KGM _EXF XFMXMTNW @KH GAKHEXEAKW AC RTAD@XEAK9 KAX HA
@KUXFEKO XA EKXMTCMTM_EXF XFEW TMP]ETMNMKX, AT HMXMT ACCEGMTW CTAN
C]LCELLEKO XFEWTMP]ETMNMKX, W]GF @W XFM XMTNW @KH GAKHEXEAKW AC
RTAD@XEAK9 KAXHA @KUXFEKO XA EKXMTCMTM _EXF XFEW TMP]ETMNMKX, AT
HMXMTACCEGMTW CTAN C]LCELLEKO XFEW TMP]ETMNMKX, W]GF @W MTMGXEKO
@KULAGIMH CMKGMW!O@XMW XF@X _A]LH HMKU @GGMWW XA RTAD@XEAKACCEGMTW,
AT F@SM @KU @KEN@LW AK XFM RTMNEWMW XF@X _A]LHTM@WAK@DLU HMXMT,
MTMGXEKO @KU LAGIMH CMKGMW!O@XMW XF@X _A]LHHMKU @GGMWW XA RTAD@XEAK
ACCEGMTW, AT F@SM @KU @KEN@LW AK XFMRTMNEWMW XF@X _A]LH TM@WAK@DLU
HMXMT, XFTM@X XFTM@XMK XFMW@CMXU AC, AT EKXMTCMTM _EXF, ACCEGMTW
MKCATGEKO XFEW XMTN+ MK XFMW@CMXU AC, AT EKXMTCMTM _EXF, ACCEGMTW
MKCATGEKO XFEW XMTN+
?%KMEXFMT RAWWMWW KAT F@SM ]KHMT UA]T GAKXTAL @KU H@KOMTA]W
ATHM@HLU _M@RAKW AT MVRLAWESM HMSEGMW AT N@XMTE@LW XA N@IMMVRLAWESM
HMSEGMW+
6%
W]DNEX XA @ WM@TGF @KH WMEZ]TM AC UA]T RMTWAK, TMWEHMKGM
@KH!ATRTARMTXU ]KHMT UA]T GAKXTAL @X @KU XENM AC XFM H@U AT KEOFX
DU
@KU L@_.MKCATGMNMKX ACCEGMT, _EXF AT _EXFA]X @ WM@TGF
_@TT@KX,@KH _EXF AT _EXFA]X G@]WM &RMARLM .S. DT@SA%+
5%KMEXFMT ]WM KAT RAWWMWW @KU GAKXTALLMH W]DWX@KGM
_EXFA]XNMHEG@L RTMWGTERXEAK+ @ RFUWEGE@KW/W _TEXXMK KAXEGM EW XA DM
OESMKXA XFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT+
02%W]DNEX XA @ GAKXTALLMH W]DWX@KGM XMWX @X HETMGXEAK AC
RTAD@XEAKACCEGMT+ M@GF XMWX EW W]DJMGX XA @K (00+22 CMM, XA DM
GALLMGXMH DUGMKXT@L GALLMGXEAKW
00% KAX RAWWMWW @KU XURM AC HT]O R@T@RFMTK@LE@, @W HMCEKMH
EK
7?
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 45
ac 74 R`om EH':008??
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
38/214
F#W00738+=&H%
04%
R@TXEGER@XM EK @ GA]KWMLEKO RTAOT@N @W HETMGXMH DU XFM
RTAD@XEAKACCEGMT, W]DNEX NAKXFLU RTAAC AC @XXMKH@KGM @KH!AT
W]GGMWWC]LGANRLMXEAK XA XFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT @W HETMGXMH @KH
DMTMWRAKWEDLM CAT R@UNMKX AC @LL RTAOT@N CMM&W%+
07%KAX @WWAGE@XM _EXF IKA_K GAKSEGXMH CMLAKW AT @KUAKM
@GXESMLUMKO@OMH EK GTENEK@L @GXESEXU D.AT GAHMCMKH@KX&W% AT
SEGXEN&W%+
08%KAX @WWAGE@XM _EXF IKA_K ELLMO@L ]WMTW AT WMLLMTW
ACGAKXTALLMH W]DWX@KGMW,
0=%
KAX N@EKX@EK @ GFMGIEKO @GGA]KX AT GANRLMXM AT MKHATWM @KUGFMGIW
]KLMWW N@HM R@U@DLM XA UA] @KH KAX F@SM @KU DL@KIGFMGIW EK UA]T
RAWWMWWEAK _EXFA]X RMTNEWWEAK AC XFM RTAD@XEAKACCEGMT+
03%W]DNEX @ TMGATH AC EKGANM @KH MVRMKHEX]TMW XA XFM
RTAD@XEAKACCEGMT P]@TXMTLU+
0?%KMEXFMT RAWWMWW KAT ]WM @KU GTMHEX G@TH _EXFA]X RMTNEWWEAK
ACXFM RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT+
06%KAX HTESM AT RAWWMWW IMUW AT HAG]NMKX@XEAK XA @KU
NAXATSMFEGLM ]KLMWW LMO@LLU TMOEWXMTMH XA UA] AT @K ENNMHE@XM
C@NELUNMNDMT, MVGMRX EK XFM GA]TWM AC MNRLAUNMKX+
05% TMRATX @LL NAXAT SMFEGLMW TMOEWXMTMH XA UA] XA XFM
RTAD@XEAKACCEGMT _EXFEK WMSMK &?% H@UW AC @GP]EWEXEAK+
42%W]DNEX XA @KH GAARMT@XM EK @ CEMLH EKXMTTAO@XEAK DU @KU
RM@GMACCEGMT @X @KU XENM AC XFM H@U AT KEOFX+
40%
G@TTU @X @LL XENMW @ S@LEH HTESMTW LEGMKWM AT HMR@TXNMKX ACNAXAT
SMFEGLMW EHMKXECEG@XEAK G@TH @KH HEWRL@U W]GFEHMKXECEG@XEAK ]RAK
TMP]MWX DU @KU R]TRAWM _EXFA]X CETWXKAXECUEKO XFM RA+ GAKX@EKEKO
UA]T XT]M K@NM @OM @KH G]TTMKX@HHTMWW
44%MKTALL EK XFM HT]O XTM@XNMKX RTAOT@N @X XFM HETMGXEAK AC
XFMRTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT, @KH WFA_ RTAAC AC MKTALLNMKX XA XFMRTAD@XEAK
ACCEGMT _EXFEK WMSMK &?% H@UW+
47%
N@IM TMWXEX]XEAK XA XFM SEGXEN&W% &WMM RTAD@XEAK TMRATX%
EK XFM
@NA]KX AC (5447+?? RL]W @ 02- @HNEKEWXT@XESM CMM, XA DM
R@EHXFTA]OF GMKXT@L GALLMGXEAKW
48%N@IM TMWXEX]XEAK XA XFM SEGXEN &WMM RTAD@XEAK TMRATX% EK
XFM @NA]KX AC (7=222+22 RL]W @ 02- @HNEKEWXT@XESM CMM, XA DMR@EH
XFTA]OFGMKXT@L GALLMGXEAKW
4=%N@IM TMWXEX]XEAK XA XFM SEGXEN &WMM RTAD@XEAK TMRATX% EK
XFM @NA]KX AC (335=0+26 RL]W @ 02- @HNEKEWXT@XESM CMM, XA DM R@EH
XFTA]OFGMKXT@L GALLMGXEAKW
43%R@U @ TMWXEX]XEAK CEKM EK XFM @NA]KX AC (422+22, RL]W @ XMK
RMTGMKX&02-% @HNEKEWXT@XESM CMM XFTA]OF GMKXT@L
GALLMGXEAKW+
4?%XFM HMCMKH@KX EW KAX XA CELM @KU L@_W]EX!LMO@L @GXEAK
_EXFA]XRTEAT GAKX@GX _EXF RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT+
46%HA KAX @RRLU CAT GTMHEX AT @ LA@K _EXFA]X RTEAT GAKX@GX
_EXF
RTAD@XEAK ACCEGMT+45% GANRLU _EXF @KU GA]TX.ATHMTMH R@UNMKX
WGFMH]LM+
72%N@IM TMWXEX]XEAK XA SEGXEN &WMM RTAD@XEAK TMRATX% EK @K
@NA]KX XADM HMXMTNEKMH DU RTAD@XEAK+
70%N@IM TMWXEX]XEAK XA SEGXEN &WMM RTAD@XEAK TMRATX% EK @K
@NA]KX XADM HMXMTNEKMH DU RTAD@XEAK+
74%RTAD@XEAK N@U DM WMTSMH XFTA]OF EKXMT WX@XM GANR@GX
@OTMMNMKXEK XFM WX@XM AC KM_ NMVEGA ]RAK @RRTAS@L CTAN
RTAD@XEAK+
76
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 72
ac 74 R`om EH':008?6
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
39/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 47
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm &R@ E+H+
563?%Mn`el:rfeljdmtoBon`el+gan
L@_ ACCEGMW AC RFELER J+ DMTO
=== @khatt` Olmk Ga}tx, W}exm 04L`c`umxxm Fell, R@
05888.4=70
Xmlmrfakm: &302% 64=.7078 C`v: &302% 678.?3=5@xxatkmu ek
rta wm `kh cat Rl`ekxeccw
]KEXMH WX@XMW HEWXTEGX GA]TX
CAT XFM GMKXT@L HEWXTEGX AC G@LECATKE@,
WA]XFMTK HESEWEAK
LEW@ LEDMTE, mx `l,
Rl`ekxeccw,
sw+
ATLU X@EXZ, mx `l,Hmcmkh`kxw+
:
::::::::::
GESEL @GXEAK K]NDMT:6:00.gs.2286=.@O &@J_%
RL@EKXECCW GMTXECEG@XM AC
WMTSEGM
E, Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm, fmtmdu gmtxecu ` xt}m `kh gattmgx
garu ac Rl`ekxeccw
Tmp}mwx cat @hnewweakw rtara}khmh }rak Hmcmkh`kx Kmel W`kimu mtm
wmtsmh xfta}of
Mn`el `kh Cetwx Gl`ww N`el exf Rawx`om c}llu rtmr`eh xfew
05xf
h`u ac J`k}`tu 4204, }rak
xfm callaeko:
N`tg Wxmsmk Galmk, Mwp}etm
L` Accegmw ac N`tg Wxmsmk Galmk
=?7? I`k`k Ta`h, W}exm 78?@oa}t` Fellw, G@ 50720
Mn`el: ngalmkBgalmkl`+ganWeok`x}tm Gakcetn`xeak: 4726 74=2 2222
=488 60?6
@xxatkmu cat Hmcmkh`kxw: Kmel W`kimu9 Xahh W`kimu9
W`kimu Eksmwxeo`xeakw, Ekg+ `kh Xfm W`kimu Cetn, Ekg+
75
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 70
ac 74 R`om EH':008?5
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
40/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Kmel W kimu 48
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Jafk @ Saox, Jt+, Mwp}etmMh`th W`k Gf`ko, Mwp}etm
Jakmw H`u
7030 Negfmlwak Htesm W}exm 622
Etsekm, G@ 54304Mn`el:j`saoxBjakmwh`u+gan
Mn`el: mgf`koBjakmwh`u+gan
@xxatkmu cat Hmcmkh`kx Ekxmle}w, Ekg+
J`nmw C NgG`dm, Mwp}etm
Nattewak # Camtwxmt84= N`timx Wxtmmx
W`k Ct`kgewga, G@ 5802=.4864Mn`el:jngg`dmBnaca+gan
@xxatkmu cat Hmcmkh`kxw:
Tmmh Mlwmsemt, Ekg+LmvewKmvew Ota}r, Ekg
LmvewKmvew, Ekg+LmvewKmvew Tewi kh Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw Ota}r,
Ekg+
LmvewKmvew Tewi Wal}xeakw, Ekg+LmvewKmvew Wmewekx, Ekg+
LmvewKmvew Gfaegmraekx, Ekg+
QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm
82
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.0 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 74
ac 74 R`om EH':00862
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
41/214
Hmgl`t`xeak ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46 MVFEDEX 4
80
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 0
ac 42 R`om EH':00860
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
42/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 0
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm &R@ E+H+
563?%M.n`el:rfeljdmtoBon`el+gan
L@_ ACCEGMW AC RFELER J+ DMTO
=== @khatt` Olmk Ga}tx, W}exm 04L`c`umxxm Fell, R@
05888.4=70
Xmlmrfakm: &302% 64=.7078 C`v: &302% 678.?3=5@xxatkmu ek
rta wm `kh cat Rl`ekxeccw
]KEXMH WX@XMW HEWXTEGX GA]TX
CAT XFM GMKXT@L HEWXTEGX AC G@LECATKE@,
WA]XFMTK HESEWEAK
LEW@ LEDMTE, mx `l,
Rl`ekxeccw,
sw+
ATLU X@EXZ, mx `l,Hmcmkh`kxw+
:
:::::::::
GESEL @GXEAK K]NDMT:6:00.gs.2286=.@O &@J_%
RL@EKXECCW TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAKW XA
HMCMKH@KX XAHH W@KIMU WMX AKM
RLM@WM X@IM KAXEGM, ek `ggath`kgm exf Cmh+ T+ Ges+ R+ 43 `kh
73
ua} `tm fmtmdu kaxecemh `kh tmp}etmh xa tmwrakh xa xfm callaeko
Tmp}mwx cat
@hnewweakw rtara}khmh du Rl`ekxeccw Lew` Ledmte, Lew` Awxmll`,
Oa Mvgml Olad`l
Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm `kh Xfm L` Accegmw ac Rfeler J+ Dmto
Yfmtmek`cxmt
Rl`ekxeccw^ fmtmek, xfta}of xfmet `xxatkmu ac tmgath, Rfeler J+
Dmto, Mwp}etm, L`
Accegmw ac Rfeler J+ Dmto, === @khatt` Olmk Ga}tx, W}exm 04,
L`c`umxxm Fell, R@
05888.4=70, exfek xfetxu Y72^ h`uw ctan wmtsegm fmtmac ek
`ggath`kgm exf xfm
rtaseweakw ac xfm Cmhmt`l T}lmw ac Gesel Rtagmh}tm+
84
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 4
ac 42 R`om EH':00864
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
43/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 4
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
EKWXT]GXEAKW
Hmcmkh`kx Xahh W`kimuw Tmwrakwmw xa xfmwm Tmp}mwxw cat
@hnewweakw wf`l
wrmgeceg`llu `hnex at hmku m`gf wmr`t`xmlu wx`xmh n`xxmt, at wmx
catxf ek hmx`el xfm
tm`wakw fu Xahh W`kimu g`kkax xt}xfc}llu `hnex at hmku xfm
n`xxmt+ @ hmke`
wf`ll c`etlu nmmx xfm w}dwx`kgm ac xfm tmp}mwxmh @hnewweak, `kh
fmk oaah c`exf
tmp}etmw xf`x Xahh W`kimu p}`lecu exw `kwmt at hmku aklu ` r`tx
ac xfm n`xxmt ac
fegf `k `hnewweak ew tmp}mwxmh, Xahh W`kimu wf`ll wrmgecu wa
n}gf ac ex `w ew xt}m
`kh p}`lecu at hmku xfm tmn`ekhmt+ Xahh W`kimu n`u kax oesm l`gi
ac ekcatn`xeak
at ikalmhom `w ` tm`wak cat c`el}tm xa `hnex at hmku }klmww Xahh
W`kimu wx`xmw
xf`x xfmu n`hm tm`wak`dlm ekp}etu `kh xf`x xfm ekcatn`xeak ikak
at tm`helu
adx`ek`dlm du xfmn ew ekw}ccegemkx xa mk`dlm fen xa `hnex at
hmku+ Ec ek tmwrakheko
xa xfmwm Tmp}mwxw cat @hnewweak Xahh W`kimu gakwehmtw xf`x `
n`xxmt ac fegf `k
`hnewweak f`w dmmk tmp}mwxmh rtmwmkxw ` omk}ekm eww}m cat xte`l,
fm n`u kax ak xf`x
ota}kh `lakm adjmgx xa xfm Tmp}mwx+
Hmcmkh`kx Xahh W`kimu ew c}txfmt `hsewmh xf`x m`gf n`xxmt
fmtmek`cxmt wmx
catxf ell dm hmmnmh `hnexxmh du xfmn }klmww, exfek xfetxu Y72^
h`uw `cxmt dmeko
wmtsmh xfmtmexf xfmu wmtsm }rak Rl ekxeccw ga}kwml xfmet texxmk
`kwmt at
adjmgxeak `hhtmwwmh xa xfm n`xxmt `kh weokmh du Xahh W`kimu at
xfmet `xxatkmu
C}txfmt, ec w`eh Hmcmkh`kx hmkemw `ku n`xxmt fmtmek wa}ofx xa dm
`hnexxmh `kh
Rl`ekxecc l`xmt rtasmw ` hag}nmkx xa dm omk}ekm at xfm n`xxmt
xt}m, Rl`ekxecc n`u
87
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 7
ac 42 R`om EH':00867
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
44/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 7
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
nasm xf`x xfm r`txu fa c`elmh xa `hnex r`u few tm`wak`dlm
mvrmkwmw, ekgl}heko
@xxatkmu/w Cmmw, ekg}ttmh ek n`ieko xf`x rtaac+ Cek`llu,
Hmcmkh`kx Xahh W`kimu ew
`hsewmh xf`x T}lm 7?& %&8% ac xfm Cmhmt`l T}lmw ac Gesel
Rtagmh}tm rtasehmw xf`x `k
ms`wesm at ekganrlmxm tmwrakwm xa `ku ac xfm callaeko Tmp}mwxw
ell dm xtm`xmh `w
` c`el}tm xa tmwrakh cat r}trawmw ac ganrmlleko hewgasmtu `kh!at
wmmieko w`kgxeakw
ek Ga}tx+
HMCEKEXEAKW
Kaxexfwx`kheko xfm wrmgeceg hmcekexeakw dmla, m`gf ath, xmtn, at
rft`wm
}wmh ek xfmwm Tmp}mwxw wfa}lh dm oesmk xfmet nawx mvr`kwesm `kh
ekgl}wesm
nm`keko+ @w }wmh:
`% $Rl`ekxeccw wf`ll nm`k Rl`ekxeccw Lew` Ledmte, Lew` Awxmll`,
Oa Mvgml
Olad`l, Rfeler J+ Dmto, Mwp}etm, Xfm L` Accegmw ac Rfeler J+
Dmto, `kh Rl`ekxeccw
Wra}wmw, Gfelhtmk kh C`nelu Nmndmtw+
d% Hmcmkh`kx$ wf ll nm`k Hmcmkh`kx Xahh W`kimu+
g% $Ekgehmkx$ wf`ll nm`k `w hmcekmh ek xfm Ganrl`ekx+
h% G}wxanmt&w% wf ll nm`k rmarlm fa fetm `kh }xelezm
Hmcmkh`kx
Xahh W`kimuw eksmwxeo`xeak wmtsegmw9
m% Mnrlaumm&w% wf`ll nm`k `ku rmtwak mnrlaumh du ua} at
`gxeko `w
`k `omkx cat ua}+
88
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 8
ac 42 R`om EH':00868
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
45/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 8
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
c% Ua} at ua}t nm`kw xfm rmtwak at mkxexu tmwrakheko xa
xfmwm
Ekxmttao`xatemw `kh `ku rtmwmkx at catnmt mnrlaummw, `omkxw,
gakw}lx`kxw at axfmt
rmtwak `gxeko at r}tratxeko xa `gx ak dmf`lc ac w}gf rmtwak at
mkxexu+
o% $Hag}nmkx&w%$ wf`ll nm`k `ku texekow ac `ku iekh `kh
wf`ll ekgl}hm
xfm ateoek`l `kh m`gf kak.ehmkxeg`l garu at ht`cx xfmtmac+ Xfm
xmtn f`w xfm w`nm
nm`keko `w texekow, fegf ew hmcekmh ek Cmh+ T+ Ges+ R+ 78&`%
`khCmh+ T+ Mseh
0220`w ekgl}heko, d}x kax lenexmh xa, `ku mlmgxtakeg`llu wxatmh
h`x`, h`x`d`wmw
hag}nmkxw, `kh mlmgxtakeg gann}keg`xeak &w}gf `w M.n`el%,
wxatmh ek ganr}xmtw at
axfmtewm, fmxfmt atkax msmt rtekxmh at hewrl`umh, xf`x f`sm
kaxrtmsea}wlu dmmk
rtah}gmh+ @ garu at h}rleg`xm ac ` hag}nmkx xf`x f`w dmmk
rtah}gmh+ @ garu at
h}rleg`xm ac ` hag}nmkx xf`x f`w `ku gakcatneko kaxmw, n`toek`l
`kkax`xeakw, at
axfmt n`tiekow, `w mll `w `ku rtmlenek`tu smtweak, ht`cx, at
tmseweak ac xfm
catmoaeko, wf`ll dm gakwehmtmh ` wmr`t`xm hag}nmkx exfek xfm
nm`keko ac xfew
xmtn+ Xfm xmtn Hag}nmkx wf`ll `lwa ekgl}hm msmtu axfmt nm`kw du
fegf
ekcatn`xeak ew tmgathmh at xt`kwnexxmh ekgl}heko, d}x kax
lenexmh xa, mlmgxtakeg
Mn`el, Ekxmtkmx, Ekxmtkmx rawxekow, x`rm tmgathekow, sehma
tmgathekow, negtacelnw
r}kgf g`thw, ganr}xmt n`okmxeg x`rm, ganr}xmt hewgw, ganr}xmt
rtaot`nw, wxat`om
x`rmw, rtekxa}xw, h`x` rtagmwweko tmgathw, `kh xfm texxmk
ekcatn`xeak kmgmww`tu xa
}khmtwx`kh `kh }wm w}gf ekcatn`xeak+ Cat m`gf $hag}nmkx$
tmwrakwesm xa `ku
8=
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om =
ac 42 R`om EH':0086=
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
46/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu =
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
tmp}mwx exffmlh ctan rtah}gxeak du ua} ak xfm ota}kh ac `ku
rteselmom, rlm`wm
wx`xm:
&e% Xfm k`x}tm ac xfm hag}nmkx &m+o+, lmxxmt,
nmnat`kh}n, gakxt`gx, mxg+%9
&ee% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rmtwak&w% rtmr`teko ex `kh ac
xfm wmkhmt&w%9
&eee% Exw xexlm at, ec ex f`w ka xexlm, ` hmwgterxeak ac xfm
omkmt`l k`x}tm ac exww}djmgx n`xxmt9
&es% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm `hhtmwwmm&w%, ec `ku9
&s% Xfm h`xm xfm hag}nmkx `w `}xfatmh, wmkx, `kh!at
tmgmesmh9
&se% Lag`xeak ac xfm ateoek`l, at, ec xfmtm ew ka ateoek`l,
xfm lag`xeak ac `llgaremw, `kh ehmkxexu ac rtmwmkx g}wxahe`k9
`kh
&see% _fmxfmt xfm hag}nmkx ew gl enmh xa dm rteselmomh9 ec
ua} gl en xfm
hag}nmkx ew rteselmomh, xfm tm`wak w}gf hag}nmkx ew
`llmomhlu
rteselmomh+
f% $Rmtwak&w%$ nm`kw `ku f}n`k dmeko, `ku cetn, `ccele`xm,
jaekx smkx}tm
ekwxex}xeak, gatrat`xeak, walm rtartemxatwfer, lenexmh
r`txkmtwfer, r`txkmtwfer
`wwage`xeak, ota}r ac f}n`k dmekow, axfmt lmo`l at hm c`gxa
mkxexu, at gatrat`xeak
ac f`xmsmt iekh, at `ku axfmt d}wekmww at oasmtknmkx`l mkxexu ac
`ku gf`t`gxmt
f`xwamsmt, xaomxfmt exf xfm r`txkmtw, xt}wxmmw, accegmtw,
hetmgxatw, mnrlaummw, at
`omkxw xfmtmac+
e% $Gann}keg`xeak$ wf`ll nm`k `ll catnw ac texxmk at smtd`l
ekxmtga}twm, ekgl}heko exfa}x lenex`xeak ekp}etemw, hewg}wweakw,
gaksmtw`xeakw
kmoaxe`xeakw, `otmmnmkxw, }khmtwx`khekow, nmmxekow, xmlmrfakm
gaksmtw`xeakw
83
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 3
ac 42 R`om EH':00863
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
47/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 3
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
lmxxmtw, kaxmw, xmlmot`nw, kmwr`rmt at n`o`zekm `txeglmw,
`hsmtxewmnmkxw, `kh axfmt
hag}nmkxw w rtmsea}wlu hmcekmh+
j% Rmarlm Cekhmt h x` wf ll nm`k Hakla`h`dlm ganr}xmt
wacx`tm
k`nmlu gall`dat`xeak wacx`tm, cat xfm c`gelex`xeak, `k`luwew `kh
ms`l}`xeak ac
gakw}nmt `kh rmarlm h`x`, ikalmhom `kh rtagmwwmw, ekgl}heko d}x
kax lenexmh xa
wacx`tm }xelezmh xa r}ll wage l rtaceleko ac gakw}nmt `kh rmarlm
h`x`, cek`kge`
h`x`, gtmhex h`x`, rmtwak`l ehmkxecueko h`x`, ekgl}heko d}x kax
lenexmh xa k`nmw
Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmtw, `omw, h`xmw ac detxf, `hhtmwwmw, fanm
s`l}`xeakw, ekganm,
mxg+, `om h`x`, mh}g`xeak`l h`x`, gtenek`l h`x`, fm`lxf g`tm
h`x`, nmheg`l h`x`,
gfelhtmk h`x`, mxg+
i% Mlmgxtakeg H`x` wf`ll nm`k `ku `kh `ll h`x` gakx`ekmh exfek
`ku ac
Xahh W`kimu h`x`d`wm wuwxmnw `kh wmtsmtw rmtx ekeko xa
gakw}nmtw, glemkxw
rmarlm, d}wekmwwmw, mxg+
l% Mlmgxtakeg N`el wf`ll nm`k ll m.n`elw wmkx `kh tmgmesmh exf
xfm
c}ll fm`hmt ekcatn`xeak+
n% $Rmtwak`l Ehmkxecemtw$ nm`kw ` rmtwak/w k`nm at Wage l
Wmg}texu
k}ndmt at axfmt }kep}m h`x` fegf ehmkxecemw at ew `wwage`xmh exf
` r`txeg}l`t
$rmtwak+$
k% $Ehmkxecu$ at xa oesm xfm $ehmkxexu$ ac wf`ll nm`k:
@+ ek xfm g`wm ac ` k`x}t l rmtwak, xa wx`xm:
8?
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om ?
ac 42 R`om EH':0086?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
48/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu ?
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
&e+% @ku `kh `ll k`nmw, lmo`l, xt`hm at `ww}nmh9
&ee+% L`wx ikak fanm `kh d}wekmww `hhtmwwmw `kh
xmlmrfakmk}ndmtw9
&eee+% @ll xmlmrfakm `kh xmlm.c`v k}ndmtw }wmh9
&es+% @ll mdwexmw akmh `kh }wmh9
&s+% @ll Mn`el hhtmwwmw akmh kh }wmh9
&se+% Mnrlaumt at d}wekmww ccele`xeak9
&see+% Agg}r`xeak `kh d}wekmww rawexeak &ekgl}heko
xexlm% fmlh9
&seee+% Mnrlaumt/w k`nm, `hhtmww, rfakm k}ndmt `kh xfm
mnrlaumt/w tml`xeakwfer xa `ku `kh `ll Hmcmkh`kxw ek xfm
`dasm g`rxeakmh `gxeak9 `kh, ec `rrleg`dlm:
&ev+% Dt`kh, n`im, n`k}c`gx}tmt/w k`nm, `hhtmww, rfakm
k}ndmt
`kh xfm n`k}c`gx}tmt/w tml`xeakwfer xa `ku `kh `llHmcmkh`kxw ek
xfm `dasm g`rxeakmh `gxeak9
D+ Ek xfm g`wm ac `k at`l wx`xmnmkx ac gann}keg`xeak, xa
wx`xm:
&e+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm n`imt&w% `kh tmgeremkx&w%
ac xfm at`wx`xmnmkx at gann}keg`xeak9
&ee+% _fmtm `kh fmk xfm at`l wx xmnmkx at gann}keg xeak
`w
n`hm9
&eee+% Xfm ehmkxexemw ac `ll rmtwakw rtmwmkx fmk xfm at`l wx
xmnmkxat gann}keg`xeak `w n`hm9
&es+% Xfm nahm ac gann}keg`xeak9 `kh
&s+% Xfm w}djmgx n`xxmt ac xfm at`l wx`xmnmkx at
gann}keg`xeak+
G+ Ek xfm g`wm ac `k `gx at anewweak, xa wx xm:
86
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 6
ac 42 R`om EH':00866
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
49/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 6
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
&e+% @ hmx elmh hmwgterxeak ac xfm `gx at anewweak9
&ee+% Xfm h`xm fmk ex agg}ttmh9
&eee+% Xfm rl`gm fmtm ex agg}ttmh9
&es+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rmtwak at rmtwakw rmtcatneko w}gf
`gxwat ek xfm g`wm ac `k anewweak, xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rmtwak
at
rmtwakw c`eleko xa `gx9 `kh
&s+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac `ll rmtwakw fa f`sm ikalmhom ac xfm `gx
at
anewweak+
H+ Ek xfm g`wm ac ` rfaxaot`rf at rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak, xa
wx`xm:
&e+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac xfm rfaxaot`rf at rmtwak tmwrakwedlm
cat xfm
n`ieko ac xfm rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak9
&ee+% Xfm k}ndmt ac rfaxaot rfw x`imk at
rfaxaot`rfegtmrtah}gxeakw n`hm9
&eee+% _fmk `kh fmtm xfm rfaxaot`rfw mtm x imk at xfm
rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeakw mtm n`hm9
&es+% Xfm w}djmgx n`xxmt hmregxmh ek m`gf rfaxaot rf
atrfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak9 kh
&s+% Xfm ehmkxexu ac m`gf rmtwak fa f`w rawwmwweak, g}wxahu,
at
gakxtal ac m`gf rfaxaot`rf at rfaxaot`rfeg tmrtah}gxeak+
f+ Xfm rft`wm $tml`xmw xa,$ $tml`xeko xa,$ at $ek tml`xeak xa$
nm`kw xa
gakwewx ac, tmcmt xa, tmclmgx, at dm ek `ku `u laoeg`llu,
c`gx}`llu, at lmo`llu
gakkmgxmh exf xfm n`xxmt hewg}wwmh+
e+ $@}hex Xt`el$ nm`kw ` ganrlmxm, hmx`elmh lewxeko ac m`gf `kh
msmtu
`lxmt`xeak, hmlmxeak, ekp}etu ekxa, naheceg`xeak at axfmt gf`kom
xa xfm gtmhex tmrat
85
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 5
ac 42 R`om EH':00865
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
50/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 5
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
at rtacelm `w n`ekx`ekmh ek tmgathmh catn, ek xfm dta`hmwx
wmkwm, du $ua}$+ Xfm
lewxeko wfa}lh ekgl}hm xfm ehmkxexu, `hhtmww, mnrlaumt `kh xexlm
ac xfm rmtwak&w%
x`ieko xfm `gxeak, xfm ehmkxexu, `hhtmww, mnrlaumt `kh xexlm ac
xfm rmtwak&w%
`}xfatezeko xfm `gxeak, ` hmx`elmh mvrl`k`xeak ac xfm `gxeak
x`imk, xfm h`xm ac xfm
`gxeak, xfm nm`kw }wmh xa mccmgx w}gf `gxeak, xfm lag`xeak ac
ateoek ac xfm `gxeak `kh
xfm tm`wak xfm `gxeak `w x`imk+ Xfm xmtn $`}hex xt`el$ `lwa
ekgl}hmw xfm hmcekexeak
rtasehmh cat xfm rft`wm ek xfm CmhmtD}wf, Cmhmt`l Xt`hm
Gannewweak `kh Catn`
Wx`cc Arekeak Lmxxmt, N`tgf 02, 0567+
j+ $H`x`$ nm`kw xfm rfuweg`l wundalw ek xfm dta`hmwx wmkwm
xf`
tmrtmwmkx ekcatn`xeak, tmo`thlmww ac fmxfmt xfm ekcatn`xeak ew
at`l, texxmk at
axfmtewm tmgathmh+
i+ $Ganr}xmt$ nm`kw ku kh ll rtaot`nn`dlm mlmgxtakeg hmsegmw
at
`rr`t`x}wmw, ekgl}heko f`th`tm, wacx`tm, `kh axfmt h`x`d`kiw,
xf`x g`k wxatm,
tmxtemsm, `ggmww, }rh`xm, gandekm, tm`tt`kom, rtekx, tm`h,
rtagmww at axfmtewm `lxmt
h`x` fmxfmt w}gf h`x` n`ekx`ekmh ek xf`x hmsegm at `x wanm axfmt
lag`xeak+ Xfm
xmtn $ganr}xmt$ ekgl}hmw `ku `kh `ll n`okmxeg tmgathekow at
wuwxmnw, wuwxmnw
armt`xeko ak at n`ekx`ekeko h`x` ek heoex`l, `k`lao, at fudteh
catn`x, at axfmt
nmgf`keg`l hmsegmw, at axfmt hmsegmw g`r`dlm ac n`ekx`ekeko
texekow at
tmgathekow, ac `ku iekh, ek gakhmkwmh catn`x, `kh ekgl}hmw `ku
hewi, x`rm,
=2
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 02
ac 42 R`om EH':00852
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
51/214
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
52/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 00
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
`kh `ll axfmt wekolm at asmtl`ueko rtaot`nw, `rrleg`xeakw `kh!at
wuwxmnw `kh hamw
ekgl}hm, d}x ew kax lenexmh xa xfm n`ek armt`xeko wuwxmn+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAKW:
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 0:
@hnex UA] mtm ``tm `kh `llamh Kmel W`kimu xa }wm UA]T lao ek
gtmhmkxe`lw xa `ggmww Rl`ekxeccw Rmarlm Cekhmt h`x` `kh Rmtwak`l
Ehmkxecemtw xfta}of
xfm Tmmh Hmcmkh`kxw &Tmmh Hmcmkh`kxw ekgl}hmw Tmmh Mlwmsemt,
Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew
Tewi `kh Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw Ota}r, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Tewi
Wal}xeakw, Ekg+
LmvewKmvew+gan9 LmvewKmvew, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Ota}r9 @gg}tekx,
GfaegmRaekx, Ekg+%
`kh Hmcmkh`kx Ekxmle}w, Ekg+ exfa}x `ku xurm ac rmtnewwedlm
r}trawm at lmo`
mkxexlmnmkx+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 4:
@hnex UA] f`sm `gga}kxw exf Gakce.Gfmi, ]+W+ Wm`tgf, Ekxmle}w,
Ekg+
Tmmh Mlwmsemt, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Tewi `kh Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw
Ota}r, Ekg+
LmvewKmvew Tewi Wal}xeakw, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew+gan9 LmvewKmvew,
Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew
Ota}r9 @gg}tekx, GfaegmRaekx, Ekg+%
=4
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 04
ac 42 R`om EH':00854
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
53/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 04
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 7:
@hnex UA] mtm ``tm `kh `llamh Kmel W`kimu xa }wm UA]T lao.ek
gtmhmkxe`lw `kh adx`ek Rl`ekxeccw cek`kge`l tmgathw, gtmhex
tmgathw, mnrlaunmkx
tmgathw, nmheg l tmgathw `kh axfmt tmgathw ctan Ekxmle}w, Ekg+,
Tmmh Mlwmsemt, Ekg+
LmvewKmvew Tewi `kh Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw Ota}r, Ekg+9
LmvewKmvew Tewi
Wal}xeakw, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew+gan9 LmvewKmvew, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew
Ota}r9 @gg}tekx,
`kh GfaegmRaekx, Ekg+, Ekxmle}w, Ekg+, ]+W+ Wm`tgf, IkaV,
Gakce.Gfmi, mxg+
exfa}x ` rmtnewwedlm r}trawm at `ku xurm ac lmo`l
mkxexlmnmkx+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 8:
@hnex Kmel W`kimu ew kax ` legmkwmh Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xat cat xfm
W`kimu
Cetn+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ =:
@hnex UA] `tm xfm akmt `kh armt`xat ac Xfm W`kimu Cetn, Ekg+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 3:
@hnex UA] mtm ``tm `kh `wwewxmh Kmel W`kimu ek celeko c`lwm
`llmo`xeakw
`da}x xfm Rl`ekxeccw exf Wx`xm `kh Cmhmt`l @omkgemw, ekgl}heko
rtad`xeak
hmr`txnmkxw+
=7
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 07
ac 42 R`om EH':00857
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
54/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 07
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ ?:
@hnex Kmel W`kimu }wmh UA]T accegm, UA]T xmlmrfakm k}ndmt,
UA]T
Ganr`ku, Xfm W`kimu Cetn, `kh UA]T lao.ek gtmhmkxe`lw xa adx`ek
xfm Rmarlm
Cekhmt h`x`, cek`kge`l h`x`, wm`lmh ga}tx hag}nmkxw, nmheg`l
h`x`, `kh Rmtwak`
Ehmkxecemtw ac xfm Rl`ekxeccw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 6:
@hnex UA] `ggmwwmh `kh adx`ekmh xfm Rmarlm Cekhmt h`x`,
Rmtwak`l
Ehmkxecemtw, Gtmhex Tmratxw, Cek`kge`l Tmratxw, Wm`lmh Ga}tx
Hag}nmkxw `kh axfmt
hag}nmkxw ak xfm Rl`ekxeccw, Rl`ekxeccw Wra}wmw, Rl`ekxeccw
Gfelhtmk `kh Rl`ekxeccw
C`nelu nmndmtw xfta}of Ekxmle}w, Ekg+, Tmmh Mlwmsemt, Ekg+9
LmvewKmvew Tewi `kh
Ekcatn`xeak @k`luxegw Ota}r, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Tewi Wal}xeakw,
Ekg+
LmvewKmvew+gan9 LmvewKmvew, Ekg+9 LmvewKmvew Ota}r9 @gg}tekx,
`kh GfaegmRaekx
Ekg+, Ekxmle}w, Ekg+, ]+W+ Wm`tgf, IkaV, Gakce.Gfmi, mxg+,
exfa}x `ku xurm ac
rmtnewwedlm r}trawm at lmo`l mkxexlmnmkx `kh rtasehmh Rl`ekxeccw
h`x` xa xfm axfm
Hmcmkh`kxw, ekgl}heko d}x kax lenexmh xa Kmel W`kimu
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 5:
@hnex Kmel W`kimu f`w ratxt`umh fenwmlc `w ` Rtes`xm
Eksmwxeo`xat cat Xfm
W`kimu Cetn+
=8
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 08
ac 42 R`om EH':00858
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
55/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 08
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 02:
@hnex UA] mtm ``tm Kmel W`kimu wmkx `k mn`el xa Tmratxmt Dad
]kt}f
exf _atlh Kmx H`elu, ctan xfm W`kimu Cetn, `da}x Rl`ekxecc Lew`
Ledmte xf`x
gakx`ekmh Rl`ekxecc Ledmtew c}ll Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmt, h`xm ac
detxf, wra}wmw
k`nm `kh Wage`l Wmg}texu k}ndmt `kh axfmt rtes`xm h`x`+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 00:
@hnex xfm G`lecatke` D}tm`} ac Wmg}texu `kh Eksmwxeo`xesm
Wmtsegmw tmwxtegxw
Rtes`xm Eksmwxeo`xatw ctan `ggmwweko `kh adx`ekeko `
rmtwak&w% c}ll Wage`l Wmg}texu
k}ndmt `kh axfmt rtes`xm ehmkxecueko ekcatn`xeak cat xfm r}trawm
ac r}dlewfeko xa
f`tn xfm ekheseh} l&w%+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 04:
@hnex UA] mtm ``tm `kh `llamh Kmel W`kimu xa }xelezm UA]T lao
ek
gtmhmkxe`lw `kh adx`ek ekcatn`xeak ctan xfm G`lecatke Hmr`txnmkx
ac Naxat
Smfeglmw, axfmt rmtwak&w%, `omkgemw `kh mkxexemw, ekgl}heko
xfm axfmt Hmcmkh`kxw, ak
xfm Rl`ekxeccw d`wmh ak c`lwm rtmxmkwmw+
==
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=.@O.@J_ Hag}nmkx 860.4 Celmh 27!44!04 R`om 0=
ac 42 R`om EH':0085=
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Philip J Berg Esquire Doc
481
56/214
Ledmte, mx `l Rl`ekxeccw TC@ rtara}khmh ak Xahh W`kimu 0=
0
4
7
8
=
3
?
6
5
02
00
04
07
08
0=
03
0?
06
05
42
40
44
47
48
4=
43
4?
46
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 07:
@hnex UA] f`sm gtm`xmh ettmsmtwedlm f`tn `kh h`n`omw xa
Rl`ekxeccw du
hewwmnek`xeko mttakma}w ekcatn`xeak9 xfmet Rmarlm Cekhmt H`x`
`kh xfmet Rmtwak`l
Ehmkxecemtw xa `k ennm`w}t dlm `na}kx ac rmarlm `kh
d}wekmwwmw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 08:
@hnex UA] heh kax f`sm `ku rmtnewwedlm r}trawm at lmo`l
mkxexlmnmkx xa
`ku ekcatn`xeak tmo`theko `ku ac xfm Rl`ekxeccw+
TMP]MWX CAT @HNEWWEAK KA+ 0=:
@hnex UA] `tm }k`dlm xa hmnakwxt`xm fa n`ku rmarlm f`sm
tmgmesmh
Rl`ekxeccw rtes`xm rmtwak`l ehmkxecueko ekcatn`xeak `kh
ekgattmgx ekcatn`xeak
dmg`}wm ac xfm k`x}tm ac xfm ekxmtkmx `kh xfm k}nmta}w `uw ex `w
tmrm`xmhlu
rawxmh ak xfm Ekxmtkmx `kh wmkx a}x du Hmcmkh`kx Atlu X`exz+
=3
G`wm 6:00.gs.2286=
