I

-

II

III

-

E-mail: contact@all4fairtrials.org.mk Web: www.all4fairtrials.org.mk

-

- -

-

-

IV

V

1. ..................................... 1

1.1. ........................................................................................1

1.2. ............................................... 3

2. ....... 5

2.1. ......................................................................... 5

2.2. .................................................................. 5

2.3.

............................................................... 6

2.4. .................................................................. 8

3.

.................................................................................................. 11

3.1. ............................................................................... 11

4. ............................................. 13

4.1. ............................... 13

4.2. ............................................... 16

4.3. ............................................................... 19

4.4. ...................................................................................... 21

4.5. ............................................................. 23

4.6. ............................................................ 24

4.7. ............................................................................. 29

4.8. ..... 31

5. ......................................................................... 34

5.1. ............................................................................................ 34

5.2. ............................................................................................ 35

6. ........................................................................... 36

7. ............................................ 37

VI

1

1.

1.1.

Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere Martin Luther King

9

,

,

.1

1

2011

2

.

2

.

.3

2

3

3

1.2.

,

,

- .

54 (45

.

4

.

5

2.

2.1.

.

2.2.

6

2.3.

4 5

-

4 http://justice.gov.mk/documents/IZvestaj2014.pdf 5 http://justice.gov.mk

7

21790/03)

,

, ,

. ,

.

,

( ,

-

-

.6

6

8

2.4.

.

.7

7 Zakon o varstvu pravice do sojenja brez nepotrebnega odlasanja, Uradni list RS br.49/2006

9

.

,

.8

8

10

11

3.

3.1.

54 .

,

7

4

2 2

4

12

3

1

5 5

9

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

1

278-

368-

12

,

199.

9

.

16%

84%

13

4.

-

4.1.

,

.

14

9

.10

.11

9

10 http://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Convention_MKD.pdf 11 Fair Trials Manual ,

15

7/14

,

42 12

,

2%

70%

28%

16

21 21

.

4.2.

12

.

12 Luis Lopez Guerra Iustitia

17

.

13

.

9

10 6

7

13 61/2008, 118/2008, 16/2009, 150/2010, 39/2012

18

13/12 58/14

97/13

83/14

29

4

10

1

6

13

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1

19

58/14

4.3.

14

14

20

.15

,

.

O . .7/14 ,

,

O .1/13 ,

.62/14

5

7

15

sch v. Austria, 6. maj 1985 (Application no. 8658/79)

21

4.4.

.

16

6

2

16 Fair Trials Manual,

Amnesty International Fair Trials Manual)

22

15

57/12

.86/14 ,

29/14 - ,

: , :00

.

5%

95%

4% 5%

91%

23

,

4.5.

24

- 17

7 2%

5

4.6.

97/13

.

17

.

25

4

47/14

64/14)

42

4 7

27

22

2729 28 29 29

2

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1

26

.

78%

7%

4%11%

ДА

НЕ

По службена должност

Нема податок

28%

18%

54%

27

.

53

75/14.

,

28

. 2

5 .

73/14 83/14

9%2%

41%

48%

ДА

ДА, но не веднаш

НЕ

Нема податок

29

4.7.

.

94%

6%

ДА НЕ

30

97/13

.18

, -

18

31

4.8.

.

)

.

32

ratione temporis

(

( ,

.

. .

.

,

444/14

.

,

33

,

1612/12 ,

,

34

5.

5.1.

35

5.2.

36

6.

;

-

2010;

;

;

Zakon o varstvu pravice do sojenja brez nepotrebnega odlasanja, Uradni list

RS br.49/2006 Slovenija;

Pravo na pravicno sudjenje, Zbornik radova, Pravni fakultet

244;

37

;

-

http://www.osce.org/mk;

Prof Uzelac Alan, Pravo na pravicno sudjenje u gradjanskim predmetima:

Nova praksa Europskog suda za ljudska prava I njen utjecaj na hravtsko pravo

I praksu;

Centar za

razumnom roku, Zbirka izabranih presuda Evropskog suda za ljudska prava u

protiv Bosne i Hercegovine, Hrvatske, Makedonije, Slovenije i

Srbije, Sarajevo 2009;

7.

38

17-

,

(http://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Convention_MKD.pdf