Cuaderno No. 7 Desarrollo Pensamiento Político Cruceño 2012

7/23/2019 Cuaderno No. 7 Desarrollo Pensamiento Poltico Cruceo 2012

1/13

!

!"#$%&'( $% *+#,( -(. /

0123445665 016 71-23891-*5 756:*9!5 !4;!13 ? 2;2 0123@:52

1- 63 >569A93 3;*5-B89!3

#$%&' &() *+,() - &( ./01*.( ( &() *+,() - )2) (..*'3,)

3') 4(/53 &*6/,)7 89: ;:' ;*31' ,/)*+(+ D(1%&*.( 9/,K'/*(3( +,L'M(:

H*N&'M(+' ,3 I3),O(3P( C3*>,/)*1(/*( +, &(C3*>,/)*+(+ QCLR $(31( D/2P +, &( $*,//(:

H*N&'M(+' ,3 D'3)1*12-,31, - G21'3'M0(R DF9SERD(1(&2O( 8I)N(O(= J ;/,B,.12/( +, $(31( D/2P:

$(31( D/2P +, &( $*,//(R (K')1' +, TU!T

-(C#D I)1, ,3)(-' B'/M( ,& D2(+,/3' +, V/(6(W' Q': X +, ,)1( ),/*, >*/12(& ?2, N'3,M') (& (&.(3., +, &') &,.1'/,)*31,/,)(+') ,3 .'3'.,/ ,& N,3)(M*,31' - &( .2&12/( +, &') .(M6() +,& S/*,31, 6'&*>*(3': I& 1,Y1' 6(), +, ,)1, 1/(6(W' ),

,&(6'/% N(/( +(/ 23( .'3B,/,3.*( ,& (O' TU!! (31, &') M*,M6/') +, 23 N(/1*+' ' (K/2N(.*%3 .*2+(+(3( +, $(31( D/2PR (

N,1*.*%3 +, )2) +*/*K,31,): D'M' N/'B,)*'3(& *3+,N,3+*,31,R - N'/ >,3*/ ,)12+*(3+' ,)1, 1,M( +,)+, 4(., (& M,3') 23

?2*3?2,3*'R (.,N1Z &( *3>*1(.*%3:


2/13

T

!= 6(E F&"F%G(ED E(' H# "' I"%+J( ( "' I#KE F(' F#FC%&KECLF#E F"JC"J%E I&(IL#E %' %J ELMJ( N9N

(= @') ./2.,O')R ( N'.') (O') +, B23+(/), &( .*2+(+ +, $(31( D/2P +, &( $*,//( .'M' )2 .(N*1(& +, &( K'6,/3(.*%3 ./,(+(

.'3 ,& 3'M6/, +, #N/'>*3.*( +, *//,- +, 12/3'R ,1.: I)1') ./*1,/*')

' *+,() ?2, +,W( 1/()&2.*/ +*.4( D(/1(R M2,)1/( .%M' &') ./2.,O') -( 1,30(3 +, (&K23( M(3,/( 23 ),31*+' +, K/2N'R 6(),

N(/( +,)(//'&&(/ .'3 &') )*K&') >,3*+,/') 23( .'3.*,3.*( .'&,.1*>(: I), ),31*+' +, K/2N'R .'3 &') (O') (+?2*/*/5 ,& ),31*+' +,

N2,6&'R 1(& .'M' -( ,3 &') N/*M,/') (O') +, *3*.*(/), &( >*+( /,N26&*.(3( &' +,)1(.(/53 (&K23') >*(W,/') - ,)12+*')') +, &(

ZN'.(:

I3 ,B,.1'`

6= H, &') ./2.,O') +*W' HaS/6*K3- ,3 !b^!\^T ?2, B'/M(6(3 23 #+*.4')' N(0)7R ,)1' ,)R 23 N2,6&' B,&*P .2(3+' ,)./*6*%`

c@') ./2.,O')R N'/ )2 &,3K2(W,R )2) 456*1') - &() &&(32/() 4dM,+() ?2, 4(6*1(3R ), +*B,/,3.*(3 ,3 1'+' +, &') '1/')

4(6*1(31,) e,) +,.*/ +, &') .'&&()f +, &( /,Nd6&*.( e+, E'&*>*(f::: Q(+( *K2(&( ,& ,)N0/*12 +, 4')N*1(&*+(+ ?2, (3*M( ( 23') -

'1/') e.(MN,)*3')R M,)1*P') - ./*'&&') .(M6()fR ( 1(& N231' ?2, ,& >(K(623+' ?2, ?2*,/, >*>*/ ,3 ,& '.*' ,) /,.*6*+' ,3 1'+()

N(/1,) M,),) ,31,/') - .'3)*+,/(+' .'M' +, &( .()(: I& >*(W,/' ,) /,.*6*+' (&&0 .'3 1'+() &() +,M')1/(.*'3,) N')*6&,) +,

(B,.1': $, N'3, 1'+' ,3 M'>*M*,31' N(/( (&'W(/&' 6*,3R )*3 M,P.&(/ 323.( &( M,3'/ *+,( +, .5&.2&'R N'/ ,)'R ,3 ,)1, +*.4')'

N(0) e), /,B*,/, (& N(0) ' N2,6&' ./2.,O' 4(6*1(3+' ,3 )2 1,//*1'/*'R .'3 )2 .2&12/(R .')12M6/,)R B'/M( +, >*+( N(/1*.2&(/ '

N/'N*(R ,1.: J ,& )26/(-(+' ,) 32,)1/'fR ,& (3.*(3' - ,& ,3B,/M' 323.( )'3 23( .(/K( - 3' 1*,3,3 3,.,)*+(+ +, /,.2//*/ ( &')

()*&') Nd6&*.')R +,).'3'.*+') ,3 $(31( D/2P: I& ),31*+' +, 42M(3*+(+ )2N&, ( 1'+'g 8Hh S/6*K3- !iii=:

.= ,/Kk,3P(R 3' )'3 6,6,+'/,) N,/' ,3 .(M6*' )'3 1,//*6&,) W2K(+'/,):

Q' )'3 (M*K') +,& ,)12+*'R N,/' )'3 456*&,) (K/*.2&1'/,) - ./*(+'/,) +, K(3(+'_ 1*,3,3 23 K/(3 1(&,31'R 23 /5N*+'

,31,3+*M*,31' - 23( >*>( *M(K*3(.*%3` N/'>*)1( +, 23( 62,3( B'/M(.*%3 ),/0(3 N,/)'3() .(N(.,): L,)N,.1' ( )2)

(1/*621') B0)*.') )'3 )*3 +2+( &') M,W'/,) - M5) 6,&&') 42M(3') ,3 1'+' ,& ;,/d - E'&*>*(R M2- 6&(3.')R +, 6,&&(

B*)'3'M0( - 6*,3 +,)(//'&&(+') .'M' &') N(/(K2(-')_ 3(12/(&M,31, ), ,3.2,31/( M2.4( )(3K/, *3+0K,3( ,31/,

,&&')R &( .2(& 4(., .()* &( .(31*+(+ N/,+'M*3(31,: V*,3,3 23 '+*' .'31/( 1'+' &' B'/()1,/' - ,Y1/(3W,/'R -

+,3'M*3(3 1'+' &' ?2, 3' ,) +, $(31( D/2P .'3 ,& M'1, +,)N,.1*>' +, .'&&(: D'3)1*12-, (&K' )*3K2&(/ ,3.'31/(/ ,3


3/13

^

,& *31,/*'/ +, $2+(MZ/*.(R .'/1(+( +, '1/() .*2+(+,)R 23( 1/*62 +, 4'M6/,) +, >*,W( )(3K/, ,)N(O'&(R ?2, 4(6&(

)%&' ,)N(O'&g eI& )26/(-(+' ,) 32,)1/'f 8E(.4R .(/1( +, !bjT=:

+= I& N(.,O' H(&,3P 92(/(.4* ,3 !bl! +, &') ./2.,O') (B*/M%` #1*,3,3 ,& (.,31'R ,& K,3*' - &() .')12M6/,) +, &') (3+(&2.,)`

)'3 M2- (B*.*'3(+') (& 6(*&, - ( &( ,?2*1(.*%3- 1*,3,3 23 (M'/ .*,K' ( )2 N(0) 8,)1' ,)R ( )2 1*,//( ' N2,6&'=: $*3 ,M6(/K'R

(23?2, (&,K/,) N'/ '/K(3*P(.*%3 - .')12M6/,)R &') ./2.,O') 3' 1*,3,3 +,.*)*%3 8*3.&*3(.*%3= N'/ &') &*.'/,) ,)N*/*12')')R

/(/( >,P ), >,3 4'M6/,) ,M6/*(K(+') ,3 &() .(&&,) +, $(31( D/2P: @() M2W,/,) )'3 ,)6,&1() - 6*,3 +,)(//'&&(+()_ +, N,&' -

'W') /()K(+') 3,K/')R .'3 23 .21*) 23 N'.' N5&*+'R >,)1*+() .()* )*,MN/, +, KZ3,/' 6&(3.' 1/(3)N(/,31,)R 3(+( 1*,3,3 ?2,

,3>*+*(/ ( &() 6,&&() 4*W() +,& L*M(.7: m '6),/>( 1(M6*Z3` #;'/ .(2)( +, &( 4'M'K,3,*+(+ +, )2 .*>*&*P(.*%3 - N'/ &(

+*)1/*62.*%3 .()* *K2(& +, &( /*?2,P(R ,& N2,6&' ./2.,O' ,) M5) (N1' ?2, 3*3K23' '1/' +, E'&*>*( N(/( ,& K'6*,/3'

/,N26&*.(3'_ - ,3 ,B,.1' ,3 3*3K23( N(/1, ), 4(&&( M5) (//(*K(+' ?2, (&&0 ,& N/*3.*N*' +,M'./51*.': ;'/ ,)' &') ./2.,O') )'3

+, .(/5.1,/ *3+,N,3+*,31, - (d3 23 N'.' (&1*>')7: eI& )26/(-(+' ,) 32,)1/'f: 8H(&,3) !bl! .*1: ,3 E(N1*)1( TU!U=

,= G B*3,) +,& )*K&' nFnR >*>*,3+' -( ,3 $(31*(K' +, D4*&,R 9(6/*,& L,3Z ,K(6&,) /0')R 3(+( 1*,3,3 +, .'Md3 .'3&') (&1'N,/2(3'): $2 M'+' +, ),/ N/'.,+, +, '1/') '/0K,3,)R 3' M,3') +,1,/M*3(31,) ?2, )2 )2,&' - )2 .&*M(:

;/*M,/(M,31, )2) 1/*62) K2(/(30,) 1*,3,3 &( 6(/6(/*, .'M' .(N012&' d3*.' +, )2 4*)1'/*( (31,) +,& +,).26/*M*,31': I& *3.(

&&,K% 4()1( ,& N')1/,/ M'31, ' .'&&(+'_ +*>*)% (&&5 (6(W' ,& >,/+, (P2&,W' +, &( *3M,3)*+(+ ),&>51*.( - N/(+,/')(: c@( M(/gR

+*W' - ), >'&>*% .'3 )2) 42,)1,) +, .'&&() ( &( )*,//(:g 8*(R (&K23') +, )2) M*,M6/') ' N,/)'3(W,)R >(3 ( 1,3,/R K,3,/(/

' ,YN/,)(/ *+,() N'&01*.()R ,3 23') .()')R N(/( .(M6*(/ ( E'&*>*( .'M' I)1(+'R ,3 '1/') N(/( (3(&*P(/R ./*1*.(/ - /,B&,Y*'3(/

)'6/, &( /,(&*+(+ - &( N/5.1*.( N'&01*.(R ()0 .'M' )'6/, &') *+,(&,) ' N,/)N,.1*>() ?2, Z)1( N&(31,(6( N(/( E'&*>*( - 1(M6*Z3N(/( $(31( D/2P -( +,)+, &( ),K23+( M*1(+ +,& )*K&' nFn:

T= 3O( +L%'P O#H Q"% C%'%& %' F"%'C# Q"% #JM"'#E $% J#E L$%#E H #FFL('%E I(JKCLF#E $% %EC(E F&"F%G(E R#' # $#&E% %' %J

S#&F( $% "'# S#C&LT F('F%IC"#J ( S%'C#J UC%V&LF#WP JJ#S#$# F(SX'S%'C% ( %' M%'%JP J# S($%&'L$#$ I(JKCLF#R ?2, ,3

23( +, )2) >,/1*,31,)R .'M' ,) ,& B,+,/(&*)M'R N&(31,(6( &( +,).,31/(&*P(.*%3 -o' +*)1/*62.*%3 +,& N'+,/ N'&01*.' ,)1(1(&

.2(3+' ,& I)1(+' ,)1(6( .'3B'/M(+' N'/ 23( +*>,/)*+(+ +, N2,6&') - /,K*'3,)R ,31,3+*+' .'M' &( M,W'/ B'/M( +,

N/,),/>(/ )2 *31,K/*+(+ 1,//*1'/*(& , *MN2&)(/ )2 +,)(//'&&' ' N/'K/,)' )'.*(&R ,.'3%M*.' - .2&12/(& +, M(3,/( ,?2*&*6/(+(_

,3 '1/( +, )2) >,/1*,31,)R ,)15 &( &03,( ?2,R N(/( &'K/(/ ,& N/'K/,)' - 6*,3,)1(/ +, &') N2,6&') ' 3(.*'3,) ' I)1(+') 8*+,(

*&2)1/(+( +,& )*K&' npFFF=R ), +,60( 1,3,/ 23 N'+,/ N'&01*.' ' K'6*,/3' B2,/1,M,31, .,31/(&*P(+'_ ' ),(R .'3 /,.2/)')

.'3.,31/(+') - (+M*3*)1/(+') +,)+, 23 )'&' .,31/' ,)1(1(&` ,3 ,)1, .()'R &( ),+, +,& K'6*,/3' 8&Z(), $2./, N/*M,/' - &2,K'

@( ;(P=:

I3 ,B,.1'R N(/( ,& .()' ./2.,O'R ,3 ,& N/*M,/ 1*N' +, *+,(& N'&01*.'R 23' +, &') M5) N/,.&(/') B,+,/(&*)1() B2, G3+/Z F6(O,P:

(= G3+/Z) F65O,PR (6'K(+'R 4(60( )*+' ),./,1(/*' +,& N/,B,.1' V/*)153 L'.(R .'3.,W(& +,& M23*.*N*' +, &( .*2+(+ +, $(31(

D/2P +, &( $*,//(R +*N21(+' N'/ $(31( D/2P - (6/(P(6( &( .(2)( B,+,/(&: A23+% ,& D&26 +, &') FK2(&*1(/*')R .2-') M*,M6/')

,/(3 .'3'.*+') .'M' c*K2(&*1(/*')g - ,& %/K(3' +, N/'N(K(3+( B2, 23 N,/*%+*.' &&(M(+' !" !$% &' "( )*+("&(&:


4/13

j

I3 !bX]R F65O,P ), ,3B/,31% ,3 +') '.()*'3,) .'31/( ,& K'6*,/3' +,& N'1')*3' V'M5) A/0()` &( N/*M,/( ,3 M(/P'R ,3 &(

.'3'.*+( c6(1(&&( +,& V/'MN*&&'gR ,3 &() (B2,/( +, &( .*2+(+R +'3+, B2, +,//'1(+' N'/ ,& D'M(3+(31, 9,3,/(&: I& ),K23+'R

), &&,>% ( .(6' ,3 3'>*,M6/,R ,3 &') .(MN') +, ;'/'/%)R ./2P(3+' ,& /*% 9/(3+,: Q2,>(M,31, B2, +,//'1(+' (31, &( B2,/P(

Nd6&*.( - +,6*% M(31,3,/), ,3 &( .&(3+,)1*3*+(+: I/( (.2)(+' +, .'M23*)1(: I3 B,6/,/' +, !bXlR ,& K'6*,/3' &&(M% (

,&,..*'3,) - +,./,1% &( (M3*)10( N(/( N/,)') - N,/),K2*+') N'&01*.'): I)1' N,/M*1*% ( F65O,P )(&*/ +, &( .&(3+,)1*3*+(+ -

'/K(3*P(/ 32,>(M,31, ,& D&26 FK2(&*1(/*' ?2, +,.*+*% (N'-(/ &( .(3+*+(12/( +, q*&(/*%3 H(P( N(/( &() ,&,..*'3,) K,3,/(&,)+, M(-' +,& M*)M' (O': ;,/' H(P( +*' 23 K'&N, +, ,)1(+'R .(M6*(3+' &( )*12(.*%3 N/,>*)1( ,3 $(31( D/2P - 3'M6/(3+'

.'M' N/,B,.1' ( H,M,1/*' L'.(: C3( ),/*, +, *31/*K() +,)(./,+*1(/'3 ( F65O,P B/,31, (& N/,)*+,31, +*.1(+'/ H(P( - ,& Ti +,

(K')1'R B2, 1'M(+' N/,)' 6(W' ,& W2)1*B*.(1*>'` cN(/( ),K2/*+(+ +,& +,N(/1(M,31'g:

I& ! +, '.126/, +, !bXlR ), /,6,&% &( D'&2M3( +,& S/+,3R ,Y*K*,3+' ,& N(K' +, )(&(/*') (+,2+(+') N'/ >(/*') M,),): I)1,

*3.*+,31, (*)&(+' B2, ,& *3*.*' +, &( /,>'&2.*%3 +, F65O,PR ?2, ), ,3.'31/(6( N/,)': @( 1/'N( /,6,&+, +,)'6,+,.*% ( &(

(21'/*+(+ - ,3 ,& ,3B/,31(M*,31' M2/*% ,& D'M(3+(31, 9,3,/(& FK3(.*' L'M,/': I& T +, '.126/, &*6,/(/'3 ( F65O,P ,3 23(

.'3.,31/(.*%3 N'N2&(/ +,3'M*3(+( D'M*)*%3 ;'N2&(/R +'3+, ), +,&*6,/% )'6/, &') )2.,)') (.(,.*+') - ), N/'.&(M% ,& G.1(

+,& ;2,6&'R B*/M(+( N'/ M5) +, XT] N,/)'3():

I& G.1( +,& ;2,6&' 3'M6/% ( F65O,P N/,B,.1' - .'M(3+(31, K,3,/(& +,& +,N(/1(M,31': F65O,P N,/M(3,.*% ,3 ,)1, .(/K': m

,& T! +, +*.*,M6/, +, !bXlR ./,% ,& D&26 A,+,/(&*)1( .'3 ,& '6W,1*>' +, N/'.&(M(/ &( A,+,/(.*%3R .'M' ,B,.1*>(M,31, &' 4*P',& +0( +, Q(>*+(+ +,& M*)M' (O':

I& (O' !bXX B2, ,& *3*.*' +, &( N/'N(K(.*%3 +, &() *+,() B,+,/(&*)1() N'/ &() N/'>*3.*() +,& +,N(/1(M,31': @( N/'.&(M(.*%3 +,

&( B,+,/(.*%3 - &() (..*'3,) +, &( r231( $2N,/*'/ +,& I)1(+' A,+,/(1*>' S/*,31(& N/'>'.(/'3 ?2, ,& K'6*,/3' +*.1(1'/*(& +,

H(P( ,3>*(/( (& M*3*)1/' +, 92,//( W231' ( ]UU )'&+(+')R B'/M(3+' &( H*>*)*%3 ;(.*B*.(+'/( +,& S/*,31,R N(/( /,N/*M*/ ( &')

B,+,/(&*)1() ./2.,O'): G)0 ), *3*.*% 23( 32,>( N,/),.2.*%3 ( F65O,P - ( &') FK2(&*1(/*') ?2, ), 4(&&(6(3 ,3 D4*?2*1'):

A*3(&M,31,R ,& ^U +, (6/*&R (&.(3P(/'3 ( F65O,P - )2) 4'M6/,) ,3 $(3 H*,K'R ,)1(3.*( 26*.(+( ( T] sM): +, &( B/'31,/( .'3

E/()*& - ,& ! +, M(-' +, !bXX B2,/'3 ,W,.21(+'): H, ,)1( B'/M( 1,/M*3% ,& N/*M,/ *31,31' ),/*'R N&(3*B*.(+' - '/K(3*P(+'

N(/( N/'.&(M(/ &( B,+,/(&*P(.*%3 +, $(31( D/2P - +, 1'+( E'&*>*(: S ),(R N(/( .(M6*(/ &( ,)1/2.12/( .,31/(&*)1( +,& I)1(+' N'/

23( +,).,31/(&*P(.*%3 (+M*3*)1/(1*>(R B*3(3.*,/(R W2/0+*.( - N'&01*.(R (.'/+, ( &( /,(&*+(+ K,'K/5B*.(R 4*)1%/*.(R Z13*.( -

.2&12/(& +, E'&*>*(: @( *+,( B,+,/(&*)1( N(/( ,), ,31'3.,) -( ,/( .'Md3 (& ./2.,O' +, N')*.*%3 (&1( - 6(W(:

6= I& ),K23+' &,>(31(M*,31' ,3 N/'.2/( +, &( B,+,/(&*P(.*%3 +, $(31( D/2P - E'&*>*( ), /,(&*P% ,3 ,3,/' +, !bi! .'3 ,&

3'M6/, +, &( #L,>'&2.*%3 +, &') H'M*3K')7: I& 3'M6/, +,& &,>(31(M*,31' ), +,6, ( ?2, ,& M*)M' ), *3*.*% 23 +'M*3K' T

+, ,3,/' +, !bi! - B2, &*+,/(+' N'/ &') .'/'3,&,) 8./2.,O')= H'M*3K' G/+(-( - r')Z H'M*3K' t>*&(R (N'-(+') N'/ &(

D'&2M3( +,& S/+,3:

@( /,>2,&1( &&,>% ( &( N/'.&(M(.*%3 +, &( B,+,/(.*%3 +, $(31( D/2P - +, 23( r231( 926,/3(1*>( A,+,/(& +,& S/*,31, ?2, ),

,3.(/K(/0( +, '/K(3*P(/ ,& I)1(+' A,+,/(& +,& S/*,31,: @() N/*M,/() (..*'3,) ,)12>*,/'3 '/*,31(+() ( ./,(/ ,& E(3.' A,+,/(&R

*MN/*M*,3+' 6*&&,1,) +, .2/)' B'/P')' - ),K2*+(M,31, &( B'/M(.*%3 +,& IWZ/.*1' A,+,/(&R .'3 &( ./,(.*%3 +, 23( 92(/+*(

Q(.*'3(& - ,& ,WZ/.*1' .'3 23 6(1(&&%3 +, *3B(31,/0(R 1/,) /,K*M*,31') +, .(6(&&,/0( - 23( 6/*K(+( +, (/1*&&,/0(:

H*.4( W231( ,MN,P% &( N/'.&(M(.*%3 +, &( B,+,/(.*%3 +, 1'+() &() N/'>*3.*() +,& +,N(/1(M,31' ./2.,O'R ,3.'31/(3+' ,&

(N'-' +, D4*?2*1') - D'/+*&&,/(: @() .'3)*K3() ,/(3 cA,+,/(.*%3 ' ( &( A,+,/(.*%3g: I& N/,B,.1' q'/(.*' L0')R

42-% ( $(M(*N(1( - +,)+, (&&0 N*+*% (-2+( (& K'6*,/3' 6'&*>*(3' +, G3*.,1' G/., N(/( /,N/*M*/ &( /,>2,&1(: I& K'6*,/3' ,3>*%

23 .'31*3K,31, M*&*1(/ - 23( D'M*)*%3 ;(.*B*.(+'/( +,& S/*,31, - ,& TU +, B,6/,/' ,31/(/'3 ( &( .*2+(+: @') B,+,/(&*)1() ),

+*)N,/)(/'3 ,3 +*>,/)() +*/,..*'3,)R 4(6*Z3+'), *+' &( M(-'/ N(/1, +, ,&&') 4(.*( D4*?2*1'): @( D'M*)*%3 ;(.*B*.(+'/( +,&

S/*,31, ), M(312>' ,3 $(31( D/2P 4()1( W23*' +, ,), (O' .2(3+' +,12>' ( 1'+') &') 8.'M' ,/(3 &&(M(+') - 4(3 )*+'


5/13

]

1*&+(+') &') ./2.,O') N'/ &') K'6*,/3') (3+*3') +,)+, ?2, 4(3 62).(+' ,& .(M6*' +, &() ,)1/2.12/() +,& I)1(+'= cB(..*')')R

+,&*3.2,31,) /,>'&1')')R ),+*.*')') - B2K*1*>')gR ?2, N()(/'3 ( &( W2)1*.*( '/+*3(/*(:

@( /,>2,&1( +, &') H'M*3K') B2, /,N/*M*+( - .'3 ,&&( &') d&1*M') *31,31') +, &'K/(/ &( B,+,/(.*%3 N'/ &( >0( >*'&,31(: G N(/1*/

+, ,)( +,//'1(R &') ./2.,O') +,)(//'&&(/0(3 32,>() M(3,/() +, ,3B/,31(/ ,& .,31/(&*)M' +,& I)1(+' 6'&*>*(3' ,3 ,& )*K&' nn -

( *3*.*') +,& )*K&' nnF .'3 &( +,M(3+( +, &( G21'3'M0( H,N(/1(M,31(&:

^= 2L #Q"%JJ#E Y"%&(' #FFL('%E I(JKCLF#E $% O%FO( I# %ZLML& J# Y%$%JLT#FLV' $% >(JLRL#P F('RL&CL%'$( # 2#'C# !&"T %' "'

1EC#$( Y%$%JP %' %J F#SI( $% J#E L$%#EP # YL'%E $%J ELMJ( N9NP #JM"'(E I%'E#$(&%E F&"F%G(E %ZI"EL%&(' (CE L$%#E

I(JKCLF#E %' %J S#&F( $% J# S($%&'L$#$ F"JC"J (FFL$%'C#J %"&(I%#.

G)0`

(= V(& ,& .()' +, (/*() >,.,) ,3 )2 &*6/' c@( /(P%3 23*>,/)(&g 8!bib=` cvQ'

N'+/5 )2.,+,/ ?2, 23 H*') N'+,/')' - M(&*K3' 12>*,), ,& N&(.,/ +, ,3K(O(/3')R /,>*)1*,3+' ,& ,//'/ ( 32,)1/') 'W') .'3(N(/*,3.*( +, .,/1*+2M6/, - +, ,>*+,3.*(wg:

$, N/,K231(6(R 3' )*3 (3K2)1*(R )* +,1/5) +,& '/+,3 (N(/,31, +, &( 3(12/(&,P( 4(60( 23 >,/+(+,/' '/+,3R ' )* N'/ ,&

.'31/(/*'R ,& M23+' ,3 >,P +, ),/ 1'+' '/+,3(+' - /(.*'3(& ,/( 23( /,(&*+(+ ,3 ?2, /,*3(6(3 >'&231(+,) (/6*1/(/*() -

.(N/*.4')(): Q' 4(- ?2, '&>*+(/ ?2, N(/( H,).(/1,) ,& M23+' 1,30( 23 '/+,3 M,.53*.'R .2-() &,-,) 3(12/(&,) H*') &()

4(60( N2,)1' ,3 ,& M*)M': ;,/' ),K2/(M,31,R ,& >,/ .(M6*') - B,3%M,3') 3(12/(&,) .(N/*.4')') ,3 ,& M23+'R &&,>(/'3 (

S-'&( ( +2+(/ +, ,), )2N2,)1' '/+,3 3(12/(&:

x I3 &' N'&01*.'R B2, &*6,/(&: m )2 &*6,/(&*)M' &' 1/(1% +, )2)1,31(/ ,3 &( B*&')'B0( .(/1,)*(3(: I)1' ,)R S-'&( N/'B,)(6( 23

&*6,/(&*)M' 3' 6()(+' ,3 &( >'&231(+ .'M' N/*3.*N*' +, &( W2)1*.*(R N'/?2, &( >'&231(+ +, &() M(-'/0()R )*3 .'3'.,/ M5)

B/,3' ?2, )2) N()*'3,)R ,W,/., 1*/(30( +, N,'/ .(/5.1,/ ?2, ,& +,)N'1*)M' +,& )(6&,R )*3' ,3 &( /(P%3R ?2, (+M*1, &( /,(&*+(+

+, 23 ),/ *3B*3*1' - (6)'&21' 8H*')= .'M' '/*K,3 +, 1'+') &') N/*3.*N*') ,1,/3'): I3 )2 (/10.2&' N26&*.(+' ,3 !bbXR ,3 23+*(/*' +, $(31( D/2P +, &( $*,//(R +,.0( (& /,)N,.1'`

cQ' N(/1*.*N' +, ,)( ,)N,.*, +, &*6,/(&*)M' ?2, 4(., &( )*MN&, >'&231(+ ,& N/*3.*N*' +, &( W2)1*.*(_ N'/?2, &(

>'&231(+ +, &() M(-'/0()R )*3 .'3'.,/ M5) B/,3' ?2, )2) N()*'3,)R ,W,/., 1*/(30( +, N,'/ .(/5.1,/ ?2, ,&

+,)N'1*)M' +,& )(6&,R ?2, 1(MN'.' /,.'3'., '1/( /,K&( ?2, )2 >'&231(+ )'6,/(3(: I& &*6,/(&*)M' /(.*'3(& 4(

B23+(+' &() *3)1*12.*'3,) N'&01*.()R )'6/, 6(),) N,/M(3,31,)R /,.'3'., - N/'.&(M( 23 '/+,3 )2N,/*'/ ( &') N'+,/,)

42M(3')R N'/?2, (+M*1, &( )(3( +'.1/*3( +, &( /(P%3_ ,MN,/'R ,)') N/*3.*N*') 23*>,/)(&,) 3' &') /,&(.*'3( ( &(

>,/+(+ )2N/,M( /,+2.*Z3+'&') ( 3,.,)*+(+,) N)*.'&%K*.() +,& ,)N0/*12: I& &*6,/(&*)M' /(.*'3(& - ( &( >,P '31'&%K*.'

?2, (+M*1,R .'3 .,/1*+2M6/, &( /,(&*+(+ +,& $,/ *3B*3*1' - (6)'&21' .'M' '/*K,3 +, &') N/*3.*N*') ,1,/3')R ,) ,& ?2,

4( 1'M(+' (//(*K' ,3 M* .'3.*,3.*(` 1(& ,) &( +'.1/*3( &*6,/(& ?2, N/'B,)'g 8S-'&( ,3 A/(3.'>*.4R !iibR N: T!U=:

x V(M6*Z3 N(/( S-'&( ,& N(31,0)M' *+,(&*)1( +, q,K,& ,/( N,/3*.*')' - +,)'&(+'/: I), N(31,0)M' ), +,)N/,3+0( +,&

s(31*)M': @( +'.1/*3( +, &( /(P%3 N2/( ,3.*,//( ,& K,/M,3 +,& N(31,0)M' 4,K,&*(3': I)1, N(31,0)M'R ),Kd3 S-'&(R .'3+2.0(

(& (1,0)M'R N2,) 4(.0( +, H*') 23( *+,( N2/(M,31, &%K*.(: ;'/ ,3+,R &( /,(&*+(+ N(/( q,K,& ,/( N2/( *&2)*%3: c@') ),/,)

B*3*1') 3' )'3 M5) ?2, )'M6/() >(3()R M'+') N()(W,/') +, &( >*+( *3B*3*1(gR +*W' S-'&(:


6/13

l

x I), N(31,0)M' 4,K,&*(3' 1,30( .'3),.2,3.*() N'&01*.()R ),Kd3 S-'&(: ;2,)R 4(.0( +,)(N(/,.,/ &( &*6,/1(+ - +,)1/20( &(

N,/)'3(&*+(+ *3+*>*+2(&: G N(/1*/ +, ,), N(31,0)M' ,& cI)1(+' ,) &( *+,( +*>*3( /,(&*P(+( .'M' M23+' )'.*(&_ ,) &( )2)1(3.*(

+, 1'+') &') ,)N0/*12) - +, 1'+() &() ,Y*)1,3.*()_ ,) 3(+(` &( )2M( &%K*.( +, 1'+') &') ,)N0/*12)R ?2, ( )2 >,P 3' )'3 )*3'

(..*+,31,)R M'+') N()(W,/') ?2, ), N*,/+,3 ,3 ,& '.Z(3' +, &( >*+( 23*>,/)(&R ,) +,.*/R ,3 &( *+,( +, &() *+,() +, q,K,&g: I)

.*,/1'R ,& 4,K,&*(3*)M' ,) +, (&K23( M(3,/(R ,3 )2 *3B&2,3.*( N'&01*.( M'+,/3(R ,& /,)N'3)(6&, +, &( (6)'&21*P(.*%3 +,&

I)1(+'R ,), M'3)1/2' *3)1*12.*'3(& +, &( M'+,/3*+(+ ?2, ), N'3, N'/ ,3.*3( +,& )2W,1' &*6/,R 4()1( ,& N231' +, ?2, ), ,/*K,N'/ ,3.*M( +, &( M*)M( )'.*,+(+R ?2,+(3+' ,& 4'M6/, /,+2.*+' ( M,/' '6W,1'R .')( ' *3)1/2M,31' 21*&*P(6&, N'/ &') ?2,

,)153 ,3 ,& N'+,/ ,)1(1(& +, 12/3': I)( ./01*.( ' >*)*%3 +, S-'&( &( 1,3+/0(M') ?2, ),K2*/ .'3)*+,/(3+' ,3 &( 6d)?2,+( +,

23( >,/+(+,/( (21'3'M0( +,N(/1(M,31(&: ;2,)R Z)1( 1*,3, ?2, .'3)1*120/),&( +, 1(& M(3,/( ?2, ,& *3+*>*+2' ),( M5)

*MN'/1(31, ,3 )2 )26W,1*>*+(+ - +,/,.4') ?2, .2(&?2*,/ *3)1*12.*%3 Nd6&*.( ' ,)1(1(&:

x I)1' d&1*M' 1*,3, /,&(.*%3 &%K*.( .'3 &' ?2, S-'&( +*W' +,& )'.*(&*)M': p*3.2&53+'&' .'3 ,& 4,K,&*(3*)M'R +*W' +,&

)'.*(&*)M' )(M)*M'3*(3' 83' .'3'.0( ,& )'.*(&*)M' M(/Y*)1(=R ?2, &') N/*3.*N*') /,>'&2.*'3(/*') +, Z)1')R ()N*/(6(3 (

)2N/*M*/ &( &*6,/1(+ *3+*>*+2(&R &( N/'N*,+(+R &( B(M*&*(R ' ),(R 1'+' &' ?2, N'+0( ),/ N,/)'3(&R N(/( (6)'/6,/&' 1'+' ,3 ,&

I)1(+': G23?2, S-'&( 3' &&,K% ( .'3'.,/ ,& N,3)(M*,31' +, ( (& )'.*(&*)M' )2N2,)1(M,31, c.*,310B*.'g +, *( ), 4(6&( - +,B*,3+, ,& c)'.*(&*)M' +,& )*K&' nnFg` 23

N/'-,.1' +, )'.*,+(+ d3*.'R ?2, )2,3( ( 1'1(&*1(/*)M'R *31'&,/(3.*(R 4,K,M'3*P(.*%3 +,& N'+,/ N'&01*.' N'/ 23 )'&' ),.1'/

)'.*(& ' 23( ,13*( 84'- &( (*M(/( ' )2) +,)+,3.*,31,)\ ,)1, (O' 9(/.0( @*3,/( )')12>' ?2, &') (*M(/() )'3 ,& )2W,1' +, &(

4*)1'/*( ,3 E'&*>*(=R N,/),.2.*%3 W2+*.*(& +, &( ./01*.( 1*&+53+'&( +, c+,)(.(1' ( &( (21'/*+(+gR ,1.: Q'y$* &( 4*)1'/*( N(/,.,

?2, +'6&( &( ,)?2*3( - /,1'/3( (& N231' +, N(/1*+(: G >,.,) ,) .0.&*.( .'M' N,3)% Q*,1P).4,: ;,/' 3' 1*,3, N'/ ?2Z ),/ ()0:

;2,)R &( >'&231(+ +, &') 4'M6/,)R .'M' &( +, &') ./2.,O') ' .(M6()R ,) '31'&%K*.(M,31, &*6/,: m 3' 1*,3, N'/ ?2Z ),/

.0.&*.(: Q' 4(- ,1,/3' /,1'/3': Q*3Kd3 /,1'/3' ,) ,1,/3' ,3 &( >'&231(+R .'3.*,3.*( - &*6,/1(+ 42M(3( ' +, &') ./2.,O'):

6= @2,K'R ,3 ,& M(/.' +, &() *+,() N'&01*.() +,& 3(.*'3(&*)M' +,.*M'3%3*.' ,2/'N,'R .'N*(+' ,3 &') I)1(+')

&(1*3'(M,/*.(3') N'/ &') *31,&,.12(&,) +, 12/3'R >(/*') +, ,&&') +, B'/M(.*%3 (6'K(+')R (N(/,.,/53 23 .'3W231' +, *+,()

N'&01*.() .'M6*3(+() .'3 *+,() Z13*.() - ,.'3%M*.()R ,YN/,)(+() ,3 ,& .'3'.*+' *( ),( 23(

3(.*%3R .'3&&,>( &( 1,3+,3.*( ( ,31,3+,/ *31,K/(.*%3 .'M' )*3%3*M' +, #()*M*3(.*%37R ,)1' ,)R &') ./2.,O') (& N(/,.,/

,)1(6(3 +*)N2,)1') ( ()*M*&(/&,R ,3 3'M6/, +, &( *+,( +, 23( 3(.*%3 d3*.( - 4'M'KZ3,(R 1(& .'M' &' N&(31,(6( ,&

3(.*'3(&*)M' N'&01*.' +,& )*K&' nFnR ( &( 3(.*%3 ' I)1(+' )*K3(+' N'/ &' (3+*3'R )*3 *MN'/1(/&,) ,& .')1' 4*)1%/*.'R )'.*(& -.2&12/(& ?2, *MN&*.(/0( N(/( &') ./2.,O') .'M' N2,6&' ' )'.*,+(+ +*B,/,3.*(+( +,31/' +, E'&*>*(:

.= I3 ,& M(/.' +, ,)1, 3(.*'3(&*)M' *31,K/(.*'3*)1(R 6'//(+'/ +, +*B,/,3.*() .2&12/(&,) - Z13*.()R - N'/ 1(31'R

4'M'K,3*P(+'/ +,)+, ,& N231' +, >*)1( .2&12/(&R )'.*(& - N'&01*.'R .'3 23 I)1(+' B2,/1,M,31, .,31/(&*P(+'R N/,+*.(+'/ +, &'

?2, ), &&(M( 1(M6*Z3 ,& #3(.*'3(&*)M' ,)1(1(&*)1(7R (N(/,.,/5 '1/' (O(+*+' M5) ,3 ,& N,3)(M*,31' N'&01*.' ./2.,O' +, &(

N/*M,/( M*1(+ +,& )*K&' nn` ,) ,& N,3)(M*,31' +,)(//'&&*)1(R ,& .2(& 4(., ,31,3+,/ &( N,/)*)1,3.*( +, (&K23') K/2N') N'&01*.')


7/13

X

- +, *31,&,.12(&,)R ,3 &( +,M(3+( +, &() /,K(&0() +,& FFz .'3 1'+() &() .'3),.2,3.*() 3,K(1*>() N(/( >(/*() B(M*&*() ./2.,O()

+, &( ZN'.( .'M' B2, ,& ,Y*&*' +, &0+,/,) ./2.,O')_ +,M(3+( ?2, N(/( .'3),K2*/), ' (//(3.5/),&( (& N'+,/ .,31/(&*P(+'R

12>' ?2, .'31(/ .'3 &( B2,/P( +,& ),.1'/ )'.*(& .(M6(R )'6/, 1'+' +,& M,)1*P' ,MN'6/,.*+'R +, ,)( N&,6, ./2.,O( +, &( .2(&

4(6&(6( 9(6/*,& L,3Z *)1( Z13*.' 3' ), +*B,/,3.*(6( M2.4' +, &')

./*'&&') ./2.,O')R N,/' ?2, +,)+, ,& N231' +, >*)1( )'.*'\,.'3%M*.' {)2B/0( ' N(+,.0( M5) &') ,B,.1') +,& )26+,)(//'&&'

)'.*(& - M(1,/*(& +, $(31( D/2P: @( &2.4( B2, *3.&(2+*.(6&,R 4()1( ,& N231' ?2, ,& M*)M' N(.,O' |3P(K( +, &( p,K(R &&,K%(+M*/(/ ,), ,)N0/*12 .'M6(1*>'R &*6/, - +,M'./51*.' +,& N2,6&' ./2.,O' ,3 &') (O') ]U +,& )*K&' nn:

j= 1E %E% '#FL('#JLES( L'C%MFL('LEC#=$%E#&&(JJLEC#%J Q"% O#&[ Q"% S"FO(E F&"F%G(EP %'C&% OLEC(&L#$(&%EP #+(M#$(E H $%

C($# K'$(J% E(FL#J H F"JC"JP E% E"S%' %J I&(H%FC( \'#FL('#JLEC# &%R(J"FL('#&L(] $%J 84- $%E$% ^_`a O#FL# #$%J#'C% : I3

3'M6/, +, ./,(/ 23 I)1(+' ' 23( 3(.*%3 6'&*>*(3( M'+,/3'R (&K23') ./2.,O')R M*&*1(31,) +, (?2,& N(/1*+'R 3' +2+(/'3 ,3

.'M,1,/ (62)') .'31/( )2 M*)M' N2,6&' ' .'31/( B(M*&*() +, ,)1, N2,6&' ./2.,O': D'3'.*+') N'&01*.') ,M,3,//*)1()

./2.,O')R ,3 3'M6/, +, (&K23') *+,(&,) N'&01*.') ),)K(+') ' M(&*31,3.*'3(+')R .'M' ,& +, #/,>'&2.*%3 3(.*'3(&7R #I)1(+'

M'+,/3'7R #3(.*%3 6'&*>*(3(7 8d3*.( - M'3'.2&12/(&R )*K3(+( ,3 1'+' .()' N'/ &' (3+*3' - N'/ &( *+,( +, ?2, &( .2&12/(

(3+*3( *3.(*.( ,/( )2N,/*'/ ( &() '1/() .2&12/() +, E'&*>*(=R #32,>( 62/K2,)0( 6'&*>*(3(7R ,1.:R ), )2M(/53 ( (.12(/

N'&01*.(M,31, 1(M6*Z3 ,3 .'31/( +, &') M*)M') ./2.,O'): G& B*3 - (& .(6'R 1'+() ,)() *+,() N'&01*.() +, &( M'+,/3*+(+

M,/.(31*&*)1( ' .(N*1(&*)1(R .(&(/53 ,3 &( M,31( -R N'/ 1(31'R ,& (..*'3(/ +, M2.4') ./2.,O'):

`W 1E %' %EC% F('C%ZC( I(JKCLF(=L$%(JVMLF( Q"% O#H Q"% %'C%'$%& J# $LY%&%'FL#E %'C&% J#E Y(&S#E $% I%'E#& H %'C%'$%&

>(JLRL# H J# $%S(FFL#R +, +') N,3)(+'/,)` 23' ,& +, &( P'3( (3+*3(R N(.,O'R r')Z G: G/., - ,& '1/'R ./2.,O'R *( 1,3+/0( )2) /(0.,) 3' )%&' ,3 ,& V*(42(3(.2R c)*3'

1(M6*Z3 ,3 &() 4,/,3.*() 3(1*>() +, ' ),31*+'g 8;Z/,P A:R !iiUR N: Ti=: G },MNBB &,) N/,'.2N(6(3 &') N/'6&,M() +,

E'&*>*(R N,/' M5) &') N/'6&,M() ./2.,O')R ,M,/K,31,) +,& ),.2&(/ (6(3+'3' M(1,/*(& - ,)N*/*12(& +, )2 N2,6&'R ,3 ,)1,.()'R ,& N2,6&' ./2.,O': I)1'R ,- *.:R ), /,B&,W( ,3 )2 (/10.2&' )'6/, cI& ./2.,O' - &() 4(M(.()g: I3 ,)1, 1,Y1' N*,3)( ?2,

(31,) +, ?2, &( M'+,/3*+(+ &&,K2, ( $(31( D/2PR &') ./2.,O') ), ,.4(6(3 ,3 )2) 4(M(.() N(/( ,)N,/(/ ' )'O(/ ,3 ,&

N/'K/,)' ' B212/': G4'/( ?2, ,)' &&,K% - ?2, ,& 1/(6(W' - &( >*+( ), 4(.,3 M5) +*B0.*&,)R &') ./2.,O') 2)(3 &( 4(M(.( N(/(

+,).(3)(/ +,)N2Z) +, 23( (K'1(+'/( W'/3(+( +, 1/(6(W': I3 )2) N(&(6/()` cy,& ./2.,O'R +2/(31, M5) +, 23( .,312/*(R ), 4(

'.2N(+' +, &,>*1(/: I& *3)1/2M,31' M5K*.' &' 1,30( ( &( M(3'` &( 4(M(.(: 8y= m )* &( 4(M(.( +( ),/,3*+(+ (& 53*M'R ,)

N'/?2, (& M*)M' 1*,MN' (>*>( ,& N,3)(M*,31'` 3' ,3 >(3' H,).(/1,) 3') .2,31( ?2, (.')12M6/(6( ( /,.')1(/), N(/(

N,3)(/ M,W'/: 8y= mR K/(.*() ( )2 >*/12+ +, ),/,3(/ ,& 53*M'R &( 4(M(.( &, .'3.,+*% (& ./2.,O' ,& *3>(&'/(6&, +'3 +, )(6,/

,)N,/(/: @( ,)N,/( &, +2/% .,/.( +, .*,31' .*3.2,31( (O'):g q'-R .'3 ,& +,)(//'&&' 2/6(3' - ,& N/'K/,)' ?2, &&,K( ( $(31(

D/2PR c,& ./2.,O' -( 3' ?2*,/, ),/ M5) ,& B212/': *,W( 4(M(.( .'M' )*,MN/,R &' ),K2*/5 (.'MN(O(3+': ;,/' ,& NZ3+2&' +, )2 M'>*M*,31' -( 3' ), 1/(+2.*/5 ,3 *3.(&M(6&,)4'/() +, ,)N,/(R .'M' )2.,+*% 4()1( (-,/: p'&>*,3+' ( )2 (31*K2' 2)' K2(/(301*.'R ,& ?2*W5 8&( 4(M(.(= ),/5 &( M,W'/

,YN/,)*%3 +, )2 (.1*>*+(+ - ,)B2,/P': I& 4(M(.(/), N(/( +,).(3)(/ )26)1*12*/5 (& 4(M(.(/), N(/( ,)N,/(/: H') (.1*12+,) ?2,

/,.'K,3 &( +*B,/,3.*( /(+*.(& ,31/, +') B'/M() 'N2,)1() +, >*+(` +, 23( &(+' &( >*+( ?2, ), +,B*3, ,3 1Z/M*3') +, +*35M*.(

- +, N/'K/,)'_ +,& '1/'R &( >*+( N(/(&*P(+( ?2, 3' 4(., )*3' /,N,1*/), ( )* M*)M(:::I& ./2.,O'y8/=,323.*% ( )'O(/ ,3 &()

B(31()0() 21%N*.() .'3 &() ?2, ), (+'/M,.*,/( ,3 )2 4(M(.( B212/*)1(R - +, 23 N()' ), N2)' ,3 N*,: m( 3' >'&>,/5 (

(.')1(/), M5) ,3 ,&&( N(/( ,)N,/(/gR &' 4(/5 N(/( +,).(3(/ 1(M6*Z3 +,)N2Z) +,& 1/(6(W': 8},MNBB TUUjR N: bXT\bX]=:


8/13

b

H, )2 ./01*.( - +*).2)*%3 .'3 ,& )'.*%&'K' M(/Y*)1( N(.,O' r')Z G31'3*' G/P,R ), N2,+, +,)1(.(/ ?2, },MNBB 3' ), +,B*30(

(31*M(/Y*)1(R N'/?2, 3' ,)1(6( +, (.2,/+' .'3 &') c(31*gR )*3' ?2, )*MN&,M,31, 3' ,/( M(/Y*)1( 3* )'.*(&*)1(R N'/?2, ,)1()

*+,() N/,+*.(6(3 ,& (1,*)M'R &( N/*M(.0( +, &( M(1,/*( N'/ ,3.*M( +, &' ,)N*/*12(& - N'/?2, },MNBB ,/( .(1%&*.( -

+,M'./51*.( ./*)1*(3': u& N,3)(6( ?2, ,& cB*&%)'B' 1*,3, 23( M*)*%3 ?2, .2MN&*/R ,)1( ,) &( +, N/'.2/(/ ,& M5) (6)'&21'

/,)N,.1' ( &( N,/)'3(&*+(+ 42M(3(R +,B,3+,/ (& 4'M6/, .'M' N,/)'3( - ,>*1(/ ?2, ),( 1'M(+' .'M' 23 )*MN&, M,+*'

N(/( &( N/'),.2.*%3 +, *+,(&,) N'&01*.')g 8;Z/,P A: !iiUR N: ]!=_ (&K' ?2, ,& M(/Y*)M'R M2- &*K(+' (& B().*)M'R 3' 4(.0(R(31,) 6*,3R .'3)*+,/(6( (& ),/ 42M(3' .'M' 23 )*MN&, *3)1/2M,31'R )*3 +,/,.4')R 23( M,/( M(1,/*(R N(/( .'3)1/2*/ 23(

)'.*,+(+ )'.*(&*)1( ' .'M23*)1( 'N/,)'/( - 3,K(+'/( +, &( &*6,/1(+ - +, &( +*M,3)*%3 '31'&%K*.( /,&*K*')( +,& ),/ 42M(3':

V(31') &() *+,() N'&01*.() +, S-'&( D2Z&&(/ .'M' &() +, },MNBB *+( .'&,.1*>*)1( - (-&&*)1( 8.'M23*1(/*)1(

.'M' ), &, &&(M( 4'-R (&K' ?2, ), 3') ?2*,/, *MN'3,/ ( &') N2,6&') ' 3(.*'3,) .(M6() +,& S/*,31, 6'&*>*(3'=:

;*,3)' ?2, ,3 ,& S/*,31, 6'&*>*(3'R *3.&2)' 4()1( N'/ 4,/,3.*( , *3B&2,3.*( +, &') N2,6&') ' .2&12/() *3+0K,3() .(M6()R323.( ), (6/(P(/5 .'3 ,312)*()M' &( *+,( ' ,& N/'-,.1'R M,31*/')' , *//,(& N(/( M0R +, .'3)1/2*/ 23( )'.*,+(+ )'.*(&*)1( '

.'M23*)1(: ;'/ )* (&K23' ,)15 N,3)(3+' ?2, &() M*)*'3,) W,)201*.() +, *+( ./*)1*(3( ?2, *31,31(/'3 4(.,/ /,(&*+(+ ,& M,3)(W, +, &') I>(3K,&*')R

(&K' ?2, 3(+( 12>' ?2, >,/ .'3 ,& (1,0)M' ?2, N/,+*.(3 &') )'.*(&*)1() ' .'M23*)1() +,& )*K&' nnF:

l= 6"%M( RL%'% "' I%&L($( $% $LFC#$"E SLJLC#&%EP #I(H#$#E I(& I#&CL$(E I(JKCLF(EP Q"% O#&[ Q"% J(E F&"F%G(E #$(IC%'

I(EC"E S[E IMS[CLF#EP #I(H#'$( ( F('CI('Lb'$(E% #J $LFC#$(& $% C"&'(` G E(3P,/ ,3 )2 K'6*,/3' +, B(.1' - &2,K' (

'1/'):

I3 ,), N,/*'+'R 3' )2/K,3 ./2.,O') &*6/,N,3)(+'/,) ,3 &( N'&01*.(: GN(/,.,3 )0R &') M5) +,M%./(1() ?2, >(3 ( .'M,3P(/ (

+,M(3+(/ +,M'./(.*( - +,).,31/(&*P(.*%3R +,)N2Z) +, &( .(0+( +, &( +*.1(+2/( +, @2*) 9(/.0( 0( N(/1*+') N'&01*.') +,&

M'M,31' .'M' GHQR 0( &( +,).,31/(&*P(.*%3 +, 23( N(/1, +, &') /,.2/)') ,.'3%M*.') +,& V9Q ,YN/,)(+( ,3 &( @,- +, ;(/1*.*N(.*%3

;'N2&(/ +, !ii]:

X= 7%&( #JM"'(E F&"F%G(EP %'C&% I&(Y%EL('#J%E H #"C(&L$#$%E ( JK$%&%EP F(S%'T#&[' # I&%M"'C#&E% C#S+Lb' I(& 2#'C# !&"T

F(S( FL"$#$P F(S( I"%+J( ( F"JC". @( ./*)*) +, &( M'+,/3*+(+R ,& .2,)1*'3(M*,31' ( &') I)1(+') 3(.*'3(&,) - ,&

N,3)(M*,31' +, &( +*>,/)*+(+ .2&12/(& ' ,& M231*.2&12/(&*)M' ?2, >,30( +,)(//'&&53+'), +,)+, &') (O') XU ,3 &') II:CC:R -

'1/() ,YN,/*,3.*( N'&01*.() ,3 I2/'N(R .'M' ,& )2/K*M*,31' +, &() (21'3'M0() ,3 I)N(O(_ ,& )2/K*M*,31' +, &') M'>*M*,31')

,13'1,//*1'/*(&,) ' ,13'3(.*'3(&,)R ,& .2,)1*'3(M*,31' +, &') I)1(+') ,13'./51*.') ,3 #I)1(+') ;&2/*.2&12/(&,)7::: 1'+' ,)'

,3 .'3W231'R 4*.*,/'3 ?2, (&K23') ./2.,O') .'M,3P(/( ( N,3)(/ ,& 1,M( +, &( *+,31*+(+ .2&12/(& ./2.,O( ' .(M6(:

I) ,)1( 32,>( M*/(+(R ' &( /,&,.12/( +, &( 4*)1'/*( - &( .2&12/( .(M6(R ,3 )2M( +, &( *+,31*+(+ .(M6( ,3 ,& S/*,31,

6'&*>*(3'R N&(31,(+( N'/ ,& /'0%.12&+0 +,& (O' TUU!R &( ?2, 4( +,)N,/1(+' &( *+,( ' N,3)(M*,31' N'&01*.' &&(M(+'

c3(.*'3(&*)M' .(M6(7_ 3(.*'3(&*)M' ?2,R ,3 ,& .'31,Y1' +,& N,3)(M*,31' N'&01*.' N')1M'+,/3'R +,B*,3+, &( ,Y*)1,3.*( +,


9/13

i

23( 3(.*%3 ' 3(.*'3(&*+(+ ( N(/1*/ +, 23( *+,31*+(+ 4*)1%/*.'\.2&12/(& .'M' &' ,) &( *+,31*+(+ .(M6( 8./2.,O(R 6,3*(3( -

N(3+*3(=: I)1, 3(.*'3(&*)M' .(M6( N')12&( &' )*K2*,31,`

x ~2, ,& N2,6&' ./2.,O' ,3 )2 +,>,3*/ (.12(& 4'- M5) ?2, 323.( ), >*,3, ()2M*,3+' .'M' Q(.*%3: @') ,&,M,31') ?2,

1*,3, ,)1( 3(.*%3 8?2, -( &') 4,M') +,)./*1' - ,YN&*.(+' ,3 '1/') 1/(6(W')= )'3 ,)1')`

8I31*,3+' N'/ c3(.*%3g 1'+' K/2N' 42M(3' ' N2,6&' 4*)1%/*.( - .2&12/(&M,31, +*B,/,3.*(+' +, '1/')R ?2,(),31(+' - '.2N(3+' 23 +,1,/M*3(+' 1,//*1'/*'R 4( +,)(//'&&' 23( .2&12/( N(/1*.2&(/ ,YN/,)(+( ,3 )2 B'/M( +,

N/'+2.*/ &') 6*,3,) M(1,/*(&,) +, )26)*)1,3.*(R ,3 &( 4*)1'/*( ?2, 4( N/'1(K'3*P(+'R ,3 &( &,3K2( ' B'/M( +,

4(6&(/&(R ,3 ,& (/1, 8&*1,/(12/(R Md)*.(R N',)0(R N*312/(=R ,3 ,& '34%5 .'&,.1*>' ' 3'/M() M'/(&,) ?2, /,K2&(3 ,&

.'MN'/1(M*,31'R ,3 &() .')12M6/,) - 1/(+*.*'3,)R &( *+*')*3./()*( )'.*(&R ,3 &() ()N*/(.*'3,) N'&01*.() +, &*6,/1(+ '

&*6,/(.*%3R ,3 &( B'/M( +, ),/R (.12(/ - .'3>*>*/y,&,M,31') ?2, ,3 ,& +,>,3*/ 4*)1%/*.' +,& M*)M' K/2N' K,3,/(3

23 ),31*M*,31' +, N,/1,3,3.*(R )'&*+(/*+(+ - (21'*+,31*B*.(.*%3 ,3 - ,31/, .(+( 23' +, &') *3+*>*+2') ?2, &(

.'3B'/M(3: I3 1'+( 3(.*%3R .'M' ,3 ,)1, .()'R ,3 &( Q(.*%3 .(M6(R ), ,3.2,31/(3 ,&,M,31') '6W,1*>') 8,&

1,//*1'/*'R &( /(P(R &( ,13*( ' &( M,P.&( +, ,13*()=R &( &,3K2( ' &( B'/M( +, 4(6&(/&( 8,& 4(6&( N'N2&(/=R &() 1/(+*.*'3,)R

&( 4*)1'/*( /,K*)1/(+( ,3 +'.2M,31') ' &*6/')y- ,&,M,31') )26W,1*>')R &') M5) N/'B23+')R &') ?2, ,)153 ,3 &(

.'3.*,3.*( .'&,.1*>( - ,3 &') ),31*M*,31')R ?2, )'3 (?2,&&') ?2, 1*,3,3 ?2, >,/ .'3 &') >(&'/,) .2&12/(/,)R ,& '34%5R

&( N)*.'&'K0(R &( B'/M( +, ),/R N,3)(/R (.12(& - .'3>*>*/_ &( /,&*K*%3: I) +,.*/R &' ?2, 1*,3, ?2, >,/ .'3 &' )*M6%&*.'\.2&12/(&: D2(3+' &') M*,M6/') +, ,)1, K/2N' 42M(3' ' 3(.*%3R ' (&K23') +, ,&&')R 4(.,3 .'3).*,31, ,)1')

,&,M,31') - (.1d(3 ,3 .'3),.2,3.*(R K,3,/(3 23 N/'.,)' +, &*6,/(.*%3 3(.*'3(&R ,YN/,)(+'R ),( ,3 &( +,M(3+(

+, B,+,/(&*P(.*%3 +,& I)1(+' +'3+, ), 4(&&( +*.4( 3(.*%3R ' ,3 &( +, (21'3'M0(R ' N'/ d&1*M' )* ), .'3)*+,/( ,3

)*12(.*%3 +, .'&'3*(R ,3 &( &2.4( N'&01*.( N'/ (&.(3P(/ )2 &*6,/(.*%3 +, &( +'M*3(.*%3 +, '1/( ,13*(R N2,6&' ' I)1(+':

867&: 9: ;*31' *)1' -

(3(&*P(+'R &( .(31*+(+ +, &( N'6&(.*%3 ?2, ), ()2M, .'M' .(M6( 8M,)1*P(R ./*'&&( , *3+0K,3(\'/*K*3(/*(= 3' ,) M,3'/ ( !h

bUU:UUU 4(6*1(31,): m )* ( ,)1( .(31*+(+ &, )2M(M') &( K,31, ?2,R >,3*+( +,& *31,/*'/ ' +,& ,Y1,/*'/ N'/ ,M*K/(.*%3R ), 4(

()*M*&(+' &*6/,M,31, ( &( .2&12/( .(M6(R ,)( .*B/( .'3 ),K2/*+(+ (2M,31(/0(: ;'/ ,)'R 2/K, 4(.,/ 32,>') .,3)')

+,N(/1(M,31(&,) ,3 ,)1') 1/,) +,N(/1(M,31') .(M6():

x I)1( N'6&(.*%3 .'3B'/M( 23 cN2,6&'gR N'/?2, ( &' &(/K' +, j]U (O') +, 4*)1'/*( 8!]l! 4(.*( +,&(31,= +,)(//'&&% ,3 +*.4'

1,//*1'/*' 4*)1%/*.'R - M(31*,3, (d3R 23 .'3W231' +, 1/(+*.*'3,)R >(&'/,) .2&12/(&,) - B'/M( +, ),/ ?2, ), M(3*B*,)1(3 ,3

>(/*() .')12M6/,)R B*,)1() ?2, ), .,&,6/(3R W2,K')R B'/M( N(/1*.2&(/ +, 4(6&(/ &( &,3K2( .()1,&&(3(R ,3 23( /,&*K*%3

N/,+'M*3(31,M,31, ./*)1*(3( .(1%&*.(R ,1.:


10/13

!U

x G &( .'3B'/M(.*%3 +, ,)1, cN2,6&' .(M6(gR .'M' 4,M') >*)1'R (N'/1(/'3 .'3 )2 )(3K/,R .')12M6/,)R &,3K2()R >(&'/,) -

B'/M() +, ),/ &() ,13*() ' N2,6&') *3+0K,3() .'M' &') K2(/(30,)R &') .4*?2*1(3') - .'3 ,& 1*,MN' &') M'>*M()R M'W,O')R

/,-,)(3')::::1'+') ,&&') N,/1,3,.*,31,) ( &' ?2, (&K23') ,13%K/(B') &&(M(3 c/(P( N(MN,(3(g: !53%5 B+';"%5 2(37,%5 5%2

5+;2($7%2("7&(&'5 &' "( 9($7:2 $(0;(-m Z)1( 3' ), &( ,YN&*.( .(6(&M,31, )*3 &( N/,),3.*( +, &') .(M6() *3+0K,3() ?2, 4(-

,3 $(31( D/2PR E,3* - ;(3+': ;'/ &') +(1') ,)1(+0)1*.') N/,.,+,31,)R &( N'6&(.*%3 .(M6( *3+0K,3( '/*K*3(/*( ,3 1'+' ,&

1,//*1'/*' .(M6( &&,K( (&/,+,+'/ +, 23 !Tz:

x V*,3, 23 4(6&( N'N2&(/ .(M6( ' ./2.,O( ?2, 4( )*+' ,)12+*(+' N'/ (21'/,) *+,31*B*.(+') .'3 ,)1( .2&12/(&: A>.-N(/( ,&

.()' +,& 4(6&( ./2.,O' ( q: $(3(6/*( A:R !" 4(;"( B%B+"(. &' C(23( A.+DR $(31( D/2P +, &( $*,//( TUUb: ;(/( ,& .()' +,& 4(6&(

./2.,O( - )2 ,YN(3)*%3 N'/ 1'+' ,)1, 1,//*1'/*' 4*)1%/*.' .(M6(R .'3 )2) ,)N,.*B*.*+(+,) ' >(/*(.*'3,) ,3 (&K23()

)26/,K*'3,)R $>.-@: G: L'.(R E.',' 4753%.7( &'" 4(;"( $.+$'F( = 5+ 0'537D(G'R $(31( D/2P +, &( $*,//( TUUX:

x V*,3, 23( 4*)1'/*( N/'N*( ?2, ,)15 ,)./*1(: $, &( N2,+, &,,/R ,31/, '1/()R ,3 &( '6/( M,3.*'3(+( +,& ./2.,O' q,/3(3+'

$(3(6/*(` !2 E+5$( &' '" &%.(&%8!ibb= - ,3 &( 1(M6*Z3 -( M,3.*'3(+( - M5) /,.*,31, +,& 6,3*(3' r')Z @2*) L'.(` C%$7'&(&

= !$%2%0?( '2 '" H.7'23' E%"7,7(2%R $: npF (& nn 8TUU!=:

x V*,3, ()N*/(.*'3,) N'&01*.() +, (21'3'M0(: m ,)1' +,)+, !]l!R N/*M,/' (31, &( (+M*3*)1/(.*%3 .'&'3*(& ,)N(O'&( -R

+,)N2Z)R B/,31, ( &( L,Nd6&*.( +, E'&*>*( - )2) K'6*,/3') (3+*3') +, 12/3': @') .(6*&+') /,(&*P(+') ,3 &') d&1*M') j (O')+,M(3+(3+' (21'3'M0( )'3 '1/() +, &() ,YN/,)*'3,) +, +*.4() ()N*/(.*'3,):

x q(- 23 ,?2$+"% B57$%":*7$% = $+"3+.(" '23.' "%5 $(0;(5I (5? $%0% +2 5'23707'23% >+'.3' = B.%>+2&%I &' 5'237.5' = J+'.'.

5'*+7. 57'2&% $(0;(: I) 23( ,)N,.*, +, )*MN(10( - ,MN(10( ,31/, &') .(M6(): $'6/, 1'+' .2(3+' +,).26/*M') ?2, &(

N(&(6/( c.(M6(g )*K3*B*.( O(S+&% #SLM( UE%G(& ( E%G(WR - 1*,3, )2 '/*K,3 ,1*M'&%K*.' ,3 &( &,3K2( K2(/(30R - ,) 23(

N(&(6/( ?2, B2, /,K*)1/(+( N'/ N/*M,/( >,P ,3 B'/M( ,)./*1( ,3 23( L,&(.*%3 )'6/, &') ,/)(& - &( ?2, M,W'/ .'31,3*+' )'.*'&%K*.' - (31/'N'&%K*.' 1*,3,: ;'/ 1(31'R

N,/M*1, (21' *+,31*B*.(/), - ),31*/), +*)1*31' (& ./2.,O'R 6,3*(3' - N(3+*3' (31, &') c'1/')g:

I& ,13%K/(B' 3'/1,(M,/*.(3' q,(14 ,3 &') (O') ]U +,& ): nn +*., +,& D(M6(` c@') D(M6() .'3)1*12-,3 23 K/2N' +,

*3+*>*+2') ?2, ,3 B'/M( +,&*6,/(+( ), /,&(.*'3(3 ,31/, )0: ;(/( ),/ .(M6( ), 3,.,)*1( 4(6,/ )*+' )'.*(&*P(+' .'M' M*,M6/'

+, 23 K/2N' ?2, 4( N,/)*)1*+' +2/(31, K,3,/(.*'3,)_ 23 K/2N' .2-') M*,M6/') .'MN(/1,3 M'+(&*+(+,) .'M23,) ,3 ,&

N,3)(M*,31'R ),31*M*,31')R ./,,3.*() - M'+') +, .'MN'/1(/),g: c@() (/1,) - 'B*.*') +, &') D(M6() 4'- /,B&,W(3 )2

4,/,3.*( *3+0K,3(R ( N,)(/ +, ?2, )2 M'+' +, >,)1*/ ,) .'MN&,1(M,31, I)N(O'&( e)*.:f: I3 )2 (/?2*1,.12/(R (&*M,31') ,

*+*'M( N'+,M') (4'/( +*).,/3*/ ,&,M,31') 1(31' +, &() 1/(+*.*'3,) 3(1*>() .'M' ,)N(O'&(): $2) W2,K')R B(6/*.(.*'3,)

.(),/()R .2,31') B'&s&%/*.')R B(/M(.'N,(R - 23 )*33dM,/' +, '1/') ()N,.1') +, )2 .2&12/( *K2(&M,31, ,M,/K,3 +, )2

(3.,)1/' +2(&: ;'/ .'3)*K2*,31,R +,6,M') /,.'3'.,/ ?2, &') D(M6() 3' )'3 3* *3+0K,3() 3* G3+(&2.,) N,/' )'3 23 N2,6&'

32,>' ?2, (d3 ), 4(&&( ,3 N/'.,)' +, B'/M(.*%3 ,3 .2(31' ( )2) .')12M6/,) +, >*+(: $2 .2&12/( 3' ,) .'N*( +, 3*3Kd3

M'&+, (31*K2' )*3' 23( .2&12/( 32,>( N'),0+( +, 23( >*1(&*+(+ ?2, .'3.2,/+( .'3 )2 ,)1(+' ,M,/K,31,g: c@') D(M6()

B'/M(3 23( 32,>( .'3)1,&(.*%3 ,3 ,& 23*>,/)' +, &( .2&12/( 42M(3(: V'+' N(/,., *3+*.(/ ?2, ,)1( .'3)1,&(.*%3 ), 4(&&(),

,3 ().,3)'g: eI& )26/(-(+' ,) 32,)1/'f 8q,(14 TUUU=:

x I)1, 3(.*'3(&*)M' .(M6( 3' ,) *K2(& (& /,K*'3(&*)M' 3* (& *31,K/(.*'3*)M' ./2.,O' +,& ): nn: V(MN'.' ), /,+2., ( ,Y*K*/

)%&' (21'3'M0( +,N(/1(M,31(& +,31/' +,& I)1(+' +, E'&*>*(: ;'/ 1(31'R /'MN, .'3 (?2,&&() N')12/() ./2.,O() N&(31,(+()

,3 ,& M(/.' +,& 3(.*'3(&*)M' (&1'N,/2(3' 6'&*>*(3' ?2, 62).% .'3)1/2*/ c&( 3(.*%3 6'&*>*(3(g ,3 6(), ( &() .2&12/()

(3+*3()R )'6/, 1'+'R &( (*M(/(R 3,K53+'&,) ( &') ./2.,O') ' .(M6() ,3 K,3,/(& ( 1,3,/ 23( *+,31*+(+ .2&12/(& N/'N*(R

(21Z31*.(R 3' N/,)1(+( 3* *MN2,)1(:


11/13

!!

x G4'/( 6*,3R ,& 3(.*'3(&*)M' .(M6( 3' ,) *K2(& (& *(R ,3 (N(/*,3.*( (d3 #N&2/*3(.*'3(&7=:

x I& 3(.*'3(&*)M' .(M6( ,) ,& 32,>' *+,(/*' N'&01*.' ?2, &') .(M6() /,?2,/0(3 N(/( .'31*32(/ &2.4(3+' N'/ ,& +,/,.4'

42M(3' +, &*6/, (21'+,1,/M*3(.*%3 .'M' Q(.*%3 B/,31, ( 23 I)1(+' 6'&*>*(3' +*/*K*+' 4()1( (4'/( N'/ &') (3+*3') ?2,

,W,.21(3 23 .'&'3*(&*)M' *31,/3' 8?2, ,) '1/( B'/M( +, >*'&,3.*(= .'31/( &') .(M6()R >0( ,+2.(.*%3 Nd6&*.(R ,YN'&*(.*%3 +,

&') /,.2/)') ,.'3%M*.')R +,)N/,)1*K*' )'.*(&R N'&01*.' - /(.*(&:

b= 7# %EC# I&LS% SLC#$ $%J ELMJ( NN9P %J I%'E#SL%'C( I(JKCLF( F&"F%G( H E" #FFL('#&P RLEJ"S+S(E Q"% $%+%&K#

F#SL'#& I(& J(E ELM"L%'C%E JL'%#SL%'C(E ( I&L'FLIL(E Y"'$#S%'C#J%E `

(= V,3,/ ,3 .2,31( ?2, &( M'+,/3*+(+R ?2, .'3&&,>( &( M'+,/3*+(+ N'&01*.( - '1/') +*).2/)') ' M,1(//,&(1') .'M' ,&

3(.*'3(&*)M' +,.*M'3%3*.' ' #,)1(1(&*)1(7R ?2, 323.( /,)N,1(/'3 &( +*>,/)*+(+ +, N2,6&') ' .2&12/() ' 3(.*'3,) ?2, 1*,3,23 I)1(+' - ?2, ,3 3'M6/, +, 23( )'&( 3(.*%3 M'+,/3( 8M'3'.2&12/(& ' M'3'Z13*.(= *MN'30(3 23( )'&( >*)*%3 ( 1'+')

,)') +*>,/)') N2,6&')R - N(/( ,&&' .'3.,31/(6( ' .,31/(&*P(6( ,& N'+,/ ,)1(1(&R -( 3' >( M5) - 4( &&,K(+' ( )2 B*3:::Q' N'/

3(+( ,3 ,& M23+' 4'- M5) +,& ]Uz +, &') I)1(+') )'3 +,).,31/(&*P(+') 6(W' ,& M'+,&' B,+,/(& ' ,& +, &() (21'3'M0():::m 3'

N'/ 3(+( 4(., lU ' XU (O') ,3 ,& M23+' 4(60(3 23') !jU I)1(+') - (4'/( 4(- M5) +, TUU I)1(+'):::: G&K' 3') ,)15

+*.*,3+' ,)1( 32,>( /,(&*+(+ N'&01*.( M23+*(&

6= V,3,/ ,3 .2,31( ?2, ,& N,3)(M*,31' N'&01*.' N')M'+,/3' +,B*,3+, &' #N&2/*7 .2&12/(&R &( +,M'./(.*( N(/1*.*N(1*>( .'3

*3.&2)*%3 +, &() M*3'/0() .2&12/(&,)R Z13*.( - 3(.*'3(&,)_ N&(31,( &( +,).,31/(&*P(.*%3 +,& N'+,/ N'&01*.'R ,.'3%M*.' -

&,K*)&(1*>' .'3 (21'3'M0( +, K,)1*%3 - +,.*)*%3 N'&01*.( 83' (.,N1( 23 I)1(+' .,31/(&*)1( ' ,13'./51*.'R ,) +,.*/R 23 I)1(+'

M(3,W(+' N'/ 23( )'&( ,13*( ' .2&12/(& ?2, ?2*,/, *MN'3,/ )2 B'/M( +, >*+( - )2 >*)*%3 ( &() '1/() ,13*()R 3(.*'3,) '

.2&12/(&,) ?2, ,Y*)1,3 +,31/' +,& M*)M' I)1(+'R (N/'>,.453+'), N(/( ,&&' +, &') /,.2/)') ?2, .'3.,31/( ' .,31/(&*P( ,&N'+,/ ,)1(1(&=:

.= ;'/ ,&&'R ,& N,3)(M*,31' - ,& (..*'3(/ N'&01*.' ./2.,O' ' .(M6( +,6, - 1*,3, ?2, ()2M*/ &( +,B,3)( *3.&(2+*.(6&, +, &(

&*6,/1(+ 42M(3( .'31/( 1'+' *31,31' , *31,/Z) +, *MN'3,/ ( $(31( D/2P ' ( &') .(M6() ,3 K,3,/(& /,K0M,3,) 1'1(&*1(/*')

),(3 +, 1*N' )'.*(&*)1(R .'M23*)1(R ,)1(&*3*)1(R .()1/*)1(R K(+(B*)1(R .'M23*1(/*)1( ' (-&&*)1(: ;'/?2, ,)1, 1*N' +, )'.*,+(+ 3'

>( .'3 ,& ,)N0/*12 &*6/, +,& N2,6&' ' &( 3(.*%3 .(M6(: ;'/ ,)'R &( +,B,3)( +, &( +,M'./(.*( N(/1*.*N(1*>( , *3.&2)*>( 1*,3, ?2,

),/ N(/1, +, ,), *+,(/*' N'&01*.'_ 23( +,M'./(.*(R (+,M5)R +'3+, ,& I)1(+' +,W, +, ),/ &( $(31( F3?2*)*.*%3 M'+,/3( ?2,

.'3 )2) *3?2*)*+'/,)R ,) +,.*/R W2,.,) - B*).(&,)R N,/)*K2,3 (& ?2, 3' ./,, ' N*,3)( +*)1*31' ( &') ?2, ,)153 *3./2)1(+') ,3 ,&

N'+,/ - N*,3)(3 ?2, ,), I)1(+' +,6, *MN'3,/ >*)*'3,) - B'/M() +, >*+( (& (31'W' +, &') ?2, 1*,3, 23( *+,'&'K0( .'M' )*

B2,/( 23( /,&*K*%3R .'M' &' ?2*,/,3 4(.,/ &') .'M23*)1() ' )'.*(&*)1() +,& )*K&' nnF: I3 )031,)*) 4(- ?2, +,B,3+,/ (&

*3+*>*+2' N'/ )'6/, ,& I)1(+': I& 4'M6/, ,) M5) *MN'/1(31, ?2, ,& I)1(+' N(/( ,& N,3)(M*,31' N'&01*.' N')M'+,/3':

+= I), N,3)(M*,31' - (..*'3(/ N'&01*.' ./2.,O' 1*,3, ?2, *3.&2*/ &( +,B,3)( - /,>*1(&*P(.*%3 +, &( *+,31*+(+ 4*)1%/*.'\.2&12/(&

./2.,O( ' .(M6(_ )'6/, 1'+' +, (?2,&&() 1/(+*.*'3,) - >(&'/,) .2&12/(&,) ?2, &, 4(.,3 #6*,3 ( 23 N2,6&'7` ?2, &' 4(.,3

M5) (&,K/,R M5) 4')N*1(&(/*'R M5) )'&*+(/*') ,31/, )2) M*,M6/')R ,3 )2M( M5) B,&*P - .'3 M,3'/ )2B/*M*,31' 42M(3':

;*,3)' ?2, ,& (..*'3(/ N'&01*.' +, &') ./2.,O') ' .(M6() ,3 K,3,/(& +,6,/0( K*/(/ ,3 1'/3' ( ,)1') +') >(&'/,)

B23+(M,31(&,)` &( &*6,/1(+ - ,& M,3'/ )2B/*M*,31' N')*6&, +,& .(M6(: ;'/?2, (& B*3 - (& .(6' ,)' ,) &' ?2, *MN'/1( N(/( ,&


12/13

!T

4'M6/, .2(3+' N()( N'/ ,)1, M23+': @( N'&01*.( ' ,& N'+,/ N'&01*.' ?2, ), 1,3K( +,6,/0( ,3.(M*3(/), N'/ ( N,/),K2*/ ,),

'6W,1*>'R - 3' (& /,>Z)` ( 4(.,/&, &( >*+( Nd6&*.( - N/*>(+( M5) (M(/K(+( ( &( K,31,:

,= V(M6*Z3 +,6, +*/*K*/), ( ),K2*/ .(M6*(3+' &( ,)1/2.12/( +,& I)1(+' 6'&*>*(3' ?2, 4()1( (4'/( 4( ),/>*+' N(/( ,3/*?2,.,/

N/*M,/' ( &( /').( M*3,/'\B,2+(& (3+*3(R &2,K' ( )2) Z&*1,) N'&01*.() , *31,&,.12(&,) +,& ),.1'/ )'.*(& M,+*' - (4'/( ( &')

+*/*K,31,) )*3+*.(&,) .(MN,)*3') , *3+0K,3() (3+*3')R (3)*')') 1(M6*Z3 +, &2./(/ .'3 &') /,.2/)') +,& I)1(+' ?2, 4(.,M')

N')*6&, .'3 32,)1/') *MN2,)1') - .'3 &') /,.2/)') 3(12/(&,) +, &() /,K*'3,): 6*.:R 4'- &') *3+*K,3*)1()R *3+*(3*)1()R

)'.*(&*)1()::::4(3 ./,(+' 23 B'3+' *3+0K,3( +*P?2, N(/( ,& +,)(//'&&' *3+0K,3(: H, &') !UUU M*&&'3,) ?2, 1*,3, ,), B'3+'R ,&

b]z ), &' /,N(/1,3 - ?2,+(3 ,3 &( P'3( (3+*3(_ ,& /,)1'R ' ),(R ,& !]zR ,) +,.*/R M*K(W()R &, +(3 ( &') N2,6&') ' 3(.*'3,)

*3+0K,3() +, &() 1*,//() 6(W() ' +,& S/*,31, 6'&*>*(3': m >,(3 ,)1, '1/' 1/(1' +*)./*M*3(1'/*' ( &() 3(.*'3,) ' N2,6&')

'/*,31(&,)` +,& N/,)2N2,)1' ?2, (N/'6(/'3 N(/( ,)1, (O' ?2, (&.(3P( ( !!! M*& M*&&'3,) +, E):R ,& b^z &' M(3,W(3 +,

M(3,/( *3+*)./,.*'3(& +,)+, 23 I)1(+'R N(/(+%W*.(M,31, .'3 (21'3'M0()R N,/' ?2, 1*,3, 23 b^z +, .'MN,1,3.*() ,31/,

N/*>(1*>() - ,Y.&2)*>() .,31/(&*P(+(): I)( 1'/1( ,.'3%M*.(R ?2, +2+( .(6,R &,) 6,3,B*.*( M5) ( ,&&')R ,) +,.*/R ( &') N2,6&')R

3(.*'3,) - .*2+(+,) +, &( P'3( (3+*3(: D'31/( ,)() *3W2)1*.*() ,.'3%M*.() 1(M6*Z3 4(- ?2, 4(.,/ N'&01*.( - &2.4(/ ,3 -

+,)+, $(31( D/2P: ;'/?2, )* 3' ), &' 4(.,R 3' ), ,)15 4(.*,3+' /,)N,1(/ ' 1'&,/(/ ,)( +*>,/)*+(+ Z13*.(R .2&12/(& - 3(.*'3(&

?2, 1*,3, E'&*>*( .'M' I)1(+':

B= @( B'/M( +, 4(.,/ N'&01*.( +,& ./2.,O'R 3' N2,+, +,W(/ +, &(+' &( 1,)*) +, ?2, N(/( +,)(//'&&(/), .'M' N2,6&'R )'.*,+(+ '3(.*%3R ,& .(M6( 3,.,)*1( 1,3,/ .(N*1(& ,.'3%M*.'R 1,.3'&%K*.'R N,/' 1(M6*Z3 .(N*1(& .2&12/(&R ,)1' ,)R M(-'/ - M,W'/

.'3'.*M*,31'R ?2, >( (.'MN(O(+' +, M,W'/,) (N1*12+,) .'K3*1*>() N(/( ),K2*/ 4(.*,3+' N'&01*.( N(/1*.*N(1*>( ?2, N'3K( (&

*3+*>*+2' - (& .*2+(+(3' N'/ ,3.*M( +, &') N'+,/,) Nd6&*.') - 3' (& /,>Z) .'M' )2.,+, ' 4( )2.,+*+' 4()1( (4'/( ,3 &(

4*)1'/*( M'+,/3( +,& I)1(+' 6'&*>*(3': G& B*3 - (& .(6'R &( N'&01*.( - ,& N'&01*.'R (?2,& ?2, >*>, +, ' N(/( &( N'&01*.(R ), +,6, (

&( K,31, - ( )2 &*6/, >'&231(+ +, ),/ K'6,/3(+') N'/ &') M5) .(N(.,) +, ,31,3+,/ ?2, &' ?2, &, *MN'/1( ( &( K,31, ,) >*>*/

&*6/, 8)*3 3*3Kd3 1*N' +, 'N/,)*%3R 3* ,.'3%M*.(R 3* N'&01*.(R 3* ,)1(1(&R 3* )'.*(&R 3* W2/0+*.(R 3* N)*.'&%K*.(R 3* ,)N*/*12(&= -

1,3,/ ,& M,3'/ )2B/*M*,31' N')*6&, (& N()(/ N'/ ,)1, M23+': m ,3 1'/3' ( ,)1') +') >(&'/,) '31'&%K*.') - 3(12/(&,) +,6,/0(3

'/K(3*P(/), - ,)1/2.12/(/), 4'- &') I)1(+')R &() )'.*,+(+,) ' )2) 3(.*'3,):

K= I3 M,+*' +, ,)() 1,3+,3.*() - B'/M() +, ,31,3+,/ &( N'&01*.( - )2 (..*'3(/ N(/( ,& )*K&' nnFR ,& M(/.' *+,'&%K*.'\N'&01*.'

?2, 1*,3,3 (&K23() (K/2N(.*'3,) .*2+(+(3() 3(.*+() ,3 $(31( D/2P ,) B23+(M,31(&R 1(& .2(& ), &' /,)2M, ,3 ,)1() &03,()`

x $, ()2M, &( &*6,/1(+ .'M' N/*3.*N*' B23+(M,31(& +, *+,31*+(+ +,& N2,6&' .(M6(\./2.,O'_

x $, ()2M, ,& .'MN/'M*)' )'.*(& 6(W' &') N/*3.*N*') +, )'&*+(/*+(+ , *K2(&+(+_

x ;'/ ,)'R ), ()2M, &( +,M'./(.*( )'.*(&_

x $, 62).( 23*/ ,& 1/(6(W' .'3 ,& ,MN/,3+*M*,31' 8(&K' ?2, +,M2,)1/( ?2, 3' >, (& I)1(+' +, M(3,/(N(1,/3(&*)1(=_

x $, ()2M, &( +,B,3)( +,& +,)(//'&&' )')1,3*6&,_

x $, ()2M, &( (21'3'M0( .'M' 23 *3)1/2M,31' N(/( &2.4(/ - .'3?2*)1(/ &') +,/,.4') +, &') ./2.,O') - +, &').*2+(+(3') +, 1'+( E'&*>*(_

x $, ()2M, &( +,B,3)( +, &( *+,31*+(+ .2&12/(& .(M6( ' ./2.,O(:

x $, ()2M,3 &( +,B,3)( +, &') +,/,.4') 42M(3') +, &') .(M6() ' ./2.,O') - +, 1'+' 4(6*1(31, 3' ./2.,O' +,&1,//*1'/*' .(M6(:


13/13

!^

>L+JL(MYK# +[ELF# &%Y%&%'FL#$#

S-'&( D2Z&&(/ ,/)*+(+ G21%3'M( c9(6/*,& L,3Z *(3'gR ,3 E(N1*)1( 92M2.*' *(R C3*>,/)*+(+ ;/*>(+( +, $(31( D/2PR !iii:

D()1*&&' r'),N +,&R cL,&(.*%3 +, &( N/'>*3.*( +, 7$( &' "( L'B[;"7$( &' E%"7,7(IV: F:R @( ;(PR !iUi:

(& L: 8,+:=R /(.$(&%. &' .+0;%5 '2 "( ,7&( $.+$'F(R

$(31( D/2PR E'&,103 +, &( $'.*,+(+ +, I)12+*') 9,'K/5B*.') , q*)1%/*.'):

Documents

Cuaderno No. 7 Desarrollo Pensamiento Político Cruceño 2012