CitizenScienceasCivicScience:Newspacesforreflexivepractice?

GwendolynBlueDept.ofGeographyUniversityofCalgary

CITIZENSCIENCEINALBERTA:CHANGINGPERSPECTIVES,BREAKINGBARRIERSMacEwan University

September26&27,2018

1

SCIENCE

PUBLIC

CITIZEN

2

SCIENCES

PUBLICS

CITIZENS

3

789:8;<=<>?

U

Tobendback

Reflexivity=

reflection+

possibilityofchange

Imagesource:ClydeRobinsonCC5

N

Citizenscienceisasocialprocessasmuchasitisascientificprocess

Scienceandenvironmental–decisionmakingaresocialprocessestoo

7

CIVICSCIENCE?

8

\;4#).38V)&0).4#)0+.+2#)68).&)L+6'%)V$&"'#%1#)3$%)+$%#28.3$%6$1)3K&$1)3$%)L#."##$)J6.6]#$8)3$%)8J6#$.68.8G)8&).43.).4#)%68.6$J.6&$8)L#."##$).4#)."&)12&+-8)73$684#8)[ 8&).43.)L&.4)L#J&K#)J6.6]#$)8J6#$.68.8G)-&.#$.63''()3L'#).&)8&'7#)&+2)-2&L'#K8).&1#.4#2^))

528+'3)_23$V'6$)

`

RQ

DATACOLLECTIONANDQUALITY

DOESMOREDATAALWAYSLEADTOBETTERDECISION-MAKING?

11

Steffenetal.ThetrajectoryoftheAnthropocene:TheGreatAcceleration(AnthropoceneReview)16January2015.Design:Globaia12

RT

567&89:!;9<&9;=!17;>9;?@A&B17CA9><&#40&<7AD?!7;<E&

:17>&56@?&-DA?D1@A&@<<D>B?!7;<&@;8&=@AD9<ERU

;4#).2&+L'#)"6.4)"6'%#2$#88C)!#..6$1)L3JV).&).4#)"2&$1)$3.+2#/)

RZ

SCIENTIFICCULTURE

16

:3$&FG&<+3%4H3'H'I&J*3(*3H3K#H3(4&(L&L3M%&+("")43+#H3(4&(2N%+H3M%'&L(*&(4.34%&J)2.3+&%4$#$%"%4H&OF&P&.(Q%'H&J*3(*3H/R&S&P&T3$T%'H&J*3(*3H/UG

,+%&)@G)*#8'#()i9)hMQRNj)?J6#$.68.8k)E26&26.6]3.6&$)&0)9&KK+$6J3.6&$)aLg#J.67#8)0&2)E+L'6J)=$131#K#$./)EAa?)a>=)RRhMjC)#QRUSSNP/4..-8Cll%&6/&21lRQ/RTPRlg&+2$3'/-&$#/QRUSSNP4..-8Cllg&+2$3'8/-'&8/&21l-'&8&$#l32.6J'#f6%XRQ/RTPRlg&+2$3'/-&$#/QRUSSNP

RP

PublicFacingScience

“Backstage”Science

Scientificsufficiency

Publicdeficiency

Uncertaintyandignorancenecessarypartofscience

BrunoLatour - ScienceinActionSteveHilgartner ScienceonStage:ExpertAdviceasPublicDrama

18

<.8CDE:<>?'<.'(!<8.!8-'.2#'*44',"%/+')2&+"F%3%F

R`

>9@;!;V&>@??91<

<?71!9<&>@??91

MQ

G8E7'HI'J.*#"2&*4'9"4@'G2*3FK

MR

L2/%3'@*##%3+

MM

D&)%3#*"&#M'*&F'

<N&23*&)%'O*##%3

MT

Towhatextentshouldcitizensbepartofdebatesoverknowledge,standards,protocolsandpolicyapproaches?• Ifthegoalistoempowercitizens…

• Standardsensureconsistency• Oldpractices• Newtechnologies• Makepossiblewidelysharedknowledge

• Standardsaresocialtechnologies– outcomesofslowpainfulnegotiations• Standardsdiscipline

• “technicalsafetystandards(levelsofcontrolrequiredtoprotectagainstharm)andformsofsocialorder(institutionalizedresponsestocivicandpoliticalexpectations)operateinanysocietytosustainoneanother (Jasanoff,1988)

• Negotiationsoverstandardsmatter– towhatextentshouldcitizensbeapartofthis?

24

=E:D8('OE>>87=E:D8('OE>>87

5T#H&M#.)%'&L(*&QT#H&W340&(L&+3H3K%4&'+3%4+%E&

MZ

S+Q%0#")*4R'TA%+#"2&"&N',"3#A%+'21'%50%3"@%&#*4'#A3&'21'@"&FU6

V0%&&%++R'#3*&+0*3%&)MR'B2&%+#MR'%TA*4"#MR'%TA"#M6

d43.)73'+#8)84&+'%)1+6%#)-26$J6-'#8f)

MN

! ;2+.4)68)-2&7686&$3')! H$&"'#%1#)3$%)-&"#2)J3$k.)L#)8#-323.#%! b+#8.6&$6$1)&0)#W-#2.8)3$%)6$8.6.+.6&$8)84&+'%)L#)

#$J&+231#%! ?.#-8)0&2"32%)K3()$##%)J&22#J.67#)8.#-8)L3JV! ;#J4$&'&1()3$%)6$0&2K3.6&$)"&$k.)8&'7#)-2&L'#K8)&$)

.4#62)&"$! 5$%#28.3$%6$1)468.&2()3$%)J+'.+2#)32#)38)6K-&2.3$.)38)

%3.3! ,#J686&$8)2#n+62#).23%#e&008)

! d4&)"6'')L#)"6$$#28)3$%)'&8#28f

! D+K6'6.()6$).4#)03J#)&0)+$J#2.36$.()3$%)61$&23$J#

!",")'+)"%&)%'+B2A4F'%@P3*)%'#B%'@2F%+#',"3#A%+'#B*#'A&F%34"%'#B%'+A))%++'21'P2#B'+)"%&)%'*&F'F%@2)3*)MW'

MP

Which path for citizen science?

Integration of citizens into the logic of the present system and bring about conformity to it

AND / OR????????

‘practice of freedom’, the means by which men and women deal critically with reality and discover how to participate in the transformation of their world.

Paulo Friere, Pedagogy of the Oppressed

28

29