8/12/2019 CIC_SS_A_2012_000988_M_87381.pdf

1/3

Central Information CommissionCentral Information Commission

Room No. 305, 2nd

Floor, B Wing, August Kranti Bhavan,Bhikaji Cama Place, New Delhi-110066

Web:www.cic.gov.inTel No: 26167931

Case No. CIC/SS/A/2012/000988Dated: 20.07.2012

Name of Appellant : Shri !nee"h #arg

Name of $e"pon%ent : &n"tit!te of 'hartere% Acco!ntant" of&n%ia

(ate of )earing : 2*.+6.2+12

ORDER

Shri !nee"h #arg, the appellant ha" file% thi" appeal %ate% 2*.12.2+11

before the 'ommi""ion again"t the re"pon%ent &n"tit!te of 'hartere%

Acco!ntant" of &n%ia -&'A&, New (elhi for provi%ing incomplete information in

repl/ to hi" $T& application %ate% 1+.9.2+11. The matter came !p for hearing on

2*.+6.2+12. The appellant wa" ab"ent an% the re"pon%ent were repre"ente% b/

Shri N.. Singh, 0AA, Shri . !rali%haran, (S an% ". Seema #erotra, (ep!t/

(irector '&4.

2. The appellant file% an application %ate% 1+.9.2+11 !n%er the provi"ion" of

the $T& Act, 2++5 in which he "o!ght information on nine !erie" pertaining to

vario!" a"pect" of eamination an% eval!ation of '.A. 0inal aper 2 Strategic

0inancial anagement.

The '&4 vi%e repl/ No.&'A&:$T&A:'&4:1613:2+11%ate% 11.1+.%enie% information on oint No. 3 an% 5 of the $T& application i.e.

g!i%eline"8in"tr!ction" i""!e% b/ the amining bo%/ to the aminer" an%

mo%el an"wer" i""!e% b/ the amining bo%/ to the eaminer" b/ !oting

S!preme 'o!rt !%gement %ate% 2.9.2+11 in a "imilar ca"e &'A& ;". Sha!na

8/12/2019 CIC_SS_A_2012_000988_M_87381.pdf

2/3

Case No. CIC/SS/A/2012/000988

). Sa/ta -'ivil Appeal No. 7571 of 2+11 ari"ing o!t of S= - ' No. 2+>+82+11.

4n oint No. 7 the '&4 %enie% information "tating that the verification proce""

of the final eamination hel% in a/ 2+11 wa" in proce""? on the remaining

point" re!i"ite information ha" been provi%e% to the appellant.

3. The 0AA, before whom the appellant file% fir"t appeal, ha" vi%e hi" or%er

%ate% 29.11.2+11 conc!rre% with the repl/ of the '&4.

>. (!ring the hearing the re"pon%ent "!bmit that the/ wo!l% now provi%e

information on oint No. 7 of the $T& application to the appellant, a" the

verification proce"" i" now over.

5. )aving con"i%ere% the "!bmi""ion" of the partie" an% per!"e% the

relevant %oc!ment" on file, the 'ommi""ion hereb/ %irect" the '&4 to provi%e

information on oint No. 7 of the $T& application to the appellant within one

weekof receipt of thi" or%er. The repl/ of '&4 on oint No. 3 an% 5 i" !phel% a"

the p!blic a!thorit/ ha" no %i"clo"!re obligation !n%er the provi"ion" of Section

*-1 -e of the $T& Act, 2++5 an% in view of the aforementione% @!%gement of the

S!preme 'o!rt of &n%ia. 4n the remaining point" re!i"ite information ha" been

provi%e% to the appellant b/ the re"pon%ent.

The matter i" %i"po"e% of with the above %irection"8ob"ervation".

(Ssh!a Sin"h#&nformation 'ommi""ioner

A!thenticate% tr!e cop/:

-.. Sharma4S( (ep!t/ $egi"trar

2

8/12/2019 CIC_SS_A_2012_000988_M_87381.pdf

3/3

Case No. CIC/SS/A/2012/000988

A%%re"" of the partie":Shri !nee"h #arg,). No. 63*81, aler1++1.

The '&4,The &n"tit!te of 'hartere% Acco!ntant" of &n%ia,&'A& hawan, &n%rapra"tha arg,o"t o No. 71++,New (elhiB11+++2.

The 0ir"t Appellate A!thorit/,The &n"tit!te of 'hartere% Acco!ntant" of &n%ia,

&'A& hawan, &n%rapra"tha arg,o"t o No. 71++,New (elhiB11+++2.

3