APPENDICES

CONTENTS

Appendix Subject Page Nos. Nos.

I PUBLIC NOTICE 551

II COMPOSITION OF COMMISSION'S SECRETARIAT 551

III STATEMENT SHOWING CATEGORYWISE REPLIES RECEIVED IN RESPONSE TO THE COMMISSION QUESTIONNAIRE 552

IV DATES AND SUBJECTS OF SUPPLEMENTARY QUESTIONNAIRE ISSUED TO RELEVANT ORGANISATIONS/INDIVIDUALS 552

V DATES OF STATES VISITED BY THE COMMISSION AND MEETINGS HELD WITH THE STATE GOVERNMENTS AT NEW DELHI 552

VI LIST OF INDIVIDUALS/BODIES WHO MADE SUBMISSIONS IN THE FORM OF MEMORANDA/REPLIES TO THE QUESTIONNAIRE ETC. 553—563

VII LIST OF INDIVIDUALS/BODIES WHO MET THE COMMISSION 564—580 VIII SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY 581—594

APPENDIX-I

COMMISSION ON CENTRE-STATE RELATIONS Public Notice

Government of India have, vide notification No. IV. 11017/1/83-CSR, dated the 9th June, 1983 set up a commission to "examine and review the working of the existing arrangements between the Union and State in regard to powers, functions and responsibilities in all spheres and recommend such changes or other measures as may be appropriate".

The Commission's assignment being comprehensive in character and of nation-wide interest, it is but appropriate at the very outset, to collect some basic information. The Commission, therefore, hereby solicits from all interested individuals, organisations and other sources such information (including published or written views) and factual data as may be relevant to any aspect of the aforesaid arrangements between the Union and the States, including the legislative, administrative, fiscal, economic and other spheres. An analytical study of such data would facilitate the identification of the problems, issues and difficulties experienced in the working of these arrangements during the last 33 years. This would also render facile the preliminary task of preparing working papers and questionnaires for ascertaining by the Commission the views thereon of eminent experts or groups in the specified spheres.

The Commission trusts that all concerned will extend their fullest co-operation and assistance to it and furnish the required information at their earliest to the Secretary to the Commission, Lok Nayak Bhavan, 4th Floor, Khan Market, New Delhi-110003.

BY ORDER OF THE COMMISSION ON CENTRE-STATE

RELATIONS

Sd/—

(K.A. RAMASUBRAMANIAM) SECRETARY

APPENDIX-II Composition of Commission's Secretariat

Name and Designation Period

Secretary

1. Shri K.A. Ramasubramaniam 23-3-83 to 31-7-84

2. Shri G.V. Ramkrishana 1-8-84 to 13-2-85

3. Shri D. Sankaraguruswamy 3-4-85—to date

Joint Secretary

1. Shri M.K. Moitra 19-10-83—30-9-86

2. Shri A.K. Varma 18-2-87—to date

Directors

1. Shri B.P. Sinha 20-10-83—to date

2. Shri B.M. Rao 4-1-84—to date

3. Shri A. Neelakantan 21-2-84—to date

4. Dr. Vivek Bhattacharya 15-3-84—29-3-87

Honorary Constitutional Advisor

1. Shri Lalnarayan Sinha 10-10-83—30-4-87

Part Time Consultants

1. Shri J. Srinivasa 7-9-83—to date

2. Shri P.P. Singh 8-11-83—30-6-84

3. Dr. N.M. Khilani 16-8-84—28-2-85

Senior Research Officer

1. Shri Ramesh Sharma 30-6-83(AN)—to date

2. Shri T.S. Rangamannar 1-9-83—to date

3. Shri P.C. Kannan 15-12-83—28-7-86

4. Shri R.R. Mittal 19-4-84—to date

5. Shri K.B. Lall 30-8-85—23-9-87

6. Smt. Tahera Ajmal 25-8-86—30-4-87

Research Officers

1. Shri R.D. Sharma 3-8-83—to date

2. Shri Niranjan Singh 11-8-83—21-7-87

3. Shri L. Yegnanarayanan 14-11-83—to date

4. Dr. Sanjay Singh 21-11-83—to date

5. Smt. Tahera Ajmal 25-11-83—24-8-86

6. Shri A.N. Wadhwa 28-11-83—3-1-86

7. Shri K.K. Sharma 7-12-83—30-4-87

8. Dr. S.K. Sharma 16-2-84—to date

9. Dr. Raja J. Singh 6-1-86—1-8-86

Administrative Officer

1. Shri Diwan Chand 1-7-83—30-8-85

2. Shri S. Jayasankar 9-12-85—to date

Section Officer 1. Shri S.S. Sikka 19-8-83—to date

APPENDIX-III

Statement Showing Categorywise Replies Received in Response to the Commissions Questionnaire S.No. Category No. of Replies received

1. Serving and former Presidents/Vice-Presidents/Prime Ministers/Speakers of Lok Sabha/Chief Justices of India ..

2. Serving & Former Union Ministers 7

3. Union Ministers/Departments of Government of India 23

4. State Governments/Union Territories 25(States 22 UTs.3)

5. Serving & Former Governors & Lt. Governors of State and Union Territories 7

6. Serving & Former Chief Ministers of States & Union Territories 12 7. Finance Ministers and other former Ministers of State 4 8. Members of Constituent Assembly 11 9. Serving & Former Speakers/Chairman and Members of State Legislatures 9

10. Presidents/General Secretaries of all the National, State/ Regional and Registered Political Parties as per lists maintained by the Chief Election Commissioner of India 36

11. Other Political Parties & Groups 20

12. Serving & Former Members of Parliament 6

13. Serving & Former Chief Justices and Judges of Supreme Court & High Court 13

14. Serving & former Auditor General of India 1

15. Serving & former Attorneys/Solicitors General of India and Advocates General of the States 1

16. Presidents/Secretaries of Bar Council of India and of States and Bar Associations of Supreme Court and High Court 3

17. Eminent Jurists & Advocates 24

18. Former Chairman/Members & Secretaries of Finance Commissions 2

19. Serving and former Governors/Deputy Governors of Reserve Bank of India 2

20. Serving & former Chief Election Commissioners of India 1

21. Eminent Economists/Political Scientists, Universities and Research Institutes 79

22. Editors of Important Dailies/Periodicals and distinguished Journalists & Correspondents 7

23. Financial Institutions and Chambers of Commerce & Industry 8

24. Trade Unions, Service Associations, Farmer's Bodies & Employer's Associations, etc. 19

25. Mayors/Administrators of Municipal Bodies, etc. 3

26. Miscellaneous (including individuals) 82 TOTAL 405 Note.—In all, more than 6,800 copies of Questionnaire in English, and 500 copies in Hindi were canvassed.

APPENDIX-IV Dates and Subjects of Supplementary Questionnaire Issued to Relevant Organisations/Individuals Sl. Subject Date of Issue No. 1. Industry (for Central Govt). September 22, 1984 2. Industry (for State Govts.) October 31, 1984 3. Inter-State River Water Disputes February 14, 1985 4. Governor's Discretionary Powers under Articles 163 and 200 January 18, 1985 5. Office of the Governor and President's Rule etc. March 30, 1985 6. Article 249 of the Constitution March 30, 1985 7. Article 252 of the Constitution March 30, 1985 8. Miscellaneous Questions regarding various Articles of the Constitution March 30, 1985 9. Article 356 of the Constitution November 8, 1985 10. Taxation of Agricultural Income August 1, 1986

APPENDIX-V

Dates of States visited by the Commission and Meetings Held with the State Governments at New Delhi

Sl. State/Union Territories Date of Meetings No. 1. Kerala (Trivandrum) June 1-7, 1984 2. Madhya Pradesh (Bhopal) August 2-8, 1984 3. Himachal Pradesh (Shimla) September 17-19, 1984 4. West Bengal (Calcutta) November, 15-21, 1984 5. Tripura (Agartala) February 19-21, 1985 6. Assam (Guwahati) February 23-26, 1985 7. Karnataka (Bangalore) April 1-12, 1985 8. Andhra Pradesh (Hyderabad) June 10-14, 1985 9. Orissa (Bhubaneshwar) July 5-6, 1985 10. Nagaland (Kohima) September 27-28, 1985 11. Meghalaya (Shillong) Sept. 30-Oct. 1, 1985 12. Maharashtra (Bombay) Nov. 16-22, 1985 13. Goa (Panaji) Nov. 23-25, 1985

14. Bihar (Patna) Dec. 18-20, 1985 15. Tamil Nadu (Madras) Dec. 26-31, 1985 16. Pondicherry January 1-2, 1986 17. Uttar Pradesh (Lucknow) January, 20-22, 1986 Meetings held with Government Representatives at New Delhi 18. Haryana March 12, 1986 19. Gujarat November 20, 1986 20. Jammu & Kashmir February 16, 1987 21. Manipur February 20, 1987 22. Rajasthan March 19, 1987 Note.— Sardar Surjit Singh Barnala, former Chief Minister of Punjab, who had submitted the State Government's Memorandum, as Chief Minister of April 24, 1987, met the Commission at New Delhi on July 14, 1987.

APPENDIX-VI List of Individuals Bodies who made Submissions in the form of Memoranda/Replies to the

Questionnaire etc.

ANDHRA PRADESH 1. Government of Andhra Pradesh.

2. Shri Gopal Rao Ekbote, Ex-Chief Justice, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad.

3. Shri K.V. Vema Reddy, Former Speaker, A.P. Legislative Assembly, Anantapur.

4. Shri M.V. Subrahmanya Sastry, Shri A. Subba Rao, Shri K. Hanumantha Rao, Shri Mollakalapalli Koleshwar Rao, Shri P.J. Mallikharijuna Rao and Shri B.V. Raghava Rao. Paidipadu.

5. Shri Mendu Venkata Rao, General Secretary, All India Telephone Traffic Employees' Association, Vijayawada.

6. Shri Vavilala Gopala Krishnayya, Former MLA, Andhra Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Sattenapalli.

7. Waltair School of Economics, Andhra University—Represented by Prof. G. Parthasarathy, Prof. M. Jagadeswar Rao and Prof. Ch. A. Krishna Rao.

8. Hony. Secretary, Prakasam Institute of Development Studies, Hyderabad.

9. Shri Avva Satyanarayana Rao, Advocate, Hyderabad.

10. Shri S. Radhakrishna, Editor, The Andhra Patrika, Vijayawada.

11. Shri C.V. Raghavulu, Prof. & Head of Political Science & Public Administration Nagarjuna University, Nagarjunasagar.

12. Shri Pandrangi Rajeshwara Rao, Advocate & Journalist,

Agraharam.

13. Shri V.B. Raju, Former Minister, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad.

14. Prof. N.A. Muttalib, Director, Regional Centre for Urban and Environmental Studies, Osmania University, Hyderabad.

15. Dr. V. Bhaskara Rao, Prof. Kakatiya University, Warangal.

16. Dr. D. Ramchandram, Lecturer in Public Administration, Secunderabad. 17. Shri Vijay Kumar Adwant, Lecturer in Economics, Vivek Vardhini College, Hyderabad. 18. Justice Alladi Kuppuswamy, Chief Justice, Andhra Pradesh (Retd.) Hyderabad. 19. Dr. C.P. Kasaiah, Reader in Economitrics, S.V. University College of Arts & Science, Tirupati. 20. President, Telugi Jatti Vimukthi Sangam, Hyderabad. 21. Shri N.V. Rao, I.F.S. (Retd.), Hyderabad. 22. Shri K. Brahmananda Reddi, Former Chief Minister, Former Union Home Minister, Former President, Indian National Congress, Hyderabad. 23. Shri M. Ramakrishnayya, I.A.S. (Retd.), Former Dy. Governor of RBI, Hyderabad. 24. Shri Akbar Ali Khan, Ex-Governor, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad. 25. Shri N. Laxminarayan, Ex-Mayor, Ex. M.L.A., Hyderabad. 26. Shri M. Baga Reddy, Leader of the Opposition, AP Legislative Assembly, Hyderabad. 27. Shri R. Srihari Rao, Social Worker, Nampally, Hyderabad.

28. Shri N. Poornachandra Rao, Nehru Nagar, Guntur.

29. General Secretary, Forum for Right to Work, Hyderabad.

30. President, Weavers Welfare Society, Kakinada.

ASSAM 31. Government of Assam. 32. General Secretary, Asom Jatiyatabadi Dol, Guwahati. 33. Shri Deveswar Sarmah, Senior Advocate and Ex.-MP, Ex-Minister of Assam, Jorhat.

34. General Secretary, Assam State Employees' Federation, Guwahati.

35. Chairman, Action Committee of North East Regional Parties, Guwahati.

36. Shri Satis C. Kakati Guwahati.

BIHAR 37. Government of Bihar.

38. Dr. Jagannath Mishra Ex-Chief Minister, Bihar, Patna.

39. Dr. Kedar Nath Kumar Reader, Magadh University, Bodh-Gaya.

40. Shri Barfi Dev Wafa, Panasayan.

41. Prof. Madan Mohan Sharma, Deptt. of Political Science, University of Bihar, Muzaffarpur.

42. Dr. P.K. Jha Deptt. of Economics, L.N. Mithila University, Darbhanga.

43. Director, Jagjivan Ram Institute of Parliamentary Studies & Political Research, Patna.

44. Dr. A.D. Roy Choudhuri Head of Department of Law, Patna University, Patna.

45. Shri K.P. Verma Advocate, Purnea. 46. Shri Saryu Roy Convener, J.P. Vichar Manch, Patna. 47. Shri Pradhan H. Prasad Prof. of Economics, A.N. Sinha Institute of Social Studies, Patna. 48. Dr. J.N. Tewari,

Deptt. of Economics, Patna University, Patna. 49. Bihar State Bar Council Patna. 50. Shri Kedar Nath Singh Daryapur, Distt. Saran (Chappra).

51. Dr. Shaibal Gupta Lecturer in Economics, A.N. Sinha of Institute of Social Studies, Patna.

52. President, Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Dhanbad.

53. Prof. Durganand Sinha A.N. Sinha Institute of Social Studies, Patna.

54. Prof. Dibakar Jha Retired Professor of Economics, Patna University, Patna.

55. Shri Ram Shobha Singh & Other fourteen teachers of RDS College, Muzaffarpur.

GUJARAT 56. Government of Gujarat.

57. Shri Rafiuddin Shaikh Mayor of Ahmedabad & Chairman, All India Council of Mayors, Ahmedabad.

58. Shri Babubhai J. Patel Ex-Chief Minister of Gujarat, Gandhinagar.

59. Dr. I.G. Patel, Former Governor, R.B.I., Director, Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad.

60. Prof. D.N. Pathak, Peace Research Centre, Gujarat Vidyapith, Ahmedabad.

61. Prof. H.C. Dholakia, Dean, Faculty of Law, MS University of Baroda, Baroda.

62. Shri Chimanbhai S. Patel, Editor "Sandesh", Ahmedabad.

63. Dr. Himmat Patel, Reader in Economics, Department of Economics, Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar.

HARYANA 64. Government of Haryana.

65. Dr. Himmat Singh Sinha Deptt. of Philosophy, Kurukshetra University, Kurukshetra.

66. Registrar, Maharshi Dayanand University, Rothtak.

67. Dr. Visnoo Bhagwan, Principal, Pt. J.L.N. Govt. College, Faridabad.

68.Registrar, Haryana Agriculture University, Hissar.

HIMACHAL PRADESH

69. Government of Himachal Pradesh. 70. Justice D.K. Mahajan Ex-Chief Justice, Punjab & Haryana High Court, Bhadwar. 71. Justice T.V.R. Tatachari Ex-Chief Justice, Delhi High Court, Lok Ayukta, Himachal Pradesh, Shimla. 72. Shri Hokisha Sema Governor, Himachal Pradesh, Shimla. 73. Dr. I.P. Massey Prof. & Head, Deptt. of Law

& Shri A.R. Chauhan,

Registrar, H.P. University, Shimla. 74. President, Democratic Socialist Party, Himachal Pradesh, Shimla. 75. Dr. Ranbir Sharma, Prof. & Head Department of Political Science, H.P. University, Shimla.

JAMMU & KASHMIR 76. Government of Jammu & Kashmir. 77. Dr. Arun K. Gupta Director, Model Institute of Education & Research, Jammu. 78. Dr. Farooq Abdullah Ex-Chief Minister, Jammu & Kashmir. (Forwarding a copy of Statement released by opposition parties after Srinagar Conclave).

KARNATAKA

79. Government of Karnataka.

80. Shri G.S. Sampat, IRS (Retd.), Bangalore. 81. Shri Kadidal Manjappa Ex-Chief Minister of Karnataka, Bangalore.

82. Shri B.S. Sambasiva Iyer, Retd. Under Secretary, Government of Karnataka,

Bangalore. 83. Shri K.N. Seshadri Reader, Post Graduate, Deptt. of Law, Karnataka University.

84. Smt. N.R. Ahalya Bangalore.

85. Dr. K. Raghavendra Rao Deptt. of Political Science, Karnataka University, Dharwad.

86. Dr. R.S. Narayan Advocate, Bangalore.

87. Shri N.K. Ganapaiah Secretary General, The Farmers' Federation of India, Saklaspur.

88. Dr. (Mrs.) Hemalata Rao Associate Professor, Economic Unit, Institute for Social & Economic Change, Bangalore.

89. Dr. G. Thimmaiah Director, Institute for Social & Economic Change, Bangalore.

90. Shri T. Devidas Reader and Shri P. Iswar Bhat Lecturer, Deptt. of Post Graduate Studies & Research in Law, University of Mysore. 91. Shri P.S. Appu, IAS (Retd.) Bangalore. 92. Shri R.B. Nadiger Kuppagadde, Shimoga Distt. 93. Registrar, Karnataka University, Dharwad. 94. Shri B.V. Naik Member of Parliament, Gonehalli, Via Madanageri. 95. Shri K.V. Sadashiviah Jayanagar, Bangalore. 96. Dr. B.K. Chandrashekhar, Prof. of Law, Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore. 97. Shri L. Srikantiah, Advocate, MLC (Retd.) Mysore. 98. Shri S. Subramaniam Former Director, Administrative Intelligence, Bangalore.

99. President,

Karnataka Rationalist Association, Bangalore.

100. Shri K.S. Narayan Advocate, Bangalore.

101. Secretary, Karnataka State Council of CPI, Bangalore.

102. Dr. M.C. Kodli Bangalore.

103. Shri M.Y. Ghorpade Former State Finance Minister, Sandur.

104. President, The Karnataka State Government, Employees Association, Bangalore.

105. Shri S. Sivappa Former Chairman, Karnataka Legislative Council, Bangalore.

106. Shri D.R. Venkataramanan N.R. Colony, Bangalore.

107. Dr. N.V. Ratnam Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore.

108. Shri P.K. Srinivasan Assistant Editor Deccan Herald, Bangalore.

109. President, Federation of Karnataka Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Bangalore.

110. Dr. N.S. Ramaswamy Director, Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore.

111. Shri K.H. Patil President, Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (I) Bangalore.

112. Shri N. Santosh Hegde Advocate General, Karnataka, Bangalore.

113. Shri Michael B. Fernandes Ex-MLC, Legislative Assembly, Bangalore.

114. Shri B.T. Parthasarthy Advocate, Bangalore.

115. President, Republican Party of India(K), Bhimshakthi, Belgaum.

116. Secretariat-Member, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Karnataka State Committee, Bangalore.

KERALA

117. Government of Kerala.

118. Shri M.V. Krishnan Nair Keecherry, Pappinisserri P.O., Cannanore.

119. Dr. C.N. Purushothaman Nair Prof. & Head, Department of Commerce & Management Studies, University of Calicut, Calicut.

120. Dr. N. Chendersekharan Pillai School of Management Studies and Prof. Dr. K.C. Sankaranarayanan Head of Department, Applied Economics, University of Cochin, Cochin.

121. Shri G. Ramanathan Retd. Principal of Training Colleges, Trivandrum.

122. Shri P.P. Pillai Reader and Head of Deptt. of Economics, Dr. John Mathai Centre, P.O. Aranattukara, Trichur.

123. Dr. K. Parameswaran Professor, Centre for Advanced Legal Studies and Research, Trivandram.

124. Shri P.S. Habeeb Mohamed Vice-Chancellor, University of Kerala, Trivandrum.

125. Dr. I.S. Gulati Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum and Dr. K.K. George School of Management Studies, University of Cochin, Cochin.

126. Prof. A. Vaidyanathan Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum.

127. Prof. Dr. M.V. Pylee Directore General (AIDE) Former Vice Chancellor, University of Cochin, Cochin. 128. Shri T. Madhava Menon, Vice-Chacellor, Kerala Agricultural University, Trichur. 129. Commissioner Corporation of Cochin, Ernakulam (Cochin). 130. Shri C.K. Kochukoshy, IAS (Redt.) Former Member, Board of Revenue and Chairman, Kerala State Electricity Board, Trivandrum. 131. Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer Former Judge of Supreme Court, Ernakulam. 132. Member-Secretariat Communist Party of India (Marxist),

Kerala State Committee, Trivandrum. 133. President, Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee (I), Trivandrum.

134.President, Janata Party, Kerala, Trivandrum.

135. General Secretary, Kerala Congress (J), Trivandrum.

136. General Secretary, Indian National Congress Party, Kerala Unit, Trivandrum.

137. Chairman, Kerala Congress (Mani Group), Trivandrum.

138. General Secretary, Praja Socialist Party, Trivandrum.

139. General Secretary Malayalee Desheeya Munnani, Cochin.

140. General Secretary Revolutionary Socialist Party, Kerala Committee, Trivandrum.

141. Secretary, State Committee of the Peasants & Workers Party of India (Kerala Unit), Trivandrum.

142. Vice-President, Kerala Pradesh Congress (Socialist) Committee, Ernakulam.

143. Shri N.A. Mammuhaji, MLA, (On behalf of Muslim League State Committee), Trivandrum.

144. General Secretary, Federation of State Employee & Teachers' Organisations, Kerala, Trivandrum.

145. Shri E. K. Nayanar, Leader of Opposition, Kerala Legislative Assembly, Trivandrum.

MADHYA PRADESH 146. Government of Madhya Pradesh.

147. Shri B. D. Sharma, Former Chief Minister Haryana and Governor of M.P., Bhopal.

148. President, Mahakoshal Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Jabalpur.

149. Dr. R. C. Shukla, Vice-Chancellor, Bhopal University, Bhopal.

150. Justice P.K. Tare, Ex-Chief Justice, M.P., Chairman, M.P. Law Commission, Bhopal.

151. Shri A.N. Saxena, President, MP Electricity, Inspectorate Engineer's Association, Bhopal. 152. Shri Ram Sahai Tiwari, Member Constituent Assembly and Ex. M.P., Chhattarpur.

153. Shri Ram Sahai, Member Constituent Assembly and Ex.-M.P., Vidisha.

154. Shri M. G. Malegaonker, Secretary, Congress Committee (I), Jabalpur.

155. Shri P. N. Sanaddar, Shastri Nagar, Gwalior.

156. Secretary, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Madhya Pradesh State Committee, Bhopal.

157. General Secretary, Madhya Pradesh Congress Committee (I), Bhopal.

MAHARASHTRA

158. Government of Maharashtra.

159. Shri Dilip Shantaram Dahanukar, Industrial Assurance Building, Churchgate, Bombay.

160. Shri V. S. Murti, Professor & Head of Deptt. of Public Admn., Nagpur University, Nagpur.

161. Deputy General Manager, Industrial Development Bank of India, Bombay.

162. Secretary, Bombay Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Bombay.

163. Shri S. Subbiah, Malad (West), Bombay.

164. The Registrar, Marathwada University, Aurangabad.

165. Shri D. R. Mandke, Editor Ajanta Express, Purna.

166. Shri Nani A Palkhivala, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court, Bombay.

167. Shri M. R. Masani, Member constituent Assembly, Bombay.

168. Dr. N. R. Inamdar, Professor & Head of Deptt. of Political Science and Public Admn., University of Poona,

Pune.

169. Shri Mohan Dharia, Ex-Union Minister, Pune.

170.Shri M. G. Bhasin, Professor & Head of Deptt. of Geography, DBF Dayanand College of Arts & Science, Solapur.

171. Prof. S. R. Ozarkar, Principal, Rajaram College, Kolhapur.

172. Vice-Chancellor, Marathawada Agriculture University, Parbhani.

173. Dr. Ankush B. Sawant, Convener, Indian Centre for Democratic Socialism Aurangabad.

174. Shri D. R. Pendse, Economic Advisor, Tata Industries, Bombay.

175. Shri A. G. Noorani, Nepean Sea Road, Bombay.

176. Acting Secretary, The Employers' Federation of India, Bombay.

177. Shri H. M. Seervai, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court, Bombay.

178. Shri Mohammad Rashid, Baramati, Pune.

179. Shri K. K. Shah, Former Union Member and Ex-Governor, Bombay.

180. Mr. B. C. Kamble, Ex-M.P. & Leader, Republican Party of India (Kambl) Bombay.

181. Dr. H. K. Paranjape, Professor, Indian Institute of Public Administration Research Fellow, Indian Council of Social Science Research, Pune.

182. Shri Sudhir Joshi, Ex-Mayor, Bombay.

183. Shri Shivraj Nakade, Principal, Dayanand College of Law, Latur.

184. Shri V. G. Rajadhyaksha, Member, Planning Commission, Chairman, High Level Committee on Power.

185. Dr. (Mrs.) Krishnabai Nimbkar, Pune.

MANIPUR

186. Government of Manipur.

MEGHALAYA 187. Government of Meghalaya.

188. Shri B. B. Lyngdoh, Leader of the Opposition, Ex-Chief Minister of Meghalaya, Shillong.

189. Chief Executive Member, Khasi Hills Autonomous, District Council, Shillong.

190. Shri R. Dutta, Planning Advisor, North Eastern Council Sectt., Shillong.

NAGALAND

191. Government of Nagaland.

192. President, Nagaland People Party, Kohima.

193. Shri Nihovi Sema, Ex-Minister, Chairman, Nagaland Ex-Parliamentarian Association, Mokokchung.

ORISSA 194. Government of Orissa.

195. Dr. Harekrushna Mehtab, Ex-Chief Minister, Orissa, Bhubaneswar.

196. Shri Nityanand Acharya, Agragami Karyalaya, Bolangir.

197. Dr. B. B. Jena, Prof. & Head of the Deptt. of Political Science, Berhampur University, Berhampur.

198. Shri R. K. Mishra, IAS, Orissa.

199. Shri S. K. Chattopadhyaya, Retd. Professor of Philosophy, Cuttuck.

200. Shri Tankadhan Mahapatra, Advocate, Dhenkanal.

201. Shri K. Ramamurthi, Vice-Chancellor, Orissa University of Agriculture & Technology, Bhubaneswar.

PUNJAB

202. Shri Fateh Singh Bagga, Jandiala Guru, Amritsar.

203. Prof. Dr. R. R. Sharma, Prof. & Head Deptt. of Biophysics, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, Chandigarh.

204. Shri S. A. Johl,

Vice-Chancellor, Punjab University, Patiala.

205.Shri Ajit Singh Sarhadi, Sr. Advocate, Chandigarh.

206. Shri Gian Chand, Sector 8-C, Chandigarh.

207. Shri Brij Bhushan Mehra, Ex-Speaker, Punjab Vidhan Sabha, Chandigarh.

208. Deptt. of Public Administration, Punjabi University, Patiala.

209. Shri K.T.S. Tulsi, Advocate, Chandigarh.

210. Shri Sham Singh Harikay, Advisor, Punjab Pradesh Congress Kisan Dal (I), Ludhiana.

RAJASTHAN 211. Government of Rajasthan.

212. Shri Agam Singh and Shri Sukh Lal Sharma, Jaipur.

213. Shri B. L. Panagariya, Member, Senate, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur.

214. Dr. M.C. Jain Kagzi, Professor, University Studies in Law, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur.

215. Shri Gokulbhai Bhatt, Member Constituent Assembly, Jaipur.

SIKKIM 216. Government of Sikkim. 217. Shri Nar Bahadur Bhandari, President, Sikkim Sangram Parishad, Gangtok.

TAMIL NADU

218. Government of Tamil Nadu.

219. Mrs. Vijayavalli, Srivilliputtur.

220. Shri V. V. Sundaresan, Freedom Fighter, Velappadi, Vellore.

221. Shri R. R. Dalavai, Convener, Civil Liberties Council, Madras.

222. Dr. K. P. Krishna Shetty, Advocate, Former Reader in Constitutional Law, University of Madras, Madras.

223. Registrar, Department of Economic Studies, Sociology and Political Science, Madurai Kamaraj University, Madurai.

224. Shri M. S. Vedanayagam, Former Senior Supervisor, Madras Telephones, Madras.

225. Shri K. S. Anandhan, Advocate, Gobichettipalayam, Distt. Periyar.

226. Shri N. T. Vanamamalai, Senior Advocate, High Court of Madras, Madras.

227. Secretary, Bar Council of Tamil Nadu, Madras.

228. Secretary, Hindustan Chamber of Commerce, Madras.

229. Shri B. Robert Gananamuthu, Political Advisor, Pattiveeranpatti, Madurai.

230. Shri G. Paramananthan, Jr. Assistant, Directorate of Medical Education, Madras.

231. General Secretary, Tamil Nadu Government Employees' Association, Madras.

232. Justice M.M. Ismail, Former Chief Justice, Madras High Court, Madras.

233. Shri D. Vaseekaran, President, All India Christian Party, Madras.

234. Shri M. Ramasamy, President, Annamandram, Madurai.

235. Shri M. P. Sivagnanam, President, Tamil Arasu Kazhagam, Madras.

236. Shri R. K. Balasubramanian, Chief Executive, Bureau for Parliamentary Work, Madras.

237. Shri M. Karunanidhi, President, Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, Madras.

238. Shri Sathyalaya P. Ramakrishnan, General Secretary. "Sathyalaya", Madras.

239. Shri R. Sankaran, Sivaprasad Industries,

Coimbatore.

240. Shri B. R. Guruswamy, Nehru Illam, Tiruchirapalli. 241. Dr. M. Naganathan, Reader, Deptt. of Economics, University of Madras. Madras.

242. Smt. Jothi Yencatachellum, Ex-Governor of Kerala, Cuddalore.

243. Shri R. S. Narayanaswamy, Retd. News Editor, The Indian Express, Madras.

244. Dr. Satyanarayana Moturi, Member Constituent Assembly, Madras.

245. President, Tamil Nadu Kamaraj Congress, Mylapore, Madras.

246. Shri O. V. Alagesan, Member Constituent Assembly & Former Union Minister, Madras.

247. General Secretary, Namadhu Kazhagam, Madras.

248. Shri P.C. Mathew, ICS (Retd.), Madras,

TRIPURA 249. Government of Tripura.

250. General Secretary, Tripura Government Employees' Federation, Agartala.

UTTAR PRADESH 251. Government of Uttar Pradesh.

252. Dr. P. Sharan, Retd. Principal, and Shri S.P. Dwivedi, Lecturer, Meerut College, Meerut.

253. Dr. C. M. Jariwala, Reader in Law, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi.

254. Dr. P.C. Mathur, Prof. of Economics (Retd.), L.B.S. National Academy of Administration, Mussoorie.

255. General Secretary, All India Vaishya Federation, Jwalapur, Distt. Saharanpur.

256. Shri Shyam Dhar Misra, Former Union Minister, Varanasi.

257. Shri L.D. Thakur, Head of Deptt. of Political Science, Lucknow University, Lucknow.

258. Dr. Shailendra Singh, Reader in Economics, Deptt. of Economics, Lucknow University, Lucknow.

259. Dr. Anirudh Prashad, Reader, Deptt. of Law, University of Gorakhpur, Gorkhpur.

260. Shri Sunder Lal Bahuguna, Chipko Information Centre, Tehri Garhwal.

261. Hony. Secretary, Institute for Constitutional and Parliamentary Studies, U.P. Regional Branch, Lucknow.

WEST BENGAL 262. Government of West Bengal.

263. Shri Dilip Suraana, Advocate, Calcutta High Court, Calcutta.

264. Shri Prafulla Chandra Sen, Former Chief Minister, West Bengal, Calcutta.

265. Shri Balai Chandra Ray, Senior High Court, Calcutta High Court, Calcutta.

266. Justice S.A. Masud (Retd.) Hony. Treasurer, Viswa Bharati, Calcutta.

267. Shri Somendra Chandra Bose, Sr. Advocate & President, Bar Association, High Court, Calcutta.

268. General Secretary, Bank Employees' Federation, West Bengal, Calcutta.

269. Shri S. P. Sen Verma, Former Chief Election Commissioner of India, Calcutta.

270. Shri Suhas Chattopadhyay, Economic Research Unit, Indian Statistical Institute, Calcutta.

271. Prof. Bhabatosh Datta, Emeritus Professor of Economics, Presidency College, Calcutta, and Former Member, Fourth Finance Commission.

272. Secretary, The Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Calcutta.

273.Shri Upendranath Barman, Member Constituent Assembly, Jalpaiguri. 274. Shri Prabhudayal Himatsingka, Member Constituent Assembly,

Calcutta. 275. President, Calcutta Chamber of Commerce, Calcutta. 276. Shri Annada Sankar Ray, LCS. (Retd.), Calcutta. 277. Smt. Renuka Ray, Member Constituent Assembly, Calcutta. 278. General Secretary, Revolutionary Socialist Party, Central Secretariat, Calcutta. 279. Shri Nakuleswar Banerjee, Advocate, Calcutta High Court, Calcutta. 280. Shri Atulya Ghosh, Calcutta. 281. Smt. Manjusri Mondal, Calcutta. 282. Shri Saroj Mukherjee, Secretary, West Bengal State Committee, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Calcutta. 283. President, Indian Association, Calcutta. 284. Shri S. R. Chakrabarti, Secretary (Retd.), Bengal National Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Calcutta. 285. President, West Bengal Headmasters' Association, Calcutta. 286. Dr. A. Sanyal (Vettadhish), Viswa Sanakrit Mission, Calcutta. 287. Shri Sanat Kumar Chakrabarty, Asstt. Teacher, Masat A.M. High School, Masat, Distt. Hooghly. 288. Secretary, Revolutionary Communist Party of India, West Bengal State Committee, Calcutta. 289. Shri Chittaranjan Bag, Advocate, Lecturer, Calcutta University, College of Law, Calcutta. 290. Dr. Biplab Dasgupta, Professor, University of Calcutta and Executive Vice-Chairman, West Bengal Comprehensive Area Development Corporation, Calcutta.

291. President, Bhartiya Janata Party, West Bengal, Calcutta.

292. General Secretary, Socialist Unity Centre of India,

Central Committee, Calcutta. 293. Shri Amit Jyoti Sen, Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta.

294. Secretary, Communist Party of India, West Bengal State Council, Calcutta.

295. Convener, Vritti Vikas, Calcutta.

UNION TERRITORIES DELHI

UON TERRITORIESDELHI

296. Shri Dharma Vira, I.C.S. (Retd.), Former Governor.

297. Shri E.M.S. Namboodiripad, Former Chief Minister (Karala).

298. Justice H. R. Khanna, Former Judge of the Supreme Court.

299. Hony. General Secretary, New Delhi Traders Association.

300. Executive Secretary, All India Panchayat Parishad.

301. Prof. Sher Singh, Former Union Minister of State.

302. Shri H. N. Bahuguna, Former Union Minister, President, Democratic Socialist Party.

303. Vice-Chairman, Deendayal Research Institute.

304. Dr. B. R. Kharlukhi, Member of Parliament.

305. Shri Vimal Dave, Advocate, Supreme Court.

306. Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha, General Secretary, Democratic Socialist Party.

307. Shri K. L. Moza, Editor, Bhartiya Post.

308. Shri P. Ramaswamy, Special Correspondent.

309. Dr. Nagendra Singh, Judge of the International Court of Justice, & Member of Constituent Assembly.

310. Prof. Ajit Kumar Sharma, Member of Parliament, (Rajya Sabha).

311. General Secretary, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Central Committee. 312.Shri Tarlok Singh, Former Member, Planning Commission.

313. Secretary,

Centre of India Trade Unions.

314. Shri G. Narsimha Reddy, Member of Parliament, (Lok Sabha)

315. Shri D. D. Malhotra, Reader, C.U.S. Indian Institute of Public Administration.

316. Secretary (Econ.), Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry.

317. General Secretary, All India Forward Bloc.

318. Shri Govind Narain, ICS (Retd.), Former Governor.

319. General Secretary, Communist Party of India, Central Office.

320. Secretary, All India Organisation of Employers.

321. Dr. Sushila Nayar, Former Union Minister.

322. Shri M. L. Dwivedi and Chaudhari Ranbir Singh, Members of Constituent Assembly.

323. Justice R. S. Narula, Retd. Chief Justice, Punjab & Haryana High Court.

324. Shri P. R. Dubhashi, IAS, Director, Indian Institute of Public Administration.

325. Shri Anil K. Nauriya, Advocate, Supreme Court.

326. General Secretary, All India State Government, Employees' Federation.

327. Shri S. Bhoothalingam, ICS (Retd.).

328. Justice S. Rangarajan, Sr. Advocate and Former Judge of the Delhi High Court.

329. Shri R.C.S. Sarkar, Former Chairman, UPSC, Government of India.

330. Secretary General, Indian Sugar Mills Association.

331. Prof. P. B. Desai, Professor, Institute of Economic Growth.

322. Justice Jaswant Singh, Former Judge, Supreme Court.

333. Shri Soli J. Sorabjee, Sr. Advocate, Supreme Court.

334. President, Janata Party.

335. Shri S. N. Manda, Director, Ambedkar Institute of Social Research & Training.

336. Smt. K. Rukmini Menon,

Former Ambassador.

337. President, Bhartiya Janata Party.

338. General Secretary, Lok Dal.

339. Prof. Dr. Raj Krishna, Former Member, Planning Commission & Former Member, Seventh Finance Commission.

340. Dr. Karan Singh, Former Union Minister.

341. General Secretary, All India Congress Committee (I).

342. Dr. S. R. Maheshwari, Professor of Political Science and Public Administration, Indian Institute of Public Administration.

343. Shri K. S. Sastry, Director of Audit, Office of the Comptroller & Auditor General of India.

344. Shri Raghukul Tilak, Former Governor.

345. General Secretary, All India Congress Committee (Socialist).

346. Secretary, Indian Administrative Service Association, New Delhi.

347. General Secretary, Indian Forest Service Association, New Delhi.

GOA, DAMAN & DIU 348. Government of Goa, Daman & Diu.

349. Miss Kastura Ravlu Naik, Thana Cortalim.

350. General Secretary, United Goans, Panjim.

351. President, Yuva Janata (Goa Unit), Panjim.

352. General Secretary, United Goans Party, Panjim.

353. General Secretary, Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha, (Goa, Daman & Diu).

354. Convener, Konkani Projecho Avaz, Panaji. 355. President, All Goa Youth Federation, Panaji.

356. President, Gomantak Bahujan Samaj Sanghatana, Panaji.

357. General Secretary, Konkani Lekhak Sangh, Panaji.

358. President,

Maharashtrawadi Gomantak, Panaji.

359. General Secretary, Gomant Lok Pokx, Panjim.

PONDICHERRY 360. Government of Pondicherry.

361. Shri S. Ramassamy, Former Chief Minister of Pondicherry, Pondicherry.

362. Shri M.O.H. Farook, Speaker, Legislative Assembly, Pondicherry.

363. Shri V. Narayanasamy, Member of Parliament.

364. Shri D. Ramachandran, Ex-Chief Minister, Pondicherry.

ANDAMAN & NICOBAR 365. Government of Andaman & Nicobar.

MISCELLANEOUS 366. Shri Rajeev Dhavan, Department of Law, Brunel University, Uxbridge, Middlesex, United Kingdom.

367. Col. Viron Jain, Commander, H.Q. 66, Mobile Depot, C/o. 99 APO.

368. Dr. Max Frenkel, Executive Director, Stiftung fur eidgenassische Zussammendrbeit, Hanptgasse 70, Switzerland.

369. Dr. M.A. Fazal, Principal Lecturer in Law, Trent Polytechnic, Notingham, UK.

UNION OF INDIA 370. Ministry of Agriculture.

371. Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilzers.

372. Ministry of Tourism & Civil Aviation (Department of Civil Aviation).

373. Ministry of Communication.

374. Department of Electronics.

375. Ministry of Energy. (Department of Power)

376. Ministry of Finance. (Department of Revenue). 377. Ministry of Food and Civil Supplies. 378. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. 379. Ministry of Home Affairs. 380. Ministry of Human Resource Development. (Department of Education). 381. Ministry of Industry. 382. Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.

383. Ministry of Labour. 384. Department of Ocean Development. 385. Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions.

386. Ministry of Planning. (Department of Statistics).

387. Planning Commission.

388. Ministry of Railways.

389. Ministry of Shipping and Transport.

390. Ministry of Social Welfare.

391. Ministry of Urban Development.

392. Ministry of Water Resources.

Supplementary List 393. President, Andhra Pradesh Congress Committee (I), Hyderabad.

394. Secretariat Member, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Andhra Pradesh State Committee.

395. The Karnataka United Urban Citizen, Federation (Regd.), Bangalore.

396. Mr. Justice G.K. Govinda Bhat, Former Chief Justice, Karnataka.

397. Shri H. Srikantiah, M.L.C. (Retd.), Bangalore.

398. Government of Punjab.

399. General Secretary, Shiromani Akali Dal, Shri Amritsar.

400. Citizenship Front in India, Delhi.

401. Chairman, All India Tribes and Minorities Federation, Shimla.

402. Shri Amar Singh Ambalvi, Advocate, Chandigarh.

403. 21st February Celebration Committee, Calcutta.

404. Shri J. Sarma Sarkar, Judge (Retd.), High Court, Calcutta.

405. President, Gandhi Kamraj National Congress, Madras.

APPENDIX VII—List of Individuals/Bodies who met the Commission

ANDHRA PRADESH (Hyderabad)

Government of Andhra Pradesh— represented by

1. Shri N.T. Rama Rao, Chief Minister.

2. Shri Shravan Kumar, Chief Secretary.

3. Shri S. Santhanam, Secretary, GAD & Officer on Special Duty.

4. Dr. Y. Venugopala Reddy, Secretary (Planning).

5. Shri K. Kosalram, Secretary (Finance).

6. Shri Sushil Kumar, Secretary (Industry, Commerce & Power)

7. Shri U.B. Raghavendra Rao, Secretary to Chief Minister.

8. Shri T.R. Prasad, Secretary (Irrigation).

9. Shri M.L. Sastry, Consultant, Finance.

10. Shri K. Obayya, Secretary (Political), GAD

11. Shri G.V. Narasimha Reddy, Director, Information & Public Relations.

12. Shri P.V. Ramakrishna, Special Secretary to the Chief Minister.

13. Shri V.B. Raju, Former Minister, A.P. & Ex-Member Rajya Sabha.

Prakasam Institute of Development Studies— represented by

14. Shri M. Ramakrishnaya, Former Dy. Governor, R.B.I.

15. Shri H.S. Guru Raja Rao.

16. Dr. T. Surayanarayana Rao.

17. Shri P. Purna Chandra Rao.

18. Shri M. Parthasarathy.

19. Shri P.S.R. Anjaneyulu.

20. Shri Sadiq Ali, Former Governor, Maharashtra & Tamil Nadu.

21. Shri B.P.R. Vithal, IAS (Retd.) Former Secretary, Finance Government of Andhra Pradesh.

22. Shri K. Ramachandra Reddy, Ex-Director General of Police, A.P.

23. Justice Alladi Kuppuswamy, Former Chief Justice, A.P.

24. Shri Vavilala Gopala Krishnayya, Former MLA, MLC, A.P.

25. Shri Akbar Ali Khan,

Ex-Governor, U.P. & Orissa.

26. Prof. M.A. Muttalib, Director, Regional Centre for Urban & Environmental Studies, Osmania University.

27. Shri K. Subramanya Reddy, Advocate General, A.P.

28. Shri M. Bagga Reddy, Leader of the Opposition.

29. Shri K. Brahmanada Reddy, Former Union Home Minister, Former President AICC, Ex-Chief Minister, A.P.

30. Shri Vijay Kumar Adwant, Lecturer in Economics, Vivek Vardhini College.

31. Shri Gurukula Mitra, President, Telugu National Liberation.

32. Shri D. Manuswamy, Secretary APCC.

33. Shri A. Veerappa, Former Minister, A.P.

34. Shri P. Narsa Reddy, Former President, APCC.

35. Shri N. Raghava Reddy, MLA, CPI(M).

36. Dr. C.P. Kasaiah, Reader in Econometrics, S.V. University, Tirupati.

37. Justice Gopal Rao Ekbote, Former Chief Justice, A.P.

38. Shri S.B. Nakade, Principal, Daya Nand College of Law, Latur (MS).

39. Shri E. Ayyapu Reddy, M.P., Leader, Telugu Desam Party.

A.P. Non-Gazetted Officers Association— represented by

40. Shri G. M. Kasi Viswanadham, President.

41. Shri E. Rama Rao, Associate President with eighteen members.

42. Shri M.V. Narayana Rao, Former Director General of Police, A.P.

43. Shri S.P.V. Reddy, Convener, Democratic Socialist Forum.

44. Shri V. Narsimha Rao, MLA.

45. Dr. (Mrs.) Shamim Aleem, Reader in Public Administration, Osmania University.

46. Dr. D. Ramachandram, Lecturer in Public Administration, Secunderabad.

47. Shri Avva Satyanarayana Rao, Advocate.

48. Justice C. Kondaiah, Former Chief Justice, A.P.

Jana Sabha (Telangana)— represented by

49. Shri Vandemataram Ramachandra Rao

50. Shri B. Kishan Lal

51. Shri Pratap Kishore

52. Shri G. Srinivas Reddy

Assam (Guwahati) Government of Assam— represented by

53. Shri H. Saikia, Chief Minister.

54. Shri D.R. Rangpi, Minister, Food & Civil Supplies.

55. Shri B. Barman, Minister, Health & Family Welfare.

56. Shri G. Rajbangshi, Minister, Agriculture.

57. Shri K. Gogai, Minister, Industries.

58. Shri T. Gogai, Minister, P. & C.D.

59. Shri J. Sinha, Minister, Transport.

60. Shri U.C. Das, Minister, Co-operation.

61. Shri M. Sharma, Minister, Education.

62. Shri J. Chaudhury, Minister, P.H.S.

63. Shri Sadhan Sarkar, Minister, Veterinary.

64. Shri A.K. Palit, Chief Secretary.

65. Shri J. Hazarika, Commissioner, Home. 66. Shri H.N. Das, Commissioner, P. & D. 67. Shri A. Bhattacharya, Commissioner, A.R. & Training. 68. Shri B. Barua, Agriculture Production Commissioner. 69. Shri P. Bora, Finance Commissioner. 70. Shri J. Changkokoti, Special Secretary, Hill Areas. 71. Shri T.K. Kamilla, Commissioner, Hills & Dev. Commissioner. 72. Shri P. Sengupta, Commissioner & Special Secretary, Transport. 73. Shri K.D. Lahkar, Commissioner, PWD. 74. Shri A.P. Singh, Secretary, Industries. 75. Shri K.C. Majumdar, Secretary, P. & C.D. 76. Shri U.C. Sarania, Special Secretary, W.P.T. & B.C.

77. Shri R. Dutta,

Special Secretary, Revenue.

78. Shri Md. Sadullah, Secretary, Legislative.

79. Shri B.C. Medhi, Secretary Flood Control.

80. Shri J.P. Rajkhowa, Secretary, Public Enterprises.

81. Shri B.C. Thahuria, Secretary, Power (Electricity).

82. Shri A. Chowdhury, Secretary, Irrigation.

83. Shri B. Gogoi, Secretary, PWD.

84. Shri A. Rahman Mandal, Joint Secretary, Law.

85. Shri B.K. Barua, Commissioner of Taxes.

86. Shri S.H. Choudhury, Joint Commissioner of Taxes.

87. Shri D. Das Gupta, Deputy Secretary, Finance.

88. Shri S. Dutta, Officer on Special Duty, Financial.

89. Shri Dinesh Goswami, Ex-MP representing Asom Jatiyatabadi Dol.

90. Shri Ajit Kumar Sharma, Ex-Member of Parliament.

91. Shri Bipan Pal Das, Chairman, Committee on 20-Point Programme.

92. Shri R.C. Choudhury, President, High Court Bar Association.

93. Shri Anup Kr. Das, Joint Secretary, High Court Bar Association.

94. Justice B.N. Barma Retd. Judge, Guwahati High Court.

95. Shri Gauri Shankar Bhattacharya, Ex-MLA, Assam.

Bihar (Patna)

Government of Bihar— represented by

96. Shri Bindeshwari Dubey, Chief Minister.

97. Shri Lahthan Choudhary, Minister of Agriculture.

98. Shri Dinesh Kumar Singh, Minister of Food.

99. Smt. Uma Pandey, Minister of Education.

100. Shri Harihar Mahto, Minister of Transport.

101. Shri Ram Ashray Pal Singh, Minister of Industries.

102. Prof. Sidheshwar Prasad, Minister of Energy.

103. Shri Mahabir Chaudhry, Minister of Urban Development. 104. Shri K.K. Srivastava, Chief Secretary. 105. Shri Bhaskar Banerjee, Secretary, Cabinet Coordination. 106. Shri H. Subramaniam, Private Secretary to Chief Minister. 107. Shri Arun Pathak, Finance Commissioner. 108. Shri H.K. Sinha, Joint Secretary, Finance. 109. Shri Raghuraj Singh, Joint Secretary, Civil Supplies. 110. Shri Pancham Lal, Special Secretary, Food & Civil Supplies. 111. Shri S.V. Saran, Industrial Dev. Commissioner. 112. Shri P. Mittal, Director, Industries.

113. Shri K.K. Sah, Additional Director, Industries.

114. Shri R.P. Sandwar, Special Secretary, Education.

115. Shri K. Vaidyanathan, Development Commissioner.

116. Shri Nishikant Sinha, Secretary, Agriculture.

117. Dr. Kedar Nath Kumar, Reader, Magadh University.

118. Dr. A.D. Roy Chowdhary, Head of Deptt. of Law, Patna University.

119. Shri Durga Nand Sinha, Director, A.N. Institute of Social Studies.

120. Shri V.P. Verma, Director, Jagjivan Ram Institute of Parliamentary Studies & Political Research.

121. Dr. Jagan Nath Mishra, Ex-Chief Minister of Bihar.

122. Prof. J.N. Tiwari, Head of Department of Economics, Patna University, Patna. 123. Shri Ram Balak Mahto, Advocate General, Bihar. 124. Prof. M.M. Sharma, Department of Political Science, University of Bihar, Muzaffarpur. 125. Dr. P.K. Jha, Head of Department of Economics, L.N. Mithila University, Darbhanga.

126. Shri Karpoori Thakur, Leader of Opposition, Ex-Chief Minister of Bihar.

127. Shri K.P. Varma, Advocate, Purnia.

128. Shri K.N. Sahay, Mayor, Patna.

Gujarat (At Delhi)

Government of Gujarat— represented by

129. Shri Amar Sinh Chaudhary, Chief Minister.

130. Shri Arvindbhai Sanghavi, Minister for Finance and Law.

131. Shri Nalinbhai Patel, Minister of State for Forest, Environment and Energy.

132. Shri R.V. Chandramouli, Chief Secretary.

133. Shri B.T. Trivedi, Additional Chief Secretary, Finance Department.

134. Shri P.M. Chauhan, Secretary, Legal Department.

135. Shri Arun Sinha, Resident Commissioner, Government of Gujarat, New Delhi.

136. Shri S.K. Duggal, Principal Secretary to Chief Minister.

137. Shri Balwant Singh, Secretary (Personnel), General Administration Department.

Haryana (At Delhi)

Government of Haryana— represented by

138. Shri Bhajan Lal, Chief Minister.

139. Shri Sagar Ram Gupta, Finance Minister.

140. Shri P.P. Caprihan, Chief Secretary.

141. Shri B.S. Ojha, Principal Secretary to the Chief Minister.

142. Shri M.C. Gupta, Financial Commissioner & Secretary, Finance, Irrigation and Power.

Himachal Pradesh (Shimla)

Government of Himachal Pradesh— represented by

143. Shri Virbhadra Singh, Chief Minister.

144. Shri Sukh Ram, PW Minister

145. Shri Guman Singh, Agriculture Minister.

146. Shri Sat Mahajan, Industries Minister.

147. Shri B.B.L. Khachi, Planning Minister.

148. Shri Vijendra Singh, Minister of State (Health).

149. Smt. Chandresh Kumari, Minister of State (Tourism).

150. Shri Sagar Chand Nair, Minister of State (Science & Technology).

151. Shri K.C. Pandeya, Chief Secretary.

152. Shri B.C. Negi, Financial Commissioner (Dev.).

153. Shri S.M. Kanwar, Financial Commissioner (Finance).

154. Shri Attar Singh, Financial Commissioner (Revenue).

155. Shri R.K. Anand, Financial Commissioner (Appeal).

156. Shri M.K. Kaw, Secretary (Education).

157. Shri A.K. Goswami, Principal Secretary to C.M.

158. Shri Harsh Gupta, Secretary (PWD).

159. Shri V.P. Bhatnagar, Secretary (Law).

160. Shri G.S. Chambial, Special Secretary (GAD).

161. Shri Yogesh Khanna, Director (HIPA).

162. Shri S.S. Madan, Deputy Secretary (GAD).

163. Shri S.K. Bedi, Press Secretary to CM.

164. Shri B.B. Tandon, Secretary (Planning).

165. Shri Shanta Kumar, Ex-Chief Minister, Leader of Opposition, H.P.

166. Shri D.R. Duggal, representing Lok Dal Party, H.P.

167. Shri J.C. Malhotra, Chairman, H.P. Public Service Commission.

168. Shri P.N. Nag, Advocate General, HP.

169. Shri Durga Chand, representing Democratic Socialist Party, HP.

170. Shri N.C. Pal, representing Bhartiya Janta Party, H.P.

171. Shri Bhawani Singh, Chairman, Bar Council, HP.

172. Shri K.S. Patyal, President, High Court Bar Association (HP).

173. Dr. G.C. Negi, Vice-Chancellor, Agriculture University, HP.

174. Shri A.R. Chauhan, Registrar, HP University.

175. Dr. I.P. Massey, Dean, Faculty of Law, H.P. University.

176. Dr. R.D. Sharma, Associate Professor, Public Administration, HP University.

177. Dr. Chander Pal, Associate Professor of Law,

H.P. University.

178. Shri T.V.R. Tatachari,

Former Chief Justice, Delhi High Court,

Lokayukt, H.P.

Jammu and Kashmir (At Delhi)

Government of Jammu and Kashmir— represented by

179. Shri Abdul Ahad Vikil, Law and Revenue Minister.

180. Shri Altaf Ahmad, Advocate General.

181. Shri Mohd. Yaseen Kawoosa, Law Secretary.

Karnataka (Bangalore)

Government of Karnataka— represented by

182. Shri Ramkrishna Hegde, Chief Minister.

183. Shri S.R. Bommai, Minister of Revenue, Planning & Institutional Finance.

184. Shri T.R. Satish Chandran, Chief Secretary.

185. Dr. D.M. Nanjundappa, Commissioner & Secretary to the State Government, Deptt. of Planning, Institutional Finance & Statistics.

186. Shri M. Sankaranarayanan, Finance Commissioner.

187. Shri R.K. Chamayya, Secretary, Deptt. of Law & Parliamentary Affairs.

188. Shri N. Gokul Rao, Joint Secretary to Chief Minister.

189. Shri G.S. Sampath, I.R.S. (Retd.), Bangalore.

190. Smt. N.R. Ahalya, Educationist, Bangalore.

191. Shri K.V. Sadashiviah, Retd. Defence Officer, Bangalore.

192. Shri B.T. Parthasarathy, Advocate, Bangalore.

193. Shri Shrikantiah, Advocate, Mysore.

194. Shri V. Krishnamurthy, Advocate, Bangalore.

195. Shri N. Santosh Hegde, Advocate General, Karnataka.

Advocate Association Bangalore— represented by

196. Shri H.K. Vasudev Reddy, President.

197. Shri Padma Raj, Secretary.

Janata Party State Unit—

represented by

198. Shri H.D. Deve Gowda, President. 199. Shri Shrikanthamurthy, Secretary. Bhartiya Janata Party State Unit— represented by 200. Shri B.B. Shivappa, President, 201. Shri Karambath Sanjeeva Setty, Secretary. 202. Shri Vasanta Kumar, Advocate & BJP Leader. 203. Shri S.B. Swetadri, Advocate & BJP Leader. 204. Shri S. Mallikarjuniah, Vice-President, BJP & MLC.

205. Shri Yadiyurappa, MLA, BJP. Karnataka State Council, Communist Party of India— represented by

206. Shri M.S. Krishnan, MLA, Secretary.

207. Shri P. Raman, Asstt. Secretary.

208. Shri M.C. Venkataraman, Member of Sectt., CPI State Unit.

209. Shri M.C. Narasimhan, Member of Sectt., CPI State Unit.

210. Shri K.B. Shanappa, MLA, Member of Sectt., CPI State Unit.

211. Shri H.V. Anantha Subba Rao, Member, of Sectt., CPI State Unit. Communist Party of India (Marxist)— represented by

212. Shri S. Suryanarayana Rao, Sectt. Member (CPI M) State Unit.

123. Shri G.N. Nagaraja, Secretary Legislature Party, Communist Party (Marxist).

214. Shri M.Y. Ghorpade, Former Finance & Industries Minister, Karnataka. Karnataka Pradesh Congress(I) Unit— represented by

215. Shri K.N. Patil, President.

216. Shri N.K. Ganapaiah, General Secretary Farmers' Federation of India (Saklaspur).

217. Shri Kadidal Manjappa, Former Chief Minister.

218. Dr. K.S. Krishnaswamy, Former Dy. Governor, RBI. 219. Shri T. Devidas, Reader, Deptt. of Post-Graduate Studies and Research in Law, Mysore University.

220. Shri Ishwar Bhatt, Lecturer, Mysore University.

221. Prof. K. H. Cheluva Raja, Deptt. of Political Science, Bangalore University.

222. Dr. N. S. Ramaswamy, Director, Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore.

223. Prof. V.K. R. V. Rao, Former Union Minister, Former Member, Planning Commission & Academician.

224. Shri N. Lakshman Rau, President, Karnataka United Urban Citizens' Federation.

225. Prof. M. D. Nanjundaswamy, President, Board of Directors, Principal, College of Law, Socio-Legal Services & Research Centre, Bangalore.

226. Shri Michael Fernandez, Former MLA, Bangalore.

227. Shri P. S. Appu, IAS (Retd.) Former Director, Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Administration, Mussoorie. Karnataka State Employees Federation— represented by

228. Shri K. A. Keshavamurthy, President.

229. Shri P. M. Puttaswamy, Vice-President.

230. Shri T. V. Raghavan, Joint Secretary.

231. Shri S. M. Gurulingasamy, Joint Secretary.

232. Shri M. T. Krishnappa, Joint Secretary.

233. Shri Syed Basheer Ahmad, Treasurer.

234. Shri H. N. Sesha Gowda, Organising Secretary.

235. Shri Chaluva Raju, Auditor.

236. Shri H. Manumanthappa, Cultural Secretary.

237. Dr. G. Thimmaiah, Director, Institute for Social & Economic Change, Bangalore.

238. Dr. (Mrs.) Hemalata Rao, Associate Professor, Institute for Social & Economic Change, Bangalore.

239. Dr. Amal Ray, Associate Professor, Institute for Social & Economic Change, Bangalore.

240. Dr. V. M. Rao, Associate Professor, Institute for Social & Economic Change, Bangalore.

241. Shri B. V. Naik, Ex-M.P.

242. Shri Thallam Nanjunda Shetty, President, Karnataka Chamber of Commerce & Industry.

243. Shri S. Sivappa, Former Chairman, Karnataka Legislative Council.

244. Shri H. Srikantiah, Ex-MLC.

245. Shri N.V. Rathnam, Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore.

246. Shri Basavalingappa Former Minister Karnataka, Bangalore.

247. Shri G. R. Suryanarayana, President, Karnataka Unaided Schools Management Association.

248. Dr. G. V. K. Rao IAS (Retd.) Former Chief Secretary & Former Member of Planning Commission,

249. Justice G. K. Govinda Bhat, Former Chief Justice, Karnataka.

250. Shri C. M. Poonacha, Former Governor and Member of Constituent Assembly.

251. Shri B. S. Sambasiva Iyer, Retd. Under Secretary

252. Shri P. K. Srinivasan, Asstt. Editor, Deccan Herald.

253. Shri N. Srinivasa Rau, Retd. Chief Justice Karnataka.

254. Shri B. V. Krishnamurthy, Economist, Bangalore.

255. Dr. K. Raghavendra Rao, Head of Department of Political Science, Karnataka University, Dharwad.

256. Shri B. D. Jatti, Former Vice-President of India.

KERALA (Trivandrum)

Government of Kerala— represented by

257. Shri K. Karunakaran, Chief Minister.

258. Shri K.M. Mani, Minister for Finance & Law.

259. Shri M.P. Gangadharan, Minister for Irrigation.

260. Shri K. Sivadasan, Minister of Labour

261. Smt. M. Kamalam, Minister for Co-operation.

262. Shri C.M. Sundaram, Minister for Local Administration.

263. Shri N. Sreenivasan, Minister for Excise.

264. Shri T. M. Jacob, Minister for Education.

265. Shri N. Sundaram Nadar, Minister for Transport.

266. Shri K. Avakadakutty Naha, Dy. Chief Minister.

267. Shri R. Gopalaswamy, Chief Secretary.

268. Shri V. Ramachandran, Economic Development Commissioner.

269. Shri M. Dandapani, Commissioner & Secretary, GAD

270. Shri K. Sreedharan, Law Secretary.

271. Shri K.V. Rabindran Nair, Finance Secretary, Kerala State Planning Board— represened by 272. Shri Sathyapal, Vice-Chairman, Planning Board. 273. Dr. P. K. Gopalakrishnan, Member, Planning Board. 274. Shri V. R. Pilai,

Member, Planning Board 275. Dr. O. P. Warrier, Member, Planning Board. 276. Shri S. Vardhachary, Member, Planning Board. 277. Shri E. K. Nayanar, Ex-Chief Minister & Leader of the Opposition. 278. Dr. I. S. Gulati, Former Member, Finance Commission, Senior Fellow, Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum. 279. Dr. K. K. George, Institute for Management Studies. Cochin University. 280. Dr. K. G. Adiyodi, Chairman, PSC, Kerala. 281. Shri G. Ramanathan, Retd. Principal, Training College, Trivandrum. 282. Shri K.P. Madhavan Nair, Former President, Kerala Predesh Congress Committee. 283. Dr. M.V. Pylee, Director General (AIDE) Former VC, Cochin University. 284. Shri C.K. Kochukoshy, IAS Retd. Former Member, Board of Revenue & Chairman Kerala State Electricity Board. 285. Dr. K. Paramaswaran, Professor, Centre for Advanced Legal Studies & Research, Trivandrum.

286. Prof. A. Vaidyanathan, Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum.

287. Shri V.P. Gopalan Nambiar, Retd. Chief Justice of Kerala.

All India Muslim League— represented by

288. Shri M.A. Hammu Haji,

Revolutionary Socialist Party— represented by

289. Shri Baby John.

290. Shri K. Pankajakshan. Communist Party of India (State Unit)— represented by

291. Shri P.S. Srinivasan.

292. Shri K.V. Surendranath. Communist Party of India (Marxist) (State Unit)— represented by

293. Shri Ramachandra Pillai. Congress(I) (State Unit)— represented by

294. Shri M.M. Jacob, Joint Secretary, MP

295. Shri C.B. Padmarajan, President.

296. Dr. Gopalakrishna, Adviser, Economic Committee.

297. Shri Ganga Dharan, General Secretary, SRP. National Democratic Party— represented by

298. Shri T. N. Upendranathan.

299. Shri Raghuvira Pillai,

Praja Socialist Party— represented by

300. Shri Madhavan Nair, General Secretary.

301. Shri G. Ashok Pillai, General Secretary.

302. Shri Peroorkada Sasi, STUC secy.

303. Shri A. Kochukarapan, Harijan Sabha.

304. Shri J. Rajendran, Secy. Harijan Sabha,

Kerala Congress (Socialist)— represented by

305. Shri K.K. Madhavan, Vice-President.

306. Shri K.S. Sankaranarayana, General Secretary.

307. Shri A.K. Basheendran.

Janata Party, Kerala— represented by

308. Shri P. Viswambharan, MLA President.

309. K.C. Chandrasekharan, MLA,

Indian National Congress— represented by

310. Shri Amaravile Krishnan Nair, Malayalea Desheeya Munnani— represented by

311. Shri J.F. Kuriyan, General Secretary.

312. Shri N. Vikraman Nair, Jt. Secretary.

313. Shri T. Rajan V. Nath.

314. Shri N. Neelakantan Nair, Federation of State Employees & Teachers Organisation— represented by

315. Shri K.V. Devadas.

316. Shri P. Venugopalan Nair.

317. Shri P. Anandan.

318. Shri K. Prabhakaran.

319. Shri P. K. Gopinathan Nair.

320. Shri G. Somasekharan Nair, Kerala Congress(J)— represented by

321. Shri T.M. Jacob, Minister for Education.

322. Shri T.S. John, MLA, General Secretary.

323. Prof. Joseph Skariah.

324. Shri S. Surendran Pillai, MLA.

325. Shri M.S. Madhusudan, Editor, Kerala Kaumudi. 326. Dr. Habeed Mohd., VC, Kerala University.

327. Dr. Madhavan Menon Nair, VC., Kerala Agriculture University.

328. Dr. K.T. Chandy, Former Chairman State Planning Board, Kerala.

329. Smt. Leela Damodra Menon, Former M.P.

MADHYA PRADESH (Bhopal)

Government of Madhya Pradesh— represented by 330. Shri Arjun Singh, Chief Minister. 331. Shri Shiva Bhanu Solanki, Dy. Chief Minister.

332. Shri Krishnpal Singh, Law Minister. 333. Shri Jhunuklal Bhendia, Finance Minister. 334. Dr. Rajendra Jain, Minister for Industries. 335. Shri Digvijay Singh. Minister for Major and Medium Irrigation.

336. Shri Motilal Vora, Minister for Higher Education. 337. Capt. Jaipal Singh, Dy. Minister GAD. 338. Shri Brahma Swarup, Chief Secretary. 339. Shri M.S. Singh Deo, Additional Chief Secretary. 340. Shri M.R. Sivaraman, Finance Secretary. 341. Shri R.C. Jain, Secretary Agriculture. 342. Shri V.C. Nigam, Secretary, GAD. 343. Shri S.C. Gupta, Secretary, GAD. 344. Shri A.C. Qureshi, Law Secretary. 345. Shri Ashok Vajpeyi, Secretary Education. 346. Shri Manish Behl, Secretary Commerce & Industries. 347. Shri L.N. Meena, Special Secretary, GAD. 348. Shri K. B. Sharma, Home Secretary. 349. Shri N.R. Krishnan, Secretary to CM. 350. Smt. M.V. Garde, Secretary Food & Civil Supplies. 351. Shri A.D. Mohile, Deputy Secretary, Commerce & Industries. 352. Shri N.B. Lohani, Secretary Tribal Welfare. 353. Shri Sandip Banerjee, Special Secretary, Publicity.

354. Shri Kailash Joshi, Ex-Chief Minister, Madhya Pradesh.

355. Shri Ram Sahay Tiwari, Member Constituent Assembly.

356. Shri Kalu Ram Virulakar, Member, Constitutent Assembly, Ex-MLA, Advocate.

357. Justice P.K. Tare, Ex-Chief Justice, MP.

358. Shri M.B. Malhotra, Vice-chancellor, Sagar University.

359. Dr. K.K. Tiwari, Vice-Chancellor, Jiwaji University, Gwalior.

360. Shri D.R. Sharma, Vice-Chancellor,

Vikram University, Ujjain.

361. Shri S.C. Behar, Vice-Chancellor Guru Ghasi Ram University, Bilaspur.

362. Shri S.B. Arya, Vice-Chancellor, Jawahar Lal Nehru University, Jabalpur.

363. Shri R.C. Shukla, Vice-Chancellor, Bhopal University.

364. Shri B.K. Srivastava, Vice-Chancellor, Ravi Shankar University, Raipur. M.P. Congress Committee(I)— represented by

365. Shri Lalit Srivastava, General Secretary. Communist Party of India, M.P. Unit— represented by

366. Shri Homi Daji, Secretary, Communist Party of India (M), MP— represented by

367. Shri Moti Lal Sharma, Secretary.

368. Shri Shailendra Shailly, Secretary, MP Electricity Inspectorate Engineer Association— represented by

369. Shri A.N. Saxena, President.

MAHARASHTRA (Bombay) Government of Maharashtra— represented by

370. Shri Shivajirao Patil Nilangekar, Chief Minister.

371. Shri Jawaharlal Darda, Minister for Energy, Cultural Affairs, Prohibition & Excise.

372. Shri Shivajirao Deshmukh, Minister for Irrigation and Food and Civil Supplies.

373. Shri Vijayasinh Mohite Patil Minister for Agriculture, CADA, Rehabilitation, Sports, Youth Welfare.

374. Shri Sudhakarrao Naik, Minister for Industries, Revenue & Social Welfare.

375. Shri Sushil Kumar Shinde, Minister for Finance, Planning & Environment.

376. Dr. V. Subramanyan, Repairs & Reconstruction.

377. Shri Narendra Tidke, Minister for Co-operation, Labour and Legislative Affairs.

378. Shri Ramachandra Rao Patil, Minister of State for Law & Judiciary, Technical Education, Employment, Energy, Prohibition and Excise.

379. Shri. B.G. Deshmukh, Chief Secretary.

380. Shri B.K. Halve, Additional Chief Secretary.

381. Shri B.K. Choughle, Additional Chief Secretary.

382. Shri S.G. Kale, Secretary to Chief Minister.

383. Shri P.V. Nayak, Secretary (Personnel) GAD. 384. Shri N.R. Ranganathan, Secretary (Law & Order), H.D.

385. Shri N. Raghunathan, Secretary (I) F.D.

386. Shri K.G. Paranjape, Secretary (P.D.)

387. Shri V.T. Chari, Secretary R& F.D.

388. Shri V.B. Chavan, Secretary, Law & Judiciary Deptt., R.L.A.

389. Shri K. Rajan, Secretary,

(Coop). A. & C.D.

390. Shri Ashok Basak, Secretary, (Coop.), A. & C.D.

391. Shri D.K. Afzulpurkar, Secretary, Housing.

392. Shri M.R. Kolhatkar, Secretary (Education), Ednl. & Empl. Department.

393. Shri R.T. Atre, Secretary P.W. Deptt.

394. Shri N.A. Palkhivala, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court.

395. Shri A.G. Noorani, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court.

396. Shri H.M. Seervai, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court.

397. Dr. P.R. Brahmananda, Prof. of Economics, University of Bombay, Bombay.

398. Shri Mohan Dharia, Ex-Union Minister, Poona. Employers' Federation of India— represented by

399. Shri Naval Tata, President Emeritus.

400. Shri Pratap Bhogilal, Vice-President.

401. Shri N. Ahmed, Adviser.

402. Shri V.B. Mahatme Ag. Secretary.

Bombay Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BCCI)— represented by

403. Shri Ashok B. Garware,

President.

404. Shri N.M. Desai, Vice-President. 405. Shri D.P. Mehta. 406. Shri T. Pooran. 407. Prof. Gangadhar Gadgil. 408. Shri N.C. Mehta. 409. Shri B.P. Gunaji, Secretary.

410. Shri S.M. Billimoria, Asstt. Secretary.

Republican Party of India (Kamble)— represented by

411. Shri B.C. Kamble, Ex-Member of Lok Sabha.

412. Dr. H.K. Paranjape, Economist & Ex-Member MRTP, Pune.

413. Shri Dilip S. Dahanukar, Engineer & Author in Planning Bombay.

414. Prof. S.R. Ozarkar, Academician & Economist, Principal, Raja Ram College, Kolhapur.

415. Shri V.G. Rajadhyaksha, Economist & Former Member, Planning Commission.

Industrial Development Bank of India (IDBI)—Bombay— represented by

416. Dr. S.A. Dave, Executive Director.

417. Shri R.H. Patil, General Manager.

418. Shri A.L. Dias, Ex-Governor, West Bengal, Bombay.

419. Shri K.K. Shah, Ex-Governor, Tamil Nadu, Bombay.

420. Shri M.R. Masani, Member, Constituent Assembly, Bombay.

421. Shri Morarji Desai, Former Prime Minister of India, Bombay.

MANIPUR (At Delhi)

Government of Manipur— represented by

422. Shri Rishang Keishing Chief Minister.

423. Shri D.N. Barua, Chief Secretary.

MEGHALAYA (Shillong)

Government of Meghalaya— represented by

424. Shri W.A. Sangma, Chief Minister.

425. Shri D.D. Labeng, Home Minister.

426 Shri R. Lyngdoh, P.W.D. Minister

427. Shri R.C. Laloo, Education Minister.

428. Shri S.K. Marak, Health Minister.

429. Shri O. Lyngdoh, Agriculture Minister

430. Shri J.C. Nampui, Chief Secretary.

431. Shri R. V. Lyngdoh, Additional Chief Secretary.

432. Shri Dilip Singh, Financial Commissioner. 433. Shri R.V. Pillai, Development Commissioner.

434. Shri K.K. Sinha, Special Secretary Political

435. Shri S.N. Phukan, A.J.S., Law.

436. Shri M.I.S. Iyer, Inspector General of Police.

437. Shri N. Goswami, Chief Conservator of Forests.

438. Shri B.B. Lyngdoh, M.L.A., Leader of Opposition and Former Chief Minister. North Eastern Council— represented by

439. Shri P.H. Trivedi, Secretary.

440. Shri R. Datta, Planning Adviser.

Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council (KHADC)— represented by

441. Shri H.S. Lyngdoh, Chief Executive Member.

442. Shri B.R. Giri, Secretary, Executive Committee. Meghalaya Pradesh Congress Committee— represented by

443. Dr. B.B. Dutta, General Secretary.

444. Shri U. Kharbuli, General Secretary East Khasi Hills District Congress Committee— represented by

445. Shri Mohan Singh, President. Shillong City Congress Committee— represented by

446. Shri R.T. Rymbai, President.

NAGALAND (Kohima)

Government of Nagaland— represented by

447. Shri S.C. Jamir, Chief Minister.

448. Dr. H.V. Sakhrie, Minister (Medical).

449. Shri Kariba, AO Minister (Forest).

450. Shri K.L. Chishi, Minister (Education).

451. N.I. Namir, Minister (Planning).

452. Shri Chongshen, Minister (PHE)

453. Shri Rethrong, Minister (Transport)

454. Shri Puse, Minister (I&P)

455. Shri J. Khenoto Sema, Minister (Agriculture).

456. Shri Shikiho, Minister (Rural Development)

457. Shri T.A. Ngullie, Minister (Finance).

458. Shri Tiameran, Minister (Industry)

459. Shri I. Long Kumer, Chief Secretary.

460. Shri S.S. Ahluwalia, Finance Commissioner.

461. Shri L. Colney, Commissioner & Secretary (AH & Vet.).

462. Shri Abong Imllong,

Commissioner Secretary (Medical).

463. Shri T.C.K. Lotha, Development Commissioner & Secretary (Plg.).

464. Shri R.S. Pandey, Secretary (Industry).

465. Shri Daniel Kent, Home Commissioner.

466. Shri V. Zao, Commissioner & Secretary (Home).

467. Shri R. Ezung, Commissioner & Secretary (Soil Conservation).

468. Shri S.B. Chetri, Secretary (Education).

469. Miss I. Chubala, Secretary (Social Welfare).

470. Shri C.N. Ngullie, Commissioner & Secretary (Agriculture).

471. Shri Imkongmar Aier, Secretary (Supply).

472. Shri Lalhuma, Additional Secretary (Forest).

473. Shri Anil Kumar, Additional Secretary (Education).

474. Shri Talitemjen, Additional Secretary (Geology & Mining).

475. Shri J.P. Imchen, Additional Secretary (Transport).

476. Shri A.K. Biswas, Additional Secretary (Home).

477. Shri Darshan Singh, O.S.D. (Law).

478. Shri R.S. Bedi, Joint Secretary (Law).

479. Shri Imtikunzuk, Joint Secretary, (P & AR).

480. Shri Vizol, Former Chief Minister, Nagaland.

481. Shri Shorhozelie, Former Minister of Education.

Nagaland Peoples Party— represented by

482. Shri Kuska Sumi,

Chairman and Former Minister of Agriculture.

483. Shri Neikhotso Liny, Public Secretary.

484. Shri Kipfelhou Angami, Memeber.

485. Shri T.N. Angami, Former Chief Minister, Nagaland.

486. Shri M. Vero, Former Member Rajya Sabha.

487. Shri Khyamolotha, Former Member Rajya Sabha.

ORISSA (Bhubaneswar)

Government of Orissa—

represented by 488. Shri J.B. Patnaik, Chief Minister. 489. Shri Gian Chand, Chief Secretary. 490. Shri Gangadhar Mahapatra, Minister, Finance and Law. 491. Shri L.I. Parija, Addl. Chief Secretary. 492. Shri A.K. Ray, Addl. Dev. Commissioner & Secretary, Plg. & Coord. 493. Shri R.N. Das, Secretary, Home. 494. Shri R.K. Bhujabal, Secretary, Finance. 495. Shri S.B. Mishra, Secretary, Industry. 496. Shri B.C. Kanungo, Secretary, Law. 497. Dr. Chakradhar Mishra, Special Secretary, Plg. & Coord. 498. Smt. C. Narayanaswamy, Special Secretary, G.A.D. 499. Shri A.R. Nanda, Secretary to Chief Minister. 500. Shri Devdas Chhotray, Addl. Secretary, Home.

501. Smt. Nandini Sathpathi, Former Chief Minister, Orissa.

502. Shri Biju Patnaik, former Chief Minister, Orissa.

503. Shri Hare Krushna Mehtab, Former Chief Minister, Orissa.

504. Shri K. Ramamurthy, Vice-Chancellor, Agriculture University, Orissa.

RAJASTHAN (At Delhi) Government of Rajasthan— represented by

505. Shri Harideo Joshi, Chief Minister.

506. Shri V.B.L. Mathur, Chief Secretary. 507. Shri T.V. Ramanan, Secretary (Finance).

508. Shri Rajinder Jain, Secretary (Irrigation)

509. Shri H.R. Bhansani, Secretary (Law).

510. Shri D.R. Mehta, Secretary to Chief Minister.

511. Shri D.C. Samant, Special Secretary (Planning)

TAMIL NADU (Madras) Government of Tamil Nadu— represented by 512. Dr. M.G. Ramachandran, Chief Minister.

513. Dr. V.R. Nedunchezian,

Minister for Finance.

514. Shri S. Ramachandran, Minister for Electricity.

515. Shri R.M. Veerappan, Minister for Tourism & Religious Endowments.

516. Shri K. Rajaram, Minister for Industries.

517. Shri K.A. Krishnasamy, Minister for Labour.

518. Shri P.U. Shanmugam, Minister for Local Administration.

519. Shri C. Arranganayagam, Minister for Education.

520. Dr. K. Kalimuthu, Minister for Agriculture.

521. Shri C. Ponnaiyan, Minister for Law.

522. Shri S. Muthusamy, Minister for Transport.

523. Shri S. Thirunavukkarasu, Minister for Food.

524. Shri V.V. Swaminathan, Minister for Excise, Handloom & Textiles.

525. Shri R. Soundararajan, Minister of Nutritious Meals.

526. Shri T. Veerasamy, Minister for Commercial Taxes.

527. Shri N. Nallusamy, Minister for Housing.

528. Shri Anoor P.G. Jagadeesan, Minister for Rural Industries.

529. Shri T. Ramasamy, Minister for Rehabilitation & Employment.

530. Shri A. Arunachalam, Minister for Adi Dravidar Welfare.

531. Shri M.R. Govendhan, Minister for Backward Class.

532. Smt. Vijayalakshmi Palanisamy, Minister for Khadi.

533. Smt. Gomati Srinivasan, Minister for Social Welfare.

534. Shri K.K.S.S.R. Ramachandran, Minister for Co-operation.

535. Shri T.V. Antony, Chief Secretary to the Government.

536. Shri U.S. Natarajan, Commissioner & Secretary to Government.

537. Shri S. Vadivelu, Commissioner & Secretary to Govt., Law Department.

538. Shri Ramachandran, Commissioner & Secretary to Govt., Finance Department.

539. Shri S. Guhan, Director, Madras Institute of Development Studies, Madras.

540. Shri M. Bakthavatchalam, Former Chief Minister, Tamil Nadu.

Tamil Arasu Kazhagam— represented by

541. Shri M.P. Sivagnanam, and 2 office bearers. 542. Smt. Jothivenkatachalam, Former Governor, Kerala. 543. Shri K. Krishnamoorthy, Advocate General. 544. Justice M.M. Ismail, Former Chief Justice, Madras High Court.

Namadhu Kazhagam— represented by

545. Shri S.D. Somasundaram, & 5 other office bearers.

546. Shri K.S. Anandhan, Advocate, Gobichettipalayam, Distt. Pariyar.

547. Dr. Satyanarain Motturi, Member, Constituent Assembly, Madras.

548. Shri O.V. Alagesan, Former Union Minister and Member of Constituent Assembly.

549. Shri P.C. Mathew, ICS(Retd.), Madras.

President of All India Christian Party— represented by

550. Shri D. Vaseekaran.

D.M.K., Party— represented by

551. Shri Murasoli Maran, M.P.

552. Shri Sadiq Pasha, M.L.C., Treasurer of D.M.K. Party.

553. Shri K. Manoharan, M.L.A.

554. Shri N.V.N. Somu, M.P.

555. Shri Veerasamy, Ex-M.L.A.

556. Shri Dhandapani, Ex-M.P.

557. Shri Kandappan, Ex-M.P.

558. Shri C. Subramaniam, Former Union Minister and Member of the Constituent Assembly.

559. Shri N.T. Vanamamalai, Senior Advocate, Madras High Court.

560. Shri Thanjai V. Ramamurthy, Representing Tamil Nadu Kamraj Congress.

TRIPURA (Agartala)

Government of Tripura—

represented by

561. Shri Nripan Chakravarti, Chief Minister.

562. Shri Jogesh Chakraborty, Minister for Jail & Rehabilitation.

563. Shri Badal Choudhury, Minister for Agriculture.

564. Shri Arber Rahman, Minister for Forest.

565. Shri Sundhanwa Deb Barma, Minister for Co-operation

566. Shri I.P. Gupta, Chief Secretary.

567. Shri H. Das, Law Secretary.

568. Shri S.R. Sinha, Deputy Secretary (Law).

569. Shri A.K. Deb, Secretary, Education.

570. Shri S. Chattopadhay, Secretary, PWD.

571. Shri K.B. Bhattacharya, Deputy Secretary (Finance).

572. Shri Naresh Chander, Commissioner Tribal Welfare.

573. Shri R.N. Chakrabarty, Commissioner Industry & Labour.

574. Shri C.S. Samal, Commissioner Agriculture, Forest & ICAT.

575. Shri J.L. Roy, Commissioner Local Self Government.

576. Shri D. Roy, Secretary Transport.

State Government, CPI(M)— represented by

577. Shri Bhanu Ghosh, Secretary

578. Shri Manik Sarkar

579. Shri Sudarshan Bhattacharji, Representing RSD.

State Committee Forward Block— represented by

580. Shri Brajo Gopal Roy, Secretary

Pradesh Congress Committee (Tripura)— represented by

581. Shri Sudhir Ranjan Majumdar, Secretary.

Tripura Government Employees Federation— represented by

582. Shri Sibendra Bhattacharjee, General Secretary.

583. Shri Sunil Choudhuri.

584. Shri Pritosh Debbarma

585. Shri Nani Gopal Saha. 586. Shri Amelendu Dey. 587. Smt. Sadhana Sinha. 588. Smt. Santi Biswas.

UTTAR PRADESH (Lucknow)

Government of Uttar Pradesh— represented by 589. Shri Veer Bahadur Singh, Chief Minister. 590. Dr. Sanjay Singh, Transport Minister. 591. Shri Sibte Rizvi, Education Minister. 592. Shri J.A. Kalyanakrishan, Chief Secretary. 593. Shri M. Vardarajan, Agriculture Production Commissioner. 594. Shri J.P. Singh, Finance Secretary. 595. Shri B.N. Tiwari, Planning Secretary. 596. Shri Mahesh Prasad, Principal Secretary (Industries).

597. Shri S.A.T. Rizvi, Secretary (Industries). 598. Shri V.K. Dixit, Secretary (Irrigation). 599. Shri K.K. Chaube, Additional Secretary (Law). 600. Shri Shahzad Bahadur, Special Secretary. 601. Shri P.P. Agarwal, Joint Secretary (Finance). 602. Shri Narain Das, Joint Secretary (Law). 603. Shri R.S. Mathur, Secretary to Chief Minister. 604. Shri Chandra Pal, Special Secretary (Education). 605. Shri H.M. Sharan, Joint Secretary (Food). 606. Shri H.C. Gupta, Special Secretary (Personnel). 607. Shri Rajeev Kher, Joint Secretary (Appointment). 608. Dr. Anirudh Prasad, Reader in Law, Gorakhpur University, Gorakhpur.

609. Dr. C.M. Jariwala, Reader in Law, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi.

610. Shri T.S. Papola, Director, V.V. Giri Institute of Development Studies, Lucknow.

611. Shri D.K. Bhattacharya, Former Chief Secretary, U.P. Varanasi.

612. Shri Shailendra Singh, Reader in Economics, Lucknow University.

613. Dr. L.D. Thakur, Prof. & Head of Department of Political Science, Lucknow University.

614. Shri Sripat Misra, Former Chief Minister, U.P.

615. Shri Vibhava Bhushan, Advocate General, Uttar Pradesh.

WEST BENGAL (Calcutta)

Government of West Bengal— represented by

616. Shri Jyoti Basu, Chief Minister

617. Dr. Ashok Mitra, MIC, Finance, Development & Planning.

618. Shri Prasanta Kumar Sur, MIC, Local Government and Urban Development.

619. Shri Kamal Guha, MIC, Agriculture.

620. Shri Nani Bhattacharyya, MIC, Irrigation & Waterways.

621. Shri Nirmal Bose, MIC, Commerce & Industries.

622. Shri Radhika Ranjan Banerji, MIC, Food & Supplies.

623. Shri Kanti Biswas, MIC, Education (School).

624. Shri Sambhu Charan Ghose, MIC, Education (Higher).

625. Shri S.V. Krishnan, Chief Secretary.

626. Shri R. Kharlukhi, Secretary, L.G. & U.D.

627. Shri L.M. Ghosh, Secretary, Judicial.

628. Shri P.K. Banerjee, Secretary, Legislative.

629. Shri P.V. Shenoi, Secretary, Agriculture.

630. Shri S.P. Sen, Engineer-in-Chief & Ex-Officio Secretary, Irrigation & Waterways.

631. Shri T.S. Broca, Secretary, Commerce & Industries.

632. Shri A.K. Chatterjee, Secretary Food & Supplies.

633. Shri A.K. Basu, Secretary, Education (School).

634. Shri C.N. Penn-Anthony, Secretary, Education (Higher).

635. Shri P.K. Sarkar, Secretary, Finance. 636. Shri A.K. Banerjee, Officer on Special Duty & Ex-Officio Secretary, Home (P. & A.R.). 637. Shri Annada Sankar Ray, Intellectual & Water, Calcutta. 638. Shri S.B. Sen, Economist, Calcutta. 639. Shri S.K. Acharya, Advocate General. 640. Dr. Bhabatosh Datta, Emeritus Professor of Economics and Former Member, Finance Commission. All India Forward Block (West Bengal Committee)— represented by 641. Shri Anil Mukherjee, Forward Block (Marxist)— represented by 642. Shri Ram Chatterjee, Chairman.

643. Shri R.K. Poddar Former Vice-Chancellor, Calcutta University.

644. Prof. Barun De, Professor of History Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta.

645. Shri Atulya Ghosh, Former Congress President.

West Bengal State Committee (CPI) (M)— represented by

646. Shri Saroj Mukharjee, Secretary. Revolutionary Communist Party— represented by

647. Shri Bimalananda Mukherjee, West Bengal Headmasters' Association—represented by

648. Shri Bishnubrata Bhattacharya, President, (with 7 other members).

649. Dr. S.K. Bhattacharya, Vice-Chancellor, Calcutta University.

650. Smt. Renuka Ray, Member of Constituent Assembly.

651. Shri Sukumar Mullick, Ex-Chief Minister, West Bengal.

652. Dr. Biplab Das Gupta, Economist, Calcutta.

653. Shri Somendra Chandra Bose, President, High Court Bar Association.

654. Shri Mohit Bhattacharya, Professor of Political Science, Calcutta University.

655. Dr. M.L. Upadhyaya, Principal & Dean Calcutta University Law College. Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry— represented by

656. Shri J.D. Sinha, President.

657. Shri T.K. Ramasubramanyam, Chairman.

658. Shri P. Das Gupta, Secretary.

659. Shri R. Ghosh, Economist.

Bharatiya Janata Party— represented by

660. Shri Vishnu Kant Shastri, President, West Bengal, B.J.P. Revolutionary Socialist Party— represented by

661. Shri Jatin Chakrabarty, PWD & Housing Minister, Govt. of West Bengal.

662. Shri Saurin Bhattacharya.

663. Shri Sunil Sen Gupta.

664. Shri Suniti Chattaraj, M.L.A. Congress (I), West Bengal.

665. Shri Chittaranjan Bag, Advocate, Lecturer Calcutta University College of Law. West Bengal State Committee CPI— represented by

666. Shri Kanai Bhowmik, Secretary.

667. Shri Swadhin Guha.

668. Shri Prabhat Das Gupta.

GOA

689. Sardar Gopal Singh, Lt. Governor, Goa, Daman & Diu. Government of Goa, Daman & Diu— represented by

670. Shri Pratap Singh Raoji Rane, Chief Minister.

671. Shri Saikh Hassan Haroon, Minister for Law & Industries.

672. Shri Francisco Caetano Sardinha, Minister for Agriculture.

673. Shri Harish Narayan Prabhu Zantya. Minister for Power.

674. Shri Vaikuntha Govind Desai, Minister for Labour & Employment.

675. Shri K.K. Mathur, Chief Secretary,

676. Shri M. Raghuchander, Law Secretary.

677. Shri S.K. Genthe, Special Secretary (Planning).

678. Shri B.S. Subhanna, Secretary to Chief Minister.

679. Shri G.G. Kambli, Under Secretary (G.A.), Goa Congress— represented by

680. Dr. Wilfred de Souza, President.

681. Shri Govind Panvelcar, General Secretary.

682. Shri Luizimbo Fabiro, M.L.A., General Secretary.

683. Shri Lyam Sunder Lengi, Treasurer.

684. Shri R.D. Khalap, Leader of the Opposition & General Secretary, Maharashtrawadi Gomantak. Maharashtrawadi Gomantak— represented by

685. Shri Ravi Naik, President. Konkani Lekhak Sangh— represented by

686. Shri Datta Naik, General Secretary All Goa Youth Federation— represented by

687. Shri Sushrut A. Martins, President.

688. Shri Damodar Ghanekar, Vice-President, All Goa Youth Federation Editor, Sanydi. Yuva Janata— represented by

689. Shri Cyril Pacheco, President, Konkani Projecho Ava— represented by

690. Shri Pundalik N. Naik, Convenor. 691. Shri Uday Bhembre, M.L.A.

692. Shri Chander Kant Keni, Editor, Daily Rashtramet. Bhartiya Janata Yuva Morcha— represented by

693. Shri Madhav Manohar Dhond, General Secretary, Goment Lok Polox— represented by

694. Shri Mathanhy Saldanha, General Secretary.

695. Shri Raju D. Manushkar, Joint Secretary.

PONDICHERRY Pondicherry Government— represented by

696. Shri M.O.H. Farook,

Chief Minister.

697. Shri P. Kannan, Health Minister.

698. Shri V. Vaithilingam, Public Works Minister.

699. Shri V. Govindarajan, Agriculture Minister.

700. Shri L. Joseph Mariadoss, Labour & Cooperation Minister.

701. Shri F. Pahnuna, Chief Secretary.

702. Shri P.M. Nair, Development Commissioner.

703. Shri A. Chandraskhara Menon, Seretary to Government (Law).

704. Shri R. Padmanbhan, Secretary to Government (Finance).

705. Shri R.S. Chari, Secretary to Government (L.A.D.).

706. Shri Rakesh Mehta, Secretary to Government (Education).

707. Shri A. Subbaraya Pillai, Secretary to Government (Revenue).

708. Shri S. Ramasamy, Former Chief Minister Puduvai Mukkal Munnani Party— represented by

709. Shri Era Cheram, Secretary.

710. Shri D. Ramachandran Former Chief Minister, State D.M.K. Convenor with

711. Shri R.V. Jankiraman, M.L.A.

712. Smt. Ganimaran, Ex-M.L.A.

713. Shri S. Gomala, M.L.A.

714. Dr. S. Anandavelu.

715. Shri Subramaniam.

NEW DELHI 716. Shri N.A. Palkhivala,1 Senior Advocate, Supreme Court.

717. Dr. Karan Singh, Former Union Minister.

718. Shri Dharama Vira, ICS (Retd.), Former Governor.

719. Shri E.M.S. Namboodripad, Former Chief Minister, Kerala.

720. Shri M.L. Dwivedi, Member, Constituent Assembly.

721. Prof. N.G. Ranga, Member Constituent Assembly.

722. Shri R.R. Diwakar, Member Constituent Assembly.

723. Shri Kishori Mohan Tripathi, Member Constituent Assembly.

724. Shri Satish Chandra, Member Constituent Assembly.

725. Shri Mohan Singh Mehta, Member, Constituent Assembly.

726. Smt. Ram Sahai Tiwari,2 Member, Constituent Assembly.

727. Shri Renuka Ray,3 Member, Constituent Assembly.

728. Ch. Ranbir Singh, Member, Constituent Assembly.

729. Shri R.K. Malviya, Member, Constituent Assembly.

730. Shri S. Nijalingappa, Member, Constituent Assembly.

731. Shri K.K. Jain, Member, Constituent Assembly.

732. D. Raj Krishna, Economist, Former, Member, Planning Commission & Former Member, Seventh Finance Commission.

733. Dr. C. H. Hanumantha Rao, Economist, Member, Planning Commission.

734. Prof. P.C. Mathur, Professor Economist (Retd.), L.B.S. National Academy of Admn., Mussoorie.

735. Shri L.P. Singh, ICS (Retd.), Former Governor.

736. Shri N.K. Mukarji, IAs (Retd.), Former Cabinet Secretary, Government of India.

737. Shri V. Vishwanathan, ICS (Retd.), Former Governor.

738. Shri B.G. Verghese, Editor-in-Chief The Indian Express.

739. Shri L.K. Jha, ICS (Retd.) Formerly Chairman, Economic Admn. Reforms Commission and Chairman Indirect Taxation Enquiry Committee.

740. Shri S. Sahay, Editor, The Statesman, New Delhi.

741. Shri Raja J. Chelliah, Former Director, National Institute of Public Finance and Policy, New Delhi. Member, Planning Commission.

742. Shri G.K. Reddy, Spl. Correspondent, The Hindu.

743. Prof. Mrinal Datta Chowdhuri, Professor, Delhi School of Economics.

744. Dr. (Mrs.) Alice Jacob, Director, Indian Law Instt.

745. Shri Tarlok Singh, Former Member Planning Commission.

746. Dr. M.V. Mathur, Economist, & Educationist, Member IV Pay Commission.

747. Dr. N. Raj, Fellow, Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum & Member Economic Advisory, Council, Planning Commission.

748. Dr. Y.K. Alagh, Former Chairman, Bureau of Industrial Costs & Prices, Member, Planning Commission.

749. Mr. Inder Malhotra, Resident Editor, The Times of India, New Delhi.

750. Dr. Ashish Bose, Professor, Institute of Economic Growth, Delhi.

751. Dr. B.B. Bhattacharya, Professor, Institute of Economic Growth, Delhi.

752. Justice S. Rangarajan, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court, Retd. Judge, Delhi High Court.

753. Shri P.R. Dubhashi, Director, Indian Institute of Public Administration, New Delhi.

754. Shri A.R. Shirali, Member Secretary, Committee on Change in Financial Year.

Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI)—represented by

755. Shri Ram Krishna Bajaj, President.

756. Shri A.K. Jain, Ex-President.

757. Shri D.D. Puri, Committee Member.

758. Dr. Sanjiv Gupta, Secretary (Eco.).

759. Prof. Verney Douglas, Senior Fellow, Shastri Indo-Canadian Institute, New Delhi.

760. Shri K.F. Rustomji, Former Director General, Border Security Force and Member, National Police Commission.

761. Dr. S.R. Maheshwari, Prof. of Political Science & Public Admn., Indian Institute of Public Administration.

762. Shri R.C.S. Sarkar, Ex-Law Secretary, and Former Chairman, U.P.S.C.

763. Shri G. Ramachandran, Former Finance Secretary, and Member-Secretary Planning Commission.

764. Shri K. Ganesen, Former Secretary, Election Commission.

765. Dr. Edward Mc Whinney, Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration, Canada.

766. Mrs. K. Rukmani Menon, Former Ambassador to Nigeria, Italy & Denamark.

767. Shri Shyam Dhar Misra, Former Union Minister.

Janta Party— represented by

768. Prof. Madu Dandavate, Leader of the Janata Party in Lok Sabha.

769. Dr. S. Jaipal Reddy, Dy. Leader of the Janata Party

Lok Dal— represented by

770. Shri Satya Prakash Malviya, Member of Parliament, General Secretary.

771. Shri J.P. Goyal, Member of Parliament.

772. Shri Mahavir Singh,

Ex-Judge, Allahabad High Court Bhartiya Janata Party— represented by

773. Shri L.K. Advani, President.

774. Shri Ram Jethmalani Vice-President.

775. Shri V.K. Malhotra, Secretary.

776. Shri K.L. Sharma, Secretary Communist Party of India, Central Sectt.— represented by

777. Shri Homi Daji, Secretary, Central Secretariat.

778. Shri N. Raja Sekhar, Reddy, Member. A.I.C.C. (Socialist)— represented by

779. Shri K.P. Unnikrishnan, MP, General Secretary.

780. Shri V. Kishore S. Deo, MP, General Secretary.

781. Shri Dharam Bir Sinha, Former Union Deputy Minister & Former Minister, Bihar.

A.I.C.C. (I)— represented by

782. Shri Arjun Singh, Vice-President.

783. Shri P. Shiv Shankar, Union Minister for External Affairs.

SECRETARIES TO THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA 784. Shri T.U. Vijayasekharan, Secretary, Department of Food.

785. Shri M.M. Kohli, Secretary, Department of Power, accompanied by

786. Shri M.K. Sambamurti, Chairman, C.E.I.

787. Shri R.K. Sharma, Additional Secretary.

788. Shri J.C. Gupta, Joint Secretary.

789. Shri T.N. Seshan, Secretary, Department of Forests & Wild Life (Environment and Forests).

790. Shri R. Ganpati, Secretary, Department of Expenditure accompanied by

791. Shri C.S. Rao, Joint Secretary.

792. Shri Prakash Narain, Chairman, Railway Board, accompanied by

793. Shri S.R. Chaudhri, Member (Staff).

794. Shri Kuldip Narain, Advisor, (Industrial Relations).

795. Shri S.P. Banerjee, Director General, Railway Protection Force.

796. Shri M.B. Kaushal, Additional Inspector General, Railway Protection Force.

797. Shri M.P. Srivastava, Director, Railway Reforms Committee.

798. Shri C.G. Somiah, Secretary, Planning Commission accompanied by

799. Dr. S. P. Gupta, Adviser, Prespective Planning Division.

800. Dr. P.D. Mukherjee, Advisor, Financial Resources Division.

801. Shri Badal Roy, Adviser, Plan Coordination Division.

802. Shri Ramaswamy R. Iyer, Secretary, (Water Resources), accompanied by

803. Shri D.W. Telang, Additional Secretary.

804. Shri M.A. Chitale, Chairman, Central Water Commission.

805. Shri N. K. Sharma, Member (W.R.) C.W.C.

806. Shri G.S. Jakhade, Adviser (P.P.)

807. Shri B.K. Rao, Secretary, Department of Mines, accompanied by

808. Shri T.N. Srivastava, Joint Secretary.

809. Shri S. D. Srivastava, Secretary, Department of Industrial Development accompanied by

810. Shri P.R. Latey, Secretary & Director General Technical Development.

811. Shri P. Murari, Additional Secretary.

812. Shri R.P. Khanna, Additional Secretary and Development Commissioner, Small Scale Industry.

813. Shri S.K. Lall, Joint Secretary.

814. Shri B. Sahay, Joint Secretary.

815. Shri G. Venkataramanan, Joint Secretary,

816. Shri C.R. Sundararajan, Joint Secretary, Department of Company Affairs.

817. Shri A.M. Chakraborti, Deputy Secretary.

818. Shri R.D. Pradhan, Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs accompanied by

819. Shri S. Balakrishnan, Adviser.

820. Shri Anand Sarup, Secretary, Department of Education accompanied by

821. Shri P.K. Patnaik, Joint Secretary (Planning), Department of Education.

822. Shri M. Subramanian, Secretary, Department of Agriculture.

823. Shri G.M. Mehra, Secretary, Information and Broadcasting.

UNION MINISTERS

824. Shri Ajit Kumar Panja, Minister of State for Planning accompanied by

825. Dr. P. D. Mukherji, Adviser, Financial Resources Division.

826. Shri K.D. Sakesena, Joint Secretary, State Plans Division.

827. Shri G.C. Mathur, Deputy Adviser, Plan Coordination Division.

828. Dr. R. Mandal, P. S. to Minister.

829. Shri G.S. Dhillon, Union Minister of Agriculture, Cooperation and Rural Development accompanied by

830. Shri D. Bandyopadhyay, Secretary, Department of Rural Development.

831. Shri K.N. Ardhanareeswaran, Additional Secretary, Department of Agriculture & Cooperation.

832. Smt. Moshina Kidwai, Union Minister for Health and Family Welfare accompanied by

833. Shri S.S. Dhonoa, Secretary,

834. Shri P.K. Umashankar, Addl. Secretary.

835. Shri S.V. Subramaniyan, Joint Secretary.

836. Dr. D.B. Bisht, Director General, Health Service.

837. Shri N.D. Tiwari, Union Minister for Industries accompanied by

838. Shri S.D. Srivastava, Secretary, Deptt. of Industrial Development.

839. Shri V. K. Dhar, Secretary, Deptt. of Public Enterprises.

840. Shri C.R. Sundra Rajan, Joint Secretary, C.A.

841. Shri P.K.S. Iyer, Director

842. Shri A.M. Chakraborty, Deputy Secretary, C.A.

843. Shri P. Shiv Shankar, Union Minister of Commerce.

844. Shri Vishwanath Pratap Singh, Union Minister for Finance, accompanied by

845. Shri R. Ganapati, Secretary, Deptt. of Expenditure.

846. Shri V. Srinivasan, Officer on Special Duty.

847. Shri S.P. Sharma, P.S. to Secretary.

848. Shri P. V. Narasimha Rao, Union Minister for Human Resource Development.

849. Shri Buta Singh, Union Minister of Home Affairs.

COMPTROLLER AND AUDITOR GENERAL OF INDIA

850. Shri T.N. Chaturvedi. accompanied by

851. Shri Sattu Rama,

Deputy Comptroller and Auditor General of India. Indian Forest Service Association— represented by

852. Shri Narayan Singh, General Secretary.

853. Shri C.S. Joshi, Treasurer

854. Shri A.C. Chaubey, Member. Shiromani Akali Dal—(L) represented by

855. Sardar Surjit Singh Barnala, President and former Chief Minister, Punjab

856. Sardar Balwant Singh, Former Finance Minister, Punjab.

857. Sardar Manjit Singh Khaira, General Secretary.

858. Sardar Balwant Singh Ramoowalia, M.P. Secretary General.

859. Dr. K.S. Gill, Vice-Chairman,

Punjab State Planning Board.

APPENDIX VIII Select Bibliography

I. BOOKS Sl. Author's Name Title No.

1. Aggrawal, P. P. The System of Grants-in-aid in India, (1959).

2. Ahluwalia, Isher Judge Industrial Growth in India: stagnation since the Mid-Sixties, (1985).

3. Aiyangar, N. R. Government of India Act, 1935, with a Commentary, Critical and Explanatory, (1937).

4. Alagh, Y. K. Some aspects of Planning Process in India, (1986).

5. Basu, D. D. Commentary on the Constitution of India, Volumes A (1982) to L, (1986).

6. Basu, D. D. Comparative Constitutional Law, (1985).

7. Basu D. D. Comparative Federalism, (1987).

8. Basu, D. D. Constitutional Law of India, (1983).

9. Basu, D. D. Introduction to the Constitution of India, (1983).

10. Basu, D. D. Shorter Constitution of India, (1984).

11. Basu, D. D. World Constitutions.

12. Basu, N. D. Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act 45 of 1860).

13. Bhagwati, J.N. and India: Planning for Industrialization Desai, Padma and Trade Policies Since 1951, (1970).

14. Bhargava, Madhuri Inter-Governmental Financial Relations in India Since Independence, (1976).

15. Bhargava, P. K. Essays on Indian Public Finance, (1982).

16. Bhargava, P. K. Centre-State Resource Transfers in India, (1982).

17. Bhargava, R. N. The Theory and Working of Union Finances in India, (1956).

18. Bhatnagar, Sudha Union-State Financial Relations and Finance Commissions, (1979).

19. Birla Institute of Scientific Centre-State Financial Relations Research, New Delhi. in India, (1979). 20. Chanda, Asoka Federalism in India: A Study of Union-State Relations, (1965).

21. Choudhary, Valmiki President and the Indian Constitution, (1985).

22. Clarke, M. G. Modern Political Constitutions (1975).

23. Corwin, Edward The President: Office and Powers, (2nd edition).

24. Coupland R Report on Constitutional Problems in India.

25. Dharm Vira "The Exercise of Discretion" in "The Governor—Sage or Saboteur", (1985).

26. Dhavan, Rajeev President's Rule in the States, (The Indian Law Institute), (1979).

27. Dicey, A. V. An Introduction to the Study of the Law of Constitution, (1969).

28. Diwan, Paras The Union-State Fiscal Relations: An Over-view, (1981).

29. Doss, Veda Impact of Planning on Centre-State Financial Relations in India, (1978).

30. Dua, B. D. Presidential Rule in India, 1950-84—A Study in Crisis Politics, (1985).

31. Dubhashi, P. R. Grammar of Planning (1984).

32. Fedia, Babulal State Policy in India, Volume I and II (1984).

33. Ghelot, N. S. State Governors in India: Trends and Issues (1985).

34. Government of India, Jawaharlal Nehru's Publication Division Speeches, Vol. 2 (1949-53), Vol. : 3 (1953-57), Vol.: 5 (1963-64).

35. Govind Narain "Constitutional Obligations" in "The Governor—sage or Saboteur", (1985).

36. Grewal, B. S. Centre-State Financial Relations in India, (1975).

37. Gupta, S. C. The Law relating to Commissions of Inquiry, (1977).

38. Hanks, P. J. Australian Constitution.

39. Hanson, A. H. The Process of Planning, (1966).

40. Hegde, Ramakrishna Electrical Reforms—Lack of Political Will.

41. Hegde, Ramakrishna Judiciary Today—Disturbing Trends and Suggestions for Reforms.

42. Hegde, Ramakrishna The Judiciary Today—A plea for a Collegium, (1986).

43. Hicks, U. and others (Ed). Federation and Economic Growth in Under developed Countries, (1961).

44. Hilliard L. Rober Radio Broadcasting.

45. Hogg, Peter, W. Constitutional Law of Canada.

46. Hussain, Yusuf Glimpses of Medieval Indian Culture.

47. Huntington, Samuel, P. Political Order in Changing Societies, (1968).

48. Indian Institute of Planning and its Implementation, Public Administration (1984).

49. Indian Institute of Selected Articles Police Public Administration Administration, (1982). (Editors: Chaturvedi, T.N. and Rao, S. Venugopal).

50. Indian Institute of Selected Articles Union-State Public Administration Relations, (1984). (Editors: Chaturvedi, T.N. and Dutta, Abhijit).

51. Indian Law Institute, The Union and the States. Indian Institute of Administration, and Institute of Constitution and Parliamentary Studies (Editors: S.N. Jain and others).

52. Indra, M.S. The Role of the Centre and the States in the Improvement of Agriculture. (1963).

53. Institute for Constitutional Federal Financial Relations in and Parliamentary India, (1974). Studies, New Delhi

54. Jacob, Alice Presidential Assent to State Bills—A Case Study, Vol. 12, (1970), No. 1.

55. Jain, M.P. Indian Constitutional Law, (1987).

56. Jain, Rajendra State Taxation in India, (1972).

57. Jain, Rajendra Dilemma of State Finances, (1983).

58. Jain, S.N.; Jacob, Inter-State Water Dispute in Alice and Jain, Subhash, C. India.

59. Jawaharlal Nehru Letters to Chief Ministers, Memorial Fund. Volume 1, 1947-1949, (1985) (Editor: G. Parthasarthy). and Volume 2, 1950-1952, (1986).

60. Jha, L.K. Economic Strategy For the 80's: Priorities for the Seventh Plan, (1979). 61. Jha, L.K. Growth, Inflation and Other Issues, (1985). 62. Jha, P.K. Federal Finance in Developing India, (1983). 63. Jennings, Ivor Cabinet Government, (1959).

64. Jennings, Ivor The Law and the Constitution, (1976). 65. Jannings, Ivor The Common Wealth Conference, 1949: The British Year Book of International Law, (1948).

66. Johnson, Nevil Government in the Federal Republic of Germany.

67. Jones, W.H. Morris The Government and Politics of India, (1964). 68. Julian, Hale Radio Power—Propoganda and International Broadcasting.

69. Kelly and Harbinson The American Constitution.

70. Keith, A. B. A Constitutional History of India (1600—1935), 1961 edition.

71. Krishnamurthi, M. Union State Relations, (1981).

72. Kumar, Narender Taxing Powers and Distribution of Revenue, (1987).

73. Kurian, K. Mathew and Centre-State Relations, (1981). others

74. Lakdawala, D. T. Union-State Financial Relations (1967).

75. Laski, H. J. A Grammar of Politics, 1938.

76. Law Publishers, Allahabad. Princep's Commentaries on Code of Criminal Procedure, (Volumes I and II, (1984).

77. Lijphart, Arned. Democracies—Patterns of Majoritarial and Consensus Government in Twenty-One Countries, (1984).

78. Lok Sabha Secretariat Presidential Ordinances 1950—84, (1985).

79. Lumb, R. D. and Ryan, The Constitution of the K. W. Commonwealth of Australia, (1981).

80. Mahajan, V. S. Planning, Development and Economic Policy in India, (1982). 81. Majumdar, Datta Advanced History of India. Roychoudhary.

82. Marshall, Geoffrey Constitutional Conventions—The Rules and Forms of Political Accountability, (1984).

83. McWiney, Edward Comparative Federalism University of Tronto Press, (1962).

84. Menon, V. P. Montague—Chelmsford Reforms.

85. Mishra, Jagannath India's Economic Development, (1984). 86. Mishra, Jagannath Financing of State Plans, (1984). and Sinha, R. K.

87. Mukherjee, T. B. Inter-State Relations in Ancient India, (1967).

88. Munro, W. B. The Governments of Europe, (1947).

89. Munshi K. M. Indian Constitutional Documents : Vol. I, Pilgrimage to Freedom, (1902—1950).

90. Murthi, B. V. K. Centre-State Economic and Financial Relations, (1958).

91. Namboodiripad, E. M. S. The Governor : A spoke in the Federal Wheel in "The Governor—Sage or Saboteur", Published by Roli Books International, (1985).

92. Nanjundappa, D. M. Inter Governmental Financial Relations in India, (1974).

93. National Institute of Trends and Issues in Indian Federal Public Finance and Policy. Finance, (1981).

94. Nelson, W. Polsby Congress and the Presidency, (4th Ed.).

95. Nehru, Jawaharlal Discovery of India.

96. Noorani, A. G. Public Law in India, (1982).

97. Norsiter, T. J. Communism in Kerala—A Study, in Political Adoptation, (1982).

98. Ogg, Frederic Austin European Governments and Politics, (1945). 99. Ojha, P. D. "Centre-State Financial Relations in India" in Sinha, S. L. N. (Ed.) Economic and Social Development, (Essays in Honour of Dr. C. D. Deshmukh), (1972). 100. Pal, Chandra Centre-State Relations and

Co-operative Federalism. 101. Pal, Chandra State Autonomy in Indian Federation.

102. Pal, Chandra Co-operative Federalism in India.

103. Panigrahi, D.D. Centre-State Financial Relations in India, (1985).

104. Planning Commissions The Planning Process, (1976).

105. Prasad, Anirudh Centre-State Relations in India.

106. Prasad, Anirudh Centre and State Powers Under Indian Federalism, (1981).

107. Rakshit, Gangadhar Planning in India : India's Five Year Plans, (1982).

108. Randhawa M.S. A History of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research, (1979).

109. Ray, S.K. Commentaries on Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951, (1985).

110. Ray, Sunanda K. Datta Himalayan Caprice in "The Governor-Sage or Saboteur", published by Roli Books International, (1985).

111. Rao, Hem Lata Centre State Financial Relations (Criteria of Federal Fiscal Transfers and their Application in India), (1981).

112. Rao, N. R. Union-State Financial Relations in India, (1972).

113. Rau, B.N. India's Constitution in the Making, (1963).

114. Reddy, Y. Venugopal Multi-Level Planning in India, (1978).

115. Robinson, D.L. Reforming American Government, (The Bicentennial Papers of CCS), (1985).

116. Sarkar, R.C.S. Union State Relations, (1986).

117. Sarojini, K. Union-State Relations in the Field of Industrial Development, (1963).

118. Sastri, K.V.S. Federal-State Fiscal Relations in India : A Study of the Finance Commission and the Technique of Fiscal Adjustment, (1966).

119. Sastri, K.V.S. Centre-State Fiscal Relations in India, (1970).

120. Santhanam, K. Union-State Relations in the (1960).

121. Saxena, M.C. Dynamics of Federalism.

122. Saywell, John Canada Past and Present.

123. Schwartz, Bernard Constitutional Law—A Text-book, (1979).

124. Schwartz, Bernard Test Book of US Constitutional Law, 2nd Edition.

125. Seervai, H.M. Constitutional Law and India, Volumes I (1983) and II (1984).

126. Sen, Asoke K. Role of Governors in the Emerging Pattern of Centre-State Relations in India, (1984).

127. Setalvad, M.C. My Life, Law and Other Things, (1970).

128. Setalvad, M.C. Union and State Relations under the Indian Constitution (Tagore Law Lectures), (1974).

129. Sehi, R.B. Law of Foreigners and Citizenship, (1981).

130. Sharma, J.N. The Union and the State : A Study in Fiscal Federalism, (1974).

131. Sharma, Sriram Constitutional History of India, (1949).

132. Shepiro, Martin and American Constitutional Law. Tresolini.

133. Shukla, V.N. Constitution of India, (1982).

134. Singh, L.P. "Guide, Philosopher and Friends" in “The Governor—Sage or Saboteur”, (1985).

135. Singh, Shailendra (Ed.) Union State Financial Relations in India. (With special reference to the underdeveloped States), (1980).

136. Singh, S.P. Centre-State Relations in Agricultural Development, (1973).

137. Singh, Tavleen “A Tale of Two Governors” in “The Governor—Sage or Saboteur”, (1985).

138. Sinha, R.K. Centre-State Financial Relations in India, (1986).

139. Siwach, J.R. The Office of the Governor, (1977).

140. Sorabjee, Soli J. “The Constitution and the Governor” in “The governor—Sage or Saboteur”, (1985).

141. Strong, C.F. Modern Political Constitutions.

142. Subrahmanya, K.N. Taxation and Centre-State Finncial Relations, (1983).

143. Sundquist, James L. Constitutional Reforms and Effective Government, (1986).

144. Thavaraj, M.J.K. Financial Management of Government, (1978).

145. Thimmaiah, G. Federal Fiscal Systems of Australia and India : A Study in Comparative Relevance, (1976).

146. Thimmaiah, G. A Critique of the Finance Commissions, (1981).

147. Thimmaiah, G. Burden of Union Loans on States, (1977).

148. Thimmaiah, G. Burning Issues in Centre-State Financial Relations, (1985).

149. Thimmaiah, G. and Finance Commissions and Centre- Rao, H. State Financial Relations, (1986).

150. Titus, Varkey K. Agricultural Taxation in a Developing Economy : A Case Study of India, (1984).

151. Tribe, Lawrence H. American Constitutional Law, (1976). 152. Tripathi, R.N. Federal Finance in Developing Economy, (1980).

153. Upendra, P. "The Ramlal Episode : A Breach of Democracy" in "The Governor—Sage or Saboteur", (1985).

154. Veera Ragavachari, S. M. Union-State Financial Relations in India, (1980).

155. Venkataraman, K. State Finances in India : A Perspective Study for the Plan Periods, (1968).

156. Venkataramanaiah, V. (Ed.) Essays on Constitutional Law.

157. Wadhwa, D.C. Re-promulgation of Ordinances : A Fraud on the Constitution of India, (1983).

158. Wheare, K.C. Federal Government (Fourth Edition).

159. Wiecek The Guarantee Clause of the United States Constitution.

II. CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY DEBATES AND CONSTITUTIONAL DOCUMENTS

INDIA

1. Lok Sabha Secretariat—Constituent Assembly Debates, Vols. I to XII (Reprint) and Index.

2. Government of India Act, 1919.

3. Report of the Indian Statutory Commission, Vol. I—Survey, Vol II—Recommendations, (1930).

4. Report of the Joint Committee on Indian Constitutional Reforms, Session 1932—34 Vol. I, Part I Report and Part II—Proceedings.

5. Government of India Act, 1935.

6. Government of India, Home Department-Proceedings of the Premiers' Conference, October, 1946.

7. Constitution of India.

8. Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir (including certain related Provisions and Rules and Orders issued thereunder). Vol. I, (1970).

9. The Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir, Srinagar, (1984).

10. The Constitution (Amendment) Acts (First to Fifty-seventh), 1951 to 1987.

11. Statement of Objects and Reasons appended to:

(i) The Constitution (thirteenth Amendment) Bills, 1962 (72 of 1962), as introduced in Lok Sabha.

(ii) The State of Nagaland Bill, 1962 (73 of 1962) as introduced in Lok Sabha.

12. Constitution Orders:

(i) The Andhra Pradesh Regional Committee Order, 1958 (S.R.O. 443-A),

(ii) The Government of India (Governors' Allowances and Privileges) Order, 1950.

(iii) The Manipur Legislative Assemly (Hill Areas Committee) Order, 1972 [GSR 317 (E)].

(iv) Orders issued under the Constitution of India, Part I.

(v) The Punjab Regional Committees Order, 1957 (S.R.O. 3524).

(vi) The State of Gujarat (Special Responsibility of Governor for Kutch) Order, 1981.

(vii) The States Reorganisation (Governors' Allowances) Order, 1957.

13. Rao, B. Shiva: The Framing of the India's Constitution : A Study, (1968).

OTHER COUNTRIES: 14. Constitution of the United States of America (1787).

15. Constitution of the Dominion of Canada, (1867).

16. Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia, (1900).

17. The Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Geramany, (1949).

III. REPORTS Sl. Ministry/Department Title No. Institution Body

Government of India:

1. Administrative, Machinery for Planning, (1968). Reforms Commission

2. Administrative, Report on Centre-State Relations, Reforms Commission (1969).

3. Administrative, Reforms Report on the Machinery of the forms Commission Government of India and its Procedures of work, (1968).

4. Administrative, Reforms Report on Personnel Administra- Commission tion, (1969).

5. Administrative, Reforms Report on State Administration, Commission (1969).

6. Administrative, Reforms Recommendations and Conclusions, Commission (1970).

7. Administrative, Reforms Report on Centre-State Relations, Commission, Study Team Volumes I to III. on Centre State

Relationships.

8. Administrative, Reforms Report on the Machinery of the Commission, Study Team Government of India and its on the Machinery of the Procedures of Work, Part II. Government of India and (Vol. I), (1968). its Procedures of Work.

9. Administrative, Reforms Report of the Study Team on Commission, Study Team Administration of Union on Administration of Territories and NEFA, (1968). Union Territories and NEFA.

10. Administrative, Reforms Report of the Study Team on Commission. Financial Administration, (1968).

11. Bureau of Police Research Crime in India, (1975 to 1979). and Development.

12. Bureau of Public Enter- Public Enterprises Survey, prises (1984-85 and 1985-86).

13. Economic Advisory Report on Decentralisation of Council of the Prime Development Planning and Imple- Minister mentation Systems in the States, (1983).

14. Economic Administration Reports on Tax Administration, Reforms Commission. (1981—83).

15. Ministry of Education Report of the University Education Commission (Chairman : S Radhakrishnan). 16. Ministry of Education Report of the Committee of Members of Parliament on Higher Education, (1964) (Chairman : P.N. Sapru).

17. Ministry of Education Challange of Education—A policy Perspective, (August, 1985).

18. Ministry of Human Development (Dept. of Education) Resource National Policy on Education—A Presentation, (1986).

19. Ministry of External Instrument of Ratification of Affairs Treaty of Secession of the French Establishments of Pondicherry, Karaikal, Mahe and Yanam

between the President of India and the President of French Republic, (1956).

20. Ministry of Finance Reports of the various Finance Commissions.

21. Ministry of Finance Direct Taxes Enquiry Committee Report,(1971) (Chairman : K. N. Wanchoo).

22. Ministry of Finance Report of the Committee on Taxation of Agricultural Wealth and Income, (1972) (Chairman : K. N. Raj)

23. Ministry of Finance Changes in the Accounting Systems of the States and the Roles of Treasuries, (Report by R. Ganapati), (1976).

24. Ministry of Finance Report of the Indirect Taxation Enquiry Committee, (1978) (Chairman : L. K. Jha)

25. Ministry of Finance Report of the Direct Tax Laws Committee, (1978) (Chairman : C. C. Chokshi)

26. Ministry of Finance Report of the Committee on Controls and Subsidies, (1979) (Chairman : Vadilal Dagli)

27. Ministry of Finance Report of the Expert Committee on Replacement of Sales Tax on Vanaspati, Drugs & Medicines, Cement, Paper & Paper Board and Petroleum Products by Additional Excise Duties, (1983)

(Chairman : Kamalapati Tripathi)

28. Ministry of Finance Report of the Committee to Examine Principles of a Possible Shift from Physical to Financial Controls, (1985).

29. Ministry of Finance Long Term Fiscal Policy, (1985).

30. Ministry of Finance Aspects of the Black Money in India, (1986).

31. Ministry of Food and Civil Advisory Council on Public Supplies, (Department of Distribution (Summary Records of Civil Supplies) Third, fourth, Fifth, Sixth and Seventh Meetings), (1983 to 1985).

32. Ministry of Home Affairs Report of the Committee of Governors, (1971).

33. Ministry of Home Recommendations of the Affairs, Department of Administrative Reforms Personnel and Commission (pertaining to Administrative Central Government), Government

Reforms Decisions thereon and their Implementation Position, (1977).

34. Ministry of Home Affairs Report of the Committee on Union Territories, (1962).

35. Ministry of Home Affairs Report of the Committee on Defections, Part I & II, (1968).

36. Ministry of Home Affairs Report of the Working Group on Tribal Development during the Sixth Plan, (1980).

37. Ministry of Information Report of the Working—Group on and Broadcasting Autonomy for Akashwani and Doordarshan, Volumes I & II. (Chairman : B. G. Verghese)

38. Ministry of Information Report of the Committee on Broad- and Broadcasting casting and Information Media. (Chairman : A. K. Chanda)

39. Ministry of Information Report of the Working Group on and Broadcasting Software for Doordarshan (Chairman : P. C. Joshi)

40. Ministry of Industry Report of the Study Group on Industrial Regulations and Procedures, (1978).

41. Godavari Water Disputes Report of the Godavari Water Tribunal Disputes Tribunal, Vol. I, (1980).

42. Krishna Water Disputes Report of the Krishna Water Tribunal Disputes Tribunal, Vol. I, (1976).

43. Linguistic Minorities Twenty-third and Twenty-fourth Commission Reports by the Deputy Commissioner for Linguistic Minorities in India, (1982-83) and (1983-84). 44. Narmada Water Disputes Report of the Narmada Water Tribunal Disputes Tribunal, Vol. I, (1979).

45. National Commission on Interim and Final Reports of the Agriculture National Commission on Agriculture, (1976) (Various Volumes).

46. National Institute of Workshop on Supply Management Rural Development, of Public Distribution System (at Hyderabad District Level) Jan. 9-10—1986, sponsored by Ministry of Food and Civil Supplies, (Department

of Civil, Supplies).

47. National Irrigation Report of the National Irrigation Commission Commission, (1972).

48. National Police First to Eighth and Concluding Commission Reports, (1979 to 1981).

49. Planning Commission Various Five Year Plan Documents.

50. Planning Commission Memorandum on Existing Pattern of Central Assistance to States, (1957). 51. Planning Commission Report of the Working Group on Identification of Backward Areas, (1969) (Chairman : B. D. Pande). 52. Planning Commission Report of Inter-Ministerial Group on Freight—Equalisation of Commodities, (1977).

53. Planning Commission Report of the Working Group on Block Level Planning, (1978). 54. Planning Commission National Committee on the Development of Backward Areas, (1980).

55. Planning Commission Report of the National Transport Policy Committee, (1980).

56. Planning Commission Report of the Working Group on District Planning, (1984).

57. Planning Commission Report of the Expert Committee in connection with the Seventh Plan Formulation on the Question of Provisions for Maintenance of Assets as Plan Outlay, (1984).

58. Planning Commission Report of the Expert Committee on the Role of Centrally Sponsored Schemes in Seventh Plan (Mimeographed), (1985).

59. Planning Commission Report of the Working Group on Administration of Justice in North-Eastern India, (1984).

60. Planning Commission Report of the Working Group to study the Selection and Implemen-tation of Development Programmes with particular reference to Community Participation in the North-Eastern Region, (1985).

61. Planning Commission Report on Development of North-Eastern Region National Committee on the Development of Backward Areas, (1981).

62. Planning Commission Evaluation Report on Essential Supplies Programme, (1985).

63. Registrar General & Census Census of India, 1981—Final Commissioner of India Population Totals.

64. Department of Rural Report of the Committee on

Development, Committee Panchayati Raj Institutions, (1978). on Panchayati Raj (Chairman : Asoka Mehta). Institutions

65. Department of Rural Report of the Committee to Review Development the Existing Administrative Arrange-ments for Rural Development and Poverty Alleviation

Programmes (CAARD), (1985).

66. Ministry of State White Paper on Indian States, (1950).

67. States' Reorganisation Report of the States' Reorganisation Commission Commission, (1955).

68. Ministry of Steel & Mines Report of the Study Group on Revision of Royalty Rates of Major Minerals, (1979).

69. Taxation Enquiry Report of the Taxation Enquiry Commission Commission, (1953-54).

70. National Institute of Centre-State Relations in Educational Planning Financing Education in India. and Administration

71. University Grants Report of the Committee to Commission Enquire into the Working of the Central Universities, (1984).

72. University Grants Annual Reports of the University Commission Grants Commission, (1959-60, 1972-73 and 1982-83).

73. Union Public Service Civil Services Examination, Report Commission of the Committee on Recruitment Policy and Selection Methods, (1976).

74. Government of Gujarat Report of the Gujarat Taxation Enquiry Commission, (1980).

75. Government of Kerala Report of the Committee on Commodity Taxation, (1976).

76. Government of Conclusions and Recommendations Maharashtra of the Fact Finding Committee on Regional Imbalances in Maharashtra, (Published by Centre for

Monitoring Indian Economy), (1984).

77. Government of Tamil Nadu Report of the Centre-State Relations Inquiry Committee, (1971). (Chairman : P. V. Rajamannar).

78. Government of Uttar Taxation Enquiry Committee Pradesh Report, (1980).

79. Reserve Bank of India Report of the Committee to Review Arrangements for Institutional Credit for Agriculture and Rural Development (CRAFICARD), (1981).

80. Reserve Bank of India Report of the Committee on Agricultural Productivity in Eastern Indian States, (1985). (Chairman : S. R. Sen).

81. Reserve Bank of India Report of the Committee to Review the Working of the Monetary System, (1986).

(Chairman : S. Chakravarty). 82. Reserve Bank of India Report on Currency and Finance (Various Issues) 83. Lok Sabha Union State Relations : A Study, (1970). 84. Lok Sabha Estimates Committee Report On Industrial Licencing, (50th Report, Fifth Lok Sabha), (April,

1974). 85. Lok Sabha Estimates Committee (Seventh Lok Sabha)—77th Report on the Ministry of Home Affairs, All

India Services, (1984). 86. Lok Sabha Estimates Committee (Eighth Lok Sabha)—13th Report on Action Taken by Government on the

Recommendations contained in the 77th Report of Estimates Committee (Seventh Lok Sabha) on the Ministry of Home Affairs—All India Services, (1985).

87. Lok Sabha Report of the Joint Committee on the Central Industrial Security Force Bill, 1966—Evidence, (1968).

88. Lok Sabha Report of the Joint Committee of Parliament on the Government of Union Territories Bill, 1963. 89. Lok Sabha Report of the Joint Committee on the States Reorganisation Bill, 1956.

FOREIGN :

90. Government of U.S.A. The Commission on Inter-Governmental Relations—A Report to the President for transmitting to the Congress, June 1955.

91. Government of Canada, Report of the Royal Commission Minister of Supply on the Economic Union and and Services. Development Prospects for Canada, Volumes I to III, August, 1985. (Chairman : Donald S. Macdonald).

IV. PERIODICALS

1. Akerlof. Gelrge. A. Centre-State Fiscal Relations in India—Indian Economic Review, October, 1969.

2. Ansari, M.M. Resource Mobilisation Through Taxation, Yojana, September 16—30, 1984.

3. Bagchi, Amaresh Fiscal Federalism: Problems & Possibile Soultions, Indian Economic Review, October, 1977.

4. Bagchi, A. Reform of Direct Taxes, The Financial Express, February 26 1983.

5. Bapat, L.G. Problem of Centre's Loans to States, Yojana, April 12, 1972.

6. Bar Council of India Trust Journal of the Bar Council of India, Special Number on Three Decades of Constitution, Vol. VIII(3), (1981).

7. Basavarajan, K.B. Centre-States Financial Relationship Under Indian Constitution Parliamentary Affairs, Vol, I, No. II, March, 1983.

8. Bhambri, C.P. Bureaucracy in India; Challenges in the Eighties, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Volume 26.

9. Bhargava, P.K. Eighth Finance Commission: Practice Falls Sort of Precept, The Business Standard, April 25, 1985

10. Bhargava, R.N. Federalism: A Fiscal Inequity, The Economic Times, August 13, 1974.

11. Bhatia, H.L. Tax Devolution in a Frame-work of Federal Resource Transfers: The Indian Case. Indian Economic Journal, July—September, 1978.

12. Bhatnagar, Satbir Kumar. A Federal Aspect of Regulation of Industries in India, Law Journal, June 30, 1984.

13. Bhattacharya, J.K. Development Plans and Impact on Union-State Financial Relations (1950—70), Journal of Constitutional & Parliamentary Studies,

July—Sept., 1972.

14. Chakrabarti, S.R. Freight Equalization-I—Lopsided- ness of Balanced Growth, and II—Proof of a A Promise in the Keeping, The Business Standard, June 28 & 29, 1985.

15. Chakrabarti, S.R.C. Sales Tax: Is Additional Excise an Adequate Subtitute? The Business Standard, July 23, 1985.

16. Chattopadhyay, P. Consignment Tax : Some Considera- tions, Commerce, June 9, 1984.

17. Commerce (Editorial) Consignment Tax : A Bonanza To States, June 9, 1984.

18. Dang, Ajit A. Market Borrowings by. States, The Financial Express, March 20, 1985.

19. Dattagupta, Arun K. Centre-State Financial Relations : What the Controversy is All About Capital, Feb. 28—March 6, 1983.

20. Deshpande, V.S. The President : His Powers and Their Exercise, Journal of the Indian Law, Instutute, Volume 13, 1971.

21. Economic Times Octroi and Sales Tax, The Economic Times Saturday Supplement, July 16, 1983.

22. Fazal, Mohd. Positive Approach to Planning, Facts for you, August, 1984.

23. Financial Express Centre-State Fiscal Relations (A Financial Express Symposium, February 16, 1983).

24. Gadgil, D.R. Some Aspects of Centre-State Financial Relations, Public Affairs, August, 1970.

25. Gauri Shankar Tax on Consignment of Goods, The Economic Times, June 20, 1983.

26. George, K.K. Discretionary Budgetary Transfers: A Review, Economic & Political Weekly, November 15, 1986.

27. George, K.K. & Gulati, I.S. Central In-Roads into State Subjects—An Analysis of Economic Service, Economic & Political Weekly, April, 6, 1986.

28. Ghorpede, M.Y. States of the Union-I Planning Better Money Management, The Statesmen, May 5, 1985.

29. Ghosh, Arun Decentralisation of Planning, The Business Standard, September 5—7, 1985.

30. Gopalakrishnan, P.K. Centre-State Relations in financial Planning, Mainstream, July 14, 1984. 31. Gopalakrishna, P.S. Surcharge on Income Tax: Nature & Relevance of the Levy, The Economic Times, June 4,

1983.

32. Gopalakrishna, P.S. Tax on Farm Income: Examination of Pros and Cons, The Economic Times, June 14, 1984.

33. Gopalaswamy, R. & (i) Financial Co-operation be Ramaswamy, T. tween Centre & States.

(ii) Need to correct Imbalance, The Economic Times, December 11, & 12, 1968.

34. Guhan, S. Centre-State Fiscal Ties: Some Comments, The Financial Express, March, 4, 1984.

35. Guhan, S. Devolution Criteria; From Gamble to Policy, Economic and Political Weekly, December 1. 1984.

36. Gulati, I.S. & Inter-State Distribution through George, K.K. Budgetary Transfers, Economic & Political Weekly, March, 18, 1978.

37. Gulati, I.S. & Inter-State Redistribution through George, K.K. Institutional Finance, Economic & Political Weekly, August, 5, 1978.

38. Gulati, I.S. & Centre-State Finances: Stock Taking Nambiar, K.V. of Relations, The Economic Times, August, 25, 1979.

39. Gupta, D.R. (i) Market Borrowings: Their Role in Financing 5 year Plans.

(ii) Market Borrowings : Criteria for allocation among States, The Economic Times, July 14 & 15, 1983.

40. Homes (Jr.) Henry W. Powers of President: Myth or Reality, Journal of the Indian Law Institute, Vol. 12, 1970.

41. Jain, Rajender Regional Disparities and Federal Finance, Yojana, September 1—15, 1983.

42. Jha. Premshankar Centre-State Finances, The Times of India, January 11, 1982.

43. Jha, P.K. Co-ordination between Finance Commission and Planning Commission, Journal of Indian Institute of Bankers, April—June, 1976.

44. Jha, P.K. Fiscal Autonomy of States in Indian Federation, Southern Eonomist, May, 1, 1976.

45. Kabra, K. It is time to Overhaul this Planning Process, Yojana, January 26, 1984.

46. Kahlon, A.S. & A Critical Study of Centre— Kehal, H. S. State Financial Relations in India, Indian Journal of Economics, July, 1971.

47. Kamath, N.J. Union-State Relations in India's Industrial Administration, Indian Journal of Public Administration, July— September, 1970.

48. Karode, P.S. & Trends in Public Debt, The Chakraborty, T.K. Financial Express, December, 21, 1983.

49. Khanna, K.C. Centre State Relations, Dangers for their Devaluation, The Times of India, September 8, 1977.

50. Khare, G.P. Why Decentralize Planning, Yojana, July 15, 1985.

51. Khatkhate, D.R. & Centre-State Financial Relations Bhatt, V.V. in Context of Planned dvelopment, Economic & Political Weekly, February 21, 1970.

52. Kumar, Rajiv State and Economic Growth: I—Coalition, Conflicts & Crisis, and

II—Power of Subordinates, The Busniess Standard, August 29 & 30, 1985.

53. Lakdawala, D.T. Some Problems of Indian Federal Finance, Commerce December, 1965.

54. Lakdawala, D.T. Centre-State Relations in Planning, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Jan.—March, 1970.

55. Lakdawala, D.T. Evaluation of Union-State Financial Relations, Commerce Supplement, August 19, 1972.

56. Lakdawala, D.T. Review of Centre-State Fiscal Relations, Yojana, October 16, 1978.

57. Lakdawala, D.T. Sixth Finance Commission: Elusive Search for Centre—State Debt Settlement, Commerce, February 16, 1974.

58. Lakdawala, D.T. Plan Finances in Federal Economy, Yojana, May 16, 1979.

59. Lakdawala, D.T. Finance Panel's Role, The Economic Times, February 24 & 25, 1983.

60. Lakdawala, D.T. Centre-State Fiscal Relations, The Financial Express, March 24, 1983.

61. Lakdawala, D.T. Eighth Finance Commission's Recommendations, Economic & Political Weekly, September 1, 1984.

62. Machiraju, H.R. Issues in Inter-Governmental Fiscal Relations in India, Margin 11: 2, January, 1979.

63. Mathur P.C. Centre-State Relations in Economic Sphere, The Hindu, January 17, 1984.

64. Menaria, R.K. Resource Mobilisation—Potential and Constraints in States, The Economic Times, December, 9, 1983.

65. Mitra, Ashok Planning & Planning Commission, The Financial Express, February 4, 1984.

66. Nanjundappa, D.M. & Basis of Resource Transfers from

Rao, G.V.K. Centre to States, Economic & Political Weekly, September 15, 1973.

67. Panchmakhi, V.R. Tax Evasion & Tax Rate, The Financial Express, June 8, 1983.

68. Paranjape, H.K. Machinery for Planned Develop-ment, The Economic Times, January 2, 1982.

69. Patel, Himat State's Share in Income Tax Revenue, Indian Journal of Public Administration, April— June, 1974.

70. Patel, J.F. Central Taxation Level & Com-position in States, The Economic Times, November 16, 1983.

71. Patel, J.F. Central Taxation: Level and Com-position In States, The Economic Times, November 16, 1983.

72. Pendse, D.R. State Autonomy, The Economic Times, January 30 and 31, 1984.

73. Pillai, G. Karunakaran Why Should States Overdraw? Yojana, September 15 1985.

74. Prasad, Kamta Planning: Some Basic Issues, The Financial Express, January 23—26, 1984.

75. Puri, S.S. Union-State Relationship in Agricultural Administration, Indian Journal of Public Administration, July—September, 1970.

76. Rajamannar, P.V. Plea for Re-examination of Centre-State Relations, Commerce, April 8—15, 1967. 77. Raj, K.N. Decentralisation in Perspective Indira Gandhi Development Planning & Centre-State Relations,

Mainstream, December 22, 1984.

78. Remachandra, G. Union-State Relations in Finance and Planning, Indian Journal of Public Administration, July—September, 1966.

79. Remachandra, K.S. Decentralization of Planning, The Financial Express, February, 18, 1984.

80. Rao, Hemlata Federal Fiscal Transfers in India: Criteria & Their Application Artha Vikas, 20: 4, December, 1978.

81. Rao, V.K.R.V. Indian Planning: Some Perspectives, Main Stream, January, 26, 1985.

82. Rao. V.K.R.V. Fresh Approach to Planning, Link, May 5, 1985.

83. Rao, V. Lakshmana Special Financial Institutions : Aiding Rich States, The Business Standard, January 28, 1984.

84. Reddy, Y. Venugopal State Planning and Regional Development Objectives—Some Issues, Indian Journal of Regional Science, Vol. IV. No. 3, 1972.

85. Reserve Bank of India Annual Reports, (1982 to 1985).

86. Reserve Bank of India Reserve Bank of India, Occasional Papers, Vol. 7, No. 2, December, 1986.

87. Santhanan, K. Financial Relations Between the Union and the States : Need for Review by a High Level Commission, Commerce, November, 12, 1966.

88. Santhanam, K. Centre-State Finance: An Objectionable Twist, Eastern Economist, April 3, 1970.

89. Santhanam, K. Centre & States: The Changing Relationship: Financial Mess, Monthly Commentary on Indian Economic Condition, 11: 12, July—August, 1970.

90. Sen, S.R. Planning Machinery in India, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Vol. VII, July—September, 1961.

91. Sinha, Ramashraya Centre-State Financial Relations, Indian Journal of Public Administration, April—June, 1979.

92. Sinha, R.K. E.A.C. Report on Planning, Centralized Decentralization, The Economic Times, April, 5 & 6, 1984.

93. Siva Kumar, J. Union-State Financial Relations, Indian Journal Public Administration, April—June, 1970.

94. Sivaraman, B. Agriculture: State-Union Relations, Indian Journal of Public Administration, July—September, 1970.

95. Srinivasan, N. Union-State Relations in Agriculture Development, Indian Journal of Public Administration, July—Septemebr, 1966.

96. Thavaraj, M.J.K. Centre-State Relation : Mobilisation and Transfer of Resources, Mainstream, Feb. 11 1978.

97. Thavaraj, M.J.K. Centre-State Financial Relations: How to Make them Truly Federal, The Hindu, September, 4, 1978.

98. Thimmaiah, G. Finance Commission Awards and the State's Revenue, Asian Economic Review, November, 1965.

99. Thimmaiah, G. Finance and Plan Panel's Merger: a Re-examination, The Economic Times, June 8, 1974.

100. Thaimmaiah, G. Fiscal Harmonization in Indian Federation, Indian Economic Journal, July—September, 1976.

101. Thaimmaiah, G. Market—Borrowings, The Economic Times, Februrary 28 & March, 1, 1983.

102. Thaimmaiah, G. Finance Commission : Gap Filling Approach Perpetuated, The Economic Times, October 12 & 13, 1984.

103. Thimmaiah, G. Centre's Fiscal Philosophy : An Asseseement, The Economic Times, June 24, 1986.

V. OTHERS

1. Administrative Staff Col- Proceedings of the Second seminar lege of India, Hyderabad. minar on Multi-Level Planning (April 23—28, 1984).

2. Advisory Commission on Study in Comparative Federalism: Inter-Governmental Re- Australia, Canada, the United Lations, United States States and West Germany (1981). of America. 3. Basu, Jyoti Centre-State Relations : Economis & Financial Relations, (Srinagar, 1983).

4. Centre for Monitering Basic Statistics Relating to Indian Indian Economy, Bombay. Economy (Vols. 1 & 2),

(Economic Intelligence Service), (1984).

5. Chelliah Raja J. The Theory of a Federal Economy (M.G. Kutty, Memorail Lecture, 1985. Also published in The Economic Times, August 2 & 3, 1985).

6. Chellaih, Raja J. and State Finances in India, Vol. III Sinha, Narain 'The Measurement of Tex Efforts of State Governments' World Bank Staff Working Papers, No.

523, (1982).

7. Debhashi, P.R. Foundation Lecture on Centre- State—Local Government Relations, (Regional Centre for Urban & Environmental Studies, Osmania University, Hyderabad), (May 18, 1984).

8. Economic Times Special Supplement on Planning Commission, January 2, 1982.

9. George, K.K. Centre-State Financial Flows and Inter-State Disparities in India, (Institute of Management Studies, Unviersity of Cochin), (1982) (Mimeographed).

10. Government of Central Assistance for State Plans Andhra Pradesh (A Monograph), (1979).

11. Government of Centre-State Financial Relations : Andhra Pradesh Certain Relevant Date, (1979).

12. Government of Andhra Correspondence between the Pradesh Chief Minister and the Prime Minister and Union Ministers, (1983).

13. Government of Gujarat Market Borrowings by State Governments, (1981).

14. Government of India, Union Budget 1959-60 Speech of the Ministry of Finance. Finance Minister.

15. Government of India, Resolution (No. F. 7 (5)-(Coord.) 79, Ministry of Finance dated 29th May 1979 setting up the Expenditure Commission.

16. Government of India, Economic Survey (for various Ministry of Finance years).

17. Government of India, White Paper on Punjab Agita- Ministry of Home Affairs tion, (New Delhi, July 10, 1984).

18. Government of India, Incentives for Industries in Ministry of Industry. Backward Areas, (1984).

19. Government of India, Manual of Election Law, (1982). Ministry of Law, Justice and Company Affairs.

20. Government of India, All India Services Manual (Fifth) Ministry of Personnel Edition), Parts I & II. and Training, Adminis- trative Reforms and Public Grievances.

21. Government of India, Summary Records of the Meet- Planning Commission. ings of the National Develop- ment Council (Various meetings).

22. Government of Correspondence between the Karnataka. Chief Minister, Karnataka and the Prime Minister and Union Ministries, Vols. I to VI (1983-85).

23. Government of White Paper on Prices, (1984). Karnataka.

24. Government of White Paper on the Office of the Karnataka. Governor-Constitutional position and Political Perversion, (1983).

25. Government of Kerala. Note on the Replacement of Sales Tax by Additional Excise Duties, (1984).

26. Government of Kerala. Report of the Study Groups No. II on Union-State Relations financial and Development Aspects), (January, 1984).

27. Government of West A Memorandum on Centre- Bengal. State Relations (including Do- cument on Centre-State Rela- tions adopted by the West Bengal Cabinet at its meeting held on December 1, 1977).

28. Government of West Chief Minister's Letters to the Bengal. Central Government : A Selection (Vols. I & II), (1981-82).

29. Goyal, S.K. New Industrial Policy : An Empirical Assesment, (Indian Institute, of Public Administration, New Delhi, Corporate Studies, Research Programme on Foreign Private Capital in India, Working Paper No. 11), (1982).

30. Goyal, S.K. Small Scale Sector and Big Business Chalapati Rao, K.S. (Corporate Studies Groups, Indian & Kumar, Nagesh. Institute of Public Administration, New Delhi) : Studies in National Development, No. 2,

(February, 1982).

31. Hegde, Ramakrishna Planning Process in India, (1986).

32. Hegde, Ramakrishna Freedom of Media (Seventh Bhimsen Sachar Memorial Lecture, December 1, 1985).

33. Hicks, Ursula Federal Finance in a Developing Economy (Lecture delivered by Ursula Hicks at the Indian Institute of Public Administration,

New Delhi), (1971).

34. Indian Economic Centre-State Financial Relations Association (Papers read at the Indian Economic Conference, Bodh Gaya, 1972), (1974).

35. Indian Sugar Mills Indian Sugar Year Book, 1979-80, Association, New Delhi. Vol. II.

36. Institute for Financial Papers and Proceedings of the Management and Re- Seminar on Centre-State Finan- search, Madras. cial Relations, (January 3, 1983).

37. Kerala State Planning Notes on (a) Centre-State Relation- Board. ship in Economic and Social Planning, (b) Measures to Strengthen the Planning Process at the

State Level, and (c) Decentralization of Planning.

38. Maheshwari, S. Report on All India Services (Study done at the Indian Institute of Public Administration, New Delhi, sponsored by the

Commission on Centre State Relations, (1986), (Mimeographed).

39. Raj Krishna The Centre and the Periphery : Inter- State Disparities in Economic Development, (G.L. Mehta Memorial Lecture delivered at I.I.T., Bombay), Published by Centre

for Monitoring Indian Economy, Bombay, Economic Intelligence Service, (September, 1980).

40. Reserve Bank of India Notification on Appointment of a National Finance and Credit Council, (June 2, 1986).

41. Sathyamurthy, T.V. Centre-State Relations in India : With Special Reference to Kerala, Madras Development Seminar Series Bulletin, (October, 1982).

42. Seventh Conference Address by Shri T.N. Chaturvedi, of Chairmen of Public Comptroller & Auditor General Accounts Committees, of India. September 9, 1986.

43. Shahare, M.L. Constitution and the Public Services, Second Lal Bahadur Shastri Memorial Lecture.

44. Singh, Chhatrapati Forestry and The Law: The Reports on Amending the Forest Laws (Indian Law Institute, New Delhi, 1986).

45. Singh, Tarlok (i) Centre-State Financial Relations & Planning—Earlier Experiences, A.I.R. Broadcast, (May 9, 1978).

(ii) Centre-State Financial Relations & Planning Future Requirements, AIR Broadcast, (May 16, 1978).

46. Singh, Tarlok The Planning Process and Public Policy: A Reassessment, R.R. Kala Memorial Lecture, 1979, (Gokhale Institute of Politics & Economics, Pune).

47. Singh, V.B. and Elections in India: Data Handbook Bose, Shankar (Ed.) on Lok Sabha Elections, 1952-80, (1984).

48. State Bank of India, India's Growing Internal Debt and Indian Economic News its Implication, June 1, (1987). letter, Vol. II, No. 3.

49. Sundaram, K.V. Centralisation of Planning to Sub-national Levels—Rhetoric & Reality (Mimeographed) (1984).

50. The Australian National (i) Intergovernmental Fiscal University, Centre for Relations and Regional Growth Research on Federal in a Federal Context, (Russell Financial Relations. Mathews) Reprint Series, No. 42.

(ii) Fiscal Equalization through the Local Grants System, (Russell Mathews), Reprint Series, No. 43.

(iii) The Commonwealth-State Financial Contract, (Russell Mathews), Reprint Series, No. 46.

(iv) Federal-State Fiscal Arrangements in Australia, (Russell Mathews), Reprint Series, No. 57.

51. The Australian National (i) Contemporary and Historical University, Centre for Economic Dimensions of Canadian Research on Federal Confederation, (Douglos Al Auld), Financial Relations. Occasional paper, No. 12.

(ii) New Directions in Financing Canadian Federation, (George E. Carter), Occasional Paper, No. 13.

52. Wallich, Christine State Finances in India, Vol. II, 'Studies in State Finances'. World Working Papers No. 523. (1982).

53. Wallich, Christine State Finances in India, Vol. I, 'Revenue Sharing', World Bank Staff Working Papers No. 523. (1982).

54. Annual Reports of Minis- (i) Ministry of Civil Supplies tries/Departments (1981-82).

(ii) Ministry of Food and Civil Supplies (Department of Civil Supplies), (1982-83 to 1985-86).

(iii) Ministry of Food and Civil Supplies, (Department of Food), (1982-83 to 1985-86).

(iv) Food Corporation of India, (1980-81, 1981-82 and 1984-85).

(v) Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, (1982-83 and 1983-84).

(vi) Ministry of Home Affairs (1983-84).

(vii) Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, (1982-83 to 1984-85).

(viii) Ministry of Energy (Department of Power), (1982-83 to 1984-85).

(ix) Ministry of Labour, (1985-86), Vols. I and II.

(x) Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, (1985-86).

(xi) Ministry of railways (Railway Board), (1984-85 and 1985-86).

(xii) Ministry of Steel and Mines, Department of Mines (1986-87). (xiii) Ministry of Works and Housing, (1982-83).

55. Central Acts, Ordinances, (1) The Administrative Tribunals Regulations. Act, 1985.

(2) The Armed Forces (Punjab and Chandigarh) Special Powers Act, 1983.

(3) The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958.

(4) The Assam (Alternation of Boundaries) Act, 1951 (47 of 1951).

(5) The Border Security Force Act, 1968.

(6) The Border Security Force Rules, 1969.

(7) The Central Industrial Security Force Act, 1968.

(8) Centrral Industrial Security Force Rules, 1969.

(9) Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949.

(10) The Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955.

(11) The Chandigarh Disturbed Areas Act, 1983.

(12) The Chandigarh Disturbed Areas Ordinance, 1983 (No. 6 of 1983).

(13) The Chief Election Commissioner's (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1972.

(14) The Comptroller and Auditor-General's (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act, 1971.

(15) The Comptroller and Auditor-General's (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Amendment Act, 1984 (No. 2 of 1984).

(16) The Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (52 of 1974).

(17) The Dadra and Nagar Haveli Act, 1961 (35 of 1961).

(18) The Dadra and Nagar Haveli (Laws) Regulation, 1963 (6 of 1963).

(19) The Dadra and Nagar Haveli (Civil Courts and Miscellaneous Provisions) Regulation, 1963 (8 of 1963).

(20) The Delhi Administration Act, 1966 (19 of 1966).

(21) The Disturbed Areas (Special Courts) Act, 1976.

(22) The Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.

(23) The General Clauses Act, 1897 (10 1897).

(24) The Goa, Daman and Diu (Administration) Act, 1962 (1 of 1962).

(25) The Goa, Daman and Diu (Laws) Regulation, 1962 (12 of 1962).

(26) The Government of Part C States Act, 1951 (XLIX of 1951).

(27) The Government of Part C States (Amendment) Act, 1954 (7 of 1954).

(28) The Government of Union Territories Act, 1963 (20 of 1963).

(29) The Governors (Emoluments, Allowances and Privileges) Act, 1982.

(30) The High Court Judges (Conditions of Service) Act, 1954 (28 of 1954).

(31) Index to Unrepealed Central Acts, (1982).

(32) The Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968.

(33) The Naga Hills Tuensang Area Act, 1957 (42 of 1957).

(34) The North-Eastern Areas (Re-organisation) Act, 1971 (81 of 1971).

(35) The North-Eastern Areas (Re-organisation) Act, 1971 (84 of 1971).

(36) The Police Act, 1861 (1976).

(37) The Pondicherry (Administration) Act, 1962 (49 of 1962).

(38) The Pondicherry (Laws) Regulation, 1963 (7 of 1963).

(39) The President's Emoluments and Pension Act, 1951 (30 of 1951 and 77 of 1985).

(40) The President's Pension (Amendment Act, 1985 (No. 77 of 1985).

(41) The President's Pension Rules, 1962.

(42) The Punjab Disturbed Areas Ordinance, 1983 (No. 5 of 1983).

(43) The Punjab Disturbed Areas Act, 1983.

(44) The Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966 (31 of 1966).

(45) The State of Arunachal Pradesh Act, 1986 (69 of 1986). (46) The State of Mizoram Act, 1986 (34 of 1986).

(47) The state of Nagaland Act, 1962 (27 of 1962).

(48) The State Reorganisation Act, 1956 (37 of 1956).

(49) The Supreme Court Judges (Conditions of Service) Act, 1958 (No. 41 of 1958).

(50) The Territorial Councils Act, 1956 (103 of 1956).

(51) The Territorist Affected Areas (Special Courts) Act, 1984.

(52) The Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1985.

(53) The Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Rules, 1986.

(54) The unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.

(55) The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Amendment Act, 1969.

(56) The Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, No. 69 of 1980.

(57) The Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 (33 of 1956).

(58) The Oilfields (Regulation and Development) Amendment Act, 1984.

56. State Enactment The Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council Act, 1979.

57. Statutory Rules, Orders (i) The All India Services (Death-cum-Retirement Benefits) Rules, 1958.

(ii) Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business at Joint Meetings of the Zonal Councils.

58. All India Reporter, A.I.R. Manuals, Civil and Criminal, Nagpur. Vols. 1 to 35.

VI. TABLE OF CASES

Supreme Court Judgements 1. A. K. Roy V. Union of India AIR 1982 SC 710.

2. Andhra Pradesh Road Transport Corporation V Union of India, 1964 (7) SCR 17.

3. Atiabari Tea Co. Ltd., and Khayerbari Tea Co. Ltd., V. State of Assam and others, 1961 (1) SCR 809.

4. Automobile Transport (Rajasthan) Ltd., V. State of Rajasthan AIR 1970 SC 1436.

5. Babu Lal Parate V State of Bombay, 1960(1) SCR 605.

6. Chandra Mohan V State of U.P. AIR 1966 SC 1987.

7. Hargovind Pant V Dr. Raghukul Tilak, AIR, 1979, SC 1109.

8. In Re Sea Customs Act, (1964) 3 SCR 787.

9. In Re Coffee Board, 1970(3) SCR 147.

10. Jayantilal Amratlal Shodhan V. F. N. Rana AIR 1964 SC 648.

11. State of Karnataka V. Union of India 1978(2) SCR 1.

12. Khazan Chand V. State of Jammu and Kashmir, (1984), 2 SC 456.

13. Mohd. Maqbool Damnoo V. The State of Jammu and Kashmir, AIR 1972 SC 963.

14. Mohamad Serajudin V. State of Orissa, 1975 (Spp.) SCR 169.

15. Moti Ram Deka V. N.E. Frontier Railway, AIR 1964 SC 600.

16. Rai Sahib Ram Jawaya Kapur V State of Punjab, (S) AIR 1955 SC 549.

17. Ram Manohar Lohia V State of Bihar, AIR 1966 SC 740.

18. Rohtas Industries Ltd. V S.D. Agarwal, AIR 1969 SC 707.

19. S.L. Kapoor V Jagmohan, AIR 1981 SC 136.

20. Samsher Singh V State of Punjab, AIR 1974 SC 2192.

21. Satya Narain Singh V District Engineer, P.W.D. Ballai AIR 1962 SC 1161.

22. State of Punjab V Satya Pal Dang, AIR 1969 SC 903.

23. State of Rajasthan V Union of India, AIR 1977 SC 1361.

24. State Trading Corporation of India Ltd. V The Commercial Tax Officer, AIR 1963 SC 1811.

25. State of West Bengal V Union of India, 1964(1) SCR 371.

26. Union of India V H.S. Dhillon, 1971(2) SCR 33.

27. U.N.R. Rao V Smt. Indira Gandhi, AIR 1971 SC 1002.

28. Bandhua Mukti Morcha V State of Tamil Nadu and Others (writ Petition No. 574/86, with writ Petition No. 633/86—Civil Miscellaneous Petition Nos. 10659/86 and 18377/86, SC.

29. Bandhua Mukti Morcha V Union of India and others Writ Petition (Civil/Crl.) No. 2135 of 1986, SC.

30. Osmania University Teachers' Association V State of Andhra Pradesh 1983(3) SC 424.

31. Bengal Immunity Co. V State of Bihar 1955(1) SCR 603.

32. Bombay V.F.N. Balsara (1951) SCR 682.

33. Chicago and N.W. Tr. Co. V Kalo Brick & Tile, 950 US 311.

34. City Municipal Council, Bellary AIR 1978 SC 1803.

35. Diamond Sugar Mills Ltd., V U.P. (1961) SC 652.

36. G.K. Krishnan V State of Tamil Nadu (1975) 2 SCR 715.

37. Gift Tax Officer V.D.H. Nazareth and others AIR 1970 SC 999.

38. Hari krishna Bhargava V Union of India, 1966 (2) SCR 22.

39. Hans Muller V Superintendent 1955(1) SCR 1285.

40. H. Anrai and Others V State of Maharashtra, (1984) 2 SCR 440.

41. In re C.P. & Berar Sales of Motor Spirit and Lubricants Taxation Act. 1938, AIR 1939 FC I.

42. ITO V M.K. Mohammad Kunhe (1969), 2 SCR, 69.

43. Jadab Singh and other V Himachal Pradesh Administration (1960) 3 SCR 75.

44. Jupudi Sesharatnam V Gift Tax Officer AIR 1960 AP 115.

45. Jaora Sugar Mills V State of M.P. (AIR 1966 SC 416).

46. Licence Cases 5, How, 504, 538.

47. M/s International Tourist Corporation V State of Haryana 1981 (2) SCR 364(372).

48. M' Culloch V. Marylands (1819) 4 Wheat 316.

49. Mrs. Ghendi W/o Umrao Singh V. Union of India and others AIR 1965 Punjab, 65. 50. M.T. Joseph and others V. Gift Tax Officer, AIR 1962 Ker. 97.

51. M/s. Satpal & Co. etc. V. Lt. Governor of Delhi & others AIR 1979 SC 1550.

52. M/s Sable Wagers & Co., and others V. Union of India (AIR 1975 SC 1172).

53. Re Special Courts Bill, 1978, 1979(2) SCR 476.

54. R.M.D.C. V. State of Mysore, AIR 1962 SC 594.

55. Re Delhi Laws Act (1951) SCR 747.

56. Ram Jawaya Kapur V. State of Punjab (1955) 2 SCR 225.

57. State of Bombay V. All Gulshan, 1955 (2) SCR 867.

58. State of Bombay V. Chamarbaugwala, 1957 SCR 874.

59. Satya Narain Singh V. District Engineer, P.W.D., AIR (1962) SC 1161.

60. State of Bombay V. United Motors (India) Ltd., 1953 SCR 1069.

61. S. Dandapani V. Addl. Gift Tax Officer AIR 1963 Mad. 419.

62. Shyam Sunder V. Gift Tax Officer AIR 1967 All. 19.

63. Shree Vinod Kumar & others V. The State of Himachal Pradesh AIR 1959 SC 223.

64. Shetkari Sahakari Shakhar Karkhana V. The Collector of Sangli and other (AIR 1979 SC 1972).

65. S.P. Mittal V. Union of India, AIR 1983 SC I.

66. Waverly Jute Mills Co. Ltd. and others V. Ramon and Co. and the Attorney General of India (AIR 1963 SC 90).

67. Western Coal Fields Ltd. V. Special Area Development Authority (1982) 2 SCR I.

68. Baijnath Kedya V. State of Bihar & Rest (AIR 1970 SC 1436).

69. Hingir Rampur Coal Company V. State of Orissa, 1961 (2), (SCR 537).

70. State of Orissa V. M. A. Tulloch and Company (AIR 1964 SC 1284).

71. H.R.S. Murthy V. Collector of Chittoor and others (AIR 1965 SC 177).

72. Ishwari Kaitan Sugar Mills (P) Ltd. V. The State of U.P. & Others (AIR 1980 SC 1955).

73. The case of Sea Customs Act, 1946 [AIR 1963 SC 1960 (1771)].

High Court’s Judgements

74. Bijayananda Patnaik V. President of India, AIR 1974 Orissa 52.

75. Dy. Acctt. General, Kerala V. State of Kerala AIR 1970 Kerala 158.

76. Golak Behari V. State AIR 1972 Orissa I.

77. In re K. Jayarama Iyer, AIR 1958 A.P. 648.

78. Jay Engineering Works Ltd. V. State of West Bengal, AIR 1968 Calcutta 407.

79. Joti Prasad Upadhya V. Kalka Prasad Bhatnager, AIR 1962 Allahabad 128.

80. M. Kiran Babu V. The State of Andhra Pradesh AIR 1986 Andhra Pradesh 275.

81. Mahabir Prasad Sharma V. Prafulla Chandra Ghose, AIR 1969 Calcutta 198.

82. S.C. Barat V. Hari Vinayak : AIR 1962 Madhya Pradesh 73.

83. (i) Judgement of the single judge of the Calcutta High Court in Civil Rules No. 489(W) of 1971 (April, 1972).

(ii) Judgement of Diversion Court on the appeal against the judgement at (i) above (July, 1972).

(Vires of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949).

Foreign Courts

84. Gibbons V. Ogden, Wheat 1 (US 1824).

85. In Re Eugene Debs, 158 US, 564.

86. Mc-Culloch V. Maryland, Wheats 316, 436 (US 1819). 87. Reference Re Amendment of the Constitution of Canada (Nos. 1, 2 and 3), 125 D.L.R. (3rd) September, 1981.