8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

1/49

4

Ihj` Emgsnerhr Sjh|c}vhwx

]cvce}fa ejg Fkjvsnwhj` Hjvwhwswc

Osennho Osaeooeg 'Epeg

Mhj Negcj Faeh} kl Us}'ejhf Vwsghcv

Wac Vc}hcv kl -]ctnxhj wk Ejwh/HvneohfEnncewhkjv-

!6(

E ]ctnx wk wac Ennc`ewhkj

Kmbcfwhj` wk Tsjhvaocjw

ev tc} Hvneohf Nep

T}cte}cg mx

T}klcvvk} Acioew Mhj Mevacc}Mhj Xevccj

Osennho Osaeooeg Epeg Mhj Negcj Faeh}kl Us}'ejhf Vwsghcv

W}ejvnewcg mx2 Weoc} Osaeooeg Vencco

]c|hvcg mx2 G}* Iaencg Weplhi

8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

2/49

5

Hjw}kgsfwhkj

Enn t}ehvc hv gsc wk wac Nk}g kl wac Pk}ngv. ejg tcefc ejg mncvvhj`v mc stkj Ennea'v Ocvvcj`c} Osaeooeg ejg enn wakvc

nkxen wk aho*

Wk fkoocjfc. wahv }cvce}fa tetc} fkocv ev e }ctnx wk -wac

Ennc`ewhkj Kmbcfwhj` wk Tsjhvaocjw ev tc} Hvneohf Nep-. phwahj wac

vc}hcv kl -]ctnxhj` wk Ennc`ewhkjv-9 kjc kl wac pk}iv mx Mhj Negcj

Faeh} lk} Us}'ejhf Vwsghcv*

Ew wac cjg kl wahv hjw}kgsfwhkj. H pksng nhic wk cqt}cvv gcct

waejiv wk wac vtkjvk}v kl wahv Faeh}* Oex wac Oc}fx kl Ennea

Enoh`awx mc stkj wac lewac} kl wakvc hj fae}`c kl wac Faeh}.

Os'ennho Osaeooeg 'Epeg Mhj Negcj. elwc} pakvc jeoc ks}

Faeh} aev mccj jeocg% Vtcfhen waejiv e}c envk gsc wk Gh}cfwk} kl

wac Tkvw/Ohnncjjhso Gc|cnktocjw T}k`}eo. T}klcvvk} Emgs}/

]eaoej Iaeoeiaho. lk} ahv mncvvcg cllk}wv. fkjfc}j phwa ejg

ett}cfhewhkj kl wac Faeh}* H pksng envk nhic wk cqwcjg waejiv wk wac

Sjh|c}vhwx T}cvhgcjw. T}klcvvk} Sveoea Mhj Vegcu Wexxhm. wac

Sjh|c}vhwx \hfc T}cvhgcjw lk} Msvhjcvv ejg Fk`jhwh|c F}cewh|hwx.

Eaoeg Mhj Aeohg Jeuegh. wac Gcej kl wac ]cvce}fa ejg

Fkjvsnwhj` Hjvwhwswc. 'Emgsn/Oenci Mhj Enh En/Bsjchgh. ejg \hfc

Gcejv. T}klcvvk} 'Emgsnnea Mhj Eaoeg En/@aeocgh ejg T}klcvvk}

Aehwaeo Mhj Aevej Nhj`eph* Waejiv envk `k wk wac ocomc}v kl wac

IES Vfhcjwhlhf Faeh}v ]cvce}fa Fkoohwwcc*

Ncw oc envk cqt}cvv gcct `}ewhwsgc wk Faeh} Vstc}|hvk}.

T}klcvvk} Osaeooeg Mhj Emgsnnea En/Aenepejh. pak cqc}wcg

t}ehvcpk}wax cllk}wv hj wahv }cvce}fa tetc}* H envk waeji Evvhvwejw

8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

3/49

=

]cvce}fac}. Vachia Hm}eacco Mhj Osaeooeg Eppen. pak wxtcg

wahv }cvce}fa tetc}*

Ennea Enoh`awx hv wac Vks}fc kl enn vsffcvv%

T}klcvvk} Acioew Mhj Mevacc} Mhj Xevccj

Os'ennho Osaeooeg 'Epeg Mhj Negcj Faeh} kl Us}'ejhf Vwsghcv

8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

4/49

6

]ctnxhj` wk wac Ennc`ewhkj

Kmbcfwhj` wk Tsjhvaocjw ev tc} Hvneohf Nep

Ennea Enoh`awx f}cewcg asoejihjg. }c|cencg wac Us}'ej phwa}snhj`v phwa pahfa nhlc elleh}v fej mc oeje`cg t}ktc}nx* Vsfa }snhj`vhjfnsgc wac egohjhvw}ewhkj kl tsjhvaocjw effk}ghj` wk Hvneohf Nep.pahfa vk osfa fkjw}hmswcv wk wac lsnlhnnocjw kl wac lh|c kmbcfwh|cv kl Hvneohf Nep2 Wac t}cvc}|ewhkj kl lehwa. nhlc. okjcx ejg t}ktc}wx. ocjwen

lefsnwhcv ejg akjk}* Hjgccg. wac egohjhvw}ewhkj kl tsjhvaocjw effk}ghj`wk Hvneohf Nep hjvs}cv enn wacvc t}c}cushvhwcv l}ko |e}hksv ej`ncv*

Gcvthwc wahv vc}hksv ett}kefa wk t}cvc}|hj` wacvc lh|ct}c}cushvhwcv. vkoc `}kstv kl tkvhwh|c nep oeic}v oeic osfa lsvv ejgvwh} wsosnwsksv fkjw}k|c}vhcv f}hwhfhrhj` wac phvc Us}'ejhf }snhj`v.gcvf}hmhj` waco ev mefipe}g k} fnehohj` waew wacx ahjgc} asoej}cvks}fcv gc|cnktocjw. oswhnewc vkoc te}wv kl wac asoej mkgx ejg

sjgc}ohjc asoej gh`jhwx* Wac }ctnx wk wacvc ennc`ewhkjv fkocv hj waclknnkphj` vhq tkhjwv2

Lh}vw2 Wac Lcp Fevcv ]cush}hj` wac Egohjhvw}ewhkj kl Hvneohf Nep

Tsjhvaocjw2

Wac fevcv hj pahfa Hvneohf Nep tsjhvaocjw hv wk mc egohjhvwc}cg

e}c nhohwcg* Vkoc }cfikj waew wac }snhj`v kj Hvneohf Nep tsjhwh|cocevs}cv e}c ev oejx ev wakvc kj t}exc}* Wac w}swa hv wac}c e}casjg}cgv kl Hvneohf Nep }snhj`v. msw kjnx vc|cj kl pahfa gclhjc wac fevcv}cush}hj` tsjhwh|c ocevs}cv hj Hvneo2 Ac}emea !h*c*. mejghw}x k} e}ocg}kmmc}x(. etkvwewhrhj`. e``}cvvhkj. lk}jhfewhkj. vnejgc}. waclw ejgg}hjihj` enfkaknhfv* Wac }cnewcg tsjhwh|c ocevs}cv e}c wk mc weicj kjnxelwc} fc}wehj vwe`cv ejg wac kmvc}|ewhkj kl vw}hfw }cvw}hfwhkjv. kjnx hl ejxkl wac emk|c/ocjwhkjcg vhjv hv lk} vs}c fkoohwwcg. t}k|hghj` t}kklve`ehjvw wac kjc effsvcg kl fkoohwwhj` waco mx pex kl fkjlcvvhkj k}

8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

5/49

7

wcvwhokjx lk} cqeotnc* Hj wac fevc kl lk}jhfewhkj. wac egohjhvw}ewhkj kl Hvneohf tsjhvaocjw }cush}cg ae|hj` lks} phwjcvvcv. t}k|hgcg wacx e}cw}svwpk}wax ejg mcxkjg effsvewhkj* Wahv hv wk hjvs}c wac t}ktc}hj|cvwh`ewhkj kl w}swa. fc}wehjwx ejg weihj` t}cfeswhkjv phwa waew jsomc}kl phwjcvvcv tcfsnhe} wk wac f}hoc kl lk}jhfewhkj*

Wac phvgko kl waew hv waew Ennea Enoh`awx tncevcv waew Ahvvc}|ejwv' vhjv }coehj fkjfcencg* Envk wac f}hoc kl lk}jhfewhkj hvfkoohwwcg mx wpk9 vk hw vccov waew cefa kl pako osvw ae|c wpkphwjcvvcv wcvwhlxhj` e`ehjvw aho+ac} lk} tsjhvaocjw wk mcegohjhvwc}cg*5

Hmj En/Uexxco. oex ac }cvw hj tcefc. vehg waew ksw kl Ennea'vswokvw Phvgko ejg Oc}fx. Ac aev jkw k}gehjcg tsjhvaocjw lk} vhjjc}vphwaksw t}k|hj` wach} vhjv ejg Ac pksng jkw faevwhvc waco hj wacAc}celwc} phwaksw t}k|hj` wach} vhjv lk} waco* Hmj En/Uexxco eggcg waewwac t}kklv wk mc t}k|hgcg lk} waco e}c chwac} mx pex kl fkjlcvvhkj k}vakphj` akp wach} vwewcv kl elleh}v ewwcvw wk wach} mchj` vhjjc}v. k}t}k|hghj` kwac} sjfkjwcvwcg t}kklv ksw kl wach} aejgv. t}k|hgcg bsvwhfcejg hjwc`}hwx* Ac pcjw kj vexhj` waew wac asoej ohjg ejg hjvwhjfwfejjkw lhjg ejx mcwwc} ocwakgv9 wacx fejjkw hjw}kgsfc mcwwc} kjcv wkvc}|c tcktnc'v hjwc}cvwv hj e mcwwc} pex*=

Ac}c hv ej cqeotnc kl wac }e}c fevcv kl tsjhvahj` lk}jhfewhkjeffk}ghj` wk Hvneohf Nep9 vhjfc wac tsjhvaocjw lk} lk}jhfewhkj pev}c|cencg hj wac Us}'ej. hw aev jc|c} mccj ace}g waew vsfa tsjhvaocjwpev egohjhvwc}cg effk}ghj` wk wac lks}/phwjcvv fkjghwhkj* Envk jkpkoej aev c|c} mccj tsjhvacg lk} lk}jhfewhkj phwaksw ac} fkjlcvvhj` wkhw. c|cj hl phwjcvvcv phwjcvv e`ehjvw ac}. ev hj wac fevc kl hot}cfewhkj* Hjej eswacjwhf Vexhj` mx T}ktacw Osaeooeg. tcefc ejg mncvvhj`v mcstkj aho !TMSA(. ac ghg jkw tsjhva e pkoej hj wac hjfhgcjw kl hot}cfewhkj* Wac vwk}x `kcv ev lknnkpv2 Ahnen mhj Soexxea effsvcg ahvphlc kl fkoohwwhj` hnnc`en vcqsen hjwc}fks}vc phwa Vae}hi mhj Veaoe' ejglhncg wac fevc mclk}c wac T}ktacw* Wac T}ktacw vehg !wk Ahnen(. -Chwac} xksm}hj` lk}wa e t}kkl !lks} phwjcvvcv( k} xks phnn }cfch|c wac nc`en

tsjhvaocjw !nevacv( kj xks} mefi*- Ahnen vehg. -K Ennea'v ocvvcj`c}% Hl ejxkjc kl sv vep e oej k|c} ahv phlc. pksng ac `k wk vcci phwjcvvcv;-

8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

6/49

3

Wac T}ktacw ictw kj vexhj`. -Chwac} xks m}hj` lk}wa wac phwjcvvcv k} xksphnn }cfch|c wac nc`en tsjhvaocjw !nevacv( kj xks} mefi*- Ahnen wacj vehg.-Mx Aho Pak vcjw xks phwa wac W}swa. H eo wcnnhj` wac w}swa ejg Enneaphnn }c|cen wk xks paew phnn ve|c ox mefi l}ko nc`en tsjhvaocjw*- Wacj@em}hcn feoc gkpj ejg }c|cencg wk aho2/'Ev lk} wakvc pak effsvc wach}ph|cv***'' !Wac Us}'ej. =72

8/8/2019 A Reply to the Allegation

7/49

<

vwkjcv. ac f}hcg2 'K tcktnc% ]cws}j oc wk wac Ocvvcj`c} kl Ennea!TMSA(* Ox tcktnc ihnncg oc ejg gcfch|cg oc9 wacx wkng oc waew wacOcvvcj`c} kl Ennea !TMSA( pksng jkw ihnn oc*' Pc ghg jkw icct epexl}ko aho whnn pc ihnncg aho* Pacj pc }cws}jcg wk wac Ocvvcj`c} kl Enneaejg hjlk}ocg aho kl hw. ac vehg2 'Pax ghg xks jkw nce|c aho enkjc ejgm}hj` aho wk oc;' ejg ac vehg wahv vk waew wac Ocvvcj`c} kl Ennea !TMSA(oh`aw evfc}wehj hw l}ko aho*- 3

Nc`en Cqtc}w. T}klcvvk} Emgsnnea mhj Eva/Vachia Oealksr mhjMcxxea vehg. -Wac snwhoewc kmbcfwh|c ejg okvw vsmnhoc `ken kl f}hohjennc`hvnewhkjv hv wk gcf}cevc ejg t}c|cjw f}hoc wk t}cvc}|c asoej }h`awvwk nhlc ejg vcfs}hwx. ejg wk t}cvc}|hj` kjc'v t}ktc}wx ejg t}kwcfw kjc'vt}k`cjx* Vsfa }h`awv e}c jkw vsllhfhcjwnx kmvc}|cg hj tkvhwh|c f}hohjenfkgcv9 wach} vsffcvv ejg lehns}c e}c ocevs}cg mx wach} emhnhwx wk t}cvc}|cwacvc }h`awv*-

Ev Hvneohf Nep vw}hfwnx lh`awv e``}cvvhkj e`ehjvw wacvc }h`awv mxvw}kj`nx tsjhvahj` waco. hw envk t}k|hgcv phjgkpv lk} vkoc kl wakvcfkoohwwhj` `}e|c f}hocv wk }cg}cvv wach} ohvweicv. pahfa fnce}nxhjghfewcv waew t}cvf}hmcg tsjhvaocjw mevhfennx ehov ew fk}}cfwhj`kswnepv ejg }clk}ohj` vkfhcwx*