A review of FMV from a RECOil feed rewealed

Allegation I unKnown individuals moving

into a target area during a

striKe on PIO ISIL fighters

under SROE 001

9282014 sv Syrian Obs~tVatory 120000 AM Human Rifhts reported that AII~cation 2 civilians were killed and

wounded during US strilces

conducted into Sria 412015 The SNHR alleges that an internation~1

warplane ttJrReting ANF weapons storage

warehouses caused the

collapse of a residence

nearby killine 13

1062014 Sources I 1057014 80000 AM AlleGation 3

described US airstrice in the viHaee of Hit

On reviewing WSV from

1111 1 AUS FI8F) Alleeation 4 following a strike on an Isrl

checkpoint to tne West of

Ramadl r 6BU 12 lams delav) it was apparent that a

truck entered the target ~rea

between weapon releae

and impact lUll

covering the strike

091414 TF conducted Inquiry

inqLl iry

determine that cllIilians were requred prfsent at the site Open

source images presented as casualties from the strikes

actuallv came from previous GoS strikes

No furthp-f

inquiry rcqurcd

requred due

to a review of

FMV 1 10

10

1O152014 120000 AM

AlieBation S

Sources I 10152014 Sy

_-shy 1-_

1 bullbull - bull

sources reported that

an 87 year old woman was

killed during a dvnamic stirke

IVO Kobanl and that two main hospitals were destroyed by us bombing

TO I I

101714 TF conducted an initial crcd i bilit~

determination on both

allegations

101720

Sources 110172014 120000 AM IEVfV lei ZoirDeZI SVlseven civilians were killed Ireported Iconducted a delibe-ratc strike I Idetfrlnine CIVCAS CFACe Allegation 6

stirke

DOS provided a

the SNHR

3 civilians were

killed durinll the

Collection Point

personnel present in the

target area

Allegation 7 I Iconducted on se-eral and (03-0 that no Irequred operationCiI reports wer~

r~ceivcd about alleged

ClVCAS from this strike

102514 JOe JA spoke to

fb~I I She tOnfirmed that TF

had received no r~port5 of

Olleged CIVCAS C1rising from

this strike Note TF has

previously self-reported one

potential CIVeAS incid~nt and conducted credibility

determinations on two

allegations

10292014 Reviewed the INO further dynamic strikes for Syria Dn inquir

Allegation 8 I Ireport that coalition forces I 28 OCT The onl strike that requred

corresponded w ith the

report was a strike on CI tank

about 70 krn N of Raqaa Review of the aircrews video

showed that tj trike

conducted wit ~GM

struck the target No civilIans were present on the video

either pre- or post -strike An

inilial review of a strike

during the Initial dclibcrdle

strikes in SVria prior to 29

September on the area IVO

grain silos in Idlib had

been conducted determined

not to have been ClVCAS

1O152014 120000 AM

AlieBation S

Sources I 10152014 Sy

_-shy 1-_

1 bullbull - bull

sources reported that

an 87 year old woman was

killed during a dvnamic stirke

IVO Kobanl and that two main hospitals were destroyed by us bombing

TO I I

101714 TF conducted an initial crcd i bilit~

determination on both

allegations

101720

Sources 110172014 120000 AM IEVfV lei ZoirDeZI SVlseven civilians were killed Ireported Iconducted a delibe-ratc strike I Idetfrlnine CIVCAS CFACe Allegation 6

stirke

DOS provided a

the SNHR

3 civilians were

killed durinll the

Collection Point

personnel present in the

target area

Allegation 7 I Iconducted on se-eral and (03-0 that no Irequred operationCiI reports wer~

r~ceivcd about alleged

ClVCAS from this strike

102514 JOe JA spoke to

fb~I I She tOnfirmed that TF

had received no r~port5 of

Olleged CIVCAS C1rising from

this strike Note TF has

previously self-reported one

potential CIVeAS incid~nt and conducted credibility

determinations on two

allegations

10292014 Reviewed the INO further dynamic strikes for Syria Dn inquir

Allegation 8 I Ireport that coalition forces I 28 OCT The onl strike that requred

corresponded w ith the

report was a strike on CI tank

about 70 krn N of Raqaa Review of the aircrews video

showed that tj trike

conducted wit ~GM

struck the target No civilIans were present on the video

either pre- or post -strike An

inilial review of a strike

during the Initial dclibcrdle

strikes in SVria prior to 29

September on the area IVO

grain silos in Idlib had

been conducted determined

not to have been ClVCAS

Allegation 7 I Iconducted on se-eral and (03-0 that no Irequred operationCiI reports wer~

r~ceivcd about alleged

ClVCAS from this strike

102514 JOe JA spoke to

fb~I I She tOnfirmed that TF

had received no r~port5 of

Olleged CIVCAS C1rising from

this strike Note TF has

previously self-reported one

potential CIVeAS incid~nt and conducted credibility

determinations on two

allegations

10292014 Reviewed the INO further dynamic strikes for Syria Dn inquir

Allegation 8 I Ireport that coalition forces I 28 OCT The onl strike that requred

corresponded w ith the

report was a strike on CI tank

about 70 krn N of Raqaa Review of the aircrews video

showed that tj trike

conducted wit ~GM

struck the target No civilIans were present on the video

either pre- or post -strike An

inilial review of a strike

during the Initial dclibcrdle

strikes in SVria prior to 29

September on the area IVO

grain silos in Idlib had

been conducted determined

not to have been ClVCAS

17

13

14

15

Allegation 12

12102014 IOpen Source 12o()(UXlAM

Allceat ion 13

1213201 4 Source I 12132014 40600 PM

Allegation 14

12162014 12162014 IHOOOAM

AlieCittlon 15

cative females were IclUed in

a strike on a named 081 Iva Mosul

Ccd

11

11 BOA on _strike on nilmed

objective (Nebu la) 121 62014 TF assessed the allegation

not to be credible based on a

review of all source inleL

Review of FMV showed that

the 4 individuals in question

eventually fled the sc~nc of the strike _11 1) 1 shy

indicated thait he only

persons killed or injured

were those in the targeted

vehicle No reflections of

ClVCAS received throuch

l i t ~ and media report s

However TF is still

conducting an investigation

into deciSions made related to the strike

16

17

18

19

121212014 nOOOOAM

Allegation 16

11262014 D8S5Z

Allegation 17

1226f]014 nOOOOAM

AIle-cation 18

1117 2014 Allegation 19

12212014

12252014

12262014 IUNclASS

12212014 ISRCL-FVPI

At 00202 22 DEC 141 Tf1 Airfield IF-16 US) conducted re shy

attack uSi~G8U-54 on an

ISIL fighter fleeing from the

Strike 1422 checkpoint

engagement This fe-attack

resulted in Ix building

damaged 1x EK1A and 2x

nearby pax possiblV injured

CAOC reported that on

085SZ 26 DEC 14 whilf

conducting dynamic coalition

dirslriices on ISIL fichters and technica l vehkles~ )1 1)1 4

(NLD Fmiddot l6AMj may have

unintentionally struck two

unidentified persons on

motorcycles who entered the

tctrget area during the

striies

11 1

a result of a deliberate striie

conducted by the ustrlians

on a suspected weapons

factory In Fallujah

~JiI liIt ~AiiOiIOj

unknown

11l222014 CAOC

review lAW

policy_

12302014 No further

inquiry

required

IlnolfstiRation ongoing (AF

of an AR 15middot6)

directed in the

a similar

by

Completed bV

CAOC Forwarded

on 2 MAR 15 orr )rovded potlO to LTG To Need

mCADC

12242014

12( 272014

and CAO( recommends cholt there is insufficient

information to warrant

further inquiry Australia used the materials resultinl from the initial credibility

I

Not credible

20

21

in the vicinitv of the rane

received minor injuries The

US members were not firing

at the rang~

22

structu res tnget was in

open terrain 1918 101111 III JAN1S Covered

Revetment 25km SE AI

Hasalcah Occurred after reported time

I

prisoner~ ott a pri50nlociillion

in AI Bab City that it knew would be targeted by the coalition

SFG w ere operating as range

safeties while an Iraqi Special

Ta ctics Unit (STU) was

conducting a 50 cal range On 2 JAN the unit received

reports that 2 civilians living

5 J2 targets

ndueted it review of recent

strikes in and around At

Hassatah 2 engagements

found 11894 I 11-M JANIS ISll

Personnel targeted 66km NE

AI Hasalcah NatlVO citv or

Nafurt

inqUIry

required

[ntnP

inquiry

required

23

(lvad_ asc in Ninawa Pro___ inceon 21 - linqU iry nJary) 22JAN IS 6 strilces inllolved required

buildings Initial aSsessment

is that only 2 stnlces possiblt

for this allcgation (one was 24

I cngaged by UAV both had

UAV coverage) - 198022

IAN 15 -1990 2Jbull II r ~AN 15

25

4150319

Allcgation 26

Web Ops ISll

media office

inMMul

Nnawa Media

and time of m specific

allegation

26

16

17

18

19

121212014 nOOOOAM

Allegation 16

11262014 D8S5Z

Allegation 17

1226f]014 nOOOOAM

AIle-cation 18

1117 2014 Allegation 19

12212014

12252014

12262014 IUNclASS

12212014 ISRCL-FVPI

At 00202 22 DEC 141 Tf1 Airfield IF-16 US) conducted re shy

attack uSi~G8U-54 on an

ISIL fighter fleeing from the

Strike 1422 checkpoint

engagement This fe-attack

resulted in Ix building

damaged 1x EK1A and 2x

nearby pax possiblV injured

CAOC reported that on

085SZ 26 DEC 14 whilf

conducting dynamic coalition

dirslriices on ISIL fichters and technica l vehkles~ )1 1)1 4

(NLD Fmiddot l6AMj may have

unintentionally struck two

unidentified persons on

motorcycles who entered the

tctrget area during the

striies

11 1

a result of a deliberate striie

conducted by the ustrlians

on a suspected weapons

factory In Fallujah

~JiI liIt ~AiiOiIOj

unknown

11l222014 CAOC

review lAW

policy_

12302014 No further

inquiry

required

IlnolfstiRation ongoing (AF

of an AR 15middot6)

directed in the

a similar

by

Completed bV

CAOC Forwarded

on 2 MAR 15 orr )rovded potlO to LTG To Need

mCADC

12242014

12( 272014

and CAO( recommends cholt there is insufficient

information to warrant

further inquiry Australia used the materials resultinl from the initial credibility

I

Not credible

20

21

in the vicinitv of the rane

received minor injuries The

US members were not firing

at the rang~

22

structu res tnget was in

open terrain 1918 101111 III JAN1S Covered

Revetment 25km SE AI

Hasalcah Occurred after reported time

I

prisoner~ ott a pri50nlociillion

in AI Bab City that it knew would be targeted by the coalition

SFG w ere operating as range

safeties while an Iraqi Special

Ta ctics Unit (STU) was

conducting a 50 cal range On 2 JAN the unit received

reports that 2 civilians living

5 J2 targets

ndueted it review of recent

strikes in and around At

Hassatah 2 engagements

found 11894 I 11-M JANIS ISll

Personnel targeted 66km NE

AI Hasalcah NatlVO citv or

Nafurt

inqUIry

required

[ntnP

inquiry

required

23

(lvad_ asc in Ninawa Pro___ inceon 21 - linqU iry nJary) 22JAN IS 6 strilces inllolved required

buildings Initial aSsessment

is that only 2 stnlces possiblt

for this allcgation (one was 24

I cngaged by UAV both had

UAV coverage) - 198022

IAN 15 -1990 2Jbull II r ~AN 15

25

4150319

Allcgation 26

Web Ops ISll

media office

inMMul

Nnawa Media

and time of m specific

allegation

26

I

Not credible

20

21

in the vicinitv of the rane

received minor injuries The

US members were not firing

at the rang~

22

structu res tnget was in

open terrain 1918 101111 III JAN1S Covered

Revetment 25km SE AI

Hasalcah Occurred after reported time

I

prisoner~ ott a pri50nlociillion

in AI Bab City that it knew would be targeted by the coalition

SFG w ere operating as range

safeties while an Iraqi Special

Ta ctics Unit (STU) was

conducting a 50 cal range On 2 JAN the unit received

reports that 2 civilians living

5 J2 targets

ndueted it review of recent

strikes in and around At

Hassatah 2 engagements

found 11894 I 11-M JANIS ISll

Personnel targeted 66km NE

AI Hasalcah NatlVO citv or

Nafurt

inqUIry

required

[ntnP

inquiry

required

23

(lvad_ asc in Ninawa Pro___ inceon 21 - linqU iry nJary) 22JAN IS 6 strilces inllolved required

buildings Initial aSsessment

is that only 2 stnlces possiblt

for this allcgation (one was 24

I cngaged by UAV both had

UAV coverage) - 198022

IAN 15 -1990 2Jbull II r ~AN 15

25

4150319

Allcgation 26

Web Ops ISll

media office

inMMul

Nnawa Media

and time of m specific

allegation

26

inquiry

required

23

(lvad_ asc in Ninawa Pro___ inceon 21 - linqU iry nJary) 22JAN IS 6 strilces inllolved required

buildings Initial aSsessment

is that only 2 stnlces possiblt

for this allcgation (one was 24

I cngaged by UAV both had

UAV coverage) - 198022

IAN 15 -1990 2Jbull II r ~AN 15

25

4150319

Allcgation 26

Web Ops ISll

media office

inMMul

Nnawa Media

and time of m specific

allegation

26

28

29

responsible for conducting iii

determination of credibility

of the accusations and a first impressions report It should

be noted t haI (JOC legad opinion is that under th~

for the CAF to

Awiting

Awaiting

Not credIble After assessing

the information on the four

tal~et$ I CAOC agrees

that IS it not iI credible allegation Against ill il

r (LAOe assesses n01

enough information to

confirm credibility

Not credible Closest strike W3S Ghunah oilfield ReVIew

of WSV conducted and did not show ny people in the

WSV throughout the strike

CENTCOMI middot1

Allegation 30

30

232015 CAOC 232015 Allega tion 31

31

242015 OSINT unknown IUII~uo Allegation 32

32

33

Tishrin In AI Hasakah

Governorate killing several employees and workers

posslhle child entering a

targeted bunker and then

disappeiuing out of the field

of view (FOV) approltimate

19 minute5 before Strike

At ( lit 03 FEB 15 CJTFmiddotOIR

conducted II dynamic strilce

on the targeted bunlcerbv

Race 43 (M ~ 2000 FRAJ using

11 III t 9U-49 reSUlting in 5x

EKIA

Raqaa SV Twiner usp~ I--- I ~ f I tWIttcd that

coalition aircraft kil led an

entire famity in an airstrilce on Ar RaQqah in response to

t he killing of Jordan ian pilot

Mu ttdh al-KasClslbah The

allegation was accompanied

by an attached photo showinR th~ alicHed lIictims

wrapped in white doth

Jordanian alrstrikc Iva RaqaaSV

Unknown

CENTCOM CHOPS

report via Ops

Not credible

No further

inquiry

required

llreets I ~

f Itt)1 J CAoe ilsrees that is it not a credible

allcJ tion A8aiflS1 ~

poe assesses not

enough information to

confirm credibility

Not credible INT reflections

that individuals struck were

fightc rs

34

35

36

Allegation 34

Open Sources I 2242015 IUIfOUG-AlleEation 35

struck a Mosque in Haditha

AI Anbar Province during

afternoon hours on 18 February 201S causing 15

civilian casualties

IZ Open source media reports

iflcudinC

I -I Colition lt)ircraft alleged

struck seven houses in the

villages of Abu Sauda tlnd

Abu Jasim located east of AIshy

Karmah AI Anbar Province

IRQ on 24 FEB 15 cClusine 20 civilian casuallics and 30

more civilian injuries Upon

initial review of Coalition

airs trikes since 15 FEB 2015

only two strikes have been

conducted 0 the AIshyKarmah area

Qa im IZ Open 50ruce media report

120000 AM that the hospital source in al-

Allegation 36 Qaim a town on the

Euphrates River hopila l said

nine iiUans were killed and

29 militants were wounded

in the strike bV the US-led

coalition Some 0 [he

wounded were taken across

the border to Syria for

treatmenl

inqu iry

required

Not credIble

No further

Inquiry

required

inquiry

required

3-

AlIel3tion 17

strike rSR imagery shOoVed that an unintentional

potential ClVCAS mav have

occurred Unidentified and unexpected personnel were

seen Iva of the detonations

CAOC is ilsses-lng

Ill 1- ~SF - 16)mav

have unintentionally struck

In lEGAOCC

38

3292015 ICAOC 3282015 UoOOltJ)AM

Allegat ion 39

39

t he nearest collateral object (NCO) and m~v hlIe

unintentionallv struck a car

that moved into the FOV

11 )1 PBU-31 struck the correct

JDPI but a car was seen

moving Into the FOV as the

G8U-31 hit the correct JDPI

40

41

4

Allegation 40

4 6201

4131015 4122015 IZ 200 Aliceatlon 42 received the lnit i1

notificatjo n (5Ws) IF

indicated they are workinc

with subordinate units to conduct oJn middotssessment of the strike lAW the CC

CENTCOM polic~

Allegation 30

30

232015 CAOC 232015 Allega tion 31

31

242015 OSINT unknown IUII~uo Allegation 32

32

33

Tishrin In AI Hasakah

Governorate killing several employees and workers

posslhle child entering a

targeted bunker and then

disappeiuing out of the field

of view (FOV) approltimate

19 minute5 before Strike

At ( lit 03 FEB 15 CJTFmiddotOIR

conducted II dynamic strilce

on the targeted bunlcerbv

Race 43 (M ~ 2000 FRAJ using

11 III t 9U-49 reSUlting in 5x

EKIA

Raqaa SV Twiner usp~ I--- I ~ f I tWIttcd that

coalition aircraft kil led an

entire famity in an airstrilce on Ar RaQqah in response to

t he killing of Jordan ian pilot

Mu ttdh al-KasClslbah The

allegation was accompanied

by an attached photo showinR th~ alicHed lIictims

wrapped in white doth

Jordanian alrstrikc Iva RaqaaSV

Unknown

CENTCOM CHOPS

report via Ops

Not credible

No further

inquiry

required

llreets I ~

f Itt)1 J CAoe ilsrees that is it not a credible

allcJ tion A8aiflS1 ~

poe assesses not

enough information to

confirm credibility

Not credible INT reflections

that individuals struck were

fightc rs

34

35

36

Allegation 34

Open Sources I 2242015 IUIfOUG-AlleEation 35

struck a Mosque in Haditha

AI Anbar Province during

afternoon hours on 18 February 201S causing 15

civilian casualties

IZ Open source media reports

iflcudinC

I -I Colition lt)ircraft alleged

struck seven houses in the

villages of Abu Sauda tlnd

Abu Jasim located east of AIshy

Karmah AI Anbar Province

IRQ on 24 FEB 15 cClusine 20 civilian casuallics and 30

more civilian injuries Upon

initial review of Coalition

airs trikes since 15 FEB 2015

only two strikes have been

conducted 0 the AIshyKarmah area

Qa im IZ Open 50ruce media report

120000 AM that the hospital source in al-

Allegation 36 Qaim a town on the

Euphrates River hopila l said

nine iiUans were killed and

29 militants were wounded

in the strike bV the US-led

coalition Some 0 [he

wounded were taken across

the border to Syria for

treatmenl

inqu iry

required

Not credIble

No further

Inquiry

required

inquiry

required

3-

AlIel3tion 17

strike rSR imagery shOoVed that an unintentional

potential ClVCAS mav have

occurred Unidentified and unexpected personnel were

seen Iva of the detonations

CAOC is ilsses-lng

Ill 1- ~SF - 16)mav

have unintentionally struck

In lEGAOCC

38

3292015 ICAOC 3282015 UoOOltJ)AM

Allegat ion 39

39

t he nearest collateral object (NCO) and m~v hlIe

unintentionallv struck a car

that moved into the FOV

11 )1 PBU-31 struck the correct

JDPI but a car was seen

moving Into the FOV as the

G8U-31 hit the correct JDPI

40

41

4

Allegation 40

4 6201

4131015 4122015 IZ 200 Aliceatlon 42 received the lnit i1

notificatjo n (5Ws) IF

indicated they are workinc

with subordinate units to conduct oJn middotssessment of the strike lAW the CC

CENTCOM polic~

34

35

36

Allegation 34

Open Sources I 2242015 IUIfOUG-AlleEation 35

struck a Mosque in Haditha

AI Anbar Province during

afternoon hours on 18 February 201S causing 15

civilian casualties

IZ Open source media reports

iflcudinC

I -I Colition lt)ircraft alleged

struck seven houses in the

villages of Abu Sauda tlnd

Abu Jasim located east of AIshy

Karmah AI Anbar Province

IRQ on 24 FEB 15 cClusine 20 civilian casuallics and 30

more civilian injuries Upon

initial review of Coalition

airs trikes since 15 FEB 2015

only two strikes have been

conducted 0 the AIshyKarmah area

Qa im IZ Open 50ruce media report

120000 AM that the hospital source in al-

Allegation 36 Qaim a town on the

Euphrates River hopila l said

nine iiUans were killed and

29 militants were wounded

in the strike bV the US-led

coalition Some 0 [he

wounded were taken across

the border to Syria for

treatmenl

inqu iry

required

Not credIble

No further

Inquiry

required

inquiry

required

3-

AlIel3tion 17

strike rSR imagery shOoVed that an unintentional

potential ClVCAS mav have

occurred Unidentified and unexpected personnel were

seen Iva of the detonations

CAOC is ilsses-lng

Ill 1- ~SF - 16)mav

have unintentionally struck

In lEGAOCC

38

3292015 ICAOC 3282015 UoOOltJ)AM

Allegat ion 39

39

t he nearest collateral object (NCO) and m~v hlIe

unintentionallv struck a car

that moved into the FOV

11 )1 PBU-31 struck the correct

JDPI but a car was seen

moving Into the FOV as the

G8U-31 hit the correct JDPI

40

41

4

Allegation 40

4 6201

4131015 4122015 IZ 200 Aliceatlon 42 received the lnit i1

notificatjo n (5Ws) IF

indicated they are workinc

with subordinate units to conduct oJn middotssessment of the strike lAW the CC

CENTCOM polic~

3-

AlIel3tion 17

strike rSR imagery shOoVed that an unintentional

potential ClVCAS mav have

occurred Unidentified and unexpected personnel were

seen Iva of the detonations

CAOC is ilsses-lng

Ill 1- ~SF - 16)mav

have unintentionally struck

In lEGAOCC

38

3292015 ICAOC 3282015 UoOOltJ)AM

Allegat ion 39

39

t he nearest collateral object (NCO) and m~v hlIe

unintentionallv struck a car

that moved into the FOV

11 )1 PBU-31 struck the correct

JDPI but a car was seen

moving Into the FOV as the

G8U-31 hit the correct JDPI

40

41

4

Allegation 40

4 6201

4131015 4122015 IZ 200 Aliceatlon 42 received the lnit i1

notificatjo n (5Ws) IF

indicated they are workinc

with subordinate units to conduct oJn middotssessment of the strike lAW the CC

CENTCOM polic~

40

41

4

Allegation 40

4 6201

4131015 4122015 IZ 200 Aliceatlon 42 received the lnit i1

notificatjo n (5Ws) IF

indicated they are workinc

with subordinate units to conduct oJn middotssessment of the strike lAW the CC

CENTCOM polic~