Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQuality
ObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlantoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattoleRiverWatershed,ActionPlantoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheNavarroRiverWatershed,andActionPlantoAddressTemperatureImpairment
intheEelRiverWatershed
FINALDRAFT
March13,2014
StateofCaliforniaNorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard
5550SkylaneBoulevard,SuiteASantaRosa,California95403
707‐576‐2220www.waterboards.ca.gov/northcoast
TableofContents
PAGE
1.0 INTRODUCTION 11.1 BackgroundandPurpose 11.2 DocumentOrganization 2
2.0ANALYSISOFTEMPERATURE 32.1 IdentificationofDriversofElevatedWaterTemperature 32.2InteractionofTemperatureDrivers 42.3AdditionalConsiderations 62.4TemperatureTMDLAnalyses 72.4.1ShadeAnalyses 82.4.2 HydrologicAnalyses 122.4.3 Microclimate 13
3.0 TEMPERATUREWATERQUALITYOBJECTIVES
15
4.0 INTERPRETATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEWATERQUALITYOBJECTIVESFORTEMPERATURE
17
4.1EstimationofNaturalStreamTemperatures 194.2Site‐specificPotentialEffectiveShade 224.3Project‐specificImplementation 274.4RelianceonManagementPracticesforNonpointSources
AssociatedwithLandUses29
4.5ImplementationinImpairedvsUnimpairedWaterbodies 334.6RegulationofShadeasaControllableFactor
34
5.0REGIONALPOLICYTOIMPLEMENTTHEWATERQUALITYOBJECTIVESFORTEMPERATURE
36
5.1 FactorsIdentifiedinthePolicytoImplementtheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature
36
5.2 JustificationofthePolicyFactors 375.2.1Activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceriparianshade 375.2.2Activitieswiththepotentialtoincreasesedimentdelivery 395.2.3Actionswiththepotentialtochangestreamchannel
geometry42
5.2.4Thequality,quantity,locationandtimingofeffluent,stormwater,andagriculturalreturnflowdischarges
43
5.2.5Thelocation,size,andoperationofin‐channelimpoundmentswiththeabilitytoalterthenaturaltemperatureregime
44
5.2.6Activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceinstreamflowsorreducespecificsourcesofcoldwater,includingcoldwaterrefugia
44
5.3ActionstoAchieveandMaintaintheWaterQualityObjectives 46
forTemperature5.3.1 AddressSite‐SpecificPotentialShadeUsingRegulatory
andNon‐RegulatoryTools47
5.3.2 ImplementSedimentControls 505.3.3 AddressTemperatureConcernsinFutureNonpoint
SourcePrograms51
5.3.4 AddressTemperatureConcernsinIndividualPermits 525.3.5 AddressTemperatureConcernsUsingOtherTools 535.3.6 AddressTemperatureConcernsThroughSupportof
Restoration53
5.3.7 CoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsintheWaterRightsPermittingProcess
54
5.3.8 CoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsintheDevelopmentofInstreamFlowStudiesandFlowObjectives
55
5.3.9 ProvideOtherAgenciesGuidanceandRecommendations
55
5.3.10CoordinatewithOtherStateAgencies 565.3.11MonitorTemperatureTrends 575.3.12DevelopandMaintainaTemperatureWorkplan 57
6.0 ACTIONPLANSTOADDRESSTEMPERATUREIMPAIRMENTSINTHEMATTOLE,NAVARRO,ANDEELRIVERWATERSHEDS
58
6.1 StipulatedAgreement 586.2 GeographicScope 586.3 RelationshiptoRegionalTemperaturePolicy 596.4TemperatureTotalMaximumDailyLoadAssessments 59
6.4.1ProblemStatements 596.4.2SourceAnalyses 596.4.3TotalMaximumDailyLoads 596.4.4NumericTargets 606.4.5MarginsofSafety 65
6.5 DescriptionofImplementationActionstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentsintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershed
65
6.5.1TimberHarvestActivitiesonNon‐FederalLands 656.5.2ActivitiesonLandsManagedbytheUSForestService 676.5.3AgriculturalActivitiesonNon‐FederalLands 686.5.4RoadConstructionandMaintenanceofStateHighway
Facilities69
6.5.5RoadConstructionandMaintenanceonCountyLands 696.5.6DairyOperations 706.5.7DredgeandFillActivitiesinWatersoftheState 716.5.8WasteDischargeRequirements 716.5.9WaterUse 71
7.0 DESCRIPTIONOFSURVEILLANCEACTIVITIES 77
8.0 ENVIRONMENTALSETTING 808.1 Aesthetics 838.2 Agriculture 838.3 AirQuality 848.4 BiologicalResources 868.5 CulturalResources 878.6 GeologyandSoils 878.7 GreenhouseGasEmissions(GHGs) 898.8 HazardsandHazardousMaterials 908.9 HydrologyandWaterQuality 928.10 LandUseandPlanning 948.11 MineralResources 948.12 Noise 948.13 Population,Housing,andPublicServices 958.14 Recreation 968.15 Transportation/Traffic,UtilitiesandServiceSystems 96
9.0 CALIFORNIAENVIRONMENTALQUALITYACT(CEQA)ENVIRONMENTALANALYSIS
98
9.1 Introduction 989.2CaliforniaEnvironmentalQualityActRequirementsforExempt
RegulatoryPrograms100
9.2.1DescriptionoftheProposedActivity 1009.2.2Scoping 101
9.3.AnalysisofReasonableAlternativestotheProposedActivity 1029.3.1NoAction‐NoChangeinBasinPlanLanguageorinProgram
Implementation102
9.3.2AdoptaBasinPlanAmendmentthatdefinesprescriptiverulesforspecificlandusesandestablishesprohibitions(broadriparianprotection)attheregionallevel
103
9.3.3DeveloptechnicalTMDLs,ActionPlans,andAdoptBasinPlanAmendmentsforeachindividualimpairedwatershed
104
9.3.4AdoptBasinPlanAmendmenttoincludeaRegionalTemperatureImplementationPolicyandTemperatureActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs(RecommendedAlternative)
105
9.4AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPossibleMitigationMeasures
106
9.4.1AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoPreserveandMaintainShade
107
9.4.2AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoAddressSedimentation
109
9.4.3AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoAddressTailwaterandSurfaceImpoundments
113
9.4.4AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmental 117
Impacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasuresAssociatedwithPreservingExistingColdWaterResources
9.4.5AnalysisofComplianceMeasures, PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasuresAssociatedwithAquaticEcosystemRestorationtoAddressStreamTemperatures
121
9.4.6 AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoRestoreandMaintainStreamFlowsthatSupportBeneficialUses
123
9.5.DiscussionofPotentialEnvironmentalImpacts 1279.5.1ThresholdsofSignificance 1279.5.2 EnvironmentalChecklist 128
9.6 AlternativeMeansofCompliance 16910.0 ECONOMICANALYSIS 170
10.1Introduction 17010.2ScopeoftheEconomicAnalysis 170
10.2.1Methodology 17010.2.2ExistingRequirements 17110.2.3GeographicScope 171
10.3EstimatedCostsofCompliance 17410.4SourcesofFunding 181
10.4.1SummaryofPertinentStateFundingPrograms 18110.4.2SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms 182
11.0 PUBLICPARTICIPATION 19111.1 TemperaturePolicyStatementResolutionProcess 19111.2 CEQAScoping 19111.3 PresentationstotheRegionalWaterBoard 19111.4 OtherActivities 19111.5 TMDLDevelopmentProcess 192
12.0 REFERENCESCITED 195Appendix1:RegionalWaterBoardStaffResponsetoPeerReviewCommentson
thePeerReviewDraftStaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature
FIGURE PAGEFigure2.1:ResultsofasensitivityanalysisfromtheNavarroRivertemperatureTMDLrankingtemperaturedrivers
3
Figure2.2:Conceptualrepresentationofriparianshademodels 10
Figure2.3:Temperaturemodelinganalysisresultsshowingtheoreticalimpactsofmicroclimaterelativetoimpactsofcanopyremoval
14
Figure4.1:DecisiontreerepresentingthelogicalprocessfordeterminingattainmentoftheIntrastateWaterQualityObjectiveforTemperature
18
Figure4.2:Watercourseandlakeprotectionzoneforconfinedfish‐bearingstreamsoutsidethecoastalanadromouszone
31
Figure5.1:Conceptualrepresentationofthecausesandeffectsoftemperaturealterationandassociatedimpactstobeneficialuses
41
TABLE PAGETable2.1:SummaryofNorthCoastTemperatureTMDLdevelopmentinformation
9
Table6.1:SummaryoftheTotalMaximumDailyThermalLoadsestablishedforeachwatershed
61
Table6.2:SummaryofNumericTargetsintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedTemperatureTMDLs
63
Table8.1.HighwaysEligiblebutnotDesignatedasStateScenicHighways 83Table8.2.2012AirQualityStatisticsforthe3AirBasins,andSonomaCounty,containedwithintheNorthCoastRegion
85
Table10.1EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasurestoPreserve,MaintainandRestoreShade
175
Table10.2EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasuresAssociatedwithErosionandSedimentControl
176
Table10.3EstimatedComplianceMeasuresCoststoAddressTailwater/SurfaceWaterImpoundments/ColdWaterResources/In‐StreamFlows
180
Table10.4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms 184
1 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
1.0 INTRODUCTIONThisdocumentpresentsthebackgroundinformationandrationalethatsupportstheNorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard’sproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlantoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattoleRiverWatershed,ActionPlantoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheNavarroRiverWatershed,andActionPlantoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheEelRiverWatershed.ThisPolicyandthoseActionPlansareproposedasasingleamendmenttochapter4,(ImplementationPlans)oftheWaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegion(BasinPlan).1.1BackgroundandPurposeApproximatelysixty‐threepercentoftheareaoftheNorthCoastRegionislistedastemperatureimpaired,perSection303(d)oftheCleanWaterAct,becausethewaterqualityofthoseriversandstreamsdoesnotmeetthetemperaturewaterqualityobjectives.TemperatureimpairmentsinthewatershedsoftheNorthCoastRegionarepredominantlyassociatedwithnonpointsourcesofpollution,suchastimberoperations,agriculture,streambedalteration,landconversionandotherconstructionactivities.Temperatureimpairmentsarealsoassociatedwithactivitieswhichdonotgenerallyinvolvewastedischarge,suchasvegetationalteration,waterwithdrawal,andhydromodification.TemperatureTotalMaximumDailyLoad(TMDL)analysesof13watershedsinthenorthcoastfoundthesamefactorstoberesponsibleforelevatedwatertemperatures:increasedexposuretosolarradiationduetolossofstreamshade,physicalstreamchannelalterationinresponsetoelevatedsedimentloads,engineeredstreamchannelalteration,andalterationofhydrologyresultingfromimpoundments,waterdiversions,hydromodification,andlandscapealteration.ThewidespreadtemperatureimpairmentsandcommonsourcefactorswithintheNorthCoastRegionpointtotheneedforaregion‐wideapproachforaddressingtemperatureissues.TheestablishmentandimplementationofthisPolicywillprovideacommonapproachtoensuringattainmentofthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.Similarly,theestablishmentandimplementationofsuchapolicywillensurethathighqualitywatersarealsoprotected.OnJanuary19,2012,theNorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(RegionalWaterBoard)adoptedResolutionR1‐2012‐0013titled“PolicyStatementforImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectiveforTemperatureintheNorthCoastRegion”(PolicyStatement)1.ThePolicyStatementdescribesthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature,identifiescommonactivitiesthathavethepotentialtoelevatewatertemperaturesinexcessofwaterqualityobjectives,andidentifiestheregulatorymechanismsatthedisposaloftheRegionalWaterBoardusedtocontrolwastedischargesandassociatedactivitiesinacomprehensiveandconsistent
1ResolutionR1‐2012‐0013canbedownloadedat:http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/northcoast/board_decisions/adopted_orders/pdf/2012/120127_12_0013_Resolution_Temperature.pdf
2 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
manner.ThePolicyStatementalsoprovidesdirectiontostaffdevelopingandimplementingpermitsandevaluatingthewaterqualityimpactsofproposedactions,providesclarificationtothepublicregardingwhatisrequiredtocomplywiththeobjective,andprovidesdirectiontostafftoincorporateaTemperatureImplementationPolicyintotheBasinPlan.1.2DocumentOrganizationTheremainderofthisdocumentisorganizedinthefollowingmanner:
Chapter2presentsthescienceofwatertemperaturesinbothageneralsense,andasappliedinnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLanalyses.
Chapter3presentsthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperaturecontainedintheBasinPlan.
Chapter4discussestheinterpretationofthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureandthemannerinwhichtheyareimplementedforactivitiesandsituations.
Chapter5identifiesanddiscussesthetemperaturefactorsthispolicyfocuseson,aswellastheactionstoaddresstheidentifiedtemperaturefactors.
Chapter6discussestheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatershedTemperatureTMDLs,andtheactionsidentifiedtoimplementthem.
Chapter7providesasimpledescriptionofthemonitoringstrategystaffwilluseasthebasisofamonitoringplantobedevelopedinthefuture.
Chapter8describestheenvironmentalsettingandbaselineconditionfortheenvironmentalanalysis.
Chapter9presentstheenvironmentalanalysisofalternativesandreasonablemeansofcompliance.
Chapter10presentsaneconomicanalysisoftheimpactsofthispolicy. Chapter11discussesthepublicprocessthathasbeenconductedtodate. Chapter12liststhereferencescitedinthetextofthereport.
3 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
2.0 ANALYSISOFTEMPERATUREThissectionofthedocumentpresentsanoverviewoftemperaturedynamics,drawingonthefindingsoftemperatureTMDLanalysesandthebodyofscientificliteraturerelevanttothetopicofstreamtemperature.Thediscussionhasundergonescientificpeerreview,asrequiredbylaw.Thethreereviewersconcurredwiththescientificassumptions,assertions,andconclusionsthatthisPolicyreflects,althougheachhadsuggestionsforstrengtheningthediscussion.Thediscussionbelowreflectssuggestionsmadebythereviewers.Thepeerreviewers’specificcommentsandRegionalWaterBoardstaff’sresponsecanbefoundinAppendixAofthisdocument.2.1IdentificationofDriversofElevatedWaterTemperatureThesensitivityandresponseofstreamtemperaturestofactorsthatdrivethemhavebeenevaluatedintemperatureTMDLanalysescompletedintheNorthCoastRegion.Figure2.1presentsanexampleofsuchsensitivityanalyses.Similarreach‐scalesensitivityanalysesweredevelopedfortheMattole,Salmon,andUpperLostRiverTMDLs.Thesesensitivityanalyseswereconductedusingreach‐scaletemperaturemodelsanddatarepresentingsite‐specificconditions,representedasaveragevaluesforthereach.Themodelcalculatesthetemperaturethatresultsatthedownstreamendofthemodeledreachbasedonthereachaveragedinputs.ThesensitivityofstreamtemperaturestodrivingfactorsovermultiplereacheswasalsoevaluatedinboththeScottandShastaRivertemperatureanalysesusingdeterministictemperaturemodelsthatsimulatedtemperaturedynamicsovermanymiles(NCRWQCB2005,NCRWQCB2006).
Figure2.1:ResultsofasensitivityanalysisfromtheNavarroRivertemperatureTMDLrankingtemperaturedrivers(Source:NCRWQCB2000)
4 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Theinvestigationofelevatedstreamtemperaturesinnorthcoaststreamspointstoalimitednumberofstreamtemperaturefactorsthataredirectlyaffectedbymanagementactivities.Figure2.1presentstheresultsofananalysisexaminingthesensitivityofstreamtemperaturestothevariousfactorsactingtodrivewatertemperaturedynamicsintheNavarroRiverwatershed(NCRWQCB2000).Ofthefactorsthatdeterminestreamtemperatures,shadeandflowcanbemostdirectlyaffectedbymanagementactivities.Airtemperature,relativehumidity,windspeed,groundtemperature,width‐to‐depthratio,channelroughness,andgroundreflectivitycanbeindirectlyaffectedbymanagementactivities,butgenerallydonotcausetemperaturealterationofthesamemagnitudeinresponsetochangesinthevaluesovertherangethatmanagementactionsmostoftencreate.Itshouldbenotedthatsubstantialchangesinwidth‐to‐depthratiosandchannelroughnesscanresultinsubstantialtemperaturechanges.Increasedwidth‐to‐depthratiosprimarilyaffecttemperaturethroughincreasedexposedsurfacearea,whichincreasessolarexposure.Increasedchannelroughnessresultsinadeeperwettedchannel,whichoftendecreaseswidth‐to‐depthratios,therebyreducingsolarexposure.Streamswithgreaterdepthsarelesssensitivetochangesintemperaturedriversthanshallowerstreams(HerbandStefan2010).Increasedchannelroughnesscanalsoincreasethetimeoftravelthroughareach,whichmayhaveacoolingorwarmingeffectdependingonthecharacteristicsofthereach.2.2InteractionofTemperatureDriversSensitivityanalysessuchasthosementionedaboveevaluatethesignificanceofchangesinindividualtemperaturedriverswell.Evaluatingtheinteractionofmultipledriversismorecomplex;howevertheirinteractioncanbemoreeasilyunderstoodwhenconsideredinthecontextofequilibriumtemperature.Astreamisconsideredinequilibriumwithitssurroundingswhenthesumoftheheatfluxesequalszero(i.e.,heatinputsandoutputsarebalanced)(Boganetal.2003,Mohsenietal.2002).Essentially,theequilibriumtemperatureisthetemperatureastream(oranybodyofwater)willreachifgivenenoughtimetocomeintobalancewithitssurroundings.Asimpleexampleofthisconceptisaglassofcoldwaterplacedinawarmroom:givenenoughtime,thewaterwillreachthetemperatureoftheroom,andthattemperatureistheequilibriumtemperature.Headwaterstreamtemperaturesreflectthetemperatureoftheirsources,suchassnowmelt,groundwater,orlakes.Aswatertravelsdownstream,itstemperaturechangesinresponsetoitssurroundings,trendingtowardthelocalequilibriumtemperature.Thestrongestdriverofequilibriumtemperatureisairtemperature,whileshading,windsheltering,andgroundwaterinputsarethegreatestmodifiersoftherelationshipofairtemperaturetoequilibriumtemperature(Boganetal.2003,Morrilletal.2005,Mohsenietal.2002).ThesefactsarerepresentedinthesensitivityanalysisresultsshowninFigure2.1.ThemodelusedtogenerateFigure2.1,SSTEMP,calculatesdailyaveragewatertemperaturesbasedinparton
5 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
equilibriumtemperatures.Itisnotsurprisingthen,thatthesimulatedreach,whichislowintheNavarrosysteminareachwithlittlegroundwaterinputs,iscalculatedtobemostsensitivetoairtemperature,shade,andwindspeed.Despitethesensitivityofequilibriumtemperaturetoairtemperatureandwindspeed,solarradiation(whichisrepresentedinFigure2.1bytotalshadeandpossiblesun)hasbeendemonstratedtoresultinheatfluxesanorderofmagnitudehigherthanthoseassociatedwithairtemperatureandwindspeed(i.e.,convectionandevaporation),whichexplainswhyshadeissoimportantforstreamtemperaturecontrol(Johnson2004).Theequilibriumtemperatureisnotconstant,justasairtemperatureisnotconstant.Whileallstreamreachesapproachtheequilibrium,manystreamreachesdonotreachthehighestdailyequilibriumtemperatureofthedaybeforetheequilibriumtemperaturedropsastheairtemperaturesdropinthelateafternoonandevening.Factorsotherthanairtemperature,suchasshade,depth,flow,andgroundwaterinputs,determinehowquicklyastreamreachestheequilibriumtemperature,andwhatthatequilibriumtemperatureisinthatreach(Mohsenietal.2002,Boganetal.2004,HerbandStefan2010).Tosummarizethediscussionabove:
1. Streamsreflectthetemperatureoftheirsources(e.g.,groundwater,snowmelt,orlaketemperatures)neartheirheadwaters.
2. Anequilibriumtemperatureexiststhatrepresentsthetemperatureastreamwilleventuallyreach,giventheexternaltemperaturedriversdon’tchangeandenoughtimehaspassed.
3. Streamsthatareaboveorbelowtheequilibriumtemperaturetrendtowardthatequilibriumtemperature.
4. Increasingshade,depth,flow,orgroundwaterinputswillslowtherateatwhichstreamsapproachequilibrium.
5. Increasingsolarradiation,orreducingflowand/ordepthwillincreasetherateatwhichstreamsapproachequilibrium.
Giventhetemperaturedynamicsdescribedabove,thewaysinwhichthedriversoftemperatureinteractbecomesclearer.Airtemperaturedeterminesequilibriumtemperatures,andthushowhotastreamcanbe,whileshadeandflowdeterminehowquicklyastreamapproachestheequilibrium,andthushowhotastreamactuallybecomes.Areductioninflowrequiresanincreaseinshadeinordertomaintainthesametemperaturesandviceversa.Also,increasesinairtemperaturewillresultinincreasedwatertemperatures,withthemagnitudeoftheincreasedampenedbyhighershadeandflowlevels.Thewatertemperaturedynamicsdescribedabovehaveimplicationsforthefuture,giventhefactthatglobaltemperaturesareincreasing(Wuetal.2012,Bartholow2005).ClimateisoutsidethecontroloftheRegionalWaterBoard.However,thefactorsthatcanlessentheimpactsofclimatechange‐shade,flow,anddepth(tothedegreethatsedimentloadsandchannelalterationsaffectstreamdepth)‐canbe
6 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
managed.Giventheforecastedchangesinglobalclimate,theprotectionofshadeandflowsandcontrolofsedimentloadsbecomesevenmoreimportantfortheprotectionofbeneficialusesintothefuture.Anotherpracticalimplicationofthediscussionaboverelatestothepreservationandrestorationofshade.Preservationofshadeismostimportantinstreamreacheswithtemperaturesfarbelowtheequilibriumtemperaturebecausetheyarethereachesthemostsusceptibletorapidheating.Newton’sLawofCoolingstatesthattherateoftemperaturechangeisproportionaltothedifferenceintemperature,whichisthedifferencebetweenthestreamtemperatureandequilibriuminthesesituations.Conversely,restorationofshadeinreachesofstreamthatregularlyreachorcomenearequilibriumtemperaturesisnotlikelytoresultinsignificanttemperaturechangesuntilupstreamreachesareaddressed,andinsomecases,suchaswidehigh‐orderstreams,theincreasedshademayonlyhaveanegligibleeffect,regardless,asdescribedinmoredetailinsection2.3,below.2.3AdditionalConsiderationsItisimportanttonotethatsolarradiationloadsarenotalwaystheprimarycontrollabledriverofelevatedwatertemperaturesinmostwaterwaysintheNorthCoastRegion.Forinstance,somesituationsexistwherevegetationisineffectiveatincreasingeffectiveshade.High‐orderstreamsareoftentoowiderelativetotheheightofvegetationtoprovidelevelsofshadethathaveasubstantialtemperatureeffect.TheKlamathandEelRiverTemperatureTMDLsrecognizethisphenomenonanddonotassignriparianshadeloadallocationsforthemainstems.However,inthesecasestheshadeprovidedbyriparianvegetationmaystillbeimportantforthemaintenanceofthermalrefugia.Insummary,increasedsolarradiationloadsarelikelytobetheprimarycontrollabledriverofelevatedwatertemperaturesinmostwaterwaysintheNorthCoastRegion,butaren’talways.Inadditiontothebenefitsofshade,riparianvegetationprovidesmanyotherwaterqualitybenefitsbesidesthoseassociatedwithtemperature,suchasbankstability,nutrientandsedimentfiltering,andlargewoodydebrisrecruitment(seesection5.2.2forfurtherdiscussion).ThesebenefitsareadditionalconsiderationsthatshouldbeevaluatedwhentheRegionalWaterBoardevaluatesprojectsthatinvolvealterationstoriparianvegetation,inadditiontoshade.Anotherimportantconsiderationregardingtemperaturedynamicsandcompliancewithtemperatureobjectivesinvolvesscale,frombothspatialandtemporalperspectives.Theintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturestates“atnotimeorplace”shallthetemperaturebeincreasedbymorethan5°Fabovenaturalreceivingwatertemperature(seesection3.0).Somehavequestionedifthereisaminimumscaleofconsiderationthatshouldbeappliedtotheassessmentofthisobjective.Theobjectivedoesn’texplicitlystatethereareminimumdimensionsthatshouldbeconsidered,however,theobjectivereferencesadverseimpactstobeneficialusesastheultimatecriteria.Fromapracticalperspectivethen,thespatialscaleofconsiderationisthatwhichisrelevanttothebeneficialusesinquestion.
7 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Staffhavewitnesseddistressedjuvenilesteelheadgatheredinhighdensitieswithinasmallvolumeofwatercolderthanitssurroundingsasaresultofhyporheicexchangethroughagravelbar.Inthatcase,therelevantspatialscalewassmall,yetthebiologicalimportanceappearedtobeveryhigh.Otherissuesofspatialandtemporalscalesinvolvetherateofphysicalandbiologicalprocesses.Oneofthetimescalesmostrelevanttotherecoveryoftemperatureinpreviouslyimpactedstreamsystemsofthenorthcoastistherateoftreegrowth.Inplaceswhererecoveryoftemperaturesisdependentontherestorationofriparianshade,recoveryoccursasfastastreesgrow.Similarly,theimpactsoflargesedimentpulsesonstreammorphologycanpersistformanydecades.AnexampleofthisistheEelRiversystemwherelargevolumesofsedimentdeliveredinthe1955and1964floodsstillremainintheactivechannel(USEPA2007).2.4TemperatureTMDLAnalysesAnecessarystepinthedevelopmentofTotalMaximumDailyLoadsistheinterpretationofwaterqualityobjectives.TheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureistheonlytemperatureobjectiveapplicabletoalloftheTMDLsdeveloped,andthushasbeenthefocusoftemperatureTMDLdevelopmentintheNorthCoastRegion.ThetemperatureTMDLanalyseshaveconsistentlyfoundthattheshadeprovidedbyriparianvegetationhasadramaticbeneficialeffectonstreamtemperatures,andthatachievingtheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturerequiresriparianshadeconsistentwithnaturalconditions.ThisconceptisthebasisofTMDLloadallocationsprescribedineverynorthcoasttemperatureTMDL.Similarly,northcoasttemperatureTMDLshavealsoidentifiedthealterationofchannelgeometrycausedbyelevatedsedimentloadsasafactorthatmustbecontrolledinordertomeettheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.LoadallocationsforsedimentareabsentfrommanynorthcoasttemperatureTMDLsduetothefactthatsedimentTMDLsweredevelopedconcurrentlyforthesamewaterbodies.Inthosecases,thecontrolofelevatedsedimentloadswasidentifiedinthetemperatureTMDLmarginsofsafety.Additionally,somenorthcoasttemperatureTMDLshaveidentifiedtheroleofhydrologicalterationasacausativefactorthatmustbeaddressedinordertomeettheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.ThetechnicalapproachtodevelopingloadallocationsmeetingthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureinnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLshasvariedamongthe13temperaturesourceanalyses,basedonthesituationspresent.However,the13temperatureTMDLanalysessharecommonelements.AllofthetemperatureTMDLshavemadeuseoftemperaturemodelstoinvestigatetemperaturedynamicsusinglocallyderiveddata.MosttemperatureTMDLsalsohavemadeuseofshademodelsthatpredicttheincidenceofshadeonstreamsegments.Table2.1summarizesinformationpertainingtothedevelopmentofthe13temperatureTMDLscompletedintheNorthCoastRegiontodate.
8 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
2.4.1ShadeAnalysesShademodelshavebeenusedinthedevelopmentofnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLstoquantifythedifferencebetweencurrentandpotentialstreamshadeconditionsonbothawatershedandreachscale.Theproductsofthewatershed‐scaleshademodels‐spatialdatabasesofcurrentandpotentialshadeconditionapproximations‐wereusedasthebasisofTMDLloadallocations(loadsthatmeettheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature).Thewatershed‐scaleshademodelsusedinthedevelopmentofnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLsaresimplifiedapplicationsoftheapproachpresentedbyChenandothers(1998a&1998b),whodevelopedtheapproachfortheUpperGrandRondeRiver(Oregon)TemperatureTMDL.TheshademodelsusedtodeterminenorthcoasttemperatureTMDLsdeterminewhethersunlightreachesagivensegmentofstreambasedonthelocationofthestreamchannel,thesurroundingtopography,attributesofthesurroundingvegetation,andthepathofthesuninthesky.Themodelscalculateshadeusingreadilyavailabledatadescribinggroundelevations,streamhydrography,andvegetationpresentonthelandscape(BoydandKasper2003,Kennedyetal.2005,TetraTech2002).Informationdescribingbankfullchanneldimensionsandtherelationshipoftreediametertotreeheightwasalsocollectedandincorporatedintothespatiallyexplicitshademodels.TheshademodelsusedinthedevelopmentofnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLsprovidearelativeindexofshadevaluesinaspatiallyexplicitmanner.Themodelscalculatetheincidenceofsunlightonastreamchannelforeachhouroftheday,bydeterminingwhethersunlightisblockedbytopographyorvegetationatagivensiteandtimeofday.Thedailyscoreisthesumofthehourlyscores,weightedbytherelativemagnitudeofthesolarloadforeachhouroftheday.Thedeterminationofwhethersunlightisblockedbyriparianvegetationispartlybasedontheassumedheightofthevegetation,whichinturnisbasedonrelationshipsofdiameter‐at‐breast‐height(dbh)totreeheightforthespeciesofvegetationpresent.Informationdescribingthespeciesofvegetationatagivensiteisbasedonremotelysenseddatadescribingvegetationdistributions.Currentvegetationheightswereapproximatedbasedonthedbhofthespeciespresentineachgridcell,whereasthepotentialvegetationheightswerebasedontheassumedmatureheightforthesamespecies.TheremotelysenseddatausedfortheseanalysesincludetheTimberTaskForceKlamathProvincehabitatdatabasedevelopedaspartoftheKlamathRegionVegetationMappingProjectandtheCALVEGdatabasedevelopedbytheUSFS.
9 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentinthe
Mattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table2.1:SummaryofNorthCoastTemperatureTMDLdevelopmentinformation
TMDL Assessment
South Fork Eel River
Navarro River
Mattole River
North Fork Eel River
Middle Fork Eel River
Upper Main Eel River
Middle Main Eel River
Lower Main Eel River
Upper Lost River
Salmon River
Scott River
Shasta River
Klamath River
Year 1999 1999 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2007 2004 2005 2005 2006 2009
Temperature Model
Bas inTemp SSTEMP SSTEMP Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE SSTEMP SSTEMPHeat Source
TVA
RMA‐2, RMA‐11, CE‐QUAL‐
W2
Shade Model Topquad RipTopo RipTopo Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE Q2ESHADE n/a SSTEMPHeat Source
n/a n/a
Vegetation Data Source
Klamath Bioregional Mapping Project
Klamath Bioregional Mapping Project
Ca lveg Ca lveg Ca lveg Ca lveg Ca lveg Ca lvegmeasured va lues
measured va lues
Ca lvegmeasured values
n/a
Factors Identi fied
Shade, Sediment
Shade, Sediment,
Flow
Shade, Sediment
Shade, Sediment
Shade, Sediment
Shade, Sediment
Shade, Sediment
Shade, Sediment
Del is tedShade,
Sediment
Shade, Sediment,
Flow
Shade, Flow, Ag Return Flows
Shade, Sediment, Impoundments
Concurrent Sediment TMDL?
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes No No
Lead agency (development)
USEPA NCRWQCB NCRWQCB USEPA USEPA USEPA USEPA USEPA NCRWQCB NCRWQCB NCRWQCB NCRWQCBNCRWQCB, ODEQ, USEPA
10 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ThefirsttemperatureTMDLdevelopedintheNorthCoastRegionwastheSouthForkEelRiverTemperatureTMDL(USEPA1999).ThetemperaturesourceanalysiswasconductedbyStillwaterSciencesundercontracttotheUSEPAandutilizedatemperaturemodelcalledtheStillwaterSciencesTemperatureModel,whichinturnreliedonageographicinformationsystem(GIS)basedmethodtocalculatesolarradiationreductionsresultingfromriparianvegetationandtopography(StillwaterSciences1999).Thesolarradiationloadswerethenincorporatedintoaone‐dimensionalheatbalancemodel(ibid).Figure2.2presentsagraphicalrepresentationofthestreamshademodelingapproach.TheresultsoftheSouthForkEelRivertemperatureTMDLanalysisdemonstratedtheimportanceoftheshadeprovidedbyriparianvegetationforachievementoftheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.
Figure2.2:conceptualrepresentationofriparianshademodel.(Allen2008)ThesecondtemperatureTMDLdevelopedintheNorthCoastRegionwastheNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDL(NavarroTMDL;USEPA2000).TheNavarroRivertemperaturesourceanalysisalsoidentifiedtheimportanceofshadeprovidedbyriparianvegetationforprotectionofstreamtemperatures.TheNavarroRivertemperaturesourceanalysiswasconductedbytheNCRWQCBwithassistancefromtheUCDavisInformationCenterfortheEnvironment.ThetemperaturesourceanalysisutilizedariparianshademodelcalledRipTopo,aGIS‐basedmodelmuchlikethemodeldevelopedbyStillwaterSciencesfortheSouthForkEelRiverTemperatureTMDL(Kennedyetal.2005).TheNavarroTMDLalsoreliedontheuseoftheUSGSstreamreachtemperaturemodelSSTEMPasascreeningtool,asdiscussedabove.TheTMDLloadallocationsweresetattheeffectiveshadelevelsthatrepresentpotentialvegetationconditions,basedonthescreeninganalysis
11 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
conclusions.TheRipToposhademodelingresultswerethebasisoftheTMDLloadallocations(NCRWQCB2000,USEPA2000).TheRipTopomodelwaslaterusedfortheMattoleRiverTemperatureTMDL(NCRWQCB2002,USEPA2002a)andtheScottRiverTemperatureTMDL(NCRWQCB2005)inthesamemanner(definingTMDLloadallocations)asintheNavarroTMDL.However,theMattoleRiverTemperatureTMDLsourceanalysisalsoestimatedcurrentandpotentialtemperaturesinninetributaryandthreemainstemreachesusingtheSSTEMPmodel(NCRWQCB2002),whiletheScottRiverTemperatureTMDLmadeuseoftheHeatSourcetemperaturemodeltocalculatestreamshadeandtemperatureapproximationsfortheScottRivermainstemandthreetributaries(BoydandKasper2003,NCRWQCB2005).ThemoresophisticatedmodelingapproachwasemployedfortheScottRiverTemperatureTMDLduetothemorecomplexhydrology(i.e.,effectsofsurfacediversions,groundwater‐surfacewaterdynamics)presentinthatwatershed.TheMattoleRiverandScottRivertemperatureTMDLsalsoassignedtemperatureloadallocationsatlevelscorrespondingtoshadeconditionsrepresentingpotentialvegetationconditions(USEPA2003a,NCRWQCB2005).FiveofthesixoftheEelRiverbasintemperatureTMDLsourceanalysesweredevelopedbyTetraTech,Inc.,undercontracttotheUSEPA(USEPA2002b,USEPA2003a,USEPA2004,USEPA2005,USEPA2007).TetraTechdevelopedamodelingsystemcalledQ2ESHADEforuseinthetemperatureTMDLprocess(TetraTech2002).TheQ2ESHADEmodelcombinestheUSEPA‐supportedQUAL2EhydrodynamicandwaterqualitymodelwithashademodelingroutinecalledSHADE,aGIS‐basedmodelformulatedbasedonthemodeldevelopedbyChenetal.(1998a)andappliedtotheUpperGrandeRondeRiverwatershed(Chenetal.1998b).TheQ2ESHADEmodelingsystemcalculateshourlyshade‐attenuatedsolarradiationatvariouslocationsbasedonriparianvegetationcharacteristicsandtopographicrelief,andutilizesthesesolarradiationloadstopredictin‐streamtemperaturesthroughoutastreamnetwork(TetraTech2002).ThesixtemperatureTMDLsdevelopedintheEelRiverbasinassignedtemperatureloadallocationsatlevelscorrespondingtoshadeconditionsrepresentingpotentialvegetationconditionsbasedontheresultsofthemodelinganalysis(USEPA2002b,USEPA2003a,USEPA2004,USEPA2005,USEPA2007).TheKlamathRivertemperatureTMDLanalysisalsoevaluatedtheimpactsofshadeontributarytemperatures.TheKlamathtributaryanalysisreliedonprinciplesofstreamthermaldynamicssupportedbyscientificliteratureandtheanalysesandconclusionsofprevioustemperatureTMDLs,particularlythosedevelopedfortheSalmon,Scott,andShastaRiver,andassignedloadallocationforeffectiveshadeatlevelscorrespondingtoshadeconditionsrepresentingpotentialvegetationconditionsaccordingly(NCRWQCB2010).
12 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
2.4.2HydrologicAnalysesTheevaluationoftemperatureimpactsassociatedwithchangesinhydrologywasamajorfocusofboththeShastaRiverTemperatureTMDL(ShastaTMDL)andKlamathRiverTemperatureTMDL(KlamathTMDL).TheShastaTMDLanalysisevaluatedtheeffectsofstreamdiversions,irrigationtailwaterreturnflows,impoundments,andriparianvegetationontemperaturesoftheShastaRiver.TheanalysisofimpactsreliedonanapplicationoftheTennesseeValleyAuthority’sRiverModelingSystem(TVA‐RMS)temperaturemodeloriginallydevelopedfortheShastaValleyResourceConservationDistrict’sShastaRiverFlowandTemperatureModelingProject(Deasetal.2003,Deas2005).TheshadevaluesdepictingcurrentvegetationconditionsandrepresentedinthemodelwerebasedonriparianvegetationinventoriesandmeasurementsconductedbyUCDavis,WatercourseEngineering,andRegionalWaterBoardstaff.PotentialsolartransmittancevaluesrepresentingpotentialvegetationconditionsweredevelopedbyRegionalWaterBoardstaff,withconsiderationofexistingvegetation,channelgeometry,andsoilconditions(NCRWQCB2006).TheeffectsoftailwaterreturnflowsandstreamdiversionswerealsoevaluatedusingtheTVA‐RMSmodel.Temperatureloadallocationscorrespondingtopotentialshadeconditions,increasedcoldwaterflowsof45ft3/s,andzerothermalloadingfromtailwaterreturnswereassignedbasedonthemodelingexercise.TheKlamathTMDLanalysisevaluatedtheeffectsofflowalterationandimpoundmentsusingapackageofriverinehydrodynamicandwaterqualitymodels(RMA‐2andRMA‐11,respectively),coupledwithareservoirmodel(CEQual‐W2).TheKlamathTMDLanalysisevaluatedthetemperatureimpactsofalteredtributaryflows,alteredmainstemflows,pointsources,andreservoiroperationsonmainstemKlamathRivertemperatures.TheanalysisevaluatedtheeffectsofcurrentandhistorictributaryflowsonthetemperatureoftheKlamathmainstemanddeterminedthatthetributaryflowsaretoosmalltosubstantiallyalterthetemperatureofthemuchlargerKlamathRiverineitherthecurrentorhistoricsituation.TheimpactsofreducedflowsfromUpperKlamathLake,theoriginoftheKlamathRiver,werealsoevaluatedandfoundtohavenoappreciableeffectontemperaturesattheCalifornia‐Oregonborder.TheUpperMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLandMiddleMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLalsoincludedanexplicitevaluationoftemperatureeffectsassociatedwiththePotterValleyProject,aPacificGasandElectricprojectthataltershydrologicconditionsintheEelRiver(USEPA2004,USEPA2005).Thatanalysisdeterminedthattheimpactsoftheflowalterationwerenotimpactingbeneficialusesbecausetheflowsduringthesummermonthsunderthe2004FERC/NMFSflowscheduleareofthesamemagnitudeasunimpairedflows.EPAfoundthatthecurrentFERC/NMFSsummerflowschedulelikelyresultsinstreamtemperaturescoolerornearlyequaltothepossiblenaturalstreamtemperatures,andthustheFERC/NMFSflowscheduleisprojectedtoattainwaterqualitystandards.
13 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
TheScottRivertemperatureTMDLsourceanalysisexplicitlyevaluatedthestreamtemperatureimpactsofreducedgroundwateraccretion.RegionalWaterBoardstaffusedtheHeatSourcemodeltoevaluatechangesinstreamtemperatureassociatedwithbothincreasesanddecreasesinthemagnitudeofgroundwateraccretionvaluesbasedonmeasuredflowsandmassbalances.TheresultsoftheanalysisshowedthatthetemperaturesoftheScottRiver,whichisprimarilyagroundwaterdominatedstreamfromJuly‐September,aredriveninpartbytheamountofgroundwaterenteringtheriverasdiffuseaccretion.2.4.3MicroclimateAirtemperature,windspeed,andrelativehumidityinteractwithoneanothertocreatemicroclimatesassociatedwithripariancorridors,andthuscanaffectstreamtemperatures.However,whiletheseconditionsaredemonstratedtobefactorsindirectlyaffectedbyhumanactivities,theinformationdescribingthemagnitudeofeffectsofhumanactivitiesonmicroclimatesindicatechangesarerelativelysmallanddifficulttoquantify(Bartholow2000,Brosofske1997,Chenetal.1993,Chenetal.1999,Dongetal.1998,Ledwith1996).Additionally,thetypesofchangesinairtemperature,windspeed,andrelativehumidityanticipatedtoarisefromdisturbanceofriparianareasdonotallacttoincreasestreamtemperatures.Forinstance,decreasedrelativehumidityandincreasedwindspeed,alikelyresultofriparianzonedisturbances,actinconcerttoremoveheatfromastreamsurfacebyincreasingevaporation(Mooreetal.2005).Conversely,increasedairtemperaturesthatmayresultfromripariandisturbancesacttoincreasestreamtemperatures.ThemagnitudeofstreamtemperatureimpactsassociatedwithchangesinmicroclimatewasexplicitlyevaluatedintheScottRiverTMDLanalysis.InthatTMDLanalysis,amodelingexercisewasconductedthatevaluatedthechangeinstreamtemperatureresultingfromacombinationofchangesinairtemperature,relativehumidity,andwindspeedofmagnitudesreportedintheliterature.Themicroclimatechangeswererepresentedinthreescenariosthatspantherangeofchangesreportedintheliterature.Theanalysisresults,presentedinFigure2.3,indicatethatthemagnitudeoftemperaturealterationwouldbesmall,ontheorderof0.5oCorless,whereasthetemperaturealterationassociatedwithchangesinvegetativeshadecouldresultinchangesofupto1.5oCoverthesamereach.Theimpactsofelevatedsedimentloadsareanotherfactoridentifiedashavingthepotentialtoelevatewatertemperatures.Elevatedsedimentloads,whilenotdirectlyaddressedinthesensitivityanalysispresentedinFigure2.1,indirectlyimpactmanyofthefactorsevaluatedbythesensitivityanalysis.Forinstance,elevatedsedimentloadscanresultinincreasedchannelwidths.Increasesinchannelwidthsresultinashallowerstreamforagivenflowcondition,whichresultsinmoreofthewaterbeingaccessibletosolarradiationincidence.Conversely,narrowerchannelshavelessoftheirsurfaceexposedtosolarradiation.Elevatedsedimentloadscanalsoleadtotheremovalofvegetationthatshadesawatercourse,aswellasfillindeeppoolsthatmaythermallystratifyinlowflowconditions.
14 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Figure2.3:Temperaturemodelinganalysisresultsshowingtheoreticalimpactsofmicroclimaterelativetoimpactsofcanopyremoval(Source:NCRWQCB2005).Notethat“MC”standsformicroclimate.Basedontheanalysesdescribedaboveandtheavailableliterature,theimplementationstrategiesdevelopedtoachieveTMDLsandtheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturehavefocusedonacommonsetofpollutantdischargesandcontrollablefactorsthathavethepotentialtoelevatewatertemperatures.Thesecontrollablefactorsanddischargesareshade,flow,andsedimentload.
15 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
3.0 TEMPERATUREWATERQUALITYOBJECTIVESTheBasinPlanincludesbothnarrativeandnumericwaterqualityobjectiveswhichdescribetheambientwaterqualityconditionsnecessarytoprotectbeneficialuses.TheBasinPlancontainstwoseparatewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.Thefirstobjectiveistheintrastatetemperatureobjective.Thisobjectiveappliestoallwatersofthestate.Theintrastatetemperatureobjectiveisanarrativeobjectivewithassociatednumericcriteriaandreads:
Thenatural receivingwater temperatureof intrastatewaters shallnot be alteredunless it canbedemonstrated to the satisfaction oftheRegionalWaterBoardthatsuchalterationintemperaturedoesnotadverselyaffectbeneficialuses.At no time or place shall the temperature of any COLD water beincreased by more than 5°F above natural receiving watertemperature.At no time or place shall the temperature of WARM intrastatewaters be increasedmore than 5°F above natural receivingwatertemperatures.
ThesecondwaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureistheinterstatetemperatureobjectivecontainedinthestatewideWaterQualityControlPlanforControlofTemperatureintheCoastalandInterstateWatersandEnclosedBaysandEstuariesofCalifornia(ThermalPlan).TheThermalPlan,asadoptedbytheStateWaterBoard,isincorporatedbyreferenceintheBasinPlan(seeAppendix3oftheBasinPlan).The“ColdInterstateWaters”objectiveisasfollows:
Elevatedtemperaturewastedischargesintocoldinterstatewatersareprohibited.
“ElevatedTemperatureWaste”isdefinedas:
Liquid,solid,orgaseousmaterialincludingthermalwastedischargedatatemperaturehigherthanthenaturaltemperatureofreceivingwater.Irrigationreturnwaterisnotconsideredelevatedtemperaturewasteforthepurposeofthisplan.
Theinterstateobjectiveappliestowatersthatcrossordefinethestateborder.Theinterstatetemperatureobjectiveaugments,butdoesnotsupersede,theintrastatetemperatureobjective.Forthosewaterbodieswhichdonotattaintheambientwaterqualityconditionsdescribedbythewaterqualityobjectives,thefederalCleanWaterAct(CWA)
16 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
requiresanevaluationofthesourcesofpollutioncontributingtotheimpairmentandthecalculationofthereducedpollutantloadsnecessarytoattainobjectives.Forwatersimpairedbyelevatedtemperatures,CWAsection303(d)(1)(D)specificallyrequiresthatstatesestimate“thetotalmaximumdailythermalloadrequiredtoassureprotectionandpropagationofabalanced,indigenouspopulationofshellfish,fish,andwildlife.”Finally,theStateWaterBoardadoptedResolutionNo.68‐16,"StatementofPolicywithRespecttoMaintainingHighQualityofWatersinCalifornia",commonlyknownastheAntidegradationPolicy.TheAntidegradationPolicystates:
“Whenevertheexistingqualityofwaterisbetterthanthequalityestablishedinpoliciesasofthedateonwhichsuchpoliciesbecomeeffective,suchexistinghighqualitywillbemaintaineduntilithasbeendemonstratedtotheStatethatanychangewillbeconsistentwithmaximumbenefittothepeopleoftheState,willnotunreasonablyaffectpresentandanticipatedbeneficialuseofsuchwaterandwillnotresultinwaterqualitylessthanthatprescribedinthepolicies.”(StateWaterBoardResolution68‐16)
Accordingly,allwatersintheNorthCoastRegionwithambientwatertemperaturesrepresentingnaturalconditionsareidentifiedashighqualitywaters.ThereisacurrentscarcityofwaterbodieswithtemperaturesthatfullysupporttheRegion’sCOLDbeneficialuse,asindicatedinpartbythelistingofred‐leggedfrogsandseveralPacificsalmonidsasthreatenedorendangered,andothersdesignatedasspeciesofspecialconcern(e.g.,southerntorrentsalamandersandsummer‐runsteelhead).TheimplicationoftheAntidegradationPolicyisthatwaterbodieswithtemperaturesthatarecoldenoughtosupportthesesensitiveorganismsduringtheirtemperaturesensitivelifestages,orcolder,representhighqualitywatersregardlessoftheirtemperaturestatus,andthatanyproposallikelytoresultintheelevationofwatertemperaturesmustbeabletomakethedemonstrationsspelledoutintheAntidegradationPolicy.ThisapplicationoftheAntidegradationPolicytotemperatureissupportedbytheBasinPlanonpage3‐2.00,whichstates:
“Wherewaterqualityisbetterthantheminimumnecessarytosupportinstreamuses,thefederal[antidegradation]policyrequiresthatqualitytobemaintainedandprotectedunlessthestatefinds,afterensuringpublicparticipation,that:
1)Suchactivityisnecessarytoaccommodateimportanteconomicorsocialdevelopmentintheareainwhichthewatersarelocated,2)Waterqualityisadequatetoprotectexistingbeneficialusesfully,and3)Thehigheststatutoryandregulatoryrequirementsforallnewandexistingpointsourcedischargesandallcost‐effectiveandreasonablebestmanagementpracticesfornonpointsourcecontrolareachieved.”
17 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
4.0 INTERPRETATIONANDIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEWATERQUALITYOBJECTIVESFORTEMPERATURE
Theinterstatetemperatureobjectiveiswrittenintheformofaprohibitionpreventingthedischargeofelevatedtemperaturewaste.Interpretationoftheinterstateobjectiveisrelativelysimple,requiringthedeterminationofwhetheradischargemeetstherobustdefinitionof“elevatedthermalwaste”presentedinSection3.0.Theintrastatetemperatureobjectivecallsforthemaintenanceofnaturalambienttemperatureconditions,withcertainflexibilityaffordedatthediscretionoftheRegionalWaterBoard.Theintrastatetemperatureobjectiveisanarrativeobjectivewithassociatednumericcriteriathatallowsforitsinterpretationinthecontextofspecificbeneficialuses.Figure4.1presentsadecisiontreerepresentingthelogicalprocessofinterpretingtheintrastateobjective.Theintrastateobjectiveisinterpretedatboththewatershedscaleandatdiscretelocationssuchasastreamreachorpond.TheprocessshowninFigure4.1ismostusefulinassessmentsofpointsources,impoundments,anddiscretesourcesofelevatedwatertemperature.Inothercontexts,suchasnonpointsourcelandusepermitting,stafftypicallyreliesontheimplementationofmanagementpracticessuchasriparianbuffersandsimilarconservationpractices(seesection4.4,RelianceonManagementPracticesAssociatedwithLandUses).Nonpointsourcepollutionischallengingtocontrolbecauseitistheresultofmanydiffuseanddiversesourcesoccurringacrossthelandscape.Eachindividualsourcemaycontributeonlyasmallportion,butallthesourcescombinedcancumulativelyresultinwaterqualityproblems.Aprecisequantificationofeithertheconditionorthepotentialimpactsassociatedwithanyindividualparcelisnotpracticableinimplementingtemperatureprotections.Rather,theNonpointSourceProgramfocusesonimplementingmanagementmeasuresthatareknowntobeeffectiveincontrollingnonpointsourcepollution,ofteninthecontextofotheragency’srulemakingprocessesorestablishedbestmanagementpractices.Staffoftenincorporatesuchpracticesaspermitterms,asappropriate;Figure4.1depictstheprocessthatstafffollowinevaluatingtheefficacyofthosepractices,andwhetheradditionalpermitstermsarerequired.However,thisprocessisnottypicallyincorporatedintothepermitapplicationorenrollmentprocessinthesesituations.AsseeninFigure4.1,thefirsttestininterpretingtheintrastateobjectiveiswhetherwatertemperatureisalteredfromnaturalconditions.Iftemperatureshavealreadybeenalteredorcouldbealteredbyaproposedproject,thenademonstrationmustbemade(tothesatisfactionoftheRegionalWaterBoard)that(1)thealterationinambientwatertemperaturehasbeenorwouldbelessthan5oFabovenaturalreceivingwatertemperaturesand(2)anyelevatedambientwatertemperaturesdonotadverselyaffectbeneficialuses.TheassessmentofnaturaltemperatureconditionsisdiscussedinSection4.1,below.
18 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Figure4.1:DecisiontreerepresentingthelogicalprocessfordeterminingattainmentoftheIntrastateWaterQualityObjectiveforTemperatureIntheabsenceofademonstrationthatagiventemperaturealterationwon’tadverselyaffectbeneficialusesorincreasetemperaturesby5oFormore,theobjectivedefaultstonochangeintemperature.Thelanguageoftheobjectiveplacestheburdenofproofontheproponentoftheactionthathaspotentialtoalterthetemperature.Accordingly,RegionalWaterBoardstafftypicallyestablishespermitconditionsthatareexpectedtoresultinnoalterationoftemperature.TheRegionalWaterBoardmayauthorizeanincreaseintemperatureofupto5oF,ifappropriate.Giventheongoingandacceleratingimpactsofglobalclimatechange(Cayanetal.2006),considerationshouldbegiventotheexpectedriseinairtemperatureoverthelifeofaprojectwhenconsideringincreasesoftemperatureofupto5oF.Forinstance,ifairtemperaturesareexpectedtorise2oFoverthelifeofaproject,theRegionalWaterBoardshouldconsiderlimitinganywatertemperatureincreasesto3oFasaprecautionarymeasure.InastudyofairtemperaturerecordsintheKlamathBasin,Bartholow(2005)foundthatairtemperatureshaveincreased0.5oC/decadesincethe1960s.Otherresearchershaveestimatedthatwatertemperatureswillrise0.6‐0.8oCforevery1.0oCofairtemperaturerise(Nulletal.2012,Morrilletal.2005).Giventhathuman‐causedclimatechangeisexpectedtoincreaseairtemperaturesfordecadestocome,andthatthoseimpactsareoutsideof
19 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
thecontroloftheRegionalWaterBoard,theeffectsofthoseimpactsshouldbetakenintoaccountwhenconsideringcontrollablewatertemperatureincreases.Thedeterminationofadverseeffectsonbeneficialusesisbasedonthethermalrequirementsofthemostsensitivebeneficialusepresent.InmostcasesintheNorthCoastRegion,thecoldfreshwaterhabitatbeneficialuse(COLD)isthemostsensitivebeneficialuse.ColdwaterecosystemsintheNorthCoastRegionsupportfish,amphibians,macroinvertebrates,andotherorganismswithspecificthermaltolerances.Therefore,interpretingtheintrastatetemperatureobjectivenearlyalwaysinvolvescomparingthetemperatureconditionsbeingconsideredrelativetothetemperatureconditionsthatfullysupportoneormoreoftheseorganisms.Insituationsinwhichtemperaturesexceedthebiologicaltemperaturerequirementsforfullsupportofthebeneficialusespresent,noincreaseintemperaturecanoccurwithoutadverseeffects.RegionalWaterBoardstafftypicallyaddressesbothcumulativeimpactsassociatedwiththeimplementationofmultipleprojectsacrosslandscapesanddiscreteimpactsassociatedwithindividualprojectsthroughprohibitionsandtermsofpermits.Permittermsarecraftedtoensureindividualimpactsdonotcauseorcontributetothecumulativeimpactsofmultipleactivitiesbyrequiringmanagementpracticesthatsimulatenaturalconditions(seesections4.1and4.4).Thisapproachispreferredbecauseitensurescompliancewithobjectives,preventsimpairmentassociatedwiththecumulativeimpactsofmultipleprojects,andavoidstheneedforprojectproponentsandstafftoquantifythermalimpactsassociatedwithsmallindividualprojectsandassessthecumulativeimpactsofoneprojectinthecontextofotherprojects.ThedevelopmentoftemperatureTMDLsintheNorthCoastRegionrequiresinterpretationoftheintrastateobjective,andthustheapplicationofthelogicalprocessshowninFigure4.1.ThetemperatureTMDLshavealsoidentifiedanddefinedconditionsnecessarytoachievetheobjectiveatawatershedscale,drawingontheresultsoftemperaturemodelingandpeer‐reviewedscientificliterature.4.1EstimationofNaturalStreamTemperaturesNaturalreceivingwatertemperaturesareeitherestimatedusingstandardtechniquesasdescribedbelow,orassumedwherethefactorscontrollingstreamtemperature(e.g.,shade,sedimentdeposition,andflow)representnaturalconditions.Naturalreceivingwatertemperaturesarethetemperaturesthatoccurwhenthefactorscontrollingwatertemperature,includingshade,flow,andchannelmorphology,areequivalenttotheirnaturalcondition.Accordingly,theRegionalWaterBoardissuespermitstoachievetheenvironmentalconditionscontrollingstreamtemperaturethatareequivalenttothethermalregimeassociatedwith
20 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
naturalconditions(e.g.,restorationofsite‐specificpotentialshade,restorationofnaturalhydrologicformandfunction,andcontroloferosiontonaturalrates).ThecontrolofshadeonthesurfaceofwatersofthestateisamajorfocusoftheRegionalWaterBoard’seffortstomeettheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.AlltemperatureTMDLsdevelopedintheRegionassignloadallocationsforshade,withtheallocatedamountequivalenttonaturalconditions,andreferredtoassite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.Site–potentialeffectiveshadereferstotheamountofshadethatcanbeprovidedbyvegetationatasite,giventhespeciesofvegetationpresent,andtakingintoconsiderationthegrowingconditionsatthesite(seesection4.2,below).ThetemperatureTMDLsandloadallocationsarediscussedindetailinsection2.4,above.Theintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturereferencesnaturalreceivingwatertemperatures.Anaccurateinterpretationoftheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturethenreliesinpartontheassessmentofnaturaltemperatures.Insuchanassessment,allanthropogenicfactorsthatmaycumulativelyactonastreamtoalteritstemperaturesmustbeconsidered,including:
Upstreamflowalterations; Pastcanopyremoval,eithermechanicallyorasaresultofincreased
sedimentloadsorothertypesofdisturbance;and, Alterationofchannelcharacteristicssuchaswidth,depth,andstreambed
permeability,eitherfromengineeredalterationsorthoseassociatedwithgeomorphicchangescausedbyhydromodificationoralteredsedimentloads.
Oftenthetemperatureofawaterbodyinquestionhasbeenalteredinthepast.Inthiscase,thedegreeoftemperaturealterationmustbeevaluatedtodetermine:
Whethertheexistingtemperaturesmeettheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature;
Whatbeneficialusesmayhavebeensupportedpriortoalterationofthetemperature;and,
Howmuchtemperatureincreasecanoccurwithoutexceedingtheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.
Avarietyofcommontechniquesareavailableforestimationofnaturalstreamtemperaturesforagivensituation.Reasonableestimatesofnaturaltemperaturescanbedevelopedbycomparisonwithreferencestreams,simplecalculations,oruseofcomputermodels,dependingonthesituation.Thoughanumberoftechniquesmaybeapplied,themostappropriatetechniquewilldependonthesite‐specificconditionsofthelocationofinterest.Factorsthatmaynecessitateamorein‐depthanalysisare:
Significantalterationofshadeconditions; Significantalterationofnaturalhydrologicconditions;, Uniquehydrologicfeaturessuchasspringsorcoldtributaries;
21 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Estuarineenvironments;and, Thermalstratification.
DefiningthealterationofthermalinfluencesThefirststepinestimatingnaturalstreamtemperaturesistoidentifythethermalfactors(suchasthoselistedabove)thathavebeenalteredfromnaturalconditions.Oncethealteredthermalfactorshavebeenidentified,theeffectsofthosealterationscanbeassessedusingthetoolsdescribedbelow.ComparisonwithreferencestreamsReferencestreamscanbehelpfulforestimatingnaturaltemperaturesifthereferencestreamcloselyresemblesthelocationofinterestinanaturalstate.Headwaterstreamreachesandmainstemtrunkstreamreachesaretwotypesofstreamenvironmentsthatareparticularlysuitedforthistypeofanalysis,ifshadeandmeteorologicalconditionsarecomparable.Headwaterstreamsaresuitedtothesetypesofcomparisonsbecausetheyareclosetothestreamsource,mostoftengroundwaterormeltingsnow.Groundwaterisfairlyconstantyearround,andgenerallydefinesthelowertemperaturelimitforstreamsinthesummermonths.Thelowestreachesofmainstemtrunkstreams,suchasthemainstemEelRiveratAlderpoint,arealsosuitedtothesetypesofcomparisonsbecausetheytypicallyrepresenttemperaturesthatareinequilibriumwithheatsourcesandsinks.Maximumstreamtemperaturesofthelowerreachesofmajorriversaretypicallyverysimilarinthesummermonths.Streamreachesinbetweentheheadwatersandlowermainstemstreamreachesareonlysuitedforcomparisonwithreferencestreamsiftheriparian,hydrologic,andmeteorologicconditionsarecomparablefromtheheadwaterstothelocationofinterest,whichbecomesincreasinglyunlikelywithincreasingdistancefromtheheadwaters.SimpleCalculationsTheuseofsimplecalculationscanbeusefulinestimatingnaturalstreamtemperatures.Themixingequation,Qds*Tds=Qus*Tus+Qtrib*Ttrib(wheretheQsrepresentflows,Tsrepresenttemperatures,dsdenotesdownstream,usdenotesupstream,andtribdenotestributarytemperaturesandflows)isahelpfulequationforcalculatingthechangeintemperaturedownstreamofaconfluenceoftwostreams.Similarly,Brown’sequation,asimpleequationrepresentingtherelationshipofflow,channelgeometry,andsolarradiation,givesareasonableestimateoftemperaturechangeduetoalterationofsolarexposureforshortstreamreaches,wheretheconditionsinthereacharehomogeneous(Brown1970).ComputermodelsManycomputermodelshavebeendevelopedwiththeabilitytocalculatestreamtemperatures.Someofthesemodelsweredevelopedforotherpurposesandonlycalculatetemperatureinordertocalculateotherwaterqualityrelatedprocesses,whileotherswerespecificallydevelopedwithstreamtemperatureapplicationsin
22 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
mind.Eithertypeofmodelcanbeusedtoestimatestreamtemperaturesifalltherelevantprocessesandfactorsareaccountedforinthemodel.Forinstance,somemodelsdonottakeintoaccountriparianshade,whileothersdo.OneofthemorecommonlyusedsimplestreamtemperaturemodelsisSSTEMP,maintainedbytheUSGS.SSTEMPisconsideredasimplemodelbecauseitrequiresnocompilerorcomplicatedinputfiles.Thecalculationschemeisalsosimple,relyingondailyaverageinputdatatoestimatedailyaveragestreamtemperaturesforasinglereach.Accordingly,SSTEMPiswell‐suitedforsimplethermalsituations.Itcanbeusedtoevaluatetheeffectsofchangesinchannelgeometry,vegetation,meteorologicalconditions,andchangesinflow.AlimitationoftheSSTEMPmodelisthattheaveragingperiodofthedatausedtorunthemodelmustbeapproximatelyequaltothetraveltimeofthereachbeingmodeled.Also,theSSTEMPmodeldoesnotperformwellifthereachinquestionencompassesdrasticdifferencesinshade,flow,channelgeometry,ormeteorologicalconditionswithinit.Deterministiccomputermodelsareusefulinsituationswhereareachofstream,orastreamnetwork,requiresamoresophisticatedanalysis.Thesemodelsaredesignedtoaccommodatevariableconditionsintimeandspace,whichrequiresthatthosevariablesbedefinedintimeandspace.Thedefinitionofthoseconditionsrequireslargeamountsofdata.Touseadeterministicmodeltoestimatenaturaltemperatures,thenaturalconditionofeachfactorthatinfluencesstreamtemperaturesmustbeestimatedoverfortheentiretemporalandspatialextentoftheanalysis.TheKlamathTMDLtemperatureanalysisisanexampleoftheuseofdeterministicmodelstoestimatenaturaltemperatures.Aspartofthatanalysis,naturaltemperatureswereestimatedbydefiningtheestimatednaturalconditionsoftheKlamathRiverandcalculatingthetemperaturesthatwouldresultfromthoseconditionsusingtheRMAmodel(TetraTech2009).EstimatesofnaturalflowsfromUpperKlamathLakeanddownstreamtributarieswereusedtorepresentnaturalhydrologicconditions.Similarly,thenatural,un‐dammedgeometryoftheKlamathRiverwascharacterizedtodefinethenaturalchannelgeometry.Finally,existingmainstemshadeandmeteorologicalconditionswereassumedtobecomparabletonaturalconditions.4.2Site‐SpecificPotentialEffectiveShadeTemperatureTMDLsdevelopedintheNorthCoastRegionhaveinterpretedtheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureandassignedloadallocationsforsolarradiationloadingbasedonitssurrogate,effectiveshade.Thismetricwaschosenbecauseeffectiveshadeisinverselyanddirectlyproportionaltoheat,anditisreadilymeasuredinthefieldorcalculatedusingmathematicalmodels.NorthCoastTemperatureTMDLloadallocationsassociatedwitheffectiveshadeconditionsarebasedontheconceptofnaturalvegetationconditions,andhavebeendescribedusingvariousterminology.TheNavarro,Mattole,Salmon,Scott,and
23 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ShastaRiverTemperatureTMDLs,developedbytheRegionalWaterBoard,expressshade‐relatedloadallocationsas“adjustedpotentialeffectiveshade.”Inthoseanalyses,thepotentialeffectiveshadeconditionsatasiteareestimatedaspotentialeffectiveshade(basedonfullymaturetreesgrowingalongthebankfullchannelofthestreams)reducedby10percenttoaccountfornaturaleffectssuchasfire,windthrow,andearthmovementsthatwouldreducetheactualriparianareavegetationbelowthesitepotential.TheEelRiverTemperatureTMDLs,developedbytheUSEPA,definesshade‐relatedtemperatureallocationsintermsofLangleys,aunitofheatloading.Theshade‐relatedallocationsfortheseTMDLsaresetattheheatloadthatcorrespondstoeffectiveshadelevelscorrespondingtonaturalvegetationconditions.Thoughtheallocationsareexpressedusingdifferentterms,theconditionsthattheallocationsdefinearethesame:thelevelofeffectiveshadeprovidedbyvegetationwhenthevegetationisgrowingatpotential.Foranygivenlocation,thistermiscalled“site‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.”4.2.1DefinitionofTerms:Theterm“site‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade”isdefinedas:
Theshadeequivalenttothatprovidedbytopographyandpotentialvegetationconditionsatasite.
Thistermcombinestwoconcepts:“effectiveshade”and“site‐specificpotential.”Thesetwoconceptsaredescribedherein.Theterm“effectiveshade”iswidelyusedinthesolarpowerindustryasameasureofsolarradiationavailableatasite.Effectiveshadeisalsousedtocomparesolarpowerpotentialbetweensites.Thetermhasbeenadoptedbyhydrologiststoquantifythesolarradiationamountreceivedbybodiesofwater.Theterm“effectiveshade”isdefinedintheBasinPlanas:
Thepercentageofdirectbeamsolarradiationattenuatedandscatteredbeforereachingthegroundorstreamsurfacefromtopographicandvegetationconditions.
Webster’sdictionarydefines“effective”as“producingtheintendedordesiredeffect”,and“shade”as“comparativedarknesscausedbythescreeningofraysoflight.”Inthiscontext,thetermsarecombinedtodenotethedegreetowhichobjectscreatingshadeeffectivelyreducesolarradiation.Effectiveshadeisameasurementunitthatdescribestheamountofsolarenergyreceivedinrelationtothepossiblesolarenergyassociatedwithanunobstructedsky.Effectiveshadeisdifferentfromotherunitsofmeasurerelatedtothedensityoftrees,branchesandleavesoverhead.Itexplicitlytakesintoaccountthepathofthesunthroughthesky.Italsoaccountsforthefactthattheintensityofsolarradiationisgreatestatnoonandleastinthemorningandevening.Othervegetationdensity
24 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
measurements‐forexample,thepercentageofoverheadvegetationandbasalarea‐donotdistinguishbetweenvegetationthatreducessolarradiationandvegetationthatonlyblockstheviewtothesky.Theterm“site‐specificpotential”isamodifierthatdescribesaparticulareffectiveshadecondition.Theterm“site‐specificpotential”isdefinedas:thevegetationconditionspossibleatalocation,consideringthevegetationspeciespresent,andanynaturalfactorsthatlimitvegetationsizeanddensity.Site‐specificisdefinedas“relatingtoaparticularplace.”TheNorthCoastRegionencompassesavarietyofvegetationcommunitiesandecologicalsettings.ThePolicyrecognizesthisvariabilityandrequiresthatpotentialeffectiveshadebeevaluatedrelativetothevegetation,soil,hydrology,andotherfactorsaffectinggrowingconditionsatanygivensite.Theterm“site”isalsousedinforestry,andhasbeendefinedinthatcontextasfollows:
Theareainwhichaplantorstandgrows,consideredintermsofitsenvironment,particularlyasthisdeterminesthetypeandqualityofthevegetationtheareacancarry.(SocietyofAmericanForesters1998)
Thisdefinitionisconsistentwithitsuseintheterm“site‐specific”,howeverinforestrythetermisoftencombinedwithotherterms(e.g.,siteclass,siteindex,sitequality,andsiteproductivityclass)torefertothegrowthrateandproductioncapacityofalocation.Site‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadereferstothesite‐specificpotentialforeffectiveshadeatasite,anddoesnotpertaintogrowthrateandproductivecapacity.Webster’sdictionarydefines“potential”as“capableofbeingorbecoming.”Inthiscase,thetermreferstotheshadethatoccurswhentheriparianvegetationnaturallyoccurringatasiteisatalevelthatthesiteiscapableofsupporting,ManyriparianareasintheNorthCoastRegionreflecttheeffectsofpastmanagementactivitiesthathaveremovedorpreventedtheongoingpresenceofvegetation.Theapplicationandassessmentofsite‐specificpotentialshadeisdiscussedinsection4.2.3.Site‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadedescribesaneffectiveshadelevelthatexistedpriortoreductionsassociatedwithmanagementactivities.Riparianareasthathaven’texperiencedvegetationremovalorsuppression,orthathaveregainedcharacteristicsreflectingthosethatexistedpriortomanagement‐relatedreductions,areconsideredtobeatapotentiallevelofvegetation,andthereforeprovidepotentialeffectiveshade.4.2.2MeasurementandApproximationofEffectiveShadeEffectiveshadecanbemeasuredusingsimpledevices.SolarPathfindersandangularcanopydensiometersareexamplesofsuchdevices.Suchdevicesidentify
25 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
severalfactors:theobjectsobstructingdirectsunlight,thetimeofdaythattheobjectwillobstructsunlight,andthecorrespondingintensityofsolarradiation.Thesedevicesarebasedongeometricrelationshipsbetweenearthandsunatagivenlatitude,andthedailydistributionofsolarradiation.Effectiveshadecanbeapproximatedusingmodelsthattakeintoaccountthesamegeometricrelationshipsandsolarradiationdistributionsasthedevicesusedformeasuringit.Thesemodelsusespatialdatadescribingtheelevation,vegetation,andstreamlocationforasitetocalculatethetimingandeffectofsolarobstructions.4.2.3ApplicationandAssessmentEvaluatingtheeffectsofaproposedactionrelativetosite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshaderequiresevaluationofwhethertheactionwillresultinriparianshadeconditionsequivalenttothatprovidedbypotentialriparianvegetationconditionsinthenearorlongterm.Thefactorsthatmustbeassessedgenerallyrelatetotheheight,depth,anddensityofvegetationasitrelatestoeffectiveshade.Theassessmentofmanagementeffectsoneffectiveshaderelatedtovegetationremovaloccursintwocontexts:(1)theeffectiveshadeatasiteisequivalenttothesite‐specificpotential,and(2)theeffectiveshadeatasiteislessthanthesite‐specificpotential.Inthefirstcase,theevaluationoftheproposedmanagementactionsoneffectiveshadeinvolvesjudgingwhethertheproposedpracticeswillreducetheeffectiveshade(i.e,increasesolarradiation)onthewaterbody.Todothis,thevegetationproposedforremovalisconsideredintermsofitspositionrelativetothepathofthesunandthewaterbody.Maintainingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeinvolvesretainingthevegetationthatprovidetheeffectiveshade.Inthesecondcase,theevaluationoftheproposedmanagementactionsoneffectiveshadeinvolvesjudgingwhethertheproposedpracticeswillpreventthere‐growthofvegetationtosite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeconditions.Inthissituation,theassessmentofpracticesisverysimilartothatofthefirstsituation,wherethevegetationproposedforremovalisconsideredintermsofitspositionrelativetothepathofthesunandthewaterbody.However,inthiscasemanagementconsistentwithsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeinvolvesretainingthevegetationthatwillprovide,orwillcontinuetoprovide,effectiveshadeasitreachessite‐specificpotential.Theassessmentofmanagementeffectsoneffectiveshadedoesn’talwaysinvolveactiveremovalofvegetation.Somesituations,suchasevaluationofagrazingmanagementplan,involveevaluatingtheeffectsofproposedmanagementpracticesonthenaturalprocessesthatestablishandmaintainriparianvegetation.Inthesecasestheactivityisevaluatedforimpactsthatwilllimitgermination,growth,andpersistenceofriparianvegetationinamannerthatreducedtheamountofriparian
26 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
vegetationprovidingeffectiveshadeoverthetimeframethemanagementactivityisproposed.TheRegionalWaterBoarddevelopsandadministerspermitsandprogramsforvariousactivitiesthatincluderestrictionsandrequirementsfortheprotectionofwaterquality.Insomecasestheserestrictionsandrequirementsincludeeffectiveshadeconsiderations,asappropriate.Evaluationoftheeffectivenessofpermitorprogramrestrictionsandrequirementsissimilartotheevaluationofproject‐specificmanagementactionsdescribedabove.Thesepermitsandprogramsoftenrelyonthedevelopmentofriparianmanagementplansthatdescribepracticesthatwillbeemployedtoachieveormaintainsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.4.2.4RestorationandMaintenanceofSite‐SpecificPotentialEffectiveShadeAction1ofthePolicydirectstheRegionalWaterBoardto“Restoreandmaintainriparianshade.”Theuseoftheterm“restore”inAction1appliestosituationsinwhichtheeffectiveshadeatasiteislessthanthesite‐specificpotential.Insuchacase,thePolicydirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtouseitsauthoritiesinamannerthatensuresthatthemanagementoccurringatthesiteallowsthevegetationpresenttoachieveconditionsequivalenttosite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.Theuseoftheterm“maintain”inAction1appliestosituationsinwhichtheeffectiveshadeatasiteisequivalenttothesite‐specificpotential.Inthissituation,thePolicydirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtouseitsauthoritiestoensuremanagementoccurringatthesiteisconsistentwiththemaintenanceofeffectiveshadeequivalenttothesite‐specificpotential.ThisPolicyisnotintendedtoprecludemanagementofriparianareas.Useoftheterms“restore”and“maintain”doesnotmeanthattheRegionalWaterBoardshouldrequireactiverestorationsuchastreeplantingprojects,nordoesitmeanthatmanagementactionsintheriparianzoneareprohibited,eitherinareaswheresite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadealreadyexistsorinareaswheresite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeconditionsdonotexist.Thispolicyisnotintendedtopredeterminepreciseparametersforachievingpotentialeffectiveshadeforaspecificlocationorlanduse,anddoesnotnecessarilyprecludemanagementinriparianareas.Therearecircumstancesinwhichmanagementactionswithinriparianareasthatreduceeffectiveshadeconditionsinthenear‐andshort‐termarenecessaryandappropriateinordertoachievepotentialeffectiveshadeinthelong‐term.4.3Project‐specificImplementationInterpretationoftheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureattheprojectscalerequiresconsiderationoftheparticularconditionspresentineachuniquesituation.Thedriversofelevatedwatertemperaturearewellunderstood(seesections2.0‐4,5.1,and5.2),howeverthesite‐specificimpactsofthosedriversinanyspecificsettingarebestevaluatedonacasebycasebasisforeachsituation.
27 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Inthecaseofnonpointsourcelanduses,theseevaluationsareoftenmadeonthebasisofprescribedoperationrules,performancestandards,orbestmanagementpractices(seesection4.4:RelianceonManagementMeasuresforNonpointSourcesAssociatedwithLandUses).However,eveninthesesituationssomesite‐specificevaluationisoftennecessarytoevaluatetheapplicationofoperatingrulesormanagementpracticestotheuniqueattributesofthesettinginquestion.Forinstance,somepermitsinvolveanon–the‐groundassessmentofwaterqualityprotectionandpreparationofplanstoaddressspecificwaterqualityissuesidentifiedintheassessment.AnexampleofthisistheRegionalWaterBoard’sUSFSWaiver(orderR1‐2010‐0029),whichallowsfortheremovalofriparianvegetationifitcanbedemonstratedthattheexceptionwillresultinanetlong‐termbenefittowaterqualityandstreamtemperatures,whichmustbeevaluatedagainstthespecificcharacteristicsoftheproject.TheCAForestPracticeRuleshaveasimilarprovisionforexceptionstocanopyretentionprescriptionswhenalternativeprescriptionsprovideequalormorefavorableprotectionthanthataffordedbythestandardprescriptions.Inprocessessuchasthese,theapplicationofmanagementpracticesorperformancestandardsistranslatedtotheuniqueconditionspresentatthesiteinquestion.Inordertoevaluatewhetherwatertemperaturesinagivenwaterbodyrepresentnaturalconditions,thenaturalstateoftemperaturedriversmustbeassessed.Forinstance,ariparianareawithahistoryofcanopyremovalmayprovidethesamelevelofsolarattenuationasanotherundisturbedriparianareawithlowlevelsofcanopyduetosub‐optimalgrowingconditions,withresultingtemperaturesthatarenearlyidentical.Inthefirstcase,thesitemaynotbemeetingtheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturebecausethelevelsofsolarradiationareunnaturallyhighduetoreducedriparianvegetationfrompastactivitiesresultinginunnaturallyelevatedwatertemperatures,whereasthesametemperaturesinthesecondstreamwouldmeettheobjectiveiftheotherdriverswerealsoconsistentwithnaturalconditions.Similarly,aprojectthatremovesriparianvegetationmayormaynotincreasesolarradiationloadinginthestreamdependingonthegeometryofthevegetationrelativetothestreamandsurroundingtopography.Finally,therelativestreamtemperatureconditionisanotherfactorthatmustbeconsideredwhenevaluatingwhetheraprojectwillcauseexceedenceoftheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.Forinstance,astreamthatiscoldrelativetoairtemperatures,suchasaspring‐fedinlandstreamnearitssource,willbemuchmoresensitivetoadditionalheatloadsthanastreamthatisalreadywarmandneartheequilibriumtemperature(seesection2.2,InteractionofTemperatureDrivers).Thesite‐specificapproachtoimplementingthetemperatureobjectivesattheprojectscalealsoallowsforRegionalWaterBoardstafftomakedeterminationsthatuniquecircumstancesexistthatallowexceptionstostandardpracticesemployedfortheprotectionofwatertemperature.Forinstance,theRegionalWaterBoardhasapprovedrestorationprojectsconductedontheMendocinoCoastthatinvolvethefellingofripariantreesintowatercoursestoaddlargewoodydebristothestream.Largewoodydebrisinstreamchannelshasbeenidentifiedasacriticallyimportant
28 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
habitatcomponentforCohosalmonthataremissinginthesestreams.Theseprojectsoccurredinstreamsthathavecoldwatertemperatures,relativelyhighcanopyandshadelevels,andcoolcoastalairtemperatures.Inthesecases,RegionalWaterBoardstaffweighstheriskofelevatingwatertemperaturesagainstthebenefitsofeliminatinganimportantfactorlimitingtherecoveryofalistedspecies.AnotheruniqueexampleofaninstanceinwhichactionsresultinginreducedshadewereapprovedbytheRegionalWaterBoardistheGeneralWaterQualityCertificationfortheBureauofReclamationTrinityRiverRestorationProgram’schannelrehabilitationactivitiesdownstreamoftheTrinityRiverreservoirs(OrderNo.R1‐2010‐0028).TheprimarypurposeoftheprojectistoincreasesalmonidhabitatinthemainstemTrinityRiveranditssidechannels.Channelrehabilitationactivitiesincluderemovalofencroachingriparianvegetation,rehabilitationoffloodplainandin‐channelalluvialfeatures,constructionofoff‐channelhabitatforaquaticandripariandependentspecies,coarseandfinesedimentmanagement,andrehabilitationofuplandhabitat.ChannelhabitatrehabilitationactivitiesaredesignedtousethealluvialprocessesoftheTrinityRivertomaintainandincreasesalmonidhabitatandcomplexityforalllife‐stagesovertime,andtoprovideconditionssuitableforreestablishingandsustainingnativeriparianvegetation.Collectively,channelrehabilitationactivitiesareintendedtomeettheoverarchinggoaloftheTrinityRiverRestorationProgram(TRRP)tocreate,restore,andenhancethefullrangeofhabitatsfornativeanadromousfishes,includingsalmonandsteelhead.TheremovalofriparianvegetationassociatedwiththeprojectwasdeemednecessarytomeetthegoalsoftheprogrambecausedecadesofcontrolledreleasesfromtheTrinityRiverreservoirshadeliminatedhighflowsthatpreventedtheencroachmentofriparianvegetation.Theresultingriparianencroachmentalteredthechannelmorphologyinamannerdetrimentaltobeneficialuses.Othersituationsinwhichreductionsofshademaybeconsistentwiththegoalofrestoringandmaintainingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeincludeactionsthatrequireshort‐termreductionsofeffectiveshadetoenhancethesize,density,orresiliencyofriparianvegetationovertime.Short‐termreductionofeffectiveshadeassociatedwithfuelsreductionprojectsinriparianareasmaybeappropriatewhenthelong‐termbenefitsareconsidered.Insuchcases,theimpactsofvegetationthinningareweighedagainstthelong‐termbenefitsofariparianecosystemthatisresilientagainstfireimpacts.Similarly,theshort‐termreductionofshadeassociatedwiththinningprojectsdesignedtoincreasethegrowthrateofdominanttreesorreplacestuntedtreeswithvigoroussaplingsmayrepresentanacceptabletradeoffiftheprojectresultsinincreasedshadelevelsinashortertimeframe.Likewise,ashort‐termreductionofeffectiveshadeassociatedwitheffortstoincreasehardwoodspeciesinariparianzonemaybeappropriatewhereitcanbedemonstratedthatnaturalprimaryproductivitylevelsaresuppressedduetoalackofnutrients,leadingtoareducedcapacitytosupportbeneficialuses.
29 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Ineachofthesituationsdescribedabove,theRegionalWaterBoardconsiderstheshorttermimpactsoftheproposedactioninlightofthesite‐specificconditionsintheaffectedarea.Factorstakenintoconsiderationincludeexistingwatertemperaturesrelativetobiologicalthresholds,thelevelofsolarradiationincreaseassociatedwiththeproject,likelytemperatureimpactsassociatedwiththeproject,thecurrentcapacityforsupportofbeneficialuses,conditionofriparianvegetationinadjacentreaches,andtheexpectedamountoftimefornecessaryforriparianrecovery.4.4RelianceonManagementPracticesforNonpointSourcesAssociatedwithLandUsesTheRegionalWaterBoardpreferstoregulatedischargesofwasteandcontrollablewaterqualityfactorsassociatedwithnonpointsourcesinthecontextofadaptivemanagement,whereinmanagementmeasuresdesignedtoaddressawaterqualityconcernareimplementedandmonitoredinamannerthatprovidesforfeedbackontheperformanceofthemeasuresandanyneedformodificationofthepractice,asappropriate.Inthecaseoftemperature,thisapproachsubstitutestheuseofpre‐definedoperatingrules,performancestandards,bestmanagementpractices,orrestrictionsoncertainactivities,forthesometimesdifficultandunwieldyprocessofdeterminingnaturalconditionsandestimatingtheanticipatedtemperaturechangesassociatedwithanactivity.Thisapproachisadvantageoustotheprojectproponentbecauseitstreamlinestheevaluationandapprovalprocessandprovidesalevelofregulatorycertainty.ThesameprocessisadvantageousfortheRegionalWaterBoardbecauseitincreasestheefficiencyofregulatorypermitting,allowingstafftofocusonon‐the‐groundwaterqualityissues,bystreamliningtheevaluationandapprovalprocess.Thisapproachalsoallowsforthedevelopmentofgeneralpermitsforcertainactivities,ratherthantheinefficientprocessofdevelopingindividualpermitsforsimilaractivities.Certainnonpointsourceactivitiesmayalsobesubjecttoregulatoryornon‐regulatoryactionsofotherentitiesthatprovidetemperatureprotections.IftheRegionalWaterBoarddeterminesthatthoseactionswillresultinattainmentofwaterqualitystandards,theRegionalWaterBoardmayincludethoseactionsasimplementationmeasuresinapermit.TheRegionalWaterBoardcan,andoftendoes,relyonexistingnon‐WaterBoardprogramsforpermitmeasures,addingnewrequirementsonlyasnecessarytoprovideadequatewaterqualityprotection.Whenaddressingcompliancewiththetemperatureobjective,thegeographiclocation,existingregulatoryandnon‐regulatoryprograms,andotherrelevantfactorsshouldbeevaluatedindeterminingappropriateandnecessaryshadecontrols.Compliancewiththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureasitrelatestoshadeandsolarradiationisgenerallyachievedbymanagingvegetationthatprovidesshadetoawaterbodyinamannerconsistentwithsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.Toaccomplishthis,responsiblepartiesareencouragedtodelineateaseparatemanagementareaforriparianvegetationthathasthepotentialtoshadea
30 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
waterbody,andmanagetheseriparianareasdifferentlythanthesurroundingland.Theseareasareoftenreferredtovariouslyasariparianmanagementzone,streamsidebufferarea,orawatercourseandlakeprotectionzone.WhenRegionalWaterBoardstaffevaluatestheshade‐relatedtemperaturecontrolsprovidedthroughriparianmanagementpractices,staffevaluatewhetherthepracticesemployedresultinriparianshadeconditionsconsistentwithshadeconditionsrepresentativeofriparianvegetationundiminishedbyhumanactivities.Theevaluationisnotwhetherthevegetationconditionsare,infact,unaltered,butratherifthevegetationconditionsresultinroughlyequivalentsolarradiationloadingatthewatersurface.Forinstance,site‐specificpotentialvegetationconditionsinacoastalredwoodenvironmentmayhavehistoricallyincludedredwoodstreesinexcessof300feetinheight.However,thesamesolarradiationloadingmayresultfromtreeshalfthatheightorless,duetovegetationoverhang,understoryvegetation,andriparianhardwoodspeciespresent.Thefactorsthatmustbeassessedgenerallyrelatetotheheight,depth,anddensityofvegetation,aswellasthegeometryofthewatersurfacerelativetothesunandanytopographicshadingprovidedbymountainsandstreambanks.Managementpracticesthatprovidethistypeofprotectionareconsideredconsistentwiththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectiveasitrelatestoshadeandsolarradiation.AnexampleofmanagementpracticesreliedonforthemaintenanceofshadearetheForestPracticeRulesrelatingtowatercourseandlakeprotectionzonesforfish‐bearingstreamsinareaswhereanadromoussalmonidsarepresent.Theserulesresultinshadelevelsconsistentwithnaturalconditionsthroughthedesignationofno‐cutzonesadjacenttostreamsandcanopyretentionzonesadjacenttotheno‐cutzone.Additionally,therulesrequireretentionofthe7largesttreesperacreoftheinnerandcorezonesintheinteriorofthenorthcoast(SeeFigure4.2),andthe13largesttressperacrewithinthecoreandinnerzonesinthecoastalanadromouszone.TheForestPracticeRulesallowforexceptionstotheserequirementsforprojectsthat“wouldresultineffectstothebeneficialfunctionsoftheriparianzoneequaltoormorefavorablethanthoseexpectedtoresultfromtheapplicationoftheoperationalprovisionsrequiredunder”thestandardwatercourseandlakeprotectionrulesthatapply(CAForestPracticeRules2013).
31 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Figure4.2:Watercourseandlakeprotectionzoneforconfinedfish‐bearingstreamsoutsidethecoastalanadromouszone.Inthissetting,thecorezonemustbeleftun‐cut,70%overstorycanopymustberetainedintheinnerzone,and50%overstorycanopyintheouterzone.Additionally,the7largesttreesperacreofthecoreandinnerzonemustberetained.(CAForestPracticeRules2013)Manytimbercompanieshaveadoptedadditionalstandardmanagementpracticesthattheyimplementasamatterofpractice,andthatareconsideredduringthetimberharvestplanreviewprocess.Forexample,theGreenDiamondResourceCompanyhasdevelopedanaquatichabitatconservationplan(AHCP)thatdefinesoperationrulesandmanagementpracticesthataddresshabitatconcernsrelatedtosensitiveandthreatenedaquaticspecies,includingrulesandpracticestoaddresshabitatneedsoftemperature‐sensitivespeciesthatinsomecasesgobeyondthelevelsofprotectionaffordedbytheForestPracticeRules,andareconsistentwiththisPolicy.TheRegionalWaterBoardreliesontheimplementationoftheAHCP’swaterqualityprotectionpracticesasapartofthetimberregulatoryprogram.TheForestPracticeRulesalsoestablishmanagementpracticesforthecontrolofsedimentdischarges.TheRegionalWaterBoardreliesontheimplementationofthosemanagementpractices,inpart,asanelementofthesedimentcontrolrequirementsofitstimberregulatoryprogram.AnotherexampleoftherelianceonmanagementpracticesistheincorporationoftheUSFSbestmanagementpracticesasconditionsoftheUSFSWaiver.Thispermit,
32 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
byvirtueofitsconditions,alsoimplementssediment,temperature,andnutrientTMDLs,andmeetstheBasinPlanintrastatetemperatureobjective.TheUSFSWaiveradoptstheUSFSprogramthatmanagesandmaintainsdesignatedriparianzonestoensureretentionofadequatevegetativecoverthatresultsinnaturalshadeconditions.TheUSFSprogramrequiresretentionoftreeswithin300feetslopedistanceoneachsideoffish‐bearingstreams,150feetslopedistanceoneachsideofperennialstreams,and100feetslopedistanceoneachsideofephemeral/intermittentstreams,orthesite‐specificpotentialtreeheightdistanceoneachsideofthestream,whicheverisgreatest.TheUSFSWaiverprovidesforexceptionstotheserequirementsifitcanbedemonstratedthattheexceptionwillresultinanetlong‐termbenefittowaterqualityandstreamtemperatures.Additionalbestmanagementpracticesaredefinedforthecontrolofsedimentandnutrientdischargesassociatedwithroadmanagement,grazing,andothersourcesofnonpointsourcepollution.RegionalWaterBoardstaffsometimesreliesonmanagementmeasuresdefinedatasite‐specificleveltoaddressspecificwaterqualityconcerns.AnexampleofthisapproachisthattakenintheScottandShastaRiverTMDLconditionalwaivers.Thesewaiversrelyonthedevelopmentofsite‐specificplans,includingranchplans,todefinewhatactionsthelandownerwilltaketoaddressidentifiedwaterqualityconcerns,includingthoseassociatedwithtemperature,sediment,andnutrients.Anadaptivemanagementprocessinvolvingeffectivenessmonitoringandadaptionofpracticestoachievewaterqualitygoalsensurestheapproachesachievewaterqualityprotection.Theuncontrolleduseofriparianareasbylivestockcanleadtoimpactsthatelevatewatertemperatures.However,theuseofriparianareasbylivestockcanbeconductedwithoutthesetemperatureimpacts.Grazingofriparianareasisnotincompatiblewithwaterqualitygoalsifconductedinamannerwithwaterqualityprotectioninmind.Theintensity,duration,andtimingoflivestockusearecriticalconsiderationsthatdeterminewhetherlivestockuseisorisnotharmfultoriparianareas.Livestockmanagementinriparianareasoftenrequiresanapproachsimilartothemanagementpracticesemployedinforestry,whereinaspecialmanagementzonenearthestreamismanageddifferentlyfromthesurroundingareas.Practicessuchasflashgrazing,wherelivestockareallowedtograzeinthespecialmanagementzoneuntilthresholds,suchasaminimumstubbleheightofgrass,aremetcanbeconductedwithoutinterferingwiththenaturalriparianvegetationprocessesthatprovidetheshadenecessarytoachievetemperatureobjectives.Insuchcases,aripariangrazingandmonitoringplancanbethebasisofRegionalWaterBoardstaff’sevaluationofwaterqualityprotection.4.5ImplementationinImpairedvsUnimpairedWaterbodiesWaterbodiesthatarenotmeetingthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureareconsideredimpaired,andareidentifiedonthe303(d)listofimpairedwaterbodiesassuch.Many,butnotallwaterbodiesimpairedbyelevatedwatertemperatureshavehadTMDLsdevelopedforthem.ThedevelopmentoftemperatureTMDLsin
33 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
theNorthCoastRegionisdiscussedinSection2.0.Whenwaterbodiesarenotmeetingthetemperatureobjectives,eitherbecausetheirwatertemperatureshavebeenelevatedaboveatemperaturethresholdassociatedwithabeneficialuse,orbecausetheyhavetemperatureselevatedabove5oF,noadditionaltemperatureincreasecanbeaccommodated.Becausetemperatureimpairedwaterbodiescannotaccommodateanyincreaseintemperatures,theintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturerequiresthatpermittedconditionsresultinnaturalconditionsinthesewaterbodies.Inthecaseofshade,naturalconditionsaredefinedassite‐specificpotentialconditions,asdiscussedinsection3.1,above.Thus,theapproachtoregulatingimpairedwaterbodiesmustbeconsistent,regardlessofwhetheraTMDLhasbeendeveloped.Theactionsnecessarytorecoverawaterbodythatistemperatureimpairedduetoalterationofthedriversofwatertemperaturearethesametypesofactionsthatpreventawaterbodyfrombecomingtemperatureimpairedbysuchalterations.Forinstance,inthecaseofastreamwithelevatedtemperaturescausedbyincreasedsolarradiationresultingfromvegetationremoval,theactionnecessarytorecoverthenaturaltemperatureregimeistoallowtheriparianvegetationtogrowback(oractivelyrestorethevegetationconditions)suchthatthenaturalshadeconditionisonceagainachieved.Inthecaseofanunimpairedstreamwithunalteredtemperatures,theriparianmanagementactionnecessarytopreventtheelevationofwatertemperaturesistopreventincreasesinsolarradiationbymaintainingsufficientriparianvegetation.Inbothcases,theriparianvegetationmustbemaintainedandallowedtopersist.ThedifferenceisthatsomeamountofincreasedsolarradiationexposuremaybeallowedintheunimpairedstreamifitcanbedemonstratedtotheRegionalWaterBoard’ssatisfactionthat:
anytemperaturechangewon’tadverselyaffectbeneficialuses; watertemperaturesarenotincreasedby5oFormoreatanytimeor
place;and, theAntidegradationPolicyisnotviolated.
TheRegionalWaterBoardestablishespermitconditionsthatareexpectedtoresultinnoalterationoftemperature,asexplainedinsection4.0,above.Accordingly,itisappropriatefortheRegionalWaterBoardtoestablishpermitconditionsconsistentwithnaturalconditions,includingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.Dischargersandprojectproponentsseekingarelaxationofthisrequirementshouldsubmitananalysisthatsatisfiestherequirementsdescribedintheparagraphabove.Inordertopreventfutureimpairmentsandaddressexistingtemperatureimpairments,theregulatoryapproachtomanagingriparianvegetationfortheprotectionofunimpairedtemperaturesandtheregulatoryapproachtomanagingriparianvegetationtocorrectelevatedwatertemperaturesshouldbeconsistentthroughouttheregion.Furthermore,theregulatoryapproachshouldbebasedon
34 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
implementationofboththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureandtheAntidegradationPolicy,asdescribedabove.4.6RegulationofShadeasaControllableFactorTheRegionalWaterBoardsregulatethethermalimpactsassociatedwithincreasedsolarradiationloadsandtheshadeprovidedbyriparianvegetationinthecontextofdischarges.ThePorter‐CologneWaterQualityControlAct(Act)authorizestheStateandRegionalWaterBoardstocontrolthedischargesofwastetowatersofthestatethroughissuanceofpermitsandbyprohibitingcertainactivities.Solarradiationloadsarenotadischargeofwaste,asdefinedbytheAct.However,theActstatesinSection13263,RequirementsforDischarge:
“Theregionalwaterboard,afteranynecessaryhearing,shallprescriberequirementsastothenatureofanyproposeddischarge,existingdischarge,ormaterialchangeinexistingdischarge…withrelationtotheconditionsexistinginthedisposalareaorreceivingwatersupon,orintowhich,thedischargeismadeorproposed.Therequirementsshallimplementanyrelevantwaterqualitycontrolplansthathavebeenadopted,andshalltakeintoconsiderationthebeneficialusestobeprotected,thewaterqualityobjectivesreasonablyrequiredforthatpurpose,otherwastedischarges,theneedtopreventnuisance,andtheprovisionsofSection132412.”(emphasisadded.)
Theactdefines“waterqualitycontrol”asfollows:
“Waterqualitycontrol”meanstheregulationofanyactivityorfactorwhichmayaffectthequalityofthewatersofthestateandincludesthepreventionandcorrectionofwaterpollutionandnuisance.[Section13050(i)]
TheBasinPlanisawaterqualitycontrolplan.Thus,theActauthorizestheRegionalWaterBoardto“prescriberequirements”,includingrequirementsrelatedto“anyactivityorfactorwhichmayaffectthequalityofthewatersofthestate”,thatimplementtheBasinPlananditsprogramsofimplementation.ControllablewaterqualityfactorsareexplicitlyaddressedintheBasinPlan.TheBasinPlanstatesonpage3‐1.00:
“Controllablewaterqualityfactorsshallconformtothewaterqualityobjectivescontainedherein.Whenotherfactorsresultinthedegradationofwaterqualitybeyondthelevelsorlimitsestablishedhereinaswaterqualityobjectives,thencontrollablefactorsshallnotcausefurtherdegradationofwaterquality.Controllablewaterqualityfactorsarethoseactions,conditions,orcircumstancesresultingfrom
2 Section13241pertainstotheestablishmentofwaterqualityobjectives.
35 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
man'sactivitiesthatmayinfluencethequalityofthewatersoftheStateandthatmaybereasonablycontrolled.”
ThePorter‐CologneActestablishestheauthorityofRegionalWaterBoardstoadoptwastedischargerequirementsandprohibitionstocontrolthedischargeofwastetowatersoftheStateinordertoachievewaterqualityobjectivesthatsupportbeneficialuses,asdefinedintheBasinPlan.ThisproposedamendmenttotheBasinPlanclarifiesthatthealterationofshadecausedbyhumanactivitiesisacontrollablewaterqualityfactorthatmustbeaddressed,asappropriate,inwastedischargerequirementsissuedbytheRegionalWaterBoard,andregulatoryactionsbyotherstateagencies.Thisisnotanewinterpretation,norisitachangeinRegionalWaterBoardpractice.However,identifyingshadeasacontrollablewaterqualityfactorintheBasinPlanmakescleartheimportanceofaddressingshadetootheragencies,dischargers,andotherinterestedparties.
36 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
5.0 REGIONALPOLICYTOIMPLEMENTTHEWATERQUALITYOBJECTIVESFORTEMPERATURE
ThestaffoftheRegionalWaterBoardisproposingaBasinPlanamendmentthatwillestablishaPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature(Policy)intheNorthCoastRegion.ThePolicyidentifieslanduseanddischargefactorsthathavepotentialtoelevatewatertemperatures,anddirectsstafftouseallavailabletoolsandapproaches,bothregulatoryandnon‐regulatory,toensurewatertemperatureconcernsareaddressed.ThelanduseanddischargefactorshavebeenidentifiedduringthedevelopmentofnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLs.Theamendmentidentifiesactionsstaffwillundertaketoaddressthosefactorsthatmaypreventtheattainmentofthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.TheactionsweredevelopedsothatimplementationoftheactionsimplementloadallocationsestablishedintemperatureTMDLsandmaintainscompliancewiththewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureinwaterbodiesnotalreadyimpairedbyelevatedwatertemperatures.5.1FactorsIdentifiedinthePolicytoImplementtheWaterQualityObjectivesForTemperatureTheproposedPolicyidentifiesanumberofactivitiesandotheractions(factors)thathavepotentialtoelevatewatertemperatures.ThePolicyidentifiesthesegeneralfactorsasthosetheRegionalWaterBoardwilladdressthroughimplementationofregulatoryprogramsandcollaborationwithpartnerstoattainandmaintaintheintrastateandinterstatewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.ThefactorswereidentifiedbasedontheconclusionsandinsightsdevelopedduringthedevelopmentoftemperatureTMDLanalyses,asexplainedinSection2.0.Thefactorsare:
1. Activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceriparianshadingofwaterbodies;2. Activitieswiththepotentialtoincreasesedimentdelivery;3. Thequality,quantity,locationandtimingofeffluent,stormwater,and
agriculturalreturnflowdischarges;4. Thelocation,size,andoperationofin‐channelimpoundmentswiththe
abilitytoalterthenaturaltemperatureregime;5. Actionswiththepotentialtochangestreamchannelgeometry;6. Activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceinstreamflowsorreducespecific
sourcesofcoldwater,includingcoldwaterrefugia.Thefactorsidentifiedaboverepresentarangeofactivitiesandactions.ManyofthefactorscomeunderthedirectpermittingauthorityoftheRegionalWaterBoard,whileothersareregulatedthroughtheauthoritiesofotheragencies.
37 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
5.2JustificationofthePolicyFactorsThejustificationandscientificrationaleforeachoftheidentifiedfactorsispresentedbelow.EachofthePolicyFactorsisalsorepresentedinFigure5.1,aconceptualmodeloriginallydevelopedfortheKlamathRivertemperatureTMDLwhichgraphicallyrepresentsthedriversoftemperaturealteration,theresultingphysicalchangestoenvironmentalconditions,andconsequentimpactstobeneficialuses.5.2.1ActivitieswiththepotentialtoreduceriparianshadingofwaterbodiesDirectsolarradiationistheprimaryfactorinfluencingstreamtemperaturesinmoststreamenvironmentsduringsummermonths.Theenergyaddedtoastreamfromsolarradiationfaroutweighstheenergylostorgainedfromevaporationorconvection(Beschtaetal.1987,Johnson2004,SinokrotandStefan1993).Atagivenlocation,incomingsolarradiationisafunctionofpositionofthesun,whichinturnisdeterminedbylatitude,dayoftheyear,andtimeofday.Duringthesummermonths,whensolarradiationlevelsarehighestandstreamflowsarelow,shadefromstreamsideforestsandvegetationcanbeasignificantcontrolondirectsolarradiationreachingstreams(Beschtaetal.1987).Becauseshadelimitstheamountofdirectsolarradiationreachingthewater,itprovidesadirectcontrolontheamountofheatenergythewaterreceives.AtaworkshopconvenedbythestateofOregon’sIndependentMultidisciplinaryScienceTeam,21scientistsreachedconsensusthatsolarradiationistheprincipalenergysourcethatcausesstreamheating(IndependentMultidisciplinaryScienceTeam2000).Althoughthedominanceofsolarradiationastheprimarydriverofstreamtemperatureiswellaccepted(Johnson2004,Johnson2003,SinokrotandStefan1993,Theureretal.1984),somestudieshaveindicatedthatairtemperaturesaretheprimedeterminantofstreamtemperatures.Thisisbecauseoftherelationshipbetweenairtemperatureandequilibriumtemperaturediscussedinsection2.2.Inshort,airtemperaturedeterminesequilibriumtemperatures,andthushowhotastreamcanbe,whileshadeandflowdeterminehowquicklyastreamapproachestheequilibrium,andthushowhotastreamactuallybecomes.Heatbudgetsdevelopedtotrackheatexchangeconsistentlydemonstratethatsolarradiationisthedominantsourceofheatenergyinstreamsystems(Johnson2004,ODEQ2002,SinokrotandStefan1993).StreamtemperaturemodelingconductedinsupportofnorthcoasttemperatureTMDLs(seesection2.4,above)confirmedthatsolarradiationisthedominantheatexchangeprocessintheNorthCoastRegion.Theconclusionthatsolarradiationisthedominantsourceofstreamtemperatureincreasesissupportedbystudiesthathavedemonstratedbothtemperatureincreasesfollowingremovalofshade‐producingvegetation,andtemperaturedecreasesinresponsetoriparianplanting.JohnsonandJones(2000)documentedtemperatureincreasesfollowingshadereductionsbytimberharvestinganddebrisflows,followedbytemperaturereductionsasriparianvegetationbecamere‐established.Astudyofchangesinprimaryproductivityandfishbiomassassociatedwithincreasedexposuretosolarradiationdocumentedaninstancewhere
38 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
temperaturesincreasedby1.5oCovera100meterreachduetocanopyremoval(Wilzbachetal.2005).Shadelosscausedbydebrisflowsandhighwatersofthefloodof1997ledtotemperatureincreasesinsomeKlamathNationalForeststreams(delaFuenteandElder1998).RiparianrestorationeffortsbytheCoosWatershedAssociationreducedthemaximumvalueoftheweeklyaveragetemperatureofWillanchCreekby2.8oC(6.9oF)overasix‐yearperiod(CoosWatershedAssociationundated).MinerandGodwin(2003)reportedsimilarsuccessesfollowingriparianplantingefforts.Shadeiscreatedbyvegetationandtopography;however,vegetationtypicallyprovidesmoreshadetoriversandstreamsthantopographyinstreamsthatarenotwiderelativetotheheightofvegetation.Inthesestreamstheshadeprovidedbyvegetationhasadramatic,beneficialeffectonstreamtemperatures.Theremovalofvegetationcandecreaseshade,whichincreasessolarradiationlevels,which,inturn,increasesbothaverageandmaximumstreamtemperatures,andleadstolargedailytemperaturevariations(seeFigure5.1).Additionally,theremovalofvegetationcanaltermicroclimates,increasingambientairtemperatures,andvegetationremovalcanresultinbankerosion,andresultinawiderandshallowerstreamchannelgeometry,allofwhichcanincreasewatertemperatures.AreviewofthescientificliteraturepreparedfortheCaliforniaBoardofForestryandFireProtection(BoardofForestry)supportstheprinciplesregardingriparianshadeandwatertemperaturethatthisPolicyincorporates(SoundWatershedConsulting2008).Forinstance,theopeningsentencesofthereport’ssectiontitled“InferencesforForestManagement”states:
“Theliteratureonriparianheatexchangetellsusthatshadefromripariantimberstandsisakeyfactorcontrollingheatinputtostreams.Therefore,maintainingriparianvegetationtoblockdirectsolarradiation(i.e.,shade)istheintentofforestpracticeprescriptionsforprotectingstreamtemperatureduringthesummer.However,watertemperatureisafunctionofahostofphysicalfactorsthatcontrolheattransferbetweenair,water,andthestreambed.Consequently,therelativeimportanceofriparianvegetationtoinfluencestreamtemperaturevariesbylocation(geographicprovince)andbysitespecificconditions(streamwidth,depth,flow,groundwaterinflow,streambedsubstratecomposition,valleyorientation,topographicshadingandwatershedposition).Thisspatialvariabilityindicatesthatasimplefixed‐widthbufferorcanopyclosureprescription(e.g.,minimum50%canopycoverasrequiredinCA)willprobablynotachievemanagementgoalsinallcases.”(SoundWatershedConsulting2008,page29).
Thereportgoesontodiscussthepotentialofwatershedscaleanalysestoidentifystreamreachesmostsensitivetotemperaturechanges,andcombiningrankingsoftemperaturesensitivitywithassessmentsofsite‐specificconditionstoidentifyspecificshaderequirementstoprotectindividualreachesfromtemperatureincreases,bufferingclassIIstreamstopreventtemperatureincreasesinclassI
39 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
receivingwaters,andtheneedtoconsiderthetemperatureneedsofsalmonids.Thesectionofthereportendswiththefollowing:
“Finally,riparianstandeffectivenessforshadingisafunctionoftheforestcanopydensity,height,andspeciescomposition,whichisrelatedtostandtypeandage.Becausestandtypeandagemayvarybygeographicprovinceanddisturbancehistorythebufferwidththatisadequateforshadingwillvaryaswell.Thisfactunderminestheone‐size‐fits‐all(i.e.,fixedwidth)prescriptionthatiscommonlyappliedinforestmanagement.Researchshowsthateffectiveshadingcanbeprovidedbybufferwidthsrangingfrom10mto30m(30to100ft)dependingonstandtype,age,andlocation.However,quantitativerelationshipsbetweenbufferwidthandshadefortypicalforesttypesandstandageclassesinCaliforniaarenotreportedintheliterature.Potentialquantitativerelationshipsbetweenstanddensityandshadeorbasalareaandshadearelacking.Consequentlyariparianstandmetricthatmayfunctionasareliablesurrogateforshadehasnotbeendeveloped.”(SoundWatershedConsulting2008,page31)
TheSoundWatershedConsultingliteraturereviewsupportstheprinciplesthatmanagementofshadeisparamountforcontrolofelevatedwatertemperatures,thatafixed‐widthbufferorcanopyclosureprescriptionisnotlikelytoachievemanagementgoalsinallcases,andthatsite‐specificconsiderationsneedtobemadeonacase‐by‐casebasis.AsimilarsummaryofcurrentunderstandingsofthermalprocessesinforestedenvironmentswaspreparedbyatechnicaladvisorycommitteeforconsiderationbytheBoardofForestry(CBOF‐TAC2007).ThissummaryreliedonapublishedreviewofforestmanagementeffectsonwatertemperatureandmicroclimatebyR.D.Moore,D.L.Spittlehouse,andA.Story(Mooreetal.2005).TheconclusionsofthereviewandsummaryarealsoconsistentwiththeprinciplesofthisPolicy.Activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceriparianshadeincludetimberharvest,roadbuildingandmaintenance,propertydevelopment,vegetationconversions,agriculture,grazing,andotheractivitiesthathavethepotentialtoresultinmodificationofriparianvegetationconditions.5.2.2ActivitieswiththepotentialtoincreasesedimentdeliveryIncreasedsedimentloadsandassociatedchangesinchannelmorphologycanaffectstreamtemperatureconditionsinmultipleways.Theseeffectscanmanifestatbothlarge(watershed‐wide)andsmall(individualreach)scales.Sedimentisdefinedasanyinorganicororganicearthenmaterial,includingbutnotlimitedto:soil,silt,sand,clay,androck(NCRWQCB2007).Thesizesofsedimentthatpresentatemperatureconcernarethosethatmayresultinpoolfilling,increasedchannelwidth,decreasedchanneldepth,and/orareductionofhyporheic(i.e.,intergravel)flow.
40 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Increasedsedimentloadsmayalsoreduceheatexchangeassociatedwithhyporheicprocessesthroughsimplificationofthebedtopographyandreducedpermeabilityduetoincreasesinfinesedimentdeposition.Hyporheicexchangeoccurswhensurfacewatersinfiltrateintotheinterstitialspacesofstreambeds.Assurfacewaterpassesthroughtheporoussediment,heatislost(orgained)throughconductionwiththesediments.Insomesettings,streambedconductioncanbeasignificantheatsinkthatbuffersdailymaximumtemperaturesinthesummerseason(LoheideandGorelick2006).
41 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentinthe
Mattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Figure5.1:Conceptualrepresentationofthecausesandeffectsoftemperaturealterationandassociatedimpactstobeneficialuses.(Source:NCRWQCB2010)
42 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Severalpublishedstudiesdescribemechanismsofheattransferdependentonpermeabilityofbedsediments,effectsofsedimentonstreamchannelmorphology,andstreamchannelcharacteristicsrelatedtothermalrefugia.Vaux(1968)demonstratedthathyporheicexchangeisdependentonthetopographiccomplexityofthebedsurfaceandpermeabilityofthesediments.Lisle(1982)reportedasimplificationofstreambedcomplexityassociatedwithaggradationatstreamgaugesitesintheNorthCoastRegionfollowingthe1964flood.Heobservedthatgaugingsiteswentfromapool‐likeformpriortoaggradation,toariffle‐likeformwithflatcross‐sectionalprofilesfollowingaggradation.WondzellandSwanson(1999)similarlyevaluatedtheeffectsoflargeeventsonchannelform.Theyspecificallyevaluatedchangesinthehyporheiczoneresultingfromlargefloodeventsanddemonstratedthatsimplificationofstreamchannelgeometry,includinglossofstep‐poolsequences,decreasesintra‐gravelexchangerates.Morerecently,researchershavequantifiedthereductioninsurfacestreamtemperaturesattributabletohyporheicexchange.InastudyofDeerCreekinnorthernCalifornia,Tompkins(2006)foundthatreduceddailymaximumwatertemperaturesinhyporheicseepsontheorderof3.5oC(6.3oF)createdthermalrefugiaforsalmonids.InastudysimilartoTompkins’,LoheideandGorelick(2006)documenteddailymaximumtemperaturereductionsontheorderof2oC(3.8oF)instudyofa1.7km(1.1.mi)streamreachofCottonwoodCreekinPlumasCounty,California.Temperatureandsedimentconcernsareoftenaddressedtogetherthroughcarefulmanagementofriparianareas.Theestablishmentofriparianbuffersfortemperatureprotectionisaneffectiveandimportantmanagementmeasureforthecontrolofsometypesofsedimentdischarges(Rashinetal.2006).Maintenanceofavegetatedbufferprovidesacontrolonthedischargeofsedimentmobilizedbysurfaceerosion(Brandowetal.2006).Also,theretentionofmaturetrees(andtheirroots)alongastreambankprovidesbankstability,reducingthedischargeofsedimentassociatedwithstreambanklandslides,streambankerosion,anddebrisflows(Cafferataetal.2005).Maintenanceofavegetatedbufferalongstreamsalsocanensureasupplyoflargewoodydebristothestreamchannel,whichiscriticalformeteringofsediment,channelformingprocesses,andfishhabitat.Activitieswiththepotentialtoincreasesedimentdeliveryincluderoadbuildingandmaintenance,timberharvest,propertydevelopment,vegetationconversions,agriculture,andotheractivitiesthathavethepotentialtodisturbsoils,concentraterunoff,anddecreasehillslopeandstreambankstability.5.2.3Thequality,quantity,locationandtimingofeffluent,stormwater,andagriculturalreturnflowdischargesDischargesofwastesuchaswastewatereffluent,coolingwater,stormwaterrunoff,andirrigationreturnflowscanelevatethetemperatureofreceivingwaterbodiesthroughthedirectdischargeofwarmerwater.
43 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
FloodirrigationisacommonirrigationpracticeinpartsoftheKlamathbasin,includingtheKlamathProjectareaandtheShastaRiverwatershed.Whenirrigationwaterisappliedtoafieldinthismanner,itgenerallyflowsacrossthefieldasathinsheetorinshallowrivulets.Astheirrigationwaterrunsacrossthegrounditabsorbsheat.Whenirrigationflowsreturntoastream,theycarrywiththemtheincreasedheatloadaddedastheypassedthroughtheirrigatedlands.TemperaturemonitoringoftailwaterreturnsintheShastaValleyfoundthehighestvaluesofthe7‐dayaverageofmaximumtemperaturerangedfrom26.9–34.5oC(80‐94oF)at7sites(AquaTerra2012).Theneteffectofdirectthermaldischargesisanincreaseinbothdailyaverageandmaximumtemperatures.Thethermalimpactofadirectdischargetoastreamcanbecalculatedusingthemixingequationdiscussedinsection3.1,above.5.2.4Thelocation,size,andoperationofin‐channelimpoundmentswiththeabilitytoalterthenaturaltemperatureregimeThewaterstoredbehindanin‐channelimpoundment(e.g.,dam)functionsasthermalmass,storingheat.Becauselargervolumesofwaterheatandcoolslowerthansmallervolumes,thelargevolumeofwaterbehindanimpoundmentactsasatemperaturebuffer,reducingdailytemperaturevariationsdownstream.Similarly,largevolumesofwaterresistseasonalchangesintemperature,andthusdelayseasonaltemperaturechanges,resultingincoldertemperaturesinthespringandwarmertemperaturesinthefall.IntheKlamathRiver,theseeffectsextend190milesdownstreamtothePacificOceanundercertainconditions(Bartholowetal.2004).OntheKlamathRivertheeffectsaremostpronouncedimmediatelydownstreamofIronGateDam,diminishinginthedownstreamdirection.Theexpectedbiologicalimplicationsofthechangesindiurnaltemperaturepatternscausedbydamsaremixed.Thedecreaseddiurnaltemperaturevariationsassociatedwithdamsleadtoreducedpeaktemperatures,therebyreducingthemostacutelyharmfultemperatures.Conversely,theincreaseddailylowtemperaturesassociatedwithdamscouldreducethetimeavailableforfishtoleavethermalrefugiatofeed.Also,higherdailylowtemperaturesmayleadtohighertemperaturesatthebottomofthermallystratifiedpools(Nielsenetal.1994).TheanalysisoftheimpactsofthefourimpoundmentsassociatedwiththeKlamathHydropowerProjectonrivertemperaturesconductedaspartoftheKlamathRivertemperatureTMDLfoundthatthoseeffectsweresignificant(NCRWQCB2010).Theseasonaltemperaturechangescausedbythedamshavebiologicalimplications.TheresultsoftheKlamathTMDLanalysisareconsistentwiththefindingsofBartholowetal.(2005),whoevaluatedthethermaleffectsoftheKlamathRiverdamsondownstreamreachesanddeterminedthatthedamsdelaytheseasonaltemperaturepatternsbyapproximately18daysonanannualbasis.Thephysicalimplicationofan18‐dayshiftintheseasonaltemperaturepatternisthattheriveriscoolerinthespringtimewhenjuvenilesalmonidsaremigratingto
44 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
theocean,andwarmerinthefallwhenadultsaremigratingupstreamandspawning,andwheneggsareincubatinginthegravels.Coolertemperaturesareknowntoreducejuvenilesalmonidgrowthrates;howeverthiseffectmaybemitigatedbythebenefitgainedbyreducedincidenceofstressfullyhightemperaturesduringoutmigration.Warmertemperaturesinthesummerperiodmayreducethenocturnalfeedingopportunitiesofjuvenilesalmonidsthatpersistatthermalrefugia,therebyreducingtheirabilitytowithstandstressfullyhighdaytimetemperatures(NationalResearchCounciloftheNationalAcademies2004).Warmertemperaturesinthefallmaydelayadultmigrationorleadtostressfullyhightemperatureswhenadultsarepresentoreggsareincubatingingravels.5.2.5ActionswiththepotentialtochangestreamchannelgeometryAwiderandshallowerchannelgainsandlosesheatmorereadilythananarrowanddeepchannel.Thisprincipalistrueforanystream.Astream’swidth‐to‐depthratioinfluencesstreamheatingprocessesbydeterminingtherelativeproportionofthewettedperimeterincontactwiththeatmosphereversusthestreambed.Waterincontactwiththestreambedexchangesheatviaconduction.Conductiveheatexchangewiththestreambedhasamoderatinginfluence,reducingdailytemperaturefluctuations.Waterincontactwiththeatmosphereexchangesheatviaevaporation,convection,solarradiation,andlong‐waveradiation.However,wideandshallowchannelshaveagreatersurfaceareaperunitofvolumeincontactwiththeatmospherethananarrower,deeperchannel.Heatexchangefromsolarradiationfaroutweighsheatexchangefromevaporation,convection,andlong‐waveradiation,unlessthestreamissignificantlyshaded.Theneteffectofchangesinwidth‐to‐depthratiosisthatstreamsthatarewideandshallowheatandcoolfasterthanstreamsthatarenarrowanddeep(PooleandBerman2001).Theeffectsofawiderandshallowerchannelaresimilartotheeffectsofincreasedsolarloading,inpartbecausechannelwideningresultsinincreasedsolarloading.Bothchangesleadtoincreasesindailyaverageandmaximumtemperatures,increaseddiurnalfluctuations,andmayleadtodecreaseddailyminimumtemperatures.Thewidth‐to‐depthratioofastreamcanbealteredthroughmanyavenues.Directmanipulationofthestreamchannelduringconstructionorfloodcontrolmaintenanceactivitiescanresultintheremovalofroughnesselementssuchasbouldersandlargewoodydebris.Activitieswithpotentialtocausecoarsesedimentdischargescancausechangesinstreambedmorphologydownstreamofthesedimentinputs.Similarly,hydromodificationassociatedwithincreasesinimpervioussurfacesandstormwaterroutingcanalsochangethegeometryofastreamchannel.5.2.6Activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceinstreamflowsorreducespecificsourcesofcoldwater,includingcoldwaterrefugia.Surfacewaterdiversionsdecreasethevolumeofwaterinthestream,andtherebyalterastream’sresponsetoheatinputs.Whenwaterisremovedfromastreamthe
45 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
thermalmassandvelocityofthewaterisdecreased.Thermalmassreferstotheabilityofabodytoresistchangesintemperature.Basically,lesswaterheatsorcoolsfasterthanmorewater.Decreasesinvelocityincreasethetimerequiredtotravelagivendistance,andthusincreasesthetimeheatingandcoolingprocessescanactonthewater.Theseprinciplesaretrueforanystream,andworkinconcertwithotherheatexchangeprocessestodeterminetheoveralltemperatureofastream.Groundwaterwithdrawalscanalsodecreasethevolumeofwaterinastream,dependingonthesituation.Wheregroundwateraquifersinteractwithstreamsgroundwaterwithdrawalscaneitherdrawwaterfromthestreamorinterceptgroundwaterthatwouldhaveotherwisedischargedtothestream(Winteretal.1998).TheScottRivertemperatureTMDLanalysisidentifiedtheinteractionofgroundwaterandsurfacewaterasakeyfactordeterminingstreamtemperaturesofthemainstemScottRiver.TheScottRiverisprimarilyagroundwaterdominatedstreamfromJuly‐September(NCRWQCB2005).Theincreaseintherateofheatingthataccompaniesadecreaseinthevolumeofflowinastreamcanhavesignificanttemperatureeffects.Adecreaseinthermalmassresultsinhigherdailyhighstreamtemperaturesandlowerdailylowstreamtemperatures,aswellashigherdailyaveragetemperatures.Reducedvelocitiesalsoresultinhigherdailyaveragestreamtemperatures.Directdiversionofsurfacewaterreducesstreamflowsandextractionofgroundwaterconnectedtosurfacewatersmayaswell.Activitiesthatreduceinfiltrationofprecipitationandfloodwaters,suchasconstructionofimpervioussurfacesandlevees,canreducegroundwaterinputstosurfacewaters(Winteretal.1998).Thermalrefugiaaretypicallyidentifiedasareasofcoolwatercreatedbyinflowingtributaries,springs,seeps,upwellinghyporheicflow,stratifiedpools,and/orgroundwaterinanotherwisewarmstreamchannelofferingrefugehabitattocold‐waterfishandothercoldwateraquaticspecies(NCRWQCB2007).Thermalrefugiaareoftentheonlyenvironmentsinnorthcoaststreamsthatarehabitabletosalmonidsduringthehotsummermonths(Nielsenandothers1994,WatercourseEngineering2006,Belchik1997).Thermalrefugiaareoftenformedindeeppoolsorpocketsofwatershelteredfrommixingduringlowflowperiods.Nielsenetal.(1994)demonstratedtherelationshipbetweenpoolvolumeandflowandpoolstratification.Simplyput,inorderforapooltostratifyintheabsenceofphysicalfeaturesthatseparatecoldwaterinputsfromthemainstreamflow,thevolumeofthepoolmustbelargerelativetotheflow,resultinginextremelylowvelocities.Inthesesituations,thebottomtemperatureisdeterminedbythedailylowtemperature.Activitiesthateitherraisethedailyminimumtemperatureordecreasethevolumeofthepoolcanimpactthesestratifiedpools.
46 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Thermalrefugiaalsocanforminareasofastreamseparatedfromcurrentswherecoldwatersourcessuchassprings,tributaries,orintergravelflowsenterthestream(Nielsenandothers1994,Belchik1997).Theserefugialareascanbeimpactedinvariouswaysbyactivitiesthatdischargefinesediments.Finesedimentscanfillthevoidsbetweensubstrate,therebydecreasingintergravelflowdecreasingintergravelflow,reducethevolumeorcausewarmingofcoldtributaryorspringflows,orreducethetopographiccomplexityofstreamchannels.Morphologicalchangesassociatedwithincreasedsedimentloadscanalsoeliminateorresultinadecreasedvolumeofthermalrefugiainastreamorriverandimpedeaccesstothermalrefugiaprovidedbytributaries.Refugialvolumecanbereducedoreliminatedwhendeeppoolsfillwithsediment,whensidechannelsareburied,orwhencoldtributaryflowspercolateintoaggradedtributarydeltasorgravelbarsbeforeenteringtheriver.Similarly,accesstorefugialtributariescanbereducedoreliminatedwhensedimentloadsresultinaggradationandcauseatributarytopercolatebeforeenteringthemainstemandthusbecomedisconnectedfromthemainstemorbecometooshallowforfishtoswim.AggradationhasimpactedthemouthsofHunter,Turwar,Independence,Walker,Oneil,PortugueseandGriderCreeks(KlamathRivertributaries),aswellas14of17smalllowerKlamathRivertributariessurveyedbytheYurokTribe(DeLaFuenteandElder1998,KierAssociates1999).Finally,refugiacanbeeliminatedwhentributarytemperaturesincreasebeyondsalmonidthresholdsduetotheothereffectsofincreasedsedimentloadsdiscussedabove.Activitiesthatcanleadtoreducednumbersorvolumesofthermalrefugiaincludethosethatcanalterthestreamchannelconfiguration,reducepoolvolumes,reduceflows,ordischargesediment,suchasconstruction,timberharvest,roadbuilding,irrigation,mining,andotheractivitieswiththepotentialtodisturbsoils,decreaseslopestability,increasesurfaceerosion,alterchannelmorphology,andreducestreamflows.5.3ActionstoAchieveandMaintainWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureThefollowingareactionsidentifiedintheproposedPolicytoImplementtheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatures(Policy).TheactionsareintendedtoachievewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureandimplementtemperatureTMDLs,includingEPA‐establishedTMDLs.ThePolicylanguageispresentedinboldforemphasis,withadiscussionfollowing.
47 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
5.3.1AddressRiparianShade,ControlSedimentLoadingandAddressHydrologicConditionsResultinginExceedenceofTemperatureObjectivesUsingRegulatoryandNon‐RegulatoryToolsRestoreandmaintainmaintainriparianshade,controlsedimentloading,andaddresshydrologicconditionsresultinginexceedenceoftemperatureobjectivesthroughnonpointsourcecontrolprograms;permitsandwaivers,grantsandloans,andenforcementactions;supportofrestorationprojects;andcoordinationwithotheragencieswithjurisdictionovercontrollablefactorsthatinfluencewatertemperature,asappropriate.ThisactiondirectsRegionalWaterBoardstafftoconsiderallopportunitiestorestoreandmaintainriparianshade, controlsedimentloading,andaddresshydrologicconditionsresultinginexceedenceoftemperatureobjectives,includingbothregulatoryandnon‐regulatorymeans.Thisdirectionincorporatestheconceptofshadeasacontrollablefactorintothewaterpollutioncontrolplan,andinsodoingstrengthenstheRegionalWaterBoard’sauthoritytoaddressriparianshadewhenestablishingwastedischargerequirements,waivers,and/orprohibitions.NonpointSourcePermitting,Permits,andWaiversTheRegionalWaterBoardhasdevelopednonpointsourcepermittingprogramstoaddresswaterqualityconcernsassociatedwitharangeofactivities.Todate,permittingprogramsinvolvingwastedischargerequirements,waiversofwastedischargerequirements,oracombinationofbothhavebeendevelopedforprivatetimberactivities,USFSactivities,dairyoperations,implementationoftheScottandShastaRiverTMDLs,andmanagementofcountyroads.RegionalWaterBoardstaffarecurrentlyintheprocessofdevelopingapermittingprogramtoaddresswaterqualityconcernsassociatedwithagriculturaloperations,aseparatepermittingprogramtoaddressroadimprovementandrelatedrestorationactivitiesinMendocinoCounty,andparticipatinginamulti‐regionalefforttodevelopaframeworkforapermittingprogramaddressinggrazing‐relatedwaterqualityconcerns.AnexampleoftheincorporationofshadeandsedimentconcernsinnonpointsourcepermittingistheWaiverofWasteDischargeRequirementsforNonpointSourceDischargesRelatedtoCertainFederalLandManagementActivitiesonNationalForestSystemLandsintheNorthCoastRegion(USFSWaiver).TheUSFSWaiverestablishesconditionsdesignedtopreventwaterqualityimpactsassociatedwithUSFSmanagementactivities,suchasthoserelatedtothemanagementofriparianareasforthepurposesofcontrollingsedimentdischargesandpreservingriparianshade.TheUSFSWaiverconditionsaddresstemperatureconcernsbyrequiringtheprotection,maintenance,andenhancementofriparianconditionsandshade.AnotherexampleoftheimplementationofshadeandsedimentconcernsisintheimplementationoftheGeneralWasteDischargeRequirementsforDischargesRelatedtoTimberActivitiesonNon‐FederalLandsintheNorthCoastRegion(Timber
48 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
GWDRs)andotherpermitsoftheNorthCoastRegion’stimberregulatoryprogram3.Timberharvestactivitieshavethepotentialtoimpactwatertemperature,dependingonhowtheactivitiesareconducted.Fortimberharvestactivitiesonprivatelands,theRegionalWaterBoardincorporatestheCaliforniaBoardofForestry’sForestPracticeRulesintowaterqualitypermitsforeaseofreference,forconsistentterminology,andtoavoidduplicativeprocessestothedegreepossible.TheCaliforniaDepartmentofForestryandFireProtection(CALFIRE),astheleadagencyinapprovingtimberharvestactivitiesonprivatelands,convenesamulti‐agencyteamthatincludesCALFIRE,theCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandWildlife,theCaliforniaRegionalWaterQualityControlBoards,theCaliforniaGeologicalSurvey,andotheragenciesasneeded,toconductareviewofatimberharvestplan(THP).EachagencymayrecommendincorporatingmitigatingmeasuresintotheTHPtoreduceadverseimpactsoftheoperationontimberlandresources,includingthebeneficialusesofwater.Throughthisprocess,RegionalWaterBoardstaffhaveanopportunitytomakespecificTHPrecommendationsandclarifyBasinPlanrequirements,ifneeded,sothatthefinalTHPiseligibleforenrollmentinthetimberGWDRsorwaivers.UndertheForestPracticeRules,timberoperationswithindesignatedwatercourseandlakeprotectionzonesmustadheretocanopyretentionstandardstoaddressstreamtemperatureissues,sedimentandnutrientloading,andrecruitmentoflargewoodydebris.RecentmodificationstotheForestPracticeRulestoaddressanadromousfishhabitat(AnadromousSalmonidProtectionrules)haveresultedincanopyretentionstandardsthataregenerallyprotectiveofshadeandwatertemperaturesintheareaswheretheyapply.Compliancewiththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturemayinsomeinstancesrequireadditionalcanopyprotections,particularlyinareasoutsidetherangeofanadromy(e.g.,upstreamofdams,headwatersofstreamsandotherplanningwatershedsabovemigrationbarriers,andcoastalstreamswithnoanadromoussalmonidhabitatthatflowdirectlytotheocean)andinstreamsthatsupportaquatichabitatotherthanfish(i.e.,streamsidentifiedintheForestPracticeRulesasClassIIwatercourses).IntheseareastheenhancedriparianprotectionsoftheForestPracticeRules’AnadromousSalmonidProtectionrulesdonotapply.Theprotectivemeasuresforwatercourseandlakeprotectionzonesonsuchstreamsrequirethatatleast50%totalvegetativecanopy,includingatleast25%oftheexistingoverstoryconifersberetained(theRulesalsohaveadditionalrequirementsforretentionofaminimumbasalarea,whichcanresultinhighercanopylevels).TheRegionalWaterBoardhasfoundthatthe50%totalcanopyretentionstandardisconsistentwithsite‐specific 3OtherpermitsthatcomprisetheNorthCoastRegion’stimberregulatoryprogramincludetheCategoricalWaiverofWasteDischargeRequirementsforDischargesRelatedtoTimberHarvestActivitiesOnNon‐FederalLandsintheNorthCoastRegion(Non‐FederalTimberWaiver),GeneralWasteDischargeRequirementsforDischargesforTimberOperationsonNon‐IndustrialTimberManagementPlans(NTMPs)intheNorthCoastRegion(NTMPGeneralWDR),andWDRsfordischargesrelatedtimberharvestingandrelatedlandmanagementintheBearCreek,ElkRiver,andFreshwaterCreekwatersheds.
49 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
potentialeffectiveshadeconditionsinsome,butnotallsituations,andthusdoesnotensurethesite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeconditionismet.ToaddressthispotentialgapbetweentemperatureprotectionandForestPracticeRulerequirements,RegionalWaterBoardstaffevaluatetheproposedharvestinthefieldduringpre‐harvestfieldinspectionswiththeforesterandothermembersoftheinterdisciplinaryreviewteam,andfollowingdiscussionwiththeinterdisciplinaryteam,makerecommendationstoensureadequatetemperatureprotection,asneeded.TheTimberGWDRscontainaprovisionthatallwaterqualityrequirementsmustbemettoqualifyforenrollmentintheTimberGWDRs.Asdefined,waterqualityrequirementsincludewaterqualityobjectives(narrativeornumeric),prohibitions,TMDLimplementationplans,policies,orotherrequirementscontainedinawaterqualitycontrolplanadoptedbytheRegionalWaterBoardandapprovedbytheStateWaterBoard,andallotherapplicableplansorpoliciesadoptedbytheRegionalWaterBoardorStateWaterBoard,including,butnotlimitedto,theStateWaterBoardResolutionNo.68‐16:StatementofPolicywithRespecttoMaintainingHighQualityWatersinCalifornia.ThisproposedPolicywouldrequirethattimberharvestplansbeconsistentwiththisPolicyinordertoqualifyforenrollmentintheTimberGWDRs.Inapplication,thispolicydirectsstafftocontinueimplementingtemperatureloadallocationsthroughTimberGWDRsenrollmentsinareassubjecttoexistingtemperatureTMDLs,includingEPA‐establishedtemperatureTMDLs.ItalsodirectsstafftoimplementsimilarshadecontrolsthroughTimberGWDRsenrollmentsinareaslistedasimpairedfortemperature,asappropriate,andregion‐wide,asappropriateandnecessary,topreventfutureimpairmentsandensurecompliancewiththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.GrantsandLoansandSupportofRestorationProjectsTheRegionalWaterBoardadministersprogramsthatincludeloanandgrantfundingforconstructionofmunicipalsewageandwaterrecyclingfacilities,remediationofundergroundstoragetankreleases,watershedprotectionandrestorationprojects,irrigationefficiency,andnonpointsourcepollutioncontrolprojects.Thesefundscanbeusedforprojectsthatpreserveand/orenhanceriparianshadeandreducesedimentloading,suchasriparianfencing,alternativestockwateringsystems,riparianplanting,beavermanagement,andbioengineeredbankstabilizationprojects.California’sCleanWaterStateRevolvingFundsaretypicallyusedtofundmunicipalwastewaterinfrastructure.However,it’spossiblethatthesetypesofprojectscouldinvolveaspectsthatrelatetoriparianshadealso,suchasprojectsinvolvingtheupgradingoftreatmentsystemsthatareadjacenttoriparianareas.EnforcementActionsTheRegionalWaterBoardoftentakesenforcementactionstoaddresstheimpactsassociatedwithunpermittedactivitiescausingdischargesofwasteandassociatedimpactstoriparianareas,includingsedimentdischargesandunpermittedremovalordestructionofriparianvegetationassociatedwithotherdischarges.Insuch
50 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
cases,theRegionalWaterBoardissuesorders,suchasacleanupandabatementorder,thatrequiretheremediationofimpactstowatersofthestate,includingimpactstoriparianvegetation.Remediationofsuchimpactstypicallyinvolvestherestorationofvegetationthathasbeenremovedordestroyed.CoordinationwithOtherAgencieswithJurisdictionOverControllableFactorsthatInfluenceWaterTemperatureTheRegionalWaterBoardhastheauthoritytoissuepermitsforthedischargeofwastetowatersofthestate.Temperatureimpactsaresometimescausedbyfactorsthatarenotassociatedwithdischargesofwaste,butareinsteadcausedbyactivitiescomingunderthedirectauthorityofotheragencies.Anexampleofthisisthenearstreamactivitiesthatcomeunderthelanduseplanningauthorityofcitiesandcounties.Citiesandcountiesdevelopordinancesanddefineappropriatelandusesthroughtheadoptionoflanduseplansandzoning.SonomaCounty,forexample,hasestablishedripariansetbacksintheirgeneralandareaspecificplansthatcallforrestrictedactivitieswithincertaindefineddistancesfromstreams.5.3.2ImplementSedimentControlsContinuetoimplementtheSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicyasameansofaddressingelevatedwatertemperatureassociatedwithexcesssedimentdischarges.ImplementsedimentcontrolsconsistentwiththeapproacharticulatedintheSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicytoaddresstemperatureconcernsassociatedwithsedimentinareasnotimpairedbysediment.ThisactiondirectsstafftopursuetheexistingSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicy(SedimentPolicy)asameansofaddressingsedimentloadsforthebenefitoftemperatureconditions.TheSedimentPolicydirectsstafftouseexistingauthoritiestostrengthenregulatorycontrolsofnonpointsourcedischargesofsediment.ImplementationofthatSedimentPolicyalsopartiallyimplementstheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureinsofarasthecontrolofsedimentdischargespartiallyaddresseselevatedwatertemperatures.TheSedimentPolicyisverysimilartothisproposedpolicyandreads,inpart:
“TheSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicystatesthattheRegionalWaterBoardshalladdresssedimentwastedischargesonawatershed‐specificbasisanddirectsstafftotakethefollowingactionstocontrolsedimentwastedischarges:1.Relyontheuseofexistingpermittingandenforcementactions.TheseactionsareconsistentwiththeNPSPolicy.
2.Relyontheuseofexistingprohibitions,includinganyfutureamendments.3.Pursuenon‐regulatoryactions,suchasMemorandaofUnderstanding,withotheragenciesandorganizations.
4.Workwithlocalgovernmentsandnon‐profitorganizationstodevelopsedimentcontrolstrategies,suchasgradingordinances.
5.Encourageorganizationsandindividualstocontrolsedimentwastedischargesandconductwatershedrestorationactivities.
6.Focusonpublicoutreachandeducation.
51 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
7.Developaguidancedocumentonsedimentwastedischargecontrol.8.DevelopasedimentTMDLimplementationmonitoringstrategy.”(BasinPlan,page4‐36)
TheimplementationoftheSedimentPolicyhasbeenlargelyachievedtodatethroughthesamenonpointsourcepermittingprogramsidentifiedabove.Forinstance,theTimberGWDRsrequirethedevelopmentoferosioncontrolplansandmitigationofallcontrollablesedimentdischargesiteswithinthetimberharvestplanareaduringthelifeoftheplan(usually5years).5.3.3AddressTemperatureConcernsinFutureNonpointSourceProgramsExamineandaddresstemperatureimpactswhendevelopingpermitsorprogramsfornonpointsourceactivities.Considerandimplement,whereapplicable,allavailablemeasurestopreventandcontroltheelevationofwatertemperaturesinpermitorprogramdevelopment.Suchmeasuresshallinclude,butarenotlimitedto,sedimentBestManagementPracticesandcleanups,memorandaofunderstandingoragreementwithotheragencies,prohibitionsagainstwastedischarges,managementofriparianareastoretainshade,andcontrolandmitigationoftailwaterandimpoundments.Whereappropriate,includemonitoringrequirementsforincorporationintopermits,programs,andotherorderstoconfirmthatmanagementactionsrequiredtopreventorreduceelevatedtemperaturesareimplementedandeffective.Thisactiondirectsstafftoincorporateelementsthataddresstemperatureconcernswhendevelopingnonpointsourcecontrolprograms.RegionalWaterBoardstaffiscurrentlyintheprocessofdevelopingapermittingprogramtoaddresswaterqualityconcernsassociatedwithcultivatedagriculturaloperations,andparticipatinginamulti‐regionalefforttodevelopaframeworkforapermittingprogramaddressinggrazing‐relatedwaterqualityconcerns.Thereisawiderangeofpracticesthatcanbeemployedtoaddresstemperatureimpactsassociatedwithnonpointsources.Theseincludethedesignationofriparianmanagementzonesthataremanageddifferentlythansurroundinglands,aswellastheavoidanceofotherfactorsliketailwaterdischargesandtheremovalofvegetationthatprovidesshadetoawaterbody.Inmanycasesthedevelopmentofawaterqualitymanagementplanisapreferredframeworkforidentifyingareasthatrequirespecialmanagementconsiderationstopreventwaterqualityimpacts,aswellasthemanagementpracticesemployed,anddocumentationoftheeffectivenessofthepractices.ThisactionalsodirectsRegionalWaterBoardstafftoincorporatemonitoringrequirementsintopermitstoensurethatactionstakentoaddresstemperatureconcernsareeffective.Thetypesofmonitoringthatmightaccomplishthisspanarangeofmonitoringtypes.Forinstance,photopointmonitoringcouldbeusedtoverifythatbestmanagementpracticesareeffectiveatmaintainingriparian
52 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
vegetation.Similarly,instreamtemperaturemonitoringcouldberequiredtoverifythatrequiredconditionsofanNPDESpermitsareachieved.5.3.4AddressTemperatureConcernsinIndividualPermitsAddressfactorsthatcontributetoelevatedwatertemperatureswhenissuing401certifications,NPDESpermits,WasteDischargeRequirements,orWaiversofWasteDischargeRequirements,orProhibitions.Thisactionenvisionsconditioningindividualwastedischargerequirements,waiversofwastedischargerequirements,401waterqualitycertifications,orprohibitionstoaddressanyfactorsthatcontributetoelevatedwatertemperatures.TheCleanWaterActdelegatestheauthoritytoissuepermitsfordredgeandfillactivitieswithinwatersoftheUStotheUSArmyCorpsofEngineers(USACE)andUSEPA.Theauthoritytoissuesuchpermitsisdeclaredinsection404oftheCleanWaterAct,andthesepermitsareoftencalled404permits.Section401oftheCleanWaterActrequiresapplicantsfor404permitstoobtaincertificationfromthestateverifyingthattheactivitywillcomplywithstatewaterqualitystandards.Thesecertificationsareoftencalled401waterqualitycertifications,orjust401certifications.ThescopeoftheState’sjurisdictionismorebroadthantheUSACEandUSEPA’sdredgeandfillpermittingjurisdiction.Thefederalauthorityislimitedtowaterbodies(i.e.,streams,wetlands,andtidalareas)thatarenavigable,orhaveaclearnexustoanavigablewaterway(e.g.awetlandthathasasurfaceconnectiontoanavigablestream).TheState’sauthorityappliestoallwaterbodieswithinthebordersoftheState.Forthisreason,theRegionalWaterBoardoftenissueswastedischargerequirementsforsomedredgeandfillactivitiesthroughageneralwastedischargerequirementpermitfordredgeandfillactivities.However,thesameconcernsandconsiderationsareaddressed,regardlessofthepermit.RegionalWaterBoardstaffroutinelyissue401certificationsanddredgeandfillpermitsforprojectssuchasbridgemaintenanceandretrofitting,streambankrestoration,roadconstructionandmaintenance,aswellasone‐timeprojectssuchaspipelineandcommunicationlinecrossings,floodchannelmaintenance,andlanddevelopmentsinareaswithwetlands.TheRegionalWaterBoardhasalsoissued401certificationsforuniqueprojectssuchastheTrinityRiverRestorationProgramandtheHighway101Willitsbypass.TheRegionalWaterBoardalsodevelopsandadministersWasteDischargeRequirementsandWaiversofWasteDischargeRequirementsforindividualprojects.Theseprojectsareoftenuniqueprojectsforwhichnogeneralpermithasbeendeveloped.Thesetypesofprojectsareoftencombinedwitha401certificationwhentheyinvolvedredgeandfillactivities.TheRegionalWaterBoardissuesNationalPollutantDischargeEliminationSystem(NPDES)permitsforpointsourcedischarges,suchaswastewatertreatmentplants,
53 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
industrialprocessingfacilities,statehighways,dairiesandconfinedanimalfeedingoperations,andotherfacilitiesthatdischargeeffluenttosurfacewaters.TheRegionalWaterBoardalsoissuesNPDESpermitsforstormwaterdischargesassociatedwithconstructionsites,industrialsites,andmunicipalrunoff.The401certifications,NPDESpermits,wastedischargerequirements,orwaiversofwastedischargerequirementsissuedbytheRegionalWaterBoardsetconditionstoaddressconcernsassociatedwithtemperaturefactorssuchasreductionsinshade,changesincrosssectionalconfiguration,temporarydewateringimpacts,and/orsedimentdeliveries.Prohibitionsagainstdischargesofwaste,suchastheprohibitionagainstthedischargeofsoil,silt,bark,slash,sawdust,orotherorganicandearthenmaterialinrelationtologging,construction,andassociatedactivities,acttocontroldischargesthatmayimpacttemperatureconditionsthroughthedischargeofsedimentandothersettleablematerials.5.3.5AddressTemperatureConcernsUsingOtherToolsUseotherregulatory,executive,andenforcementtools,asappropriate,toaddresselevatedwatertemperaturesandpreserveexistingcoldwaterresources.Thisactioncallsforapproachesthatcanbeemployedtoaddresstemperatureconcernsthatdon’tinvolvethedevelopmentandadministrationofpermittingprocesses.Otherregulatory,executive,andenforcementtoolsincludebasinplanningexercises,memorandaofunderstandingand/oragreementwithtribesorotheragencies,andenforcementorders,suchascleanupandabatementordersandceaseanddesistorders.OtherregulatoryactionsincludethosethatarisefromtheRegionalWaterBoard’sbasinplanningauthority,suchastheestablishmentofbeneficialusesandwaterqualityobjectives.Forinstance,theestablishmentofariparianecologybeneficialusecouldbecontemplatedasanappropriatebeneficialusethatwarrantsincorporationintotheBasinPlan.Similarly,theBoardhastheauthorityto“establishprohibitionsthatspecifycertainconditionsorareaswherethedischargeofwaste,orcertaintypesofwaste,willnotbepermitted”(Porter‐Cologne,Section13243).Executivetoolssuchasmemorandaofunderstandingwithstates,tribes,orotheragenciescanbeutilizedtoacknowledgecommoninterests,establishproceduresforcoordinationandcollaborationintheexerciseofauthorities,andestablishagreementsrelativetotheadministrationoftheirauthoritiesandprogramsforthebenefitofwatertemperatureandotherwaterqualityconditions.5.3.6AddressTemperatureConcernsThroughSupportofRestoration
54 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Supportandencouragerestorationprojectsthataredesignedtoeliminate,reduce,ormitigateexistingsourcesoftemperatureimpairments.Administer,encourage,andsupporttheuseofgrantfundstofacilitateprojectsthataddresselevatedwatertemperatureconcerns.Pursuenon‐regulatoryactionswithorganizations,landownersandindividualstoencouragethecontrolofelevatedwatertemperatures,watershedrestoration,andprotectionactivities.Restorationisanimportanttoolforachievingwaterqualityconditionssufficienttoprotectandrestorebeneficialuses,andmaybeparticularlynecessarytoaddresssometemperatureimpairments.Thisactiondirectsstafftoencourageandpromoterestorationthroughtheadministrationofgrantfundsandcollaborationwithorganizationsandindividualsasatooltoachievethewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.TheRegionalWaterBoardadministersanumberofgrantprogramsthatfundrestoration,includingthe319(h)and205(j)grantprograms,andsometimespropositionbondfunds.However,mostofthegrantfundedprojectsthataddresstemperatureconcernsintheNorthCoastRegionarefundedthroughgrantprogramsadministeredbyotheragencies,suchastheCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandWildlife,USFishandWildlifeService,orNaturalResourceConservationService.ThisactionidentifiestheroletheRegionalWaterBoardcanplayinthepromotionofindividualprojectsfundedthroughgrantprogramsadministeredbytheRegionalWaterBoard,aswellasthosefundedthroughotherfundingprograms.Someexamplesofrestorationprojectsaddressingtemperatureconcernsthathavebeenorcouldbefundedthroughgrantsarethefollowing:
theplantingofriparianvegetationinareasslowtorecoverfromthelegacyeffectsofpastmanagementactivities;
infrastructure,suchasfences,stockwateringsystems,andshadestructurestoreduceimpactsoflivestockonriparianvegetation;
projectsthatconservewater,resultinginreduceddiversionofcoldwaterfromsprings,streams,andaquifersinconnectionwithsurfacewaters;
projectsthatleadtoimprovedunderstandingofgroundwaterandsurfacewaterdynamicsinareaswheretheinteractionofthesewatershasbeenidentifiedasafactorcontributingtoelevatedwatertemperatures;and,
waterstorageprojectsthatresultinreduceddiversionofwaterduringthedriermonths.
5.3.7CoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsintheWaterRightsPermittingProcessContinuetocoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsbyparticipatinginthewaterrightapplicationandpetitionprocess,providingmonitoringrecommendations,conductingjointinspections,submittingdatainsupportof401certificationsrelatedtowaterdiversionsand/orfacilitiesregulatedbytheFederalEnergyRegulatoryCommission,andanyotherappropriatemeans
55 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
tohelpensurethatthetermsofwaterrightpermitsandlicensesareconsistentwiththewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.ThisactiondirectsstafftomakeuseoftheprocessesavailableforinteractingwiththeStateWaterResourcesControlBoard’sDivisionofWaterRightsinallofficialcapacitiestheRegionalWaterBoard’sauthorityprovides.TheStateWaterBoard’sDivisionofWaterRights(DivisionofWaterRights)issueswaterrightpermitsforthediversionofsurfacewaters,andRegionalWaterBoardstaffoftenworkwithDivisionofWaterRightsstafftoensureBasinPlanrequirementsarereflectedinwaterrightpermitsandotherwaterrightorders.ThePolicyforMaintainingInstreamFlowsinNorthernCaliforniaCoastalStreams(May4,2010)specificallycallsforinvolvementbyRegionalWaterBoardstohelpensureadequateconsiderationofwaterqualityconcerns.TheDivisionofWaterRightsalsoissues401waterqualitycertificationsforprojectsrequiringaFederalEnergyRegulatoryCommission(FERC)license.RegionalWaterBoardstaffprovidesrecommendationsandidentifywaterqualityconditionsthatarenecessarytoensurethattheactivitywillcomplywithwaterqualitystandards.ThisactiondirectsRegionalWaterBoardstafftocontinuetoworkwiththeDivisionofWaterRightstoensurethattemperatureandotherwaterqualityconcernsareidentifiedandaddressedinthewaterrightpermittingprocessinallwaterbodies.TheprocessinwhichtheRegionalWaterBoardstaffandDivisionofWaterRightsstaffhaveagreedtocoordinateontheseissueshasbeenestablishedinaninteragencymemorandum.5.3.8CoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsintheDevelopmentofInstreamFlowStudiesandFlowObjectivesCoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsonthedevelopmentofinstreamflowstudiesandflowobjectives,asappropriate.ThisactiondirectsstafftocoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsonthedevelopmentofinstreamflowstudies.Instreamflowstudiesaresometimesnecessarytodeterminethedynamicsofhydrologicsystems,includingthesourcesandlossesofwater,andtounderstandtheamountanddistributionofwaternecessarytosupportbeneficialuses.ThisactionalsodirectsstafftocoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsonthedevelopmentofflowobjectives.Thedevelopmentofflowobjectivesmaybeappropriateincaseswheretheinstreamflowrequirementsforsupportofbeneficialusesaredefined.Forinstance,awatershedhydrologyobjectivethatdescribesnarrativegoalsforthetiming,quantity,anddistributionofwatercouldbeincorporatedintotheBasinPlan,ascouldanumericflowobjectiveforaparticularwatershedwherespecificflowrelatedthresholdsareunderstood.5.3.9ProvideOtherAgenciesGuidanceandRecommendationsProvidecities,counties,state,andfederalagenciesguidanceandrecommendationsoncompliancewiththewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.Workwithlocalgovernmentstodevelopstrategiestoaddresstheprevention,reduction,andmitigationofelevatedwatertemperatures,
56 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
including,butnotlimitedto,riparianordinances,generalplans,andothermanagementpolicies.Thisactiondirectsstafftocommunicateguidanceandrecommendations,suchascommentlettersorface‐to‐facemeetings,withstate,federal,andlocalgovernmentofficialsandplanningstaff,toadviseandassistthemindevelopingpoliciesandplansthatcomplywithandsupportthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.RegionalWaterBoardstaffoftensubmitswaterqualitycommentstocitiesandcountiesduringthedevelopmentoftheirordinancesandgeneralplans.Section13247ofthePorter‐CologneWaterQualityControlActstates:
“Stateoffices,departments,andboards,incarryingoutactivitieswhichmayaffectwaterquality,shallcomplywithwaterqualitycontrolplansapprovedoradoptedbythestateboardunlessotherwisedirectedorauthorizedbystatute,inwhichcasetheyshallindicatetotheregionalboardsinwritingtheirauthorityfornotcomplyingwithsuchplans.”
AnexampleoftheRegionalWaterBoardprovidingguidanceandrecommendationstoanotherstateagencyistheinputRegionalWaterBoardstaffhasprovidedtheCaliforniaBoardofForestryregardingrevisionsandimplementationoftheForestPracticeRules.RegionalWaterBoardstaffregularlyattendBoardofForestrymeetingsinwhichchangesintherulesarecontemplated,andhavesubmittedcommentlettersonrulechangestoensuretheBoardofForestryisawareofBasinPlanconsiderations.Similarly,RegionalWaterBoardstaffparticipatedinCalFire’sSectionVTechnicalAdvisoryCommitteethatdevelopedaguidancedocumentforforesterswishingtomakeuseofthatrelativelyrecentsectionoftheForestPracticeRulesaddedaspartoftheAnadromousSalmonidProtectionrulepackage,whichinvolvestimberoperationswithintheriparianzone.StateguidelinesrequirethatlocalgeneralplansshouldincorporatewaterqualitypoliciesfromBasinPlanstotheextenttheyarerelevant.Theplanningandlanduseauthoritiesentrustedtocitiesandcountiesincludetheauthoritytolimitimpactsfromlandusestowatersofthestateandothernaturalresources.Thisactiondirectsstafftocontinuetoprovideguidanceandrecommendationstocitiesandcountiesoncompliancewiththewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureandworkwithlocalgovernmentstodevelopstrategiestoaddresstheprevention,reduction,andmitigationofelevatedwatertemperatures,including,butnotlimitedto,riparianordinances,generalplans,andothermanagementpolicies.RegionalWaterBoardstaffhaveactivelyparticipatedinmeetingswiththeSonomaCountyPermitandResourceManagementDepartmentregardingthedevelopmentoftheCounty’sRiparianZoningordinance,andhopetohavesimilaropportunitieswithothercountyplanningdepartments.5.3.10CoordinatewithOtherStateAgencies
57 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Identifystatewidepoliciesunderdevelopmentwithimplicationsforwatertemperature,collaboratewithStateWaterBoardcounterparts,andproviderecommendationsandguidancewithrespecttothispolicy.ThisactiondirectsstafftocollaboratewithStateWaterBoardandotherstateagenciesinthedevelopmentofstatewidepoliciesthatmayhaveimplicationsforwatertemperature.AnexampleofsuchapolicyistheWetlandandRiparianAreaProtectionPolicycurrentlybeingdevelopedbytheStateBoard.Similarly,theStateandRegionalWaterBoardsarecollaboratinginamulti‐regionalefforttodevelopaframeworkforapermittingprogramaddressinggrazing‐relatedwaterqualityconcerns.5.3.11MonitorTemperatureTrendsDevelopandimplementaregion‐widewatertemperaturetrendmonitoringprogramtoassisttheRegionalWaterBoardindeterminingwhetherthisPolicyiseffectivelyreducingandpreventingelevatedtemperaturesoverthelong‐term.ThisactiondirectsstafftodevelopamonitoringplantotrackregionaltemperaturetrendstounderstandwhethertheactionsidentifiedinthisPolicyareeffectiveatcontrollingstreamtemperatures.Section7.0isadescriptionofthetemperaturemonitoringstrategyRegionalWaterBoardstaffarepursuing.5.3.12DevelopandMaintainaTemperatureWorkplanDevelopandmaintainatemperatureimplementationworkplanconsistentwiththePolicytoprioritizeefforts,trackprogress,andidentifyspecificactiontoaddresselevatedwatertemperatures.ThetemperatureimplementationworkplanshalldescribeactionsthatwillbetakenthroughouttheNorthCoastRegionandsetwatershedprioritiesforaddressingelevatedwatertemperaturesatawatershed‐specificlevel.ThetemperatureimplementationworkplanshallbepresentedtotheRegionalWaterBoardonatriennialbasis.ThisactiondirectsstafftodevelopandmaintainatemperatureimplementationworkplansimilartotheWorkPlantoControlExcessSedimentinSedimentImpairedWatershed(NCRWQCB2008),whichidentifiestheactionsandtasksRegionalWaterBoardstaffshouldtaketocontrolhuman‐causedexcesssedimentinthesediment‐impairedwaterbodiesoftheNorthCoastRegionoveraten‐yeartimeframe.Thetemperatureimplementationworkplanshouldidentifybothregionalandwatershed‐specifictasksRegionalWaterBoardstaffintendtoexecutetocontrolelevatedtemperaturesintheNorthCoastRegion.ThisactionalsomandatesreviewoftheworkplanbytheRegionalWaterBoardeverythreeyears.
58 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
6.0 ACTIONPLANSTOADDRESSTEMPERATUREIMPAIRMENTSINTHEMATTOLE,NAVARRO,ANDEELRIVERWATERSHED
6.1StipulatedAgreementTheRegionalWaterBoardandStateWaterResourcesControlBoardweresuedseveralyearsagobysixenvironmentalgroups.ThesuitwasfiledtocompelthedevelopmentofimplementationplansforthetemperatureTMDLsdefinedinthefollowingdocuments4:
NavarroRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature(2000),
MattoleRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature(2002),
UpperMainEelRiverandTributaries(includingTomkiCreek,OutletCreekandLakePillsbury)TotalMaximumDailyLoadsforTemperatureandSediment(2004),
MiddleMainEelRiverandTributaries(fromDosRiostoSouthFork)TotalMaximumDailyLoadsforTemperatureandSediment(2005),
LowerEelRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforTemperatureandSediment(2007),
SouthForkEelRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature(1999),
NorthForkEelRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature(2002),and
MiddleForkEelRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature(2003)
TheTMDLslistedabovecontainallofthecomponentsofaTMDL(problemstatement,sourceanalysis,loadallocation,numerictargets,loadallocations,linkageanalysis,andmarginofsafety)butdonotincludeimplementationplans.TheseTMDLsweredevelopedonanaggressiveschedule,pursuanttoaconsentdecree,whichdidnotallowforthedevelopmentandadoptionofimplementationplans.Thethreestand‐aloneActionPlanstoControlElevatedWaterTemperaturesintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedsweredevelopedtoaddresselevatedwatertemperatures,implementtheTMDLslistedabove,andsatisfythestipulatedagreement.6.2GeographicScopeThestand‐aloneActionPlanstoControlElevatedWaterTemperaturesintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedsapplytothefollowingwatersheds:
4 ThewatershedsreferencedabovehadTMDLsdevelopedforbothtemperatureandsediment,whichweredevelopedatthesametimeandpresentedinthesamedocument.ThesedimentTMDLscontainedinthesedocumentsareaddressedthroughimplementationoftheSedimentPolicy.ThisPolicyaddressesthetemperatureTMDLsonly.
59 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
MattoleRiver NavarroRiver UpperMainEelRiver MiddleMainEelRiver
LowerMainEelRiver SouthForkEelRiver NorthForkEelRiver MiddleForkEelRiver
6.3RelationshiptotheRegionalTemperaturePolicyThestand‐aloneActionPlanstoControlElevatedWaterTemperaturesintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedsareconsistentwiththeconcurrentlyproposedPolicyandfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.Theactionsdescribedinthestand‐aloneActionPlanstoControlElevatedWaterTemperaturesintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedsapplytheprinciplesofthePolicytotemperatureissuesidentifiedinthosewatershedswithagoalofimplementingtheTMDLloadallocationsandachievingtheTMDLtargets.ThePolicydirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtofocustemperatureimplementationactionsonthreefactors:shade,flow,andsediment.TheactionsdescribedintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatershedActionPlansaddressshadeandflowissues.ElevatedsedimentissuesinthesewatershedsareaddressedthroughimplementationoftheSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicycontainedintheBasinPlan.6.4TemperatureTotalMaximumDailyLoadAssessments6.4.1ProblemStatementsEachoftheeightTMDLsaddressedbytheseActionPlanscontainsaproblemstatement.Theproblemstatementsconsistentlyidentifythedeclineofthesalmonidfisheryanddegradationofhabitatassymptomsofthewaterqualityimpairmentcausedbyelevatedwatertemperatures.Manyoftheproblemstatementsalsodiscussthescienceofsalmonidlifecycleandhabitatrequirements,withadiscussionofthetemperatureconditionsastheyexistedatthetimetheTMDLswereprepared.Forfurtherinformationdescribingtheproblemsassociatedwithelevatedwatertemperaturesintheeightwatersheds,seetheTMDLdocumentslistedinSection2.4.6.4.2SourceAnalysesThesourceanalysismethodsandconclusionsaresummarizedinsection2.4,TemperatureTMDLAnalyses,above.SeetheTMDLdocumentslistedinSection6.1,StipulatedAgreement,above,forafulldiscussionofeachofthesourceanalyses.6.4.3TotalMaximumDailyLoadsThetemperatureTMDLsdevelopedfortheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatershedsweredevelopedusingconsistentmethodologiesandinterpretations.Accordingly,theTMDLs,loadallocations,andtargetswereestablishedtoachieveconditionsthatareconsistentamongalloftheTMDLs.Despitethisconsistency,the
60 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureand
ActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
calculatedthermalloadsestablishedvaryfromwatershedtowatershedduetodifferencessuchasvegetationtype,channelwidth,andchannelorientation.However,theloadsweredevelopedconsistentlyonasingleconceptualbasis:thepotentialamountofeffectiveshadeprovidedtothewatersurfacefromnearstreamvegetationtakingintoaccounttopography,streamorientation,differencesinvegetationtype,andnaturalfactorsthatcanreducethatamountsuchasfire,disease,geology,soils,landslides,windthrow,andothernaturalprocesses.TheestablishedTMDLsandadescriptionofthebasisfortheTMDLarepresentedinTable6.1,below.6.4.4NumericTargetsTotalmaximumdailyloadnumerictargetsareaquantitativevalueorvaluesusedtomeasurewhetherornottheapplicablewaterqualitystandardisattained.NumerictargetsfortemperatureTMDLsdevelopedintheNorthCoastRegionareusedtomeasureprogresstowardsachievementoftheapplicablewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature,astheobjectivesapplytotheindividualTMDLwatersheds.TheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatershedsareintrastatewaters,andthusonlytheintrastatewaterqualityobjectiveapplies.ThetargetsaresummarizedinTable6.2,below.
61 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentinthe
Mattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table6.1:SummaryoftheTotalMaximumDailyThermalLoadsestablishedforeachwatershed.Watershed TotalMaximumDailyThermalLoad Basis
UpperMainEelRiver Averagesolarloadingof289langleys/day Shadeassociatedwith“fullnaturalgrowth”
MiddleMainEelRiver Averagesolarloadingof233langleys/dayShadeassociatedwith“fullnaturalgrowth”
LowerMainEelRiverSaltRiversubbasin:362langleys/dayAllothertributaryreaches:118langleys/dayLowermainEel:noTMDLneeded.
Heatloadthatcorrespondsto“naturalshadeconditions”
SouthForkEelRiver Effectiveshadelevels,variedbystreamwidthandvegetationtype,rangingfrom26‐96%
Shadeassociatedwith“naturalconditions”
MiddleForkEelRiver
NFofMFEel:118langleys/dayUpperBlackButte:100langleys/dayOtherMFEeltributaries:109langleys/dayMFEelMainstem:9%reductioninheat
Shadeassociatedwith“naturalfullgrowthvegetation”
NorthForkEelRiverNorthForkEelwatershedupstreamofYellowjacketCreekandHullsCreeksubbasin:Modeledshaderesultsdepictedinfigures.RemainderofNorthForkEel:41%averageshade.
“NaturalPotentialShade”
62 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentinthe
Mattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
NavarroRiver
Cumulativedistributionofpotentialeffectiveshade(presentedinTable3‐1andFigure3‐4oftheNavarroTMDLdocument[USEPA2000]):
Potentialeffectiveshadeconditions,withallowancesforeffectsofnaturalfactorsthatreduceshade
MattoleRiver
Thedistributionofeffectiveshadeconditionsidentifiedas“adjustedpotentialvegetation”,below(figure4‐8oftheMattoleTMDL[USEPA,2002]):
Potentialeffectiveshadeconditions,withallowancesforeffectsofnaturalfactorsthatreduceshade
63 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentinthe
Mattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table6.2:SummaryofNumericTargetsintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedTemperatureTMDLsWatershed NumericTargetsUpper Main Eel River Achievementoftemperatureatdesignatedlocation.Middle Main Eel River Noneexplicitlydefined.Lower Main Eel River Noneexplicitlydefined.South Fork Eel River
Middle Fork Eel River The minimum target value is the distribution of stream lengths that fall into the adequate and marginal temperature categories under the full growth scenario:
TemperaturerangeUpperBlackButte
subbasin
NorthForkofMiddleForksubbasin
RemainderoftheMiddleForkEelRiverwatershed
Good(MWAT<15°C) 0% 0% 0%Adequate(15°C<MWAT<17°C)
28% 6% 23%
Marginal(17°C<MWAT<19°C)
71% 78% 72%
North Fork Eel River Thedistributionofstreamtemperaturesrepresentedinthefollowingtable:
64 StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentinthe
Mattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Navarro River “TemperatureconditionsintheNavarroshouldshowthegeneralpatternillustratedinFigure3‐2.Goodorsuitablehabitatconditionsforcoldwaterfish(<17°C[62.6°F]asmeasuredbyMWAT)shouldexistinmosttributaries.Streamsthatcannotsupportambientsuitableconditions(e.g.,mainstemNavarro,AndersonandlowerRancheria)willprovideimprovingconditionsforpoolrefugiaandconnectivitybetweenrefugiathroughsufficientnaturalsurfaceandgroundwaterflow.”
“ThequantityofflowdivertedfromtheNavarrointhesummerisnotincreased,unlessitcanbeshownthatsuchanincreasedoesnotadverselyaffectbeneficialuse.TheNMFSguidelinesprovidedetailsofthedocumentationrequiredforsummerdiversions.”
Mattole River Adjustedpotentialshadeconditionsfromriparianvegetation Increasedvolumeofthermallystratifiedpools
65StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
6.4.5MarginsofSafetyTheCleanWaterActrequiresthatTMDLsincludeamarginofsafetythattakesintoaccountanylackofknowledgeconcerningtherelationshipbetweenthepollutantloadsandthedesiredreceivingwaterquality.Themarginofsafetyisoftenimplicitlyincorporatedintoconservativeassumptionsusedincalculatingloadingcapacities,wasteloadallocations,andloadallocations(EPA1991).ThemarginofsafetymayalsobeincorporatedexplicitlyasaseparatecomponentintheTMDLequation.TheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatershedtemperatureTMDLanalysesallcontainimplicitmarginsofsafety,basedonconservativeassumptionsthatweremadetoaccountforuncertaintiesintheanalysis.SeetheindividualTMDLdocumentslistedinSection6.1,StipulatedAgreement,above,forafulldiscussionoftheconservativeassumptionsthatcomprisethemarginsofsafetyfortheseTMDLs.6.5DescriptionofImplementationActionstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentsintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatershedTheimplementationactionsdescribedbelowcomprisethesuiteofimplementationactionsidentifiedinthethreeActionPlanstoaddresstemperatureimpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatersheds.However,becausesomeactivitiesarenotpresentineachofthewatersheds,notallapplyineverywatershed.6.5.1 TimberHarvestActivitiesonNon‐FederalLandsResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:RegionalWaterBoardstaffshallmakerecommendationsforadditional
measurestoensuretheTMDLloadallocationsandwaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureareachievedduringthetimberharvestreviewprocess,ifnecessary.
ThisactioncallsonRegionalWaterBoardstafftorelyontheriparianshadeprotectionsrequiredbytheCaliforniaForestPracticeRulesasastartingpointtoprotectandmaintainriparianshade.However,compliancewiththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturemayinsomeinstancesrequireadditionalcanopyprotections,particularlyinareasoutsidetherangeofanadromy(seeadditionaldiscussioninsections4.4and5.3.1).Accordingly,thisactioncallsforRegionalWaterBoardstafftomakerecommendationsforadditionalmeasuresnecessarytoachievethewaterqualityobjectivesduringthetimberharvestreviewprocesswhentheForestPracticeRuleprotectionsareinsufficient.ThroughthisprocessRegionalWaterBoardstaffhaveanopportunitytomakespecificTHPrecommendationsandclarifyBasinPlanrequirements,ifneeded,duringthetimberharvestreviewprocesssothatthefinalTHPiseligibleforenrollmentinthetimberGWDRsorwaivers.TheRegionalWaterBoardregulatesdischargesofwasteassociatedwithprivatetimberactivitiesintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverwatershedsthroughthefollowinggeneralpermitsandwatershed‐widepermit:
66StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
GeneralWasteDischargeRequirementsforDischargesRelatedtoTimberHarvestActivitiesonNon‐FederalLandsintheNorthCoastRegion(TimberGWDRs)
CategoricalWaiverofWasteDischargeRequirementsforDischargesRelatedtoTimberHarvestActivitiesOnNon‐FederalLandsintheNorthCoastRegion(Non‐FederalTimberWaiver)
GeneralWasteDischargeRequirementsforDischargesforTimberOperationsonNon‐IndustrialTimberManagementPlans(NTMPs)intheNorthCoastRegion(NTMPGeneralWDR)
WasteDischargeRequirementsForDischargesRelatedtoTimberHarvestingandRelatedLandManagementActivitiesConductedbyHumboldtRedwoodCompany,LLC,intheBearCreekWatershedHumboldtCounty
In2011,theMattoleRestorationCouncilreceivedapprovalfortheirMattoleForestFuturesProject.Thisprogramestablishesasuiteof“lighttouch”forestrypracticesdescribedandanalyzedintheMattoleProgrammaticTimberlandEnvironmentalImpactReport.Thisprogramprovideslandownersastreamlinedapprovalprocessfortheirloggingplans,providedtheirharvestmeetstheprogram’sstandards.RegionalWaterBoardparticipatedinthedevelopmentoftheprogram,whichaddressestemperatureconcerns.ResponsibleParty:Partiesconductingtimberactivitiesonprivatelands.ActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Implementriparianmanagementmeasuresthatmeettheriparianshade
allocationsandwaterqualitystandards.WheretheForestPracticeRulesarenotsufficienttomeettheTMDLallocationsorwaterqualitystandards,implementadditionalmeasuresasdirectedbyRegionalWaterBoardstaffduringthetimberharvestreviewprocess.
Thisactiondirectsprivatepartiesconductingtimberharvestactivitiesthatdischargewaste,orhavethepotentialtodischargewaste,tomanageriparianareasconsistentwiththeTMDLloadallocationsforriparianshade.BecauseTMDLloadallocationsareestablishedasnecessaryconditionsforachievementofwaterqualitystandards(i.e.,waterqualityobjectivesinthecontextofbeneficialuses),applicableloadallocationsshouldbeincorporatedintoatimberharvestplantoqualifyforenrollmentinanyofthetimberpermitsdescribedabove.TheactionalsodirectsthosepartiestoimplementadditionalmeasuresidentifiedbyRegionalWaterBoardstaffduringthetimberharvestplanningprocess.Theseactionsimplementactions1and2oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.
67StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
6.5.2ActivitiesonLandsManagedbytheU.S.ForestService(USFS)ResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlan: Eel Actions:1)ImplementOrderNo.R1‐2010‐0029,WaiverofWasteDischarge
RequirementsforNonpointSourceDischargesRelatedtoCertainFederalLandManagementActivitiesonNationalForestSystemLandsintheNorthCoastRegion,andanyfuturerevisions,(USFSWaiverofWDRs)asamechanismforcompliancewithtemperatureobjectives.2)RegionalWaterBoardstaffshallmakerecommendationsforadditionalmeasurestoensurethewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureisachievedduringtheprojectreviewprocess,asnecessary.
TheseactionsdirectstafftocontinueimplementingtheUSFSWaiverofWDRsasamechanismforcompliancewithtemperatureTMDLsandtheintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature,andtomakefurtherrecommendationsduringtheprojectreviewprocess,asnecessary,toensureachievementofthewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.In2010,theRegionalWaterBoardissuedOrderR1‐2010‐0029:WaiverofWasteDischargeRequirementsforNonpointSourceDischargesRelatedtoCertainFederalLandManagementActivitiesonNationalForestSystemLandsintheNorthCoastRegion(USFSWaiver),aconditionalwaiveraddressingcertainnonpointsourceactivitiesonUnitedStatesForestServicelandsintheregion,includingtimber,roads,andgrazing.Thispermit,byvirtueofitsconditions,alsoimplementssediment,temperature,andnutrientTMDLs,andmeetstheBasinPlanintrastatetemperatureobjective.TheUSFSWaiver ofWDRsadoptstheUSFSprogramthatmanagesandmaintainsdesignatedriparianzonestoensureretentionofadequatevegetativecoverthatresultsinnaturalshadeconditions.TheUSFSprogramrequiresretentionoftreeswithin300feetslopedistanceoneachsideoffish‐bearingstreams,150feetslopedistanceoneachsideofperennialstreams,and100feetslopedistanceoneachsideofephemeral/intermittentstreams,orthesite‐specificpotentialtreeheightdistanceoneachsideofthestream,whicheverisgreatest.TheUSFSWaiverofWDRsprovidesforexceptionstotheserequirementsifitcanbedemonstratedthattheexceptionwillresultinanetlong‐termbenefittowaterqualityandstreamtemperatures.TheUSFSWaiverofWDRsisthesoleimplementationmechanismintheBlackButteRiver,UpperMiddleForkEelRiver,andUpperNorthForkEelRiverwatersheds.ResponsibleParty:U.S.ForestServiceActionPlan: Eel Actions:ConductlandmanagementactivitiesincompliancewiththeUSFSWaiver
ofWDRs,andinaccordancewithproject‐levelrecommendations.
68StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ThisactionsimplycallsontheUSFStocomplywithtermsoftheUSFSWaiverofWDRs.Theseactionsimplementsactions1and2oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.3AgriculturalActivitiesonNon‐FederalLandsResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action: DevelopandimplementtheAgriculturalLandsDischargeProgramasa
mechanismforcompliancewithtemperatureobjectives.ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtodevelopanAgriculturalLandsDischargeProgram(ALDP)thatachievesriparianloadallocations,andtoimplementtheALDPorelementsthereof,uponadoption,asameansofachievingthewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.TheALDPiscurrentlyunderdevelopment,andisintendedtoaddresswaterqualityconcernsassociatedwithcultivatedagriculturalcropssuchasgrapes,orchardcrops,flowers,medicalmarijuana,vegetables,andothercommodities.TheregulatoryprogramwilllikelybecomposedofanumberofwaiversandWDRsforspecificagriculturalcategories.ResponsibleParty:Anypartyconductingactivitiesassociatedwithagriculturethat
dischargewasteorhavethepotentialtodischargewasteonnonfederalland,exceptdairies.
Action:1)“Implementriparianmanagementmeasuresthatmeettheriparian
shadeloadallocationsandwaterqualitystandards.”
2)“ConductlandmanagementactivitiesincompliancewiththeAgriculturalLandsDischargeProgramwhenadopted.“
Thefirstofthesetwoactionsdirectspartiesengagedinagriculturalactivitiesthatdischargewaste,orhavethepotentialtodischargewaste,tomanageriparianareasconsistentwiththeTMDLloadallocationsforriparianshade.ThesecondoftheseactionssimplydirectsagriculturaloperatorstocomplywiththeALDPuponadoption.Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions1,2,and3oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.4RoadConstructionandMaintenanceofStateHighwayFacilitiesResponsibleParty:StateWaterResourcesControlBoard,RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Navarro,andEel
69StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Action:ImplementtheNPDESStatewideStormWaterPermitandWasteDischargeRequirementsfortheStateofCalifornia,DepartmentofTransportation(Caltranspermit).
ThisactiondirectstheStateandRegionalWaterBoardstoimplementtheCaltranspermitasameansofaddressingtemperatureconcernsassociatedwithmaintenanceandoperationofthestatehighwaysystem.TheCaltranspermitwasadoptedbytheStateWaterBoardafterclosecoordinationwiththeRegionalWaterBoardsandwasdevelopedtoaddressTMDLsandgeneralBasinPlanrequirements.ResponsibleParty:CaltransActionPlans: Navarro,andEel Action: Conductroadconstruction,maintenanceandassociatedactivitiesin
compliancewiththeCaltranspermit.ThisactionsimplyrequiresCaltranstocomplywiththetermsoftheCaltranspermit.Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions1and2oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.5RoadConstructionandMaintenanceonCountyLandsResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:1)ImplementOrderNo.R1‐2013‐0004,WaiverofWasteDischarge
RequirementsandGeneralWaterQualityCertificationforCountyRoadManagementandActivitiesConductedundertheFiveCountiesSalmonidConservationProgramIntheCountiesofDelNorte,Humboldt,Mendocino,Siskiyou,andTrinityinTheNorthCoastRegion,andanyfuturerevisions(5CWaiverofWDRs).
2)Intheeventthatacountydoesnotshowintenttoimplementthe5CWaiverofWDRs,developWDRsoraconditionalwaiverofWDRsforthatcounty.
ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtoaddresstemperatureconcernsthroughtheimplementationofthe5CWaiverofWDRs.The5CWaiverProgramaddressessedimentandtemperatureimpairmentsbyrequiring:
TheapplicationofBMPsoncountyroadsandatcorporationyardstoavoidexcesssedimentdischarges;
Theprotectionandmaintenanceofriparianconditionsandshade,withintheCountyroadrightofwayandproperty;and
Inventories,prioritizationandremediationofsedimentdeliverysites.ThesemeasuresareconsistentwithexistingsedimentandtemperatureTMDLimplementationrequirementstomeetrelevantloadallocations.
70StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
The5CProgramisalsorecognizedasaproperimplementationtoolundertheSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicy.
Intheeventthatacountydecidestonotparticipateintheprogram,theRegionalWaterBoardisdirectedtodevelopapermittoaddressthatcounty’sroadmaintenanceandassociatedoperations.ResponsibleParty:Humboldt,Mendocino,andTrinityCountiesActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Conductroadconstructionandmaintenanceincompliancewiththe5C
WaiverofWDRs.ThisactiondirectsHumboldt,Mendocino,andTrinityCountiestocomplywiththe5CWaiverasameansofaddressingtemperatureconcernsassociatedwithcountyroadmaintenanceandassociatedactivities.Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions1and2oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.6DairyOperationsResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlan: Eel Action:ImplementtemperatureallocationsthroughtheWaterQualityCompliance
ProgramforDairies&ConcentratedAnimalFeedingOperationsandanyfuturerevisions(DairyProgram).
ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtocontinueaddressingtemperatureimpactsassociatedwithdairyoperationsthroughtheimplementationoftheDairyProgram.TheDairyPrograminvolvesinspectionsofindividualdairyfacilitiestoidentifywaterqualityconcerns,includingconcernsassociatedwithriparianmanagement.RegionalWaterBoardstaffcommunicatewaterqualityconcernsatthetimeoftheinspectionandthroughinspectionreportsthatidentifyimprovementstobeaddressedbytheoperator.RegionalWaterBoardstafffollow‐upwiththeoperatorsregardingtheimplementationoftherecommendations,andoftenworkwiththirdpartiessuchastheWesternUnitedDairymen,NRCS,orresourceconservationdistricts,ortheUCCooperativeExtensiontohelptheoperatorsfindassistancewithimplementingtherecommendations.Examplesofthetypesofrecommendationsthataddresstemperatureconcernsincluderiparianfencing,alternativewatersourcedevelopment,constructionofshadestructures,andplacementofsaltblocksawayfromwatercourses.ResponsibleParty:DairyOperatorsActionPlan: Eel Action:ConductlandmanagementactivitiesincompliancewiththeDairy
Program.
71StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ThisactiondirectsdairyoperatorstocomplywiththeDairyProgramasameansofimplementingthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature,andisconsistentwithaction1oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.7DredgeandFillActivitiesinWatersoftheStateResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Incorporatemeasurestomeetthetemperatureallocationsin401water
qualitycertifications.ThisactiondirectsRegionalWaterBoardstafftocondition401waterqualitycertificationstoaddressanyfactorsthatcontributetoelevatedwatertemperatures.Thisactionisconsistentwithaction4oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.8WasteDischargeRequirementsResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:IncorporatemeasurestomeetthetemperatureallocationsinWaste
DischargeRequirementsandWaiversthereof.ThisactiondirectsRegionalWaterBoardstafftoconditionindividualwastedischargerequirementsandwaiversofwastedischargerequirements,toaddressanyfactorsthatcontributetoelevatedwatertemperatures.Thisactionisconsistentwithaction4oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.6.5.9WaterUseResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoard;StateWaterResourcesControlBoard,DivisionofWaterRightsActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Workwithotheragenciesandnon‐governmentalorganizationstosupport
off‐streamstorageprojectsforwaterdiverterscurrentlydivertingdirectlyfromstreamsduringsummer.Workwithotheragenciesandnon‐governmentalorganizationstostreamlinepermittingprocessforconversionofon‐streamtooff‐streamstorage.
ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtosupporteffortstodevelopoff‐streamwaterstoragefordivertersthatcurrentlydivertsurfacewaterduringthedryseason(e.g.,JunethroughSeptember).Thiseffortisintendedtoleadtoincreasedcoldwaterflowsinstreamduringthetimeofhighestwatertemperatures.TheRegionalWaterBoardcansupportthisactioninthefollowingways:
72StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Prioritizationofgrantfundsfortheconstructionofoff‐streamreservoirs,theremovalofon‐streamimpoundments,andotherinfrastructureneededtofacilitatethetransitionfromdirectdiversiontooff‐streamstorage.
SupportofprojectsingrantprogramsnotadministeredbytheRegionalWaterBoard.ThismayincludelettersofsupportforindividualprojectstoagenciessuchastheNaturalResourceConservationService(NRCS),whoadministerstheEnvironmentQualityIncentivesProgram.
Permitstreamlining.TheRegionalWaterBoardcanaffectpermitstreamliningthroughthedevelopmentofgeneralWDRsforpondconstructionand/orimpoundmentremoval.DevelopmentofgeneralWDRsand401waterqualitycertificationscouldbecompletedinawaythatincludesaCEQAanalysisthatcouldbereliedonformultipleprojects,therebydecreasingthecostsassociatedwithprojects.Thissameapproachhasalreadybeentakentostreamlinethepermittingofsedimentsourcereduction,streambankrestoration,andriparianplantingprojectsimplementedbytheMendocinoResourceConservationDistrictandNRCS.
Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions4,5,6,and7oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.ResponsibleParty:WaterUsersActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:TheRegionalWaterBoardencouragesallwateruserstoimplementwater
conservationpracticesanddevelopoff‐streamstoragefacilitiestominimizewaterdiversionsduringlowflowperiods.
Thisstatementmakescleartoallwateruserstheactionsthatcanbetakenontheirowninitiativetoaddresswaterqualityconcernsassociatedwiththeirwateruse.ResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoard,StateWaterResourcesControlBoard,DivisionofWaterRightsActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Pursueinstreamflowstudies:
Workwithotherstoattainfundingforinstreamflowstudiesto(1)quantifyflowsnecessaryforbeneficialusesupport,(2)quantifyflowimpactstoassistoutreachandeducationefforts,or(3)identifyopportunitiestoincreasesummerlowflows.
CoordinatewiththeDivisionofWaterRightsandCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandWildlife.
Considerallsourcesofwater,includingheadwaters,groundwater,andwatersflowinginsubterraneanstreams.
ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtopursuethedevelopmentofinstreamflowstudiestoprovideinformationforthedevelopmentofregulatoryactions,assistoutreachandeducationefforts,andidentifyopportunitiestoincreaselowflows.
73StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
TheactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtoworkinclosecoordinationwiththeStateWaterResourceControlBoardDivisionofWaterRightsandCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandWildlife.Studiesdevelopedpursuanttothisactionshouldconsideruplandhydrologicprocess,theinteractionofgroundwaterandsurfacewater,andsurfacewaterflowinginsubterraneanstreams.RegionalWaterBoardstaffhaveidentifiedtheNavarrowatershedasthehighestprioritywatershedforflowstudies,giventhelevelofflowreductionsapparentfromhistoricflowrecords.TheRegionalWaterBoardshouldalsoconsiderinstreamflowstudiesintheMattoleandEelRiverwatersheds,asappropriate.FlowstudiesinindividualsubbasinsmaybeparticularlyappropriateintheMattoleandEelRiverwatersheds,wherewateruseisoftenconcentratedinlocalizedareas.Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions6,7,and8oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.ResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoard,StateWaterResourcesControlBoard,DivisionofWaterRightsActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Supportthird‐partyeffortstoaddresstemperaturerelatedconcerns,
including: Educationofwaterusersontheimportanceofwaterconservationefforts;
Educationofwaterusersonwaterconservationpracticesandopportunities;
Assistanceforwaterusersintheimplementationofwaterconservationpractices;,
Restorationofriparianvegetation;and, Othereffortsthataddresswatertemperature‐relatedconcerns.
Thisactiondirectsthesupportofthirdpartyeffortstoaddresstheimpactsofwaterdiversionandlossofriparianvegetationonstreamtemperatures.Amultitudeofnon‐profitorganizationsarecurrentlyactiveintheNorthCoastRegion,workingoneffortstorestorefishpopulations,addresspollution,andimproveoverallwatershedhealth.IntheMattolewatershed,SanctuaryForesthasdevelopedatankandforebearanceprogramthathassuccessfullyreducedsummerwaterdiversionsfromtheupperMattoleRiverintheWhitethornarea.Similarly,theSalmonidRestorationFederationandFriendsoftheEelRiverhavebeenactiveintheSouthForkEelRiverwatersheddevelopinginformationalflyersandraisingawarenessofflowandwaterqualityissuesthroughfeatureshowsonlocalradioprograms.ThesesamegroupswerealsoinstrumentalinconveningacommunityinformationalmeetingonJuly11,2013,whichprovidedaforumforcommunitymemberstoaskagencyrepresentatives,includingtheRegionalWaterBoardstaff,questionsregarding
74StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
compliancewiththewatercodeandprotectionofstreamsandtheorganismsthatinhabitthem.TheMattoleRestorationCouncilandMattoleSalmonGroupalsohavelonghistoriesofassistingtheMattoleRiverwatershedcommunitiesinconservationeffortstorestorestreamsandrecoversalmonruns.TheMattoleRestorationCouncilhasbeenarecipientof319(h)andProposition50grantfundsadministeredbytheRegionalWaterBoard.TheEelRiverRecoveryProjectisanothergroupworkingonissuesrelatedtoflowandtemperature.TheirapproachinvolvesmonitoringtemperaturesandflowthroughouttheEelRiverwatershedatsitespreviouslymonitoredbytheHumboldtResourceConservationDistrictinthe1990s,andpresentingtheinformationtowateruserstoillustratethemagnitudeofflowreductionsthathaveoccurredinthepast15yearsandpersuadeuserstoconservewater.TheRegionalWaterBoardhassupportedthiseffortbyloaningtemperaturedataloggersforthecollectionoftemperaturedata.ArecenteffortledbyCalTrout,calledtheEelRiverForum,providesaforumfordiscussionsamongagenciesandwatershedrestorationpractitionerswiththegoalofsharinginformation,discussingstrategies,andcoordinatingandintegratingconservationandrecoveryeffortsintheEelRiverwatershed.TheEelRiverForumhasbeenwellattendedbyagenciesandwatershedstewardshipandrestorationpractitioners.TheNatureConservancyhasrecentlytakenanactiveroleIntheNavarroRiverwatershed.TheireffortsinvolvestreamgaugingandfundingsupportforastudyofagriculturalwateruseinAndersonValley.Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions5and6oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.ResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoard,StateWaterResourcesControlBoard,DivisionofWaterRightsActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:Takeactionstoaddresstheimpactsofmarijuanacultivation,throughthe
following: Outreachandeducation;, Grantsupportforoutreachandwaterconservationandpollution
controlefforts; Coordinationwithotheragencies;and, Enforcementactions.
ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtoaddresstheimpactsofmarijuanacultivationusingallavailablemeans,bothregulatoryandnon‐regulatory.The
75StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
regulationofwaterqualityimpactsassociatedwithmarijuanacultivationisaddressedintheactiondirectingthedevelopmentandimplementationoftheAgriculturalLandsDischargeProgram(seesection6.5.3).Oneofthemosteffectivemeansofaddressingwaterqualityimpactsassociatedwiththisactivityisthedisbursalofinformationonwaterconservationandpollutionpreventionthroughoutreachandeducationonabroadlevel.Therecentrapidexpansionofthemarijuanacultivationindustryhasresultedinaninfluxofnewlandownersfromoutsidethearea.Manyoftheselandownersarenotawareoftheregulatoryrequirementsinplacetoprotectfishandwaterresources.TheRegionalWaterBoardhasbeenactiveininteragencyenforcementeffortstoaddresstheenvironmentalimpactsassociatedwithmarijuanacultivationactivities.Manyoftheseenforcementsituationsinvolvethecleanupandabatementofdischargesassociatedwithroadbuilding,sitepreparation,reservoirconstruction,fuelandpesticidestorage,anddebrisdisposal.Theseactionsareconsistentwithactions1and2oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.ResponsibleParty:RegionalWaterBoardActionPlans: Mattole,Navarro,andEel Action:ContinuetocoordinatewiththeStateWaterBoard’sDivisionofWater
Rightsbyparticipatinginthewaterrightapplicationandpetitionprocess,providingmonitoringrecommendations,jointinspectionsasappropriate,submittalofdatainsupportof401certificationsrelatedtowaterdiversionsand/orfacilitiesregulatedbytheFERC,participationininstreamflowstudies,participationinproceedingsrelatedtoinstreamflow,andanyotherappropriatemeanstohelpensurethatthetermsofwaterrightpermitsandlicensesareconsistentwiththeintrastatewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature.
ThisactiondirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtocontinuecoordinationeffortswiththeStateWaterBoard’sDivisionofWaterRightstoaddresswatertemperatureconcerns.TheDivisionofWaterRightsprovidestheRegionalWaterBoardnotificationofopportunitiestocommentonwaterrightpermittingactionsthatoccurintheNorthCoastRegion,aswellasotheropportunitiesforinput.Thiscoordinationhasresultedinenhancedstreamprotectionfromsedimentationandtemperatureimpactsandprotectionofwetlands.Thisactionisconsistentwithaction7oftheconcurrentlyproposedPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature.ResponsibleParty:StateWaterResourcesControlBoardDivisionofWaterRightsActionPlans: Navarro
76StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Action:AchievetheNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLFlowandTemperatureTargetthroughimplementationofthePolicyforMaintainingInstreamFlowsinNorthernCaliforniaStreams.
TheNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLFlowandTemperatureTargetstates:“ThequantityofflowdivertedfromtheNavarrointhesummerisnotincreased,unlessitcanbeshownthatsuchanincreasedoesnotadverselyaffectbeneficialuses.”5ThetargetisbasedontheGuidelinesforMaintainingInstreamFlowstoProtectFisheriesResourcesDownstreamofWaterDiversionsinMid‐CaliforniaCoastalStreams,developedbytheNationalMarineFisheriesServiceandCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandGame(2000).TheguidelinessuggestnewdiversionsbelimitedtotheDecember15toMarch31timeperiod.TheseguidelineswereeventuallyincorporatedintothePolicyforMaintainingInstreamFlowsinNorthernCaliforniaCoastalStreams(flowpolicy),whichiscurrentlyvacatedduetolegalchallenges,butduetobeconsideredforreadoptionbytheStateWaterResourceControlBoardbeforethisPolicy’sadoptionhearing.Implementationoftheflowpolicywillachievethetarget.Intheinterim,oriftheflowpolicyisnotreinstated,RegionalWaterBoardstaffwillcontinuetoparticipateintheDivisionofWaterRights’permittingprocesstoensurethewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureandtargetaremet.
5Section101(g)oftheCleanWaterActexpressesacongressionalpolicynottointerferewithstateauthorityoverallocationofwaterquantities.Consistentwiththispolicy,itwouldbeinappropriateforUSEPAtorequireastatetoadoptorimplementaTMDLthroughwaterrightpermitconditioningtolimittheseasonoramountofdiversion.Butitwouldalsobeinconsistentwiththepolicyofsection101(g)tolimittheauthorityofastatetoincludemeasuresinvolvingallocationofwaterquantitiesorwaterrightadministrationinaTMDLifthestatechoosestoadoptthosemeasures,andtheCaliforniaWaterCodeexpressesapolicythatstatewaterrightadministrationandstatewaterqualitycontrolshouldbeintegrated.Thus,theinclusionofthismeasureintheTMDLisbasedonstatelawandstatepolicy,andshouldnotbeinterpretedasrecognitionofUSEPAauthorityinthisarea.
77StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
7.0 DESCRIPTIONOFSURVEILLANCEACTIVITIES RegionalWaterBoardstaffwilldevelopandimplementaregion‐widetemperaturemonitoringplantoassisttheRegionalWaterBoardindeterminingwhetherthispolicyiseffectivelyreducingandpreventingelevatedtemperaturesoverthelong‐term.Themonitoringplanwillhavethefollowingelements:
Long‐termtrendmonitoringatestablishedsitesmonitoredbytheSurfaceWaterAmbientMonitoringProgram(SWAMP).
Aregionalcooperativemonitoring,coordination,anddatasharingprogramdrawingonthevoluntaryeffortsoflandownersandorganizationscollectingwatertemperaturedata.
Acooperativemonitoringequipmentloananddatasharingprogram. Specialstudiestosupportinvestigationsofdiscretetemperatureissues. ParticipationintheBoardofForestry’sEffectivenessMonitoringCommittee. Guidanceandcriteriaforstafftoconsiderregardingtemperaturemonitoring
requirements.Adescriptionofeachoftheproposedmonitoringplanelementsispresentedbelow.Long‐termtrendmonitoringatSWAMPmonitoringsitesThiselementinvolvestheadditionofcontinuoustemperaturemonitoringinthewarmermonths(MaytoSeptember)atasubsetofsitesroutinelymonitoredaspartoftheSWAMPStatusandTrendMonitoringProgram.TheRegionalSWAMPProgramrotatesthroughwatershedsonaplannedbasisasresourcesallow.TheRegionalBoardbelievesthisapproachallowsforthebestuseofresourcesgivenavailableresources.Theapproachfocusesonafewwatershedsatatime,cyclingbackthroughthemeveryfouryearsasfundingallows.TheRegionalSWAMPProgrambegantheStatusandTrendMonitoringPrograminFiscalYear(FY)2000‐01.Theoriginalmonitoringdesignutilizedatwo‐componentapproachtoaddressregionalmonitoring:1)long‐term“permanent“monitoringsitesfortrendanalysis,and2)rotating“temporary“sitesforbasinsurveys.TheoriginalrotationschedulewascloselycoordinatedwiththeTMDLdevelopmentscheduletoprovideadditionalcurrentinformationonwaterqualityparameterstotheTMDLdevelopmentprocess.ThecurrentSWAMPworkplanforCalendar((CY)2012throughCY2015identifies28oftheoriginallong‐termsitesand38oftherotatingbasinsitesformonitoring,whilealsoadding12newsites.TheRegionalTemperatureMonitoringProgramwillmonitortemperatureatasubsetofthesesitestomonitortemperaturestatusandtrendsatkeylocations.Regionalcooperativemonitoring,coordination,anddatasharingprogramManyorganizationscollectwatertemperaturedataintheNorthCoastRegion.Theseincludetimbercompanies,governmentagencies,resourceconservationdistricts,watershedgroups,andresearchorganizations.Thiseffortwillrelyonthevoluntaryparticipationoftheseorganizations.ThiselementoftheRegionalTemperatureMonitoringPlanwillfocusondatasharing,datacollectionprotocols,
78StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
andcoordinationofeffortstopreventunnecessaryduplication.StaffwilldrawontheexperiencesgainedthroughparticipationintheKlamathBasinMonitoringProgram’seffortstodevelopasimilarcooperativetemperaturedatasharingandanalysisprocessfortheregion.ThiseffortwillbothaidandbenefitfromtheWatershedStewardshipApproachinitiativeidentifiedintheregion’sNonpointSourceFive‐YearPlan.TheWatershedStewardshipApproachaimsinparttopromotecollaboration,andprovidefeedbackonprogressinimprovingwaterqualityinanadaptivemanagementframework.CooperativemonitoringequipmentloananddatasharingprogramOneofthemostcosteffectivewaystheRegionalWaterBoardattainstemperaturedataisthroughcooperativeagreementswithconservationorganizations.TheRegionalWaterBoardloansapproximately150temperaturedataloggerseachyeartoorganizationsseekingtounderstandthetemperaturedynamicsintheirwatersheds.Inreturn,theRegionalWaterBoardreceivesthetemperaturedatacollectedusingtheinstruments.ThiselementoftheRegionalTemperatureMonitoringPlanwillcontinuethiscooperativeprogramandbolsteritseffectivenessthroughthedevelopmentofamorestandardizedapproachtoqualityassuranceanddatasubmittal,aswellasastandardizedapplicationprocessfororganizationsrequestingequipment.SpecialstudiestosupportinvestigationsofdiscretetemperatureissuesTheRegionalWaterBoardoftenengagesineffortstodeterminethetemperaturedynamicsatplayinspecificinstances.TheseincludemonitoringinsupportofTMDLdevelopment,focusedwaterqualityinvestigations,suchasthestudyofalgaedynamicsintheSouthForkEelRiverorgroundwaterdynamicsinScottValley,andotherinvestigationsofdiscretetemperatureissues.Thesestudiestypicallyinvolvethedeploymentofsimplecontinuousdataloggers,butcouldalsoinvolvemoresophisticatedmonitoringtechniquesinvolvingthermalinfrareddatacollection,deploymentoffiberopticcables,oruseofotherspecialdatacollectiontechnologies. ParticipationintheBoardofForestry’sEffectivenessMonitoringCommitteeTheBoardofForestryiscurrentlyintheprocessofestablishinganEffectivenessMonitoringCommittee(EMC)toprovideanactivefeedbacklooptopolicymakers,agencies,managers,andthepublicinsupportofadaptivemanagementprinciples.OneofthespecificpurposesoftheEMCidentifiedinitscharteristheevaluationoftheeffectivenessoftheForestPracticeRuleswatercourseandlakeprotectionzonerequirementsinachievingthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature.Throughthiseffort,staffhopetofurtherthecollectiveunderstandingofsuchtopicsaspost‐harvestcanopyretentionlevelsrelativetotargetedcanopylevels,therelationshipofoverheadcanopytoeffectiveshade,andchangesintemperaturerelativetochangesineffectiveshade.
79StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
GuidanceandcriteriaforstafftoconsiderregardingtemperaturemonitoringrequirementsThiselementoftheRegionalTemperatureMonitoringProgramwillbeprimarilyintendedasguidancetostaffdevelopingpermitsandcontemplatingtemperaturemonitoringrequirements.MostRegionalWaterBoardpermitsdonotcontaintemperaturemonitoringrequirements.However,somepermits,particularlythoseassociatedwithpointsources,containmonitoringandreportingprogramswhichrequirethemonitoringoftemperature.Thiselementwilldiscussthecircumstancesinwhichtemperaturemonitoringisappropriate,therequiredfrequencyofmeasurementtoachievethemonitoringgoals,theproximityofmonitoringtodischarges,andotherconsiderationsimportantforasuccessfultemperaturemonitoringandreportingprogram.
80StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
8.0 ENVIRONMENTALSETTINGTheenvironmentalsettingofaproposedprojectestablishesthebaselineconditionagainstwhichpotentialenvironmentalimpactsoftheproposedprojectarecompared.Theproposedprojectisawaterqualityprotectionprogram,designedtoaddressexistingorpotentialimpactstowaterqualitywithintheRegionwiththegoalofimprovingwaterqualityfortheprotectionofhumanhealth,recreation,aquaticlife,andecosystemfunction.Asaprogrammaticanalysis,thissectionprovidesageneraldescriptionoftheRegion,highlightingthekeyfactorsidentifiedintheCEQAanalysisincluding:aesthetics,agriculturalresources,airquality,biologicalresources,culturalresources,geologyandsoils,greenhousegasemissions,hazardsandhazardousmaterials,hydrologyandwaterquality,landuseandplanning,mineralresources,noise,populationandhousing,publicservices,recreation,transportation/traffic,andutilitiesandservicesystems.TheNorthCoastRegioncomprisesallbasinsincludingLowerKlamathLakeandLostRiverBasinsdraininggenerallywestwardintothePacificOceanfromtheCalifornia‐OregonstatelinesoutherlytothesoutherlyboundaryofthewatershedoftheEsterodeSanAntonioandStempleCreekinMarinandSonomaCounties6.TheRegionisdividedintotwonaturaldrainagebasins:1)theKlamathRiversub‐basinwhichdrainstheCascadeRangeGeomorphicProvince,theModocPlateauGeomorphicProvinceandtheKlamathMountainGeomorphicProvinceand2)theNorthCoastalsub‐basinwhichdrainstheCoastRangeGeomorphicProvince.TheNorthCoastRegioncoversallofDelNorte,Humboldt,Trinity,andMendocinoCounties,majorportionsofSiskiyouandSonomaCounties,andsmallportionsofShasta,Glenn,Lake,andMarinCounties.TheNorthCoastRegioncomprisesatotalareaofapproximately19,390squaremiles(mi2),including340milesofsceniccoastline,362milesofdesignatedWildandScenicRivers,416mi2ofNationalRecreationAreas,and1,627mi2ofNationalWildernessAreas,aswellasurbanizedandagriculturalareas.TheRegionischaracterizedbysteep,mountainousforestedterrainwithdistincttemperatureandprecipitationzones.Themountaincrests,whichformtheeasternboundaryoftheregion,areabout6,000feetelevationwithafewpeakshigherthan8,000feet.Muchoftheregionismountainousandrugged;only13percentofthelandisclassifiedasvalleyormesa,andmorethanhalfofthatisinthehigher‐elevationnortheasternpartoftheregionintheupperKlamathRiverBasin.Thecoastismild,foggyandproducesmoderatevariationsinseasonaltemperatures.CoastalredwoodsandDouglasfir‐tanoakforestsdominatethislandscape.Inlandareasoutsideofthecoastalinfluenceundergomoreextremeseasonaltemperaturevariationwithseasonalmaximumsexceeding100ºF.Oaksandpinesinterspersedwithgrasslandsandchaparralaremorecommoninland.
6CWC§13200(a)
81StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
In1998,theU.S.GeologicalSurvey(USGS)publishedareportentitled“TheStatusandTrendsoftheNation’sBiologicalResources.”WhatfollowsareexcerptsfromthisreportfornorthwesternCalifornia7.
“NorthwesternCaliforniahasthewettest,mostconsistentclimateinthestate.Itiscomposedmainlyofthecoastlineandseveralmetamorphicmountainranges,includingtheKlamathMountainsandthenorthCoastRanges.Thecoastalregion,fromtheOregonbordersouthtoBodegaBay,isdominatedbyareasofcoastalprairie,somecoastalmarsh,closed‐conepineandcypressforestsonpoorsoils,andgrandfir–Sitkaspruceforestsonbettersoils(Hickman1993).Manyofthecypressgrovesareassociatedwithchaparral,rockoutcrops,orserpentinesoils.Theclosed‐conepinesaregenerallysmallinstatureand,likethecypresses,areassociatedwithchaparral,fire,andshallow,acidic,nutrient‐poorsoils,oftenserpentineorsandstone.Thesepinesareshort‐lived(50–100years),andtheirseedscanonlygerminateonbaremineralsoils.Likethecypresses,theclosed‐conepinesrequirefireforsuccessfulreproduction.Knobconepineisthemostwidespreadoftheclosed‐conepines,rangingnearlythelengthofthestate.”“TheKlamathMountainsaregeologicallyoldandsupportmixedevergreenforestsofDouglas‐fir,ponderosapine,andsugarpine,withmountainhemlock,whitefir,andchinquapinfoundathigherelevations.SerpentinesoilsarecommonintheKlamathMountains.Onthewestside,Douglas‐fir–hardwoodforestsgrowatlowelevations,givingwayathigherelevationtowhitefir–Douglas‐firforests,whitefir–Californiaredfirforests,andfinallytomountainhemlock–Californiaredfiratthehighestelevations.Eastandsouthofthehighestridges,theclimateisdrierandmorecontinental.Atlowelevations,forestsaredominatedbyponderosapine,whichisreplacedbywhitefir–pineforestsathigherelevations,thenredfir–whitefirforests,andfinallymountainhemlock–redfir,withwhitebarkpineoccurringatthehighestelevations.TheKlamathMountainshaveahighfloristicdiversity,inpartbecausetheyhaveactedasrefugiasupportingmanyendemicsandrelictspecies,includingPacificsilverfir,subalpinefir,Alaska‐cedar,Brewerspruce,Engelmannspruce,andfoxtailpine.ThecomplexvegetationpatternsintheKlamathMountainsseembasedprimarilyondifferencesinsoilsandsecondarilyonelevationandsoilmoisture(SawyerandThornburgh1977).”“ThenorthernCoastRangesoccurimmediatelysouthoftheKlamathMountains.CoastRangeforestsdonotincludehemlockandhave
7http://www.nwrc.usgs.gov/sandt/SNT.pdfaccessedAugust16,2013.
82StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
nobleorredfirreplacinggrandfir,withrhododendronreplacingchinquapinintheunderstory.Hardwoodsincreaseinfrequencyonthedrierslopesinland.TheouternorthernCoastRanges,thosefarthesttothewest,receiveagreatdealofrain(Hickman1993).Riparianareasandnorth‐facingslopesoftheCoastRangefogbeltsupportredwoodforests…,whichthrivewherecoastalfogisfrequent.RedwoodisaCaliforniaendemicandisthetallest(112meters)andfastest‐growingtreeintheworld(Zinke1977);oneofthesetreesmaylivemorethan2,000years(Bakker1972).AlthoughredwoodswerecommonintheTertiaryovermuchofNorthAmerica,theyarenowrestrictedtothefogbeltofmaritimecentralandnorthernCalifornia.Proximitytotheseamoderatestemperatures,andfoghelpspreventevapotranspiration(moisturelossfromleaves).Fogdripcontributesconsiderablemoisturetothesoilduringtheotherwisedrysummerseason(18–30centimetersperyear;Zinke1977).Thecontinuousmoistureenablesredwoodforeststobehometoanumberofamphibians,includingensatinas,ocelot‐spottedgiantsalamanders,tailedfrogs,andseepsalamanders,aswellasthemorecommonbananaslugs(Bakker1972).”“Douglas‐firisoftenacodominantinredwoodforests,becomingestablishedafterfires,andtanoak,Californiabay,madrone,andwesternhemlockarecommonunderstorytreeswhereenoughlightpenetratesthecanopy(Zinke1977).Redwoodisavaluabletimbertreebecauseofitssizeandbecauseofthewood’suniqueresistancetorot.Morethan85%oftheoldgrowthcoastredwoodforestshasbeenlogged,butmuchoftheoriginaldistributionofabout810,000hectaresremainsinsecond‐growthredwoodforestsofvaryingages.Second‐growthredwoodforestssupportmostofthesamenativevascularplantsasold‐growthforests,buthabitatforspeciesthatdependonold‐growthforests—suchasspottedowls,marbledmurrelets,somearthropods,mollusks,andcanopylichens—hasbeengreatlyreduced(U.S.FishandWildlifeService1995a).Loggingofredwoodcontinues,althoughmostold‐growthstandsarenowprotectedinstateparksandinRedwoodNationalPark.”“DrierslopesoftheCoastRangessupportmixed‐evergreenandmixed‐hardwoodforests,whereasmontaneforestsofsubalpinefirandpinesarefoundathigherelevations.VegetationonthehighestpeaksissimilartothatfoundathighelevationsintheSierraNevada;peaksabove1,500metersaretreelessandexperienceheavywintersnows.SummersarehotandrainfallislowintheinnernorthernCoastRanges,especiallyoneasternslopesintherainshadowofthepeaks.Serpentinesoilsarecommon,anddryeasternslopessupportchaparralandpine–oakwoodland.(Hickman1993).”
83StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
8.1AestheticsTheNorthCoastRegionisapredominantlyruralregionwithnumerousoutstandingnaturalfeaturesandscenicvistas,includingdramaticcoastline,rollinghills,mountains,forests,rivers,wetlands,andestuaries.HundredsofmilesofhighwaycrossthroughtheNorthCoastRegion.But,onlyatotalof52mileshavebeendesignatedofficiallyasStateScenicHighway.Thisincludes12milesofHighway101asitpassesthroughRedwoodStateParkinDelNorteCounty;12milesofHighway12eastofSantaRosainSonomaCounty,and28milesofHighway116westofSantaRosainSonomaCounty.MuchoftherestofthehighwaysystemintheregioniseligibleasStateScenicHighwaybuthasnotbeendesignated.ThesearelistedinTable8.1.
Table8.1.HighwayseligiblebutnotdesignatedasStateScenicHighways8County HighwaysDelNorte 101northofCrescentCity,169,197,and199Glenn NoneLake 20,29,and281Mendocino 1,20and101Modoc 139and299Siskiyou 96Sonoma 1andportionsof12Trinity 2and299
Asageneralmatter,lightpollutionresultingfromoutdoorlightingisrestrictedtotheurbanareasaroundHumboldtBayfromMcKinleyvilletoFortuna,FortBragg,Willits,Ukiah,andthegreaterSantaRosaareafromWindsortoCotati.Lightpollutionmaybelocallypresentwherevertherearemultipleoutdoorlights.8.2AgricultureThepredominantlandusesintheNorthCoastRegionareintheagriculturalsector,includingfarming,ranchingandtimberproduction.TheCaliforniaStateDepartmentofConservation(Conservation)producesmapsofcountieswithPrimeFarmland,UniqueFarmland,andFarmlandofStatewideImportance(agriculturallandsofspecialsignificance).Thesearefarmlandswhichbasedontheirsoilcharacteristicsareespeciallywellsuitedforagriculturalproduction.ConservationhasproducedmapsforModoc,Siskiyou,Mendocino,andSonomacounties.Thesemapsindicateagriculturallandsofspecialsignificancepredominantlyconcentratedin:1)theTuleLakeregioninModocCounty;2)theScottValley,ShastaValley,andupperKlamathRiverValleyinSiskiyouCounty;3)RoundValley,PotterValley,EdenValley,AndersonValleyandtheupperRussian
8http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/LandArch/scenic_highways/,accessed8/16/13.
84StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
RiverValleyinMendocinoCounty;and4)AlexanderValley,DryCreekValley,andtheLagunadeSantaRosainSonomaCounty.Conservationalsodefinesareasofgrazingland,basedoncertainenvironmentalcharacteristics.MendocinoCountyisidentifiedaspredominantlygrazingland.SonomaCountyisapatchworkoffarmlandandgrazingland.ModocandSiskiyoucountiesarepredominantlyNationalForest,interspersedwithfarmlandandgrazingland.TheU.S.ForestService(USFS)manageslandsencompassingapproximately56%oftheNorthCoastRegion(6,889,419acres)spreadbetweentwoUSFSRegionsandsixnationalforests:
1. USFSRegion5(PacificSouthwestRegion),managesalloforaportionofthefollowingNationalForests:ModocNationalForest,KlamathNationalForest,Shasta/TrinityNationalForest,SixRiversNationalForest,andMendocinoNationalForest.TheseForestscompriseabout6,793,819acresoftheNorthCoastRegion.
2. USFSRegion6(PacificNorthwestRegion)managesaportionoftheRogueRiver‐SiskiyouNationalForest,accountingforapproximately95,600acresoftheNorthCoastRegion.
Privatetimberlandaccountsforasubstantialamountoftheregion’slandarea,includinglandsmanagedforindustrialandnon‐industrialtimberproduction.TheCaliforniaBoardofEqualizationreportsatotalharvestfromcountiesoftheNorthCoastRegionof575,900MBFor575,900,000boardfeetin2012.Thisismorethan40%ofthetimberharvestedinthestate.TheNorthCoastRegioncontainsabout57%ofCalifornia’sprivatelandszonedasTimberProductionZone(Shih2002).8.3AirQualityAccordingtotheCaliforniaAirResourcesBoard(AirBoard),theNorthCoastRegioncontains3separate,designatedairbasins.Theseinclude:
1. NorthCoastAirBasinencompassingDelNorte,Humboldt,Mendocino,Trinity,andsubstantialportionsofSonomacounties;
2. NortheastPlateauBasinencompassingModoc,Lassen,andSiskiyoucounties;and
3. LakeCountyAirBasinThesouthernportionofSonomaCountyiscontainedintheBayAreaAirBasin.Thepollutantsofconcerntoairqualityinclude:particulatematter(PM),ozone,nitrogendioxide,sulfates,carbonmonoxide,sulfurdioxide,visibilityreducingparticles,lead,hydrogensulfide,andvinylchloride.Statisticsforozone,particulatematter,carbonmonoxide,nitrogendioxide,andhydrogensulfidearereadily
85StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
availableforthe3airbasinswithintheNorthCoastRegion,andSonomaCounty,asshowninTable8.2.Ozone,animportantingredientofsmog,isahighlyreactiveandunstablegascapableofdamagingtheliningsoftherespiratorytract.Thispollutantformsintheatmospherethroughcomplexreactionsbetweenchemicalsdirectlyemittedfromvehicles,industrialplants,andmanyothersources.Keypollutantsinvolvedinozoneformationarehydrocarbonandnitrogenoxidegases.Particulatematter(PM)isacomplexmixtureoftinyparticlesthatconsistsofdrysolidfragments,solidcoreswithliquidcoatings,andsmalldropletsofliquid.Theseparticlesvarygreatlyinshape,sizeandchemicalcomposition,andcanbemadeupofmanydifferentmaterialssuchasmetals,soot,soil,anddust.Particles10micronsorlessindiameteraredefinedas"respirableparticulatematter"or"PM10."Fineparticlesare2.5micronsorlessindiameter(PM2.5)andcancontributesignificantlytoregionalhaze,reductionofvisibility,andrespiratoryillness.Carbonmonoxide(CO)isacolorless,odorlessgas.Itresultsfromtheincompletecombustionofcarbon‐containingfuelssuchasgasolineorwood,andisemittedbyawidevarietyofcombustionsources.Sulfurdioxide(SO2)isagaseouscompoundofsulfurandoxygen.SO2isformedwhensulfur‐containingfuelisburnedbymobilesources,suchaslocomotives,ships,andoff‐roaddieselequipment.SO2isalsoemittedfromseveralindustrialprocesses,suchaspetroleumrefiningandmetalprocessing.Hydrogensulfide(H2S)isacolorlessgaswiththeodorofrotteneggs.Itisformedduringbacterialdecompositionofsulfur‐containingorganicsubstances.Also,itcanbepresentinsewergasandsomenaturalgas,andcanbeemittedastheresultofgeothermalenergyexploitation.Table8.2.2012AirQualityStatisticsforthe3AirBasins,andSonomaCounty,containedwithintheNorthCoastRegion9 North
CoastAirBasin
SonomaCounty
NortheastPlateauAirBasin
LakeCountyAirBasin
Ozone,#ofdays>1‐hourCAstandard
1 0 0 2
Ozone,#ofdays>8‐hourCAstandard
0 0 1 3
PM2.5,#ofdays>24‐hourNat’lstandard
0 0 0 0
PM10,#days>24‐hourCAstandard 0 * 0 0CarbonMonoxide,#ofdays>CAstandard
0 * * *
NitrogenDioxide,#ofdays>CAstandard
0 0 * *
9http://www.arb.ca.gov/adam/topfour/topfour1.php,accessedonAugust16,2013.
86StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
HydrogenSulfide,#ofdays>CAstandard
* * * 0
*InsufficientdatatocalculateAsindicatedinTable8.2,theairqualityintheNorthCoastRegionisexceptionallygood.TheCaliforniaAirPollutionControlOfficersAssociationreportsthatnoneofthecountieswithintheNorthCoastRegionhadanydaysin2012inwhichoverallairqualitywas“unhealthy”andallhad”good”overallairqualityforanaverageof349daysoftheyear(CAPCOA2013).Withrespecttoozone,thenumbersofexceedencesindicatedinTable8.2areamongthelowestofanyoftheairbasinsintheState.8.4BiologicalResourcesThemissionoftheRegionalWaterBoardistodevelopandimplementwaterqualitystandardsandprogramsofimplementationdesignedtorestoreandmaintainthebeneficialusesofwaterwithintheregion.IntheNorthCoastRegion,someofthebeneficialusesofwaterthatoftendrivethewaterqualityprotectioneffortsoftheagencyareColdFreshwaterHabitat(COLD);Spawning,Reproduction,andEarlyDevelopment(SPWN);MigrationofAquaticOrganisms(MIGR);andRare,ThreatenedorEndangeredSpecies(RARE).Thewaterqualityprogramsdesignedtoprotectthesebeneficialuses,inturn,aremostoftendrivenbythehabitatrequirementsofsalmonids.Salmonidaeareafamilyofaquaticvertebrateswhichduringthefreshwaterportionoftheirlifecyclerequirecold,clear,well‐oxygenatedfreshwater,freeofexcessivefinesedimentorobstructionstomigration.Assuch,theyareoftenrecognizedasindicatorsofwatershedhealth,wherepopulationsarestable.Historically,theywereabundantinwatershedsoftheNorthCoastRegion.Today,populationsofseveralSalmonidaespeciesarelistedbyfederalandstatewildlifeagenciesasthreatenedorendangeredbyextinction.SpecieslistedinsomeorallwatershedsoftheNorthCoastRegioninclude:Chinooksalmon,cohosalmon,andsteelheadtrout.Theproposedprogramisdesigned,inpart,toprotecttheCOLD,SPWN,MIGR,andRAREbeneficialuses.TheRegionalWaterBoarddesignsitswaterqualityprogramstoprotectotherbeneficialusesassociatedwiththeRegion’sbiologicalresourcesaswell,including:
WarmFreshwaterHabitat(WARM) EstuarineHabitat(EST) WildlifeHabitat(WILD) PreservationofAreasofSpecialBiologicalSignificance(ASBS) WetlandHabitat(WET)
TheNorthCoastRegionincludesnumerousthreatenedandendangeredfaunalandfloralspecies(T&Especies).ThepresenceanddispositionofT&Especiesmustbeevaluatedattheprojectleveltoensuretheiradequatesitespecificprotection.The
87StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
proposedprogramwhichisthesubjectofthisCEQAanalysisisintendedtobeimplementedinamannerwhichrestoresandmaintainsthebeneficialusesoftheNorthCoastRegion,includingthosebeneficialusesidentifiedabove.AselsewhereintheState,thequantityandqualityofwetlandhabitathasbeensubstantiallyreducedfromhistoriclevels.Assuch,therestorationandmaintenanceoftheRegion’swetlandandriparianresourcesisanimportantelementoftheRegionalWaterBoard’seffort.RiparianhabitatisassociatedwithvirtuallyeverywaterbodyintheNorthCoastRegion.SubstantialwetlandhabitatexistsintheupperKlamathRiverbasin,theLagunadeSantaRosa,HumboldtBay,BodegaBay,andassociatedwiththeestuariesofmostoftheriversintheRegion.Similarly,thewaterqualityprotectioneffortsoftheRegionalWaterBoardareintendedtosupportandcomplementtheenvironmentalprotectioneffortsrepresentedinlocalpoliciesandordinances,HabitatConservationPlans,NaturalCommunityConservationPlans,andotherapprovedlocal,regional,orstatehabitatconservationplans.Anyprojectimplementedunderthisproposedprogramshouldbedesignedtoavoid,minimizeormitigateanypotentialimpacttobiologicalresources.8.5CulturalResourcesTheNorthCoastRegionhasarichhumanhistorygoingbackperhaps10,000years.LandsthroughouttheRegion,thereforehavethepotentialtoharborburiedancientculturalresources.Similarly,therearenumeroussitesofhistoricinterestscatteredthroughouttheRegion,representingtheRegion’smining,shipping,logging,andagriculturalhistory,amongothers.Thepresenceanddispositionofculturalresourcesmustbeevaluatedattheprojectleveltoensuretheirsite‐specificprotection.Anyprojectimplementedunderthisproposedprogramshouldbedesignedtoavoid,minimizeormitigateanypotentialimpacttoculturalresources.TheRegionalWaterBoardhasadoptedaNativeAmericanCulture(CUL)beneficialusedesignedtosupporttheculturaland/ortraditionalrightsofindigenouspeoplesuchassubsistencefishingandshellfishgathering,basketweavingandjewelrymaterialcollection,navigationtotraditionalceremoniallocations,andceremonialuses.TheCULbeneficialusehasbeendesignatedintheSmithRiver,KlamathRiver,TrinityRiver,RedwoodCreek,MadRiver,JacobyCreek,FreshwaterCreek,SalmonCreek,VanDuzenRiver,andOilCreekwatersheds,aswellasTrinidadHydrologicUnit,HumboldtBay,andFerndaleHydrologicSubarea..However,CULisanexistingbeneficialuseinotherlocationsthroughouttheRegion,whichwillbedesignatedoncethedataiscollected.TheproposedprogramwhichisthesubjectofthisCEQAanalysisisintendedtobeimplementedinamannerwhichrestoresandmaintainsthebeneficialusesoftheNorthCoastRegion,includingtheCULbeneficialuse.8.6GeologyandSoilsTheCaliforniaGeologicalSurveydividesthestateinto11distinctgeomorphicprovinces.Ageomorphicprovinceisanaturallydefinedgeologicregionthat
88StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
displaysadistinctlandscapeorlandform.TheKlamathRiversub‐basinincludestheModocPlateau,CascadeRange,andKlamathMountainprovinces.TheNorthCoastalsub‐basinincludestheCoastalRangeprovince.ModocPlateauGeomorphicProvinceTheModocPlateauisavolcanictableland(elevation4,000‐6,000feetabovesealevel)consistingofathickaccumulationoflavaflowsandtuffbedsalongwithmanysmallvolcaniccones.Occasionallakes,marshes,andsluggishlyflowingstreamsmeanderacrosstheplateau.Theplateauiscutbymanynorth‐southfaults.TheprovinceisboundindefinitelybytheCascadeRangeonthewestandtheBasinandRangeProvinceontheeastandsouth.CascadeRangeGeomorphicProvinceTheCascadeRange,achainofvolcaniccones,extendsthroughWashingtonandOregonintoCalifornia.ItisdominatedbyMt.Shasta,aglacier‐mantledvolcaniccone,rising14,162feetabovesealevel.KlamathMountainGeomorphicProvinceTheKlamathMountainGeomorphicProvincehasruggedtopographywithprominentpeaksandridgesreaching6,000‐8,000feetabovesealevel.InthewesternKlamath,anirregulardrainagepatternisincisedintoanupliftedplateaucalledtheKlamathpeneplain.Theuplifthasleftsuccessivebencheswithgold‐bearinggravelsonthesidesofthecanyons.TheKlamathRiverfollowsacircuitouscoursefromtheCascadeRangethroughtheKlamathMountains.TheprovinceisconsideredtobeanorthernextensionoftheSierraNevada(CDC2002).TheKlamathMountainGeomorphicProvinceconsistsoffourmountainbelts:theeasternKlamathMountainbelt,centralmetamorphicbelt,westernPaleozoicandTriassicbelt,andwesternJurassicbelt.Low‐anglethrustfaultsoccurbetweenthebeltsandallowtheeasternblockstobepushedwestwardandupward.ThecentralmetamorphicbeltconsistsofPaleozoichornblende,micaschists,andultramaficrocks.ThewesternPaleozoicandTriassicbelt,andthewesternJurassicbeltconsistofslightlymetamorphosedsedimentaryandvolcanicrocks.Thisisanupliftedanddissectedpeneplainonstrongrocks;thereareextensivemonadnockranges.Elevationrangesfrom1,500to8,000ft(456to2,432m).SoilsincludeAlfisols,Entisols,Inceptisols,andUltisols,incombinationwithmesicandfrigidsoiltemperatureregimesandxericandudicsoilmoistureregimes.CoastRangesTheCoastRangesarenorthwest‐trendingmountainranges(2,000to4,000,occasionally6,000feetelevationabovesealevel),andvalleys.Therangesandvalleystrendnorthwest,subparalleltotheSanAndreasFault.StratadipbeneathalluviumoftheGreatValley.TothewestisthePacificOcean.Thecoastlineisuplifted,terracedandwave‐cut.TheCoastRangesarecomposedofthickMesozoicandCenozoicsedimentarystrata.ThenorthernandsouthernrangesareseparatedbyadepressioncontainingSanFranciscoBay.ThenorthernCoastRangesaredominatedbyirregular,knobby,landslide‐topographyoftheFranciscanComplex.
89StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Theeasternborderischaracterizedbystrike‐ridgesandvalleyinUpperMesozoicstrata.Inseveralareas,FranciscanrocksareoverlainbyvolcanicconesandflowsoftheQuienSabe,SonomaandClearLakevolcanicfields.TheCoastRangesaresubparalleltotheactiveSanAndreasFault.TheSanAndreasismorethan6000mileslong,extendingfromPointArenatotheGulfofCalifornia(CDC2002).Thisareahasparallelranges,andfolded,faulted,andmetamorphosedstrata;thereareroundedcrestsofsubequalheight.Elevationrangesfrom1,000to7,500ft(304to2,280m).SoilsincludeAlfisols,Entisols,Inceptisols,MollisolsandUltisolsincombinationwithmesicandthermicsoiltemperatureregimesandxericsoilmoistureregime.TectonicsOfprimesignificancetothegeologyandsoilsoftheNorthCoastRegion,arethecollisionandsubductionoftheJuandeFucatectonicplateundertheNorthAmericanplateandthetransform(strike‐slip)movementbetweenthePacificandNorthAmericanplatesalongtheSanAndreasfault,includingactivityattheTripleJunctionwheretheNorthAmerican,Gorda,andPacificplatesmeet.ThetectonicactivityoftheNorthCoastRegiongenerallyresultsinsteep,unstableslopesandamixtureofconsolidatedandunconsolidated,marineandcontinental‐derivedgeology.AsaresulterosionalpotentialintheNorthCoastRegioncangenerallybedescribedashigh.8.7GreenhouseGasEmissions(GHGs)Gasesthattrapheatintheatmospherearecalledgreenhousegases(GHGs).10Themajorgreenhousegasesofconcernincludethefollowing:
Carbondioxide(CO2)‐‐Carbondioxideenterstheatmospherethroughburningfossilfuels(coal,naturalgasandoil),solidwaste,treesandwoodproducts,andalsoasaresultofcertainchemicalreactions(e.g.,manufactureofcement).Carbondioxideisremovedfromtheatmosphere(or"sequestered")whenitisabsorbedbyplantsaspartofthebiologicalcarboncycle.
Methane(CH4)‐‐Methaneisemittedduringtheproductionandtransportofcoal,naturalgas,andoil.Methaneemissionsalsoresultfromlivestockandotheragriculturalpracticesandbythedecayoforganicwasteinmunicipalsolidwastelandfills.
Nitrousoxide(N2O)‐‐Nitrousoxideisemittedduringagriculturalandindustrialactivities,aswellasduringcombustionoffossilfuelsandsolidwaste.
Fluorinatedgases‐‐Hydrofluorocarbons,perfluorocarbons,andsulfurhexafluoridearesynthetic,powerfulgreenhousegasesthatareemittedfromavarietyofindustrialprocesses.Fluorinatedgasesaresometimesusedassubstitutesforstratosphericozone‐depletingsubstances(e.g.,chlorofluorocarbons,hydrochlorofluorocarbons,andhalons).Thesegasesaretypicallyemittedinsmallerquantities,butbecausetheyarepotentgreenhouse
10http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/gases.htmlaccessedAugust26,2013.
90StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
gases,theyaresometimesreferredtoasHighGlobalWarmingPotentialgases("HighGWPgases").
AstatewideGHGinventoryconductedbytheCaliforniaAirBoardindicatesthatofthetotalGHGemissionsinCaliforniain2004,thecategoriesofGHGsourcesrankasfollowsbypercentcontribution:transportation(38%);electricitygeneration(25%);industrialprocesses,includinglandfillsandwastewatertreatment(20%);commercialandresidentialfueluses(9%);agricultureandforestry(5%);andunspecifiedemissions(3%).TheestimateofagricultureandforestrycontributionstoGHGemissionsincludesconsiderationofthecarbonsequestrationservicesprovidedbytreesandrangeland.11ThenetGHGemissionsinthestateincreasedfrom1990to2004byabout12%.Thesourcecategoriescontributingmostsignificantlytotheincreaseinemissionscamefromelectricitygeneration(19%increaseabove1990contributionsfromthissourcecategory),transportation(21%increase),agricultureandforestry(39%increase)andanincreaseinunspecifiedemissionsources(1161%increase).Theseincreaseswerebalancedbydecreasesinothersourcecategories,includingdecreasedemissionsfromcommercialandresidentialfueluses(13%decrease)andindustrialfueluses(7%decrease).TheGlobalWarmingSolutionsActof2006(AB32)callsforthereductionby2020ofGHGemissionstoCalifornia’s1990levels.Withrespecttotheanalysisofpotentialenvironmentalimpactsassociatedwiththisproposedprogram,thesourcecategoriesofmostinterestinclude:roadtransportation,electricitygeneration,landfills,wastewatertreatment,residentialandcommercialfueluses,andagricultureandforestry.AprojectimplementedunderthisproposedprogramcouldresultinanincreaseinGHGsoverbaselineconditionsifitresultsinanincreasein:fueluseassociatedwithtransportation,electricityuse,landdisposalorcompostingofwaste(includingwoodandagriculturalwaste),wastewaterinfluentvolumesorconcentrations,residentialorcommercialdensity,orfirepotential.AprojectcouldresultinadecreaseinGHGsoverbaselineconditionsifitresultsinanincreaseinwoodybiomassoradecreaseinanyofthecategorieslistedabove.8.8HazardsandHazardousMaterialsACEQAanalysisincludesevaluationoftheprojectimpactswithrespecttotheuseofhazardoussubstances,proximitytohazardouswastefacilities,proximitytoairports,likelihoodofinterferingwithemergencyresponse,andpotentialtoexposepeopletosignificantwildfirerisk.
11 http://www.arb.ca.gov/cc/inventory/archive/tables/ghg_inventory_sector_90‐04_sum_2007‐11‐19.pdfaccessedAugust26,2013.
91StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
HazardousMaterialsAccordingtotheCaliforniaDepartmentofToxicSubstancesControl’s(DTSC)website12therearenocommercialoffsitehazardouswasteremovalfacilitiesintheNorthCoastRegion,exceptforausedoilandantifreezefacilityintheCityofFortuna.Alsoreportedontheirwebsite,thereare12sitesintheNorthCoastRegionwhichareincludedonalistofhazardousmaterialssitescompiledpursuanttoGovernmentCodeSection65962.5.Theyinclude:1inDelNorte,2inHumboldt,1inLake,3inMendocino,1inModoc,2inSonoma,2inSiskiyouand0inTrinitycounties.Further,staffoftheRegionalWaterBoardoverseeshundredsofgroundwatercontaminationsitecleanupsintheNorthCoastRegion,includingleakingundergroundstoragetankandspillsites.ThesesitesarespreadthroughouttheRegionandinformationaboutthemcanbefoundontheStateWaterBoard’swebsite.13AirportsTherearenumerousairportsthroughouttheNorthCoastRegion,including3passengerairports:theJackMcNamaraFieldAirportinDelNorteCounty,theArcata‐EurekaAirportinHumboldtCounty,andtheCharlesSchultzAirportinSonomaCounty.Inaddition,thereare22publicuseairportsfoundinCloverdale,Covelo,Eureka(3),Fortuna,Garberville,Gasquet,Gualala,Hayfork,Healdsburg,Hoopa,Hyampom,KlamathGlen,LittleRiver,Sonoma,TrinityCenter,Tulelake,Ukiah,Weaverville,andWillits.RiskofWildfireTheNorthCoastRegionispredominantlyruralandlargelyvegetatedwithgrassland,woodland,andforest.TheCaliforniaDepartmentofForestryandFireProtection(CalFire)hasidentifiedhundredsofNorthCoastcommunitiesatriskfromwildfiresoneitherfederalornon‐federallands.Further,CalFirehasidentifiedatleast5communitiesasexistinginaVeryHighFireHazardSeverityZone,including:Cloverdale,SantaRosa,Ukiah,Willits,andYreka.Assuch,theexistingrisktoNorthCoastresidentsfromwildfirecanbeconsideredhigh.HazardousSubstancesandEmergencyResponsePlansThebaselineconditionasitrelatestotheuseofhazardoussubstanceandtheavailabilityofalocalemergencyresponseplancanonlybedeterminedattheprojectlevel.Anyprojectimplementedunderthisproposedprogramshouldbedesignedtoavoid,minimizeormitigateanypotentialimpactduetohazardoussubstances.
12http://www.envirostor.dtsc.ca.gov/public/accessedAugust16,2013.13http://geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/accessedAugust16,2013.
92StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
8.9HydrologyandWaterQualityWaterQualityThesurfacewaterqualityissuesofmostconcernintheNorthCoastRegionareexcesssediment,elevatedwatertemperatures,andexcessnutrients.Thesewaterqualityconditionsaretheresultofpointandnon‐pointsourcesofpollutionandothercontrollablefactors(e.g.,landscapealteration,roadbuilding,etc.)andareexacerbatedbyhydrologicmodification,waterwithdrawal,andthelossofcompetentriparianzonesandfloodplainstodevelopment,agriculture,andlogging.Manynorthcoastaquaticecosystemsareimpactedbytheseconstituentsandcontrollablefactors,resultinginalossofstreamsidepropertytoerosion,destructionofwaterintakes,lossofaquatichabitatandrisktothreatenedandendangeredaquaticspecies,increasedwinterfloodpotential,andincreasedriskofsummernuisancealgalblooms(includingmicrocystisandothercyanobacteria).Therearemorelocalizedwaterqualityissues,aswell.Forexample,surfacewatermonitoringindicatesaproblemwithpathogensinBodegaBayHydrologicArea,HareCreekBeachandPuddingCreekBeachontheMendocinoCoast,severalcoastalbeachesintheTrinidadHydrologicUnit,andriverfrontbeachesontheRussianRiveranditstributaries,aswellastheLagunadeSantaRosaanditstributaries.Inaddition,severaloftheregion’swaterbodiesareimpairedbymercury,including:LakePillsbury,theLagunadeSantaRosa,LakeSonoma,TrinityLake,andtheEastForkTrinityRiver.ExoticspeciesarelistedasawaterqualityprobleminBodegaBayanddioxinandPCBsarelistedasimpairingHumboldtBay.In2009,theUSGS,inconjunctionwiththeStateWaterResourcesControlBoard,collecteduntreatedgroundwaterdatafrom58wellsselectedfromtheCaliforniaDepartmentofPublicHealthdatabasewithin34groundwaterbasinslocatedintheNorthCoastRegion.WellswererandomlyselectedfromNapa,Lake,Mendocino,Glenn,Humboldt,andDelNorteCounties.TheresultsofthestudyarepublishedinMethanyetal.(2011).Alldetectedconcentrationsoforganicconstituents,nutrients,majorandminorions,andradioactiveconstituentswerelessthanhealth‐basedbenchmarksforthe30wellssampledintheNorthernCoastRanges.Therewereafewdetectionsofarsenic,boron,andbariuminthe28wellsoftheinteriorbasinswhichexceededMCLsornotificationlevels;but,thesearelikelyrelatedtothearea’sgeology.TheresultsofthisstudyindicatethatcommunitydrinkingwatersystemsdrawingfromprimaryaquifersystemsintheNorthCoastRegiongenerallyprovidesafedrinkingwater,withtheexceptionsnoted.Shallowgroundwater,however,hasbeenpervasivelycontaminatedbyalonghistoryofactivitiesandoperations,primarily:woodtreatmentfacilities,unlinedlandfills,leakingundergroundstoragetanks,anddrycleaningfacilities.Inmanyregions,shallowgroundwaterisneitherusednoruseable.But,becausetheNorthCoastRegionispredominantlyrural,manypeoplerelyonshallow(sometimeshand‐dug)wellsfortheirdrinkingwater.Theremaybecontributionsofnutrientsandpesticidestoshallowgroundwaterresultingfromthecontinuedconversionof
93StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
landtovineyardsinSonomaandMendocinocountiesandotherwidespreadfarmingactivitiesintheUpperKlamathRiverbasinandtheSmithRiverplain,amongotherdisperselocationsoftheregion.AgingwastewatertreatmentpondsandleakingseptictanksplayapartinshallowgroundwatercontaminationintheRegion,aswell.Groundwaterislikelytobecomeanincreasinglyimportantsourceofdomestic,municipal,andagriculturalwatersupply,asaresultofclimatechangeandpredictedimpactstosurfacewaterdischargevolumesandtiming.HydrologyBecauseofthelowinfiltrationcapacityandpermeabilityoftheFranciscanandvolcanicrockscommonintheNorthCoastRegion,groundwateroriginbaseflowsinstreamsaresometimespoorlymaintained.Alongthemountaindrainages,baseflowthatdoesoccurismaintainedbygroundwaterdischargeemergingfromfracturesthroughspringsandseeps.Somestreamsmaybecomposedofdiscontinuouswetreacheswithpoolssustainedoversummerbygroundwaterdischarge.Somehigherelevationstreamsmayrundryfromsummertolatefall.Asaconsequence,flowsbetweentheseephemeralstreamsandtheunderlyingaquifermayperiodicallycease.Inthevalleys,groundwateroccursinthealluvialdeposits.There,baseflowismaintainedbygroundwaterdischargealongreacheswherethewatertableishigherthantheadjacentstream.Inthelargervalleydrainages,suchastheRussianRiver,groundwaterdischargeislargeenoughtosustainperennialflow(R2ResourceConsultants&StetsonEngineers,2007).ThisissimilarlythecaseintheKlamathRiverbasin.Groundwaterpumpingforirrigationcanimpactstreamflows;astudyintheScottRiverwatershedindicatesthatgroundwaterpumpinghasimpactedScottRiverflows.Groundwaterdepletionisapotentialrisk,includingforexampleintheSantaRosaPlainGroundwaterBasin,whereagroundwatermanagementplanisbeingdevelopedundertheleadershipoftheSonomaCountyWaterAgency.ManyruralresidentsthroughouttheRegioninterceptgroundwaterinfracturesorlocalizedalluvium.Inthesesettings,groundwatermaybeimpactedbyperiodicorseasonaldepletion.SurfaceflowsintheNorthCoastRegionareimpactedbynumerouswaterdiversions,bothpermittedandunpermitted,legalandillegal.TheStateWaterBoardhasadoptedtheNorthCoastInstreamFlowPolicytobetterensurethatfuturewaterrightspermitscontaintheprovisionsnecessarytoprotectthestreamflowsnecessarytosupportsalmonidsandsalmonidhabitat.Further,recentcollaborationbetweenthestaffoftheNorthCoastRegionandtheDivisionofWaterRightshasresultedincontemporarywaterrightspermitscontainingprovisionsspecifictotheprotectionofwaterqualityconditionsintheNorthCoastRegion,aswell.Forexample,erosioncontrolplansandriparianprotectionplansaresometimesrequiredinnewwaterrightspermits.
94StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Ontheotherendofthespectrum,theNorthCoastRegioncontainshundredsofmilesofruralprivateandpublicroadswhichsometimesservetoextendthedrainagenetworkoftheRegion’swatershedswithinadequate,poorlydesigned,orfailingroaddrainagefeatures.Theresult,insomewatersheds,hasbeenanincreaseinpeakflowsorpeakflowtiming,accompaniedbyanincreasedriskoferosion,sedimentation,andflooding.Also,withrespecttoflooding,manyofthewatershedsoftheNorthCoastRegionarestillmovingquantitiesofstoredsedimentfirstdepositedduringcatastrophicfloodingeventsof1955and1964.Floodingeventsof1974,1982,1995,and1997alsohavehaddramaticimpactonNorthCoastrivers.TheCaliforniaEmergencyManagementAgencyhasmappedatsunamiinundationriskforallofDelNorteCounty,HumboldtCountyfromitsborderwithDelNortetoFerndale,MendocinoCountyfromBrunelPointtoGualala,andSonomaCountyfromRussianGulchtoBodegaHead.148.10LandUseandPlanningAsabove,itisnottheintentionofthisproposedprogramtointerferewithorsupercedeanylanduseplan,policyorregulationofanotheragency.Anyprojectimplementedunderthisproposedprogramshouldbedesignedinamannerconsistentwithotherapplicablelanduseplans,policies,orregulations.8.11MineralResourcesAselsewhereintheState,theNorthCoastRegionwassubstantiallyimpactedbythethepresenceofpreciousmetals,particularlyintheKlamathGeomorphicProvincewherehundredsofgoldclaimswereexercisedandwheresuctiondredgingisstillofinterest.AbandonedminesintheKlamathBasinarethefocusofcleanup.Further,sand,gravelandotheraggregateisasubstantialcommodityintheNorthCoastRegion,whoseextractionhasthepotentialtoimpactnumerouswatershedsintheRegion.8.12NoiseTheNorthCoastRegionissubstantiallyrural,withalimitednumberoflargercommunities,thelargestbeingSantaRosaanditssurroundingcommunitiesinSonomaCounty.Asageneralmatter,noisepollutionislimitedtolocalizedareas.Anyprojectimplementedunderthisproposedprogramshouldbedesignedtoavoid,minimizeormitigateanypotentialnoiseimpacts.
14http://www.consrv.ca.gov/cgs/geologic_hazards/Tsunami/Inundation_Maps/Pages/Statewide_Maps.aspxaccessedAugust16,2013.
95StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
8.13Population,Housing,andPublicServicesTheNorthCoastRegionincludesallresidentsofDelNorte,Humboldt,Trinity,andMendocinocounties,themajorityofModoc,Siskiyou,andSonomacounties,andasmallpercentageofthepopulationsofGlenn,LakeandMarincounties.ThepopulationoftheentireNorthCoastRegionwasabout670,700inyear201015,whichislessthan2percentofCalifornia’stotalpopulation.Morethanhalfofthisregion’spopulationlivesinthesouthernpart,primarilyinSantaRosaandthesurroundingcommunitiesofCotati,Healdsburg,RohnertPark,SebastopolandWindsoralongtheRussianRiverwatershed.Urbangrowthinthesecities,whosepopulationtotaledanestimated261,485peopleinyear201016,isheavilyinfluencedbytheoverallurbanexpansionoftheadjacentSanFranciscoBayregion.OthersmallercommunitiesinthenorthernportionsofthisregionincludeEureka,27,191;Ukiah,16,075;Arcata,17,231;CrescentCity,7,643;andYreka,7,765.17Whencomparedwiththe2000regionalpopulationof636,000,the670,300in2010representsagrowthrateof5.4percentoverthe10years,whichisalittleoverhalfthestatewidegrowthrateofabout9.7percentoverthesameperiod.Projectionstodayindicatethattheregionalpopulationisexpectedtogrowtoabout809,400byyear2050,whichrepresentsabouta21percentincreasefromyear2010totals.MorethanhalfofthisprojectedgrowthisanticipatedtooccurintheSantaRosaregion,asurbanpopulationsfromtheSanFranciscoBayareacontinuetoexpandnorth.Populationincreasesintheruralcommunitiesinthenorthernportionofthisregionareprojectedtogrowmoreslowly.TheNorthCoastRegionhasexperiencedsteadypopulationgrowthoverthepasttwodecadesandisprojectedtocontinuepositivegrowththroughtheyear205018.Duetotheruralnatureofmuchoftheregionandthefactthatthereisalowerassociatedcostofliving,manycommunitieswithintheregionareseeinganinfluxofretireesfromlarger,moreurbanizedsettings.Thishasplacedpressureonexistingcommunityservices.Additionally,aspopulationdensitiesencroachinthemoreurbansettings,someofthemoreruralcommunitiesarebecomingbedroomcommunities.Thereisalsoariseinmigrantworkerswithintheregion.ModocCountyhasacountyoperatedmigrantcamp.ThetrendforbothModocandSiskiyoucountiesisthatmanyofthemigrantworkersarebecomingpermanentresidents,whileyoungernon‐migrantresidentscontinuetoleavethearea.DespitetheoverallgrowthratesoftheRegion,populationgrowthratesarenotasgreatasthoseoftherestoftheState,reflectingtheruralcharacteroftheRegion.Infact,someofthemoreremotecountiesoftheregion‐ModocandSiskiyou‐areprojectedtoloseoverallpopulationinthecomingdecades.ThemostpopulatedareaoftheRegion, 15http://www.dof.ca.gov/research/demographic/state_census_data_center/census_2010/accessedAugust16,2013.16Ibid.17Ibid.18Ibid.
96StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
SonomaCounty,experiencedahighergrowthratethantheState’saveragein1980and1990,andisestimatedtocontinuethispatternwithpopulationincreasesof14%by2020.8.14RecreationTheRegionalWaterBoardimplementswaterqualityprotectionprogramsdesignedtoresultinwaterqualitysuitableforfullcontactwaterrecreationsuchasswimmingandsurfing(REC‐1),aswellasnon‐contactwaterrecreation(REC‐2).OtherbeneficialusespotentiallyrelevanttorecreationalusesincludeNavigation(NAV),CommercialandSportFishing(COMM),andShellFishHarvesting(SHELL).Asapredominantlyruralregion,theNorthCoastRegionoffersamultitudeofrecreationalopportunitiesinadditiontowater‐relatedactivities,includingcamping,hiking,backpacking,horsebackriding,bikeriding,birdwatching,andmuchmore.8.15Transportation/Traffic,UtilitiesandServiceSystemsTransportationandTrafficTheNorthCoastRegionisservicedbyDistricts1,2,and4oftheCaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation(CalTrans).Highway101isthemajorhighwaycorridorfromnorthtosouthandHighways128,20,162,36,299,and199arethemajorhighwaycorridorsfromwesttoeast.Thesehighwaycorridorsare2and4lanehighways,vulnerabletotrafficdelayswhenroadworkisundertaken.CalTransprojectscurrentlyaffectingtransportationandtrafficinclude:theWillitsBypassinDistrict1;on‐goingmaintenanceonHwy299andtheAndersonGradeProjectnearYrekainDistrict2;androadwideningonHwy101throughSonomaCountyinDistrict4.ActivitiesassociatedwiththedevelopmentoftheSMARTtrainfromCloverdaleinSonomaCountytotheLarkspurLandingferryterminalinMarinCountyalsohavethepotentialtocausetrafficcongestionasabaselinecondition.WastewaterTreatmentFacilities,WaterTreatmentFacilities,StormwaterFacilities,LandfillsThepointsourcedischargeofwastetowatersoftheRegionisprohibitedexceptintheMad,theEel,andRussianriversduringthewetweatherseason.Allotherwastewatertreatmentisprovidedbypercolationponds,evaporationponds,orotherlanddisposal,includingsepticsystems.DischargetotheMad,EelandRussianriversisfurtherlimitedto1%ofriverflow.Manyofthewastewatertreatmentsystems,includingsepticsystems,intheNorthCoastRegionareveryoldandrequireupgrade.WaterisabundantinmanypartsoftheNorthCoastRegion.AccordingtoMethanyet.al.(2011),communitywaterdeliverysystemsintheNorthCoastRegionprovidegooddrinkingwatertotheircustomers.ManyresidentsoftheNorthCoastRegion,however,relyonprivatedomesticwells,surfacewaterintakes,orsmallcommunitysystems;exceptinlocalizedareas,wateravailabilityisgenerallygoodandissometimesconsumeduntreated.TheRegionalWaterBoardimplementswaterqualityprotectionprogramsdesignedtoresultinwaterresourceswhichare
97StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
suitableasdrinkingwater,asdefinedbytheMunicipalandDomesticSupply(MUN)beneficialuse.TheRegionalWaterBoardoverseesimplementationofNPDESpermitsforthecontrolofstormwaterfromindustrialfacilities,constructionsites,andmunicipalities.Theseprimarilyrelyonbestmanagementpractices(BMPs)toavoid,reduceandmitigatetheimpactsofstormwaterdischarge.TheCityofSantaRosa,SonomaCounty,andSonomaCountyWaterAgencyimplementanextensivestormwatercontrolprogramundertheirMS4permitissuedbytheRegionalWaterBoard.AllthelandfillsintheNorthCoastRegionhavebeenclosed,excepttheMeachamRoadLandfillinSonomaCounty.TransferstationsareoperatedthroughouttherestoftheregionwithmuchofthewastematerialtransferredoutsidetheRegionfordisposal.
98StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
9.0 CALIFORNIAENVIRONMENTALQUALITYACT(CEQA)ENVIRONMENTALANALYSIS
9.1IntroductionStafffromtheRegionalWaterBoarddevelopedaproposedamendmenttotheWaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegion(BasinPlan)thatwouldincorporatethePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature(hereinafterproposedTemperatureImplementationPolicy)intotheBasinPlan.TheproposedamendmentwouldmodifySection4oftheBasinPlanbyaddingtheTemperatureImplementationPolicy.Additionally,staffproposetheadoptionofactionplanstoimplementtheTotalDailyMaximumLoads(TMDLs)forelevatedwatertemperatureintheUpperMainEel,MiddleMainEel,LowerMainEel,SouthForkEel,NorthForkEel,MiddleForkEel,Mattole,andNavarroRiverwatersheds(hereinafterproposedActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs).ThisstaffreportwhichincludesthediscussionsonthebackgroundandpurposeoftheproposedBasinPlanamendment,theinterpretationandimplementationofthewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperature,NorthCoastTemperatureTMDLanalyses,proposedTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlans,environmentalimpactandeconomicanalysis,ispartoftheoverallSubstituteEnvironmentalDocument(hereinafterSED).Thischapterofthestaffreportidentifiesmitigationforcompliancemeasuresidentifiedforthefactorsinfluencingtemperature.ConsistentwiththeCaliforniaEnvironmentalQualityAct(CEQA),thisdocumentdoesnotengageinspeculationorconjecture,butratherconsiderstheprojectalternatives,thereasonablyforeseeableenvironmentalimpactsofthereasonablyforeseeablemethodsofcompliance,andthemitigationmeasureswhichwouldberequiredtoavoid,minimize,ormitigatetheidentifiedimpacts.TheadoptionoftheproposedBasinPlanamendmentdoesnotresultinanydirectadverseeffectsontheenvironment.Allpotentiallysignificantadverseeffectsarerelatedtoindividualsite‐specificprojectsorpermitsandsite‐specificcompliancemeasures.Theanalysisprovidedusessite‐specificcircumstancesasexampleorillustrationofhowtheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlanscouldbeimplemented,andthusindirectlyeffecttheenvironment.However,thisanalysisdoesnotconstituteanabsoluteoutcomeorcertaintyinthedeterminationsmadeinthisstaffreport.Therefore,thisenvironmentalanalysisissetataprogrammaticlevelandismoregeneralinnaturetocovertherangeofpotentialeffects.ManyoftheprojectsthatmightbeundertakenbyaffectedpersonsasaresultoftheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlanswouldbesubjecttoaproject‐levelCEQAreviewconductedbytheRegionalorStateWaterBoardorbyanotherleadagency,whichwouldentailidentificationandmitigationofanysignificantenvironmentaleffects.Inaddition,otherregulatorymechanismscanbeexpectedtoprovideopportunitiesforminimizingandavoidingsignificantenvironmentaleffects.Theseregulatoryrequirementsandmitigationmeasuresarelikelytoreducemany,butnotall,ofthepotentialindirectimpactstolessthansignificantlevels.In
99StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
somecasesitmaynotbepossibletomitigatetheindirectimpactsoftheTemperatureImplementationPolicytoaless‐than‐significantlevel.Inadditionsomeactionsmaynotrequirediscretionaryapprovalsoranagencywithregulatoryauthoritymaynottakeaction.Finally,someimpactsmaynotbeidentifiedormitigatedbecauseitisimpossibletopredictwhowilltakeactioninresponsetotheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlans,orwhatactiontheywilltake.Forthesereasons,thisprogrammaticanalysismustacknowledgethepotentialforsignificantimpactsthatcannotbemitigatedtoalessthansignificantlevel.9.2CaliforniaEnvironmentalQualityActRequirementsforExempt‐RegulatoryProgramsTheRegionalWaterBoardistheleadagencyforevaluatingtheenvironmentalimpactsofBasinPlanamendmentspursuanttoCEQA.AlthoughsubjecttoCEQA,theRegionalWaterBoardbasinplanningprocessiscertifiedbytheSecretaryforResourcesas“functionallyequivalent”toCEQA,andthereforeexemptfromtherequirementforpreparationofanenvironmentalimpactreportornegativedeclarationandinitialstudy19.TheStateWaterResourcesControlBoard(StateWaterBoard)haspromulgatedguidelinesforexemptregulatoryprogramsthatdescribethedocumentsrequiredfortheadoptionorapprovalofstandards,rules,regulationsorplans20.
Thesedocumentsmustdothefollowing:1. Provideabriefdescriptionoftheproposedactivity. Inthiscase,theproposedactivityistheadoptionofaBasinPlanamendment
including:a)AregionalTemperatureImplementationPolicy;andb)TemperatureActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs.TherationaletosupportthepolicyandactionplansarefullydescribedintheChapters5and6.AbriefdescriptionisprovidedinSection9.2.1.
2. Provideareasonablediscussionofalternativestotheproposedactivity.
DiscussionisprovidedinSection9.3.3. Provideananalysisofmitigationmeasuresneededtominimizeanysignificant
adverseenvironmentalimpactsoftheproposedactivity.DiscussionisprovidedinSection9.4.
Additionally,foractionsbytheRegionalWaterBoardthatadoptaruleorregulationrequiringtheinstallationofpollutioncontrolequipment,establishaperformancestandardorestablishatreatmentrequirement,CEQA21andCEQAGuidelines22
requireanenvironmentalanalysisofthereasonablyforeseeablemethodsbywhich
19 Cal.CodeRegs.,tit.14,§15251(g).20 Cal.CodeRegs.,tit.23,§3777.21 Pub.ResourcesCode,§21159(a).22 Cal.CodeRegs.,tit.14,§15187(c).
100StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
compliancewiththatruleorregulationwillbeachieved.ASEDsatisfiesthisrequirementifitcontainsthefollowingcomponents,someofwhicharerepetitivewiththelistabove:1. Ananalysisoftheenvironmentalimpactsfromthereasonablyforeseeable
methodsofcompliance.Thereasonablyforeseeablemethodsofcompliance(hereinaftercompliancemeasures)arethepotentialactionsthatresponsiblepartiesmayemploytocomplywiththeTMDLloadallocations,numerictargetsandtheimplementationmeasuresintheproposedActionPlans.ThisanalysisispresentedinSection9.4.
2. Ananalysisofthereasonablyforeseeablefeasiblemitigationmeasuresrelatingtotheidentifiedenvironmentalimpacts.ThisanalysisispresentedinSection9.4.
3. Ananalysisofreasonablyforeseeablealternativemeansofcompliancewiththeruleorregulation,whichwouldavoidoreliminateanyidentifiedimpacts.ThisanalysisispresentedinSection9.4.
Theenvironmentalanalysismusttakeintoaccountareasonablerangeof:23
Environmentalfactors(seeEnvironmentalSettingandLandUse,Chapter
8.0); Technicalfactors(seeAnalysisofComplianceMeasures,Associated
EnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasures,Sections9.4and9.5);
Population(seeEnvironmentalSettingandLandUse,Chapter8.0); Geographicareas(seeEnvironmentalSettingandLandUse,Chapter8.0); Specificsites(seeAnalysisofComplianceMeasures,AssociatedImpacts,
andPotentialMitigationMeasures,Section9.4);and Economicfactors(seeEconomicConsiderations,Chapter10).
Whiletheregulationsrequireconsiderationofa“reasonablerange”ofthefactorslistedabove,anexaminationofeverysiteisnotrequired,onlyconsiderationofareasonablyrepresentativesampleofthem.Thestatutespecificallystatesthattheagencyshallnotconducta“projectlevelanalysis24.”Rather,inmostcircumstances,theprojectlevelanalysiswillbeperformedbytheresponsiblepartyortheagencywithjurisdictionovertheactivityconducted.9.2.1DescriptionoftheProposedActivityTheproposedprojectistheadoptionofaTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlans,whichcomprehensivelyaddresscontrollablefactorsthatadverselyaffectstreamtemperatures.Controllablefactorsincludeincreasedexposuretosolarradiationduetolossofstreamshade,physicalstreamchannelalterationinresponsetoelevatedsedimentloads,engineeredstreamchannelalteration,and
23 Cal.CodeRegs.,tit.14,§15187(d);Pub.ResourcesCode,§21159(c).24 PublicResourcesCode,§21159(d).
101StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
alterationofhydrologyresultingfromimpoundments,waterdiversions,andlandscapealteration.TheintentoftheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansistodocumentinoneplacethetoolsandactionsavailableandnecessarytoachievetemperaturewaterqualitystandardssoastoprotectandrestorethebeneficialusesofwaterintheNorthCoastRegion.25ManyofactionsdescribedintheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansarealreadyineffectandbeingimplemented,whileotherswillbedevelopedinthefuture.TheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansprovideacommonapproachtoensuringattainmentofthewaterqualityobjectivefortemperature,andensurethathighqualitywatersarealsoprotected.Implementationactionstomeettemperatureobjectivesaredescribedinthischapterasarangeofcompliancemeasuresinthefollowingcategories:MeasurestoPreserveandMaintainShade;MeasurestoControlSedimentation;MeasurestoAddressTailwaterandSurfaceImpoundments;MeasurestoPreserveExistingColdWaterResources;Restoration;andMeasurestoRestoreandMaintainStreamFlows.Specificcompliancemeasuresaredetailedinsection9.4,alongwithassociatedimpactsandmitigationmeasures.Furtherdiscussionofpotentialenvironmentalimpactsandlevelsofsignificancefromimplementingcompliancemeasuresispresentedinsection9.5.Whilethecompliancemeasuresthemselvesareformsofmitigationtobeappliedinthecontextoftheactivityorfactorinfluencingwatertemperatures,CEQArequiresreviewofenvironmentalimpactsthatresultfrommeasuresintendedtoimprovetheenvironment.Severalcompliancemeasuresevaluateddohavepotentiallysignificantadverseeffectsontheenvironmentsuchasairquality,noiseandtrafficfromtemporaryconstructionactivities.However,thelongtermbenefitsfromimplementationofcompliancemeasures(suchasaquaticecosystemrestoration)couldandwilllikelyoutweighanyshorttermadverseeffects.9.2.2ScopingTheRegionalWaterBoardhassolicitedcommentsfrominterestedpersonsandgovernmentalagenciesregardingthescopeandcontentoftheenvironmentalinformationtobeincludedintheSED.OnFebruary5th,2013,theRegionalWaterBoardcirculatedaNoticetoHoldCEQAScopingMeetingsforaProposedAmendmenttotheWaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegionIncorporatingaPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectiveforTemperatureandTemperatureTMDLActionPlansfortheNavarro,Eel,andMattoleRiverWater.OnFebruary15th,27thand28th,2013,RegionalWaterBoardstaffheldscopingmeetingsinSantaRosa,Bayside,andYrekaCA,respectively.Thepurposeofthemeetingswastoexplaintheproposedprojectandproviderelatedinformationtoresourceagencypersonnelandtheinterestedpublicandto
25 40CFR§131:waterqualitystandardsincludebeneficialuses,thewaterqualityobjectivesto
protectthoseuses,andtheanti‐degradationpolicy(ResolutionNo.68‐18).
102StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
invitethemtosubmitwrittencommentsconcerningtherangeofactions,Policyalternatives,mitigationmeasures,andsignificanteffectsthatshouldbeanalyzedintheSED.StaffprovidedrelevantinformationincludingapresentationontheBasinPlanamendmentprocess,theTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlans,andCEQAprocess.Informationalhandoutsincludedthescopingnoticeandfactsheet,RegionalWaterBoardResolutionNo.R1‐2012‐0013(PolicyStatementfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectiveforTemperatureintheNorthCoastRegion),andchecklistbasedonappendixGoftheCEQAguidelines.ThescopingperiodendedonApril1,2013.41commentsprovidedwerereceivedinwrittenform,while59werereceivedverballyformatthescopingmeetings.Withsomecommentsbeingidenticaltherewasatotalof88publiccommentsreceived.Commentswerereceivedfromfivefederal,stateandlocalagencies,eightnongovernmentalorganizationsandspecial‐interestgroups,andfourindividuals.9.3AnalysisofReasonableAlternativestotheProposedActivityRegionalWaterBoardstaffhasidentifiedfourapproaches(oralternatives)tosucceedinthefulfillmentoftheprojectobjectivestoattainwaterqualitystandardsforambientwatertemperaturesintheNorthCoastRegion.Thepurposeofthisanalysisistodetermineifthereisanalternativethatwouldfeasiblyattainthebasicprojectobjectiveoftheruleorregulation,butwouldlessen,avoid,oreliminateanyidentifiedadverseenvironmentalimpacts.Thefirstalternative,analyzesa“NoAction”alternativewithnochangetotheBasinPlanorprogramimplementation.Thesecondalternativecontemplatesabroadapproachtoriparianprotectionthatrequiresdesignationofriparianbufferzone(e.g.streamsetbackrequirement)andimplementsaregionalwastedischargeprohibition.ThethirdalternativeincludestheadoptionofindividualtemperatureTMDLsforeachimpairedwatershedlistedontheCleanWaterAct303(d)listasdiscreteandindividualactions.Thefourthandfinalalternative,andstaff’srecommendedapproach,istodevelopandadoptacomprehensivepolicyforrestoringandmaintainingambientwatertemperaturethroughouttheregioninimpairedandnon‐impairedwaters,aswellas,threestand‐alonetemperatureTMDLActionPlansfortheEel,MattoleandNavarroRiverwatersheds.Thealternativesarecomparedonthebasisoftheirabilitytoprotectwaterqualityandbeneficialuses(i.e.,theirlikelihoodofsuccess)andwhethertheapproachisfeasible,flexibleandequitable.9.3.1NoAction‐NoChangeinBasinPlanLanguageorinProgramImplementationUnderthe“NoAction”alternative,noamendmenttotheBasinPlanwouldoccurandstaffwouldcontinuetoimplementexistingRegionalandStateWaterBoardprograms,asinthepast.Underthisalternative,theRegionalWaterBoardwouldcontinuetoimplementtemperaturecontrolsinapiecemealfashionasindividualpermitsweredevelopedandadopted.Thisalternativewouldnotincreasethelikelihoodofwaterqualityprotectionbecauseitmaynotaddressallthecontrollable
103StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
factorsthataffectstreamtemperature(i.e.,shade,sedimentandflow)norprioritizetherestorationoftheimpairedbeneficialusesofwater.Further,underthisalternativetheRegionalWaterBoardwouldnothavedocumentedandorganizeditsstrategyforaddressingtemperatureinoneplacethathelpsguidestaff,otheragencies,andthepublic.Additionally,withtheBasinPlanremainingnearlysilentonthecontrollablefactorsthataffectstreamtemperaturesotheragenciesaremorelikelytodevelopprogramsthatdonotconsideroroverlooktheseimportantinfluences.
Pros: Allowsre‐directionofBasinPlanningstafftobegin/continueworkonthe
nextissueonTriennialReviewPriorityList. AllowsTMDLDevelopmentstafftobegin/continueworkonthe
developmentofthenextTMDLonImpairedWatersList.Cons: Temperaturecontinuestobeaddressedinapiecemealfashionas
individualpermitsaredevelopedandadopted. Lackofdocumentedandorganizedstrategyforaddressingtemperatureto
helpguidestaff,otheragenciesandpublictoensureregionalactiontoattainandmaintainthewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturethroughouttheregion.
Thebasinplanremainssilentontheimportanceofshade,sedimentandflowascontrollablefactorsaffectingstreamtemperatures.
9.3.2AdoptaBasinPlanAmendmentthatdefinesprescriptiverulesforspecificlandusesandestablishesprohibitions(broadriparianprotection)attheregionallevelThisapproachwouldbebasedonthedevelopmentofriparianbuffersforstreamsandwastedischargeprohibitionstothoseareasontheregionallevelforalllanduseactivities.Adoptionofgeneralripariansetbacksonallstreamsthroughouttheregionisanoptiontoprotectwaterqualityandachievewaterqualitystandards.Naturaland/orwellvegetatedriparianzonesprovidenumerousfunctionsandvaluesincludingbutnotlimitedtoaesthetics,wildlifehabitat,sedimentretention,pollutantreduction/removal,nutrientcycling,floodpeakattenuation,habitatcomplexityandstreamtemperature.Thisapproachwouldincludetheregionwideapplicationofripariansetbacksalongstreamcoursestoensurethepreservationofriparianvegetationtoprotectbeneficialuses,notwithstandingsitespecificconditionsoractivities.Controlfactorsandcompliancemeasureswouldnotbeassessedattheprojectlevel,butapplieduniversallythroughouttheregion.Wastedischargeprohibitionswithinariparianbufferwouldbetheprimaryregulatorytoolusedtoprotectbeneficialuses.Streamand/orripariansetbackswouldalsobeimplementedandenforcedthroughexistingpermits/ordersadministeredwithinexistingregulatoryprogramssuchastimberharvest,non‐pointsource,401certification,andstormwater.
104StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Theapplicationofriparianbuffersdoesnotdirectlyaddressareasthathavebeendegradedordonotcurrentlymeetsite‐specificpotentialshade.Restorationactionsalonewillbeinsufficienttorestoreambientwatertemperaturesinsomeareas.Forexamplemanagementmeasureswithinregulatedlands,suchasstreamandriparianenhancement/mitigation,sedimentremediation,andstreamflowallocationswillstillbeneededinsomeareassoastorestoredegradedareastofullyattainwaterqualitystandards.Furthermore,thisblanketapproachmaybeoverlyprescriptiveandburdensomeinsomegeographicareaswhileinadequateinothers.Eventhoughthisapproachprotectswaterqualityandprovidesseveralbenefitstowildlife,itonlypartiallypromotessite‐specificpotentialshadeanddoesnotaddresstheothercontrollablefactors(i.e.,flowandsediment)thataffectstreamtemperatures.
Pros: Broadlysupportswaterqualityprotectionandpreservationofexisting
conditions. Wouldsavetimeandresourcesforstaffbyavoidingsitebysitereviewand
assessmenttoareaswithwellvegetatedriparianarea.Cons: Wouldnotproactivelyaddressproactivelydegradedorbarrenriparian
areas. Wouldbeoverlyburdensomeinsomegeographicareaswhileinadequate
inothers. Doesnotaddressallcontrollablefactorssuchasflow,andlacks
documentedandorganizedstrategytohelpguideotheragenciestoensureregionalactiontoattainandmaintainthewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturethroughouttheregion.
Couldmaketheconversionofin‐streamimpoundmentstooff‐channelstoragewithintheriparianzonesdifficult.
9.3.3DeveloptechnicalTMDLs,ActionPlans,andAdoptBasinPlanAmendmentsforeachindividualimpairedwatershedThisalternativewouldentailthestatusquoapproachtotemperatureTMDLdevelopmentforeachimpairedwatershed.Ingeneralthisapproachrequiresdatacollectionandassessmentand303(d)listingforwatersnotyetidentified.ItrequirestechnicalTMDLdevelopment(extensivedatacollection,assessment,andmodelingofloadallocations)andthedevelopmentofanactionplanandBasinPlanamendment.TechnicalTMDLsforelevatedwatertemperatureshavebeendevelopedfortheEel,MattoleandNavarrowatersheds;buttheactionplans/BasinPlanamendmentsarestillrequired.ThefollowingarealistoftemperatureimpairedwatersrequiringbothatechnicalTMDLandactionplan.AlbionRiverHydrologicArea(HA)BigRiverHAGarciaRiverHAGualalaRiverHA(withtheexceptionoftheLittleNorthForkGualalaRiver)
105StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
NoyoRiverHydrologicSub‐Area(HSA)PuddingCreekHSATenMileRiverHSARedwoodCreekHARussianRiverWatershed:LowerRussianRiverHA,MiddleRussianRiverMarkWestCreekHSA,MiddleRussianRiverHA:SantaRosaCreekHSATrinityRiver:SouthForkHAIndividualTMDLdevelopmentforthewatershedslistedabovewouldbeoverlyconsumptiveofstaffresourcesasthetimelineforcompletionofeachtechnicalTMDLandActionsPlanwouldbearangeofthreetofiveyearstocomplete.
Pros: Morepublicoutreach.Cons: DeferstheimplementationofTMDLactionplansformanyyears‐to‐
decades. Createsanunfairregulatoryenvironmentwheresomewatershedscome
underregulationmuchsoonerthanothers. Focusesconsiderablestaffresourcesoveralongperiodoftimetoasingle
waterqualityissue.9.3.4AdoptBasinPlanAmendmenttoincludeaRegionalTemperatureImplementationPolicyandTemperatureActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs(RecommendedAlternative)StaffrecommendsadoptionoftheBasinPlanamendmenttoincludeaRegionalTemperatureImplementationPolicyandTemperatureActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs.ThescientificjustificationforthepolicyandactionplansisdetailedinSection2ofthisstaffreport.Insummary,RegionalWaterBoardstafffindstheproposedpolicytocomprehensivelyaddressallcontrollablefactorsthatadverselyaffectstreamtemperaturesandhighlighttheimportanceofshade,sedimentandstreamflow.AddressingactionstoachieveandmaintainthewaterqualityobjectivefortemperatureintheproposedfashionisthemostefficaciousstrategyforRegionalWaterBoardstaffresourcesandregionalwaterqualityprotectionandrestoration.ExistingprogramsattheRegionalWaterBoardandStateWaterBoardDivisionofWaterRightswillbedirectedtoconsiderallopportunitiestorestoreandmaintainriparianshade,includingbothregulatoryandnon‐regulatorymeans.Whilethisamendmentdoesnotestablishblanketripariansetbacksthroughouttheregion,itdoesestablishriparianprotectionintheBasinPlanandinsodoingstrengthenstheRegionalWaterBoard’sauthoritytoaddressriparianshadewhenissuingpermitsandmakingrecommendationstootherlocal,state,andfederalagencies.Thecase‐by‐casenatureofthepolicyavoidsoverlyburdensomeprescriptionsandpromotesriparianprotectionattheprogramandpermitlevels.Inaddition,theTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionsPlansenablestafftoeffectively
106StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
addressdiscretetemperaturerelatedconcernsthroughouttheentireregioninaconsistentmanner.ThesciencesupportingtheproposedBasinPlanamendmentiswellestablishedandresultsinconsistentfindingsthroughouttheregion.Therefore,theproposedadoptionoftheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionsPlansisthepreferredalternative.Itappliesbroadlytoaddressallimpairedwatersandnon‐impairedwatersandfocusesstaffresourcesonregionalimplementationactionsasopposedtothedevelopmentofindividualTMDLs.Sincefactorsaffectingstreamtemperaturearesosimilarthroughouttheregionthisamendmentisthesuperioralternativeinboththeattainmentandmaintenanceoftemperatureobjectivesandeffectiveuseofstaffresources.ThetechnicalsupportfortheproposedTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlanscanbefound,inpart,inSections2and6ofthisstaffreport.ThetechnicalTMDLsarealsoavailableontheRegionalWaterBoardwebpage:http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/northcoast/water_issues/programs/tmdls/
Pros: IdentifiesshadeasanimportantcontrollablefactorintheBasinPlan. Ensuresregionalactiontoattainandmaintainthewaterqualityobjective
fortemperaturethroughouttheregion. Takesfulladvantageofthecommonalityoffactorsthataffectstream
temperatureinallwatersheds. Promotesefficientworkingrelationshipswithotheragenciestobuild
synergiesinactionsaddressingtheprotectionofbeneficialuses. Clarifiesprioritiesfortemperatureprotectionforconsiderationbyother
agencies.Cons: Relianceonsite‐specificapproachesdoesn’tprovideclearinformationon
compliancemeasuresinaprospectivemanner.
9.4AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPossibleMitigationMeasuresThisanalysisofpotentialenvironmentalimpactswasconductedbyconsideringawiderangeofcompliancemeasuresavailabletocomplywiththeTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlans.SpecificcompliancemeasuresandotherpollutioncontrolsthatlikelywillbeusedtocomplywithrequirementsoftheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlanswilldependonanumberofconditionssuchasthefactorscontributingtoimpairment(e.g.,shade,sediment,and/orflow),sourcecategory(e.g.,landuseactivitysuchasroadandcrossingconstruction,reservoirmanagement,oragriculture)andenvironmentalsetting(e.g.,rainfall,geology,andtopography).Acombinationofstructural(e.g.,engineered)andnon‐structural(e.g.,operationandmaintenance)compliancemeasureswilllikelybeusedbyresponsibleparties.Compliancemeasureslikelytobeincludedaspartofthosefutureprogramsareanalyzedbroadlyinthisdocument.ThecompliancemeasuresthatcouldbeusedtocomplywiththeproposedTemperature
107StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ImplementationPolicyandActionPlans,andthepotentialenvironmentalimpactsassociatedwiththeirimplementationarediscussedbelow.ThecategoriesofresourcesthattheRegionalWaterBoardhasidentifiedaspotentiallybeingimpactedbytheimplementationofcompliancemeasuresinclude:26
Aesthetics; Agriculture Airquality; Biologicalresources; Culturalresources; Geologyandsoils; GreenhouseGases; HazardsandHazardousMaterials; Hydrologyandwaterquality; Landuse/planning; Mineralresources; Noise; Populationandhousing; PublicServices; Recreation; Transportation/traffic;and Utilitiesandservicesystems;
Theenvironmentalanalysisofthecompliancemeasures,potentialimpactsandpossiblemitigationmeasurestoavoidthoseimpactsispresentedbelow.ItisgenerallyorganizedtocorrespondwiththeorganizationoftheproposedimplementationactionspresentedinthedraftTemperatureImplementationPolicywhichcorrespondtotheactionsdetailedintheActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs.Thefollowingexamplesarenotmeanttobeexhaustiveofthesuitablesuiteofcompliancemeasures,butratherprovidearepresentativesamplewiththewidestrangetoaccommodateasmanycompliancescenariosaspossible.9.4.1AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoPreserveandMaintainShadeComplianceMeasurestoRestoreandMaintainSite‐SpecificPotentialEffectiveShade: Increaseriparianandin‐channeltreecanopyretentionforsurfacewatersto
supportbeneficialuses. Limitdevelopmentandharvestactionsinriparianareastoattainsite‐specific
potentialeffectiveshade. Developagrazingmanagementplanforuplandandriparianmanagement.
26 SeeCEQAChecklist(Section9.5.2)
108StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Calculatethetimingandnumberoflivestockthatcanbeaccommodatedwhilemaintainingadequatevegetativecover,streamcorridorintegrity,andwaterresources.
Establishnativeorintroducedforagespecies(grasses,forbs,legumes,shrubs,andtrees)throughpasture,field,orchardandrangelandplanting.
Implementthecontrolledharvestofvegetationwithgrazingorbrowsinganimalstoachieveaspecificobjective.
Excludeanimals,people,orvehiclesfromanareatoprotect,maintain,orimprovethequantityandqualityofriparianvegetation.
Constructanimaltrailstoprovidemovementoflivestockthroughdifficultorecologicallysensitiveterrain.
Stabilizestreamcrossingstoprovidecontrolledaccessacrossastreamforlivestockandfarmmachinery.
Plantvegetationtoincreaseshadeinaccordancewithsite‐specificpotential.
PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts Aesthetics‐Decreasescenicviewsofwaterbodiesthroughtheretentionof
vegetation.Pondscouldcreateanewsourceofglare.Increasedriparianvegetationandthepreservationoflargewoodyvegetationcouldleadtoincreasedfuelloadforwildfireswhichdegradedscenicviews.
Agriculture‐PotentialconflictwithorconversionofprimeagriculturallandorlandsubjecttotheWilliamsonActfromimplementinggrazingrestrictions.
BiologicalResources‐Riskofintroducinginvasivespeciesthoroughpasture,hayandrangelandplantingandmanagement.Riskofconflictbetweensite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeandrequirementsofsensitivefloraorfauna.
Hydrology/waterquality–Reductioninstreamflowsduetotheincreaseinevapotranspirationfromincreasedripariantreeretention.Temporarysedimentdischargesfromconstructionand/orrestorationactivities.
Mineralresources‐Decreasedaccessforgravel,goldorothermineralextractionactivities.
Transportation/traffic–Increasedtreeretentionmayconflictwithtransportationagencies(publicroads)sitedistancerequirementsandareasdesignatedasclearrecoveryzones.
PossibleMeasurestoAvoid,MinimizeorMitigatePotentialImpactsfromComplianceMeasurestoMaintainSite‐SpecificPotentialEffectiveShade Aesthetics–Propersiting,constructingbermsorexcessfreeboardaroundthe
perimeterofapond.Plantingvegetationsuchasnativetrees,grasses,andforbs.Fuelmanagementmeasuressuchasunderstorythinning,selectharvestprescriptionsandfirebreaks.
Agriculture‐Coordinationbetweenprojectproponents,RegionalWaterBoardstaffandotherlocal,stateandfederalagenciestoachievesite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeandattempttoensurethepreservationofagriculturallands.
BiologicalResources‐Usecertifiedweed‐freegrassandseedmixtoprevent
109StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
theintroductionofinvasivespecies.Consultwithfederal,stateandlocalagenciesregardinglocationofsensitive(e.g.,threatenedorendangered)wildliferesources.
Hydrology/waterquality–Plantnativevegetationthathasevolvedwiththenaturalenvironment.Allowfortheremovalorthinningofuplandvegetationthathashighevapotranspirationratesandincreasesfirerisks.ImplementstandardBMPstocontrolerosionandsedimentfromconstructionsites.
PublicServices–Strategicallyplacingfirebreaklinesinripariananduplandareasthatdon’taffecttemperature,topreventfires,reduceerosionandsedimentation,andprotectpublicsafety.
Transportation/traffic–Strategicplanninganddesigntoavoidandminimizetheplacementoffacilitiesthathavesitedistanceconflicts.Case‐by‐caseevaluationsmayrevealthatappropriatesitedistancemaybeattainedthroughminorvegetationtrimmingthatdoesnotaffectwatertemperatures.Otherwise,off‐sitecompensatorymitigationsuchasriparianplantingorrestorationwithinawatershedboundarymaybenecessarytooff‐settheaffects.
9.4.2AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoAddressSedimentation
ComplianceMeasuresforErosionandSedimentControl:Structuralerosionandsedimentcontrolcompliancemeasures: Soilconservationcoverstrawcover,bondedfibermatrix,grassseeding,
temporaryplasticcover,residuetillage,heavyuseareaprotection,stripcropping.
Siltfence,strawwaddle,strawbale,gravelcheckdam,gravelbagberm,stockpilecover.
Sedimentcontrolbasin,pond,embankmentpond. Riparianbuffer/filterstrip,grassedwaterway/bioswale. Activesedimenttreatmentsystem. Culverts,streamcrossings,waterdiversions,bridges. Benchcontouring,contourfarming,terrace,vegetatedwindbreak/hedgerow
planting. Exclusionaryfences. Micro‐irrigationsystems. Linedirrigationchannels. Rockslopeprotection,linedwaterway/outlet,road/trailaccesscontrol,
undergroundoutlet,verticaldrain. Road/traillandingclosures/treatment,foresttrailsandlandings. Slidestabilization,soilstabilizationorfillandcutslopes,removalofunstable
fill. Lowimpactdevelopment(LID)tomaintainthepredevelopmenthydrographto
sustainsiterunoffvolumeandvelocitytoattainsedimentandwaterdischargeequilibriumwithinstreams.
110StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
In‐streambioengineering. In‐streamandriparianplanting. Streambank/shorelineprotection. Roadsurfacematerials,paving,chipsealing,rocking,dustabatement.Establish
nativeorintroducedforagespecies(grasses,forbs,legumes,shrubs,andtrees)throughpasture,field,orchardandrangelandplanting.
Excludeanimals,people,orvehiclesfromanareatoprotect,maintain,orimprovethequantityandqualityofriparianvegetation.
Constructanimaltrailstoprovidemovementoflivestockthroughdifficultorecologicallysensitiveterrain.
Stabilizestreamcrossingstoprovidecontrolledaccessacrossastreamforlivestockandfarmmachinery.
Non‐structuralerosionandsedimentcontrolcompliancemeasures: Dryweatherconstructionorharvestscheduling. Inventoryexcessivesedimentdeliverysites,prioritizesitesbythreattowater
quality,designandplanremediation,trackandreportremediationimplementationsuccess.
Roaddrainagedesign,disconnectroaddrainagefromwatercourses(draintohillslopes),installdrainagestructuresatintervalstopreventerosionoftheinboardditchorgullformationatthehillslopeoutfall,outsloperoads.
Timingandintensityofroaduse. Proximityofroadstowatercourses. Proximityofroadstounstableorlandslideproneareas. Developagrazingmanagementplanforuplandandriparianmanagement. Calculatethenumberoflivestockthatcanbemaintainedwhilemaintaining
adequatevegetativecover,streamcorridorintegrity,andwaterresources.PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts Aesthetics‐Decreasescenicviewsofwaterbodiesthroughtheretentionor
plantingofvegetation. Agriculture‐Potentialconflictwithorconversionofprimeagriculturallandor
landsubjecttotheWilliamsonActfromimplementingriparianbuffers. Airquality–Shorttermconstruction‐relatedemissionscouldincludeexhaust
fromconstructionequipmentandfugitivedustfromlandclearing,earthmoving,movementofvehicles,andwinderosionofexposedsoilduringreservoirconstructionorremoval,streamand/orriparianrestoration.Potentialodorsfromstagnantwaterinsedimentbasinsorponds.
Biological–Shorttermconstruction,streamdewateringordiversions,turbiditydischargesfromconstructionactivesorin‐streamdamremoval,streamand/orriparianrestoration.Severalspeciesoffauna(e.g.,snakes,fish,salamanders,andbirds)havebeenentrappedortangledinerosioncontrolproductssuchastheplasticcasingcoveringstrawwaddles,orfromthemonofilamentfibersfromsiltfencesthatareeitherinplaceonactiveconstructionsitesorfrommaterialsthatwereleftinplaceanddegraded.
111StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Streamrestorationactionstoreduceerosion,removesediment,andimprovehabitatorriparianrestorationactionstoincreaseshademayconflictswiththerequirementsofcertainfloraorfauna.
Cultural‐Shorttermconstructiondisturbancefromearthmoving. Geology/Soils–Constructionactivitiesorpoorlydesignedfacilitiescould
resultsinshorttermandlongtermerosion,andcouldresultsinsoilscompactionreducingsoilmoistureandbiologicalfunctions.
WaterQuality–Excessiveuseofrip‐raporstreamstabilizationstructuresintendedtobeneficiallyaffectflowcouldalterconditionsdownstream.Workwithinandadjacenttowatersincreasestheriskofleakingequipmentorhazardousmaterialspills,shorttermturbidityincreasesand/ordischargesofsettablesolids.Decreasestreamflowsand/oraquiferstoragefromdustabatement.Alterationsofnaturalhydrologyandincreasesinstreamtemperaturesbyconcentratingorredirectingroadrunoff.Increasedriskofsoilorgroundwatercontaminationwithconcentratedminerals,salts,orpersistentpesticides.Increasedriskoferosionandsedimentationfromtheconstructionoftrails,streamcrossings,andripariangrazing.Increaseriskofgroundwatercontaminationofpetroleumhydrocarbonsandmetalsfromtheinfiltrationofstormwaterrunoff.
Mineralresources–Decreasedaccessforgravel,goldandothermineralactivities.
Noise–Exposuretoshorttermconstructionequipment,alternativewatersupplyoperationsandmaintenance.
PublicServices–Restorationorconstructionactivitieswithinparksthathavestreamsorlandslidesadjacenttostreams.Increasedenforcementonsedimentdischargesfromillegalcultivationscouldleadtoanincreaseddemandinlocal,stateandfederallawenforcementresources.Increaseburdenonvectorcontrolfromwetlandcreationandsedimentcontrolbasins.
Transportation–Shorttermtrafficincreasesassociatedwithsedimentreductionproject,constructionprojects,damremoval,streamand/orriparianrestoration.
Utilitiesandservicesystems–Constructionandinstallationofsedimentcatchbasinsorirrigationdelivery/recoverysystemscouldcauseanadverseimpacttotheenvironment.
PotentialMeasurestoAvoid,MinimizeorMitigateImpactsfromErosionandSedimentControlComplianceMeasures Airquality–Dustcontrol,avoiddaysorpoorairquality,monitorlevelsand
ceaseworkpriortoexceedingstandards,retrofitequipment,uselowemissionsvehicleswhenpossible,scheduleworktoreducetheuseofhighemissionvehicles.Properdesigntoeliminatestandingwater,covers,aeration,filters,barriers,and/orodorsuppressingchemicaladditives.
Biological–Consultwithfederal,stateandlocalagenciesregardinglocationofsensitive(e.g.,threatenedorendangered)wildliferesources.SelectappropriateoralternatestructuralBMPssuchasbio‐degradable,synthetic
112StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
freeorearthenmaterialBMPs.Implementnon‐structuralBMPssuchasscheduling,properdesignandtheremovaloftemporaryBMPsforerosionandsedimentcontrolsafterstabilizationandorprojectcompletion.Developingspeciesrelocationplansorinterpretingnaturalsitevegetativeconditionstoincludesensitiveflora.Developcompensatorymitigationprojectsforaquaticecosystemcreation,restorationorenhancement.
Cultural–ConsultwithTribes,historicalsocieties,federal,stateandlocalagenciesregardinglocationofculturalresourcespriortouseofheavyequipmentinareaswithknownorsuspectedculturalresources.ProjectssubjecttothejurisdictionoftheWaterBoardswillberequiredtocomplywithPublicResourceCodesection21159.Thisisexpectedtoensuretheimplementationofnecessarysitespecificactionstoavoid,minimizeandmitigateanyimpactstohistorical,archaeological,andpaleontologicalresourcesorsite,oruniquegeologicfeatures.AllfutureactionsmustcomplywiththeCEQAprocessandrequirementsfortribalconsultationprovidedbySenateBill18(SB18)(State2004,Ch905)andGovernmentCodesection65252.
Geology/Soils–Oneofthecoreactionsintheproposedpolicy,aswellasexistingregulation,iserosionandsedimentcontrol.AllfutureactionssubjecttothisproposedBasinPlanamendmentmustfocusontheavoidance,minimizationandmitigationofimpactsrelatedtounstableorsensitivegeologicareas,soilerosionorthelossoftopsoil.Typically,anarrayofstructuralandnon‐structuralBMPswillbeusedinanyfutureprojectasthemeanstocomplywiththisproposedBasinPlanamendmentandexistingregulationssuchastheSedimentImplementationPolicy,WDRsandWaivers,NPDESpermits,and401Certifications.
WaterQuality–Plantnativevegetationthathasevolvedwiththenaturalenvironment.Allowforthethinningofuplandvegetationthathashighevapotranspirationratesandincreasesfirerisks.Usesediment,erosion,spillprevention,andwastemanagementBMPsduringconstructionandvegetationthinningactivities.Forexamplescheduling,straw,seed,siltfence,strawwaddle,strawbales,dripprotection,vehiclecleaningandmaintenance,andsiteinspections.Installandmaintainerosioncontrolmeasures(e.g.waterbars,rollingdips,mulch,rockrip‐rap)topreventdischargeofexcesssedimentfromsoildisturbingactivities.Relocateroadsawayfromunstableandlandslideproneterrain.Drainroadsawayfromunstableareasduringconstruction,reconstructionofmaintenanceactivities.Locatenewroadsonstablegroundtothemaximumextentpracticable.Minimizecutbankheightandavoidplacementoffillonsteepslopes.Useoff‐channelwatercollectionfeaturesfordustabatementpurposes.Installadequatenumber/typeofroaddrainagefeaturestopreventconcentrationofroadrunoff.Seekprofessional(e.g.NaturalResourcesConservationService,localresourceconservationdistrict)indevelopinglandmanagementplansandobservationaltechniquestoensureoptimalstockingratesforrangelands.Protectdrainagechannelsfromsedimentcontributionswithvegetatedbuffers,wattlesorsimilarerosion
113StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
controldevices.Plantacovercroponexposedsoiltoreducethelengthoftimeinwhichsoilisexposedtowindandwater.Coverexposedsoilthatwillnotreceiveimmediateplantingwithstraworothersuitableerosioncontrolmaterial.Ensureproperdesign,siting,andoperationaltimingtoreducealterationsofnaturalhydrologyandadverseeffectsonstreamandgroundwaterqualityandqualityfromstructuralBMPs.
Transportation–Throughtheexistingprojectplanning,CEQAprocess,interagencycoordinationandexistingregulation(NPDESstormwaterpermitsand401Certifications)potentialconflictsareresolvedbyavoidance,minimization,oroff‐sitecompensatorymitigation.
9.4.3AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoAddressTailwaterandSurfaceImpoundmentsFloodirrigationisacommonirrigationpracticeinpartsoftheNorthCoastRegion.Whenirrigationwaterisappliedtoafieldinthismanner,itgenerallyflowsacrossthefieldasathinsheetorinshallowrivulets,andispronetoheatingduringdaylighthoursandcoolingatnightinresponsetoairtemperature.PropertailwatermanagementisafactorinachievingcompliancewiththewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureandtemperatureTMDLs.AnumberoftailwatermanagementpracticesarepresentedintheNon‐PointSource(NPS)ProgramandtheCDFWCohoRecoveryStrategy.Practicesincludethereuseoftailwater,constructingoff‐streamretentionpondsforevaporatingandpercolatingtailwaterthroughtheground,andacommunitybasedapproachtomanagingtailwateramonggroupsofwaterusers.SeverallargedamsexistthroughouttheNorthCoastRegion;additionally,thereareseveralsmallerimpoundments–oftentermed“flashboard”dams–thatareusedtoraisethewaterlevelsinstreamstoprovidefordiversion(eitherdirectorpumping)primarilyforagriculturaluse.Largeandsmallscaleimpoundmentscanalterthethermalregimeofariversystem.Differencesinheatloadingduetoimpoundmentscanoccurbecauseofanincreaseinwatersurfacearea,providingalargersurfaceareaoverwhichenergytransfercanoccur.Largerair‐waterinterfaceprovidesadditionalareaforsolarradiationtoenterthesystem;however,thelargersurfaceareaalsoallowsincreasedfetch(allowingmorewindmixing)andpotentiallyimprovedcoolingduetoevaporation.Probablyamoreimportantcharacteristicoftheimpoundmentistheincreasedthermalmass,whichleadstomoderationofthediurnaltemperaturesignal.Finally,impoundmentsgenerallyincreaseriverwidthandlimittheabilityofriparianshadingtoreduceincomingsolarradiation.Similarly,theeffectoftopographicshadingduetostreambanksorbluffsisreducedwhentheriverwidthisincreasedduetoanimpoundment.Therefore,addressingsurfacewaterimpoundmentsisamajorfactorinachievingcompliancewiththewaterqualityobjectivesfortemperatureandtemperatureTMDLs.ComplianceMeasuresforTailwaterandSurfaceWaterImpoundments:Structuralcompliancemeasures:
114StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Pond,embankmentpond. Riparianbuffer/filterstrip,grassedwaterway/bioswale. Liningofanirrigationchannel. Installationofapipelineinlieuofanuncoveredchannel. Installsurfacedrainagefieldditchtocollectexcesswater. Minimizedischargefromedgeoffields. Constructtailwatermanagementsystem.
o Constructionofareservoirandpumpingfacilities. Landlevelingtopreventdischargefromfieldedgestosurfacewaters. Constructoff‐streamretentionpondsforevaporatingandpercolating
tailwater. Controlstructuresforirrigation. Micro‐irrigationsystems. Damremoval. Bypassflowstructures.
Non‐structuralBMPs/compliancemeasures: Irrigationmanagementplanstooperatetheirrigationsystemsothatthe
timingandamountofirrigationwaterappliedmatchescropneeds.PotentialEnvironmentalImpactsAssociatedwithComplianceMeasuresforTailwaterandSurfaceWaterImpoundments Aesthetics–Potentialglarefrompondsorunsightlywaterfacilities. Airquality–Shorttermconstruction‐relatedemissionscouldincludeexhaust
fromconstructionequipmentandfugitivedustfromlandclearing,earthmoving,movementofvehicles,andwinderosionofexposedsoilduringpondorembankmentconstruction.
Biological–Shorttermconstruction,streamdewateringordiversions,turbiditydischargesfromconstructionactivesorin‐streamdamremoval.Lossofwetlandshabitatfromrepairofleakyconveyancesystemsoralterationofirrigationpractices.Switchingfromon‐streamstoragefacilitiestosprings,seepsorgroundwateraspotentialwatersourcescouldreducetheinputofcoldwaterandcouldresultsinimpactstoareasofthermalrefugia.Lossofcriticalhabitatfromsedimentdischarges.Lossofwarmwaterhabitfornon‐nativespecies.
Cultural‐Shorttermconstructiondisturbancefromearthmovingorreservoirdrawdowns.Constructionorremovalofrecreational,watersupplyorhydroelectricfacilitiescouldresultinlongtermadverseculturalorhistoricalimpacts.
Geology/Soils–Poorlydesignedoroperatedirrigationfacilitiescouldresultsinshorttermandlongtermerosion.Waterfacilityconstructioncouldresultsinsoilscompactionreducingsoilmoistureandbiologicalfunctions.
WaterQuality–Increasedriskofsoilorgroundwatercontaminationwithconcentratedminerals,salts,nutrientsorpersistentpesticidesfromtheinfiltrationofirrigationwater.Increasedriskofsoilerosionfromsoil
115StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
disturbance.Workwithinandadjacenttowatersincreasestheriskofleakingequipmentorhazardousmaterialspills,shorttermturbidityincreasesand/ordischargesofsettablesolids.Theremovalofdamscouldresultinashorttermviolationofwaterqualitystandardsassedimentsandorganicrichwatersflowdownstream.Theremovalofon‐streamandoff‐streamstoragefacilities,dams,andconstructionofminimumbypassflowandfishpassagestructurescouldresultinchangestohydrologyinstreamsaswellasshorttermviolationofwaterqualitystandards.Switchingfromon‐streamstoragefacilitiestosprings,seepsorgroundwateraspotentialwatersourcescouldreducetheinputofcoldwaterandcouldresultsinimpactstoareasofthermalrefugia.
Noise–Exposuretoshorttermconstructionequipment,alternativewatersupplyoperationsandmaintenance.
Transportation–Shorttermtrafficincreasesassociatedconstructionprojectsanddamremovals.
Utilitiesandservicesystems–Damremovalcouldleadtoshortterminterruptionsinutilitiessuchasgas,water,electricity,phone,etc.Damremovalcouldleadtoatemporarydecreaseinavailablewatersupply.
Themonitoringconductedwillfocusontheprotocolsthatwillaidinthecompilationandassessmentofdatacollectedtoverifyeffectiveness.PotentialMeasurestoAvoid,MinimizeorMitigateImpactsfromTailwaterandSurfaceWaterImpoundmentComplianceMeasures Aesthetics‐Propersitingforfacilities,constructingbermsorexcessfreeboard
aroundtheperimeterofapond,orplantingvegetationalongtheperimeterofapond.
Airquality–Dustcontrol,avoiddaysorpoorairquality,monitorlevelsandceaseworkpriortoexceedingstandards,retrofitequipment,uselowemissionsvehicleswhenpossible,scheduleworktoreducetheuseofhighemissionvehicles.
Biological–Consultwithfederal,stateandlocalagenciesregardingsensitive(e.g.,threatenedorendangered)wildliferesources.Implementnon‐structuralBMPssuchasscheduling,properdesignandtheremovaloftemporaryBMPsforerosionandsedimentcontrolsafterstabilizationandorprojectcompletion.Developingspeciesrelocationplansorinterpretingnaturalsitevegetativeconditionstoincludesensitiveflora.Developcompensatorymitigationprojectsforaquaticecosystemcreation,restorationorenhancement.
Cultural–ConsultwithTribes,historicalsocieties,federal,stateandlocalagenciesregardinglocationofculturalresourcespriortouseofheavyequipmentinareaswithknownorsuspectedculturalresources.ProjectssubjecttothejurisdictionoftheWaterBoardswillberequiredtocomplywithPublicResourceCodesection21159.Thisisexpectedtoensurethattheimplementationofanynecessarysitespecificactionstoavoid,minimizeandmitigateanyimpactstohistorical,archaeological,andpaleontologicalresourcesorsite,oruniquegeologicfeatures.Allfutureactionsmustcomply
116StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
withtheCEQAprocessandrequirementsfortribalconsultationprovidedbySenateBill18(SB18)(State2004,Ch905)andGovernmentCodesection65252.
Geology/Soils–Oneofthecoreactionsintheproposedpolicyaswellasexistingregulationiserosionandsedimentcontrol.AllfutureactionssubjecttothisproposedBasinPlanamendmentmustfocusontheavoidance,minimizationandmitigationofimpactsrelatedtounstableorsensitivegeologicareas,soilerosionorthelossoftopsoil.Typicallyanarrayofstructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasureswillbeusedinanyfutureprojectasmeanstocomplywiththisproposedBasinPlanamendmentandexistingregulationssuchastheSedimentImplementationPolicy,WDRsandWaivers,NPDESpermits,and401Certifications.
Noise–Exposuretoshorttermconstructionequipment,alternativewatersupplyoperationsandmaintenance.
WaterQuality–Plantnativevegetation.Allowfortheremovalorthinningofuplandvegetationthathashighevapotranspirationratesandincreasesfirerisks.Useprecision(sitespecific)farmingtechniques;monitorchemicalconditionofsoil,water,andplantresidualscarefullypriortoapplyingfertilizers,pesticides,orwater,includingtailwater.Leachsoilswithintherootzoneasnecessarytopreventsaltbuildupinthatportionofthesoilprofile.Monitorgroundwatertoensurenosalt(orotherconstituents)accumulateingroundwater.Avoidintroductionofstormwaterintotailwatersystemtopreventimpactstostormwater.Maintainfilterstripsbetweenfieldsandsurfacewatertopreventdischargeoftailwaterdirectlyintosurfacewaters.Installsurfacedrainagefieldditchtocollectexcesswater.Seekprofessional(e.g.NaturalResourcesConservationService,localresourceconservationdistrict,consultants,etc.)indevelopinglandmanagementplansandobservationaltechniquestoensureefficientandeffectivewateruse.Ensureproperdesign,siting,andoperationaltimingtoreducealterationsofnaturalhydrologyandadverseeffectsonstreamandgroundwaterqualityandqualityfromstructuralcompliancemeasures.Don’tconcentratedrainagesuchthattoxiclevelsofconstituentsaredischargetowaters.
Transportation–Shorttermtrafficincreasesassociateddamremoval. Utilitiesandservicesystems–Developwastemanagementplansfordam
removalprojects.Coordinatewithprospectivelandfillsregardingtheestimatedamountofwastegeneratedbyaproposedprojectandlandfillcapacity.Planforanddevelopconservationandefficiencyprojectsforwatersupply.Planforanddeveloprecycledwaterprojectsandaquiferstorageandrecovery(ASR)projects.
117StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
9.4.4AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasuresAssociatedwithPreservingExistingColdWaterResourcesThepreservationofcoldwaterresourcesisacriticalcomponentintheproposedBasinPlanamendment.AreasofthermalrefugiaintheNorthCoastRegionareessentialtothesupportofthecoldwaterfisherybecausetheymoderatetheimpactofnaturallyelevatedtemperatures.Thermalrefugiaaretypicallyidentifiedasareasofcoolwatercreatedbyinflowingtributaries,springs,seepsupwellinghyporheicflow,and/orgroundwaterinanotherwisewarmstreamchannelofferingrefugehabitattocold‐waterfishandothercoldwateraquaticspecies(Watercourse,2005).Therefugiacreatedbysometributariesaretypicallyintheplumesandpoolsofcoldwaterthatforminthemainstemsatthetributaryconfluence.Refugiaalsoexistinsometributarystreamsthemselves.Theshapeandextentofrefugiaarehighlyvariableandaredependentonstreamgeomorphology,ripariancanopy,sedimentdynamics,andflow.RegionalWaterBoardstaffsrecognizethereareanumberoffactorsthatcancauseseasonalandinter‐annualchangesintheexistence,location,andsizeofthethermalrefugia.Takenasawhole,thesethermalrefugiacompriseanetworkofsupportforpopulationsofcoldwaterfishesandhealthyaquaticecosystemconditions.TheirprotectionhasbecomeevenmoreimportantwiththeabundanceofimpairmentsfortemperaturethroughouttheNorthCoastRegion.ComplianceMeasuresAssociatedwithPreservingColdWaterResources:
Avoidofareasofknownthermalrefugiaduringcriticaltimeforfish. Controloferosionandsedimentdischargestoareasofknownthermal
refugia. Removefishpassagebarrierstoareasofknownthermalrefugia. Conductstreambankrestorationandriparianrevegetationtoareasofknown
thermalrefugia. Constructriparianfencingtopreserveareasofknownthermalrefugia Modifyand/orremoveon‐streamstoragefacilitiesanddamswhichinfluence
identifiedcoldwaterresources. Constructnewormodifyoff‐streamstoragefacilitiestoreplaceon‐stream
facilitiesaffectingcoldwaterresources. Installandoperategroundwaterwellsatalocationwithlittleornoinfluence
overtheflowsassociatedwithacoldwaterresource. Modifytheoperationandtimingofgroundwater,surfacewater,orriparian
rightwaterextraction. Relyonalternativewatersourcesandconservationefforts. Constructand/ormodifywatertransfer,irrigationand/orirrigationwater
managementfacilitiestoimprovewateruseefficiency. Enhancedaquiferrecharge(i.e.,ASR).
118StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
PotentialEnvironmentalImpactsAssociatedwithPreservingColdWaterResources Aesthetics–Constructionactivitiescouldhaveshorttermaestheticimpacts
whilesittingforwaterfacilitylocationscoulddegradeorimpedescenicviewsinthelongterm.
AgriculturalResources–PotentialconflictwithorconversionofprimeagriculturallandorlandsubjecttotheWilliamsonActfromimplementingriparianbuffers.
AirQuality–Constructioncouldincreaseshorttermexhaustandparticulatematter.Alternativewatersuppliesorincreasedpumpingcouldresultinlongtermincreaseingreenhousegases.
BiologicalResources–Constructionorremovalofin‐streamfacilitiescouldresultinshorttermdisturbancesofwetlands,specialstatusspeciesandsensitivenaturalareas.Reductioninsurfaceflowsthroughgroundwaterextractionorincreasedrelianceonriparianrightscoulddegraderiparianhabitat.Switchingfromon‐streamstoragefacilitiestosprings,seepsorgroundwateraspotentialwatersourcescouldreducetheinputofcoldwaterandcouldresultsinimpactstoareasofthermalrefugia.
CulturalResources–Shorttermconstructiondisturbancefromearthmovingorreservoirdrawdowns,streamand/orriparianrestorationcouldcauseadverseimpactstoculturalorhistoricalresources.Constructionorremovalofrecreational,watersupplyorhydroelectricfacilitiescouldresultinlongtermadverseculturalorhistoricalimpacts.
Geology/Soils–Constructionactivitiesorpoorlydesignedfacilitiescouldresultsinshorttermandlongtermerosion,andcouldresultsinsoilcompaction,reducedsoilmoisture,andreducedbiologicalproductivitywithinsoils.
HazardsandHazardousMaterials–Constructionactivitiescouldresultintheincreaseinhazardousmaterialsusedinconstruction,andintheoperationandmaintenanceofneworexpandedfacilities.
Hydrology/WaterQuality–Excessiveuseofrip‐raporstreamstabilizationstructuresintendedtobeneficiallyaffectflowcouldalterconditionsdownstream.Workwithinandadjacenttowatersincreasestheriskofleakingequipmentorhazardousmaterialspills,shorttermturbidityincreasesand/ordischargesofsettablesolids.Decreasestreamflowsand/oraquiferstoragefromdustabatement.Alterationsofnaturalhydrologyandincreasesinstreamtemperaturesbyconcentratingorredirectingroadrunoffordivertingstreamduringconstruction.Increasedriskoferosionandsedimentationfromtheconstructionofstreamcrossings,andriparianfencing.
LandUse/Planning–Relianceonalternativewatersources,waterconservationefforts,andpreservationofareasofknownthermalrefugiacouldhaveaconflictwithlocalplansorordinancesthatcallforanincreasethroughvariouswatersupplyand/ordevelopmentprojects.Municipal,domestic,agriculturalandindustrialwatersupplycouldbeimpactedbycertainrestrictionsontheextractionofwaterfromriparianareasorareasof
119StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
knownthermalrefugia.Constructionorexpansionofoff‐streamwaterstoragefacilitiescouldconflictwithlocalplansorordinances.
MineralResources–Theconstructionorexpansionofawaterstoragefacilitycouldreducetheabilitytoaccessmineralresourcesintheprojectfootprint.
Noise–Construction,modificationorremovaloffacilitiesforthepurposeofgroundwaterorsurfacewaterextraction,energysupplyand/orrecreationcouldresultinshorttermandlongtermimpactsfromnoise.
PopulationandHousing–Waterconservationand/orrelianceonalternativewatersourcescouldhaveanimpactonhousingdevelopmentorexistinghousingpopulations.Movingtorelianceonlargerwatersupplierscouldincreasetheirdemandandthusleadtoanincreasedlevelofwaterextractioninspecificlocations.
Recreation‐Dams(forwhateverpurpose–hydropower,summerrecreation,anddrinkingwaterextraction)couldberemovedtoachieveflowsneededtocomplywithtemperatureobjectivesreducingtheareaofwateravailableforrecreating.Ifdamremovalisselectedasacompliancemeasureswimmingandboating(lakeskiingandwhitewaterboating)couldbeadverselyaffected.Inaddition,recreationalfacilitiessuchascampgroundsandboatlauncheswouldberemovediffullorpartialremovalofthedamsisselectedasacompliancemeasure.Additionally,recreationalfishingforintroducedspecieswouldbelostafterdamremovaleliminatedtheirhabitatandconditionsfavorednativespecies.
TransportationandTraffic–Compliancemeasuresthatrequireconstructionactivitiescouldresultintrafficdelays.Areductioninwaterresourceavailabilitycouldleadtoagriculturallandconversion,whichinturncouldleadtoincreaseddevelopmentandtraffic.
Utilities/ServiceSystems–Compliancemeasuresthatrequireconstructionordemolitionoffacilitiescouldresultinshortterminterruptionofutilities.Hydroelectricdamremovalcouldcreatealocalorregionalshiftinpowersupplyservices.Waterconservationand/orrelianceonalternativewatersourcescouldhaveanimpactonmunicipalwatersupply.
PossibleMitigationMeasuresAssociatedwithPreservingofColdWaterResourcesComplianceMeasures
Aesthetics–Propersiting,constructingbermsorexcessfreeboardaroundtheperimeterofapond,orplantingvegetationalongtheperimeterofapond.
AgriculturalResources–Implementstructuralandnon‐structuralwaterirrigationwatermanagement,irrigationpipelines,conservationcover,covercrop,pondsealingorlining,fieldborders,streambuffers,roofrunoffcapturestructures,andculvertsforwaterconveyance.Coordinationbetweenprojectproponents,RegionalWaterBoardstaff,DivisionofWaterRights,otherlocalstateandfederalagenciestoachievemutuallybeneficialsolutionsthatensurethepreservationofagriculturallandsandcoldwaterresources.
AirQuality–Airmonitoring,dustcontrolBMPs,designwaterretentionBMPstructurestodrainin72hourstopreventvectorsandodors,equipment
120StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
timing,windbarriers,aggregatecover,multi‐yearcrop,andresiduemanagement.
BiologicalResources–ConsultwithUSFWS,CDFW,andNMFS,erosionandsedimentcontrolBMPs,wastemanagementBMPS,biologicalmonitors,work‐windows,vegetatedstreambuffers,criticalhabitat/speciesidentificationsurveys,waterdiversionfishscreens,velocitydissipaters,andwaterdraftingprotocols.
Geology/Soils–Oneofthecoreactionsintheproposedpolicy,aswellasexistingregulation,iserosionandsedimentcontrol.AllfutureactionssubjecttothisproposedBasinPlanamendmentmustfocusontheavoidance,minimizationandmitigationofimpactsrelatedtounstableorsensitivegeologicareas,soilerosionorthelossoftopsoil.Typically,anarrayofstructuralandnon‐structuralBMPswillbeusedinanyfutureprojectasthemeanstocomplywiththisproposedBasinPlanamendmentandexistingregulationssuchastheSedimentImplementationPolicy,WDRsandWaivers,NPDESpermits,and401Certifications.
HazardsandHazardousMaterials–Developpollutionpreventionplansincorporatingstructuralandnon‐structuralwastehandling,storageandmanagementBMPsincluding,butnotlimitedtowatertightcontainers,spillkits,andappropriatemateriallabels.
Hydrology/WaterQuality–Ingeneral,thecombinationofseveralstructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasures/BMPscanbeusedtomitigateimpactstowaterquality.Usesediment,erosion,spillprevention,andwastemanagementBMPsduringconstructionandvegetationthinningactivities.Forexamplescheduling,straw,seed,siltfence,strawwaddle,strawbales,dripprotection,vehiclecleaningandmaintenance,andsiteinspections.Installandmaintainerosioncontrolmeasures(e.g.waterbars,rollingdips,mulch,rockrip‐rap)topreventdischargeofexcesssedimentfromsoildisturbingactivities.Useoff‐channelwatercollectionfeaturesfordustabatementpurposes.Ensureproperdesign,siting,andoperationaltimingtoreducealterationsofnaturalhydrologyandadverseeffectsonstreamfromstructuralcompliancemeasures.
LandUse/Planning–Consultwithlocal,stateandfederalagenciesforguidanceandrecommendations.
Transportation–Throughtheexistingprojectplanning,CEQAprocess,interagencycoordinationandexistingregulation(NPDESstormwaterpermitsand401Certifications)potentialconflictsareresolvedbyavoidance,minimization,oroff‐sitecompensatorymitigation.
Utilitiesandservicesystems–Developmanagementplansforwaterconservationandwaterefficiencyprojects(i.e.,ASR).
121StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
9.4.5AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasuresAssociatedwithAquaticEcosystemRestorationtoAddressStreamTemperaturesGenerallyaquaticecosystemrestorationactionsareplanned,designedandimplementedinwaystobestreduceenvironmentalimpacts.Whiletherearepotentialshorttermimpactsassociatedwiththesetypesofcompliancemeasurestheyaregenerallybeneficialfortheenvironmentinthelongtermandcanbeimplementedwithoutanyadverseenvironmentalimpacts.ForexamplethereisacategoricalexemptionwithintheCEQAguidelinesthatallowforsmallhabitatrestorationprojects27.ComplianceMeasuresAssociatedwithAquaticEcosystemRestorationtoAddressStreamTemperatures Stabilizestreamcrossingstoprovidecontrolledaccessacrossastreamfor
livestockandfarmmachinery. Streamorriverbankrevegetationtoincreaseshadeinaccordancewithsite
potential. In‐streamgravelaugmentation. Largewoodydebris/habitatenhancementprojects. Streamorriverbankstabilizationwithnativevegetationorother
bioengineeringtechniques,theprimarypurposeofwhichistoreduceoreliminateerosionandsedimentationandsupportsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.
CulvertreplacementconductedinaccordancewithpublishedguidelinesoftheDepartmentofFishandWildlifeorNationalMarineFisheries,theprimarypurposeofwhichistoimprovehabitat,provideshade,reducesedimentation,orprovideaccesstoareasofthermalrefugia.
PotentialEnvironmentalImpactsAssociatedwithAquaticEcosystemRestorationtoAddressStreamTemperatures Aesthetics‐Decreasescenicviewsofwaterbodiesthroughtheretentionof
vegetation. Airquality–Shorttermconstruction‐relatedemissionscouldincludeexhaust
fromconstructionequipmentandfugitivedustfromlandclearing,earthmoving,movementofvehicles,andwinderosionofexposedsoilduringreservoirconstructionorremoval,streamand/orriparianrestoration.
Agriculture‐PotentialconflictwithorconversionofprimeagriculturallandorlandsubjecttotheWilliamsonActfromimplementinggrazingrestrictions.
BiologicalResources‐Riskofintroducinginvasivespeciesthoroughpasture,hayandrangelandplantingandmanagement.Shorttermconstruction,streamdewateringordiversions,turbiditydischargesfromconstructionactivesorin‐streamdamremoval,streamand/orriparianrestoration.
27Cal.Pub.ResourcesCode,§21083&21084
122StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Cultural‐Shorttermconstructiondisturbancefromearthmoving. Hydrology/waterquality–Reductioninstreamflowsduetotheincreasein
evapotranspirationfromincreasedripariantreeretention.Temporarysedimentdischargesfromconstructionand/orrestorationactivities.Excessiveuseofrip‐raporstreamstabilizationstructuresintendedtobeneficiallyaffectflowcouldalterconditionsdownstream.Workwithinandadjacenttowatersincreasestheriskofleakingequipmentorhazardousmaterialspills,shorttermturbidityincreasesand/ordischargesofsettablesolids.Decreasestreamflowsand/oraquiferstoragefromdustabatement.
Mineralresources‐Decreasedaccessforgravel,goldorothermineralextractionactivities.
Noise–Exposuretoshorttermconstructionequipment,alternativewatersupplyoperationsandmaintenance.
PublicServices–Restorationorconstructionactivitieswithinparksthathavestreamsorlandslidesadjacenttostreams.
Transportation/traffic–Increasedtreeretentionmayconflictwithtransportationagencies(publicroads)sitedistancerequirementsandareasdesignatedasclearrecoveryzones.Shorttermtrafficincreasesassociatedwithsedimentreductionproject,constructionprojects,damremoval,streamand/orriparianrestoration.
PossibleMitigationMeasuresforImpactsAssociatedwithComplianceMeasurestoRestoreAquaticEcosystems Airquality–Dustcontrol,avoiddaysorpoorairquality,monitorlevelsand
ceaseworkpriortoexceedingstandards,retrofitequipment,uselowemissionsvehicleswhenpossible,scheduleworktoreducetheuseofhighemissionvehicles.
Agriculture‐Coordinationbetweenprojectproponents,RegionalWaterBoardstaffandotherlocal,stateandfederalagenciestoachieverestorationgoalsandattempttoensurethepreservationofagriculturallands.
BiologicalResources‐Consultwithfederal,stateandlocalagenciesregardinglocationofsensitive(e.g.,threatenedorendangered)wildliferesources.SelectappropriateoralternatestructuralBMPssuchasbio‐degradable,syntheticfreeorearthenmaterialBMPs.Implementnon‐structuralBMPssuchasscheduling,properdesignandtheremovaloftemporaryBMPsforerosionandsedimentcontrolsafterstabilizationandorprojectcompletion.Developingspeciesrelocationplansorinterpretingnaturalsitevegetativeconditionstoincludesensitiveflora.
Cultural–ConsultwithTribes,historicalsocieties,federal,stateandlocalagenciesregardinglocationofculturalresourcespriortouseofheavyequipmentinareaswithknownorsuspectedculturalresources.ProjectssubjecttothejurisdictionoftheWaterBoardswillberequiredtocomplywithPublicResourceCodesection21159.Thisisexpectedtoensuretheimplementationofnecessarysitespecificactionstoavoid,minimizeandmitigateanyimpactstohistorical,archaeological,andpaleontological
123StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
resourcesorsite,oruniquegeologicfeatures.AllfutureactionsmustcomplywiththeCEQAprocessandrequirementsfortribalconsultationprovidedbySenateBill18(SB18)(State2004,Ch905)andGovernmentCodesection65252.
Geology/Soils–Oneofthecoreactionsintheproposedpolicy,aswellasexistingregulation,iserosionandsedimentcontrol.AllfutureactionssubjecttothisproposedBasinPlanamendmentmustfocusontheavoidance,minimizationandmitigationofimpactsrelatedtounstableorsensitivegeologicareas,soilerosionorthelossoftopsoil.Typically,anarrayofstructuralandnon‐structuralBMPswillbeusedinanyfutureprojectasthemeanstocomplywiththisproposedBasinPlanamendmentandexistingregulationssuchastheSedimentImplementationPolicy,WDRsandWaivers,NPDESpermits,and401Certifications.
WaterQuality–Plantnativevegetationthathasevolvedwiththenaturalenvironment.Usesediment,erosion,spillprevention,andwastemanagementBMPsduringconstructionandvegetationthinningactivities.Forexamplescheduling,straw,seed,siltfence,strawwaddle,strawbales,dripprotection,vehiclecleaningandmaintenance,andsiteinspections.Installandmaintainerosioncontrolmeasures(e.g.waterbars,rollingdips,mulch,rockrip‐rap)topreventdischargeofexcesssedimentfromsoildisturbingactivities.Relocateroadsawayfromunstableandlandslideproneterrain.Useoff‐channelwatercollectionfeaturesfordustabatementpurposes.Installadequatenumber/typeofroaddrainagefeaturestopreventconcentrationofroadrunoff.Ensureproperdesign,siting,andoperationaltimingtoreducealterationsofnaturalhydrologyandadverseeffectsonstreamfromstructuralcompliancemeasures.
Transportation–Throughtheexistingprojectplanning,CEQAprocess,interagencycoordinationandexistingregulation(NPDESstormwaterpermitsand401Certifications)potentialconflictsareresolvedbyavoidance,minimization,oroff‐sitecompensatorymitigation.
9.4.6AnalysisofComplianceMeasures,PotentialEnvironmentalImpacts,andPotentialMitigationMeasurestoRestoreandMaintainStreamFlowsthatSupportBeneficialUsesCoordinationwiththeStateWaterBoardisongoing.TheRegionalWaterBoardparticipatesintheappropriativewaterrightpermittingandwaterqualitycertification(pursuanttosection401oftheCleanWaterAct)processesassociatedwithwaterrights.Potentialprojectsthatrequire401certifications(e.g.FederalEnergyRegulatoryCommission‐LicensingProjects)and/orwaterrightspermitswillbesubjecttotheCEQAprocessandmustprovideadditionalproject‐levelanalysis.Themajorityoftheforeseeablecompliancemeasuresassociatedwiththeactionsreferencedaboveaddressdams(hydropower,seasonal,andrecreationanddrinkingwatersupply)andsurfacewaterallocations.
124StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ComplianceMeasurestoRestoreandMaintainStreamFlowsthatSupportBeneficialUses Construct,modifyand/orremoveon‐streamstoragefacilitiesanddams. Constructnewormodifyoff‐streamstoragefacilities. Installandoperategroundwaterwells. Modifytheoperationandtimingofgroundwater,surfacewater,orriparian
rightwaterextraction. Relyonalternativewatersourcesandconservationefforts. Constructand/ormodifywatertransfer,irrigationand/orirrigationwater
managementfacilities. Enhancedinfiltrationofgroundwater(i.e.,ASR)
PotentialEnvironmentalImpactsofComplianceMeasurestoRestoreandMaintainStreamFlowsthatSupportBeneficialUses
Aesthetics–Constructionactivitiescouldhaveshorttermaestheticimpactswhilesittingforwaterfacilitylocationscoulddegradeorimpedescenicviewsinthelongterm.
AgriculturalResources–Switchingfromsurfacewaterdiversionstogroundwaterpumpingcouldlowerwatertable,reducesoilmoisture,contributetolandsubsidenceandreduceaquiferstoragecapability.Regulationonwaterusecouldleadtotheconversionofagriculturallands.
AirQuality–Constructioncouldincreaseshorttermexhaustandparticulatematter.Alternativewatersuppliesorincreasedpumpingcouldresultinlongtermincreaseingreenhousegases.
BiologicalResources–Constructionorremovalofin‐streamfacilitiescouldresultinshorttermdisturbancesofwetlands,specialstatusspeciesandsensitivenaturalareas.Reductioninsurfaceflowsthroughgroundwaterextractionorincreasedrelianceonriparianrightscoulddegraderiparianhabitat.Switchingfromon‐streamstoragefacilitiestosprings,seepsorgroundwateraspotentialwatersourcescouldreducetheinputofcoldwaterandcouldresultsinimpactstoareasofthermalrefugia.
CulturalResources–Shorttermconstructiondisturbancefromearthmovingorreservoirdrawdowns,streamand/orriparianrestorationcouldcauseadverseimpactstoculturalorhistoricalresources.Constructionorremovalofrecreational,watersupplyorhydroelectricfacilitiescouldresultinlongtermadverseculturalorhistoricalimpacts.
Geology/Soils–Constructionactivitiesorpoorlydesignedfacilitiescouldresultinginshorttermandlongtermerosion,andcouldresultsinsoilcompaction,reducedsoilmoisture,andreducedbiologicalproductivitywithinsoils.
HazardsandHazardousMaterials–Theincreaseduseofgroundwaterandconstructionofwatersupplyfacilitiescouldresultintheincreaseinhazardousmaterialsusedinconstruction,andintheoperationandmaintenanceofneworexpandedfacilities.
125StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Hydrology/WaterQuality–Shorttermconstructionandpoorlydesignedfacilitiescouldleadtoerosion,sedimentationorhazardousmaterialsdischarges.Theincreaseingroundwaterextractioncouldreducesurfacewaterflowsandresultinincreasedpollutantconcentrationduetolessdilution.Theremovalofdamscouldresultinashorttermviolationofwaterqualitystandardsassedimentsandorganicrichwatersflowdownstream.Theremovalofon‐streamandoff‐streamstoragefacilities,dams,andconstructionofminimumbypassflowandfishpassagestructurescouldresultinchangestohydrologyinstreamsaswellasshorttermviolationofwaterqualitystandards.Switchingfromon‐streamstoragefacilitiestosprings,seepsorgroundwateraspotentialwatersourcescouldreducetheinputofcoldwaterandcouldresultsinimpactstoareasofthermalrefugia.
LandUse/Planning–Increasedriparianwaterrightsuseasaresultofthepolicymayresultinimpactsonlocalplanstoincreasesurfaceandgroundwaterextraction.Relianceonalternativewatersourcescouldhaveaconflictwithlocalplansorordinances.Constructionorexpansionofoff‐streamwaterstoragefacilitiescouldconflictwithlocalplansorordinances.
MineralResources–Theconstructionorexpansionofawaterstoragefacilitycouldreducetheabilitytoaccessmineralresourcesintheprojectfootprint.
Noise–Construction,modificationorremovaloffacilitiesforthepurposeofgroundwaterorsurfacewaterextraction,energysupplyand/orrecreationcouldresultinshorttermandlongtermimpactsfromnoise.
PopulationandHousing–Waterconservationand/orrelianceonalternativewatersourcescouldhaveanimpactonhousingdevelopmentorexistinghousingpopulations.Movingtorelianceonlargerwatersupplierscouldincreasetheirdemandandthusleadtoanincreasedlevelofextractioninspecificlocations.
Recreation‐Dams(forwhateverpurpose–hydropower,summerrecreation,anddrinkingwaterextraction)couldberemovedtoachieveflowsneededtocomplywithtemperatureobjectivesreducingtheareaofwateravailableforrecreating.Ifdamremovalisselectedasacompliancemeasure,swimmingandboating(lakeskiingandwhitewaterboating)couldbeadverselyaffected.Inaddition,recreationalfacilitiessuchascampgroundsandboatlauncheswouldberemovediffullorpartialremovalofthedamsisselectedasacompliancemeasure.Additionally,recreationalfishingforintroducedspecieswouldbelostafterdamremovaleliminatedtheirhabitatandconditionsfavorednativespecies.
TransportationandTraffic–Compliancemeasuresthatrequireconstructionactivitiescouldresultintrafficdelays.
Utilities/ServiceSystems–Compliancemeasuresthatrequireconstructionordemolitionoffacilitiescouldresultinshortterminterruptionofutilities.Hydroelectricdamremovalcouldcreatealocalorregionalshiftinpowersupplyservices.
126StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
PotentialMeasurestoAvoid,MinimizeorMitigateImpactsfromComplianceMeasurestoPreserveAdequateStreamFlows
Aesthetics–Propersiting,constructingbermsorexcessfreeboardaroundtheperimeterofapond,orplantingvegetationalongtheperimeterofapond.
AgriculturalResources–Implementstructuralandnon‐structuralwaterirrigationwatermanagement,irrigationpipelines,conservationcover,covercrop,pondsealingorlining,fieldborders,streambuffers,roofrunoffcapturestructures,andculvertsforwaterconveyance.
AirQuality–Airmonitoring,dustcontrolBMPs,designwaterretentionBMPstructurestodrainin72hourstopreventvectorsandodors,equipmenttiming,windbarriers,aggregatecover,multi‐yearcrop,andresiduemanagement.
BiologicalResources–ConsultwithUSFWS,CDFW,andNMFS,erosionandsedimentcontrolBMPs,wastemanagementBMPS,biologicalmonitors,work‐windows,vegetatedstreambuffers,criticalhabitat/speciesidentificationsurveys,waterdiversionfishscreens,velocitydissipaters,andwaterdraftingprotocols.
Geology/Soils–Oneofthecoreactionsintheproposedpolicy,aswellasexistingregulation,iserosionandsedimentcontrol.AllfutureactionssubjecttothisproposedBasinPlanamendmentmustfocusontheavoidance,minimizationandmitigationofimpactsrelatedtounstableorsensitivegeologicareas,soilerosionorthelossoftopsoil.Typically,anarrayofstructuralandnon‐structuralBMPswillbeusedinanyfutureprojectasthemeanstocomplywiththisproposedBasinPlanamendmentandexistingregulationssuchastheSedimentImplementationPolicy,WDRsandWaivers,NPDESpermits,and401Certifications.
HazardsandHazardousMaterials–Developpollutionpreventionplansincorporatingstructuralandnon‐structuralwastehandling,storageandmanagementBMPsincluding,butnotlimitedtowatertightcontainers,spillkits,andappropriatemateriallabels.
Hydrology/WaterQuality–SeecompliancemeasuresthroughoutthisSED.Ingeneral,thecombinationofseveralstructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasures/BMPscanbeusedtomitigateimpactstowaterquality.
LandUse/Planning–Consultwithagenciesforguidanceandrecommendations.
Transportation–Throughtheexistingprojectplanning,CEQAprocess,interagencycoordinationandexistingregulation(NPDESstormwaterpermitsand401Certifications)potentialconflictsareresolvedbyavoidance,minimization,oroff‐sitecompensatorymitigation.
Utilitiesandservicesystems–Developmanagementplansforwastehandling.Waterconservationandwaterefficiencyprojects.Aquiferstorageandrecovery(ASR).
127StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
9.5DiscussionofPotentialEnvironmentalImpactsPotentialimpactsofthereasonablyforeseeablecompliancemeasureswereevaluatedwithrespecttoearth,air,water,plantlife,animallife,noise,light,landuse,naturalresources,riskofupset,population,housing,transportation,publicservices,energy,utilitiesandservicessystems,humanhealth,aesthetics,recreation,andarcheological/historicalconcerns.Additionally,mandatoryfindingsofsignificanceregardingshort‐term,long‐term,cumulativeandsubstantialimpactswereevaluated.9.5.1ThresholdsofSignificanceAsignificanteffectontheenvironmentisdefinedinstatuteas“asubstantial,orpotentiallysubstantial,adversechangeintheenvironment”where“Environment”isdefinedbyPublicResourcesCodesection21060.5as“thephysicalconditionswhichexistwithintheareawhichwillbeaffectedbyaproposedproject,includingair,water,minerals,flora,fauna,noise,objectsofhistoricoraestheticsignificance.”28
Socialoreconomicchangesrelatedtoaphysicalchangeoftheenvironmentwerealsoconsideredindeterminingwhethertherewouldbeasignificanteffectontheenvironment.However,adversesocialandeconomicimpactsalonearenotsignificanteffectsontheenvironment.Amoredetailedanalysisoftherangeofcostsofcompliancemeasures,andpotentialfundingsourcesindiscussedinChapter10.Inthisanalysis,thelevelofsignificancewasbasedonbaselineorcurrentconditions.Short‐termimpactsassociatedwiththeconstructionofcompliancemeasureswiththeexceptionofdamdecommissioningactivities)wereconsideredlessthansignificantwithmitigationbecausetheimpactsduetoconstructionactivitiesaretemporaryandsimilartotypicalcapitalimprovementprojectsandmaintenanceactivitiescurrentlyperformedthroughouttheregion.Becauseofthis,whereitisuncertainwhetherthepotentialimpactscouldbemitigatedtolevelsofinsignificance,theRegionalWaterBoardactedconservativelyandconcludedinthisanalysisthatpotentialcompliancemeasureswouldresultinapotentiallysignificantimpacts.Whenassessingthesignificanceofimpact‐relatedimplementationoftheproposedBasinPlanamendmentitisimperativetodistinguishthelevelofmitigationpossibleunderaproposedprojectversusaproposedpolicy.Acomplexpolicycouldleadtoseveralpotentialoutcomesthataremuchmoredifficulttopredictascomparedtoacomplicatedprojectatoneplaceintimethathasmanymovingparts,butnonethelesshasaquantifiableimpactontheenvironment.Additionally,theinclusionofmitigationmeasureswithintheadoptionofapolicyoractionplanhasthesamelevelofpotentialasdoestheimpactitself.Forexample,apotentialmitigationmeasuretoaddressairqualityimpactsasaresultofacompliancemeasuredesignedtocomplywithTemperatureImplementationPolicyorActionPlansisnotdirectly
28 Pub.ResourcesCode§21068
128StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
enforceablebytheRegionalWaterBoardandthereforeisdeferredmitigationthatcanonlybeaddressedandimplementedattheprojectlevel.Theevaluationconsideredwhethertheconstructionorimplementationofcompliancemeasureswouldcauseasubstantial,adversechangeinanyofthephysicalconditionswithintheareaaffectedbythemeasure.Inaddition,theevaluationconsideredenvironmentaleffectsinproportiontotheirseverityandprobabilityofoccurrence.9.5.2EnvironmentalChecklist1.Projecttitle:ProposedAmendmenttotheWaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegiontoaddthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressWaterTemperatureImpairmentsintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds.2.Leadagencynameandaddress:NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard5550SkylaneBlvd.,SuiteASantaRosa,CA954033.Contactpersonandphonenumber:MattStJohn(707)576‐37624.Projectlocation:TheprojectwouldbeapplicabletotheareaunderthejurisdictionoftheNorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard.5.Descriptionoftheproject:Seesection9.2.1.I.AESTHETICS‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Haveasubstantialadverseeffectonascenicvista?
X
b)Substantiallydamagescenicresources,including,butnotlimitedto,trees,rockoutcroppings,andhistoricbuildingswithinastatescenichighway?
X
c)Substantiallydegradethe
129StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
existingvisualcharacterorqualityofthesiteanditssurroundings?
X
d)Createanewsourceofsubstantiallightorglarewhichwouldadverselyaffectdayornighttimeviewsinthearea?
X
AESTHETICSa)andc):LessThanSignificantDiscussion:Compliancemeasuressuchasplantingtreesand/orretainingtreesaregenerallyregardedaspositiveaesthetics.Scenicvistasusuallyincludewellvegetatedareas.Insomecasestheplantingorretentionoflargewoodyvegetationcouldreducevisibilitytoandadjacentwaterbody;however,vegetationalsoprovideshabitatforwildlifeandinknowntoenhancewaterqualitywhichwouldimprovetheoveralllandscape.Compliancemeasuressuchasriparianrestoration,modificationstowatersupplyandwaterstoragepracticesinagriculturallands,anderosionandsedimentcontrolmeasuresmaymodifytheappearanceofanarea;however,thesemeasuresarenotlikelytoresultintheeliminationofagriculturaloccupationstherebyeliminatingareasofopenspace.Therefore,impactstoscenicvistasareconsideredlessthansignificant.AESTHETICSb)andd):LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedCompliancemeasuressuchasthepreservationoflargewoodyvegetationcouldleadtoanincreasefuelloadforwildfireswhichcouldthenimpactscenicareas.Fireimpactsonriparianzonesvaryproportionallywiththeseverityandextentofburninginthecatchmentandareaffectedbystreamsize.Riparianzonescanactasabufferagainstfireandthereforeasarefugeforfire‐sensitivespecies.However,undersomecircumstances,suchasdrypre‐fireclimaticconditionsandtheaccumulationofdryfuel,ripariancanareasbecomecorridorsforfiremovement.Fireincursionintoriparianzonescreatescanopygapsanddrierconditions,whichallowsubsequentbuildupofdeadwoodandestablishmentoffireadaptedspecies.Inconcert,thisincreasesfuelloadsandtheprobabilityofanotherfire.Secondaryeffectsofriparianfireincludealteringnutrientfluxesandcycling,increasingsedimentloads,andstimulatingerosion.Riparianfiresarepotentiallyimportantinshapingecologicalcharacteristicsinmanyregions,butthisispoorlyquantified.Abetterunderstandingofriparianfireregimesisessentialtoassesstheeffectsoffireinhelpingshapethecomplexecologicalcharacteristicsofriparianzonesoverthelonger‐term.(Pettit,N.E.,andR.J.Naiman.2007)Basedontheevidenceandnatureofforestfiresthisappearstobealessthansignificantimpactontheenvironment,ifmitigatedwithproperfuelmanagement.Forexample,thethinningofunderstoryvegetationandselectharvestprescriptionscandecreasethefuelloadwhileconcurrentlypreservingandrestoringshadealongwatercourses.Additionally,
130StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
firebreakscanbeusedinuplandandriparianareasthatdonotaffectwatertemperaturestoensurestrategicdefenseagainstwildfires.
Acompliancemeasurethatrequiredlanddisturbance,suchastheconstructionofasettlingbasinorariparianfence,mayincludeminorsurfacesoilexcavationorgradingduringconstruction,whichcouldresultinincreaseddisturbanceofthesoil.If,however,scenicresourceswereidentifiedatthesite,theywouldbeavoided,andstandardconstructiontechniquesanderosionandsedimentcontrolpracticeswouldrequirerevegetationandwouldnotresultinpermanentdamagetoscenicresources.Neitherthestructuralnorthenon‐structuralcompliancemeasureswouldbeexpectedtodegradetheexistingvisualcharacterorqualityofasiteanditssurroundingswiththeapplicationofappropriatemitigationmeasures.AlthoughimplementationofstructuralBMPscouldresultinsomechangeinvisualcharacterorgroundsurfacerelieffeatures,mostofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedaspartoftheenvironmentalanalysisareofrelativelysmallscale,suchasinstallationofroaddrainagefeatures,riparianplanting,riparianfencing,orsmallscalewaterdiversionsystems.Likely,changestothevisualcharacterorqualityofthesiteanditssurroundingswillnotbenoticeable.Thelargerscaleprojects,suchasdamdecommissioning,roaddecommissioningonUSFSland,orconstructionofanoffstreamwaterstoragefacilitycouldpotentiallyimpactaestheticresources.Visualimpactsassociatedwithdamdecommissioningcanbeaddressedthroughthedecommissioningplanbyincludingmitigationmeasuressuchasearlyestablishmentofnativevegetation(grass,forbesandtrees)onexposedsurfaces.Theconstructionofanoffstreamstoragefacility(i.e.,pond)couldbeexpectedtooccasionallycreateanewsourceofsubstantialglare.Mitigationmeasurestoreducethesignificanceincludepropersiting,constructingbermsorexcessfreeboardaroundtheperimeterofapond,orplantingvegetationalongtheperimeterofapond.II.AGRICULTUREANDFORESTRESOURCES:Indeterminingwhetherimpactstoagriculturalresourcesaresignificantenvironmentaleffects,leadagenciesmayrefertotheCaliforniaAgriculturalLandEvaluationandSiteAssessmentModel(1997)preparedbytheCaliforniaDept.ofConservationasanoptionalmodeltouseinassessingimpactsonagricultureandfarmland.Indeterminingwhetherimpactstoforestresources,includingtimberland,aresignificantenvironmentaleffects,leadagenciesmayrefertoinformationcompiledbytheCaliforniaDepartmentofForestryandFireProtectionregardingthestate’sinventoryofforestland,includingtheForestandRangeAssessmentProjectandtheForestLegacyAssessmentProject;andforestcarbonmeasurementmethodologyprovidedinForestProtocolsadoptedbytheCaliforniaAirResources
131StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Boards.Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)ConvertPrimeFarmland,UniqueFarmland,orFarmlandofStatewideImportance(Farmland),asshownonthemapspreparedpursuanttotheFarmlandMappingandMonitoringProgramoftheCaliforniaResourcesAgency,tonon‐agriculturaluse?
X
b)Conflictwithexistingzoningforagriculturaluse,oraWilliamsonActcontract?
X
c)Conflictwithexistingzoningfor,orcauserezoningof,forestland(asdefinedinPublicResourcesCodesection12220(g)),timberland(asdefinedbyPublicResourcesCodesection4526),ortimberlandzonedTimberlandProduction(asdefinedbyGovernmentCodesection51104(g))?
X
d)Resultinthelossofforestlandorconversionofforestlandtonon‐forestuse?
X
e)Involveotherchangesintheexistingenvironmentwhich,duetotheirlocationornature,couldresultinconversionofFarmland,tononagriculturaluseorconversionofforestlandtononforestuse?
X
AGRICULTUREANDFORESTRESOURCES:a),b)ande)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:CompliancemeasuressuchasriparianbufferscouldcauseincidentallossofagriculturaluseinlandsmappedasPrimeFarmland,UniqueFarmlandor
132StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
FarmlandofStatewideImportance.Theselossesonaregionwidebasiswouldonlyaffectaverynarrowbandoflandoneithersideofthewatercourse,andasderivedfromthereadilyaccessibleinformationfromtheFarmlandMappingandMonitoringProgramtheU.S.DepartmentofAgricultureNationalAgricultureStatisticsServiceitisestimatedthatnomorethan5%oftheNorthCoastRegionismappedasPrimeFarmland,UniqueFarmland,andFarmlandofStatewideImportance.Additionally,someareasthataremappedasprime,uniqueorimportantmaycomplywiththeproposedBasinPlanamendmentwhileothersmaynot.Althoughtherearemanyfactorsthataffectthisdetermination,itcanbeassumedthatagriculturallandsthatimplementnewriparianprotectionactionsorcompliancemeasurestomitigateelevatedstreamtemperaturescouldbetakinglandoutofproduction.Whileavoidanceandminimizationmeasurescanbeusedtolessenimpacts,thereisnomitigationforlossofland;therefore,thisispotentiallysignificantandunavoidableimpact.AGRICULTUREANDFORESTRESOURCES:c)andd)NoImpactDiscussion:NoelementsoftheproposedBasinPlanamendmentwillrezoneorforcetherezoningofTimberlandsProductionorresultintheconversionofforestedlandtonon‐forestedland.Inshort,theanticipatedcompliancemeasuresfortimberlandsistoretainmoreforestedareasalongstreamsandthereforehasnoimpactontheclassificationofconversionoftimberlands.III.AIRQUALITY‐‐Whereavailable,thesignificancecriteriaestablishedbytheapplicableairqualitymanagementorairpollutioncontroldistrictmaybereliedupontomakethefollowingdeterminations.Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Conflictwithorobstructimplementationoftheapplicableairqualityplan?
X
b)Violateanyairqualitystandardorcontributesubstantiallytoanexistingorprojectedairqualityviolation?
X
c)Resultinacumulativelyconsiderablenetincreaseofanycriteriapollutantforwhichtheprojectregionisnon‐attainmentunderanapplicablefederalorstateambientairqualitystandard(includingreleasing
X
133StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
emissionswhichexceedquantitativethresholdsforozoneprecursors)?d)Exposesensitivereceptorstosubstantialpollutantconcentrations?
X
e)Createobjectionableodorsaffectingasubstantialnumberofpeople?
X
AIRQUALITY:a)andd)NoImpact.Discussion:Compliancemeasureswouldnotresultinanyconflictswithorobstructiontotheimplementationoftheapplicableairqualityplanorexposesensitivereceptorstosubstantialpollutantconcentrations.AIRQUALITY:b)andc)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidable.Discussion:ExcludingtheissueofKlamathdamremoval,thepolicyisanticipatedtohaveabeneficialeffectontheenvironment,greenhousegas(GHG)emissionsandclimatechange.Further,actionssuchasriparianpreservationandrestorationwillsequestercarbonfromtheatmospherethroughplantphotosynthesis.Inaddition,trappingsoilsthrougherosionandsedimentcontrolwillreduceGHGswhencarbonislockedupintrappedsediments,aswellaslivingvegetation.Therefore,itisstaff’sjudgmentthattheoveralllongtermbenefitsoftheproposedBasinPlanamendmentwillaidinthereductionofGHGsandhelpprovideresilienceintheconditionofNorthCoastwatershedsandwaterresourcesaswefacetheuncertaintyofclimatechange.Compliancemeasurescouldresultinthegenerationoffugitivedustandparticulatematterduringconstructionormaintenanceactivities,whichcouldtemporarilyimpactambientairquality.Anysuchimpactswouldbetemporary,andwouldbecontrolledwithstandardconstructionoperations,suchastheuseofmoisturetoreducethetransferofparticulatesanddusttoairandconductingoperationswhentheairqualityinthebasinisgood(i.e.nocatastrophicwildfires).Theemissionsofairpollutantsduringtheconstructionoffacilitiesforcomplianceareunlikelytohaveaneffectonambientairquality.Implementationofcompliancemeasuresthatrequiretheuseofheavyequipment,suchasdamdecommissioning,constructionofsettlingbasins,roaddrainageinstallationorre‐contouringofexistingroadprisms,couldresultinvehicleemissionsduringconstruction.However,theseimpactswouldbeshort‐term,andwouldnotresultinconflictswith,orobstructionoftheimplementationoftheapplicableairqualityplan.Airqualityimpactsassociatedwithheavyequipmentusedtomodifyorremoveon‐streamoroff‐streamstoragefacilitiesorimplement
134StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
otherstructuralcompliancemeasuressuchasthosecouldbepotentiallysignificant,buttheywouldbelimitedtothoseresultingfromshort‐termconstructionactivities.Largescaledamremoval(demolition)andotherlarge‐scalerestorationactivitiesarereasonablyforeseeablecompliancemeasurethatcouldresultintheshorttermviolationoflocalairqualitystandards,andthereforeposeapotentiallysignificantimpact.Compliancemeasuressuchaserosioncontrol,reservoirreseedingandriparianplantingarenotlikelytoresultinaviolationofairqualitystandards;however,thefineparticulatematterandvehicleemissionsfromdamremovalactivitiescouldexceedestablishedthresholdsandasaresultwouldbeconsideredapotentiallysignificantimpactandunavoidable.AIRQUALITY:e)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationDiscussion:Themajorityofcompliancemeasureswouldnotbeexpectedtoresultinobjectionableodorsaffectingasubstantialnumberofpeople.
Compliancemeasuresmayresultinobjectionableodorsintheshort‐termduetoexhaustfromconstructionequipmentandvehicles.Certainstructuralcompliancemeasures,suchasdetentionbasins,couldbecomeasourceofobjectionableodorsifdesignsallowforwaterstagnationorcollectionofwaterwithsulfur‐containingcompounds.Thiscouldalsobethecaseifanaerobicsedimentisexposedtotheairasaresultofdamremovaloperations.Theapplicationofmitigationmeasuresdesignedtooffsetthenumberofpeopleimpactedwilllikelydecreasethistoalessthansignificanteffect.Anyodorswouldbeveryshort‐lived.Dischargersandotherresponsiblepartieswilllikelyberequiredtomonitortheimplementationofcompliancemeasurestoensuretheyareworkingcorrectly.Ifodorswereoccurringfromimplementationofasettlingorfiltrationbasin,mitigationmeasures,suchasproperdesigntoeliminatestandingwater,covers,aeration,filters,barriers,and/orodorsuppressingchemicaladditives,wouldberequired.Compliancemeasuresthatcouldresultinstagnantwatershouldbeinspectedregularlytoensurethattreatmentdevicesarenotclogged,poolingwater,odorous,ormosquitovectors.
IV.BIOLOGICALRESOURCES‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Haveasubstantialadverseeffect,eitherdirectlyorthroughhabitatmodifications,onanyspeciesidentifiedasacandidate,
X
135StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
sensitive,orspecialstatusspeciesinlocalorregionalplans,policies,orregulations,orbytheCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandGameorU.S.FishandWildlifeService?b)Haveasubstantialadverseeffectonanyriparianhabitatorothersensitivenaturalcommunityidentifiedinlocalorregionalplans,policies,regulationsorbytheCaliforniaDepartmentofFishandGameorUSFishandWildlifeService?
X
c)HaveasubstantialadverseeffectonfederallyprotectedwetlandsasdefinedbySection404oftheCleanWaterAct(including,butnotlimitedto,marsh,vernalpool,coastal,etc.)throughdirectremoval,filling,hydrologicalinterruption,orothermeans?
X
d)Interferesubstantiallywiththemovementofanynativeresidentormigratoryfishorwildlifespeciesorwithestablishednativeresidentormigratorywildlifecorridors,orimpedetheuseofnativewildlifenurserysites?
X
e)Conflictwithanylocalpoliciesorordinancesprotectingbiologicalresources,suchasatreepreservationpolicyorordinance?
X
f)ConflictwiththeprovisionsofanadoptedHabitatConservationPlan,NaturalCommunityConservationPlan,orotherapprovedlocal,regional,orstatehabitatconservationplan?
X
136StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
BIOLOGICALRESOURCES:a)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporationDiscussion:Compliancemeasuresmayhaveapotentialimpactuponspeciesidentifiedasacandidate,sensitive,orspecialstatusspeciesinlocalorregionalplan,policiesorregulationsorbytheCDFWorUSFWSiftheyoccurinanareawheresuchspeciesarelocated.RiparianandwetlandcommunitieshavebeengreatlyreducedinsizewithinCaliforniawithwetlandlossesofupto91percentbyestimationoftheUSFishandWildlifeService(USFWS).Thus,suchhabitatswithintheregionareveryimportanttothemanyspeciestheysupport.Special‐statusspeciesarevulnerabletoanyhabitatlossordegradation.Theabilitytomovetootherhabitatthroughwildlifecorridorsisvitaltomanyterrestrialspecies.Modificationofexistingterrestrialhabitatintheprojectarea,especiallylimitedriparianandwetlandhabitat,wouldhavethepotentialtocauseadverseeffects.Compliancemeasurescouldpotentiallyhaveanimpactiftheyareimplementedinsensitiveareasorareasofcriticalhabitat.Wheninstallingstructuralcompliancemeasuresthatinvolvesubstantialearthmovingorriparianrestorationactivitiesthathavethepotentialtoaffectcandidate,sensitive,orspecialstatusspecies,projectproponentsarerequiredtoconsultwithfederal,stateandlocalagencies,includingbutnotlimitedtothecounty,CDFWandtheUSFWS.Projectproponentsmustensureprojectactionsavoid,minimizeand/ormitigateforimpactstorare,threatenedorendangeredspecies.Disturbancesassociatedwithdamdemolitionorhaulroadswhereclearing,grading,andstagingofequipmentoccurscouldhaveimpactsonsensitivehabitats,includingwetlandsandriparianhabitatsalongreservoirsandriverreaches.Heavymachinerytraversingwetlandandriparianareascouldchangelocaltopographyanddestroywetlandandriparianvegetation,andcouldintroducehazardousmaterialsthatwouldadverselyaffectwaterqualityinwetlandandriparianareas.Onceaprojectplanispreparedandconstructionareasaredelineated,measureswouldbeimplementedpriortoandduringconstructiontoavoidandmitigateimpactstosensitivevegetationcommunitiessuchaswetlands.Duringprojectlevelconstructionactivitiestoimplementcompliancemeasures,bothstructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasurescanbeimplementedtoavoid,minimizeormitigatepotentiallysignificantimpactstosensitivespecies.Forexample,wetlandswithin100feetofanygrounddisturbanceandconstruction‐relatedactivities(includingstagingandaccessroads)wouldbeclearlymarkedand/orfencedtoavoidimpactsfromconstructionequipmentandvehicles.Ifnew,temporaryaccessroadsarerequired,gradingwouldbeconductedsuchthatexistinghydrologywouldbemaintained.Inaddition,waterpollutioncontrolmeasuressuchaserosioncontrol,sedimentcontrol,andwastemanagementwouldbeimplemented
137StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
toavoidandminimizepotentialwaterqualityimpactsfrompollutedstormwaterrunofftostreams,wetlandsandriparianareas.Anotherexampleofavoidanceorminimizationincludesworkwindowrestrictiononstreamrestorationactivitiesfortheprotectionofseveralaquaticspecies.Additionally,aquaticecosystemcreation,restorationorenhancementprojectsareoftendesignedtoprovidecompensatorymitigationforimpactsthatcannotbeavoidedorminimized.Seesection9.4formoredetailonpotentialcompliancemeasuresthatcanalsobeimplementedasmitigationmeasurestoreduceimpactstobiologicalresources.Streamrestorationactionstoreduceerosion,removesediment,andimprovehabitatorriparianrestorationactionstoincreaseshademayconflictwiththerequirementsofcertainfloraorfauna.Specificexamplesincludelowlyingflorathatwouldbeoutcompetedintheriparianzonebytallershadeproducingtrees.Inmostcasesimpactscouldbeavoidedbyadjustingthetimingand/orlocationoftheactionstotakeintoaccountcandidate,sensitive,orspecialstatusspeciesortheirhabitats.Additionally,theTemperaturePolicyandActionsPlansrelyonsitepotentialconditionsandcase‐by‐casedeterminationsforimplementation.Therefore,conflictsbetweentheproposedTemperatureImplementationPolicy/ActionPlansandparticularspecieswouldberesolvedattheprojectlevel.MitigationmeasureswouldincludecollaborationbetweenwaterboardstaffandCDFWandUSFWSstafftoreachagreementonthemostsensitivebeneficialuse.
Substantialadverseeffectseitherdirectlyorthroughhabitatmodification,onanyspeciesidentifiedasacandidate,sensitiveorspecialstatusspeciesinlocalorregionalplans,policies,orregulations,orbytheCDFWorUSFWSarelessthansignificantwithmitigation.BIOLOGICALRESOURCES:b)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporationDiscussion:SubstantiallongtermadverseeffectsonanyriparianhabitatorothersensitivenaturalcommunityarenotexpectedbecausetheproposedPolicyandActionPlanrequiresprotectionofriparianareas,reductionofanthropogenicsourcesofsediment,andrecommendationstoallocatewaterrightsinamannerthatsupportallbeneficialuses.However,theimplementationofvariouscompliancemeasureshasthepotentialtoresultinshorttermadverseeffects.
Forexample,accordingtooneofthedamdecommissioningstudiesfortheKlamathRiverhydroelectricfacilities,approximately480acresofriparianareasurroundingthethreereservoirscouldbelostthroughdamremoval.Ifwetlandconstruction,watershed‐wideriparianprotectionandreplanting,andre‐vegetationoftheexposedreservoirsurfacesareappliedasmitigationmeasures,theimpactfromthelossofriparianhabitatfromthesesiteswilllikelybelessthansignificant(KlamathEIS/EIR,2012).
138StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Compliancemeasuresthatmaynothaveanimpactwhenimplementedinoneareacouldpotentiallyhaveanimpactiftheyareimplementedinasensitivearea.Therefore,wheninstallingstructuralBMPsthatmayincludesubstantialearthmovingorotheralterationtoriparianhabitat,riparianhabitatorothersensitivenaturalcommunitiesshouldbeavoided.Becauseofthesemitigationrequirements,substantialadverseeffectsarenotexpectedtooccureitherdirectlyorthroughhabitatmodifications,onanyspeciesidentifiedasacandidate,sensitiveorspecialstatusspeciesinlocalorregionalplans,policies,orregulations,orbytheCDFWorUSFWS.AsaresultoftheTemperaturePolicy,therecouldbeanincreaseinripariandiversionofsurfacewaterandgroundwaterifwateruserschoosetoutilizeriparianbasisofrightinadditiontoorinlieuofutilizinganappropriativewaterright.Increasedripariandiversioncouldreducesurfacewaterflowsinthespringandsummer,whicharecriticalperiodsforfishhabitat.AlthoughriparianwaterrightsdonotrequiretheStateWaterBoard’sapproval,theStateWaterBoardhastheauthoritytoregulateriparianrightsunderthereasonableusedoctrine.Aparticularwateruseormethodofdiversionmaybedeterminedtobeunreasonablebasedonitsimpactonfish,wildlife,orotherinstreambeneficialuses.(EnvironmentalDefenseFund,Inc.v.EastBayMunicipalUtilityDistrict(1980)26Cal.3d183[161Cal.Rptr.466].)TheStateWaterBoardalsohasanaffirmativedutytotakethepublictrustintoaccountintheplanningandallocationofwaterresources.Thepurposeofthepublictrustdoctrineistoprotectnavigation,fishing,recreation,environmentalvalues,andfishandwildlifehabitat.(NationalAudubonSocietyv.SuperiorCourt(1983)33Cal.3d419,434‐435[189Cal.Rptr.346].)Underthepublictrustdoctrine,theStateretainssupervisorycontroloverthenavigablewatersofthestateandthelandsunderlyingthosewaters.(Id.atp.445.)Inapplyingthepublictrustdoctrine,theStateWaterBoardhasthepowertoreconsiderpastwaterallocationseveniftheStateWaterBoardconsideredpublictrustimpactsinitsoriginalwaterallocationdecision.Thus,theStateWaterBoardmayexerciseitsauthorityunderthedoctrinesofreasonableuseandthepublictrusttoaddressreducedinstreamflowsinthepolicyareaandadverseeffectstofish,wildlife,orotherinstreambeneficialusesduetoripariandiversions.Thepotentialimpactsarelessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.BIOLOGICALRESOURCES:c)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:Allactivitiesinfederallyprotectedwetlands,exceptthosestatutoryexemptionlikeagricultural,requiretheresponsiblepartytoobtainaCleanWaterAct(CWA)Section404permitfromtheArmyCorpsofEngineersandaCWASection
139StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
401WaterQualityCertification.Thesepermitsmustincludeconditionsthatensurethatallwaterqualityobjectivesforthewetlandareprotected.Disturbancesassociatedwithdamdemolitionorhaulroadswhereclearing,grading,andstagingofequipmentoccurscouldhaveimpactsonsensitivehabitats,includingwetlandsandriparianhabitatsalongreservoirsandriverreaches.Heavymachinerytraversingwetlandandriparianareascouldchangelocaltopographyanddestroywetlandandriparianvegetation,andcouldintroducehazardousmaterialsthatwouldadverselyaffectwaterqualityinwetlandandriparianareas.However,onceaprojectlevelplanispreparedandconstructionareasaredelineated,measureswouldbeimplementedpriortoandduringconstructiontoavoid,minimizeandmitigateimpactstosensitivevegetationcommunitiessuchaswetlands.Duringprojectlevelimplementationofcompliancemeasures,bothstructuralandnon‐structuralBMPscanbeusedtoavoid,minimizeormitigatepotentiallysignificantimpactstosensitivespecies.BMPsavoidandminimizeimpactstowetlandsbyidentifyingconstructionbufferstolimitaccesstowetlandsneartheconstructionarea.Forwetlandsthataretemporarilyorpermanentlyimpacted,compensatorymitigationrequirementswillberequired,implementedandmonitoredforsuccessunderstateandfederallaw.Inaddition,ifnewtemporaryaccessroadsarerequiredforconstructionordemolition,gradingwouldbeconductedsuchthatexistinghydrologywouldbemaintained.Also,BMPswouldbeimplementedtoaddresspotentialwaterqualityimpactsfrompollutedstormwaterrunofftostreams,wetlandsandriparianareas.Therefore,thisisalessthansignificantimpactwithmitigationincorporated.BIOLOGICALRESOURCES:d)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:ThemajorityoftheNorthCoastriversandtheirtributariesprovidehabitat,includingthemigration,forbothnativeresidentandmigratoryfish.Amigratorycorridorisgenerallydescribedasalandscapefeature(suchasaridgeline,canyon,streamorriparianstrip)withinalargernaturalhabitatareathatisusedfrequentlybyanimalstofacilitatemovementandprovideaccesstonecessaryresourcessuchaswater,food,ordensites.Wildlifecorridorsaregenerallyanareaofhabitat,usuallylinearinnature,whichconnecttwoormorehabitatpatchesthatwouldotherwisebefragmentedorisolatedfromoneanother.Mostofthecompliancemeasureswilllikelynotinterferewiththemovementofthesespecies.Althoughdamremovalwouldultimatelyresultingreatermovementforspawningfish,significantadverseeffectsonfishmovementcouldoccuratleasttemporarilyunlessappropriatemitigationisimplementedtolimitthedurationofincreasedturbidlyassociatedwithdamremovalandthedecommissioningactivitiesaretimedtoprotectthemostsensitivespecies/lifestages.
140StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
CompliancemeasuresandBMPssuchasriparianfencing(forcattleexclusion),siltfenceandstrawwattles(forsedimentcontrol)havebeenknowntoentraporentangleterrestrialwildlife(suchaselkanddeer)aswellassomeaquaticspecies(salamanders)andreptiles(snakes).Somespecificareasaremorepronetocreatingbarrierstowildlifeandcanbestbedealtwithonacase‐by‐casebasis.Ifthereisapotentialforanadverseimpacttowildlifemigrationand/oruseofanativewildlifenursery,thetimingofthedischarge,thelocationorthetypeofthecompliancemeasurecanbechangedtoavoidorminimizetheimpacttolessthansignificantlevels.Forexamplerotationalgrazingpracticesandhotwirefencesarealternativestoexclusionaryfencingthathavethepotentialtoimpedewildlifemigration.Anotherexampleisconcentratingeffortsonerosioncontrolmethodstoavoidusingsiltfencesinsensitiveareas.Additionally,naturalfiberstrawwaddleswithoutplasticnettingareavailabletouseasalternativestosedimentcontroltechnologiesthatmaybeamigrationbarrier.Basedonthesitespecificsituation,thecase‐by‐caseflexibilityassociatedwiththeTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansandtheavoidance,minimization,andmitigationmeasuresassociatedwithaparticularproject,thepotentialimpactsarelessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.BIOLOGICALRESOURCES:e)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:Compliancemeasuresencourageriparianprotectionthroughthedevelopmentoflocalizedpoliciesandordinancesarenotexpectedtoconflictwithordinancesprotectingbiologicalresources,suchasatreepreservationpolicy.BIOLOGICALRESOURCES:f)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:ItisunlikelythattheimplementationofcompliancemeasureswouldconflictwiththeprovisionsofanadoptedHabitatConservationPlan(HCP),NaturalCommunityConservationPlan(NCCP)orotherapprovedlocal,regional,orstatehabitatconservationplan.Morelikelythecompliancemeasureswouldbesimilartomeasuresalreadycommittedtounderthesetypesofplans.SuchsimilaritiesarelikelytoensurethatcompliancemeasuresareinalignmentwithanyadoptedHCP,NCCPorotherapprovedlocal,regional,orstatehabitatconservationplan.Insomerareinstancesitcouldbepossiblethatalowlyingspecialstatusspecieswithanassociatedconservationplancouldbepresentintheriparianzonethatcouldaccommodatelargertreestoproduceshade.However,thelargershadeproducingvegetationmayoutcompeteoradverselyaffectthatspecialstatusspecies.TheseinstancesarelikelysparseandsincetheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansaretobeimplementedcase‐by‐casethesetypesofdiscrepanciescanbehandledattheprojectorpermitlevelthroughagencycollaborationandsoastopreventsignificantimpactontheenvironment.
141StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
V.CULTURALRESOURCES‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Causeasubstantialadversechangeinthesignificanceofahistoricalresourceasdefinedin§15064.5?
X
b)Causeasubstantialadversechangeinthesignificanceofanarchaeologicalresourcepursuantto§15064.5?
X
c)Directlyorindirectlydestroyauniquepaleontologicalresourceorsiteoruniquegeologicfeature?
X
d)Disturbanyhumanremains,includingthoseinterredoutsideofformalcemeteries?
X
CULTURALRESOURCES:a),b)andd)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:Itisunlikelythatthemajorityofcompliancemeasureswouldcauseasubstantialadversechangeinthesignificanceofahistoricalorarchaeologicalresourcepursuanttosection15064.5.TheimplementationofcompliancemeasuresasrecommendedundertheproposedBasinPlanamendmentwouldnotresultinthealterationofasignificanthistoricalorarchaeologicalresourceunlessthatresourcewasotherwiseimpairingflows,causingexcessiveerosionorlimitingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade.However,incaseswheretheinstallationofstructuralcompliancemeasuresmayinvolvelargescaleexcavationactivitiesortheconstructionofalargescaleinfrastructure,aculturalresourcesinvestigationshouldbeconductedbeforeanysubstantialdisturbance.Theculturalresourcesinvestigationwillinclude,ataminimum,arecordssearchforpreviouslyidentifiedculturalresourcesandpreviouslyconductedculturalresourcesinvestigationsoftheprojectparcelandvicinity.AllfutureactionsmustcomplywiththeCEQAprocessandrequirementsfortribalconsultationprovidedbySenateBill18(SB18)(State2004,Ch905)andGovernmentCodesection65252.Intheeventthatavoidanceisinfeasible,thefutureprojectswillberequiredtofollowNativeAmericanHeritageCommission’smandateforNativeAmericanHumanBurialsandSkeletalRemains,inpartnershipwithaffectedtribe(s),inordertoadequatelyprovideforrecoveringscientificallyconsequentialinformationforthesite.Intheeventthatthegrounddisturbancesorreservoirdrawdownsuncover
142StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
previouslyundiscoveredordocumentedresources,CalifornialawprotectsNativeAmericanburials,skeletalremains,andassociatedgravegoodsregardlessoftheantiquityandprovidesforthesensitivetreatmentanddispositionofthoseremains.(Health&SafetyCode,Section7050.5;PublicResourceCode,Section5097.9etseq)Thisrecordsearchshouldalsoinclude,ataminimum,contactingtheappropriateinformationcenteroftheCaliforniaHistoricalResourcesInformationSystem,operatedundertheauspicesoftheCaliforniaOfficeofHistoricPreservation.Incoordinationwiththeinformationcenteroraqualifiedarchaeologist,adeterminationregardingwhetherpreviouslyidentifiedculturalresourceswillbeaffectedbytheproposedprojectmustbemadeandifpreviouslyconductedinvestigationswereperformedtosatisfytherequirementsofCEQA.Ifnot,aculturalresourcessurveywouldneedtobeconducted.Thepurposeofthisinvestigationwouldbetoidentifyresourcesbeforetheyareaffectedbyaproposedprojectandavoidtheimpact.Ifresourcesareidentifiedsite‐specificimplementationwillminimizeimpacts.Evenwithsuchmeasuresincorporated,impactsmaystillbepotentiallysignificantandunavoidable.CULTURALRESOURCES:c)LessThanSignificantImpactDiscussion:Theimplementationofcompliancemeasureswouldnotdirectlyorindirectlydestroyauniquepaleontologicalresourceorsiteoruniquegeologicfeature.Non‐structuralBMPswillnotresultinthedirectorindirectdestructionofauniquepaleontologicalresourceorsiteoruniquegeologicfeature.
Similarly,itisunlikelythatimplementationofanystructuralBMPwouldresultinthedestructionofauniquepaleontologicalresourceorsiteoruniquegeologicfeature.However,incaseswheretheinstallationofstructuralBMPsmayinvolveexcavationactivities,aninvestigationofpaleontologicalresourceswouldneedtobeconductedbyatrainedprofessionalbeforeanysubstantialdisturbanceoflandthathasnotbeendisturbedpreviously.VI.GEOLOGYANDSOILS‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Exposepeopleorstructurestopotentialsubstantialadverseeffects,includingtheriskofloss,injury,ordeathinvolving:
i)Ruptureofaknownearthquakefault,asdelineatedonthemostrecentAlquist‐PrioloEarthquakeFaultZoning
X
143StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
MapissuedbytheStateGeologistfortheareaorbasedonothersubstantialevidenceofaknownfault?RefertoDivisionofMinesandGeologySpecialPublication42.ii)Strongseismicgroundshaking?
X
iii)Seismic‐relatedgroundfailure,includingliquefaction?
X
iv)Landslides? X b)Resultinsubstantialsoilerosionorthelossoftopsoil?
X
c)Belocatedonageologicunitorsoilthatisunstable,orthatwouldbecomeunstableasaresultoftheproject,andpotentiallyresultinon‐oroffsitelandslide,lateralspreading,subsidence,liquefactionorcollapse?
X
d)Belocatedonexpansivesoil,asdefinedinTable18‐1‐BoftheUniformBuildingCode(1994),creatingsubstantialriskstolifeorproperty?
X
e)Havesoilsincapableofadequatelysupportingtheuseofseptictanksoralternativewastewaterdisposalsystemswheresewersarenotavailableforthedisposalofwastewater?
X
GEOLOGYANDSOILS:a)(iv),b)andc)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationCompliancemeasuresdonotchangetheexposureofpeopleorstructurestopotentialsubstantialadverseeffectsinvolvinglandslidesovercurrentconditions.ThegeographicscopeoftheactivitiescoveredundertheproposedBasinPlanamendmentwillincludeareasthatarehighlysusceptibletosoilerosionandshallowlandslidesduetothepresenceofsteepslopes,highrainfallrates,and/orunderlyinggeology.Amajorfocusofthesedimentcontrolactionsandinexistingregulationensureproperroaddrainage,surfacesoilstability,andfullvegetationpotentialwhichreducessoilerosion,andcanreduceorpreventlarge‐scaleslopeandfillfailures.
144StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ImplementationofcompliancemeasuresmayresultinminortemporarysoilexcavationordisturbanceduringimplementationofcompliancemeasuresthatinvolveconstructionofstructuralBMPssuchasroaddrainageinstallation,fieldlevelingforirrigationmanagementorinstallationofoffchannelstockwateringponds.Constructionrelatederosionimpactsshouldceasewiththecessationofconstructionactivity.Asaresultofthecorrectimplementationandmaintenanceofcompliancemeasuresoutlinedinsection9.4.2thepotentialforincreasedsoilerosion,lossoftopsoilorlandslidesislessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.GEOLOGYANDSOILS:a)(i,iiandiii),d)ande)NoImpactNoneofthecompliancemeasureswouldresultinanyadverseimpactrelatedtofaultzones,liquefactionorotherseismicrelatedactivity.Norwoulditresultinanylateralspreading,subsidence,liquefaction,orcollapse.EvenifstructuralBMPsthatwererecommendedwerelocatedonexpansivesoil,asdefinedinTable18‐1‐BoftheUniformBuildingCode(1994),theywouldnotcreatesubstantialriskstolifeorproperty.ThestructuralBMPsthathavebeenidentifiedastheforeseeablemeansofcompliancedonotinvolvemovingpermanentstructuresorpeopleintoanewarea,andsotherewouldbenorisktolifeorpropertycreated.Inaddition,theproposedBasinPlanamendment(andtheidentifiedcompliancemeasures)willnotresultinanyimpactsfromseptictanksoralternativewastewaterdisposalsystems.
VII.GREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONS–Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)GenerateGreenhousegasemissions,eitherdirectlyorindirectly,thatmayhaveasignificantimpactontheenvironment?
X
b)Conflictwithanapplicableplan,policyorregulationadoptedforthepurposeofreducingtheemissionsofgreenhousegases?
X
GREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONS:a)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:Adoptionofthepolicyitselfwillnotcauseadirectimpacttogreenhousegases(GHGs).Implementationofthecompliancemeasuresattheprojectlevelcouldresultsinanincreaseriskorcontributiontogreenhousegases
145StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
relatedtoexhaustandequipmentfromvehiclesduringconstructionactivitiessuchasrestorationandalternatewatersupplyconstruction.Inthecaseofdamremoval,emissionsfromreplacementpowersourceswilllikelycauseasignificantandunavoidableimpactfromGHGemissionsuntilPacifiCorpcanaddnewsourcesorrenewablepowertocompensateforthelossofthehydroelectricfacilities.GREENHOUSEGASEMISSIONS:b)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:Compliancemeasurescouldconflictwithanapplicableplan,projectorregulationofanagencyadoptedforthepurposeofreducingtheemissionsofgreenhousegases.However,thisprojectwillbeconsistentwiththeStateWaterBoardResolutionNo.2008‐0030whichdirectsWaterBoardstaffsto“require…climatechangeconsiderations,inallfuturepolicies,guidelines,andregulatoryactions.”Also,theproposedBasinPlanamendmentisintendedtoconformwiththegoalsofAssemblyBill(AB)32(States,2005,ch488).AB32requiresthatGHGemissionsbereducedto1990levelsby2020.ThisrequirementrelatestoanthropogenicsourcesofGHGs.ImpactassociatedwithindividualprojectswillbeanalyzedandappropriatemitigationimplementedtoreduceGHGs.
VIII.HAZARDSANDHAZARDOUSMATERIALS‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Createasignificanthazardtothepublicortheenvironmentthroughtheroutinetransport,use,ordisposalofhazardousmaterials?
X
b)Createasignificanthazardtothepublicortheenvironmentthroughreasonablyforeseeableupsetandaccidentconditionsinvolvingthereleaseofhazardousmaterialsintotheenvironment?
X
c)Emithazardousemissionsorhandlehazardousoracutelyhazardousmaterials,substances,orwastewithinone‐quartermileofanexistingorproposedschool?
X
d)Belocatedonasitewhichisincludedonalistofhazardous
X
146StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
materialssitescompiledpursuanttoGovernmentCodeSection65962.5and,asaresult,woulditcreateasignificanthazardtothepublicortheenvironment?e)Foraprojectlocatedwithinanairportlanduseplanor,wheresuchaplanhasnotbeenadopted,withintwomilesofapublicairportorpublicuseairport,wouldtheprojectresultinasafetyhazardforpeopleresidingorworkingintheprojectarea?
X
f)Foraprojectwithinthevicinityofaprivateairstrip,wouldtheprojectresultinasafetyhazardforpeopleresidingorworkingintheprojectarea?
X
g)Impairimplementationoforphysicallyinterferewithanadoptedemergencyresponseplanoremergencyevacuationplan?
X
h)Exposepeopleorstructurestoasignificantriskofloss,injuryordeathinvolvingwildlandfires,includingwherewildlandsareadjacenttourbanizedareasorwhereresidencesareintermixedwithwildlands?
X
HAZARDSANDHAZARDOUSMATERIALS:a)andb)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:RoadrepairandmaintenancecaninvolvethetransportanduseofmaterialsthatwouldqualifyashazardouspursuanttotheCaliforniaHealthandSafetyCodesection25501(o).Thereisthepossibilitythathazardousmaterialsmaybetransportedtoasiteandbepresentduringcompliancemeasureconstruction,installationandmaintenanceactivities.Thesematerialsincludegasolineanddieseltofuelequipment,hydraulicfluidassociatedwithequipmentoperationsandmachinery,asphaltandoilsforroadsurfacing,andsurfacestabilizers(e.g.lignin)forrunningsurfacesonunimprovedroads.Maintenanceyardshousefuel,oil
147StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
(machine,hydraulic,crankcase),chemicals(acids,solvents°reasers,corrosives,antifreeze),hazardouswaste,heavymetals,nutrients,fertilizer,pesticides,herbicides,paintproducts,andsediments.Maintenanceyardactivitieshavethepotentialtodischargethesematerialstostormwaterdrainsystemsorwatercourses.SomeBMPsspecificallytargetproperstorageofthesetypesofmaterials.Dustpalliativesandde‐icingagentsmaybeusedinsomeinstancesbutthesematerialsproperlyappliedaccordingtoBMPsarenotconsideredhazardousmaterials.Compliancemeasureswouldhavethepotentialforasignificanthazardtothepublicortheenvironmentthroughtheroutinetransport,useordisposalofhazardousmaterials.Inordertomitigatethepotentialadverseeffects,pollutionpreventionandwastemanagementBMPsshouldbeusedintheimplementationofcompliancemeasures.Existingregulationsrequiretheproperstorage,handlinganduseofthesetypesofmaterials.TheU.S.ForestService,CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,FiveCountiesSalmonidConservationProgramintheCountiesofDelNorte,Humboldt,Mendocino,Siskiyou,andTrinityintheNorthCoastRegion,CaliforniaAssociationofStormWaterQuality,arejustafewoftheexamplesofexitingmanualsthatprovidenumerouspollutionpreventionandwastemanagementBMPs.Manyofthesemanualsincludemeasurestobetakenintheeventofaspill.Intheeventofanaccident,responsiblepartiesmustcomplywiththerequirementsoftheCaliforniaEmergencyManagementAgencyHazardousMaterialsSpillreportingprocess.AnysignificantreleaseorthreatenedreleaseofahazardousmaterialrequiresimmediatereportingbytheresponsiblepersontotheCalEMAStateWarningCenter(800)852‐7550andtheCertifiedUnifiedProgramAgency(CUPA)or911.TheCUPAmaydesignateacallto911asmeetingtherequirementtocallthem.Contactinformationforajurisdiction’sCUPAcanbefoundat:http://cersapps.calepa.ca.gov/Public/Directory/orhttp://cersapps.calepa.ca.gov/Public/UPAListing.NotifyingtheStateWarningCenter(800)852‐7550andtheCUPAor911constitutescompliancewiththerequirementsofsection11004oftitle42oftheUnitedStatesCoderegardingverbalnotificationoftheSERCandLEPC(CaliforniaCodeofRegulations,Title19Section2703(e)).Additionalinformationregardingspillreportingmaybefoundat:http://www.calema.ca.gov/HazardousMaterials/Pages/Spill‐Release‐Reporting.aspxAnyhazardouswastegeneratedfromthedemolitionofdamsandanyassociatedhydroelectricfacilitieswouldneedtobedisposedofindesignatedhazardouswastelandfills.Thiswouldincludetreatedwoodwaste,PCBspresentintransformersandotherelectricalequipment,asbestosinbuildingmaterials,fuelsandoils,concretedust(ifitgenerateshighpHwaste)andsoilsorothermaterialcontaminatedwithleadfromtheuseoflead‐basedpaint.Incorporatingasuiteofmitigationmeasureswillreducethepotentialimpactstolessthansignificant.
148StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Anyblastingactivitieswouldneedtobeconductedbyalicensedprofessionalandmitigationmeasuresclearlydescribedinthedamdecommissioningplan,includingatransportationplanfortheexplosivematerials.Ataminimum,thesemeasuresshouldinclude,allnon‐essentialworkersbeingprohibitedfromenteringthesiteandstationeddownwindatasafedistanceawayfromblastingoperations.BasedontheexistingregulationsandBMPsavailabletouseinconjunctionwithselectedcompliancemeasures,thepotentialimpactfromtheproposedBasinPlanamendmentislessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.HAZARDSANDHAZARDOUSMATERIALS:c)andd)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:Compliancemeasureswouldnotemithazardousemissionsorresultinthehandlingofhazardousoracutelyhazardousmaterials,substances,orwastewithinone‐quartermileofanexistingorproposedschool.Again,thereisthepossibilitythathazardousmaterials(e.g.,oil,gasoline)maybepresentduringconstructionandinstallationactivities,butpotentialrisksofexposurewouldbesmall,especiallywithproperhandlingandstorageprocedures.Allrisksofexposurewouldbeshorttermandwouldbeeliminatedwiththecompletionofconstructionandinstallationactivities.HAZARDSANDHAZARDOUSMATERIALS:e),f),g)andh)NoImpactDiscussion:Compliancemeasureswouldnotresultintheemissionorhandlingofhazardousoracutelyhazardousmaterials,substances,orwastewithinone‐quartermileofanexistingorproposedschool,norisitlocatedonasitewhichisincludedonalistofhazardousmaterialssitescompiledpursuanttoGovernmentCodesection65962.5.Theproposedprojectwouldnotexposepeopleorstructurestoasignificantriskofloss,injuryordeathinvolvingwildlandfires,includingwherewildlandsareadjacenttourbanizedareasorwhereresidencesareintermixedwithwildlands.Therefore,thereisnoimpact.IX.HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Violateanywaterqualitystandardsorwastedischargerequirements?
X
b)Substantiallydepletegroundwatersuppliesorinterferesubstantiallywithgroundwaterrechargesuchthattherewouldbeanetdeficitinaquifervolumeoraloweringof
X
149StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
thelocalgroundwatertablelevel(e.g.,theproductionrateofpre‐existingnearbywellswoulddroptoalevelwhichwouldnotsupportexistinglandusesorplannedusesforwhichpermitshavebeengranted)?c)Substantiallyaltertheexistingdrainagepatternofthesiteorarea,includingthroughthealterationofthecourseofastreamorriver,inamannerwhichwouldresultinsubstantialerosionorsiltationon‐oroff‐site?
X
d)Substantiallyaltertheexistingdrainagepatternofthesiteorarea,includingthroughthealterationofthecourseofastreamorriver,orsubstantiallyincreasetherateoramountofsurfacerunoffinamannerwhichwouldresultinfloodingon‐oroffsite?
X
e)Createorcontributerunoffwaterwhichwouldexceedthecapacityofexistingorplannedstormwaterdrainagesystemsorprovidesubstantialadditionalsourcesofpollutedrunoff?
X
f)Otherwisesubstantiallydegradewaterquality?
X
g)Placehousingwithina100‐yearfloodhazardareaasmappedonafederalFloodHazardBoundaryorFloodInsuranceRateMaporotherfloodhazarddelineationmap?
X
h)Placewithina100‐yearfloodhazardareastructureswhichwouldimpedeorredirectfloodflows?
X
i)Exposepeopleorstructurestoasignificantriskofloss,injuryordeathinvolvingflooding,
X
150StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
includingfloodingasaresultofthefailureofaleveeordam?j)Inundationbyseiche,tsunami,ormudflow?
X
HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY:a)PotentiallySignificantDiscussion:Byrequiringtheimplementationofcompliancemeasurestopreserveandmaintainshade,controlsediment,andmaintainstreamflowssupportiveofbeneficialuses,theproposedBasinPlanamendmentwillhaveanoverallbeneficialimpactonwaterqualityintheNorthCoastRegion.Therearespecialcircumstances,however,underwhichpotentialsignificantimpactscouldoccur.Forexample,theprimaryenvironmentalimpactassociatedwithdamremovalistheshorttermimpacttowaterqualityfromthereleaseofthestoredin‐reservoirsediment.Damdecommissioningwillresultintemporaryincreasesinturbidity,suspendedsedimentloadandreductionofdissolvedoxygen,whichwilllikelyexceedBasinPlanwaterqualityobjectives.Shorttermwaterqualityexceedancesmaybeacceptableincaseswherelongtermbenefitstobebeneficialusesoutweighshorttermimpacts,basedondetailed,site‐specificinformationandfindings.HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY:b)PotentiallySignificantDiscussion:TheproposedBasinPlanamendmentidentifiesthealterationofthenaturalpatternandrangeofsurfacewaterflowsasacontrollablefactorwithrespecttoambientwatertemperatures.Alterationofawaterrightasaresultofthispolicycouldresultinsomeprojectproponentsseekingalternativewatersources.Inaddition,surfacewatersuppliesmaybeinsufficienttomeetallfuturedemandsevenintheabsenceoftheproposedBasinPlanamendment.SurfacewaterresourcesarealreadylimitedinsomeregionsoftheNorthCoastRegionandfuturewatersuppliesinthoseareaswillbelimitedbythenaturalsupplyavailabilityratherthanrestrictionsonwaterdiversionandstorage.Somestreamsintheregionarealreadyfullyappropriatedforsomeoralloftheyear.Pumpinggroundwaterinsteadofdivertingsurfacewatercouldpotentiallydepletegroundwaterresources,whichcouldpotentiallyresultinareductioninsurfacewaterflows,particularlysummerflows,whichcouldaffectsurfacewaterflows.Reducedsurfacewaterflowcouldpotentiallyharmriparianvegetationordegradehabitatforsensitivespecies;couldpotentiallyadverselyaffectwatertemperatureandincreaseconstituentconcentrationsduetoreduceddilution;andcouldpotentiallyadverselyaffectrecreationalopportunities.Dependingonthecircumstances,switchingfromsurfacewaterdiversionstogroundwaterpumpingordivertingwaterunderriparianrightscouldhavea
151StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
significantadverseimpactonbiologicalresources,waterquality,orrecreation.Asdiscussedbelow,however,thepossibleeffectsofauserswitchingfromasurfacewaterdiversiontoagroundwaterdiversionaredependentonawiderangeofvariables,andthereforeitishighlyuncertainwhetheranyparticularuserwhomayswitchtogroundwaterwillcauseadelayinsurfacewaterflowdepletion,whetheranysuchdelaywillcauseasignificantreductioninsurfacewaterflows,orwhetheranydelayedreductioninflowswillhaveasignificantadverseimpactontheenvironment.Surfacewaterflowdepletionmaycontinueaftergroundwaterpumpingstopsbecauseittakestimeforgroundwaterlevelstorecoverfromthepreviouspumpingstressandforthedepletedaquiferdefinedbytheconeofdepressiontoberechargedwithwater.Thereforethetimeofmaximumstreamdepletionmayoccurafterpumpinghasstopped.Eventually,theaquiferandstreammayreturntotheirpre‐pumpingconditions,butthetimerequiredforfullrecoverymaybequitelongandexceedthetotaltimethatthewellwaspumped.Anytimedelaymayrangefromafewdaysinthezoneadjacenttothestreamtothousandsofyearsforwaterthatmovesfromthecentralpartofsomerechargeareasthroughdeeperpartsofthegroundwatersystem(Heath,1983).Thelevelofsignificanceforapotentialimpacttohydrology/wateryqualityattributabletoadelayinsurfacewaterflowdepletionasaresultofdivertersswitchingtogroundwaterpumpingorriparianrightsisdependentonsitespecificcircumstances.Inlightofthefactthattheswitchtogroundwaterorripariandiversionsasalternativesourcesofsupplyispossiblethepotentialimpactstohydrologyandwaterqualityaresignificantandunavoidable.HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY:c)PotentiallySignificantDiscussion:Thisstaffreporthasidentifiedanumberofcompliancemeasuresthatcouldresultintheconstructionofstructuralcompliancemeasures,suchasinfiltrationbasins,fieldlevelingorroadconstruction,bioengineeringandin‐streamrestorationwhichcouldpotentiallycauseanalterationoftheexistingdrainagepatternofasite.Inmostcaseshowever,thesemeasureswouldbesmallandinstalledwithappropriatelydesignedmitigationmeasures,whichwouldlimitanyalterationoftheexistingdrainagepatternunlessbeneficialtotheenvironment,andthereforewouldnotresultinsubstantialerosionofsiltationon‐oroff‐site.TheexceptionwouldbeintheeventofdamdecommissioningsuchashasbeenproposedfortheKlamathRiverhydroelectricfacilities.ThegreatestimpactsfromerosionorsiltationassociatedwiththedecommissioningofthedamsKlamathwouldbeduringdrawingdownofthereservoirwaterlevel.However,onceanewchannelwasestablished,theerosionofthein‐reservoirsedimentwoulddissipate.Impactsthatcauseerosionorsiltationarepotentiallysignificantandunavoidable.
152StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY:h)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:ItispossiblethatcompliancewiththeproposedBasinPlanamendmentwouldplacestructureswithina100‐yearfloodhazardareawhichcouldimpedeorredirectfloodflows.Forexample,switchingfromanin‐streamdiversiontooff‐streamstoragecouldresultinastructurebeingplacedwithinthefloodplain.However,itisintheseinstancesthatcoordinationwithprojectproponentsandotheragenciesisbestsuitedtoreducepotentiallysignificantimpacts.Ideally,thesetypesofconversionswouldbesubjecttoanindividualCEQAanalysisandwouldbeimplementedinamannerthatavoid,minimizeormitigatespotentialsignificantimpacts.Aspresentedinsection9.4.3,mitigationmeasuresincludeproperdesign,siting,andoperationaltimingtoreducealterationsofnaturalhydrologyandadverseeffects.Althoughthereisapossibilitythatthesetypesofcompliancemeasurescouldcauseanadverseimpact,anypotentiallysignificantimpactswillbeavoidedormitigatedtolessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY:d)e),f),andi)LessThanSignificant
Discussion:Anumberofcompliancemeasurescouldresultintheconstructionofinfiltrationbasins,fieldlevelingorroadconstruction,bioengineeringandin‐streamrestorationeachofthesehavethepotentialtocauseanalterationoftheexistingdrainagepatternofasite.Inmostcaseshowever,thesemeasureswouldbesmallandbeinstalledwithappropriatelydesignedmitigationmeasuressuchasthosepresentedthroughoutsection9.4,soastoreducethealterationsoftheexistingdrainagepatterninamannerwhichwouldresultinapotentialforfloodingon‐oroff‐site.
TheRegionalWaterBoardimplementstheNPDESprogramforstormwaterintheNorthCoastRegion.StaffimplementingthisproposedBasinPlanamendmentwillconsultwithstormwaterstafftoensurethatnopermittedprojectsresultintheconcentrationofrunoffthatwouldexceedthatcapacityofplannedstormwaterfacilitiesorresultinadditionalsourcesofpollutedrunoff.Noneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisstaffreportcontemplatetheuseofnon‐structuralorstructuralBMPsthatwouldexposepeopleorstructurestoasignificantriskofloss,injuryordeathinvolvingflooding,includingfloodingasaresultofthefailureofaleveeordam.HYDROLOGYANDWATERQUALITY:g)andj)NoImpactDiscussion:Noneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisstaffreportwouldplacehousingwithina100‐yearfloodhazardareaasmappedonafederalFloodHazardBoundaryorFloodInsuranceRateMaporotherfloodhazarddelineationmap.Staffhasdeterminedthatthisfindingisstillappropriateevenunderadam
153StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
decommissioningscenarioasthedamswerenotdesignednoroperatedasfloodcontrolstructures.AssuchtheirultimatelyremovalwouldnotsignificantimpacthousingwithafloodareaasdescribedaboveNoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisstaffreportcontemplatetheuseofnon‐structuralorstructuralBMPsthatwouldcauseinundationbyseiche,tsunami,ormudflow.X.LANDUSEANDPLANNING‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Physicallydivideanestablishedcommunity?
X
b)Conflictwithanyapplicablelanduseplan,policy,orregulationofanagencywithjurisdictionovertheproject(including,butnotlimitedtothegeneralplan,specificplan,localcoastalprogram,orzoningordinance)adoptedforthepurposeofavoidingormitigatinganenvironmentaleffect?
X
c)Conflictwithanyapplicablehabitatconservationplanornaturalcommunityconservationplan?
X
LANDUSEANDPLANNING:a)NoImpactDiscussion:NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofnon‐structuralorstructuralBMPsthatwouldphysicallydivideanestablishedcommunity.LANDUSEANDPLANNING:b)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:TheprimarygoalofthisprojectistheprotectionandrestorationofwaterqualityandbeneficialusesofwaterintheNorthCoastRegion.OneofthestaffactionsintheproposedBasinPlanamendmentistoprovidecities,counties,andstateandfederalagenciesguidanceandrecommendationsoncompliance.
154StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Additionally,theproposedamendmentdirectsstafftoworkwithlocalgovernmentstodevelopstrategiestoaddresstheprevention,reduction,andmitigationofelevatedwatertemperatures,including,butnotlimitedto,riparianordinances,generalplans,andothermanagementpolicies.Therefore,itisunlikelythatcompliancewiththeproposedBasinPlanamendmentwouldconflictwithanyapplicablelanduseplan,policy,orregulationofanagencywithjurisdictionovertheproject(including,butnotlimitedtothegeneralplan,specificplan,localcoastalprogram,orzoningordinance)adoptedforthepurposeofavoidingormitigatinganenvironmentaleffectandtheappropriatefindingislessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.LANDUSEANDPLANNING:c)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:Dependingonthestructuralcompliancemeasuresselected,directorindirectimpactstoexistingfishorwildlifehabitatmayoccur;however,anysuchimpactwouldbetemporary.Compliancemeasuresthatmaynothaveanimpactwhenimplementedinoneareacouldpotentiallyhaveanimpactiftheyareimplementedinasensitivearea.Forinstancetheconstructionofacompliancemeasuresuchasanoff‐channelwaterstoragefacilitycouldbelocatedinanidentifiedhabitconservationarea.Therefore,wheninstallingstructuralcompliancethatmayincludesubstantialearthmovement,responsiblepartieswillberequiredundertheirapplicablepermit(orasnecessarytocomplywithapplicableprohibitions),toconsultwithvariousFederal,Stateandlocalagencies,includingbutnotlimitedtothecountytheprojectislocatedin,CDFGandtheUSFWS.TypicallyRegionalWaterBoardstaffworkwithotheragenciesandprojectproponentsonthedevelopmentofHabitatConservationPlan(HCP)orNaturalCommunityConservationPlan(NCCP)toensurecompliancewithallregulations.IfappropriatetoavoidconflictswithanyHCPorNCCP,thetimingand/orlocationoftheBMPsmaybeadjustedtoreduceanypotentialconflictwithanysuchplans.If,however,suchadjustmentscouldnotbemade,thecompliancemeasureswouldhavetobechangedtoavoidanyadverseimpactstorare,threatenedorendangeredspecies,orthedischargewouldnotbepermittedtooccur.Becauseofthesemitigationrequirements,conflictwiththeprovisionsofanadoptedHCPorNCCPisnotlikelytooccur.Thereforetheappropriatefindingislessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.XI.MINERALRESOURCES‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Resultinthelossof X
155StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
availabilityofaknownmineralresourcethatwouldbeofvaluetotheregionandtheresidentsofthestate?b)Resultinthelossofavailabilityofalocallyimportantmineralresourcerecoverysitedelineatedonalocalgeneralplan,specificplanorotherlanduseplan?
X
MINERALRESOURCES:a)andb)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofnon‐structuralorstructuralBMPsthatwouldresultinthelossofavailabilityofaknownmineralresourcethatwouldbeofvaluetotheregionandtheresidentsofthestateorthelossofavailabilityofalocally‐importantmineralresourcerecoverysitedelineatedonalocalgeneralplan,specificplanorotherlanduseplan.Itispossiblethataccesstocertainareasforgravel,goldorothermineralextractionactivitiescouldbeaffectedbycompliancemeasuressuchasriparianbuffers,orareasofexclusionorstreambankstabilizationprojects.Whilepossible,thesemanagementmeasuresareunlikelytobaraccesscompletely.Therefore,theappropriatefindingislessthansignificant.XII.NOISE‐‐Wouldtheprojectresultin: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Exposureofpersonstoorgenerationofnoiselevelsinexcessofstandardsestablishedinthelocalgeneralplanornoiseordinance,orapplicablestandardsofotheragencies?
X
b)Exposureofpersonstoorgenerationofexcessivegroundbornevibrationorgroundbornenoiselevels?
X
c)Asubstantialpermanentincreaseinambientnoiselevelsintheprojectvicinityabovelevelsexistingwithouttheproject?
X
156StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
d)Asubstantialtemporaryorperiodicincreaseinambientnoiselevelsintheprojectvicinityabovelevelsexistingwithouttheproject?
X
e)Foraprojectlocatedwithinanairportlanduseplanor,wheresuchaplanhasnotbeenadopted,withintwomilesofapublicairportorpublicuseairport,wouldtheprojectexposepeopleresidingorworkingintheprojectareatoexcessivenoiselevels?
X
f)Foraprojectwithinthevicinityofaprivateairstrip,wouldtheprojectexposepeopleresidingorworkingintheprojectareatoexcessivenoiselevels?
X
NOISE:a),b)andd)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:Increasednoiselevelswouldlikelybeassociatedwithheavyequipmentoperationassociatedwithconstructionofstructuralcompliancemeasures.Forthemostparttheimplementationofstructuralcompliancemeasuresmayresultinlocalizedincreasednoiselevelsthatcanbeminimizedormitigatedthroughtimingarenotpredictedtobeasignificantimpact.Forexamplenoiselevelsfromactivitiessuchasroadconstructionand/ormaintenancewouldnotexceedtheexistinglevelsandtheloudestactivitiesfromotherconstructionactionscanbeplannedduringpeakdailynoise.However,damdecommissioningwouldlikelyinvolvedrillingandblastingoftheconcretestructures,andthiswillcauseanadverseimpacttothenoiselevelinthesurroundingcommunitiesevenwithminimizationandmitigationmeasuresincorporated.Demolitionofseveralofthedamsandtheirassociatedfacilitieswouldresultinsignificantandunavoidableimpactsbyexceedinglocalnoiseordinances,exposingpeopletogroundbornevibrationsandincreasingtheambientnoiselevelsforoutdoorreceptors.NOISE:c),e)andf)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwouldresultinasubstantialpermanentincreaseinambientnoiselevelsintheprojectvicinityabovelevelsexistingwithouttheprojectasnoisegenerationisassociatedwiththeshortterm,temporaryuseofheavyequipment.
157StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwouldlikelybelocatedwithinanairportlanduseplanorwithintwomilesofapublicairportorpublicuseairport.However,evenifthisweretooccur,theimplementationofthecompliancemeasureswouldnotresultinexcessivenoiselevels.TheuseofheavyequipmentfortheconstructionandinstallationofsomestructuralBMPscouldresultintemporaryincreasesinexistingnoiselevels,butthenoiseassociatedwithheavyequipmentuseisnotanylouderthannoisesthatwouldtypicallyoccurwithintwomilesofanairport.NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwouldlikelybelocatedinthevicinityofaprivateairstrip.However,evenifthisweretooccur,thecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDwouldnotresultinexcessivenoiselevels.TheuseofheavyequipmentfortheconstructionandinstallationofsomestructuralBMPscouldresultintemporaryincreasesinexistingnoiselevels,butthenoiseassociatedwithheavyequipmentuseisnotanylouderthannoisesthatwouldtypicallyoccurwithinthevicinityofaprivateairstrip.
XIII.POPULATIONANDHOUSING‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Inducesubstantialpopulationgrowthinanarea,eitherdirectly(forexample,byproposingnewhomesandbusinesses)orindirectly(forexample,throughextensionofroadsorotherinfrastructure)?
X
b)Displacesubstantialnumbersofexistinghousing,necessitatingtheconstructionofreplacementhousingelsewhere?
X
c)Displacesubstantialnumbersofpeople,necessitatingtheconstructionofreplacementhousingelsewhere?
X
POPULATIONANDHOUSING:a),b)andc)NoImpactDiscussion:NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwouldinducesubstantialpopulationgrowthinanarea,eitherdirectly(forexample,byproposingnewhomesandbusinesses)or
158StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
indirectly(forexample,throughextensionofroadsorotherinfrastructure).NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDcontemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwoulddisplacesubstantialnumbersofexistinghousing,necessitatingtheconstructionofreplacementhousingelsewhere.NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDwoulddisplacesubstantialnumbersofpeople,necessitatingtheconstructionofreplacementhousingelsewhere.Therefore,thereisnoimpact.XIV.PUBLICSERVICES Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Wouldtheprojectresultinsubstantialadversephysicalimpactsassociatedwiththeprovisionofneworphysicallyalteredgovernmentalfacilities,needforneworphysicallyalteredgovernmentalfacilities,theconstructionofwhichcouldcausesignificantenvironmentalimpacts,inordertomaintainacceptableserviceratios,responsetimesorotherperformanceobjectivesforanyofthepublicservices:
Fireprotection? X Policeprotection? X Schools? XParks? XOtherpublicfacilities? XPUBLICSERVICES:FireProtection)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedLogically,theincreaseinriparianvegetationincreasesthefuelloadsforwildfires.Whilefuelloadsdonotcausefirestheincreasingmassavailablecanincreaseseverityofafireandcouldimpactthedemandonfireprotectionservices.Allowingfortheremovalorthinningofuplandvegetationthathashighevapotranspirationratesandincreasesfireriskscouldbeamitigationmeasurethatresultinmultiplebenefitstotheenvironment.Formorediscussionseethesectiononaesthetics.Theappropriatefindingislessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.
159StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
PUBLICSERVICES:PoliceProtection)LessThanSignificantWiththewidespreadincreaseinmarijuanacultivationthroughouttheregionbothlocalandstatelawenforcementandresourceagencieshaveseenanincreaseinthenumberofcasesthatleadtoenforcementactions.Marijuanacultivationintheregionhascauseddischargesofsedimentandpesticidesaswellasanincreasedwaterdemand.WhilemanyoftheseoperationsarelegalunderCalifornialawtheyarestillillegalunderfederallaw.AccordingtoRegionalWaterBoardstaff,manyofthesesmallandstatelegaloperationsareseekinginputandmakingattemptstoreducetheirimpactstoenvironmentthroughroutineBMPsthataddresserosionandsedimentcontrolaswellaswaterefficiencystrategies.Stillmanymorelargescaleoperationsgofullybeyondthescopelawwithlittlecautiontowardscriminalandenvironmentallegality.Withobservationsspanningoverthepastfewdecadesandspecialemphasisonthelastfewyears,thedemandonlawenforcementincludingtheRegionalWaterBoardhasalreadytakenplace.Moreover,whiletheTemperaturePolicywillapplytomarijuanagrowerswithrespectshade,sediment,andflow,thesecomponentsdonotnecessarilyimplicatepoliceresources.Therefore,asignificantincreaseinthedemandforpublicserviceshasalreadyoccurredandtheimpactfromthisPolicyonpoliceservicesislessthansignificant.PUBLICSERVICES:Schools,Parksorotherpublicfacilities)NoImpactDiscussion:TheproposedBasinPlanamendmentdoesnotinvolveneworphysicallyalteredgovernmentfacilities.Becausetheproposedprojectdoesnotinvolvetheseelements,theappropriatefindingisnoimpact.XV.RECREATION‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Wouldtheprojectincreasetheuseofexistingneighborhoodandregionalparksorotherrecreationalfacilitiessuchthatsubstantialphysicaldeteriorationofthefacilitywouldoccurorbeaccelerated?
X
b)Doestheprojectincluderecreationalfacilitiesorrequiretheconstructionorexpansionofrecreationalfacilitieswhichmighthaveanadversephysicaleffectontheenvironment?
X
160StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
RECREATION:a)andb)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSED,withtheexceptionofdamdecommissioning,contemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwouldincreasetheuseofexistingneighborhoodandregionalparksorotherrecreationalfacilitiessuchthatsubstantialphysicaldeteriorationofthefacilitywouldoccurorbeaccelerated.IntheeventthattheKlamathRiverreservoirsaredecommissioned,flatwaterrecreationuserswillhavetousetheotherflatwaterfacilitiesintheregion.Inaddition,impacttowhite‐waterrecreationwillbeadverselyaffectedinspecificreachesoftheKlamathRiverduetochangesinflowstagesatcertaintimesofyearandhavebeendeterminedtobesignificantandunavoidable.Onceadecommissioningplanisdeveloped,mitigationmeasuresidentified,intheplanmustensurethattheotherregionalfacilitieshavetheinfrastructureinplacetosupporttheincreaseduserbase.Mitigationmeasuresidentifiedincludesuchthingsasinstallation/relocationofcampgrounds,restrooms,boatramps,garbageservice,etc.Although,significantimpactstorecreationhavebeenidentifiedthelongtermbenefitassociatedwiththeremovaloftheKlamathhydroelectricfacilitiesispositivetowardsrecreationalvalues.ForexampleseveralofthereservoirsandreachesoftheKlamathRiverareimpairedforrecreationduetopoorwaterqualityassociatedwithtoxicalgalblooms.Ithasbeendeterminedthatdamremovalwouldalleviatetheseimpairments.Additionally,ithasbeendeterminedthatdamremovalwouldhavelong‐termbeneficialeffectsonfree‐flowingcondition,waterquality,scenic,wildlife,fishery,andrecreationrivervaluesassociatedwiththeupstreamanddownstreamreachesdesignatedasWildandScenic.XVI.TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)Conflictwithanapplicableplan,ordinanceorpolicyestablishingmeasuresofeffectivenessfortheperformanceofthecirculationsystem,takingintoaccountallmodesoftransportationincludingmasstransitandnon‐motorizedtravelandrelevant
X
161StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
componentsofthecirculationsystem,including,butnotlimitedtointersections,streets,highwaysandfreeways,pedestrianandbicyclepaths,andmasstransit?b)Conflictwithanapplicablecongestionmanagementprogram,including,butnotlimitedtolevelofservicestandardsandtraveldemandmeasures,orotherstandardsestablishedbythecountycongestionmanagementagencyfordesignatedroadsorhighways?
X
c)Resultinachangeinairtrafficpatterns,includingeitheranincreaseintrafficlevelsorachangeinlocationthatresultsinsubstantialsafetyrisks?
X
d)Substantiallyincreasehazardsduetoadesignfeature(e.g.,sharpcurvesordangerousintersections)orincompatibleuses(e.g.,farmequipment)?
X
e)Resultininadequateemergencyaccess?
X
f)Conflictwithadoptedpolicies,plans,orprogramsregardingpublictransit,bicycle,orpedestrianfacilities,orotherwisedecreasetheperformanceorsafetyofsuchfacilities?
X
TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC:a)andb)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:NoneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSED,contemplatetheuseofstructuralBMPsthatwouldcauseanincreaseintrafficwhichissubstantialinrelationtotheexistingtrafficloadandcapacityofthestreetsystem(i.e.,resultinasubstantialincreaseineitherthenumberofvehicletrips,thevolumetocapacityratioonroads,orcongestionatintersections).Constructionactivitieshavethepotentialtoincreasetrafficvolumesorreducespeedsonpublicroads.
162StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
However,itisstaffsjudgmentthatthepotentialcompliancemeasuresareunlikelytobecorrelatedwiththepublicroadsystemstoanysignificantdegree.
TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC:c)andd)LessThanSignificantwithMitigationIncorporatedDiscussion:Increasedtreeretentionmayconflictwiththesitedistancerequirementsoftransportationagencies(publicroads)areasdesignatedasclearrecoveryzones.Differentlevelsofroadsystems(e.g.freeways,highways,interstates,citystreetsandcountyroads)havevariouslevelsofdesignrequirementsinconsiderationofsitedistancetohelpensurepublicsafety.Inaddition,clearrecoveryzones(areasadjacenttoroadshoulders)arecreatedandmaintainedincertainlocationsoutsidethehighwayshouldertoprovideanopportunityforvehiclesthatleavetheroadwaytocometoasafestoportoreturntotheroadway.Arecoverableslopeisaslopeonwhichamotoristmay,toagreaterorlesserextent,retainorregaincontrolofavehiclebyslowingorstopping.Slopesflatterthan1V:4Haregenerallyconsideredrecoverable(U.S.FederalHighwayAdministration).Thousandsofmilesofroadseitherparallelorintersectstreams,riparianareasand/orfloodplains.Therefore,itispossiblethatretainingriparianvegetationtoprovidesite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshadeortheinstallationofsedimentcontrolcompliancemeasurescouldinfringeuponsitedistanceorclearrecoveryzonerequirements.However,withproperplanningandcoordinationwithlocal,countyandstatetransportationagenciesmostconflictscouldberesolved.Forinstanceduringtheroadplanning,designandenvironmentalimpactassessmentstagesthesetypesofconstraintsorconflictsareanalyzedbytransportationengineersandbiologists.Throughtheexistingprojectplanning,CEQAprocess,interagencycoordinationandexistingregulation(NPDESstormwaterpermitsand401Certifications)potentialconflictsareresolvedbyavoidance,minimization,oroff‐sitecompensatorymitigation.ForexamplemanystructuralBMPsdesignedtoreducesedimentandpollutedstormwaterrunnoffhaveoftenbeendeterminedtobepossibletoconstruct,butinfeasibleduetosafetyconstraints.Alternately,adequatelyvegetatedslopesflatterthan1V:4HarealsopotentiallocationsforstructuralBMPsforbiofiltrationofpollutedstormwaterandareknowntoreduceerosionandsedimenttransport.Throughpropercoordination,planninganddesignclearrecoveryzonescanmeetpublicsafety,stormwatertreatment,anderosionandsedimentcontrolgoals.Therefore,itisstaffsdeterminationthatthepotentialimpactsarelessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporated.TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC:e)andf)LessThanSignificant
Theproposedprojectdoesnotinvolveinstallationofhazardousdesignfeatures,andwillnotaffectemergencyaccessorparkingcapacity.Theproposedprojectwillnotconflictwithpolicies,plans,orprogramsregardingpublictransit,bicycle,orpedestrianfacilities,orotherwisedecreasetheperformanceorsafetyofsuch
163StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
facilities.Becausetheproposedprojectdoesnotinvolvetheseelements,theappropriatefindingislessthansignificant.XVII.UTILITIESANDSERVICESYSTEMS‐‐Wouldtheproject: Potentially
SignificantImpact
LessThanSignificant
withMitigationIncorporated
LessThanSignificantImpact
NoImpact
a)ExceedwastewatertreatmentrequirementsoftheapplicableRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard?
X
b)Requireorresultintheconstructionofnewwaterorwastewatertreatmentfacilitiesorexpansionofexistingfacilities,theconstructionofwhichcouldcausesignificantenvironmentaleffects?
X
c)Requireorresultintheconstructionofnewstormwaterdrainagefacilitiesorexpansionofexistingfacilities,theconstructionofwhichcouldcausesignificantenvironmentaleffects?
X
d)Havesufficientwatersuppliesavailabletoservetheprojectfromexistingentitlementsandresources,orareneworexpandedentitlementsneeded?
X
e)Resultinadeterminationbythewastewatertreatmentproviderwhichservesormayservetheprojectthatithasadequatecapacitytoservetheproject’sprojecteddemandinadditiontotheprovider’sexistingcommitments?
X
f)Beservedbyalandfillwithsufficientpermittedcapacitytoaccommodatetheproject’ssolidwastedisposalneeds?
X
g)Complywithfederal,state,
164StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
andlocalstatutesandregulationsrelatedtosolidwaste?
X
UTILITIESANDSERVICESYSTEMS:a)ande)NoImpactTheproposedBasinPlanamendmentwillnothaveanyeffectonwastewatertreatmentrequirements.Therefore,theappropriatefindingisnoimpact.UTILITIESANDSERVICESYSTEMS:b),c),andd)andPotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableCompliancemeasuresthatrequireconstructionordemolitionoffacilitiescouldresultinshortterminterruptionofutilities.Severalcompliancemeasures,includingbutnotlimitedto,sedimentcontrolbasins,LIDfeatures,irrigationsystemsandtailwatermanagementsystemstoreducesedimenttransporttostreamshavethepotentialtocauseanimpactonutilities.However,mitigationmeasurescanreduceanyimpactstoalessthansignificantlevel.Damremovalcouldleadtoshortterminterruptionsinutilities,includingbutnotlimitedtowater,gasandelectricity.Relianceongroundwateroralternatewatersourcescouldresultinexpansionofexistingwaterandenergydeliverysystems.Thisamountwoulddependonwhichcompliancemeasuresareselectedandonthehydrologyandextentofexistingpermittedwateruseatfuturepointsofdiversion.Inaddition,surfacewatersuppliesmaybeinsufficienttomeetallfuturedemandsevenintheabsenceoftheBasinPlanamendment.Surfacewaterresourcesarealreadylimitedinsomeareasandfuturewatersupplieswillbelimitedbythenaturalsupplyavailabilityratherthanbyrestrictionsonwaterdiversionandstorage.Somestreamsintheregionareaarealreadyfullyappropriatedforsomeoralloftheyear.Theselectionoftheappropriatecompliancemeasuresbyresponsiblepartieswillneedtotakeintoconsiderationtheirexistingwaterresources.Basingselectionofcompliancemeasuresonexistingwaterresourceswillpreventtheneedtoseeknewentitlements.AnotheralternativewatersupplypracticeforwaterpurveyorscurrentlybeingconsideredintheNorthCoastRegionisgroundwaterbanking,alsoknownasaquiferstorageandrecovery(ASR).WithpotentialrestrictionsonmunicipalwatersuppliesthereisthepotentialforASRprojectstobecomemorecommonplacethroughouttheregion.Therearepotentialadverseenvironmentalimpactswiththesetypesofprojects.However,inlightofclimatechangeandexistingregulationsonflowrestrictionsinmanyareasintheNorthCoastRegion,thesetypesofmeasurescouldmitigatepotentialincreasesindemand.
165StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Oneofthepotentialalternativepracticesthatcouldbeusedbygrowerswouldbetheuseofcovercropstoincreaseinfiltrationandreducesurfacerunoffofwater,whichmaycontaincontaminants.Theuseofcovercropsmayrequireadditionalirrigationwater,butmayalsoresultinreducedevaporationfromsoilsurfaces,resultinginnoorlittlenetchangeinirrigationwaterneeds.Improvedirrigationefficiency,oneoftheprinciplemeansofreducingagriculturaldischarges,willlikelyresultinwatersavings.Ifadditionalripariandiversionfacilitiesareconstructed,theconstructionactivityshouldbeundertakeninamannerthatdoesnotadverselyaffectfishandwildliferesources,perFishandWildlifeCodesection1602.IfCDFWdeterminesthattheconstructionactivitymaysubstantiallyadverselyaffectfishandwildliferesources,aLakeorStreambedAlterationAgreement(Agreement)wouldbeprepared.ConditionsthatCDFWmayrequireinclude,butarenotlimitedto,avoidanceorminimizationofvegetationremoval,useofstandarderosioncontrolmeasures,limitationsontheuseofheavyequipment,limitationsonworkperiodstoavoidimpactsonfisheriesandwildliferesources,minimumbypassflowrequirements,andrequirementstorestoredegradedsitesorcompensateforpermanenthabitatlosses.Inaddition,renderingadamincapableofstoringwaterbyleavingthestructureinplacewhileallowingwatertopassthrough,maybealesscostlyalternative,andmayreduceimpactstofishandwildlifehabitattolessthansignificantlevels.TheAgreementwouldincludereasonableconditionsnecessarytoprotectthoseresourcesandmustcomplywithCEQA.Inadditiontotheregulatoryrequirementsdescribedabove,theseasonalstorageofsurfacewaterinmostnewoffstreamstoragefacilitieswillrequireawaterrightpermitfromtheStateWaterBoard.Unlessanexemptionapplies,theStateWaterBoard’sreviewofwaterrightapplicationsissubjecttoCEQA.Inaddition,inactingonwaterrightapplications,theStateWaterBoardmusttakeintoconsiderationthepublicinterestandtheapplicableBasinPlan.(Wat.Code,§§1253,1255,1257,1258.)Accordingly,theStateWaterBoardwillhavetheopportunitytoidentifyandmitigatetheimpactsofconstructingoff‐channelstoragereservoirsaspartoftheStateWaterBoard’sreviewofindividualwaterrightapplications.Similarly,theStateWaterBoardwillhavetheopportunitytoensurethatapplicantscomplywithanyotherapplicableregulatoryrequirements.Inclusionofthefollowingpermitterms,willensurethatapplicantscomplywithanyotherapplicableregulatoryrequirements.
Nowatershallbedivertedunderthispermit,andnoconstructionrelatedtosuchdiversionshallcommence,untilpermitteeobtainsallnecessarypermitsorotherapprovalsrequiredbyotheragencies.Ifanamendedpermitisissued,nonewfacilitiesshallbeutilized,norshalltheamountofwaterdivertedincreasebeyondthemaximumamountdivertedduringthepreviouslyauthorizedtimeperiod,untilpermitteecomplieswiththerequirementsofthisterm.
166StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Within90daysoftheissuanceofthispermitoranysubsequentamendment,permitteeshallprepareandsubmittotheDivisionofWaterRightsalistof,orprovideinformationthatshowsproofofattemptstosolicitinformationregardingtheneedfor,permitsorapprovalsthatmayberequiredfortheproject.Ataminimum,permitteeshallprovidealistorotherinformationpertainingtowhetheranyofthefollowingpermitsorapprovalsarerequired:(1)lakeorstreambedalterationagreementwiththeDepartmentofFishandWildlife(Fish&G.Code,§1600etseq.);(2)DepartmentofWaterResources,DivisionofSafetyofDamsapproval(Wat.Code,§6002.);(3)RegionalWaterQualityControlBoardWasteDischargeRequirements(Wat.Code,§13260etseq.);(4)U.S.ArmyCorpsofEngineersCleanWaterActsection404permit(33U.S.C.§1344.);or,(5)localgradingpermits.Permitteeshall,within30daysofissuanceofallpermits,approvalsorwaivers,transmitcopiestotheDivisionofWaterRights.
Basedonthewiderangeofpotentialimpactsassociatedwithwatertreatmentandsupply,andenforcementofmitigationameasureisuncertain,adverseimpactstotheenvironmentarepotentiallysignificantandunavoidable.UTILITIESANDSERVICESYSTEMS:f)andg)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:Otherthanthediscussionofcompliancemeasuresfordamremoval,noneofthecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisSEDgenerateasignificantsourceofsolidwaste.ConstructionandimplementationofstructuralBMPsmaygeneratesolidwastesrequiringdisposalsuchasearthenmaterialorerosioncontrolmaterials(e.g.siltfences,temporaryfencing,rustedoutculverts).Theamountofwasteneedingdisposal,however,willbeveryminimal,andcouldthereforebeservedbyanexistinglandfill.Fordamremoval,theimplementationofaHazardousMaterialsManagementPlan(HMMP)wouldmitigatetheeffectsontheenvironmenttoalessthansignificantamount.HMMPstypicallyincludepotentialoptionsfordisposalsitesandBMPsforwastehandling,transportinganddisposal,aswellashealthandsafetymeasurestoprotectworkersandthepublic.Thismitigationmeasureshouldreducetheimpactsandeliminateproblemswithcompliancewithfederal,state,andlocalstatutesandregulationsrelatedtosolidwastedisposal.Thepotentialpracticesthatcouldbeappliedbygrowersshouldnotresultinanychangesinthegenerationofsolidwasteandthereforeshouldnotaffectcompliancewithfederal,state,orlocalstatutesandregulationsrelatedtosolidwaste.
167StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
MANDATORYFINDINGSOFSIGNIFICANCEa)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:Allofthesecompliancemeasuresidentifiedinthisenvironmentalanalysiswilllikelyimprovewaterqualityfromthecurrentbaselineinthewatershedwhichwilllikelycontinuewithouttheapplicationoftheseadditionalprotections.Compliancemeasuresthatrequiresubstantialearthmovementwouldlikelyundergoconsultationwithfederal,stateandlocalagencies,includingbutnotlimitedtothecountytheprojectislocatedin,CDFGandtheUSFWS.Specificmitigationmeasureswouldbeappliedbytheagenciestoavoidimpactstorare,threatenedorendangeredspecies.Ifnosuchmitigationisavailable,theuseofthatcompliancemeasureinthespecificareashouldnotbeimplemented.Inmostcasestheimpactsofinstallingstructuralcompliancemeasureswouldbetemporary,andanyimpactscouldbeavoidedbyadjustingthetimingand/orlocationtotakeintoaccountanycandidate,sensitive,orspecialstatusspeciesortheirhabitats.Theexceptiontothiswouldbeshorttermimpactsassociatedwithdamdecommissioningwhichhasthepotentialtosignificantlyimpactwaterqualityfromthereleaseofincreasedloadsoffinegrainedsediment.Itisestimatedthatimpactstowaterqualitywouldrangefromweekstomonthswiththeapplicationofappropriatemitigationmeasures.
Thepotentialimpactsoftheprojectwillnotcauseasignificantcumulativeimpactintheenvironmentwiththeexceptionofadamdecommissioningscenario.Infact,theadoptionoftheproposedBasinPlanamendmentshouldresultinimprovedwaterqualityintheNorthCoastRegionwillhavesignificantbeneficialeffectsontheenvironmentoverthelongterm.MANDATORYFINDINGSOFSIGNIFICANCEb)PotentiallySignificantandUnavoidableDiscussion:Cumulativeimpacts,definedinsection15355oftheCEQAGuidelines,refertotwoormoreindividualeffects,thatwhenconsideredtogether,areconsiderableorthatincreaseotherenvironmentalimpacts.CumulativeimpactassessmentmustconsidernotonlytheimpactsoftheproposedBasinPlanamendment,butalsotheimpactsfromotherBasinPlanAmendments,municipal,andprivateprojects,whichhaveoccurredinthepast,arepresentlyoccurring,andmayoccurinthefuture,inthewatershedduringtheperiodofimplementation.Non‐structuralcompliancemeasuresthatmaybeimplementedarenotlikelytohavecumulativeimpactsontheenvironment.Impactsassociatedwithimplementationofmostofthestructuralmeasureswillbeshort‐term,temporaryandspatiallydistributedacrossthewatershed,andwillnothavesignificantadverseeffectsontheenvironment.Compliancemeasuresthatinvolvesubstantialearth
168StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
movementcouldhavepotentiallysignificantcumulativeimpacts.However,manyoftheseactivitieswillberegulatedunderexistingStateandRegionalpermits,includingbutnotlimitedtostate‐wideCaltransstormwaterpermit,stormwaterpermitforconstructionsitesoverone(1)acre,ortimberharvestoperationsonpublicandprivatelands.Thelikelihoodofinstallationofstructuralcompliancemeasuresonfederallandisquitehighasapproximately55%oftheregionisinfederalownership.RegionalWaterBoardstaff’sengagementintheseregulatoryprogramswillprovideanopportunitytolimitthepotentialforcumulativeimpactsbyensuringthatmultipleprojectsproposingimplementationofBMPswiththepotentialtocauseshort‐termimpactsarephasedappropriatelytolimitpotentialcumulativeimpacts.Basedonareviewoftheavailableinformation,andasaresultofimplementingtherangeofcompliancemeasuresfromthepreservationofshadetosedimentcontrolsandthemodificationofwatersupplytodamdecommissioning,ithasbeendeterminedthatsignificantandunavoidableimpactstotheenvironmentarelikelytooccur.Theseimpactsincludeelevatedexhaustlevels,fugitivedust,vehicleandGHGemissions,turbidity,suspendedsedimentloadsandreductionsofdissolvedoxygen,potentialnegativealterationofcriticalhabitatformultiplefishspecies,groundwaterresources,culturalresources,scenicquality,recreation,andnoise.Mostoftheseimpactsareexpectedtobeshortterm.Individualproject‐specificCEQAreviewwillbenecessaryinthosecasesasappropriate.Manycanandwillbemitigatedtolessthansignificantlevelswiththeimplementationofspecificmitigationmeasures.However,becauseoftheprogrammaticnatureofthisCEQAanalyses,itisnotpossibletosaywithcertaintythatallimpactswillbemitigatedtolessthansignificantlevels.IdentifiedmitigationwillbecomeenforceableinpermitsandotherordersbytheRegionalWaterBoard,butwecannotbecertainthatotheragencieswilladopttherecommendedmitigationforactivitiesunderthejurisdictionofotheragencies.Asaresult,evenimpactsidentifiedaslessthansignificantwithmitigationincorporatedmustalsobeconsideredunavoidableatthistime.NotwithstandingthepotentialnegativeaffectsdiscussedaboveandthroughoutthisSED,itislikelythatlongtermbeneficialeffectswillberealizedonaestheticresources,biologicalresources,geologyandsoils,GHGemissions,hydrologyandwaterquality,andrecreation.MANDATORYFINDINGSOFSIGNIFICANCEc)LessThanSignificantDiscussion:Asexplainedpreviously,theproposedBasinPlanamendmentisdesignedtoimprovelongtermwaterqualitybyprovidingaregulatoryprogramdesignedtoprotectandrestorewaterqualityandthebeneficialusesofwaterintheNorthCoastRegion.AnimportantobjectiveoftheproposedBasinPlanamendmentistherestorationofahealthyandviablesalmonidfisheryandthepreservationofhighqualitywaters.
169StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
9.6AlternativeMeansofComplianceTheCEQArequiresananalysisofreasonablyforeseeablealternativemeansofcompliancewiththeruleorregulation,whichwouldavoidoreliminatetheidentifiedimpacts29.Theresponsiblepartiescanusethestructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasuresdescribedinsection9.4,orotherstructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasures,tocontrolandpreventpollution,andmeettherequirementsoftheproposedBasinPlanamendment.Thealternativemeansofcomplianceconsistofthedifferentcombinationsofstructuralandnon‐structuralcompliancemeasuresthattheresponsiblepartiesmightusetomeettheirloadallocationsandachievecompliancewiththetemperatureobjectivesorTMDLActionPlans.Becausethereareinnumerablewaystocombinecompliancemeasures,allofthepossiblealternativemeansofcompliancecannotbediscussedhere.However,becausemostoftheadverseenvironmentaleffectsareassociatedwiththeconstructionofstructuralcompliancemeasuresrelatedtoearthmovementorconstructionofinfrastructure(e.g.,fencing,off‐channelwaterfacilities,aquaticecosystemrestorationrestoration)toavoidoreliminateimpacts,projectproponentsshouldalwaysmaximizetheuseofnon‐structuralmeasurestotheextentfeasible,anddesignstructuralcompliancemeasurestotakeintoconsiderationsite‐specificconditionstominimizeenvironmentaleffects.
29 Cal.CodeRegs.,tit.14,§15187(c)(3).
170StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
10.0 ECONOMICANALYSIS10.1IntroductionTheRegionalWaterBoardsarelegallyrequiredtoconsidereconomicsinTotalMaximumDailyLoad(TMDL)30developmentandwaterqualitycontrolplanning(basinplanning)31.TherearethreetriggersforRegionalWaterBoardconsiderationofeconomicsorcostsinbasinplanning.Theyare:
TheBoardmustconsidereconomicsinestablishingwaterqualityobjectivesthatensurethereasonableprotectionofbeneficialuses.
TheBoardsmustcomplywiththeCaliforniaEnvironmentalQualityAct(CEQA)32whentheyamendtheirbasinplans.CEQArequiresthattheBoardsanalyzethereasonablyforeseeablemethodsofcompliancewithproposedperformancestandardsandtreatmentrequirements.Thisanalysismustincludeeconomicfactors.
Chapter9istheanalysisofpotentialenvironmentalimpacts,asrequiredunderCEQA,associatedwithadoptinganamendmenttotheWaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegion(BasinPlan)toincludethedraftregionalTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansfortheEelRiver,MattoleRiverandNavarroRiverTemperatureTMDLs.InChapter9,staffidentifiesthereasonablyforeseeablecompliancemeasuresnecessarytoachievecompliancewiththeTemperatureImplementationPolicyandassociatedactions.Thesecompliancemeasuresaremanagementpracticesmostlikelytobeimplementedtoachievecompliancewithwaterqualitystandardsfortemperature.10.2ScopeoftheEconomicAnalysisWhatfollowsisanestimateofthecostsassociatedwithcompliancemeasures.Thecostsaregivenasarange,dependentonthespecificcharacteristicsofthelandoroperationtowhichagivenmanagementpracticeisapplied.Alistofpotentialfundingsourcesisalsogiven.TheRegionalWaterBoardisnotobligatedtoconsiderthebalanceofcostsandbenefitsassociatedwithimplementationofaTMDLorBasinPlanamendment.ItisonlyobligatedtoconsidereconomicfactorsandmayadoptaTMDLorBasinPlanamendmentevenifthecostsaresignificant.10.2.1MethodologyThecostsidentifiedinthischapterprimarilycomefromfoursourcesofinformation:theNaturalResourcesConservationService(NRCS)FieldOfficeTechnicalGuide(FOTG),CaliforniaDepartmentofFishandWildlife(CDFW)SalmonidStreamHabitatRestorationManual(2006)(Manual),CDFWCohoSalmonRecovery
30See33U.S.C.§1313(d);40C.F.R.§130.7.31SeeWat.Code,§13240‐1324732Pub.ResourcesCode§21000etseq.
171StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Strategy,CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation(Caltrans)2013contractproposalawardinformation.ThecostinformationprovidedintheNRCSFOTGisanationaldatasettoassistlocalNRCSDistrictsinsettingcostsharesforimplementingconservationpractices.CostestimatesareprovidedatthecountylevelandthedatausedforthisanalysisarespecifictoNorthernCalifornia(includingDelNorte,Humboldt,Trinity,Siskiyou,MendocinoandSonomaCounties),asdescribedintheirFiscalYear2013PaymentSchedule.ThecostsincludedintheCDFGManualaredescribedasupslopeerosioninventoryandsedimentcontrolguidance.ThenumbersarebasedonestimatesfromPacificWatershedAssociates,aconsultingfirmspecializinginerosioncontrolwork.Actualcostscanvaryconsiderablydependingonoperatorskillandexperience,equipmenttypes,localsiteconditions,andregionallocation.10.2.2ExistingRequirementsLandownersandprojectproponentsareboundbyvariousexistingregulatoryrequirementsthatinvolvewaterqualityandnaturalresourceprotection.TheeconomicimpactofexistingobligationsshouldnotbeattributedtothecostsofcompliancewiththeproposedBasinPlanamendment.Limitingthescopeoftheeconomicanalysisisdifficultgiventhesimilarityofmeasuresnecessarytoachieveawiderangeofwaterqualityandwildlifeprotectiongoals.Toremainasfocusedaspossible,thiseconomicanalysisonlycontemplatesthecostsofmeasuresidentifiedasreasonablyforeseeable(seeChapter9)intheimplementationoftheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlans.However,iftakenasawhole,theyarelikelyanoverestimateoftheactualcostsofcompliance.Thisisbecauseofthemultipleandoverlappingregulatoryprogramsunderwhichthesamemeasuresarereasonablyforeseeable.Forexample,sometemperaturecontrolcostsarerelatedtoactionsnecessarytoavoidaviolationofthesedimentprohibitionsintheBasinPlanandtoavoidatakingundertheEndangeredSpeciesActortofullymitigateimpactsofauthorizedtakes.OthercostsmaybeincurredasaresultofcompliancewiththeCleanWaterAct(CWA),otherrelatedstatutesandregulations,orlocallanduseordinances.Conversely,compliancewiththeproposedTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlan(s)willhelpdischargerscomplywiththeotherregulatoryrequirements.10.2.3GeographicScopeTheimplementationactionswithintheproposedBasinPlanamendmentarenotuniformlyrequiredacrosstheNorthCoastRegionorevenacrosspropertieswithsimilarlanduses.Instead,manyoftheimplementationactionswillberequiredoflandowners/projectproponentsonanas‐needed,site‐specificbasisoraresimplyactivitiesthatareencouragedbytheRegionalWaterBoard.Economicconsiderationsdifferwithsite‐specificissuesandapplicableactionsnecessaryforcompliancewithinthethreemaincategories(shade,sedimentation,andflow)thataffectstreamtemperature.Forexamplethecostforretainingshade
172StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
ontimberlandswillbedifferentacrosstheregiondependingontheamountofyieldandproduct(a.ka.species)toharvest.Likewiserestorationactioncostwillnotbeuniformsincediversebioregionsandmicroclimateswithinthoseregionswillplayaroleinthespeciescompositioninriparianareas.Inaddition,moreintensivelanduseactivitieswillfacegreatercoststhanlessintensivelanduseactivities.Activitiesonsteep,erosiveslopesinproximitytowaterbodieswillrequiregreatercareandhighercoststhanactivitiesonlandsthatdonotdelivertoawaterbodyoronlandsthatarenothighlyerosive.Additionally,developingalternativewatersupplies,conservationpractices,andswitchingfromsurfacewaterdiversionstogroundwaterpumpingarehighlysite‐specificeconomicconsiderationsthatcanbegenerallyassessedbutshouldnotbeimpliedastheabsoluteupperandlowerlimitofcostsinallinstances.DamRemovalThecostofremovingdamsvariesfairlyregularlywiththeheightandwidthofthedam,butproject‐specificfactors,suchasstructuretype,sediments,waterrights,easements,andtheneedformonitoringcangreatlyimpactthetotalcostoftreatment.FriendsoftheEarthperformedcasestudiesofmorethan30damremovalprojectsintheUnitedStatesandfoundthatsomesmalldamscanberemovedforunder$10,000.Theremovalofalargerdam(e.g.,15‐20feetinheight)cancostasmuchas$1million.Inneithercasedothesecostestimatesincludetheimportantconsiderationsofthecostofpermits,easements,design,ormonitoring.Themediancostofdamremovalinthisstudywasabout$100,000.However,thisfindingcannotbeinterpretedtosuggestthatthiswillalwaysbetrueinCaliforniaorelsewhereinthefuture.Previousdamremovalswerenottheresultofarandomselection;itislikelythatrelativelyinexpensiveremovalprojectshavebeenundertakenfirstandthataverageremovalcostswillriseovertime.(Sunding,D./A.P.Zwane,2004)IrrigatedAgricultureIrrigatedagricultureoccursthroughouttheNorthCoastRegionandis
predominantlyconcentratedin:1)theTuleLakeregioninSiskiyouandModocCounties;2)theScottValley,ShastaValley,andupperKlamathRiverValleyinSiskiyouCounty;3)RoundValley,PotterValley,EdenValley,AndersonValleyandtheupperRussianRiverValleyinMendocinoCounty;and4)AlexanderValley,DryCreekValley,RussianRiverValleyBelowDryCreekandtheLagunadeSantaRosainSonomaCounty.Principalirrigatedcropsarebarley,irrigatedpasture,alfalfahayandotherhay,oats,potatoes,wheatandgrapes.Formostofthemanagementpractices,arangeofcostsisgiven,dependingonnumeroussite‐specificfactorstobedeterminedbylandowners/dischargers.Typicalcategoriesofcomplianceforirrigatedagricultureincludemaintainingandpreservingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade,controllingerosionandsediment,addressingtailwaterandsurfacewaterimpoundments,preservingexistingcoldwaterresources,aquaticecosystemrestorationandactionstorestoreormaintainstreamflowstosupportallbeneficialuses.
173StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
GrazingGrazingactivitiesoccurthroughouttheNorthCoastRegionbothonprivateandpubliclands.AswiththeestimatedcoststotheirrigatedagriculturalcommunitytocomplywiththeproposedBasinPlanAmendment,theestimatestothegrazingcommunityarederivedfromNRCSFiscalYear2013PaymentSchedule.Typicalcategoriesofcomplianceforgrazingincludemaintainingandpreservingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade,controllingerosionandsediment,preservingexistingcoldwaterresources,aquaticecosystemrestorationandactionstorestoreormaintainstreamflowstosupportallbeneficialuses.RoadsTheroadnetworksintheNorthCoastRegioncontributetoelevatedtemperaturesintributarywatershedsthroughthedischargeofexcesssediment.Insomecases,aninventoryofroadswilldeterminethatdecommissioningorupgradingofroadsisrequired.Regardlessofthemethodofregulationortheresponsibleparty,therequirementsforcontrollingsourcesofsedimentfromroadsaresimilarandimplementationwillpotentiallyfocusonthefollowingprocess:
1. Inventory:Identifysourcesofexcesssedimentdischargeorthreateneddischargeandquantifythedischargeorthreateneddischargefromthesource(s).
2. Prioritize:Prioritizeeffortstocontroldischargeofexcesssedimentbasedon,butnotlimitedto,severityofthreattowaterqualityandbeneficialuses,thefeasibilityofsourcecontrol,andsourcesiteaccessibility.
3. Implement:Developandimplementfeasiblesedimentcontrolpracticestoprevent,minimize,andcontrolthedischarge.Roaddecommissioningmayberequiredaspartofaresponsibleparties’loadallocationifmaintainingtheroadiscostprohibitive,roadisnotneededorisasourceofuncontrollableexcesssedimentdischarge.
4. MonitorandAdapt:UsemonitoringresultstodirectadaptivemanagementinordertorefineexcesssedimentcontrolpracticesandimplementationschedulesuntildischargesarereducedtoalevelthatmeetsanyapplicableTMDLloadallocationsandwaterqualitystandards.
Typicalcategoriesofcomplianceforroadsincludemaintainingandpreservingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade,controllingerosionandsediment,preservingexistingcoldwaterresources,andaquaticecosystemrestoration.TimberTimberharvestactivitiescansubstantiallyimpactwatertemperature.TheTemperatureImplementationPolicyandActionPlansfocusesoncontrollingsedimentandprotectingriparianfunctionsfromtimberharvestactivitiestomeet
174StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
thewatershed‐wideTMDLallocationsandtemperatureobjectivesasdescribedthroughoutthisstaffreport.TimberharvestonnonfederallandsiscurrentlyregulatedbytheRegionalBoardthroughacombinationofgeneralWDRsandconditionalwaiversofWDRs.ThecostsassociatedwithWDRsarenotoutlinedhereastheyareacurrentrequirement.RoadsthatarepartofatimberharvestplanorNon‐IndustrialTimberManagementPlan(NTMP)arearequiredbytheWDRsandwaiversfortimberharvestonnonfederallandstoimplementanerosioncontrolplan.AdditionalcoststotimberoperatorsassociatedwiththeproposedBasinPlanamendmentcouldcomefromtheadditionalretentionoftreesabovetheexistingrequirementsincertainareas.Therefore,theadditionalretentionoftreescouldpotentiallybeaforegonerevenue.However,duetothebroadrangeofpotentialfactorsincludingsitepotential,topography,existingrequirements,andamountoftimberavailablethespecificcostsaretoocomplextoestimate.Typicalcategoriesofcompliancefortimberoperationsincludemaintainingandpreservingsite‐specificpotentialeffectiveshade,controllingerosionandsediment,preservingexistingcoldwaterresources,andaquaticecosystemrestoration.10.3EstimatedCostsofComplianceThefollowingexamplesarenotmeanttobeexhaustiveofthesuitablesuiteofcompliancemeasures,butratherprovidearepresentativesamplewiththewidestrangetoaccommodateasmanycompliancescenariosaspossible.Sitepotentialisdefinedastheshadeprovidedbytopographyandfullpotentialvegetationconditionsatasite,withanallowancefornaturaldisturbancesuchasfloods,windthrow,disease,landslides,andfire.Table10‐1presentstheestimatedcostsofcompliancemeasurestopreserve,maintainandrestoreshade.Addressingelevatedwatertemperatureassociatedwithexcesssedimentdischargesincludescontrollingthecumulativeimpactsofsedimentwastedischargesonsuchwatershedsthataffectstreamtemperature.Table10‐2presentstheestimatedcostsofcompliancemeasurestocontrolsedimentation.Addressingelevatedwatertemperatureassociatedwithalterationofnaturalthermalregimesincludesabalanceofwaterdemandforallbeneficialuses.Table10‐3presentstheestimatedcostsofcompliancemeasuresthataddresstailwater,surfacewaterimpoundments,inputfromcoldwaterresources,andsurfacewaterflows.
175StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐1
EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasurestoPreserve,MaintainandRestoreShade
ReasonablyForeseeable
ComplianceMeasure
PracticeName Rangeof PracticeCosts
NRCSPracticeCodeorSource
Useexclusion Forageexclusion $0.64‐1.32/ft #472
RiparianRestoration Riparianforestbuffer/herbaceouscover
$165.04‐22,916.06/acre #390,#391
Protectandmanageexistingwetlandand/orriparianareasfortheirnaturalfilteringfunctions
Riparianherbaceouscover/forestbuffer,wetlandrestoration
$165.04‐22,916.06/acre #390,#391,#657
Animaltrailsandwalkways
Animaltrailsandwalkways
Notavailable #575
Streamcrossing Ford,culvert,bridge $363‐1,488per/Lft #578
RiparianRestoration ‐‐ $44.03/ft2‐$2,706/Lft A.Riley,2008
RiparianRestoration ‐‐ A.Riley,2008
Retainin‐channeltreesfollowingtimberoperationsIncreasedripariancanopyretentioninClassIIandIIIwatercourses
Notapplicable Dependentonsitespecificdeterminations
Staffjudgment
176StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐2EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasures
AssociatedwithErosionandSedimentControlReasonablyForeseeable
ComplianceMeasure
PracticeName Rangeof PracticeCosts
NRCSPracticeCodeorSource
Reduceerosion‐Maintaincropresidueorvegetativecover
CoverCrop $113.75‐206.64/acre
#340
Erosioncontrol DrySeed $0.40/ft2 Caltrans2013Erosioncontrol CompostCover $0.20‐0.80/ft2 Caltrans2013
Erosioncontrol CompostBlanket $250/cubicyard Caltrans2013
Erosioncontrol RolledErosionControlBlanket $2.00/ft2 Caltrans2013
Erosioncontrol Straw $0.05/ft2 Caltrans2013
Erosioncontrol Hydroseed $0.05/ft2 Caltrans2013
Reduceerosionandsequestersediment‐Streambufferareas/Fieldborders
FieldBorders:Ripariantree &shrubestablishment;Non‐nativeornativeseedbedpreparation
$211‐1,617/acre #386
Reduceerosionandsequestersediment‐Riparianrestoration
Tree&ShrubEstablishment $1.20‐3.20/unit #612
Reducesoilerosion‐Improvesoilproperties
Deeptillage/1 Scenario $20.10/acre #324
Res.&TillageMgt,MulchTill $28.10/acre #345Reduceslopelength,steepness,orunsheltereddistance
Precisionlandforming $175/acre #462
ContourFarming $10.10/acre #330ContourBufferStrips $282.30‐
917.40/acres#332
Reducesoilerosion‐Practicestoreducedetachment
ConservationCover $237.40‐2,279.90/acre
#327
ConservationCropRotation $6.10‐30.90/acre #328ResidueandTillManagement $36‐71.12/acre #329Covercrop $113.75‐
206.64/acre#340
Criticalarea planting $398.21‐14,046.80/acre
#342
Seasonalresiduemanagement $3.76/acre #344Diversion $3.17‐5.69/ft #362Windbreak/shelterbeltestablishment
$0.45‐0.90/ft #380
Practicestoreducedetachment(cont.)
Windbreak/shelterbeltrenovation
$0.56‐4.77/ft #650
Mulching $297.73‐756.15/acre
#484
Hydromulch $0.05/yard2 Caltrans2013Irrigationwatermanagement $28.09‐ #449
177StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐2EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasures
AssociatedwithErosionandSedimentControl202.12/acre
Crosswindridges/stripcropping/trapstrips
Notavailable #589
Surfaceroughening Wasteutilization $175.21‐
949.51/acre#612
Wildlifeuplandhabitatmanagement
Notavailable #633$17.50‐392.05/acre
#645
Practicestoreducetransportwithinthefield
Contourfarming $304.10/acre #330
Fieldwindbreak Notavailable #392Grassedwaterway $1502.42/acre #412Contourstripcropping $1.60‐3.83/acre #585Herbaceouswindbarriers Notavailable #442AFieldstripcropping Notavailable #586Terrace $2.09‐3.40/Lft #600Contourbufferstrips $282.29‐
917.41/acre#332
Practicestotrapsedimentbelowthefieldorcriticalarea
Sedimentbasins Notavailable #350
Fieldborder $210.57‐1617.25/acre
#386
Filterstrip $210.57‐448.10/acre
#393
Waterandsedimentcontrolbasin $4.86/cubicyard #638Mulchexposedareas Mulching $297.73‐
756.15/acre#484
GrazingManagementPlan
Tobedetermined
Pastureandhayplanting Seedbedpreparation,seeding,non‐native
$191.43‐501.24/acre
#512
Rangelandplanting Drillorbroadcast,nativeornon‐native
Notavailable #550
Animaltrailsandwalkways
Animaltrailsandwalkways Notavailable #575
Streamcrossing Ford,culvert,bridge $90‐1,488per/Lft #578/Caltrans2013
Forageharvestmanagement
Forageharvestmanagement $12.74‐61.61/acre #511
Vegetationcontrolwithgrazing
Prescribedgrazing $3.89‐5.80/acre #528
Wetlandwildlifehabitatmanagement
Low,mediumorhighintensity $17.50‐248.94/acre
#644
178StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐2EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasures
AssociatedwithErosionandSedimentControlInstallationofgradestabilizationstructures
Gradestabilizationstructure Notavailable #410
Streambankandshorelineprotection
Low‐highcomplexity $17.58‐80.26/ft #580
Streamchannelstabilization
Streamchannelstabilization Notavailable #584
RoadSurfacestabilization
Asphaltpaving $238,000/mile SiskiyouCountyPublicWorks
Asphaltpaving $115.00‐300.00/ton
Caltrans2013
Chipsealing $57,000/mile SiskiyouCountyPublicWorks
Rocking $4,250‐10,000/1000ft
Weaver,et.al.(2006)
ClassIIAggregateBase $75.00/cubicyard Caltrans2013ImportRockMaterial $100.00/cubicyard Caltrans2013Dustabatement $90hr
HarrisBladeRental,
RoadFillslope/cutbankcompliancemeasures
Removal/stabilizationofunstablefill.
$2‐5/cubicyard Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Soilstabilization(mulch/vegetate)offillandcutslopes.
$19‐22/1,000ft. Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Controlsediment Disconnectroaddrainagefromwatercourses(draintohillslopes).
$170/1,000ft Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Installrollingdip $85‐170/each Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Installditchreliefculvert $645‐825/each Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Installstreamcrossing $3,270/each Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Fiberroll $5.00‐20.00/Lft Caltrans2013Siltfence $8.00‐20.00/Lft Caltrans2013Gavelcheckdam $8.00‐20.00/Lft Caltrans2013
Stabilize/treatcrossingapproach
Rockroadsurface $4,250‐10,000/1,000ft
Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Installadditionalroaddrainage:waterbars,rollingdips,crossdrains
$85‐3,270/each Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Stabilize/treatcrossingsandassociatedfills
Removeundersized/failingculverts
$3‐10/cubicyard Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Removeunstablefill $2‐5/cubicyard Weaver,et.al.(2006)
Rockarmor,riprapfillslopes $150‐725.00/Cubicyard
Caltrans2013
Rockslopeprotectionfabric $5.00‐100.00/yard2
Caltrans
179StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐2EstimatedCostsofReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasures
AssociatedwithErosionandSedimentControlDrainroadawayfromunprotectedfills
$10,000‐75,000/mile
Weaver,et.al.(2006)
DevelopaRoadSystemPlan
ErosionControlPlan,non‐timberlanduse
$3528‐7,740/100acres
R.FitzgeraldMemodatedAugust6,2005
ErosionControlPlan,timberlanduse
$2,370‐7,740/100acre
WaterPollutionControlPlan $650‐10,000/per Caltrans2013Roaddecommissioning Recontourroadtoprovidefora
stable,hydrologically“invisible”site(e.g.removeperchedfill,outslopeoldroadprism,removecrossings)
$2,000‐$50,000/miledependingonsteepnessandlocationofroad
Weaver,et.al.(2004)
Minimizeroadsystem(density)tocorrespondwithmaintenanceresources
$2,000‐50,000/miletorecontourunnecessaryroads
Weaver,et.al.(2004)
Decommissionroadsadjacenttowatercourseandrelocatetomidslopeorridgetopifpossible
$3,000‐23,000permile
CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
180StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐3EstimatedComplianceMeasuresCoststo
AddressTailwater/SurfaceWaterImpoundments/ColdWaterResources/In‐StreamFlows
ReasonablyForeseeableComplianceMeasure
NRCSPracticeName NRCSPracticeCost NRCSPracticeCode
Irrigationscheduling Irrigationwatermanagement $28.09‐202.12/acre #449Efficientapplicationofirrigationwater
Microirrigation $503.85‐1835.93/acre #441
Efficienttransportofirrigationwater
Installationofpipingtoreplaceopenditches
$2.47‐5.13/ft #516
Useofrunoffortailwater
Irrigationsystem/tailwaterrecovery
Notavailable #447
Managementofdrainagewater
Runoffmanagementsystem Notavailable #570
Vegetatedfilterstrips Filterstrip $210.57‐448.10/acre #393Surfacefieldditch Fieldditch Notavailable #607Watertablecontrol,controlleddrainage
Subsurfacedrain $3.86‐6.44/ft #606
Installationofpipelineforoff‐channelwater
Pipeline,roughterrain,steelorplastic
$2.47‐5.13/ft #516
Constructingoff‐streampond
Pondupto50AcFt $12,969.38‐32,068.24/no.
#378
Installingtroughortankforoff‐channelwater
Wateringfacility $1,958.69‐5,020.64/no. #614
Constructingwell Waterwell $15,413.45‐41,537.97/no.
#642
Improvingsprings Springdevelopment $2,629.19‐4,335.61/no. #574
Barrierremoval(dam) NA $10,00‐500,000/per CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
Barrierremoval(non‐structuralsites)
NA $2,400‐34,000/per CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
Barrierremoval(streamcrossings)
NA $15,000‐500,000/per CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
Riparianrevegetation NA $5,000‐135,000/acre CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
Streambankrestoration
NA $125.00/ft2 CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
Fencing NA $3.00‐12.00/Lft CDFWCohoRecoveryPlan
181StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
10.4SourcesofFundingPotentialsourcesoffundingincludemoniesfromprivateandpublicsources.Publicfinancingincludes,butisnotlimitedto:grantfunds,asdescribedbelow;single‐purposeappropriationsfromfederal,state,and/orlocallegislativebodies;and,bondindebtednessandloansfromgovernmentinstitutions.10.4.1SummaryofPertinentStateFundingProgramsThereareseveralpotentialsourcesofpublicfinancingthroughgrantandfundingprogramsadministered,atleastinpart,bytheRegionalWaterBoardandtheStateWaterBoard.Theseprogramsvaryovertimedependinguponfederalandstatebudgetsandballotpropositionsapprovedbyvoters.StatefundingprogramspertinenttotheproposedBasinPlanamendmentaresummarizedanddescribedbelow.AdditionalinformationcanbefoundontheStateWaterResourcesControlBoardwebpage(http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/water_issues/programs/grants_loans/).AgriculturalDrainageLoanProgramTheAgriculturalDrainageLoanProgramwascreatedbytheWaterConservationandWaterQualityBondActof1986toaddresstreatment,storage,conveyance,ordisposalofagriculturaldrainagewaterthatthreatenswatersoftheState.Thereisafundingcapof$20millionforimplementationprojectsand$100,000forfeasibilitystudies.Loanrepaymentsareforaperiodofupto20years.AgriculturalDrainageManagementLoanProgramTheAgriculturalDrainageManagementLoanProgram,createdbyProposition204anddistributedthroughtheAgriculturalDrainageManagementSubaccount,providesloanandgrantfundingforDrainageWaterManagementUnits.DrainageWaterManagementUnitsarelandandfacilitiesforthetreatment,storage,conveyance,reductionordisposalofagriculturaldrainagewaterthat,ifdischargeduntreated,wouldpolluteorthreatentopollutethewatersoftheState.Thisprogramisavailabletoanycity,county,district,jointpowerauthority,orotherpoliticalsubdivisionoftheStateinvolvedwithwatermanagement.AgriculturalWaterQualityGrantsProgramTheAgriculturalWaterQualityGrantProgramprovidesfundingforprojectsthatreduceoreliminatenon‐pointsourcepollutiondischargetosurfacewatersfromagriculturallands.FundingfromPropositions50hasapproximately$15millioningrantfundingisavailableunderthisfundingcycle.Eligibleprojectsinclude:
AgriculturalWaterUseEfficiencyImplementationProjectsthatresultinwatersavings,increasedin‐streamflow,increasedwaterquality,andincreasedenergyefficiency
AgriculturalWaterUseEfficiencyTechnicalAssistance,Planning,FeasibilityStudies,ResearchandDevelopment,Training,Education,PublicOutreach,andPilotprojects
182StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
FederalCleanWaterActSection319NonpointSourceImplementationProgramThisprogramisanannualfederallyfundednonpointsourcepollutioncontrolprogramthatisfocusedoncontrollingactivitiesthatimpairbeneficialusesandonlimitingpollutanteffectscausedbythoseactivities.Statesmustestablishpriorityrankingsforwatersonlistsofimpairedwatersanddevelopactionplans,knownasTotalMaximumDailyLoads(TMDLs),toimprovewaterquality.ProjectproposalsthataddressTMDLimplementationandthosethataddressproblemsinimpairedwatersarefavoredintheselectionprocess.Thereisalsoafocusonimplementingmanagementactivitiesthatleadtoreductionand/orpreventionofpollutantsthatthreatenorimpairsurfaceandgroundwaters.CleanWaterStateRevolvingFundTheFederalWaterPollutionControlAct(CleanWaterActorCWA),asamendedin1987,providesforestablishmentofaCleanWaterStateRevolvingFund(CWSRF)program.Theprogramisfundedbyfederalgrants,Statefunds,andRevenueBonds.ThepurposeoftheCWSRFprogramistoimplementtheCWAandvariousStatelawsbyprovidingfinancialassistancefortheconstructionoffacilitiesorimplementationofmeasuresnecessarytoaddresswaterqualityproblemsandtopreventpollutionofthewatersoftheState.TheCWSRFLoanProgramprovideslow‐interestloanfundingforconstructionofpublicly‐ownedwastewatertreatmentfacilities,localsewers,sewerinterceptors,waterrecyclingfacilities,aswellas,expandeduseprojectssuchasimplementationofnonpointsource(NPS)projectsorprograms,developmentandimplementationofestuaryComprehensiveConservationandManagementPlans,andstormwatertreatment.IntegratedRegionalWaterManagementGrantsIntegratedRegionalWaterManagement(IRWM)isacollaborativeefforttomanageallaspectsofwaterresourcesinaregion.IRWMcrossesjurisdictional,watershed,andpoliticalboundaries;involvesmultipleagencies,stakeholders,individuals,andgroups;andattemptstoaddresstheissuesanddifferingperspectivesofalltheentitiesinvolvedthroughmutuallybeneficialsolutions.
TheDepartmentofWaterResourceshasanumberofIRWMgrantprogramfundingopportunities.CurrentIRWMgrantprogramsinclude:planning,implementation,andstormwaterfloodmanagement.DWR'sIRWMGrantProgramsaremanagedwithinDWR'sDivisionofIRWMbytheFinancialAssistanceBranchwithassistancefromtheRegionalPlanningBranchandregionaloffices.
10.4.2SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingProgramsSeveralfederalagencies,includingbutnotlimitedtotheU.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency,NOAAFisheries,U.S.FishandWildlifeService,andUSDANaturalResourcesConservationService,alsoprovidegrantsandotherfundingopportunities.Table10‐4presentedbelowprovidesasummaryofthepertinentfederalfundingprograms.
183StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
TheU.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgencyprovidesaccessthroughitswebpagetoacatalogoffederalfundingopportunities:http://water.epa.gov/grants_funding/shedfund/databases.cfmTheU.S.DepartmentofAgriculture–NaturalResourceConservationServicehasawidevarietyofagricultural/timberfinancialsupportprograms.TheEnvironmentalQualityIncentivesProgram(EQIP)isavoluntaryprogramthatprovidesfinancialandtechnicalassistancetoagriculturalproducersthroughcontractsuptoamaximumtermoftenyearsinlength.Thesecontractsprovidefinancialassistancetohelpplanandimplementconservationpracticesthataddressnaturalresourceconcernsandforopportunitiestoimprovesoil,water,plant,animal,airandrelatedresourcesonagriculturallandandnon‐industrialprivateforestland.Inaddition,apurposeofEQIPistohelpproducersmeetFederal,State,Tribalandlocalenvironmentalregulations.Thefinancialassistanceprogramsinclude:AgriculturalManagementAssistanceAgriculturalWaterEnhancementProgramAirQualityInitiativeCooperativeConservationPartnershipInitiativeConservationInnovationGrantsConservationStewardshipProgramEnvironmentalQualityIncentivesProgramEmergencyWatershedProtectionProgramWildlifeHabitatIncentiveProgramWebsite http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/main/national/programs/financial/cig/Foradditionalagriculturespecificgrants:http://www.grants.gov/search‐grants.html?fundingCategories%3DAG%7CAgriculture
184StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptionAquaticEcosystemRestoration(CAPSection206)
Workunderthisauthoritymaycarryoutaquaticecosystemrestorationprojectsthatwillimprovethequalityoftheenvironment,areinthepublicinterest,andarecost‐effective.ThereisnorequirementthatanexistingCorpsprojectbeinvolved
BringBacktheNativesGrantProgram
TheBringBacktheNativesinitiative(BBN)fundson‐the‐groundeffortstorestorenativeaquaticspeciestotheirhistoricrange.Projectsshouldinvolvepartnershipsbetweencommunities,agencies,privatelandowners,andorganizationsthatseektorehabilitatestreamsideandwatershedhabitats.Projectsshouldfocusonhabitatneedsofspeciessuchasfish,invertebrates,andamphibiansthatoriginallyinhabitedthewaterwaysacrossthecountry.FundingfortheBBNprogramisadministeredthroughNFWFfromfederalagenciescooperatingtosupportthisprogram.CooperatingagenciesandorganizationsincludetheUSFishandWildlifeService(USFWS),BureauofLandManagement(BLM),USDAForestService(USFS),andTroutUnlimited(TU).
CoastalProgram TheU.S.FishandWildlifeService(USFWS)CoastalProgramworkstoconservehealthycoastalhabitatsonpublicorprivatelandforthebenefitoffish,wildlife,andpeoplein22specificcoastalareas.Theprogramformscooperativepartnershipsdesignedto(1)protectcostalhabitatsbyprovidingtechnicalassistanceforconservationeasementsandacquisitions;(2)restorecoastalwetlands,uplands,andriparianareas;and(3)removebarrierstofishpassageincoastalwatershedsandestuaries.Programbiologistsproviderestorationexpertiseandfinancialassistancetofederalandstateagencies,localandtribalgovernments,businesses,privatelandowners,andconservationorganizationssuchaslocallandtrustsandwatershedcouncils.
Community‐basedHabitatRestorationPartnershipGrants
TheNOAACommunity‐basedRestorationProgram(NOAACRP)providesfundsforsmall‐scale,locallydrivenhabitatrestorationprojectsthatfosternaturalresourcestewardshipwithincommunities.Theprogramseekstobringtogetherdiversepartnerstoimplementhabitatrestorationprojectstobenefitlivingmarineresources.Projectsmightincluderestoringsaltmarshes,mangroves,andothercoastalhabitats;improvingfishpassageandhabitatqualityforanadromousspecies;removingdams;restoringandcreatingoysterreefs,removingexoticvegetationandreplantingwithnativespecies;andsimilarprojectstorestorehabitatorimprovehabitatqualityforpopulationsofmarineandanadromousfish.
ConservationReserveProgram
TheConservation ReserveProgram(CRP)isavoluntaryprogramforagriculturallandowners.ThroughCRP,youcanreceiveannualrentalpaymentsandcost‐shareassistancetoestablishlong‐term,resourceconservingcoversoneligiblefarmland.
ConservationSecurityProgram
TheConservationSecurityProgram(CSP)isavoluntaryconservationprogramthatsupportsongoingstewardshipofprivatelandsbyprovidingpaymentformaintainingandenhancingnaturalresources.CSPidentifiesandrewardsthosefarmersandrancherswhoaremeetingthehigheststandardsofconservationandenvironmentalmanagementontheiroperations.
Cooperative Watershed Management Program
DepartmentoftheInteriorBureauofReclamation.ThepurposeoftheCooperativeWatershedManagementProgramistoenhancewaterconservation,includingalternativeuses;improvewaterquality;improveecologicalresiliencyofariverorstream;,andtoreduceconflictsoverwateratthewatershedlevelbysupportingtheformationofwatershedgroupstodeveloplocalsolutionstoaddresswatermanagementissues.
EmergencyWatershed
TheUSDANaturalResourcesConservationService'sEmergencyWatershedProtection(EWP)programhelpsprotectlivesandpropertythreatenedby
185StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptionProtection naturaldisasterssuchasfloods,hurricanes,tornadoes,droughts,and
wildfires.EWPprovidesfundingforsuchworkasclearingdebrisfromcloggedwaterways,restoringvegetation,andstabilizingriverbanks.Themeasuresthataretakenmustbeenvironmentallyandeconomicallysoundandgenerallybenefitmorethanonepropertyowner.EWPalsoprovidesfundstopurchasefloodplaineasementsasanemergencymeasure.Floodplaineasementsrestore,protect,maintain,andenhancethefunctionsofthefloodplain;conservenaturalvaluesincludingfishandwildlifehabitat,waterquality,floodwaterretention,groundwaterrecharge,andopenspace;reducelong‐termfederaldisasterassistance;andsafeguardlivesandpropertyfromfloods,drought,andtheproductsoferosion.EWPcanprovideupto90percentcostshareinlimitedresourceareasasdeterminedbytheUSCensus.
EnvironmentalQualityIncentivesProgram
TheUSDANaturalResourcesConservationService'sEnvironmentalQualityIncentivesProgram(EQIP)wasestablishedtoprovideavoluntaryconservationprogramforfarmersandrancherstoaddresssignificantnaturalresourceneedsandobjectives.EQIPofferscontractswithaminimumtermthatendsoneyearaftertheimplementationofthelastscheduledpracticesandamaximumtermoftenyears.Thesecontractsprovidefinancialassistancetoprogramparticipantstoimplementconservationpractices.Personsorlegalentities,whoareownersoflandunderagriculturalproductionorwhoareengagedinlivestockoragriculturalproductiononeligiblelandmayparticipateinEQIP.EQIPactivitiesarecarriedoutaccordingtoanenvironmentalqualityincentivesprogramplanofoperationsdevelopedinconjunctionwiththeproducerthatidentifiestheappropriateconservationpracticeorpracticestoaddresstheresourceconcerns.ThepracticesaresubjecttoNRCStechnicalstandardsadaptedforlocalconditions.NRCSapprovestheplanofoperationsandobligatescontractfundsfortheconservationpracticeslistedintheplanofoperations.
FarmandRanchLandsProtectionProgram(FRPP)
TheUSDANaturalResourcesConservationService'sFarmlandProtectionProgram(FPP)isavoluntaryprogramthathelpsfarmersandrancherskeeptheirlandinagricultureandpreventsconversionofagriculturallandtonon‐agriculturaluses.Theprogramprovidesmatchingfundstoorganizationswithexistingfarmlandprotectionprogramsthatenablethemtopurchaseconservationeasements.Theseentitiespurchaseeasementsfromlandownersinexchangeforalumpsumpayment,nottoexceedtheappraisedfairmarketvalueoftheland'sdevelopmentrights.Theeasementsareforperpetuityunlessprohibitedbystatelaw.Eligiblelandislandonafarmorranchthathasprime,unique,statewide,orlocallyimportantsoilorcontainshistoricalorarchaeologicalresources;supportsthepolicyofaStateorlocalfarmandranchlandprotectionpolicy;issubjecttoapendingofferbyaneligibleentity;andincludescropland,rangeland,grassland,pastureland,forestlandandotherincidentallandthatispartofanagriculturaloperation.
Five‐StarRestorationProgram
TheEPAsupportstheFive‐StarRestorationProgrambyprovidingfundstotheNationalFishandWildlifeFoundationanditspartners,theNationalAssociationofCounties,NOAA'sCommunity‐basedRestorationProgramandtheWildlifeHabitatCouncil.Thesegroupsthenmakesubgrantstosupportcommunity‐basedwetlandandriparianrestorationprojects.Competitiveprojectswillhaveastrongon‐the‐groundhabitatrestorationcomponentthatprovideslong‐termecological,educational,and/orsocioeconomicbenefitstothepeopleandtheircommunity.Preferencewill
186StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptionbegiventoprojectsthatarepartofalargerwatershedorcommunitystewardshipeffortandincludeadescriptionoflong‐termmanagementactivities.Projectsmustinvolvecontributionsfrommultipleanddiversepartners,includingcitizenvolunteerorganizations,corporations,privatelandowners,localconservationorganizations,youthgroups,charitablefoundations,andotherfederal,state,andtribalagenciesandlocalgovernments.Eachprojectwouldideallyinvolveatleastfivepartnerswhoareexpectedtocontributefunding,land,technicalassistance,workforcesupport,orotherin‐kindservicesthatareequivalenttothefederalcontribution.
FishandWildlifeManagementAssistance
DepartmentoftheInteriorFishandWildlifeServiceFundsmaybeusedtoconductfishandwildlifemanagementactivitiesthatalignwiththeconservation,restoration,andmanagementgoalsandprioritiesoftheFishandWildlifeConservationOffices.ThisincludesgoalsandprioritiesidentifiedbytheNationalFishPassageProgram(NFPP)andindividualpartnershipsundertheNationalFishHabitatPartnership(NFHP).Restorationworkcanconsistofhabitatconstructionactivitiessuchasculvertreplacements,damnremovals,fishwayconstruction,installationoffishhabitatstructuresandvegetationplantings.Examplesoffundedactivitiesincludehabitatrestoration(streamimprovementsordeconstructionofbarrierstoincreasequalityofaquatichabitats),monitoringandassessment,removalofbarrierstopassage,fishpropagation,andaquaticplantestablishment.Thisalsoincludeseffortstominimizetheestablishment,spread,andimpactofaquaticinvasivespecies,includingthoseeffortsconductedundertheauspicesoftheState/InterstateAquaticNuisanceSpecies(ANS)ManagementPlanGrantProgram.Technicalassistance–intheformofadviceonbiological,chemical,and/orphysicalaspectsofaproject–isalsoavailabletoawardees.Awardeesareexpectedtoincludeapublicoutreachcomponentintheirproject.ApplicantsapplyingforState/InterstateANSManagementPlanfundsmustbeaStateorInterstateorganizationwithanANSTaskForceapprovedplan.
HealthyForestsReserveProgram
TheHealthyForestsReserveProgram(HFRP)isavoluntaryprogramestablishedforthepurposeofrestoringandenhancingforestecosystemsto:1)promotetherecoveryofthreatenedandendangeredspecies,2)improvebiodiversity;and,3)enhancecarbonsequestration.ProgramimplementationhasbeendelegatedbytheSecretaryofAgriculturetotheNaturalResourcesConservationService.
ForestLegacyProgram
ThroughitsForestLegacyProgram(FLP),theUSDAForestServicesupportsstateeffortstoprotectenvironmentallysensitiveforestlandsfromtheconversiontonon‐forestusesthroughtheuseofconservationeasementsandfee‐simplepurchase.Designedtoencouragetheprotectionofprivatelyownedforestlands,FLPisanentirelyvoluntaryprogram.Theprogramenableslandownerstoretainownershipoftheirlandandcontinuetoearnincomefromitwhilekeepingdrinkingwatersafeandclean,conservingvaluableopenspaceaswellasprotectingcriticalwildlifehabitatsandoutdoorrecreationopportunities.Theprogrampromotesprofessionalforestmanagementandrequiresforestmanagementplans.Theprogramemphasizesstrategicconservation‐workinginpartnershipwithStates,localcommunitiesandnon‐governmentalorganizationstomakeadifferenceonthelandandforcommunitiesbyconservingareasof
187StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptionunbrokenforest,watershedorrivercorridorforestsorbycomplimentingexistinglandconservationefforts.FLPconservationeasementsrestrictdevelopment,protectarangeofpublicvaluesandmanyrequirepublicaccessforrecreation.
NOAAOpenRiversInitiative
TheNOAAOpenRiversInitiative(ORI)providesfundingandtechnicalexpertiseforcommunity‐driven,smalldamandriverbarrierremovals,primarilyincoastalstates.Projectsareexpectedtoprovideaneconomicboostforcommunities,enhancepublicsafety,andimprovepopulationsofNOAAtrustresourcessuchasstripedbass,Atlanticandshortnosesturgeon,AtlanticandPacificsalmon,Americaneel,Americanshad,bluebackherring,andalewife.Proposalsselectedwillbeimplementedthroughacooperativeagreement
NationalIntegratedWaterQualityProgram(NIWQP)
TheNationalIntegratedWaterQualityProgram(NIWQP)providesfundingforresearch,education,andextensionprojectsaimedatimprovingwaterqualityinagriculturalandruralwatersheds.TheNIWQPhasidentifiedeight"themes"thatarebeingpromotedinresearch,educationandextension.Theeightthemesare(1)Animalmanureandwastemanagement(2)Drinkingwaterandhumanhealth(3)Environmentalrestoration(4)Nutrientandpesticidemanagement(5)Pollutionassessmentandprevention(6)Watershedmanagement(7)Waterconservationandagriculturalwatermanagement(8)Waterpolicyandeconomics.Awardsaremadeinfourprogramareas‐NationalFacilitationProjects,RegionalCoordinationProjects,ExtensionEducationProjects,andIntegratedResearch,EducationandExtensionProjects.Pleasenotethatfundingisonlyavailabletouniversities.
NationalWildlifeRefugeFriendsGroupGrantProgram
TheNationalFishandWildlifeFoundationprovidesgrantsforprojectsthathelporganizationstobeeffectiveco‐stewardsofourNation'simportantnaturalresourceswithintheNationalWildlifeRefugeSystem.Thisprogramprovidescompetitiveseedgrantstohelpincreasethenumberandeffectivenessoforganizationsinterestedinassistingtherefugesystemnationwide.Theprogramwillfund:(1)Start‐upGrantstoassiststartingrefugesupportgroupswithformativeand/orinitialoperationalsupport(membershipdrives,training,postage,etc.);(2)CapacityBuildingGrantstostrengthenexistingrefugesupportgroups'capacitytobemoreeffective(outreachefforts,strategicplanning,membershipdevelopment);and(3)ProjectSpecificGrantstosupportaspecificproject(conservationeducationprogramsforlocalschools,outreachprogramsforprivatelandowners,habitatrestorationprojects,etc.)
NativePlantConservationInitiative
TheNationalFishandWildlifeFoundation'sNativePlantConservationInitiative(NPCI)supportson‐the‐groundconservationprojectsthatprotect,enhance,and/orrestorenativeplantcommunitiesonpublicandprivateland.Projectstypicallyfallintooneofthreecategoriesandmaycontainelementsofeach:protectionandrestoration,informationandeducation,andinventoryandassessment.Applicantsareencouraged,whenappropriate,toincludeapollinatorcomponentintheirproject.ThisprogramisfundedbytheBureauofLandManagement,ForestService,FishandWildlifeService,andNationalParkService.
NorthAmericanWetlandsConservationActGrantsProgram
TheU.S.FishandWildlifeService'sDivisionofBirdHabitatConservationadministersthismatchinggrantsprogramtocarryoutwetlandsandassociateduplandsconservationprojectsintheUnitedStates,Canada,andMexico.Grantrequestsmustbematchedbyapartnershipwithnonfederal
188StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptionfundsataminimum1:1ratio.ConservationactivitiessupportedbytheActintheUnitedStatesandCanadaincludehabitatprotection,restoration,andenhancement.Mexicanpartnershipsmayalsodeveloptraining,educational,andmanagementprogramsandconductsustainable‐usestudies.ProjectproposalsmustmeetcertainbiologicalcriteriaestablishedundertheAct.Visittheprogramwebsiteformoreinformation.(Clickonthehyperlinkedprogramnametoseethelistingfor"PrimaryInternet".)
PartnersforFishandWildlifeProgram
ThePartnersforFishandWildlifeProgramprovidestechnicalandfinancialassistancetoprivatelandownerstorestorefishandwildlifehabitatsontheirlands.Since1987,theprogramhaspartneredwithmorethan37,700landownerstorestore765,400acresofwetlands;over1.9millionacresofgrasslandsandotheruplandhabitats;and6,560milesofin‐streamandstreamsidehabitat.Inaddition,theprogramhasreopenedstreamhabitatforfishandotheraquaticspeciesbyremovingbarrierstopassage.
PesticideEnvironmentalStewardshipGrants
EPA'sPesticideEnvironmentalStewardshipProgram(PESP)offersgrantstosupportthereductionofrisksfrompesticidesinagriculturalandnon‐agriculturalsettings,andtoimplementpollutionpreventionmeasures.AllorganizationswithacommitmenttopesticideriskreductionareeligibletojoinPESPasmembers,eitherasPartnersorasSupporters.Formoreinformationaboutmembershiprequirementsandavailablegrants,clickontheprogramnameandrefertothelinklistedunder"PrimaryInternet."
ProjectModificationsforImprovementoftheEnvironment(CAPSection1135)
WorkunderthisauthorityprovidesformodificationsinthestructuresandoperationsofwaterresourcesprojectsconstructedbytheCorpsofEngineerstoimprovethequalityoftheenvironment.Additionally,theCorpsmayundertakerestorationprojectsatlocationswhereanexistingCorpsprojecthascontributedtothedegradation.Theprimarygoaloftheseprojectsisecosystemrestorationwithanemphasisonprojectsbenefitingfishandwildlife.Theprojectmustbeconsistentwiththeauthorizedpurposesoftheprojectbeingmodified,environmentallyacceptable,andcompletewithinitself
PullingTogetherInitiative
TheNationalFishandWildlifeFoundation'sPullingTogetherInitiative(PTI)providesameansforfederalagenciestopartnerwithstateandlocalagencies,privatelandowners,andotherinterestedpartiestodeveloplong‐termweedmanagementprojectswithinthescopeofanintegratedpestmanagementstrategy.ThegoalsofPTIare:(1)toprevent,manage,oreradicateinvasiveandnoxiousplantsthroughacoordinatedprogramofpublic/privatepartnerships;and(2)toincreasepublicawarenessoftheadverseimpactsofinvasiveandnoxiousplants.PTIprovidessupportonacompetitivebasisfortheformationoflocalweedmanagementarea(WMA)partnerships,allowingthemtodemonstratesuccessfulcollaborativeeffortsanddeveloppermanentfundingsourcesforthemaintenanceofWMAsfromtheinvolvedparties.Successfulprojectswillservetoincreasepublicawarenessandinterestinfuturepartnershipprojects.
WatershedProtectionandFloodPreventionProgram
Alsoknownasthe'WatershedProgram'orthe'PL566Program,'thisprogramprovidestechnicalandfinancialassistancetoaddresswaterresourceandrelatedeconomicproblemsonawatershedbasis.Projectsrelatedtowatershedprotection,floodmitigation,watersupply,waterquality,erosionandsedimentcontrol,wetlandcreationandrestoration,fishandwildlifehabitatenhancement,agriculturalwaterconservation,andpublicrecreationareeligibleforassistance.Technicalandfinancialassistanceisalsoavailableforplanningnewwatershedsurveys.
189StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptionSustainableAgricultureResearchandEducation
TheSustainableAgricultureResearchandEducation(SARE)programoftheU.S.DepartmentofAgricultureworkstoadvancefarmingsystemsthataremoreprofitable,environmentallysoundandgoodforcommunitiesthroughaninnovativegrantsprogram.Morespecifically,SAREfundsscientificinvestigationandeducationtoreducetheuseofchemicalpesticides,fertilizers,andtoxicmaterialsinagriculturalproduction;toimprovemanagementofon‐farmresourcestoenhanceproductivity,profitability,andcompetitiveness;topromotecrop,livestock,andenterprisediversificationandtofacilitatetheresearchofagriculturalproductionsystemsinareasthatpossessvarioussoil,climatic,andphysicalcharacteristics;tostudyfarmsthathavearemanagedusingfarmpracticesthatoptimizeon‐farmresourcesandconservationpractices;andtopromotepartnershipsamongfarmers,nonprofitorganizations,agribusiness,andpublicandprivateresearchandextensioninstitutions.ClickonprogramnameandcheckthelinkinthePrimaryInternetboxformoreinformationaboutgrantopportunitiesandprogramresults.
WatershedRehabilitationProgram
ThisprogramprovidesFederalcost‐sharefundingfortherehabilitationofagingdamsthatwereinstalledprimarilythroughtheWatershedProtectionandFloodPreventionProgramoverthepast55years.Thepurposeforrehabilitationistoextendtheservicelifeofdamsandbringthemintocompliancewithapplicablesafetyandperformancestandardsortodecommissionthedamssotheynolongerposeathreattolifeandproperty.
WatershedRehabilitationProgram
ThisprogramprovidesFederalcost‐sharefundingfortherehabilitationofagingdamsthatwereinstalledprimarilythroughtheWatershedProtectionandFloodPreventionProgramoverthepast55years.Thepurposeforrehabilitationistoextendtheservicelifeofdamsandbringthemintocompliancewithapplicablesafetyandperformancestandardsortodecommissionthedamssotheynolongerposeathreattolifeandproperty.
WatershedRestorationandEnhancementAgreementAuthority
DepartmentofAgricultureForestService.Projectsthatprotect,enhance,orrestoreresourceswithinawatershedandprovidetangiblebenefitstoachievingForestServicegoalsandobjectivesareallowableunderWyden.Projecttypesarenotlimitedtoactualprojectsontheground;forexample,streamgabioninstallation,checkdamconstruction,fishhabitatrestoration,orculvertcleaning.Watershedanalysisstudies,habitatsurveysandwildlifespeciesmonitoring,dependingonthebenefittoresourceswithinthewatershed,arealsopermissibleunderWyden.AnyprojectcarriedoutunderWydenauthoritymustcomplywithallapplicableFederal,Stateandlocallawsandregulations,policiesandpermitrequirements;forexample,NationalEnvironmentalPolicyAct,CleanWaterAct,andEndangeredSpeciesAct.Projectsmustbewithinawatershedforthestatedprogramobjectives.UseofgrantsisrestrictedtoStateandPrivateForestryfunding.
WetlandsReserveProgram
Throughthisvoluntaryprogram,theUSDANaturalResourcesConservationService(NRCS)provideslandownerswithfinancialincentivestorestoreandprotectwetlandsinexchangeforretiringmarginalagriculturalland.Toparticipateintheprogramlandownersmaysellaconservationeasementorenterintoacost‐sharerestorationagreement(landownersvoluntarilylimitfutureuseoftheland,butretainprivateownership).LandownersandtheNRCSjointlydevelopaplanfor
190StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Table10‐4SummaryofPertinentFederalFundingPrograms
FundingProgram ProgramDescriptiontherestorationandmaintenanceofthewetland.
WildlifeHabitatIncentivesProgram
TheWildlifeHabitatIncentivesProgram(WHIP)isavoluntaryprogramforpeoplewhowanttodevelopandimprovewildlifehabitatonprivatelands.Itprovidesbothtechnicalassistanceandcostsharingtohelpestablishandimprovefishandwildlifehabitat.ParticipantsworkwithUSDA'sNaturalResourcesConservationServicetoprepareawildlifehabitatdevelopmentplaninconsultationwithalocalconservationdistrict.Theplandescribesthelandowner'sgoalsforimprovingwildlifehabitat,includesalistofpracticesandascheduleforinstallingthem,anddetailsthestepsnecessarytomaintainthehabitatforthelifeoftheagreement.
191StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
11.0 PUBLICPARTICIPATIONThischapterdescribessomeoftheopportunitiesthathavebeenmadeavailabletothepublicforcommentonandparticipationinthedevelopmentofthePolicytoImplementtheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentsintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds.11.1TemperaturePolicyStatementResolutionProcessThePolicyStatementforImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectiveforTemperatureintheNorthCoastRegion(policystatement;ResolutionNo.R1‐2012‐0013)establishedthescopeandapproachofthisPolicyanddirecteditsincorporationintotheBasinPlan.ThecontentofthepolicystatementisincorporatedintothisPolicy.TheRegionalWaterBoardheldthreepublichearingsaspartofthepolicystatementadoptionprocess:onSeptember29,2011,November3,2011,andJanuary19,2012.Thatprocessincludedtwopubliccommentperiods.Additionally,RegionalWaterBoardstaffheldnumerousmeetingswithstakeholdersduringthatprocess.11.2CEQAScopingRegionalWaterBoardstaffheldCEQAscopingmeetingsonFebruary15th,27thand28th,2013,inSantaRosa,Bayside,andYrekaCA,respectively.Forty‐onecommentswerereceivedinwrittenform,while59werereceivedinverbalformatthescopingmeetings.Commentswerereceivedfromfivefederal,stateandlocalagencies,eightnongovernmentalorganizationsandspecial‐interestgroups,andfourindividuals.Seesection9.2.2forfurtherdiscussion.11.3PresentationstotheRegionalWaterBoardRegionalWaterBoardstaffhasprovidedtwoupdatestotheRegionalWaterBoardasinformationitemsatRegionalWaterBoardmeetings.ThefirstofthesewasonMarch15,2012,andfocusedonthescheduleforthedevelopmentofthisPolicy.ThesecondwasonJune13,2013.Atthatmeetingstaffpresentedabroadoverviewofthehistory,approach,status,andremainingstepsintheprocessofdevelopingthisPolicy.11.4OtherActivitiesRegionalWaterBoardstaffhastakentheopportunitytodiscussthedevelopmentandapproachofthisPolicyatvariousmeetingsin2012and2013.StaffhasgivenbriefupdatesandoverviewsofthePolicyattheEelRiverWatershedForum,CalFire’sSectionVTechnicalAdvisoryCommitteemeetings,aSonomaCountyPlanningCommissionmeeting,andothersimilarvenues.Additionally,stafforganizedameetingwiththeplaintiffsinthelawsuitthatresultedintheStipulatedAgreement(seesection6.1)onMay28,2013.StaffalsoorganizedmeetingswithenvironmentaladvocatesonJune26,2013,FarmBureaurepresentativesonAugust9,2013,andwithforestryadvocatesonAugust13,2013.
192StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
11.5TMDLDevelopmentProcessThedevelopmentoftechnicalTMDLanalysesfortheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverTMDLsincludedafullpublicparticipationprocessatthetimeoftheirdevelopment.Eachoftheprocessesincludedatleastonepublicmeetinginornearthewatershed,aswellasapublichearing,publiccommentsolicitation,andresponsestocomments.ThepublicprocessforeachoftheseTMDLsisdiscussedbelowforcompleteness.ThefollowingdiscussionparaphrasesthepublicparticipationdiscussionscontainedintheindividualTMDLs.MattoleRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAandRegionalWaterBoardstaffheldtwopublicmeetingsintheMattoleRiverwatershedduringthepubliccommentperiodonthedraftTMDL.ThefirstwasheldonNovember12,2002,attheMattoleGrangeinPetrolia,andthesecondwasheldonNovember13,2002,attheWhitethornGrangeinWhitethorn.StafffromtheUSEPAandtheRegionalWaterBoardstaffgavepresentationsonthecontentofthedraftTMDLandassociatedTechnicalSupportDocument(TSD)andansweredquestionsfromthepublicatthosemeetings.AlegalnoticewasplacedintheEurekaTimes‐StandardandHumboldtBeacon,whicharenewspapersofgeneralcirculationintheMattoleRiverwatershed.Inaddition,thepubliccommentperiodwasannouncedintheMattoleRestorationCouncilnewsletterdistributedduringthecommentperiod.TheUSEPApreparedaresponseforallwrittencommentsonthedraftTMDLsreceivedduringthecommentperiod,aswellasthemajorcommentsfromtheinformationalpublicmeetings.(USEPA2002a)Navarro RiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAplacedapublicnoticeofthedraftNavarroRivertemperatureTMDLintheSantaRosaPressDemocrat,AndersonValleyAdvertiser,andMendocinoBeacon,whicharenewspapersofgeneralcirculationintheNavarroRiverwatershed.TheUSEPAheldapublicmeetingonTuesday,October3,2000,attheAppleHallDiningRoomattheMendocinoCountyFairgroundsinBoonville.Atthemeeting,staffoftheUSEPAandRegionalWaterBoarddescribedtheTMDLandansweredquestionsregardingthem.TheUSEPApreparedawrittenresponsetoallwrittencommentsonthedraftTMDLreceivedbyEPAduringthecommentperiod.Inresponsetocomments,theRegionalWaterBoardstaffconductedadditionaltechnicalanalysisontheimpactsofflowconditionsontemperature.AtechnicaladdendumwaspreparedandthedraftTMDLwasrevised.TheTMDLestablishedbytheUSEPAwerelargelybasedontheTSDpreparedbyRegionalWaterBoardstaff.RegionalWaterBoardstaffprovidedforpublicparticipationinthedevelopmentoftheTSDthroughmeetings,presentations,andanewsletter.(USEPA2000)SouthForkEelRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAheldtwopublicmeetingsinGarberville,severalmeetingswithinterestedparties,apublichearing,andrespondedtopubliccommentsthroughchangestotheTMDLandacommentresponsesummary.Inaddition,USEPAstaffparticipatedinaradioshowdiscussingtheTMDL.NoticesoftheavailabilityofthedraftTMDLweresenttolocalnewspapersandradiostations,whichgenerated
193StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
severalnewspaperarticlesintheEurekaTimesStandardandSantaRosaPressDemocrat.(USEPA1999)NorthForkEelRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAplacedapublicnoticeofthedraftNorthForkEelRivertemperatureTMDLintheWillitsNewsandSantaRosaPressDemocrat,whichareofgeneralcirculationinMendocinoandTrinityCounty,aswellastoindividualsontheUpperEelWatershedForummailinglist.TheUSEPApreparedawrittenresponsetoallwrittencommentsonthedraftTMDLreceivedduringthecommentperiod.Inaddition,aninformalmeetingtodiscussthedraftTMDLwasheldonSeptember18,2002inCovelo.(USEPA2002b)MiddleForkEelRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAplacedapublicnoticeofthedraftMiddleForkEelRiverTemperatureTMDLintheWillitsNewsandSantaRosaPressDemocrat,whicharepapersofgeneralcirculationinMendocinoandTrinityCounties.Inaddition,theUSEPAsentanoticetothoseonthemailinglistoftheUpperEelWatershedForum.TheUSEPAheldapublicmeetingonOctober16,2003,inCovelo,California.TheUSEPApreparedaresponsivenesssummarythataddressedallthecommentsthatwerereceivedduringthepubliccommentperiod.(USEPA2003)UpperMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAplacedapublicnoticeofthedraftUpperMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLintheWillitsNewsandSantaRosaPressDemocrat,whicharepapersofgeneralcirculationinMendocinoCounty.TheUSEPAalsometwithPG&E,FriendsoftheEelRiver,andNationalMarineFisheriesServiceduringtheFallof2003.TheUSEPAheldameetinginWillitsduringthesummerof2004forlandownerswhoselandwastobesurveyedforthesedimentsourceanalysis.ThepublicnoticeregardingavailabilityofthedraftUpperMainEelTMDLwaspostedontheUSEPA’swebsite,andmailedoremailedtoadditionalparties.TheUSEPApreparedaresponsivenesssummarythataddressedallthecommentsthatwerereceivedduringthepubliccommentperiod.(USEPA2004)MiddleMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAplacedapublicnoticeofthedraftMiddleMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLintheWillitsNewsandEurekaTimes‐Standard,papersofgeneralcirculationinMendocino,Humboldt,andTrinitycounties.TheUSEPAandtheRegionalWaterBoardstaffalsoheldpublicmeetingsinAlderpointinAprilandNovember2005todiscusstheTMDL.ThepublicnoticeregardingavailabilityofthedraftMiddleMainEelTMDLswaspostedontheUSEPA’swebsiteandmailedoremailedtoadditionalparties.TheUSEPAreceived3commentsonthedraftTMDLandmaderevisionsbaseduponthosecomments.(USEPA2005)LowerMainEelRiverTemperatureTMDLTheUSEPAplacedapublicnoticeofthedraftLowerEelRiverTemperatureTMDLintheWillitsNewsandEurekaTimes‐Standard,papersofgeneralcirculationin
194StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
MendocinoandHumboldtcounties.TheUSEPAalsodiscussedtheTMDLwithvariouslandownersinthewatershed,beginninginearly2006.ThepublicnoticeregardingavailabilityofthedraftLowerEelRiverTMDLwaspostedontheUSEPA’swebsiteandmailedoremailedtoadditionalparties.ApublicmeetingonthedraftLowerEelRiverTemperatureTMDLwasheldonOctober22,2007,attheSixRiversNationalForestconferenceroominEureka,California.TheUSEPAalsorespondedtoinquiriesforinformationduringthepubliccommentperiod.TheUSEPAreviewedallwrittencommentsthatwerereceivedduringthepubliccommentperiod,revisedthefinalTMDLasappropriate,andpreparedaresponsivenesssummarythataddressesthecommentsreceived.(USEPA2007)
195StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
12.0 REFERENCESCITEDAllen,D.M.,2008.Developmentandapplicationofaprocess‐based,basinscale
streamtemperaturemodel.[dissertation].Berkeley,California.UniversityofCalifornia,Berkeley.183p.
AquaTerra2012. ShastaRiverTailwaterReduction:Demonstrationand
ImplementationProject.Finalprojectreport.PreparedforShastaValleyResourceConservationDistrict.March2012.
Bakker,E.1972.AnislandcalledCalifornia.UniversityofCaliforniaPress,Berkeley
andLosAngeles.357pp.Bartholow,J.M,S.G.Campbell,andM.Flug.2005.PredictingtheThermalEffectsof
DamRemovalontheKlamathRiver.EnvironmentalManagement.34(6):856‐874
Bartholow,J.M.,2000,Estimatingcumulativeeffectsofclearcuttingonstream
temperatures:Rivers,vol.7,no.4,p.284‐297.Bartholow,J.M.,Campbell,S.G.,&Flug,M.,2004,Predictingthethermaleffectsof
damremovalontheKlamathRiver.EnvironmentalManagement,vol.34(6),856‐874.
Bartholow,J.M.2005.RecentwatertemperaturetrendsinthelowerKlamathRiver,
California.NorthAmericanJournalofFisheriesManagement,25(1),152‐162.Barlow,P.M.andLeake,S.A.,2012.Streamflowdepletionbywells–Understanding
andmanagingtheeffectsofgroundwaterpumpingonstreamflow:U.S.GeologicalSurveyCircular1376,84p.
Belchik,M1997.SummerLocationsandSalmonidUseofCoolWaterAreasinthe
KlamathRiver;IronGateDamtoSeiadCreek,1996.YurokTribalFisheriesProgram.Klamath,CA,13pp.
Beschta,R.L.,R.E.Bilby,G.W.Brown,L.B.Holtby,andT.D.Hofstra.1987.Stream
temperatureandaquatichabitat:fisheriesandforestryinteractions.IN:E.O.SaloandT.W.CundyEds.Streamsidemanagement:Forestryandfisheryinteractions.Contrib.57:UniversityofWashington,CollegeofForestResources,Seattle,pp.191–232.
Bogan,T.,Mohseni,O.,Stefan,H.G.,2003.Streamtemperature–equilibrium
temperaturerelationship.WaterResourcesResearch39(9),1245.
196StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Bogan,T.,H.G.Stefan,andO.Mohseni.2004.Imprintsofsecondaryheatsourcesonthestreamtemperature/equilibriumtemperaturerelationship,WaterResour.Res.,40(12).
Boyd,M.,andKasper,B.,2003,Analyticalmethodsfordynamicopenchannelheat
andmasstransfer:MethodologyforheatsourcemodelVersion7.0,193p.Brandow,C.A.,Cafferata,P.H.,andMunn,J.R.,2006.Modifiedcompletionreport
monitoringprogram:monitoringresultsfrom2001through2004.CADepartmentofForestryandFireProtection,94p
Brosofske,K.D.,Chen,J.,Naiman,R.J.,andFranklinJ.F.,1997,Harvestingeffectson
microclimaticgradientsfromsmallstreamstouplandsinwesternWashington:EcologicalApplications,vol.7,no.4,p.1188‐1200.
Brown,G.,1970,Predictingtheeffectofclearcuttingonstreamtemperature.Journal
ofSoilandwaterConservation,25(1):11‐13Cafferata,P.,M.Berbach,J.Burke,J.Hendrix,R.Klamt,R.Macedo,T.Spittler,K.
Vyverberg,andC.Wright‐Shacklett.2005.Floodproneareaconsiderationsinthecoastredwoodzone.FinalReportoftheRiparianProtectionCommittee.CaliforniaDepartmentofForestryandFireProtection.Sacramento,CA67p
CaliforniaAirPollutionControlOfficersAssociation(CAPCOA).2013.California’s
progresstowardcleanair:AreportbytheCaliforniaAirPollutionControlOfficers’Association.Sacramento.155pp.
CaliforniaBoardofForestryandFireProtectionTechnicalAdvisoryCommittee
(CBOF‐TAC),2007,PrimeronHeatRiparianExchangesRelatedtoForestManagementintheWesternU.S.,Appendix3Cof“ScientificLiteratureReviewofForestManagementEffectsonRiparianFunctionsforAnadromousSalmonids:StaffReport”,October2008,StateBoardofForestryandFireProtection
CalifoniaDepartmentofConservation(CDC),CaliforniaGeologicalSurvey,2002.
CaliforniaGeomorphicProvinces.Note36.Sacramento.4pp.CaliforniaDepartmentofTransportation,OfficeofEngineering,BidSummary
Results,WebsiteaccessedAugust16,2013http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/esc/oe/planholders/oe_bidsum_result.php
Cayan,D.,A.L.Luers,M.Hanemann,G.Franco,andB.Croes.2006.Scenariosof
climatechangeinCalifornia:Anoverview.CaliforniaClimateChangeCenter.
197StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Chen,J.,Franklin,J.F.,andSpies,T.A.,1993,Anempiricalmodelforpredictingdiurnalairtemperaturegradientsfromedgeintoold‐growthDouglas‐firforest:EcologicalModelling,vol.67,p.179‐198.
Chen,J.,Saunders,S.C.,Crow,T.R.,Naiman,R.J.,Brosofske,K.D.,Mroz,G.D.,
Brookshire,B.L.,andFranklin,J.F.,1999,Microclimateinforestecosystemandlandscapeecology:variationsinlocalclimatecanbeusedtomonitorandcomparetheeffectsofdifferentmanagementregimes:Bioscience,v.49,no.4,p.288‐297.
Chen,Y.D.,Carsel,R.F.,McCutcheon,S.C.,Nutter,W.L,1998a.StreamTemperature
Simulationofforestedriparianareas:Iwatershed‐scaledevelopment.JournalofEnvironmentalEngineering,124(4):304‐315
Chen,Y.D.,McCutcheon,S.C.,Norton,D.J.,Nutter,W.L,1998b.StreamTemperature
Simulationofforestedriparianareas:IImodelapplication.JournalofEnvironmentalEngineering,124(4):316‐325
CoosWatershedAssociation,undated,WillanchCreek:projecteffectiveness
monitoringandstreamtemperaturestudy1997‐2002,6p.DelaFuente,J.,andElder,D.,1998,Thefloodof1997,KlamathNationalForest,
PhaseIFinalReport,November24,1998:KlamathNationalForest,Yreka,CA,76p.plusappendices.
Deas,M.,Abbot,A.;andBale,A.,2003,ShastaRiverflowandtemperaturemodeling
project,April,2003:WatercourseEngineeringInc.,Napa,CA,188p.plusappendices.
Deas,M.2005.TechnicalMemorandum:TVARiverModelingSystem:ADYNand
RQUAL‐RMSModelSpecificationsandBackground.WatercourseEngineering,Inc.August17,2005.11pp.
Dong,J.,Chen,J.,Brosofske,K.D.,andNaiman,R.J.,1998,Modelingairtemperature
gradientsacrossmanagedsmallstreamsinwesternWashington:JournalofEnvironmentalManagement,v.53,p.309‐321.
FederalEnergyRegulatoryCommission(FERC).2007.FinalEnvironmentalImpact
StatementforRelicensingoftheKlamathHydroelectricProjectNo.2082‐027.November16,2007.
Fitzgerald,R.2005.MemorandumfromR.FitzgeraldoftheNorthCoastRegional
WaterQualityControlBoardtoGeraldHorner,OSIregardingErosionControlPlancostsfortheScottTMDL.August29,2005.
198StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
FiveCountiesSalmonidConservationProgram(5C).2009.Aboutus.WebsiteaccessedAugust5,2013.Availableat<http://www.5counties.org>.
GathardEngineeringConsulting.2006.KlamathRiverDamandSediment
Investigation.PreparedfortheCaliforniaStateCoastalConservancyandtheOceanProtectionCouncil.November2006.
Goldsmith,W.,M.Silva,andC.Fischenich.2001.Determiningoptimaldegreeofsoil
compactionforbalancingmechanicalstabilityandplantgrowthcapacity.ERDCTN‐EMRRP‐SR‐26.U.S.ArmyEngineerResearchandDevelopmentCenter,Vicksburg,MS.9pp.
HarrisBladeRental.PersonalcommunicationfromLaurenClydeoftheNorthCoast
RegionalWaterQualityControlBoardviatelephonetoHarrisBladeRental,Livermore,CAonJune30,2009.
Heath,RalphC.,1983.Basicground‐waterhydrology;U.S.GeologicalSurveyWater‐
SupplyPaper2220,86p.Herb,W.andS.Heinz.2010.Projectingtheimpactofclimatechangeoncoldwater
streamtemperaturesinMinnesotausingequilibriumtemperaturemodels.St.AnthonyFallsLaboratoryProjectReportno.546. Prepared for theLegislative‐CitizensCommissiononMinnesotaResources,St.Paul,Minnesota.66p.
Hickman,J.C.,editor.1993.TheJepsonmanual:higherplantsofCalifornia.
UniversityofCaliforniaPress,BerkeleyandLosAngeles.1400pp.IndependentMultidisciplinaryScienceTeam(IMST),2000.Influencesofhuman
activityonstreamtemperaturesandexistenceofcoldwaterfishinstreamswithelevatedtemperature.Reportofaworkshop.Technicalreport2000‐2totheOregonPlanforSalmonandWatersheds.OregonWatershedEnhancementBoard.Salem,Oregon.35p.+appendices.
Johnson,S.L.,2003,Streamtemperature:scalingofobservationsandissuesfor
modeling:HydrologicalProcesses,v.17,p.497‐499.Johnson,S.L.2004.Factorsinfluencingstreamtemperaturesinsmallstreams:
substrateeffectsandashadingexperiment.CanadianJournalofFisheriesandAquaticSciences.61:913‐923.
Johnson,S.L.,andJones,J.A.,2000,Streamtemperatureresponsestoforestharvest
anddebrisflowsinwesternCascades,Oregon:CanadianJournalofFisheriesandAquaticSciences,v.57(Suppl.2),p.30‐39.
199StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Kennedy,J.A.,Shilling,F.M.,andViers,J.H.,2005,CurrentandpotentialriparianforestconditionalongScottRiverwatershedtributaries:areporttotheNCRWQCB:DepartmentofEnvironmentalScienceandPolicy,UniversityofCalifornia,Davis,June13,2005,50p.
KierAssociates.1999.Mid‐termEvaluationoftheKlamathRiverBasinFisheries
RestorationProgram.PreparedfortheKlamathRiverBasinFisheriesTaskForce.April1999.
KlamathFacilitiesRemovalEnvironmentalImpactStatement/Environmental
ImpactReport,U.S.DepartmentoftheInterior,CaliforniaDepartmentofFishandWildlife,December2012,StateClearinghousenumber2010062060
Ledwith,Tyler,1996,Theeffectsofbufferstripwidthonairtemperatureand
relativehumidityinastreamriparianzone:TheWatershedManagementCouncilNewsletter,Summer1996,4p.Availableonlineat:http://www.watershed.org/news/sum_96/buffer.html
Lisle,T.E.1982.Effectsofaggradationanddegradationonriffle‐poolmorphologyin
naturalgravelchannels,northwesternCalifornia.WaterResourcesResearch.18(6):1643‐1651.
Loheide,S.P.,Gorelick,S.M.2006.QuantifyingStream‐AquiferInteractionsthrough
theAnalysisofRemotelySensedThermographicProfilesandInSituTemperatureHistories.EnvironmentalScienceandTechnology40(10):3336‐3341.
Moore,R.,Spittlehouse,D.L.,&Story,A.,2005.Riparianmicroclimateandstream
temperatureresponsetoforestharvesting:areview.JAWRA,41(4),813‐834.
Methany,T.M.,Dawson,B.J.,Shelton,J.L.,andBelitz,Kenneth,2011,Groundwater‐
qualitydatainthenorthernCoastRangesstudyunit,2009:ResultsfromtheCaliforniaGAMAProgram:U.S.GeologicalSurveyData‐Series609,88p.
Micheli,E.R.,andJ.W.Kirchner.2002.Effectsofwetmeadowriparianvegetationon
streambankerosion.2.measurementsofvegetatedbankstrengthandconsequencesforfailuremechanics.EarthSurfacesandLandforms27:687‐697.
Micheli,E.R.,J.W.Kirchner,andE.W.Larsen.2004.Quantifyingtheeffectofriparian
forestversusagriculturalvegetationonrivermeandermigrationrates,centralSacramentoRiver,California,USA.RiverResearchandApplications20:536‐548.
200StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Miner,J.R.,andGodwin,D.,2003,DocumentingprogresstowardachievingstreamtemperaturecomplianceinOregonTMDLplans:OregonStateUniversityExtension,Salem,Oregon,10p.
Mohseni,O.,T.R.Erickson,andH.G.Stefan.2002.UpperBoundsforstream
temperaturesinthecontiguousUnitedStates.JournalofEnvironmentalEngineering,128(1):4‐11.
Moore,R.D.,D.L.Spittlehouse,andA.Story,2005.RiparianMicroclimateand
StreamTemperatureResponsetoForestHarvesting:AReview.JournaloftheAmericanWaterResourcesAssociation(JAWRA)41(4):813‐834.
Morrill,J.,Bales,R.,andConklin,M.(2005).”EstimatingStreamTemperaturefrom
AirTemperature:ImplicationsforFutureWaterQuality.”J.Environ.Eng.,131(1),139–146.
NationalResearchCounciloftheNationalAcademies(NRC).2004.Endangeredand
ThreatenedFishesintheKlamathRiverBasin.Washington,D.C.NationalAcademiesPress.
NaturalResourcesConservationService.2008.“CaliforniaApprovedFiscalYear
2008PaymentSchedule”providedbyJimPattersonoftheSiskiyouCountyDistrictoftheNaturalResourcesConservationService.
Nielsen,J.L.,T.E.Lisle,andV.Ozaki.1994.Thermallystratifiedpoolsandtheiruseby
steelheadinnorthernCaliforniastreams.TransactionsoftheAmericanFisheriesSociety.123:613‐626.
NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(NCRWQCB),2000,Navarro
Riverwatershedtechnicalsupportdocumentforthetotalmaximumdailyloadforsedimentandtechnicalsupportdocumentforthetotalmaximumdailyloadfortemperature.December2002.
NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(NCRWQCB)2002.StaffReport
fortheActionPlanfortheMattoleRiverWatershedSedimentandTemperatureTotalMaximumDailyLoads.December2002
NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(NCRWQCB)2005.StaffReport
fortheActionPlanfortheScottRiverWatershedSedimentandTemperatureTotalMaximumDailyLoads.December2005.
NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(NCRWQCB)2006.StaffReport
fortheActionPlanfortheShastaRiverWatershedTemperatureandDissolvedOxygenTotalMaximumDailyLoads.June2006.
201StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(NCRWQCB).2007.WaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegion(BasinPlan).January2007.
NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(NCRWQCB)2010Finalstaff
reportfortheKlamathRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoads(TMDLs)addressingTemperature,DissolvedOxygen,Nutrient,andMicrocystinImpairmentsinCalifornia,theProposedSiteSpecificDissolvedOxygenObjectivesfortheKlamathRiverinCalifornia,andtheKlamathRiverandLostRiverImplementationPlans.March2010.
Null,S.E.,Viers,J.H.,Deas,M.L.,Tanaka,S.K.,&Mount,J.F.2013.Stream
temperaturesensitivitytoclimatewarminginCalifornia’sSierraNevada:impactstocoldwaterhabitat.ClimaticChange,116(1),149‐170.
OregonDepartmentofEnvironmentalQuality(ODEQ),2002,UpperKlamathLake
drainagestreamtemperatureanalysis:vegetation,hydrology,andmorphology,UpperKlamathLakedrainageTMDL,attachment1:preparedbyODEQ,May,2002.
Pettit,N.E.;Naiman,R.J.2007.FireintheRiparianZone:Characteristicsand
EcologicalConsequences.Ecosystems,v10,No.5p.673‐687Poole,G.C.,andC.H.Berman.2001.AnEcologicalPerspectiveonIn‐Stream
Temperature:NaturalHeatDynamicsandMechanismsofHuman‐CausedThermalDegradation.EnvironmentalManagement27(6):787‐802.
R2ResourceConsultants,Inc.&StetsonEngineers,Inc.,2007.NorthCoastInstream
FlowPolicy:Scientificbasisanddevelopmentofalternativesprotectinganadromoussalmonids.
Rantz,S.E.,andT.H.Thompson.,1967.SurfacewaterhydrologyofCaliforniacoastal
basinsbetweenSanFranciscoBayandEelRiver.U.S.GeologicalSurveyWater‐SupplyPaper1851.60p.
Rashin,E.B.,C.J.Clishe,A.T.Loch,J.M.Bell,2006.Effectivenessoftimberharvest
practicesforcontrollingsedimentrelatedwaterqualityimpacts.JournaloftheAmericanWaterResourcesAssociation,42(5):1397‐1327.
Riley,A,Region2,January2008,PuttingaPriceonRiparianCorridors,Sawyer,J.O.,Jr.,andD.A.Thronburgh.1977.Montaneandsubalpinevegetationof
theKlamathmountains.Pages699‐732inM.G.BarbourandJ.Major,editors.TerrestrialvegetationofCalifornia.JohnWiley&Sons,NewYork.
202StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Shih,Tian‐Ting.2002.Timberlandsiteclassonprivatelandszonedfortimberproduction:Technicalworkingpaper1‐03‐02.CaliforniaDepartmentofForestryandFireProtection,FRAP.Sacramento,10pp.
Sinokrot,B.A.andH.G.Stefan.1993.Streamtemperaturedynamics:Measurements
andmodeling.WaterResourcesResearch.29(7):2299‐2312.SiskiyouCountyPublicWorks.2008.RoadCostInformation.FacsimilesentbyScott
Sumner,DeputyDirectorofPublicWorks,SiskiyouCounty,9/12/2008.SoundWatershedConsulting(SWC).2008,ScientificLiteratureReviewofForest
ManagementEffectsonRiparianFunctionsforAnadromousSalmonids,Chapter3:HeatExchangeFunctions.PreparedfortheCaliforniaStateBoardofForestryandFireProtection.42pp.
StetsonEngineersInc.,2008a.NorthCoastInstreamFlowPolicy;Potentialindirect
impactsonmunicipal,industrialandagriculturalwateruseandrelatedindirectimpactsonotherenvironmentalresources.(IncludedasAppendixDofthe2008SubstituteEnvironmentalDocumentfortheNorthCoastInstreamFlowPolicy).
StetsonEngineersInc.,2008b.ApproachtoDelineateSubterraneanStreamsand
DeterminePotentialStreamDepletionAreas,FinalTechnicalMemorandumpreparedforthePolicyforMaintainingInstreamFlowsinNorthernCaliforniaCoastalStreams.
StillwaterSciences,1999.StillwaterSciencesTemperatureModel(SSTM):A
watershed‐scalestreamtemperaturemodel.Unpublished16p.AppendixAofSouthForkEelRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.
Sunding,D.andA.P.Zwane.2004.CostandSocioeconomicImpactsofImplementing
theCaliforniaCohoSalmonRecoveryStrategy.IN:CaliforniaDepartmentofFishandGame.RecoveryStrategyforCaliforniaCohoSalmon:ReporttotheCaliforniaFishandGameCommission.Sacramento,CA.1Appendix1.
TetraTech,2002.Qual2E‐ShadeTemperatureModelingSystem(Draft).Prepared
forU.S.EPARegion9.September2002.TetraTech,2009.Modelconfigurationandresults:KlamathRivermodelforTMDL
development.Fourthrevision,December2009.PreparedforUSEPAregion9,USEPAregion10,NorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard,andOregonDepartmentofEnvironmentalQuality.
203StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Theurer,F.D.,Voos,K.A.,andMiller,W.J.,1984,Instreamwatertemperaturemodel:instreamflowinformationpaper16:USFWS,WashingtonD.C.,316pp.approx.
Tompkins,M.2006.Floodplainandrivercorridorcomplexity:implicationsforriver
restorationandplanningforfloodplainmanagement.PhDdissertation,UniversityofCalifornia,Berkeley.Availableat:<http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/WRCA/restoration/theses.html
Tooth,S.2000.Process,formandchangeindrylandrivers:areviewofrecent
research.Earth‐ScienceReviews51:67‐107.UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA),1999.SouthForkEel
RiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December1999.
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2000.NavarroRiverTotal
MaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December2000.
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2002a.MattoleRiverTotal
MaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December2001
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2002b.NorthForkEel
RiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December2002.
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2003a.MiddleForkEel
RiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December2003.
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2003b.National
ManagementMeasuresfortheControlofNonpointPollutionfromAgriculture.OfficeofWater.July2003.
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2004.UpperMainEel
RiverandTributaries(includingTomkiCreek,OutletCreekandLakePillsbury)TotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December2004.
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2005.MiddleMainEel
RiverandTributaries(fromDosRiostotheSouthFork)TotalMaximumDailyLoadsforTemperatureandSediment.SanFrancisco,CA.December2005.
204StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
UnitedStatesEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(USEPA).2007.LowerEelRiverTotalMaximumDailyLoadsforSedimentandTemperature.SanFrancisco,CA.December2007.
UnitedStatesFederalHighwayAdministration.AccessedAugust5,2009.Available
at<http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/programadmin.cfm>UnitedStatesFishandWildlifeService.1995a.Draftenvironmentalalternatives
analysisfora4(d)rulefortheconservationofthenorthernspottedowlonnonfederallands.U.S.FishandWildlifeService.Portland,OR.468pp.
UnitedStatesForestService(USFS).2000.Waterqualitymanagementforforest
systemslandsinCalifornia:Bestmanagementpractices.ForestService,PacificSouthwestRegion138pp.
Vassey,SheilaK.1999.MemorandumtoStefanLorenzato,TMDLCoordinator,
DivisionofWaterQuality,StateWaterResourcesControlBoardfromSheilaK.Vassey,SeniorStaffCounsel,OfficeofChiefCounsel,StateWaterResourcesControlBoardregarding“EconomicConsiderationsinTMDLDevelopmentandBasinPlanning”datedOctober27,1999.
Vaux,W.G.1968.Intergravelflowandinterchangeofwaterinastreambed.Bureau
ofCommercialFisheriesBiologicalLaboratory.AukeBay,Alaska.FisheryBulletin.66(3):479‐489.
WatercourseEngineering,2006.KlamathRiverthermalrefugiastudy:flowand
temperaturecharacterization:summer2004.PreparedfortheUnitedSatesBureauofReclamationKlamathAreaFieldOffice
Weaver,W.andD.Hagans.2004.RoadUpgrading,Decommissioningand
Maintenance—EstimatingCostsonSmallandLargesScales.IN:Allen,S.T.,C.Thomson,andR.Carlson,eds.ProceedingsoftheSalmonHabitatRestorationCostWorkshop.November14‐16,2000;Gladstone,OR.PacificStatesMarineFisheriesCommission
Weaver,B.,Hagans,D.,andWeppner,E.2006.SalmonidStreamHabitatRestoration
ManualPartX:UpslopeErosionInventoryandSedimentControlGuidance.CaliforniaDepartmentofFishandGame,InlandFisheriesDivision.Sacramento,CA.
Wilzbach,M.A.,Harvey,B.C.,White,J.L.,&Nakamoto,R.J.,2005,Effectsofriparian
canopyopeningandsalmoncarcassadditionontheabundanceandgrowthofresidentsalmonids.CanadianJournalofFisheriesandAquaticSciences,62(1),58‐67.
205StaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperatureandActionPlanstoAddressTemperatureImpairmentintheMattole,Navarro,andEelRiverWatersheds
Wondzell,S.M.andF.J.Swanson.1999.Floods,channelchange,andthehyporheiczone.WaterResourcesResearch.35(2):555‐567.
Wu,H.,J.S.Kimball,M.M.Elsner,N.Mantua,R.F.Adler,andJ.Stanford(2012),
ProjectedclimatechangeimpactsonthehydrologyandtemperatureofPacificNorthwestrivers,WaterResour.Res.,48(11).
Zinke,P.J.1977.NTheredwoodforestandassociatednorthcoastforest.Pages
679‐698inM.G.BarbourandJ.Major,editors.TerrestrialvegetationofCalifornia.JohnWiley&Sons,NewYork.
A‐1ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Appendix1:RegionalWaterBoardStaffResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftStaffReport
SupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature
August28,2013
InaccordancewithSection57004oftheCaliforniaHealthandSafetyCode,theNorthCoastRegionalWaterQualityControlBoard(RegionalWaterBoard)isrequiredtoreceiveexternalscientificpeerreviewofthescientificbasisofanyproposedamendmenttotheWaterQualityControlPlanfortheNorthCoastRegion(BasinPlan).ThisdocumentisacompilationofcommentsprovidedbythescientificpeerreviewersofthePeerReviewDraftStaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature,July12013.ThefollowingindividualsprovidedscientificpeerreviewofthePeerReviewDraftStaffReportSupportingthePolicyfortheImplementationoftheWaterQualityObjectivesforTemperature:
MarkT.Stacey,Ph.D.Professor,DepartmentofCivilandEnvironmentalEngineeringUniversityofCaliforniaJohnC.Stella,Ph.D.AssistantProfessorDepartmentofForestandNaturalResourcesManagementStateUniversityofNewYorkSallyE.Thompson,Ph.D.AssistantProfessorDepartmentofCivilandEnvironmentalEngineeringUniversityofCalifornia
Thereviewerswereaskedtoevaluate6statementsrepresentingtheassumptions,assertions,andconclusionsthatconstitutethescientificbasisoftheproposedactionstodeterminewhetherthescientificportionoftheproposedruleisbaseduponsoundscientificknowledge,methods,andpractices.Reviewerswerealsoinvitedtoaddressanyotherscientificissuesthatshouldbepartofthescientificportionoftheproposedrulethatarenototherwisedescribed.Finally,thereviewerswereinvitedtocommentonwhethertakenasawhole,thescientificportionoftheproposedactionsarebaseduponsoundscientificknowledge,methods,andpractices.Thereviewer’scommentsandRegionalWaterBoardstaffresponsesarepresentedbelow.
A‐2ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
1.Increasedsolarradiationloadsaretheprimarycontrollabledriverofelevatedwatertemperatures.Increasingsolarradiationloads(decreasedshade)resultinincreasingstreamtemperatures.Preservingshadeisalegitimatemeansofpreventingstreamtemperatureincreases.Stacey1:Theapproachofpreservingshadeiswellarguedandpresented,buttheconceptualmodelforhowshadeinteractswithotherfactorsshouldbefurtherdeveloped,inparticulartheroleofairtemperature,equilibriumtemperatureandtheinteractionofshadeandflowindefiningthespatialstructureofwatertemperaturemustbeconsideredbothinthediscussionofthefactorsthatgovernwatertemperatureandindefiningthe“naturalstate”forthesystem(discussedabovein“BigPicture”comments).RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Additionaldiscussiondescribingequilibriumtemperatureandtheinteractionoftemperaturedrivershasbeenaddedtothereportinresponsetothecomment.Thompson1:Firstly,itisclearfromthereviewpresentedbythescientistshere,aswellasotherresearch,thatsolarradiationisnotalwaystheprimarydriverofelevatedwatertemperatures.Examplescanbereadilyfoundwhereloweredgroundwatertables(Loinaz,Davidsenetal.2013),surfacewaterdiversions,point‐scaledischarges(Loinaz,Davidsenetal.2013),agriculturalreturnflows(Oremland,Steinbergetal.1991;Fujimoto,Ouchietal.2008),andpotentiallyanthropogenicclimatechange(Roth,Westhoffetal.2010)contributetostreamtemperatureincreases.WhileConclusion5“Evaluationoftheseimpactsismostappropriateonasite‐specific,case‐by‐casebasis”broadlycoversthesedistinctions,itmaybeappropriatetoconsiderrephrasingConclusion1:“IncreasedsolarradiationloadsarelikelytobetheprimarycontrollabledriverofelevatedwatertemperaturesinmostwaterwaysintheNorthCoastRegion.”RegionalWaterBoardresponse:RegionalWaterBoardstaffacknowledgethatthesuggestedqualifiersareappropriate.TheconclusionreferredtowaswrittentodirectthereviewerstothescientificissuesinthePolicy;however,thespecificlanguageisnotcontainedinthePolicy.Thetemperatureimpactsassociatedwithsurfacewaterdiversions,pointsourcedischarges,andagriculturalreturnflowsareaddressedthroughthisPolicy.Staffhavemodifiedthestaffreporttoreflectthequalifiedstatement.Thompson2:Secondlyitisnotclearthatpreservingshadewillalwaysbeeffectiveinpreventingstreamtemperatureincreases.Thevalueofriparianshadingfortemperaturemodificationiscontingentonchannelwidth(Moore,Spittlehouseetal.2005).In
A‐3ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
largestreamswhereripariancanopiescannoteffectivelyshadetheentirewatersurface,riparianshadingisunlikelytomodifystreamtemperatureonaverage(Lee,Huangetal.2012).Similarly,theimportanceofriparianshadingfortemperaturecontrolappearstovarythroughouttherivernetwork.Arecentstudysuggeststhatriparianbuffersmayhaveminimalinfluenceonthetemperatureofheadwaterstreams.Inaclear‐cutexperimentsover11smallheadwaterchannels(1.9–8.5hawatersheds)inWashingtonState,Janischetal.(2012)foundnosignificantdifferencesintemperaturebetweenclearcutchannels,continuouslybufferedchannels,andpatch‐bufferedchannels.Treecoverprovidedlittlepredictiveinsightintotemperaturechanges,whichweremorestronglycorrelatedtothetotalwatersurfaceareainthestreams.Again,thecase‐by‐caseapproachsuggestedinConclusion5issuitableforaddressingmanyofthesespecialcases.Theseobservationsdosuggest,however,thatamorecautiousstatementaboutthelegitimacyofpreservingshadetomaintainlowstreamtemperaturesmightbewarranted.“Whereexistingstreamchannelshadingisextensiveorcanotherwisebeshowntorepresentasignificantcontrolonstreamtemperatures,preservingshadeisalegitimatemeansofpreventingstreamtemperatureincreases.”RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffagreesthatshadeisnotaneffectivemeansofpreventingtemperatureincreasesinstreamswithgreatwidthsinrelationtotreeheights,onaverage.StaffalsoagreeswithDr.Thompson’scomment(Thompson12)thatshadeprovidedbyvegetationmaybeecologicallysignificantinsituationswhereitreducessolarloadingtothermalrefuges.Languageacknowledgingtheseconceptshasbeenincorporatedintothestaffreport.StaffhavereviewedthearticlebyJanisch,etal(2012),andnotetheauthors’reservationsthatconfoundingfactorswerenotcontrolledintheexperiment,suchastheshadeprovidedbyslashdebris,thecompositionofthestreambedsubstrate,andthedegreeofinteractionwithwetlands.Boththeinteractionwithwetlandsandthesubstratecompositionwereshowntocorrelatewithtemperaturesafterthefact.Furthermore,theauthorspointoutthatwhiletheresultsofthestudygenerallyshowhighertemperatureincreasesinclearcutstreamsversusbufferedstreams,theresultsdidnotagreewithotherstudiesofheadwaterstreams(Gomietal2006),thatshowedmuchhighertemperatureincreasesassociatedwithlossofshade.Theauthorspointouttheextremelylowflowsthatexistedduringtheexperiment,aswellasthepossibilitythatthetemperatureswerebufferedbyhyporheicexchange.Thesumofthisinformationindicatesthatinsomecasesthermalprocessesotherthansolarinsolationmaybethedominantprocessdeterminingstreamtemperatures.Languageacknowledgingthisconcepthasbeenincorporatedintothestaffreport.
A‐4ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Thompson3:Sitepotentialeffectiveshade:Thesitepotentialeffectiveshadeconceptisappealing,butwillpresentchallengesintermsofevaluationoverlargescales,realismandconsistencybetweendifferentlocationswithdifferentlandusehistory,climate,geologyetc.Inhighlydisturbedsystemswherestreamsarealreadyextensivelymanaged,linkingchannelstolocalnaturalbenchmarksmaybeunrealistic.BysettingTMDLlevelsonshadeasafunctionofpotentialshading,problematicsituationscouldarisewheretheshadecouldbeconsideredhighlyimpacted,evenwherefullshadingwoulddolittletoaffectbulkstreamtemperatures(thelowerreachesoflargeriversagainprovideanexampleofthissituation).Thesedistinctionsareaddressedatthepolicylevelbasedontheproposedsite‐specificapproach.TheTMDLdevelopment,however,doesnotseemtohaveadoptedafullysite‐specificapproachbylinkingTMDLstopotentialeffectiveshading,ratherthanthetemperaturechangesthatcouldbeachievedbypotentialeffectiveshading.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Thetopicofwhenshadecontrolsarenoteffectiveatcontrollingtemperatures,suchaswidestreamchannelsrelativetotheheightofvegetation,hasbeenincorporatedintothestaffreport.Stella1:Fromthelargenumberofstudiesconducted,itappearsthatriparianshadeisthemajordriverofwatertemperaturethatcanbecontrolleddirectlybyhumanlandmanagementactions…RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.2.Theestablishmentofriparianbuffersfortemperatureprotectionisaneffectiveandimportantmanagementmeasureforthecontrolofsometypesofsedimentanddischarges.Stacey2:Ifoundthereportconvincingthatmanymanagementactionswouldacttocontrolsedimentdischargeandwatertemperaturesimultaneously.However,thecausallinkbetweensedimentloadsandwatertemperatureislesswellestablished,butinmyopinionitdoesn’tneedtobe.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.Thecausallinkbetweensedimentloadsandwatertemperatureisdiscussedbelow.Thompson4:Itisuncontroversialthatthepresenceofriparianvegetationwillreduceratesofbankerosionandsedimentmobilizationinmanycircumstances(Liu,Zhangetal.
A‐5ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
2008).Providedthespatialextentofriparianvegetationislargeenough(bothintermsofbufferwidth,bufferslopeandbufferlengthalongthechannel),andthevegetationissufficientlydense,itisfeasiblethatriparianvegetationwillprovideanimportantmanagementmeasuretopreventadditionofsedimentintostreams.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.Thompson5:Twothingsareunclearinthisconclusionspecifically,andinthepolicyoverall.Thefirstisthebasisfordefiningariparianbuffer.Thesecondiswhetherthe“establishmentofriparianbuffers”isintendedpurelyasapreventativemeasure(topreserveexistingvegetationandpreventfutureimpacts)orifitalsoisconsideredatechniqueformitigation,offsetorrestoration.Assessingthelikelyvalueofrestorationforbothsedimentandtemperaturemanagementperspectivesisconsiderablymoreproblematicthanassessingthevalueofprevention.Ihaveexpandedonthesecommentsunderthe“BigPicture”section.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Theseissuesareaddressedintheresponsetothe“bigpicture”comments,below.Thompson6:Alltheprovidedsupportinginformationrelatestoin‐channelgeomorphology,whichmaybenegativelyimpactedbyincreasedsedimentloadingonstreams.Theadditionalroleofsedimentinincreasingturbidity,whichalterstheabsorptionoflightbythewatercolumnwasnotdiscussed(Henderson‐Sellers1986).Itisunclearwhetherthisfactorhasbeenoverlookedorconsideredunimportantinthisstudy.Itmaybemoredirecttodevelopconclusionsaboutchannelgeomorphology,andthevalueofriparianvegetationforchannelgeomorphology(bystabilizationofbanksandregulationofsedimentdischarges).RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffhasbeenunabletofindsupportintheliteratureforthehypothesisthatturbidityhasasignificanteffectonstreamtemperatures.Staffarefamiliarwiththeliteratureonstreamheatingprocessesandnotethattheseminalworksonthetopicaresilentonthetopicofturbidity(e.g.,PooleandBerman2001,SinokrotandStefan1993,Webbetal2008).Itmaybethatturbidityimpactsthedistributionoftemperaturesinthewatercolumn.Thenotionthatturbidityleadstoincreasedtemperaturesthroughalteringtheabsorptionoflightdoesn’tcomportwiththeknownpropertiesofwater,wherewaterbodiesactas“blackbodies”withhighabsorptionproperties.Tosomedegreetheissueismoot,becauseturbidityismostoftenpresentattimeswhentemperaturesarenotaconcern,andmoresignificantlyturbidityisapollutantthatisalreadyregulated.Thewaterqualityobjectiveforturbidityrequiresturbiditybeincreasednomorethan20%abovebackground,whichisarelativelystringentstandard.
A‐6ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Stella2:…Maintainingsomeformofriparianbufferprotectionthroughoutanetwork,particularlyinlow‐orderstreamreaches,shouldresultinthepreservationofmoreriparianshadeandconsequentlylowerlevelsofsolarheatingtothewatersurface.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.3.Thediversionandstorageofwaterhasthepotentialtoelevatewatertemperatures.Stacey4:Asdescribedinthe“BigPicture”commentsabove,theinterplaybetweenshade,flowandairtemperature(eventhoughitisexternaltomanagementcontrol)shouldbemoreclearlydevelopedinthereport.Flowhasasimilareffectonwatertemperaturetoshade:bothreducetherateatwhichthewatertemperatureapproachesitsequilibrium.Assuch,changesinflowcanmitigateoraccentuatetheeffectivenessofshadeinpursuingthepolicyobjectives.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:SeeresponsetoStacey1.Thompson7:Again,thisconclusionissubstantivelysound,withminorcaveats.Reductionsinflowwillreducethethermalmassandthevelocitywithinastream.Thiscanbereadilyobservedfromtheenergybalanceequationforareach:
Hereρisthedensityofwater,Cptheheatcapacityofwater,Vthemeanstreamflow,Dthemeandepth,andQisthenetheatexchange.Clearlyforlowerdepthsandvelocities,greatertemperatureincreaseswilloccur(Moore,Spittlehouseetal.2005).Itisnotalwaystrue,however,thatstoragewillincreasetemperatures.TheKlamathRiverstudycitedintheStaffReportsuggeststhatthermaldelaysandreducedtemperatureextremesresultfromdamreleases.Whilethesedelaysandreducedtemperatureextremesmaybeproblematicinunimpairedwaterbodies,theymayalsoofferopportunitiestomitigatethermaleffectsinstreamsthatareexperiencinghightemperatureconditions.
A‐7ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffagreethatstorageofwaterdoesn’talwaysincreasetemperatures,andthatmanagementofcoldwaterfromthebottomofreservoirsmayprovideopportunitiestopositivelyaffectwatertemperatures.However,thestatedassumptionisthatthestorageofwaterhasthepotentialtoincreasewatertemperatures;theimplicationisthattheRegionalWaterBoardshouldevaluatesuchconditionswhenconsideringthewaterqualityimpactsassociatedwithonstreamimpoundments.Thompson8:Similarly,diversionofflowsuggeststhatonlysurfacewaterabstractionhasthepotentialtoalterstreamtemperatures.Ingroundwater‐fedstreams,itisclearthatsignificantimpactsmayalsoresultfromgroundwaterpumping.Forinstance,inamodelingstudy,watertablefluctuationsleadingtoreducedgroundwaterinputwereshowntopotentiallyincreasestreamtemperaturesby0.3to1.5oC(Loinaz,Davidsenetal.2013).Thisiscomparabletothechangesassociatedwithsolarradiation.Groundwaterabstractionhasthesamepotentialtoinfluencestreamflowandtemperaturesassurfacediversionsandshouldbeexplicitlyidentifiedassuch.Thus,amoreappropriateconclusionmightbe:Reductionsinstreamflowduetosurfacewaterdiversion,groundwaterabstractionorstorageofwaterhavethepotentialtoelevatewatertemperaturesandalterthemagnitudeandtemporalpatternofin‐‐streamtemperaturevariations.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffagreesthatgroundwaterwithdrawalshavepotentialtoimpactstreamtemperatures,dependingonthesituation.Thetopicisexplicitlyidentifiedinsection4.3(hydrodynamics)inrelationtotheScottRiverTMDL.ThePolicydirectsstafftoaddress“…activitieswiththepotentialtoreduceinstreamsummerflowsorreducesourcesofcoldwater…”,whichincludesreductionsofcoldwaterderivedfromgroundwater.4.ThePolicycomprehensivelyidentifiesthetemperaturefactorsthatmustbeaddressed.Stacey4:Ithinkthereportdoesagoodjobofidentifyingtheimportantcontrollablefactors,buttheirinteractionisnotwell‐developed,andIthinkitisamistaketoleaveoutfactorsthatarenotunder(immediate)humancontrol(specificallyairtemperature).Further,althoughManning’snisidentifiedasafactor,itisdiscountedquicklyanditseffectonbothdepthandflow,andhencewatertemperature,arenotdeveloped.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:
A‐8ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Additionaldiscussiondescribingequilibriumtemperatureandtheinteractionoftemperaturedrivers,aswellasairtemperaturesandchannelroughness(Manning’sn)hasbeenaddedtothereportinresponsetothisandothercommentsofferedbyDr.Stacey.Thompson9:Thepolicyhasidentifiedthemajorfactorsthatmustbeaddressed,howeverthereisscopetobemoreexplicitandtoaddsomefurtherfactorsthatarelikelytobeminorinmostcases,butmightbeimportantinsomespecificinstances:
1.Asdiscussedabove,turbidityaltersstreamenergybudgets,andhasnotbeenexplicitlyaddressedinthispolicy.
2.Groundwaterabstractionshouldbemoreexplicitlyidentifiedasafactorimpactingtemperature.Listingitasa“landuse”factorisindirect.
3.Similarly,surfacewaterabstractionshouldbeexplicitlyidentifiedasafactor,ratherthanconsideringitafunctionoflanduse.
4.Recentstudieshighlightanationaltrendofincreasingstreamtemperatures.Onepotentialreasonforthismaybeglobalwarming(Kaushal,Likensetal.2010).Whileitisunlikelythatthiscanbeaddressedatthelocallevel,itmaybeimportanttoconsiderstrongerlocalmitigationtargetstooffsetthisbackgroundofregionaltemperaturerise.Forexample,if1oCtemperatureriseswereexpectedduetobackgroundwarming,itmaybemoreappropriatetolimitin‐‐‐streamwarmingto4oCratherthan5oC,asanuncontrollablefactorwouldbelikelytoimposetheadditional1oCrise.
5.Urbanizationisstronglyassociatedwithincreasedstreamtemperatures,andurbanstormwatermaythusmeritconsiderationasapointsourceofheat(Kaushal,Likensetal.2010).WhileNorthernCaliforniaisnotextensivelyimpactedbyurbanization,populationgrowthintheregionislikelytomeanthaturbanlandareawillincreaseinthefuture.Sinceurbandevelopmentisoftenplannedandregulated,therearerealopportunitiestodesignurbanwatermanagementtominimizethermalimpactsonreceivingwaterbodies.
6.Irrigationreturnflowshavearealpotentialtoprovideapointheatsourceandmayrequiremoreovertconsideration(Oremland,Steinbergetal.1991;Fujimoto,Ouchietal.2008).
RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Thefollowingresponsescorrespondtothenumberedpointsabove:1:Seeresponsetocomment“Thompson6”,above.2&3:Theintentistoaddresstemperatureconcernswithwaterwithdrawals,bothsurfaceandsubsurface.Thewording“landusesassociatedwith”ismeanttobebroadtocovertherangeofactivitiesthatmayreducecoldwaterflows.Oftenthereductionsinflowsareassociatedwithactivediversions,butotherlanduseactivities,suchasthosethatlimitoreliminategroundwaterrechargeresultingin
A‐9ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
decreasedgroundwaterinputstoastream,forinstance,arenotassociatedwithdiversions.Texthasbeenaddedtothereportdiscussingthistopic.4.Additionaltexthasbeenaddeddiscussingtheissueofglobalwarmingandtheassociatedregulatoryimplications.5&6.ThePolicyexplicitlydirectstheRegionalWaterBoardtoprevent,minimize,andmitigatetemperaturealterationsassociatedwith“(t)hequality,quantity,locationandtimingofeffluent,stormwater,andagriculturalreturnflowdischarges.”5.Evaluationoftheriskoftemperatureimpactsassociatedwithaprojectismostappropriateonasite‐specific,case‐by‐casebasis.Stacey5:Ibelievethisbalanceishandled,andjustified,well.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.Thompson10:Itishighlyappropriatethattemperatureimpactsshouldbeevaluatedonasitespecific,case‐by‐casebasis.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.6.Thetypesofactionsnecessarytorecoverawaterbodythatistemperatureimpairedduetoreductionsinstreamshadearethesametypesofactionsthatpreventawaterbodyfrombecomingtemperatureimpaired.Stacey6:Icommendtheauthorsontheclaritywithwhichtheyaddressedthisissue.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.Thompson11:Thisisscientificallyjustifiable.Theonlypointofdifferentiationthatrequiresclarificationishowthepolicyrelatestomitigation/offsets/restoration,inthecontextofimpairedversusunimpairedwaterbodies.Thereismoreconfidenceandagreaterchanceofsuccessassociatedwithpreventingtemperatureimpairmentthroughtherecommendedstrategiesthanthereisinreversingtemperatureimpairmentthroughrestoration,mitigationoroffsetcreation.Seebigpicturecommentsbelow.
A‐10ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Commentnoted.Theissueofpreventionvsrestorationisaddressedbelow.7.“BigPicture”Comments:Stacey7:DiscussionofConceptualmodel.Theauthorsmakeitclearthatmultiplefactorsaresimultaneouslyactingtoalterstreamtemperatures,butthedescriptiontheyprovideseemstoconveyaconceptualmodelthatdoesnotaddresstheinteractionsbetweenthevariousfactors.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:SeeresponsetoStacey1.Stacey8:Further,theroleoflong‐termatmosphericwarmingmustbebetterintegratedintothediscussion,asshade,flowandotherfactorsmustallbeconsideredinthatcontext.Briefly,airtemperature,whichwillincreasebyseveraldegreesundermostclimateprojections,establishestheequilibriumtemperatureforawaterbody.Theotherfactorsdescribedinthisreport,includingshade,flow,andratioofdepthtowidth,affecttherate(inspaceortime)atwhichthewatertemperatureapproachesthatequilibrium.Asaresult,ifairtemperaturesincrease,thedemandsonshade,flowandotherfactorswillincreaseifwatertemperaturesaretobepreserved.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:SeeresponsestoStacey1,Stacey4,andThompson9.Stacey9:Itrytoillustratetheseinteractionswiththefollowing,conceptualfigureshowingtheevolutionofwatertemperaturealonganarbitrarychannelreach:
A‐11ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Inthiscase,westartatacooltemperature(‘Tst’)attheupstreamendofthereach,andthenthewatersapproachtheequilibriumtemperature(‘Teq’)withdistancealongthereach.HereIshowthetemperaturesactuallyreachingtheequilibriumtemperature,butofcoursethatmayormaynothappenwithinagivenreach.Thekeypointhereisthatthebasecasetrajectorywillbedeterminedbytheequilibriumtemperature,whichisitselfstronglydependentonairtemperatureandwillincreaseovertimewithclimateforcing.Thesecondcaseshowninthefigureillustratestheeffectsofincreasedflow(dashedredline),whichdecreasestheeffectivespatialrateofapproachtotheequilibriumtemperature(notethatthetemporalrateofincreaseremainsthesame,butthewholetemperaturedistributionispusheddownstream).Thefinalcaseillustrateshowaregionofcompleteshadingmodifiesthetemperaturetrajectory(dashedgreenline).HereIshowtheextremecasewhereinaportionofthereach(thepartwiththeflatpartofthegreencurve)thewatertemperaturedoesnotincreaseatallinordertoillustratethespatialinteractionsbetweenthesethreedrivingforces.Notethatdownstreamoftheshadedsection,thewatertemperatureagainbeginstoincreasetowardstheequilibriumtemperature;thisrateofincreaseisdeterminedbytheflowrate.Assuch,bothshadeandflowhavesimilarbufferingeffectsonwatertemperature–theyextentthecoolwatersignaturefromupstreamfurtherdownintothereach–
A‐12ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
butneitheraddressestheequilibriumtemperaturethatwouldbereachedattheendofalongreach.Ithinkthereportwouldbenefitfromaclearer,andmorecomplete,presentationofthesefactorsandhowtheyinteracttodeterminethedistributionofwatertemperaturealongastreamreach.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:StaffagreewiththeDr.Stacey’sdescriptionoftheseprocesses.Theconceptsdiscussedabovehavebeenincorporatedintothestaffreport.Stacey10:Thisalsoleadstoarelatedquestionastohowthe“naturalstate”shouldbedefined.If“naturalstate”isbasedonhistoricaltemperatures,thenunderwarmingairtemperatures,moreshadeorflowwouldberequiredthanduringhistoricalconditions.Alternatively,if“naturalstate”isbasedonhistoricaldistributionsofshadeandflow,thenpreservingthenaturalstatewillleadtoincreasesinwatertemperatureduetochangesinairtemperature(andequilibriumwatertemperature).Inessence,myconceptualpictureofthegoalsofthepolicyistodoourbesttofightalosingbattleagainstincreasingairandwatertemperatures,bymakinguseofshadeandflowstomitigatetheeffectsofelevatedequilibriumtemperatures.Eventhoughairtemperaturesand,byextension,equilibriumwatertemperaturesarebeyondmanagementcontrol,theyneedtobediscussedinordertoclearlyestablishthegoalsandapproachesofthepolicy.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:ThisPolicyattemptstoachievenaturaltemperaturesbyrestoringandmaintainingtheconditionsthatdrivetemperatureconsistentwiththeirunalteredstates.Dr.Staceyiscorrectinpointingoutthatthisistosomedegreealosingbattleinthefaceofglobalclimatechange.Additionallanguagediscussingthesetopicsandtheirregulatoryimplicationshasbeenincorporatedintothestaffreport.Stacey11:SpatialScalesofInterestandLevelofDetailintheReport.Itwasverydifficulttodeterminetheapproachusedtoreachthequalitativeresults,forexampleinFigure2inthereport.Evengoingtothesupplementarymaterials(NCRWQB2000),Iwasleftwithuncertaintyastoexactlyhowthesesensitivitycalculationsweredone.Ofparticularconcerninthiscaseisthespatialstructureofthecalculationsandwheretheanalyzedtemperatureswererelativetotheshade.Itappearsthattheanalysiswasforasinglereachwithasingle‐valuedfractionalshadingandtheoutputtemperaturewasatthedownstreamendofthatreach.Thesensitivityofwatertemperaturetoshadingwilldecreasewithdistancedownstreamoftheshadedregion(asillustratedinthefigureabove),anditisn’tclearwhatspatialscaleshouldberesolvedorconsideredtomeetthepolicygoals.
A‐13ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Dr.Staceyiscorrectthat“theanalysiswasforasinglereachwithasingle‐valuedfractionalshadingandtheoutputtemperaturewasatthedownstreamendofthatreach.”Thishasbeenclarifiedinthetextofthestaffreport.Stacey12:Thisleadstoarelatedconcernabouthowthermalrefugiaaretobeconsidered,bothintheanalysisofwatertemperatureandintheapplicationofthepolicy.Doestheremovalofasmallpoolthatlocallyleadstoanincreaseinwatertemperatureofmorethan5degreesviolatethestandard?Howsmallofapoolwouldbenegligible?Ithinkthereportwouldbenefitfromaclearstatementastohowtheauthorsarethinkingaboutspatialscalesofinterest,evenifitisjusttogiveacontexttothereportandtheresultspresented(particularlyinFigure2).RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Thewaterqualityobjectivefortemperaturestates“atnotimeorplace”shalltemperaturesbeincreased5oF.Thislanguageisunequivocal,thustheconsiderationofthermalrefugiaisappropriate.Thequestionofhowsmallofapoolwouldbenegligiblerelatesbacktobeneficialuses.Waterqualityobjectivesareestablishedtomaintainbeneficialuses,thereforethescalethatisrelevantisthescalethatissignificantinthecontextofthebeneficialusesinquestion.Languagedescribingthisconcepthasbeenincorporatedintothestaffreport.Stacey13:Finally,Iwouldnotethatthelinkbetweensedimentloadandwatertemperatureisnotwelldeveloped.Thereportdoesmaketheeffectiveargumentthatmanyofthemanagementoptionsavailableforcontrollingwatertemperaturewillalsohelpcontrolsedimentloading.But,theauthorsalsogoontostatethatsedimentloadisoneofthefactorsthatcauseschangesinwatertemperatures.Thereasoninggoesthatsedimentloadcan(a)changethewidth‐to‐depthratioofthestream;and(b)alter(reduce)hyporheicexchanges,whicharesourcesofcoolwateratvariouslocationsalongthestreams.WhileIagreethattheeffectsoffinesedimentsonhyporheicexchangewouldlikelyincreasestreamtemperatures,thescaleoftheeffect,bothintermsofthespatialscaleandthemagnitudeofthetemperaturechange,isnotanalyzedorpresented.Thereportwouldbemorepersuasiveiftheseeffectswerequantified.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffalsoidentifiedthelossofriparianvegetationassociatedwithchannelwideningandthelossofthermalrefugiaassociatedwithstratifiedpoolsaspossibletemperatureimpactsassociatedwithincreasedsedimentloads.Howeverthisdiscussionwasnotincludedinthesectiontitled“Landuseactivitieswiththepotentialtoincreasesedimentdelivery.”ThereportincludesdiscussionofastudyofDeerCreekinnorthernCalifornia,whereTompkins(2006)foundthatreduceddailymaximumwatertemperaturesinhyporheicseepsontheorderof3.5oC(6.3
A‐14ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
oF)createdthermalrefugiaforsalmonids.ThereportalsodiscussesastudysimilartoTompkins’,inwhichLoheideandGorelick(2006)documenteddailymaximumtemperaturereductionsontheorderof2oC(3.8oF)inastudyofa1.7km(1.1.mi)streamreachofCottonwoodCreekinPlumasCounty,California.Stacey14:Withregardstotheinfluenceofsedimentloadonwidth‐to‐depthratio,Iwouldnotethatthisisanindirecteffectonwatertemperature.Further,thereareotherfactorsbesidessedimentloadthathavestronginfluenceonwidth‐to‐depthratio,mostnotablyManning’sn.Iwouldsuggestthatthereportacknowledgetheserelatedinfluences:thatwidth‐to‐depthratiomaybethefactorthatdirectlyinfluenceswatertemperature(orrather,therateofchangeofwatertemperatureasdiscussedabove),butthatotherfactors(suchasManning’sn)thatareundermanagementcontrolwillworktodeterminethewidth‐to‐depthratio.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffhaveincludedlanguagetothestaffreportacknowledgingotherfactorsundermanagementcontrolthatdeterminewidth‐to‐depthratios.Thompson12:Onelimitationoftheexistingpolicyisthatthenuancesofstreamtemperatureasanindicatorofhabitatqualityarenotexplored.Forexample,whilebulkstreamtemperaturesmaynotbeaffectedbybankshading,localcoolsitesmightbegenerated.Thesesitesaresignificantaquaticrefuges.Becauseonly“streamtemperature”wasdiscussed,Ihavehighlightedthatriparianvegetationinwidechannelsmaynotbesignificantasadriverofin‐‐‐channeltemperatures.Thisofcourseignoresitspotentialsignificanceingeneratinglocalthermalrefuges,whichcanbeecologicallysignificant(Nichols,Willisetal.2013).RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffhaveaddedlanguagetothestaffreportthatdiscussestheseconcepts.Also,seeresponsetoStacey12.Thompson13:Significanttemporalvariabilityinstreamtemperaturesalsooftenoccurs,evenwithinaday.Lagsduetotraveltimebetweenupstreamanddownstreamareasmaymeanthat“pulses”ofhotwaterarriveindifferentlocationsatdifferenttimes.Thisgenerateschallengesformonitoring,butalsovariationthatcanbeimportantforhabitatdiversity(Nichols,Willisetal.2013).Itisunclearwhetherorhowthispolicycouldaccountforspatialandtemporalvariability.Thereareseveralanecdotalaccountsofmisinterpretationoflocalstreamtemperaturesbasedonafixedmonitoringtimemissingthearrivalofthermalpulsesfromupstream.Highfrequencymonitoringmethodscancircumventthisproblem.Explicitlyconsideringtheroleoflocalizedcoolrefugesmightalsoprovidegreaterflexibilityinidentifyingsite‐specificstrategies.
A‐15ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
RegionalWaterBoardresponse:ThisPolicyattemptstoachievenaturaltemperaturesbyrestoringandmaintainingtheconditionsthatdrivetemperatureconsistentwiththeirunalteredstates.Thisapproachaddressesspatialandtemporalvariabilitythroughtherecognitionofthespatialandtemporalvariabilityofthedriversoftemperature.RegionalWaterBoardstaffhavefoundtemperaturedatacollectedfromgrabsamplestohavelittleutility.Staffmonitorstemperatureusingtemperaturerecordersthatmeasureatleasteveryhour,deployedformultipledaysandoftenmanyweeks.Thompson14:Althoughthereissignificantliteraturedescribingtheeffectofremovingshadeandriparianvegetationonstreamtemperatures,peerreviewedstudiesdescribingtheeffectsofrestorationofriparianvegetationarelesswidelypublished,andunclearintheirresults.Forinstance,inapairedstudyalongfourstreamsinNewZealand,someofwhichhadexperiencedrestorationofriparianhabitat20yearspreviously,nosignificantdifferencesinstreamtemperaturebetweentreatmentandcontrolsitescouldbefound(Collins,Doscheretal.2013).AreviewofmultipleriparianbufferplantingsinNewZealandfoundthatinonlyonesite(wherecompletecanopyclosurehadoccurred)werestreamtemperaturesreducedinthereachwhererestorationoccurred(Parkyn,Davies‐‐‐Colleyetal.2003).Thereisthereforeanasymmetry,inthatitisveryclearthatremovalofvegetationandincreasesinsolarexposurearelikelytoincreasetemperatures;butitisnotclearthatrestorationofriparianvegetationwilllowerstreamtemperatures.Itislikelythatthisdiscrepancyresultsfromtheneedtoconsiderthespecificcharacteristicsofriparianbuffers.Sincetheseconsiderationsarerelevanttothedesignofbuffers,whetherforrestorationorprotection,Ihaveelaboratedonsomeissuesbelow.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffhavereviewedthepaperscited,andnotethatthebuffersevaluatedinthemwereintendedtoaddresssedimentandnutrientconcerns.Staffagreethataddingshadetoastreamthatisatequilibriumwithhighairtemperatureswillnothaveagreateffect.Thisappearstobethecaseinthereachesstudied.Still,othershavedemonstratedthatreductionsintemperatureassociatedwithrestoredriparianareas,andevenrestoredemergentvegetation,canbeachievedinrelativelyshorttimescales.ThereportprovidesexamplesofthisfromthePacificNorthwest.Thisissueisalsorelevanttothetopicofequilibriumtemperature.Staffhaveaddedlanguagetothestaffreportdiscussingtheconceptsofequilibrium,preservation,andrestoration.Thompson15:Ignoringgroundwater,hyporheicandtributaryinputs,thechangeintemperatureΔTwithinastreamoveranyreachlengthL:
A‐16ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Hereρisthedensityofwater,Cptheheatcapacityofwater,Vthemeanstreamflow,Dthemeandepth,andQisthenetheatexchange.ThelengthofthereachLoverwhichsolarinputsarereducedneedstobelargeenoughtomeetatargetvalueofΔTforthatreach;thegreatertheflowrate(VD)thelongerLwillhavetobe(Moore,Spittlehouseetal.2005).Thus,shortbufferlengthsmaybeineffectiveinmodifyingtemperatures.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:TheRegionalWaterBoardmostoftenreliesontheimplementationofpre‐definedoperatingrules,performancestandards,bestmanagementpractices,orrestrictionsoncertainactivitiestoaddresspotentialwaterqualityimpactsassociatedwithnonpointsourcelanduses,inlieuofprescribedbufferrequirementsforindividualprojects,ofteninthecontextofadaptivemanagement.Thisapproachaddressesmultiplewaterqualityconcernsassociatedwithnear‐streamactivities,aswellasthecumulativeimpactsassociatedwithmultipleprojectsacrossthelandscape.LanguagedescribingthisapproachhasbeenincorporatedintotheStaffReport.Thompson16:Whileanarrowbuffercanreducestream‐shading,widerbuffersareneededtoallowadistinctmicroclimate(e.g.withcoolerairtemperaturesandgreaterhumidity)tobegeneratedrelativetoopensurroundings(Moore,Spittlehouseetal.2005).Widerbuffersalsohaveagreaterpotentialtobecomeself‐sustainingfromanecologicalpointofview,ratherthanbecomingcolonizedbyweedyvegetation(Collins,Doscheretal.2013).RegionalWaterBoardresponse:SeeresponsetoThompson15.Also,theinformationdescribingthemagnitudeofeffectsofhumanactivitiesonmicroclimatesindicateschangesarerelativelysmallanddifficulttoquantify(Bartholow2000,Brosofske1997,Chenetal.1993,Chenetal.1999,Dongetal.1998,Ledwith1996).TheRegionalWaterBoard’sapproachofaddressingsitepotentialeffectiveshadethroughriparianbuffersaddressessolarradiation,whichhasbeendemonstratedtoresultinheatfluxesanorderofmagnitudehigherthanthoseassociatedwithairtemperatureandwindspeed(i.e.,convectionandevaporation)(Johnson2004).Nonetheless,riparianmanagementpracticesthataddresssitepotentialeffectivealsoprovidealevelofprotectionofmicroclimates.Thompson17:Detailedanalysesofsedimentsourcesinstreamnetworksusuallyidentifyparticularlocations(subwatersheds,pointsources,etc)thatdominatetheinputof
A‐17ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
sedimentintowatersheds.Buffersshouldincludetheseareastohaveasignificantimpactonsedimentloading.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Whileitistruethatbuffersmustfunctionallycaptureandcontainsignificantvolumesofsedimentinorderforthemtoaffectgeomorphology,thisisnottheonlypurposebuffersserve.Bufferspreventdisturbancesthatoftengeneratesedimentdeliveredtostreamchannels,theyfiltersedimentserodedfromactivitiesoutsideofbuffers,theyproviderootstrengthinstreambanksandunstableareas,andtheyprovidevegetativecovertopreventsurfaceerosion.Sedimentloadreductionsassociatedwiththesebenefitsmaynotbelargeenoughtoaffectgeomorphology,buttheydocontributetootherwaterqualityissuesassociatedwithbiology,suchasspawninggravelcomposition,thattheRegionalWaterBoardhasaninterestincontrolling.Thepointofassumptionnumber2isthatriparianbuffersfortemperatureprotectionareaneffectiveandimportantmeasureforotherwaterqualityconcernsbesidestemperature,notthattheyprovidethesedimentcontrolsnecessarytopreventchangesingeomorphologybythemselves.TheRegionalWaterBoardaddressessedimentdischargesdirectlythroughtheimplementationoftheSedimentTMDLImplementationPolicy,whichrequirestheRegionalWaterBoardaddresssedimentsourcesthroughbothregulatoryandnonregulatoryactivities,similartothisPolicy.Thompson18:AsintimatedintheexamplesfromNewZealand,itmayrequiredecadesforrestorationofriparianvegetationtomeaningfullyalterphysicalcharacteristicsofthelocalthermalregime.Similarly,evenifbuffersaresuccessfulinreducingsedimentinputsintochannels,thelongresidencetimeofsedimentwithinchannelsmaymeanthatfewifanychangestothein‐streamgeomorphologyandthusvulnerabilitytothermalloadingoccuronobservabletimescales.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:RegionalWaterBoardstaffconcurwithDr.Thompson’sstatementregardinglongrecoverytimescalesfollowingvegetationremovalandsedimentinputs.Thesetimescalesofrecoverysupporttheneedtoprevent,minimize,andmitigateimpactassociatedwithnonpointsourcesofpollution.Thompson19:Asalludedtoinseveralpointsabove,thepolicyissilentonspaceandtimescales.Whileperhaps“site‐specific”and“case‐by‐case”analysisencapsulatesthis,itisworthreiteratingthattherearespecificlengthscales(relatedtoflowandchannelmorphology)andtimescales(relatedtoprocessesofplantgrowth,riparianrecoveryandsedimentresidencetimes)thatwillimpacttheefficacyofanygivenintervention.Abroaderdiscussionoftheseissueswouldbebeneficial.
A‐18ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
RegionalWaterBoardresponse:StaffhaveaddednewtextthataddressestheissuesDr.Thompsonraisesabove.Thompson20:Protectionofriparianbuffersleadstobroaderquestionsofriparianmanagement,weedcontrol,ecologicalvalueetc.Whilethispolicyisclearlytargetedatin‐channelconditions,aholisticapproachthatacknowledgestheinterfacewithriparianecologymorebroadlywouldbevaluable.Ialsonotethatalthoughthepolicyhasfocusedonriparianvegetation,emergent,in‐channelvegetationhasalsobeenshowntohelpcontrolstreamtemperatures,andoftenleadstoimprovementsonfastertimescalesthanareneededtodevelopaclosed‐canopyriparianbuffer(Roth,Westhoffetal.2010).RegionalWaterBoardresponse:TheRegionalWaterBoardrecognizesthateffortstoprotectthefunctionsofriparianareasshouldnotleadtoriparianareasbecoming“nomanagementzones”,andthatdoingsocancreateotherissuessuchasthoseidentifiedbyDr.Thompson.TheRegionalWaterBoardembracesanapproachofprevention,minimization,andmitigationofimpactsassociatedwithactivitiesthathavepotentialtocauseorcontributetoelevatedwatertemperatures.Atthesametime,theRegionalWaterBoardacknowledgesthatmanagementactivitiesinriparianzonesareoftennecessary.Texthasbeenaddedtothestaffreportthatacknowledgestheseideas.StaffarealsokeenlyawareoftheincredibletemperaturereductionsthathaveaccompaniedthegrowthofemergentvegetationfollowingcattleexclusioninareasoftheShastaRiverwatershedandrecognizetheneedtoconsiderthesebenefitsaswellasbenefitsassociatedwithriparianvegetation.Staffhasaddedlanguageclarifyingthesitepotentialeffectiveshadeconceptalsoappliestoemergentvegetation.Stella3:Thereisagenerallackofquantificationofuncertaintyineitherthenaturalsystemorintemperaturemodelspresentedasthescientificbasisfortheproposedpolicychange.Quantifyinguncertaintyiscriticalforassessinghowwellmodelscanpredictsystembehavior,andmanagementprescriptionsandrecommendationsthatarebasedonmodelingresultsneedtobeconsideredinlightofuncertaintyinthemodels.Thereareatleastthreetypesofuncertaintyanalysiswhicharerelevanthere:(a)accuracyassessmentofmodeledtemperaturecomparedtoobservedinstreamtemperature(i.e.,modelvalidation);(b)sensitivityanalysisofmodelparametersonpredictedtemperatures;and(c)propagationofparametererrorthroughthetemperaturemodels.Inabriefreviewofseveraloriginalreports(e.g.,Navarro,ScottandKlamathRiverTMDLstudies),Ihavenotseenmanyexamplesofrigorousmodelvalidationoruncertaintyanalysispresented.TheNavarroRivertemperatureTMDLstudyprovidesonegoodexampleofaparametersensitivityanalysis(Figure4oftheStaff
A‐19ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Report,andFigure5‐2ofNCRWQCB2000),andtheprominenceofriparianshadeasadriverissupportedbystrongcorrelationsbetweenwatertemperatureandmeasuredshade(Figures5‐3and5‐4inNCRWQCB2000).However,thedegreetowhichthetemperaturemodelswerequantitativelyvalidated,andhowuncertaintyinmodelparametersmayqualifymodelpredictionsarenotapparent.Irecognizethatthesestudiesoperatedundertimeandbudgetconstraints,andinsomecasesthecomplexityofthewaterquality/temperaturemodelsmadeuncertaintyanalysisdifficult.ConsistentwithTMDLguidelines,thestudiestypicallyincludesectionsonMarginsofSafety,andassumeaconservativeapproachtorecommendations.Nevertheless,somenumericalestimatesastomodeluncertaintyshouldbeincludedintheStaffReport,tothedegreethattheseanalyseswerecompletedforindividualprojectswithspecificconsiderationofmodelingshadeanditsinfluenceonwatertemperature.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:RegionalWaterBoardstaffagreethatmodelvalidationandaccuracyassessmentareimportantcomponentsofwaterqualitymodelinganalyses.TheRegionalWaterBoard,theUSEPA,andtheircontractorshaveattemptedtoaddressthisstepintheprocessineachinstance.Forinstance,theScottRivertemperaturemodeldevelopmentprocessforthetemperatureTMDLanalysisfollowsthestandardapproachofcalibratingthemodelusingdatafromoneperiodandevaluatingtheperformanceofthemodelbasedonthemodel’spredictionsforanother,independenttimeperiod.Asuiteofaccuracystatisticsareprovidedinatableanddiscussedinthetext,andcomparisonsbetweenpredictedandobservedtemperaturestracesareprovidedinanappendix.AseparateappendixcontainsanassessmentoftheRIPTOPOshademodel’sperformancecomparedtomeasureddata.Themodelingexerciseconductedexplicitlyevaluatedthesensitivityofthemodelparametersonpredictedtemperatures.Similarly,theKlamathRiverTMDLreportincludesanappendixthatdiscussesthemodeltestingprocessingreatdetail.Otheranalysesalsocontaindiscussionsofmodelvalidation,andsensitivity,albeitnotthroughaconsistentapproach.Itisimportanttounderstandtheutilityofthemodelingexercises,whichistheidentificationoftemperaturefactorsthatareaffectedbyhumanactivitiesandmostimportantforthecontroloftemperature.Theresultsofthemodelingexercisesarenotintegratedintopermitsandhaveonlybeenintegratedinwaterqualitygoalsinafewselectcases.TheresultsoftheshadeandtemperaturemodelsdevelopedforthetemperatureTMDLsarenotintendedtobeusedinplaceofasite‐specificapproachtoimplementingtemperatureprotection.Theshadeandtemperaturemodelshavebeenusedtoidentifythemostimportantfactorstoconsiderinsourcereductionefforts,estimateloadingatawatershedscale,andelucidateimportantphysicalprocessesandinteractions,suchasthetemperatureeffectsoftheinteractionofgroundwaterandsurfacewater.
A‐20ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Stella4:Oneparticularlyimportantcaseoftheuncertaintyissuesdescribedaboveisinthecalculationofshadepotentialforanygivenproject.Knowingwhatthepotentialshadeforareachis,relativetoitscurrentcondition,iscriticalfor‘regulationofshadeasacontrollablefactor’(Section3.4oftheStaffReport).Thoughtemperaturemodelsdiffersomewhatinapproach,allthestudiesIreviewedappeartoincludeaspatially‐explicit(e.g.,GIS‐based)submodelthatcalculatesthepotentialshadeforeachsiteorreach.Asreportedinthemethodssectionsofthesestudies,potentialshadeiscalculatedbasedonthestreamchannelmorphologyandorientation,surroundingtopography,vegetationcommunitiespresentintheriparianzone,treedensity,andthemaximumheightgrowthpotentialoftreespeciesinthosecommunities.Thecalculationofpotentialtreeheightanddensitycanvaryconsiderablyamongsitesandreaches,especiallywithinenvironmentallyheterogeneousenvironmentssuchasriparianzones(FriedmanandLee,2002;BalianandNaiman,2005;FierkeandKauffman,2005).IftheapproachtakenintheNavarroRiverstudyistypical,potentialshadeispredictedusingpredictionsoftreeheightbasedondiameteratbreastheight(dbh),withasinglecurvedeterminedforeachspecies33.However,thereisconsiderablevariationinboththedbh‐heightcurveandmaximumtreeheightatmaturityforkeyspeciessuchasredwoodandDouglas‐fir.Whenimplementingtheproposedpolicychangesforreachesofinterest,itwouldbehelpfulataminimumtopropagatetheerrorassociatedwiththedbh‐heightrelationship,aswellasriparianstanddensity,throughthecalculationsofpotentialshade,inordertounderstandthelikelyvariationpotentialshadevalues.Somerangeofthesevaluesshouldbeusedasgoalsforrestorationandasinputstothestreamtemperaturemodels.ThedataonmodeledversusobservedshadepresentedinFigure5‐17oftheNavarroRiverstudy(NCRWQCB2000)isagoodstartinthisdirection.Thisstudyalsousedarangeof5%to70%shadeinthemodelsensitivityanalysis,andfounddifferencesinpredictedtemperatureof>3degreesC.ForanygivenprojectthatfallswithintheproposedWaterQualityControlPlanamendment,howgreatistheuncertaintyinpotentialshadeestimates,andhowgreattheresultingtemperatureuncertainty?RegionalWaterBoardresponse:TheresultsoftheshadeandtemperaturemodelsdevelopedforthetemperatureTMDLsarenotintendedtobeusedinplaceofasite‐specificapproachtoimplementingtemperatureprotection.ThegreatestutilityofthemodelexercisesconductedinsupportoftemperatureTMDLdevelopmentisinidentifyingwhichfactorsthatdrivetemperaturedynamicsareimportant,aswellaswhentemperaturedrivershaveanegligibleeffectontemperatures.AnexampleofthisistheanalysisconductedfortheLowerEelRivertemperatureTMDL.Theresultsof
33Thoughoutofthescopeofthecurrentreview,itshouldbenotedthatrecentadvancesinremotesensing,especiallyinacquisitionandprocessingofLiDARdata,havethepotentialtogreatlyincreasetheaccuracyofripariancanopyheightestimationandstructure(e.g.,Seavyetal.,2009),andconsequentlyestimatesofriparianshadepotential.
A‐21ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
thatanalysiswereusedtodemonstratethat:1)theshadingofthemainstemEelRiver(andcorrespondingtemperaturedifferences)wasnegligibleunderanyvegetationscenario.Thesameanalysisshowedthattemperaturesoftributarystreamsarequitesensitivetoriparianvegetationconditions.Theresultswerenotusedtodefinewhatlevelsofshade,orheightofvegetation,orwatertemperaturesarenecessaryforachievementoftheTMDLandwaterqualityobjectives.Rather,theresultsareusedtoillustratethatriparianvegetationneedstobemanagedinamannerthatdoesnotelevatetemperaturesintheseareas.Inthiswaythepolicyimplicationsandimplementationstrategiesarenotsensitivetothemodelcalibration.However,RegionalWaterBoardstaffacknowledgesthatdevelopingabetterunderstandingoftherelationshipofeffectiveshadetobufferdepthanddensityisagoodgoalandintendtopursuethegoalthrougheffectivenessmonitoring.Stella5:TheStaffReportincludesasectionon“Site‐specificimplementation”(Section3.2),whichidentifiessomeofthelocalfactorsthatmayinfluencetheeffectofriparianshadeoninstreamtemperature.Inadditiontothefactorslisted,Isuggestseveralmoretoconsiderinreferencetotheireffectonpotentialshadeforasite.Thesearedescribedbelow.Overall,itisunclearhowtheseconsiderations—boththosedescribedintheexistingdocumentandothersthatreviewersidentify—willbeimplementedinaconsistentwaywithinthepolicyamendment.Perhapsfurtherdevelopmentofquantitativeorqualitativeguidelineswillbenecessary,eitherasrangesofparameterinputsintomodelsorsomerubrictoscaletheiroutputsinlightofsite‐specificfactors.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:RegionalWaterBoardstaffhasexpandedthesectiononsite‐specificimplementationandaddedasectiondiscussingtheuseofmanagementmeasuresandadaptivemanagementinthecontextofnonpointsourcepermitting.Stella6:Oneimportantconsiderationinfluencingshadepotentialisthatspeciescompositionandcanopystructureofriparianvegetationvariesgreatlydependingonnetworkpositionandgeomorphiccontrolsonthereach(e.g.,unconfinedvs.confined,alluvialversusbedrock).ParticularlyintheNorthCoastregion,low‐orderstreamstendtobedominatedbytallconifersthatgrowclosetothestreamchannel,whereashigh‐orderstreamsmayhaveamixtureofconifersandmuchshorterhardwoods,particularlyalongwideralluvialreaches.Vegetationcommunitymapsusedtocalculatepotentialshadetypicallydonottakeintoaccountthislevelofdetail,yetthiscanbeveryimportantintermsofestimatingmaximumpotentialheightofthestreamsidevegetation.Thevariationinriparianvegetationcompositionwithinanetworkcanamplifythedifferenceinshadepotentialbetweennarrow,confined,conifer‐dominatedheadwaterstreamsanddownstreamreacheswithwideractivechannels,lesstopographicshadingfromunconfinedvalleys,andmorevaried
A‐22ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
vegetationwithsignificantamountsofhardwoodandshrubspeciesofshorterstature.ThedescriptionsofshademodelsthatIreviewedtakeintoaccountthetopographyandactivechannelwidth,butnotthenear‐streamvegetationcommunitiesasseparatefromthelandscapelevelvegetationmaps.LookingtotheapplicabilityofthistemperatureTMDLapproachbeyondtheNorthCoastregion,thevariationinripariancommunitystructureandcompositionwithinanetworkcanbeevenmorepronouncedinotherregions(e.g.,CentralValleyand/ordesertstreams).ThereforeinboththeNorthCoastregionandmoregenerally,thereshouldbesomethoughtastohowtoquantifytheeffectsofvegetationcompositiongradientswithinstreamnetworksasinputstoshade‐basedtemperaturemodels.RegionalWaterBoardResponse:Theseissuesareimportantconsiderationsinthedevelopmentofshademodels.However,theseconsiderationsaremadeatthesite‐specificlevelforindividualprojects.Inthesesituationsthetypesofvegetationpresentareknown.Theassumptionsoftheshademodelsdonotcomeintoplayattheprojectlevelpermittingscale.Thispolicydirectsstafftoaddresselevatedwatertemperatureconcernsattheproject‐level,takingintoaccountthesite‐specificfactors,astheyrelatetotheconsistentconclusionsofnorthcoastTMDLs:thatshade,sediment,andflowconcernsneedtobeevaluatedandaddressed,ifnecessary,fortheprotectionofwatertemperature.Stella7:Arelatedissueisthatthenaturalandhumandisturbancehistoryofareachneedstobeconsideredwhensettingpotentialshadetargets.Riparianzonesarehighlydynamicecosystems,withphysicaldriverssuchasflooding,fireanddroughtexertingstronginfluencesonthevegetationcommunitytrajectory.Thestructureofriparianvegetationwillbehighlydependentonthetimesincealargedisturbance,particularlyinsteep,semi‐aridsystemssuchastheNorthCoastregionwhereextremeevents(e.g.,the1964and1997floods)causechannel‐settingdisturbancesoverlargespatialscales(e.g.,networkstoregions)andsubsequentripariancommunityrecoverycanlastdecadesuntilmaximumvegetationheightanddensityareachieved.TheStaffReportalludestothisprocessdirectlyaffectinginstreamtemperatures,initscitationofKlamathRiverwatertemperaturerisingfollowingtheclearingofriparianvegetationinthe1997floodevent(delaFuenteandElder1998,ascitedonp.22oftheStaffReport).Thatpeakflowevent,whichwasclassifiedata19.5yearrecurrenceinterval,resultedinacutealteration—bankerosion,depositionorremovalofvegetation—of16%to19%ofallstreamchannelswithintheKlamathRiverbasin(delaFuenteandElder1998).Presumablyeventsofthismagnitudewilloccuratleastseveraltimesacentury,wellwithinthelifespanofthedominantshadetreespeciesintheregion.ThereforedisturbanceisamajorcontrolontheshadepotentialoftheriparianecosystemintheNorthCoastregion,canaffectlargeareasofthestreamnetworksynoptically,andcanlimitthespatialextentofolderriparianstandsdominatedbytalltrees.Thisprocessmustbe
A‐23ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
consideredwhenusingreferencereachestosetpotentialshadetargetsandinpredictingthelong‐termeffectofmanagementactions.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffagreesthattheissuespresentedinthecommentabovearerelevantandmustbeconsideredinanyanalysisofasite’shistory,trajectory,andpotential.Thesite‐specificapproachthispolicydirectsallowsforthosetypesofconsiderationsintheimplementationofthepermittingandgrantprograms.Thegeneralapproachthatthispolicyandtheintrastatetemperatureobjectivecallsforistheregulationofactivitiesinamannerthatensuresthatnaturalrecoveryprocessesthatdisturb,rearrange,andrecoverstreamchannelsandriparianzonescontinue.AdditionaltextdiscussingtheseissueshasbeenaddedtotheStaffReport.Stella8:ThediscussionofsedimentprocessesinconjunctionwithstreamtemperatureisausefulfeatureoftheStaffReportandreflectscomplexinteractionsamongmultiplewaterqualitycomponents.Asnotedinthereport,excesssedimentloadingcanaffectinstreamtemperaturethroughalterationofthechannelmorphologyandinteractionswithriparianvegetationdynamics.Inaddition,manyoftheriparianbufferprescriptionstomitigatehighinstreamtemperaturesthroughincreasedshadewillhavethepositivebenefitofmitigatingsedimentdeliverytothechannel,andviceversa.Inasimilarvein,itisimportanttoconsiderpotentialnegativeinteractionsbetweenriparianvegetationmanagementandgeomorphicprocessgoals,particularlyalongregulatedstreamsintheNorthCoastregion.AlongtheTrinityRiver,forexample,severealterationoftheriver’shydrologyledtoriparianencroachmentwithintheformeractivechannel(Trushetal.,2000).Presumably,thiscreatedincreasedriparianshadeastheactivechanneldecreasedandvegetationincreasedindensityandheight,andtheincreasedshadewaspresumablyabenefittomaintaininglowinstreamtemperature,particularlyinareachwithgreatlyreduceddischargeandthuslesscapacitytobufferhighheatloads.However,thevegetationencroachmentandsubsequentformationofhigh,immobileriparianbermsseverelyalteredthechannelmorphodynamics,sedimentdeliveryprocesses,andlargewoodydebrisrecruitment,andgreatlyreducedtheoverallhabitatfornativesalmonidsandotheraquaticorganisms.InthecaseoftheTrinityRiver,theinterestsofmaintainingriparianshadeandofmaintaininganatural,dynamicstreamchannelwereatodds,andcontemporaryriverrestorationeffortsarefocusedonremovingtheriparianbermsandrescalingtheactivechannel(TRRP2013).TheTrinityRiverisafairlyextremecaseofrivermanipulation,butithighlightstheimportanceofconsideringpotentialtradeoffsbetweencompetingmanagementconcerns,inthiscaseshadepotentialandsedimentprocesses.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:StaffagreeswiththepointDr.Stellamakesandhasaddednewtextdescribinghowthesite‐specificapproachisintendedtoallowforthesekindsofsituationstobeacknowledgedandaddressed.
A‐24ResponsetoPeerReviewCommentsonthePeerReviewDraftPolicyfortheImplementationoftheWater
QualityObjectivesforTemperature
Stella9:Theissueofclimaticwarmingposeschallengestostreamandriparianmanagementworldwide,inparticularinsensitiveareassuchasCaliforniaandotherMediterranean‐climateregions(Underwoodetal.,2009;Stellaetal.,2012).Becauseofthestronglinkbetweenairtemperatureandinstreamtemperatures,ongoingregionalwarminginCaliforniawillmakefreshwaterstreamslesshabitableforsalmonidsandothercoldwaterorganismsatthesouthernedgeoftheirranges.Itisuncleartomehowthisnon‐stationarityofthesystemwillbeconsideredwithintheproposedTMDLpolicyamendment.Howwilltemperaturemodelsincorporatethe‘newnormal’intopredictionsandlandmanagementprescriptions?Isitpossiblethatmeterologicalandhydrologicchangesmayincreasetherelativestrengthofthesedriversoninstreamwatertemperature,withpotentiallylessinfluencefromriparianshade?IrecommendthattheStaffReportprovidesomeacknowledgementofthisissue,andpotentialimplicationsforpolicy.RegionalWaterBoardresponse:Staffhaveaddednewtexttothestaffreportdiscussingthetopicofclimatechangeanditsramifications.