120707 Why China Can't Adjust

7/28/2019 120707 Why China Can't Adjust

1/15

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

User Account

Register

Login

Main navigation

Economists' ClubExclusive commentaries and debate featuring the world's leading economic thinkers.

Mind, Matter & PoliticsExclusive cutting-edge commentaries on science, philosophy, and global affairs.

Topics

Focal Points

Focal Points

Asia's Tipping Point?

The Roubini Factor

Back to Mexico's Future?

Free Trade in Troubled Times

Europe's Crisis Goes Global

Central Banks in the Firing Line Soros on Europe

The Big Bank Theory

The Road to Rio+20

Would Eurobonds Work?

Will India's Boom Go Bust?

Austerity and its Discontents

America's Precarious Recovery

The Euro at Bay

China's Scandalous Politics

View all Focal Points

Africa

Africa

African Politics

African Economies

African Development

Public Health

Page 1 of 15"Why China Cant Adjust" by Minxin Pei | Project Syndicate

7/17/2012http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/why-china-can-t-adjust


2/15

Most recent commentaries on this topic

type to search live in this

Asia

Asia

Asian Politics Asian Economies

China

India

Japan

Korean Peninsula

Southeast Asia

Central Asia



Culture and Society

Culture and Society

Social Changes/Social Movements

Philosophy and Ethics

Religion

Human Rights

Technology

Health and Medicine

Science and Society



Economic Reflections

Economic Reflections

Economic Justice

Economic History

Economic Theory

Market Economy/Capitalism



Environment

Environment

Global Warming/Climate Change

The Environment and the Economy




3/15

Natural Resources



Europe

Europe

European Politics

European Economies

Eurozone

EU Member States

Non-EU Europe

Germany

France

United Kingdom

Russia

Central Europe



Finance

Finance

Financial Institutions

Banking

Central Banking

Monetary Policy

Financial Regulation



Growth and Development

Growth and Development

Fiscal Policy

Development Strategies

Regulatory Policy Corporate Governance

Trade



International Economics

International Economics




4/15

International Financial Institutions

US Economy

European Economies

Asian Economies

Developing World



International Institutions

International Institutions

G-7, G-8, G-20

IMF/World Bank

UN

EU

NATO

International Justice

Others



International Relations

International Relations

US Foreign Policy

European Affairs

Asian Affairs

Military Affairs Diplomacy



Latin America

Latin America

Latin American Politics

Latin American Economies Brazil

Argentina

Mexico



Middle East




5/15

Middle East

Israel/Palestine

Egypt

Turkey

Iran

Iraq

Islam



Politics

Politics

US Politics

European Politics

Asian Politics

Human Rights Women's Issues

Democratic Transitions

Constitutional Government



United States

United States

US Politics US Economy

US Foreign Policy



Videos/ Podcasts

On DeckWeb-only features and blogs.

About us

About Project Syndicate

Submission Guidelines Contributors

Member Papers

Archive

RSS Feeds

search

Facebook

Twitter

RSS




6/15

LinkedIn

Google+

Youtube

More

Featured Articles

Daniel Gros

A Banking Union Baby Step

BRUSSELS At the beginning of the financial crisis, it was said that banks were, in Charles Goodharts

crisp phrase, international in life

Javier Solana

The Egyptian CrucibleMADRID As Egyptians tensely awaited the results of their countrys presidential elections, a thread of

pessimism ran through the discourse

Mark Roe

Greece and the Limits of Anti-Austerity

CAMBRIDGE Is austerity dead? At last months G-8 meeting at Camp David, the German-led austerityprogram for the eurozones troubled south

Christopher R. Hill

Where Are the Syrian Peacemakers?

DENVER Much has been said about the similarities between the chaos in Syria and the Balkan wars of

the 1990s. But, while the prolonged ki

Asian PoliticsAsian EconomiesChina

Exit from comment view mode. Click to hide this space




7/15

Minxin Pei

Minxin Pei is Professor of Government at Claremont McKenna College.

Full profile

Jul. 5, 2012Email | Print

EnglishEnglish ArabicArabic

ChineseChinese

FrenchFrench GermanGerman

SpanishSpanish

Why China Cant Adjust

Share thisSelect a serviceX

google bookmarkdelicious

digg

Tweet

10

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphCLAREMONT, CALIFORNIA Chinas current economic

slowdown has no shortage of causes: Europes financial turmoil, sputtering recovery in the United States, andweak domestic investment growth, to name the most commonly cited factors. Since exports and investment

account, respectively, for 30% and 40% of Chinas GDP growth, its economy is particularly vulnerable toweakening external demand and accumulation of non-performing loans caused by excessive and wasteful

spending on fixed assets.

Illustration by Paul Lachine

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphBut Chinas vulnerability to these factors, as serious as theyare, is symptomatic of deeper institutional problems. Until these underlying constraints are addressed, talk of a

new consumption-based growth model for China, reflected in the governments recently approved 12th Five-

Year Plan, can be no more than lip service.

24

88Like




8/15

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphAfter all, Chinas major trading partners, international

financial institutions such as the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, and senior Chinese officials

themselves have long recognized the structural vulnerabilities caused by excessive investment and low

household consumption. And, for nearly a decade, China has been urged to undertake reforms to redress these

economic patterns, which have undermined the welfare of ordinary Chinese and strained the global trading

system.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphThe best-known feature of Chinas macroeconomic

imbalances is heavy dependence on exports for growth, which is typically attributed to weak domestic demand:

as a middle-income country, China lacks the purchasing power to consume the goods that it produces. With

nearly unlimited access to advanced-country markets, China can tap into global external demand and raise its

GDP growth potential, as it has done for the past two decades.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphIf this view is right, the solution is straightforward: China

can correct its imbalances by increasing its citizens incomes (by cutting taxes, raising wages, or increasing

social spending), so that they can consume more, thereby reducing the economys dependence on exports.

Indeed, nearly all mainstream economists prescribe this approach for China.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphBut there is another explanation for Chinas excessive export

dependence, one that has more to do with the countrys poor political and economic institutions. Specifically,

export dependence partly reflects the high degree of difficulty of doing business in China. Official corruption,insecure property rights, stifling regulatory restraints, weak payment discipline, poor logistics and distribution,

widespread counterfeiting, and vulnerability to other forms of intellectual-property theft: all of these obstacles

increase transaction costs and make it difficult for entrepreneurs to thrive in domestic markets.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphBy contrast, if Chinas private firms sell to Western

multinationals, such as Wal-Mart, Target, or Home Depot, they do not have to worry about getting paid. They

can avoid all of the headaches that they would have encountered at home, because well-established economic

institutions and business practices in their export markets protect their interests and greatly reduce transaction

costs.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphThe Chinese economys institutional weakness is reflected in

international survey data. The World Bank publishes an annual review of the ease of doing business for 183countries and sub-national units. In its June 2011 survey, China was ranked 91st, behind Mongolia, Albania, and

Belarus. It is particularly difficult to start a business in China (151st), pay taxes (122nd), obtain construction

permits (179th), and get electricity (115th).

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphFaced with such a hostile environment, Chinese private

entrepreneurs have been forced to engage in institutional arbitrage taking advantage of efficient Western

economic institutions to expand their business (most export-oriented businesses are owned by private

entrepreneurs and foreign firms).

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphUnfortunately, as China has already claimed a large share of

the worlds merchandise exports (10.4% in 2010) and economic stagnation in the West is constraining external

demand, this strategy can no longer work. But reorienting their businesses toward the Chinese domestic market

requires far more than government policies that put more money in consumers' pockets.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphIn order to enjoy the same low transaction costs that they

have in exporting, Chinas entrepreneurs need a much better business environment: an effective legal system, a

sound regulatory framework, a government that protects their brands by fighting intellectual-property theft,

dependable logistics and distribution networks, and a graft-resistant bureaucracy.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphChina cannot create such an environment quickly. In

essence, the Chinese government must transform a predatory state into a nurturing one, and treat private




9/15

entrepreneurs as creators of wealth rather than targets of extraction. In nearly all other countries, such a

transformation was accomplished by establishing the rule of law and/or moving from autocracy to democracy.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphThe impossibility of sustaining growth in the absence of the

rule of law and political accountability presents the Chinese Communist Party with an existential dilemma. Ever

since it crushed the pro-democracy movement in Tiananmen Square in 1989, the party has vowed not to

surrender its political monopoly. The investment boom and the globalization dividend of the last two decades

allowed the Party to have its cake and eat it maintaining its rule on the basis of economic prosperity, while

failing to establish the institutions critical to sustaining such prosperity. Today, this is no longer possible.

CommentsView/Create comment on this paragraphSo in a sense, the Chinese bubble as much an intellectual

and political bubble as an economic one has burst. As Chinas economic deceleration exposes its structural

vulnerabilities and flawed policies, the much-hyped notion of Chinese exceptionalism that China can

continue to grow without the rule of law and the other essential institutions that a modern market economy

presupposes is proving to be nothing but a delusion.

Reprinting material from this Web site without written consent fromProject Syndicate is a violation of

international copyright law. To secure permission, please contact us.

Share this

Select a serviceXgoogle bookmark

delicious

digg

Tweet

10

Exit from comment view mode. Click to hide this space

New comment

Filter

Explain this

Comments (3)

You need to login in order to leave a comment. If you do not yet have an account, please register.

1. Commented

24

88Like




10/15

Daniel Gomes 1 week ago

China's economic model is its last strides due to many different reasons:

1. Energy costs: For a low cost export based economy all production and transportation costs are critical.Take energy costs for example, besides the amounts required to keep factories running, the amount

required dor transportation of goods all the way to europe and U.S is far from negligible.

And as we've seen in 2008, the oil prices will sky rocket as soon as the western economies start growingagain. This will give a major advantage to local production and too countries (e.g. EU members) whichhave learner not to rely on cheap energy.

2. Inflation and income gap: China's currency policy and lack of any kind of social protection in particularfor the armies of migrant workers which keep factories running, generates a continuously widening gapbetween purchasing power of the masses and the general cost of living since early 2000s.The government has started to tackle this but its too little too late, over the past 10 years basic salaries insouth china factories stagnated in around $300 US dollars where as a small flat costs around $200.000 US.Migrant workers are making barely enough to sustain their families in the countryside.

Only a small minority of the native city dwellers is seeing some of the benefits from the China's growth,but even these are being eroded by inflation.

3. On the other hand the government is simply not able to allow the hordes of migrant workers to furtherincrease to sustain manufacturing expansion and therefore abandoning the country side and foodproduction, without seriously endangering food safety, and again, as we all seen in 2008 with rice andpork prices going haywire and china producers preferring to sell to other countries to maximize theirprofit instead of selling at government fixed prices to their own citizens, we can all see how easy it wouldbe for basic laws of supply and demand to cause a serious uprise.

4. With an internal market with no relevant aggregate demand other than essential products plus cars andstatus products there is little incentive for the continuous large scale investments in china, in fact most of

the manufacturing industry which could have been transferred to China has already happened and othercountries like Vietnam are presenting themselves as more economical alternatives.

6. China is a demographic time bomb, in Asia due to the lack of social security (or the low coverageincipient ones like in china) the older generations depend on direct cash handouts from the youngergenerations and the current generation in their 30s will have to sustain 2 or even 6 elders with their ownincome.

2. Commented

Dennis Argall 1 week ago

While keenly awaiting the comments of others, let me offer this link:

http://www.smh.com.au/national/defence-boss-uses-rare-tools-to-build-foreign-friendships-20120706-21mfw.html

as illustration of how human perspectives contribute to the general need of which I wrote thus:

"...Construction of collaborative connections with China by the US, Japan and others including Australia,is of the utmost importance for global security. We will all do better if we shift from zero sum gaming,




11/15

make room."

Hostility and pessimism, in my view, breed hostile and pessimistic outcomes.

3. Commented

Dennis Argall 1 week ago

Elsewhere

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304746604577380073854822072.html

Prof Pei has spoken of China's government as a statistical outlier in its longevity among autocracies.

China is also an outlier for its population size and consequent governance issues, its poverty and the

historically unique rate of revolutionary change and its climb from poverty since 1978.

There are problems with generalisations for the whole country. I was saying to people in the 1980s that

the Chinese coastal strip contained at least four equivalents of post-war Japan, not like the 'little tigers' of

Taiwan, South Korea, Hong Kong and Singapore, but on the scale of Japan itself; same picture more

dramatic now. While other parts of China are less developed.

The discussion in Prof Pei's later paragraphs about problems of accountability might be put in context ofthe way things have gone in western economies in recent times. There has not been much on offer for

China as exemplary (or successful) political or commercial conduct in the US or EU or Russia, or India in

the reform era from 1978.

I have argued elsewhere

http://dennisargall.blogspot.com.au/2012/05/china-and-future-of-everything.html

that Chinese leaders work with more freedom, plan with more freedom than currently evident in many

western democratic systems or academic institutions.

I am not aware of any thread of political desire in this generation (or the next, the graduates mentioned) to

break up this unprecedentedly large country, apart from some elements in minority populations.

If we say there are problems for the rich and productive in China in getting more deeply into the markets

of less developed parts of China, compare the EU dilemma, Germany needing to sustain and build itspoorer and 'less well governed' fellow EU members if it is not to lose its own wealth.

Mind you, I worry about my country's 20% GDP dependence on exports

http://www.tradingeconomics.com/australia/exports-of-goods-and-services-percent-of-gdp-wb-data.html

... while having more confidence in China's government to address big new issues than I have in the

capacities of my own country's political system, let alone those of the US. We need to think about

ourselves when doing this too-common rough-up of China.

Yes, there are dinosaurs in the Chinese system, I recognise them because they are familiar locally. But

there needs to be something more than this kind of statistical chartism, some more refined politicalexamination, to really claim that China is on the verge of collapse.

I am concerned not least because arguing in the United States about China in this way has for decades fed

adversarial ways of thinking about China, which do nothing to lead towards positive outcomes. Feeding

the kind of thinking that still imagines Reagan brought down the Soviet Union. Construction of

collaborative connections with China by the US, Japan and others including Australia, is of the utmost

importance for global security. We will all do better if we shift from zero sum gaming, make room.




12/15

Related Resources

More on this topic

facebooktwitter

Shashi Tharoor Jul. 13, 2012

Indias Frugal Dynamism

NEW DELHI Indias sliding economy has inspired gloom and doom far and wide, but increasingly

bearish sentiment is misplaced. India still o

facebooktwitter

Andrew Sheng, Geng Xiao Jul. 12, 2012

The East Asian Miracle Revisited

HONG KONG Almost two decades ago, the World Bank published its landmark study The East Asian

Miracle, analyzing why East Asian economies g

facebooktwitter

Malcolm Fraser Jul. 11, 2012

Obamas China Card?

MELBOURNE According to the United States Federal Reserve, Americans net worth has fallen 40%

since 2007, returning to its 1992 level. Pro

facebooktwitter

Jagdish Bhagwati, Arvind Panagariya Jul. 8, 2012

The Bell Tolls for Indias Congress PartyNEW YORK Politics in Asias two giants, India and China, has suddenly turned very uncertain. China

remains in authoritarian mode, of cours

Show more

Other commentaries by this author




13/15

facebooktwitter

May 14, 2012

The Myth of Chinese Meritocracy

CLAREMONT, CALIFORNIA Political scandals sometimes perform a valuable function in cleansing

governments. They destroy the political career

facebooktwitter

Apr. 17, 2012

The Paranoid Style in Chinese Politics

HONG KONG Henry Kissinger, who learned a thing or two about political paranoia as Richard Nixons

national security adviser and Secretary

Show more

Related articles

facebooktwitter

Michael Raska Jun. 6, 2012

China on the Launch PadSINGAPORE Behind a veil of secrecy, Chinas development of strategic and tactical missiles is well

into its third generation of modernizat

facebooktwitter

Jamie F. Metzl May 18, 2012

The Paradox of Chinas Reform

NEW YORK The compelling drama of former Chongqing Communist Party chief Bo Xilais ouster

amid allegations of corruption and murder, and o

facebooktwitter

Minxin Pei May 14, 2012




14/15

The Myth of Chinese Meritocracy

CLAREMONT, CALIFORNIA Political scandals sometimes perform a valuable function in cleansing

governments. They destroy the political career

facebooktwitter

Minxin Pei Apr. 17, 2012

The Paranoid Style in Chinese Politics

HONG KONG Henry Kissinger, who learned a thing or two about political paranoia as Richard Nixons

national security adviser and Secretary

Show more

TopProject Syndicate commentaries Most read

Most commented

Most shared

Most read

facebooktwitter

Joseph E. Stiglitz Jul. 3, 2012

The Euros Latest Reprieve

NEW YORK Like an inmate on death row, the euro has received another last-minute stay of execution.

It will survive a little longer. The ma

facebooktwitter

Mohamed A. El-Erian Jul. 2, 2012

Will Europe Be Willing but Disabled?

NEWPORT BEACH When it comes to describing Europes ever-worsening crisis, metaphors abound.

For some, it is five minutes to midnight; for

facebooktwitter

Norbert Walter Jul. 5, 2012




15/15

What Euro Crisis?

FRANKFURT What constitutes a crisis? Is it sustained economic decline, high and long-term

unemployment, poverty, rampant inflation, a prec

facebooktwitter

Raghuram Rajan Jul. 10, 2012

Is Inequality Inhibiting Growth?

CHICAGO To understand how to achieve a sustained recovery from the Great Recession, we need to

understand its causes. And identifying caus

Show more

Contributors

Archive Contact

Advertising

Terms & Privacy

(c) 1995-2012 Project Syndicate

RSS

Twitter

Facebook

App Store


Documents

120707 Why China Can't Adjust