27
แบบจาลองความช้นสมดุลของสับปะรดแช่อ่ม นายนาพล แสงผาบ รหัสนักศกษา 570651010 รายงานฉบับน้เป็นส่วนหน่งของวชาวศวกรรมการอบแห้ง (254857) ภาควชาวศวกรรมเคร่องกล คณะวศวกรรมศาสตร์ มหาวทยาลัยเชยงใหม่ การศกษา 2557

แบบจำลองความชื้นสมดุล Halsey

  • Upload
    -

  • View
    38

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

เป็นการหาค่า A B

Citation preview

  • 570651010

    (254857)

    2557

  • - 1 -

    Halsey A B

    Halsey (Least Square Method)

    1.

    1.1 (Least Square Method)

    Halsey exp BeqA

    RH MRT

    RH ,

    T , C

    Meq , %db

    R = 8.314 kJ/kg-K

    A, B

    Halsey

    1 2Y C C X

    ln ln ln ln eqA

    T RH B MR

    ln lnY T RH

    ln eqX M

    1 lnA

    CR

    ( 1CA Re )

    2C B ( 2B C )

    1C 2C

    21 21

    n

    i i

    i

    E Y C C X

  • - 2 -

    1.1.1 1C E 1C

    1

    E

    C

    = 1 2

    1

    2 1n

    i i

    i

    Y C C X

    = 0

    1 21

    n

    i i

    i

    Y C C X

    = 0

    1 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C n C X

    = 0

    1C = 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C X

    n

    1.1.2 2C E 2C

    2

    E

    C

    = 1 2

    1

    2n

    i i i

    i

    Y C C X X

    = 0

    2

    1 2

    1 1 1

    n n n

    i i i i

    i i i

    X Y C X C X

    = 0

    1C = 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C X

    n

    2

    21 12

    1 1 1

    n n

    i in n ni i

    i i i i

    i i i

    Y C X

    X Y X C Xn

    = 0

    2C 2C

    2C = 1 1 1 22

    1 1

    n n n

    i i i i

    i i i

    n n

    i i

    i i

    n X Y X Y

    n X X

    1.1.3 2R (Coefficient of determination)

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    1

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    modelY Y

    Y Y 1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    n

  • - 3 -

    1.2

    (dry basis)

    100%dbw d

    M xd

    dbM

    w ()

    d ()

  • - 4 -

    2. A B Halsey

    2.1 50 C

    2.1 50 C

    (g)

    (g) RH (%) Meq (%db)

    1 LiCl 30.5500 28.6200 11.4000 6.7435

    2 LiCl 32.4600 30.2600 11.4000 7.2703

    3 MgCl2.6H2O 32.2700 29.6500 31.4000 8.8364

    4 NaCl 35.6600 27.2500 75.2000 30.8624

    5 NaCl 37.6700 28.5900 75.2000 31.7594

    6 KNO3 37.7000 26.8400 84.9900 40.4620

    7 KNO3 39.5100 28.2100 84.9900 40.0567

    2.1.1 1C 2C

    1C 1C = 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C X

    n

    2C 2C = 1 1 1 22

    1 1

    n n n

    i i i i

    i i i

    n n

    i i

    i i

    n X Y X Y

    n X X

    2.2 1C 2C

    N lni eqX M ln lniY T RH i iX Y 2

    iX

    1 1.9086 4.6875 8.9464 3.6427

    2 1.9838 4.6875 9.2990 3.9355

    3 2.1789 4.0590 8.8441 4.7475

    4 3.4295 2.6568 9.1117 11.7617

    5 3.4582 2.6568 9.1878 11.9591

    6 3.7004 2.0958 7.7552 13.6927

    7 3.6903 2.0958 7.7341 13.6183

    1

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 20.3497 1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 22.9392 1

    n

    i i

    i

    X Y

    = 60.8783 21

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 63.3575

  • - 5 -

    2C 2C =

    2

    60.8783 20.3497 22.9392

    63.3575 20. 7

    7

    7 349

    2C = 1.3832

    2C 1C

    1C = 22.9392 1.3832 20 7

    7

    .349

    1C = 7.2980

    1.3832 7.2980Y X

    2.1.2 2R

    1 22.9392 3.27707

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    model 1.3832 7.2980XY

    2.3 2R

    N X Y modelY 2

    modelY Y 2

    Y Y

    1 1.9086 4.6875 4.6581 0.0009 1.9893

    2 1.9838 4.6875 4.5541 0.0178 1.9893

    3 2.1789 4.0590 4.2843 0.0507 0.6115

    4 3.4295 2.6568 2.5544 0.0105 0.3847

    5 3.4582 2.6568 2.5148 0.0202 0.3847

    6 3.7004 2.0958 2.1798 0.0071 1.3953

    7 3.6903 2.0958 2.1937 0.0096 1.3953

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 22.9392 2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 0.1167 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 8.1502

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    0.1167

    8. 5 21

    1 01

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9857R

  • - 6 -

    X Y

    2R = 0.9857 1

    2.1.3 A B

    1CA Re 2B C

    8.3147.2980 12282.6851A e x

    1.3832B

    A B Halsey

    1.383212282.exp6851

    eqRH MRT

    1

    1.3832

    12282.6851

    lneq

    RT RHM

    Halsey 50

    RH 1% 90% Halsey

    y = -1.3832x + 7.298

    R = 0.9857

    0.00

    1.00

    2.00

    3.00

    4.00

    5.00

    1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00

  • - 7 -

    2R Halsey

    1 165.9907 23. 1 07

    7 3

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    1.

    1

    mode

    3832

    l12282.685

    l

    1

    nRT XY

    2.4 2R Halsey

    N X =

    Y =

    modelY

    2

    modelY Y 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    1 11.4000 6.7435 6.6020 0.0200 287.9615

    2 11.4000 7.2703 6.6020 0.4467 270.3604

    3 31.4000 8.8364 10.3991 2.4419 221.3114

    4 75.2000 30.8624 28.6596 4.8523 51.1142

    5 75.2000 31.7594 28.6596 9.6085 64.7444

    6 84.9900 40.4620 42.9960 6.4214 280.5301

    7 84.9900 40.0567 42.9960 8.6396 267.1183

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    =

    165.9907

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 32.4305

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    =

    1443.1404

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    50 C

    Halsey

  • - 8 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    32.4305

    1443.141

    41

    0

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9775R

  • - 9 -

    2.2 57 C

    2.5 57 C

    N

    (g)

    (g) RH (%) Meq (%db)

    1 LiCl 22.6600 21.2900 11.2600 6.4349

    2 LiCl 23.9400 22.5300 11.2600 6.2583

    3 MgCl2.6H2O 26.5300 24.5300 30.9100 8.1533

    4 Mg(NO3)2.6H2O 24.4300 21.6300 45.1596 12.9450

    5 Mg(NO3)2.6H2O 21.3800 19.0200 45.1596 12.4080

    6 NaCl 25.0300 18.9300 75.0600 32.2240

    7 NaCl 23.0900 17.5200 75.0600 31.7922

    8 KNO3 28.7600 20.4100 82.2363 40.9113

    9 KNO3 26.6500 18.9500 82.2363 40.6332

    2.2.1 1C 2C

    1C 1C = 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C X

    n

    2C 2C = 1 1 1 22

    1 1

    n n n

    i i i i

    i i i

    n n

    i i

    i i

    n X Y X Y

    n X X

    2.6 1C 2C

    N lni eqX M ln lniY T RH i iX Y 2

    iX

    1 1.8617 4.8242 8.9814 3.4661

    2 1.8339 4.8242 8.8471 3.3632

    3 2.0984 4.2035 8.8208 4.4034

    4 2.5607 3.8136 9.7655 6.5572

    5 2.5183 3.8136 9.6039 6.3420

    6 3.4727 2.7944 9.7040 12.0597

    7 3.4592 2.7944 9.6663 11.9662

    8 3.7114 2.4112 8.9491 13.7745

    9 3.7046 2.4112 8.9326 13.7240

    1

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 25.2211 1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 31.8903 1

    n

    i i

    i

    X Y

    = 83.2708 21

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 75.6564

  • - 10 -

    2C 2C =

    2

    83.2708 25.2211 31.8903

    75.6564 25. 1

    9

    9 221

    2C = 1.2246

    2C 1C

    1C = 31.8903 1.2246 25 1

    9

    .221

    1C = 6.9751

    1.2246 6.9751Y X

    2.2.2 2R

    1 31.8903 3.54349

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    model 1.2246 6.9751XY

    2.7 2R

    N X Y modelY 2

    modelY Y 2

    Y Y

    1 1.8617 4.8242 4.6952 0.0166 1.6405

    2 1.8339 4.8242 4.7293 0.0090 1.6405

    3 2.0984 4.2035 4.4054 0.0407 0.4358

    4 2.5607 3.8136 3.8393 0.0007 0.0730

    5 2.5183 3.8136 3.8911 0.0060 0.0730

    6 3.4727 2.7944 2.7224 0.0052 0.5610

    7 3.4592 2.7944 2.7389 0.0031 0.5610

    8 3.7114 2.4112 2.4301 0.0004 1.2817

    9 3.7046 2.4112 2.4385 0.0007 1.2817

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 31.8903 2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 0.0824 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 7.5483

  • - 11 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    0.0824

    7. 4 31

    5 81

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9891R X Y

    2R = 0.9891 1

    2.2.3 A B

    1CA Re 2B C

    8.3146.9751 8893.1465A e x

    1.2246B

    A B Halsey

    1.22468893.1ex46

    p5

    eqRH MRT

    1.2 6

    1

    24

    8893.1465

    lneq

    RT RHM

    y = -1.2246x + 6.9751

    R = 0.9891

    0.00

    1.00

    2.00

    3.00

    4.00

    5.00

    1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00

  • - 12 -

    Halsey 57

    RH 1% 90% Halsey

    2R Halsey

    1 191.7603 21. 0 79

    3 6

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    1.

    1

    mode

    2246

    l8893.1465

    lnRT XY

    2.8 2R Halsey

    N X =

    Y =

    modelY

    2

    modelY Y 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    1 11.2600 6.4349 5.7918 0.4137 221.1691

    2 11.2600 6.2583 5.7918 0.2177 226.4537

    3 30.9100 8.1533 9.6142 2.1342 173.0124

    4 45.1596 12.9450 13.2192 0.0752 69.9183

    5 45.1596 12.4080 13.2192 0.6580 79.1870

    6 75.0600 32.2240 30.3855 3.3799 119.1870

    7 75.0600 31.7922 30.3855 1.9788 109.9465

    8 82.2363 40.9113 41.5474 0.4046 384.3410

    9 82.2363 40.6332 41.5474 0.8356 373.5153

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 191.7603

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 10.0977

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 1756.7304

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    57 C

    Halsey

  • - 13 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    10.0977

    1756.731

    41

    0

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9943R

  • - 14 -

    2.3 65 C

    2.9 65 C

    (g)

    (g) RH (%) Meq (%db)

    1 LiCl 36.1200 33.9900 11.1000 6.2665

    2 LiCl 36.3100 34.3100 11.1000 5.8292

    3 MgCl2.6H2O 36.8100 34.0300 30.3500 8.1693

    4 MgCl2.6H2O 38.2600 35.4200 30.3500 8.0181

    5 Mg(NO3)2.6H2O 39.5600 35.7700 43.0456 10.5955

    6 Mg(NO3)2.6H2O 37.4600 33.7700 43.0456 10.9269

    7 NaCl 44.7700 33.8200 74.9000 32.3773

    8 NaCl 45.2900 34.1500 74.9000 32.6208

    9 KNO3 48.7300 34.4700 79.2103 41.3693

    10 KNO3 47.1200 33.3900 79.2103 41.1201

    2.3.1 1C 2C

    1C 1C = 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C X

    n

    2C 2C = 1 1 1 22

    1 1

    n n n

    i i i i

    i i i

    n n

    i i

    i i

    n X Y X Y

    n X X

    2.10 1C 2C

    N lni eqX M ln lniY T RH i iX Y 2

    iX

    1 1.8352 4.962038 9.1065 3.3681

    2 1.7629 4.962038 8.7475 3.1077

    3 2.1004 4.350333 9.1373 4.4116

    4 2.0817 4.350333 9.0561 4.3335

    5 2.3604 4.003492 9.4500 5.5716

    6 2.3912 4.003492 9.5732 5.7180

    7 3.4775 2.933115 10.1998 12.0927

    8 3.4849 2.933115 10.2218 12.1449

    9 3.7225 2.717944 10.1177 13.8573

    10 3.7165 2.717944 10.1012 13.8123

    1

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 26.9333 1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 37.9338 1

    n

    i i

    i

    X Y

    = 95.7110 21

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 78.4177

  • - 15 -

    2C 2C =

    2

    95.7110 26.9333 37.9338

    78.4177 26.9

    1

    10 3

    0

    33

    2C = 1.0986

    2C 1C

    1C = 37.9338 1.0986 26.

    10

    9333

    1C = 6.7524

    1.0986 6.7524Y X

    2.3.2 2R

    1 37.93381

    3.79340

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    model 1.0986 6.7524XY

    2.11 2R

    N X Y modelY 2

    modelY Y 2

    Y Y

    1 1.8352 4.9620 4.7361 0.0510 1.3657

    2 1.7629 4.9620 4.8156 0.0214 1.3657

    3 2.1004 4.3503 4.4448 0.0089 0.3102

    4 2.0817 4.3503 4.4653 0.0132 0.3102

    5 2.3604 4.0035 4.1591 0.0242 0.0441

    6 2.3912 4.0035 4.1253 0.0148 0.0441

    7 3.4775 2.9331 2.9319 0.0000 0.7401

    8 3.4849 2.9331 2.9237 0.0001 0.7401

    9 3.7225 2.7179 2.6626 0.0031 1.1566

    10 3.7165 2.7179 2.6693 0.0024 1.1566

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 37.9338 2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 0.1392 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 7.2334

  • - 16 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    0.1392

    7. 3 41

    2 31

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9808R X Y

    2R = 0.9808 1

    2.3.3 A B

    1CA Re 2B C

    8.3146.7524 7117.6105A e x

    1.0986B

    A B Halsey

    1.09867117.6ex10

    p5

    eqRH MRT

    1.0 6

    1

    98

    7117.6105

    lneq

    RT RHM

    y = -1.0986x + 6.7524

    R = 0.9808

    0.00

    1.00

    2.00

    3.00

    4.00

    5.00

    6.00

    1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00

  • - 17 -

    Halsey 65

    RH 1% 90% Halsey

    2R Halsey

    1 197.29291

    1 .72 30

    9 9

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    1.

    1

    mode

    0986

    l7117.6105

    lnRT XY

    2.12 2R

    N X =

    Y =

    modelY

    2

    modelY Y 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    1 11.1000 6.2665 5.1018 1.3565 181.2454

    2 11.1000 5.8292 5.1018 0.5291 193.2124

    3 30.3500 8.1693 8.9030 0.5383 133.6342

    4 30.3500 8.0181 8.9030 0.7830 137.1527

    5 43.0456 10.5955 12.2079 2.6000 83.4266

    6 43.0456 10.9269 12.2079 1.6411 77.4828

    7 74.9000 32.3773 32.3417 0.0013 159.9719

    8 74.9000 32.6208 32.3417 0.0779 166.1908

    9 79.2103 41.3693 39.3387 4.1233 468.2903

    10 79.2103 41.1201 39.3387 3.1733 457.5666

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    =

    197.2929

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 14.8238

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 2058.1738

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    65 C

    Halsey

  • - 18 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    14.8238

    2058.171

    81

    3

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9928R

  • - 19 -

    2.4 72 C

    2.13 72 C

    (g)

    (g) RH (%) Meq (%db)

    1 LiCl 22.18 21.21 11.1000 4.5733

    2 LiCl 28.67 27.51 11.1000 4.2166

    3 MgCl2.6H2O 29.34 26.51 30.3500 10.6752

    4 MgCl2.6H2O 26.77 24.46 30.3500 9.4440

    5 Mg(NO3)2.6H2O 24.89 22.44 43.0456 10.9180

    6 Mg(NO3)2.6H2O 27.32 24.76 43.0456 10.3393

    7 NaCl 31.15 21.15 74.9000 47.2813

    8 NaCl 27.58 18.76 74.9000 47.0149

    9 KNO3 30.34 20.46 79.2103 48.2893

    10 KNO3 29.06 19.05 79.2103 52.5459

    2.4.1 1C 2C

    1C 1C = 2

    1 1

    n n

    i i

    i i

    Y C X

    n

    2C 2C = 1 1 1 22

    1 1

    n n n

    i i i i

    i i i

    n n

    i i

    i i

    n X Y X Y

    n X X

    2.14 1C 2C

    N lni eqX M ln lniY T RH i iX Y 2

    iX

    1 1.5202 5.0643 7.6990 2.3111

    2 1.4390 5.0643 7.2878 2.0708

    3 2.3679 4.4526 10.5435 5.6071

    4 2.2454 4.4526 9.9978 5.0417

    5 2.3904 4.1058 9.8145 5.7141

    6 2.3359 4.1058 9.5909 5.4567

    7 3.8561 3.0354 11.7048 14.8696

    8 3.8505 3.0354 11.6877 14.8261

    9 3.8772 2.8202 10.9346 15.0328

    10 3.9617 2.8202 11.1728 15.6950

    1

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 27.8444 1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 38.9566 1

    n

    i i

    i

    X Y

    = 100.4333 21

    n

    i

    i

    X

    = 86.6249

  • - 20 -

    2C 2C =

    2

    100.4333 27.8444 38.9566

    86.6249 27.8

    10

    1 40 44

    2C = 0.8840

    2C 1C

    1C = 38.9566 0.8840 27.

    10

    8444

    1C = 6.3572

    0.8840 6.3572Y X

    2.4.2 2R

    1 38.95661

    3.89570

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    model 0.8840 6.3572XY

    2.15 2R

    N X Y modelY 2

    modelY Y 2

    Y Y

    1 1.5202 5.0643 5.0133 0.0026 1.3657

    2 1.4390 5.0643 5.0850 0.0004 1.3657

    3 2.3679 4.4526 4.2639 0.0356 0.3102

    4 2.2454 4.4526 4.3722 0.0065 0.3102

    5 2.3904 4.1058 4.2440 0.0191 0.0441

    6 2.3359 4.1058 4.2921 0.0347 0.0441

    7 3.8561 3.0354 2.9483 0.0076 0.7401

    8 3.8505 3.0354 2.9533 0.0067 0.7401

    9 3.8772 2.8202 2.9296 0.0120 1.1566

    10 3.9617 2.8202 2.8549 0.0012 1.1566

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    = 38.9566

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 0.1265

    2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 7.2334

  • - 21 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    0.1265

    7. 3 41

    2 31

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9825R X Y

    2R = 0.9808 1

    2.4.3 A B

    1CA Re 2B C

    8.3146.3572 4794.1793A e x

    0.8840B

    A B Halsey

    0.88404794.1ex79

    p3

    eqRH MRT

    0.8 0

    1

    84

    4794.1793

    lneq

    RT RHM

    y = -0.8840x + 6.3572

    R = 0.9825

    0.00

    1.00

    2.00

    3.00

    4.00

    5.00

    6.00

    1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50

  • - 22 -

    Halsey 72

    RH 1% 90% Halsey

    2R Halsey

    1 197.29291

    1 .72 30

    9 9

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    Yn

    1.

    1

    mode

    0986

    l7117.6105

    lnRT XY

    2.16 2R

    N X =

    Y =

    modelY

    2

    modelY Y 2

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    1 11.1000 4.5733 4.3167 0.0658 398.2611

    2 11.1000 4.2166 4.3167 0.0100 412.6239

    3 30.3500 10.6752 8.6230 4.2115 191.9494

    4 30.3500 9.4440 8.6230 0.6740 227.5815

    5 43.0456 10.9180 12.7659 3.4146 185.2809

    6 43.0456 10.3393 12.7659 5.8884 201.3714

    7 74.9000 47.2813 42.8436 19.6937 517.6320

    8 74.9000 47.0149 42.8436 17.4002 505.5811

    9 79.2103 48.2893 54.6501 40.4590 564.5162

    10 79.2103 52.5459 54.6501 4.4275 784.9039

    1

    n

    i

    i

    Y

    =

    245.2980

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 96.2445

    2

    model

    1

    n

    i

    Y Y

    = 3989.7014

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    72 C

    Halsey

  • - 23 -

    2R

    2

    model2 1

    2

    1

    96.2445

    3989.701

    41

    1

    n

    i

    n

    i

    Y Y

    R

    Y Y

    2 0.9759R

  • - 24 -

    3.

    50, 57, 65 72 C

    11.11% 84.99%

    Halsey 50, 57,

    65 72 C

    50 C R2 = 0.9775, 57 C R2 = 0.9943,

    65 C R2 = 0.9928 72 C R2 = 0.9759 1

    A, B R2 17

    17 A, B R2

    T ( C ) A B R2

    50 12282.6851 -1.3832 0.9775

    57 8893.1465 -1.2246 0.9943

    65 7117.6105 -1.0986 0.9928

    72 4794.1793 -0.8840 0.9759

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    50 C 57 C 65 C 72 C

  • - 25 -

    Halsey

    50, 57, 65 72 C ( 50 %)

    Halsey

    Halsey Halsey

    R2 (0.97-0.99)

    Halsey 50 C

    Halsey 57 C

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    50 C

    Halsey

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    57 C

    Halsey

    R2 = 0.9775

    R2 = 0.9943

  • - 26 -

    Halsey 65 C

    Halsey 72 C

    Halsey 50, 57, 65 72 C

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    65 C

    Halsey

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    72 C

    Halsey

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

    (%

    db)

    (%)

    Halsey T = 50 C

    Halsey T = 57 C

    Halsey T = 65 C

    Halsey T = 72 C

    R2 = 0.9928

    R2 = 0.9759