13
Barter How to use The ORCA Report to calculate the opportunity cost of barter and better manage the trade relationship between you and your 3 rd Party Marketing & Technology Partner

How ORCA helps a golf course manage 3rd parties

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • BarterHow to use The ORCA Report to calculate the opportunity cost of barter and better manage the trade relationship between you and your 3rd Party Marketing & Technology Partner

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    (Only) Eight Things

    Know your Channel Distribution

    Know where the barter is being booked

    Know the Opportunity Cost calculation

    Know where the GolfNow paid rounds are being booked

    Know the price differential between GolfNow and ARPR

    Know how many rounds are booked via Call Center

    Know which Rate Categories are using Call Center

    Dont be afraid to let them know you know

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    Channel Distribution Channel Distribution is tracked inside ORCA based on the

    reporting available from your electronic tee sheet and the way it is set up for your instance.

    The major channels:

    Golf Shop Rounds booked via the golf shop

    Call Center Rounds booked via your call center (if you use one)

    GC Website Rounds booked electronically from your website

    GC Mobile Rounds booked electronically from your mobile app

    3P Website Rounds booked electronically from 3rd Party

    3P Mobile Rounds booked electronically from 3rd Party mobile app

    3P Wholesale Rounds booked electronically from Wholesaler

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    -Rnds %Golf Shop 2,466 62%Call Center 659 17%Barter 382 10%GC Website 245 6%3P Website 173 4%3P Wholesale 53 1%GC Mobile 2 0%Grand Total 3,980 100%

    Your Golf Course

    Golf Shop 59% GC Website 15% 3P Website 8% Call Center 7% GolfNow Barter 2% GC Mobile 2% EZLinks Barter 1% Everything Else 6%

    ORCA Network Distribution

    How does your golf course compare to others on the ORCA Platform?

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    Barter

    GolfNow Barter RoundsMon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Grand Total

    10 AM 0.0% 0.6% 0.0% 0.6% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.2%11 AM 4.0% 4.0% 4.6% 1.9% 6.2% 4.6% 1.2% 26.5%12 PM 3.7% 4.6% 4.9% 4.3% 6.2% 7.1% 6.5% 37.3%

    1 PM 4.6% 4.9% 4.9% 3.7% 4.6% 6.5% 3.7% 33.0%2 PM 1.2% 0.0% 0.0% 0.6% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.9%

    Grand Total 13.6% 14.2% 14.5% 11.1% 17.0% 18.2% 11.4% 100.0%

    Be aware of where the barter rounds are being booked on your tee sheet. Are they according to your agreement?

    ORCA has caused courses to change the time of the barter round thus saving money by putting the barter round in an area of the tee sheet with less occupancy.

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    Barter Opportunity Cost-Est. Rev

    ORCA calculates the average rate for all paid rounds in each day/daypart where a barter round is sold and individually applies that rate to each barter round.

    %OCCORCA also individually calculates the occupancy % for each day and daypart where a barter round is sold.

    (Est. Rev * % OCC = Opportunity

    Cost)-Rnds -ARPR -Est. Rev % OCC Opportunity Cost

    Barter-EZCC 3 $81.16 $243 19.6% $48Barter-EZWS 55 $99.88 $5,493 36.9% $2,027Barter-GN 319 $90.67 $28,924 27.6% $7,983

    377 $91.94 $34,661 $10,058

    CURRENT MONTH BARTER OPPY. COST

    Opportunity CostEstimated revenue multiplied by %OCC = Opportunity Cost

    Table of Contents

    The ORCA Report

    Scottsdale, Arizona

    @theORCAReport

    [email protected]

    www.orcareport.com

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course Monthly ORCA Report

    For the month of: April 2016

    The Competitive Set Includes Subject Property

    Table Of ContentsPAGE

    Report #1 Monthly Performance Detail1LEVEL ILEVEL IILEVEL IIISNAPSHOTS

    Report #2 CompSet and Industry Summary Segments Detail2

    Report #3 18 Month Historical Report3

    Report #4 Day of the Week Report4

    Report #5 Monthly by Day Report5

    Report #6 Response Tab6

    Dashboard #1 Distribution7

    Dashboard #2 Heat Maps8

    Dashboard #3 Additional Revenue Opportunity9

    Report #7 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM10

    Report #8 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Mon11

    Report #9 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Tue12

    Report #10 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Wed13

    Report #11 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Thr14

    Report #12 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Fri15

    Report #13 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Sat16

    Report #14 Rate Group Analysis by DayPart-CM-Sun17

    SNAPSHOT - Current Month Performance18

    SNAPSHOT - Comp Set + Industry Segments19

    SNAPSHOT - Day of the Week20

    SNAPSHOT - 18 Months21

    SNAPSHOT - Daily for the Month22

    SNAPSHOT - DayPart Segmentation23

    Help24

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Snapshot

    Report #1 - Monthly Performance Snapshot - My Course vs. Competitive Set

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    April 2016

    Occupancy (%)RevPAR ($)Channel Mix (%)ARPR ($)

    My CourseComp SetIndex (OCCI)My CourseComp SetIndex (PARI)My CourseComp SetIndex (CHMI)My CourseComp SetIndex (ARRI)

    Current Month55.363.786.839.4047.0383.884.790.593.671.1873.8296.5

    Year To Date79.382.696.066.8267.4099.187.292.594.384.3181.62103.3

    Running 3 Month76.182.292.666.9268.2698.087.392.494.587.9483.06105.8

    Running 12 Month60.053.3112.638.5436.28106.186.491.394.664.1968.0594.3

    April 2016vs. 2015 Percent Change (%)

    OccupancyRevPARChannel MixARPR

    My CourseComp SetIndex (OCCI)My CourseComp SetIndex (PARI)My CourseComp SetIndex (CHMI)My CourseComp SetIndex (ARRI)

    Current Month-18.1-5.186.3-9.00.690.5-3.0-4.2101.310.96.2104.4

    Year To Date-2.2-2.199.98.8-2.5111.6-1.9-2.0100.111.4-0.4111.8

    Running 3 Month-5.3-1.496.08.6-0.7109.4-1.8-2.0100.214.80.8113.9

    Running 12 Month2.21.5100.711.3-1.1112.5-1.3-0.799.49.0-2.6111.9

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    ORCASummary

    Report #2 - ORCA Summary - My Course vs. Comp Set and Industry Segments

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Supply

    Current Month% ChgYear to Date% ChgRunning 3 Month% ChgRunning 12 Month% ChgMonth % ChgYTD % ChgRun 3 Mon % ChgRun 12 Mon % Chg

    courseMarriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course55.3-18.179.3-2.276.1-5.360.02.2

    DMADMA: Palm Springs CA54.10.074.1-3.673.9-1.647.7-0.8

    FTFacility Type: Resort53.63.370.9-4.471.8-1.847.6-0.2

    SMSubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)56.3-3.977.0-2.076.9-1.250.6-1.7

    MTFacility Management Type: Mgmt Co54.10.074.1-3.673.9-1.647.7-0.8

    CompCompetitive Set: Competitors63.7-5.182.6-2.182.2-1.453.31.5

    REVPaR ($)Demand

    Current Month% ChgYear to Date% ChgRunning 3 Month% ChgRunning 12 Month% ChgMonth % ChgYTD % ChgRun 3 Mon % ChgRun 12 Mon % Chg

    courseMarriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course39.40-9.066.828.866.928.638.5411.3

    DMADMA: Palm Springs CA35.836.553.04-0.254.052.328.210.0

    FTFacility Type: Resort37.358.155.232.057.195.129.802.8

    SMSubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)42.161.062.35-0.363.411.333.89-1.7

    MTFacility Management Type: Mgmt Co35.836.553.04-0.254.052.328.210.0

    CompCompetitive Set: Competitors47.030.667.40-2.568.26-0.736.28-1.1

    Channel Mix (%)Revenue

    Current Month% ChgYear to Date% ChgRunning 3 Month% ChgRunning 12 Month% ChgMonth % ChgYTD % ChgRun 3 Mon % ChgRun 12 Mon % Chg

    courseMarriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course84.7-3.087.20-1.987.30-1.886.40-1.3

    DMADMA: Palm Springs CA85.9-2.986.2-1.385.7-1.586.5-0.5

    FTFacility Type: Resort84.6-2.283.2-1.282.5-1.784.4-0.5

    SMSubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)86.9-3.087.2-0.586.6-0.887.1-0.2

    MTFacility Management Type: Mgmt Co85.9-2.986.2-1.385.7-1.586.5-0.5

    CompCompetitive Set: Competitors90.5-4.292.5-2.092.4-2.091.3-0.7

    ARPR ($)Census

    Current Month% ChgYear to Date% ChgRunning 3 Month% ChgRunning 12 Month% ChgDMA: Palm Springs CA

    CensusSample

    courseMarriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course71.1810.984.3111.487.9414.864.199.0PropertiesHolesPropertiesHoles

    DMADMA: Palm Springs CA66.236.671.553.673.184.359.180.95687317306

    FTFacility Type: Resort69.754.777.897.079.617.062.622.8314419162162

    SMSubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)74.874.980.971.882.492.567.010.08144

    MTFacility Management Type: Mgmt Co66.236.671.553.673.184.359.180.917306306

    CompCompetitive Set: Competitors73.826.281.62-0.483.060.868.05-2.67126

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    18MoComp

    Report #3 - ORCA Summary - 18 Months Historical

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)201420152016Year To DateRunning 3 MonthRunning 12 Month

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr201420152016201420152016201420152016

    My Course88.583.783.794.783.567.560.347.039.533.355.514.594.292.491.497.581.655.382.381.179.378.680.476.142.358.760.0

    Competitive Set77.369.888.199.688.767.150.134.023.921.937.633.877.269.484.1100.487.863.785.984.482.683.983.482.246.152.553.3

    Index (OCCI)114.5119.995.095.194.1100.6120.4138.2165.3152.1147.642.9122.0133.1108.797.192.986.895.896.196.093.796.492.691.8111.8112.6

    Rank4 of 73 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 75 of 71 of 71 of 71 of 72 of 71 of 76 of 74 of 71 of 73 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 74 of 74 of 7

    % Chg

    My Course-12.1-0.9-12.84.0-1.65.58.5-6.730.81.2-1.8-9.46.410.49.23.0-2.3-18.1-1.5-2.22.3-5.338.82.2

    Competitive Set-0.6-5.3-5.83.6-3.6-1.38.28.632.82.85.6-6.9-0.1-0.6-4.50.8-1.0-5.15.9-1.7-2.13.7-0.6-1.487.413.91.5

    Index (OCCI)88.4104.692.6100.4102.1106.9100.385.998.598.493.097.3106.5111.1114.3102.298.786.3100.299.9102.996.0121.9100.7

    Rank5 of 73 of 77 of 74 of 73 of 72 of 72 of 76 of 74 of 75 of 74 of 74 of 73 of 73 of 71 of 72 of 74 of 77 of 76 of 75 of 75 of 74 of 71 of 76 of 77 of 71 of 73 of 7

    RevPAR ($)201420152016Year To DateRunning 3 MonthRunning 12 Month

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr201420152016201420152016201420152016

    My Course72.0854.3760.6777.4569.2943.2923.1119.7614.7813.6820.2911.5275.8357.5966.4693.2575.9739.4061.761.466.861.961.666.929.034.638.5

    Competitive Set61.2649.6470.5588.7577.5646.6627.5514.728.578.1316.5424.4458.1446.0464.1091.6372.7747.0368.969.267.469.268.868.333.436.736.3

    Index (PARI)117.6109.786.087.389.392.783.7134.7172.1169.1123.047.1130.5125.2103.7101.9104.483.889.688.799.189.589.598.086.894.3106.1

    Rank3 of 74 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 72 of 71 of 72 of 74 of 76 of 73 of 73 of 75 of 76 of 75 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 75 of 76 of 7

    % Chg

    My Course-8.52.4-0.50.90.4-3.8-8.716.574.157.510.3109.15.15.99.620.49.7-9.0-0.58.8-0.58.619.311.3

    Competitive Set1.2-0.64.14.2-1.0-5.84.211.430.35.23.8-8.3-5.2-7.3-9.23.3-6.20.62.10.3-2.51.0-0.6-0.763.79.9-1.1

    Index (PARI)90.4103.095.696.8101.4102.187.6104.6133.6149.7106.3228.0110.9114.2120.7116.6117.090.599.2111.6100.1109.4108.6112.5

    Rank5 of 74 of 76 of 76 of 74 of 74 of 74 of 73 of 72 of 72 of 73 of 73 of 73 of 72 of 71 of 71 of 71 of 77 of 76 of 75 of 71 of 74 of 74 of 71 of 77 of 72 of 72 of 7

    Channel Mix (%)201420152016Year To DateRunning 3 MonthRunning 12 Month

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr201420152016201420152016201420152016

    My Course88.288.288.689.789.787.385.787.582.981.585.482.989.786.586.987.389.284.787.288.987.286.688.987.387.887.586.4

    Competitive Set92.193.394.793.894.594.593.290.785.086.387.190.791.691.893.193.193.290.589.794.492.589.694.392.488.291.991.3

    Index (CHAI)95.894.593.695.694.992.492.096.597.594.498.091.497.994.293.393.895.793.697.294.294.396.794.394.599.595.294.6

    Rank6 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 75 of 75 of 76 of 76 of 75 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 77 of 76 of 74 of 76 of 76 of 7

    % Chg

    My Course-1.5-1.7-0.41.82.04.33.5-0.5-3.9-4.7-1.4-4.11.7-1.9-1.9-2.7-0.6-3.01.9-1.92.7-1.8-0.3-1.3

    Competitive Set5.46.15.05.04.36.75.31.91.02.1-0.6-0.5-0.5-1.6-1.7-0.7-1.4-4.23.25.2-2.03.15.2-2.01.54.2-0.7

    Index (CHAI)93.592.694.997.097.897.898.397.695.193.399.296.4102.299.799.898.0100.8101.396.9100.197.6100.295.799.4

    Rank7 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 74 of 75 of 76 of 75 of 75 of 75 of 74 of 72 of 74 of 76 of 76 of 74 of 74 of 76 of 76 of 75 of 74 of 76 of 74 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 7

    ARPR ($)201420152016Year To DateRunning 3 MonthRunning 12 Month

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr201320142015201320142015201420152016

    My Course81.4065.0072.5081.7583.0264.1538.3442.0537.4141.0736.5579.4480.4962.2972.7195.6193.0571.1875.175.784.378.876.687.968.658.964.2

    Competitive Set79.2771.1580.0789.1087.4269.5054.9343.3535.9137.1244.0372.3075.3366.3976.2491.2482.8873.8280.281.981.682.482.583.172.470.068.1

    Index (ARRI)102.691.390.591.895.092.469.897.0104.2110.883.2109.8106.993.895.4104.8112.396.593.692.4103.395.692.8105.894.884.194.3

    Rank4 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 77 of 76 of 74 of 71 of 77 of 71 of 72 of 77 of 77 of 72 of 71 of 76 of 75 of 75 of 73 of 75 of 75 of 71 of 76 of 77 of 76 of 7

    % Chg

    My Course4.03.514.2-3.12.1-8.7-15.624.632.256.311.9130.1-1.1-4.20.317.012.010.90.811.4-2.814.8-14.19.0

    Competitive Set1.85.310.50.72.6-4.7-3.52.6-1.62.2-1.6-1.2-5.0-6.7-4.92.4-5.16.2-3.62.1-0.4-2.60.00.8-13.0-3.5-2.6

    Index (ARRI)102.298.3103.396.299.595.887.5121.4134.3152.9113.7232.9104.1102.7105.5114.3118.0104.498.7111.897.2113.989.0111.9

    Rank2 of 74 of 73 of 77 of 75 of 76 of 77 of 72 of 72 of 72 of 72 of 71 of 74 of 73 of 73 of 71 of 71 of 72 of 76 of 77 of 71 of 74 of 77 of 71 of 77 of 77 of 71 of 7

    Index (RGI)100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100The ORCA Report

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.

    100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100

    Year to Date

    Running 3 Month

    Running 12 Month

    Day of Week

    Report #4 - Day of Week and Weekday/Weekend Report

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    FridaySaturdayWeekdayWeekend

    Occupancy (%)RevPAR ($)Channel Mix (%)ARPR ($)65.56463.264.3

    My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (MPI)My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (ARI)My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (RGI)My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (RGI)39.0942.6337.2641.84

    Day of WeekTime Period% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg49.3250.6645.3548.97

    MondayCurrent Month57.2-4.063.7-2.089.898.038.27-2.846.066.583.191.382.1-7.888.9-5.192.497.266.891.272.298.692.593.2

    Year To Date79.00.080.4-4.498.3104.667.437.763.16-4.4106.6112.789.8-0.192.5-1.997.1101.885.377.778.53-0.1108.8107.8

    Running 3 Month75.1-6.678.9-6.095.299.466.253.363.38-5.2104.6109.090.5-0.492.2-2.198.2101.788.1910.480.320.8109.8109.5

    Running 12 Month55.2-2.649.2-1.0112.298.436.032.932.17-3.9111.8107.187.6-0.591.4-0.995.8100.465.245.765.42-3.099.7109.0

    TuesdayCurrent Month51.0-25.964.3-2.979.376.336.59-21.548.3410.075.871.481.8-4.791.0-2.589.997.771.695.975.1613.495.393.4

    Year To Date76.2-6.581.1-4.894.098.262.075.465.22-3.195.2108.886.4-3.092.7-1.793.298.781.4712.980.471.9101.2110.8

    Running 3 Month75.9-4.983.2-1.291.296.364.7811.168.251.594.9109.586.8-2.492.8-1.593.599.185.3316.782.022.8104.0113.5

    Running 12 Month55.90.548.4-0.6115.5101.135.099.732.88-2.1106.7112.185.9-2.291.5-0.593.998.362.769.267.96-1.492.4110.8

    WednesdayCurrent Month54.5-22.560.9-11.689.587.736.51-20.041.23-11.888.690.784.5-2.090.5-3.993.4102.067.033.467.65-0.399.0103.7

    Year To Date79.2-5.682.8-3.495.797.764.457.364.26-4.5100.3112.487.5-2.292.7-1.894.499.681.3813.777.59-1.3104.9115.2

    Running 3 Month76.0-9.782.8-3.491.893.563.803.265.40-4.797.6108.387.1-2.192.6-1.694.199.583.9614.478.99-1.4106.3116.0

    Running 12 Month57.14.250.32.4113.5101.837.7318.233.42-0.6112.9118.986.9-1.191.6-0.594.999.466.0213.466.49-2.899.2116.7

    ThursdayCurrent Month55.0-20.463.7-6.386.385.037.68-11.145.77-2.882.391.582.9-3.689.7-5.392.4101.868.5411.671.863.995.3107.4

    Year To Date81.4-3.484.7-1.396.197.966.968.468.26-2.698.1111.387.3-1.892.6-1.994.3100.182.3012.380.59-1.5102.1114.0

    Running 3 Month77.8-7.684.6-0.592.092.965.605.869.22-0.794.8106.587.2-1.792.3-2.194.5100.484.3514.781.79-0.2103.2114.9

    Running 12 Month57.51.152.02.6110.698.538.6516.335.76-0.8108.1117.285.8-1.091.1-0.994.299.967.1615.168.82-3.597.7119.3

    FridayCurrent Month55.1-22.365.5-10.684.186.939.09-16.349.32-8.079.391.084.7-6.590.7-5.393.498.770.897.875.293.094.2104.7

    Year To Date84.6-5.187.2-4.197.099.074.766.773.45-5.5101.8112.987.2-2.192.1-2.294.7100.188.3412.384.25-1.6104.7114.1

    Running 3 Month79.8-9.185.7-4.893.195.574.215.474.12-4.6100.1110.587.2-1.791.8-2.995.0101.292.9716.086.450.1107.5115.9

    Running 12 Month63.71.457.2-0.5111.4101.941.377.840.01-3.8103.5112.186.8-0.791.0-1.095.4100.364.986.069.90-3.393.0109.6

    SaturdayCurrent Month56.2-26.264.0-6.787.879.142.63-13.850.660.284.086.087.10.691.2-3.495.5104.175.8617.179.127.296.0109.2

    Year To Date79.3-2.783.7-1.994.799.270.094.873.43-3.295.5108.384.8-3.592.3-2.191.998.688.357.887.74-1.3100.8109.2

    Running 3 Month75.0-6.481.2-2.292.495.769.725.172.37-1.196.3106.384.7-3.492.3-1.991.898.592.9912.389.111.0104.4111.2

    Running 12 Month69.34.461.92.5112.0101.944.8714.043.730.0102.7114.086.6-2.391.2-0.195.097.864.709.170.66-2.291.5111.6

    SundayCurrent Month58.33.663.36.792.197.144.3035.546.3911.895.5121.289.01.091.0-4.597.8105.876.0530.873.334.9103.8124.7

    Year To Date74.89.777.75.396.3104.261.3123.863.256.096.8116.887.60.392.8-2.094.4102.381.9912.981.360.7100.7112.1

    Running 3 Month72.89.078.58.392.7100.663.7330.564.679.598.5119.287.7-0.592.7-2.094.6101.587.5019.782.431.1106.2118.4

    Running 12 Month61.15.754.05.1113.1100.635.7911.935.752.3100.0109.485.3-0.791.4-0.493.399.758.605.866.17-2.888.5108.8

    Weekday/Weekend

    WeekdayCurrent Month54.4-19.263.2-6.086.186.037.26-14.345.35-0.282.285.982.8-4.490.0-4.392.099.968.475.971.796.295.499.7

    (Mon-Thu)Year To Date78.9-4.082.3-3.495.999.465.237.265.23-3.7100.0111.387.8-1.792.7-1.894.7100.182.6311.679.30-0.3104.2111.9

    Running 3 Month76.2-7.382.4-2.792.595.365.115.766.57-2.297.7108.187.9-1.792.5-1.895.0100.185.4414.080.790.5105.7113.4

    Running 12 Month56.50.949.90.8113.2100.136.8811.833.56-1.8109.8113.886.5-1.391.4-0.894.699.565.3110.767.19-2.797.2113.8

    WeekendCurrent Month56.4-16.864.3-4.087.786.741.84-2.648.971.085.396.486.8-1.891.0-4.495.4102.774.1817.276.115.197.5111.5

    (Fri-Sun)Year To Date79.70.183.0-0.496.0100.568.8811.070.19-1.398.1112.586.5-1.992.4-2.193.6100.286.4510.684.59-0.8102.2111.5

    Running 3 Month76.0-2.481.90.492.897.269.3712.870.551.198.3111.686.5-1.992.2-2.393.8100.491.3315.686.150.7105.9114.8

    Running 12 Month64.73.957.72.3112.1101.640.7211.239.86-0.5102.0111.886.2-1.491.2-0.494.599.062.907.269.03-2.891.2110.3

    TotalCurrent Month55.3-18.163.7-5.186.886.339.40-9.047.030.683.890.584.70-3.090.50-4.293.6101.371.1810.973.826.296.5104.4

    Year To Date79.3-2.282.6-2.196.099.966.828.867.40-2.599.1111.687.20-1.992.50-2.094.3100.184.3111.481.62-0.4103.3111.8

    Running 3 Month76.1-5.382.2-1.492.696.066.928.668.26-0.798.0109.487.30-1.892.40-2.094.5100.287.9414.883.060.8105.8113.9

    Running 12 Month60.02.253.31.5112.6100.738.5411.336.28-1.1106.1112.586.40-1.391.30-0.794.699.464.199.068.05-2.694.3111.9

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Daily by Month

    Report #5 - Daily Data for the Month

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    d1d2d3d4d5d6d7d8d9d10d11d12d13d14d15d16d17d18d19d20d21d22d23d24d25d26d27d28d29d30d31

    FriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSat--

    Occupancy (%)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    courseMy Course85.087.789.990.857.871.084.164.475.261.763.162.454.949.635.633.333.246.346.149.643.341.243.750.231.338.843.644.652.044.3--

    compCompetitive Set95.091.980.088.677.374.379.881.986.663.071.973.065.867.255.348.459.064.558.359.361.655.748.152.232.350.045.747.555.248.5--

    courseIndex (MPI)89.595.4112.4102.574.895.6105.478.686.897.987.885.583.473.864.468.856.371.879.183.670.374.090.996.296.977.695.493.994.291.3--

    % Chg

    courseMy Course11.4-0.668.745.0-31.5-14.324.8-0.224.582.039.94.5-10.7-23.6-40.3-46.3-35.2-16.7-27.4-27.7-43.9-50.4-53.5-41.0-57.9-43.3-18.4-26.5-36.7-45.1--

    compCompetitive Set12.813.341.612.4-4.8-4.53.936.733.819.315.015.7-3.5-6.7-19.2-18.4-3.92.2-10.2-12.7-2.7-30.9-31.1-21.0-42.8-11.8-18.7-17.1-23.3-31.3--

    courseIndex (MPI)98.887.7119.1129.072.089.7120.173.093.0152.6121.790.392.581.973.965.867.481.580.882.857.771.867.574.773.664.3100.488.782.579.9--

    RevPAR ($)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    courseMy Course67.0580.1673.7267.8340.3351.8265.1549.3162.6550.5145.2348.3237.7637.3024.9521.4122.7327.2033.9432.8529.1826.7130.8832.2915.2624.6224.7520.9330.0222.06--

    compCompetitive Set80.9480.7567.3669.9866.2352.2863.3966.8674.0449.0153.0455.5142.6048.2437.9633.4335.4541.4041.5441.3944.4636.3232.9235.2221.9831.6829.5528.4238.5135.71--

    courseIndex (ARI)82.999.3109.396.960.999.0102.873.784.7103.185.387.088.777.465.864.163.965.781.779.565.673.693.991.869.577.683.873.677.961.9--

    % Chg

    courseMy Course7.0-8.6134.037.0-46.3-12.641.23.448.394.219.60.0-25.0-30.7-47.8-55.5-42.7-27.9-15.0-2.1-4.9-11.339.8-3.6-53.8-2.424.6-11.122.4-48.6--

    compCompetitive Set22.618.264.828.917.83.221.254.558.530.020.525.3-11.6-4.4-24.3-22.0-14.9-4.6-7.8-6.56.5-34.1-27.9-22.8-31.92.3-10.3-17.9-17.0-25.6--

    courseIndex (ARI)87.377.3142.0106.345.684.7116.566.993.6149.499.379.884.872.569.057.167.375.692.2104.789.3134.6193.9124.967.895.4138.9108.3147.569.1--

    Channel Mix (%)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    courseMy Course88.589.491.289.988.090.286.288.792.093.888.684.583.183.976.576.380.074.169.681.078.375.287.085.560.383.581.780.487.083.0--

    compCompetitive Set92.594.591.792.294.989.790.891.292.492.288.387.190.689.789.792.992.388.090.592.590.488.689.987.583.891.789.186.890.783.4--

    courseIndex (RGI)95.794.699.597.592.7100.694.997.399.6101.7100.397.091.793.585.382.186.784.276.987.686.684.996.897.772.091.191.792.695.999.5--

    % Chg

    courseMy Course-5.51.55.90.3-4.70.73.40.70.54.22.02.5-2.2-2.2-15.8-4.6-11.4-16.6-10.1-5.5-12.5-16.30.3-2.1-32.9-6.12.30.0-1.1-4.9--

    compCompetitive Set-5.2-1.3-2.9-1.3-0.2-4.7-4.0-3.2-4.8-2.7-5.8-5.0-5.1-5.5-4.70.9-4.9-7.9-2.8-2.2-5.0-8.3-2.6-7.7-9.1-1.2-3.7-6.4-3.4-8.8--

    courseIndex (RGI)99.7102.8109.1101.695.5105.7107.7104.0105.6107.1108.3107.9103.1103.588.494.593.290.692.596.692.191.3103.0106.173.895.0106.2106.8102.4104.3--

    ARPR ($)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    courseMy Course78.9291.4481.9974.6869.7572.9977.5176.6083.2981.8771.6477.3868.8475.2470.1464.2468.4758.7873.6366.2467.4564.8070.6264.3148.7063.4556.7746.9157.7649.83--

    compCompetitive Set85.2287.8884.1879.0085.6570.3979.4381.6985.4677.8173.7576.0464.7971.8268.5769.0860.0464.1671.3169.7872.1465.1568.4267.5168.0663.3664.7259.8169.7473.63--

    courseIndex (RGI)92.6104.097.494.681.4103.797.693.897.4105.397.0101.8106.2104.7102.292.9114.291.6103.294.893.699.4103.295.371.5100.287.878.482.967.7--

    % Chg

    courseMy Course-3.8-8.038.7-5.6-21.71.813.33.519.26.9-14.6-4.4-16.1-9.4-12.4-17.3-11.4-13.317.435.469.378.5200.463.29.472.652.321.294.0-6.6--

    compCompetitive Set8.74.416.514.523.78.116.613.018.39.15.08.3-8.22.4-6.5-4.3-11.5-6.72.96.99.1-4.54.7-2.219.115.910.2-1.28.18.2--

    courseIndex (RGI)88.588.1119.182.463.394.297.291.6100.898.081.388.391.488.593.786.4100.192.9114.1126.7155.2186.9286.9166.991.9148.9138.2122.7179.586.3--

    Index 100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Response

    Report #6 - Response Report

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # ChainID: MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    This Year

    Easter Sunday March 27

    Last Year

    Easter April 5

    NameAddressOpendateStateHolesOpen DateCourseIDRPH

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course9002 Shadow Ridge RdPalm DesertCA1820007428

    Desert Willow Golf Resort - Mountain View38995 Desert Willow DrPalm DesertCA1819975124

    Desert Willow Golf Resort - Firecliff38995 Desert Willow DrPalm DesertCA1819975224

    Indian Wells Golf Resort - Celebrity Course44500 Indian Wells LaneIndian WellsCA1819867624

    Indian Wells Golf Resort - Players Course44500 Indian Wells LaneIndian WellsCA1819867724

    SilverRock Resort79-179 Ahmanson LnLaQuintaCA1820058228

    Classic Club75200 Classic Club Blvd.Palm DesertCA1820069428

    ----------------

    ----------------

    ----------------

    ----------------

    ----------------

    ----------------

    ----------------

    The ORCA Report

    Distribution

    Dashboard #1 - Distribution Dashboard

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    -Rnds%--ARPR

    Golf Shop2,46662%$71.90

    Call Center65917%$92.23

    Barter38210%$0.00

    GC Website2456%$96.64

    3P Website1734%$100.78

    3P Wholesale531%$73.62

    GC Mobile20%$89.00

    Grand Total3,980100%$74.88

    CURRENT MONTH BARTER OPPY. COST

    (Est. Rev * % OCC = Opportunity Cost)

    -Rnds-ARPR-Est. Rev% OCCOpportunity Cost

    Barter-EZCC3$81.16$24319.6%$48

    Barter-EZWS55$99.88$5,49336.9%$2,027

    Barter-GN319$90.67$28,92427.6%$7,983

    377$91.94$34,661$10,058

    BARTER RNDS W/O OPPY. COST5

    -Rnds%--ARPR

    Golf Shop27,32558%$64.47

    Call Center10,94323%$72.18

    Barter3,4407%$0.00

    3P Website2,6506%$88.05

    GC Website2,5425%$85.23

    3P Wholesale3331%$91.45

    GC Mobile260%$55.87

    Grand Total47,259100%$65.32

    TRAILING 12 MONTH BARTER OPPY. COST

    -Rnds-ARPR-Est. Rev% OCC

    Barter-EZCC76$94.20$ 7,15984.5%

    Barter-EZWS1,115$87.98$ 98,09776.9%

    ----------

    Barter-GN2,177$82.40$ 179,39499.2%

    3,368$ 284,650

    BARTER RNDS W/O OPPY. COST72

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Heat Maps

    Dashboard #2 - Heat Maps

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    GolfNow Barter Distribution CMGolfNow Course Rounds Distribution CM

    PORPOR

    MonTueWedThrFriSatSunMonTueWedThrFriSatSun

    60.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%60.0%0.0%0.0%1.4%0.0%1.4%0.0%

    70.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%72.9%1.4%0.0%0.0%3.6%1.4%2.2%

    80.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%82.9%0.0%0.0%2.2%4.3%5.8%2.9%

    90.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%91.4%0.0%0.0%0.0%4.3%2.9%0.0%

    100.0%0.6%0.0%0.6%0.0%0.0%0.0%100.0%4.3%0.0%6.5%5.0%1.4%0.0%

    114.0%4.0%4.6%1.9%6.2%4.6%1.2%110.0%2.2%0.0%0.0%1.4%0.0%0.0%

    123.7%4.6%4.9%4.3%6.2%7.1%6.5%120.0%0.0%2.9%0.0%4.3%0.0%0.0%

    134.6%4.9%4.9%3.7%4.6%6.5%3.7%132.9%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%2.9%0.0%

    141.2%0.0%0.0%0.6%0.0%0.0%0.0%148.6%2.9%5.0%2.9%0.0%0.0%0.0%

    150.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%150.0%0.0%0.0%1.4%0.0%0.0%0.0%

    160.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%160.0%0.0%2.9%0.0%1.4%0.0%0.0%

    170.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%170.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%

    180.0%0.0%0.0%180.0%0.0%0.0%

    GolfNow Barter Distribution lst12mGolfNow Course Rounds Distribution lst12m

    PORPOR

    MonTueWedThrFriSatSunMonTueWedThrFriSatSun

    50.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%50.1%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%

    61.1%0.7%1.4%1.1%0.8%0.1%0.4%60.6%0.7%1.1%0.8%2.5%1.5%1.8%

    70.0%0.3%0.2%0.3%0.4%0.0%0.1%71.1%1.0%0.5%1.2%1.8%2.5%2.7%

    80.0%0.3%0.0%0.0%0.1%0.0%0.0%81.0%1.4%1.3%1.0%1.9%1.9%2.0%

    90.1%0.2%0.0%0.0%0.2%0.1%0.0%91.5%1.2%1.1%1.1%2.1%2.3%2.9%

    100.1%0.4%0.1%0.2%0.3%0.1%0.0%101.3%1.6%1.8%1.3%2.3%2.6%1.4%

    113.0%2.1%2.7%3.3%2.5%3.7%2.1%110.4%0.6%0.7%0.5%1.0%1.5%1.7%

    124.4%5.3%6.7%5.3%5.5%6.3%7.0%121.9%1.8%2.0%2.9%3.0%2.4%2.6%

    135.0%4.2%2.9%4.1%3.6%3.6%3.5%131.4%1.7%0.8%1.3%1.1%3.0%0.5%

    140.7%0.8%0.6%0.3%0.5%0.4%0.1%140.7%0.9%1.2%0.8%1.4%1.9%1.1%

    150.1%0.0%0.2%0.0%0.0%0.1%0.0%150.0%0.5%0.2%0.2%0.5%0.3%0.3%

    160.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.1%0.0%160.1%0.3%0.2%0.4%0.5%0.3%0.3%

    170.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%170.0%0.1%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.3%0.0%

    180.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%180.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%0.0%

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    AdditionalRevenueDash

    Dashboard #3 -Additional Revenue Opportunity vs. Competitive Set Leader

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    ZipCode Dash

    Report 2 - Monthly Performance Snapshot - My Course vs. Competitive Set

    ERROR:#REF!

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the Month of: October 2015 Date Created: November 11, 2015 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    -Rnds

    852621,091

    85255969

    85254301

    85266262

    85260246

    85331244

    85259215

    85258173

    85251151

    85050151

    85054117

    85253115

    8501690

    8502880

    8508675

    8524874

    8526873

    8524971

    8525069

    8520766

    8501865

    8502464

    8537762

    8508557

    8538355

    (blank)

    DayPart-CM

    Report #7 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month -ALL DAYS

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM44.553.183.833.626.3127.81.25.920.344.817.7253.19.137.824.11.89.119.89.52.9327.6--0.3--

    8-10:00AM56.079.570.440.331.3128.8--7.3--29.517.2171.59.422.242.312.619.764.07.31.9384.20.90.4225.0

    10-12:00PM48.961.379.822.528.878.1--5.9--49.020.5239.01.226.54.516.111.0146.44.82.5192.06.54.8135.4

    12-2:00PM41.346.688.615.136.441.50.13.33.063.123.1273.21.724.27.09.27.9116.55.83.5165.74.91.7288.2

    2-4:00pm94.479.5118.735.044.179.4--1.8--51.428.7179.12.710.725.20.31.618.810.713.181.7--0.1--

    4-Close------4.722.321.1--0.1--94.456.5167.1--15.8--------0.95.317.0------

    Total55.363.786.828.232.088.10.25.23.849.221.4229.94.724.719.08.311.373.57.03.9179.52.41.5160.0

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-39.0-12.883.8-22.75.3127.8-4.820.31.1-28.7253.122.010.424.122.020.219.8184.654.5327.6---4.3--

    8-10:00AM-3.80.470.47.615.7128.8--5.4---28.3-23.9171.536.5-12.842.327.531.964.066.824.2384.2315.7-73.7225.0

    10-12:00PM-5.8-3.979.8-30.810.078.1--14.3---5.5-14.2239.018.0-12.74.51302.017.8146.4-10.05.8192.0-20.778.7135.4

    12-2:00PM-12.9-2.388.6-67.232.441.5-23.13.045.0-10.7273.2-60.6-4.67.0-35.3116.5-2.3-17.5165.7158.8288.2

    2-4:00pm-17.8-6.3118.7-20.84.879.4--10.6--3.8-9.0179.1127.016.325.2-2.918.8106.5-6.181.7--110.9--

    4-Close-------79.9-0.821.1---85.1--43.525.8167.1---18.9---------91.9-55.217.0------

    Total-18.0-5.186.8-28.313.788.11.83.84.0-16.6229.913.1-5.319.0225.114.973.536.7-3.6179.558.230.1160.0

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM83.7174.27112.7116.49107.45108.429.0080.4736.093.0193.6999.33.3346.027.2125.6779.27158.50.001.730.0--0.00--

    8-10:00AM90.7686.84104.5115.45112.31102.8--87.59--99.0197.68101.46.2548.1013.0114.1390.28126.40.002.750.00.000.00

    10-12:00PM75.1976.4898.3107.85101.56106.2--76.37--73.3986.7784.65.0049.9310.092.62105.7987.60.001.540.00.000.00

    12-2:00PM51.4369.4974.092.8890.70102.429.0057.3450.647.2366.4471.18.3349.6916.880.1390.6588.40.002.880.00.000.00

    2-4:00pm54.9448.55113.282.4965.50125.9--46.08--49.8344.95110.910.2945.7922.569.0063.86108.00.000.520.0--0.00--

    4-Close45.1741.84108.033.7338.0288.7--0.00--46.1450.4291.5--30.93--------0.000.00------

    Total71.1873.8296.4105.0296.50108.829.0078.4337.067.1877.6586.55.7547.8712.099.0391.78107.90.001.500.00.000.00

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM6.41.7104.626.316.7108.2-4.69.4-1.4111.01.793.35.5183.21.2--0.0--

    8-10:00AM21.89.4111.3-6.58.186.5--9.3--118.88.1202.42.017.51.6115.651.40.0

    10-12:00PM7.03.9103.05.68.297.6---7.5--6.6-1.8108.62.1-21.812.769.454.50.0

    12-2:00PM12.15.0106.8160.327.4204.3-24.9-30.1-15.482.64.31.113.70.0

    2-4:00pm-4.81.893.57.84.0103.7---24.1--3.2-7.6111.76.618.5-11.9--0.0--

    4-Close42.132.4107.3-34.1-6.170.2---100.0--53.136.7112.0--17.0---------100.0------

    Total10.96.2104.424.712.4110.9-2.311.0-2.7114.12.84.65.099.616.20.0

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Mon

    Report #8 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - MONDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM46.453.387.145.127.4164.6--8.1--31.917.2185.58.838.323.0--5.5--14.33.0476.7--0.5--

    8-10:00AM62.975.483.434.036.094.4--7.5--35.521.3166.77.120.534.6--8.8--17.75.1347.15.70.8712.5

    10-12:00PM42.063.066.734.029.5115.3--7.3--47.921.6221.82.125.18.4--10.1--5.31.7311.810.64.8220.8

    12-2:00PM39.348.481.227.333.581.5--3.3--58.022.4258.92.322.710.1--13.3----2.1--12.52.8446.4

    2-4:00pm105.779.9132.333.343.177.3--1.6--50.529.9168.96.512.850.8------9.712.677.0------

    4-Close------5.016.131.1--0.9--95.061.6154.2--8.9----------12.5--------

    Total57.263.789.832.532.899.1--6.0--47.522.9207.45.123.821.4--8.1--9.54.5211.15.31.9278.9

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-20.4-3.687.1-11.411.5164.6--19.5---12.0-22.4185.5-7.3-8.123.0--251.1--314.30.8476.7--110.7--

    8-10:00AM11.0-3.083.4-27.922.494.4---4.4--4.7-19.0166.7-35.7-29.534.6--175.0--181.5264.0347.1260.3-69.7712.5

    10-12:00PM-21.7-9.466.7-22.97.1115.3--44.6--17.25.9221.827.7-22.08.4--0.4---57.4-41.3311.8147.1220.8

    12-2:00PM1.15.781.2-34.121.481.5---12.4--17.3-23.4258.9-67.0-9.110.1--15.1-----27.9--446.4

    2-4:00pm-2.09.4132.3-25.6-3.977.3--146.6---4.93.0168.9209.782.150.8-------28.377.0------

    4-Close-------78.3-20.331.1----54.4112.8154.2---43.5-----------64.4--------

    Total-4.0-2.089.8-27.612.799.1--11.6--11.4-8.1207.4-16.3-17.221.4--42.5--64.8-8.2211.11416.347.3278.9

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM83.470.2118.8121.0791.83131.8--82.83--90.5393.0597.30.0044.500.0--97.40--0.000.00--0.00--

    8-10:00AM77.287.488.3119.26111.43107.0--89.07--103.1793.21110.70.0049.190.0--120.54--0.000.830.00.000.00

    10-12:00PM70.372.597.0109.7086.58126.7--76.94--68.8983.3082.70.0050.960.0--104.88--0.001.470.00.000.00

    12-2:00PM60.371.484.487.1786.16101.2--50.20--62.9872.8186.50.0047.290.0--104.66----0.00--0.000.00

    2-4:00pm51.147.5107.483.2967.05124.2--55.00--43.9740.01109.916.6745.3236.8------0.000.00------

    4-Close36.439.392.529.5027.02109.2--0.00--36.7451.2571.7--38.00----------0.00--------

    Total66.972.392.5106.3691.07116.8--78.93--67.5376.5188.33.5747.667.5--108.67--0.000.390.00.000.00

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM7.34.3102.929.69.0118.9---1.9--8.5-3.5112.40.3--55.8---100.0----

    8-10:00AM-1.419.082.9-3.120.380.5--17.3--73.43.0168.37.4--25.8---71.7

    10-12:00PM8.53.1105.249.62.0146.7---4.0---11.8-4.492.36.3--8.7--88.2

    12-2:00PM35.04.3129.472.116.0148.4---34.4--31.40.8130.40.8---1.0-----100.0--

    2-4:00pm-22.63.674.74.710.195.1--50.0---23.0-20.296.513.0-------100.0------

    4-Close12.563.668.8-46.4-32.178.9----15.040.082.1--32.6-----------100.0--------

    Total1.28.593.322.212.9108.2--0.7--7.2-5.2113.14.1--10.9---74.3

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Tue

    Report #9 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - TUESDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM39.248.081.732.128.6112.2--7.8--43.620.0218.07.738.919.8--1.8--16.72.4695.8--0.6--

    8-10:00AM42.981.952.440.630.4133.6--6.2--39.618.1218.810.422.147.1--21.3--9.41.4671.4--0.5--

    10-12:00PM54.563.885.415.631.449.7--5.7--54.923.0238.70.824.03.313.98.1171.63.32.0165.011.55.9194.9

    12-2:00PM40.647.984.814.341.734.3--4.1--73.624.4301.6--24.5----1.6--3.32.5132.08.81.2733.3

    2-4:00pm75.383.090.725.442.260.2--1.5--55.230.4181.61.510.414.41.50.2750.016.415.3107.2------

    4-Close------2.823.012.2------94.460.0157.3--14.0--------2.83.093.3------

    Total51.064.379.323.333.569.6--5.3--56.523.1244.63.724.015.43.78.842.08.43.6233.34.51.8250.0

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-49.5-9.381.7-43.8-17.2112.2--25.9--17.2-21.0218.050.031.619.8---16.5--2500.027.3695.8--48.5--

    8-10:00AM-33.31.252.42.64.2133.6---16.9---20.8-29.8218.836.4-28.247.1--401.5--237.597.7671.4---74.2--

    10-12:00PM7.0-4.585.4-62.210.349.7--98.9--39.1-10.1238.7-18.73.3-8.8171.6-37.74.7165.0-18.2105.9194.9

    12-2:00PM-19.514.184.8-63.354.934.3--13.2--38.7-14.7301.6---4.0-----81.9---25.5-56.2132.057.7733.3

    2-4:00pm-30.2-15.790.7-53.618.860.2--91.9--37.413.4181.666.014.4-94.3750.0218.5-43.9107.2------

    4-Close-------88.05.612.2------36.411.0157.3---3.6---------63.9-38.093.3------

    Total-25.9-2.979.3-48.410.969.6--16.1--24.5-14.6244.65.9-6.515.460.242.0131.1-37.5233.386.032.1250.0

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM83.1572.99113.9129.3697.51132.7--89.16--95.6491.49104.50.0047.080.0--89.00--0.000.00--0.00--

    8-10:00AM87.1386.40100.8119.92103.94115.4--93.68--97.0396.15100.90.0049.640.0--96.72--0.000.00--0.00--

    10-12:00PM78.8880.0698.5103.61112.8991.8--81.27--78.9886.9690.80.0048.520.0139.00103.94133.70.000.000.000.00

    12-2:00PM57.1975.6675.6102.65103.9298.8--58.26--57.7670.7581.6--47.50----67.00--0.000.000.000.00

    2-4:00pm56.0945.93122.183.5965.05128.5--51.25--61.0342.30144.30.0045.110.079.0079.00100.00.000.00------

    4-Close47.0843.41108.530.0030.4398.6------48.9755.0289.0--24.29--------0.000.00------

    Total71.6975.1695.4111.1098.01113.4--83.20--72.2977.7992.90.0047.780.0135.6797.03139.80.000.000.000.00

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-6.40-3.0096.539.99.9127.3--5.2---1.4-5.7104.69.4---7.5---100.0----

    8-10:00AM29.1016.00111.3-4.26.590.0--17.6--170.413.9237.47.5--1.1---100.0----

    10-12:00PM5.9010.1096.27.028.183.5--11.1---9.8-4.994.81.014.7

    12-2:00PM22.2021.30100.7329.561.8265.5---23.9---18.2-4.885.9---0.5-----32.2---100.0

    2-4:00pm-12.3019.8073.214.812.3102.2---6.8--1.5-9.4112.01.930.8------

    4-Close40.7029.70108.5-49.3-17.561.5------71.351.3113.2---2.4--------------

    Total5.9013.4093.431.019.9109.3--6.0--11.6-0.9112.64.16.9-100.0

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Wed

    Report #10 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - WEDNESDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM41.559.170.236.122.0164.1--5.7--42.213.8305.88.446.118.24.810.446.28.41.8466.7--0.2--

    8-10:00AM56.767.883.648.837.2131.2--8.1--33.119.7168.012.625.050.4--7.3--5.52.0275.0--0.8--

    10-12:00PM38.861.363.331.030.0103.3--5.9--44.818.9237.01.129.23.8--8.5--16.12.9555.26.94.5153.3

    12-2:00PM39.741.595.713.537.635.9--3.5--75.322.6333.2--22.0--2.28.127.29.04.6195.7--1.5--

    2-4:00pm117.880.8145.840.640.1101.2--2.2--41.529.5140.76.68.676.70.90.8112.510.418.955.0------

    4-Close------3.116.119.3------96.959.1164.0--18.3----------6.5--------

    Total54.560.989.533.432.4103.1--5.5--49.220.9235.45.927.621.41.37.417.69.04.8187.51.11.573.3

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-44.1-2.870.2-6.5-5.6164.1--0.0---12.3-43.9305.8-4.612.518.2157.046.290.834.5466.7--151.0--

    8-10:00AM8.7-16.783.618.835.4131.2---2.2---30.019.8168.041.5-13.650.4---53.0--101.2-17.0275.0---19.9--

    10-12:00PM-18.8-5.663.312.47.1103.3--12.6---23.0-20.8237.07.53.8---9.6--15.8555.2-51.421.1153.3

    12-2:00PM-14.4-6.895.7-73.419.535.9---45.9--112.8-15.0333.2---2.2--4.527.2-2.618.3195.7--21.9--

    2-4:00pm-27.9-20.0145.8-20.7-6.1101.2--51.5---8.8-7.6140.7487.74.176.7-62.1112.5361.838.555.0------

    4-Close-------89.6-23.819.3------78.538.2164.0---22.4-----------44.1--------

    Total-22.5-11.689.5-18.810.7103.1---4.2--3.5-13.4235.434.13.021.4-14.117.693.011.3187.5-49.419.473.3

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM80.7865.71122.9103.3091.20113.3--78.03--91.7192.4599.20.0045.070.099.0074.00133.80.000.00--0.00--

    8-10:00AM85.2483.41102.2110.24105.56104.4--88.69--89.0697.4891.415.6347.7432.7--80.35--0.000.00--0.00--

    10-12:00PM60.2968.0288.6113.1790.71124.8--67.95--56.1579.7370.40.0047.930.0--90.12--0.000.000.000.00

    12-2:00PM49.8364.6777.184.9677.46109.7--59.09--48.6159.1382.2--50.05--79.00111.6070.80.000.00--0.00--

    2-4:00pm58.6145.27129.588.2768.79128.3--45.91--51.9042.58121.910.7142.3025.359.0063.5092.90.000.00------

    4-Close53.1244.15120.329.0035.5481.6------53.9054.7898.4--32.94----------0.00--------

    Total67.0367.6599.1101.9188.76114.8--76.03--63.3874.1185.510.4846.7522.487.5786.44101.30.000.000.000.00

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-5.2-10.2105.68.6-1.3110.0---4.9---9.0-7.598.4-1.6-18.3----

    8-10:00AM5.48.397.3-12.26.682.4--16.2--43.912.4128.00.7---19.4------

    10-12:00PM-4.7-4.099.315.22.8112.1---22.3---9.6-7.097.21.9--2.8---100.0

    12-2:00PM18.0-2.1120.5222.020.5267.2---19.2---40.3-32.388.2--10.4--13.2----

    2-4:00pm-3.9-5.0101.214.68.6105.5---23.1--9.3-10.7122.41.031.9-100.0------

    4-Close62.037.5117.8-45.3-28.176.1------73.355.3111.6--36.8-----------100.0--------

    Total3.5-0.2103.727.08.4117.2---3.0---5.1-6.0101.02.4-8.2-100.0

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Thr

    Report #11 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - THURSDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM42.952.481.931.027.6112.3--5.4--48.318.5261.110.331.632.6--12.5--10.34.0257.5--0.4--

    8-10:00AM46.475.361.648.135.6135.1--8.6--26.018.5140.59.628.333.911.56.5176.94.82.1228.6--0.5--

    10-12:00PM54.566.182.522.130.971.5--5.5--54.117.8303.90.825.33.25.711.051.84.13.8107.913.15.8225.9

    12-2:00PM38.446.382.97.035.020.0--2.6--61.623.1266.73.526.613.211.67.4156.816.34.8339.6--0.4--

    2-4:00pm98.983.0119.233.335.992.8--2.8--62.227.8223.7--11.9----0.8--4.420.821.2------

    4-Close------4.819.824.2------95.261.5154.8--16.5----------2.2--------

    Total55.063.786.326.732.781.7--5.4--53.521.2252.44.325.616.85.57.969.67.05.6125.03.01.7176.5

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-46.7-16.981.9-18.59.4112.3--9.6---7.7-30.7261.135.913.332.6---8.8--409.5235.0257.5--8.9--

    8-10:00AM-18.70.261.639.915.9135.1--28.5---53.3-24.7140.539.929.833.9-50.7176.953.819.9228.6---62.6--

    10-12:00PM-4.12.182.5-2.313.271.5--4.1---3.4-20.7303.9-34.8-10.43.24.951.862.949.2107.9-25.553.0225.9

    12-2:00PM-18.6-4.082.9-84.97.720.0---33.2--35.6-13.6266.753.513.213.24.9156.8168.6-8.9339.6---56.6--

    2-4:00pm7.6-8.2119.2-22.7-15.092.8--99.3--24.4-21.2223.7--23.1----6.3--126.794.921.2------

    4-Close-------77.1-26.824.2------31.027.7154.8--7.6-----------74.3--------

    Total-20.5-6.386.3-22.97.281.7--15.7---1.3-21.9252.4-0.511.716.8-17.869.6105.848.1125.0-11.017.5176.5

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM81.5375.78107.6117.30103.17113.7--77.51--93.4794.5598.90.0045.240.0--90.05--0.002.500.0--0.00--

    8-10:00AM102.1384.58120.7123.72106.75115.9--84.72--106.48102.67103.70.0047.280.0130.00107.08121.40.003.000.0--0.00--

    10-12:00PM69.7673.3195.293.6580.89115.8--76.38--76.8582.0893.60.0049.350.0130.00155.0683.80.000.000.000.00

    12-2:00PM40.9370.3358.258.9996.2761.3--46.58--44.3664.1069.28.3349.8616.779.0097.3081.20.002.140.0--0.00--

    2-4:00pm55.5943.00129.374.5760.09124.1--31.33--49.3951.5095.9--44.65----119.00--0.000.00------

    4-Close39.2538.33102.427.2538.5070.8------39.8542.9592.8--26.00----------0.00--------

    Total68.5471.8695.4102.3091.28112.1--74.85--65.4478.2483.61.0947.352.3112.41117.0496.00.000.930.00.000.00

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM1.2-1.1102.344.019.7120.3---8.3---1.3-1.199.80.8---2.2---35.0----

    8-10:00AM52.44.1146.4-3.45.791.4---1.1--157.722.0211.21.73.173.3----

    10-12:00PM15.22.5112.4-16.9-9.691.9---21.7--22.8-5.3129.70.188.5-100.0

    12-2:00PM-12.510.079.572.532.5130.2---41.1---34.9-14.976.53.021.4----

    2-4:00pm-7.6-9.2101.8-2.9-4.0101.1---44.1---8.614.779.7--10.8----183.3---100.0------

    4-Close35.218.4114.2-36.30.563.4------43.918.6121.3---6.3------------------

    Total11.73.8107.625.710.5113.8---13.4--7.03.4103.52.127.518.1

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Fri

    Report #12 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - FRIDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM39.249.579.230.226.6113.5--4.9--53.121.9242.55.237.913.7--4.0--11.54.2273.8--0.4--

    8-10:00AM52.585.961.148.327.9173.1--8.3--37.416.1232.312.921.460.3--25.5--1.40.7200.0------

    10-12:00PM48.960.580.818.223.477.8--5.9--74.523.0323.91.533.84.40.77.29.75.11.5340.0--5.2--

    12-2:00PM41.447.287.77.832.024.4--4.4--73.325.1292.05.226.319.810.38.3124.13.43.4100.0--0.5--

    2-4:00pm100.988.3114.336.043.882.2--0.7--51.429.0177.21.810.018.0--5.4--10.811.098.2------

    4-Close--------25.5--------98.159.2165.7--10.8--------1.94.542.2------

    Total55.165.584.126.429.390.1--5.4--60.822.9265.55.225.820.22.012.116.55.63.3169.7--1.3--

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-53.3-19.479.2-22.84.1113.5---38.2--8.3-21.1242.5-23.813.413.7--106.5--130.639.9273.8--45.8--

    8-10:00AM-12.21.161.1-3.41.4173.1--45.8--11.4-24.7232.3116.5-3.160.3--26.0---87.0-56.8200.0------

    10-12:00PM-3.9-9.580.8-28.3-3.677.8---14.1--21.3-12.9323.9-16.8-5.04.497.69.7-55.26.0340.0--188.3--

    12-2:00PM-10.8-18.187.7-83.927.324.4---24.5--85.9-4.8292.0-32.8-14.419.8-3.6124.1-28.30.9100.0----

    2-4:00pm-9.7-9.1114.314.19.782.2---69.6---18.7-10.0177.2-19.718.0--96.6--105.48.198.2------

    4-Close--------60.8--------27.520.4165.7---53.9---------58.3-61.142.2------

    Total-22.2-10.684.1-29.28.390.1---5.8--18.7-14.8265.519.7-6.120.240.916.5-21.3-7.5169.7--59.5--

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM80.0680.6699.3118.12124.5494.8--80.57--83.5389.6393.20.0046.540.0--155.71--0.000.00--0.00--

    8-10:00AM92.9989.34104.1111.98118.0894.8--82.45--103.5396.49107.31.3247.752.8--92.98--0.006.250.0------

    10-12:00PM78.5374.91104.8107.94110.3197.9--75.66--78.5387.3789.90.0050.750.049.50102.5048.30.002.780.0--0.00--

    12-2:00PM49.2269.1671.278.8988.7388.9--65.20--45.6665.3069.98.3352.0216.089.0093.4495.20.001.610.0--0.00--

    2-4:00pm56.7250.14113.181.9964.31127.5--50.00--52.9148.49109.10.0046.910.0--51.76--0.000.330.0------

    4-Close49.9643.62114.5--37.35--------50.9452.5497.0--27.53--------0.000.00------

    Total70.8975.2994.2103.82100.25103.6--77.67--68.4876.8989.12.2148.774.585.9695.1790.30.001.120.0--0.00--

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM3.54.798.928.927.0101.5---9.1---1.2-6.8106.04.5---7.5---100.0----

    8-10:00AM18.14.6112.9-10.9-1.790.6--0.7--118.8-5.6231.84.1--20.4--------

    10-12:00PM4.1-2.1106.3-13.55.881.8---4.6--10.3-4.9116.00.66.666.7----

    12-2:00PM5.60.3105.367.310.0152.1---15.2---24.7-21.896.39.76.3----

    2-4:00pm-3.9-5.2101.4-1.8-3.0101.2---27.2--2.4-11.2115.32.7--21.8---88.8------

    4-Close43.944.399.7---9.6--------59.646.4109.0--7.1--------------

    Total7.73.0104.611.74.9106.5---4.3--12.6-8.7123.34.814.5-14.6--0.0--

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Sat

    Report #13 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - SATURDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM52.653.997.632.132.399.46.16.495.345.018.0250.011.535.432.5--4.6--5.33.4155.9------

    8-10:00AM69.380.486.230.933.791.7--6.9--19.117.1111.72.119.510.839.720.6192.78.22.0410.0--0.3--

    10-12:00PM51.160.983.925.229.585.4--6.9--34.320.8164.92.121.49.838.515.7245.2--2.2----3.7--

    12-2:00PM41.449.184.316.437.743.50.92.832.150.925.5199.6--23.6--27.66.2445.24.33.2134.4--0.9--

    2-4:00pm69.671.697.235.954.565.9--1.4--60.325.8233.71.310.212.7--2.1--2.65.547.3--0.4--

    4-Close------7.727.228.3------92.345.7202.0--19.9----------7.3--------

    Total56.264.087.827.635.278.41.35.324.539.021.3183.13.422.415.224.311.6209.54.43.0146.7--1.1--

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-33.8-17.797.6-14.323.799.418.995.37.4-32.8250.0195.8-5.832.5--155.6---17.260.2155.9------

    8-10:00AM-4.2-3.286.2138.628.691.7--18.5---24.6-30.3111.711.3-15.810.8-33.716.9192.734.8410.0---79.3--

    10-12:00PM-8.52.983.9-28.516.485.4--8.0---37.9-18.7164.9-12.6-38.19.8434.2196.6245.2--102.1----90.0--

    12-2:00PM-25.2-14.384.3-69.261.443.59.632.131.439.2199.6---1.0---77.4445.2-23.6-19.6134.4--180.1--

    2-4:00pm-49.2-3.297.2-15.37.965.9---20.7--20.5-20.7233.77.712.7-----66.42.547.3--58.6--

    4-Close-------70.6-3.228.3------68.616.4202.0--1.2-----------22.1--------

    Total-26.2-6.687.8-20.026.478.411.524.5-7.3-15.1183.154.6-16.815.244.6-1.9209.5-2.216.6146.7--22.2--

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM79.1180.7698.0111.64119.6193.329.0068.6042.389.7196.5093.010.0045.3222.1--92.30--0.004.690.0------

    8-10:00AM96.3491.47105.3109.58117.5593.2--84.49--84.7899.1785.50.0048.200.0116.6195.07122.70.004.840.0--0.00--

    10-12:00PM82.1486.1995.3108.83117.3092.8--74.42--64.0596.2566.516.6750.5833.084.3599.8984.4--2.88----0.00--

    12-2:00PM48.5568.7270.699.7388.96112.129.0059.8148.521.2263.6433.3--51.78--76.7576.9399.80.008.060.0--0.00--

    2-4:00pm53.1654.7197.277.3966.24116.8--56.25--42.1240.49104.00.0051.160.0--81.67--0.006.610.0--0.00--

    4-Close48.1141.34116.429.5041.7570.7------49.6750.3098.7--35.30----------0.00--------

    Total75.8679.1295.9103.62102.44101.229.0075.1538.658.5480.1573.08.7048.4018.098.0194.33103.90.005.120.0--0.00--

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM14.511.2103.022.120.7101.2-14.333.69.5122.0-3.7--42.0--78.1------

    8-10:00AM23.25.2117.1-2.21.996.0--3.0--288.55.5368.2-2.920.0-3.9124.9----

    10-12:00PM-1.112.987.61.511.191.4---8.8---2.613.485.90.4-32.5-1.968.8--------

    12-2:00PM-9.00.190.9101.114.9175.0-21.3-69.5-16.436.5--1.1---3.8-22.6----

    2-4:00pm18.44.2113.66.11.3104.7---9.6--50.4-8.2163.822.0--------

    4-Close48.524.4119.4-41.88.753.5------42.330.6109.0--31.0------------------

    Total17.17.2109.230.59.4119.3-5.614.50.2114.3-0.73.25.497.942.3--0.0--

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    DayPart-CM-Sun

    Report #14 - DayPart Segmentation by Rate Group - Current Month - SUNDAY

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)Percentage of Rounds Sold (%)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM49.256.287.529.519.1154.5--3.3--48.414.6331.510.536.528.88.425.433.13.21.1290.9------

    8-10:00AM58.988.066.937.121.7171.0--5.4--22.011.2196.414.420.470.622.739.956.93.81.1345.5--0.2--

    10-12:00PM51.854.095.916.428.058.6--3.4--29.317.7165.5--26.5--44.817.0263.53.43.597.16.03.8157.9

    12-2:00PM48.244.8107.620.438.253.4--2.1--51.916.7310.80.923.63.87.410.471.25.64.1136.613.94.8289.6

    2-4:00pm97.769.3141.036.949.275.0--2.4--41.728.5146.3--11.8--------21.48.2261.0------

    4-Close------21.124.386.8------78.952.3150.9--23.4--------------------

    Total58.363.392.127.628.098.6--3.6--38.816.8231.05.424.322.217.722.877.66.52.8232.14.01.6250.0

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-11.5-16.587.5-39.47.5154.5---52.5--25.7-27.8331.5-11.724.328.84.833.1244.28.1290.9------

    8-10:00AM25.722.966.9-15.323.9171.0---12.7---47.6-44.4196.4115.9-7.870.627.456.9-50.3-18.6345.5---82.6--

    10-12:00PM9.4-0.195.9-54.334.158.6---19.3---40.3-26.0165.5--1.5---8.2263.5-54.3-11.797.1-20.068.6157.9

    12-2:00PM0.914.7107.6-51.658.953.4---34.6--13.2-37.0310.8-80.2-14.43.8-18.471.2-25.7-9.7136.6270.5289.6

    2-4:00pm22.827.4141.012.320.275.0---27.0---11.6-10.7146.3---10.5--------7.1-22.0261.0------

    4-Close-------4.1-0.586.8------19.912.4150.9--5.5--------------------

    Total3.56.692.1-30.630.498.6---27.9---15.5-29.5231.016.5-1.922.211.677.6-20.5-15.9232.1167.144.6250.0

    ARPR ($)

    TotalPublicCardholderPromoMemberGroupCompBarter

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM99.0471.98137.6117.25116.48100.7--94.49--107.9199.76108.25.0048.7610.3139.0055.70249.60.006.250.0------

    8-10:00AM93.6083.02112.7118.49122.8296.5--96.25--111.47100.03111.414.4747.2730.6101.4075.51134.30.0010.000.0--0.00--

    10-12:00PM79.6278.86101.0119.58112.47106.3--89.06--79.4188.9289.3--51.29--82.0086.9994.30.004.170.00.000.00

    12-2:00PM54.5565.8482.9106.7090.95117.3--52.33--51.1271.1571.825.0047.8152.382.0063.34129.50.006.030.00.000.00

    2-4:00pm52.2953.1898.385.9766.78128.7--47.00--49.3449.04100.6--43.98--------0.000.740.0------

    4-Close44.5842.12105.842.2448.5886.9------45.2044.32102.0--30.48--------------------

    Total76.0573.33103.7108.12101.37106.7--87.08--75.1879.8894.111.6748.0724.392.5972.33128.00.004.530.00.000.00

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM49.04.8142.213.518.795.6--11.5--156.38.6236.05.62.5------

    8-10:00AM31.88.9121.02.218.086.6--16.7--130.97.8214.2-4.62.720.0----

    10-12:00PM6.1-1.2107.40.34.296.3--36.0--20.7-2.9124.3--4.3---17.688.9

    12-2:00PM36.63.8131.6501.747.2408.8---33.4---27.9-9.679.84.6-35.6575.9

    2-4:00pm14.70.4114.213.62.9110.4---26.6--12.2-13.3129.4---4.7--------2.9------

    4-Close58.720.9131.3-9.730.869.0------66.96.7156.4--4.7--------------------

    Total30.84.9124.726.415.6109.3--10.6--43.2-3.2147.92.0-5.8135.3

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Snapshot-Month

    Snapshot - Current Month Performance Snapshot - My Course vs. Competitive Set

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)RevPAR ($)

    My CourseComp SetIndex (OCCI)My CourseComp SetIndex (PARI)

    55.363.786.839.4047.0383.80

    Channel Mix (%)ARPR ($)

    My CourseComp SetIndex (CHMI)My CourseComp SetIndex (ARRI)

    84.790.593.671.1873.8296.50

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Snapshot - Industry

    SNAPSHOT - Comp Set + Industry Segments

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)REVPaR ($)

    Current Month% ChgCurrent Month% Chg

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course55.3-18.1Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course39.40-9.0

    DMA: Palm Springs CA54.10.0DMA: Palm Springs CA35.836.5

    Facility Type: Resort53.63.3Facility Type: Resort37.358.1

    SubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)56.3-3.9SubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)42.161.0

    Facility Management Type: Mgmt Co54.10.0Facility Management Type: Mgmt Co35.836.5

    Competitive Set: Competitors63.7-5.1Competitive Set: Competitors47.030.6

    Channel Mix (%)ARPR ($)

    Current Month% ChgCurrent Month% Chg

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course84.7-3.0Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course71.1810.9

    DMA: Palm Springs CA85.9-2.9DMA: Palm Springs CA66.236.6

    Facility Type: Resort84.6-2.2Facility Type: Resort69.754.7

    SubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)86.9-3.0SubMarket: Central Valley (RM, PD, IW)74.874.9

    Facility Management Type: Mgmt Co85.9-2.9Facility Management Type: Mgmt Co66.236.6

    Competitive Set: Competitors90.5-4.2Competitive Set: Competitors73.826.2

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Snapshot - DOW

    SNAPSHOT - Day of the Week

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)RevPAR ($)Channel Mix (%)ARPR ($)65.56463.264.3

    My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (MPI)My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (ARI)My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (RGI)My CourseCompetitive SetIndex (RGI)39.0942.6337.2641.84

    Day of WeekTime Period% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg% Chg49.3250.6645.3548.97

    MondayCurrent Month57.2-4.063.7-2.089.898.038.27-2.846.066.583.191.382.1-7.888.9-5.192.497.266.891.272.298.692.593.2

    TuesdayCurrent Month51.0-25.964.3-2.979.376.336.59-21.548.3410.075.871.481.8-4.791.0-2.589.997.771.695.975.1613.495.393.4

    WednesdayCurrent Month54.5-22.560.9-11.689.587.736.51-20.041.23-11.888.690.784.5-2.090.5-3.993.4102.067.033.467.65-0.399.0103.7

    ThursdayCurrent Month55.0-20.463.7-6.386.385.037.68-11.145.77-2.882.391.582.9-3.689.7-5.392.4101.868.5411.671.863.995.3107.4

    FridayCurrent Month55.1-22.365.5-10.684.186.939.09-16.349.32-8.079.391.084.7-6.590.7-5.393.498.770.897.875.293.094.2104.7

    SaturdayCurrent Month56.2-26.264.0-6.787.879.142.63-13.850.660.284.086.087.10.691.2-3.495.5104.175.8617.179.127.296.0109.2

    SundayCurrent Month58.33.663.36.792.197.144.3035.546.3911.895.5121.289.01.091.0-4.597.8105.876.0530.873.334.9103.8124.7

    Weekday/Weekend

    Weekday (Mon-Thr)Current Month54.4-19.263.2-6.086.186.037.26-14.345.35-0.282.285.982.8-4.490.0-4.392.099.968.475.971.796.295.499.7

    Weekend (Fri-Sun)Current Month56.4-16.864.3-4.087.786.741.84-2.648.971.085.396.486.8-1.891.0-4.495.4102.774.1817.276.115.197.5111.5

    TotalCurrent Month55.3-18.163.7-5.186.886.339.40-9.047.030.683.890.584.7-3.090.5-4.293.6101.371.1810.973.826.296.5104.4

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Snapshot - 18Mo

    SNAPSHOT - 18 Months Historical

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)201420162016

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr

    My Course88.583.783.794.783.567.560.347.039.533.355.514.594.292.491.497.581.655.3

    Competitive Set77.369.888.199.688.767.150.134.023.921.937.633.877.269.484.1100.487.863.7

    Index (OCCI)114.5119.995.095.194.1100.6120.4138.2165.3152.1147.642.9122.0133.1108.797.192.986.8

    Rank4 of 73 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 75 of 71 of 71 of 71 of 72 of 71 of 76 of 74 of 71 of 73 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 7

    RevPAR ($)201420162016

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr

    My Course72.0854.3760.6777.4569.2943.2923.1119.7614.7813.6820.2911.5275.8357.5966.4693.2575.9739.40

    Competitive Set61.2649.6470.5588.7577.5646.6627.5514.728.578.1316.5424.4458.1446.0464.1091.6372.7747.03

    Index (PARI)117.6109.786.087.389.392.783.7134.7172.1169.1123.047.1130.5125.2103.7101.9104.483.8

    Rank3 of 74 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 72 of 71 of 72 of 74 of 76 of 73 of 73 of 75 of 76 of 75 of 77 of 7

    Channel Mix (%)201420162016

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr

    My Course88.288.288.689.789.787.385.787.582.981.585.482.989.786.586.987.389.284.7

    Competitive Set92.193.394.793.894.594.593.290.785.086.387.190.791.691.893.193.193.290.5

    Index (CHAI)95.894.593.695.694.992.492.096.597.594.498.091.497.994.293.393.895.793.6

    Rank6 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 75 of 75 of 76 of 76 of 75 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 7

    ARPR ($)201420162016

    NovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarApr

    My Course81.4065.0072.5081.7583.0264.1538.3442.0537.4141.0736.5579.4480.4962.2972.7195.6193.0571.18

    Competitive Set79.2771.1580.0789.1087.4269.5054.9343.3535.9137.1244.0372.3075.3366.3976.2491.2482.8873.82

    Index (ARRI)102.691.390.591.895.092.469.897.0104.2110.883.2109.8106.993.895.4104.8112.396.5

    Rank4 of 77 of 77 of 76 of 76 of 76 of 77 of 76 of 74 of 71 of 77 of 71 of 72 of 77 of 77 of 72 of 71 of 76 of 7

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100100

    Year to Date

    Running 3 Month

    Running 12 Month

    Snapshot - Daily

    SNAPSHOT - Daily Data for the Month

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    FriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSatSunMonTueWedThuFriSat--

    Occupancy (%)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    My Course85.087.789.990.857.871.084.164.475.261.763.162.454.949.635.633.333.246.346.149.643.341.243.750.231.338.843.644.652.044.3--

    Competitive Set95.091.980.088.677.374.379.881.986.663.071.973.065.867.255.348.459.064.558.359.361.655.748.152.232.350.045.747.555.248.5--

    Index (MPI)89.595.4112.4102.574.895.6105.478.686.897.987.885.583.473.864.468.856.371.879.183.670.374.090.996.296.977.695.493.994.291.3--

    RevPAR ($)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    My Course67.0580.1673.7267.8340.3351.8265.1549.3162.6550.5145.2348.3237.7637.3024.9521.4122.7327.2033.9432.8529.1826.7130.8832.2915.2624.6224.7520.9330.0222.06--

    Competitive Set80.9480.7567.3669.9866.2352.2863.3966.8674.0449.0153.0455.5142.6048.2437.9633.4335.4541.4041.5441.3944.4636.3232.9235.2221.9831.6829.5528.4238.5135.71--

    Index (ARI)82.999.3109.396.960.999.0102.873.784.7103.185.387.088.777.465.864.163.965.781.779.565.673.693.991.869.577.683.873.677.961.9--

    Channel Mix (%)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    My Course88.589.491.289.988.090.286.288.792.093.888.684.583.183.976.576.380.074.169.681.078.375.287.085.560.383.581.780.487.083.0--

    Competitive Set92.594.591.792.294.989.790.891.292.492.288.387.190.689.789.792.992.388.090.592.590.488.689.987.583.891.789.186.890.783.4--

    Index (RGI)95.794.699.597.592.7100.694.997.399.6101.7100.397.091.793.585.382.186.784.276.987.686.684.996.897.772.091.191.792.695.999.5--

    ARPR ($)April

    123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930--

    My Course78.9291.4481.9974.6869.7572.9977.5176.6083.2981.8771.6477.3868.8475.2470.1464.2468.4758.7873.6366.2467.4564.8070.6264.3148.7063.4556.7746.9157.7649.83--

    Competitive Set85.2287.8884.1879.0085.6570.3979.4381.6985.4677.8173.7576.0464.7971.8268.5769.0860.0464.1671.3169.7872.1465.1568.4267.5168.0663.3664.7259.8169.7473.63--

    Index (RGI)92.6104.097.494.681.4103.797.693.897.4105.397.0101.8106.2104.7102.292.9114.291.6103.294.893.699.4103.295.371.5100.287.878.482.967.7--

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Snapshot - DayPart

    SNAPSHOT - DayPart Segmentation

    Marriott's Shadow Ridge Golf Course 9002 Shadow Ridge Rd Palm Desert, CA 92211

    ORCA # MgtCo:

    For the month of: April 2016 Date Created: May 10, 2016 Monthly Competitive Set Data Includes Subject Property

    Occupancy (%)

    TotalMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturdaySunday

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM44.553.183.846.453.387.139.248.081.741.559.170.242.952.481.939.249.579.252.653.997.649.256.287.5

    8-10:00AM56.079.570.462.975.483.442.981.952.456.767.883.646.475.361.652.585.961.169.380.486.258.988.066.9

    10-12:00PM48.961.379.842.063.066.754.563.885.438.861.363.354.566.182.548.960.580.851.160.983.951.854.095.9

    12-2:00PM41.346.688.639.348.481.240.647.984.839.741.595.738.446.382.941.447.287.741.449.184.348.244.8107.6

    2-4:00pm94.479.5118.7105.779.9132.375.383.090.7117.880.8145.898.983.0119.2100.988.3114.369.671.697.297.769.3141.0

    4-Close------------------------------------------------

    Total55.363.786.857.263.789.851.064.379.354.560.989.555.063.786.355.165.584.156.264.087.858.363.392.1

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM-39.0-12.883.8-20.4-3.687.1-49.5-9.381.7-44.1-2.870.2-46.7-16.981.9-53.3-19.479.2-33.8-17.797.6-11.5-16.587.5

    8-10:00AM-3.80.470.411.0-3.083.4-33.31.252.48.7-16.783.6-18.70.261.6-12.21.161.1-4.2-3.286.225.722.966.9

    10-12:00PM-5.8-3.979.8-21.7-9.466.77.0-4.585.4-18.8-5.663.3-4.12.182.5-3.9-9.580.8-8.52.983.99.4-0.195.9

    12-2:00PM-12.9-2.388.61.15.781.2-19.514.184.8-14.4-6.895.7-18.6-4.082.9-10.8-18.187.7-25.2-14.384.30.914.7107.6

    2-4:00pm-17.8-6.3118.7-2.09.4132.3-30.2-15.790.7-27.9-20.0145.87.6-8.2119.2-9.7-9.1114.3-49.2-3.297.222.827.4141.0

    4-Close------------------------------------------------

    Total-18.0-5.186.8-4.0-2.089.8-25.9-2.979.3-22.5-11.689.5-20.5-6.386.3-22.2-10.684.1-26.2-6.687.83.56.692.1

    ARPR ($)

    TotalMondayTuesdayWednesdayThursdayFridaySaturdaySunday

    Current MonthMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndexMy CrseComp SetIndex

    Open-8:00AM83.7174.27112.783.4070.22118.883.1572.99113.980.7865.71122.981.5375.78107.680.0680.6699.379.1180.7698.099.0471.98137.6

    8-10:00AM90.7686.84104.577.1887.3688.387.1386.40100.885.2483.41102.2102.1384.58120.792.9989.34104.196.3491.47105.393.6083.02112.7

    10-12:00PM75.1976.4898.370.3272.5097.078.8880.0698.560.2968.0288.669.7673.3195.278.5374.91104.882.1486.1995.379.6278.86101.0

    12-2:00PM51.4369.4974.060.2771.4484.457.1975.6675.649.8364.6777.140.9370.3358.249.2269.1671.248.5568.7270.654.5565.8482.9

    2-4:00pm54.9448.55113.251.0647.54107.456.0945.93122.158.6145.27129.555.5943.00129.356.7250.14113.153.1654.7197.252.2953.1898.3

    4-Close45.1741.84108.036.3839.3192.547.0843.41108.553.1244.15120.339.2538.33102.449.9643.62114.548.1141.34116.444.5842.12105.8

    Total71.1873.8296.466.8972.2992.571.6975.1695.467.0367.6599.168.5471.8695.470.8975.2994.275.8679.1295.976.0573.33103.7

    % Change

    Open-8:00AM6.41.7104.67.34.3102.9-6.4-3.096.5-5.2-10.2105.61.2-1.1102.33.54.798.914.511.2103.049.04.8142.2

    8-10:00AM21.89.4111.3-1.419.082.929.116.0111.35.48.397.352.44.1146.418.14.6112.923.25.2117.131.88.9121.0

    10-12:00PM7.03.9103.08.53.1105.25.910.196.2-4.7-4.099.315.22.5112.44.1-2.1106.3-1.112.987.66.1-1.2107.4

    12-2:00PM12.15.0106.835.04.3129.422.221.3100.718.0-2.1120.5-12.510.079.55.60.3105.3-9.00.190.936.63.8131.6

    2-4:00pm-4.81.893.5-22.63.674.7-12.319.873.2-3.9-5.0101.2-7.6-9.2101.8-3.9-5.2101.418.44.2113.614.70.4114.2

    4-Close42.132.4107.312.563.668.840.729.7108.562.037.5117.835.218.4114.243.944.399.748.524.4119.458.720.9131.3

    Total10.96.2104.41.28.593.35.913.493.43.5-0.2103.711.73.8107.67.73.0104.617.17.2109.230.84.9124.7

    **CONFIDENTIAL** Intended solely for the use by subscriber.The ORCA Report

    Help

    - Help

    Definitions

    Key Performance Indicator (KPI) - A term used to describe a well-known and valuable measure of a business's performance

    Occupancy - A percentage that reports how many rounds of golf reported divided into the available capacity for the time period. Always expressed as a percentage.

    Capacity - The total amount of rounds available for sale at an 18 hole equivilent golf facility for each particular market. The Capacity is calculated by adding 28 players per hour for each partial and full hour within the range of 25 minutes after sunrise and 4.5 hours prior to sunset.

    Revenue per Available Round (RevPAR) - Is calculated by dividing total revenue for the time period into the Capacity for the same period.

    Channel Mix - Is the ratio of rounds booked from Direct Channels vs. All Rounds. Direct Channels are Golf Shop, Call Center, GC Website, GC Mobile. Indirect Channels are 3rd Party Websites, Wholesalers and other non-golf facility owned entities.

    ARPR (Average Revenue Per Round) - Green fee/Cart revenue (as reported) divided by rounds played displayed as the average rate for a round of golf.

    Competitive (Comp) Set - A peer group of competitive golf courses selected by golf course management to benchmark the subject propertys performance.

    Index (Occupancy, RevPAR, Channel Mix, ARPR) - Property performance divided by competitive set performance multiplied by 100.

    ARI Average Rate Index (ADR Index), and RGI Revenue/RevPAR Generation Index (RevPAR Index).

    Market Class - Class is an industry categorization which includes management company operated (MCO) and independent golf courses The class for a mco-affiliated golf course is the same as its mco scale. An independent golf course is assigned a class based on its ARPR,

    relative to that of the mco golf courses in their geographic proximity. There are six (6) class groups: Luxury, Upper Upscale, Upscale, Upper Midscale, Midscale and Economy.

    Market Class Combined (or Collapsed) If a single class segment is insufficient for reporting, classes are combined. There are three combined class segments: Luxury and Upper Upscale, Upscale and Upper Midscale,

    and Midscale and Economy.

    Market Scale - Golf courses located in the subject propertys market and classified in the subject propertys ORCA mco scale segment. There are seven (7) scale groups; Luxury, Upper Upscale, Upscale, Upper Midscale, Midscale, Economy and Independent.

    Market Scale (Collapsed) Golf courses located in the subject propertys market and classified in the subject propertys ORCA's mco scale segment. There are two (2) market scale (collapsed) groups; Upscale (includes Luxury, Upper Upscale, Upscale, Independent) and

    Midscale/Economy (includes Upper Midscale, Midscale and Economy).

    MTD (Month to Date) - If a month ends during the current week, the MTD number would represent the month that ended.

    Occupancy - Rounds sold divided by Capacity multiplied by 100. Occupancy is always displayed as a percentage of rounds sold.

    Percent Change (% Chg) - Amount of growth up, down or flat this period versus same period last year (day, week, running 28 days, running month-to-date). Calculated as ((TY-LY)/LY)*100.

    Percent Change Rank (Occupancy, RevPAR, Channel Mix, ARPR) - The percent change for the property is compared to the percent change of each golf course in the comp set.

    Rank (Occupancy, RevPAR, Channel Mix, ARPR) - Property performance ranked versus golf course in the competitive set (e.g. a 3 of 6 ADR ranking means the subject golf courses absolute ARPR is third highest of the six competitors).

    RevPAR (Revenue per Available Round) - Green Fee revenue divided by Capacity

    FAQ

    How is my golf facility performing versus competition?

    The monthly ORCA report provides timely occupancy,revenue per available round, channel mix and average rate per round benchmarking of your golf facility's performance versus your own selected competitors and an ORCA defined industry segment.

    Is my golf facility's data included in the competitive numbers?

    yes

    How are percentage changes computed?

    Golf Facility and competitive performance changes are measured against same period prior year.

    Why do my percentage change numbers have such a large range?

    The data for this year vs. the same period last year may vary greatly. Consider if you sold 2294 rounds this month vs. 743 last year, the percent change would be 208.7% ((2294-743)/743)*100.

    What is an index?

    An index is an easy way to compare your golf facility's performance versus competition. An index of 100 or higher means your golf facility's absolute performance is the same or better than competition.

    What does the Rank information mean?

    Your golf facility's performance is ranked against the other properties in your competitive set. If your golf facility's RevPAR rank is 2 of 6, that means your golf facility's RevPAR was second highest of the six golf facilities in your competitive set.

    What if there are blanks in my competitive set numbers?

    Your competitive set did not include sufficient data for reporting. A minimum of three (3) golf facilities excluding the subject property must report data in order for ORCA to provide competitive set performance.

    What if there are blanks in my competitive set percentage change?

    Your competitive set did not include sufficient data for reporting prior year data.

    Who can I contact if I have more questions?

    Check out the glossary and FAQ at www.orca.golf or e-mail [email protected]

    Golf Marketing Advisors

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    GolfNow Paid RoundsMake sure you know what days and daypart your marketing partner is filling

    GolfNow Paid RoundsMon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Grand Total

    6 AM 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.4% 0.0% 1.4% 0.0% 2.9%7 AM 2.9% 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 3.6% 1.4% 2.2% 11.5%8 AM 2.9% 0.0% 0.0% 2.2% 4.3% 5.8% 2.9% 18.0%9 AM 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 4.3% 2.9% 0.0% 8.6%

    10 AM 0.0% 4.3% 0.0% 6.5% 5.0% 1.4% 0.0% 17.3%11 AM 0.0% 2.2% 0.0% 0.0% 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 3.6%12 PM 0.0% 0.0% 2.9% 0.0% 4.3% 0.0% 0.0% 7.2%

    1 PM 2.9% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 2.9% 0.0% 5.8%2 PM 8.6% 2.9% 5.0% 2.9% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 19.4%3 PM 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.4%4 PM 0.0% 0.0% 2.9% 0.0% 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 4.3%

    Grand Total 18.7% 10.8% 10.8% 14.4% 24.5% 15.8% 5.0% 100.0%

  • P O W E R I N N U M B E R S

    GolfNow Paid Rounds

    Average Rate for GolfNow.com paid rounds

    Average Rate for GolfNow Paid Rounds

    Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Grand Total6 AM $62.50 $62.50 $62.507 AM $24.75 $49.50 $44.80 $89.00 $33.00 $43.698 AM $39.75 $74.67 $47.83 $42.13 $64.50 $50.609 AM $64.50 $49.67 $32.25 $46.33

    10 AM $33.00 $45.11 $38.14 $89.00 $43.7111 AM $45.00 $54.50 $48.8012 PM $32.25 $49.50 $42.60

    1 PM $32.25 $27.25 $29.752 PM $34.50 $17.25 $29.57 $29.63 $29.943 PM $69.00 $69.004 PM $14.75 $44.50 $24.67

    Grand Total $35.77 $33.40 $26.33 $50.58 $46.21 $48.00 $51.00 $41.88

    Sheet1

    ChannelCall Center

    RoundsAve. Rate

    Public321$52.30

    Promo283$47.45

    Member27$1.85

    Comp23$0.00

    Group5$49.50

    Grand Total659$46.31

    Sheet2

    DistGroupNameWeb-GN

    Average Rate for GolfNow Paid Rounds

    MonTueWedThuFriSatSunGrand Total

    6 AM$62.50$62.50$62.50

    7 AM$24.75$49.50$44.80$89.00$33.00$43.69

    8 AM$39.75$74.67$47.83$42.13$64.50$50.60

    9 AM$64.50$49.67$32.25$46.33

    10 AM$33.00$45.11$38.14$89.00$43.71

    11 AM$45.00$54.50$48.80

    12 PM$32.25$49.50$42.60

    1 PM$32.25$27.25$29.75

    2 PM$34.50$17.25$29.57$29.63$29.94

    3 PM$69.00$69.00

    4 PM$14.75$44.50$24.67

    Grand Total$35.77$33.40$26.33$50.58$46.21$48.00$51.00$41.88

    Shadow_Ridge_ImportSet_1215 (4)

    TeeDateTimeDOWPlayersFeeFeeWithAdjustmentDistributionChannelFeeNameRateGroupNameRateCategoryNameDistGroupNameDistCategoryNameCustomerNameCustomerEmailAddressPostalCodeCustomerPhone

    4/1/16 7:39Fri1129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center94024

    4/1/16 8:06Fri400EZLinks -Res CenterWeekly MembershipMemberMemberCall Center-EZCall Center55446

    4/1/16 8:24Fri4129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92201

    4/1/16 8:33Fri1059.99EZLinks -Res CenterShadow Ridge PackageResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/1/16 8:33Fri1149149EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/1/16 8:33Fri1149149EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/1/16 9:00Fri200EZLinks -Res CenterMGA Student - 2 Day SchoolResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center94526

    4/1/16 9:00Fri2129129EZLinks -Res CenterMVCI Owner- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center94526

    4/1/16 9:09Fri2129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center48854

    4/1/16 9:27Fri4129129EZLinks -Res CenterDSV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center95813

    4/1/16 9:36Fri2148148EZLinks -Res CenterPublic 18/ OutsidePublicPublicCall Center-EZCall Center98419

    4/1/16 10:30Fri2135135EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92310

    4/1/16 11:06Fri22584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center91324

    4/1/16 11:15Fri22584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92647

    4/1/16 12:00Fri12584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92124

    4/1/16 15:36Fri100EZLinks -Res CenterKids4Free (ZERO)PromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92201

    4/1/16 15:36Fri17979EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92201

    4/2/16 6:45Sat1129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center94502

    4/2/16 6:54Sat2059.99EZLinks -Res CenterShadow Ridge PackageResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/2/16 7:03Sat1129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center68022

    4/2/16 7:03Sat200EZLinks -Res CenterWeekly MembershipMemberMemberCall Center-EZCall Center68022

    4/2/16 7:12Sat2129129EZLinks -Res CenterMVCI Owner- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center53213

    4/2/16 7:30Sat22584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center94086

    4/2/16 7:39Sat1139139EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/2/16 7:39Sat1139139EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/2/16 7:39Sat1059.99EZLinks -Res CenterShadow Ridge PackageResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/2/16 7:39Sat1139139EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/2/16 10:21Sat2129129EZLinks -Res CenterMVCI Owner- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center1776

    4/2/16 10:21Sat1139139EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center6001

    4/2/16 10:39Sat2152152EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Guest- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92024

    4/2/16 11:15Sat179.579.5EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center55424

    4/2/16 11:15Sat3129129EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center55424

    4/2/16 12:36Sat2129129EZLinks -Res CenterMVCI Owner- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center91773

    4/2/16 15:00Sat22584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92603

    4/2/16 15:18Sat200EZLinks -Res CenterKids4Free (ZERO)PromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90720

    4/2/16 15:18Sat28989EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- TwilightResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center90720

    4/3/16 6:18Sun1129129EZLinks -Res CenterMVCI Owner- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center68022

    4/3/16 6:18Sun200EZLinks -Res CenterWeekly MembershipMemberMemberCall Center-EZCall Center68022

    4/3/16 6:27Sun1152152EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center90278

    4/3/16 6:36Sun1144144EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92130

    4/3/16 7:48Sun2125125EZLinks -Res CenterExplorer Golf Peak 2015PromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center95687

    4/3/16 8:06Sun3129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center94010

    4/3/16 8:06Sun12525EZLinks -Res CenterSR MemberMemberMemberCall Center-EZCall Center92260

    4/3/16 8:24Sun2059.99EZLinks -Res CenterShadow Ridge PackageResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center90277

    4/3/16 9:00Sun2152152EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center98105

    4/3/16 9:36Sun2149149EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center46845

    4/3/16 10:12Sun4129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92262

    4/3/16 10:21Sun3147147EZLinks -Res CenterPublic 18/ OutsidePublicPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92210

    4/3/16 10:21Sun1059.99EZLinks -Res CenterShadow Ridge PackageResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center91387

    4/3/16 10:30Sun2147147EZLinks -Res CenterPublic 18/ OutsidePublicPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92210

    4/3/16 11:33Sun12584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center22039

    4/3/16 11:33Sun1112112EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center22039

    4/3/16 14:42Sun22584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center60502

    4/4/16 6:18Mon400EZLinks -Res CenterWeekly MembershipMemberMemberCall Center-EZCall Center68022

    4/4/16 6:27Mon2129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center91355

    4/4/16 6:54Mon3129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center99208

    4/4/16 7:03Mon1159159EZLinks -Res CenterPublic 18/ OutsidePublicPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92673

    4/4/16 7:03Mon179.579.5EZLinks -Res CenterWeb SpecialsPromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center92673

    4/4/16 7:39Mon2129129EZLinks -Res CenterDSV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center90272

    4/4/16 7:48Mon12584.99EZLinks -Res CenterSR Marketing CertificatePromoPromoCall Center-EZCall Center10576

    4/4/16 7:48Mon1059.99EZLinks -Res CenterShadow Ridge PackageResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center91387

    4/4/16 8:15Mon400EZLinks -Res CenterCOMP tcCompCompCall Center-EZCall Center92223

    4/4/16 8:33Mon3129129EZLinks -Res CenterSRV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center92024

    4/4/16 8:33Mon1129129EZLinks -Res CenterDSV Owners- PrimeResortPublicCall Center-EZCall Center55436

    4/4/16 8:42Mon2129129EZLinks -Res CenterMVCI Owner- PrimeRes