34
Daniel Himmelstein Physarum polycephalum BBC Journal Club link to source

Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 3: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

plasmodium

• vegetative state

• acellular

• multinuclear

• protoplasmic veins (tubules)

Page 6: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Nakagaki et al. Nature 2000

finds shortest path

hour 4 hour 8time 0

Maze Solving

coats entire agar plasmodium retracts

Page 9: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Tero et al. Science 2010

• efficiency• fault tolerance• cost

Actual Rail Network Slime Tubule Network

Page 10: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Navigation Schemes

reactive

• immediate environment

• efficient

• novel exploration

global

• span entire search space

• map precedes solution

• no internalized memory

Page 11: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Slime mold uses an externalized spatial “memory” to navigate in

complex environments.Chris R. Reid, Tanya Lattya, Audrey Dussutour, and Madeleine Beekman

PNAS October 23, 2012 vol. 109 no. 43 17490-17494

Page 12: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?
Page 13: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Extracellular Slime Avoidance?

Page 14: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

391

40

< 0.001

Slime Coated Agar Blank

Page 15: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

1822

40

0.636

Page 16: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

716

23

0.93

Page 17: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

24 trials120 hours

Does extracellular slime function as a navigational aid?

blank(trail perceivable)

slime coated(trail masked)

glucose plasmodium

investigate the ability of the plasmodium to navigate around the trap and reach the glucose

Page 18: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

blan

k ag

ar

39 hours

71 hours

slim

e co

ated

aga

r

Page 19: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Mean Speed of Plasmodium

50

0.345

2.5

millimeters per hour

Page 20: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Proportion Finding Goal

96%

33%

< 0.001

Page 21: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Mean Time to Reach Goal

800

0.012

40

hours

excluding trials over 120 hours

Page 22: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Mean Distance Traveled

5000

< 0.001

250

millimeters

Page 23: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Mean Time Spent in Trap

500

0.016

25

hours

Page 24: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Mean Time Spent on own slime trail

400

0.042

20

hours

Page 25: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

13 trials 16 trials

measurement p-value

time to reach goal 0.374distance travelled 0.471

speed 0.889

Page 26: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

blan

k ag

ar

39 hours

71 hours

slim

e co

ated

aga

r

Page 27: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

first conclusion: extracellular slime avoidance provides a navigational benefit

• choice of 120 hour cutoff

• avoids extracellular slime for non-navigational reasons

• do navigational benefits hold across a variety of complex environments

• how are competing stimuli balanced

Page 28: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

• “storage and retrieval of information relating to past events”

• Spatial

• Externalized

• Collective

• Functional precursor

second conclusion: extracellular slime avoidance is a form of memory

Page 29: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Memory

• epigenetic processes (chromatin structure)

• vernalization (chromatin remodeling records length of winter)

• immune response (antibodies)

• evolution (stored adaptations)

• ants (pheromone trails)

• sticky notes

“storage and retrieval of information relating to past events”

Page 30: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Memory

• epigenetic processes (chromatin structure)

• vernalization (chromatin remodeling records length of winter)

• immune response (antibodies)

• evolution (stored adaptations)

• ants (pheromone trails)

• sticky notes

“internal storage and retrieval of information relating to past events”

Page 31: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

Memory

• epigenetic processes (chromatin structure)

• vernalization (chromatin remodeling records length of winter)

• immune response (antibodies)

• evolution (stored adaptations)

• ants (pheromone trails)

• sticky notes

“storage and retrieval of information relating to personal past events”

Page 32: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?
Page 33: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?
Page 34: Intelligent slime mold, but can it remember?

The End: Questions