37
2/11/12 1 Gerald M. Dworkin Consultant, Aquatics Safety & Water Rescue Lifesaving Resources, LLC www.lifesaving.com Developed for National Drowning Prevention Symposium (2012) THE POWER OF WATER THE POWER OF WATER SHOULD NEVER BE UNDERESTIMATED 2ITS BEAUTY, STRENGTH OR FORCE. LIFE CANNOT EXIST WITHOUT WATER. IT EMPOWERS US AND COMMANDS RESPECT. BE READY FOR IT! www.lifesaving.com

Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

1$

Gerald'M.'Dworkin'Consultant,'

Aquatics'Safety'&'Water'Rescue'

Lifesaving'Resources,'LLC'www.lifesaving.com'

'Developed(for(

National'Drowning'Prevention'Symposium'(2012)'

''

!!

THE!POWER!OF!WATER!!THE!POWER!OF!WATER!SHOULD!NEVER!BE!UNDERESTIMATED+2!ITS!BEAUTY,!STRENGTH+OR!FORCE.!

!LIFE!CANNOT!EXIST!WITHOUT!WATER.!IT!EMPOWERS+US!AND!COMMANDS!RESPECT.!!!

BE!READY+FOR!IT!!!!

www.lifesaving.com!

Page 2: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

2$

Page 3: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

3$

Page 4: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

4$

Page 5: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

5$

Page 6: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

6$

Page 7: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

7$

Page 8: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

8$

Page 9: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

9$

26'

Gerald'M.'Dworkin'Consultant,'

Aquatics'Safety'&'Water'Rescue'

Lifesaving'Resources,'LLC'www.lifesaving.com'

'Developed(for(

National'Drowning'Prevention'Symposium'(2012)'

''

Page 10: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

10$

PRINCIPLES$!  Rule'of'Numbers'!  PRM'Factors'!  RID'Factors'!  Threat'Assessment'&'HRD'Factors'!  Suction'Entrapment'&'VGB'Act'!  Legal'Responsibility'&'Liability'

Factors'!  Rules,'Regulations'&'EEC'Factors'!  Layers'of'Protection'(LOP)'!  Surveillance'Protocols'!  Standard'Operating'Procedures'

(SOPs)'!  FacilityUUse'Guidelines'(FUG)'

!  Emergency'Action'Plans'(EAPs)'!  Emergency'Response'Plans'(ERPs)'!  Incident'Command'(IC)'&'Incident'

Action'Plans'(IAPs)'!  Spinal'Injury'Management'&'

Mechanism'of'Injury'(MOI)'!  Body'Substance'Isolation'(BSI)'

Protocols'!  Rescue'Priorities'!  Management'of'Hypoxia'(MOH)'!  Positive'Pressure'Ventilation'(PPV)'

Protocols'!  CPR'Protocols'!  AED'Protocols'

28'

MURPHY’S$LAWS$

1.  Anything'that'can'happen'–'will'happen.'

2.  When'it'does,'it'will'happen'at'the'least'opportune'time.'

3.  Mother'Nature'is'a'Bitch!'

29'

1.''Anything'that'can'happen'–'will'happen.'

30'

Page 11: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

11$

2.  When'it'does,'it'will'happen'at'the'least'opportune'time.'

31'

3.''Mother'Nature'is'a'Bitch!'

32'

EMERGENCY$RESPONSE$PLAN$

THUNDER$&$LIGHTNING$STORMS$

!  Recognize(the'Danger'

!  Evacuate(all'Patrons'&'Staff'

!  Return(Procedures'

Policy'Development'

33'

Page 12: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

12$

34'

RULE$OF$NUMBERS$'

Frequency!:'Probability!'

The'more'patrons'who'use'your'facility'increases'the'probability'of'a'significant'incident.'

'

Each'day'you'operate'without'a'significant'incident'brings'you'one'day'closer'to'when'the'incident'will'occur.'

35'

36'

Page 13: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

13$

37'

38'

DROWNING$101$

!  7th'leading'cause'of'unintentional'injury'deaths.'

!  2nd'leading'cause'of'unintentional'injury'deaths'for'children(1(–(14(years(of(age.'

!  3rd(leading(cause(of(death(for(children(0(–(4(years(of(age.(

!  6'–'10'times'more'people'suffer'brain'damage'than'death'from'submersion'incidents.'

!  Minorities'drown'at'a'rate'2x'greater'than'''''''''''''''''''''''''''whites.'

!  Males'drown'at'a'rate'4x'greater'than'females.'

39'

Page 14: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

14$

40'

!  6,000'–'7,000'drownings'annually.'

!  3,500'during'recreational'swimming'activities.'

!  90%'in'open'water.'

!  50%'U'67%'are'alcohol'or'drugUrelated.'

!  100+'in'“guarded”'facilities.'

41'

42'

Page 15: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

15$

PEDIATRIC$SUBMERSIONS$

!  Second'leading'cause'of'unintentional'death'nationwide.'

!  Leading'contributing'factor:'Lack(or'lapse(in'adult(supervision(

'!  Young'children'are'attracted(to'water'and'have' '''little'concept'of'the'dangers(associated'with'water.'' ''''The'action'of'children'around'water'is''''''''''''unpredictable.'

43'

!  BIG'HEAD'/'LITTLE'BODY'SYNDROME.'

!  Nearly'half'of'the'victims'were'out'of'sight' ' '''''less'than'5'minutes'prior'to'the'incident.'

!  Drowning'is'a'silent(death.'

!  64%'of'the'victims'were'not'expected'to'be' ' ''''''''in'or'near'the'swimming'pool'prior'to'the' ''''''''incident.'

44'

WATER$CRISES$Distress'Swimmer' Drowning'Victim'

!  Can'support(self'in'water'by'swimming'or'floating.'

!  Can'keep'head'out'of'water'to'breathe.'

!  Can'call(out'for'help.'

!  Can'wave(for'help.'

!  Cannot'support(self'in'water'by'swimming'or'floating.'

!  Cannot'keep'head'out'of'water'to'breathe.'

!  Cannot'call(out'for'help.'

!  Cannot'wave(for'help.'

45'

Page 16: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

16$

INSTINCTIVE$DROWNING$RESPONSE$

!  Head(is'tilted(back(in'attempt'to'breathe.'

!  Vertical(position'in'the'water.'

!  Arms(are'extended'laterally.'

!  Victims'don’t(call(out'for'help.'

!  Victims'don’t(wave(for'help.'

!  Appear(to(be(playing(in(the(water.(

!  Struggle'for'20'–'60'seconds.'

46'

THE$DROWNING$PROCESS$

!  Struggle((20'–'60'seconds)'

!  Ingest'&'aspirate'water'into'stomach'&'airway'

!  Laryngospasm(

!  Hypoxia(

!  Unconsciousness'

!  (Aspirate'water'into'lungs)'

!  Respiratory(arrest(

!  Cardiac(arrest(

47'

TYPES$OF$DROWNING$

!  Wet'drowning'

!  Dry'drowning'

!  Laryngeal(drowning(

!  Mammalian'diving'reflex'

!  Shallow'water'blackout'(hyperventilation)'

!  Silent'(passive)'drowning'

!  Long'QT'Syndrome'

!  Torso'Reflex'

48'

Page 17: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

17$

SECONDARY$DROWNING$INCIDENT$

49'

50'

CHERRY$HILLS$WATERPARK$INCIDENT$

51'

Page 18: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

18$

P$R$M$FACTORS$

' 'Prevention('' ' 'Recognition(

'' ' ' 'Management(

52'

PREVENTION$

!  Establish'&'enforce'rules(&'regulations(

!  Strategic'positioning'of'lifeguard(stations(

!  Remove'or'warn'of'hazards(

!  Prohibit'or'safeguard'risks(

!  Vigilant'surveillance(&'supervision(

53'

RECOGNITION$

!  Incidents(

!  Potential(for'Incidents'!  Hazards'!  Risks'

54'

Page 19: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

19$

MANAGEMENT$

!  Potential(for'incidents'!  Hazards'!  Risks'

!  Incidents(!  Rescue'!  Emergency'patient'care'

!  Rescue'equipment'

!  Personal'protective'equipment'(PPE)'

55'

56'

LOUISIANA$SUBMERSION$INCIDENT$

57'

Page 20: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

20$

R$I$D$FACTORS$

'Recognition('' ' 'Intrusion(

'' ' ' 'Distraction(

58'

A$SERIES$OF$EVENTS$

59'

THREAT$ASSESSMENT$&$HRD$FACTORS$

Hazard''+''Risk''=''Danger''

Hazards'!  Remove'!  Warn'

Risks'!  Prohibit'!  Safeguard'

60'

Page 21: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

21$

61'

62'

VIRGINIA$GRAHAM$BAKER$(VGB)$ACT$

63'

Page 22: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

22$

64'

65'

http://www.lifesaving.com'

LEGAL$RESPONSIBILITY$&$LIABILITY$

!  Duty(to(Act(

!  Good'Samaritan'Laws'

!  Consent(

!  Abandonment'

!  Records(&(Reports(

!  Negligence'

66'

Page 23: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

23$

NEGLIGENCE$

1.  Duty(to'Plaintiff'

2.  Breach(Duty'

3.  Injury(or'Loss(

4.  Direct'Correlation(of'Breach'to'Injury/Loss(

67'

COEUR$D’ALENE$INCIDENT$

68'

''''''''''

'''''

www.yonigottesman.com'

69'

Page 24: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

24$

RULES,$REGULATIONS$&$EEC$FACTORS$''Establish(

'' ' 'Enforce(

'' ' ' 'Consequences(

70'

71'

LAYERS$OF$PROTECTION$

!  Supervision(!  Isolation(fencing(!  SelfSclosing,(selfSlatching(&(selfSlocking(gates(!  Gates'open'outward,'away'from'the'pool'!  Pool'cover'!  Pool'alarm'!  Passive'monitoring'!  Lifeline(!  Depth(line(!  Depth'markers'!  Telephone(

72'

Page 25: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

25$

GOFF$V.$HAMLET$APARTMENTS$INCIDENT$

73'

'http://www.lifesaving.com/poolUsafelyUdigitalUassets'

74'

75'

Page 26: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

26$

PERSONAL$FLOTATION$DEVICES$(PFDS)$

76'

WEAR$IT!$

77'

PFD$TYPES$

78'

Page 27: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

27$

79'

SURVEILLANCE$PROTOCOLS$

!  30Ssecond(Rule(

!  10/20(Rule(

!  10'x'10'Reaction'Rule'

!  Rotation(

!  Zone(of(Responsibility((ZOR)(

!  Sunglasses'

80'

SUNGLASSES$

!  Protection(from'ultraviolet(rays(during'sunlight.'

!  Protection(from'powerful(light(because'when'eyes'receive'extra'light,'it'closes'the'iris'causing'the'lifeguard'to'squint.'

!  Protection(from'glare(because'water'can'reflect'a'great'deal'of'light'and'conceal'objects.'

!  Eradicate'light'frequencies'that'can'blur( ((((((((((((((vision'or'reduce(contrast.'

81'

Page 28: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

28$

POLARIZED$SUNGLASSES$

!  From'the'moment'of'reflection,'light'becomes'polarized'and'forms'visual'noise'–'blinding(glare(that'interferes'with'the'real'image.'

!  Polarized'lenses'enhance(visual(acuity,(color,(contrast(and(comfort.'

!  Tinted(lenses(only'reduce'light'transmittance'–' ''''they'do(not(block(blinding(glare.'

82'

USLA$POSITION$ON$

PATRON$SURVEILLANCE$'Lifeguards'assigned'to'supervise'an'aquatic'area'shall(not(be(subject(to(duties'that'would'distract(or'intrude(their'attention'from'proper'observation'of'persons'in'the'waterfront'area,'or'that'prevent(immediate(assistance(to'persons'in'the'water.'

'Specifically,'lifeguards(assigned'to'water' ' ''surveillance'shall(not(be(assigned(to(any( ((((((((((((((duties(other(than(public(safety!'

83'

84'

Page 29: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

29$

OPERATIONAL$PROTOCOLS$

!  Standard'Operating'Procedures'(SOPs)'

!  Emergency'Action'Plans'(EAPs)'

!  Emergency'Response'Plans'(ERPs)'

!  Incident'Command'(IC)'&'Incident'Action'Plans'(IAPs)'

! Missing'Person'vs.'Missing'Bather'

!  Credible'Witness'

85'

LIFEGUARD$QUALIFICATIONS$'

Certification'vs.(Qualification''

!  Screening'!  PreUService'Training'!  Standard'Operating'Procedures'(SOPs)'!  Surveillance'Protocols,'Victim'Recognition'&'Zones'of'Responsibility'!  Emergency'Action'Plans'(EAPs)'!  Emergency'Response'Plans'(ERPs)'&' ' '''''' ''''''''

Emergency'Drills'!  Incident'Command'(IC)'&'Incident'Action' ' ''''''''''''''''''

Plans'(IAPs)'!  Rescue'&'PPE'Equipment'

RESPONSIBILITY$OF$

AUTHORITY$HAVING$JURISDICTION$(AHJ)$

!  Conduct'Threat'Assessment'

!  Determine'Level'of'Operational'Capability'Required'

!  Plan(for'the'Incident'

!  Train(for'the'Incident'

!  Acquire'the'Resources(Required'to' ' '''''''''''''Safety'&'Effectively'Manage(the'Incident'

87'

Page 30: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

30$

JAMIE$KENNEDY$EXPERIMENT$

88'

A$B$C$RESCUE$'(Primary(Response'

'( (CoverSup(Response'

'( ( (Secondary(Response'

89'

FACILITYNUSE$GUIDELINES$

!  Accountability'

!  Supervision'

! Within'Arm’s'Reach'

!  Lifejackets'

90'

Page 31: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

31$

91'

COMPETITION$DIVING$INCIDENT$

92'

WATER$ENTRIES$

93'

Page 32: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

32$

SPINAL$IMMOBILIZATION$PROTOCOLS$

The'lack'of'neurological'deficit'does'not'rule'out'injury.''It'just'means'the'injury'is'not'yet'apparent.'

'If'the'Mechanism'of'Injury'(MOI)'is'sufficient'to'have'caused'a'spinal'injury,'then'assume'the'injury'exists.'

'Emergency'Care'Protocols'

!  Standing'takeUdown'!  Shallow'water'!  Deep'water'!  Land'

94'

DIVING$INCIDENT$

95'

96'

Page 33: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

33$

PATIENT$ASSESSMENT$'

A'''''='''''Airway''

B'''''='''''Breathing''

C'''''='''''Circulation''

D'''''='''''Disability''

E'''''='''''Examination''

M'''''='''''Mechanism'of'Injury'

97'

BSI$PROTOCOLS$

!  Universal'Precautions'

!  Personal'Protective'Equipment'(PPE)'

!  Vaccine'Preventable'Hepatitis'!  Hepatitis'B'Vaccine'!  Hepatitis'A'Vaccine'!  Hapatitis'A/B'Vaccine'

98'

MANAGEMENT$OF$HYPOXIA$

Positive'Pressure'Ventilation'(PPV)'!  Personal'resuscitation'mask'(PRM)'!  Personal'resuscitation'shield'(PRS)'!  BagUValveUMask'(BVM)'resuscitator'

Oxygen'Administration''Airway'Management'

!  Suction'

99'

Page 34: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

34$

MASSACHUSETTS$INCIDENT$

100'

BASIC$LIFE$SUPPORT$

Chain'of'Survival'!  Access'!  CPR'!  AED'!  Advanced'Life'Support'(ALS)'

'

CPR:'Life'Saving'or'Life'Sustaining?'!  30:2'ratio'

'

AED'Protocols'

101'

AED$PROTOCOLS$'

Automated'External'Defibrillator''

!  High'&'Dry'

!  Verbal'Commands'!  I’m'Clear!'!  You’re'Clear!'!  Everyone’s'Clear!'

102'

Page 35: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

35$

HUNTINGTON$BEACH$AED$RESCUE$

103'

PRINCIPLES$!  Rule'of'Numbers'!  PRM'Factors'!  RID'Factors'!  Threat'Assessment'&'HRD'Factors'!  Suction'Entrapment'&'VGB'Act'!  Legal'Responsibility'&'Liability'

Factors'!  Rules,'Regulations'&'EEC'Factors'!  Layers'of'Protection'(LOP)'!  Surveillance'Protocols'!  Standard'Operating'Procedures'

(SOPs)'!  FacilityUUse'Guidelines'(FUG)'

!  Emergency'Action'Plans'(EAPs)'!  Emergency'Response'Plans'(ERPs)'!  Incident'Command'(IC)'&'Incident'

Action'Plans'(IAPs)'!  Spinal'Injury'Management'&'

Mechanism'of'Injury'(MOI)'!  Body'Substance'Isolation'(BSI)'

Protocols'!  Rescue'Priorities'!  Management'of'Hypoxia'(MOH)'!  Positive'Pressure'Ventilation'(PPV)'

Protocols'!  CPR'Protocols'!  AED'Protocols'

104'

SAN$JOSE$NEARNDROWNING$INCIDENT$

105'

Page 36: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

36$

106'

107'

108'

Page 37: Gerald Dworkin "Standard of Care"- NDPA Symposium 2012

2/11/12$

37$

TOMORROW’S$LIFEGUARD$

109'

110'

Lifesaving!Resources,!LLC!www.lifesaving.com!

[email protected]'