Effective Online Effective Online Threaded DiscussionsThreaded Discussions

The pros, cons, and strategies

by Dr. Kelly Edmonds

Some Uses of Threaded Some Uses of Threaded DiscussionsDiscussions

respond to a comment, idea, or question discuss an issue discuss a process brainstorm review literature reflect on an experience

Pros and ConsPros and Cons

Pros of Online Threaded Discussions◦everyone has a chance to post, share their voice ◦asynchronous and flexible timing ◦think before posting ◦ in-depth (and assessable) discussion ◦review and reflect

Cons of Online Threaded Discussions◦redundant posts ◦dominant posters ◦overwhelming number of posts

Solutions and Strategies for Solutions and Strategies for Effective Online Threaded Effective Online Threaded DiscussionsDiscussions

moderating

small group discussions

themes

Other concerns and issues to Other concerns and issues to think about....think about....

 What is your philosophy on teaching and learning?

◦ This will affect how you use discussions as a learning activity.

What is your perception of moderated discussions?◦ Can they intimidate students? Are they biased and leading?

Or just good leadership?

Did you know that not all students enjoy working in groups?◦ Though a favoured activity in the constructivist and

socialists world, not so with all students.