U.S. Department of U.S. Department of LaborLabor
Employment & Training Employment & Training AdministrationAdministration
Developing Career Pathways Systems: Six Key
Elements
R5 ETA ASTD Technical Assistance ForumOctober 17-19, 2011
Purpose
To share information on career pathways
To promote career pathways as a successful strategy in the workforce investment system
To provide you with resources and tools to help states and local areas develop career pathway systems
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 2
Objectives
By the end of this session, you will be able to do the following:
Explain what a career pathway system is
Name the six key elements of a career pathway system
Identify some challenges in developing and implementing a career pathway system
Identify online resources and tools
Identify steps for helping states and local areas in your region develop career pathways
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 3
Agenda
Background and Context: Why Career Pathways?
Definition and Framework
Steps for Supporting Career Pathways in Your Region
Wrap-Up
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 4
U.S. Department of U.S. Department of LaborLabor
Employment & Training Employment & Training AdministrationAdministration
BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT:WHY CAREER PATHWAYS?
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 5
Vast Numbers of Unemployed Adults and Older Youth
As of the end of 2010, an average of 14.8 million Americans were unemployed.
Over 43% of them had been out of work for 27 weeks or more (long-term unemployed).
This is the highest percentage of long-term unemployment on record since 1948.
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 6
Many Needing Skill Upgrade
Many cannot return to their previous occupations because the jobs are gone (dislocated workers).
To transition to new careers, they will require new skills and industry-recognized credentials.
Some can return to their industry but have been unemployed for a long time and need to upgrade their skills or obtain new credentials.
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 7
Alarming Statistics on Education
14.8 unemployed in 2010
14.2 million were 18 years of age or older
54.9% have only a high school diploma or less
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 8
More Jobs RequiringBetter than High School
More jobs now require education and training beyond high school.
Year
Percentage of Jobs Requiring
Some College or Above
1973 28%
2007 59%
2018(projection)
63%
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 9
Advantage to Adults and Older Youth with Postsecondary
CredentialsThose with postsecondary credentials earn more and are more likely to keep their jobs.
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 10
In Summary
Vast numbers of unemployed adults & older youth.
Many of them need skill upgrade or new credentials.
Workers with postsecondary credentials earn more and are more likely to keep their jobs.
But adults/older youth often do NOT complete postsecondary training – particularly if they’re required to complete remedial or developmental education before earning a credential.
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 11
– especially those withlow skills and low education –
The Challenge
How can we help adults/older youth
get jobs with livable wages?
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 12
What is Needed
A system of support that will make it easierfor adults to complete their postsecondary
training and education and earn the credentials that will improve their
employability, increase theirsecurity, and boost their
earning power
What is Needed (cont.)
A systemic approach to education, training, and employment that focuses on supporting these unemployed adults & OY
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 14
What is Needed (cont.)
An alignment of programs and servicesacross the workforce, education, human
service, and economic development systems
to support these unemployed adults/OY and equip them with in-demand skills and
credentials
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 15
The term “career pathways” refers to a clear sequence of education coursework and/or training credentials that:
Is aligned with the skill needs of regional industries
Includes the full range of secondary, adult education, and postsecondary education options
Includes curriculum and instructional strategies that contextualize learning
As appropriate, integrates education and training that combines occupational skills training with adult education services, gives credit for prior learning, and adopts other strategies that accelerate advancement
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 16
The Answer: Career Pathways
Leads to the attainment of an industry-recognized degree or credential
Includes academic and career counseling, and support services
Is organized to meet the particular needs of adults, with flexible and non-semester-based scheduling, and the innovative use of technology
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 17
The Answer: Career Pathways
(cont.)
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 18
Key Achievement ofCareer Pathways
Help adults and older youth gain industry-recognized, postsecondary credentials and transition into new careers through:
Adult-centered program designs
Articulated service delivery models
Direct involvement of employers
Extensive use of labor market information in designing programs that focus on developing in-demand skills
Enhanced coordination of comprehensive services – from adult basic education, to occupational skills training, to career and academic counseling, to support services, to job search assistance
. . . But Do They Work?
Career pathways work! States and local areas with a career pathway approach have seen improvements in credential attainment and employment.
I-Best results
P/PV results
Capital Idea results
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 19
U.S. Department of U.S. Department of LaborLabor
Employment & Training Employment & Training AdministrationAdministration
WHAT ARE THE ELEMENTS OF EFFECTIVE CAREER PATHWAY
SYSTEMS?
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 20
Career pathway systems provide a clear sequence of education coursework or training credentials and have the following elements:
Six Key Elements ofCareer Pathway Systems
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 21
1. Build cross-agency partnerships & clarify roles
2. Identify industry sector or industry & engage employers
3. Design education & training programs
4. Identify funding needs & sources
5. Align policies & programs
6. Measure system change & performance
#1: Build Cross-Agency Partnerships and Clarify Roles
Key cross-agency partners at the local and state levels are engaged to participate in the initiative.
Local team is formed to design, pilot, launch, and grow a local or regional career pathway system.
Partners are invited to design, craft, and implement a shared vision.
State team supports the local team with administrative policies and legislation to aid in local implementation and statewide growth. Senior state and regional leaders visibly support the initiative.
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 22
#1: Build Cross-Agency Partnerships and Clarify Roles (cont.)
Roles and responsibilities are clearly defined and formalized.
Create a leadership or steering committee to guide the development process.
Clarify and formalize roles and responsibilities of the following:
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 23
Workforce system
Economic development system
Education system
Human service system
CBO’s
Employers
Sectors and industries are selected and employers are engaged in the development of career pathways.
Determine labor market trends, skill development needs and opportunities, and employer preferences.
Select employers or industry representatives and plan how to pitch the initiative to them.
Plan how to work with employers in the different phases of the initiative (design, launch, operation, evaluation).
#2: Identify Industry Sector and Engage Employers
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 24
Career pathway programs provide a clear sequence of education courses and credentials that meet the skill needs of high-demand industries.
Provide a clear sequence of education courses and credentials that lead to postsecondary education/training and employment.
Design programs to accommodate individuals regardless of their skill level at the point of entry.
Design programs around high demand industries and career ladders that pay family-sustaining wages.
Support programs through state legislation and administrative policies for sustainability.
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 25
#3: Design Education and Training Programs
Key questions to ask: How will we . . .Incorporate & align secondary & post-secondary education elements?
Integrate & contextualize adult basic education & occupational skills training?
Chunk curricula into shorter programs of study?
Meet the need for flexible training & education options?
Include academic & CTE content in a coordinated, non-duplicative progression?
Integrate wrap-around services?
Ensure the program leads to an associate or baccalaureate degree or industry-recognized credentials or certificates at the postsecondary level?
#3: Design Programs… (cont.)
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 26
Necessary resources are raised and/or leveraged to develop and implement career pathway programs.
Identify resources needed to operate programs and core system components.
Program development
Professional development
Operating costs
Supportive services
Ensure state and local partners work together to raise and leverage funding from federal, state, local, and foundation sources.
#4: Identify Funding Needs & Sources
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 27
#4: Identify Funding Needs and
Sources (cont.)
What are your funding needs?
Curriculum development
Professional development
Operating costs
Supportive services
What funding sources should you explore?
WIA Titles I, II, & IV funds
Wagner-Peyser Act funds
Carl Perkins Act funds
TANF funds
State funds
Private foundations
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 28
Key questions to ask:
Federal, state, and local legislation or administrative policies promote career pathway development and implementation.
Local and state partners identify key policy and program changes and actions needed.
Partners actively coordinate efforts across the region and/or state and establish formal procedures to institutionalize system change.
Agencies and programs collaborate to provide professional development across organizations and systems.
#5: Align Policies and Programs
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 29
Key questions to ask:
How are career technical & academic programs linked (or not) at the community college? How can linkages be strengthened?
How does the eligible training provider list (ETPL) promote career pathway development?
How can One Stop and TANF service providers coordinate with each other in providing services?
What can be used to fund curriculum & professional development?
How can policymakers support the development of portable and stackable credentials?
#5: Align Policies and Programs (cont.)
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 30
Track effect of policy changes and program designs on participant outcomes
Arrange data-sharing agreements with key partners and employers, as appropriate
Design systems for sharing performance information to support continuous learning and improvement
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 31
#6: Measure System Change and Evaluate Performance
Career Pathways: Six Elements
U.S. Department of U.S. Department of LaborLabor
Employment & Training Employment & Training AdministrationAdministration
HOW DO YOU START?
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 33
Initial Steps
Learn more about career pathways
Determine interest and commitment from key stakeholders
Form a steering committee
Define vision and goals
Assess readiness
Create action plan
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 34
Learn More:Current Career Pathway Initiatives
DOL-ETA Career Pathways TA Initiative
HHS-ACF’s HPOG Grants
DOEd-OVAE’s RPOS
Joyce Foundation – Shifting Gears
Ford Foundation – Career Pathways
Gates Foundation – ABE to Credentials
The National Fund for Workforce Solutions
TAACCCT (program designs)
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 35
Learn More:Career Pathways: Six Elements Framework
Learn More:Career Pathways: Readiness Assessment Tool
https://learnwork.workforce3one.org/page/home
Learn More:Career Pathways Community of Practice
Web Site
Additional Resources
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 39
WHITE PAPERS
“Career Pathways: Background Paper for a Discussion of How the Federal Government Can Support their Expansion,” white paper prepared by Rachel Pleasants and Mary Clagett for the Adult Learning Strategies Forum on April 19, 2010, U.S. Department of Labor, Employment & Training Administration.
“Adult Learning Strategies for Workers in Transition,” white paper prepared by Ray Uhalde, Heath Prince, and Mary Clagett for the Adult Learning Strategies Forum on July 14, 2010, U.S. Department of Labor, Employment & Training Administration.
“Credentials that Count: The Role of the Public Workforce System in Strengthening Credential Attainment Among American Workers,” white paper prepared by Pamela Frugoli, Mary Alice McCarthy, and Michael Qualter for the Adult Learning Strategies Forum on September 28, 2010, U.S. Department of Labor, Employment & Training Administration.
LINKS TO MODEL CAREER PATHWAY PROGRAMS
“Integrated Basic Education and Skills Training (I-BEST): Washington State’s Career Pathway Initiative,” http://www.sbctc.ctc.edu/college/e_integratedbasiceducationandskillstraining.aspx
“Higher Learning and Higher Earning: Oregon's Statewide Pathways Initiative,” http://worksourceoregon.org/index.php/career-pathways
“Regional Industry Skills Education: Wisconsin’s Career Pathways Initiative,” http://risepartnership.org/
“FastTrac Initiative: Minnesota State’s Career Pathways Initiative,” http://fasttrac.project.mnscu.edu/
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 40
Additional Resources (cont.)
LINKS TO MODEL CAREER PATHWAY PROGRAMS (cont.)
“Arkansas Career Pathways,” http://www.arpathways.com/home.html
“Capital Idea: Austin, Texas, Career Pathways Initiative,” http://www.capitalidea.org/academic_sponsorship/becoming_participant/career_research.html
RELATED STUDIES
“Charting a Path: An Exploration of the Statewide Career Pathway Efforts in Arkansas, Kentucky, Oregon, Washington, and Wisconsin,” prepared by Rosanna Perry Stephens, Seattle Jobs Initiative, May 2009. http://www.workingpoorfamilies.org/pdfs/Career_Pathways_Report.pdf
“Underserved Students Who Earn Credit Through Prior Learning Assessment (PLA) Have Higher Degree Completion Rates and Shorter Time-to-Degree,” research brief published by the Council for Adult & Experiential Learning, http://www.cael.org/pdf/PLA-Underserved.pdf
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 41
Additional Resources (cont.)
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 42
RELATED STUDIES (cont.)
“Washington State’s Integrated Basic Education and Skills Training Program (I-BEST): New Evidence of Effectiveness,” Working Paper No. 20 of the Community College Research Center , prepared by Matthew Zeidenberg, Sung-Woo Cho, and Davis Jenkins, September 2010. http://ccrc.tc.columbia.edu/Publication.asp?UID=805
“Tuning In to Local Labor Markets: Findings from the Sectoral Employment Impact Study,” published by Public/Private Ventures, 2010, http://www.ppv.org/ppv/publications/assets/325_publication.pdf
Smith, Tara, Christopher T. King and Daniel G. Schroeder, Local Investments in Workforce Development: 2011 Evaluation Update, Austin: Ray Marshall Center, University of Texas, April 2011 (forthcoming); and Glover, Robert G. and Christopher T. King, “The Promise of Sectoral Approaches to Workforce Development: Towards More Effective, Active Labor Market Policies in the United States,” in Charles J. Whalen, Ed., Human Resource Economics.
Additional Resources (cont.)
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 43
RELATED STUDIES (cont.)
“Tuning In to Local Labor Markets: Findings from the Sectoral Employment Impact Study,” published by Public/Private Ventures, 2010, http://www.ppv.org/ppv/publications/assets/325_publication.pdf
“Courses to Employment: Sectoral Approaches to Community College- Nonprofit Partnerships, Initial Education and Employment Outcomes Findings for Students Enrolled In Healthcare Career Training 2003-2009, Capital IDEA and Austin Community College Partnership, Austin, Texas,” prepared by Matt Helmer and Amy Blair, Revised March 2011, published by The Aspen Institute. http://www.aspenwsi.org/publications/10-015.pdf
TOOLS“Funding Career Pathways and Career Pathway Bridges: A Federal Policy
Toolkit for States,” October 2010, http://www.clasp.org/postsecondary/pages?id=0003
Additional Resources (cont.)
Resources: Contact Person
If you have questions or need some guidance:
Lori Crockett HarrisFederal Project Officer
Youth and Target Population SpecialistDepartment of Labor, ETA
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 44
U.S. Department of U.S. Department of LaborLabor
Employment & Training Employment & Training AdministrationAdministration
Implementing Career Pathways
Implementing Career Pathways
Implementing Career Pathways ♦ Page 46
Recommended