Recognition and Control
of Respiratory Hazards in
the Flavoring IndustryTraining Developed by:
Photo by National Jewish Health used with written permission.
Disclaimers
This presentation was produced under grant number SH-22304-11-60-F-8 from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, U.S. Department of Labor. It does not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the U.S. Department of Labor, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations imply endorsement by the U.S. Government.
2
Why are we here?
Provide information to workers:1. Signs and symptoms of potential flavor-related lung disease2. Ways to detect lung disease that may be related to flavoring
exposure3. Methods to reduce exposure to flavorings associated with
lung disease
http://www.osha.gov/SLTC/flavoringlung/index.html accessed 3/28/2012
3
Outline
• Introduction to OSHA• Overview of flavoring exposures• Health effects of flavorings• Medical surveillance (testing) for
possible flavoring-related health effects
• Recognizing and controlling flavoring exposures
4
Definitions• Part per million (ppm)
– Small unit of concentration– 1 ppm = 1 drop in 13 gallon gas tank
• Flavoring exposure– Inhalation of flavoring vapors or
particles• Bronchiolitis Obliterans Syndrome
(BOS)– An uncommon lung disease where
scars form in the small airways5
Introduction to OSHATraining Goals
• Understand the role of OSHA in occupational safety and health
• Describe employer responsibilities and employee rights provided by OSHA
• Understand specific OSHA and industry standards for handling flavorings
6
What is OSHA?• Occupational Safety and Health
Administration• Government agency within the U.S.
Department of Labor• Responsible for worker safety and
health protection• Created in 1970 by the Occupational
Safety and Health (OSH) Act• OSH Act allows states to take
responsibility for implementing OSH Act providing their regulations are at least as stringent as Federal OSHA
7
What does OSHA do?• Requires employers to implement
programs to reduce workplace safety and health hazards
• Investigates workplace fatalities or catastrophic accidents
• Enforces safety and health standards through workplace inspections by compliance officers
• Monitors job-related injuries and illnesses through required record-keeping
• Provides assistance, training, and other support programs to help employers and workers 8
What are employers’ responsibilities under OSHA?
Provide employment and a workplace that is:
1. In compliance with established OSHA standards.
2. Free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to employees.
9
What are employees’ rights under OSHA?
1. Get training from your employer as required by OSHA standards
2. Request information from your employer about OSHA standards, worker injuries/illnesses, and job hazards
3. Request action from your employer to correct hazards or violations of OSHA standards
4. File a complaint with OSHA if you believe there are violations of OSHA standards or serious hazards
• Must be submitted in writing, signed by a current employee or employee representative, and state the reason for the inspection request
• Forms and more information available at www.osha.gov
10
What are employees’ rights under OSHA?
5. Be involved in OSHA’s inspection of your workplace
6. Find out results of an OSHA inspection7. Get involved in meetings or file a
formal appeal concerning your employer’s timely abatement of OSHA citations
8. File a discrimination complaint9. Request a research investigation by
the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH)
10.Provide comments and testimony to OSHA during rulemaking on new standards 11
Are there specific OSHA standards that apply to my
workplace?• Recordkeeping• Housekeeping• Medical & First Aid• Walking/Work
Surfaces• Emergency Action• Noise• Hazardous materials
– Compressed gases– Flammable liquids
• Personal protective equipment
• Confined spaces
• Lockout/tagout• Fire protection• Powered industrial
trucks• Cranes• Machine guarding• Electrical• Respiratory
protection• Exposure to toxic
substances• Hazard
communicationThere may also be others that apply to your
workplace! 12
How are exposures regulated?
– Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL)• Maximum permitted 8-hour time-
weighted average concentration
– Short-Term Exposure Limit (STEL)• 15-minute time-weighted average
concentration not to be exceeded at any time during a workday
– Ceiling Limit• Maximum concentration to which an
employee may be exposed at any time 13
Limits the total amount of flavoring you can inhale in a
work day
OSHA sets legally enforceable limits
Makes sure that you don’t inhale
too much flavoring in a short time
Protects you from immediate irritation
Does OSHA have a standard for diacetyl?
• OSHA – No PEL or Federal OSHA Standard– Currently working on developing a standard
• CalOSHA (2010), No PEL– Exposure monitoring for airborne diacetyl – Regulated areas for all diacetyl processes– Controls to reduce exposures to lowest feasible
levels– Medical surveillance (every 6 months) for
workers– Respirators for workers
• At all times when working with diacetyl-containing powders
• When there are measurable diacetyl levels– 8-hour exposures are greater than 0.012 ppm– 15-minute exposures are greater than 0.035 ppm
14
Are there other groups that recommend exposure levels for diacetyl and
substitutes?
• NIOSH=National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
• ACGIH=American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
• TERA=Toxicology Excellence for Risk Assessment
15
Agency or Organization
8-hour Limit(ppm)
15-min Limit(ppm)
NIOSH (2011, Draft) 0.005 0.025ACGIH (2012) 0.01 0.02TERA (2010) 0.2 N/ANIOSH (2011, Draft)
0.009 0.031
We don’t know which of these recommendations will be effective.
Best approach is to reduce exposures as low as possible using these numbers to measure progress.
Diacetyl
2,3-Pentanedione
Are there OSHA standards for other flavorings?
Chemical
OSHA PEL8-hour(ppm)
ACGIH TLV 8-hour/
STEL (ppm)
CalOSHA PEL8-hour/STEL
(ppm)Acetaldehyde 200 25 (c) 25 (c)Acetic Acid 10 10/15 10/15 & 40 (c)Formic Acid 5 5/10 5/10Furfural 5 2 2Phosphoric acid 0.25 0.25/0.75 0.25Propionic acid N/A 10 10Sulfur dioxide 5 N/A/0.25 2/5
> 2,000 individual flavorings and < 100 with exposure limits 16
Overview of Flavoring Exposures
Training Goals• Understand that some flavorings
may cause lung injury under some conditions
• Know where to find a listing of flavorings that may cause lung injury
17
Why are exposures hard to predict in flavoring
manufacturing?• More than 2,000 flavorings– Some have irritant properties– Small number have exposure limits– Many with not enough information to
determine whether they are a respiratory health hazard
• Exposures to different forms– Pure flavorings– Concentrated liquid and powder
mixtures– Low concentration final products
• Multiple processes– Mixing, heating, packaging, etc.
• Batch processes– Volumes vary – Daily and seasonal variability
18Not much information on possible hazards from breathing flavorings.
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
Is there a list of flavorings that might be hazardous when inhaled?
• The Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association (FEMA) has a list of “High Priority” flavorings
• “High Priority” flavorings may cause respiratory injury when:
• Exposure levels are high• Repeated exposures at lower
levels• Processed using heat• Processed without proper
exposure controlsImage by the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers AssociationUsed with written permission
19
“High Priority” flavorings should be labeled to alert workers that they require careful handling.
What are the “High Priority” flavorings?
• Acetoin• Diacetyl• Diacetyl Trimer• 2,3-Heptanedione
• Methyl Mercaptan• Methyl Sulfide• 2,4-Pentadienal• 2-Pentenal• Phosphoric Acid• Propionaldehyde• Propionic Acid• Sulfur Dioxide• Triethylamine• Valeraldehyde
FEMA LISTED
HIGH PRIORITYMATERIAL
FOLLOW APPROPRIATE ENGINEERING AND PROCEDURAL CONTROLS TO MINIMIZE EXPOSURE
20
Figure by National Jewish Health
Diacetyl & Substitutes
Other Flavorings• Acetaldehyde• Acetic Acid• Benzaldehyde• Butyric Acid• Ethyl Acrylate• Formic Acid• Furfural• Hydrogen Sulfide• Isobutyraldehyde• Isobutryic Acid
• 2,3-Hexanedione• 3,4-Hexanedione• 2,3-Pentanedione
These flavorings may cause respiratory injury
when not handled properly.
What about natural flavoring complexes?
• Capsaicin• Oils
– Balsam fir– Bitter almond– Garlic– Grapefruit– Lemon– Lime– Mustard– Onion– OrangePhoto by Scott Bauer available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
21
Natural flavoring complexes may also cause irritation and respiratory symptoms when not handled properly.
Health Effects and Medical Surveillance
Training Objectives• Learn about respiratory health
effects • Learn methods to detect possible
flavoring-related health effects• Understand the importance of
medical surveillance
22
Definitions• Airways
– The tubes that carry air into and out of your lungs
• Airway Disease– Airways become narrowed.– Causes slowing of the flow of air into and out of your lungs
• Bronchiolitis Obliterans Syndrome (BOS)– Airway disease in small airways in the
lungs– Injury from a chemical or infection– Scars form, causing airways to narrow.
• Associated with exposure to diacetyl • Possibly diacetyl substitutes
23
Normal Airway
Image by National Jewish Health
Narrow Airway
Image by National Jewish Health
PermanentScarring
Respiratory Health Effects• Irritation
– Eyes, nose, throat– Chest– Skin irritation (high exposure)
• Airway diseases–Bronchiolitis
Obliterans Syndrome (BOS)
–Asthma• Allergies
– Allergic reactions– Asthma
Air travels through the small airways to the air sacs and into the blood stream.
Diagram of a Normal Lung
Image by National Jewish Health
24
• Cough– Dry cough– Cough with phlegm
• Wheeze• Chest tightness• Shortness of breath
Photo by National Jewish Health
There are many causes of breathing symptoms.
Photo by National Jewish Health
25
Airway irritation and airway diseases cause breathing
symptoms.
A medical evaluation is needed to know the cause of the
symptoms.
26
• Colds and other infections • Cigarette smoking• Airway Irritation• Asthma• Bronchiolitis Obliterans Syndrome (BOS)• Allergies• Other lung diseases
– Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Photo by National Jewish Health
It is important to find BOS early!This is the true story of one worker •29 years old with no lung problems. He never smoked.•He worked for 2 years as a flavor compounder.
– When he used a respirator, his beard prevented a good fit.
•He began to have breathing symptoms.– He was treated for bronchitis.
•His symptoms continued to worsen.•He had to stop working.•He saw a doctor who knew about flavorings and BOS.•He already had severe airway disease (BOS).•He was not able to work or do many other things again.
If his BOS had been diagnosed earlier, the ending to the story might have been different.
27
Not all “High Priority” flavorings are irritating.
Flavorings can cause irritation and injury.
• Usually, there is only irritation– Burning in the throat, nose, and eyes– Burning in the chest, cough, and chest
tightening– Symptoms get better away from exposure
• Airway injury can occur– High levels of exposure– Very irritating flavorings
Figure by National Jewish Health
Photo by Cliff Hutson available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
28
Normal Airway
Some flavorings can trigger asthma “attacks”.
• During an asthma “attack”:– Airway muscles tighten.– Airways become inflamed and narrowed.– Symptoms may be mild or severe.
• Treatment with medications is often needed.• Airways return to normal.
Figures by National Jewish Health
Asthma
Airways inflamed and narrowed
Medications
Normal airway
29
Muscletightening
Swelling
Mucus
Asthma “attacks” can be triggered in workers who already have
asthma.• Triggered by irritant flavorings
–Capsaicin–Some natural oils–Some “High Priority” Flavorings
•Acetic acid •Acetaldehyde (aldehydes)
• The higher the exposure, the higher the risk.
Workers with asthma should be extra careful to avoid breathing in irritating flavorings.
Photo by Cliff Hutson available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
30
Some natural flavorings can cause allergic reactions.
• Not common in this industry• Runny nose (rhinitis)• Asthma
– Allergic reactions to• Shellfish, fish, eggs, flour, some spices
• Rarely, a body-wide allergic reaction– Hives– Swelling of the mouth and throat– Chest tightness, shortness of breath– Allergic reactions to
• Shellfish, fish, some spices• Peanuts and other tree nuts
31
Photo available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
Photo by Bierfaß available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
Bronchiolitis Obliterans Syndrome (BOS) is scarring in small airways.
• Diacetyl, possibly diacetyl substitutes• After injury, scars form. • Scars cause airways to narrow.
Normal airway Late BOS
Images by National Jewish Health
Early BOS
32
EarlyScarring
Inflammation
Airwayinjury Permanent
Scarring
Diacetyl and diacetyl substitutes do not have good warning properties.
It is important to find BOS early!
• Early: Mild airway narrowing– Mild breathing symptoms– Removal from exposure can help prevent
worsening.• Late: Severe airway narrowing
– Severe breathing symptoms– Nothing makes BOS better -- medications do not
help.
Normal airway
Late BOS
Figures by National Jewish Health
Early BOS
EarlyScarring
Inflammation
Airwayinjury Permanent
Scarring
33
Avoid breathing in diacetyl and substitutes.
• BOS has been found in workers exposed to butter flavorings.– Popcorn manufacturing workers – Flavor manufacturing workers – Diacetyl production workers
34
Photo by NIOSH available under public domain
• These workers had exposure to high levels of diacetyl.• In animals, diacetyl causes airway injury and
scars. • Diacetyl substitutes may not be better.
It is important to keep exposures to diacetyl and diacetyl substitutes as low as possible.
It is important to find BOS early!
If you are exposed to diacetyl or diacetyl substitutes:
– Report unexplained breathing symptoms to Human Resources or Health and Safety and to your doctor.
– Participate in medical surveillance.
Photo by National Jewish Health
35
Talk to your doctor about your symptoms and your work with
flavorings
Flavoring-Related Lung Disease (NIOSH)– Available on the NIOSH website
(www.cdc.gov/niosh)
NIOSH 2011
36
Medical Surveillance:Questionnaires and Breathing
Tests• Breathing Test (Spirometry)
– How much air you can breathe in and out– How fast you can blow air out– Testing is recommended at
least every year.• Every 6 months (CalOSHA)
• Are the results normal?– Compared to other people who are your same
age, height, and gender• Are the results normal for you?
– Are the results similar to your past test results?
Photo by National Jewish Health
37
Repeated breathing tests are needed.
25 years of age
FirstTest
1) Is the result normal? YES
Test After 5 Years
of Work 2) Is the result
normal for you?YESNO
Keep your test results.
Normal
38
Special tests are needed to diagnose work-related lung
disease.• If your test results
are not normal for you– Repeat the
breathing test.
• If the test is still not normal for you, the doctor will do more testing to find out the cause.
Photo by National Jewish Health
39
Photo by National Jewish Health
Protect Your Lungs!• Keep your exposure to all
“High Priority” flavorings as low as possible.
• Do not rely on smell or irritation to warn you about exposure.
• Report new or worsening breathing symptoms.
• Don’t smoke!Photo available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
40
FEMA LISTED
HIGH PRIORITYMATERIAL
FOLLOW APPROPRIATE ENGINEERING AND PROCEDURAL CONTROLS TO MINIMIZE EXPOSURE
Image by National Jewish Health
Flavoring Exposure Recognition and
Control
Training Goals• Recognize flavorings and work processes where you might be exposed
• Understand the methods used to measure flavoring exposure
• Understand the proper use of control methods to reduce exposure to flavorings 41
How do I know if it is hazardous?
• Labeling of individual flavorings and compounded flavors
• Handling precautions on batch sheets– Health effects– Proper handling– Necessary
precautions• MSDS or SDS
readily availableFigure by National Jewish Health
Figures by Torsten Henning available under public domain from Wikimedia Commons
42
Workers need to be alerted when working with “High Priority”
flavorings
WARNING – This flavor may pose an inhalation hazard if improperly handled. Please contact your workplace safety officer before opening and handling, and read the MSDS. Handling of this flavor that results in inhalation of fumes, especially if the flavor is heated, may cause severe adverse health effects.
Hazard Communication
What does exposure to flavorings look like?
Possible exposure anywhere “High Priority” flavorings are:
– Sampled– Weighed– Mixed– Poured– Transferred– Packaged
43
Flavoring particles and vapors quickly move into a worker’s
breathing zone unless removed at the source.
How are exposures measured?• Personal air samples
– Estimate the amount of flavoring a worker might inhale into their lungs
– Workers wear sampling pump for entire work shift
• Different air sampling collectors for different flavorings
• Currently, no method for diacetyl powders
Sample collector in “breathing zone”
Worker “wears” sampling pump
Particle/Dust Collectors
Gas/Vapor Collectors
Photos by National Jewish Health
44
Exposures can change depending on the tasks performed and the products
produced.
What does the level of exposure depend on?
• Amount of “High Priority” flavoring used
• Amount of time exposed• How well the vessels are sealed• Ventilation• Liquids
– Pouring distance– Use of funnels
• Powders – Hand scooping– Sifting– Packaging
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
45
Short-term high exposures AND longer term lower exposures are both important.
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
• 0.91 ppm (n=63)
• 0.99 ppm (n=2)• 0.46 ppm (n=3)• 0.099 ppm
(n=21)• 0.030 ppm
(n=2)
Liquid CompoundingAverage
8-Hour Exposures
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
What levels of diacetyl havebeen measured in
flavorings?
46
NJHOSHANIOS
H
8-Hour Exposure Limits• NIOSH: 0.005 ppm• ACGIH: 0.01 ppm• TERA: 0.2 ppm
Many flavor worker tasks have short-term diacetyl exposures over 2 ppm.Little information available on exposures to other “High Priority” flavorings.
QA LaboratoriesAverage
8-Hour Exposures• 0.004 ppm
(n=7)• 0.07 ppm (n=3)• 0.009 ppm
(n=3)Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
Powder ProcessingAverage
8-Hour Exposures
• 0.71 ppm (n=31)
• 0.05 ppm (n=10)
• 0.34 ppm (n=3)• 0.22 ppm (n=9)
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
2-Hour Exposures
Spray Drying8-Hour Exposure
• 1.5 ppm (n=1)
• 2.6 ppm (n=6)
How are flavoring exposures controlled?
47
Elimination & Substitution
Engineering ControlsWork
Practice Controls
PPE
High Exposure
Acceptable Exposure
Personal protective equipment: respirators, gloves, goggles, and
protective clothing
Changes in procedures or worker behavior to reduce
exposure
Changes that capture or enclose the source
of exposure
Changes in raw materials or flavoringsDecreasing
Effectiveness Increasing dependence on worker behavior
Does substitution work?
Larger molecules– Pros:
• Lower exposures• Less evaporation at room
temperature – Cons:
• Chemically similar to diacetyl• May have similar health effects
Figures by National Jewish Health48
Diacetyl Substitutes
Until there is more information available, diacetyl and diacetyl substitutes should be controlled the same.
O
O
Diacetyl
2,3-Pentanedione
O
O2,3-Hexanedione
O
O 2,3-Heptanedione
O
O
What is the best solution?
• Closed lines for all ingredients and finished products
• Closed vessel cleaning system
• Containment verified with air sampling
• Maintenance workers may still be exposed.
49
Completely Enclosed Processes
Photo by National Jewish Health used with written permission.
May not be a realistic solution due to cost and production variability.
What is the next best solution?
50
Local Exhaust
Ventilation
Process Isolation
Work Practice Controls
Combination of controls used to
reduce exposures to acceptable levels
What is process isolation?• Designated area or
room for work with “High Priority” flavorings
• Separate ventilation system from offices or other production areas
• Lidded tanks and vessels
• Flavorings stored in sealed containers
• Volatile “High Priority” flavorings kept in cold storage
Photo by National Jewish Health used with written permission.
51Reduces exposure levels and the number of exposed
workers
What is local exhaust ventilation?
• Suction to remove flavoring prior to worker exposure
• Effective if properly designed and used
• Requires worker training
52Most important control to reduce exposure to
flavorings!
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission.
Does ventilation reduce exposure?
53
Photo by NIOSH available under public domain.
Figure by NIOSH available under public domain.
Ventilation reduces exposures when properly
designed and used correctly!
How do I use ventilation correctly?
• Capture depends on distance from the capturing hood• Capture greatly decreases at a distance of two duct
diameters• Cross drafts reduce the capture of flavorings
Contains public sector information published by the Health and Safety Executive and licensed under the Open Government Licence v1.0
54Work as closely as possible to the ventilation hood!
What can I do to reduce exposure?
• Keep temperatures of liquids as low as possible.
• Replace lids immediately after adding flavorings.
• Pour slowly and use funnels.• Add “High Priority”
flavorings last.• Avoid pouring from 55 gallon
drums.• Avoid hand scooping
powders.• Make sure other workers in
your area know when you are using “High Priority” flavorings.
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission
55Use engineering controls properly all of the
time!
What if I am a laboratory worker?
• Use the lab hood for handling “High Priority” flavorings.
• Keep containers closed as much as possible.
• Avoid odor evaluations of high concentration or neat “High Priority” flavorings.
56
Photo by New-Tech™ used with written permission.
Laboratory workers can have high exposures!
What about cleaning?• Use HEPA vacuum for
cleaning powder spills.• Use cold water to pre-
rinse mixing vessels prior to cleaning with hot water.
• Keep work areas where flavorings are handled clean.
57Photos used by National Jewish Health with written permission
Clean-up spills immediately to prevent unnecessary exposure.
When should I use a respirator?• When exposures cannot be
controlled in other ways• When employees complain
of irritation regardless of exposure level
• When using diacetyl and diacetyl substitutes– Always with diacetyl or
diacetyl substitute powder exposures
– Always when exposures have not been measured
– To keep exposures as low as possible
Photo by National Jewish Health
58
Respirators are a last choice for controlling exposures, but may be an important part of the
solution in the flavoring industry.
How do I know my respirator is working?• Yearly training
• Must fit properly– Fit tested annually– No facial hair
• Must have the right cartridges– Organic vapor for liquid
exposures– Organic vapor + P100 for
powder exposures• Cartridges don’t last
forever– Need change-out schedule– If you can smell it, you
should change it.59
Photo by Jeanne Mozier available under public domain.
Respirators are only effective when used properly!
Photo by Stuart Butterfield available under CCA-2.0.
Human Hair
Glass Fiber
Asbestos Fiber
Fume Particles
Figure by National Jewish Health
What about skin and eye protection?
• Use gloves and aprons appropriate for flavoring exposure– Chemical resistant gloves
and aprons are made from:• Nitrile• Butyl rubber• Teflon™• Tychem ™
• Tight-fitting eye goggles not safety glasses
60
Photo used by National Jewish Health with written permission
PPE is only effective when used properly!
How does it all fit together?
61
Elimination & SubstitutionEngineering
ControlsWork Practice
ControlsPPE
Acceptable Exposure
Use of “High Priority” FlavorsExposure Recognition
Exposure MonitoringHigh Exposure
Temporary controls when
not enough exposure
measurements
No controls needed
Medical surveillance:Helps protect workers when little is known
about exposure
Questions?
Photo by National Jewish Health
This material was produced under grant number SH-22304-11-60-F-8 from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, U.S. Department of Labor. It does not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the U.S. Department of Labor, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations imply endorsement by the U. S. Government.
62