Download pdf - Ligeti Yu 41

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ligeti-yu-41 1/22

..3

2TNB@6OB5 \WML "LL&O "e&FMG"L MGE"%%"#&EMHGLWMDL HI T&%MHKL 'M&EHGMN F&E"%MMG fM$"EMgL XEK'" ;H@ .7 n7GFC8 :< 7GFC8?j IHNKLMG$ HG E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HD"%EM"L [E^""G 'MII"%"GE 'M&EHGMN E%MNWH%'L@ fM$"EMgL 'MLEMGNEMT" E%"&EF"GEL HI 'M&EH%"I#"NE EW" KEM#M_&EMHG HI E%M&'MN MGE"%T&##MN LE%KNEK%"L MG E%&GLIH%F&E

D&%EMNK#&%( MN7 'HFMG&E"L MG &[KG'&GN"( NHGE%M[KEMG$ EH EW" NHGLHG&GE EHG&E^""G T&%MHKL DMENWBN#&LL E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL &FHG$ E%MNWH%'L( &G' EW&E LHF" MGE"%NHGG"NE"' [O NHFFHG EHG"L IH% D%"L"%TMG$ 'M&EHGMN NHW"%"GE LHKG'@ Z''MELHF" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL &%" &G&#H$HKL EH EHG&# D%HN"'K%"L = W&%FHGM"L D%H$%"LEH 'HFMG&GE H% LK['HFMG&GE &G' TMN" T"%L& = EW&E F&GMI"LEL fM$"EMgL D%HGHKGN"' %EH EW" NHGE"eE HI EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%&NEMN" &L EW%"" DMENWBN#&LL"L &FEOD"L HI E%MNWH%'L F&D HGEH "&NW HEW"% LH#"#O [O MN7@ Z#HG$ ^MEW EW" NHW"%"LHKG' EW&E fM$"EM IH%$"L( EHG&# NHGE%&LEL &%" &NWM"T"' EW%HK$W LMFK#E&G"HKL%"GN"L ["MG$ "LE&[#MLW"' [O E%&GLIH%F"' DMENWBN#&LL"L( IH%FMG$ EHG&# D&M%MG$L#&EMHGLWMD ^MEW MNL / &G' < EW&E M##KFMG&E" EW" E%&'MEMHG&#MLEMN EHGMN &

D%"T&M#MG$ MG EW" GMG"E""GEW N"GEK%O@3<UV8@?N5 fM$"EM( E%&GLIH%F&EMHG( 'HK[#" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG( NHFFHG EHG"( 'M&EHGNWH%'( 'M&EHGMN NH##"NEMHG( FMN%HDH#ODWHGO( W&%FHGMN G"EBLE%KNEK%"( EHGT&#BN#&LL@

Z;Zf9:X:

Z%EMN#" %"N"MT"' HG ,, :"DE"F["% ,-./Z%EMN#" &NN"DE"' HG /- :"DE"F["% ,-./

0125 34C@,@-43@7@-4h@C

,$(T=9/(2 O-\W" UHG$ QHG$ *GLEMEKE" HI X'KN&EMHG2K#EK%&# &G' 2%"&EMT" Z%EL 1"D&%EF"GEJKLMN&# Z%EL 1MTMLMHG

&+2%(L$+)2&/$%( $L =/2&$%/# )2&'+/20( 2%= &$%20*+$#'=.+'( /% 0/1'&/R( ()3.( ,#1 45 67/&)( #, 7/&)( j

m ZKEWH% NHGE&NE MGIH%F&EMHG5 F&GNWMG$OKcFLG@NHF

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

.,-

'O&'L ^MEWMG EW" NW%HF&EMN LN&#" ["GNWF&%Y"' MG WML "&%#M"% ^H%YL@ LD"NMIMN &EE"GEMHG EH EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HD"%EM"L HI DMENWBN##"T"#L &G' MG 'MII"%"GE 'MF"GLMHGL HI EW" DM"N"@ JH%"HT"%( * IK%EW"% NHGE"GfM$"EM NHGE%&LEL '%&LEMN&##O ^MEW WML "&%#M"% FMN%HDH#ODWHGMN E"N&%" D%HFMG"GE#O I"&EK%"' [O L&EK%&EMG$( KGIH#'MG$( &G' E%&GLIH%FMG$ NWN"##L &G' 'O&'L( [O F&eMF&##O "FD#HOMG$ NHGLHG&GE MGE"%T&#., MN7 &G' D%"L"%TBMG$ EHG&#MEM"L &G' E%&'MEMHG&# &DD%H&NW"L IH% $HT"%GMG$ W&%FHGMN ZL & F&EE"% HI I&NE( EW" LM$GMIMN&GN" HI MN7 W&L [""G WM$W#M$WE"' MG :Y"ENW V&$" * IH% '898[;<[ ./ @ ZL M##KLE%&E"' MG "e&FD#" .( fM$"EM ^%ME"L IHK%

D"%I"NE IMIEWL &G' EW" D&%EMNK#&% MGE"%T&#L L"%T" &L N"GE%&# &%%MT&^W"%" T&%MHKL NW%HF&EMN 'O&'L KGIH#'@ \W" NHGE%&LEMG$ NHGLHG&GE qK&#L"%T"L &L & [&LML IH% 'MLD#&OMG$ E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL &G' EHG&# D

EW%HK$WHKE EW" IM%LE FHT"F"GE HI n7GFC8 :< 7GFC8@j

*G (C;=8 ,:1 45 67GFC8 :< 7GFC8 (j 'M&EHGMNMLF MG &LLHNM&EMHG ^MEW NHGLG&GE.< EHG&# LHKG' [&L"' HG &## DMENW"L HI EW" ^WME" Y"OL.7 ML LH N"GE%&# EW&E EW"LHKG' %"I#"NEL fM$"EMgL &DD#MN&EMHG HI E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# E"NWGMqK"L@ &## 'M&EHGMN L"EBN#&LL"L MG T&%MHKL E%&GLDHLMEMHG&# #"T"#L &%" "eD#H&%" FH%" HIE"G 'MLD#&O"' MG & NHG'"GL&EMHG&# IH%F HI E%MNWH%'&# NHGIM$K

\W"L" 'M&EHGMN L"EBN#&LL"L 'HFMG&E" EW" ^WH#" FHT"F"GE &E T&%MHKL #"T"#L IT"%EMN&# EH WH%M_HGE&# 'MF"GLMHGL( F&GMI"LEMG$ fM$"EMgL KL" HI "NHGHFM

!" U"%" * NHGE"G' EW&E MNL . &G' 7 &%" MG LE&%Y NHGE%&LEL MG E"%FL HI EW" G&EK%" HI 'M&G' NHGLHG&GN"@!# :"" 2KNMK%"&GgL 6,-.,( D@ ,,/8 "LL&O@!$ S&%MHKL EW"H%MLEL W&T" '"#MG"&E"' "eD#MNME#O EW" #"T"# HI NHGLHG&GN"L &G' 'MLLHG&NH%'MG$ EH UH^&%' U&GLHG 6.hC-8( SMGN"GE V"%LMNW"EEM 6.hC.8( &G' V&K# UMG'"FMEW 6.h<

D"%I"NE MGE"%T&#L MGN#K'" D"%I"NE <EW &G' D"%I"NE 7EW W&TMG$ EW" FHLE NHGLHG&GE LHKG'@!%

* %"I"% EH EW" ^WME" Y"OL HI EW" DM&GH Y"O[H&%'( %"I#"NEMG$ EW" EME#" n]WME" HG ]WME

Xe&FD#" .5 :Y"ENW V&$" * IH% '898[;<[ "FDW&LM_"L D"%I"NE IMIEWL

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


.,.

HJ<N+GF<[ n;b )DJ<LO:DPJCF:<L :O .FJC:<FV HJC8DFJML 1@@ 6..3=./48

EHG&# F&E"%M&#L.C IH% $"G"%&EMG$ NHW"%"GE LHKG'@ Z''MEMHG&##O( & LE%MNE N&%"#&EMHGLWMD 'HFMG&E"L ["E^""G EW" KDD"% &G' [HEEHF #&O"%L HI EW" DM"NLK[L"qK"GE#O NHFFHG EHG"L "eE"GLMT"#O "eMLE ["E^""G &'R&N"GE E%MNWH%'L I'MLD#&OMG$ & LFHHEW E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL@ \W" WH%M_HGE&# NHKG"GE"' N&GHGMN D%HN"LL NHF[MG"L ^MEW EW" T"%EMN&# W&%FHGMNBH%M"GE"' IT&%MHKL E%MNWH%'&# F&E"%M&#L( N%"&EMG$ & LK[LE&GEMT" 'M&EHGMN T&%EHG&# D%HN"'K%"L.3 &%" F&GMI"LE"' &L & %"LK#E HI EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""E%MNWH%'L( &G' EW"L" D&%EMNK#&% E%M&'MN MGE"%T&# N#&LL"L &%" "FD#HG&GE#O IH% E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L 'K%MG$ EW" NHK%L" HI E

;"T"%EW"#"LL( EW" EHG&# D%HN"'K%"L F&GMI"LE fM$"EMgL '%&^MG$ HG EW" D&LEGMqK"L &G' M##KFMG&E" fM$"EMgL LD"NM&# F&GMDK#&EMHG HI 'M&EHGMN F&E"#&E" ^H%Y@

Xe&FD#" , M##KLE%&E"L "&NW E%MNWH%'&# NHGIM$K%&EMHG 'MLD#&O"' N&# 'MF"GLMHG( &G' MG F@ . EW"%" &%" L"T"G 'MII"%"GE E%MNWH%'&# NHGIM$K^MEW 'MII"%"GE DMENW N#&LL"L MG EW" KDD"% &G' #H^"% #&O"%L@ 2HFFHG EHG

D%"L"%T"' ["E^""G "&NW D&M% HI G"M$W[H%MG$ E%MNWH%'L( %"LK#EMG$ I%HF E

N&GHGMN %"#&EMHGLWMD ["E^""G EW" KDD"% &G' [HEEHF #&O"%L I%HF s[g EH sWMGLE&GN"( HG" NHFFHG EHG" DN h "eMLEL ["E^""G NWH%' s[g &G' NWH%' sNgr E^HNHFFHG EHG"L DN < &G' 3 "eMLE ["E^""G NWH%' sNg &G' NWH%' s'(g &G' LH IH%EW@\W" NHGLE&GE D%"L"%T&EMHG HI NHFFHG EHG"L LE%HG$#O NHGL"%T"L EW" &IIM#&EMHGLWMD &G' EW" LMFM#&% 'M&EHGMN LHKG' ["E^""G "&NW D&M% HI E%MNW

!& U"%"MG * KL" nDHLEBEHG&# F&E"%M&#Lj EH '"LN%M[" T&%MHKL 'M&EHGMN L"EBN#&LL"L E%&GLDHLMEMHG&# %"#&EMHGLWMDL@!' * KL" EW" E"%F nEHG&# D%HN"'K%"Lj IH% %"I"%%MG$ EH &## EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%

#&E"' EH W&%FHGMN D%H$%"LLMHGL &G' IH%FMG$ EHG&#MEM"L@

Xe&FD#" ,5 2W&MG HI NHFFHG EHG"L ["E^""G "&NW &'R&N"GE E%MNWH%'LI%HF s[g EHsWg MG F@ .

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

.,,

&L LFHHEWMG$ EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL ["E^""G "&NW NWH%'r WH^"T"NHFFHG EHG"L ["E^""G "&NW D&M% &%" MG &G HNE&T" %"#&EMHGLWMD@ ZL LW"e&FD#" ,( DN h MG NWH%' sNg ML &G HNE&T" #H^"% EW&G EW&E MG NWH%' s[@g 1"EW" nHNE&T" E%&GLI"%j(.4 EW" L"GL" HI L&F"G"LL ["E^""G EW" NHFFHG EHG"L MLGHE '"LE%HO"'( &L EW"O ["#HG$ EH EW" L&F" DMENWBN#&LL"L( &G' ME &#LH HII"%MGE"%"LEMG$ ^&O EH "NWH EW" L&F" DMENWBN#&LL"L MG &G HNE&T" "qKMT&#"GLWMD ["E^""G "&NW E%MNWH%'&# D&M%L@ fM$"EM '%&^L HG EW" NW&%&NE"%MLEFHGMN D%H$%"LLMHG HI EW" E%&'MEMHG&# W&%FHGMN D%&NEMN" [O D%"L"%TEHG"L ["E^""G E%M&'MN F&E"%M&#L( WH^"T"%( EW" NHFFHG EHG"L MG EWML DM"N"&G HNE&T" %"$MLE%&# %"#&EMHGLWMD ^WMNW ML qKME" &G MGE"%"LEMG$ E%"&

!"N&KL" HI EW" T&LE &FHKGEL HI NHFFHG EHG"L( E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL &FHGGHGBNHFFHG EHG"L "F"%$" ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L@ Xe&FD#" / %"T"&#L EW&E "eE"GLMTE%&GLIH%F&EMHGL HNNK% ["E^""G 'MII"%"GE DMENWBN#&LL"L@ *G E%MNWH%' s[

DN .. LD#ME MGEH & 'O&'( [O E%&GLIH%FMG$ MGEH DNL < &G' 3r DN h MG E%MNWE%&GLIH%FL MGEH DN , MG E%MNWH%' s'(g LMFM#&%#O( DN < &G' DN 3 LD#ME MG^MEW DNL 3 &G' h( &G' LH IH%EW@ \W" MGE"%T&# N#&LL"L HI &## EW" E%&GLIH%F&EE^""G DMENWBN#&LL"L &%" HT"%^W"#FMG$#O 'HFMG&E"' [O MNL7 &G' /( ^WMNW &%"

D&%&FHKGE MGE"%T&##MN LE%KNEK%" HI & E%M&'@ \W" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL &% [O EW" NHGLHG&GE E%M&'MN MGE"%T&#L IH% $"G"%&EMG$ EHG&# LHKG' &G' EWHLNW&MGL HI NHGLHG&GE LYMDL.h HI MNL/ &G' 7 LE%HG$#O LE&[M#M_" EW" NHGLHG&GE &G

!( \W" nHNE&T" E%&GLI"%j EW&E * &''%"LL W"%" ML EW" LD&EM&# E%&GLDHLMEMHG HI EW" NH ["#HG$MG$ EH EW" L&F" DMENWBN#&LL"L@

!) U"%" EW" NHGLHG&GE LYMD EW&E * F"GEMHG ML &G &LLHNM&EMHG&# FH'"#( ^WMNW ML 'MEW&E HI EW" NHGN"DE KL"' MG EW" E%&'MEMHG&# :NW"GY"%M&G ZG&#OLML@ \WML NHGLHG&LM_"L EW" E%M&'MN NHGLHG&GE MGE"%T&##MN N#&LL"L( MN/( <( &G' 7 HD"%&EMG$ HG E%&GL

E^""G E%MNWH%'L@

Xe&FD#" /5 \%&GLIH%F&EMHG HI 'MII"%"GE DNL ["E^""G G"M$W[H%MG$ E%MNWH%'L I%HF s[g E

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


.,/


EHG&# qK&#MEO HI EW" D&LL&$"@ *E LWHK#' [" GHE"^H%EWO EW&E MN7( ^WMNW "%"' &L EW" FHLE NHGLHG&GE MGE"%T&# MG & E%M&'( "eWM[MEL MEL F&eMFKF HN\WML MGE"%T&# D#&OL & LM$GMIMN&GE %H#" MG IH%$MG$ NHGLHG&GE &G' EHG&

DM"N"( &L ^"## &L %"I#"NEMG$ EW" DK%MEO HI 'M&EHGMN LHKG'@

:HF" MGE"%"LEMG$ EHG&# DW"GHF"GHG &%ML"L &L & %"LK#E HI EW" E%&GLEMHGL( #"&'MG$ EH EW" IH%F&EMHG HI EHG&# D&M%MG$,- &E EW" D%"#MFMG&%O L"NEMHG HIEW" DM"N"@ \W" IH%F&EMHG #&E"% IH%"N&LEL EW" "F"%$"GN"L HI HEW"% EHG&#'K%MG$ EW" NHK%L" HI EW" IM%LE E^H F"&LK%"L &G' ME ^M## [" &''%"LL"' MG EW" "MG$ 'MLNKLLMHG@

ZL MG "e&FD#" ,( E%MNWH%'L s[(gs'(g &G' sIg &E EW" [HEEHF #&O"% &%" NW&%&NM_"' [O E^H THMN"L &G' "&NW E%&GLIH%FL MGEH E^H 'MII"%"GE DMENW"L( &G' EWKE%&GLIH%F&EMHGL HNNK%@ Xe&FD#" < M##KLE%&E"L 'HK[#" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGLE^""G E%MNWH%'L s[g &G' sNg( s'g &G' s"g( &G' s"g &G' sIg@ \W" %"LK#E %"T"&#L EW&E M"F"%$"L MG LMe E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL"L( MNL/ &G' < &DD"&% E^MN"( &G' M, LWH^ EW"M% FMGMFKF HNNK%%"GN"L@ \WKL( ME ML "TM'"GE EW&E E%M&'MN N#&LL 7 'HFMG&E"L EW" 'HK[#" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL"L@ *G &''MEMHG( EWN&EMHG HI EW" KGMHGL HI E^H 'MII"%"GE E%M&'L( 2 F&RH% &G' X FMGH%( ML MF&$"G"%&E"' [O LMFK#E&G"HKL NHGLHG&GE FHEMHGL@ \W" NHF[MG&EMHG HI EW"

IH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL"L HI [HEW E%M&'L %"LK#EL MG EHG&# D&M%MG$( N%"&EEHGMN NHFD#"e,. EW&E NHFD%ML"L EW" DMENW"L 2BXBaB!@ ZDD&%"GE#O( & 2 EHGML DHE"GEM&##O MFD#MN&E"' MG EW" NHFD#"e &G' MEL LM$GMIMN&GN" $%&'K&#

"* \HG&# V&M%MG$ W&L [""G IM%LE &''%"LL"' [O AH["%E !&M#"O 6.h478 MG WML ^H%Y HG ]&$G"%ML $"G"%&##O '"IMG"' &L & LMEK&EMHG ̂ W"%" E^H EHGMNL LMFK#E&G"HKL#O HNNKDO EW" L&F^MEWMG & EHG&# WM"%&%NWO@"! 1HK[#"BEHGMN NHFD#"e W&L &#LH [""G MGE%H'KN"' [O AH["%E !&M#"O 6.h478 &G' ME ML IH%F

[O EW" KGMHGL HI E^H 'MII"%"GE E%M&'L MG EWM%' %"#&EMHGLWMD( &L MG EWML N&L"( EW"

2 F&RH% &G' X FMGH% E%M&'L EH IH%F 2BXBaB!@

Xe&FD#" <5 1HK[#" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L s[g &G' sNg(s'g&G' s"g( &G' sIg &G' s$g

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

.,<

'K%MG$ EW" NHK%L" HI EW" DM"N"@ PH% MGLE&GN"( MEL IM%LE &%%MT&# MG E%"G' HI F@. F&%YL EW" IM%LE N&'"GEM&# DHMGE 6L"" "e&FD#" ,8@ ?G EW" HEW"% W&G Z FMGH% EHG&#MEO $%&'K&##O NHGIH%FL IH% "LE&[#MLWMG$ EHG&# IHNKL EW" 2 EHG&# N"GE%"@ \W%HK$WHKE EW" ^WH#" DM"N" EW" LMFK#E&G"HKL "F"%$HI Z FMGH% &G' 2 F&RH% EHG&# N"GE"%L D#&O D%HFMG"GE %H#"L MG LOGEW"LM_EHG&#MEM"L HI EW" DM"N"@

\W" FKLMN ML MGMEM&E"' ^MEW &G MFDH%E&GE 'O&' ^MEW DNL- &G' .. &E EW ["&E MG F@. &G' ME E%&GLIH%FL MGEH DNh MG E%MNWH%' s[(g 6L"" "e&FD#" /8r EW" IH%F&EMHG L"%T"L &L & %"LH#KEMHG %"L"F[#MG$ EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%MFD#MN&EMG$ &G Z FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO@ !O MGE"%&NEMG$ EW" Z FMGH%ML^MEW DNL < &G' 3 MG E%MNWH%' sNg( & $"G"%&#M_"' E"%EM&G hEW NWH%' ML LKD"&L LWH^G MG "e&FD#" 7@ \WML E"%EM&G NWH%' %"T"&#L EW" NHFDHL"%gL W&%LM$G&EK%" L"EBN#&LL 7=,3( "F"%$MG$ MG WML #&E"% LEO#"@,, JH%"HT"%( EW" MGE"%T&##MNLE%KNEK%" HI EW" NWH%' %"I#"NEL &G MGE"%T&# NON#" 'HFMG&EMG$ EW" LMGN#&LL"L &L LWH^G MG "e&FD#" C@ \W" &LN"G'MG$ &%D"$$M&EMHG HI DNL ,( 7( h( &-( ^MEW EW" "eN"DEMHG HI DN<( HKE#MG" &G MGE"%T&# NON#" IM##"' ^MEW MNL / &HEW"% ^H%'L( EW" MGE"%T&##MN D&EE"%G( MN/=MN<=MN/=MN<( ML NHG'"GL"' ^MEFMGH%MLW E"%EM&G hEW NWH%' MG "e&FD#" 7@ ZL ^" N&G L""( NHGLHG&GE MGE"%T&#L MNMN<( &G' MN7 D#&O NHGLE%KNEMT" %H#"L MG LOGEW"LM_MG$ DMENW F&E"%M&'MF"GLMHGL &E EW" FKLMN&# LK%I&N" "T"G EWHK$W EW" ^WH#" DM"N" ML NWM"I#G&E"' [O DHLEBEHG&# L"EBN#&LL"L ^MEW 'MLLHG&GN"L FMGH% ,G' &G' 3EW &G' F&RH% ,G' &G' 3EW@ 6Xe&FD#" ,8

*GE"%"LEMG$#O( &GHEW"% HNN&LMHG HI EHG&# D&M%MG$L N&G &#LH [" LHK D#" 38( WH^"T"%( EW"L" EHG&# D&M%MG$L ["E^""G 1B &G' P‡,/ NHFD%ML" DMENW"L D%HB R"NE"' &E & #&%$"% LK%I&N" #"T"# &G' EW"O &%" MG EWM%'B%"#&E"' EHG&# %"#&EZL LWH^G MG "e&FD#" 3( GHGB'HEE"' &%%H^L MG'MN&E" EW&E E%&GLIH%F&EMHG

D#&N" ["E^""G 'MII"%"GE LMG$#" DMENWBN#&LL"L( ^W"%"&L 'HEE"' &%%H^L %"D%"NHFFHG DMENWBN#&LL"L ["E^""G EW" KDD"% &G' #H^"% #&O"%L@ ZL F"GEMHG"' D%"HKL#O MG "e&FD#" /( [O WH#'MG$ NHFFHG EHG"L ["E^""G &'R&N"GE E%MNWH%'L( E%&GIH%F&EMHGL HI 'MII"%"GE DMENWBN#&LL"L E&Y" D#&N" ["E^""G EW" #H^"% &G' K#&O"%L@ *G "e&FD#" C( DN h MG E%MNWH%' sNg E%&GLIH%FL MGEH DN , MG E%M&G' EWKL 'K" EH EW" L&F" DNL h DHLL"LL"' [O E%MNWH%'L s[g &G' sN(g E%&GLIH%FEMHG &#LH E&Y"L D#&N" MG EW" KDD"% #&O"% ["E^""G DN h MG E%MNWH%' s[g &G' E%MNWH%' s'(g &G' LH IH%EW@ :K[L"qK"GE#O( EW" NW&MG HI E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL E

"" fM$"EM "FD#HOL WML EODMN&# E%MNWH%'&# LM$G&#L &L & I&FM#O HI LK[L"EL ^WMNW &D ["''"' LE%KNEK%"L ^MEWMG FH%" NHFD#"e LK%I&N" W&%FHGM"L EW&E &%ML" EW%HK$W E%&GLNHF[MG&EMHG HI L"EBN#&LL"L /=, 6-./8( /=C 6-,<8( /=3 6-,78( /=.- 6-/C8( &G' /=.. 6-/3862KNMK%"&G ,-.,( D@ ,,78@"#

U"%" * KL" EW" LM$GL ‡ &G' = EH '"GHE" F&RH% &G' FMGH% %"LD"NEMT"#O@ 6:E%&KL .748

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


.,7


"eE"GLMT"#O ["E^""G 'MII"%"GE LMG$#" DMENWBN#&LL"L MG EW" KDD"% #&O"% &LMG "e&FD#" 3@ \W" MGE"%T&# NON#" EW&E 'HFMG&E"L EW" &%D"$$M&E"' DMENWBN"e&FD#" 3 ML EW" L&F" &L EW" MGE"%T&# N#&LL"L EW&E 'HFMG&E" EW" E%&GLIH%

["E^""G 'MII"%"GE DMENWBN#&LL"L MG EW" KDD"% &G' #H^"% #&O"%L MG "e&FD#"

HEW"% ^H%'L( E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL $HT"%G EW" E%M&'MN &%D"$$M&EMHG HI EW" DMG EW" KDD"% #&O"% MG "e&FD#" 3@

PK%EW"%FH%"( EW" MFDH%E&GN" HI EW" LMG$#" HKE#MG"' DMENWBN#&LLKDD"% #&O"% MG "e&FD#" 3 N&G &#LH [" F&GMI"LE"' [O EW" FHEMHG&# E"G'"GNO H"&NW DMENWBN#&LLgL D%"TMHKL 'O&'@ \WML ML &G&#H$HKL EH EW" %"LH#KEHI EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%&NEMN" D"%MH'( M@"@ D&%EMNK#&% DMENW LH#T"L EH EW" G"M$W[H%MG$ DMENW [O F"&GL HI LE"D^ML" FHEMHG@ *G EWML KGLE&[#" 'O&' HG EW" 'H^G ["&E( DNL - &G' ..( MG NWH%' s&g( E"G'L EH $%&TME&E"EH^&%' EW" %&EW"% LE&[#" LMG$#" DN h MG NWH%' s[g HG EW" KD["&E &G' LH &L EW

HI EW" E%MNWH%'L I%HF sNg EH sR(g WH^"T"%( EW" 'O&' ^MEW DNL 7 &G' 3 MG NWH%

Xe&FD#" C5 *GE"%T&# NON#" IM##"' ^MEW MNL/ &G' < IH%F"' [O LMG$#" DMENWBN#&LL"L

Xe&FD#" 75 \"%EM&G hEW NWH%' ^MEW %HHE Z ML IH%F"' &L & %"LK#E HI EW" LKD"%MFDHLMEMEW%"" E%M&'L( ZB( 2‡( &G' X MG F@.

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

.,C

%"LH#T"L EH DN < MG NWH%' sGg &G' EWML %"LH#KEMHG ML '"#&O"' [O DNL - &G' , MGE^""G@ !O NHF[MGMG$ EW" HKE#MG"' %"LH#T"' DMENW"L MG E%MNWH%'L s[(gs'(g sI(g&G' sR(g EW%"" 'MII"%"GE E%M&'L N&G [" IH%F"'( 1B( P‡( &G' ZB E%M&'L &L M##KLE%&MG "e&FD#" 3@ \HG&# D&M%MG$L ["E^""G 1B &G' P‡ &L ^"## &L P‡ &G' ZB $"G"%&E"E^H D&M%L HI EWM%'B%"#&E"' EHG&# N"GE"%L@ \W"L" D%HGHKGN"' EHG&# %"#&W&%Y [&NY EH EW" .hEW N"GEK%O ^W"%" EWM%'B%"#&E"' EHG&# N"GE"%L &%" & NHFFHG

D#&N",< @ *G &''MEMHG( [O NHF[MGMG$ &## EW%"" E%M&'L EH$"EW"%( &G MFD#MN&EMhEW NWH%' N&G [" IH%F"' &L LWH^G MG "e&FD#" 4@ \W" NWH%' ML F&'" KD HI EW"

LKD"%MFDHLMEMHG HI EW%"" 'MII"%"GE E%M&'L &G' EW" nKDD"% LE%KNEK%",7

j HI EW" NWH%'ML F&'" KD HI &G ZB E%M&'@ 1K" EH EW" KDD"%FHLE DMENW"Lg LHKG'MG$ HI EW" nK

"$ \HG&# D&M%MG$L MG EWM%'B%"#&EMHGLWMD &%" &#LH F&GMI"LE"' MG HEW"% E^"GEM"EWB!%H^G 6,--h8 GHE"' EW" D%"T&#"GN" HI EWM%'B%"#&E"' EHG&# D&M%MG$ MG :WHLE&YHTMNWgL "% *G R&__ FKLMN( EW" E"%F KDD"% LE%KNEK%" H% KDD"% LE%KNEK%" E%M&' %"I"%L EH & T

D%H&NW '"T"#HD"' [O R&__ DM&GMLEL &G' &%%&G$"%L( '"IMG"' [O EW" LHKG'MG$ HI & F&RH

FMGH% E%M&' MG EW" KDD"%FHLE DMENW"L HI & FH%" NHFD#"e W&%FHGO@ 6X##"G["%$"%( ,--78

Xe&FD#" 35 A"LH#T"' DMENW"L HKE#MG" EHG&# D&M%MG$L

Xe&FD#" 45 ZGHEW"% E"%EM&G hEW NWH%' ML IH%F"' &L & %"LK#E HI EW" LKD"%MFDHLMEMHG HI EWEW%"" E%M&'L( 1B( P‡( &G' ZB

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


.,3


LE%KNEK%"(j &G Z FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO ML &$&MG "FDW&LM_"'( &G' EW" MFD#MFMGH% EHG&#MEO ["NHF"L D%HGHKGN"' G"&% EW" "G' HI F@,@ *G "e&FD#"L 7 &G' 4EW" E"%EM&G hEW NWH%'L F&GMI"LE L"T"%&# EHG&#MEM"L "F"%$MG$ &E EW" L&F" EMFN%"&EMG$ &G MGE"%"LEMG$ EHG&# DW"GHF"GHG@ \HG&# D&M%MG$L MG EWM%&E 'MII"%"GE #"T"#L 'K%MG$ EW" D%"#MFMG&%O DH%EMHG HI EW" DM"N"( &G' EW" EE"%T&##MN LE%KNEK%"B MN/ &G' MN<= &E EW" #&%$"% LK%I&N" #"T"# MG "e&FD#" F&GMI"LE"' MG EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL"L &E EW" FMN%HLNHDMN #"TEW" E%MNWH%'L MG "e&FD#"L / &G' <@

ZGHEW"% MGE"%"LEMG$ DW"GHF"GHG ML EW&E EW" E^H E"%EM&G E&## NWH&G MN 7 E%&GLDHLMEMHG&# %"#&EMHGLWMD &L LWH^G MG "e&FD#" h@ \WML MMGE"%T&# MGE"%NHGG"NEL EW" E^H FK#EMD#" EHG&# NHFD#"e"L ^WMNW %"L"F[EHG&# D%HN"'K%"5 EW" NON#" HI 7EWL MG EW" E%&'MEMHG&# W&%FHGMN D%H$%"LLMT" NH

&G' EW" EHGMNBLK['HFMG&GE %"#&EMHGLWMD@ Z''MEMHG&##O( NHFFHG EHG"L HI &G Z FMGH% E%M&' &%" $"G"%&E"' KDHG KG'"%$HMG$ MN7 E%&GLDHLMEMHG@"GN" HI EW" NHFFHG EHG"L %"&IIM%FL EW" D%HFMG"GN" HI EW" Z FMGH%MLW EHG'"LDME" EW" D%"L"GN" HI EHG&# D&M%MG$L@

\W" NHGIM%F&EMHG HI Z FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO N&G &#LH [" LHK$WE MG F@ / &MG "e&FD#" .-( LMGN" &GHEW"% EHG&# D&M%MG$ "F"%$"L ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L sN.s'.g@,C *G "e&FD#" .-( DNL < &G' 7 HI E%MNWH%' sN.g KG'"%$H E%&GLIH%F&EMHG [OLD#MEEMG$ MGEH DNL h &G' - HI E%MNWH%' s'.g %"LD"NEMT"#O@

Z$&MG( MN7 'HFMG&E"L EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL &G' %"I#"NEL EW" NHGLHG&

EMHGL ["E^""G EW" DNL@ 0DHG EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL( E^H 'MII"%"GMG EWM%' %"#&EMHGLWMD &%" $"G"%&E"'( Z= &G' P‡@ \HG&# N"GE"% ML L^KG$ ["E%M&'L P‡ &G' ZB( WH^"T"%( Z FMGH% EHG&#MEO ML "FDW&LM_"' MG E%MNWH%' MN7 E%&GLIH%FMG$ EW" DN .. MG E%MNWH%' s'.g MGEH EW" DN< MG E%MNWH%' s".& NHFD#"E" Z FMGH% E%M&'@ *E LWHK#' [" GHE"^H%EWO EW&E EW" Z FMGH% E%MHG#O E%M&' "F"%$MG$ &L & E%MNWH%' MG EW" ^WH#" DM"N"( MG EWML N&L"( E

,C PH% EW" L&Y" HI NHGT"GM"GN"( * #&["# EW" E%MNWH%'L MG F@/ ^MEW &.=W. 'K" EH EW" I&NE NHGEHK%L HI EW" LHD%&GH GHE"L 6EW" KDD"% #&O"%8 MG F@/ &%" EW" L&F" &L EW&E HI EW" LH

MG F@.@ ?[TMHKL#O( EW"%" ML & N#HL" %"#&EMHGLWMD HI EW" LHD%&GH GHE"L ["E^""G F@. &G

Xe&FD#" h5 \̂ H EHG&# NHFD#"e"L &%" MG &G MN7 %"#&EMHGLWMD@

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

.,4

s".(g &G' EW" N%KNM&# MFDH%E&GN" HI EWML EHG&#MEO ML %"MGIH%N"'@ *G &FH%" MGE"%"LEMG$ LDHE ML EW&E EW" EHG&#MEO HI Z FMGH% ML F&'" "T"G FH%""GE [O F"&GL HI MEL EHGMNB'HFMG&GE %"#&EMHGLWMD ^MEW & X FMGH% E%M&IH%F"' [O EW" &%D"$$M&E"' E%&GLIH%F&EMHG HI EW" LMG$#" DNL 3( ..( &G' < &L M#KLE%&E"' MG "e&FD#" ..@

\WKL( I%HF FF@.=/ 6"e&FD#" /8( &G Z FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO F&Y"L MEL IM%L&DD"&%&GN" MG E%MNWH%'L s[g &G' sN(g &G' 'K%MG$ EW" NHK%L" HI EW" E%ME%&GLIH%F&EMHGL I%HF E%MNWH%'L s'g EH sG(g Z FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO NHFD"E

EHG&#MEO MG E%MNWH%'L sNg &G' sWg &L ^"## &L HEW"% EHG&#MEM"L IH%F"' [O EMG$L I%HF FF@.=,( &G' #&LE#O ME NHGIM%FL MG E%MNWH%' s".g MG F@/@ *G "e&h( EW" Z FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO ML %"LE&E"' &E EW" L"NHG' N&'"GEM&# DHMGE,3 MG E%MNWH%'sW.@g Z#EWHK$W sW.g ML GHE &G Z FMGH% E%M&'( MEL EHG&#MEO ML LK[E#O MFD#M%M"GNMG$ & n'MLLHG&GE NHKGE"%DHMGE(,4 j ^W"%" EW" DN - MG E%MNWH%' s$.g %"LH#T"L EH

DNL h &G' .. MG sW.@gZ FMGH%MLW EHG&#MEO $%&'K&##O LWMIEL EH 2 F&RH%MLW EHG&#MEO I%H

Xe&FD#" ., %"T"&#L EW" I&NE EW&E EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# LMG$#" DMENWBN#&KDD"% &G' #H^"% #&O"%L( DNL 7 MG E%MNWH%'L sqg &G' s%(g DNL , MG E%MNWH%'

sE(g DNL .. MG E%MNWH%'L sKg &G' sT(g &G' DNL 3 MG E%MNWH%'L s^g&G' se(g HKE#'HFMG&GE 3EW E%M&' HI 2‡@ \W" EHG&# DH#&%MEO HI FKLMN E"G'L EH $%&TME&E" EH

"' U"%" * %"I"% EW" N&'"GEM&# DHMGE EH EW" &DD&%"GE FHF"GE MG ^WMNW EW" FKLMN &%%&EW"% LE&[#" EHG&#MEO( M"@ Z= H% 2‡@ ZL & F&EE"% HI I&NE( fM$"EM I&TH%"' "FD#HOMG$ DW&%FHGM"L IH% LM$GMIOMG$ MFDH%E&GE N&'"GEM&# &%%MT&# DHMGEL MG WML FMN%HD62KNMK%"&G ,,C8( &G' EWKL ME ML GHE LK%D%MLMG$ EW&E W" %"E&MG"' EW" LMFM#&% E"NWN"DE MG EW" 'M&EHGMN ^H%Y@"( 1MLLHG&GN" NHKGE"%DHMGE 'MII"%L I%HF E%&'MEMHG&# NHKGE"%DHMGE MG EW&E &## EW%"LH#KEMHGL MG EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHKGE"%DHMGE &%" %"T"%L"'@ *E ^&L IM%LE "LE&[#M

:""$"% MG .h/-@

Xe&FD#" .-5 \%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L sN.g &G' s'.(g&G' E%MNWH%' s".g &L &G Z FMGH% E%M&'

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


.,h


F"&GL HI EW" LE%HG$ %"LH#KEMHG&# E"G'"GNO HI EW" E%MEHG"( DNL 7 &G' .. MGJH%"HT"%( MG F@7 EW" EWM%' N&'"GEM&# DHMGE E&Y"L D#&N" MG EW" KDD"% #&O&G' < MG E%MNWH%' s$,g E%&GLIH%FL MGEH DN - MG E%MNWH%' sW,@g *G EWML DFF@<=7( EW" EHG&# D%HN"'K%" %"L"F[#"L E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%&NEMN" [O D%MG$ EW" 'HFMG&GE 3EW NWH%' EH EHGMN( WH^"T"%( MG EWML N&L"( EW" 'HFMG&GE 3EW NWH%'ML IH%F"' [O EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# LMG$#" DMENWBN#&LL"L MG & E%&GLT"%LG&# F&GG"%( &G' EW&E EW" DMENWBN#&LL"L &%" D%HR"NE"' HT"% & I&%EW"% 'MLEW" EHGMN DMENW@ \WKL( I%HF & #&%$"BLN&#" EHG&# D"%LD"NEMT"( EHG&# D&%ZB &G' 2‡ E&Y"L D#&N" I%HF FF@.=7( &G' EW" DH#&%MEO LWMIEL I%HF ZB EH 2‡'K%MG$ EW" NHK%L" HI EW" IM%LE IMT" F"&LK%"L@ XT"G FH%"( EW" EWM%' %"#&

["E^""G Z &G' 2 "qK&E" ^MEW EW" F&RH% &G' %"#&EMT" FMGH% Y"O %"#&EMHGLW D%"T&M#MG$ MG EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%&NEMN" D"%MH'@

Xe&FD#" .,5 :MG$#" DNL IH%F 'HFMG&GE 3EW HI 2 F&RH% MG F@<&G' EW" %"LH#KEMHG HI 2 MG F@7

Xe&FD#" ..5 :MG$#" DNL IH%F X FMGH% E%M&'

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


./.


6Xe&FD#" ./8( [KE EW"O &#LH L"%T" &L & LFHHEWMG$ &$"GE IH% E%&GLIH%F&EMHE^""G EW" E^H 'MII"%"GE EOD"L HI LN k-./l@

!"LM'"L LN k-./l( E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G LNL k-,<l &G' EWHL" ["E^""Gk-,7l &%" &#LH $HT"%G"' [O MN 7 &L LWH^G MG "e&FD#" .7@ !O E%"&EMG$ 2 F&RH% &LEW" N"GE%&# EHG&#MEO MG EW" D&LL&$" I%HF E%MNWH%'L sIg EH sYg( E%MNWHML EW" IM%LE N&'"GEM&# DHMGE( L"%T"L &L & N"GE%&# DHMGE IH% E%&GLIH%

Xe&FD#" ./5 \%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G "&NW EOD" HI LN k-./l I%HF FF@.=.-@

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

./,

k-,<l( &## EW%"" DNL ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L sI(g sW(g &G' sYg "eD"%M"GN" IKGNEMHG&# $%"LLMHGL MG EW" NHGE"eE HI E%&'MEMHG&# NHFFHG D%&NEMN"@ VNL s7(g s3(g E%MNWH%' sIg E%&GLIH%F MGEH DNL s-(g s,(g &G' s<g MG E%MNWH%' sWg &L & LK['HFEHGMN %"#&EMHGLWMD &G' TMN" T"%L& I%HF E%MNWH%'L sWg EH sY@g *GE"%"LEMsYg LD#MEL MGEH E^H k-,l 'O&'L sFg &G' sG@g VNL s7g &G' s3g MG E%MNWH%' sYg E%IH%F MGEH DN s-g MG E%MNWH%' sFg &G' DN s,g MG E%MNWH%' sGg %"LD"NEMT"#O(

DN shg MG E%MNWH%' sYg E%&GLIH%FL MGEH E^H DNL( DN s,g MG E%MNWH%' sFg &

MG E%MNWH%' sG@g ZGHEW"% MGLE&GN" HI MN7 E%&GLIH%F&EMHG HNNK%L ["E^

Xe&FD#" .<5 \%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G 'MII"%"GE EOD"L HI LN k-./l

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


.//


sW,g &G' s[gg MG FF@7=C ^W"%" "&NW DN MG E%MNWH%' sW,g '"LN"G'L & D"%I"NE <EW MGBE"%T&# ["NHFMG$ & G"^ DN MG E%MNWH%' s[@gg \WML E%&GLIH%F&EMHG NH%%"#IKGNEMHG&# W&%FHGMN D%H$%"LLMHG I%HF EHGMN EH 'HFMG&GE MG EW" E%&E"eE@ PH% LN k-,7l( LMFM#&% "T"GEL W&DD"G( WH^"T"%( EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL

D#&O"' HT"% & #&%$"% 'MLE&GN" ["E^""G L"EBN#&LL"L@ JH%"HT"%( F&eMF&##O LFHHE%&GLIH%F&EMHG "eMLEL ["E^""G E%MNWH%'L sNg &G' s'g &L ^"## &L E%MNWH%'Ls^g 'K" EH EW" HNNK%%"GN" HI E^H NHFFHG EHG"L MG "&NW E%MNWH%'&# D&M%@HI EW"L" D&M%L( HG" DN E%&GLIH%FL EH &GHEW"% HG" [O MN7r DN shg MG E%ME%&GLIH%FL EH DN s,g MG E%MNWH%'L s'g &G' sI.(g &G' MEL %"T"%L" ML &DD#M"' ["E%MNWH%'L sLg &G' s^g@ *G F@7( &## EW%"" DNL MG E%MNWH%' s&,g E%&GLIH%F$"G"%&E" EW%"" G"^ DNL MG E%MNWH%' s",@g ]WM#" L"%TMG$ E%MNWH%' sW,g &L &EHGMN N"GE"%( HG" N&G $"G"%&#M_" EW&E EW" D%H$%"LLMHG I%HF E%MNWH%'LML I%HF 'HFMG&GE EH EHGMN( NHGT"OMG$ & L"GL" HI D"%I"NE N&'"GEM&# N#HLK%

Xe&FD#"L .C EH .4 '"FHGLE%&E" &G MGE"%"LEMG$ DW"GHF"GHGr GKF"%HKL 'MIBI"%"GE NHF[MG&EMHGL HI E%MNWH%'L ^MEW LN k-,3l E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWF@/( &G' "&NW E%&GLIH%F&EMHG ML &NWM"T"' [O & D&M% HI k-,3l E%MNWH%'LHD"%&E"' [O MN7@ JHLE MFDH%E&GE#O( EW" D%HFMG"GN" HI E%MNWH%' s$.g ML %

Xe&FD#" .75 :NL k-,7l &G' k-,<l $HT"%G"' [O MN7

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


./7


"FDW&LM_" EW" N"GE%MN %H#" HI DN - &G' MFD#MN&E" EW" N"GE%&# 2 EHG&#MEOMG$ EW" %"LE HI EW" DM"N"@ Xe&FD#" .h %"ME"%&E"L EW" LM$GMIMN&GN" HI DNF@ <r E%MNWH%'L s#g &G' sDg MG F@, E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWH%' sEg MG F@ <@&##O( "e&FD#"L ,- &G' ,. LWH^ EW&E [HEW E%MNWH%'L seg &G' sI,g MG FF@ < &G' 7

&%" MN7 E%&GLIH%F"' [O E%MNWH%'L s$.gMG F@ / &G' sEg MG F@ <( &G' EW" L"NHGMFDH%E&GE %H#" HI E%MNWH%'L seg &G' sI,g ^MEW DN 673-8 ML F&'" &DD&%"GE [OMN7 %"#&EMHGLWMDL ^MEW E%MNWH%'L s$.g &G' sE@g *G E%MNWH%'L seg &G' sI,gIM%LE DN MG EW" L"E &G' NH%%"#&E"' EH DN 6-,38 MG & L"GL" HI & EHGMN EH LK['HF%"#&EMHGLWMD MG EW" IKGNEMHG&# NHGE"eE@ *G "e&FD#" ,,( E%MNWH%' sRgg k-ML MN7 E%&GLIH%F"' [O E%MNWH%'L sTg MG F@< &G' s"gg MG F@C@ \WML E%&GLE&Y"L D#&N" HT"% & #&%$"% 'MLE&GN" LD&G EW&E #&%$"#O FMGMFM_"L EW" M%H#" HI E%MNWH%' sR@gg JH%"HT"%( sRgg ML F&'" KD HI DN 6,<h8 ^MEW DN , L"%TMGLKD"%EHGMN %H#" EH E%MNWH%'L s$.g &G' sE@g a"G"%&#M_MG$ EW" '"$%"" HI D%HHI 'MII"%"GE LN k-,3l F"F["%L( F"F["% DN 6-,38 D#&OL MEL D%"'HFMG&GE %H#" MG'"E"%FMGMG$ EW" EHG&#MEO HI EW" DM"N"r DN 673-8 W&L MEL L"NHG'&%O MFDH%NHGG"NEMG$ ^MEW DN 6-,38 MG & LK['HFMG&GE L"GL"( ^W"%"&L DN 6,<h8 W&L EW" #LM$GMIMN&GE %H#" MG NHGE%M[KEMG$ EH EW" HT"%&## E%&GLIH%F&EMHG MG"%EW"#"LL( "e&FD#"L .C EH ,, $"G"%&##O F&GMI"LE EW&E MN7 E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL HMG E%MNWH%'L ^MEW LN k-,3l( &G' EW&E LHF" &%" E%&GLIH%F"' [O GKF"%HKL DHI k-,3l E%MNWH%'L &E EW" L&F" EMF" ^MEWMG LWH%E"% 'MLE&GN" LD&GL( ^WME%&GLIH%F"' [O RKLE HG" D&M% HI k-,3l E%MNWH%'L HT"% & #&%$"% 'MLE&GN" LD&MLWMG$ MEL "II"NE HG "LE&[#MLWMG$ EW" EHG&#MEO HI EW" DM"N"@

Xe&FD#" .45 \%MNWH%'L sDg &G' s&.g ̂ MEW LN k-,3l E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWH%' s$.g ̂ MEW LN

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

./C

Xe&FD#" .h5 \%MNWH%'L s#g &G' sDg ^MEW LN k-,3l E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWH%' sEg ^MEW LN

Xe&FD#" ,-5 \%MNWH%'L s$.g &G' sEg ^MEW LN k-,3l E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWH%' seg ^MEW LN

Xe&FD#" ,.5 \%MNWH%'L s$.g &G' sEg ^MEW LN k-,3l E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWH%' sI,g ^MEW LN k

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


./3


*G n]WME" HG ]WME"j fM$"EMgL 'MLEMGNEMT" E%"&EF"GEL HI 'M&EHGMN F&&#L %"I#"NE EHG&# D%HN"'K%"L $HT"%G"' [O MN 7( %"L"F[#MG$ EHGMNB'HFMG&GEEHGMNBLK['HFMG&GE %"#&EMHGLWMDL MG EW" E%&'MEMHG&# NHGE"eE &L ME F"%HKL DMENWBN#&LL"Lg E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G L"EBN#&LL"L k-./l( k-,<l( k-,7&G' k-,3l &G' EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL &%" FH%" HIE"G LFHHEW#O MGE"%NHGG"NEF"&GL HI NHFFHG EHG"L@ Z#HG$LM'" ^MEW NHFFHG EHG"L( THMN"B#"&'MG$ E%&GIH%F&EMHGL MG'KNMG$ "qKMT&#"GE F&DDMG$ ["E^""G L"EBN#&LL"L &#LH "F"%$"MN7 ML EW" D%HFMG"GE HD"%&EH% ["E^""G EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL@ Z''MEMHG&

"GE EHG&#MEM"L &%" "LE&[#MLW"' [O "FDW&LM_MG$ E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# %"LHN#&LL"L( $"G"%&EMG$ EHG&# &F[M$KHKLG"LL [O EHG&# D&M%MG$L 'K%MG$ EW" EW" DM"N"@ Z## EHG&# D&M%MG$L &%" MG EWM%' %"#&EMHGLWMD ^MEW MNL /FMG&E"L EW" E%&'MEMHG&#MLEMN EHGMN &G' F"'M&GE #MGY&$" [&NY MG EW" .h*E ML "TM'"GE EW&E E%M&'MN MGE"%T&#LB MNL /( <( &G' 7= &%" D%HIKL"#O IHKL"' NHGLMLE"GE#Or EW"O &%" &#LH N"GE%&# IH% E%&GLIH%F&EMHGL ["E^""G "HI &'R&N"GE E%MNWH%'L EW%HK$WHKE EW" ^WH#" DM"N" LK[R"NE EH EW" LE%M

D%HN"'K%"L ["E^""G EW" E^H #&O"%L@ :MFM#&% EH EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG( KG&G' L&EK%&EMHG HI NW%HF&EMN N"##( MN.( MG WML "&%#M"% FMN%HDH#ODWFHGMN G"EBLE%KNEK%"j NHFDHLMEMHGL( EW" "eN#KLMT" 'HFMG&GN" HI MN7 MG

Xe&FD#" ,,5 \%MNWH%'L sTg &G' s"gg ^MEW LN k-,3l E%&GLIH%F MGEH E%MNWH%' sRgg ^MEW LN

8/9/2019 Ligeti Yu 41


,89 0:;<= >4? &@AB42

/4

%"LK#EMG$ I%HF E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&# D%HN"LL"L ["GNWF&%YL WML I&TH%ME" K& D&%EMNK#&% MGE"%T&# IH% IH%$MG$ &G' %"IMGMG$ EW" E%&GLIH%F&EMHG&WML #&E"% 'M&EHGMN ^H%YL@

+<C<@<7O<N

!&M#"O( A@ 6.hCh8@)G8 l8<8LFL :O )DFLCJ< ;<= &L:M=8 J<= J 0C;=Z :O 7J[<8D_L 0Q8CVG8L J<= .DJOCL O:D CG8 -FDLC *VC1 VW@1@ 'MLL@( V%MGN"EHG 0GMT"%LMEO@

!"%G&%'( d@ 6.h438@ n*G&K'M[#" LE%KNEK%"L( &K'M[#" FKLMN5 fM$"EMgL D%H[#"F &G' WML LH#K H;LFV *<JMZLFL( ./( ,-3=,/C@

!%H^G( :@ 6,--h8@ nZeML \HG&#MEO &G' :K[F"'M&GE MG EW" JKLMN HI :WHLE&YHTMNW@j H;LFV )G8N:DZ #<MF<8( .7( ,@

2&##"G'"%( 2@ 6,--38@ n*GE"%&NEMHG HI EW" #&F"GEH FHEMI &G' R&__ W&%FHGM"L MG aOz%$O fMZ%NB"GBNM"#@j &<Cw[DJM,.@

2HD"( 1@ 6.hh38@)8VG<Fh;8L :O CG8 +:<C8PX:DJDZ +:PX:L8D @ ;"^ 9H%Y( ;"^ 9H%Y5 :NWM%F"%!HHYL@

2KNMK%"&G( d@ 6,-.,8@ nZLD"NEL HI U&%FHGMN :E%KNEK%"( SHMN" f"&'MG$( &G' Z"LEW"EMN PKGMG aOz%$O fM$"EMgL MG p&%E P#M"LL"G'"% !"^"$KG$@j+:<C8PX:DJDZ H;LFV "8EF89? /.(,,.=,/4

2HWG( A@ 6.hhC8@ nJ&eMF&##O :FHHEW 2ON#"L( U"e&EHGMN :OLE"FL( &G' EW" ZG&#OLML HI f&E"AHF&GEMN \%M&'MN V%H$%"LLMHGL@j H;LFV *<JMZLFL? .7( h=<-@

X##"G["%$"%( Q@ 6,--78@ HJC8DFJML J<= +:<V8XCL F< UJYY &PXD:EFLJCF:<( ,-@

U&GLHG( U@ 6.hC-8@ /JDP:<FV HJC8DFJML :O H:=8D< H;LFV1 ;"^ 9H%Y5 ZDD#"EHGB2"GEK%OB2%HIEL@

UMG'"FMEW( V@ 6.h<. &G' .h<,8@)G8 +DJOC :O H;LFVJM +:PX:LFCF:<1 ;"^ 9H%Y5 XK%BZFJKLMN@

V"%LMNW"EEM( S@ 6.hC.8)98<CF8CG +8<C;DZ /JDP:<Z1 ;"^ 9H%Y5 ;H%EHG@A"MD%MNW( !@ 6.h348@n\%&GLIH%F&EMHG HI 2H#H%&EMHG &G' 1"GLMEO MG aOz%$O fM$"EMgL fHGE&GH@j !8DLX8VCFE8L:O ,89 H;LFV? .C( .C3=4-@

AHM$BP%&GNH#M( J@ 6.hh78@ nU&%FHGMN &G' IH%F&# D%HN"LL"L MG fM$"EMgL G"EBLE%KNEK%EMHGL@j H;LFV )G8:DZ LX8VCD;P( .3( ,<,=,C3@

:E%&KL( d@ 6,--78@ &<CD:=;VCF:< C: !:LCNC:<JM )G8:DZ1 0DD"% :&''#" AMT"%( ;d5 V%"GEMN" U&##@:_M$"EM( *@ 6.h4<8@ nZ !K'&D"LE MGE"%TM"^ ̂ MEW aOz%$O fM$"EM@j)G8 ,89 /;<[JDFJ< s;JDC8DMZ?

,7( ,-7=,.-@Sx%G&M( V@ 6.h4/8@lZoD[Z %F[8CF CJMQF<[ C: !8C8D KJD<JF1 &< %F[8CF F< V:<E8DLJCF:<1 6a@ d@

:NW&["%E( \%&GL@8 6DD+./=4,8@ fHG'HG5 XK#"G[K%$ !HHYL@