i " -

... •

I

l3'_ ... __ .... "'_~ __ ._ (."b{l. J m·L

D;.:'~~;L_""_."7 or ; , - .. ------_ .... , '-"'--"--'-"----_.=. =-.. -:'-' D' ---o ""'- ,_,

... ;.::.:.~.:-:- .. - - ... __ ... - - .. " ... -...... " .. _ . . ,.. _ ...... _._-. . .. __ ...... _-_. _. _ ., ... ;!.iLJ/,,-,I1lCV,-__

.. ~---.-- ..... ---.. -•

l IT 0 r n : Dl TRI lW,TRICr

U I.

Rilld Elsulb Uttmad

/'/lIJmij}

l".

Cl!nlu for thl! Iud, of Populilr

Culturl!, d

Da"id 1I0FtJ-wll'l ..

The Slate of Texo\ ~(

JOI.' flall/TIIUfI &

llllt!/'icum gllin.,J Hille &

DUfliel Pipe,

('uml'll' Waf"

'" iliu1II1 hlaTllTllofl itor. org

('8 At"t:mllll." Inc.

DI!/f!fIIlmll.\.

FI COllRT FOR TIff \VE. Tt.R2 6JUJ -2 PH 1= 06

OFTE L

IN DrYI [Or. • ST [l!

y - --;:;;~---.. ..

()6 C ·285

"

" .. • ..

"

"

"

* .. .. ..

Am"nlledPetition for l.ibel and

Business OlJtracl, Interference Wirb intentate OmJDer,C~, ("'onsoirae, "{o ' uttrre re Witb Inttrst-'llte Commerce, I nteri"e,renct With InteFnel Commerce. on~pirllcy To Inter ftre with lnttr nd ommerc~ lotc lltillnal InmcDon of I 'lentil] Anguish And nxictv With Tht Iment 10 Inju re, lm'asillD of Prh ~', " mild . I 'celi!!!!I1!!!!, (; filS- Negligen ce. OJ Pllr:lgtlmenl IIf :1 " .. ,itw,,-, Name, Uisrnuloll!cmelli of P rodlll:~. Oilllliun or a Busi)ltsS Nilme. Torturous InterfeRDce With ProsJ)e:clivc BnsiDesS dVDDtH~~ ViohiCion or Ftid_ l OlIuIlO!l ~ct 15 t LS.«;:. II1Stc\

To the HODornbJe Judge Sam ' I1lirk. .. :

(elm"" N"", Rlau [J..,lh tl.un..u, u l'nh~J ~IUl~ clli7en. r<:s.d'lIl III' '\lI11" 1,:11" ("'II1I~. l~o, UJlel lik~ hls_PlurnlilTs Sl"Ctllid OriJ!IIw.1 AJD~m.l"" r~titi.\ll ror I ihel ~nd ~lnnJer. MDllcmu~ t,bet. Muhcious SLmJrt. o.;fom.Ltiun l1f l h~r-iliCl~r

l)ol.lmulluA 01 ('h.Jroct~r Walb Inlcnl 10 Couse MenlAl AJ1flUlsh. bbdLnl,! IInu i>lallu~ml'" " Flminc" Namc. Il~f"'nllli"n Ihl\lu 'Jl I muJ III D Bu~iDl."'~ Nome. Inll:liercn<c Wllh {l'l'<illo:~', (\'011'",,1. T"nllrnl" lmcrf~r"I1~" Wilh ,\ FlIL~iJlC'l.' Olllr:u:l. ('on"]'i,,, ') h' Inl~rli'l~ Wilh LI BIl'lin<.-",' r"I1In..;1 I nkrf;;rcnc~ \\1 111 Interstlilc (""mill'" r,.n'rj",,~\

rll Il1lcrfcfc Wilh Inl~n tnt" CllntniCIU, r nl~flcn:' ... .., "1111 Intern'l ("mllll!r.:~ . CIlllspim(\ To In l ~rfCt~ Ililh [1i1~rn~1 '11I11l1ler<!C. IJllemio[I.Jj luJ1j.lj,," l.r "lemur '\[1l\lIl -11 1\"" \n~'c" Willi n]~ Il1t~1I1 1<1 Iniul'l:. (n\'."i('11 (,f Prl'llt' frauJ. N~\!.IIl!<'rI'c, COrtI" N~i!Ii~cn(·c . Oiqf'1ra~clIl"111 " I a BlI~i/lcss NLlRl Dip:1nlgtllllcll1 llf I'Il.IUU,h. 1111111"'1\ ,,1.1 BII,,'l1c'<nm' ViolMlon Of Fedlltlll DiIIlUM Act 15 U. ,c, 111'1~1 a.IlU

~h" ,'.

1

Plaintm' Rilld Elsolh H!lInIlid in l'rls po:,g,nnl llIIpB£ily B.~ B Unital S\ll~ citi7:<n, n:sidcnl of Austin. TrtI\li~ Count)'. T~;ws ",nose mldress is 4807 White Elm Orive. AlLquo, Tens 71r749 and the OWIIeT of PCWF.ORO Defmdnnl5 me: CcnlL!r for the truly Qr I'opullll" Culture. 440 l Wil!hirc Driv.; 4th Floor, Los An 'd c, llIifomia 900 I 0 "'nose pbone IlWDOO- is (323 SSb-2SS0 and David IiQr'Owi.tz, Edilor in C'hkf of

hlIp:llWW'l\' Frol'llpagemgQ,org ill Ilis P"~l..u C<IpIJCLl)' and ..., CIlJ] be !lef\'od Ell ("enler

fUT !he SUJdy of Popular CultlJl\l 4401 Wilsbiro Drive. 4th floor, l..m; Anboe11:!., CnlifumUt. 90010 whose phone number is (323) 5!i6-2550. CEN1ER FOR JEWISH COMMUNITY Sl UDIES whose ndd:rl:ss is 58(1(1 Park Heigl! A\'enue Bal t.i.nmrc. MD 21215 USA uruJ the SID~ D TC<ftS lind it can \Ie 5lmIed UUDllgll its AttIlm~lI Oeneral Gn:g Aboll ll1 (JUke of 111" i\ttomo, (icn~1 1011 W 1 ~tlt SII'C';>L.i\lJ.I.1in. TX 78701 Joe KuuJnmn. (hwnnon IIf AI1I<fICilllS Al.!'ljPSI I I ~t. in hi, p~rS<lrnll Col"'lCII)' mid Amcnams AgUlfL,t 11010 ilnd holh !,anl<-" ~"11 he wr'l C~I ill theil IklJ""", lOr Def .. 'tII.iunl Joe "-oul:man aJ tn. dttl.ucd 1'11t<T' .. I' bliSUIl'" • 'IiOI W""l CUl11mcl\OmL Slllilr 24. Fort L:turd~rd.l", H<lrida ,,1[11',

Panid I' j PC" in 1* j nLli' l<Juol caJl'l~II) nn..! h. call "" s~'"' et! al CwnPUl> W nIdi . 1500 Wolnol !'i.trt!CL Suite 1050 Philndcl nbia.. f'A 1 q 1112. Cmnpu.q Wukh III1d Ihey elln ~ ~cr\'cd al CmllJ1U!l Wllleh. 150U WBlmul St.reeL SUite 1050. PhilClde-ll'hl.a. PA 19L02.

'Ilrtnnll-lj13lT\J1l00ftN.QT\f IlJIId the).' can be ,."...ed III thrQ,,!!h ell ACCOUNTS. INC. 110] MAIN STRf'FT )\trl11' 1001'0 ROX 12K9PI'ORIA .11 .61602J1nd( 'U AfTOl fJITTS. INC 1101 MAIN STREET SUITE 300 PO BOX 1289.PEORIA lL .6 I IiO:!

" .Iuri .... lctlnn

JurisdictIOn 01 II:U5 (0ur1 " DpprLlpn.lle due 10 mll5[llullon.U '1u~'11\J~ [he 'i.hennCln A~L lit ... LillI RI)!hL' \1:1 "I I 'l(..t. nl~ [Job!:" \<L fh. lunlmm \(L I ~d"'J:il1 I deC!lmmonk~llOn '\cl oj I·~1)6. ri,e RICO AlL ...., Fed~rul rademmi: DlIol",n ACl: I C~lI.' I:iLLQlncs: ru>J Commerce cpdc. kxltS I mdemark 51 Jill:'; ;md duL' I" JJ\'Crsll) "I I unsJ iet Ion IDld the lo~' lhal PluinJ i Ill,\c"" .Iud" MI.. III I c)W,q II hilu Dt(eml.lnh 11\ C •• \1\1 Of'L'rllIL' In \on\lI1> cilies and slnle- ,ll1>un,I Ih~ ,Inned Shit,." Jnd hl,lel

1\1

V.nur

\ 'cnu~ I' BJ1fIrt1J'1rl.I'" 111 r~ \\ ,"'1~111 Oi>cri,,1 1\'''1111 nil j,illil ~III~~ ~lil>Jl!j b~ Ikl;'OO~IIIS f~,," I II",1 in d~n~ll1l!s chili l~~'~ rla_" III "',,,hu lUlU r flI\ h l'VUrll} k~lJ!1. l)d"'''''I''k~ In .cill IHlcil'"lifll! "jilt mlu Iturtllilll! I'h.illti lT 1Il1~e.L' io Ausun. I mil. l ,111111) . Tc,.I" .Utll Ihlull 'h"ul 111. I lml "J SI:lle". V.:nll~ i.ll alb<! .lppmpn;L~ .!uc 10 lhe "" ON" III Ilw Itlrh"ICliuli ", Uh I\lfU~' ~IIU 1~11lI11 raken b\ l"-"tend3nL~ III IlIn,'lL'

'ilar~" lind IlUlIl>lI~ .

IV

nlu..., 0 r \ rliOlI

nil ... &:li"l1 IIri ,~, from Udcnd.mL. publicallon of false rn l'nrm:tf 11m r.;~"rditl!!

Plain!IIT ~nd publlc-.J.lion 01 ~lIel!"JJ(lns u I 1'1B1n1l fr~ en!(3 '''men I in IlIc~11 \ '\l1"1I U.I.illllS

amI rccrul.lm<1l1 1m vLOI<1l1 and l"'ITDn!'l.b!l.S. IJd"nd:llU" ~I!<O "11"'~c til 1I",lt pllhlil',iJtion> 111..11 PlmnlUi npttn.te. ;[11 " I1;I<1mlr ell.:'"I)" onJ erotleu "I her 1Je. Ihi!.r.:pr"s"nI.i.1Lil'lI oj lacb ond hbcl"u~ ;;UlcmcnL~ \~ ilh Ihe Inrent of Ilri\ IJlg I'lillruJIT "UI ()f business. mlcricnnp Wllh "usmc's "()Ill~~ and C1) ll~J1lrll1[! III Ifll4Illtllll. ~1W1d~r lum ltis Ll"[lUnelu· nome IInJ Ih~ lJ;une "I' hi5 OO';{k."" .100 III jn,"rf~rc m hh ~Onlr'''''l "jlh Iili ~tt1jJlo)1!J \u~lil1 InJcp.mdcn! Scr"'lil Di,lIi,,[. [)j~l\CJtlLC1kII~orJ.. \I{,OMllnilur. MiliL:UlIlsluulIlll.nill>l u'l!- hl\111plIg • .:mal!-lIT\1 IDlJ t'umPLL' 'Inl b in conl"n Illlm~"I~ I ,klJJnOllin IJIld Ilbl:l,lII, ".Il~Ul<!llU, ~glliust PlwntiO Riad lIso1h II"ITUJd llJllI ruhlhh~..J

Ib~t11 in s~,~1 "Hides us 1.lt~ liS Jul~ 21.1tH wlU",ul Myro!' a.rr~ Inolnal filllfl(/'llh'l1s lor Ill"ir ",1I,,!,nLi,,",. lIB un. "I' tJ • .tr unides. LkfrndnnL. "':tim thaI P \~ r j, :11I - hiJnllC

,

c li~rll~ ',,1m"! rum!i n!! h lailllcd" w •• h Il7fT1f1S ITI mollC'~' " bleh " un t1uln~ 1 Il bd II I 1'('\\1 t1l1ll lb bu~in~!< proJd",,,,, unu "",ure"" "l.rIL. m.,.

\ '

lld",Ml,ml I I,I\ '~ t l ",u\\ II~ i. lh~ "d lh'r in Chid "I' "" unlin.: magll'-lJl~ IJ.1JJJL'\l

"1I 11p ... ,'" \\ I f.IIlI",'!,CIII"!! orL' whicb "nen .kfallk'S Ambs IIml Muslim, r~l",s 1'1' dl<:1J ditk; II,1ll1l ...:Iigltlu bcJ.d~ IIr ..s.. .... 1<.:.alloo, IkknJunl Ut,rowhl' lkC US('S Jt'''' unU l hi i'lIllU "h,' "f'Ol'''' ilis i.lL"t,Il'cicl1l "lH!m~ nl bcl11¥ kM usJ lm lund..lmcr1lllilqs." -.1 i lJ.Mli ~l' " IIII~ - L<m'rI 'm '~mr~lIru".= nlt.llllll!l.h t.llC\ arc <. h'L~Ulln' t>.r Jcv.s. I he l ~Ht~1 10'1 Llk' 'iL uLl~ .. I I'""ulur lulbm! b .~ !1"'1L~or llIuJ puhll,her l.t II", " l1lm" II "lUi i (1" an..! ~""lribuc"s lumllflu lor 'he .\ r.1 hs Jnu ~ , liS Ii m. iJAI ~ IiIlL'll \\ c""i lC n..-r"ndunls publisbcd on prtlde cllrl'l;!11th IWI Ihdr .~ "'site anel B\dilablc ICI t.ll ~ !'ubli ' sud'ltrtld" ~lIIJl.l1 l rL~ II ndou, , l.item,·nh oIl1,l lal riCill, 1 1I1I~g..I1IIJ II.> r~g...u dillL' PI.JJnLliT hi~ hU'illl\.: _ ~ d~.lhnl· " II lt,ral dlilr h':'l.-~. Il,.! hgl~' J~ ~1t .... 1 '\., ~I1t.J ill, '\.·h~ lnu ... , ,,",H,:hlt .mJ p"lllh::,aJ

uu.l :)S t.:'llJHIlf\

>;uJ 1Ir11c1~ d~JOrL' lh.JlI'I.,innll I lam.,J "",,1ulo;s till "['lllllllC ( hurn) , llwl JunJld~ lUllU. I" -I ~rn.>n"-~~ In ll~"Url~" 1';d~>l lll~ ,,".1 . I~~U", . f'lili n. ilT "f1't:LnI,! un -unl.l·Sem il . nlllil In'I!. .. laIClllC'nCs III flld. lie, .lInl fi," 1 j"". " ' II , ill l.:n~~d In JCl'rh t f'1.llnllll oj IllS III ""Il..r-:.lk. ,,,,,sh,p. Iflnd r~cl\ m." (II' 'r; ll~ .. "~JJ "U,iJl~s us he \\1 he' lkl,,"d~n" I bl1,u~h t.l'CIr actlClIL. couo;c,1 Pilillllif nllllld..r, u.Lmllg~ ... los, <II polcnlml Ilk:f'mc. unuell. memol nn~lli"' . ~I '"1~ Jer.un.,.) III, n.tOJL' In me, communll '

I'I.unlllJ rl:>1dc. .. ill '\",IUl. r",u. unJ I~ ,u=nI1~ ~m"l",cJ bl .-\1 1 ·~ l l1 1 1l~~pt.'1ltkol School 1) " lrklli " Iuidlll" s<:b(l~II.,.)u(~lur. !'Imnll n " 5 ne\er inn,I"",1 ill ~II \ ,j,.l!!'l1l_ mLillllnl <lr " .. iiI kill "tgaJlIlilllUlllII hi, lik -Xt1lK' slwienb 011 hIS \Lh .. >l,u ,J lil~1I rlt1\!11l> s'lIrtcd collinl hUll Il L':mln t' Wltm q~Lionc:d. IhCl' 11;<", Ih~1I

'1.ICIII"nL~ ('J] I~ a]iC!lBlj,;n\ In I lt~ ..utidc puhll"hccl b) lklenLlIlI1l' on Ih~ir "'t'C~m .

".:!"lIe, hUp:/iwww Frontpagemag'O(G pnoJ Mil il.IJl Il, I. IIIUUtJUJ I<Jr '''J1!. l' l.untll l al,;o

~;" ",'Ii lil"<l h) rus I'rlnd!"',] .11 II ... "....,,,1 thai '"lmt' porenL~ are ~lInt '111<."11"11,,,,1 I lt~ 'ld~ "I Ull'Jr cJulJ l'l!n 111 1 I reJdillg lflr ill'I Jd~ pul>II,"eu h\ TNki1l1;J.m, " " 0,,,,& \\1!b:.,lt n~ PUlJ"l,-,! "f lite Plittli,"Liun ul the art ic le I" Ilm"'\;.7 in frunlp"~~II1~1,! uru 'HIS 1(1 "i.~rUl' 1 1'lllI nu lfs lik hWl1ihulc h.OrL IIItmll dll lc IUIlI . I1l1d ';;.IUSI! 111m IDl>lll!'l.iJl)o pnd ps~Ch"\lle l c'lt dl1ll1l1~t't hI L'nlOln him Imm ~ . Cl\: i'lllg tll , r~LluIlI 111 ~""l:1i. !be ri~hL I.' d., 11tI. .. , .... " IIJJU I" "uju)' bi. li fe m pc!ICC 1'1 '" ti l !lUl' l ' 1L1.:nl

·\ud'IlIlOil!l , PIJJJlWf UIIUS u.nd l'flI'n1lc« 11\1l " 1I' lne's.:-- III ...:11 d"Llrunu::s. iI11..~ IOml u-at!, IhmllgooQI Iltl! I llIi ll~ 'l.Ul~. M~ll\ hUH" ore L- ill nJ '.1 UTIlI ,du.:liml In dll hu~.nc,~ \\lch PI.lil1111T due I,' U1C' Ires. \ahri UI\ ,n, .11111 . 11I ~!!;lI i'irb II I tJlI'nhm1dl1 on -L.!mmsm-- flI'r fJ\;r~'k/(UJlJi ' itrtldc Bnd I'1I" lic.ll i<ln. PlwnllJT~ ,Qrr~n l .mJ IUlUre Jlhd'I1~.1.1 CUItI Ihm~ LS 1e<1p:LrJII.ol Alld ,tJll lll1 Ut I" be: LlJr~alrnl"<l Wlt.ll lhc l ~nnhlOli" l l

1

"I Ius em!,I\1~menl conLrdcl Ju~ In Ihe lube .d l~I1I<lO' ", Dcknd.10h an" It..: .,mlinuUlmn I.rd", !,ul:>II(<ltion "r ,u~h Ii.:' l'hliRII ITi" CllI1l1nul'I"I} ~ f''' .... 'd Itl rl,lt .:uk hunulmUCfIl. 1I1l1lll! calhn!! .lI1J h.JruS,mml h~ 'luJcIll~. f.,.:ul l\. 1""11111('1, ,it' Ilk ~,'mmuntl\ lbe ""tlue lLad hIS InalJ .. "" 11 r",~ull "I the h~.,. . .Jw .. kr unJ IUm-.~llli"u~ 1\\ I JcfcmLlm~ nn Ihelr "c".il~. Phllntltl is (,'ru!l!rneu ilial lIis ,,1'I,,~liy"ll""" ll!I J le...:lia h.l' 00:11 dimi n ished Ilnd ",'mf1'"omisi!tl J10J dUl hi> ronlrnr:t could be knn imlled dlli! lu III" It.:" "ll<llhhri 11h'Il' h~ [}Ckl1~.1nl~ I lnm"'I1. Milltnllll,lllm ,.,,.. and ( I SP(

nd"nJ.JJ1lS knew Ihen :IIlJ 1;110\\ nnw Ihal lhen ~11.WJlil1n., [JJ1d .,llllcmenls ure h.'I.,~k",'. "1'I1J1~. in"!J111J111311I11J milhdl'll~ ul1acb III 1\.1ml r'l:dnt.fl. d~"ri\'e him 01 hi:­cll'lSli1IIl;,'n;lll~ rr"IC<:I"" ri~hl' 141 'J"C.l; n'i.,ncim,· ", .. t"hi~ ,11.1 <In "",'IlL'" Ilnli ~on"" ll e 111 J1\Lkfish 'nell ark~"Ii"l1 n~r'OOarll~ ~nc'\ Ih~1\ UIlY 1.11"", 11,,\\ Ih:Ol Iheir tllk~,"i"I\' '\I\uld h.lflll Pll>iJ1ljrr ~ 1Rkr,,<l~ '1.1I111Inl) II11lw wmmlllLlll 1101111" "'1'11I"'"'I1. t>lj"UI~" J;:;]Jill~~ ,lod '''lul1lu...: Itt rl'llblislt lh~ir Ii".", 1;lbri,;ltillll's uud lIIi"'l'11~1Ik.1Ib vi rllc\., "ilb l"wJ dl&1~gill J tu II,,: truth I" ttl.: illt~-=[S of 1'lumliJT Def ... JlLWnb ~\1:n ~1l~"U/U~~J hI II.:iJ orti~k lb~ l~rt1lin.lliun ur l'lJJinlllJ unJ Jt'rrivin~ him uJ conMituliollul right!. 111lU tJJ~ spread "r sm:b lies

O ... f~II<lOf1h C"tlSplr ... J wid, ol[~ sue b as D;mi~1 "Ipes. II Unlteu SID[,,! bas.!J ,\r .. " find f\11l.Jim [la.iI"t. III rill .... 'Jll 'JJ"~. !,uhll,h [.L"n""lion~ WId hl!s "l'1II1lS11'llLinldl In

iI II~lItJt·r. ll~ IntclI[lt,".11 ;UlU Illuliduu> mmm~r iruend~J 10 humHiBI~ PI~mll l1. InI~rt"R" lIil ll hi, hu.,j ll~". tI"J1ri\e bim "r his rig.bl 10 lI<lrk tmd !tn' ,n l''''"",C and ". ef\.'<lIe .. hoqlil" ~n\ It,.nm"nl "',-ued, !tun an [h" commuui!) thnt ~ In"" an Inr the 13-'1 111 }·c~r •. n: l"IlJill1l.~ 1 t,!1I1~r li,t 1 ~w,,!t t ul!ullUnil~ "[uu,e. pmnded tU11J 111(1 In/ l}.! Icnd.ll1l~ IIIItI"'III f\1iHlllllL1sluDLorg Jll]J ('SI't' '" (llsl,ilmte llel\.. t;,h,i .11': ml~rcrrC''''liIllti"n~ In.,, rlnl l,,, lll 'aulOid IJ. ill\"l~eJ In \.,..I~DJ. mihlDnl ,>r lerrori,1 .,,,,IIIIIIC-' lJl lite I IOIt~d S'.JI~' .. r 1""1.:.'1.",, (c:nl~r lor Jewish l'ommunlt, SluJk", nl<;n l'~" 11let.i tab.: IJJl1lrmaUlIn I" I Jd'mJanl IlonJ\\llz that ho CL.m in hi. r>,,"hcntil''' III defume. Ubd. ~ldlJcla .Jl)J h.aru." 1'I .. lnllfJ RWJ H'(lLh Ham.l,l. Ikknt1IJlb Lt.'''''''II/. { i-IPf. t'J( :" :lml Milil,lnUslummomlor.onl and ('II AC~\\II",' 1. '1" .... th~u .md 1.00" no" wh6e to lind I'lmnllll anJ couJd hm" oJlf'I\,achccl h lin h' (fu~li.'11 III m on lh~ I"el~ If I he, ~\ ~r~ '"I"n:.I.cJ In flU .. It~hlnl' J prnl6lsjlllml .trIM~. IItI\,., .... Ddoll!anl~ 1n~1L11f11'\.""~ urtJ willfulh ltllleJ 10 "~"rcj",, JUt! ~orc Imil Ilw '[<lil liaN' oj' prucClClIlu ItlU"'~It~1ll all.J ml~Slll!.lU'~ rt'SeJJICh in orUer 1,1 hal11l 1'I,tIIlllrr~ rh~SL~al Silld}. mtul'sIS 1""IItC', [wffi<'_ ""pullltlnn, JI~nlt~ pnd r rhk

nl~ Stu'" llf I C.Xl" Im!",:;...,. ""~IlU~ !If Imlil.llitln .11 oor ye;rr to lnllml" cuU'OC' 01 oct inn f('r libel. ,I"nd~f • .Jcr.11ll."i"U bllS.d lin bi.slori~ollrudltlons Ihal 1[1: 11411 c, 1lIr>;,llhk \\ llh lh" n,c\\ , ccbn"I"Ri~al de,dopm<.'11ll. m I"" mroia lJId f'1l0IiCOll"O<: rl~itltitT i.,. b"m~ hura,scLl Iii'! ,I u.aiJ, l'k,~b und ddam.J 11\= ~e::Jr5 lLtlc!r dIe JltlNi"all" " "r li'lld~ 011<: lhe \\cl1~iIU~ "r Od~'1lU,IJl I.s CS Ilt. .mu l JCS with on (Ir"I1(1Unil~ 1i"1 f'!.UJlli IT 11/ .lol1l. lnd relJ.,,;tli~l .• ,puJIl~\ nr retire> lur hiS dnnmpi:S1i htl!' ",-,>:.1 I~, IhLlfI ,,,,, yC;'IS

Ih~1 "ihl~nlls1LJt1IJIl""il,,, .orl! fJUbll,beJ lh~lr 1If1,"I" oec,,,i,w plainuJJ JuJ 1m hu~ln"" "I' """'ivin~~ winlru fumb' lrum - lcrmr link.'- and he h,1> IIU r.:.:t1ur~", ror =,,\~ .. 01 Jllllllt~'S. Th~ 111.'111< lllnJ ';ecUf1I) 1)0l'""n,,,,111 Illuml [K1 rrnmrul IJClml, ,'r WI\'nlt

J, .. n~ in ,Jn~ or Piumllir 1'<'1"'";11, ""''''''S- .,' r",r<""S ... nallKtI\'lIc~ IN: "ru"~ "II .Ilt' \\ cJ... II e, Jenl hml' he 1'1 "SIIIl1f"li, ", .. I'll Ull k el1~c ,m..! i nlcrr"r.: \\lIb .. ~c'" "I,') tl< \\.: 11 115 bu Int:S' ,-IInlr.I,-'IS ,><111 i"C, In., ••. , .... IIl<I "11111" mJI.!, Adihll"n .. II~ , lhe} ,1':111' "

(1\'11 .loJ LIln.~I'IUlllllll1l "Vhl lit;)1 Ill' I <lIwlc III und" the ( ''"<1111111''11 nl Ih, lllllrJ S'~IC' m,1 lh~ """, .. I' I",'",s rht: I t,.uS\: und Ih,' S<:nalc (,f Ihe S'"I'" III 1 ~\,I' (u,IL'J ." I\!JJI".J) 111'$ I~II "J,'I·a.k Illl~'f Ih~ dc,d"rm~11I .. llht: Int<11Ii!1 Inl"'lIIalllllllcchnlll"g) .

II,,' St,l': "I I t;",,< IltU II.< '''l1~!T".' Luk-J to aJJ .... 'SS Ihe II(·,'J I.f the (,tll!.!n. of .1", sLlte m l'cn~I.,"" PI~1I1111i's in r~r1I(lIlar til It\" in J1o:',ec. \\I"L In J"!lllT m..! "" Ircc "I h"'Il'''ltclll , 1111 illtil1"J;!Ii"rI Ju" u.) hhd IUIlI 1.lIId~ Ill.IIl'IIlll[nlld III bl'",aJ 1lIl"n.ll",1 I h ... 1" "1 'r~', (,f II,,' III1JI~J Sw,,,. ddi. I .I,e ill','rm" '" .. un inj,'rm~", II hlt!lm,JY,~ IIlI!.!r.,dll'" 11,,1 M • f,,,' n .. "let pl.l " /(., IJ~~, ' rdlh"f Ch'II1 11 DnLl<", rc.1J",·,' lollirt ~,

dcs'~I1",,'d I'~ Ih, Sell.lle IrIJ abe 1/'L1 or .11 ... :-;I,I~C ,,( rC~,1 , The LL1ucs ,,' "'IIII.I.i"" . • II)oj cite I." .11i",,, inJi\.Juuls I" ~CIII\IJ) \\1111 hf1.:I.IIIJ IJJ1J~r )1CIIJ1R~ Ih. , ''''rkti 'n "I' 111",:\1 i \:lil 111M Ih;1I C\'ulJ Ull,,, ~dl' hl ,e··,,,I\\' \k.ul\\hd" th"u,.'O:III- "f 1" IIrrLl!>1 m" ..... '·p. 1l!d1\11.,.II~ <iee J"po\eJ ", .I,,'u 1'"\.1,'). d'.,!lIll) anJ tlWJr I it ills ." "",10; .tIkI h\\!' ii' plik:~ m thtlr resre-cII\C' C] III I tlIUnllu.:."

VI

Ikfcno.i..tnl> '11I~"flJ!.!,1 h' ,,,nruli) ""buLl I! hi, \!X, Iknl fe/ullum; \"Ilt III "" I pili}!." ,inJ til m'<rkrc.' "lit. ,,,, cm[lI,'~n}Cn' lnllillel 1l,!lrmbnls' lihd. Jalllier 1111" leee,,,< \11th 111. ",,1I1te hIl5.1le'i.' .mJ 1",-,,1 " ... ,, '"1e "uk.,. Iml ,11,1",,"1 "'n I "'Yllefln~ hL~CJ.U.~ Cll-.tnmns IH.' nii-lltd In dll '11.ill~··-· '-'.,Ih hjm. ~HII1'" III (lluil1lt1l"s fh'lh~'" aml nC"ghhnr II~ Ir}lIl~ 1 •. 1 Jj. unc~ . ,,1I1~ -IH:'iJ 'Jnm 111m du til th~ hl.:'s .1IlLJ

fil~nl .. IIJL'Il"' III lkh'udllnl!; Inr lhe fi:ur til Ih " .. ~al Impli\.:Jth'n~ ,d !;uch lL'i~~'t~i.J_dfln Ildcl1l.i.ml:: nl! til !,,"II';I,.' :Jnd IJIH:SS nCj.Jh.'coL: 1n lD\~'·lq!iJlml 11)(, 11,:11\ ili~ ul PLunlill

.m.! 1,111 11,,.j~ h",inc', I"r .h~ cluldlcn ""I I" the ,,=1100 "I ,I 1""1,1" CJl\lD>nrnCnI I, w.lnh huu Ifl I hI.," I. ommuui I~' I h.:n tK II ~\'I..", and .... cn I:S r01UtJly.

lkCcoo.JOUi, ,hmlld, Ihe" ~,Ii,'n~ dal11 .• ~ • .t r/;.iIlIJlfs ,duli,>,,, \\ Ifl. tll. ~ludl!Ob.

Ih"ll'IIlRlUll"~ mid Ihe pi ",,·.poll .11 Iii" ""'!wh,1 \\h~, he \1{Jf\"", "",, 101lH' 1.111 \In IlIm~, I rW~lll\e Il,l~ 11111\.iL.-1 li'l ~II ~I!'an.. I )d~·nd.II-.r'l: r.:lIu~l DnJ !ittll ~itU"1,,' humihallilfi.

1l\'~'':ly. ".Ill II ", 111111 "p' ' him I" UIIII""'''!o,,,t~ ~u~~i""i"" "_ "'~Jnh\!n; ,,1 .h~ ("'lUIIlllll1~ II\'\:I abe illkg.l,i"", ruhlt h.1l h) [l~lcnJanl5 uO lIi":ir \d .. it.:. I'IallLlllf8 ('!lllll,- ,1"",illl'''' t. "lIl1cnnL~ Ji\l.l \\111 ,'lIlllmW 10 ~lIljcr due •• , rill! fJJ.., "11c~'"",.,1S ,01 I kkmLII"~ "II III II."" lil'S Bnd laillie.lli"'l' ub"u. Lhc "utlU, ill' Ill, OOhlrw:s5, 11. uril!JlI'"l11 th. ""I, IIr It!:. rn,JulIS, I),: 1t:1I,1~1I1 I' ll J\ccounl, II"'J WI llHi",a1 SWlc "r lIIinul rhl II,' IIl1ln).", I"f tllclr "cI iI .11\>.1, "I;o.t< "I IlIil",i tillie, II illjJn.-s~ r;,r 'ht'li "c~'I~ .111', '''"I!! I SI.lle "Ilia III tlllimllL,l<, flunull. t" ll"kllJ 1111 an d til ,"I.II 'Il' 1\lIh 11I~ hU'iIll<"S' ,IIlt1 r~""l\l-l.l I I t~

ti

I'r .. nr fiu I(cilef

II Ikr,,".LtnL~ III poy 1'lamllfJ 5 mUlll'n J"n"r, in Ctm1perL~ul(1ry d.mJ~ j.,1' Lk past. procnr I1ml lUiurr lm::p:llIIhl" .Lm.p" d"",, l(I hl~ JUmc. bu,jllC8' .11,,1 tanLlLn~ In Ull! ((lmIllUfl'i)

21 Iklend""I~r-'~' l'l~Jnlitlll.ullI)J It I mlllillncJl>ll.ll'\ h,r Iii.;, !','" 1'1' III lid fUlur ... f,otcnlu II",., "I tnCl>",~ mJ co",j will due r" 111<0 .11I.,'alillt~,. Ii. .... 111<1 fJhri~,lli,'n puhhlihrd I'n Ihelr "cilsll" ~nd Ih, cnml.lAd <41 fIlii.n." 11\I!\li'h <:;1 ",'<.I h~' ~udl

It"" 300 ~ I kt:Btlr'",,-

3) I h" t "uri '" 1-.sU<' I f"'f'l1.lIk."l1l il1juncli 'II hlAtlinli D~fmJ.UlL' lillin (.tllln~ I'ILlIOIi,l"· i'-u'lne,,, un "'sl.lJIli · ..twil)·· blll.l lu "rund bim ...,. 11 • Mus 1111 t'l1oo~m"lll'lli.C LJnl~s, II~ " 11 rr,,"c IhJ.I Lh ... PlJlinlJlT if a .. Mu.llm hmdllnlo!f11.IIi'll-," Ilmt iii, hu-in"~~ is un - hl.mi, dwnL~ .-

~) D"fcndanll.lu r~~ I'IJllllilr~\~IIII'luri' und pllnlti\~ dam.~o:s In Ihe ""I"U~1 nr~H millilln J .1I1lr'; I" b< • f'1:.1J1l>l1lim lrut! r"'}~(1.S 111 l'uJ,,-,I1DC U. 11< , e~ Iii

~ I 'I he ... ute .,f 1":'(1)< 1" ,.nl·e"" jl J ~l~lul"rs .UlJ l\klre,s Ih ... "'mLu~ III IilllilalillllS In Ihe I.lh,,1 ,III <;1,lIl<I , IJ'~ II> D~"rCS'l Ih. lechnClI" i.:...1 lk\ f"r" ,,'ul tnlln~ \~'lh th~ II ... (""n~I((Uliliti UIIU 1'1<,1.'(1 Ul< "'lbliLuIIOlI.ll n~'II., 411' ii, .-ill/l.:l1 •

f1I f)~kIld.;Jnl' III I", rd~nL'd I .. IhI:- .1u"'i~" [)"l'alim~n1 l<1r '''''c,'i,""tiIlR lur tllelr crimlnrti nnd I 1cf;~1 1111]; 1\1'r\.: lU l"bhy~'itS 1,,1' Q fi.rd 'II ~II 'n~ wILh"UI rho: pmr"r ,..,mli I~ blld I "~'Il'L"

7 l)':[I!nd"ms II> ihU~ I'll r "j I'ublk ar"lll~~ In len m"dl.l ""III"L' Lb,!JlU.lc1 In 1·I .... m'ilflo cI"." hi R-IIIIL' WIU II", 1IIlIJ1'" "fhis hu<in, ,

Nt ,\n~ amI oJ! "Lh~ relic] Ih.u Plnilllill ' llli!,!lJt y,n\\ thlLl he I ellLiU~u III m ~ lUI') 1n~1

~1"'tLUU suilmlllL-J

1)' ~,"1~ -IXU Whi'~ 11111 flriH' lu, rcs~, 7K7.j" 1~"f5L

7

IN 1m: tINITF.D ,'iT\tES n1STRICT COURT fOR THE \\'ESlfJt'\ Olsnu '" or Tl,;,.AS

AUSTIN DIVI ION

Rilld EJRIJ'lb l:llIroad .. ('ltlilrJjff

..

Tilt'Sr/JIJ.' /J/ Te.ws • Joe AuutmlJu

Aml'ricamlgailJ.\/ Hatc!. Dlmiel Pip"!>, ..

•

I hereby certify LIwu oopi~ a I-Lbo II1UId cd Plaintifi s Second Orillirul Amended Pmliml Plail1liIT's Flrstlb:q1lC!!i1 f(lr f'todudian afOocumt:ms, Pllltl1li!'r.! ,iI'it l{eqI.I~iI for Adlflissio1lS oud "PlDIDtlff ~ f'iell ReqUf::.oll fur fml~I'ri es III Defmdzmb! <:cnl« for Jewlllh ComrlJullily Sflldlc:5 .... 'IR mll1!cd by cl!l'l1fiai mllil. MWDed micipt ""loes!llll til D:lvlti I !!)nowitz lind tl:w! Cent", rUf Study urpopulllT CuhunI, Ccnta ar JI!Wi~ CtllDDJurn:ty SttJdll1S;wI lb" ILllomey of fflXlrd fot the Stale orTc;o:as on Ihls 5'10 dJir or June. 2006

·'1«17 Whl~ Iilm Urive Au!ltin. T ~lClIS 18749