Case Study“Ek Ruka Hua
Faisla”
1
Prepared by : Rajesh SrivastavaRoll No. : 20 (EPGDIM – IIFT, New Delhi)
Ek Ruka Hua FaislaDirected by Basu Chatterjee
Produced by Basu Chatterjee
Written byScreenplay: Ranjit KapurBasu ChatterjeeDialogue: Ranjit Kapur [1]
Music by Basu Chakravarti
Cinematography Ajay Prabhakar
Editing by Kamal A. Sehgal
Release date(s) 1986
Running time 117 min.
Language Hindi
Introduction : Ek Ruka Hua Faisla (एक रुका हुआ फैसला) is a Bollywood film of 1986, directed by Basu Chatterjee. It is a remake of the Golden Bear winning, American motion picture 12 Angry Men (1957), which was directed by Sidney Lumet.
2
Ek Ruka Hua Faisla
The Golden Bear is the highest prize awarded for the best film at the Berlin International Film Festival. Bears are the symbol of Berlin,
Few Facts – the Character •The story moves around a boy who is 19 years old.•Lives in slums•Belongs to minority•Childhood was in miserable conditions•His mother died when he was 9 years old•His father was a drinker, quarrelsome & a cruel person, used to beat him daily•He hit a stone on his teacher when he was 10 years old•Engaged in Car theft & gambling •Expert in knife playing•He was sent to Reformity School for 1.5 years against a case.
4
Background : There is a 19 yrs old boy who has been alleged as murder of his father by the court .
Court Decision : A panel of 12 Juror appointed to decide that, the boy has actually murdered his father or not.
Clause in Court’s statement : Jurors have to make One Decision either murder or not-murderer.
Re-take :
The Character
Juror of the Case
Deepak Kejriwal
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 5
C. D. Sindhu
Amitabh Srivastava
6
The knife; the tool used to murder the old man
Eye witness 1 – an old man who was the neighbor of the victim
Eye witness 2 – a lady who lives opposite to the victim’s house
Key evidences in the Murder Case
Deepak Kejriwal
1 2 3 4
S. M. Zaheer
5
9
Subhash Udghate
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi
Sitting arrangement
Amitabh Srivastava Pankaj Kapur
6 7 8
10 11 12
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
7
Architect
Contractor (House painting)
4 53 62
1
89101112
Jurors Sitting Arrangement
Moderator
Professional(Advertising)
Architect
ContractorLawyer
“Is the Boy a murder ?”(Voting was taken as a criteria)
Deepak Kejriwal
1 2 3 4
S. M. Zaheer
5
9
Subhash Udghate
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi
Amitabh Srivastava Pankaj Kapur
6 7 8
10 11 12
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
8
Architect
Contractor (House painting)
4 53 62
1
89101112
Root CauseOne of the Jurors voted against the motion that “the Boy might not be
a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal
1 2 3 4
S. M. Zaheer
5
9
Subhash Udghate
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi
Amitabh Srivastava Pankaj Kapur
6 7 8
10 11 12
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
9
Voting ~ 1
Architect
Contractor (House painting)
4 53 62
1
89101112
1 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal
1 2 3 4
S. M. Zaheer
5
9
Subhash Udghate
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi
Amitabh Srivastava Pankaj Kapur
6 7 8
10 11 12
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
10
Voting ~ 2
4 53 62
1
89101112
2 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 11
4 53 62
1
89101112
Voting ~ 3
5 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 12
4 53 62
1
89101112
Voting ~ 4
6 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
50 : 50
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 13
4 53 62
1
89101112
Voting ~ 5
9 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 14
4 53 62
1
89101112
Voting ~ 6
8 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 15
4 53 62
1
89101112
Voting ~ 7
11 /12
Juror’s Decision
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 16
4 53 62
1
89101112
Final
12/12
Juror’s Decision
The Group jointly decided “The Boy is
not a murder”
Moderator
Professional(Advertising)
Architect
ContractorLawyer
Deepak Kejriwal Amitabh Srivastava
1 2 3 4
Pankaj Kapur S. M. Zaheer
5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi 18
4 53 62
1
89101112
Learning…
Moderator
Advertising Architect
ContractorLawyer
“Business Organisation”
•Different People•Different Background•Different Profession•Different Age Groups•Different Mindsets
HEAD
Sales Marketing
Purchase
Service Parts
Operations ManufacturingHR Finance
R&D
SIS
Deepak Kejriwal
1 2 3 4
S. M. Zaheer
5
9
Subhash Udghate
Annu Kapoor Subbiraj Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi
Amitabh Srivastava Pankaj Kapur
6 7 8
10 11 12
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina
19
Voting
Architect
Contractor (House painting)
4 53 62
1
89101112
1 /12
Reason for Difference
“The Boy might not be a murder”.
ConflictPowerPolitics
•Different People•Different Background•Different Profession•Different Age Groups•Different Mindsets
21Either Convince /
Get convinced
Conflict
Why Conflict Occurs :
•Differences in information, beliefs, values, interests, or desires.•A scarcity of some resource.•Rivalries in which one person or group competes with another
There are 5 ways to manage conflict
Ways to Manage Conflict
• Avoidance (just leave it)• Competition (I win, you lose)• Accommodation (I lose or give in)• Compromise (we both get something)• Collaboration (we both “win”)
23
• Build good relationships before conflict occurs
• Do not let small problems escalate; deal with them as they arise
• Respect differences
• Listen to others’ perspectives on the conflict situation
• Acknowledge feelings before focussing on facts
• Focus on solving problems, not changing people
• If you can’t resolve the problem, turn to someone who can help
• Remember to adapt your style to the situation and persons involved
Tips to Manage Conflict
24
Power : (Make things happen in the way you want)A capacity that “A” has to influence the behavior of “B” so that “B” acts in accordance with “A’s”
wishes.
Politics :Behavior to influence or attempt to influence the distribution of advantages and disadvantages within the organization/group
Power & Politics
26
•Personal oriented to goal oriented
•Individual driven to team driven
•Enforcement to facilitation
•Present oriented to future oriented
Be the Change