Decentralized Basic Education Three (DBE3) Relevant Education for Youth June 2005 – December 2011
FINAL PROJECT REPORT
VOLUME 2: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
LIST OF CONTENTS
1. NORTH SUMATERA PROVINCIAL REPORT ............................................................................................... 1
1.1 MAP OF PROJECT COVERAGE IN NORTH SUMATERA ............................................................................................. 3
1.2 DISTRICT PERFORMANCE ON THE DBE3 PROJECT ................................................................................................ 4
1.3 LIST OF NON-FORMAL SERVICE PROVIDERS ........................................................................................................ 7
1.4 PARTNER SCHOOLS AND AN ASSESSMENT OF THEIR PERFORMANCE ........................................................................ 8
1.5 DISTRICT FACILITATORS / PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT ....................................................................................... 13
1.6 WORKING WITH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTIONS AND LPMP ........................................................................... 22
1.7 OVERVIEW OF TRAINEE DATA ........................................................................................................................ 23
1.8 DISSEMINATION OF DBE3 PROGRAMS ............................................................................................................. 25
1.9 REVIEW OF THE EXTENSION DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION ....................................... 27
1.10 LIST OF DBE3 TECHNICAL, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF IN NORTH SUMATERA, AUGUST 2011 ............ 33
2. BANTEN PROVINCIAL REPORT .............................................................................................................. 35
2.1 MAP OF PROJECT COVERAGE IN BANTEN ......................................................................................................... 37
2.2 DISTRICT PERFORMANCE ON THE DBE3 PROJECT .............................................................................................. 38
2.3 LIST OF NON-FORMAL SERVICE PROVIDERS ...................................................................................................... 40
2.4 PARTNER SCHOOLS AND AN ASSESSMENT OF THEIR PERFORMANCE ...................................................................... 41
2.5 DISTRICT FACILITATORS / PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT ....................................................................................... 44
2.6 WORKING WITH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTIONS AND LPMP ........................................................................... 48
2.7 OVERVIEW OF TRAINEE DATA ........................................................................................................................ 49
2.8 DISSEMINATION OF DBE3 PROGRAMS ............................................................................................................. 51
2.9 REVIEW OF THE EXTENSION DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION ....................................... 53
2.10 LIST OF DBE3 TECHNICAL, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF IN WEST JAVA AND BANTEN, AUGUST 2011 .... 54
3. WEST JAVA PROVINCIAL REPORT .......................................................................................................... 55
3.1 MAP OF PROJECT COVERAGE IN WEST JAVA ..................................................................................................... 57
3.2 DISTRICT PERFORMANCE ON THE DBE3 PROJECT .............................................................................................. 58
3.3 LIST OF NON-FORMAL SERVICE PROVIDERS ...................................................................................................... 60
3.4 PARTNER SCHOOLS AND AN ASSESSMENT OF THEIR PERFORMANCE ...................................................................... 61
3.5 DISTRICT FACILITATORS / PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT ....................................................................................... 66
3.6 WORKING WITH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTIONS AND LPMP ........................................................................... 73
3.7 OVERVIEW OF TRAINEE DATA ........................................................................................................................ 73
3.8 DISSEMINATION OF DBE3 PROGRAMS ............................................................................................................. 75
3.9 REVIEW OF THE EXTENSION DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION ....................................... 77
3.10 LIST OF DBE3 TECHNICAL, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF IN WEST JAVA AND BANTEN, AUGUST 2011 .... 80
4. CENTRAL JAVA PROVINCIAL REPORT .................................................................................................... 81
4.1 MAP OF PROJECT COVERAGE IN CENTRAL JAVA ................................................................................................. 83
4.2 DISTRICT PERFORMANCE ON THE DBE3 PROJECT .............................................................................................. 84
4.3 LIST OF NON-FORMAL SERVICE PROVIDERS ...................................................................................................... 88
4.4 PARTNER SCHOOLS AND AN ASSESSMENT OF THEIR PERFORMANCE ...................................................................... 89
4.5 DISTRICT FACILITATORS / PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT ....................................................................................... 94
4.6 WORKING WITH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTIONS AND LPMP ......................................................................... 104
4.7 OVERVIEW OF TRAINEE DATA ...................................................................................................................... 105
4.8 DISSEMINATION OF DBE3 PROGRAMS ........................................................................................................... 107
4.9 REVIEW OF THE EXTENSION DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION ..................................... 110
4.10 LIST OF DBE3 TECHNICAL, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF IN CENTRAL JAVA, AUGUST 2011 ................ 114
5. EAST JAVA PROVINCIAL REPORT ......................................................................................................... 115
5.1 MAP OF PROJECT COVERAGE IN EAST JAVA .................................................................................................... 117
5.2 DISTRICT PERFORMANCE ON THE DBE3 PROJECT ............................................................................................ 118
5.3 LIST OF NON-FORMAL SERVICE PROVIDERS .................................................................................................... 120
5.4 PARTNER SCHOOLS AND AN ASSESSMENT OF THEIR PERFORMANCE .................................................................... 121
5.5 DISTRICT FACILITATORS / PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT ..................................................................................... 126
5.6 WORKING WITH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTIONS AND LPMP ......................................................................... 136
5.7 OVERVIEW OF TRAINEE DATA ...................................................................................................................... 137
5.8 DISSEMINATION OF DBE3 PROGRAMS ........................................................................................................... 139
5.9 EAST JAVA PROVINCIAL AND DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND ACHIEVEMENTS 2010 – 2011 ........................... 142
5.10 LIST OF DBE3 TECHNICAL, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF IN EAST JAVA, AUGUST 2011 ..................... 147
6. SOUTH SULAWESI PROVINCIAL REPORT ............................................................................................. 149
6.1 MAP OF PROJECT COVERAGE IN SOUTH SULAWESI ........................................................................................... 151
6.2 DISTRICT PERFORMANCE ON THE DBE3 PROJECT ............................................................................................ 152
6.3 LIST OF NON-FORMAL SERVICE PROVIDERS .................................................................................................... 156
6.4 PARTNER SCHOOLS AND AN ASSESSMENT OF THEIR PERFORMANCE .................................................................... 157
6.5 DISTRICT FACILITATORS / PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT ..................................................................................... 162
6.6 WORKING WITH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTIONS AND LPMP ......................................................................... 171
6.7 OVERVIEW OF TRAINEE DATA ...................................................................................................................... 172
6.8 DISSEMINATION OF DBE3 PROGRAMS ........................................................................................................... 174
6.9 SOUTH SULAWESI EXTENSION DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND ACHIEVEMENTS 2010 – 2011 .......................... 176
6.10 LIST OF DBE3 TECHNICAL, MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF IN SOUTH SULWAESI, AUGUST 2011 ............ 181
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
1
1. NORTH SUMATERA PROVINCIAL REPORT
This annex contains information and data concerning the implementation of the DBE3 project in North Sumatera from 2005 to 2011. It should be read in conjunction with Volume I of the DBE3 Final Project Report, which contains a detailed account of the project activities.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
3
1.1 Map of Project Coverage in North Sumatera
Below is a map showing the districts in which the DBE3 program has been implemented in North Sumatera. There are 8 partner districts, with whom DBE had a formal agreement and 4 non-partner districts, where there was no formal agreement but in which the program was also disseminated.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
4
1.2 District Performance on the DBE3 Project
1.2.1 Highlights of District and Provincial Performance in North Sumatera
Binjai :
1. Binjai has 3 schools which can be used as models and be the target of study visits: SMPN 11, MTsN and SMP Tunas Pelita.
2. The Mayor, local parliament and District Education Office have a strong commitment to support implementation and have instituonalized the DBE 3 program. The Mayor also has created an Education Quality Development Team (Tim Pengembangan Mutu Pendidikan Kota Binjai). The budget for DBE3 implementation through the team started in APBD FY 2011 and 2012.
3. The District Education Office and MORA have issued a decree in 2011 for District Facilitators as trainers and mentors.
4. The District Education Office has issued an official letter to every target school to implement the DBE 3 program
5. The District Education Office has issued an official letter to every non school target to replicate the DBE3 program
6. Binjai has five national facilitators that have a strong commitment to facilitate training in other provinces.
Deli Serdang:
1. Deli Serdang has 3 model schools: SMPN 1 Tanjung Morawa, SMPN 2 Lubuk Pakam, and MTsN Lubuk Pakam, which are recommended for visits.
2. MTsN Lubuk Pakam has created a mathematics clinic. The purpose of the clinic is to increase student competency in mathematics
3. The District Education Office and MORA have issued a decree in 2011 for District Facilitators as trainers and mentors.
4. A strategy for program sustainability is being implemented through the MKKS (School Principal Working Group).
5. Local government has provided a budget for program replication, which will continue until end of this year.
6. The District Education Office and MORA have issued SK for District Facilitator as trainer and mentor
Tebing Tinggi:
1. Tebing Tinggi has two model schools: SMPN 1 and MTsN Tebing Tinggi recommended for visits.
2. Local Goverment, including the District Education Office, DPRD and Bappeda have a strong commitment to replicate the DBE3 program for all secondary schools with using the district budget (APBD)
3. Teachers in SMPN 1 Tebing Tinggi have a new innovation to integrate active learning with ICT
Tanjung Balai:
1. Tanjungbalai has 3 model schools: SMPN 1, SMPN 4, and SMPN 5 which are recommended for visits.
2. SMPN 4 has a new inovation to implement moving class for lessons.
3. SMPN 1 is successfully innovating teacher development through school level MGMPs.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
5
4. The District Education Office has issued SK in 2011 for District Facilitators as trainers and mentors
5. Local Goverment, including the District Education Office,DPRD,Bappeda has steong commitment to replicate DBE 3 program for all secondary school with using budget APBD
Dairi:
1. Dairi has 2 model schools: SMPN 3 Sidikalang and SMPN 1 Sumbul which are recommended for visits.
2. 15 additional District facilitators have been trained to accelerate the dissemination of the program in non target schools.
3. The District Education Office has issued a decree for District Facilitators as trainers and mentors.
Tapanuli Utara:
1. Tapanuli Utara has 3 model schools: MTsN Peanornor, SMPN 4 Tarutung, and SMPN 1 Siborong-borong which are recommended for visits.
2. 14 additional District facilitators have been trained to accelerate the dissemination of the program in non target schools.
3. Local Goverment, including the District Education Office, DPRD and Bappeda have a strong commitment to replicate the DBE3 program for all secondary schools using the district budget.
4. MGMP has been created and is being supported in each sub district for strengthening implementation of the DBE3 program
Tapanuli Selatan:
1. Tapanuli Selatan has 4 model schools: SMPN 1 Angkola Barat, SMPN 1 Batang Angkola, SMPN 1 Sayur Matinggi, SMPN 1 Sipirok which are recommended for visits.
2. Local Goverment, including the District Education Office, MORA, DPRD and Bappeda has a strong commitment to replicate DBE 3 program to non target secondary schools using the district budget APBD. For FY 2011 it has allocated a budget of Rp. 185 Million for dissemination, and for FY 2012 has allocated Rp 1 Billion
3. The Bupati and Deputy Bupati have visited target schools twice and given support to continue implementation of the DBE3 program
4. Ibu Rosmawati and Purnama Dewi, teachers in SMPN 1 Angkola Barat successfully completed classroon action research in social sicence, and the result has been published in the DBE 3 CAR journal
5. The District Education Office has issued a decree in 2011 for District Facilitators as trainers and mentors.
6. The District Education Office has instructed principals of secondary schools to use the district facilitator as a resource person to increase education quality
Sibolga:
1. Sibolga has one model school: SMPN 3 Sibolga which are recommended for visits.
2. Local goverment, The Mayor and DPRD have a strong commitment to continue the DBE program and have also allocated a budget for dissemination to non target schools.
3. At the end of this FY, 100% of junior secondary schools had replicated the DBE3 program
4. The District Education Office has issued a decree in 2011 for District Facilitators as trainers and mentors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
6
North Sumatera Provincial Government:
1. The Provincial Education Office, DPRD and Bappeda have been active in participating in project activities, and have a strong commitment to disseminate the DBE3 program to non target districts.
2. The District Education Office has allocated a budget for dissemination of teacher training using the BTL 2 and 3 modules, and the training will be conducted in February 2012 for 1320 teachers of the 4 national examination subjects from 33 districts.
3. MORA has issued an offical letter in 2011 to the MORA schools in each district to use DBE3 modules to increase teacher quality in lessons.
4. Four Bupatis/ Mayors (50%) from the target districts attended the showcase meeting at province level on 28 September 2011 as a sign of their commitment and awareness of the DBE3 program
5. DPRD Komisi E North Sumatera, Bapak Sopar Siburian has written and article in the daily newspaper Waspada Medan about his DBE experiences in increasing education quality.
1.2.2 Assessment of Partner District Performance
The performance and impact of the DBE3 program has been varied in the different districts and schools. Below is an assessment of the performance of the DBE3 partner districts in North Sumatera.
The criteria used were as follows:
• Level of commitment of local stakeholders
• Impact on partner schools
• Extent of project dissemination achieved
Each of the criteria is rated on a scale of one to three – with three being the highest rating. This has resulted in an overall star rating for each districts. Three stars in the highest rating and denotes a high level of stakeholder commitment, a generally high impact on practice in partner schools and a considerable amount of dissemination to non-partner schools. A rating of one star denotes a low level in each of these criteria.
NORTH SUMATERA
CO
HO
RT
EX
TE
NS
ION
/
CO
RE
Lo
cal G
overn
men
t
Sta
ff C
om
mit
men
t
Imp
act
on
Sch
oo
ls
Rep
lica
tio
n
alr
ead
y t
aken
pla
ce
Fu
nd
ing f
or
R
ep
lica
tio
n
Overa
ll R
an
kin
g
1. Dairi 2 E 2 2 2 2 ** 2. Tapanuli Selatan 2 E 2 2 2 3 *** 3. Tanjung Balai 2 E 2 2 2 3 *** 4. Tebing Tinggi 1 C 2 1 2 3 ** 5. Tapanuli Utara 1 & 2 E 3 2 2 2 *** 6. Binjai 1 E 3 2 2 2 *** 7. Deli Serdang 1 C 1 2 2 2 ** 8. Sibolga 1 C 2 1 2 2 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
7
1.3 List of Non-Formal Service Providers
Below is a list non-formal service providers with whom DBE3 worked between 2005 and 2008.
District NFE Provider Learners Tutors
M F Total M F Total
Tapanuli Utara 1 Kejar Paket B Mapan 12 8 20 2 4 6
Deli Serdang Kejar Paket B Pintar 4 12 16 1 5 6
Pesantren Al-Amin 10 12 22 2 4 6
Kejar Paket B Semangat 7 11 18 2 4 6
LPM Marginal 13 46 59 5 7 `3
LSM Madia Insani 10 5 15 5 3 8
Tebing Tinggi Kejar Paket B Harapan II 6 4 10 4 2 6
Kejar Paket B Harapan III 12 4 16 3 3 6
Kejar Paket B Laskar-Nurul 11 7 18 6 3 9
Kejar Paket B Cendana-Melati 26 14 40 6 6 12
PKBM Paket B Taqwa 9 8 17 3 4 7
Kejar Paket B Melati Tunas 12 6 18 6 0 6
Binjai PKBM Budi Utomo 23 10 33 10 4 14
Kejar Paket B Budi Luhur 29 11 40 5 8 13
Kejar Paket B Maju 8 8 16 1 5 6
Kejar Paket B B Utomo 13 5 18 4 2 6
Kejar Paket B Asuhan Ayah Bunda 24 6 30 3 3 6
LSM Yayasan Karang 15 5 20 7 2 9
Sibolga Kejar Paket B Cerdas 92 56 148 15 27 42
Tanjung Balai PKBM Datuk bandar 13 19 32 2 4 6
PKBM Perwira 17 20 37 1 5 6
Dairi PKBM Balee 18 5 23 2 10 12
Tapanuli Utara 2 Kejar Paket B Mawar 1 0 1 3 3 6
Kejar Paket B Matahari 3 0 3 3 3 6
Tapanuli Selatan SKB Tapanuli Selatan 72 64 136 6 12 18
PKBM Al-Ikhlash 12 8 20 5 4 9
Kejar Paket B Permata Hati 15 5 20 3 4 7
Kejar Paket B Dahlia 15 29 44 2 5 7
Total 28 502 388 890 117 146 263
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
8
1.4 Partner Schools and an Assessment of Their Performance
1.4.1 The Whole School Training Program
During the first three years of the project teacher training modules were developed, as well as subject teaching modules for the English, civics and mathematics. Facilitators were trained to deliver these modules and used them to train the partner schools in each of the 44 project districts, which joined the project in two cohorts in 2006 and 2007.
From the beginning of 2009 DBE3 focused primarily on a more intensive program in formal junior secondary schools, SMP and MTs intitally in 25 “extension” districts from existing cohort 1 and 2 districts in which to implement a more in-depth DBE3 school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement. The program included:
• An increase in the number of directly supported schools in each of the extension districts, in most cases from four to ten, in order to create a greater presence and critical mass;
• The implementation of a school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement which involves training teachers of all core subjects, school principals and other senior management staff in partner schools.
The whole school program was later extended to the remaining 19 ‘core’ districts in late 2009 but without the selection of additional partner schools in those districts.
Below is a list of partner schools that took part in the whole school training program. The original cohort 1 and 2 schools are indicated in the list by pink shading, while the additional schools in the 25 extension districts, which joined the project in 2009 are left unshaded.
1.4.2 How the Partner School Assessment was Done
DBE3 undertook an evaluation of these schools which was completed in August 2011. An instrument was developed to assess which schools are implementing DBE3 innovations well and are worth visiting. The instrument evaluated 4 key areas of the school performance:
• Teacher Activities: To what degree the teachers encourage interaction among students
provide challenging and varied tasks (discussion, experimentation, problem solving) and use formative assessment techniques.
• Student Activities: To what degree the student activities vary (working cooperatively, solving
problems, experimenting), they express their own thoughts orally and in writing and use a variety of media in their lessons.
• Classroom Environment: To what degree the students in the school sit, work and interact in
groups, work is displayed on the wall and if they learn using more diverse sources (media, environment)
• Principal Leadership: To what degree the Principal in the school encourags change, supports
the professional development of teachers and supports other innovations in the school
Following the evaluation, each school was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest. In some case a ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little impact. A ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little or no impact.
3 2 1 0
Category
Schools implementing the results of the DBE3 program well and widely, and there is a strong recommendation to visit.
Schools applying DBE3 results well in some classes but not widely there is encouragement to visit
The application of the results of the DBE3 program is limited and there is no encouragemet to visit.
There are no visible results of the DBE3 program.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
9
1.4.3 List of Training Received
The data for the partner schools in North Sumatera including the results of the assessment are set out on the next page. It also indicates the training packages which have been received by each school and are indicated by A, B, C and D as set out in the table below.
A: Cohort 1 District Schools B: Cohort 2 District Schools Life Skills Program (2005 – 2009)
Better Teaching and Learning 1 Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice ICT for Life Skills Education Civics Modules English Modules Non Curricular Toolkits School Retention Toolkit A* also included Mathematics module
Better Teaching and Learning 1 Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice ICT for Life Skills Education Civics Modules English Modules Non Curricular Toolkits B* also included Mathematics Module
C: Extension District Schools D: Core Districts Schools Whole School Approach (2009 – 2011)
Better Teaching and Learning2 Better Teaching and Learning3 Better Teaching and Learning4 How to Use ICT in BTL Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
Better Teaching and Learning2 Better Teaching and Learning3 Better Teaching and Learning4 Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
10
1.4.4 List of DBE Partner Schools in North Sumatera and an Assessment of their Performance
The original partner schools which participated in the project before the expansion to ten schools in each extension district are highlighted in pink.
NORTH SUMATERA
Extension Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP Negeri 11 Binjai SMP State Binjai Utara Kota Binjai C 409 352 761 26 29 55 *** 2 MTs N Binjai MTs State Binjai Selatan Kota Binjai A & C 199 318 517 21 28 49 *** 3 SMP Tunas Pelita SMP Private Binjai Utara Kota Binjai A & C 151 149 300 12 12 24 ** 4 SMP Negeri 2 Binjai SMP State Binjai Kota Kota Binjai C 517 493 1.010 15 55 70 * 5 SMP Negeri 4 Binjai SMP State Binjai Timur Kota Binjai C 462 422 884 17 37 54 * 6 SMP Negeri 8 Binjai SMP State Binjai Selatan Kota Binjai A & C 511 470 981 16 43 59 * 7 MTs Al Wasliyah 47 MTs Private Binjai Kota Kota Binjai C 132 105 237 13 17 30 * 8 MTs Islahiyah MTs Private Binjai Kota Kota Binjai C 72 78 150 8 14 22 * 9 SMP Negeri 6 Binjai SMP State Binjai Utara Kota Binjai A & C 471 468 939 16 54 70 -
10 SMP Negeri 7 Binjai SMP State Binjai Kota Kota Binjai C 445 450 895 13 45 58 -
11 SMPN 3 Sidikalang SMP State Sidikalang Dairi B & C 386 465 851 9 34 43 *** 12 SMPN 1 Sidikalang SMP State Sidikalang Dairi C 363 438 801 21 46 67 ** 13 SMPN1 Sumbul SMP State Sumbul Dairi B & C 392 366 758 12 30 42 ** 14 SMPN 2 Sumbul SMP State Sumbul Dairi C 260 259 519 13 19 32 * 15 SMPN 3 Sumbul SMP State Sumbul Dairi C 366 372 738 13 21 34 * 16 SMPS Bukit Cahaya Sumbul SMP Private Sumbul Dairi B & C 67 36 103 16 11 27 * 17 SMPN 2 Sidikalang SMP State Sidikalang Dairi C 439 412 851 16 34 50 - 18 SMPS HKBP Sidikalang SMP Private Sidikalang Dairi C 289 329 618 8 30 38 - 19 MTs N Sidikalang MTs State Sidikalang Dairi B & C 69 75 144 4 11 15 - 20 SMPS Bukit Cahaya Sidikalang SMP Private Sidikalang Dairi C 115 83 198 10 28 38 -
21 SMP Negeri 1 Tanjung Balai SMP State Tanjungbalai Selatan Tanjung Balai B & C 429 544 973 15 44 59 *** 22 SMP Negeri 4 Tanjung Balai SMP State Datuk Bandar Timur Tanjung Balai C 318 363 681 9 34 43 *** 23 SMP Negeri 5 Tanjung Balai SMP State Datuk Bandra Tanjung Balai B & C 289 329 618 8 30 38 ** 24 SMPN Satu Atap SMP State Tanjungbalai Utara Tanjung Balai C 144 205 349 7 14 21 * 25 MTs YMPI MTs Private Sei Tualang Raso Tanjung Balai C 267 333 600 10 28 38 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
11
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
26 SMP Negeri 2 Tanjung Balai SMP State Datuk Bandar Timur Tanjung Balai C 389 393 782 9 40 49 -
27 SMP Negeri 10 Tanjung Balai SMP State Tanjungbalai Selatan Tanjung Balai C 467 402 869 12 30 42 -
28 MTs Negeri Tanjung Balai MTs State Tanjungbalai Selatan Tanjung Balai B & C 262 362 624 17 40 57 -
29 MTs Al Fajri MTs Private Datuk Bandar Tanjung Balai B & C 37 33 70 5 10 15 -
30 MTs Al Washliyah MTs Private Tanjungbalai Utara Tanjung Balai C 117 155 272 16 11 27 -
31 SMPN 1 Angkola Barat SMP State Angkola Barat Tapanuli Selatan B & C 300 291 591 8 30 38 ***
32 SMPN 1 Sayur Matinggi SMP State Sayur Matinggi Tapanuli Selatan C 239 303 542 14 25 39 ***
33 MTSN Batang Toru MTs State Batang Toru Tapanuli Selatan C 299 362 661 17 30 47 *
34 SMPN 1 Batang Angkola SMP State Batang Angkola Tapanuli Selatan C 385 403 788 34 40 74 *
35 SMPN 2 Batang Angkola SMP State Batang Angkola Tapanuli Selatan B & C 240 189 429 7 35 42 *
36 MTs N Batang Angkola MTs State Btang Angkola Tapanuli Selatan B & C 250 287 537 22 40 62 *
37 MTs N Darul Mursyidi MTs State Angkola Barat Tapanuli Selatan B & C 44 47 91 11 11 22 -
38 MTs N Sipirok MTs State Sipirok Tapanuli Selatan C 118 102 220 11 12 23 -
39 SMPN 3 Batang Angkola SMP State Batang Angkola Tapanuli Selatan C 176 172 348 8 19 27 -
40 SMPN 2 Sayur Matinggi SMP State Sayur Matinggi Tapanuli Selatan C 191 213 404 29 24 53 -
41 MTs N Peanornor MTs State Pahae Julu Tapanuli Utara A & C 57 50 107 6 12 18 ***
42 SMPN 4 Tarutung SMP State Tarutung Tapanuli Utara A & C 229 201 430 10 20 30 **
43 SMPN 2 Pangaribuan SMP State Pangaribuan Tapanuli Utara B & C 208 164 372 9 15 24 **
44 SMPN 1 Siborong-borong SMP State Siborong-borong Tapanuli Utara C 384 408 792 17 38 55 **
45 SMPN 1 Tarutung SMP State Tarutung Tapanuli Utara A & C 303 285 588 11 33 44 *
46 SMPN 2 Pahae Julu SMP State Pahae Julu Tapanuli Utara A & C 127 124 251 7 9 16 *
47 SMPN 3 Pangaribuan SMP State Pangaribuan Tapanuli Utara B & C 154 138 292 9 10 19 *
48 SMPN 1 Sipoholon SMP State Sipoholon Tapanuli Utara B & C 297 241 538 8 21 29 *
49 SMPN 2 Sipoholon SMP State Sipoholon Tapanuli Utara B & C 183 223 406 6 19 25 -
50 SMPN 1 Siatas Barita SMP State Siatas Barita Tapanuli Utara C 296 259 555 4 27 31 -
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
12
NORTH SUMATERA Core Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMPN 2 Lubuk Pakam SMP State Lubuk Pakam Deli Serdang A & D 445 475 920 21 40 61 ***
2 SMPN 1 Tanjung Morawa SMP State Tanjung Morawa Deli Serdang A & D 387 594 981 16 44 60 **
3 MTs N Lubuk Pakam MTs State Lubuk Pakam Deli Serdang A & D 221 309 530 12 41 53 **
4 SMPN 2 Deli Tua SMP State Delitua Deli Serdang A & D 446 486 932 20 41 61 -
5 SMPN 3 Sibolga SMP State Sibolga Kota Sibolga A & D 284 331 615 10 41 51 ** 6 SMPN 6 Sibolga SMP State Sibolga Utara Sibolga A & D 233 241 474 8 26 34 * 7 MTs Negeri Sibolga MTs State Sibolga Selatan Sibolga A & D 259 452 711 15 31 46 * 8 SMPN 4 Sibolga SMP State Sibolga Utara Sibolga A & D 306 330 636 12 33 45 -
9 MTs N Tebing Tinggi MTs State Tebing Tinggi Kota Tebing Tinggi A & D 121 177 298 7 16 23 ** 10 SMPN 4 Tebing Tinggi SMP State Tebing Tinggi Kota Tebing Tinggi A & D 322 365 687 19 34 53 ** 11 SMPN 1 Tebing Tinggi SMP State Tebing Tinggi Kota Tebing Tinggi A & D 387 402 789 19 42 61 * 12 SMPN 2 Tebing Tinggi SMP State Tebing Tinggi Kota Tebing Tinggi A & D 287 332 619 23 26 49 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
13
1.5 District Facilitators / Performance Assessment
1.5.1 List of District Facilitators for Non Formal Education in North Sumatra
Below is a list of facilitators from North Sumatera trained to support the Non-Formal Education program.
Name Position District Subject
Muhammad Yuzli Yar, BA Pensiunan PNS, Ketua Komite PLS Deli Serdang Deli Serdang Management
Drs. Saur MT, Situmeang Pamong Belajar SKB Petumbukan Deli Serdang Deli Serdang Teaching and Learning
Khairuddin Noor Hasibuan, S.Ag Penyuluh Kandepag Tebing Tinggi Tebing Tinnggi Management
Zulkipli, S.Pd Staff Dinas P & K Tebing Tinggi Tebing Tinnggi Teaching and Learning
Drs. Martua Parlindungan Lumbangaol
TLD, Diknas Tapanuli Utara Tapanuli Utara Management
Sabarita Sitepu, S.Sos Pengelola PKBM Tapanuli Utara Teaching and Learning
Agus Sanjaya Pekerja LSM, Koordinator Porgram Pendidikan dan Kesehatan
Sibolga Teaching and Learning
Piher tarigan Penilik PLS Sibolga Management
Dra. Hj. Siiti Aminah Kasi Kesenian Dinas Diknas Kab. Pangkep Binjai Management
Suriati, S. Sos Staff PLS Dinas Diknas Binjai Teaching and Learning
Agus Salim S. Sos Manajer Program Komunitas Karang TB Tanjung Balai - Management
Subroto Kepala Sekolah MI Al-Falah Tanjung Balai - Teaching and Learning
Haposoan Hasugian Penilik Pendidikan Luar Sekolah Dairi Management
Ir Taufan Daniel Sembiring Tutor Paket B/SKB Sidikalang Dairi Teaching and Learning
Drs. Ismail Tutor SKB Tapsel Tapanuli Selatan Management
Irwan Saleh Siregar Tutor Paket B Permata Hati Tapanuli Selatan Teaching and Learning
Roslinda Sitanggang Guru SMPN 1 Tarutung Tapanuli Utara Teaching and Learning
Parinton Simanjuntak Kepsek SMPN 4 Sipoholon Tapanuli Utara Management
1.5.2 List of District Facilitators for the Life Skills Training Program in North Sumatra 2006 – 2008
Below is a list of facilitators from North Sumatera trained to implement the Life Skills program.
Name Position Module District Institution
Purwanto, S.Pd Teacher English Binjai SMP Negeri 9 Binjai
Muhammad Amin Nasution, MA Lecturer English Binjai STKIP Budidaya Binjai
Nurhaidah, S.Pd Teacher Civics Binjai MTs Alwasliyah 47
Warsi’in, S.Pd Teacher Civics Binjai SMP Negeri 11
Asmawati, S.Pd Teacher BTL Binjai SMP Negeri 10
Drs.Safiruddin, M.Pd Principal BTL Binjai MTs Al-Islahiyah Binjai
Hamidan, SS Kasi ICT Binjai Tenaga Teknis SMP/MTS
M.Yus Efendi, S.Pd Teacher ICT Binjai SMA Negeri 2
Drs. Anas B Supervisor Life Skills Binjai Tk.Menengah, Kandepag Binjai
Syamsul Agus, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Binjai SMP Negeri 10
Sri Rafi’ah S.Pd Teacher English Sibolga MAN Sibolga
Rusdin Aceh S.Pd Teacher English Sibolga SMPN 1 Sibolga
Parluhutan S.Pd Teacher Civics Sibolga SMPN 6 Sibolga
Tiomsar Manalu Teacher Civics Sibolga SMPN 5 Sibolga
Muallim S.Pd Teacher BTL Sibolga Fisika dan
Drs. Nuarsen Sitinjak BTL Sibolga
Togi Marito Naibaho,S.Pd Teacher ICT Sibolga Mts Islamiyah Sibolga,
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
14
Name Position Module District Institution
Minsaruddin Panggabean, S.Ag Teacher Life Skills Sibolga MTs Islamiyah Sibolga
Maruli Tua Napitupulu Teacher Life Skills Sibolga SMPN 1 Sibolga
Drs.Endra Torida English Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMP Negeri 1 Tebing Tinggi
Sopian Lubis English Teacher Tebing Tinggi MTs Al-Hasyimiah Tebing Tinggi
Hamdan Lubis S.Pd Civics Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMA Negeri 2 Tebing Tinggi
Zulkarnain, S.Pd Civics Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMP Negeri 4 Tebing Tinggi
Zaenab Nirwani BTL Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMP Negeri 1 Tebing Tinggi
Muhammad Rusli Harahap, S.Pd ICT Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMP Negeri 1 Tebing Tinggi
Purnawanto, S.Pd ICT Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMP Negeri 2 Tebing Tinggi
Juhanid, S.Pd Life Skills Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMA Negeri 2 Tebing Tinggi
Marwan Life Skills Lecturer Tebing Tinggi STAIS Tebing & Dewan Pendidikan Tebing Tinggi
Amris Siahaan S.Pd BTL Teacher Tebing Tinggi SMPN 4
Wahidin Purba, S.Pd English Teacher Deli Serdang MAN Lubuk Pakam
Drs. Osman Nadapdap English Supervisor Deli Serdang Dikmenum Deli Serdang
Fenti Karmila, S.Pd Civics Teacher Deli Serdang MTsN Lubuk Pakam
Drs. Akhiruddin Tanjung Civics Principal Deli Serdang SMPN 2 Deli Tua
Romen Priyatno, S.Pd BTL Supervisor Deli Serdang Pendais Tk.Menengah Deli Serdang
Drs.H.Adi Mutia, M.Pd BTL Principal Deli Serdang SMPN 2 Lubuk Pakam
Tiarma Sihite ST. ICT Teacher Deli Serdang SMKN 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Drs. Rusli ICT Teacher Deli Serdang SMKN 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Syahrun S.Pd Life Skills Teacher Deli Serdang SMKN 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Ilyas, S.Pd Life Skills Teacher Deli Serdang SMKN 1 Percut Sei Tuan
Basar Tua Simorangkir S.Pd Teacher English Tapanuli Utara
Susilawati S.Pd Teacher English Tapanuli Utara
Maruli Hutauruk Principal Civics Tapanuli Utara
Biola Siregar S.Pd Teacher Civics Tapanuli Utara SMP Negeri.3 Tarutung
Ricardo Silalahi S.Pd Teacher BTL Tapanuli Utara
Daniel Teacher BTL Tapanuli Utara
Poltak Sohutoron Hutauruk, SP Teacher ICT Tapanuli Utara
Ridwan SiMathematicsupang, S.Pd Principal ICT Tapanuli Utara
Meriyana Lestari Simbolon, S.P Teacher Life Skills Tapanuli Utara
Gokman Pakpahan Teacher Life Skills Tapanuli Utara
Basaria Lubis Teacher Mathematics Tapanuli Utara SMPN 1 Tarutung
Sabam Lumbantobing Teacher Mathematics Tapanuli Utara SMPN 1 Tarutung
Pujita SM Hutabarat Teacher Mathematics Tapanuli Utara SMPN 1 Tarutung
Rosyid S.Ag Teacher English Tapanuli Selatan MTSs Sipirok
Tumpal Manalu S.Pd Teacher English Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 3 B Angkola
Panusunan Harahap Teacher English Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 1 B Angkola
Tuti Asnah Sitompul Teacher Civics Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 1 B Angkola
Sonti Napitupulu Teacher Civics Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 2 B Angkola
Masniari Teacher Civics Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 1 B Angkola
Helty Ritonga Teacher BTL Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 1 PS Barat
Tupani Harahap Teacher BTL Tapanuli Selatan MTSN B Angkola
Sulianto S.Pd Teacher BTL Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 1 PS Barat
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
15
Name Position Module District Institution
Rasdin Sumarlin SS.S.Pd Teacher ICT Tapanuli Selatan MAN P Sidempuan
Sri Purnama Daulay ICT Tapanuli Selatan TU SMPN 2 B Angkola
Mangamar Portibi Hrp Teacher ICT Tapanuli Selatan MTSs Raudatul Falah
Misrenim S.Pd Teacher Life Skill Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 2 B Angkola
Drs. Tagam Dongoran Teacher Life Skill Tapanuli Selatan SMPN 1 PS Barat
Risda Handayani SE Teacher Life Skill Tapanuli Selatan MTSs Raudatul Falah
Ledy Situmorang Teacher English Dairi Dewasa/SMP Negeri 1 Sidikalang
Ferry Pinem Teacher English Dairi B Inggris/SMP Negeri 1 Sidikalang
Hiras Hutagaol, BA Teacher English Dairi /SMP Negeri 3 Sidikalang
Bintara Turnip, SH Principal Civics Dairi SMP Swasta Bukit Cahaya Sumbul
Anto Ramadhan Simbolon, S.pd Teacher Civics Dairi /MtS Swasta Sidikalang
Julienny Efrida Supervisor Civics Dairi Diknas Kab. Dairi
Jasman Manihuruk, S.pd ICT Co-ordinator
ICT Dairi Center Kab. Dairi/SMK Negeri 1 Sidikalang
Edward Sihombing ICT Co-ordinator
ICT Dairi Hardware/SMK Negeri 1 Sidikalang
Renni I M Padang Teacher ICT Dairi SMPN 3 Sidikalang
Dra Metta Rida Sianturi Teacher Life Skills Dairi SMP Swasta Bukit Cahaya Sumbul
Nurhayati Lumbanraja, S.pd Supervisor Life Skils Dairi TK/SD /Staff diknas Dairi
Drs. Minton Sinaga Supervisor Life Skills Dairi Diknas Kab. Dairi
Drs. Karmil Staff BTL Dairi /Diknas Kab. Dairi
Hernita Damanik Teacher BTL Dairi Guru
Jamangobat Nababan Teacher BTL Dairi SMP Negeri 1 Sumbul
Nurman Siregar, S. Th BTL Tanjung Balai Penyuluh Agama Depag TB
Khairul WD Panjaitan, S. Sos.I PPU BTL Tanjung Balai Waka. MA Tahfizul Qur'an TB
Syu'aib, S. Pd. I Teacher BTL Tanjung Balai SLTPN 8 TB
Boyke Azwar,S. Kom, SE Lecturer ICT Tanjung Balai STAI Al-Hikmah TB
Yudi Indra Sumana, A. Md Staff ICT Tanjung Balai
Elida Khairani, S. Pd Teacher ICT Tanjung Balai ICT SMAN 1
Syamsudin, S. Ag Teacher Life Skills Tanjung Balai SLTPN Satu Atap
Misli, S. Pd Teacher Life Skills Tanjung Balai PCivics SLTPN 1
Drs. Zulfan Efendi Teacher Life Skills Tanjung Balai
Muhammad Tahir, S. Pd Teacher Civics Tanjung Balai PCivics SLTPN Satu Atap
Evi Susilawati, M.Pd Teacher Civics Tanjung Balai PCivics SLTPN 5 TB
Syafri Daulae, S.Pd Teacher Civics Tanjung Balai PCivics MTsN TB
Nila Ariani, S. Pd Teacher English Tanjung Balai SLTPN 5 TB
Faradiba Sari Harahap Teacher English Tanjung Balai BIMA TB
Ernayanti Sinaga, S. Ag Teacher English Tanjung Balai SMAN 1 Bagan Asahan
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
16
1.5.3 The District Facilitators for the Whole School Program
In order to support the implementation of the whole school training program, more usually referred to as the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, district facilitators were selected in each district jointly by local government and DBE3 staff and trained by the project. There were originally 15 facilitators (3 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each extension district and 10 facilitators (2 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each core district. They have been trained to implement all or most of the BTL training modules. A number of the best facilitators from each province were also elevated to become national facilitators, which meant that they were trained in each module before the rest of the district facilitators and were then charged with implementing the training of the district facilitators. In their own districts they continued to act as district facilitators, supporting partner school and dissemination training, organizing MGMP activities and mentoring teachers after training. A list of the BTL facilitators operating as of August 2011 is included on the next page.
1.5.4 How the District Facilitator Performance Assessment was Done
In order to provide information on the effectiveness of these facilitators to those wishing to disseminate the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, DBE3 evaluated their performance using an instrument which focuses on a number of key areas:
• The extent to which the District Facilitator applies the training in their own work as a teacher, Principal or School Supervisor
• The extent to which the District Facilitator helps other teachers in their own school either as a teacher, Principal or Supervisor
• Their creativity in developing and implementing innovative training materials and approaches
• Their commitment as a District Facilitator for DBE3
• Their ability to relate to, communicate and interact with participants in the training and in mentoring
• Their initiative and ability to cooperate and support others District Facilitators during the training
• How effective they are as a mentor, whether they are able to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching and learning process and provide good feedback to teachers
Following the evaluation, each District Facilitator was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest.
3 2 1 0
Category
Very good, always works hard and is very able as a Facilitator
Good in general performance and ability as a Facilitator
Average, still needs to develop some skills as a Facilitator
Rarely works and not very able as a Facilitator
In a number of cases, where facilitators failed to function in an adequate manner no assessment has been given (denoted by ‘-‘).
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
17
1.5.5 List of Facilitators in North Sumatera for the Whole School Training Program and Performance Assessment
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
SUMATERA UTARA
1 Warsi,in, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 11 Binjai Utara Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081396710397 [email protected] ***
2 Khamsiah, S.Pd F Teacher English MTsN Binjai Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 06177473136 **
3 Samsul Agus, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 10 Binjai Non Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 0819842368 [email protected] ***
4 Asmawati, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMAN 7 Binjai Non Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 08196035826 ***
5 Drs Arief Fauriyuddin M Teacher Science SMPN 12 Binjai Non Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081375901108 [email protected] ***
6 Lia Windari, S.Pd F Teacher Science MTsN Binjai Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081370846347 [email protected] **
7 Murni Ervina, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPS Tunas Pelita Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081362004903 [email protected] *
8 Konfrontini Purba, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Binjai Non Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081265743189 [email protected] **
9 Saiful Bahri, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. MTs Islahiyah Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081370178474 *
10 Samsul Masri, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMKN Binjai Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 08126595067 *
11 Abdul Gani, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 11 Binjai Utara Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081376945509 [email protected] **
12 Erna Yunita, S.Pd, M.Pd F Teacher Math MTsN Binjai Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 08126578891 [email protected] *
13 Drs Zainul Fuad M Supervisor Math Dinas Pendidikan Partner Binjai N. Sumatera 081361767353 *
14 Bartimeus Sinuraya M Teacher English SMPN 3 Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081264892891 [email protected] ***
15 Aduon L Saragih M Teacher English SMPN 1 Sumbul Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 085296958933 [email protected] *
16 Ferry Pinem M Teacher English SMPN 1 Tanah Pinem Non Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 085297985246 *
17 Rijal Sinaga M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Sumbul Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081370081007 [email protected] **
18 Rianto Purba M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081361740613 **
19 Erlinda Simbolon F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Sumbul Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081375145352 -
20 Hernita D F Teacher Science SMPS Bukit Cahaya Sidikalang
Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 082165280448 [email protected] **
21 Herlina Ritonga F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081263446702 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
18
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
22 Rosalima Simanjuntak F Teacher Science SMPN 2 Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 085261234301 -
23 Bintara Turnip M Principal Social S. Bukit Cahaya Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081362184198 [email protected] ***
24 Metta Rida S F Supervisor Social S. Diknas Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 085296575672 **
25 Rudy Pinem M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Sumbul Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081260987138 [email protected] *
26 Hotmedi Hamonangan P M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081370762477 **
27 Halimatussakdiah F Teacher Math MTs Negeri Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081260859210 [email protected] *
28 Ida Nursanti F Teacher Math SMPN 3 Sidikalang Partner Dairi N. Sumatera 081376249515 [email protected] *
29 Drs Osman Nadapdap, MM M Supervisor English Dinas Pendidikan Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 08126414618 [email protected] ***
30 Trisna Valentina Sembiring, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 2 Lubuk Pakam Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 0617869961 [email protected] *
31 Dra Florida Simatupang F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Tanjung Morawa Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 0617356505 **
32 Derma Uli Sitorus, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Lubuk Pakam Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 081376830656 [email protected] *
33 Sunarno, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Tanjung Morawa Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 081370873160 [email protected] ***
34 Ani Dalimunthe, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Tanjung Morawa Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 085275525187 [email protected] -
35 Drs Akhiruddin Tanjung, M.Pd M Principal Social S. SMPN 2 Deli Tua Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 0617032813 [email protected] *
36 Drs Adi Mutia, M.Pd M Principal Math SMPN 2 Lubuk Pakam Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 081265411235 [email protected] **
37 Drs Suryadi, M.Pd M Principal Math SMPN 1 Tanjung Morawa Partner Deli Serdang N. Sumatera 0617945217 [email protected] **
38 Nurul Oktaviana Mekawaty F Teacher English MTsN Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 08126265785 [email protected] **
39 Radima Napitupulu F Teacher English SMPN 5 Non Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 081370946971 [email protected] *
40 Riamin Tetty Tambunan F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 081361191980 ***
41 Hasmidar Marpaung, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 082167440370 [email protected] *
42 Edison Gorat M Teacher Science SMPN 4 Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 08126262069 **
43 Fatlan Syafaat M Teacher Science MTsN Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 085261505535 *
44 Parluhutan Siregar M Teacher Social S. SMPN 6 Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 081361115631 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
19
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
45 Muallim M Principal Math MTsN Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 081361350301 [email protected] **
46 Fitria Ningsih Sembiring F Teacher Math SMPN 6 Partner Sibolga N. Sumatera 081375742664 [email protected] *
47 Meliyati, S. Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0852 6173 9216 [email protected] **
48 Herdayanti, S. Pd F Teacher English MTsN Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 6226 0981 [email protected] *
49 Hostiana Simbolon, S. Pd F Teacher English SMPN 4 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 7695 2100 - *
50 Julpan, S. Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Non Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 6147 9830 **
51 Hj. Setiani, S. Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0812 657 1730 - -
52 Elida R, S. Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 7695 8870 ***
53 Asnizar Saragih, S. Pd F Teacher Science MTs YMPI Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 6126 7249 [email protected] *
54 Hastuti Wulandari, S. Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 2 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 9676 0134 - *
55 Rina Mei Nelda Lubis, S. Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 5 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera - *
56 Herry Manalu, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 5 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 7986 9779 - *
57 Fatmawati, S. Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 10 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera - -
58 Jing Jing Sinurat, Drs M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0813 6109 8121 [email protected] ***
59 Henny Kurnia, S. Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 4 Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0852 6106 4127 [email protected] *
60 Rosid Abidin, S. Pd M Teacher Math MTsN Partner Tanjungbalai N. Sumatera 0852 7527 9416 - *
61 Suyono M Teacher English MTSN Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-97074169 [email protected] **
62 Tumpal Manalu M Teacher English SMPN 3 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-76271730 [email protected] **
63 Panusunan Harahap M Teacher English SMPN 1 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-75786648 *
64 Khadijah Khairani F Teacher B. Ind MTSN Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-61585758 [email protected] **
65 Monang Harahap M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0852-70010226 *
66 Gomok Sagala M Teacher B. Ind MTSN Batang Toru Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-9678647 -
67 Vebrina Simbolon F Teacher Science MTSN Batang Toru Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0852-61599599 [email protected] **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
20
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
68 Mulyanti Hasibuan F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0821-66789488 -
69 Rosmawati F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0812-6309422 [email protected] **
70 Mega Erni F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0812-65405594 *
71 Ibnu Khaldun M Teacher Social S. SMPN 3 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0852-70010138 -
72 Marasutan Harahap M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0852-75600974 [email protected] ***
73 Rahmad Nauli M Teacher Math MTSN Batang Toru Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-70573270 *
74 Nurhamidah Pulungan F Teacher Math SMPN 2 Batang Angkola Partner Tapsel N. Sumatera 0813-96956725 -
75 Susilawati, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 5 Tarutung Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081376396455 **
76 Saut Sitio, S.Pd M Supervisor English Dinas Pendidikan Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081396182234 [email protected] *
77 Basar Tua Simorangkir, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 2 Tarutung Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081265098211 *
78 Vanda Manurung, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Tarutung Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081362023777 **
79 Tinor Resdika Tampubolon, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Tarutung Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081370411446 [email protected] *
80 Erni Saragih, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Tarutung Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081396856265 *
81 Ricardo Silalahi, S.Pd M Principal Science SMKN Muara Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081376762262 **
82 Meryana Lestari Simbolon, S.P F Teacher Science SMKN Losida Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081361777853 [email protected] *
83 Jamansen Tamba M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Sipoholon Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081361544584 [email protected] *
84 Binsar Lavender Togatorop, S.Pd M Principal Social S. SMPN 5 Garoga Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081376371164 [email protected] ***
85 Gabe Lumbanbatu, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Siborong-borong Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081396921436 [email protected] *
86 Pasti Gita, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMA N 1 Sipahutar Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081396465702 [email protected] *
87 Gokman Pakpahan, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Tarutung Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081361430471 [email protected] ***
88 Sabar Pardede, S.Pd M Principal Math SMPN 5 Pangaribuan Non Partner Taput N. Sumatera 081397876830 *
89 Sabam Lumbantobing M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Tarutung Partner Taput N. Sumatera 085262485862 [email protected] *
90 Endra Torida M Teacher English SMPN 1 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0812 648 4635 [email protected] ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
21
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
91 Milda Tiurma F Teacher English SMPN 4 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0813 7062 8220 - *
92 Nurdamayanti, S. Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0813 9673 0644 [email protected] **
93 Dra. Mariana F Teacher B. Ind MTsN Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0813 9619 3022 [email protected] **
94 Zainab Nirwani F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0813 7000 2982 [email protected] ***
95 Ulil Azmi M Teacher Science Dinas Pendidikan Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0812 6405 5119 [email protected] **
96 Erlida F Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0812 6311 9867 - **
97 Syahdanil M Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0813 6134 4889 - *
98 Purnawanto M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera 0813 6134 4424 [email protected] ***
99 Saheri M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Partner Tebing Tinggi N. Sumatera - [email protected] *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
22
1.6 Working with Teacher Training Institutions and LPMP
To achieve wider impact beyond the target districts and to support improvement across the (junior secondary) education system, DBE3 worked with staff from the State University of Medan and the North Sumatera Quality Assurance Institutes (LPMP). Staff of these institutions took part in the provincial BTL training programs including the training of facilitators and training of teachers. selected lecturers also participated in the classroom action research program. Details of staff from the University and LPMP taking part in various DBE3 activities are presented below in the table below.
1.6.1 Number of Staff from Universities and LPMP taking part in DBE3 training and CAR activities
Province Better
Teaching and Learning
Classroom Action
Research Total
North Sumatra 6 5 11
1.6.2 Universities taking part in Classroom Action Research Review Meeting
A number of other universities from North Sumatera also took part in the Classroom Action Research Review Meeting in September 2011 and expressed an interest in using the materials and being involved in future program. These were as follows:
• Universitas Negeri, Medan
• Uinversitas Simalungun, Pematang Siantar
• Universitas HKBP Nomensen, Medan
• IAIN Medan
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
23
1.7 Overview of Trainee Data
1.7.1 Non Formal Education Managers Trained by District in North Sumatra
Below is a list of the number of non formal education managers by district from North Sumatera trained on the Non-Formal Education program.
District Managers
Male Female Total
Tapanuli Utara 1 1 2 3
Deli Serdang 7 5 12
Tebing Tinggi 8 5 13
Binjai 8 5 13
Sibolga 2 1 3
Tanjung Balai 4 5 9
Dairi 5 0 5
Tapanuli Utara 2 4 3 7
Tapanuli Selatan 5 6 11
Total 44 32 76
1.7.2 Non Formal Education Tutors Trained By District in North Sumatra
Below is a list of the numbers of tutors from district in North Sumatera trained to implement the Non-Formal Education program.
District # Tutors
Male Female Total
Tapanuli Utara 1 5 1 6
Deli Serdang 5 13 18
Tebing Tinggi 8 8 16
Binjai 10 8 18
Sibolga 1 5 6
Tanjung Balai 6 2 8
Dairi 3 1 4
Tapanuli Utara 2 1 2 3
Tapanuli Selatan 6 3 9
Total 45 43 88
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
24
1.7.3 Number of Teachers in North Sumaters Trained Using the Life Skills Training Program
Below is a list showing the number of teachers in each district in North Sumatera by District, Gender and School Type trained between 2006 and 2008 to implement the Life Skills training program.
District
SMP MTs Total
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Binjai 46 90 136 0 0 0 46 90 136
Deli Serdang 44 84 128 15 35 50 59 119 178
Sibolga 23 63 86 19 43 62 42 106 148
Tapanuli Utara 39 37 76 5 9 14 44 46 90
Tebing Tinggi 28 74 102 23 21 44 52 95 147
Dairi 120 160 280 3 19 22 122 179 302
Tanjung Balai 12 33 45 4 7 11 17 40 56
Tapanuli Selatan 16 48 64 13 36 49 29 84 113
Tapanuli Utara 33 33 66 33 33 66
Total 361 622 455 82 170 252 444 792 1236
1.7.4 Facilitators Trained in the BTL packages
Below is a list of the numbers of participants in the District Facilitator training for the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) modules. The training included district facilitators and a number of others, mainly lecturers from teacher training universities and trainers from LPMPs.
All Districts
Participants
District Facilitators
Others Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 102 20 122
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 103 50 153
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 122 13 135
1.7.5 Number of Teachers, School Principals and Supervisors Trained in BTL Program
Below is a list of the numbers of teachers, school principals and school supervisors from or associated with partner schools trained in the BTL program. The number of school principals and supervisors trained in BTL4 appears to be fewer. This is a result of receiving separate training to support the BTL4 program and the BTL4 package being delivered through the MGMP (Teachers Working Groups), which are teacher specific organization, which school principals and supervisors do not normally attend.
All Districts Participants
Teachers Principals Supervisors Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 637 0 0 637
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 834 95 56 985
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 951 60 45 1056
Additional School Supervisors Trained - 97 - -
The numbers of facilitators, teachers, school principals and supervisors shown as participcating in the BTL training in the tables above should not be aggregated, as they were largely the same people participating in each package of training.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
25
1.8 Dissemination of DBE3 programs
A core strategy of the DBE3 project was to develop exemplars of good practice in the partner schools and districts with the “specific intent” that these would be taken up and implemented by others to additional schools and geographical areas. Below is a summary of the dissemination of DBE3 programs in North Sumatera by province and then by district. For more details of the dissemination program and activities see Volume 1, section ?? of this report.
1.8.1 Provincial Overview of Dissemination in North Sumatera
Province Total # Schools
Total # Participants
Average # of Participants
Per Institution
Partner Districts
Disseminating
Non Partner Districts
Disseminating
Total Dissemination Budget (US$)
Contribution from Local
Partner (US$)
Local Contribution as a % of total budget spent
Average Cost per Trainee (US$)
North Sumatra 389 6,485 16.6 8 4 241,106 168,402 69.8% 37
DBE3 Project 6,440 50,179 7.7 41 42 1,738,860 1,359,279 78% 35.1
% of Project Total 6% 12.9% 19.5% 9.5% 13.8% 12.3%
1.8.2 Dissemination by District in North Sumatera
District
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Deli Serdang 387 4 29 31 7.40% 8.00%
Kota Sibolga 17 4 13 17 76.40% 100%
Kota Tebing Tinggi 31 4 24 28 77.40% 90%
Kota Binjai 59 10 49 59 83% 100%
Dairi 63 10 30 40 47.60% 63.40%
Tanjung Balai 30 10 20 30 66% 100%
Tapanuli Selatan 87 10 51 61 58% 70.10%
Tapanuli Utara 84 10 28 38 33.30% 45.20%
Langkat* 280 0 2 2 0.70% 0.70%
Serdang Bedagai* 250 0 1 1 0.40% 0.40%
Labuhan Batu* 124 0 10 10 8.00% 8.00%
Kota Medan* 488 0 45 45 9.20% 9.20%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
26
1.8.3 The Impact of Dissemination
The dissemination training in schools had some positive impact. When compared to the DBE3 comparison schools the dissemination schools did considerably better on all DBE3 teaching and learning indicators (with the exception of Instructional Leadership). However, the impact on teaching and learning in dissemination schools was not as significant as that on impact on partner schools suggesting that whilst dissemination training is beneficial, direct assistance achieves better results.
1.8.4 Chart: A comparison of the Impact of DBE3 in Partner, Dissemination and Comparison Schools in North Sumatra
1.8.5 List of District Contributions to Dissemination of DBE3 Program
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Tanjung Balai 174,000,000 19,627
Tebing Tinggi 16,600,000 1,872
South Tapanuli 180,000,000 20,304
North Tapanuli 30,000,000 3,384
Kota Sibolga 100,000,000 11,280
Binjai 34,625,000 3,905
Total 535,225,000 60,372
1.8.6 Contributions to District Dissemination of DBE3 Innovations from MORA Budget
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Tanjung Balai 48,000,000 5,414
Deli Serdang 12,000,000 1,353
Total 60,000,000 6,767
66.7
87.5
0
40
75.6
0
60
82.1
0 0
84.6
50
0
1 0
2 0
3 0
4 0
5 0
6 0
7 0
8 0
9 0
Te achers' Skill s Student Behavior Cl assroom
Environment
Princi pal Leade rshi p
Dissemination Schools
Partner Schools
Comparison Schools
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
27
1.9 Review of the Extension District Development Plans and Their Implementation
Towards the end of 2010 all partner extension districts made plans to support and disseminate the DBE3 program. A summary of the plans and a review of the extent to which districts had implemented these plans by November 2011 is set out below.
PROVINCIAL
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 500,000000 IDR (BOS and APBD) No reported budget used from APBD at Provincial Level
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination training in 8 DBE3 partner districts and towns. Scheduled for June 2011
Not completed. Budget has been included in APBD for 2011 and implementation is now scheduled for February 2012 and will involve 1,320 teachers from 33 Districts and Towns in North Sumatra for the 4 subjects of the National Examination.
Joint monitoring of the program with Provincial DPRD, Education Office, MORA and Bappeda. Scheduled for August 2011
In progress
Visit to DBE3 partner schools to observe progress on dissemination and implementation by Provincial DPRD, Education Office, MORA and Bappeda.
In progress
Circular letters by Provincial MORA for MTS on the implementation of dissemination training and mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3
The letter has been issued and distributed to all Districts and Town MORA offices in North Sumatra
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
28
BINJAI
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 402,000,000 IDR (BOS and APBD) Budget reported as actually used from APBD: 34,625,000 IDR
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination for teachers from partner and non-partner schools. Scheduled for October 2010 – April 2011
Completed with 320 teachers from 13 SMP and 4 MTS
Mentoring teachers through MGMP by District Facilitators. Scheduled for March to May 2011
Completed
Training for all Supervisors from to support the development of DBE3 program. Scheduled for June 2011
No progress
Study visit by non-partner schools to DBE3 partner schools, involving 30 non-partner school Principals. Scheduled for January 2011.
No progress
Head of Education Office and MORA to issue a Decree to District Facilitators on how to carry out their duties to train and mentor teachers in schools.
Completed
Education Office to give a certificate to all dissemination training participants and facilitators
No progress
Circular letter will be issued by Education Office and MORA regarding the dissemination and implementation of DBE3 programs, to School and MTS Principals
Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
29
TANJUNG BALAI
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 416,000,000 IDR (BOS and APBD) Budget reported as actually used from APBD: 174,000,000 IDR
Socialization of DBE3 programs to non-partner school principals and supervisors. Scheduled for September 2010.
Completed
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination for partner and non partner schools. Scheduled for September 2010 and March 2011
Completed
Study visits by non-partner schools to DBE3 partner schools. This will involve 30 participants consisting of Principals, Education Office, DPRD and Bappeda. Scheduled for October 2010
No progress: Difficulties in scheduling
Activating MGMP activities at town level using DBE3 mentoring model. Scheduled for October 2010.
No progress: Only active when there is a grant from LPMP
Giving rewards (a laptop) to teachers who have successfully develop DBE3 models. Scheduled for April 2011.
Completed
Education Office and MORA will issue a decree for District Facilitators to train using DBE3 models
Completed
Education Office and MORA will issue circular letters on the implementation of dissemination training.
No progress
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
30
DAIRI
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 362,000,000 IDR (BOS and APBD) No reported budget allocation from APBD
Recruit and train 20 additional district facilitators from non-partner schools for BTL2 and BTL3. Scheduled for November 2010 and February 2011
15 additional District Facilitators were trained
Socialization of DBE3 program to non-partner school Principals. Scheduled for January 2011
Completed
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination for teachers of non-5 core subjects in all partner schools. Scheduled for January and February 2011
Completed
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination for schools in non-partner sub-district. Scheduled for October 2010 and March 2011
Completed
Post-training mentoring on BTL2 and 3 for all partner and non-partner schools through. Scheduled for November 2010 – April 2011
Mentoring has been done in non partner schools and this has become one of the core functions and duties of School Supervisors
Training for School Supervisors in supporting the learning innovation in school. Scheduled for November 2010
Completed by DBE3
Funding a sisters’ school program between partner and non-partner schools. Scheduled for November 2010 and April 2011.
No progress, as was not part of the budget for 2010 - 2011
Head of Education Office and MORA will issue a Decree to District Facilitators on how to carry out their duties to train and mentor teachers in schools.
Completed
Education Office and MORA will issue circular letters on the implementation of replication training and mentoring
Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
31
NORTH TAPANULI
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 561,500,000 IDR (BOS and APBD) Budget reported as actually used from APBD: 30,000,000 IDR
Recruitment and training for 15 additional District Facilitators on BTL2 and 3. Scheduled for November 2010 to February 2011.
Recruitment and training for 15 additional District Facilitators including the Becoming an Effective Facilitators module was completed as scheduled.
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination training for teachers of non core subjects in partner schools and teachers in non partner schools. Scheduled for October 2010 to January 2011
100 Teachers from 10 partner schools with and 165 teachers from 5 non partner schools were trained as scheduled.
Mentoring for partner and non partner school teachers who participated in the dissemination training. Scheduled for November 2010 – June 2011
Completed
Study Visit by non partner schools to partner schools in the district. Study visit by partner schools to schools outside the district. Scheduled for November 2010 and April 2011
Completed
Head of Education Office and MORA will issue a Decree to DF on how to carry out their duties to train and mentor teachers in schools.
In progress, The Education Office is still coordinating with District Head
Education Office and MORA will issue circular letters on the implementation of replication training and mentoring
In progress. District MORA is lobbying to North Sumatra MORA Regional Office. District Education Office is also lobbying to North Sumatra Provincial Education Office.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
32
SOUTH TAPANULI
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 313,500,000 IDR (BOS and APBD) Budget reported as actually used from APBD: 180,000,000 IDR
Recruitment and training for additional District Facilitators from Sipirok, Angkola Timur, Batang Toru, and Marancar sub-districts. Scheduled for November and December 2010
In progress: Will be completed in Fiscal Year 2012.
BTL2 dissemination for teachers from 22 schools in 4 non partner sub-districts. Scheduled for January and February 2011
Completed in 22 SMPN in 4 sub districts in July 2011.
BTL3 dissemination for teachers of non core subjects in partner schools. Scheduled for March– April 2011
Delayed.
Replaced with mentoring by District Facilitators of trained teachers in 22 SMPN.
Coordination meeting involving DPRD, the Education Office, MORA, Bappeda and School Principals to discuss program implementation and planning. Scheduled periodically between November 2010and July 2011
Coordination meeting has been held at district level on a quarterly basis.
Showcase for partner schools to reward them for their achievements in implementing DBE3 program. Scheduled for May 2011.
Completed. Involved partner and non partner schools.
Head of Education Office and MORA will issue a Decree to District Facilitators on how to carry out their duties to train and mentor teachers
Decree has been issued by Educ. Office for District Facilitators
Circular letters on the utilization of BOS fund for quality improvement of education.
Circular letter and socialization has been done on the use of DBE1,2 and 3 modules in various forums and occasions.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
33
1.10 List of DBE3 Technical, Management and Administrative Staff in North Sumatera, August 2011
DBE3 – RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH
Provincial Office: North Sumatra
Name Position Residential Address Phone Numbers
Budiman Saragih Provincial Coordinator
Jl. Kartini No. 64 Saribudolok, Simalungun Sumatera Utara 21167 Res : (0622) 370727 Cell : 0812 600 3527
Agus Marwan Sr. Education Officer Jl. Setia Budi, Pasar I, Gang Anyelir 4 No.9, Medan Res : Cell : 0812 6050 404
Mhd. Ikhyar District Coordinator Jl. Permai Gg bakti No 10 Kelurahan Sidorame Timur - Medan Perjuangan Res : (061) 663 0529 Cell : 0812 600 3526
Yusriwiati District Coordinator Dusun Mulio Rejo No.27 Desa Kwala Begumit Kec. Stabat-Langkat 20251
Res : (061) 8878401 Cell : 0811 6029 38
Mathilda Hanum District Coordinator Jl. Pancasila Gg.Rawacangkuk IV No. 17 Medan
Res : Cell : 0811 6029 32
Ali Santonius Tampubolon District Coordinator Jl. Kapten Muslim gg. Sadar no.8 Medan Res: Cell : 0811 6530 29
Kamaludin Pane District Coordinator Jl. Pala No. 10 Binjai Res: Cell: 0811 6029 36
Erix S. Hutasoit
Communication Officer
Jl. Titi Papan Lorong Abadi No.11 Medan Petisah 20119
Res: 061 4575191 Cell: 0811 6043 198
Naek E. Hasiholan District Coordinator Jl. Amal Gg. Horas No. 90 Medan 20128 Res : (061) 77605728 Cell : 0811 6029 142
Anwar Suhut Situmorang District Coordinator Jl. Seser No 28 Medan
Res : Cell : 081376559687
Dini Ully Adriani
Admin & Finance Officer
Jl. Barus No. 2, Amplas-Medan Res : Cell : 0811656914
Hendy Irawan District Coordinator Jl. Durian Raya no. 81 Perumnas Langsa Baro
Res : Cell : 081370986256
Fachriza IT Assistant Jl. Utama Gg. Rambung No. 1 Medan 20215 Res : (061) 7366591 Cell : 0811 6029 143
Hotmaida Turnip Admin Assistant Jl. Bajak 2 H, Komp Puri Mediterania 63 Medan Res : Cell : 0811602907
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
35
2. BANTEN PROVINCIAL REPORT
This annex contains information and data concerning the implementation of the DBE3 project in Banten from 2005 to 2011. It should be read in conjunction with Volume I of the DBE3 Final Project Report, which contains a detailed account of the project activities.
The management of the project in Banten Province was integrated with West Java with the result that some activities were run jointly. Where possible data in this report is for Banten only, but in some cases, where disaggregation was not possible, aggregate data for both Banten and West Java has been included.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
37
2.1 Map of Project Coverage in Banten
Below is a map showing the districts in which the DBE3 program has been implemented in Banten. There are 3 partner districts, with whom DBE had a formal agreement and 1 non-partner district, where there was no formal agreement but in which the program was also disseminated.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
38
2.2 District Performance on the DBE3 Project
2.2.1 Highlights of District and Provincial Performance in Banten
Highlights from the Districts
Kota Cilegon To accelerate the dissemination program, Cilegon conducted TOT for additional facilitators. With these new district facilitators (DFs), the dissemination program has been able to spread out extensively around Cilegon and Banten Province in general.
At the end of the program, the Walikota has directly committed to train all schools (SMP and MTs) by disseminating both BTL2 and 3 modules. The program will be fully funded by the 2012 district budget.
The District Government will formally promote DFs as an Education Development Team through a decree of the Mayor or a decree from the Head of the Education Office.
It is also important to note that Cilegon has a very good coordination between MORA and the District Education Office.
Kab. Lebak Conduct TOT for additional DFs in 5 clusters of schools under DF supervision. This program is one of Education Office’s commitments to replicate DBE3 program for all junior secondary schools.
The DPRD has budgeted in the 2011 and 2012 district budgets (APBD) for the dissemination program. The district budget (APBD) explicitly mentions the “DBE3 Program dissemination”.
Kota Tangerang Nothing of note to report
Other Highlights
The District Facilitators developed a Facebook social group network in order to keep in touch among themsleves, while they were involved in the project and after the project ends. Through this network they discuss and share their information to continuously improve not only teaching and learning but also school conditions in general.
With a budget from Banten Provincial MORA office, all madrasah MTs in Banten have replicated the DBE3 Program, especially the BTL2 module. The training was facilitated by lecturers of the Education Faculty at IAIN Banten. The activity started with the TOT for all faculty members of Tarbiyah Faculty IAIN .
The Tarbiyah Faculty of IAIN Banten has used DBE3 modules in many activities such as:
• Training (TOT) all the lecturers;
• Providing students who will have teaching practice with knowledge and skills;
• Developing training materials for the teacher certification training program (PLPG teacher certification); and
• Making use of DBE3 modules as important teaching materials to be taught to students.
In most target districts, DBE3 motivated and inspired teachers to be more creative, for instance many of them have created their own teaching and learning media that suitable for their own subject matters
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
39
Relations among school principals, tachers and supervisors have become better both academically and psychologically regarding teaching and learning quality development. The supervisors’ traditional attitudes have also changed significantly.
There has been clear change in school principal leadership in district in Banten provinces, especially:
• More focus on improving teaching and learning quality;
• Supervising teaching and learning in collegial manner;
• Allocating budgets to fullfil teachers need in improving the quality of teaching and learning.
2.2.2 Assessment of Partner District Performance
The performance and impact of the DBE3 program has been varied in the different districts and schools. Below is an assessment of the performance of the DBE3 partner districts in Central Java.
The criteria used were as follows:
• Level of commitment of local stakeholders
• Impact on partner schools
• Extent of project dissemination achieved
Each of the criteria is rated on a scale of one to three – with three being the highest rating. This has resulted in an overall star rating for each districts. Three stars in the highest rating and denotes a high level of stakeholder commitment, a generally high impact on practice in partner schools and a considerable amount of dissemination to non-partner schools. A rating of one star denotes a low level in each of these criteria.
BANTEN
CO
HO
RT
EX
TE
NS
ION
/
CO
RE
Lo
cal G
overn
men
t
Sta
ff C
om
mit
men
t
Imp
act
on
Sch
oo
ls
Rep
lica
tio
n
alr
ead
y t
aken
pla
ce
Fu
nd
ing f
or
R
ep
lica
tio
n
Overa
ll R
an
kin
g
1. Cilegon 1 E 3 3 3 3 ***
2. Lebak 1 C 2 2 1 1 *
3. Kota Tangerang 2 C 1 2 1 1 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
40
2.3 List of Non-Formal Service Providers
Below is a list non-formal service providers with whom DBE3 worked between 2005 and 2008.
District NFE Provider Learners Tutors
M F Total M F Total
Cilegon PKBM Melati 54 61 115 9 27 36
PKBM Al-Insyirah 50 30 80 12 8 20
PKBM Widya Bina Karya 35 5 40 8 4 12
Lebak Al Islah 44 46 90 21 12 33
As-Salam* 6 4 10 2 1 3
PKBM Muara Madur 5 2 7 5 40 45
PKBM Tanjung Layar 16 2 18 6 0 6
PKBM Raudlatus Solihin 14 10 24 4 4 8
Tangerang PKBM Pancakarya 19 6 25 4 8 12
PKBM Bina Insani 31 50 81 6 0 6
PKBM Kelas Istimewa 20 0 20 15 6 21
PKBM Merdeka 7 2 9 7 1 8
Total 12 301 218 519 99 111 210
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
41
2.4 Partner Schools and an Assessment of Their Performance
2.4.1 The Whole School Training Program
During the first three years of the project teacher training modules were developed, as well as subject teaching modules for the English, civics and mathematics. Facilitators were trained to deliver these modules and used them to train the partner schools in each of the 44 project districts, which joined the project in two cohorts in 2006 and 2007.
From the beginning of 2009 DBE3 focused primarily on a more intensive program in formal junior secondary schools, SMP and MTs intitally in 25 “extension” districts from existing cohort 1 and 2 districts in which to implement a more in-depth DBE3 school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement. The program included:
• An increase in the number of directly supported schools in each of the extension districts, in most cases from four to ten, in order to create a greater presence and critical mass;
• The implementation of a school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement which involves training teachers of all core subjects, school principals and other senior management staff in partner schools.
The whole school program was later extended to the remaining 19 ‘core’ districts in late 2009 but without the selection of additional partner schools in those districts.
Below is a list of partner schools that took part in the whole school training program. The original cohort 1 and 2 schools are indicated in the list by pink shading, while the additional schools in the 25 extension districts, which joined the project in 2009 are left unshaded.
2.4.2 How the Partner School Assessment was Done
DBE3 undertook an evaluation of these schools which was completed in August 2011. An instrument was developed to assess which schools are implementing DBE3 innovations well and are worth visiting. The instrument evaluated 4 key areas of the school performance:
• Teacher Activities: To what degree the teachers encourage interaction among students provide challenging and varied tasks (discussion, experimentation, problem solving) and use formative assessment techniques.
• Student Activities: To what degree the student activities vary (working cooperatively, solving
problems, experimenting), they express their own thoughts orally and in writing and use a variety of media in their lessons.
• Classroom Environment: To what degree the students in the school sit, work and interact in
groups, work is displayed on the wall and if they learn using more diverse sources (media, environment)
• Principal Leadership: To what degree the Principal in the school encourags change, supports
the professional development of teachers and supports other innovations in the school
Following the evaluation, each school was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest. A ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little or no impact.
3 2 1 0
Category
Schools implementing the results of the DBE3 program well and widely, and there is a strong recommendation to visit.
Schools applying DBE3 results well in some classes but not widely there is encouragement to visit
The application of the results of the DBE3 program is limited and there is no encouragemet to visit.
There are no visible results of the DBE3 program.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
42
2.4.3 List of Training Received
The data for the partner schools in Banten including the results of the assessment are set out on the next page. It also indicates the training packages which have been received by each school and are indicated by A, B, C and D as set out in the table below.
A: Cohort 1 District Schools B: Cohort 2 District Schools Life Skills Program (2005 – 2009)
Better Teaching and Learning 1 Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice ICT for Life Skills Education Civics Modules English Modules Non Curricular Toolkits School Retention Toolkit A* also included Mathematics module
Better Teaching and Learning 1 Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice ICT for Life Skills Education Civics Modules English Modules Non Curricular Toolkits B* also included Mathematics Module
C: Extension District Schools D: Core Districts Schools Whole School Approach (2009 – 2011)
Better Teaching and Learning2 Better Teaching and Learning3 Better Teaching and Learning4 How to Use ICT in BTL Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
Better Teaching and Learning2 Better Teaching and Learning3 Better Teaching and Learning4 Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
43
2.4.4 List of DBE Partner Schools in Banten and an Assessment of their Performance
The original partner schools which participated in the project before the expansion to ten schools in each extension district are highlighted in pink.
BANTEN Extension District
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 2 Cilegon SMP State Cilegon Kota Cilegon 397 387 784 16 44 60 ***
2 SMP N 7 Cilegon SMP State Cilegon Kota Cilegon C 311 389 700 21 27 48 ***
3 SMP N 3 Cilegon SMP State Grogol Kota Cilegon C 413 454 867 34 25 59 **
4 SMP Al Ishlah SMP Private Jombang Wetan Kota Cilegon C 152 136 288 13 16 29 *
5 SMP YPW Krakatau Steel SMP Private Purwakarta Kota Cilegon A & C 329 308 637 19 23 42 **
6 MTs N Cilegon MTs State Purwakarta Kota Cilegon A & C 298 313 611 19 17 36 **
7 MTs N Ciwandan MTs State Ciwandan Kota Cilegon C 271 409 680 23 14 37 -
8 MTs N Pulomerak MTs State Gerem Kota Cilegon C 399 366 765 17 16 33 -
9 MTs Al Inayah MTs Private Cibeber Kota Cilegon C 396 454 850 23 17 40 -
10 MTs Al Khairiyah Karang Tengah MTs Private Purwakarta Kota Cilegon A & C 393 421 814 16 10 26 -
Core Districts
1 SMP N 2 Rangkasbitung SMP State Rangkasbitung Lebak A & D 492 502 994 19 19 38 **
2 SMP N 1 Bayah SMP State Bayah Lebak A & D 303 226 529 11 16 27 *
3 MTs N Model Pasir Sukarayat MTs State Rangkasbitung Lebak A & D 320 354 674 10 23 33 *
4 MTs N Bayah MTs State Bayah Lebak A & D 176 244 420 19 18 37 *
5 SMP N 4 Tangerang SMP State Tangerang Kota Tangerang A & D 578 662 1.240 20 30 50 *
6 SMP Nusa Putra SMP Private Karawaci Kota Tangerang A & D 289 223 512 26 24 50 *
7 MTs N 1 Kota Tangerang MTs State Tangerang Kota Tangerang A & D 289 478 767 27 25 52 **
8 MTs Darul Irfan MTs Private Tangerang Kota Tangerang A & D 113 121 234 18 6 24 -
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
44
2.5 District Facilitators / Performance Assessment
2.5.1 List of District Facilitators for Non Formal Education in Banten
Below is a list of facilitators from Banten trained to support the Non-Formal Education program.
Name Position District Subject
Abdul Rosyid Sekertaris PKBM Bina Insani Lebak Teaching and Learning
Syihabuddin Ketua MDC Banten Lebak Management
Lilis Aslihah Rachman, S.Kom. Ka. Subbag Publikasi dan Sistem Informasi Cilegon Management
H. Abdul Karim, S.Ag Staff PLS Dinas Pendidikan Kota Cilegon Cilegon Teaching and Learning
Masyhudi Ketua PKBM Banten Tangerang Management
Endang Santika, S.Pd Staff PLS Dinas P & K Kota Tangerang Tangerang Teaching and Learning
2.5.2 List of District Facilitators for the Life Skills Training Program in Banten 2006 – 2008
Below is a list of facilitators from Banten trained to implement the Life Skills program.
Name Module District Institution
Suryati, S.S English Cilegon STTKOM Insan Unggul, Cilegon
M. Nur Arifin, S.Pd English Cilegon IAIN"SMH" Banten, Cilegon
Drs. Saeful Bahri, M.M Civics Cilegon IAIN"SMH" Banten, Cilegon
Dra. Ilah Holilah Civics Cilegon MDC Banten
Dra. Futihat Life Skills Cilegon MTs Negeri Serang
Ir. Ali Faozin Life Skills Cilegon STTKOM Insan Unggul, Cilegon
Nina Nurdianiwaty, S.Kom ICT Cilegon STTKOM Insan Unggul, Cilegon
Muhibuddin, S.Sos ICT Cilegon UNTIRTA Serang
Drs. H. Subhan Mughni, M.Ed BTL Cilegon MDC Banten
Drs. Nana Jumhana, MA BTL Cilegon STMIK Banten Jaya Serang
Abdus Subhan Jayani, S.Pd, MBA English Lebak SMPN 2 Rangkasbitung
Moh. Djuanda, M.Ed English Lebak MTsN Pasir Sukarayat Lebak
Adnan Arifin, S.Pd Civics Lebak MAN Rangkasbitung
Sugeng Purnomo, M.Pd Civics Lebak UNTIRTA Serang
Aan MA Iskandar, S.Pd Life Skills Lebak SMPN 5 Rangkasbitung
Soleh Iskandar, M.Pd Life Skills Lebak SMPN 4 Rangkasbitung
Eko Wahyu Wibowo, S.S, M.M ICT Lebak STMIK Banten Jaya Serang
M. Rifqi Rijal, S.Si ICT Lebak IAIN"SMH" Banten, Cilegon
Drs. Asip, M.Ed BTL Lebak MTsN Pandeglang I
Dra. Iroh Suhiroh, M.Si BTL Lebak SMP Ikhsaniyah Lebak
Caswani, S.Pd English Tangerang SMPN 4 Tangerang
Fitri Hilmiyati, M.Ed English Tangerang FMIPA Mathematicslaul Anwar Tangerang
Drs. Harwanto Civics Tangerang MAN Insan Cendikia Tangerang
Drs. Anwar Musaddad Civics Tangerang Ketua MGMP MTs Kota Tangerang
Drs. Baehaqy, MA Life Skills Tangerang STAI Muhammadiyah Tangerang
Drs. Sunarto, MM Life Skills Tangerang IQC Al Azhar BSD Tangerang
Shobri, S.Kom, M.M ICT Tangerang IAIN "SMH" Banten Tangerang
Drs. Suhardi, MA BTL Tangerang Kepala MTsN Pagedangan Tangerang
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
45
2.5.3 The District Facilitators for the Whole School Program
In order to support the implementation of the whole school training program, more usually referred to as the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, district facilitators were selected in each district jointly by local government and DBE3 staff and trained by the project. There were originally 15 facilitators (3 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each extension district and 10 facilitators (2 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each core district. They have been trained to implement all or most of the BTL training modules. A number of the best facilitators from each province were also elevated to become national facilitators, which meant that they were trained in each module before the rest of the district facilitators and were then charged with implementing the training of the district facilitators. In their own districts they continued to act as district facilitators, supporting partner school and dissemination training, organizing MGMP activities and mentoring teachers after training. A list of the BTL facilitators operating as of August 2011 is included on the next page.
2.5.4 How the District Facilitator Performance Assessment was Done
In order to provide information on the effectiveness of these facilitators to those wishing to disseminate the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, DBE3 evaluated their performance using an instrument which focuses on a number of key areas:
• The extent to which the District Facilitator applies the training in their own work as a teacher, Principal or School Supervisor
• The extent to which the District Facilitator helps other teachers in their own school either as a teacher, Principal or Supervisor
• Their creativity in developing and implementing innovative training materials and approaches
• Their commitment as a District Facilitator for DBE3
• Their ability to relate to, communicate and interact with participants in the training and in mentoring
• Their initiative and ability to cooperate and support others District Facilitators during the training
• How effective they are as a mentor, whether they are able to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching and learning process and provide good feedback to teachers
Following the evaluation, each District Facilitator was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest.
3 2 1 0
Category
Very good, always works hard and is very able as a Facilitator
Good in general performance and ability as a Facilitator
Average, still needs to develop some skills as a Facilitator
Rarely works and not very able as a Facilitator
In a number of cases, where facilitators failed to function in an adequate manner no assessment has been given (denoted by ‘-‘).
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
46
2.5.5 List of Facilitators in Banten for the Whole School Training Program and Performance Assessment
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princ-ipal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
BANTEN
16 Rohbiyah, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 2 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 08176628897 *** 17 M. Nur Arifin M Dosen English IAIN SMH BANTEN Non-Partner Cilegon Banten 0811121538 ** 18 Yunilawati, S.Pd. F Teacher English MTSN Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten
08161166125 / (0254)397104
[email protected]; [email protected]
*
19 Yufa Nawaksara, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 2 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 0254-382303 / 081906208413
20 Hadiyanto Permana, S.Pd., M.Pd.
M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 0817776524 [email protected] ** 21 Mutik Margawati, Dra. F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 7 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 08129546721 *** 22 Nurkholik, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 081310692659 [email protected] * 23 Agus Supardi, S.Si. M Teacher Science MTsN Ciwandan Partner Cilegon Banten 081808674498 [email protected] *** 24 Etty Mutianingsih, S.P. F Teacher Science SMPN 2 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 081399694282 [email protected] ** 25 Suryati, S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMPN 7 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 081314827247 [email protected] * 26 Niky Noberta, Hj., S.Pd., M.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMPN 3 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 08174923183 [email protected] ** 27 Syamsuri, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 7 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 081319774579 [email protected] * 28 Zaitty Musafiroch, Hj., Dra. F Teacher Social S. MTsN Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 087871559848 [email protected] - 29 Dudung Rukmana, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Cilegon Non-Partner Cilegon Banten 08128860039 [email protected] * 30 Neneng Herawati, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMPN 2 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 08170842002
[email protected]; [email protected]
- 31 Sunarto, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 7 Cilegon Partner Cilegon Banten 081314687311 - 78
H. Abdus Subhan Jayani, S.Pd., MBA
M Principal English SMPN Satap 2 Kalanganyar Non-Partner Lebak Banten 081314387994 [email protected] * 79 Ahmad Lili Sugiri, S.Pd.I. M Teacher English SMPN 2 Panggarangan Non-Partner Lebak Banten 087820978443 [email protected] * 80 Drs. Solihin, M.Pd. M Kasi Kurikulum B. Ind
Dinas Pendidikan Kab. Lebak
Non-Partner Lebak Banten 081314722042 [email protected] *** 81 Muhamad Nur, Drs. M Principal B. Ind SMPN 5 Bayah Non-Partner Lebak Banten 081806031005 - 82 Nurlaelati, S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMPN 2 Rangkasbitung Partner Lebak Banten 087772989305 [email protected] ** 83 Mamat Rahmat, S.Pd. M Principal Science SMPN 4 Bayah Non-Partner Lebak Banten 085920014085 [email protected] * 84 Kusnadi, M.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Rangkasbitung Partner Lebak Banten 081314290653 [email protected] ** 85 Dra. Juherni, M.M.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Bayah Partner Lebak Banten 081906036025 * 86 Ence Tajudin, Drs. M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Panggarangan Non-Partner Lebak Banten 085281192980 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
47
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princ-ipal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
87 Didik Kuswinarto, S.Pd. M Principal Math SMPN 3 Cibeber Non-Partner Lebak Banten 085888261511 [email protected] ** 88 Fitri Hilmiyati, M.Ed. F Dosen Math IAIN SMH BANTEN Non-Partner Serang Banten 08121032276 [email protected] ** 109 Caswani, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 4 Tangerang Partner Tangerang Banten 085695876810 [email protected] ** 110 Adien Alvian, M.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 2 Tangerang Non-Partner Tangerang Banten 08128166374 [email protected] * 111 Drs. H. Anwar Musyadad, M.Pd. M Supervisor B. Ind
Kementerian Agama Kota Tangerang
Non-Partner Tangerang Banten 081586561725 ** 112 Komaruddin, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 4 Tangerang Partner Tangerang Banten 081219669070 [email protected] * 113 H. Dede Kusnadi, M.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 4 Tangerang Partner Tangerang Banten 081316127741 * 114 Akhmad Kosasih, S.Pd. M Teacher Science MTsN 1 Tangerang Partner Tangerang Banten 081196911990 [email protected] * 115 Teguh Budiarto, S.Ag. M Teacher Social S. MTsN 1 Tangerang Partner Tangerang Banten 081381881257 * 116 Yulianti, S.Pd. F Teacher Social S. MTsN Cipondoh Non-Partner Tangerang Banten 081314349170 [email protected] * 117 Hasyim, S.Pd. M Teacher Math MTsN 1 Tangerang Partner Tangerang Banten 081314112734 * 118 Drs. Muhali M Teacher Math MTsN Benda Non-Partner Tangerang Banten 02171599126 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
48
2.6 Working with Teacher Training Institutions and LPMP
To achieve wider impact beyond the target districts and to support improvement across the (junior secondary) education system, DBE3 worked with staff from the University Tirta, IAIN Serang and the Banten Quality Assurance Institute (LPMP). Staff of these institutions took part in the provincial BTL training programs including the training of facilitators and training of teachers. selected lecturers also participated in the classroom action research program.
In year 6, DBE3 planned and implemented a pilot program with the State University of Semarang to encourage them to adopt and make use of some of the key project programs, and approaches with a view to improving the quality of both their pre- and in-service teacher training courses. The pilot program is described in section ?? of the main report.
Details of staff from the University and LPMP taking part in various DBE3 activities are presented below:
2.6.1 Number of Staff from Universities and LPMP taking part in DBE3 training and CAR activities
Province Better
Teaching and Learning
Classroom Action
Research Total
Banten 10 2 12
2.6.2 Universities taking part in Classroom Action Research Review Meeting
A number of other universities from Banten also took part in the Classroom Action Research Review Meeting in September 2011 and expressed an interest in using the materials and being involved in future program. These were as follows:
• Universitas Tirta, Banten
• IAIN Serang, Banten
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
49
2.7 Overview of Trainee Data
2.7.1 Non Formal Education Managers Trained by District in Banten
Below is a list of the number of non formal education managers by district from Banten trained on the Non-Formal Education program.
District Managers
Male Female Total
Cilegon 6 1 7
Lebak 6 2 8
Tangerang 6 2 8
Total 18 5 23
2.7.2 Non Formal Education Tutors Trained By District in Banten
Below is a list of the numbers of tutors from district in Banten trained to implement the Non-Formal Education program.
District # Tutors
Male Female Total
Cilegon 4 5 9
Lebak 5 7 12
Tangerang 5 7 12
Total 14 19 33
2.7.3 Number of Teachers in Banten Trained Using the Life Skills Training Program
Below is a list showing the number of teachers in each district in Banten by District, Gender and School Type trained between 2006 and 2008 to implement the Life Skills training program.
District
SMP MTs Total
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Cilegon 27 49 76 47 34 81 74 83 157
Lebak 37 26 63 16 11 27 53 37 90
Tangerang 65 73 138 46 36 82 111 109 220
Total 129 148 277 109 81 190 238 229 467
2.7.4 Facilitators Trained in the BTL packages
Below is a list of the numbers of participants in the District Facilitator training for the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) modules in West Java and Banten. The training included district facilitators and a number of others, mainly lecturers from teacher training universities and trainers from LPMPs.
All Districts WEST JAVA AND BANTEN
Participants
District Facilitators
Others Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 104 9 113
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 109 43 152
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 105 23 128
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
50
2.7.5 Number of Teachers, School Principals and Supervisors Trained in BTL Program
Below is a list of the numbers of teachers, school principals and school supervisors from or associated with partner schools in West Java and Banten trained in the BTL program. The number of school principals and supervisors trained in BTL4 appears to be fewer. This is a result of receiving separate training to support the BTL4 program and the BTL4 package being delivered through the MGMP (Teachers Working Groups), which are teacher specific organization, which school principals and supervisors do not normally attend.
All Districts WEST JAVA AND BANTEN
Participants
Teachers Principals Supervisors Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 908 1 9 918
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 1045 48 23 1116
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 962 53 21 1036
Additional School Supervisors Trained - 93 - -
The numbers of facilitators, teachers, school principals and supervisors shown as participcating in the BTL training in the tables above should not be aggregated, as they were largely the same people participating in each package of training.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
51
2.8 Dissemination of DBE3 programs
A core strategy of the DBE3 project was to develop exemplars of good practice in the partner schools and districts with the “specific intent” that these would be taken up and implemented by others to additional schools and geographical areas. Below is a summary of the dissemination of DBE3 programs in Banten by province and then by district. For more details of the dissemination program and activities see Volume 1, section ?? of this report.
2.8.1 Provincial Overview of Dissemination in Banten
Province Total # Schools
Total # Participants
Average # of Participants
Per Institution
Partner Districts
Disseminating
Non Partner Districts
Disseminating
Total Dissemination Budget (US$)
Contribution from Local
Partner (US$)
Local Contribution as a % of total budget spent
Average Cost per Trainee (US$)
Banten 465 2,065 4.4 3 1 51,988 28,118 54% 25
DBE3 Project 6,440 50,179 7.7 41 42 1,738,860 1,359,279 78% 35.1
% of Project Total 7.1% 4.1% 7.3% 2.3% 2.9% 2%
2.8.2 Dissemination by District in Banten
PARTNER DISTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Cilegon 75 10 65 75 86.6% 100%
Kota Tangerang 239 4 59 63 24.6% 26%
Lebak 317 4 40 44 12.6% 13.80%
Serang* 359 0 350 350 100% 97.4%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
52
2.8.3 The Impact of Dissemination
The dissemination training in schools had some positive impact. When compared to the DBE3 comparison schools the dissemination schools did considerably better on all DBE3 teaching and learning indicators (with the exception of Instructional Leadership). However, the impact on teaching and learning in dissemination schools was not as significant as that on impact on partner schools suggesting that whilst dissemination training is beneficial, direct assistance achieves better results.
2.8.4 Chart: A comparison of the Impact of DBE3 in Partner, Dissemination and Comparison Schools in Banten
2.8.5 List of District Contributions to Dissemination of DBE3 Program
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Tangerang 40,000,000 4,512
Cilegon 70,000,000 7,896
Total 110,000,000 12,408
2.8.6 Contributions to District Dissemination of DBE3 Innovations from MORA Budget
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Cilegon 162,320,000 18,310
Total 162,320,000 18,310
62.5
94.1
0
76
97.7
0
83
100
0 0
69
00
1 0
2 0
3 0
4 0
5 0
6 0
7 0
8 0
9 0
10 0
Te achers' Ski lls Stude nt Behavior Classroom
Envi ronme nt
Principal
Le adership
Di ssemination School s
Partne r Schools
Compari son Schools
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
53
2.9 Review of the Extension District Development Plans and Their Implementation
Towards the end of 2010 all partner extension districts made plans to support and disseminate the DBE3 program. A summary of the plan from Cilegon district and a review of the extent to which it had implemented these plans by November 2011 is set out below.
CILEGON
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget for 2011 400,000,000 Budget reported as actually used from APBD between 2010 and 2011: 108,000,000 IDR Budget for 2012 300,000,000 (MONE) and 260,000,000 (MORA)
TOT on BTL-2 for additional District Facilitators Completed Mentoring on MGMP activities in district/sector/school levels Completed ICT Training Completed Study Visits Completed Trainings for all subjects teachers: BTL 2 and 3 Completed Internship for non-partner schools in partner schools Completed Sister school program with model schools Completed TOT for SMP/MTs School Supervisors Completed Invite School Committee to observe learning in the classroom. Completed Intensive supervision by School Principal on Teaching and Learning process Completed Learning Achievement Showcase (result of lesson study) Completed Cross-supervision ( only in MTS) Completed Supervision of Principals by School Supervisors and follow-up monitoring by School Principal or Supervisors.
Completed
Reward for teachers who consistently implement active learning Completed Replication of DBE3 programs Completed Decree by Head of Education Office for District Facilitators Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
54
2.10 List of DBE3 Technical, Management and Administrative Staff in West Java and Banten, August 2011
DBE3 – RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH
Provincial Office: West Java/Banten
Name Position Residential Address Phone Numbers Asep S. Muhtadi Provincial Coordinator
(West Java/Banten ) Jl. Salman Al-Farisi, G4/4 Griya Cempaka Arum Gede Bage Bandung 40613
Res : (022) 783 1709 Cell: 0812 2045193
Rifki Rosyad Education Officer Jl. Derwati No. 8 Rt. 01/Rw. 03 Kel. Rancabolang Kec. Gedebage Bandung 40296
Res: (022) 91618522 Cell: 0811219639, 0818 09815916
Syihabuddin District Coordinator Jl. Empat Lima Gg. Bhineka RT.03/13 No. 21 Kaujon Baru Serang Res: Cell: 081210154243/ 0811 223 0702
Renniati Fadhilah District Coordinator Jl. Cilandak No. 30 Sarijadi Bandung Res: Cell:/0811 223 0668
Dindin Solahudin Communication Officer Pesantren Al-Ihsan Cibiru Hilir RT.01/02 Cileunyi Bandung 40626 Res: Cell: 08112213849/ 081321319389
Abdul Majid District Coordinator Komp. Perum Mitra Posindo Blok D-2 No.28 Ds. Cinunuk Kec. Cilenyi Bandung
Res: Cell: 08112213823
Yeti Heryati District Coordinator Jl. Terusan Permai V No.32 Cipadung Bandung
Res: (022) 70943772 Cell: 081322105700
Usman Hidayat District Coordinator
Jl. P. Timor 1 No. 41 Perumnas III Bekasi 17111
Res: Cell: 0811 2213845
R. Novianto Soejatno
District Coordinator Jl. Karasak Utara 2 No. 7 Bandung 40243
Res: (022) 5221513 Cell: 08179952161
Dian Rahadian District Coordinator BTN Sindang Citra A-44/45 Sindang, Indramayu Res: Cell : 081911927228
Vivi Nurvitasari Finance & Administration Officer
Komp. Tamansari Bukit Bandung Blok IA No. 25 Jl. Raya Sindanglaya Arcamanik Bandung
Res: (022) 7831218 Cell: 0818 0959 4779
Muhammad
Imami
Finance Assistant Komp. Bumi Panyileukan G8 No. 5 Bandung
Res: (022) 7807257 Cell: 08112213817
Fitriani Almaidah Derusti
Admin Assistant Jl. Kuningan X No. 22 Antapani Bandung
Res: (022) 727 3968 Cell: 0856 2310420
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
55
3. WEST JAVA PROVINCIAL REPORT
This annex contains information and data concerning the implementation of the DBE3 project in West Java from 2005 to 2011. It should be read in conjunction with Volume I of the DBE3 Final Project Report, which contains a detailed account of the project activities.
The management of the project in West Java Province was integrated with Banten with the result that some activities were run jointly. Where possible data in this report is for West Java only, but in some cases, where disaggregation was not possible, aggregate data for both West Java and Banten has been included.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
57
3.1 Map of Project Coverage in West Java
Below is a map showing the districts in which the DBE3 program has been implemented in West Java. There are 6 partner districts, with whom DBE had a formal agreement and 7 non-partner districts, where there was no formal agreement but in which the program was also disseminated.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
58
3.2 District Performance on the DBE3 Project
3.2.1 Highlights of District and Provincial Performance in West Java
Highlights from the Districts
No Districts Activity
Extension Districts
1 Kab. Garut Peripheral Madrasahs have changed to become very good madrasahs, and even become models. They conducted a showcase at school level to facilitate changes.
They developed an MGMP for the target schools. This MGMP has become a center for teacher discussion and especially on how to implement the results of training.
2 Kab. Indramayu District Facilitators, school principals, and supervisors who were actively involved in the DBE3 programs have been designated as high achieving personnel in their district. This is regarded as a DBE3 program impact.
3 Kab. Karawang DBE3 has inspired many changes and efforts for school physical development, even though DBE3 itself does not focus on physical development. After participating in the Public Private Alliance (PPA) training conducted by DBE3, they initiated partnerships with the local business sector to develop school building. Now, after 5 years, in cooperation with DBE3 the physical changes have happened fantastically well.
4 Kota Bogor Many DFs and teachers conducted class exchange visits. They visited each others’ classes and taught in the different schools/madrasahs. This initiative, according to them, was really useful for accelerating change. This also open school partnership opportunities to support learning quality development.
It is also interesting that MTs-SMP collaborated well. This is regarded as one of the program’s successes.
Core Districts
1 Kab. Subang Conducted study visits between schools, especially from non-target schools who have conducted a replication program with the target schools.
Conducted showcases at the school level to motivate teachers to develop lesson quality and student creativity.
One of the program effects, according to the school principals, is that DBE3 has successfully enhanced school popularity, changing poorer schools to become good-achieving schools.
DBE3 has inspired schools to initiate partnerships with various institutions such as the local and regional business sectors, the World Bank and British Council.
One of District Facilitators was promoted as a staff of the Dinas Pendidikan Kabupaten (curriculum affairs) just because of his good performance after joining with DBE3.
2 Kab. Sukabumi DBE3 has successfully made schools better. Private madrasahs which are DBE3 target schools, for example, get “A” in the accreditation process.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
59
Other Highlights
District Facilitators in West Java and Banten developed a Facebook social group network in order to keep in touch among themsleves, while they were involved in the project and after the project ends. Through this network they continue to discuss and share their information to continuously improve not only teaching and learning but also school conditions in general.
In most target districts, DBE3 has motivated and inspired teachers to be more creative, for instance many of them have created themselves their own teaching and learning media that suitable for their own subject matters
Relations among school principals, tachers and supervisors have become better both academically and psychologically regarding teaching and learning quality development. The supervisors’ traditional attitudes have also changed significantly.
There has been clear change in school principal leadership in district in West Java provinces, especially:
• More focus on improving teaching and learning quality;
• Supervising teaching and learning in collegial manner;
• Allocating budgets to fullfil teachers need in improving the quality of teaching and learning.
Almost all districts have allocated and will provide budget for replication program activities trough APBD 2011-2012 budget.
3.2.2 Assessment of Partner District Performance
The performance and impact of the DBE3 program has been varied in the different districts and schools. Below is an assessment of the performance of the DBE3 partner districts in West Java.
The criteria used were as follows:
• Level of commitment of local stakeholders
• Impact on partner schools
• Extent of project dissemination achieved
Each of the criteria is rated on a scale of one to three – with three being the highest rating. This has resulted in an overall star rating for each districts. Three stars in the highest rating and denotes a high level of stakeholder commitment, a generally high impact on practice in partner schools and a considerable amount of dissemination to non-partner schools. A rating of one star denotes a low level in each of these criteria.
WEST JAVA
CO
HO
RT
EX
TE
NS
ION
/
CO
RE
Lo
cal G
overn
men
t
Sta
ff C
om
mit
men
t
Imp
act
on
Sch
oo
ls
Rep
lica
tio
n
alr
ead
y t
aken
pla
ce
Fu
nd
ing f
or
R
ep
lica
tio
n
Overa
ll R
an
kin
g
1. Karawang 1 & 2 E 2 2 2 3 ** 2. Garut 2 E 2 3 2 2 ** 3. Indramayu 1 & 2 E 2 3 2 2 ** 4. Kota Bogor 2 E 3 3 3 3 *** 5. Subang 2 C 3 3 3 3 *** 6. Sukabumi 1 C 2 2 1 1 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
60
3.3 List of Non-Formal Service Providers
Below is a list non-formal service providers with whom DBE3 worked between 2005 and 2008.
District NFE Provider Learners Tutors
M F Total M F Total
Karawang PKBM Cepat Tepat 44 0 44 67 1 68
PKBM Aditya 17 25 42 1 1 2
PKBM Warna Sari 50 30 80 11 1 12
Indramayu PKBM Jaka Anom 50 10 60 10 2 12
PP Darun Nahwi 12 8 20 6 1 7
PP Istiqamah 12 8 20 9 0 9
PKBM Tunas Warga 9 11 20 3 3 6
Kurnia Jaya* 0 0 0 0 0 0
PP Al Fattah 11 14 25 4 2 6
Sukabumi PKBM Sinar Samudera 63 27 90 32 3 35
PP Riyadhul Jannah 14 9 23 35 5 40
PKBM Mutiara* 0 0 0 0 0 0
PKBM Taruna Bakti 20 40 60 4 2 6
PKBM At-Taqwa 40 20 60 12 3 15
PP Muhajirin 10 10 20 6 0 6
PKBM Darussalam 9 29 38 5 1 6
Karawang PKBM Nurul Furqan-Kotabaru 18 2 20 3 3 6
PonTren Hikmatul Muhajirin 15 9 24 5 1 6
PKBM Nurul Islam-Talagasari 84 87 171 6 2 8
PonTren Al Isti'anah (Pkt B) 31 21 52 6 4 10
Subang PKBM Nusa Indah 9 15 24 4 2 6
PKBM Cempaka Sari 9 11 20 6 0 6
PKBM Bina Warga 22 24 46 5 1 6
PKBM Nurul Ishlah 23 8 31 3 3 6
Garut PKBM Syaifusshudur 16 9 25 2 4 6
PonTren Nurul Fatah* 0 0 0 0 0 0
PKBM Tarbiyatul Aulad 115 125 240 3 3 6
PonTren Darussaslam 19 21 30 3 3 6
Indramayu PKBM Jagantaka 47 48 95 16 7 23
PKBM Tunas Harapan 49 15 64 6 6 12
PKBM Tirta Ayu 8 2 10 2 1 3
PKBM Melati 31 40 71 13 2 15
Bogor PKBM Titian Mandiri 50 50 100 7 4 11
PKBM Damai Mekar 70 60 130 7 4 11
PKBM Matahari 84 27 111 7 9 16
PKBM Cemerlang 33 29 62 6 8 14
Total 36 1094 844 1938 315 92 407
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
61
3.4 Partner Schools and an Assessment of Their Performance
3.4.1 The Whole School Training Program
During the first three years of the project teacher training modules were developed, as well as subject teaching modules for the English, civics and mathematics. Facilitators were trained to deliver these modules and used them to train the partner schools in each of the 44 project districts, which joined the project in two cohorts in 2006 and 2007.
From the beginning of 2009 DBE3 focused primarily on a more intensive program in formal junior secondary schools, SMP and MTs intitally in 25 “extension” districts from existing cohort 1 and 2 districts in which to implement a more in-depth DBE3 school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement. The program included:
• An increase in the number of directly supported schools in each of the extension districts, in most cases from four to ten, in order to create a greater presence and critical mass;
• The implementation of a school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement which involves training teachers of all core subjects, school principals and other senior management staff in partner schools.
The whole school program was later extended to the remaining 19 ‘core’ districts in late 2009 but without the selection of additional partner schools in those districts.
Below is a list of partner schools that took part in the whole school training program. The original cohort 1 and 2 schools are indicated in the list by pink shading, while the additional schools in the 25 extension districts, which joined the project in 2009 are left unshaded.
3.4.2 How the Partner School Assessment was Done
DBE3 undertook an evaluation of these schools which was completed in August 2011. An instrument was developed to assess which schools are implementing DBE3 innovations well and are worth visiting. The instrument evaluated 4 key areas of the school performance:
• Teacher Activities: To what degree the teachers encourage interaction among students provide challenging and varied tasks (discussion, experimentation, problem solving) and use formative assessment techniques.
• Student Activities: To what degree the student activities vary (working cooperatively, solving
problems, experimenting), they express their own thoughts orally and in writing and use a variety of media in their lessons.
• Classroom Environment: To what degree the students in the school sit, work and interact in
groups, work is displayed on the wall and if they learn using more diverse sources (media, environment)
• Principal Leadership: To what degree the Principal in the school encourags change, supports
the professional development of teachers and supports other innovations in the school
Following the evaluation, each school was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest. A ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little or no impact.
3 2 1 0
Category
Schools implementing the results of the DBE3 program well and widely, and there is a strong recommendation to visit.
Schools applying DBE3 results well in some classes but not widely there is encouragement to visit
The application of the results of the DBE3 program is limited and there is no encouragemet to visit.
There are no visible results of the DBE3 program.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
62
3.4.3 List of Training Received
The data for the partner schools in West Java including the results of the assessment are set out on the next page. It also indicates the training packages which have been received by each school and are indicated by A, B, C and D as set out in the table below.
A: Cohort 1 District Schools B: Cohort 2 District Schools
Life Skills Program (2005 – 2009)
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
School Retention Toolkit
A* also included Mathematics module
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
B* also included Mathematics Module
C: Extension District Schools D: Core Districts Schools
Whole School Approach (2009 – 2011)
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
How to Use ICT in BTL
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
63
3.4.4 List of DBE Partner Schools in West Java and an Assessment of their Performance
The original partner schools which participated in the project before the expansion to ten schools in each extension district are highlighted in pink.
WEST JAVA Extension Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 7 Bogor SMP State Bogor Tengah Kota Bogor B & C 520 600 1.120 13 44 57 **
2 SMP N 16 Kota Bogor SMP State Tanah Sareal Kota Bogor B & C 579 510 1.089 14 36 50 **
3 SMP N 8 Bogor SMP State Tanah Sareal Kota Bogor C 337 458 795 14 31 45 ***
4 SMP N 11 Bogor SMP State Bogor Tengah Kota Bogor C 517 545 1.062 22 26 48 -
5 SMP N 3 Bogor SMP State Bogor Tengah Kota Bogor C 458 498 956 21 29 50 *
6 MTs N Bogor MTs State Bogor Utara Kota Bogor C 462 641 1.103 24 37 61 **
7 MTs Yasiba MTs Private Bogor Barat Kota Bogor C 376 385 761 11 16 27 *
8 MTs Yapendi MTs Private Tanah Sareal Kota Bogor B & C 78 89 167 7 8 15 -
9 MTs Yatasi / Tarbiyatusshibyan MTs Private Tanah Sareal Kota Bogor C 200 248 448 20 9 29 *
10 SMP N I Tarogong Kidul SMP State Tarogong Kidul Garut C 623 667 1.290 23 32 55 -
11 SMP N 5 Garut SMP State Garut Kota Garut C 567 503 1.070 23 29 52 **
12 SMP N 4 Tarogong Kidul SMP State Tarogong Kidul Garut B* & C 588 424 1.012 14 33 47 **
13 SMP N 2 Cikajang SMP State Cikajang Garut B* & C 418 377 795 15 17 32 * 14 SMP N I Samarang SMP State Samarang Garut C 557 596 1.153 19 42 61 *
15 SMP Ciledug Musaddadiyah SMP Private Tarogong Kidul Garut C 157 144 301 19 14 33 -
16 MTs N Garut MTs State Tarogong Kidul Garut B* & C 665 566 1.231 40 48 88 *
17 MTs Ar-Rohmah MTs Private Karangpawitan Garut C 335 349 684 18 17 35 ***
18 Mts At-Ta’awun MTs Private Sukaresmi Garut C 147 155 302 11 11 22 **
19 MTs Cikajang MTs Private Cikajang Garut B* & C 298 273 571 12 12 24 -
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
64
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
20 SMP N 1 Indramayu SMP State Indramayu Indramayu A & C 530 404 934 22 23 45 **
21 SMP N 2 Jatibarang SMP State Jatibarang Indramayu B & C 398 395 793 11 21 32 ***
22 SMP N 1 Sliyeg SMP State Sliyeg Indramayu A & C 373 456 829 25 22 47 -
23 SMP N 3 Sliyeg SMP State Sliyeg Indramayu C 139 120 259 17 13 30 *
24 SMP N 2 Balongan SMP State Balongan Indramayu B & C 342 326 668 17 15 32 **
25 MTs N Wotbogor MTs State Indramayu Indramayu A & C 202 203 405 14 17 31 -
26 MTs N Lohbener MTs State Lohbener Indramayu C 300 349 649 13 8 21
27 MTs N Jatibarang MTs State Jatibarang Indramayu B & C 204 251 455 12 15 27 **
28 MTs N Sliyeg MTs State Sliyeg Indramayu A & C 336 297 633 17 14 31 *
29 MTs Darul Ikhlas Sukaurip MTs Private Balongan Indramayu B & C 97 68 165 7 6 13 -
30 SMP N 1 Karawang Barat SMP State Karawang Barat Karawang A & C 967 1.129 2.096 22 42 64 **
31 MTs N Karawang MTs State Karawang Barat Karawang A & C 338 287 625 11 20 31 *
32 SMP N 1 Rengasdengklok SMP State Rengasdengklok Karawang A & C 1.239 1.276 2.515 23 37 60 **
33 SMP Islam Rengasdengklok SMP Private Rengasdengklok Karawang A & C 86 66 152 10 7 17 **
34 SMP N 1 Telagasari SMP State Telagasari Karawang B & C 814 819 1.633 27 20 47 ***
35 MTs Ghoyatul Jihad MTs Private Telagasari Karawang B & C 140 159 299 14 8 22 -
36 SMP N 2 Kota Baru SMP State Kota Baru Karawang B & C 936 752 1.688 20 16 36 *
37 MTs Al Ahliyah Cikampek MTs Private Kota Baru Karawang B & C 264 310 574 16 23 39 ***
38 SMP N 1 Telukjambe Barat SMP State Telukjambe Barat Karawang C 380 318 698 10 14 24 -
39 MTs N Rawamerta MTs State Rawamerta Karawang C 460 497 957 19 20 39 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
65
WEST JAVA Core Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 2 Jalan Cagak SMP State Jalan Cagak Subang B & D 326 285 611 21 19 40 ***
2 SMP N 1 Pagaden Barat SMP State Pagaden Barat Subang B & D 241 235 476 17 23 40 -
3 MTs N Kasomalang MTs State Kasomalang Subang B & D 354 339 693 26 18 44 *
4 MTs Mekarwangi MTs Private Pagaden Subang B & D 103 134 237 14 8 22 -
5 SMP N 1 Palabuhan Ratu SMP State Palabuhan Ratu Sukabumi A & D 416 491 907 22 13 35 ***
6 SMP N 1 Cisolok SMP State Cisolok Sukabumi A & D 451 516 967 20 19 39 *
7 MTs Jam'iyyatul Aulad MTs Private Palabuhan Ratu Sukabumi A & D 335 423 758 21 13 34 *
8 MTs Safinatul Falah MTs Private Cisolok Sukabumi A & D 87 97 184 11 8 19 -
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
66
3.5 District Facilitators / Performance Assessment
3.5.1 List of District Facilitators for Non Formal Education in West Java
Below is a list of facilitators from West Java trained to support the Non-Formal Education program.
Name Position District Subject
Aang Amsor, S.Ag Penilik PLS Kecamatan Sukabumi Management
Nana Suryana, S.Pd Sekertaris Forum PKBM Sukabumi Teaching and Learning
Drs. H. Rasita Ka. Sub Din Dikmas Dinas Pendidikan Kab. Indramayu Management
Hj. Heni Rohaeni, S.Pd Ketua PKBM Melati Indramayu Teaching and Learning
Deady Junaedi, S.Pd Ketua PKBM Buana Mekar Karawang Management
Dra. Rr. Oetami Pamong Belajar Karawang Management
Edi Yusup Sugianto, A.Md PKBM Warga Sejahtera Karawang Teaching and Learning
R. Oetami Noviana, S.Pd Pamong Belajar UPTD Karawang Teaching and Learning
Abdul Salam, S.Pd PKBM Cemerlang/TDL Dinas Bogor Management
Abdul Karim Halim, Drs, M.Si Univ. Ibnu Khaldun FKIP Bogor Teaching and Learning
Mustofa Penilik PLS Kec. Sliyeg Indramayu Management
Mustika, S.Pd Penilik PLS Kec. Tukdana Indramayu Teaching and Learning
Drs. Wawan Gunawan Pamong Belajar SKB Subang Teaching and Learning
Heni Rohaeni, M.Pd Forum PKBM Subang Management
Totong, S.Pd, M.Si Kasi Pemuda Dinas Pendidikan Garut Teaching and Learning
Sesep Kohar Forum PKBM Garut Management
3.5.2 List of District Facilitators for the Life Skills Training Program in West Java 2006 – 2008
Below is a list of facilitators from West Java trained to implement the Life Skills program.
Name Position Module District Institution
Teti Sabarniati, S.Pd Teacher English Karawang SMPN 1 Karawang
Drs. H. Asep Jamaludin, M.Ag Trainer English Karawang MDC Jawa Barat
Drs. Dindin Solahudin, MA Lecturer Civics Karawang UIN "SGD" Bandung
Marini, S.Pd Lecturer Life Skills Karawang UPI Bandung
Drs. Harun Harosid, M.Pd Teacher Lifeskills Karawang MAN Cipasung
Ir. Hj. Dian Endiangsih, MT Trainer ICT Karawang Solusi Pintar Indonesia
Ir. H. Budi Hartono, M.Sc Trainer ICT Karawang Solusi Pintar Indonesia
Drs. Chaerul Rochman, M.Pd Trainer BTL Karawang MDC Jawa Barat
Qiqi Yuliati Zaqiah, M.Ag Trainer BTL Karawang MDC Jawa Barat
Drs. Ruswandi Trainer Life skill Karawang Instruktur PINBUK Jabar
Dra. Dida Siti Sa'adah Teacher English Karawang SMAN 1 Klari Karawang
Purwiyati, S.Pd Teacher Life skill Karawang SMPN 1 Karawang
Iyang Gumilar, S.Pd Teacher English Karawang SMPN 1 Karawang
Drs. Daniel Yoseph SD, M.Pd Teacher Civics Karawang SMPN 1 Karawang
Danan Kristiharsa Yustinus, S.Pd Teacher ICT Karawang SMPN 1 Karawang
Enjang Rifa'i Teacher ICT Karawang SMPN 1 Rengasdengklok
Drs. Yusuf Zaenal Abidin, MM Lecturer Civics Karawang UIN Sunan Gunung Jati Bandung
Drs H. Udin, MPd Teacher BTL Karawang SMPN 4 Karawang
Rukmana, S.Pd Teacher BTL Karawang SMPN 3 Telukjambe
Drs. Sajidin, M.Pd Lecturer English Indramayu UIN "SGD" Bandung
Esti Dwi P. Oetami Teacher English Indramayu SMA Plus Muthahhari
Drs. Asep A. Hidayat, MA Lecturer Civics Indramayu UIN "SGD" Bandung
Yeti Heryati, S.Ag. M.Pd Lecturer Civics Indramayu UIN "SGD" Bandung
Drs. Abidin, M.Pd Teacher Life Skills Indramayu MAN 1 Bandung
Drs. Agus Martono, M.Ed Trainer Life Skills Indramayu MDC Jawa Barat
Cepi Riyana, M.Pd Lecturer ICT Indramayu UPI Bandung
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
67
Name Position Module District Institution
Drs. Agus Supardi, M.Pd Trainer ICT Indramayu MDC
Abdul Majid, M.Pd Trainer BTL Indramayu MDC Jawa Barat
DR. Yunita Trainer BTL Indramayu MDC Jawa Barat
Drs. Khariri Teacher BTL Indramayu MTsN Sliyeg
Subandi Lecturer BTL Indramayu Universitas Wiralodra
Nanang Carsana, S.IP Teacher Lifeskill Indramayu Universitas Wiralodra
Drs. Saekhudin Zuhri, M.Pd Teacher Lifeskill Indramayu Dinas Pendidikan Kota Cirebon
Bambang Mohamad Kartono Lecturer English Indramayu Universitas Wiralodra
Drs. Ayo Waryono Supervisor Civics Indramayu Dinas (Pengawas DIKMEN)
Tarmiah Teacher Civics Indramayu SMPN Ungulan
Pendi Susanto, M.Pd Teacher ICT Indramayu SMPN 2 Sindang (Guru)
Nasori Teacher ICT Indramayu SMPN Unggulan
Sarwono, S.Pd Teacher English Sukabumi SMPN 1 Cisolok
Jojo Suwarjo, S.Pd Teacher English Sukabumi SMPN 1 Palabuhan Ratu
Drs. Nawawi Teacher Civics Sukabumi SMPN 1 Palabuhan Ratu
Drs. Yusuf Zaenal Abidin, MM Lecturer Civics Sukabumi UIN "SGD" Bandung
Trisno Sri Hartono Teacher Life Skills Sukabumi SMPN 1 Palabuhan Ratu
Drs. Awaludin Hamzah, M.Ag Teacher Life Skills Sukabumi MAN 1 Bandung
Drs. H. Yayan Supyandi, M.Pd Teacher BTL Sukabumi MAN Palabuhan Ratu
Drs. Tajudin Iskandar, M.Pd Teacher BTL Sukabumi MAN 1 Bandung
Undang Diana Teacher ICT Sukabumi SMPN 1 Cisolok
MaMathematics Sujai Teacher ICT Sukabumi SMPN 1 Palabuhan Ratu
Nina Nurmasari, S.Pd Teacher BTL Bogor SMPN 1 Bungbulang Kab. Bogor
Dra. Maemunah Sa'diyah Lecturer BTL Bogor Univ. Ibnu Khaldun FIA
Drs. Hiswara Teacher Life skills Bogor SMA Negeri 4 Bogor
Ir. Budi Susetyo Lecturer Life skills Bogor Fak. Teknik Univ Ibnu Khaldun
Dini Ruswardningsih, S.Pd Lecturer English Bogor Univ. Ibnu Khaldun FKIP
Drs. H. Deddy Suryana, MM Lecturer English Bogor Korwas Disdik
Drs. M. Usman, M.Pd Supervisor Civics Bogor Pengawas Civics Disdik
Sri Sugiarti Teacher Civics Bogor SMPN 4 Bogor
Hendri Walika Lecturer ICT Bogor Univ. Ibnu Khaldun FKIP
Muhammad Tahjudin, S.Ag Teacher ICT Bogor SMA YPHB
Didin Mahpudin, M.Pd Teacher BTL Subang SMPN 4 Pagaden Subang
Drs. Yayan Setiawan, M.Pd Teacher BTL Subang MTsN Subang
Enjang AS, M.Si, M.Ag Staff Life skills Subang LSM
Drs. Awaluddin Hamzah, M.Ag Teacher Life skills Subang MAN 1 Bandung
Taufiq, M.Pd Teacher English Subang MTsN Subang
Willyana Ramlan, M.Pd Lecturer English Subang STKIP Subang
Yani Rohaningsih, S.Pd Teacher Civics Subang SMPN 1 Cipunegara Subang
Yeti Heryati, M.Pd Lecturer Civics Subang UIN Sunan Gunung Jati Bandung
Erik Taufikurrohman, S.Pd Teacher ICT Subang MTsN Subang
Cepi Riyana, M.Pd Lecturer ICT Subang UPI Bandung
Agus RahMathematics Nugraha Lecturer BTL Garut STAIDA Muhammadiyah Garut
Dr. Rd.Ahmad Buchari Lecturer BTL Garut ST Agama Islam Darul Arqom Muhammadiyah Garut
Gozain Mudzakir, S.Ag, S.Pd Teacher Lifeskill Garut MAN 1 Garut
Nani Chaerani, S.Sos.I Teacher Lifeskill Garut SMA Terpadu Krida Nusantara
Agus Somantri Teacher English Garut PGSD, UPI,
Iyen Nurlaelawati Lecturer English Garut Jur. B. Inggris UPI
Asep Ahmad Hidayat Teacher Civics Garut
Agus Wahyudin, M.Si Teacher ICT Garut SMAN 3 Tarogong Kidul Garut
Helmi Miftahul Khoir, A.Md ICT Garut na
Hera Sri Mudzakir, M.Pd Teacher Mathematics Garut MAN 1 Garut
Asep Jihad, M.Pd Mathematics Garut
Muntaryo, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Garut SMAN 1 Tarogong Kidul Garut
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
68
3.5.3 The District Facilitators for the Whole School Program
In order to support the implementation of the whole school training program, more usually referred to as the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, district facilitators were selected in each district jointly by local government and DBE3 staff and trained by the project. There were originally 15 facilitators (3 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each extension district and 10 facilitators (2 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each core district. They have been trained to implement all or most of the BTL training modules. A number of the best facilitators from each province were also elevated to become national facilitators, which meant that they were trained in each module before the rest of the district facilitators and were then charged with implementing the training of the district facilitators. In their own districts they continued to act as district facilitators, supporting partner school and dissemination training, organizing MGMP activities and mentoring teachers after training. A list of the BTL facilitators operating as of August 2011 is included on the next page.
3.5.4 How the District Facilitator Performance Assessment was Done
In order to provide information on the effectiveness of these facilitators to those wishing to disseminate the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, DBE3 evaluated their performance using an instrument which focuses on a number of key areas:
• The extent to which the District Facilitator applies the training in their own work as a teacher, Principal or School Supervisor
• The extent to which the District Facilitator helps other teachers in their own school either as a teacher, Principal or Supervisor
• Their creativity in developing and implementing innovative training materials and approaches
• Their commitment as a District Facilitator for DBE3
• Their ability to relate to, communicate and interact with participants in the training and in mentoring
• Their initiative and ability to cooperate and support others District Facilitators during the training
• How effective they are as a mentor, whether they are able to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching and learning process and provide good feedback to teachers
Following the evaluation, each District Facilitator was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest.
3 2 1 0
Category
Very good, always works hard and is very able as a Facilitator
Good in general performance and ability as a Facilitator
Average, still needs to develop some skills as a Facilitator
Rarely works and not very able as a Facilitator
In a number of cases, where facilitators failed to function in an adequate manner no assessment has been given (denoted by ‘-‘).
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
69
3.5.5 List of Facilitators in West Java for the Whole School Training Program and Performance Assessment
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princ-ipal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
JAWA BARAT - BANTEN
1 Ridwan, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 7 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 087870223460 [email protected]; [email protected]
** 2 Eman Suherman M Teacher English SMPN 6 Bogor Non Partner Bogor West Java 08128751209 [email protected] * 3 Nurlela, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 1 Bogor Non Partner Bogor West Java 081311465460 [email protected] ** 4 Sri Hartati, M.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 8 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 08174919579 [email protected] *** 5 Dedi Husnaeni, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 08568157775 [email protected] - 6 Ida Tutik Udiana, S.Pd. F Teacher B. Ind MTsN Kota Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 081383036116 [email protected] - 7 Lili Budiarti, Dra. F Teacher Science SMPN 8 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 081398627464 [email protected] ** 8 Lilis Supratman, S.Pd. F Teacher Science MTs Yasiba Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 087770134043
[email protected]; [email protected]
-
9 Siti Djumhurijah, S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMPN 8 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 08161363726 [email protected] ** 10 Trisno Widodo, Drs. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 6 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 081317161252 [email protected] ** 11 Ai Suaebah, Dra. F Teacher Social S. MTsN Kota Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 08561824454 - 12 Rika Dewi Roswiasih, S.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMPN 7 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 081310718010 [email protected] - 13 Dede Supardi, Drs., M.Pd. M Teacher Math MTs Yasiba Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 08121190463 [email protected] ** 14 Odik Suharyadi, M.M. M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Bogor Non Partner Bogor West Java 081381996955 [email protected] * 15 Siti Amalia, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 7 Bogor Partner Bogor West Java 081329456700 [email protected] - 16 Yusep Saepul Riwayat, M.Pd. M Teacher English MTsN 2 Cibatu Garut Non Partner Garut West Java 08179267637 [email protected] ** 17 Kusnadi, M.Si. M Teacher English SMPN 4 Tarogong Kidul Partner Garut West Java 085223001279 ** 18 Agus Somantri, Drs., M.Pd. M Teacher English STKIP Garut Non Partner Garut West Java 08164218844 [email protected] - 19 Darsono, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 2 Garut Non Partner Garut West Java 081323946984 [email protected] - 20 Diding Saprudin, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Tarogong Non Partner Garut West Java 081322194848 [email protected] * 21 Rina Rosmayana S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind MTsN Garut Partner Garut West Java 081320552925 [email protected] ** 22 Iwan Ridwan, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Limbangan Non Partner Garut West Java 081320703869 *
23 Asep Dermawan, S.Pd. M Teacher Science MTsN Garut Partner Garut West Java 8122151910 [email protected]; [email protected]
*
24 Edi Sutisna, S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 3 Banyuresmi Non Partner Garut West Java 081320159178 [email protected] *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
70
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princ-ipal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
25 Rahmat M Teacher Science Bimbel Nurul Fikri Non Partner Garut West Java 085722378833 [email protected] * 26 Gozain Mudzakkir M Teacher Social S. MAN 1 Garut Non Partner Garut West Java
08112129073/081222882348
[email protected] * 27 Uus Kusnadi, Drs. M.Pd. M Supervisor Social S. Kementerian Agama Non Partner Garut West Java 081322525461 * 28 Beni Kustiana, Drs. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Tarogong Kidul Partner Garut West Java 081321881969 [email protected] * 29 Hera Sri Mudzakir, Dra., M.Pd. F Teacher Math MAN 1 Garut Non Partner Garut West Java 081323756401 [email protected] *** 30 Cicin Kuraesin, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMPN 1 Limbangan Non Partner Garut West Java 08112117653 [email protected] * 31 Eneng Erliani, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMPN 4 Tarogong Kidul Partner Garut West Java 081323005919 [email protected] ** 32 Munip, Drs., M.Pd. M Teacher Math MTs Al-Musaddadiyah Garut Partner Garut West Java 081320484548 [email protected] - 33 Agus Suryana, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN Unggulan Sindang Non Partner Indramayu West Java 081912949781 * 34 Saekhudin Zuhri, Drs., M.Pd. M Teacher English UNWIR Non Partner Indramayu West Java 081320727589 * 35 Bambang Mohamad Kartono M Teacher English SMAN 1 Indramayu Non Partner Indramayu West Java 08156412962 [email protected] **
36 Komariah, S.Pd. F Teacher B. Ind SMPN Unggulan Sindang Non Partner Indramayu West Java 081802382090 [email protected]; [email protected]
*
37 Ojo Suharja, H., Drs., M.M. M Supervisor B. Ind Kementerian Agama Non Partner Indramayu West Java 081220000472 [email protected] *** 38 Tarsono, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind MTsN Sliyeg Partner Indramayu West Java 081394720276 * 39 D. Mapati Syarifudin, Drs. M Supervisor Science Dinas Pendidikan Non Partner Indramayu West Java 08122103745 *** 40 Wati Rosanah S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMPN 2 Jatibarang Partner Indramayu West Java 081324325850 [email protected] *** 41 Maman, S.Pd., M.Ed. M Teacher Science MTsN Anjatan Non Partner Indramayu West Java 08112434369 [email protected] * 42 Sri Sumarti, S.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Indramayu Partner Indramayu West Java 081324755800 - 43 Khariri, Drs. M Supervisor Social S. Kementerian Agama Non Partner Indramayu West Java 08122089894 - 44 Ayo Waryono M Supervisor Social S. Dinas Pendidikan Non Partner Indramayu West Java 08122089883 [email protected] ** 45 Runisah, M.Pd. F Teacher Math UNWIR Non Partner Indramayu West Java 081320699060 [email protected] -
46 Sriyono, Drs. M Teacher Math SMAN 1 Indramayu Non Partner Indramayu West Java 0234-275341 / 081214251176
49 Iskandar Sulaeman, S.Pd.I. M Teacher English SMP Islam Rengasdengklok Partner Karawang West Java 081320654997 [email protected] ** 47 Istiqomah Salamah, S.Ag. F Teacher English MTs Al-Ahliyah Partner Karawang West Java 085880681242 [email protected] *** 48 Iyang Gumilar, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 1 Karawang Barat Partner Karawang West Java 08174875802 [email protected] * 49 Abdul Khayyi, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Pakisjaya Non Partner Karawang West Java 085846555072 ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
71
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princ-ipal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
50 Irwan Kurniawan, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Karawang Timur Non Partner Karawang West Java 081584560162 [email protected] *** 51 Daud Hudawi, S.Pd. M Principal B. Ind
SMPN 2 Lemahabang Wadas
Non Partner Karawang West Java 08128245976, [email protected] * 52 Mulyana Surya Atmaja, H., S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Rawamerta Non Partner Karawang West Java 081311376748 [email protected] *** 53 Ahmad Fadloli, M.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Karawang Barat Non Partner Karawang West Java 081383694406
[email protected]; [email protected]
***
54 Rukmana, M.Pd. M Principal Science SMPN 2 Pakis Jaya Non Partner Karawang West Java 081387333319 / 081387477719
55 Ade Juhana, A.Md.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Telagasari Partner Karawang West Java 085694875467 *** 56 Obar Subarja, Drs. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Klari Non Partner Karawang West Java 081321741304 *
57 Udin, H., Drs., M.Pd. M Principal Social S. SMPN 3 Karawang Non Partner Karawang West Java 0267-411803 / 081314054480
58 Budi Sutrisno, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Ciampel Non Partner Karawang West Java 081384702401 [email protected] *** 59 Hendralanty Wahyu, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMPN 4 Klari Non Partner Karawang West Java 081807878199 ** 60 Ita Aisah, S.Si. F Teacher Math MTsN Rengasdengklok Non Partner Karawang West Java 08157153437 [email protected] *** 61 M. Taufiq P. Hidayat, M.Pd. M Teacher English MTsN Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 085720013645 [email protected] * 62 Cucu Laelasari, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 4 Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 081321753037 [email protected] * 63 Toto Sugiarto, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 085221847157 [email protected] * 64 Marliawati, M.M.Pd. F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Ciater Non Partner Subang West Java 085624696934 [email protected] ** 65 Yayan Setiawan, Drs. M.Pd. M Teacher Science MTsN Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 08157159148 [email protected] * 66 Elbania Ria Tirana, S.Pd. M Teacher Science MTsN Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 085283236789 [email protected] * 67 Rukasim, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Cipunagara Non Partner Subang West Java 081321271739 [email protected] * 68 Ahmad Djuniarsa, Drs. M.Si. M Teacher Social S. SMP 2 Dawuan Non Partner Subang West Java 08122327854 [email protected] *** 69 Didin Mahpudin, M.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 4 Pagaden Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 081320480136 [email protected] ** 70 Erik Taufiqurrohman, S.Pd. M Teacher Math MTsN Subang Non Partner Subang West Java 081320599103 [email protected] ** 71 Sarwono, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 1 Cisolok Partner Sukabumi West Java 085720502185 * 72 Jojo Suwarjo, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 1 Pelabuhan Ratu Partner Sukabumi West Java 08159873129 [email protected] * 73 Mamat Sujai, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Pelabuhan Ratu Partner Sukabumi West Java 081807080811 * 74 Sugiarto, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind MTs Jam'iyyatul Aulad Partner Sukabumi West Java 08111102047 ** 75 Jumino, S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Parung Kuda Non Partner Sukabumi West Java 081911704422 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
72
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princ-ipal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
76 Muh. Zukhron, Drs. M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Cisolok Partner Sukabumi West Java 08156304968 * 77 Sutisna, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Pelabuhan Ratu Partner Sukabumi West Java 085294185830 [email protected] * 78 Tedi Cahlan, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Pelabuhan Ratu Partner Sukabumi West Java 087822707046 - 79 Dwi Ningsih, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMPN 1 Pelabuhan Ratu Partner Sukabumi West Java 081288328060 ** 80 Yayan Supyandi, Drs. H. M.Pd. M Teacher Math MAN Palabuhan Ratu Non Partner Sukabumi West Java 08121140867 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
73
3.6 Working with Teacher Training Institutions and LPMP
To achieve wider impact beyond the target districts and to support improvement across the (junior secondary) education system, DBE3 worked with staff from the Indonesia Education University (UPI) and the West Java Quality Assurance Institute (LPMP). Staff of these institutions took part in the provincial BTL training programs including the training of facilitators and training of teachers. selected lecturers also participated in the classroom action research program.
Details of staff from the University and LPMP taking part in various DBE3 activities are presented below:
3.6.1 Number of Staff from Universities and LPMP taking part in DBE3 training and CAR activities
Province Better
Teaching and Learning
Classroom Action
Research Total
West Java 9 5 14
3.7 Overview of Trainee Data
3.7.1 Non Formal Education Managers Trained by District in West Java
Below is a list of the number of non formal education managers by district from West Java trained on the Non-Formal Education program.
District Managers
Male Female Total
Karawang 1 7 0 7
Indramayu 1 11 0 11
Sukabumi 12 1 13
Karawang 2 7 1 8
Subang 5 2 7
Garut 6 0 6
Indramayu 2 8 1 9
Bogor 8 2 10
Total 64 7 71
3.7.2 Non Formal Education Tutors Trained By District in West Java
Below is a list of the numbers of tutors from district in West Java trained to implement the Non-Formal Education program.
District # Tutors
Male Female Total
Karawang 1 8 1 9
Indramayu 1 13 2 15
Sukabumi 14 1 15
Karawang 2 5 3 8
Subang 3 4 7
Garut 7 1 8
Indramayu 2 3 5 8
Bogor 4 4 8
Total 57 21 78
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
74
3.7.3 Number of Teachers in West Java Trained Using the Life Skills Training Program
Below is a list showing the number of teachers in each district in West Java by District, Gender and School Type trained between 2006 and 2008 to implement the Life Skills training program.
District
SMP MTs Total
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Indramayu 1 47 32 79 44 24 68 91 56 147
Karawang 1 103 86 189 12 33 45 115 119 234
Sukabumi 57 42 99 26 15 41 83 57 140
Bogor 38 71 109 20 10 30 58 81 139
Garut 25 27 52 49 43 92 74 70 144
Indramayu 2 31 19 50 18 20 38 49 39 88
Karawang 2 26 33 59 44 18 62 70 51 121
Subang 22 27 49 37 41 78 59 68 127
Total 349 337 686 250 204 454 599 541 1140
3.7.4 Facilitators Trained in the BTL packages
Below is a list of the numbers of participants in the District Facilitator training for the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) modules in West Java and West Java. The training included district facilitators and a number of others, mainly lecturers from teacher training universities and trainers from LPMPs.
All Districts WEST JAVA AND WEST JAVA
Participants
District Facilitators
Others Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 104 9 113
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 109 43 152
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 105 23 128
3.7.5 Number of Teachers, School Principals and Supervisors Trained in BTL Program
Below is a list of the numbers of teachers, school principals and school supervisors from or associated with partner schools in West Java and West Java trained in the BTL program. The number of school principals and supervisors trained in BTL4 appears to be fewer. This is a result of receiving separate training to support the BTL4 program and the BTL4 package being delivered through the MGMP (Teachers Working Groups), which are teacher specific organization, which school principals and supervisors do not normally attend.
All Districts WEST JAVA AND WEST JAVA
Participants
Teachers Principals Supervisors Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 908 1 9 918
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 1045 48 23 1116
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 962 53 21 1036
Additional School Supervisors Trained - 93 - -
The numbers of facilitators, teachers, school principals and supervisors shown as participcating in the BTL training in the tables above should not be aggregated, as they were largely the same people participating in each package of training.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
75
3.8 Dissemination of DBE3 programs
A core strategy of the DBE3 project was to develop exemplars of good practice in the partner schools and districts with the “specific intent” that these would be taken up and implemented by others to additional schools and geographical areas. Below is a summary of the dissemination of DBE3 programs in West Java by province and then by district. For more details of the dissemination program and activities see Volume 1, section ?? of this report.
3.8.1 Provincial Overview of Dissemination in West Java
Province Total # Schools
Total # Participants
Average # of Participants
Per Institution
Partner Districts
Disseminating
Non Partner Districts
Disseminating
Total Dissemination Budget (US$)
Contribution from Local
Partner (US$)
Local Contribution as a % of total budget spent
Average Cost per Trainee (US$)
West Java 2,079 14,249 6.8 6 7 465,991 383,188 82.2% 32
DBE3 Project 6,440 50,179 7.7 41 42 1,738,860 1,359,279 78% 35.1
% of Project Total 32.2% 28.3% 14.6% 16.6% 26.7% 28.1%
3.8.2 Dissemination by District in West Java
PARTNER DISTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Sukabumi 462 4 45 49 10.60%
Subang 211 4 84 85 40.20% 40.20%
Garut 574 10 117 127 19.30% 22.00%
Kota Bogor 814 10 231 241 28.30% 27.70%
Indramayu 263 10 120 130 45.60% 49.40%
Karawang 199 10 175 185 87.90% 92.90%
Bandung Barat* 201 0 4 4 1.90% 1.90%
Kota Bandung* 255 0 3 3 1.10% 1.10%
Sumedang* 164 0 6 6 3.60% 3.60%
Cirebon* 266 0 51 51 19.10% 19.10%
Cimahi* 50 0 1 1 2% 2%
Tasikmalaya* 388 0 10 10 2.50% 2.50%
Purwakarta* 148 0 1 1 0.60% 0.60%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
76
3.8.3 The Impact of Dissemination
The dissemination training in schools had some positive impact. When compared to the DBE3 comparison schools the dissemination schools did considerably better on all DBE3 teaching and learning indicators (with the exception of Instructional Leadership). However, the impact on teaching and learning in dissemination schools was not as significant as that on impact on partner schools suggesting that whilst dissemination training is beneficial, direct assistance achieves better results.
3.8.4 Chart: A comparison of the Impact of DBE3 in Partner, Dissemination and Comparison Schools in West Java
3.8.5 List of District Contributions to Dissemination of DBE3 Program
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Karawang 22,650,000 2,554
Serang 55,000,000 6,204
Garut 45,310,000 5,110
Sukabumi 31,200,000 3,519
Subang 15,500,000 1,748
Total 122,960,000 19,135
3.8.6 Contributions to District Dissemination of DBE3 Innovations from MORA Budget
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Karawang 30,000,000 3,384
Indramayu 30,000,000 3,384
Total 60,000,000 6,768
62.5
94.1
0
76
97.7
0
83
100
0 0
69
00
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Teachers' Skills Student Behavior Classroom
Environment
Principal
Leadership
Dissemination Schools
Partner Schools
Comparison Schools
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
77
3.9 Review of the Extension District Development Plans and Their Implementation
Towards the end of 2010 all partner extension districts made plans to support and disseminate the DBE3 program. A summary of the plans in English and a review of the extent to which districts had implemented these plans by November 2011 is set out below.
GARUT
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR of 500.000.000 IDR from their APBD in 2011 Budget reported from APBD: 45,310,000
Workshop for School Principals and Supervisors scheduled for July 2011 No Progress TOT for an additional 15 District Facilitators scheduled for August 2011 No Progress Mentoring for DBE3 partner schools scheduled to start from August 2011 No Progress BTL2 dissemination for 450 teachers scheduled for August and September 2011 Completed BTL3 dissemination for 450 teachers scheduled for September and October 2011 Completed Study Visit for dissemination participants to DBE3 partner schools scheduled for September and October 2011
No Progress
Mentoring for participants in dissemination training scheduled for October to December 2011
No Progress
A decree will be issued for the District Facilitators by the Head of the Education Office
No Progress
A Forum for District Facilitators will be established. No Progress
INDRAMAYU
PLAN AS OF AUGUTS 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 1.150.000.000 No Reported Budget Allocation from APBD
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
78
BOGOR
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 250,000,000 IDR No reported Budget Allocation from APBD
Additional District Facilitators Completed
Forming a District Facilitators Forum Completed
BTL2 and BTL3 Dissemination Training for School Supervisors Completed
BTL2 and BTL3 Dissemination Training for Non Partner Schools and MGMP Completed
Teacher mentoring activities integrated into routine school supervision Completed
More structured MGMP activities on a monthly basis Completed
Socialization of DBE3 programs through MGMP Completed
Presentation of DBE3 at DPRD Completed
Socialization meeting in Forum SKPD Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
79
KARAWANG
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 150.000.000 IDR from APBD in 2010 and 660.000.000 IDR for 2011
Reported budget allocation of 22,650,000 from APBD
BTL2 trainings for 100 teachers from 20 non partner schools scheduled for October and November 2010
Completed
BTL2 training for teachers of other non partner schools in 2011 No Progress
Capacity building workshop for school principal and supervisor related to teaching and learning and Instructional Leadership
No Progress
Activating school level MGMP forum in schools that have participated in BTL2 and BTL3 training along with DBE3 partner schools.
These MGMP are now active and are being supported by District Facilitators
Mentoring by trained School Supervisor in Schools that have participated in DBE3 trainings.
No Progress
Study visit to DBE3 partner schools in the district Completed
A joint decree issued by the Education office and MORA regarding the role and function of DF
No Progress due to change in leadership
Instruction/Circular Letter from Head of Education Office on the use of BOS fund for MGMP activities and study visit for schools trained using APBD fund.
No Progress due to change in leadership
Instruction Letter from Head of Education Office for schools to use funds from BOS for dissemination activities (if not trained using APBD) funds.
No Progress due to change in leadership
Circular Letter on the development of progress report from School and Madrasah Principals with regards to implementation of active learning in schools/Madrasah.
No Progress due to change in leadership
Promoting the formation of cluster system with DBE3 partner school as the model/core of effective MGMP management. This is done by school supervisors.
These MGMP are now active and are being supported by District Facilitators
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
80
3.10 List of DBE3 Technical, Management and Administrative Staff in West Java and Banten, August 2011
DBE3 – RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH
Provincial Office: West Java/Banten
Name Position Residential Address Phone Numbers Asep S. Muhtadi Provincial Coordinator
(West Java/Banten ) Jl. Salman Al-Farisi, G4/4 Griya Cempaka Arum Gede Bage Bandung 40613
Res : (022) 783 1709 Cell: 0812 2045193
Rifki Rosyad Education Officer Jl. Derwati No. 8 Rt. 01/Rw. 03 Kel. Rancabolang Kec. Gedebage Bandung 40296
Res: (022) 91618522 Cell: 0811219639, 0818 09815916
Syihabuddin District Coordinator Jl. Empat Lima Gg. Bhineka RT.03/13 No. 21 Kaujon Baru Serang Res: Cell: 081210154243/ 0811 223 0702
Renniati Fadhilah District Coordinator Jl. Cilandak No. 30 Sarijadi Bandung Res: Cell:/0811 223 0668
Dindin Solahudin Communication Officer Pesantren Al-Ihsan Cibiru Hilir RT.01/02 Cileunyi Bandung 40626 Res: Cell: 08112213849/ 081321319389
Abdul Majid District Coordinator Komp. Perum Mitra Posindo Blok D-2 No.28 Ds. Cinunuk Kec. Cilenyi Bandung
Res: Cell: 08112213823
Yeti Heryati District Coordinator Jl. Terusan Permai V No.32 Cipadung Bandung
Res: (022) 70943772 Cell: 081322105700
Usman Hidayat District Coordinator
Jl. P. Timor 1 No. 41 Perumnas III Bekasi 17111
Res: Cell: 0811 2213845
R. Novianto Soejatno
District Coordinator Jl. Karasak Utara 2 No. 7 Bandung 40243
Res: (022) 5221513 Cell: 08179952161
Dian Rahadian District Coordinator BTN Sindang Citra A-44/45 Sindang, Indramayu Res: Cell : 081911927228
Vivi Nurvitasari Finance & Administration Officer
Komp. Tamansari Bukit Bandung Blok IA No. 25 Jl. Raya Sindanglaya Arcamanik Bandung
Res: (022) 7831218 Cell: 0818 0959 4779
Muhammad
Imami
Finance Assistant Komp. Bumi Panyileukan G8 No. 5 Bandung
Res: (022) 7807257 Cell: 08112213817
Fitriani Almaidah Derusti
Admin Assistant Jl. Kuningan X No. 22 Antapani Bandung
Res: (022) 727 3968 Cell: 0856 2310420
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
81
4. CENTRAL JAVA PROVINCIAL REPORT
This annex contains information and data concerning the implementation of the DBE3 project in Central Java from 2005 to 2011. It should be read in conjunction with Volume I of the DBE3 Final Project Report, which contains a detailed account of the project activities.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
83
4.1 Map of Project Coverage in Central Java
Below is a map showing the districts in which the DBE3 program has been implemented in Central Java. There are 9 partner districts, with whom DBE had a formal agreement and 11 non-partner districts, where there was no formal agreement but in which the program was also disseminated.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
84
4.2 District Performance on the DBE3 Project
4.2.1 Highlights of District and Provincial Performance in Central Java
Purworejo
1. Based on a Decree from the Head of Education and Religious Affairs Ministry Offices, all SMP and public and private MTs have dissmeinated the BTL 2 training module and more than 50% have done dissemination of BTL3.
2. Funds from the World Bank funded Basic Education Capacity (BEC) program are being used to disseminate the training of BTL.
3. SMPN 19 Purworejo has pioneered the establishment of mathematic and social science laboratories
4. The DPRD, Education Council and Bappeda will allocate a budget for the sustainability of DBE3 in APBD 2012 and beyond.
5. Training of two additional District Facilitators for each subject (10 people) took place.
6. Implementation of the DBE1, DBE2, and DBE3 programs has been integrated.
Grobogan
1. Dissemination of DBE3 has taken place in almost 90% of junior secondaru schools (SMP and MTs).
2. A budget allocation to support the continuation of the DBE3 program has been made since 2010 and still continues to be budgeted each year.
3. Training of two additional District Facilitators for each subject (10 people) has taken place.
4. District Facilitators involved in the District Curriculum Development Team.
5. Working Group of Madrasah School Principals (KKMTs) has become effective as a driving force for the dissemination of DBE3 in public and private MTs.
6. Dissemination schools have implementedt the DBE3 program after training, and SMPN 1 Gubug received a study visit from Central Java DBE3.
7. The RSBI (International Standard School) has disseminated 100% using its own funds and covered all the cost of mentoring by the District Facilitators and teaching materials needs for the year
8. Dissemination training of BTL for School Principals has taken place.
9. The Religious Affairs Ministry Head Office has conducted training in BTL for model teachers of Islamic Education.
Karanganyar
1. Dissemination of DBE3 has been completed in almost 100% of SMP and MTs. The education office expects by the end of December 2011 it will complete dissemination in 100% of schools.
2. The Education Office has established 5 DBE3 model schools that can be used for study visits.
3. In 2012 the district will form an education quality control team in the district, most of the members will be DBE3 District Facilitators
4. An additional 25 new District Facilitators have been trained with the cost of training funded by the District Education Office budget.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
85
5. An allocation from the district budget has been made in 2011 and 2012 to support the DBE3 programs.
6. Dissemination training of BTL for school principals has taken place.
7. The RSBI (International Standard School) has disseminated training of BTL2 and BTL3 using its own funds.
Kudus
1. Dissemination of DBE3 has taken place in almost 80% of public and private SMP and MTs.
2. MTsN 2 Kudus has disseminated the program to all its teachers, including teachers of Islamic Religious Education. After DBE3 is finished, the school has allocated a budget for the sustainable implementation of the DBE3 program including allocating a budget for the District Facilitators to provide mentoring. The school has selected master teachers for 15 subjects who will provide mentoring to other teachers and support the school level MGMP. MTsN 2 Kudus has also held a showcase every year for the community, especially for parents.
3. Eight additional District Facilitators have been trained
4. Partner and dissemination schools received study visits from Central Java and East Java.
5. An allocation has been made from the district budget for 2012 to support dissemination of the DBE3 program.
6. Integration of the DBE1, DBE2 and DBE3 programs has taken place. Dinas Pendidikan has encouraged school planning linked to teaching and learning inputs and teried to ensure that students using active learning in primary school continue to do so in junior secondary school.
7. Dissemination training of BTL for school principal has been implemented.
Boyolali
1. Dissemination has taken place in almost 80% of SMP and MTs
2. Partner schools received study visits from East Java and North Aceh
3. 15 additional District Facilitators (3 people per subject) have been trained.
4. An allocation has been made from the district budget for 2012 to support dissemination of the DBE3 program.
Jepara
1. Dissemination of the BTL modules has taken place in all public and private MTs and almost 70% of SMP.
2. Dissemination of BTL for school principal and heads of madrasah took place.
3. A dissemination school (SMPN 1 Majong) has given BTL training to all teachers and in 2011 was number 1 in Jepara for UAN (national examination) results.
4. An allocation has been made from the district budget for 2011 and 2012 to support dissemination of the DBE3 program.
Demak
1. Dissemination has taken place to almost 80% of SMP and MTs
2. An allocation has been made from the district budget for 2012 to support dissemination of the DBE3 program.
3. Funds from the World Bank funded Basic Education Capacity (BEC) program are being used to disseminate the training of BTL.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
86
Blora and Klaten
Nothing of note to report.
Important activities at Central Java Provincial Level
1. The provincial showcase and closeout was held on the campus of UNNES (Semarang State University)and received a very positive response not only from the district partner but also from UNNES. All the Post graduate Deans and Directors attended the event. The students also visited the displays.
2. Each school that does dissemination must make a written plan of what will implement post-training. On the last day of training at the time of preparation of follow-up activities, the school principal must sign a promissory note to implement the follow-up. This is copied to the Head of Education/ Religious Affairs Ministry Head Officeand Provincial Coordinator from the DBE3 Central Java office.
3. Training in BTL for lecturers and teachers of UNNES partner school was also attended by representatives from other teacher training institutions including: IAIN Walisongo Semarang, Semarang PGRI IKIP, UKSW Salatiga, UMS Solo, Sanata Dharma University in Yogyakarta and IAIN Sunan KalijagaYogyakarta
4. Training in classroom action research has taken place for lecturers and teachers from UNNES partner schools.
5. Training in BTL for principals UNNES school partner was also attended by the partner school principal from other teacher training institutions including: IAIN Walisongo Semarang, Semarang PGRI IKIP, SWCU Salatiga, UMS Solo, Sanata Dharma University in Yogyakarta, Yogyakarta, IAIN Sunan Kalijaga
6. A Best Practices in Learning book was published by DBE3 Central Java, to accommodate the work of teachers who could not be included in the Best Practices books at national level.
7. The Central Java Provincial Government is prepared to continue to partner with USAID in the field of education. The Government of Central Java province is ready to share the cost of future programs. UNNES party invited DBE3 to use its facilities.
4.2.2 Assessment of Partner District Performance
The performance and impact of the DBE3 program has been varied in the different districts and schools. Below is an assessment of the performance of the DBE3 partner districts in Central Java.
The criteria used were as follows:
• Level of commitment of local stakeholders
• Impact on partner schools
• Extent of project dissemination achieved
Each of the criteria is rated on a scale of one to three – with three being the highest rating. This has resulted in an overall star rating for each districts. Three stars in the highest rating and denotes a high level of stakeholder commitment, a generally high impact on practice in partner schools and a considerable amount of dissemination to non-partner schools. A rating of one star denotes a low level in each of these criteria.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
87
CENTRAL JAVA
CO
HO
RT
EX
TE
NS
ION
/
CO
RE
Lo
cal G
overn
men
t
Sta
ff C
om
mit
men
t
Imp
act
on
Sch
oo
ls
Rep
lica
tio
n
alr
ead
y t
aken
pla
ce
Fu
nd
ing f
or
R
ep
lica
tio
n
Overa
ll R
an
kin
g
1. Demak 2 C 2 2 3 2 **
2. Klaten 1 & 2 C 1 1 1 1 *
3. Karanganyar 1 E 3 3 3 3 ***
4. Purworejo 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
5. Grobogan 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
6. Boyolali 1 E 3 3 3 3 ***
7. Kudus 1 E 3 3 3 3 ***
8. Jepara 1 C 2 2 3 3 **
9. Blora 2 C 1 1 1 1 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
88
4.3 List of Non-Formal Service Providers
Below is a list non-formal service providers with whom DBE3 worked between 2006 and 2008.
District NFE Provider Learners Tutors
M F Total M F Total
Jepara KPB Nurul Muhtadin 18 5 23 7 2 9
PP Nurul Huda 39 12 51 9 1 10
PP Nurul Huda Tegalsambi 60 40 100 11 5 16
PKBM Krida Wiyata 0 20 20 3 3 6
PP Raudhatul Mubtadiin 227 204 431 9 1 10
Kudus PKBM Utomo 6 19 25 18 7 25
PP Al Qudsiyah 162 106 268 6 3 9
KPB Hargo Wasis 2 21 23 6 3 9
LPTM Wana Bakti Manunggal 35 8 43 6 2 8
PP Al-Furqon 12 12 24 7 2 9
Klaten PKBM Marsudi Karya 0 0 0 2 1 3
PP Al-Anwar Muhammadiyah 13 2 15 2 1 3
PP Muhammadiyah 49 42 91 9 10 19
PP Urwatul Wutsqo 24 18 42 5 1 6
Karanganyar SKB Karanganyar 115 86 201 21 12 33
PP Al Muhlisin 35 25 60 5 1 6
Kosegu 68 102 170 12 8 20
Darun Najah 23 29 52 3 4 7
PKBM Bima Jatipuro 19 6 25 8 5 13
Boyolali PP Nurul Ula 4 4 8 3 3 6
Kejar Paket B Desa Cepogo 14 7 21 6 6 12
PP Istiqomah 15 10 25 3 1 4
PKBM Tunas Mulia 7 10 17 5 7 12
Demak PP Subulussalam 30 120 150 40 4 44
PP Miftahul Ulum 50 45 95 6 3 9
PP Sirojul Ulum 30 46 76 3 3 6
Grobogan Paket B Ngudi Luhur 8 11 19 7 2 9
PP At Tazkir 51 36 87 17 4 21
PKBM Ploso Rejo 11 9 20 4 5 9
PP Al Hidayah* 0 0 0 0 0 0
Blora PKBM Al Karomah 0 28 28 5 5 10
PP Al Ikhlas 84 73 157 4 4 8
PKBM Wirorejo 8 0 8 4 2 6
PP Mambaul 75 25 100 10 2 12
Klaten PKBM Marsudi Kawruh 25 76 101 10 10 20
PKBM Karsa Mandiri 50 50 100 4 2 6
PP Roudhlotuzzahidin 50 50 100 4 2 6
PP Nurudh Dholam 0 27 27 6 3 9
Purworejo PKBM Tunas Muda 15 0 15 5 1 6
PP Asy Sya’roni Mafathul Huda 50 50 100 4 2 6
PKBM Rahayu* 0 0 0 0 0 0
PP Al Amin 23 28 51 10 2 12
Total 42 1507 1462 2969 309 145 454
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
89
4.4 Partner Schools and an Assessment of Their Performance
4.4.1 The Whole School Training Program
During the first three years of the project teacher training modules were developed, as well as subject teaching modules for the English, civics and mathematics. Facilitators were trained to deliver these modules and used them to train the partner schools in each of the 44 project districts, which joined the project in two cohorts in 2006 and 2007.
From the beginning of 2009 DBE3 focused primarily on a more intensive program in formal junior secondary schools, SMP and MTs intitally in 25 “extension” districts from existing cohort 1 and 2 districts in which to implement a more in-depth DBE3 school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement. The program included:
• An increase in the number of directly supported schools in each of the extension districts, in most cases from four to ten, in order to create a greater presence and critical mass;
• The implementation of a school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement which involves training teachers of all core subjects, school principals and other senior management staff in partner schools.
The whole school program was later extended to the remaining 19 ‘core’ districts in late 2009 but without the selection of additional partner schools in those districts.
Below is a list of partner schools that took part in the whole school training program. The original cohort 1 and 2 schools are indicated in the list by pink shading, while the additional schools in the 25 extension districts, which joined the project in 2009 are left unshaded.
4.4.2 How the Partner School Assessment was Done
DBE3 undertook an evaluation of these schools which was completed in August 2011. An instrument was developed to assess which schools are implementing DBE3 innovations well and are worth visiting. The instrument evaluated 4 key areas of the school performance:
• Teacher Activities: To what degree the teachers encourage interaction among students provide challenging and varied tasks (discussion, experimentation, problem solving) and use formative assessment techniques.
• Student Activities: To what degree the student activities vary (working cooperatively, solving
problems, experimenting), they express their own thoughts orally and in writing and use a variety of media in their lessons.
• Classroom Environment: To what degree the students in the school sit, work and interact in
groups, work is displayed on the wall and if they learn using more diverse sources (media, environment)
• Principal Leadership: To what degree the Principal in the school encourags change, supports
the professional development of teachers and supports other innovations in the school
Following the evaluation, each school was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest. A ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little or no impact.
3 2 1 0
Category
Schools implementing the results of the DBE3 program well and widely, and there is a strong recommendation to visit.
Schools applying DBE3 results well in some classes but not widely there is encouragement to visit
The application of the results of the DBE3 program is limited and there is no encouragemet to visit.
There are no visible results of the DBE3 program.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
90
4.4.3 List of Training Received
The data for the partner schools in Central Java including the results of the assessment are set out on the next page. It also indicates the training packages which have been received by each school and are indicated by A, B, C and D as set out in the table below.
A: Cohort 1 District Schools B: Cohort 2 District Schools
Life Skills Program (2005 – 2009)
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
School Retention Toolkit
A* also included Mathematics module
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
B* also included Mathematics Module
C: Extension District Schools D: Core Districts Schools
Whole School Approach (2009 – 2011)
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
How to Use ICT in BTL
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
91
4.4.4 List of DBE Partner Schools in Central Java and an Assessment of their Performance
The original partner schools which participated in the project before the expansion to ten schools in each extension district are highlighted in pink.
CENTRAL JAVA
Extension Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Traning Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 2 Cepogo SMP State Cepogo Boyolali A & C 124 158 282 12 8 20 ***
2 SMP N 2 Musuk SMP State Musuk Boyolali C 182 188 370 12 15 27 ***
3 SMP N 2 Ngemplak SMP State Ngemplak Boyolali A & C 325 328 653 21 20 41 **
4 SMP N 2 Selo SMP State Selo Boyolali C 102 100 202 13 8 21 *
5 SMP N 2 Karanggede SMP State Karanggede Boyolali C 160 165 325 15 8 23 **
6 MTs N Cepogo MTs State Cepogo Boyolali A & C 268 262 530 20 19 39 ***
7 MTs N Ngemplak MTs State Ngemplak Boyolali A & C 349 343 692 27 28 55 ***
8 MTs N Nogosari MTs State Nogosari Boyolali C 231 242 473 32 34 66 **
9 MTs N Karanggede MTs State Karanggede Boyolali C 172 144 316 21 9 30 *
10 MTs Miftahul Ulum Klego MTs Private Klego Boyolali C 167 152 319 12 8 20 *
11 MTs. NU Hasyim Asyari 3 MTs Private Jekulo Kudus C 206 254 460 20 12 32 ***
12 SMP N 2 Jekulo SMP State Jekulo Kudus C 366 352 718 19 19 38 ***
13 MTs N 02 Kudus MTs State Mejobo Kudus C 426 385 811 18 37 55 ***
14 SMP PGRI SMP Private Jati Kudus C 151 111 262 11 15 26 **
15 MTs. NU Miftahul Ulum MTs Private Jati Kudus C 166 146 312 10 16 26 **
16 SMP N 2 Undaan SMP State Undaan Kudus C 321 368 689 13 15 28 **
17 SMP N 1 Gebog SMP State Gebog Kudus A & C 309 393 702 21 20 41 **
18 SMP N 2 Kaliwungu SMP State Kaliwungu Kudus A & C 336 339 675 22 21 43 **
19 MTs. NU Al-Hidayah MTs Private Gebog Kudus A & C 261 318 579 25 7 32 **
20 MTs N 1 Kudus MTs State Kaliwungu Kudus A & C 383 495 878 33 28 61 **
21 SMP N 1 Kebakkramat SMP State Kebakkramat Karanganyar C 245 345 590 16 24 40 **
22 SMP N 1 Tasikmadu SMP State Tasikmadu Karanganyar C 306 403 709 17 27 44 **
23 SMP N 2 Jatipuro SMP State Jatipuro Karanganyar A* & C 136 121 257 13 21 34 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
92
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Traning Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
24 SMP N 2 Karangpandan SMP State Karangpandan Karanganyar C 265 304 569 24 24 48 *
25 SMP N 3 Colomadu SMP State Colomadu Karanganyar C 390 525 915 20 29 49 ***
26 SMP N 3 Karanganyar SMP State Karanganyar Karanganyar A* & C 422 408 830 31 30 61 ***
27 MTs N Karanganyar MTs State Karanganyar Karanganyar A* & C 451 457 908 25 17 42 **
28 MTs N Karangmojo MTs State Tasikmadu Karanganyar C 346 293 639 26 17 43 **
29 MTs N Jumapolo MTs State Jumapolo Karanganyar A* & C 133 131 264 18 12 30 *
30 MTs N Gondangrejo MTs State Gondangrejo Karanganyar C 368 477 845 35 22 57 **
31 MTs An Nawawi 01 Berjan MTs Private Gebang Purworejo B & C 201 188 389 28 26 54 *
32 MTs N Bener MTs State Bener Purworejo C 362 403 765 20 23 43 **
33 MTs N Purworejo MTs State Purworejo Purworejo C 330 335 665 18 29 47 **
34 SMP N 10 Purworejo SMP State Grabag Purworejo C 386 367 753 14 24 38 **
35 SMP N 15 Purworejo SMP State Banyuurip Purworejo C 214 264 478 16 18 34 **
36 SMP N 19 Purworejo SMP State Bener Purworejo B & C 261 303 564 18 17 35 ***
37 SMP N 22 Purworejo SMP State Gebang Purworejo B & C 378 284 662 20 24 44 *
38 SMP N 23 Purworejo SMP State Bayan Purworejo C 261 314 575 15 21 36 **
39 SMP N 30 Purworejo SMP State Ngombol Purworejo C 330 243 573 17 20 37 **
40 MTs Ma'arif NU Sidomukti MTs Private Bener Purworejo B & C 112 128 240 5 11 16 ***
41 SMP Negeri 1 Grobogan SMP State Grobogan Grobogan B & C 538 604 1.142 25 35 60 *
42 SMPN 2 Tawangharjo SMP State Tawangharjo Grobogan B & C 179 167 346 14 9 23 -
43 SMPN 1 Toroh SMP State Toroh Grobogan C 441 439 880 22 23 45 *
44 SMPN 2 Karangrayung SMP State Karangrayung Grobogan C 429 385 814 26 13 39 **
45 SMPN 2 Kradenan SMP State Kradenan Grobogan C 292 267 559 16 16 32 ***
46 MTs Yarobi Grobogan MTs Private Grobogan Grobogan B & C 129 152 281 8 7 15 **
47 MTs Nuril Huda Tawangharjo MTs Private Tawangharjo Grobogan B & C 248 238 486 23 16 39 *
48 MTs Al Hidayah Toroh MTs Private Toroh Grobogan C 209 197 406 19 8 27 -
49 MTs N Jeketro MTs State Gubug Grobogan C 354 496 850 30 19 49 ***
50 MTs N Wirosari MTs State Wirosari Grobogan C 317 335 652 21 17 38 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
93
CENTRAL JAVA
Core Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Traning Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 1 Wonosalam SMP State Wonosalam Demak B & D 340 289 629 24 14 38 ** 2 MTs NU Jogoloyo MTs Private Wonosalam Demak B & D 299 303 602 19 12 31 * 3 MTs NU Demak MTs Private Demak Demak B & D 239 241 480 15 10 25 * 4 SMP N 5 Demak SMP State Demak Demak B & D 365 326 691 16 31 47 *
5 SMP N 5 Blora SMP State Blora Blora B & D 396 322 718 14 26 40 - 6 SMP N 1 Banjarejo SMP State Banjarejo Blora B & D 351 340 691 17 14 31 * 7 MTs Ma'arif 2 Blora MTs Private Blora Blora B & D 129 169 298 11 7 18 - 8 MTs Miftahul Ilmiyah MTs Private Blora Blora B & D 235 230 465 17 11 28 *
9 SMP N 1 Tahunan SMP State Tahunan Jepara A & D 353 297 650 20 18 38 -
10 SMP NU Assalam Nalumsari SMP Private Nalumsari Jepara A & D 97 99 196 13 9 22 -
11 SMP N 1 Mayong SMP State Mayong Jepara A & D 377 450 827 25 28 53 *
12 MTs Masalikil Huda Tahunan MTs Private Tahunan Jepara A & D 189 167 356 17 7 24 *
13 MTs Ismailiyyah Nalumsari MTs Private Nalumsari Jepara A & D 241 274 515 15 9 24 -
14 SMP Pancasila SMP Private Ceper Klaten B & D 68 57 125 15 7 22 *
15 SMP N 1 Ceper SMP State Ceper Klaten B & D 330 326 656 18 35 53 *
16 MTs Al Muttaqien MTs Private Karanganom Klaten B & D 52 53 105 12 8 20 *
17 SMP N 4 Karanganom SMP State Karanganom Klaten B & D 385 322 707 22 31 53 *
18 SMP N 2 Jogonalan SMP State Jogonalan Klaten A & D 253 243 496 14 19 33 *
19 MTs N Klaten MTs State Klaten Utara Klaten A & D 340 375 715 28 32 60 *
20 SMP N 6 Klaten SMP State Klaten Utara Klaten A & D 382 327 709 28 31 59 -
21 SMP Muhammadiyah 11 SMP Private Jogonalan Klaten A & D 60 55 115 9 6 15 -
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
94
4.5 District Facilitators / Performance Assessment
4.5.1 List of District Facilitators for Non Formal Education in Central Java
Below is a list of facilitators from Central Java trained to support the Non-Formal Education program.
Name Position District Subject
Tri Mulyani,S.Pd Staf PLS Boyolali Management
Drs.Mukhson Staf Pekapontren Boyolali Teaching and Learning
Dra.Umi Lestari Pembantu Pimpinan Klaten Management
Drs.Bakri,M.Pd Staf PeNamat Pekapontren Klaten Teaching and Learning
Muh.Rusdiyanti,SE,S.Pd.I Staf Subag TU Umum Karangangyar Management
Drs.Jumiran Kasi Sarana Prasarana Dikluseporabud Karangangyar Teaching and Learning
Drs.Mustaqim Staf Pekapontren Jepara Teaching and Learning
Muryanto,S.Pd Penilik PLS Jepara Management
Mustikah,S.Pd Staf Dikmas Kudus Management
Moh.Fathoni,S.Ag Pengamat TK/SD Kudus Teaching and Learning
Amin Susanto, SE TLD Dinas P&K Grobogan Grobogan Management
Abdur Rouf, M.SI Depag Grobogan Grobogan Teaching and Learning
Suhartutik, S.Pd Guru SMPN 3 Jiken Blora Management
Bambang Sutiyono, S.Pd Penilik PLS Diknas Blora Blora Teaching and Learning
Fatkhurahman, S.Ag Staff Depag Kab. Demak Demak Management
Aunur Rofiq SKB Demak Demak Teaching and Learning
Zulfah Kirom, S.Ag Depag Purworejo Management
Yulius Marmo, S.Pd Dinas P & K Purworejo Teaching and Learning
Drs.Bakri, M.Pd Staff Pekapontren Depag Kab. Klaten Klaten Management
Dra. Umi Lestari Staff Seksi Dikmas Klaten Teaching and Learning
4.5.2 List of District Facilitators for the Life Skills Training Program in Central Java 2006 – 2008
Below is a list of facilitators from Central Java trained to implement the Life Skills program.
Name Position Module District Institution
Jati Susetyono, S.Pd Teacher Civic Jepara SMPN 1 Tahunan
Zainal Abidin, S.Pd Teacher Civic Jepara SMPN 2 Mloggo
Drs.Baidlowi Teacher Civic Jepara MTsN Bawu
Agus Adib Lutfi, S.Pd Teacher English Jepara SMPN 1 Jepara
Budi Murjiyanto,S.Pd Teacher English Jepara SMPN 3 Jepara
Edi Budi Sulistiyono, S.Pd Teacher English Jepara SMPN 2 Pecangaan
Drs. Fathul Huda Teacher BTL Jepara MTs Tsafinatul Huda
Jamal Lutfi, S. Fil. I BTL Jepara MP3A-MDC Prop. Jawa Tengah
Drs. Muhammad Heru Cahyo Teacher Life Skills Jepara MTsN Bawu
Nurhadi, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Jepara SMPN 1 Tahunan
Ririn Maryati, S.Pd, ST Teacher ICT Jepara SMPN 4 Keling
Ahmad Zainuddin, S.Ag ICT Jepara MP3A-MDC Prop. Jawa Tengah
Bambang Rahadi Priyatna, S.Pd Teacher Civic Kudus SMPN 2 Kaliwungu
Khumaedah, S.Pd Teacher Civic Kudus SMPN 1 Jati
Eko Widyastuti , S.Pd Teacher Civic Kudus SMPN 1 Kudus
M.Taufiq, S.Pd Principal English Kudus Kepala Sekolah SMPN 3 Dawe
Tumarno, S.Pd Teacher English Kudus SMPN 2 Kaliwungu
Chasnah, S.Pd Teacher English Kudus MTsN Kaliwungu
Suyono, S.IP, S.Pd Principal Mathematics Kudus KS.SMPN 1 Gebog
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
95
Name Position Module District Institution
Ali Maskur, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Kudus SMPN 2 Jati
Rodhi, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Kudus SMPN 1 Jekulo
Drs.Muhammad Halimi Supervisor BTL Kudus Pengawas PAI MTs Kabupaten
Sujoko Haryanto, S.Pd Supervisor BTL Kudus Pengawas SMP Kabupaten
Drs.Farhan Principal Life Skills Kudus Kepala Sekolah SMPN 2 Jekulo
Dra. Siti Zumaroh, M.Pd Supervisor Life Skills Kudus Pengawas MTs Kabupaten
Erlina Rachmawati, S.Pd, S.IP Staff ICT Kudus Staff Diknas Kab.Kudus, Bag.Perencanaan dan Evaluasi
Arief Imam Setyabudi, S.Pd Teacher ICT Kudus SMPN 1 Jati
Drs. Gunawan Teacher Civic Karangangyar MTsN Karanganyar
Sundarumaya, S.Pd Teacher Civic Karangangyar SMPN 3 Karanganyar
Sutiyono, S.Pd Teacher Civic Karangangyar SMPN 3 KebakkeraMathematics
Drs.Giyanto Teacher English Karangangyar SMPN 1 Karangpandan
Supartinah, S.Pd Teacher English Karangangyar SMPN 1 Karanganyar
Suprapti, S.Pd Teacher English Karangangyar SMPN 4 Karanganyar
Sabar Santoso, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Karangangyar SMPN 4 Karanganyar
Haryanto, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Karangangyar SMPN Ngargoyoso
Dra.Sri Lestari, M.Pd Teacher Mathematics Karangangyar SMPN 2 Mojogedang
Drs. Sutarno Supervisor BTL Karangangyar SMP Kabupaten
Drs.H.Mulyono, MM, Vice Principal BTL Karangangyar MTsN Karanganyar
Drs. Sutrisno,M.Hum Kasi
Pengembangan Profesi Guru
Life Skills Karangangyar Dikmen Kab
Drs.H.Abid Maksum,M.Ag Supervisor Life Skills Karangangyar PAI
Drs.Sukarmo Principal ICT Karangangyar SMPN 1 Jaten
Drs. Andang Muhammad Endro Birowo, M.Hum
Principal ICT Karangangyar SMPN 2 Mathematicsesih,Karanganyar
Agus Kristanto Teacher Civic Boyolali SMPN 3 Teras
F.Atok Dwiyono Teacher Civic Boyolali SMPN 2 Boyolali
Drs. G.J. Santosa Teacher Civic Boyolali SMPN 1 Boyolali
Solihuddin, S.Pd Teacher English Boyolali SMPN 1 Ampel
Hanik Shofia, S.Pd Teacher English Boyolali SMPN 2 Boyolali
Eka Pramana, S.Pd Teacher English Boyolali SMPN 1 Boyolali
Suharni, S.Pd Supervsior BTL Boyolali Kabupaten
Dahlan Muttaqin, S.Pd Teacher BTL Boyolali MTsN Boyolali
Dra.Eni Sulistyowati Supervisor Life Skills Boyolali Kabupaten
Nur Cholid, M.Ag Supervisor Life Skills Boyolali MP3A-MDC Prop. Jawa Tengah
Joko Hariyanto, ST Staff ICT Boyolali Dinas Pendidikan Kabupaten
Drs. Ahmadi Teacher ICT Boyolali MTsN Boyolali
Gunawan, S.Pd Teacher Civic Klaten SMPN 1 Karangnongko
Drs. Muhadi Teacher Civic Klaten MTsN Mlinjon
Sugiyono, S.Pd Teacher Civic Klaten SMPN 2 Bayat Klaten
Indah Ekiyanti Listiyaningsih, S.Ag. M.Ag
Teacher English Klaten MTsN Klaten
Rewang Agus Susilo, S.Pd Teacher English Klaten SMPN 3 Klaten
Yuwono, S.Pd, M.Pd Teacher English Klaten SMPN 1 Jogonalan
Sunarto, S.Pd Principal BTL Klaten SMPN 2 Jogonalan
Drs.Burhanuddin Supervisor BTL Klaten PAI MTs Kabupaten
Drs. Supardi Supervisor Life Skills Klaten SMP Kabupaten
Purwanta, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Klaten SMPN 3 Polanharjo
Drs. Sri Muladi Teacher ICT Klaten MTsN Mlinjon
Hatta A. Malik, S.Sos.I ICT Klaten MP3A-MDC Prop. Jawa Tengah
Puji Rahayu, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Klaten SMPN 2 Klaten
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
96
Name Position Module District Institution
Drs. Moh. Hajar Teacher Mathematics Klaten MTsN Klaten
Mohrondi, S.Pd Teacher Civic Grobogan SMPN 1 Pulokulon
M.M. Raswiratri, S.Pd Teacher Civic Grobogan SMPN 1 Penawangan
Suwardi, S.Pd., M.Pd Teacher Civic Grobogan SMPN 1 Gubug
Titiek Soertirahajoe, S.Pd Teacher English Grobogan SMPN 1 Grobogan
Saerozi, S.Pd Teacher English Grobogan SMPN 2 Toroh Grobogan
Fitria, S.Pd Teacher English Grobogan MTs. Yarobi Grobogan
Drs. H. Nurhuda Teacher BTL Grobogan SMPN 1 Grobogan
Ely Istyawati, S.Pd Teacher BTL Grobogan MTs. Nahdlatut Thullab Manggarwetan
H. Prajitno, S.Pd Supervisor Life Skills Grobogan Dinas P&K Kab. Grobogan
Na'im Mustofa S.H.I Teacher Life Skills Grobogan MTs. Nuril Huda Tarub
Bambang Rusmiyanto Supervisor ICT Grobogan Dinas P&K Kab. Grobogan
Drs. Nurcholis Teacher ICT Grobogan SMPN 1 Purwodadi
Sudarmanto, S.Pd Teacher Mathematics Grobogan MTsN Jeketro Kec. Gubug, Kab. Grobogan
Adi Waluyo, S.Pd Teacher Civic Blora SMPN 2 Jepon
Marsono, S.Pd Teacher Civic Blora MTsN Jepon
Ony Setyo Cahyono, S.Pd Teacher English Blora SMPN 1 Sambong
Moh. Mahmud, S.pd Teacher English Blora MTs. Khozinatul Ulum Blora
Fathul Himam, S.Ag Supervisor BTL Blora Depag Kab. Blora
Masturi, S.Pd Supervisor BTL Blora Diknas Blora
Kasriati, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Blora MTsN Jepon
Drs. Riyanto Teacher Life Skills Blora SMPN 1 Ngawen
Eko Adi Purwanto, S.Pd Teacher ICT Blora SMPN 6 Blora
Mohammad Sofwan W., S.Pd Teacher ICT Blora SMPN 3 Jiken
Dra. Sri TuICT Cahyaningsih Teacher Civic Demak SMPN 2 Sayung
Drs. Junaedi Teacher Civic Demak MTsN Karangawen
Sri Hartati Trainer Civic Demak LPMP Prov.
Akhmad Fauzi, S.Pd Principal Eng Demak SMPN 1 Karanganyar
Dra. Sri Hari Teacher Eng Demak SMPN 1 Karangtengah
Drs. Karsono, M.Pd Teacher BTL Demak MTsN Mranggen
Drs. H. Durachman, MM Teacher BTL Demak SMPN 3 Mranggen
Dra. Rr. Noer Indah Aprianti, M.Pd
Principal Life Skills Demak SMPN 1 Mranggen
Drs. Kasnawi, M.Ag Teacher Life Skills Demak MTsN Bonang
Drs. Bambang Sucipto Teacher ICT Demak SMKN 1 Demak
Drs. Edy Subkhan, M.M. Teacher ICT Demak SMKN 2 Demak
Supami, S.Pd Teacher Civic Purworejo SMPN 22 Purworejo
Enita Woro Hastuti, S.Pd Teacher Civic Purworejo MTsN Purworejo
Wardoyo, S.Pd Teacher Eng Purworejo SMPN 19 Purworejo
Marwiyah, S.Ag Teacher Eng Purworejo MTsN Purworejo
Drs. Subiyanto Supervisor BTL Purworejo Diknas
Mutmainah, S.Pd Teacher BTL Purworejo SMPN 9 Purworejo
Drs. H. Afandi Sunarno Supervisor Life Skills Purworejo PAI Depag
No'imah, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Purworejo SMPN 25 Purworejo
H. Achmad Hamid, S.Pd.I Supervisor ICT Purworejo Depag
Drs. Muhammad Yasin, M.Pd Supervisor ICT Purworejo Pengawas Diknas
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
97
4.5.3 The District Facilitators for the Whole School Program
In order to support the implementation of the whole school training program, more usually referred to as the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, district facilitators were selected in each district jointly by local government and DBE3 staff and trained by the project. There were originally 15 facilitators (3 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each extension district and 10 facilitators (2 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each core district. They have been trained to implement all or most of the BTL training modules. A number of the best facilitators from each province were also elevated to become national facilitators, which meant that they were trained in each module before the rest of the district facilitators and were then charged with implementing the training of the district facilitators. In their own districts they continued to act as district facilitators, supporting partner school and dissemination training, organizing MGMP activities and mentoring teachers after training. A list of the BTL facilitators operating as of August 2011 is included on the next page.
4.5.4 How the District Facilitator Performance Assessment was Done
In order to provide information on the effectiveness of these facilitators to those wishing to disseminate the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, DBE3 evaluated their performance using an instrument which focuses on a number of key areas:
• The extent to which the District Facilitator applies the training in their own work as a teacher, Principal or School Supervisor
• The extent to which the District Facilitator helps other teachers in their own school either as a teacher, Principal or Supervisor
• Their creativity in developing and implementing innovative training materials and approaches
• Their commitment as a District Facilitator for DBE3
• Their ability to relate to, communicate and interact with participants in the training and in mentoring
• Their initiative and ability to cooperate and support others District Facilitators during the training
• How effective they are as a mentor, whether they are able to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching and learning process and provide good feedback to teachers
Following the evaluation, each District Facilitator was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest.
3 2 1 0
Category
Very good, always works hard and is very able as a Facilitator
Good in general performance and ability as a Facilitator
Average, still needs to develop some skills as a Facilitator
Rarely works and not very able as a Facilitator
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
98
4.5.5 List of Facilitators in Central Java for the Whole School Training Program and Performance Assessment
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
CENTRAL JAVA
1 Ony Setyo Cahyono, S.Pd M Teacher B ING SMP N 1 Sambong Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 081228661911 [email protected] ** 2 Andreas Sutrasno, S.Pd M Principal B ING SMP N 2 Jiken Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 08122816169 [email protected] * 3 Muhammad Rokhim, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMP N 2 Menden Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 081325563058 - ** 4 Drs. Hariyanto M Teacher B. Ind SMP N 1 Blora Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 081326560134 - * 5 M. Sofwan Wiryoputro, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMP N 3 Jiken Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 08157610890 [email protected] ** 6 Tri Handayani, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMP N 5 Blora Partner Blora Central Java HP. 081326502963 - *
7 Eko Adi Purwanto, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMP N 6 Blora Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 081325013402 [email protected]/[email protected]
**
8 Drs. Sunarji Effendi, M.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMP N 3 Blora Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 085290451917 [email protected] * 9 Endang Sri Wahyuni, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMP N 3 Tunjungan Non Partner Blora Central Java HP. 081325237702 - * 10 Misri Prihatin, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMP N 6 Blora Non Partner Blora Central Java HP : 081325715611 - * 11 Hanik Shofia, S.Pd F Principal English SMP N 2 Ngemplak Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 0813 932 35230 [email protected] *** 12 Solihudin, S.Pd M Teacher English SMP N 1 Ampel Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 0813 291 06948 ***
13 Eka Pramana, S.Pd M Teacher English SMP N 1 Boyolali Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 0813 290 75138, Home: 0276-325213
14 Muh.Zuhri,S.Pd,M.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMA N 1 Nogosari Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 08112700172 [email protected] *** 15 Drs. Heru Purwanta, S.Si. M Principal B. Ind SMP N 2 Banyudono Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081329204562 [email protected] ** 16
Endah Mustaqimah,S.Pd,M.Hum
F Teacher B. Ind SMP N 2 Sawit Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 08121509344 [email protected] ** 17 Dra Retna Palupi F Teacher Science SMP N 2 Cepogo Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 08562818596 [email protected] *** 18 Siyamto Budi S,S.Pd M Teacher Science SMP N 2 Teras Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 08156714075 [email protected] ** 19 Dra Wiwik Radyuni F Teacher Science SMP N 1 Musuk Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081329295767 [email protected] * 20 Wasino,S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMP N 5 Boyolali Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081329070903 [email protected] *** 21 Jono Trimanto,M.Pd M Principal Social S. SMP N 2 Cepogo Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081328290510 [email protected] ***
22 Yusmin Aji Joko Sambudi,S.Pd
M Teacher Social S. SMP N 2 Banyudono Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081548791550 [email protected] **
23 Dra Sri Supanti Nur Hayati ,M.Pd
F Principal Math SMP N 6 Boyolali Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081329139878 [email protected] ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
99
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
24 Muhammad Amin,S.Pd M Teacher Math MTs N Cepogo Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 085642346878 [email protected] ** 25 Drs Sartono,M.Pd M Teacher Math SMP N 1 Sawit Non Partner Boyolali Central Java HP : 081329050120 [email protected] *
26 Drs. Karsono, M.Pd. M Principal Ind MTs SA Karanganyar Demak
Non Partner Demak Central Java 0888 655 6976 ***
27 Sugeng Riyadi, S.Pd, M.H M Principal Ind SMPN 1 Wonosalam Partner Demak Central Java 081 325 167 387 ** 28 Akhmad Fauzi, S.Pd M Principal Ing SMPN 1 Karangtengah Non Partner Demak Central Java 081 328 173 246 [email protected] *** 29 Dra. Sri Hari F Teacher Ing SMPN 2 Karangtengah Non Partner Demak Central Java 0815 766 4331 *** 30 Agustuti Naningsih, S.Pd. F Teacher Science MTsN Karangtengah Non Partner Demak Central Java 0811 270 5268 ** 31 Eka Purjiyanta, S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Demak Non Partner Demak Central Java 081 225 10040 [email protected] ** 32 Karsidi, S.Pd, M.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Demak Non Partner Demak Central Java 0811 270 9807 ** 33 Sudadi, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. MTsN Karangtengah Non Partner Demak Central Java 081 390 219 996 **
34 Muhammad Shofyan, M.Pd., M.Sc
M Teacher Math MTsN Gajah Non Partner Demak Central Java 081 325 402 044 [email protected] ***
35 Purwadi, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Demak Non Partner Demak Central Java 081 575 399 627 ** 36 H. Saerozi, S. Pd M Principal English SMPN 3 Tegowanu Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 08122551478 [email protected] *** 37 Titiek Soetirahajoe, S. Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Grobogan Partner Grobogan Central Java 081326466116 [email protected] *** 38 Ali Mahsun, S. Ag, S. Pd M Teacher English MTsN Jeketro Partner Grobogan Central Java 08112703903 [email protected] * 39 Haryanto, S. Pd, M. Pd M Principal B. Ind SMPN 2 Karangrayung Partner Grobogan Central Java 081326472940 [email protected] *** 40 Dra. Dwi Dayaning Rahayu F Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Pendidikan Grobogan Central Java 081325635830 [email protected] *** 41 Muhammad Safi'i, S. Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Pulokulon Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 081390770780 [email protected] *** 42 Eddy Widodo, S. Pd, M. Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Klambu Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 081325648534 [email protected] *** 43 Nur Cholis, S. Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Purwodadi Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 085290612715 [email protected] *** 44 Harmani, S. Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Godong Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 081325796773 [email protected] *** 45 Agus Suprapto, S. Pd, MM M Principal Social S. SMPN 2 Kradenan Partner Grobogan Central Java 081325669014 [email protected] *** 46 Gati Wibowo, SE, MM M Principal Social S. SMPN 2 Grobogan Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 081325393341 [email protected] *** 47 Drs. Sadali M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Purwodadi Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 085225020927 [email protected] *** 48 Basuki Nugroho, S. Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Wirosari Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 085225269919 [email protected] *** 49 Sudarmanto, S. Pd M Teacher Math MTsN Jeketro Partner Grobogan Central Java 081326780040 [email protected] ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
100
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
50 Yadi Suyanto, S. Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Purwodadi Non Partner Grobogan Central Java 085641272749 [email protected] *** 51 Budi Murjiyanto, S.Pd M Teacher B ING SMP 3 Jepara Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 081325441747 [email protected] ** 52 Edi Budi S., S.Pd M Teacher B ING SMP 2 Pecangaan Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 085225728873 [email protected] ** 53 Agus Adib Lutfi, S.Pd M Teacher English SMP 1 Jepara Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP : 081325611261 [email protected] *** 54 Rofi'I, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMP 1 Mayong Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 081225751108 [email protected] *** 55 Ah. Nurul Huda, S.Ag, S.Pd F KM B. Ind MTs Amal Muslimin Bate Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 08122913094 [email protected] *** 56 Nurhadi, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMP 1 Tahunan Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 081325734000 [email protected] ** 57 Syarif Ghufron, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMP 1 Batealit Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 081325544950 [email protected] ** 58 Mohammad Sifak, M.Pd F Principal Social S. SMP N 1 Kedung Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 08122571620 [email protected] *** 59 Roudlotul Farida, S.E F Teacher Social S. MTsN Bawu Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 085715099261 [email protected] * 60 Soepartono, M.Pd M Teacher Math SMP 5 Jepara Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 08122922427 [email protected] ** 61 Basuki, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMp 2 Jepara Non Partner Jepara Central Java HP. 081225221849 [email protected] - 62 Drs. Giyanto, M.Pd M Teacher English SMP N 1 Karangpandan Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081329317113 [email protected] *** 63 Supartinah, S.Pd F Teacher English SMP N 1 Karanganyar Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081329016737 [email protected] *** 64 Suprapti, S.Pd F Teacher English SMP N 4 Karanganyar Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081393114817 [email protected] ** 65
Dra. Endang Wuryandari, M.Pd
F Principal B. Ind SMP N 2 Tawangmangu Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081329054838 [email protected] *** 66 Dr. Nuning Hidayah Sunani F Supervisor B. Ind Pengawas Disdikpora Partner Karanganyar Central Java 08122607841 [email protected] *** 67 Sulasdi, S.Pd.,MM M Teacher B. Ind SMP N 3 Karanganyar Partner Karanganyar Central Java 08122978121 [email protected] ** 68 Wartanto, M.Pd M Teacher Science MTs N Gondangrejo Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081548717865 [email protected] *** 69 Drs. Tukimin M Teacher Science MTs N Karanganyar Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081393004249 [email protected] ** 70
Drs. Andang Muh Endro Birowo, M.Hum
M Supervisor Science Pengawas Disdikpora Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081548613299 [email protected] ** 71 Hermawan, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. MTs N Karanganyar Partner Karanganyar Central Java 085238334141 [email protected] ** 72 Slamet Kusmanto, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMP N 3 Karanganyar Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081329002945 [email protected] ** 73 Drs. Eko Sarjono M Teacher Social S. SMP N 3 Kebakkramat Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 081329188397 [email protected] - 74 Dra. Sri Lestari, M.Pd F Principal Math SMP Angkasa Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 0817442788 [email protected] *** 75 Sabar Santoso, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMP N 4 Karanganyar Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 085725102113 [email protected] **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
101
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
76 Haryanto, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMP N 1 Karanganyar Non Partner Karanganyar Central Java 0818253116 [email protected] * 77
Indah Eki Listyaningsih, S.Ag., M.Pd
F Teacher English MTsN Klaten Partner Klaten Central Java 081329183754 [email protected] **
78 Rewang Agus Susilo, S.Pd., M.Pd
M Teacher English SMPN 3 Klaten Non Partner Klaten Central Java 08122 6128164 *
79 Purwanta, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 3 Polanharjo Non Partner Klaten Central Java 08156804642 *
80 Sri Soelistya K F Teacher English SMP Muhammadiyah 11 Jogonalan
Non Partner Klaten Central Java 085642496709 *
81 Resmiyati, S.Pd., M.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMA 1 Klaten Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081328143762 [email protected] ** 82 Soedarto, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMP Pancasila Partner Klaten Central Java 08564 7356052 * 83 Budi Sutrisna, S,Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Polanharjo Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081329335279 * 84 Ponimin, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Kemalang Non Partner Klaten Central Java 085229079995 - 85 Subroto, S.Pd., M.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Jatinom Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081329504199 [email protected] ** 86 Drs. Wasis M Teacher Science SMPN 3 Klaten Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081329076390 [email protected] * 87 Pujiyanto, S.Pd., M.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 6 Klaten Partner Klaten Central Java 08112630967 * 88 Triyanto, S.Pd., M.Pd M Principal Science SMPN 3 Karangdowo Non Partner Klaten Central Java 0815 67971 955 * 89 Dra. Lies Yuni Haryanti F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Klaten Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081328641434 [email protected] * 90
Widodo Indriyanto, S.Pd., M.Pd
M Principal Social S. SMPN 2 Kemalang Non Partner Klaten Central Java 08121579417 * 91 Wiyana, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Karanganom Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081227227504 * 92
Drs. Bambang Agus Tranggono
M Teacher Social S. MTsN Mlinjon Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081794 75600 * 93 Amirudin, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 3 Karanganom Non Partner Klaten Central Java 08564 7356052 * 94 Puji Rahayu, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 2 Klaten Non Partner Klaten Central Java 085729388378 [email protected] * 95 Drs. Catur Widodo, M.M. M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Kemalang Non Partner Klaten Central Java 081578 095858 * 96 Drs. Moh. Hajar M Teacher Math MTsN Klaten Partner Klaten Central Java 085867519401 * 97 Chasnah, S.Pd. F Teacher English Guru MTsN Kaliwungu Partner Kudus Central Java
08156601765 / 085641733737
98 Drs. H. Farhan M Principal English Kepala Sekolah SMPN 1 Jekulo
Non Partner Kudus Central Java HP :08158921449 [email protected] ***
99 M. Taufiq, S.Pd. M Principal English Kepala Sekolah SMPN 3 Dawe
Non Partner Kudus Central Java 0291-3316346 [email protected] *** 100 Ahmad Shofya Edi, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMP N 2 Kaliwungu Partner Kudus Central Java O8156590371 [email protected] ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
102
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
101 Pujito, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMP N 2 Jekulo Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 081 325 218 812 [email protected] [email protected]
***
102 Salim, S.Ag. M Teacher B. Ind MTs. NU Tasywiquth Thullab Salafiyah
Non Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 085740186250 [email protected] ***
103 Triastuti Evawani, S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMP N 2 Undaan Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 081326442205 [email protected] [email protected]
***
104 Abdul Rochim, S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMP N 1 Kudus Non Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 081575244068 [email protected] ***
105 Sri Endang Nur Fathonah, S.P., S.Pd., M.Si.
F Teacher Science MTs N Kaliwungu Partner Kudus Central Java 0291-442646/ 081390272540
106 Hartadi, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMP N 5 Kudus Non Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 08157605084 [email protected] *** 107 Dra. Noor Hidayah F Teacher Social S. SMP N 1 Bae Non Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 081325205789 [email protected] ***
108 Yukhah, S.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMP N 1 Kaliwungu Non Partner Kudus Central Java 0291-4248156 08156609423
109 Rodhi, S.Pd. M Teacher Math Guru SMPN 1 Jekulo Non Partner Kudus Central Java HP : 08122556881 [email protected] *** 110 Mukhif Noor, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMP 2 Undaan Partner Kudus Central Java O811270576 [email protected] *** 111 Suyono M Teacher Math SMP 2 Kudus Non Partner Kudus Central Java 8566746533 ** 112 Mutmainah,S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 25 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 085292105405 [email protected] *** 113 Drs. M.Djamal,M.Pd. M Supervisor English Dinas P&K Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 081328287356 [email protected] ** 114 Drs. Bambang Susilo M Teacher English SMPN 2 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 081578741245 [email protected] ** 115 Sangkan,S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 24 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 081328723509 [email protected] ***
116 Menuk Suprihatin,S.Pd. F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 0275-642705/ 081328204036
117 Drs. H. Muh. Yasin,M.Pd. M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas P&K Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 081328017803 [email protected] ** 118 Tri Rahayu,S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 23 Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 085228131611 *** 119 Drs. Budi Arwanto M Teacher Science SMPN 18 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 085292566219 *** 120 Gemi Nastiti,S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMPN 28 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 08122731821 [email protected] *** 121 Drs. Kukuh Ujianto,M.Pd. M Supervisor Science Dinas P&K Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 081328751407 [email protected] ** 122 Drs. Sunaryo,M.Pd. M Supervisor Social S. Dinas P&K Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java
08112503503/0275-756339
123 Drs. H.M.Agus Wiwoho Suryo,M.M.Pd.
M Principal Social S. SMPN 8 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 081392528727 [email protected] ***
124 Latifaturrohmah,S.Pd. F Teacher Social S. MTs An Nawawi 01 Berjan Partner Purworejo Central Java 081227629733 [email protected] ** 125 Kusnan Kadari,S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 15 Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 085292779155 [email protected] *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
103
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
126 Nurdiyani,S.Pd. F Teacher MathH SMPN 13 Pwr Non Partner Purworejo Central Java 081328160724 *** 127 Drs. Supadi Abdul Tohir,MM. M Teacher MathH SMPN 30 Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 081392220035 ** 128 Amin Taukhid,S.Pd. M Teacher MathH SMPN 10 Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 081329670703 **
129 Drs. Subiyanto M Supervisor MathH Dinas P&K Pwr Partner Purworejo Central Java 08172825112/0275-
325409 [email protected] *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
104
4.6 Working with Teacher Training Institutions and LPMP
To achieve wider impact beyond the target districts and to support improvement across the (junior secondary) education system, DBE3 worked with staff from the State University of Semarang, IAIN Walisongo and the Central Java Quality Assurance Institute (LPMP). Staff of these institutions took part in the provincial BTL training programs including the training of facilitators and training of teachers. selected lecturers also participated in the classroom action research program.
In year 6, DBE3 planned and implemented a pilot program with the State University of Semarang to encourage them to adopt and make use of some of the key project programs, and approaches with a view to improving the quality of both their pre- and in-service teacher training courses. The pilot program is described in section ?? of the main report.
Details of staff from the University and LPMP taking part in various DBE3 activities are presented below:
4.6.1 Number of Staff from Universities and LPMP taking part in DBE3 training and CAR activities
Province Better
Teaching and Learning
Classroom Action
Research Pilot Program Total
Central Java 21 5 30 26
4.6.2 Universities taking part in Classroom Action Research Review Meeting
A number of other universities from Central Java also took part in the Classroom Action Research Review Meeting in September 2011 and expressed an interest in using the materials and being involved in future program. These were as follows:
• Universitas Negeri Semarang
• IAIN Walisongo
• Universitas Negeri 11 Maret, Solo
• Universitas Muhammadiyah, Solo
• Universitas Kristen Satyawacana, Salatiga
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
105
4.7 Overview of Trainee Data
4.7.1 Non Formal Education Managers Trained by District in Central Java
Below is a list of the number of non formal education managers by district from Central Java trained on the Non-Formal Education program.
District Managers
Male Female Total
Jepara 9 0 9
Kudus 7 2 9
Klaten 1 8 0 8
Karanganyar 4 0 4
Boyolali 6 1 7
Demak 8 0 8
Grobogan 6 2 8
Blora 6 2 8
Klaten 2 5 3 8
Purworejo 7 1 7
Total 66 11 76
4.7.2 Non Formal Education Tutors Trained By District in Central Java
Below is a list of the numbers of tutors from district in Central Java trained to implement the Non-Formal Education program.
District # Tutors
Male Female Total
Jepara 3 6 9
Kudus 2 6 8
Klaten 1 2 6 8
Karanganyar 1 3 4
Boyolali 2 4 6
Demak 6 2 8
Grobogan 8 3 11
Blora 5 3 8
Klaten 2 5 3 8
Purworejo 6 3 9
Total 40 39 79
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
106
4.7.3 Number of Teachers in Central Java Trained Using the Life Skills Training Program
Below is a list showing the number of teachers in each district in Central Java by District, Gender and School Type trained between 2006 and 2008 to implement the Life Skills training program.
District
SMP MTs Total
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Boyolali 22 22 44 40 81 121 62 103 165
Jepara 36 40 76 35 13 48 71 53 124
Karanganyar 46 41 87 48 29 77 94 70 164
Klaten 1 47 57 103 25 38 63 72 95 167
Kudus 39 43 83 65 30 95 104 73 455
Blora 37 30 67 29 17 46 66 47 113
Demak 32 49 81 29 23 52 61 72 133
Grobogan 35 38 73 35 10 45 69 48 117
Klaten 2 60 74 134 18 13 31 78 87 165
Purworejo 25 16 41 50 19 69 75 35 110
Total 379 410 789 374 273 647 752 683 1435
4.7.4 Facilitators Trained in the BTL packages
Below is a list of the numbers of participants in the District Facilitator training for the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) modules. The training included district facilitators and a number of others, mainly lecturers from teacher training universities and trainers from LPMPs.
All Districts
Participants
District Facilitators
Others Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 124 23 147
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 124 68 192
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 115 55 170
4.7.5 Number of Teachers, School Principals and Supervisors Trained in BTL Program
Below is a list of the numbers of teachers, school principals and school supervisors from or associated with partner schools trained in the BTL program. The number of school principals and supervisors trained in BTL4 appears to be fewer. This is a result of receiving separate training to support the BTL4 program and the BTL4 package being delivered through the MGMP (Teachers Working Groups), which are teacher specific organization, which school principals and supervisors do not normally attend.
All Districts Participants
Teachers Principals Supervisors Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 901 36 14 951
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 1013 90 57 1160
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 1057 85 45 1187
Additional School Supervisors Trained - 101 - -
The numbers of facilitators, teachers, school principals and supervisors shown as participcating in the BTL training in the tables above should not be aggregated, as they were largely the same people participating in each package of training.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
107
4.8 Dissemination of DBE3 programs
A core strategy of the DBE3 project was to develop exemplars of good practice in the partner schools and districts with the “specific intent” that these would be taken up and implemented by others to additional schools and geographical areas. Below is a summary of the dissemination of DBE3 programs in Central Java by province and then by district. For more details of the dissemination program and activities see Volume 1, section ?? of this report.
4.8.1 Provincial Overview of Dissemination in Central Java
Province Total # Schools
Total # Participants
Average # of Participants
Per Institution
Partner Districts
Disseminating
Non Partner Districts
Disseminating
Total Dissemination Budget (US$)
Contribution from Local
Partner (US$)
Local Contribution as a % of total budget spent
Average Cost per Trainee (US$)
Central Java 1,692 16,254 9.6 9 11 514,648 407,949 79% 32
DBE3 Project 6,440 50,179 7.7 41 42 1,738,860 1,359,279 78% 35.1
% of Project Total 26.2 32.3% 21.9% 26.1% 29.5% 30%
4.8.2 Dissemination by District in Central Java
PARTNER DISTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Blora 140 4 136 67 97.10% 100%
Demak 197 4 193 197 97.90% 100%
Klaten 142 8 21 29 14.70% 20.40%
Jepara 179 4 175 179 97.70% 100%
Boyolali 137 10 127 137 92.70% 100%
Grobogan 224 10 189 199 84.30% 88.80%
Purworejo 121 10 111 121 91.70% 100%
Karanganyar 102 10 64 74 62.70% 72.50%
Kudus 114 10 110 114 96.40% 100%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
108
NON-PARTNER DISTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Sukoharjo 82 0 1 1 1.20% 1.20%
Yogyakarta 65 0 30 30 46.00% 46.00%
Pekalongan 124 0 67 67 54.30% 54.30%
Magelang 213 0 13 13 6.10% 6.10%
Gunung Kidul 141 0 68 68 48.20% 48.20%
Batang 101 0 3 3 2.90% 2.90%
Bantul 118 0 74 74 62.70% 62.70%
Sleman 126 0 2 2 1.50% 1.50%
Kulon Progo 78 0 33 33 42.30% 42.30%
Sragen 125 0 23 23 18.40% 18.40%
Wonogiri 140 0 12 12 8.50% 8.50%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
109
4.8.3 The Impact of Dissemination
The dissemination training in schools had some positive impact. When compared to the DBE3 comparison schools the dissemination schools did considerably better on all DBE3 teaching and learning indicators (with the exception of Instructional Leadership). However, the impact on teaching and learning in dissemination schools was not as significant as that on impact on partner schools suggesting that whilst dissemination training is beneficial, direct assistance achieves better results.
4.8.4 Chart: A comparison of the Impact of DBE3 in Partner, Dissemination and Comparison Schools in Central Java
4.8.5 List of District Contributions to Dissemination of DBE3 Program
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Boyolali 14,000,000 1,579
Grobogan 108,000,000 12,182
Pekalongan 8,000,000 902
Jepara 100,000,000 11,280
Total 230,000,000 25,943
4.8.6 Contributions to District Dissemination of DBE3 Innovations from MORA Budget
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Kudus 38,398,172 4,331 Demak 12,125,000 1,367 Grobogan 108,000,000 12,182 Blora 3,857,000 435 Jepara 1,500,000 162 Total 163,880,172 18,477
50
98.4
10.5
83.3
98.4
5.3
66.67
92.06
5.3
14.3
56
5.3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Te achers' Ski lls Student Behavior Classroom
Envi ronme nt
Pri ncipal
Leadership
Disse mi nation Schools
Partne r School s
Comparison School s
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
110
4.9 Review of the Extension District Development Plans and Their Implementation
Towards the end of 2010 all partner extension districts made plans to support and disseminate the DBE3 program. A summary of the plans and a review of the extent to which districts had implemented these plans by November 2011 is set out below.
PROVINCIAL
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 150,000,000 IDR from MORA and 140,232,100 IDR from MONE
No reported budget allocation from APBD at Provincial Level
MORA will conduct TOT for MTS key teachers from 35 districts/towns in Central Java. Scheduled for November 2010
Central Java regional MORA delegated the implementation to District MORA.
MONE will conduct BTL2 dissemination training for teachers of 5 core subjects, MGMP Committee, School Principals and Supervisors, using APBD level 1 fund.
Due to lack of MOU with DBE3, Provincial MONE was unable to allocate the funds
GROBOGAN
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 112,345,000 IDR Budget reported as actually used from APBD: 108,000,000 IDR
BTL2 dissemination for 80 teachers from SMPN 1 Gubug, SMPN 1 Tanggungharjo, SMPN 1 and 2 Kedungjati scheduled for October 2010
Completed
BTL 2 dissemination for 60 teachers from SMPN 1 Klambu and SMPN 1 Brati scheduled for December 2010
Completed independently) every Saturday using IHT.
BTL 2 dissemination for 40 teachers from SMPN 1 Wirosari scheduled for December 2010
Completed
TOT BTL 2 and 3 dissemination for model teachers of Religious Education in MTS involving 20 teachers
Completed
Education Office and MORA supervise SMP and MTS Principals on the implementation of BTL2 and BTL3 scheduled to start in September 2010
Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
111
PURWOREJO
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 173,835,000 IDR No reported budget allocation from APBD
BTL 3 replication for 567 SMPN teachers of 5 core subjects scheduled for October and December 2010
Completed in July 2010
BTL 2 Replication for 80 Religious Education teachers from 16 MTS scheduled for October 2010
Completed as scheduled
BTL 2 Replication for teachers from 9 private SMP scheduled for October and December 2010
Completed between 21 and 27 October 2010 with participants from 44 private SMP
Training for all School Principals and Supervisors before April 2011
Completed in July 2011. Delayed to fit in with schedule of the local Education Office
Post-training mentoring for BTL2 by District Facilitators and School Supervisors between Nov 2010 – Mar 2011
Started in March 2011 and still in progress
A joint decree will be issued by Head of Education Office and MORA on the implementation of DBE3 program in all SMP/MTS in the District
Decree was issued and has been implemented by all schools and Madrasah
KARANGANGYAR
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 392,400,000 IDR No reported budget allocation from APBD
BTL 2 dissemination for teachers from 5 SMP and 1 MTS scheduled for October-December 2010
80% completed using funds from BOS
BTL 3 dissemination for teachers from 5 SMP scheduled for December 2010 Completed as scheduled
Workshop on the empowerment of MGMP scheduled for November 2010 Conducted independently in 5 working groups
TOT on BTL2 and BTL3 for additional District Facilitators in 2010 25 additional District Facilitators trained
BTL2 & 3 dissemination for SMP and MTS that have not participated in BTL trainings scheduled for 2011
For the 20% not yet participated the training will take place in 2010 using a budget of 50,000,000 IDR allocated by DPRD
Post-training monitoring by Quality Assurance Team from the District Education Office in 2011
Completed by 60 Supervisors and 60 principals trained on BTL.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
112
BOYOLALI
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 46,000,000 IDR Budget reported as actually used from APBD: 14,000,000 IDR
Dissemination to other teachers in partner SMP and MTS Completed
Dissemination of BTL2 for non-partner SMP and MTS Completed
TOT for additional District Facilitators 15 additional District Facilitators trained using APBD
Circular letter on the dissemination of DBE3 programs Completed
Decree issued on the role of District Facilitators Challenged by Legislation on Duties of Educationalists
Build relationship with CSR Completed
Study visit to model schools Completed by MTSN Cepogo which visited MTs N Bener Purworejo activities subsequently cancelled due to a rumor about an Inspectorate decision to decline study visit activities using BOS funding,
KUDUS
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of 145,450,000 IDR No reported budget allocation from APBD
BTL 2 dissemination for teachers of non partner SMP and MTS scheduled for September to December 2010
Completed
BTL 2 dissemination for teachers of non partner SMP and MTS based on their geographic location in 2011
Completed
Training for School Principals and Supervisors scheduled for December 2011 Training was done in October 2011
Post-training mentoring for BTL 2 & 3 by Supervisors and District Facilitators in schools between February and March 2011
Completed
Monitoring of dissemination by Bappeda and House at schools scheduled for March and April 2011
Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
113
KUDUS (continued)
PLAN AS OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Showcase highlighting the successes of dissemination if DBE3 programs scheduled for April 2011
Completed
Circular letter issued by Education Office to Principals of SMP and MTS on the dissemination and implementation of BTL2 and BTL3 training.
Completed
Circular letter issued by Education Office to Principals of SMP and MTS on budgeting (RKAS) for active learning in School and Madrasah.
Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
114
4.10 List of DBE3 Technical, Management and Administrative Staff in Central Java, August 2011
DBE3 – LIFE SKILLS EDUCATION
Provincial Office: Central Java
Name Position Residential Address Phone Numbers email Ajar Budi Kuncoro Provincial Coordinator
Villa Aster 2 Blok I/3 Srondol, Semarang
0813 2587 3333 0878 3456 1010
Saiful Huda Shodiq
Sr. Education Officer
Jl. A. Yani Gg. 11 RT 003/RW 002 Kauman, Batang
0813 2585 7289 0816 656 253
Anna Rosita Communication Officer Jl. Lempong Sari I No. 47 RT 02/RW 02 Semarang 50231
0811 270 4760 0812 2083 5635
M. Lutfi H. Rahman District Coordinator Jl. Pangeran Sarip 5 Saripan, Jepara
0813 2588 7604 0818 0585 0207
R. Agus Danarta District Coordinator Pilahan Asri II/12 Rejoinangun, Kotagede, Yogyakarta
0813 25892165 0813 2817 8803
Da Laela District Coordinator
Jl. Raya Baturaden 13 RT002/RW001 Pandak, Baturaden, Purwokerto
0813 2589 2043 0815 698 9495
Ahmad Mardiyanto District Coordinator
Semali RT 02/RW 11 Pucungrejo, Muntilan, Magelang 56411
0811 276 1086 0817 414 5759 [email protected]
Indra Setiawan District Coordinator
Demakan TR III/532 RT 032/RW 008 Tegalrejo, Yogyakarta 55244
0813 2585 8453 0852 2803 3221
Nur Jannah District Coordinator
Lubanglor RT.01/RW.02 Butuh Purworejo 54264
0811-2700 270 0816-687756
Agustine Dwi Kurniawati
District Coordinator Melikan Kidul, Dukuh Bantul Warung RT 07 Kec. Bantul, Bantul 55711
0811 274 3070 0858 6826 1514
Helena Pongoh Administration & Finance Officer
Jl. Karang Rejo Selatan 37 Jatingaleh, Semarang
0817-189280 0811-2748976
Andy Wibowo Administration & Procurement Assistant
Jl. Kalisari Baru 19 Semarang 50245
0813 2612 4062 [email protected]
Helen Intania Surayda Finance Assistant Jl. Kebun Permai II/39 Pucang Gading, Demak
0811 276 1461 0813 2570 6316
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
115
5. EAST JAVA PROVINCIAL REPORT
This annex contains information and data concerning the implementation of the DBE3 project in East Java from 2005 to 2011. It should be read in conjunction with Volume I of the DBE3 Final Project Report, which contains a detailed account of the project activities.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
117
5.1 Map of Project Coverage in East Java
Below is a map showing the districts in which the DBE3 program has been implemented in East Java. There are 9 partner districts, with whom DBE had a formal agreement and 18 non-partner districts, where there was no formal agreement but in which the program was also disseminated.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
118
5.2 District Performance on the DBE3 Project
5.2.1 Highlights of District Performance in East Java
Tuban
1. Developed a dissemination strategy through a cluster-based MGMP. Each cluster covers about 2-4 sub-districts to make more effective implementation and mentoring. trained 10 additional district facilitators (DFs) in each cluster.
2. Conducted TOT for additional DFs on BTL2, BTL3 and BTL4 for 60 DFs in the 6 clusters
3. The additional DFs trained 500 teachers from SMP from all over Tuban.
4. MORA also conducted TOT on BTL2 and BTL3 for 30 Facilitator under MORA
5. Allocated a budget for facilitators to mentor dissemination school teachers
6. Conducted a showcase for dissemination schools once a year using the local BOS funding.
7. Committed to allocate a budget in 2012 for sustaining the quality improvement activities.
Pasuruan
1. Conducted training of trainers in BTL2, BTL3 and BTL4 for 40 additional DFs since 2010 to disseminate DBE3 activities to all SMP / MTs in the district.
2. Using a cluster based strategy called "base camp". In each base camp there are 10 additional DFs under the District Education Office.
3. The additional DFs trained 480 teachers from 60 schools in BTL2, BTL3 and BTL4.
4. Because Pasuruan also has a lesson study program they intend to use the DBE3 program and lesson study in all schools in Pasuruan using the district budget.
5. In addition to providing decree for the District Facilitators, Pasuruan also provides additional incentives / honoraria to the additional facilitators disseminating the DBE3 program.
Sidoarjo
1. Formed an education quality improvement team that involves education stakeholders Sidoarjo.
2. Allocated Rp. 200 million in 2011 to support dissemination to non-partner schools via a cluster based MGMP.
3. SMP 2 Sedati has become a model school which implements professional teaching and meaningful learning in its daily activities
Bojonegoro
Facilitators of MTs Pasinan have signed a statement that they are prepared to be evaluated on the implementation of the DBE3 program in their school after 3 years. After that it will be up to the foundation manager if he deems the results are not satisfactory.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
119
Kabupaten Nganjuk
1. In 2009, Nganjuk used the Basic Education Capacity funding (from the World Bank) for dissemination training in BTL.
2. In 2011 the budget of the district budget has allocated Rp.1 billion to disseminate the BTL2 and BTL3 in all schools in the district of Nganjuk
(In the core districts of Kota Surabaya, Kota Mojokerto, Bangkalan and Sampang there are no special initiatives to report.)
5.2.2 Assessment of Partner District Performance
The performance and impact of the DBE3 program has been varied in the different districts and schools. Below is an assessment of the performance of the DBE3 partner districts in East Java.
The criteria used were as follows:
• Level of commitment of local stakeholders
• Impact on partner schools
• Extent of project dissemination achieved
Each of the criteria is rated on a scale of one to three – with three being the highest rating. This has resulted in an overall star rating for each districts. Three stars in the highest rating and denotes a high level of stakeholder commitment, a generally high impact on practice in partner schools and a considerable amount of dissemination to non-partner schools. A rating of one star denotes a low level in each of these criteria.
EAST JAVA
CO
HO
RT
EX
TE
NS
ION
/
CO
RE
Lo
cal G
overn
men
t
Sta
ff C
om
mit
men
t
Imp
act
on
Sch
oo
ls
Rep
lica
tio
n
alr
ead
y t
aken
pla
ce
Fu
nd
ing f
or
R
ep
lica
tio
n
Overa
ll R
an
kin
g
1. Sidoarjo 1 E 3 3 3 2 **
2. Pasuruan 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
3. Nganjuk 2 E 2 2 2 2 **
4. Tuban 1 & 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
5. Bojonegoro 2 E 3 2 2 2 **
6. Kota Mojokerto 1 C 3 2 1 1 **
7. Surabaya 1 C 2 2 1 1 *
8. Bangkalan 1 C 2 1 1 1 *
9. Sampang 2 C 2 1 1 1 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
120
5.3 List of Non-Formal Service Providers
Below is a list non-formal service providers with whom DBE3 worked between 2006 and 2008.
District NFE Provider Learners Tutors
M F Total M F Total
Tuban PKBM Kejar Paket Widya Pantura 14 6 20 3 3 6
PKBM Wilis 16 0 16 5 3 8
Pesantren Hidayatush Sholihin 14 11 25 4 1 5
Pesantren Assamargondi 17 15 32 4 3 7
Pesantren Al Amin 13 3 27 11 4 15
Pesantren AL Hidayah 10 17 27 3 1 4
Mojokerto PKBM Mojopahit 21 11 32 33 21 54
PKBM Bina Insan Sejahtera 36 21 57 33 21 54
Pesantren Sabihul Mutaqin 18 26 44 2 2 4
Pesantren As Sholihiyah 10 0 10 3 0 3
Sidoarjo PKBM Melati 11 9 20 2 3 5
PKBM Sumber Ilmu 7 9 16 4 2 6
PKBM Terampil 7 5 12 6 0 6
PKBM Edelwais 7 6 13 2 5 7
Pesantren Darul Mujthahidin 12 6 18 3 2 5
PKBM Dahlia 18 4 21 2 1 3
Surabaya PKBM Wipra 14 7 20 4 3 7
PKBM Taman Belajar 8 12 56 9 3 12
Pesantren Darut Tauhid 21 35 69 2 2 4
Pesantren Batur Rohman 33 36 69 7 4 11
Pesantren Al Fitrah 412 118 530 17 5 22
Bangkalan PKBM Ababiel 49 17 66 11 4 15
PKBM Trunojoyo 50 222 272 14 30 44
Pesantren Syaichonah Cholil 10 0 10 9 0 9
Pesantren Al Bakriyah 72 0 72 6 0 6
PP Al Holiliyah An Nuraniyah 20 10 30 3 1 4
Sampang PKBM Harapan Bangsa 29 28 57 9 3 12
PP Tahfidzil Qur'an 26 20 46 2 4 6
PKBM Al Hidayah 12 10 22 4 2 6
PP Nurul Yaqin 23 41 64 5 5 20
Tuban 2 PKBM Dung Ireng 30 21 51 3 6 9
PP Al Huda 20 10 30 4 0 4
PP Al Husain 75 52 127 23 8 31
PKBM Tunas Bangsa 46 40 86 1 7 8
Bojonegoro PP Abu Dzarrin Al Ma'arif 135 165 300 21 27 48
PP Adnan Al Chairish 46 85 131 12 0 12
PP Abu Dzarrin Al Ridlwan 115 30 145 5 2 7
PKBM Lestari 22 14 36 5 4 9
PKBM Handayani 3 14 17 4 2 6
Nganjuk PP Tri Bhakti 28 12 40 5 4 9
PP Riyadlotul Muttaqien 39 30 69 6 0 6
Kejar Paket B Budi Utomo 12 8 20 2 4 6
Pasuruan Kejar Paket B Dewantara* 0 0 0 0 0 0
Kejar Paket B Nusantara 30 17 47 3 4 7
PP Nurul Badri 151 164 315 11 14 25
Kejar Paket B Miftahul Huda 35 45 80 15 10 25
PP Al-Ayyubi 27 24 51 6 2 8
TOTAL 1,824 1,436 3,318 348 232 580
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
121
5.4 Partner Schools and an Assessment of Their Performance
5.4.1 The Whole School Training Program
During the first three years of the project teacher training modules were developed, as well as subject teaching modules for the English, civics and mathematics. Facilitators were trained to deliver these modules and used them to train the partner schools in each of the 44 project districts, which joined the project in two cohorts in 2006 and 2007.
From the beginning of 2009 DBE3 focused primarily on a more intensive program in formal junior secondary schools, SMP and MTs intitally in 25 “extension” districts from existing cohort 1 and 2 districts in which to implement a more in-depth DBE3 school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement. The program included:
• An increase in the number of directly supported schools in each of the extension districts, in most cases from four to ten, in order to create a greater presence and critical mass;
• The implementation of a school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement which involves training teachers of all core subjects, school principals and other senior management staff in partner schools.
The whole school program was later extended to the remaining 19 ‘core’ districts in late 2009 but without the selection of additional partner schools in those districts.
Below is a list of partner schools that took part in the whole school training program. The original cohort 1 and 2 schools are indicated in the list by pink shading, while the additional schools in the 25 extension districts, which joined the project in 2009 are left unshaded.
5.4.2 How the Partner School Assessment was Done
DBE3 undertook an evaluation of these schools which was completed in August 2011. An instrument was developed to assess which schools are implementing DBE3 innovations well and are worth visiting. The instrument evaluated 4 key areas of the school performance:
• Teacher Activities: To what degree the teachers encourage interaction among students provide challenging and varied tasks (discussion, experimentation, problem solving) and use formative assessment techniques.
• Student Activities: To what degree the student activities vary (working cooperatively, solving
problems, experimenting), they express their own thoughts orally and in writing and use a variety of media in their lessons.
• Classroom Environment: To what degree the students in the school sit, work and interact in
groups, work is displayed on the wall and if they learn using more diverse sources (media, environment)
• Principal Leadership: To what degree the Principal in the school encourags change, supports
the professional development of teachers and supports other innovations in the school
Following the evaluation, each school was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest. A ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little or no impact.
3 2 1 0
Category
Schools implementing the results of the DBE3 program well and widely, and there is a strong recommendation to visit.
Schools applying DBE3 results well in some classes but not widely there is encouragement to visit
The application of the results of the DBE3 program is limited and there is no encouragemet to visit.
There are no visible results of the DBE3 program.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
122
5.4.3 List of Training Received
The data for the partner schools in East Java including the results of the assessment are set out on the next page. It also indicates the training packages which have been received by each school and are indicated by A, B, C and D as set out in the table below.
A: Cohort 1 District Schools B: Cohort 2 District Schools
Life Skills Program (2005 – 2009)
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
School Retention Toolkit
A* also included Mathematics module
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
B* also included Mathematics Module
C: Extension District Schools D: Core Districts Schools
Whole School Approach (2009 – 2011)
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
How to Use ICT in BTL
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
123
5.4.4 List of DBE Partner Schools in East Java and an Assessment of their Performance
The original partner schools which participated in the project before the expansion to ten schools in each extension district are highlighted in pink.
EAST JAVA
Extension Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 MTS Al Rosyid MTs Private Dander Bojonegoro B & C 291 268 559 26 12 38 **
2 SMP N 2 Baureno SMP State Baureno Bojonegoro B & C 199 166 365 20 14 34 *
3 SMP N Trucuk SMP State Tucuk Bojonegoro C 281 256 537 12 13 25 ***
4 MTs Darul Ulum Pasinan MTs Private Baureno Bojonegoro B & C 166 186 352 21 14 35 ***
5 SMP N 3 Bojonegoro SMP State Dander Bojonegoro B & C 387 346 733 15 28 43 **
6 MTs N 1 Bojonegoro MTs State Sukorejo Bojonegoro C 445 459 904 23 32 55 *
7 MTs Islamiyah Balen MTs Private Balen Bojonegoro C 188 147 335 16 15 31 *
8 MTs Sabilul Mutaqin MTs Private Sumberjo Bojonegoro C 147 120 267 25 2 27 *
9 SMP N 6 Bojonegoro SMP State Bojonegoro Bojonegoro C 365 294 659 18 25 43 **
10 SMP Muhammadiyah 4 SMP Private Balen Bojonegoro C 97 91 188 13 10 23 *
11 SMP N 1 Beji SMP State Beji Pasuruan B* & C 519 537 1.056 20 30 50 ***
12 SMP N 2 Gempol SMP State Gempol Pasuruan C 429 410 839 13 20 33 ***
13 SMP N 1 Purwosari SMP State Purwosari Pasuruan C 414 474 888 22 27 49 ***
14 SMP N 1 Rejoso SMP State Rejoso Pasuruan C 365 240 605 12 11 23 ***
15 SMP N 2 Grati SMP State Grati Pasuruan B* & C 307 299 606 25 22 47 *
16 MTs Sunan Ampel MTs Private Beji Pasuruan B* & C 133 105 238 10 12 22 **
17 MTs Al Arif MTs Private Gempol Pasuruan C 132 97 229 8 14 22 *
18 MTs N Pohjentrek MTs State Pohjentrek Pasuruan C 155 130 285 12 11 23 **
19 MTs Darul Ulum MTs Private Grati Pasuruan B* & C 183 137 320 16 9 25 *
20 MTs YTI Nguling MTs Private Nguling Pasuruan C 101 110 211 17 14 31 *
21 SMP N 2 Sedati SMP State Sedati Sidoarjo A & C 429 422 851 13 35 48 ***
22 SMP N 2 Wonoayu SMP State Wonoayu Sidoarjo C 393 388 781 27 22 49 ***
23 MTs Nurul Huda MTs Private Sedati Sidoarjo A & C 287 280 567 29 17 46 ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
124
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
24 SMP N 1 Tarik SMP State Tarik Sidoarjo C 326 459 785 25 14 39 **
25 MTs N Tarik MTs State Tarik Sidoarjo C 280 317 597 20 22 42 ***
26 SMP N 1 Gedangan SMP State Gedangan Sidoarjo C 416 482 898 18 36 54 **
27 MTs N Tulangan MTs State Tulangan Sidoarjo A & C 391 378 769 15 21 36 **
28 MTs NU Wali Songo MTs Private Sidoarjo Sidoarjo C 320 347 667 21 20 41 **
29 SMP 5 Muhamadiyah SMP Private Tulangan Sidoarjo A & C 180 191 371 22 8 30 **
30 MTs N Krian MTs State Krian Sidoarjo C 467 525 992 20 58 78 *
31 SMP N 2 Palang SMP State Palang Tuban A & C 216 249 465 14 23 37 **
32 SMPN 2 Semanding SMP State Semanding Tuban B & C 298 250 548 17 12 29 ***
33 SMPN 1 Merakurak SMP State Merakurak Tuban B & C 320 256 576 20 18 38 ***
34 SMPN 2 Rengel SMP State Rengel Tuban C 248 302 550 15 14 29 ***
35 MTs Mambail Futuh MTs Private Jenu Tuban A & C 447 579 1.026 33 15 48 **
36 MTs Salafiyah Merakurak MTs Private Merakurak Tuban B & C 217 234 451 21 11 32 *
37 MTs Al Mustofawiyah MTs Private Palang Tuban A & C 133 198 331 18 13 31 *
38 MTs Muhammadiyah 1 MTs Private Palang Tuban A & C 83 91 174 22 6 28 *
39 MTs N Rengel MTs State Rengel Tuban C 304 263 567 18 14 32 ***
40 MTs Miftahul Huda MTs Private Semanding Tuban B & C 74 79 153 14 10 24 *
41 SMP Negeri 2 Tanjunganom SMP State Tanjunganom Nganjuk B* & C 487 479 966 59 26 85 **
42 MTs N Tanjunganom MTs State Tanjunganom Nganjuk B* & C 441 415 856 27 27 54 *
43 SMP N 3 Kertosono SMP State Kertosono Nganjuk B* & C 584 461 1.045 26 36 62 **
44 MTs N Nglawak MTs State Kertosono Nganjuk B* & C 286 292 578 18 23 41 **
45 MTs N Termas MTs State Baron Nganjuk C 267 328 595 14 25 39 *
46 SMP N 1 Baron SMP State Baron Nganjuk C 506 437 943 25 40 65 **
47 SMP N 2 Pace SMP State Pace Nganjuk C 482 369 851 22 21 43 **
48 MTs Nahdlatul Ulama Joho MTs Private Pace Nganjuk C 124 132 256 14 12 26 *
49 SMP N 2 Berbek SMP State Berbek Nganjuk C 397 307 704 19 21 40 **
50 MTs N Berbek MTs State Berbek Nganjuk C 344 356 700 91 21 112 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
125
EAST JAVA
Core Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 15 Surabaya SMP State Kenjeran Kota Surabaya A & D 439 542 981 25 38 63 ***
2 SMP N 31 Surabaya SMP State Kenjeran Kota Surabaya A & D 295 381 676 13 36 49 **
3 MTs Nurul Hikmah Surabaya MTs Private Bulak Kota Surabaya A & D 141 161 302 10 20 30 **
4 SMP Daniswara Surabaya SMP Private Gubeng Kota Surabaya A & D 99 100 199 14 9 23 *
5 SMP N 4 Bangkalan SMP State Bangkalan Bangkalan A & D 417 374 791 12 47 59 **
6 SMP N 1 Blega SMP State Blega Bangkalan A & D 380 276 656 18 22 40 **
7 MTs N Bangkalan MTs State Bangkalan Bangkalan A & D 386 387 773 19 41 60 ***
8 MTs Al Maarif Bangkalan MTs Private Bangkalan Bangkalan A & D 158 268 426 13 28 41 **
9 SMP N 6 Mojokerto SMP State Prajurit Kulon Mojokerto A & D 396 347 743 10 32 42 ***
10 SMP N 9 Mojokerto SMP State Magersari Mojokerto A & D 240 270 510 18 18 36 **
11 MTs Brawijaya Mojokerto MTs Private Magersari Mojokerto A & D 66 56 122 11 10 21 *
12 MTs Nurul Jadid Mojokerto MTs Private Magersari Mojokerto A & D 76 59 135 9 14 23 **
13 SMP N 1 Camplong SMP State Camplong Sampang B & D 421 354 775 23 32 55 ***
14 SMP N 1 Kedungdung SMP State Kedungdung Sampang B & D 195 177 372 9 14 23 **
15 MTs Bustanul Ulum MTs Private Camplong Sampang B & D 69 80 149 15 14 29 *
16 MTs Al Jawahir MTs Private Kedungdung Sampang B & D 147 89 236 10 13 23 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
126
5.5 District Facilitators / Performance Assessment
5.5.1 List of District Facilitators for Non Formal Education in East Java
Below is a list of facilitators from East Java trained to support the Non-Formal Education program.
Name Position District Subject
Drs. Moh. Hilili, SH, MPDI Penilik PLS. Bangkalan Management
H. Moh. Hamim Tutor/Penyelenggara Bangkalan Teaching and Learning
Siti Zaenah, Sag GPAI Bangkalan Management
Abdul Wahed Tutor/Penyelenggara Bangkalan Teaching and Learning
Elif Rohana, SH Staf PK Pontren Tuban Management
H. Alimin, Sn. BA Staf PK Pontren Tuban Teaching and Learning
Drs. Muslichuddin Penilik PLS. Tuban Teaching and Learning
Irma Farida Hanum TLD Tuban Management
Efi Sri Wulandari TLD Mojokerto Management
Ahmad Zainal Fanani Ustadz PP/Tutor Mojokerto Teaching and Learning
Chusnul Ashari Staf Pokapontren Mojokerto Management
Ismaul Maarif Staf Pokapontren Mojokerto Teaching and Learning
Taufiqurrahman Penyelenggara Sidoarjo Management
Sukamto Pengawas PAI Sidoarjo Teaching and Learning
Rina Sumara TLD Sidoarjo Management
Dwi Nurmilawati Tutor Sidoarjo Teaching and Learning
Subeki Penilik PLS Gubeng Surabaya Teaching and Learning
Menik Dianastiti Tutor Paket B Surabaya Management
Wahyu Irodat TLD Dikmas Surabaya Management
Pratama Surya BK Tutor Wajar Dikdas Surabaya Teaching and Learning
Ali Hanafi Tutor PP Adnan Al Haris Bojonegoro Management
Damiati Tutor PKBM Budi Ilmu Bojonegoro Management
Johan Pundi L TLD Dikmas Bojonegoro Teaching and Learning
Nilna Himawati Pengurus TBM Handayani Bojonegoro Teaching and Learning
Abdul Wakhid Staff Diknas Grati Pasuruan Management
Asnifah Staff Diknas Beji Pasuruan Management
Agung Ampuhan Staff Diknas Purwodadi Pasuruan Teaching and Learning
Dwie Meiristawati Staff Diknas Beji Pasuruan Teaching and Learning
H. Alimim, Sn.BA staff Depag Tuban Tuban Management
Drs. Muslichuddin Penilik PLS Diknas Tuban Management
Irma Farida Harum TLD Diknas Tuban Teaching and Learning
Sri Romawati Tutor PKBM Durian Mas Nganjuk Management
Sudarsangit Tutor PKBM Nurul Jadid Nganjuk Management
Dewi Fajar S SKB Nganjuk Nganjuk Teaching and Learning
Mei Wulandari Guru SDN Pelem II Kertosono Nganjuk Teaching and Learning
Abd. Manaf. S.Ag tutor PP Tahfizil Quran Sampang Management
Yeni Widyaningrum Tutor PKBM Harapan Bangsa Sampang Management
Farida Handriyani Tutuor PKBM Harapan Bangsa Sampang Teaching and Learning
Edi Subianto Kasi PLS P&K Sampang Teaching and Learning
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
127
5.5.2 List of District Facilitators for the Life Skills Training Program in East Java 2006 – 2008
Below is a list of facilitators from East Java trained to implement the Life Skills program.
Name Position Module District Institution
Suprapto, SPd Teacher BTL Bangkalan SMP Negeri 4
Drs. Subandy Widjaya, MPd Lecturer BTL Bangkalan STKIP PGRI
Syahrul Imam Ismail, SPd Teacher ICT Bangkalan MTs Neg
Bambang Poerwowidiantoro , SPd Teacher ICT Bangkalan SMA Neg 3
Drs. Moch Ilyas Supervisor Life Skills Bangkalan TK/SD Diknas
Drs. Juri Al Jurianto Supervisor Life Skills Bangkalan TK/SD Diknas
Darmadi, SPd Teacher Civics Bangkalan SMP Neg 1
Drs. Aqmam Teacher Civics Bangkalan MTs Neg
Yesis Kristiani Teacher Civics Bangkalan SMP Neg 4
Silvika Indriani, SPd Teacher English Bangkalan SMP Neg 4
Drs. Sunaryono, MPd Supervisor English Bangkalan TK/SD Diknas
Riska Puspita Sari, SPd Teacher English Bangkalan MTs Neg
Drs Wignyo Hadi Kasi BTL Tuban Kurikulum Dinas
Akub Zainal Teacher ICT Tuban SMP Neg 2
Juli Kristanto Teacher ICT Tuban SMP Neg 5
Sunarko Teacher Life Skills Tuban SMK Neg 2
Winuk Supiati Teacher Civics Tuban SMP Neg 3
Abdullah Ulil Albab Teacher Civics Tuban MTs Manbail Futuh
Chusna Teacher English Tuban SMP Neg 1
Drs. H. Soenarto Teacher ICT Tuban SMPN 1 Merakurak
Akhmad Munaim, SPd Teacher ICT Tuban MAN Rengel Tuban
Emy Dyah Susilaningtyas Teacher B Inggris Tuban SMPN 2 Palang
Ninik Sriwianna, SPd Teacher Civics Tuban SMPN 2 Semanding
Sukoco, SPd Teacher Civics Tuban MTsN Rengel
Kamali, SPd Teacher Mathematics Tuban SMPN 2 Tuban
Eko Pudjimartono Teacher Mathematics Tuban SPG Negeri
Nur Alam, M.Ag Supervisor BTL Tuban Depag Tuban
Drs Rastam Effendi Supervisor BTL Tuban Depag Tuban
Yashukan Teacher LSE Tuban SMPN 2 Plumpang
Sunarko Teacher LSE Tuban SMKN 2
Ni'amul Huda Teacher B Inggris Tuban MTs Manbail Futuh Jenu
Winuk Supiati Teacher Civics Tuban SMPN 3 Tuban
Drs. M. Nurkhusain Teacher BTL Surabaya SMPN 9
Kamisun, SPd Teacher BTL Surabaya SMP YP 17
Tjipto Wardoyo, SPd Teacher BTL Surabaya SMPN 3
Dra. Zakiah Nur Teacher BTL Surabaya SMPN 31
Chamim Rosidy Irsyad, MSi, MPd Teacher ICT Surabaya SMPN 12
Agus Iwan Kurnia, Skom Teacher ICT Surabaya SMPN 1
Budiono Teacher Life Skills Surabaya MTs Nurul Hikmah
Sri Wahyuningsih, Spd Teacher Life Skills Surabaya SMPN 1
Dra. Hj. Pudjiati Teacher Civics Surabaya SMPN 6
Nur Zubaidah Teacher Civics Surabaya SMP Wachid Hasyim
Drs. Sugiyanto, MPd Teacher English Surabaya SMPN 11
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
128
Name Position Module District Institution
Moh. Ali Imron Teacher English Surabaya SMPN 15
Dra. Hj. Nurul Laila Supervisor BTL Mojokerto SMP/SMA Diknas
Drs. Suparman Supervisor BTL Mojokerto MTs Depag
Septin Wahyuni, SPd Teacher ICT Mojokerto SMPN 5
Nur Aini, SPd Teacher ICT Mojokerto SMPN 6
Drs. Wasis Djatmiko Teacher Life Skills Mojokerto SMPN 2
Dra. Hj. Lys Setyawati Teacher Life Skills Mojokerto SMPN 8
Drs. Jaenuri, MPd Teacher Civics Mojokerto SMPN 1
Dra. Ari Judaningsih Teacher Civics Mojokerto SMPN 3
Aris Samudra Rizal, SS Teacher English Mojokerto MTs Nurul Jadid
Evi Eliana, SS Teacher English Mojokerto MTs Brawijaya
Dyah Naryati Relawati, SPd Teacher BTL Sidoarjo SMPN 2
Ani Kadarwati, MPd Supervisor BTL Sidoarjo SMP/SMA
Drs. Hartoyo, MPd Principal ICT Sidoarjo SMP 2 Jabon
Kusyanto Teacher ICT Sidoarjo SMP 1
Mohamad Rohani Teacher Life Skills Sidoarjo SMPN 2 Sedati
Nihayah, SPd Teacher Life Skills Sidoarjo SMP 3 Krian
Drs. Moh. Shodiq Teacher Civics Sidoarjo SMP 1 Candi
Dra. Nuniek Endardini Teacher Civics Sidoarjo SMP 2
Sri Aswati, SPd Teacher Civics Sidoarjo SMP 1 Gedangan
Aris Setiawan, MPd Teacher English Sidoarjo SMP 1 Taman
Didik Winarko, SPd Teacher English Sidoarjo SMP 2 Sedati
Winarsih Teacher English Nganjuk SMPN 1 Nganjuk
Drs. Nur Hamid , MM Teacher English Nganjuk SMPN 1 Gondang
Indiah Sri Suntari Teacher English Nganjuk SMPN 1 Lonceret
Tjipto Utomo Teacher Civics Nganjuk SMPN 1 Kertosono
H.Marsudi Teacher Civics Nganjuk SMPN 5 Nganjuk
J. H. Sukarno, SPd, MM Teacher Civics Nganjuk SMPN 2 Tj. Anom
Ato'illah Daimul Ikhsan Teacher ICT Nganjuk MTsN Tj. Anom
Harsono Teacher ICT Nganjuk SMPN 1 Prambon
Mochammad Hernudin Teacher BTL Nganjuk MTsN Tj. Anom
Drs.H. Qomaruddin Teacher BTL Nganjuk SMPN 1 Kertosono
Didik Adi Kuncoro Teacher Civics Nganjuk SMPN 3 Kertosono
Mirna Akmaliatun Nisa Teacher Civics Nganjuk MTs Al Huda Tj. Anom
Drs. Ismadi, MM Teacher Mathematics Nganjuk SMPN 1 Tj. Anom
Drs. Sentot Hari Purnomo, MM Teacher Mathematics Nganjuk SMPN 1 Wilangan
Mariyadi Teacher BTL Bojonegoro SMPN 3 Baureno
Yasdi Teacher BTL Bojonegoro PP Al Rasyid
Erlina Kriswidiastuti Teacher English Bojonegoro SMAN 3 Bojonegoro
Yusuf Setyo Prayitno Teacher Civics Bojonegoro SMPN 2 Bojonegoro
Arif Gunawan Teacher ICT Bojonegoro SMPN 1 Bojonegoro
Hengki Danang I Teacher Mathematics Bojonegoro SMAN 3 Bojonegoro
Sukirno Teacher English Bojonegoro SMAN 4 Bojonegoro
Srikah Teacher English Bojonegoro SMPN 6 Bojonegoro
Nunuk Nuriyati Teacher English Bojonegoro SMPN 2 Baureno
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
129
Name Position Module District Institution
Hanas Caturiansyah Teacher Mathematics Bojonegoro SMPN 2 Baureno
Muhadi Teacher Mathematics Bojonegoro SMAN 4 Bojonegoro
Amrozi Teacher LSE Bojonegoro Pemred Koran Bangkit
Ainur Rofiq Teacher LSE Bojonegoro SMA Darul Ulum
H. M. Thoyib Teacher LSE Pasuruan Dinas Pend Kab.Pasuruan
Nur El Huda Teacher LSE Pasuruan MTs Al Hidayah
Dwi Agung P. Teacher LSE Pasuruan SMPN 1 Bangil
Anastasia S. Y. Teacher BTL Pasuruan SMPN 1 Pohjenprek
Imam Ghazali Teacher BTL Pasuruan MTsN Rejoso Pohjentrek
Suprijadi Teacher ICT Pasuruan SMPN 1 Pasrepan
Tri Setyo AstuICT Teacher ICT Pasuruan SMPN 1 Prigen
Darmiati Teacher Civics Pasuruan SMPN 1 Wonorejo
Abd. Kholiq Teacher ICT Pasuruan SMKN 1 Bangil
Ustadi Teacher BTL Pasuruan SMP Ma’arif Pandaan
Slamet Mujiono Teacher Civics Pasuruan SMPN 1 Lekok
Joni Suparman Teacher Civics Pasuruan SMPN 2 Gondang Wetan
Khoirul Faizin Teacher Mathematics Pasuruan SMPN 2 Winongan
Bakhrul Ulum Teacher Mathematics Pasuruan SMPN 1 Tutur
Ach. Syahirul Alim Teacher ICT Sampang SMAN 1 Kedungdung
Rachman Setiadi Teacher ICT Sampang SMPN 1 Kedungdung
Hanik Supriatin Teacher Civics Sampang SMPN 1 Kedungdung
Muhammad Jufri Teacher Civics Sampang MTsN Sreseh
Drs. Anwar Haryono Teacher Civics Sampang Dinas Pendidikan Sampang
Diah Wulansari Teacher English Sampang SMPN 1 Camplong
Drs. Rosul Teacher English Sampang MTs Negeri Sampang
M. Holil, SPd Teacher English Sampang SMP Al Irsyad
Akhmad Arief Teacher Mathematics Sampang MTs Negeri Sampang
Sulam, SPd Teacher Mathematics Sampang SMPN 1
Amirulloh, S.Si Teacher Mathematics Sampang SMAN 2
Drs. Moh. Holil, MPd Teacher LSE Sampang MTsN Sreseh
Hj. Mukhlishotun Teacher LSE Sampang MTs Bustanul Ulum
Bambang Iriyanto, SPd, MM Teacher BTL Sampang SMP Islam An Nur Omben
Moh. Agus Jamalur Teacher BTL Sampang MTs Al Jawahir
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
130
5.5.3 The District Facilitators for the Whole School Program
In order to support the implementation of the whole school training program, more usually referred to as the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, district facilitators were selected in each district jointly by local government and DBE3 staff and trained by the project. There were originally 15 facilitators (3 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each extension district and 10 facilitators (2 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each core district. They have been trained to implement all or most of the BTL training modules. A number of the best facilitators from each province were also elevated to become national facilitators, which meant that they were trained in each module before the rest of the district facilitators and were then charged with implementing the training of the district facilitators. In their own districts they continued to act as district facilitators, supporting partner school and dissemination training, organizing MGMP activities and mentoring teachers after training. A list of the BTL facilitators operating as of August 2011 is included on the next page.
5.5.4 How the District Facilitator Performance Assessment was Done
In order to provide information on the effectiveness of these facilitators to those wishing to disseminate the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, DBE3 evaluated their performance using an instrument which focuses on a number of key areas:
• The extent to which the District Facilitator applies the training in their own work as a teacher, Principal or School Supervisor
• The extent to which the District Facilitator helps other teachers in their own school either as a teacher, Principal or Supervisor
• Their creativity in developing and implementing innovative training materials and approaches
• Their commitment as a District Facilitator for DBE3
• Their ability to relate to, communicate and interact with participants in the training and in mentoring
• Their initiative and ability to cooperate and support others District Facilitators during the training
• How effective they are as a mentor, whether they are able to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching and learning process and provide good feedback to teachers
Following the evaluation, each District Facilitator was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest.
3 2 1 0
Category
Very good, always works hard and is very able as a Facilitator
Good in general performance and ability as a Facilitator
Average, still needs to develop some skills as a Facilitator
Rarely works and not very able as a Facilitator
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
131
5.5.5 List of Facilitators in East Java for the Whole School Training Program and Performance Assessment
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
EAST JAVA
1 Eny Yuliati F Teacher English SMPN 1 Kalitidu Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 08121708413 [email protected] *** 2 Amrulloh M Teacher English SMPN 5 Bojonegoro Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 08123175101 [email protected] *** 3 Musrifah F Teacher English SMPN Trucuk Partner Bojonegoro East Java 08113446338 [email protected] ** 4 Yeni Indrastuti F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Bojonegoro Partner Bojonegoro East Java 085854491498 [email protected] *** 5 Rasmijah F Teacher B. Ind MTSN 1 Bojonegoro Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081553353772 [email protected] ** 6 Khudlori M Teacher B. Ind MTS Islamiyah Balen Partner Bojonegoro East Java 08113406728 [email protected] ** 7 Suratmi F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 6 Bojonegoro Partner Bojonegoro East Java 085230915843 [email protected] ** 8 Erminingsih F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Kapas Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081330605473 [email protected] *** 9 Fathur Rohim M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Balen Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 085648827226 [email protected] *** 10 Nursalim M Teacher Science SMPN 5 Bojonegoro Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081335296674 [email protected] ** 11 Hadi Suryono M Teacher Science SMPN 3 Bojonegoro Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081703351115 ** 12 Yasdi M Teacher Social S. MTS Al Rosyid Dander Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081335778202 [email protected] *** 13 Nomi Wijayanti F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Baureno Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081903912674 [email protected] ** 14 Fatkhan M Teacher Social S. MTS Islamiyah Balen Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081335620498 [email protected] ** 15 Ufar Ismail M Principal Math SMPN 1 Sekar Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 085259616611 [email protected] *** 16 Nurhadi M Teacher Math SMPN 6 Bojonegoro Partner Bojonegoro East Java 08125919503 [email protected] *** 17 Boedi Utomo M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Bojonegoro Non Partner Bojonegoro East Java 081335107556 [email protected] ** 18 Siti Mardiyah F Teacher Math MTS Al Rosyid Dander Partner Bojonegoro East Java 085233975242 [email protected] ** 19 Sindit Al Luhuri S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 2 Lumbang Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 085755851844' [email protected] *** 20 Khumi Laila S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Prigen Non Partner Pasuruan East Java [email protected] *** 21 Imam Ghozali M.Pd M Principal English MTsN Wonorejo Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 081803138774' [email protected] ** 22 Drs. Rumus Achliono M Teacher B. Ind SMP 2 Gempol Partner Pasuruan East Java 081335329965' [email protected] *** 23 Abdul Kadir S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMP 1 Sukorejo Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 081332012921' [email protected] *** 24 Nur El Huda S.Pdi F Principal B. Ind MTs. Al Hidayah Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 085234159007' [email protected] ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
132
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
25 Drs. Rinto Wahyu Widodo M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Winongan Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 085645446124' [email protected] *** 26 Basuki Rahmat S.Pd M Teacher Science MTsN Pohjentrek Partner Pasuruan East Java 085931088018' [email protected] *** 27 H. Baju Sigit Witjaksono M.Pd M Teacher Science SMP 1 Beji Partner Pasuruan East Java 081334536655' [email protected] *** 28 Indarjanti S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 2 Winongan Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 081615250009' [email protected] ** 29 Endah Dwi Sasi S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMP 1 Grati Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 03437754000' [email protected] *** 30 Darmanto S.Pd M Teacher Social S. MTsN Prigen Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 0343634834' [email protected] *** 31 Drs. Teguh Aribowo M Teacher Social S. SMP 1 Pohjentrek Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 085755058110' *** 32 Dra Endang Sulistiyah F Teacher Math SMP 1 Purwosari Partner Pasuruan East Java 081333200100' [email protected] *** 33 Khoirul Faizin S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Winongan Non Partner Pasuruan East Java 085234105373' [email protected] *** 34 Didiek Prihadiyanto M.Pd M Teacher Math SMP 1 Rejoso Partner Pasuruan East Java 08123178027' ** 35 Teguh Sudjatmika, M.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 1 Baron Partner Nganjuk East Java 081359155165 *** 36 Eny Junaidah, S.Pd F Teacher English MTsN Nglawak Partner Nganjuk East Java 081335333131 ** 37 Sri Koendajati, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Kertosono Partner Nganjuk East Java 081357937542 **
38 Endang Sri Wahyuningsih, S.Pd, MM.Pd
F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Nganjuk Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 081335995959 ***
39 Didik Eko Purwanto, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Berbek Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 081359374001 *** 40 Suhari, nS.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Baron Partner Nganjuk East Java 085646107300 ** 41 Winarsih, S.Pd, M.Pd F Teacher B. IndG SMPN 1 Nganjuk Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 08125955420 *** 42 Drs. Edi Sabadilla S.,S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Nganjuk Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 081335666174 *** 43 Dra. Mukhlissotin F Teacher Science MTsN Nglawak Partner Nganjuk East Java 081231639401 ***
44 Tri Cahyono Budi Santoso, S.Pd
F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Nganjuk Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 081335067018 ***
45 Moh. Miftakhul Ikhsan, M.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Nganjuk Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 081335626781 *** 46 Dra. Saidah Mardiana F Teacher Social S. SMP Islam Baitul 'Izzah Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 0818816287320 ** 47 Sa'diyati, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Tanjunganom Partner Nganjuk East Java 081357747491 ** 48 Agus Nurbaktiono M Teacher Math SMPN 3 Kertosono Partner Nganjuk East Java 081234091238 *** 49 Supriyono, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Tanjunganom Non Partner Nganjuk East Java 08123439206 ** 50 Lilik Gunarwati, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 2 Berbek Partner Nganjuk East Java 081331411507 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
133
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
51 Achmad Imam Mansur, S.Pd M Teacher Math MTsN Berbek Partner Nganjuk East Java 081553132733 ** 52 Dra.S. Muallifah, F Teacher English SMPN 3 Krian Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 03171120010 [email protected] *** 53 Dyah Naryati R, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 2 Sedati Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081330379449 [email protected] *** 54 Nurdiono,S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 1 Tarik Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081553522018 [email protected] *** 55 Much Hadiril Ihsan,S.Pd M Teacher English MTs Al Ikhsan Krian Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 085733043851
[email protected] / budiarto212@@mail.com
*** 56 Drs. Tri Widodo,M.Pd M Principal B. Ind SMPN 1 Wonoayu Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 08123059768 [email protected] *** 57 Imam Sa’duddin,S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind MTsN Tlasih Tulangan Partner Sidoarjo East Java '081323856496 [email protected] *** 58 Drs. Akmad Junaidi M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Wonoayu Partner Sidoarjo East Java 03171611106 [email protected] *** 59 Drs.Khoirul Fatikin,Mpd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Porong Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081330447011 [email protected] *** 60 Dra. Tutik Amalawati F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Gedangan Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081331092887 [email protected] *** 61 Drs.Aryo Suroso,M.Pd M Supervisor Science Pengawas Diknas Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 08130008607 [email protected] *** 62 Dra. Endang Mujiati F Teacher Science MTsN Tlasih Tulangan Partner Sidoarjo East Java 085855193563 [email protected] *** 63 Dra. Elly Chandraeny,M.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 3 Sidoarjo Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 08123164063 [email protected] ***
64 Dwi Indah Sri Astutik.S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Sidoarjo Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081330063487 [email protected] / [email protected] ***
65 Drs.Rodhi As'ad,M.M M Principal Social S. SMPN 3 Krian Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081331532933 [email protected] *** 66 Drs. Tirto Adi,M.Pd M Principal Social S. SMPN 1 Sidoarjo Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 08123090972 [email protected] *** 67 Dra. Yuwarlik F Teacher Social S. MTsN Krian Partner Sidoarjo East Java 03172756170 *** 68 Drs. Ismuni M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Sukodono Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081553789345 [email protected] *** 69 Drs. Achmad.Lutfi.M.M M Principal Math SMPN 2 Sedati Partner Sidoarjo East Java 08123227057 [email protected] *** 70 Zaini Tamam, S.Pd M Teacher Math MTs N Sidoarjo Non Partner Sidoarjo East Java 081330089916 [email protected] *** 71 Joko Prayoga, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 2 Semanding Partner Tuban East Java 081553538694 [email protected] *** 72 Dra. Chusna, M.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Tuban Non Partner Tuban East Java 081335731183 [email protected] ** 73 Drs. Suwarno, M.Pd M Principal English
MA Banin Banat Jetak Montong
Non Partner Tuban East Java 085235370766 [email protected] ** 74 H. Abd. Syakur, S.Pd.M.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 2 Rengel Partner Tuban East Java 081231270647 [email protected] ** 75 Nanang Syafii, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 4 Tuban Non Partner Tuban East Java 081357486357 [email protected] *** 76 Sutarno, S.Pd. M.Pd M Principal B. Ind SMPN 3 Singgahan Non Partner Tuban East Java 081357040389 [email protected] **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
134
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
77 Dra. Nurfaizah F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Rengel Partner Tuban East Java 081515733396 [email protected] ** 78 Dra. Anis Kasturiningsih, M.Pd F Teacher B. Ind MTs N Satu Atap Tuban Non Partner Tuban East Java 08563296316 [email protected] ** 79 Drs. Warno M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Tambakboyo Non Partner Tuban East Java 08993812266 ** 80 Gatut Murtyanto Efendi, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Semanding Non Partner Tuban East Java 08113479331 ** 81 Kiswo Widodo, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 3 Semanding Non Partner Tuban East Java 085257739309 [email protected] *** 82 Muh. Mubin, SE M Teacher Social S. MTs Manbail Futuh Partner Tuban East Java 08125926800 [email protected] *** 83 Pratikno, S.Pd. M.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Tuban Non Partner Tuban East Java 081803249099 [email protected] ** 84 Siti Basri, S.Pd. M.M.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Palang Partner Tuban East Java 081330027374 [email protected] ** 85 Kamali, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Tuban Non Partner Tuban East Java 08165458827 *** 86 Tumawar, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 2 Semanding Partner Tuban East Java 085230747774 [email protected] *** 87 Drs. Jaka Hari Budianto M Teacher Math MTsN Rengel Partner Tuban East Java 08563060145 **
88 Khoirul Anam, S.Si M Teacher Math MTs Nurul Hikmah Surabaya
Partner Surabaya East Java 03170177824, 085648923218
89 Sarpin Saragih, S.Pd, MM M Teacher Math SMPN 31 Surabaya Partner Surabaya East Java 0817 3228 72, 03171900628
** 90 Agus Yulianto, S.Pd M Teacher English MTs N 3 Surabaya Non Partner Surabaya East Java 081230866500 [email protected] *** 91 M. Ali Imron, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 15 Surabaya Partner Surabaya East Java 08155018603 [email protected] **
92 Chamim Rosyidi Irsyad, M.Si, M.Pd
M Principal B.I SMPN 44 Surabaya Non Partner Surabaya East Java 0812 1731 928 [email protected] ***
93 Ahmad Zainudin, S.Pd M Teacher B.I SMPN 15 Surabaya Partner Surabaya East Java 0856 4807 4187 [email protected] ** 94 Dra. Henny Dumi Arini F Teacher Science SMPN 15 Surabaya Partner Surabaya East Java 085850892561 [email protected] *** 95 Adji Pranyoto, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 31 Surabaya Partner Surabaya East Java 031 72457417 ** 96 Drs. Ahmad Syaihu M Teacher Social S. MTSN 3 Surabaya Non Partner Surabaya East Java 0812 319 2924 [email protected] ***
97 Ainur Rofiq, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. MTSN 2 Surabaya Non Partner Surabaya East Java 031 5615036, 03171892169
**
98 Soeprapto, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 4 Bangkalan Partner Bangkalan East Java 081 739 8035 *** 99 Nurhayati, S.Pd, F Teacher Math MTsN Bangkalan Partner Bangkalan East Java 03171105743 ** 100 Mujiono, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 6 Bangkalan Non Partner Bangkalan East Java 081 230744401 *** 101 Nur Kamilah, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 4 Bangkalan Partner Bangkalan East Java 081938327481 **
102 Sri Kusumawati, S.Pd F Teacher B.I SMPN 6 Bangkalan Non Partner Bangkalan East Java 0313090899, 03178051757
***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
135
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
103 Drs. Suganggiri M Teacher B.I SMPN 3 Bangkalan Non Partner Bangkalan East Java 085655039945 ** 104 Yudi Susiyanto, S.Pd M Teacher Science MTsN Bangkalan Partner Bangkalan East Java 081 750 882 04 [email protected] *** 105 R. Wahyudi Oetomo, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Kamal Non Partner Bangkalan East Java 08563118945 [email protected] *** 106 Lilis Sri Banowati, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Blega Partner Bangkalan East Java 081 331 069069 [email protected] ** 107 Dra. Fatimah F Teacher Social S. MTsN Bangkalan Partner Bangkalan East Java 031 70797990 ** 108 Drs. Mohamad Nizar M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Blega Partner Bangkalan East Java 087850967722 ** 109 Novita Suprianti, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Kedungdung Partner Sampang East Java 081937293144 ** 110 Rachmad Setiadi, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 1 Kedungdung Partner Sampang East Java 081331660979 [email protected] *** 111 Diah Wulansari, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Camplong Partner Sampang East Java 081331576662 *** 112 Irma Yuliantini, S.E F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Kedungdung Partner Sampang East Java 081939285278 ** 113 Mohamad Sjafiuddin, S.Pd, MM M Teacher Social S. MTs Al Jawahir Partner Sampang East Java 087850676202 [email protected] *** 114 Kurniawan Lesmananto, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Camplong Partner Sampang East Java 085850377542 ** 115 Yety Maryanata, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 1 Kedungdung Partner Sampang East Java ** 116 Drs. Suyono M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Kedungdung Partner Sampang East Java 081357369067 ** 117 ST Farhah, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Kedungdung Partner Sampang East Java ** 118 Sri Utami, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 6 Mojokerto Partner Mojokerto East Java ** 119 Anis Hani'ah, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 9 Mojokerto Partner Mojokerto East Java 08123011521 [email protected] *** 120 Nur Aini, S.Pd, M.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 6 Mojokerto Partner Mojokerto East Java 081938801037 [email protected] *** 121 Arif Sediono, SE M Teacher Social S. MTs Nurul Jadid Partner Mojokerto East Java 08563364150 [email protected] ** 122 Sri Supeni, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 9 Mojokerto Partner Mojokerto East Java 081313316499 [email protected] ** 123 Drs. Johanes Teguh Pribadi M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 6 Mojokerto Partner Mojokerto East Java 08121628307 [email protected] ***
124 Bima Purwoko Kurniawan, S.Pd
M Teacher English SMPN 9 Mojokerto Partner Mojokerto East Java 085230003879 [email protected] **
125 Evi Eliana, SS F Teacher English MTs Brawijaya Partner Mojokerto East Java 08179323732 [email protected] *** 126 Titik Mujianah, S.Pd F Teacher Math MTs Nurul Jadid Partner Mojokerto East Java 081330498269 ** 127 Nur Khamimah, S.Pd F Teacher Math MTs Brawijaya Partner Mojokerto East Java 085645065334 [email protected] **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
136
5.6 Working with Teacher Training Institutions and LPMP
To achieve wider impact beyond the target districts and to support improvement across the (junior secondary) education system, DBE3 worked with staff from the State University of Surabaya and the East Java Quality Assurance Institutes (LPMP). Staff of these institutions took part in the provincial BTL training programs including the training of facilitators and training of teachers. selected lecturers also participated in the classroom action research program. Details of staff from the University and LPMP taking part in various DBE3 activities are presented below.
5.6.1 Number of Staff from Universities and LPMP taking part in DBE3 training and CAR activities
Province Better
Teaching and Learning
Classroom Action
Research Total
East Java 7 5 12
5.6.2 Universities taking part in Classroom Action Research Review Meeting
A number of other universities from East Java also took part in the Classroom Action Research Review Meeting in September 2011 and expressed an interest in using the materials and being involved in future program. These were as follows:
• Universitas Negeri Surabaya
• Universitas Negeri Malang
• IAIN Sunan Ampel
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
137
5.7 Overview of Trainee Data
5.7.1 Non Formal Education Managers Trained by District in East Java
Below is a list of the number of non formal education managers by district from East Java trained on the Non-Formal Education program.
District Managers
Male Female Total
Tuban 1 8 2 10
Mojokerto 7 1 8
Sidoarjo 3 7 10
Surabaya 5 1 6
Bangkalan 8 2 10
Sampang 6 5 11
Tuban 2 4 4 8
Bojonegoro 5 4 9
Nganjuk 3 3 6
Pasuruan 5 1 6
Total 54 30 84
5.7.2 Non Formal Education Tutors Trained By District in East Java
Below is a list of the numbers of tutors from district in East Java trained to implement the Non-Formal Education program.
District # Tutors
Male Female Total
Tuban 1 11 9 20
Mojokerto 7 9 16
Sidoarjo 11 4 15
Surabaya 8 5 13
Bangkalan 8 2 10
Sampang 6 3 9
Tuban 2 4 4 8
Bojonegoro 6 3 9
Nganjuk 2 4 6
Pasuruan 3 5 8
Total 66 48 114
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
138
5.7.3 Number of Teachers in East Java Trained Using the Life Skills Training Program
Below is a list showing the number of teachers in each district in East Java by District, Gender and School Type trained between 2006 and 2008 to implement the Life Skills training program.
District
SMP MTs Total
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Bangkalan 43 43 86 35 47 82 78 90 168
Mojokerto 41 59 100 15 4 19 56 63 119
Sidoarjo 26 25 51 23 18 41 49 44 93
Surabaya 17 24 41 9 16 25 25 40 65
Tuban 1 15 21 36 100 37 137 115 58 173
Bojonegoro 34 39 73 47 22 68 81 61 142
Nganjuk 58 66 124 49 47 96 107 113 220
Pasurun 45 49 94 22 16 39 67 65 132
Sampang 31 33 64 22 16 37 53 49 101
Tuban 2 46 46 92 41 28 70 87 74 162
Total 356 405 761 363 251 614 718 657 1375
5.7.4 Facilitators Trained in the BTL packages
Below is a list of the numbers of participants in the District Facilitator training for the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) modules. The training included district facilitators and a number of others, mainly lecturers from teacher training universities and trainers from LPMPs.
All Districts
Participants
District Facilitators
Others Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 132 7 139
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 112 2 114
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 115 20 135
5.7.5 Number of Teachers, School Principals and Supervisors Trained in BTL Program
Below is a list of the numbers of teachers, school principals and school supervisors from or associated with partner schools trained in the BTL program. The number of school principals and supervisors trained in BTL4 appears to be fewer. This is a result of receiving separate training to support the BTL4 program and the BTL4 package being delivered through the MGMP (Teachers Working Groups), which are teacher specific organization, which school principals and supervisors do not normally attend.
All Districts Participants
Teachers Principals Supervisors Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 699 0 0 699
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 1126 50 9 1185
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 828 39 9 876
Additional School Supervisors Trained - 103 - -
The numbers of facilitators, teachers, school principals and supervisors shown as participcating in the BTL training in the tables above should not be aggregated, as they were largely the same people participating in each package of training.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
139
5.8 Dissemination of DBE3 programs
A core strategy of the DBE3 project was to develop exemplars of good practice in the partner schools and districts with the “specific intent” that these would be taken up and implemented by others to additional schools and geographical areas. Below is a summary of the dissemination of DBE3 programs in East Java by province and then by district. For more details of the dissemination program and activities see Volume 1, section ?? of this report.
5.8.1 Provincial Overview of Dissemination in East Java
Province Total # Schools
Total # Participants
Average # of Participants
Per Institution
Partner Districts
Disseminating
Non Partner Districts
Disseminating
Total Dissemination Budget (US$)
Contribution from Local
Partner (US$)
Local Contribution as a % of total budget spent
Average Cost per Trainee (US$)
East Java 1,242 7,032 5.6 8 18 277,703 247,222 89% 39
DBE3 Project 6,440 50,179 7.7 41 42 1,738,860 1,359,279 78% 35.1
% of Project Total 19.2% 14% 19.5% 42.8% 15.9% 18% East Java
5.8.2 Dissemination by District in East Java
PARTNER DISTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Kota Surabaya 390 4 6 10 1.50% 2.50%
Bangkalan 261 4 22 26 8.40% 9.90%
Kota Mojokerto 18 4 0 4 0% 22.20%
Sampang 329 4 53 57 16.10% 17.30%
Bojonegoro 220 10 45 55 20.40% 25.00%
Nganjuk 145 10 114 124 78.60% 85.50%
Sidoarjo 324 10 20 30 6.10% 9.20%
Tuban 190 10 180 190 94.70% 100.00%
Pasuruan 284 10 79 89 27.80% 31.30%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
140
NON-PARTNER
DSTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Pacitan* 115 0 1 1 0.80% 0.80%
Ponorogo* 171 0 2 2 1.10% 1.10%
Trenggalek* 108 0 1 1 0.90% 0.90%
Tulungagung* 121 0 1 1 0.80% 0.80%
Blitar* 168 0 3 3 1.70% 1.70%
Kediri* 217 0 3 3 1.30% 1.30%
Malang* 130 0 116 116 89.20% 89.20%
Jember* 492 0 3 3 0.60% 0.60%
Bangyuwangi* 266 0 3 3 1.10% 1.10%
Situbondo* 166 0 1 1 0.60% 0.60%
Jombang* 249 0 5 5 2.00% 2.00%
Madiun* 93 0 3 3 3.20% 3.20%
Magetan* 99 0 2 2 2.00% 2.00%
Ngawi* 123 0 1 1 0.80% 0.80%
Lamongan* 321 0 2 2 0.62 0.62%
Gresik* 244 0 1 1 0.40% 0.40%
Pamekasan* 295 0 16 16 5.40% 5.40%
Batu* 30 0 1 1 3.30% 3.30%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
141
5.8.3 The Impact of Dissemination
The dissemination training in schools had some positive impact. When compared to the DBE3 comparison schools the dissemination schools did considerably better on all DBE3 teaching and learning indicators (with the exception of Instructional Leadership). However, the impact on teaching and learning in dissemination schools was not as significant as that on impact on partner schools suggesting that whilst dissemination training is beneficial, direct assistance achieves better results.
5.8.4 Chart: A comparison of the Impact of DBE3 in Partner, Dissemination and Comparison Schools in East Java
5.8.1 List of District Contributions to Dissemination of DBE3 Program
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Pasuruan 104,145,934 11,747
Nganjuk 300,000,000 33,840
Tuban 281,819,100 31,790
Surabaya 10,600,000 1,195
Bangkalan 9,000,000 1,015
Total 705,565,034 79,587
5.8.2 Contributions to District Dissemination of DBE3 Innovations from MORA Budget
Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Province 111,000,000 12,408
Pasuruan 38,575,000 4,351
Bangkalan 6,700,000 756
Total 156,275,000 17,515
83.3
94.1
0
60
98
0
60
92.16
10
14.4
88.5
50
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Teachers' Skills Student Behavior Classroom
Environment
Princip al
Leadersh ip
Dissemination Schools
Partner Schools
Comparison Schools
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
142
5.9 East Java Provincial And District Development Plans And Achievements 2010 – 2011
Towards the end of 2010 all partner districts made plans to support and disseminate the DBE3 program. A summary of the plans in English and a review of the extent to which districts have implemented these plans by November 2011 is set out below.
EAST JAVA PROVINCE
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 225,000,000 No recorded budget allocation
The Office or Religious Affairs planned the dissemination of DBE3 program to MTS Principals/Supervisors/Teachers in 38 districts/towns in East Java using their own DIPA funds scheduled for August 2010. In 2011 MORA East Java planned to conduct DBE3 dissemination for 38 Districts/town between May-July 2011.
Budget allocation of IDR 1,800,000 No recorded budget allocation
East Java Provincial Education Office, supported by East Java Bappeda and East Java House proposed replication of DBE3 program in 9 Partner Districts and would cover the costs of additional training of trainer activities to add district facilitators in 9 partner districts/town (30 DF each district/town, from 5 core subjects)
900,000,000 was allocated by Provincial MONE for school quality improvement, however, it was not used to disseminate the DBE3 program as originally proposed.
BOJONEGORO
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 206.250.000 No recorded budget allocation from APBD
BTL2 and BTL3 replication for 600 teachers in 4 non-partner sub-district rayon between March-May 2011
Completed in October 2011
BTL2 replication for 375 teachers in 22 non-partner SMP/MTS between September 2010 – February 2011
No progress
A decree will be issued on the role and function of District Facilitators Joint decree by MONE and MORA to be issued shortly
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
143
PASURUAN
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 256.690.000 Budget used from APBD: IDR 104,145,934
Training of Trainers for BTL2, BTL3, BTL4 for additional District Facilitators in January-May 2011
Completed
Capacity development for School Supervisors using DBE3module in March 2011 Completed
Dissemination of DBE3 program for 10 non-partner schools in March-April 2011 Completed
BTL training for teachers in 10 partner schools teaching non-core subjects in June 2011 (teachers of Civics, Art& Culture, ICT, and Religious Study)
District MONE created a “training system”1 to disseminate the DBE3 innovations and trained 40 new District Facilitators in May using BTL2 and BTL3. These Facilitators trained 480 teachers from 60 SMPN from May to July. Disseminated DBE3 modules at KKM level under MORA.
A decree will be issued by the Head of Pasuruan Education Office on DF and school level training activities.
The District Education Office sent a Decree to Pasuruan District Head for DF to develop a DBE3 learning model in the District, and to make a work plan with regards to developing DBE3 program in Pasuruan and in the Education Office.
A model will be formed to further develop DBE3 model in 2012. This will be called PKGMP (Peningkatan Kinerja Guru Mata Pelajaran/ Teachers’ Performance Improvement) using APBD fund of Rp. 700.000.000
Currently in progress for implementation in 2012
1 The Education Office in Pasuruan use ‘base camp’ system to disseminate DBE3 programs. Schools are divided into groups according to geographic areas. For each area, a school is appointed as a DBE3 base camp to act as a learning centre for DBE3 programs. There are currently 5 DBE3 base camps representing different sub districts. The base camps are: SMPN 1 Beji which supports 19 other SMP: SMPN 2 Gempol which looks after 9 SMP: SMPN 1 Purwosari taking training 11 other SMP: SMON 2 Grati, an umbrella for 14 SMP and SMPN Gondang Wetan I, an umbrella for15 SMP. From the 5 base camp schools 40 new DF were hired to conduct the teacher training for the schools they are responsible for. This dissemination strategy shows the commitment of Pasuruan Education Office to sustain change that was brought about by DBE, and to ensure a lasting change even after the program has ended.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
144
SIDOARJO
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 201.605.000 No recorded budget allocation from APBD
Study visit by non-partner school to DBE3 partner schools scheduled for early March 2011
No progress
TOT BTL2, BTL3 and BTL4 for additional facilitators scheduled for April and May 2011
Completed
Capacity development of school supervisors using DBE3 module scheduled for May and June 2011
Completed
Dissemination of BTL 2, BTL3 and BTL4 modules in 5 non-partner sub-district (Waru, Jabon, Candi, Balungbendo, Tanggulangin) for SMP and MTS scheduled for March and May 2011
Completed in Candi
No progress in other sub districts
Post-training mentoring for teachers, by 40 District Facilitators No progress
Cluster system established to develop the DBE3 model Completed
A Decree issued by the Education Office with regards to the role of the District Facilitators
Completed
School Supervisors assigned by Head of Education Office, and development of report on the results of post-training mentoring activity
Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
145
TUBAN
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 738.244.300 Budget used from APBD: IDR 281,819,100
BTL2 training for 500 teachers from non partner schools through 6 cluster MGMP scheduled for October 2010
Completed
Post-training mentoring for teachers who participated in BTL2 training Completed TOT BTL3 for 50 additional District Facilitators (Cluster) scheduled for October 2010
Completed
BTL3 training for 500 teachers of non-partner schools through 6 clusters MGMP scheduled for November-December 2010
Completed
Post-training mentoring for teachers participated in BTL3 training Completed
TOT BTL4 for 50 additional District Facilitators (Cluster) scheduled for early 2011 No progress (planned for early 2012)
BTL4 training for 500 teachers of non-partner schools through 6 clusters MGMP in scheduled for 2011
No progress
Post-training mentoring for non-partner teachers participated in BTL4 training scheduled for 2011
No progress
Internship for 50 additional DF in partner schools in 2011 No progress
Showcase for partner schools in 2011 Completed BTL 2 and 3 training for all-subjects teachers in cluster 4 (7 SMPN and 2 private SMP) total participants131 teachers
Completed
A Decree is issued by Head of Education Office regarding the District Facilitators Completed
Formation of a District Facilitator Forum Completed Circular letter from Head of Education Office on the implementation of DBE3 program
Completed
Letter of Assignment is issued for District Facilitators Completed
A Decree issued by the Head of MORA regarding District Facilitators. Completed Letter of Assignment issued for District Facilitators by MORA Completed
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
146
NGANJUK
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 432.532.500 Budget used from APBD: IDR 300,000,000
TOT BTL 2, BTL3 and BTL4 in July-August 2011 No progress Formation and strengthening of District Facilitator Forum in August 2011 No progress Capacity building workshop for School Principals and Supervisors scheduled for April 2011
No progress
Instructional Leadership training for school principals and supervisors scheduled for April 2011
No progress
Study visit to DBE3 partner schools in other districts in July 2011 No progress Dissemination of BTL2 for 390 teachers in 6 cluster non-partner schools (4-5 SMP and MTs per cluster) scheduled for November-December 2010
Completed
Dissemination of BTL2 for 150 non-core subjects in partner schools in scheduled for January 2011
No progress
Independent dissemination of BTL3 for teachers of Science, Social Science, Mathematics, Indonesian and English scheduled for April 2011
No progress
Independent dissemination of BTL2 and BTL3 in non partner schools scheduled for September and October 2011
No progress
A joint Decree will be issued by Education Office and MORA regarding the role and function of DF
No progress
Circular letter on Development of Progress Report from School and MTS Principals with regards to implementation of Active learning.
No progress
Establishment of a cluster system with DBE3 partner school as the model No progress A joint Decree will be issued by the Education Office and MORA on the allocation of 15% School Budget for teaching and learning quality improvement in all schools
No progress
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
147
5.10 List of DBE3 Technical, Management and Administrative Staff in East Java, August 2011
DBE3 – LIFE SKILLS EDUCATION Provincial Office – East Java
Name Position Residential Address Phone Numbers Didik Yudhi Ranu Prasetyo
Provincial Coordinator (East Java)
Rungkut Asri Barat XIX/15
Res: (031) 8703652 Cell : 0813 3089 9363 / 0812 3179 441
Kuswanto Senior Education Officer Jl. Klakahrejo no. 55 RTVI RW 02 Kel. Klakahrejo Kec BenowoSurabaya Res: 03171090401 Cell: 0813 308 99365
Nugroho Arif Prabowo
Communication&Advocacy Officer
Jl. Srigunting 8 No. 16 RT. 007 RW 001 Manahan Banjarsari Surakarta Res: Cell: 08113423797
Jalil District Coordinator Perum Kertosari Indah Blok A/2 Ponorogo Res: (0352) 486 580 Cell: 0813 3089 9361 / 0815 5651 4595
Ali Imron
District Coordinator Jl. Jaksa Agung Suprapto No. 33A, Sampang, Madura Res: Cell: 0813 3089 9368
Adi Suprayitno District Coordinator Jl. Kampung Malang kulon I/54 Surabaya Res: 031 5459265 Cell: 0811 373606 / 0813 30726460
Oktin Catur Palupi
District Coordinator Doplang RT/RW 02/01 Doplang Purworejo
Res: Cell: 08113428695
Endri Rahmawati District Coordinator
Jl. Raya Sukowati, kapas Bojonegoro Res: Cell:08113452982
Khundori Muhammad
District Coordinator Wisma Lidah Kulon Blok A 73 Surabaya
Res: Cell: 0815 53214092
Endah Erawati Admin & Finance Officer
Delta Mandala II No. 137 Sidoarjo Res: Cell: 0811 342 8694
Nuke Wahyuniawati
Administration Assistant Jl. Sukarasa No. 107, Cibodas Lembang Bandung 40391 Res : (021) 2785094 Cell : 08113428693 / 0812 8645407
Novariana Gameswari
Finance Assistant Jl Manukan Peni Gang V Blok 14C No.19, Tandes-Surabaya Res: Cell: 081331315629
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
149
6. SOUTH SULAWESI PROVINCIAL REPORT
This annex contains information and data concerning the implementation of the DBE3 project in South Sulawesi from 2005 to 2011. It should be read in conjunction with Volume I of the DBE3 Final Project Report, which contains a detailed account of the project activities.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
151
6.1 Map of Project Coverage in South Sulawesi
Below is a map showing the districts in which the DBE3 program has been implemented in South Sulawesi. There are 9 partner districts, with whom DBE had a formal agreement and 1 non-partner district, where there was no formal agreement but in which the program was also disseminated.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
152
6.2 District Performance on the DBE3 Project
6.2.1 Highlights of District and Provincial Performance in South Sulawesi
DISTRICT OUTSTANDING ACHIEVEMENT
GOOD PRACTICES SUSTAINIBILITY ACTIVITY
Soppeng 1. Decree Letter from the Bupati for DFs
as resource persons of the Better
Teaching and Learning program
2. Instruction Letter of the Regent to the
all School Principals to apply active
learning
3. Dissemination of the teacher training on
the BTL2 to all SMP using BOS funds
and the district annual budget (APBD),
directly monitored by the Education
Office Head of the Basic Education.
4. Dissemination of the teacher training
on BTL2 for all MTs, revitalizing the
KKM, directly monitored by the Head of
MORA, and Schools division
1. Setting up a DF Forum, facilitated by the
Education office providing secretary,
office and inventory.
2. MOU between the MORA and District
Education office to involve the
supervisors and DFs to provide technical
assistance and train teachers applying
active learning, and school principals of
the MTs
3. MTs Negeri Takalala and SMPN 1
Liliirilau as target schools to visit by
other schools to observe directly the
application of active learning
4. Showcase of student’s works resulted
from active learning was set up as annual
activity of District Education and MORA
while commemorating the National
Education Day.
1. Dissemination of BTL 3 and 4 for all SMP,
using BOS funding, directly monitored by the
Head of the Division for Basic Education of
the District Education office.
2. Addition of district facilitators by the District
Education office (Basic Education)
3. Dissemination of the BTL 3 and 4 for MTs,
using BOS funding, directly monitored by the
head of MORA
4. District Education and Bappeda drafted a
dissemination budget of BTL3 and 4 for the
2012 annual budget. It took place in
November 2011.
5. Study visit to other target district, to partner
schools of DBE3. November 2011: school
principals, teacher, and students of MTsN
Takalala, as well as the MORA staff visited
SMPN 1 Tellulimpoe Sidrap
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
153
DISTRICT OUTSTANDING ACHIEVEMENT
GOOD PRACTICES SUSTAINIBILITY ACTIVITY
Sidrap 1. Decree of the chair of Education Office
assigned DFs as resource persons for
the Better Teaching and Learning
program
2. The 2011 Program of MORA office:
carried out dissemination of BTL 2 for
all MTs in Sidrap, using the DAK funding
1. Setting up of DF Forum, facilitated by
the District MGMP board by providing
secretary, office and office inventory
2. The target school of DBE3: SMP Negeri
1 Tellulimpoe, SMPN 4 Duapitue, MTs
YMPI Rappang (private) and non target
school SMPN 1 Empagae become target
schools to visit to learn more on the
application of active learning
3. Showcase of students works resulting
from active learning was set up as an
annual activity of District Education
office and MORA while commemorating
the National Education Day.
1. MOU of the district MGMP Forum and the
DF Forum Sidrap and the District Education
office, the project P2TK with allocation of
Rp. 90 million for teacher training articularly
for the subjects Science, Social Studies and
Bahasa Indonesia.
2. SMPN 1 Tellulimpoe received a study visit
team from MTsN Takalala, district Soppeng,
late November 2011
Pinrang 1. Decree Letter of the Head of Education
Office assigned DFs as resource persons
for Better Teaching and Learning
2. Education Office carried out teacher
training dissemination in 2010 of BTL 2
for all SMP teachers of the five main
subjects in Pinrang, using BOS funding.
3. 25 district facilitators (15 DFs DBE3 plus
10 new DFs appointed by Education
Office and district supervisor
coordinator) assigned as resource
persons for teacher capacity building
program.
1. Showcase of students’ work resulting
from active learning was set up an annual
activity of District Education office and
MORA while commemorating the
National Education Day.
2. SMPN 4 and SMPN 1 Pinrang have
become target schools to visit for other
schools to observe directly the
application of active learning.
1. District MGMP and Supervisor Coordinator
drafted a teacher training dissemination
program for the module BTL3 and 4, using
the BOS funding. It was directly monitored
by the Head of the Education Office.
2. The Head of Education Office does intensive
monitoring of the operation of active
learning at school level
Palopo 1. Decree Letter of the Head of Education 1. Showcase of students’ work resulting 1. University of Cokroaminoto trained its 550
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
154
DISTRICT OUTSTANDING ACHIEVEMENT
GOOD PRACTICES SUSTAINIBILITY ACTIVITY
Office, assigning 20 District Facilitators
(5 additional DFs) as resource persons
for Better Teaching and Learning, and
teacher capacity building program as
well.
2. All SMPs in Palopo held teacher training
dissemination of the BTL2 using BOS
funding and APBD (district budget)
3. The Education Office office appointed 5
new district facilitators as additional DFs
from active learning was set up as annual
activity of District Education and MORA
while commemorating the National
Education Day.
2. SMPN 5, 3 dan 8 Palopo become target
schools to visit for observation of active
learning
3. Best Active Learning Teacher
Competition. The Education Office
office selected 10 best teachers applying
Better Teaching and Learning.
students using the module BTL2 and 3 prior
to their PKL (practical teaching program at
school level). It took place on 3-4 and 11-12
October. Initiated by the Education Office.
2. Teacher supervisor of SMP and district
MGMP forum drafted teacher training
program involving all district facilitators.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
155
6.2.2 Assessment of Partner District Performance
The performance and impact of the DBE3 program has been varied in the different districts and schools. Below is an assessment of the performance of the DBE3 partner districts in South Sulawesi.
The criteria used were as follows:
• Level of commitment of local stakeholders
• Impact on partner schools
• Extent of project dissemination achieved
Each of the criteria is rated on a scale of one to three – with three being the highest rating. This has resulted in an overall star rating for each districts. Three stars in the highest rating and denotes a high level of stakeholder commitment, a generally high impact on practice in partner schools and a considerable amount of dissemination to non-partner schools. A rating of one star denotes a low level in each of these criteria.
SOUTH SULAWESI
CO
HO
RT
EX
TE
NS
ION
/
CO
RE
Lo
cal G
overn
men
t
Sta
ff C
om
mit
men
t
Imp
act
on
Sch
oo
ls
Rep
lica
tio
n
alr
ead
y t
aken
pla
ce
Fu
nd
ing f
or
R
ep
lica
tio
n
Overa
ll R
an
kin
g
1. Pangkep 1&2 C 1 2 2 2 **
2. Enrekang 1 &2 C 1 1 1 1 *
3. Soppeng 1&2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
4. Palopo 1 & 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
5. Pinrang 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
6. Sidenreng Rappang 2 E 3 3 3 3 ***
7. Makassar 2 E 2 2 2 2 **
8. Jeneponto 1 & 2 C 1 2 1 1 *
9. Luwu 2 C 1 1 2 1 *
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
156
6.3 List of Non-Formal Service Providers
Below is a list non-formal service providers with whom DBE3 worked between 2006 and 2008.
District NFE Provider Learners Tutors
M F Total M F Total
Palopo PKBM Melati 7 31 38 3 5 8
PKBM Paradigma 5 10 15 4 3 7
PKBM Wisata Indah 7 13 20 4 3 7
PP Modern Datuk Sulaiman Putri 8 12 20 12 9 21
LSM Walacea 9 12 21 5 3 8
Soppeng PKBM Harmonis 50 50 200 11 13 24
PKBM Lompengeng 55 65 120 20 22 42
LSM Padi 20 14 34 3 2 5
LSM Sumpunglolo 1 9 10 1 2 3
Pangkep PKBM Tunas Muda 5 14 19 7 12 19
PKBM Sempurna 12 45 47 10 10 20
Pesantren Mujahidin 36 15 51 9 5 14
Pesantren DDI Baru-Baru Tanga 8 7 15 3 3 6
Enrekang PKBM Melati 50 30 80 15 13 28
PKBM Sofi Ganesa 14 7 21 5 7 12
LSM Bambapuang 56 76 132 14 15 29
LSM Sulawesi Baru 17 12 29 7 9 16
LSM Sylvia Karya* 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jeneponto PKBM Sejati 15 16 21 7 8 15
PKBM Nur Alif 12 8 20 3 7 10
PKBM Permata Jaya 15 15 30 5 4 9
Pesantren Madaniyah 35 13 48 6 3 9
YPPLS 20 40 60 12 8 20
Pinrang PKBM Sipatokkong 19 31 50 7 5 12
PonPes Ddi Lerang Lerang 18 2 20 5 2 7
PKBM Padaidi* 0 0 0 0 0 0
Sidrap PKBM Kharisma 2 8 10 0 2 2
PKBM Arya 14 6 20 3 3 6
PKBM Yayasan Empat Lima 8 12 20 3 3 6
PP DDI Nurul Haq Bt Lewo 0 0 0 0 0 0
Luwu PKBM Sawerigading 9 2 11 10 10 20
PKBM Al Haq 33 20 53 4 2 6
PKBM Purnama 12 15 27 5 1 6
PonPes Bajo 120 99 219 16 24 40
Makassar PKBM Ratulangi (Yasinal) 15 3 18 2 2 4
PKBM Toddopuli 3 17 20 2 6 8
PKBM Sipakatau 45 56 51 10 5 15
PonPes Islam Al Irsyad 11 7 18 5 2 7
Total 38 766 792 1558 238 233 471
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
157
6.4 Partner Schools and an Assessment of Their Performance
6.4.1 The Whole School Training Program
During the first three years of the project teacher training modules were developed, as well as subject teaching modules for the English, civics and mathematics. Facilitators were trained to deliver these modules and used them to train the partner schools in each of the 44 project districts, which joined the project in two cohorts in 2006 and 2007.
From the beginning of 2009 DBE3 focused primarily on a more intensive program in formal junior secondary schools, SMP and MTs intitally in 25 “extension” districts from existing cohort 1 and 2 districts in which to implement a more in-depth DBE3 school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement. The program included:
• An increase in the number of directly supported schools in each of the extension districts, in most cases from four to ten, in order to create a greater presence and critical mass;
• The implementation of a school training program based on a “whole school integrated approach” to quality improvement which involves training teachers of all core subjects, school principals and other senior management staff in partner schools.
The whole school program was later extended to the remaining 19 ‘core’ districts in late 2009 but without the selection of additional partner schools in those districts.
Below is a list of partner schools that took part in the whole school training program. The original cohort 1 and 2 schools are indicated in the list by pink shading, while the additional schools in the 25 extension districts, which joined the project in 2009 are left unshaded.
6.4.2 How the Partner School Assessment was Done
DBE3 undertook an evaluation of these schools which was completed in August 2011. An instrument was developed to assess which schools are implementing DBE3 innovations well and are worth visiting. The instrument evaluated 4 key areas of the school performance:
• Teacher Activities: To what degree the teachers encourage interaction among students provide challenging and varied tasks (discussion, experimentation, problem solving) and use formative assessment techniques.
• Student Activities: To what degree the student activities vary (working cooperatively, solving
problems, experimenting), they express their own thoughts orally and in writing and use a variety of media in their lessons.
• Classroom Environment: To what degree the students in the school sit, work and interact in
groups, work is displayed on the wall and if they learn using more diverse sources (media, environment)
• Principal Leadership: To what degree the Principal in the school encourags change, supports
the professional development of teachers and supports other innovations in the school
Following the evaluation, each school was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest. A ‘-‘ rating has been given to schools which showed little or no impact.
3 2 1 0
Category
Schools implementing the results of the DBE3 program well and widely, and there is a strong recommendation to visit.
Schools applying DBE3 results well in some classes but not widely there is encouragement to visit
The application of the results of the DBE3 program is limited and there is no encouragemet to visit.
There are no visible results of the DBE3 program.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
158
6.4.3 List of Training Received
The data for the partner schools in South Sulawesi including the results of the assessment are set out on the next page. It also indicates the training packages which have been received by each school and are indicated by A, B, C and D as set out in the table below.
A: Cohort 1 District Schools B: Cohort 2 District Schools
Life Skills Program (2005 – 2009)
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
School Retention Toolkit
A* also included Mathematics module
Better Teaching and Learning 1
Integrating Life Skills Education into Classroom Practice
ICT for Life Skills Education
Civics Modules
English Modules
Non Curricular Toolkits
B* also included Mathematics Module
C: Extension District Schools D: Core Districts Schools
Whole School Approach (2009 – 2011)
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
How to Use ICT in BTL
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
Better Teaching and Learning2
Better Teaching and Learning3
Better Teaching and Learning4
Increasing the Capacity of School Principals and Supervisors
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
159
6.4.4 List of DBE Partner Schools in South Sulawesi and an Assessment of their Performance
The original partner schools which participated in the project before the expansion to ten schools in each extension district are highlighted in pink.
SOUTH SULAWESI
Extension Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP Muhammadiyah Watansoppeng SMP Private Lalabata Soppeng A & C 86 84 170 7 11 18 **
2 MTs N Takalala MTs State Marioriwawo Soppeng C 148 173 321 13 36 49 ***
3 SMP N 3 Watansoppeng SMP State Lalabata Soppeng C 219 206 425 11 33 44 ***
4 SMP N 1 Watansoppeng SMP State Lalabata Soppeng A & C 363 315 678 21 43 64 **
5 MTs Perguruan Islam Ganra MTs Private Ganra Soppeng C 90 63 153 8 13 21 **
6 MTs Yasrib Lapajung MTs Private Lapajung Soppeng A & C 110 49 159 18 13 31 **
7 SMP N 1 Marioriwawo SMP State Marioriwawo Soppeng C 225 231 456 11 27 38 *
8 SMP N 1 Lilirilau SMP State Lilirilau Soppeng A & C 372 382 754 20 37 57 ***
9 SMP N 1 Liliriaja SMP State Liliriaja Soppeng C 205 201 406 17 22 39 *
10 SMP Muhammadiyah Lajoa SMP Private Liliriaja Soppeng C 74 64 138 8 14 22 **
11 MTs DDI Amparita MTS Private Tellu Limpoe Sidrap C 65 73 138 11 12 23 ***
12 MTs N Baranti MTsN State Baranti Sidrap C 247 296 543 20 28 48 ***
13 MTs YMPI Rappang MTs Private Panca Rijang Sidrap C 267 239 506 17 18 35 ***
14 SMP N 1 Panca Rijang SMPN State Panca Rijang Sidrap C 318 390 708 15 28 43 ***
15 SMP N 1 Tellu Limpoe SMPN State Tellu Limpoe Sidrap C 304 347 651 21 19 40 ***
16 SMP N 2 Baranti SMPN State Baranti Sidrap C 217 183 400 16 19 35 ***
17 MTs DDI Ma'had MTs Private Maritengngae Sidrap B & C 50 56 106 5 12 17 **
18 SMP N 4 Dua Pitue SMP State Pitu Riawa Sidrap B & C 217 239 456 11 15 26 ***
19 MTs N Pangsid MTsN State Maritengngae Sidrap B & C 92 88 180 18 16 34 *
20 SMP N 1 Pangkajene SMPN State Maritengngae Sidrap B & C 313 422 735 17 28 45 **
21 SMP N 2 Palopo SMP State Wara Timur Palopo C 301 379 680 15 31 46 **
22 SMP N 3 Palopo SMP State Wara Timur Palopo A & C 507 539 1.046 16 48 64 *
23 SMP N 4 Palopo SMP State Wara Timur Palopo A & C 368 356 724 11 38 49 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
160
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
24 SMP N 5 Palopo SMP State Bara Palopo C 291 258 549 8 29 37 ***
25 SMP N 6 Palopo SMP State Mungkajang Palopo C 475 383 858 16 37 53 **
26 SMP N 8 Palopo SMP State Bara Palopo C 436 394 830 21 29 50 ***
27 SMP N 9 Palopo SMP State Tellu Wanua Palopo A & C 277 290 567 12 23 35 ***
28 MTs N Model Palopo MTs State Wara Timur Palopo A & C 464 483 947 21 39 60 *
29 SMP Kristen SMP Private Wara Timur Palopo C 131 127 258 10 14 24 *
30 SMP N 10 Palopo SMP State Wara Selatan Palopo C 143 152 295 5 23 28 ***
31 MTs N Pinrang MTs State Watang Sawitto Pinrang B & C 215 209 424 26 36 62 **
32 SMP N 1 Mattiro Bulu SMP State Mattiro Bulu Pinrang B & C 438 475 913 15 29 44 *
33 SMP N 5 Pinrang SMP State Watang Sawitto Pinrang B & C 389 361 750 16 26 42 ***
34 SMP N 1 Pinrang SMP State Watang Sawitto Pinrang B & C 343 547 890 31 30 61 **
35 SMP N 4 Pinrang SMP State Watang Sawitto Pinrang C 422 376 798 15 16 31 ***
36 SMP N 2 Mattiro Bulu SMP State Mattiro Bulu Pinrang C 228 237 465 14 13 27 **
37 SMP N 1 Mattiro Sompe SMP State Mattiro Sompe Pinrang C 317 378 695 14 19 33 **
38 SMP N 1 Cempa SMP State Cempa Pinrang C 277 271 548 17 19 36 ***
39 MTs DDI Palirang MTs Sawsta Patampanua Pinrang C 54 63 117 7 5 12 **
40 MTs DDI Patobong MTS Private Mattiro Sompe Pinrang C 75 68 143 15 6 21 **
41 SMP YP PGRI Makassar SMP Private Mamajang Makassar B* & C 274 293 567 7 19 26 ***
42 SMP N 11 Makassar SMP State Tamalanrea Makassar B* & C 357 330 687 15 24 39 **
43 SMP N 1 Makassar SMP State Mamajang Makassar C 504 613 1.117 16 50 66 **
44 SMP N 23 Makassar SMP State Panakkukang Makassar C 521 656 1.177 14 41 55 **
45 SMP Muhammadiyah I SMP Private Makassar Makassar C 232 192 424 9 20 29 ***
46 SMP N 26 Makassar SMP State Tamalate Makassar C 344 313 657 20 29 49 **
47 SMP Pesantren IMMIM Putra SMP Private Tamalanrea Makassar B* & C 609 0 609 30 23 53 **
48 SMP N 36 Makassar SMP State Biringkanaya Makassar C 334 327 661 14 27 41 **
49 MTs N Biringkanaya MTs State Biringkanaya Makassar C 544 576 1.120 31 48 79 **
50 SMP N 33 Makassar SMP State Rappocini Makassar C 468 501 969 17 38 55 ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
161
SOUTH SULAWESI
Core Districts
No. School Name SMP/MTs State/Private Sub District District Training Received
Number of Students Number of Teachers Assess-ment Male Female Total Male Female Total
1 SMP N 2 Belopa SMP State Kamanre Luwu B & D 313 386 699 13 30 43 **
2 SMP N 3 Belopa SMP State Belopa Luwu B & D 252 261 513 15 28 43 **
3 MTs N Belopa MTs State Belopa Utara Luwu B & D 203 203 406 19 26 45 **
4 SMP N 1 Bajo SMP State Bajo Luwu B & D 317 348 665 20 25 45 ***
5 SMP N 1 Anggeraja SMP State Anggeraja Enrekang A & D 352 425 777 15 31 46 **
6 SMP N 1 Enrekang SMP State Enrekang Enrekang A & D 347 447 794 15 21 36 ***
7 SMP N 2 Enrekang SMP State Enrekang Enrekang A & D 313 387 700 14 29 43 **
8 MTs DDI Enrekang MTs Private Enrekang Enrekang A & D 29 12 41 10 10 20 *
9 SMP N 2 Pangkajene SMP State Pangkajene Pangkep A & D 417 545 962 27 41 68 **
10 MTs N Ma'rang MTs State Marang Pangkep A & D 264 267 531 25 30 55 ***
11 SMP N 1 Ma'rang SMP State Marang Pangkep A & D 224 226 450 15 33 48 ***
12 MTs Darussalam MTs Private Pangkajene Pangkep A & D 95 98 193 12 18 30 **
13 SMP N 4 Tamalatea SMP State Tamalatea Jeneponto A & D 99 129 228 9 11 20 ***
14 SMP N 1 Bangkala SMP State Bangkala Jeneponto A & D 302 351 653 15 15 30 *
15 MTs N Bangkala MTs State Bangkala Jeneponto A & D 61 85 146 11 18 29 *
16 MTs N Binamu MTs State Binamu Jeneponto A & D 387 329 716 21 30 51 ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
162
6.5 District Facilitators / Performance Assessment
6.5.1 List of District Facilitators for Non Formal Education in South Sulawesi
Below is a list of facilitators from South Sulawesi trained to support the Non-Formal Education program.
Name Position District Subject
Dra. Hj. Siiti Aminah Kepala Sub. Bag. Tata Usaha Kandepag Pangkep Management
Suriati, S. Sos Staff Bidang Diklusepora Pangkep Teaching and Learning
Nur Alim, SE, MA Kepala Seksi Kurikulum Dikmenjur Dinas Jeneponto Management
Farida, S.Pd Kasi Pekapontren Depag Jeneponto Teaching and Learning
Drs. Danial, S PNS Dinas Soppeng Management
Drs. Hj. A. Barlian DL Staff Kandepag Soppeng Teaching and Learning
Tien Suharti, S.Pd PLS Dinas Dikpora Enrekang Teaching and Learning
Achmad Tamsil Staff Kandepag Kota Enrekang Management
Ichwan Tamsil Penilik PLS Kecamatan Palopo Management
Drs. Bahtiar Sekertaris Forum PKBM Palopo Teaching and Learning
Kasman, S.Pd. M.Pd. Ketua PKBM Bina Insan Kamil Makassar Management
Syamsul Pattinjo, S.Ag. Direktur LKPMP Makassar Management
Sriyenty Ridwan, S.Sos Direktris LP3NF Makassar Teaching and Learning
M. Kasim Muis, S.Ag. Pengelola LSM Makassar Teaching and Learning
Hermanto, S.Ag Pengelola PKBM Seruni Makassar Management
Drs. Muh. Arfah Guru SMAN 1 Pinrang Pinrang Teaching and Learning
Muhammad Faisal, S.Pd Guru SMPN 2 Mattirobulu Pinrang Management
Merchy Alma Soutan, S.Sos Guru SMAN 1 Lembang Pinrang Teaching and Learning
Drs. Gunawan Pengawas SMP, SMA & SMK Diknas Sidrap Management
Abd. Rahman, S.Pd.I Guru Pontren Nurul Haq Benteng Lewo Sidrap Teaching and Learning
Santi Sainu Guru SD 2 Lainungan/Tutor Paket C Sidrap Teaching and Learning
Sirajuddin Tutor Paket B Sidrap Management
Syakri, SE. PLS Diknas Luwu Luwu Teaching and Learning
Bunayya Kana, S.Pd. Tutor Paket B Luwu Teaching and Learning
Hudiani, S.Ag. Pengelola PKBM Luwu Management
Eti Jubaedah, S.Sos. Pengelola PKBM Tallang Indah Suli Luwu Management
6.5.2 List of District Facilitators for the Life Skills Training Program in South Sulawesi 2006 – 2008
Below is a list of facilitators from South Sulawesi trained to implement the Life Skills program.
Name Position Module District Institution
Pammusu, S.Pd, MM. Supervisor English Jeneponto SMP/SMA
Irwanto, S.Pd Teacher English Jeneponto SMP 1 Bangkala
Orban, S.Pd Teacher ICT Jeneponto SMAN 1 Binamu
Baso Labo, S.Pd,MM Vice Kasek ICT Jeneponto SMPN4 Binamu
H. Buluk Tantu, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Jeneponto SMPN1 Binamu
Drs. Muh. Jalil Pattah, MM. Supervisor Life Skills Jeneponto SMP/SMA
Drs.H.Yuddin, M.Pd. Supervisor BTL Jeneponto SMP/SMK
St. Suriani D, S.Pd Teacher BTL Jeneponto SMAN1 Binamu
Muh. Aslam Akib, S.Pd Teacher Civics Jeneponto SMAN1 Batang
Ahmad Basri, S.Ag, M.Pd. Teacher Civics Jeneponto Guu MTsN Binamu
Drs. Yusuf Timang S. Civil Servant English Enrekang
Nasarullah MPd. Teacher English Enrekang SMPN 4 Anggerja
Arif Candik, S.Pd.M.Pd. Teacher ICT Enrekang SMA 1 Baraka
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
163
Name Position Module District Institution
Drs. H. Mustafa Teacher ICT Enrekang SMA 1 Anggeraja
Dra. Handayani Principal Life Skills Enrekang SDN 50
Suardam Djamadi Teacher Life Skills Enrekang SMAN 1 Anggeraja
Drs. Hamzah Mundi, MM Civil Servant BTL Enrekang
Drs. Roket, M Pd Civil Servant BTL Enrekang
Nasruddin, S Pd Teacher Civics Enrekang SMPN 1 Enrekang
Agus, S Pd, M Si Teacher Civics Enrekang SMPN 7 Alla
H.Hasan, S.Pd, M.Pd Teacher English Pangkep SMAN 1 Bungoro
Dra. St. Salmiah Teacher English Pangkep MTsN Ma'rang
Muhammd Adil BG Koordinator Teknis
ICT ICT Pangkep Dinas Diknas Pangkep
Mansyur Eppe, S.Pd, M.Pd Teacher ICT Pangkep SMPN 2 Pangkep
Drs. M. Arsyad, M.Ag. Kasi Mapenda Life Skills Pangkep Depag Pangkep
Jamaluddin, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Pangkep SMPN 1 Ma'rang
Abd. Basir, S.Pd Teacher Civics Pangkep SMAN 1 Labakkang
Hamsah Abar, S.Pd Teacher Civics Pangkep SMPN 2 Pangkajene
Abd. Madjid, S.Pd Teacher BTL Pangkep Penata Tk. I/III/D
Dra.H. Nurmini Teacher BTL Pangkep MTs Ma'rang
Magdalena, S Pd Teacher English Palopo SMP 1
Dra. Harolina Teacher English Palopo SMAN 3
Akram, S. Pd. Kasi ICT Palopo Diknas
Lukman, S Pd Teacher ICT Palopo SMP 8
Hamzah, S. Pd. Teacher Life Skills Palopo SMPN 8
Arifin, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Palopo SMAN 4
Drs.Yohanis Toban Civil Servant BTL Palopo PNS
Sulastri, S Pd Teacher BTL Palopo SMP 2
Drs. Hamzah Teacher Civics Palopo SMA 1
Dra. Murpah Teacher Civics Palopo SMPN 5
Karim, S.Pd Teacher English Soppeng SMAN1
Dra.Hj.St.Halimah, M.Si Supervisor English Soppeng Dikdas
HanICT, S.Pd Kasi Kurikulum ICT Soppeng Dikdas
Drs.M.Yuliawan Teacher ICT Soppeng SMAN1 Liliriaja
Sandang, S.Pd Teacher Life Skills Soppeng SMAN1 Liliriaja
Drs.Nur Alim, M.Pd Teacher Life Skills Soppeng SMPN3 Watansoppeng
Drs.Muh.Basri, M.Si Supervisor BTL Soppeng SMP/SMK
Drs. Sultan, M.Pd Supervisor BTL Soppeng SMP/SMA/SMK
Baraniah, S.Pd Teacher Civics Soppeng SMPN1 Watansoppeng
Hj. Awaliah, S.Pd Supervisor Civics Soppeng Dikmenum
Syamsul Bahri, SS. Teacher English Pinrang SMPN 3 Tirosompa, Pinrang
Drs. Syahrir Teacher English Pinrang SMPN 4 Pirang
Drs. Rustan Teacher English Pinrang SMPN 1 Patampanua, Pinrang
Hj. Hariani, S.Pd. Teacher Civics Pinrang SMPN 1 Pinrang
Dra. Rasnah Teacher Civics Pinrang SMPN 1 Tirobulu, Pinrang
Hj. Nuralam, S.Pd. Supervisor Civics Pinrang SMP
Pawadjangi, S.Pd. Supervisor BTL Pinrang SMP
Hj. Luli Widyastuti, S.Pd. Supervisor BTL Pinrang SMP
Drs. Muhammad Tahir, M.Pd. Supervisor LSE Pinrang SMP
Drs. Ansyar Teacher LSE Pinrang MAN Pinrang
Muh. Sadik, S.Pd. Teacher ICT Pinrang SMPN 1 Pinrang
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
164
Name Position Module District Institution
Hasrijal, S.Pd. Supervisor ICT Pinrang Pengawas SMP
Ratna Haris, S.Pd. Teacher English Makassar SMAN 16
Muhammad Yusran, S.Pd, M.Hum.
Teacher English Makassar SMAN 9
Drs. Hasbullah, M.Pd. Teacher English Makassar MTsN Model
Drs. Nurdin Tawang Teacher Mathematics Makassar SMPN 23
Irwan, S.Si, M.Si. Lecturer Mathematics Makassar UIN
Pantja Nur Wahidin, S.Pd, M.Pd. Teacher Mathematics Makassar SMAN 14
Drs. Kasafuddin K. Lalijo, S.H. Principal Civics Makassar SMPN 11
Sutaji, S.Pd. Teacher Civics Makassar SMPN 6
Ansar Abdullah, S.Pd, M.Pd. Lecturer Civics Makassar FKIP Univ. 45
Dra.St. Nasrah Principal BTL Makassar SMP PGRI
Abdul Hajar, S.Pd, M.Pd. Teacher BTL Makassar SMAN 3
Armin Amri, S.Pd, M.M. Teacher LSE Makassar SMAN 15
Nurdin, S.Pd, M.Pd. Teacher LSE Makassar SMPN 27
Yasmain Gasba, S.Pd, M.Pd. Teacher ICT Makassar SMPN 13
Muhammad Syafri, S.Pd, M.Pd. Teacher ICT Makassar SMAN 3
Muh. Natsir, S.Pd. M.Si. Teacher English Sidrap SMPN 1 Pangkajene
Hariani Ilyas, S.Ag. Teacher English Sidrap MTsN Pangkajene
Sudarta, S.Ag. Teacher Civics Sidrap MTs DDI Pangkajene
Drs. Agus Salim Teacher Civics Sidrap SMPN 1 Pangkajene
Drs. Abd. Salam Teacher Civics Sidrap SMPN 5 Pancarijang
Lukman, S.Pd. Teacher BTL Sidrap SMPN 2 Pancarijang
Drs. Abd. Latif Supervisor BTL Sidrap SMP/SMA
Dra. Hamdah Ali Teacher LSE Sidrap SMPN 2 Pangkajene
Zulkarnaen Mansyur, S.Ag. Teacher LSE Sidrap MA YMPI Rappang
Muh. Haddika, S.Pd. Teacher ICT Sidrap SMPN 1 Pangkajene
Mahluddin SM, S.Pd. Teacher ICT Sidrap SMPN 3 Pangkajene
Muh. Basri, S.Pd. Teacher English Luwu SMPN 1 Bajo
Idham, S.Pd. Teacher Civics Luwu SMPN 3 Belopa
Dra. Haspida Teacher Civics Luwu SMP Muhammadiyah, Bajo
Andi Rusli, S.Pd. Teacher BTL Luwu SMPN 1 Bajo
Umar, S.Pd. Teacher BTL Luwu SMPN 2 Belopa
Drs. Syaifuddin Ahmad Teacher LSE Luwu PP Modern Babussa'ada, Bajo
Deny Yasmawan, S.Pd. Teacher LSE Luwu SMAN 2 Belopa
Nurhidayah, S.Pd.I. Teacher ICT Luwu SMPN 1 Belopa
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
165
6.5.3 The District Facilitators for the Whole School Program
In order to support the implementation of the whole school training program, more usually referred to as the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, district facilitators were selected in each district jointly by local government and DBE3 staff and trained by the project. There were originally 15 facilitators (3 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each extension district and 10 facilitators (2 persons x 5 core curriculum subjects) in each core district. They have been trained to implement all or most of the BTL training modules. A number of the best facilitators from each province were also elevated to become national facilitators, which meant that they were trained in each module before the rest of the district facilitators and were then charged with implementing the training of the district facilitators. In their own districts they continued to act as district facilitators, supporting partner school and dissemination training, organizing MGMP activities and mentoring teachers after training. A list of the BTL facilitators operating as of August 2011 is included on the next page.
6.5.4 How the District Facilitator Performance Assessment was Done
In order to provide information on the effectiveness of these facilitators to those wishing to disseminate the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) program, DBE3 evaluated their performance using an instrument which focuses on a number of key areas:
• The extent to which the District Facilitator applies the training in their own work as a teacher, Principal or School Supervisor
• The extent to which the District Facilitator helps other teachers in their own school either as a teacher, Principal or Supervisor
• Their creativity in developing and implementing innovative training materials and approaches
• Their commitment as a District Facilitator for DBE3
• Their ability to relate to, communicate and interact with participants in the training and in mentoring
• Their initiative and ability to cooperate and support others District Facilitators during the training
• How effective they are as a mentor, whether they are able to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the teaching and learning process and provide good feedback to teachers
Following the evaluation, each District Facilitator was placed into one of four categories with 3 being the highest and 0 the lowest.
3 2 1 0
Category
Very good, always works hard and is very able as a Facilitator
Good in general performance and ability as a Facilitator
Average, still needs to develop some skills as a Facilitator
Rarely works and not very able as a Facilitator
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
166
6.5.5 List of Facilitators in South Sulawesi for the Whole School Training Program and Performance Assessment
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
SOUTH SULAWESI 1 Namrullah, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 1 Maiwa Non Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081241933846 [email protected] *** 2 M. Aseng, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 2 Enrekang Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081242565663 ** 3 Drs. Arson Pata, M.Pd M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Dikpora Enrekang Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 085255076688 [email protected] *** 4 Zuhranis Dachrud, S.Pd., M.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Anggeraja Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 085242448838 [email protected] *** 5 Muhammad. Nur. S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Baraka Non Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081342155605 * 6 Andi Darna Syam,S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Enrekang Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 085255933591 ** 7 Masnah R, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Enrekang Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 085299287957 ** 8 Dra. Jasmani Abbas F Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Anggeraja Non Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081355285761 *** 9 Hatira, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Enrekang Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081355172094 * 10 Paisal DJamardin, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Anggeraja Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081355730734 ** 11 Drs. Gunawan M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Enrekang Partner Enrekang S. Sulawesi 081343884152 ** 12 Drs. Mukhtar Suddin M Teacher English SMPN 1 Bangkala Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0813 4253 1446 [email protected] * 13 Tanrilu, S.Pd F Teacher English MTs Negeri Binamu Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0815 4301 4448 * 14 Orban, S.Pd., M.Pd M KP B. Ind SMPN 4 Tamalatea Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0815 2418 9389 *** 15 Rosnawati, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Bangkala Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0852 4214 3708 ** 16 Muh. Syarif, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Binamu Non Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0852 4220 9493 [email protected] ** 17 Fadjri, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Turatea Non Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0812 4184 0100 ** 18 Sugito, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Tamalatea Non Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0813 5561 9693 ** 19 Drs. Daeng Sihaka M Supervisor Math Dinas Pendidikan Jeneponto Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0815 2405 5510 *** 20 Nuraedah, S.Ag F Teacher Math MTs Negeri Binamu Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0815 4306 5383 [email protected] ** 21 Dra. Hj. Darmawati M F Teacher Math MTs Negeri Binmau Partner Jeneponto S. Sulawesi 0858 2364 5951 * 22 Nurhidayah, S.Pd.I F Teacher English SMPN 1 Belopa Non Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 081244667832 [email protected] *** 23 M. Basri, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 1 Bajo Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 081356764337 * 24 Aminuddin, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Bupon Non Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 081355221337 *** 25 Ramrah Wahab, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Belopa Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi
081355221337 - '081355789487
**
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
167
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
26 Retno Rusdiana, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Bajo Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 085255885939 [email protected] *** 27 Legiman, S.Pd., M.Si M Supervisor Science Dinas Dikpora Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 0852242517673 [email protected] ** 28 Drs. Abd. Hakim M Supervisor Social S. Dinas Dikpora Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 081342572623 ** 29 Darmiani Tinjo, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMPN 3 Bupon Non Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 081342250932 * 30 Lestiyanungrum, S.Pd F Teacher Math SMPN 3 Belopa Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 081355810255 *** 31 Sitti Khadijah, S.Pd F Teacher Math MTsN Belopa Partner Luwu S. Sulawesi 08124220773 ** 32 Hadrayati Ilyas, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 29 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081342946750 *** 33 Nurshiam, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 36 Makassar Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 085342016533 *** 34 Ainal Fitriani, S.Pd., M.Ed. F Teacher English SMPN 26 Makassar Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 081342477703 *** 35 Drs. Kaswadi M Teacher English SMPN 34 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081342736973 *** 36 Firman, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 8 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 08124226443 *** 37 Drs. Muh. Salih, M.Pd. M Teacher English MTsN Biringkanaya Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 081355712939 ** 38 Muhammad Nasir, S.Pd., M.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 20 Makassar Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 081241002994 *** 39 Bahrum, S.Pd., M.Pd. M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Pendidikan Makassar S. Sulawesi 08124116560 *** 40 Drs. Chairuddin Hakim, M.Pd. M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Pendidikan Makassar S. Sulawesi 085255009162 *** 41 Edawati, S.Pd. F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 24 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081343929600 *** 42 Ruslan, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 12 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081354821609 *** 43 Dra. Hj. Rostini F Teacher Science SMPN 3 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 085242308339 *** 44 Muthahhir Muchtar, S.Ag M Teacher Science MTsN Model Mks Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081342603788 *** 45 Dra. Arniati Rasyid F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Makassar Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 085696464250 *** 46 La Ode Imam Sutrisno, S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 12 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081342752503 *** 47 Dra. St. Haniah, M.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMPN 6 Makassar Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081343830187 *** 48 Hasmawati, S.Pd. F Teacher Social S. SMPN 33 Makassar Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 081242310670 *** 49 Lukman Jufri, S.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMP Muh. 14 Mks Non Makassar S. Sulawesi 081354799814 *** 50 Drs. Nurdin Tawang, MM. M Supervisor Math Dinas Pendidikan Makassar S. Sulawesi 08124172405 *** 51 Huriah Syarifuddin, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMP YP PGRI Mks Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 0811468538 *** 52 Muh. Yusuf, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Makassar Partner Makassar S. Sulawesi 085299910211 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
168
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
53 Drs. Yohanis Toban M Supervisor English Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 085240022425 *** 54 Haluddin, S.Pd, M.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 3 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081342725366 *** 55 Drs. Suwanto Bambang Irawan M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081241481220 *** 56 Muh. Arifin, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 6 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 085242485702 *** 57 Nurbaeti, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 5 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081342706228 ** 58 Magdalena Karisi, S.Pd F Teacher English SMPN 1 Palopo Non Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081342935962 *** 59 Drs. Nawir, R M Teacher Science MTsN Model Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081342379327 *** 60 Anas ma'ruf Noer, S.Pd M Supervisor Science Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 085242314310 ** 61 Nur Faidah, S.Pd F Teacher Science SMPN 4 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 08124261015 [email protected] ** 62 Drs. H. Saparuddin, MM M Supervisor Social S. Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 085299672861 [email protected] *** 63 Tri Wiyono, S.Pd M Supervisor Social S. Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 085242832611 *** 64 Drs. Basri M, M.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 8 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 085255102833 *** 65 Drs. Nusram M Teacher Math SMPN 4 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081343614790 [email protected] *** 66 Drs. Nicolas Sesa M Supervisor Math Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 08124268499 *** 67 Bayu Suryading, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Palopo Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081241718289 *** 68 Ikbal, S.Pd M Teacher Math Dinas Pendidikan Partner Palopo S. Sulawesi 081342495249 ** 69 Kamaruddin Tutu, S.Pd., M.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 2 Pangkajene Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0813 4265 6737 [email protected] *** 70 Nurlina Idrus, SS F Teacher English MTs Darussalam Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0812 4119 3471 ** 71 Hj. Masna Sari, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Pangkajene Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0812 4239 1585 [email protected] *** 72 Drs. Murtala M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Pendidikan Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0813 4231 1169 * 73 Sudirman, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Marang Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0813 4261 1107 *** 74 M. Jufri, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Pangkajene Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0888 0411 7800 ** 75 Jamaluddin, S.Pd M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Marang Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0813 4256 9656 *** 76 Drs. Yusuf Saalino M Supervisor Social S. Dinas Pendidikan Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0821 8720 7678 * 77 Mansyur Eppe, S.Pd., M.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Pangkajene Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0813 4294 2204 [email protected] *** 78 Dra. Nuraeni F Teacher Math MTs Negeri Marang Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0812 4155 0997 [email protected] ** 79 St. Aminah F Teacher Math SMPN 1 Marang Partner Pangkep S. Sulawesi 0852 5504 6362 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
169
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
80 Abdul Rahman, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 1 Pinrang Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-355 288 173 *** 81 Wahyuniar Yusuf, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 5 Pinrang Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-241 699 432 *** 82 Nurul Yaqin, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 1 Cempa Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081 355 309 126 *** 83 Drs. Sahrir M Teacher English SMPN 4 Pinrang Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi *** 84 Drs. Rustam M Teacher English SMPN 1 Patampanua Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi ** 85 Corawali, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Lembang Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi 085-242 649 765 *** 86 Mangati, S.Pd. M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 1 Pinrang Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 085-242 961 676 *** 87 Drs. Sirajuddin M Supervisor B. Ind Pengawas Dikpora Pinrang S. Sulawesi 085-299 875 021 *** 88 Amran Muhiddin, S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 4 Pinrang Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 0811-420 669 *** 89 Hj. Luliwidiastuti, S, Pd F Supervisor Science Pengawas Dikpora Pinrang S. Sulawesi 0813 435 26202 *** 90 Drs. Basri M Teacher Social S. SMPN 2 Pinrang Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi 085-255 723 167 *** 91 Indrayana, S.Pd F Teacher Social S. SMP 1 Suppa Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-342-426 67 *** 92 Drs. Marten Mangera M Teacher Social S. SMPN 1 Mt. Sompe Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 085-242 102 129 ** 93 Beddu Salang, S.Pd M Principal Social S. SMPN 1 Cempa Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 0813-55974235 ** 94 Santoso Budi Sulisty M Teacher Social S. SMPN 7 Pinrang Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi 0813-42761676 ** 95 A. Pawajangi, S.Pd M Supervisor Math Pengawas Dikpora Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-299 541 726 *** 96 Muh. Yafied, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Suppa Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-241 348 774 *** 97 Dalle, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Mt. Sompe Partner Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-342 277 373 *** 98 Zubair Jumadi, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Pinrang Non Pinrang S. Sulawesi 081-343 732 022 *** 99
Muhammad Natsir Ede, S.Pd., M.Si
M Teacher English SMPN 4 Empagae Non Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081342239559 [email protected] *** 100 Hariani Ilyas, S.Ag F Teacher English MTsN Pangsid Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 085242578506 [email protected] *** 101 Muhammad Haddika, S.Pd M Teacher English SMPN 4 Baranti Non Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081355447520 [email protected] *** 102 Hasmin B Harun, S.Pd F Teacher B. Ind SMPN 2 Baranti Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081338788580 [email protected] *** 103 H. Maedani, S.Pd M Teacher B. Ind SMPN 3 Pangsid Non Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081342604135 [email protected] ** 104 Drs. Abdul Latif, M.Si M Supervisor B. Ind Diknas Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081241374367 [email protected] ** 105 Hamzah, S.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Baranti Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081354786860 [email protected] *** 106 Budiman, S.Pd., M.Pd M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Tellu Limpoe Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081241135780 [email protected] ***
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
170
No Name M/F Teacher/ Princi-pal/Supervisor
Subject Place of Work Partner /
Non Partner District Province No. Telp Email Address Assessment
107 Lukman, S.Pd., M.Si M Teacher Science SMPN 2 Pancarijang Non Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081241940668 [email protected] ** 108 Dra. Hasnawati F Teacher Social S. SMPN 4 Duapitue Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081342175775 [email protected] *** 109 Hj. Kamariah, S.Ag F Teacher Social S. MTS DDI Kalosi Non Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081343958199 ** 110 Drs. Gunawan, M.Si M Supervisor Social S. Diknas Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 08124233692 ** 111 Drs. Andi Akhir Zaman, M.Si M Supervisor Math Diknas Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081343548005 Andi_akhir @yahoo.co.id *** 112 Mansur, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 2 Pangsid Non Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 081343531555 [email protected] *** 113 Sumitro, S.Pd M Teacher Math SMPN 1 Pangsid Partner Sidrap S. Sulawesi 085242766635 [email protected] ** 114 Sandang, S.Pd.,M.Pd. M Supervisor English Dinas Dikmudora Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2554-07607 [email protected] *** 115 Iskandar, S.Pd. M Teacher English SMPN 1 Lilirilau Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2552-53620 [email protected] *** 116 Warda, S.Pd. F Teacher English SMPN 2 Liliriaja Non Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2552-20453 ** 117 Siliwarni Karim, S.Pd. F Teacher B. Ind MTsN Takalala Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2997-03215 *** 118 Mahmud Mustari, S.Pd.M,Si. M Supervisor B. Ind Dinas Dikmudora Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-3555-62041 ** 119 Dra. Hj. Harnis, F Principal B. Ind MTs Yasrib Lapajung Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-142-10139 [email protected] ** 120 Nurhasana, S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMP Muh. Watansoppeng Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2555-21572 *** 121 Hamsin, T.S.Pd. M Teacher Science SMPN 1 Donri-Donri Non Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-3437-03829 ** 122 Nurlia, S.Pd. F Teacher Science SMPN 1 Watansoppeng Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-2414-96389 ** 123 Drs. Nur Alim, M.Pd. M Supervisor Social S. Dinas Dikmudora Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-3423-05450 [email protected] *** 124 Zainuddin, S.Pd.,M.Pd. M Teacher Social S. SMPN 5 Watansoppeng Non Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-5242-72129 ** 125 Hartini, S.Pd.,M.Pd. F Supervisor Social S. Dinas Dikmudora Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-6563-73529 * 126 Syafruddin Syafar, S.Pd. M Teacher Math SMPN 5 Marioriwawo Non Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 081-3424-11225 *** 127 Hj. Arjuna, S.Pd. F Teacher Math SMPN 2 Lilirilau Non Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2552-68448 ** 128 Drs. Mustafa, M.Si M Teacher Math MTs DDI Waepute Non Partner Soppeng S. Sulawesi 085-2550-75077 **
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
171
6.6 Working with Teacher Training Institutions and LPMP
To achieve wider impact beyond the target districts and to support improvement across the (junior secondary) education system, DBE3 worked with staff from the State University of Makassar, Islamic University of Makassar and the South Sulawesi Quality Assurance Institute (LPMP). Staff of these institutions took part in the provincial BTL training programs including the training of facilitators and training of teachers. selected lecturers also participated in the classroom action research program.
In year 6, DBE3 planned and implemented a pilot program with the State University of Makassar to encourage them to adopt and make use of some of the key project programs, and approaches with a view to improving the quality of both their pre- and in-service teacher training courses. The pilot program is described in section ?? of the main report.
Details of staff from the University and LPMP taking part in various DBE3 activities are presented below:
6.6.1 Number of Staff from Universities and LPMP taking part in DBE3 training and CAR activities
Province Better
Teaching and Learning
Classroom Action
Research Pilot Program Total
South Sulawesi 20 5 30 55
6.6.2 Universities taking part in Classroom Action Research Review Meeting
A number of other universities from South Sulawesi also took part in the Classroom Action Research Review Meeting in September 2011 and expressed an interest in using the materials and being involved in future program. These were as follows:
• Universitas Negeri Makassar
• Islamic University of Makassar
• Universitas Muhammadiyah Makassar
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
172
6.7 Overview of Trainee Data
6.7.1 Non Formal Education Managers Trained by District in South Sulawesi
Below is a list of the number of non formal education managers by district from South Sulawesi trained on the Non-Formal Education program.
District Managers
Male Female Total
Palopo 7 3 10
Soppeng 5 3 8
Pangkep 5 3 8
Enrekang 6 2 8
Jeneponto 8 2 10
Pinrang 4 2 6
Sidrap 8 0 8
Luwu 7 2 9
Makassar 7 2 9
Total 57 19 76
6.7.2 Non Formal Education Tutors Trained By District in South Sulawesi
Below is a list of the numbers of tutors from district in South Sulawesi trained to implement the Non-Formal Education program.
District # Tutors
Male Female Total
Palopo 5 3 8
Soppeng 0 8 8
Pangkep 5 3 8
Enrekang 4 4 8
Jeneponto 4 6 10
Pinrang 3 3 6
Sidrap 4 6 10
Luwu 4 4 8
Makassar 3 4 7
Total 32 41 73
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
173
6.7.3 Number of Teachers in South Sulawesi Trained Using the Life Skills Training Program
Below is a list showing the number of teachers in each district in South Sulawesi by District, Gender and School Type trained between 2006 and 2008 to implement the Life Skills training program.
District
SMP MTs Total
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Enrekang 50 84 134 9 3 12 59 87 146
Jeneponto 39 70 109 31 54 85 70 123 194
Palopo 47 113 160 13 41 54 60 155 215
Pangkep 37 58 95 24 32 56 61 91 151
Soppeng 66 75 141 21 7 28 87 82 169
Luwu 41 49 90 20 38 58 61 87 148
Makassar 67 64 131 14 11 25 80 75 155
Pinrang 88 106 194 20 19 39 108 125 233
Sidrap 28 44 72 22 17 39 50 61 111
Total 463 663 1126 174 222 396 636 886 1522
6.7.4 Facilitators Trained in the BTL packages
Below is a list of the numbers of participants in the District Facilitator training for the Better Teaching and Learning (BTL) modules. The training included district facilitators and a number of others, mainly lecturers from teacher training universities and trainers from LPMPs.
All Districts
Participants
District Facilitators
Others Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 115 14 129
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 115 11 126
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 96 23 119
6.7.5 Number of Teachers, School Principals and Supervisors Trained in BTL Program
Below is a list of the numbers of teachers, school principals and school supervisors from or associated with partner schools trained in the BTL program. The number of school principals and supervisors trained in BTL4 appears to be fewer. This is a result of receiving separate training to support the BTL4 program and the BTL4 package being delivered through the MGMP (Teachers Working Groups), which are teacher specific organization, which school principals and supervisors do not normally attend.
All Districts Participants
Teachers Principals Supervisors Total
Better Teaching and Learning 4 (BTL4) 783 2 0 785
Better Teaching and Learning 3 (BTL3) 912 19 42 973
Better Teaching and Learning 2 (BTL2) 810 55 50 915
Additional School Supervisors Trained - 90 - -
The numbers of facilitators, teachers, school principals and supervisors shown as participcating in the BTL training in the tables above should not be aggregated, as they were largely the same people participating in each package of training.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
174
6.8 Dissemination of DBE3 programs
A core strategy of the DBE3 project was to develop exemplars of good practice in the partner schools and districts with the “specific intent” that these would be taken up and implemented by others to additional schools and geographical areas. Below is a summary of the dissemination of DBE3 programs in South Sulawesi by province and then by district. For more details of the dissemination program and activities see Volume 1, section ?? of this report.
6.8.1 Provincial Overview of Dissemination in South Sulawesi
Province Total # Schools
Total # Participants
Average # of Participants
Per Institution
Partner Districts
Disseminating
Non Partner Districts
Disseminating
Total Dissemination Budget (US$)
Contribution from Local
Partner (US$)
Local Contribution as a % of total budget spent
Average Cost per Trainee (US$)
South Sulawesi 579 4,094 7.0 7 1 187,424 124,400 66% 46
DBE3 Project 6,440 50,179 7.7 41 42 1,738,860 1,359,279 78% 35.1
% of Project Total 8.9% 8.1% 17% 2.3% 10.7% 9.1%
6.8.2 Dissemination by District in South Sulawesi
PARTNER DISTRICTS
# Total Junior Secondary
Schools (SMP and MTS) per
district
# Junior Secondary Schools (SMP and MTS) Reached by DBE3* % of Schools and MTS
covered by Dissemination
% Coverage by DBE3 # of DBE3 Partner Schools and MTS
# of Dissemination Schools and MTS
Total # Schools and MTS using DBE3
Programs
Enrekang 60 4 0 4 0% 6.60%
Jeneponto 112 4 0 4 0% 3.50%
Palopo 29 10 19 29 65.50% 100%
Pankep 88 4 29 33 32.90% 37.50%
Soppeng 70 10 51 61 72.80% 87.00%
Kota Makassar 249 10 91 101 36.50% 40.50%
Pinrang 80 10 59 69 73.70% 86.25%
Sidrap 63 10 43 53 68.20% 84.10%
Luwu 129 4 10 14 7.70% 10.80%
Bone* 188 0 25 25 13.20%
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
175
6.8.3 The Impact of Dissemination
The dissemination training in schools had some positive impact. When compared to the DBE3 comparison schools the dissemination schools did considerably better on all DBE3 teaching and learning indicators (with the exception of Instructional Leadership). However, the impact on teaching and learning in dissemination schools was not as significant as that on impact on partner schools suggesting that whilst dissemination training is beneficial, direct assistance achieves better results.
6.8.4 Chart: A comparison of the Impact of DBE3 in Partner, Dissemination and Comparison Schools in South Sulawesi
6.8.5 List of District Contributions to Dissemination of DBE3 Program
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Soppeng 36,360,000 4,101
Makassar 105,000,000 11,844
Pinrang 31,500,000 3,553
Total 172,860,000 19,498
6.8.6 Contributions to District Dissemination of DBE3 Innovations from MORA Budget
District Contributions (IDR) Contributions (US$)
Soppeng 23,042,000 2,599
Sidrap 19,100,000 2,154
Total 42,142,000 4,753
25
77.3
0
50
75.6
0
33.3
76
0 0
66
00
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Te achers' Skills Stude nt Be havior Cl assroom
Environment
Princi pal
Leade rship
Dissemination Schools
Partner Schools
Comparison Schools
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
176
6.9 South Sulawesi Extension District Development Plans And Achievements 2010 – 2011
Towards the end of 2010 all partner extension districts made plans to support and disseminate the DBE3 program. A summary of the plans and a review of the extent to which districts had implemented these plans by November 2011 is set out below.
SOPPENG
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget allocation of IDR 485,335,000 Budget actually from APBD: 36,360,000 IDR
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination training for all teachers in non-partner SMP and MTs: Scheduled for: July 2010 – May 2011.
Dissemination completed in nearly all MTS but not many SMP have done replication.
BTL 4 dissemination training for all teachers in all non-partner SMP and MTs – Scheduled for: January – May 2011
BTL4 replication has not been done in any school or MTS.
Covering the cost of teacher mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3 module by District Facilitators in partner and non-partner schools that have done dissemination
Mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3 training alumni was only done by SMPN 1 Lilirilau (independently).
No budget from District Education Office and MORA for post-training mentoring.
Covering the cost of district level Active Learning Showcase Scheduled for April 2011
District Showcase was com;pleted in May 2011. Funding come from DBE3 and several others (DPRD, MORA, Sekda and Education Office).
Soppeng District Head will issue a Decree to support the role and functions of DF in training and mentoring implementation in the district. This decree will be based on an agreement between Head of District Education Office and MORA
Decree on DF No. 466/XII/2010. dated 6 Desember 2010
DistRict Education Office and MORA will issue circular letters to School Principals on the implementation of active learning in SMP and MTs in Soppeng district
District Head Circular No. 03/KDS/2011 dated 4 January 2011. on the implementation of active learning in SMP/MTs.
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
177
SIDRAP
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget Allocation of 279.000.000 IDR No Budget Allocation from APBD
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination training for teachers in all non partner SMP and MTS: Scheduled for: July 2010 – May 2011.
BTL2 replication training is in progress for all SMP
BTL 4 dissemination training for teachers in all non partner SMP and MTs – Scheduled for: January – May 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of teacher mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3 module by District Facilitator in partner and non-partner schools that have done replication – scheduled for : January –May 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of end-of-year joint monitoring and evaluation on the implementation of active learning in schools that have done replication training for teachers. Scheduled for: November 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of district level Active Learning Showcase. Scheduled for April 2011
No Progress
Early October 2010 MONE and MORA will issus a decree to support the role and functions of DF in training and mentoring implementation in schools.
No Progress
A circular on the implementation of active learning will be issued by MONE and MORA.
No Progress
Head of BAPPEDA in Sidrap will align the remaining regional budget to meet needs of DBE3 program development
No Progress
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
178
PINRANG
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 Actual AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget Allocation of 247.000.000 IDR Budget actually from APBD: 31,500,000 IDR
BTL2 and BTL3 Dissemination training for teachers in all non partner SMP and MTs – Scheduled for: October 2010 – May 2011.
Three batches of training have been completed
BTL 4 dissemination training for teachers in all non-partner SMP and MTs – Scheduled for: April – September 2011
The District Facilitators are currently promoting the BTL4 module through the MGMP.
Covering the cost of teacher mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3 module by District Facilitators in partner and non-partner schools that have received dissemination training. Scheduled for: April - September 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of end-of-year joint monitoring and evaluation on the implementation of active learning in schools that have done replication training for teachers. Scheduled for: November 2011
Completed in November 2011 with independent monitoring by MONE and MORA staff
Covering the cost of the recruitment of new District Facilitators to help disseminate active learning program – scheduled for : Juli 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of district level Active Learning Showcase. Scheduled for November 2011
Scheduled for National Education day by MONE and Charity Day by MORA
MONE will issue a decree to support the role and functions of DF in training and mentoring implementation in schools.
Letters are issued for individual activities where the District Facilitators are involved.
A circular letter for school principals on the implementation of active learning will be issued by MONE and MORA.
There has been no letter but instructions to implement active learning are communicated during routine meetings and school visits
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
179
PALOPO
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget Allocation of 109.600.000 IDR No Budget Allocation from APBD
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination training for teachers in all non partner SMP and MTS – Scheduled for: January – May 2011. BTL2 replication has been done in several SMP
Completed in August 2011
BTL 4 replication training for teachers in all non-partner SMP and MTS – Scheduled for: July - November 2011
Completed in November 2011
Covering the cost of teacher mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3 module by District Facilitators in partner and non partner schools that have received dissemination training: Scheduled for: January - December 2011
Completed in November 2011
Covering the cost of end-of-year joint monitoring and evaluation on the implementation of active learning in schools that have done replication training for teachers. Scheduled for: November 2011
Completed in November 2011
Covering the cost of coordination meeting with DBE3 on monitoring the implementation of active learning in schools
Completed
Covering the cost of district level Active Learning Showcase. Scheduled for November 2011
In progress
MONE will issue a decree to support the role and functions of DF in training and mentoring implementation in schools.
Issued
A circular letter for school principals on the implementation of active learning will be issued by MONE
Issued in April 2011
Head of BAPPEDA in Palopo will align the remaining regional budget to meet needs of DBE3 program development
In progress
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
180
MAKASSAR
PLAN OF AUGUST 2010 ACTUAL AS OF NOVEMBER 2011
Budget Allocation of 225.000.000 IDR Budget actually from APBD: 105,000,000 IDR
BTL2 and BTL3 dissemination training for teachers in all non partner SMP and MTS – Scheduled for: November 2010 – November 2011.
Dissemination training for 91 schools centred on SMPN8 Makassar and supporting a lot of independent dissemination by schools.
BTL 4 dissemination training for teachers in all non-partner SMP and MTS Scheduled for: July - November 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of teacher mentoring for BTL2 and BTL3 module by District Facilitator in partner and non partner schools that have received dissemination training: Scheduled for: January - December 2011
No Progress
Covering the cost of end-of-year joint monitoring and evaluation on the implementation of active learning in schools that have done replication training for teachers. Scheduled for: November 2011
Planned for November 2011
MONE will issue a decree to support the role and functions of DF in training and mentoring implementation in schools
No Progress
MONE will align budget to support the development of active learning program in Makassar
No Progress
A circular letter for school principals on the implementation of active learning will be issued by MONE and MORA
No Progress
DBE3 RELEVANT EDUCATION FOR YOUTH, FINAL PROJECT REPORT, VOLUME II: PROVINCIAL REPORTS
181
6.10 List of DBE3 Technical, Management and Administrative Staff in South Sulwaesi, August 2011
DBE3 – LIFE SKILLS EDUCATION
Provincial Office: South Sulawesi
Name Position Residential Address Phone Numbers Email
Azhar Arsyad Provincial Coordinator Griya Prima Tonasa D4/7 Makassar 90243 Cell : 0811 460 470 Cell : 0812 428 1286
Saiful Jihad Sr. Education Officer Perumahan Dewi Kumala Sari Blok AB 7 No. 6 Makassar
Res : 0411 859 973 Cell : 0811 441 850
Hamsah Communication Officer Perumahan Andi Tonro Permai Blok A6 No. 5 Sungguminasa – Gowa
Cell: 0811 411 860 Cell : 0811 410 719
La Sunra District Coordinator Bumi Bosowa Permai Blok B2/8 Minasa Upa Res: (0411) 8214010 Cell : 0811 441 890
Jumardi Lanta District Coordinator Komp. Mitra Mas Blok CC 13 Mandai - Maros Res: 0411 554 743 Cell : 0811 466 680 Cell : 0852 4221 7305
Junardi District Coordinator Bukit Khatulistiwa Blok F. 40 Makassar Cell : 0812 4276 168 [email protected]
Muh. Hamka Syah District Coordinator Jl. Faisal V No. 22 Makassar 90222
Cell : 0811 447 242 Cell : 0812 4141 3101
Baharuddin Makkutana
District Coordinator Jl. Sukawati belakang Pengadilan Negeri Pinrang Cell : 0811 441 325 Cell : 0812 4245897
Muh. Sufyan District Coordinator Jl. Sultan Alauddin IV No. 8 Makassar Res : 0411 – 881709 Cell : 0813 4205 9110
Muhammad Azmi District Coordinator Jl. Perumahan Nusa Indah Permai Blok A4 No. 20 Makassar Cell : 0411 538 1637 Cell : 0813 4242 0991
Fajar Alam Karateng Finance and Admin Officer
Komp. Perum Graha Aliyah Blok D No. 7 Jl. Syech Yusuf - Gowa
Cell : 0811 447 125 Cell : 0812 4413 2974
Nora Yuliana Finance Assistant Jl. Tentara Pelajar lr. 202/12 No. Makassar 90222
Res : 0411 331 778 Cell : 0812 417 0250
Zuhrianah Hakim Admin Assistant Jl.Tanjung Bira No. 55 Makassar 90134 Res : 0411 851192 Cell : 0815 250 2421