Commander’s Intent: Managing Through Uncertainty
James Gwertzman, CEO
05/03/2023 2
A book review
05/03/2023 3
05/03/2023 4
05/03/2023 5
05/03/2023 6
Sources of friction in On War
GENERIC SOURCE SPECIFIC SOURCE
Imperfect information • Uncertainties• False information• Rumors
Imperfect transmitting of information
• Making judgment based on probabilities• Stress caused by emotion, including fear• Stress caused by physical exertion• The people involved who can cause misunderstanding or delay• Differences of views, especially between leaders
External factors • Chance (e.g., weather)• Complexity (reduces chances of success through accumulating
risk)
05/03/2023 7
Friction in a workplace
CHAOTIC ENVIRONMENT
COMPLEXITY
PERSONAL INTERESTS
EMOTION & STRESS
HUMANFINITUDE
Limitedknowledge
Independent agents
Independent wills
Unpredictable events
Imperfect information
Imperfect information
transfer
Noise
Lack of data
Chance
External actorsDifferent agendas
Different priorities
Different interpretations
Misunderstandings
Source: The Art of Action
05/03/2023 8
“Everybody’s got a plan until I hit them.”
– Mike Tyson
05/03/2023 10
OUTCOMES
PLANSACTIONS
Basic elements of any business
Source: The Art of Action
05/03/2023 11
The problem: 3 critical gapsOUTCOMES
PLANSACTIONS
Knowledge gap:The difference
between what we want to know and what we actually
know.
Effects gap:The difference
between what we expect our actions
to achieve, and what they actually
achieve.
Alignment gap:The difference
between what we want people to do
and what they actually do
Source: The Art of Action
05/03/2023 12
Usual reactions…OUTCOMES
PLANSACTIONS
Knowledge gap:More detailed information
Effects gap:More detailed
controls
Alignment gap:More detailed instructions
Source: The Art of Action
05/03/2023 13
The solution: Directed opportunismOUTCOMES
PLANSACTIONS
Knowledge gap:Limit direction to
defining and communicating
the intent
Effects gap:Give individuals
freedom to adjust their actions in line with intent
Alignment gap:Allow each level to
define how they will achive the
intent of the next level up, and ‘backbrief’
Source: The Art of Action
05/03/2023 14
Commander’s Intent: Less is better
FM 100-5, 14 June 1993 states:
“The commander's intent describes the desired end state. It is a concise expression of the purpose of the operation and must be understood two echelons below the issuing commander . . . It is the single unifying focus for all subordinate elements. It is not a summary of the concept of the operation.
Its purpose is to focus subordinates on the desired end state. Its utility is to focus subordinates on what has to be accomplished in order to achieve success, even when the plan and concept of operations no longer apply, and to discipline their efforts toward that end.”
OR:
- Decide what really matters- Get the message across- Give your people space & support
05/03/2023 15
Decide what really matters: strategy
COMPETITIVE
ADVANTAGE
AimsDo we want to do this?
OpportunitiesIs it possible to do this?
CapabilitiesIs this something we can do?
Source: The Art of Action
05/03/2023 16
Get the message across: the briefing
Express your intent in terms of what to achieve and why
Grant autonomy in terms of what to do, and how to realize the intent.
05/03/2023 17
Cascading intent: each level is more specific
LEVEL 1
LEVEL 2
LEVEL 3
Intent(What & why)
Intent(What & why)
Intent(What & why)
Tasks(How)
Tasks(How)
‘backbrief’
‘backbrief’
05/03/2023 18
The back brief…
• Team/person being briefed checks understanding of the direction• Superiors gains clarification about
the implications of their own directions (may need to revise as a result)• Ensures alignment across the
organization (esp. if everyone back briefs together)• Results checked for gaps, overlaps,
and coherence• Adjustment follows… FM 3-19.4 Appendix C (Back Brief Number 2)
05/03/2023 19
Commander’s Intent Example
UNMIH INTENT: “The purpose of this mission is to maintain a secure and stable environment which allows the government of Haiti to maintain functional governance, gradually transferring responsibility for the secure and stable environment to the government of Haiti. The end state is defined as the secure and stable environment that allows social and economic development, free election, and peaceful transition of responsibility to the government of Haiti.”
USFORHAITI INTENT: “The purpose of the operation is to divest Zone V of all operations in support of the government of Haiti. We will accomplish this purpose through progressively transferring all support operations to the government of Haiti, setting time limits on continued support to encourage timely transfers. Maintain only enough presence to detect an impending loss of security or stability in sufficient time to counteract it. At the end of the operation the government of Haiti assumes all responsibility for maintaining the secure and stable environment. Zone V forces are postured to facilitate and cover the withdrawal of UN forces and protect key installations.”
05/03/2023 20
Commander’s Intent Example
TASK FORCE BAYANIHAN COMMANDER’S MISSION STATEMENT: “Assist the Disaster Response Task Groups (DRTGs) in Visayas and Mindanao in the conduct of large scale humanitarian assistance and disaster response in regions 6,7,10 and 13, in order to save lives, protect property and minimize damage.”
TF BAYANIHAN COMMANDER’S INTENT:“My intent is to support the Armed Forces of the Philippines in HA/DR operations in the affected areas of the Central Philippines. We will conduct HA/DR combined operations and rehabilitation efforts. In other words, we will provide all available assistance to alleviate human suffering and restore normalcy.”
05/03/2023 21
Mission Statement as CI?
“I can teach you the secret to running this airline in thirty seconds. This is it: We are the low cost airline. Once you understand that fact, you can make any decision about this company’s future as well as I can.”
– Herb Kelleher, CEO Southwest Airlines
05/03/2023 22
Tips on writing a good intent
• The CI never specifies so much detail that it risks being rendered obsolete by unpredictable events.
• Commander’s Intent manages to align the behavior of soldiers at all levels without requiring play-by-play instructions from their leaders. When people know the desired intention, they’re free to improvise, as needed, in arriving there.
• A commander could spend a lot of time enumerating every specific task, but as soon as people know what the intent is they begin generating their own solutions.
Source: Made to Stick, by Chip and Dan Heath
05/03/2023 23
Keep it short, to the point, yet with enough information that subordinates can take it and run when things get confused.
Makes sense?
05/03/2023 24
Considerations of METT-T
05/03/2023 25
Strategy briefing template
• CONTEXT – what is the situation?• HIGHER INTENT – one level up, two levels up• MY INTENT – what are we trying to achieve and why?• MEASURES – how do we know if we succeeded?• IMPLIED TASKS, RESPONSIBILITY, TIMING• What is the main effort?
• BOUNDARIES – freedoms & constraints
05/03/2023 26
Let’s try it out!
05/03/2023 27
Lesson Learned: Understand intent
Problem: • Lengthy business directions
often focus on items that are beyond the current scope
• Intent should complement what your team needs to know and focus on key elements
Techniques:• Make sure you derive the single
most important thing you need to have done during the business evolution (current operation) and make this the focal point of your intent
• Have your team take the time to understand your intent
05/03/2023 28
Lesson Learned: Achieve focus
Problem:• Lengthy and vague intent
statements make it difficult to focus on what is important
Technique:Complete the following sentences: • If we do nothing during
tomorrow’s mission, we must __________________________.
• The single, most important thing we must do tomorrow, is __________________________.
05/03/2023 29
Lesson Learned: Make your statements conciseProblem: • Lengthy convoluted intent
statements are often due to conflicting and divergent assignment missions
Techniques:• Ask the simple question: What
is the single most important thing to accomplish during this operation?
• If you give people multiple missions, then help them prioritize them to succeed
05/03/2023 30
A framework for operations
Remember: • An intent statement provides a
framework for the operation. It doesn’t tell your staff what to do. If gives them the overall picture of what you say the company needs to accomplish to be successful.
• By making your intent a clear and concise focused statement, you increase the chance that you staff will continue the mission even when the operation doesn’t go as planned.
05/03/2023 31
• When you communicate the core concept to your staff the probability of success increases
• As a leader when you are vague or fail to communicate the core idea to your staff failure is inevitable
Can you explain it to your grandmother?
THANK YOU.