1
A Perspective on Oversight of API Manufacturing Sites
Albinus D’Sa, Ph.D.Deputy Country Director India Office U.S. Food and Drug Administration
Department of Health and Human Services
Indian Pharmaceutical Association 2012, Mumbai, July 12-13, 2012
2
Current US Pharmaceutical Industry Landscape• Increased generic drug demand
– Increase in median age of population– Innovator patents expiring– Downward cost pressure from payers
• More outsourcing and globalization of finished dosage manufacturing – Specialization in facets of upstream manufacturing
• API manufacturing is an example of a 40-year trend in outsourcing to specialists culminating by shift away from domestic (in this case specialty chemical) manufacturing base
Manufacturers will gain competitive edge through high quality and superior management of supply chains
3
Registration StatisticsRegistered Domestic and Foreign Establishments
as of FY2012 3rd Quarter
44%
36%
3%
17%
domestic manufacturer
foreign manufacturer
domestic API Manufacturer
foreign API Manufacturer
”Manufacturers” exclude API manufacturers as well as contract sterilization, analytical labs, PET, repackaging/packaging, labeling/relabeling
4
Foreign GMP InspectionsAll Drugs
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
GMP
PAI GMP
GMP China
PAI GMP China
5
Drug Inspections in India
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
6
Quality Problems Traced to Supply Chain are Driving a Heightened Focus on
Ingredient Manufacturing
• API – Highest Expectations for GMP• Excipients• Dietary supplement ingredients• Food ingredients • Cosmetic ingredients
Higher Quality Standards for Ingredients
7
Examples of Recalls Traced to ExcipientVariability or Low Levels of Impurities
• Four recalls in 2010 due to dissolution failure were ascribed to excipients– Aldehyde impurity (OTC drug)– Properties of Zein (OTC drug)– Intra-batch variability in Ethylcellulose used in
MR coating in capsule formulation (2 events involving the same product)
– Acid value of Glyceryl Behenate matrix carrier in a microsphere formulation
8
FDA Detects High Levels of Peroxide in Imported Crospovidone and Issued a Drug Safety Advisory
10/21/2010http://www.fda.gov/drugs/drugsafety/ucm230492.htm
• Peroxide levels found (1700 ppm) were 30-40x typical levels in this excipient
• Peroxides can degrade APIs resulting in sub-potent drug• Impurity levels were not being monitored by the
manufacturer of Crospovidone• Certificates of analysis were not indicating presence of
such high levels of peroxide• USP to revise monograph to add limit of peroxide
9
Observation: Manufacturers are Applying High Standards for Ingredient Quality Assurance
• More intensive supplier qualification by finished product manufacturers– Auditing of ingredient manufacturing sites– Expectations for direct communication
between makers and user of ingredients– More rigor in standards of quality for
ingredients– More frequent user confirmatory testing
10
FDA API CGMP Inspections• API - ingredient intended to furnish pharmacologic effect• The law defines API as a drug because it is a component
of a drug• The law requires all drugs to be manufactured in
conformance with CGMP– API not manufactured in conformance with CGMP is
deemed adulterated– An import alert can be issued when an API appears to
be adulterated as a result of inspection findings• ICH Q7 is a standard for FDA inspection of API
establishment (see also CDER Compliance Program Guidance Manual section 7356.002F)
11
• CGMP inspections– Focused on six systems
• Quality management system is always inspected• Facilities and equipment, Materials, Production,
Packaging and Labeling, Laboratory• On a pre-approval inspection FDA will also be looking at
the control of the API manufacturing process with greatest emphasis on critical process parameters and quality attributes
• Biotechnologically derived APIs– Are usually going to be produced as “Sterile API”– Other more rigorous inspection programs which apply finished
dosage form CGMP will generally apply
FDA API Pre-approval and CGMP Inspection Programs
12
Facilities and Equipment Systems• Risks to address
– Cross contamination risk– Contamination due to equipment or exposure of API
process– Mix-ups
------------------------------------------------------------------------------• Facility and equipment design
– Flow of materials, people, activity– Cleaning during changeovers– Compatibility of materials with process stream– Identification of each piece of equipment and piping
systems• Maintenance
13
Areas of High Contamination Risk• Dry processing such as drying or particle
size reduction can generate airborne fine particles
• Equipment which if not properly maintained or taken out of service when in irreversible disrepair can shed particles
• Areas in which there is potential for API to accumulate and not be readily removed during cleaning
14
Materials Systems• Identification and purity specifications and
testing of critical starting materials• Segregation in warehouse to avoid mix-ups• Tracking of inventory and traceability
– traceability of API starting materials– FDA is particularly concerned about agriculturally
derived starting materials• Water quality
– Minimum standard is WHO drinking water quality– Water purification systems should be validated– Water quality should be monitored and controlled
using action limits and procedures to describe actions taken when limits are exceeded
15
Suppliers of Critical Raw Materials for API Manufacturing
• System for technical evaluation of suitability• System for approval of suppliers by the QU• Agreed upon purchasing specification• Name and address of the manufacturer of the
critical raw material known• Written agreement to be notified about
significant changes to manufacturing that might impact critical material quality
16
API Guidance Which Cover Starting Materials
ICH Q7A: GMP Guidance for APIhttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/Guidances/UCM073497.pdfICH Q11: Draft Guidance on Development and Manufacture of Drug Substanceshttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/Guidances/UCM261078.pdfDraft Guidance on Heparin for Drug and Medical Device Use: Monitoring Crude Heparin for Qualityhttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/Guidances/UCM291390.pdf
Total – deficiencies seen on API inspections 2007-2010, by region
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
CONT
AMIN
ATIO
NDE
VIAT
ION
FRO
M D
MF/
ND
A...
BUI
LDIN
GS/
FAC
ILIT
IES
EQUI
PMEN
T DE
SIG
N, S
IZE
, LO
CA
EQ
UIP
ME
NT C
LEAN
ING
/MA
I...
CONT
ROL
CO
MPO
NEN
TS, I
NTE
RM
PRO
DU
CTIO
N/PR
OC
ESS
CO
NTRO
INA
DEQ
UAT
E VA
LID
ATIO
N P
RO
TOP
ACKA
GIN
G/L
ABE
LIN
GST
ABIL
ITY
PR
OG
RAM
H
OLD
ING
/DIS
TRIB
UTI
ON
CO
...IN
ADE
QUA
TE L
AB
CO
NTR
OLS
UN
VALI
DAT
ED L
AB T
EST
M...
DEFI
CIEN
CIES
IN R
ECO
RDS.
..RE
PRO
CES
SIN
G/R
EW
ORK
SC
ONT
ROL
OF
WA
TER
SY
ST...
DEF
ICIE
NCI
ES IN
ME
DIA
FILL
SIN
ADE
QU
ATE
PRO
CES
S VA
LID
ATLA
CK
OF/
INA
DEQ
UAT
E S
OP
S
QA
SYS
TEM
S
SYST
EM Q
UAL
IFIC
ATIO
NC
OM
PUTE
R V
ALID
ATIO
N IN
ADEQ
UATE
CO
MPL
AINT
I...
OR
GAN
IZA
TIO
N/P
ERS
ON
NEL
IN
ADE
QU
ATE
ENVI
RONM
ENTA
L C
All Europe India China
Source: DIDQ CO reviews of EIRs as reported in CMS
Date of data pull: Sept 19, 2011
Buildings/Facilities
Equipm
ent d
esign,
Size, location
Equipm
ent cleaning/
Maintenance
Raw M
aterial Controls
Productio
n/Process
Control
Inadequate Lab Controls
Invalidated Lab Test
Methods
Inadequate SOPS
QA System
sSystem
Qualifications
Buildings/Facilities
Equipm
ent d
esign,
Size, location
Equipm
ent cleaning/
Maintenance
Productio
n/Process
Control
Control Com
ponents,
Interm
ediates,
Raw M
aterials
Invalidated Lab Test
Methods
Inadequate SOPS
QA System
s
System
Qualifications
Equipm
ent cleaning/
Maintenance
Productio
n/Process
Control
Invalidated Lab Test
Methods
Inadequate SOPS
QA System
s
System
Qualifications
Control Com
ponents,
Interm
ediates,
Raw M
aterials
Equipm
ent d
esign,
Size, location
Equipm
ent cleaning/
Maintenance
Productio
n/Process
Control
Control Com
ponents,
Interm
ediates,
Raw M
aterials
Invalidated Lab Test
Methods
Inadequate SOPS
QA System
s
System
Qualifications
22
Lab Systems - Data Integrity• Accurate and reliable data and information• Ensuring data trustworthiness and reliability, as
related to the security of the information/data• Quality
– the degree to which a collection of data is complete, consistent, and accurate.
• Attributable, Legible, Contemporaneous, Original, and Accurate (ALCOA)– FDA may look to see that the process of data
creation at the site can be reconstructed and that it matches the information submitted to the agency. If problems are discovered, the integrity of the data is questionable.
23
Data Integrity – What We See• Not recording activities contemporaneously
– Backdating• Fabricating data
– Copying existing data as new data• Discarding data
– Not saving electronic or hard copy data• Discarding data to release failing product
– Repeat sampling or testing until compliance can be documented
24
Loss of Data Integrity - Observations• Batch production record
– 7 instances involving 2 employees signing as having completed manufacturing steps; neither employee was on the premises at the time the steps were completed
• Stability– Testing conducted late but recorded as having been
tested on time– Testing data was generated without samples having
been taken• Analytical Method Validation
– Results from the method validation of one drug were used for the method validation of another drug
25
Loss of Data Integrity - Observations• Test Data for Batch Release
– Test results for one batch were used to release other batches• Occurred for at least 3 batches• Happened at two unrelated firms
– Employee used same sample for identity testing of multiple batches
– Firm repackaged and released failing batch without performing an investigation
26
Data Integrity - References
• FDA’s Guidance to Industry: Part 11, Electronic Records; Electronic Signatures — Scope and Application, available at http://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/Guidances/UCM070295.pdf
• Glossary of Computer Systems Software Development Terminology (8/95), available athttp://www.fda.gov/ICECI/Inspections/InspectionGuides/ucm074875.htm
27
Nine FDA Warning Letters Were Issued to Foreign API Manufacturers in 2011
• Failure to conduct adequate release testing• Failure to investigate failing lab results• Failure to validate analytical methods• Lab control issues and falsification of lab data• Failure to review data before release and failure to
evaluate suppliers• Failure to implement procedures to prevent cross-
contamination with penicillin products• Failure to document manufacturing operation records
and inadequate facilities• Inadequate production records and laboratory controls• Failure to investigate deviations and inadequate
maintenance
28
Validation• All API manufacturing processes should be
validated– FDA recommends a lifecycle approach to validation
• All test methods for release of API should be validated
• All test methods should be suitable and scientifically sound for intended purpose– In process testing– Testing of starting materials, reagents, solvents,
catalysts, etc.
29
Residual Solvents and Metallic Impurities
• API manufacturers should be prepared to provide identity of potential residual solvents and metallic impurities to finished dosage form manufacturers– Requirements apply to finished drug products– See ICH Q3C for residual solvents (Option 2)– ICH Q3D (soon to be a Step 2 draft) and draft USP
chapters <231> and <232> express impending expectations for metallic impurities
• Instrumental methods to replace heavy metals test• Calculation of metallic impurities in drug products will usually
be based on levels in APIs and excipients
30
Expect To See More…• Inspections of foreign API sites
– Heightened focus on inspections related to generic drug manufacturing
– More focus on management of suppliers• Consistent raw materials fit for purpose• Integrity of API supply chains
• Sharing of information with trusted regulatory counterparts under confidentiality agreements
• 3rd party involvement, especially in supplier audits normally conducted by finished drug manufacturers
31
References• Validation
–FDA Guidance on Process Validation: General Principles and Practiceshttp://www.fda.gov/downloads/drugs/guidancecomplianceregulatoryinformation/guidances/ucm070336.pdf
• Residual Solvents –ICH Q3C
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/Guidances/UCM073394.pdf–USP <467>
• Elemental (Metallic) Impurities USP <232>–USP-PF 37(3)
32
Acknowledgements• Karan Takahashi• Grace McNally• Raphael Brykman• Steven Wolfgang